India 2011 Research Report

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 30

1

Thema – Thematic Focus

India in 2011
Strategic Focus
January 2011

1
Sustainable Swiss Private Banking since 1841.
India in 2011

It gives me great pleasure to introduce our publication “India in 2011”. India is a key market for the Sarasin Group
and we at Sarasin-Alpen are proud to be at the forefront of the Group’s expansion in the region.

As the report will demonstrate, the prospects for the Indian equity market remain appealing. The market has per-
formed nicely for many years, reflecting the country’s strong economic growth and remarkable wealth creation over the
period. Indeed, with a USD return of 19.7% p.a. over the last ten years, India has been one of the strongest equity
markets in the world.

Although this performance is impressive, India is at the beginning of its “journey” not the end. Income per capita is
estimated to be just USD 1,176 which, according to the International Monetary Fund, ranks India 137th in the world -
just behind the Solomon Islands and Yemen. It is the prospect of further rapid economic development and wealth
creation that makes India such an interesting long-term investment opportunity.

Please feel free to contact your relationship manager in case you require more information on our India offering.

Best regards,

Rohit Walia
Executive Vice Chairman & CEO
Bank Sarasin-Alpen Group
Contents

Foreword 1
India in 2011 1

Economic Outlook 3
India – soft landing for the economy in 2011 3
The global economy will weaken in 2011 3
Upswing in India is losing momentum 4
Fiscal and monetary policy 6
India's role in global rebalancing 8

Currency 11
Indian rupee for long-term investors 11

Equities 13
Equities – upside potential still exists 13
Review: India top in absolute terms, mid-table relatively 13
Outlook: earnings the driving factor 13
Valuation is expensive, but still not unattractive 15
Opportunities outweigh risks in 2011 16

Contacts 19
Foreword

Foreword

India in 2011

Dear Client, In terms of valuation, the Indian equity market is by far


the most expensive in Asia. However, the high price is
According to our cyclical research approach we are firmly justified by the best earnings trend. The question is
convinced that economic performance is the main driver whether India can maintain the growth momentum of re-
of the financial markets. It is not necessarily the absolute cent years and earnings can therefore continue to grow at
level of growth that is important, but rather the expected above-average rates in the future. Even if the pace of
change in the pace of growth. This results namely in posi- growth slows somewhat, it should still remain high com-
tive and negative surprises for economic growth and cor- pared to the other emerging markets. We see upside po-
porate earnings. As a consequence of the increasing tential of 15-20% in 2011.
globalisation, the economic cycles worldwide are syn-
chronised with small deviations. For a more detailed overview of the most important global
economic regions and financial markets, we recommend
Our expectations on the global economy and the future our publication «Global View». We hope this outlook gives
performance of the Indian economy are described in de- you a good overview of the opportunities offered by one
tail in the first part of this publication. In the second part, of the world's largest countries and the challenges it
we consider the outlook for the Indian rupee. Finally, the faces.
third part contains our outlook for the Indian equity mar-
ket. Best regards

In 2010, the Indian economy again grew very strongly. Af- Your Sarasin Research Team
ter 6% in 2009, growth accelerated to about 9% in 2010.
The Indian central bank tightened monetary policy in re-
sponse to rising inflation. The monetary policy measures
are likely to slow growth in 2011 to some extent. How-
ever, India's long-term potential is undisputed.

If India masters the two main challenges – education and


infrastructure – in the medium term, the country's econ-
omy can develop into a cornerstone of a new global eco-
nomic equilibrium with strong final demand.

There is growing international pressure on the emerging


markets to allow their currencies to appreciate faster.
The Indian rupee is undervalued and the Indian central
bank will therefore permit a gradual appreciation. How-
ever, the rupee is highly volatile and usually suffers heavy
losses when risk aversion in the financial markets rises.
This raises the risk in a portfolio. The Indian currency is
suitable for long-term investors that are willing to accept
short-term losses.

1
Economic Outlook

Economic Outlook

India – soft landing for the economy in 2011


India will not escape the global economic downturn that we expect in 2011. Continuing robust domestic growth
can cushion the Indian economy from weaker exports. Consumption and capex will remain the key growth drivers.
We expect growth to fall back from about 8.5% - 9.0% in 2010 to 7.5% - 8% this year. This moderate outlook for
economic growth means the Indian central bank will no longer be able to continue last year's aggressive rate
tightening in 2011. If India masters the two main challenges – education and infrastructure – in the medium term,
the country's economy can develop into a cornerstone of a new global economic equilibrium with strong final de-
mand.

The global economy will weaken in 2011 renewed upturn until 2012. It is only when the labour
Robust global economy in 2010… markets in the main regions have recovered that con-
The global recovery, which picked up pace in the second sumers can again be potential drivers of the economy.
half of 2009, continued in the first half of 2010. In the
global recession at the start of 2009, industrial invento- Powerful upturn in the global economy
ries were run down more than the decline in sales. From 5 104

the second half of 2009 on, industry- and export-oriented 4 102


companies were the main beneficiaries of inventory re-
3
100
building. By mid-2010, the gap between inventories and
2
sales had been closed and confidence in the global 98
1
manufacturing sector began to wane again. The OECD's
96
global leading indicator (which covers all OECD members 0

and the six most important non-members, namely Brazil, -1


94

China, India, Indonesia, Russia and South Africa) had 92


-2
reached a turning point in mid-2010. For the second half
-3 90
of 2010, everything seemed to point to a slowdown in the 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
World GDP growth (%)
OECD global leading indicator (R.H.SCALE)
global economy. However, the US government and the US Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream

central bank helped the upturn in H210 to develop new Source: Datastream
momentum. With a huge tax-cutting programme and a fur-
ther easing in US monetary policy, the outlook for the US Powerful upturn of Asia's export nations
economy improved significantly towards the end of the Asia came through the recession far better than the
year. This should also impact positively on the global western industrialised states. In the first place, the bank-
economy. ing system in Asia was more robust than in the US and
Europe. Secondly, the region is profiting from the struc-
…but there will be a slowdown in 2011 tural catch-up process in many emerging Asian countries.
Thanks to the US measures, the upturn will certainly con- However, Asia was not totally immune to the global re-
tinue in the first quarter of this year. However, the global cession. The highly export-oriented “newly industrialised
economy is then likely to cool sharply. The labour mar- Asian countries” (Hong Kong, Korea, Singapore and Tai-
kets in many western economies, especially in the US, wan) and the Asean-5 countries (Indonesia, Malaysia,
are still in a poor state. Consumers will no longer be able Philippines and Thailand) were especially hard hit by the
to maintain the economic upswing once the initial eupho- loss of demand from the western industrialised nations.
ria on fiscal and monetary stimuli has faded. The second It was these countries that recovered the most strongly in
half of 2011 is likely to be marked by a sluggish global 2010 on the back of inventory rebuilding. The following
economy. This downturn will probably not give way to a

3
Economic Outlook

chart shows the pronounced cyclical swings in Singapore Upswing in India is losing momentum
and Thailand over the last two years. Domestic supported upturn in 2010
As in China, economic growth in India was supported by
Strong downturn and upturn in Singapore and Thailand robust domestic demand in the 2009 global recession.
14 20 Robust consumption and a major fiscal programme have
12
been providing the necessary tailwind, as the following
10 15
chart reveals. Moreover, in contrast to China and other
8
10
Asian economies India is much less export-oriented. The
6
rate at which Indian GDP grew hardly ever fell below 6%
4
5
2
(yoy), as the left-side chart shows. The resilience of the
0 Indian economy in the global recession meant that the
0
-2 upturn in 2010 was less spectacular than in the heavily
-4 -5 export-oriented economies such as Singapore and Hong
-6
Kong. Nevertheless, growth in India returned to the rates
-8 -10
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 achieved by the economy prior to the global recession.
India real GDP growth y oy (%)
Singapore real GDP growth y oy (%) (R.H.SCALE)
Thailand real GDP growth y oy (%)Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream Economic growth in 2010 should be between 8.5% and
Source: Datastream 9%.

Asia is unlikely to escape the global slowdown Strong upturn in Indian investment
However, economic activity in these export-oriented 20 60

states is expected to slow in 2011. The trigger is likely to 18


50
16
come from weaker growth in the industrialised states.
40
14
China also benefited from a pick-up in export demand in
12 30
2010. Domestic demand in China is also strong. The re-
10
cession in 2009 hardly impaired domestic demand in 20
8

China. On the contrary, a huge stimulus package led to 6 10

an acceleration in domestic demand. However, China is 4


0
now grappling with the fall-out from these measures. The 2
-10
liquidity available to the economy is far higher than de- 0

-2 -20
sired and inflation is also clearly in an upward trend. The 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
India consumption y oy (%)
India inv estment y oy (%)
Chinese central bank is therefore in the process of rein- India gov ernment consumption y oy (%)(R.H.SCALE)
Sourc e: T homs on

ing in monetary policy. Stricter monetary policy and lower Source: Datastream
demand from the industrialised states will result in a
slowdown in Chinese growth at a high level in 2011.

4
Economic Outlook

Capital expenditure the most important driver Slowing in the US points to weaker confidence in India
As in the pre-recession years, investment remained the 16 65
15
key driver for the economy. Historically low interest rates 60
and a huge need for investment in India's still underde-
10 55
veloped infrastructure have ensured buoyant investment
activity. Consumption has not quite managed to regain 50

the high pre-recession growth rate. As consumption was 5


45
relatively robust in the recession, there was simply no
need to catch up. Moreover, the high food prices at the 0 40

start of the year probably dampened the consumers’ 35


mood. In line with the recovery in the global economy, In- -5
-6 30
dian exports also picked up strongly. However, in the 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
India leading indicator y oy (%)
US ISM manuf acturing(R.H.SCALE)
course of 2010 we already saw the first signs of weak- Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream

ness. Not surprisingly given the background of strong Source: Datastream


domestic demand, import grew at a faster pace than ex-
ports. India's trade balance therefore deteriorated sharply We expect the US ISM manufacturing index to drop to
during the year. about 50 during the course of the year. For India, this
also means a further decline in the OECD leading indica-
India's imports grow faster than exports tor, as the above chart illustrates. The following charts
4000 4000 show how pronounced the slowdown may be. The OECD's
leading indicator is closely correlated with the trend in In-
3500 3500 dian industrial production. A further decline in the leading
indicator points to industrial output growing by 6.0% to
3000 3000 8.0% in 2011. The correlation between industrial produc-
tion and GDP growth in turn points to economic growth of
2500 2500
some 7.5% to 8.0% in 2011. The expected growth in In-
dia is therefore lower than the average rate of about 9%
2000 2000
over the last few years.

1500 1500
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Downside potential in India's industrial production
India exports
India imports
Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream 16 18

Source: Datastream 14 16

14
12
Indian growth below eight percent 12
10
In 2011, Indian foreign trade should feel effects of the 10
slowdown in global economic activity that we expect. This 8
8
will also have an impact on the domestic economy in In- 6
6
dia. Despite the strong domestic sector, the confidence 4
4
of Indian companies is based on the global cycle. The fol-
2 2
lowing chart shows the close correlation between the In-
0 0
dian OECD leading indicator and the US business climate 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
India leading indicator y oy (%)
India industrial production ex construction 3m mav (R.H.SCALE)
index for the manufacturing sector (ISM manufacturing). Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream

The ISM manufacturing index can be viewed as the en- Source: Datastream
gine for the global economic cycle. Thanks to its domi-
nant financial market, the US economy still exerts a sig-
nificant influence on the global economy.

5
Economic Outlook

Weaker industrial production slows GDP growth 2010, the situation improved considerably. Higher growth
0.50 18 and the attendant higher tax revenues led to a significant
0.00 16 reduction in debt. This trend should continue in 2011.
9.50
14 The government deficit will again be below expected eco-
9.00
12
nomic growth, which will lead to a further decline in debt
8.50 as a percentage of GDP. However, debt will fall at a far
10
8.00 slower pace.
8
7.50
6
7.00
Debt (as % of GDP) is declining
4
6.50
-2 82

6.00 2
80
-3
5.50 0 78
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
India real GDP growth y oy (%)
India industrial production ex construction 3m mav (R.H.SCALE) 76
Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream -4

Source: Datastream 74

-5 72

70
Consumption will cushion downturn in 2011
-6
68
Investment will no longer be able to grow as fast as in
66
the previous year. There is no longer a need to make up -7
64
for inventory losses, as in 2010. In addition, the interest
-8 62
rate level has now risen. However, given the huge gaps in 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
India public def icit (%)
India debt-to-GDP(%)(R.H.SCALE)
Indian infrastructure investment will again make a posi- Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream

tive contribution to growth in 2011. Consumption should Source: Datastream


be the main growth driver. The robust and stable growth
numbers in recent years have supported the income of Focus will be on debt reduction
Indian households. A stabilisation in food prices helps Compared to other emerging nations, India's debt is very
real income. With stable domestic demand and a weaker high. The massive debt problems in the Euroland have
global economy, net exports should again lower Indian raised investor awareness regarding sovereign debt. In
growth in 2011. In view of India's high debt and high fis- the future, investors will demand a higher yield for higher
cal deficits in recent years, the state cannot be expected debt. For this reason, it should also be in India's own in-
to contribute very much either. terest to reduce its debt significantly. Given the strong
growth, India will also succeed in doing so. Even a gov-
India a ray of light in 2011, despite slowdown ernment deficit of less than 8-9% leads to lower debt
Given this economic outlook, India should again be one relative to economic growth. In the medium term, how-
of the growth engines in 2011 both in Asia and globally. ever, India will be faced with conflicting targets. Building
As most of the Asian economies are more reliant on ex- up the infrastructure requires government funds, which
ports than India, they are likely to be hit hard by the makes it harder to reduce debt. India will have to achieve
global slowdown. We believe that only China can achieve a balance between these goals.
a stronger economic growth performance in 2011. How-
ever, the growth risks are higher in China. For one thing, RBI freed itself from low rate policy in 2010
China's economy is more export-oriented. In addition, the The Indian central bank (Reserve Bank of India, RBI)
tightening of Chinese monetary policy in 2011 is likely to manages monetary policy by setting the repo rate and re-
be more pronounced than in India. verse repo rate. The repo rate represents the rate at
which the RBI takes liquidity out of the capital market.
Fiscal and monetary policy The reverse repo rate is the rate at which the RBI pro-
Debt-to-GDP ratio continues to fall vides liquidity. By setting the rate at which banks can ob-
In the 2009 crisis year, the state deficit increased tain liquidity from the RBI, the reserve bank manages
sharply following fiscal measures aimed at stabilising the short-term interest rates. The chart shows that 3-month
economy, which resulted in India's debt rising further. In Libor (3-month loan without collateral) is generally be-

6
Economic Outlook

tween the reverse repo and the repo rate. In 2009, the Food prices drive inflation in 2010
RBI cut the key rates to a record low to support growth in 25 25

India in the global economic crisis and provide the banks


20 20
with sufficient liquidity. It continued the low interest rate
phase into the first quarter of 2010. In spring 2010, 15 15

however, it became apparent that a powerful upswing


was in progress in the Indian economy. As a conse- 10 10

quence, the RBI gradually raised its key rates to 5.25%


5 5
(reverse repo rate) respectively to 6.25% (reop rate). The
movement of 3-month Libor interest rates shows that to- 0 0

wards the end of the year liquidity became tight and


-5 -5
short-term rates rose above the band defined by the RBI, 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
India wholsale price inf lation (%)
India wholsale price inf lation f ood (%)
which prompted it to inject money into the banking sys- Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream

tem with unconventional instruments. Source: Datastream

RBI raises key rates considerably in 2010 Monetary policy only marginally more restrictive
13 13 The restrictive monetary policy will probably not be con-
12 12 tinued in this form. Economic growth is likely to slow in
11 11 2011 and inflation has moved closer the RBI's comfort
10 10 zone from its high of more than 10%. In addition, there is
9 9 a risk that, as a result of the large interest rate differen-
8 8 tials between the short-term interest rates in India and in
7 7
the US or Europe (where we expect a continuation of the
6 6
zero rate policy), the Indian rupee could appreciate fur-
5 5
ther. In a year, in which exports will already suffer from
4 4
soft global demand, this is certainly undesirable. Last but
3 3
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 not least, the current tight supply of liquidity available to
India repo rate (%)
India rev erse repo rate (%)
India 3-months Libor (%) Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream the Indian banking sector could deter the RBI from con-
Source: Datastream tinuing to raise rates aggressively. This year, we expect
short-term rates to remain unchanged or rise only slightly.
Inflation in an uptrend
Besides the improved economic situation, Indian inflation Food prices could become a problem
was a further reason why the RIBI ended its low rate pol- A further rise in commodity prices represents a risk for
icy. Measured by wholesale prices, inflation was well the RBI. This could result in further increases in food
above the RBI's target of 5% to 5.5%, as is shown by the prices, leading in turn to inflation remaining well above
following chart. Inflation in India remained at a high level the comfort zone in 2011. For the RBI, this should mean
throughout 2010. The main driver of inflation was the more rate hikes even though the Indian economy is slow-
powerful upward trend in food prices to the middle of the ing. This would increase the risk of a hard landing. The
year. This is also illustrated by the following chart. In In- consequences especially for households at or below the
dia, food prices are the most important component of subsistence level could be drastic. On top of rising food
consumer prices. For this reason, changes in food prices prices (by far the largest item in such households' budg-
have a big influence on overall inflation. However, to- ets), there would be a potential loss of income. For this
wards the end of the year food price inflation – and hence reason, the Indian authorities are more likely to take ad-
overall inflation – subsided. In 2011, inflation is expected ministrative action than tighten monetary policy again if
to drop further. Indian growth is below the long-term aver- food prices continue to move higher. Such administrative
age, which should have a damping effect on prices. How- intervention could take the form of subsidies for food
ever, we expect food prices to remain at a high level in production and price caps on individual products.
2011, which will slow the decline in inflation.

7
Economic Outlook

Virtually no movement in long-term rates India's important role in the new equilibrium
In 2009, long-term rates had already anticipated a rise in The western deficit countries will have to raise their sav-
short-term rates. As a consequence, the increase in rates ings rates, which also means that consumption in those
in 2010 was moderate. Yields on 10-year Indian bonds countries will decline. However, this means that the sur-
moved more or less sideways. Stable long-term interest plus nations will lose their most important export markets
rates and rising key rates resulted in the yield curve in and will have to turn increasingly to consumption. This
India flattening considerably. This trend should remain in «global rebalancing» is not without risks. A situation could
place in 2011. While short-term rates are hardly likely to arise in which the deficit countries (have to) reduce their
rise any further, yields – above all towards the end of consumption, while the surplus countries are not pre-
2011 – could fall slightly at the long end. A weaker econ- pared to shift from export-driven growth to more con-
omy combined with weaker inflation points to lower inter- sumption. This could lead to a global shortfall in demand.
est rates. In this connection, India can play a key role in the new
equilibrium. India is one of the few countries whose
Yield curve flattened markedly in 2010 growth is not based on an export bias and whose con-
10 10 sumption is also not excessive. On the contrary, the
9 9
strong population and income growth forms the basis for
strong consumption growth in the coming years. The
8 8
chart below shows the expected growth in the labour pool
7 7 in China, India and the US over the coming 15 years.
Growth is likely to take place solely in India. Accordingly,
6 6
India will assume a key role in the global rebalancing
5 5 process, as it can offset the lower demand in the tradi-
4 4
tionally high consumption western countries.

3 3
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 India's labour market should grow strongly over the
India treasury y ield 1y ear (%)
India treasury y ield 10y ear (%)
Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream coming 15 years
Source: Datastream 900 900

800 800

India's role in global rebalancing


700 700
Consumption excesses and export boom not sustainable
600 600
In the coming years, the dominant theme for the global
economy will be «global rebalancing». This means correct- 500 500

ing the current imbalances. On the one hand, «deficit 400 400

countries» such as the US, UK and Spain have exces- 300 300
sively expanded consumption for years. This was made
200 200
possible by huge current account deficits and a sharp in-
100 100
crease in lending to households. On the other hand, 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
India labour f orce
China labour f orce
there were the «surplus countries», which financed the US labour f orce Sourc e: T homs on Reuters Datas tream

consumption boom in the deficit countries with their capi- Source: Datastream, Economist Intelligence Unit
tal exports and at the same time profited enormously by
exporting to those countries. In Europe, such surplus Can India fulfil its potential?
states include Germany and Switzerland for example and India's potential is not in dispute. The key question in the
in Asia China and the «newly industrialised countries of medium term is whether India will be able to exploit its
Asia» such as Singapore and Korea. The banking crisis potential. In this regard, two issues will be crucial. 1.
and the resultant recession have shown that this imbal- Education - while India is already an international leader
ance will no longer be tenable in the future and that the in information technology, there are enormous shortcom-
global economy will have to return to a more sustainable ings in the education sector. A growing middle class
growth path. needs investment in a solid basic education. 2. Infra-

8
Economic Outlook

structure - to maintain high economic growth in the long


term, the infrastructure must also keep pace. Today,
there are huge shortcomings in India's public infrastruc-
ture; huge efforts are required. If India manages to mas-
ter these two challenges, the country should stand out
not only in terms of high economic growth in the short
term, but should also lay the foundation for sustainable
economic growth in the long term.

Dr. Alessandro Bee, Economist & Fixed Income Strategist

9
Currency

Currency

Indian rupee for long-term investors


There is growing international pressure on the emerging economies to allow their currencies to appreciate faster.
The Indian rupee is undervalued and the Indian central bank will therefore permit a gradual appreciation. However,
the rupee is highly volatile and usually suffers heavy losses when risk aversion in the financial markets rises. This
raises the risk in a portfolio. The Indian currency is suitable for long-term investors that are willing to accept short-
term losses.

Emerging market currencies in G20 focus a «fair» current account balance for some emerging mar-
The last G20 meeting paid a great deal of attention to the kets. Accordingly, in considering whether a currency is
smouldering currency dispute. The US believes the cur- undervalued the relevant point is whether the current ac-
rency policy of the emerging markets is the main reason count balance exceeds its fundamentally justified level. If
for the global imbalances. The criticism levelled by Wash- the surplus is higher than the amount calculated by the
ington at the emerging economies is that they are keep- IMF, a currency is undervalued. Conversely, a currency
ing their currencies undervalued and obtaining an unjusti- should trade even lower.
fied competitive edge in international trade. Indeed, in-
ternational currency reserves have grown rapidly in recent The Indian rupee is undervalued: the current account
months; more than one half of the worldwide rise in forex balance is higher than the fundamentals warrant
reserves is attributable to the emerging markets. India's Current account balance minus the "fair" balance
foreign exchange reserves have also risen again. The 10.0

emerging market nations appear to be increasingly inter-


5.0
vening in the currency markets. In the G20 summit's final
statement, the 20 largest industrialised and emerging
0.0
market economies had agreed not to devalue their cur-
rencies to gain competitive advantages. In the future, -5.0
therefore, the emerging markets are likely to be less op-
posed to currency appreciation. A trade war would cause -10.0
Brazil

Israel

Egypt
Turkey
Korea

Indonesia

Thailand

South Africa

Chile

Argentina

India

China

Mexico

Malaysia

huge damage to all economies. For this reason, the


emerging economies will to some extent bow to interna-
tional pressure and allow their currencies to appreciate.
Source: IMF, Sarasin
Currency valuation crucial
How much pressure the G20 exerts on individual coun- India will permit a gradual appreciation
tries will probably depend on the respective valuations of Our calculations show that the Indian rupee is below its
the currencies. If a central bank attempts to hold a cur- fair value (see upper chart). The G20 will therefore pay
rency below its fair value, it can hardly defend itself close attention to India's monetary policy. The Indian
against criticism that it is manipulating its own currency. Central bank (RBI) will thus probably intervene less in the
The level of the current account balance is a suitable future and allow the rupee to appreciate. How quickly it
measure for assessing whether a currency is undervalued takes to complete the adjustment is likely to depend
or overvalued. However, focusing solely on the level of largely on China's currency policy. The Chinese renminbi
the current account balance is not enough. This depends is also clearly undervalued and must strengthen in the fu-
also on the demographics, economic cycle and fiscal pol- ture if the currency dispute with the US is to be defused.
icy of the economy in question. On the basis of these fac- However, China is hardly likely to accede to US demands
tors, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has calculated for a considerable appreciation. If the adjustment pro-

11
Currency

ceeded too quickly, this would threaten the existence of Indian rupee is highly risk sensitive
Chinese export industries with low margins. China will Correlation vs. USD & MSCI World
therefore spread the appreciation over several years. In- 0.8
0.7
dia too is likely to permit the rupee to gain in value only
0.6
gradually. 0.5
0.4
But the Indian rupee is very volatile… 0.3
0.2
From a valuation perspective the Indian rupee offers an
0.1
attractive investment opportunity. In the short term, how- 0.0

Israel
Brazil

Singapur Dollar

Turkey
China
Argentina

Taiwan
Philippines
Chile
Indonesia

Korea
India

South Africa

Mexico
Thailand
ever, it fluctuates very strongly. Compared to other Asian

Malaysia
currencies, the Indian rupee is more volatile against the
US dollar (see chart below). The Hong Kong dollar is
pegged to the dollar under the currency board system and
the Chinese renminbi is also closely linked to the dollar. Source: Datastream, Sarasin
By contrast, the Indonesian and Korean currencies are
even more volatile than the Indian rupee. The Indian rupee is one of the currencies that profits from
a rise in risk appetite in the financial markets. By con-
Indian rupee is more volatile than other emerging mar- trast, if risk aversion grows, international investors with-
ket currencies draw from India and the rupee suffers severe losses. Dur-
Implied volatility vs. USD ing the financial crisis in 2008 and 2009 the trade-
16 weighted external value of the Indian rupee weakened by
14
some 20 percent. As a consequence, the India rupee
12
raises a portfolio's risk profile. If the financial markets
10
correct, investors suffer currency losses on top of equity
8
6 losses.
4
2 Good environment for the Indian rupee in 2011
0 Accordingly, for investors with a longer time horizon that
Israel

Brazil
Singapur
Hong Kong

Philippines

Turkey
China
Taiwan
Thailand

Argentina

India
Indonesia

Mexico
Chile
Korea

South Africa
Malaysia

are prepared to accept short-term setbacks, the Indian


rupee is a suitable currency. However, losses should be
limited in 2011. We expect that the recovery in the global
Source: Datastream, Sarasin economy will prove to be sustainable in 2011. In recent
months, the economic risks have fallen considerably. We
…and correlates with equities therefore expect no massive rise in risk aversion and the
The Indian rupee is also a highly risk-sensitive currency. environment for the Indian rupee should be good in
This is reflected in the high correlation with equity per- 2011.
formance (see chart below). The Indian rupee correlates
more closely with equity market trends than other Asian Ursina Kubli, Economist & Forex Strategist
currencies. Only the Singapore dollar is more dependent
on sentiment in the financial markets.

12
Equities

Equities

Equities – upside potential still exists


In terms of valuation, the Indian equity market is by far the most expensive in Asia. However, the high price is justi-
fied by the best earnings trend. The question is whether India can maintain the growth momentum of recent years
and earnings can therefore continue to grow at above-average rates in the future. Even if the pace of growth slows
somewhat, it should still remain high compared to the other emerging markets. We see upside potential of 15-20%
in 2011.

Review: India top in absolute terms, mid-table relatively a mid-table ranking in the 2010 performance table for
Indian equities sharply higher in 2010 emerging markets.
In 2010, the Indian equity market developed very posi-
tively and seamlessly continued the good performance of Emerging markets performance in 2010
the previous year. After a subdued first half of the year, Thailand
Chile
the BSE Sensex index moved out of the tight trading Malaysia
range in the second half and nearly hit a new record high Indonesia
South Africa
at 21,000 points (previous high: 21,200 in January Mexico
Korea
2008). The full-year performance was 17%. Thanks to the India
slight appreciation of the Indian rupee against the US dol- Turkey
Taiwan
lar, a dollar investor with exposure to Indian equities even Russia
EM
achieved a return of 22%. Poland
World
Brazil
Indian equities: absolute & relative performance 2010 China
000'S Israel
22 112

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
21 110

Source: MSCI, Sarasin


108
20

106
19 Outlook: earnings the driving factor
104
Global economic momentum in focus
18
102 According to our cyclical research approach, we are firmly
17
100
convinced that economic performance is the main driver
16
of equity markets. It is not necessarily the absolute level
98
of growth that is important, but rather the expected
15 96
JAN FEB MAR APRMAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCTNOV DEC change in the pace of growth. This results namely in posi-
India Bombay SE 30 Index
MSCI India relative to MSCI Emerging Markets(R.H.SCALE)
Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream tive and negative surprises for economic growth and cor-
Source: Datastream porate earnings. As a result of increasing globalisation,
the economic cycles worldwide are synchronised with
No decoupling from emerging markets small deviations. Our expectations regarding the global
In the first half of 2010, the Indian equity market outper- economy and the performance of the Indian economy are
formed the emerging markets overall (see chart above). described in detail in the first part of this publication.
However, in the consolidation in Q4 2010 all of the In-
dian equity market's outperformance was lost again. Lo- Local growth drives earnings
cal factors such as the aggressive monetary tightening of A good growth forecast also enables one to predict the
the central bank (RBI) and corruption cases led to a set- trend in earnings growth. The chart below shows that
back. As a result, the Indian equity market achieved only

13
Equities

earnings growth follows growth in industrial production Only temporary slowdown in growth
with a time lag of 6-12 months. As we expect a renewed global upturn towards the end of
2011, the slowdown in earnings growth over the coming
Earnings growth trails industrial production quarters should merely be temporary. In recent months,
18 50 earnings growth momentum has declined markedly. Ac-
16 40 cordingly, the consensus of analysts has been reacting to
14 this trend by revising expectations downward for some
30

12
time.
20
10
10
Earnings revisions have been negative for several
8
0 months
6
0.80 0.60
-10
4
0.60 0.40
2 -20

0.40
0 -30 0.20
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
India industrial production ex construction yoy in %
India trailing earnings yoy in %(R.H.SCALE) 0.20
Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream 0
0
Source: Datastream
-0.20
-0.20

As we believe that economic growth will slow in H1 2011, -0.40


-0.40

earnings growth is likely to slow further. However, we ex- -0.60


-0.60
pect growth to stabilise at around 6-8%, i.e. there will be
-0.80 -0.80
a soft landing and a similar scenario as in 2005. In such 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
India EPS revision ratio 1M
India EPS revision ratio 3M avg(R.H.SCALE)
a scenario, earnings growth is likely to stabilise at a level Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream

around 15-20%. Source: Datastream, Sarasin

New record earnings in 2010 The above chart reveals that the balance of earnings es-
In recent years, corporate earning growth in India has timates (positive minus negative earnings revisions) has
been far higher than the average. In the wake of the been in negative territory for some months. To some ex-
global financial crisis, earnings came under strong pres- tent at least, weaker growth is being anticipated. How-
sure in 2009. However, they recovered astonishingly fast ever, negative earnings revisions should continue to im-
after the financial crisis. For example, listed Indian com- pact negatively on the Indian equity market in H1 2011.
panies already posted new record earnings during the
course of 2010 (see chart). Earnings expectations high, but not unrealistic
Looking forward, the key question is whether this strong
India: earnings (trailing/forward 12M) earnings growth is sustainable. After growth well in ex-
260 260 cess of 20% in 2010, the consensus also expects earn-
240 240 ings growth of some 20% for the coming two years.
220 220

200 200

180 180

160 160

140 140

120 120

100 100

80 80
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
MSCI India trailing earnings
MSCI India forward earnings
Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream

Source: Datastream

14
Equities

Expected earnings growth 2010-2012 (%) Compared to the emerging countries, it is rather the rela-
35 tive growth momentum that plays a role. Higher earnings
30
growth is also reflected in the price that investors are will-
ing to pay. The Indian market is currently trading at a
25
premium of some 30-40% to the MSCI World index and to
20
the MSCI Emerging Markets index.
15

10 Valuation premium relative to MSCI World and EM


1.80 1.80
5

0 1.60 1.60
2010 2011 2012
India Emerging Markets 1.40 1.40

Source: Datastream, Sarasin 1.20 1.20

1.00 1.00
However, if the usual forecast margin of error is deducted
from this 20% (on average earnings are overestimated by 0.80 0.80

5-10%), we arrive at a quite realistic estimate. The chart 0.60 0.60


also shows that India has the highest earnings growth
0.40 0.40
among the emerging economies. This also justifies an 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10
MSCI India forward p/e relative to MSCI World
MSCI India forward p/e relative to MSCI EM
above-average valuation. Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream

Source: Datastream, Sarasin


Valuation is expensive, but still not unattractive
Indian equity market relatively expensive This premium is about twice as high as the average over
In recent years, the valuation of the Indian equity market the last 12 years. Both in relative and absolute terms,
has increased considerably. Compared to the industrial- i.e. compared to its own past, the Indian equity market is
ised nations, this is mainly due to the fact that the valua- expensive (see chart below). Such a valuation is justified
tions of the equity markets in the industrialised countries only as long as growth remains at an above-average level.
have declined.

15
Equities

Valuation expensive historically and relatively High correlation between India and emerging markets
0.95 0.95
50%
0.90 0.90
40%
0.85 0.85
30%
0.80 0.80

20%
0.75 0.75

10% 0.70 0.70

0% 0.65 0.65
Forward PE Trailing PE
0.60 0.60

India current valuation relative to 12y average 0.55 0.55


India current valuation relative to Emerging Markets
0.50 0.50
India vs. Emerging Markets (12y average relative valuation) 2008 2009 2010
MSCI India / MSCI Emerging Markets, weekly correlation
MSCI India / MSCI World, weekly correlation
Source: Datastream, Sarasin Source: Thomson Reuters Datastream

Source: Datastream, Sarasin


We believe India will be able to maintain above-average
earnings growth in the coming years thanks to the posi- The Indian equity market's close correlation with the
tive growth momentum. The premium therefore also ap- MSCI World and the MSCI Emerging Markets index shows
pears justified. However, as expectations are already that global factors are more important than local ones for
high, there is only limited scope for positive surprises. On the performance of the equity market. In view of the In-
the other hand, there is considerable potential for disap- dian equity market's especially high correlation with the
pointment if growth expectations are not fulfilled. emerging markets, China in particular is extremely signifi-
cant for the performance of the Indian market.
Higher valuation unlikely
Given the already high valuation and premium over other Positive surprise in China an opportunity
equity markets, the valuation is unlikely to rise further. We believe that concerns of a sharp slowdown in growth
This means that equity market performance is limited to in China are overdone and expect positive surprises.
the level of earnings growth. Accordingly, we expect the While growth should slow to about 9% in 2011, the Chi-
Indian equity market to move in line with expected earn- nese economy appears unlikely to suffer a hard landing.
ings growth of 15-20% in 2011. The Chinese equity market, which investors are currently
steering clear of, is our top recommendation among the
Opportunities outweigh risks in 2011 emerging markets for 2011 from a contrarian standpoint.
Global risk aversion the biggest risk Good news from China and a good performance on the
As the significance of foreign money flows is relatively part of the Chinese equity market should also be positive
high, we believe an increase in global risk aversion repre- for Indian equities.
sents the biggest risk for the Indian equity market. While
we expect global risk aversion to continue to trend down- Double-digit return expected in 2011
wards in 2011, the Indian equity market remains vulner- We are optimistic for the Indian equity market in 2011
able. The money flows that India has attracted in recent and again expect a double-digit return. However, given the
years are highly volatile and can quickly dry up. If many high valuation the upside potential is limited and the In-
investors wanted to exit at the same time, there could be dian stock market is therefore hardly likely to outperform
a major setback. the emerging markets overall. But investors that are able
to ride out strong fluctuations should profit from exposure
to Indian equities.

Philipp Bärtschi, CFA, Chief Strategist

16
Abbreviations

A actual value
abs.ch absolute change
ASW asset swap spread
avg. average
bn billion
bp basis points
corp. corporate
CPI Consumer Price Index
Div. yield or DY dividend yield
E estimate
EBIT earnings before interest and taxes
EPS earnings per share
EV/EBITDA enterprise value to earnings before interest, taxes,
depreciation and amortisation
excl. excluding
FY financial year
GAAP Generally Accepted Accounting Principles
GDP gross domestic product
GNP gross national product
gov. government
m million
M&A Mergers & Acquisitions
mavg moving average
N.A. not available
p.a. per annum
P/B price-to-book ratio
P/E price-to-earnings ratio
P/NAV price/net asset value
R&D Research & Development
R.H. Scale right hand scale
ROE return on equity
SAA Strategic Asset Allocation, long term strategy based on investment profiles
TAA Tactical Asset Allocation; short term strategy based on return/risk expectations
vs. versus
yoy year over year

17
Contacts

Contacts

Research
Dr. Jan Amrit Poser Tel. +41 44 213 92 81
Head of Research jan.poser@sarasin.ch

Economic Research
Dr. Jan Amrit Poser Tel. +41 44 213 92 81
Chief Economist jan.poser@sarasin.ch
Dr. Alessandro Bee Tel. +41 44 213 92 83
Fixed Income Strategist alessandro.bee@sarasin.ch
Ursina Kubli Tel. +41 44 213 92 80
Forex Strategist ursina.kubli@sarasin.ch
Benoît Robaux Tel. +41 44 213 97 91
Corporate Bond Analyst benoit.robaux@sarasin.ch

Strategy Research
Philipp Bärtschi, CFA Tel. +41 44 213 95 72
Chief Strategist philipp.baertschi@sarasin.ch
Peter Bezak Tel. +41 44 213 90 80
Portfolio Strategist peter.bezak@sarasin.ch
Eliane Tanner Tel. +41 44 213 92 54
Commodity Strategist eliane.tanner@sarasin.ch
Dr. Jianyong Wen Tel. +41 44 213 97 40
Quantitative Analyst jianyong.wen@sarasin.ch

Fund Research
Irene Huber, CFA Tel. +41 44 213 93 13
Fund Research irene.huber@sarasin.ch

Equity Research
Rainer Männle, CFA Tel. +41 44 213 94 99
Head of Equity Research rainer.maennle@sarasin.ch
Sector Strategist, Industrials
Patrick Hasenböhler Tel. +41 44 213 94 81
Head Swiss Equity Research patrick.hasenboehler@sarasin.ch
Consumer Goods, Media, Misc. Services
Daniel Bischof Tel. +41 44 213 94 83
Financials (International) daniel.bischof@sarasin.ch
Dr. Philipp Gamper Tel. +41 44 213 94 97
Capital Goods, Chemicals, Construction, Automotive philipp.gamper@sarasin.ch
Ute Haibach Tel. +41 44 213 96 76
Metals & Mining ute.haibach@sarasin.ch
Dr. David Kägi Tel. +41 44 213 94 82
Health Care david.kaegi@sarasin.ch
Michael Romer Tel. +41 44 213 94 84
Energy, Utilities, Consumer Goods michael.romer@sarasin.ch
Oskar Schenker Tel. +41 44 213 94 88
Chemicals, Construction, Technology, Industrials oskar.schenker@sarasin.ch
Rainer Skierka Tel. +41 44 213 94 98
Financials (Swiss) rainer.skierka@sarasin.ch

19
General disclosure information:
The detailed disclosure information for companies mentioned in this publication can be found in our publications "Eq-
uity Note", as well as in the "Fact Sheet" of the "Equity Research".

Important information
This publication, issued by Bank Sarasin & Co. Ltd (“BSC”) is based on publicly available information, information
sources and data (“the information”) whose reliability is beyond question. Nonetheless, BSC accepts no responsibility,
either express or implied, for errors or incompleteness of the information provided. Possible errors in this information
do not constitute grounds for liability, either directly or indirectly. In particular, neither BSC nor its shareholders or em-
ployees are responsible for the accuracy or continuing accuracy of the opinions, appraisals, conclusions, plans or de-
tails of investment funds, their investment strategies, the economic environment, the market, competitive or regula-
tory environment, etc. Even if this publication has been issued in the context of an existing contractual relationship,
BSC’s liability is restricted to gross negligence or wilful misconduct. Furthermore, BSC accepts no liability for minor er-
rors of fact. In any case, the liability of BSC is limited to typical expectable damages, and liability for any indirect dam-
ages is expressly excluded.

Insofar as factual information and the opinions of third parties (interpretations and estimates) are presented, the rele-
vant sources are indicated. Our own value judgements (projections and forecasts) which reflect the outcome of work
undertaken by BSC's Research department, are not expressly marked or indicated. The substantive principles and
benchmarks underlying our own value judgements are set down in our research methodology principles.

In producing the research, the following valuation principles and methods were applied: The analysts’ investment de-
cisions are based on an analysis of the business model of the company concerned, the market in which the company
is active, and general market characteristics (Porter analysis: barriers to market entry, bargaining power of suppliers,
bargaining power of customers, threat of substitute products, level of competition). The analysts compare their results
with current market expectations and the corresponding data for the company’s peer group. Different valuation models
are used depending on the industry. Among the most important of these are the price/earnings (P/E) ratio, price-to-
book (P/B) ratio, enterprise value-to-sales (EV/sales), enterprise value to earnings before interest, tax, depreciation
and amortisation (EV/EBITDA), enterprise value to earnings before interest and tax (EV/EBIT) and dividend yield (ratio
of dividend to current share price). We do not set any share price targets for companies covered by our Equity Re-
search. The present financial analysis hast been prepared in compliance with the «Directives on the independence of
financial research» published by the Swiss Bankers Association in January 2008. The present financial analy-
ses/research results have not been made available to the issuer before their disclosure or publication.
This publication is a marketing communication from BSC, which is purely for information purposes and which does not
claim to represent a comprehensive portrayal of product characteristics. This publication does not constitute a quota-
tion, an offer or a solicitation of an offer for the purchase or sale of an investment or other specific product, and is not
a substitute for obtaining advice and a risk appraisal from your personal advisor – which we expressly recommend be-
fore making any investment decision. BSC may at any time perform services to buy, sell, subscribe to or redeem funds
which are mentioned in this publication, or act as a client or authorised representative. It is possible that BSC may re-
ceive sales commissions for portfolio management fees in respect of certain funds referred to in this publication.
Such fees are for the use of the BSC sales channel and do not generally accrue to the investors. Where future price
trends are presented in the context of this publication, these trends and/or the recommendations derived from them
are based, amongst other things, on forecasts of future trends on the financial markets and corresponding simula-
tions. These forecasts and simulations are in turn based primarily on past experience and concrete historical perform-
ance data. We would like to explicitly remind you that historical performance data, forecast calculations and other
simulations are not a reliable indicator of future trends. We can therefore give no guarantee that the forecast values
from the calculation models will actually be reflected in fact. Fees and costs are not taken into account in the per-
formance calculation.

Although BSC has taken steps to avoid or disclose conflicts of interest, BSC can give no guarantees in this regard.
Therefore BSC accepts no liability for damages arising from such conflicts of interest. If the organisational or adminis-
trative measures taken by the Bank should, on the basis of reasonable judgement, be deemed to be insufficient to
guarantee the avoidance of a risk of damage to client interests, then the Bank will unambiguously clarify the type

20
and/or cause of the conflicts of interest to the client. It impossible to rule out the possibility that a business connec-
tion may exist between a company which is the subject of research and a company within the Sarasin Group, from
which a potential conflict of interest could result. As a client, you will be informed of any relevant potential conflicts of
interest in financial research distributed by the Bank.

Discrepancies may emerge in respect of our own financial researches from the twelve months preceding publication,
relating to the same financial instruments or issuers.

BSC is regulated by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA).

Sarasin-Alpen undertakes all reasonable measures to ensure the reliability of the information included in this publica-
tion. The information and opinions contained herein constitute neither an invitation nor an offer or recommendation to
use a service, to buy/sell investment instruments, nor to perform any other transaction, but serve purelyfor marketing
and information purposes. In addition, the information is not intended for distribution to or for use by individuals or le-
gal entities that are citizens of a country, or have their domicile or registered offices in a country where the distribu-
tion, publication, provision or use of this information would violate applicable laws or regulations, or in a country in
which Sarasin-Alpen would have to comply with registration or approval requirements. It should also be noted that all
investments carry a certain amount of risk and should not therefore be entered into without first obtaining professional
advice.

Distribution in UAE:
This information has been distributed by Bank Sarasin-Alpen (ME) Limited, Dubai, UAE. Related financial products or
services are only available to clients as defined by the DFSA and to wholesale customers. Bank Sarasin-Alpen (ME)
Limited is duly authorized and regulated by Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA).

Distribution in Qatar:
This information has been distributed by Bank Sarasin-Alpen (Qatar) LLC. Related financial products or services are
only available to wholesale customers with liquid assets of over USD 1 million, and have sufficient financial experi-
ence and understanding to participate in financial markets, in a whole-sale jurisdiction. Bank Sarasin-Alpen (Qatar)
LLC is duly authorised and regulated by Qatar Financial Centre Regulatory Authority (QFCRA).

Distribution in Oman:
This information has been distributed by Sarasin-Alpen LLC. Related financial products or services are only available to
qualified investors with liquid assets of over USD 1 million, and have sufficient financial experience and understanding
to participate in financial markets and are aware of the risks and rewards of any potential investmentsrelated to such
products. Sarasin-Alpen LLC is duly authorised and regulated by the Capital Market Authority (CMA).

Distribution in Bahrain
The information has been distributed by Sarasin-Alpen (Bahrain) B.S.C. (c). Related financial products or services are
only available to “Accredited Investors” as defined by the Central Bank of Bahrain. Sarasin-Alpen (Bahrain) B.S.C. (c)
is duly licensed and regulated by the Central Bank of Bahrain.

21
Investment
Before you make an investment, we recommend that you obtain detailed information about the product in question.
Investments should only be made on the basis of the current prospectus. This document must not be transferred to
persons in a country other than the country where you received said document. If persons resident in other countries
receive this report, then they must observe the applicable sales restrictions for the products in question.
This publication first appeared on 6th January 2011. Updates are not envisaged. Opinions expressed in the publica-
tion and prices quoted can be changed at any time without prior notice.
The entire content of this publication is protected by copyright law (all rights reserved). The use, modification or dupli-
cation in whole or part of this document is only permitted for private, non-commercial purposes by the interested party.
When doing so, copyright notices and branding must neither be altered nor removed. Any usage over and above this
requires the prior written approval of BSC. The same applies to the circulation of this publication.

Bank Sarasin & Co. Ltd


Sarasin Research
Löwenstrasse 11
P.O. Box
CH-8022 Zürich
Switzerland
T: +41 44 213 94 76
F: +41 44 213 92 66
research@sarasin.ch © Copyright Bank Sarasin & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved.

22
24

You might also like