Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 1016@j Jhydrol 2019 124459
10 1016@j Jhydrol 2019 124459
Research papers
PII: S0022-1694(19)31194-1
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2019.124459
Reference: HYDROL 124459
Please cite this article as: Singh, P., Mukherjee, S., Chemical signature detection of groundwater and geothermal
waters for evidence of crustal deformation along fault zones, Journal of Hydrology (2019), doi: https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.jhydrol.2019.124459
This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the addition of a cover
page and metadata, and formatting for readability, but it is not yet the definitive version of record. This version will
undergo additional copyediting, typesetting and review before it is published in its final form, but we are providing
this version to give early visibility of the article. Please note that, during the production process, errors may be
discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
INDIA
*
Corresponding Author: Prof. Saumitra Mukherjee
New Delhi-110067
India
Fax: +91-11-26704312
Website: http://www.jnu.ac.in/Faculty/smukherjee
1
ABSTRACT
Common crustal igneous and high grade metamorphic rocks contain peroxy defects which
remain dormant until the rock experiences stress upon deformation. Stress activated peroxy
defects form highly reactive oxygen species (ROS) at the rock-water interface observed in
both terrestrial and extraterrestrial rock samples. The ROS complex is formed upon rock fluid
interaction when groundwater combines with the ROS to produce hydrogen peroxide giving
an indirect measure of the underlying rock stress and crustal deformation along active faults.
The average concentration of hydrogen peroxide from the Sohna thermal spring water falling
along the active Sohna fault and geothermal field was measured to be ~ 0.53 ± 0.014 mg/l.
Similar average concentration was also recorded from borewell sample north of the spring (~
0.56 ± 0.017 mg/l) within the same geothermal field. Lower concentration of hydrogen
peroxide was recorded within samples collected from hard rock aquifers outside the
geothermal field and the active fault zone (~0.138 ± 0.095 mg/l). The detailed analysis
suggests that the presence of hydrogen peroxide is largely dependent on the circulation
pattern through the interconnected fractures/joints within the quartzite bedrock lying adjacent
to the fault plane. Laboratory analysis results also show high hydrogen peroxide
concentration within two borewell samples falling adjacent to the epicentre of a shallow
microtremor event within the hard rock region falling alongside a lineament along the Delhi
hard rock mega fold. Rock water interaction post stress activation of peroxy defects and
formation of ROS has therefore been inferred to be responsible for the formation of hydrogen
peroxide at the rock water interface within these zones. This pilot study provides scientific
field evidence that hydrogen peroxide concentrations within groundwaters might offer
prospects for seismic stress estimation and crustal deformation along seismically active
zones.
2
Keywords: peroxy defects, positive hole, hydrogen peroxide, seismic stress, earthquake
1.0 Introduction
The build-up of tectonic stress leads to earthquakes upon crustal deformation (Chlieh et al.,
bedrocks along active fault zones and convergent plate boundaries have been under
consideration for detecting premonitory earthquake signals (Royden et al., 1997; Scheuber
and Gonzalez, 1999; Wang et al., 2001). Several case studies across the globe searching for
such premonitory signals for earthquake prediction have reported anomalous changes in the
concentration of terrestrial gases such as radon, helium, argon, hydrogen as well as ionic
concentrations of groundwater, springwater and soil air within seismically active regions
(Barberio et al., 2017; Igarashi et al., 1995; Inan et al., 2012; Hirose et al., 2011; Claesson et
al., 2004; Ghose et al., 1994; Skelton et al., 2014). An investigation correlating
hydrogeochemical changes within a tectonically active region thus can elucidate the link
between seismic stress and crustal rock deformation (Bolognesi, 1997; Andrén et al., 2016;
Observations report that during the process of igneous rock formation, water gets
incorporated into the rock’s mineral grains in the form of hydroxyl ions upon crystallisation
from water laden magmas, even within anhydrous mineral grains (Takeuchi et al., 2005).
Upon cooling, H2O gets incorporated into the anhydrous mineral grains (quartz, feldspars
etc.) into such an electronic rearrangement which enables a distribution of single OH-, OH-
pairs and sometimes larger OH- clusters. Further through redox conversion, peroxy links
(O3X-OO-XO3) are formed which are mostly found in all igneous and high grade
3
Where X,Y = Si4+, Al3+ etc
These peroxy links break when the rock experiences stress, upon which O2- coverts into O-.
This O- represents a hole or a defect electron in a matrix of O2- known as a positive hole (h•
or p-hole) (Freund and Sornette, 2007; Balk et al., 2009; Freund et al., 2006; Freund and
Freund, 2015). The transfer of charge takes place when a neighbouring electron from O2- fills
the hole, itself turning into O- (equation 2) leading to the breakage of peroxy links or positive
When igneous and high-grade metamorphic rocks experience stress due to crustal
deformation, activation of PHPs lead to the production of currents when positive charge
carriers flow from the stressed rock volume into the unstressed rock volume. The flow of
current rises with increase in stress on the unstressed rock volume (Freund and Sornette,
2007). Laboratory simulations have shown that these positive holes can travel along stress
gradients with speeds of ~100 m/s and over distances of meters. In the field, these positive
holes are estimated to propagate in kilometres causing the rock mass to transmit current and
behave like a battery (Freund et al., 2006; Freund and Freund; 2015; Freund, 2002; 2007;
Grant et al., 2011). Further, these simulations suggest that once the positive holes reach the
rock water interface, oxidation of water to hydrogen peroxide takes place when the circuit is
complete achieved by connecting a copper wire from the stressed end to the unstressed end of
the rock (Balk et al., 2009). When the potential difference is large the positive hole (h•) turns
into a highly reactive oxygen radical (•O chemically equivalent to O-) which oxidizes H2O to
4
O¯surface + H2O OH¯surface + •OH (4)
This H2O2 has been measured at nM scales in laboratory simulations involving the
application of stress through steel pistons on a block of Gabbro (Balk et al., 2009). It was
observed that the battery current started to flow as soon as a manually operated hydraulic
press was loaded onto the rock. The current increased rapidly reaching a maximum of ~10
nA at less than 20 MPa, corresponding to <10% of the compressive strength of the rock. The
ends of the rock mass were dipped in pools of water. Hydrogen Peroxide concentration was
measured upon the passage of current. It was inferred that the stressed rock volume behaves
as an anode from where h• charge carriers flow out (Balk et al., 2009). The concentration of
peroxy defects in typical rock-forming minerals and, hence, the number of h• charge carriers
in a given volume of rock, are still poorly understood but it is estimated that the average
peroxy concentration in igneous and high-grade metamorphic rocks is 100 ppm (Batllo et al.,
1990) with every km3 having the potential to produce about 1013 C km−3, equivalent to a
A study also reported the biogeochemical dark production of hydrogen peroxide in the
groundwaters of an alluvial aquifer adjacent to the Colorado River near Rifle, CO (Yuan et
al., 2017). In the study, the generation of highly reactive oxygen species (such as OH¯
radical) at the oxic anoxic boundaries was inferred to be associated with a cascade of redox
Studies have also shown that besides terrestrial rock samples, freshly crushed basaltic soil
and rock samples from Martian and lunar crusts formed highly reactive radical species on the
surfaces of the crushed samples once the rocks underwent severe mechanical stress upon
grinding (Balk et al., 2009). These radical species produced ROS such as hydrogen peroxide
5
(H2O2), hydroxyl radical (•OH) and superoxide ion (•O2-) once the crushed rock was
immersed in water (Hurowitz et al., 2007). Grant et al., 2011 also reported disappearance of
European toad species Bufo Bufo from their spring mating and spawning grounds five days
before the occurrence of a 6.3 L’Aquila earthquake in April, 2006. The toads reappeared only
after all the aftershocks ceased to occur after the primary earthquake. This behaviour was also
inferred to have occurred as the toads picked up these chemical clues such as release of H2O2
and other oxidized products from the water. Further, hydrogen gas production has been
associated with occurrence of small and large magnitude earthquakes (King, 1986; Sato,
1986) formed when freshly exposed rock surfaces react with water (Ito et al., 1999).
The present study was therefore conducted by sampling geothermal spring and hard rock
aquifers lying along fault zones and regions with microtremor epicentral clusters within
major fault intersection zone to search for presence and anomalous changes in hydrogen
peroxide concentration as an indirect measure of crustal deformation and rock stress. Further,
this study also attempts to validate through hydrochemical analysis of aquifers and spring
samples along faults and fracture zones that a fairly qualitative estimation of rock stress and
crustal deformation can be achieved by measuring the concentration of H2O2 and with other
physico-chemical parameters.
The study region is located within the states of Haryana and Delhi traversing along zones
with a dense network of small and large active faults, fractures and lineaments (Fig.1 & 2)
falling within seismic zone IV, categorized as high damage risk zone prone with the MSK
seismicity records indicate that the Mahendragarh Dehradun Subsurface Fault (MDSSF), axis
of Delhi-Sargodha Ridge (DSR) and Aravalli-Delhi Fold axis are seismically most active
6
zones within the north-western Indian region (Shukla et al., 2007, Prakash and Srivastava,
2012).
Fig. 1. Seismic Hazard map of Haryana and Delhi (Study area falls within seismic zone IV
7
Fig. 2. Study Area with sampling locations and prominent faults and lineaments (map
This seismicity is attributed to bending of the upper crust prior to underthrusting below the
Himalayas at the Eurasian and Indian convergent plate boundary (Molnar et al., 1973). The
seismic epicentral location maps of the region (Fig. 3) show that several clusters of
microtremor events ranging in magnitude between Mw 2-3 are located at the boundary of
Rohtak and Sonipat districts in Haryana as well as in some parts of the national capital region
of Delhi. The microtremor clusters for the seismic events occurring from 2000-2015 fall at
the intersection of the MDSSF and axis of DSR (Delhi Lahore Fault). These clusters indicate
8
that frequent microtremor events occur (< 3 magnitude) in this region which is mainly
Fig. 3. Seismicity of Delhi and adjoining areas during year 2000-2015 showing clustered
events along Mahendragarh-Dehradun Subsurface Fault (MDSSF) and Delhi Sargodha Ridge
(DSR): The spatial interpolation maps were prepared by Inverse Distance Weighted
The seismic microtremor clusters fall within two geomorphic zones consisting of a hard rock
region falling in the districts of Gurugram, Faridabad and a part of Delhi and within the
9
alluvial region falling in the districts of Rohtak, Sonipat and Jhajjhar. The geology of the area
occurrence of quartzites, schists, siliceous limestones, slates and phyllites (Cinti et al., 2009;
Singh, 1996).
The alluvial region comprises of polycyclic sequence of silt-clay with gravel and fine to
medium grained sand along with a few patches of aeolian windblown sand scattered within
the alluvial plain. The subsurface also contains a complex system of several interconnected
faults and lineaments as depicted in the geological map of the region (Fig. 4).
10
Fig. 5. Geomorphology of the hard rock region within the study area
The hard rock outcrop of the Delhi fold belt within the study area encompassing Delhi,
Gurugram and Faridabad districts contains numerous lineaments and fractures (Fig. 5). A
distinct N-S oriented seismogenic fault known as the Sohna fault associated with the
Himalayan orogenic movement runs from Sohna to the Delhi Ridge existing below the
alluvium in the vicinity of a thermal spring (Fig. 5 & 6) (Sharma et al., 2003).
11
Fig. 6. Study Area showing the epicentre locations along with major lineaments
The geothermal field and thermal spring fall within the tectonic depression formed by the
downward faulting of a central block lying between two anticlinal ridges belonging to the
Delhi belt. (Fig. 6).The spring is located at an altitude of ~200 m from the mean sea level at
the hinge region of the synformal fold within a tectonic depression (Pandey and Negi, 1995;
Thussu, 2001). The temperature data suggests that the geothermal field extends over an area
of ~3900 m2 (Deb and Ray, 1971). The water emanates out of a fissure within the Pre-
Cambrian quartzite bedrock. The region to the north and east of the spring is occupied by
alluvium whereas the southern and western parts are covered by Alwar Quartzite of the Delhi
supergroup. The alluvium on the east of the spring comprises of aquifers made up of sand
with some silt and clay. On the west of the spring the alluvium consists of gravel, sand, silt
and clay and is devoid of good aquifers (Fig. 7) (Deb and Ray, 1971).
12
Fig. 7. Geological Map of the region of Sohna thermal spring (box in inset)
The quartzites of the anticlinal ridges are highly jointed and compacted with the joints
occurring in two sets; one lying perpendicular to the bedding plane and the other lying
parallel. The unique pattern of joints within the bed rock gives rise to rectangular blocks of
quartzites providing passageways for the circulating water (Deb and Ray, 1971; Chaudhary et
al., 1996). The water table of the region follows the topography with the wells lying close to
the ridge to be of deeper origin. The fractures and joints within the quartzite bedrock
constitute the water bearing zone whereas the rest of the hard rock region has a poor capacity
The water circulation drains from the western alluvium travelling through the pattern of
fractures and joints till the hinge region after which it finally issues out through a fissure as a
spring (Fig. 8). The circulation pattern of the water therefore is inferred to be the main factor
13
Fig. 8. Generalized schematic representation of the hydrogeological setup and the thermal
spring water circulation (modified after Deb & Ray, 1971) along the segment A-B marked
in Fig. 7.
The quartzite bedrock of the geothermal field has a provenance dominated by evolved
granitic rocks and consists of intercalations of muscovite schist, kyanite schist and phyllite
(Tripathi and Rajamani, 2003). Quartzite is an intermediate to high grade metamorphic rock
formed when quartz-rich sandstone is exposed to high temperatures and pressures often along
quartz mineral (Chatterjee, 1974). Schist as well is produced by medium to high grade
metamorphism consisting of mineral grains of quartz, feldspar, muscovite, biotite and chlorite
(Tripathi and Rajamani, 2003). Phyllite, on the other hand is a fine grained, low grade
metamorphic rock composed of mineral grains of muscovite, chlorite, biotite along with
3.0 Methodology
3.1. Sampling
14
The investigation was initiated by surveying the region through maps (seismotectonic maps,
geological maps, geomorphological maps) depicting the features and terrain of the area in
order to delineate zones for collection of water samples. Representative samples were then
collected from aquifers at appropriate locations falling in the alluvial region within the
seismic epicentral clusters as well as the region falling within the Sohna geothermal field and
Sampling was done in the premonsoon season (April, 2015) as well in the postmonsoon
season (December, 2015) from borewells and handpumps. The polypropylene sampling
bottles were initially rinsed 2-3 times with the water being sampled. To get a fresh
representative sample of the aquifer, the handpumps were initially pumped for 50 strokes to
remove stagnant water within the iron pipes minimizing the impact of contamination. In case
of borewells, the water was allowed to run for approximately ten minutes before collecting
the sample. For the hard rock region outside the geothermal field, 16 groundwater samples
were collected in the premonsoon season and 27 samples were collected in the postmonsoon
season surrounding the Delhi Fold axis and the hard rock Aravalli outcrops at Sohna (Fig. 1).
Two samples each were collected from the geothermal spring water and the borewell 100 m
north of the spring. One sample each was also collected from the alluvium to the west and
east of the Sohna spring falling outside the geothermal field. In the alluvial region, 32
samples were collected in the premonsoon season and 20 samples were collected in the
postmonsoon season from the aquifers along the linear transect as well as within the zone of
the seismic epicentral clusters. Temperature, pH, Electrical Conductivity (EC) and Total
Dissolved Solids (TDS) measurements were done on field using thermometer and
samples collected for cation analysis were preserved using conc. HNO3 (pH<2). Post
collection, the samples were filtered using 0.45 μm millipore filter paper and stored at 4°C
15
until analysis was done. The location for each sampling point was recorded by Garmin global
positioning system (GPS) (Fig. 1). Thermal camera image of the exposed fractured hard rock
was captured by FLIR-Thermal Camera (Model C-2) to obtain the relative radiative
temperatures of the exposed hard rock. The samples for the analysis of hydrogen peroxide
concentration were collected in amber high density polypropylene (HDPE) bottles which
were kept airtight and immediately stored at 4°C after sample collection. Samples were
peroxide. Filtration of the collected samples was avoided to prevent exposure to light.
Samples were analysed for major ions (Na+, K+, Ca2+, Mg2+, HCO3-, SO42-, Cl-) and total Iron
and Silica in the laboratory using the standard methods (APHA, 1995) and methodology
outlined by Diatloff & Rengel, 2001. The methodology used as well as the detection limits
have been tabulated in supplementary table 5. Samples were analysed for sulphate and
hydrogen peroxide using UV/visible spectrophotometer (Lambda 35, Perkin Elmer); Sodium,
Potassium and Calcium using flame photometer (Elico CL-378); Magnesium and Iron using
Atomic Absorption Spectrometer and Chloride and Alkalinity (HCO3 + CO3) by titration
technique. The data generated from the analysis is tabulated in Supplementary tables 1-4.
The hydrogen peroxide concentration was measured the same day in the laboratory using a
simple and rapid spectrophotometric method based on the liberation of iodine in an acidic
medium (pH 2-3) equivalent to the hydrogen peroxide present in solution (equation 8) (Sunil
16
The method involves the liberation of iodine which bleaches the blue colour of toluidine blue
reagent (absorption maximum at 628 nm) into a colourless species. Standard stock solution of
hydrogen peroxide was prepared by dilution of 30% reagent grade hydrogen peroxide
14 μM were prepared by dilution of the stock solution which was standardized using
titrimetric method (Jeffery et al., 1995). Other reagents used for the analysis consisted of 2%
potassium iodide, 0.01% toluidine blue indicator, 2M hydrochloric acid and 2M sodium
acetate solution.
The standard curve was generated by measuring the absorbance values of solutions with
blank. The decrease in absorbance compared to the reagent blank is directly proportional to
The mineral phases of the rock and soil samples collected from the Sohna thermal spring site
were analysis using X-Ray Diffraction technique. The samples were crushed and grinded
using a pulveriser and passed through 200 μm mesh size. The samples were then loaded on
PANalytical X’Pert PRO. The generated data was processed on X’Pert HighScore Software
version 1.0a for identifying the mineralogical composition. The 2°Theta peaks of the XRD
The statistical summary of the physicochemical parameters analysed for the hard rock aquifer
samples and the alluvial aquifer samples in the premonsoon and postmonsoon season is
tabulated in Table 1.
17
Parameter Premonsoon (Hard- Postmonsoon Premonsoon Postmonsoon
Table. 1. Statistical summary of different physico-chemical parameters for the pre and
postmonsoon hard rock and alluvial aquifer samples (all concentration in ppm except
Based on the plots of major cations (Ca2+, Mg2+, Na+ and K+) and anions (HCO3-, Cl-, SO42-),
the hydrochemical facies of the groundwater was derived from piper trilinear diagrams for
both alluvial and hard rock aquifer samples (Fig. 9 a,b). In the premonsoon alluvial aquifer
samples, the groundwater type is of Ca-Mg-Cl and Ca-HCO3-Cl. In the postmonsoon alluvial
aquifer samples, the majority of the water type is of Ca-Na-HCO3-Cl type. For the
premonsoon and postmonsoon hard rock aquifer samples the water type is of Ca-Mg-Cl
whereas for the postmonsoon samples the major water type is Ca-Cl.
18
a Hard Rock b Hard Rock
Alluvium Alluvium
Fig. 9. a. Piper trilinear plot for pre-monsoon samples; b: piper trilinear plot for post-
monsoon samples
The thermal spring water is Ca-Cl water type with neutral in pH (~7) and a relatively high
salinity (~1300 μS.cm-1) which suggests a long circulation time. Among the alkali metals,
sodium is found to be the most abundant whereas calcium is dominant among the alkaline
earth metals. From the anions, bicarbonate and chloride are abundant. Although, the spring
water sample has no iron but the groundwater sample collected from the borewell just north
of the spring has high iron content (~5.4 mg/l) (Table 2). A comparative summary of the
hydrochemical constituents of the spring water sample and the borewell sample collected
~100 m north of the spring lying within the same geothermal field has been tabulated in
Table 2 along with the water constituents from the sample collected from the western and
eastern alluvial aquifers. The average concentration of hydrogen peroxide from the Sohna
thermal spring water falling along the active Sohna fault and geothermal field was measured
to be ~0.535 ± 0.014 mg/l. Lower concentration of hydrogen peroxide was recorded within
samples collected from hard rock aquifers outside the geothermal field (~0.138 ± 0.095 mg/l).
19
Sohna Tube-well water Tube well water Tube well water
pH 6.9 7 7 7.4
Table 2. Physicochemical parameters analysed for the Sohna thermal spring water,
tube well sample north of the spring and alluvium tube well water sample west and
east of the spring (Concentrations in mg/l except water type, EC (μS.cm-1), pH and
20
Fig. 10. Piper plot for the samples described in Table 2.
High Ca (131 mg/l) content was recorded within the spring water samples. The samples from
the alluvium west of the spring also had comparable calcium ion concentration as the spring
water (110 mg/l) whereas the eastern alluvium had a relatively higher calcium ion
concentration (~279 mg/l) as compared to the spring water. The Mg and Cl ion
concentrations also show comparable values as the western alluvial aquifer sample (Table 2).
Piper plot in fig. 10 shows that the western alluvial sample has similar water facies as
compared to the eastern alluvium sample further validating that the spring water sample is
derived from the western alluvium as previously observed (Thussu, 2001). Therefore, the
spring water is inferred to be derived from the western alluvial aquifers. Mixing of shallow
water with hot water during discharge has not been suggested as there are no shallow aquifers
reported within the region. High noble gas concentration such as Helium (4He) was reported
at the Sohna spring produced from α-decay of natural Uranium and Thorium by Cinti et al.,
2009. The high helium and high salinity indicates a very long residence time as well as fault
activity within the crust. The hydrochemical parameters suggest that the water from the
21
alluvium west of the spring seeps into the ground and enters the hard rock fractures and
joints. At a depth of ~ 915 m, the water starts moving upward through the joints and fractures
finally issuing out from the hinge region of the synformal fold (Fig. 8). This suggests that the
changes in the hydrochemical properties are largely dependent on the circulation pattern of
the water through the interconnected fractures within the bedrock lying along the active
Sohna fault.
4.4 Evidence of hydrogen peroxide and hydrogen gas production at rock water interface
The interaction of water with the stressed rock volume at the rock-water interface is
considered key to the production of hydrogen peroxide. Laboratory simulations have shown
that at the rock water boundary, the p-hole (O¯) turns into a highly reactive oxygen species
(ROS) in the form of •O radical which converts H2O into H2O2 (Balk et al., 2009). According
to the reaction, for every two positive holes, one H2O2 molecule is formed. The closure of the
battery circuit in the lab simulation was achieved by joining the stressed rock end to the
unstressed rock end through a copper wire. In the field, the closure of the circuit can be
achieved by the electrolytical conductivity of water across the rockbed which is represented
here by the hard rock aquifer such as the Sohna geothermal aquifer. The concentration of
hydrogen peroxide in the water samples collected from the spring and from the borewell
north of the spring was the highest as compared to the groundwater samples collected from
the western and eastern alluvium as well as from the surrounding hard rock aquifers (Table
1,2).
Apart from the stress activation of peroxy links and migration of positive holes within
crystalline oxides and silicates, evidence also suggests that redox reactions involving the
splitting off of H2 to form peroxy anions occur within fused silica wherein O3SiOH pairs are
converted into H2 and peroxy links (O3Si – OO –SiO3) (Kita et al., 1982). Molecular
22
hydrogen (H2) production also takes place due to charge transfer conversion of Si-OH pairs
This hydrogen production has been evidenced to be frictionally driven during rock fracturing
associated with cataclastic rock (McMahon et al., 2016). Preseismic increases in H2 gas
associated with nucleation process of stress-corrosion mechanism have been reported within
a deep Nagashima well along the active Yoro-Ise Bay fault zone (Ito et al., 1999). It has been
reported that hydrogen gas generation increases with high frictional work associated with
even small magnitude earthquakes (M<3) (Hirose et al., 2011; Ito et al., 1999; King, 1986;
Sato, 1986). Laboratory experiments have shown that hydrogen gas is generated when freshly
pulverized rocks react with water suggesting that exposed mineral surfaces formed by
tectonic crustal deformation react with groundwater releasing H2 (Sugisaki et al., 1983).
Detailed studies validate that the anomalous increase in hydrogen content associated with
seismic events is the result of the reaction between groundwater and Si and Si-O radicals post
rock rupture along the active fault plane (Kravtsov and Fridman, 1974; Mazor, 1991).
Further, the same mechanism is reported to form hydrogen peroxide along active faults when
High concentration of dissolved hydrogen (0.188 cm3 STP/l) was reported in the Sohna
spring water samples by Cinti et al., 2009. Therefore a longer circulation time of geothermal
water through the interconnected fractures within the stressed quartzite bedrock and the
simultaneous occurrence of small magnitude earthquakes could possibly lead to the observed
increase in the dissolved hydrogen content. Thermal camera images of the exposed hard rock
from the region show that the fractures/joints have higher internal radiative temperatures as
compared to the rest of the rock volume (Fig. 11 a & b) which suggests internal heat
production possibly from frictional work acting along the fracture planes.
23
Fig. 11. (a) Camera image of the exposed quartzite hard rock near the geothermal spring at
28.244°N, 77.065 °E; (b) Thermal camera image of the region in (a) showing higher
radiative internal temperatures at the fractures planes (black arrows); white circle (lower
left corner) depicts freshly exposed rock having highest temperatures in the field of view of
Alternatively, study discussing the dark production of hydrogen peroxide in the alluvial
aquifer of Rifle, CO suggests that the production of hydrogen peroxide is highly spatially
oxidation of organic matter and cycling of metal species (e.g. Iron) through a series of redox
reactions (Yuan et al., 2017). The absence of Iron species in the thermal spring water sample
suggests that the interconversion of Fe2+ to Fe3+ is not responsible for the generation of
hydrogen peroxide in the spring water samples. The production of hydrogen peroxide in the
Sohna spring water sample therefore seems to be dependent on the conversion of ROS
species (O-) produced through the transfer of stress activated p-holes within the subsurface
rock.
A study by Borda et al. 2003 describes the production of hydrogen peroxide upon addition of
pyrite (FeS2) to deoxygenated water. The production of hydrogen peroxide is initiated by the
24
the generation of a hydroxyl radical with a correspondingly high concentration of sulfate
(SO42-). In order to assess whether this process is active in the Sohna spring site, the mineral
Fig. 12 a and b shows the XRD diffractogram of the rock sample analysis and nearby soil
25
Fig. 12 a. Hard rock sediment XRD and b. XRD diffractogram of nearby soil sediments of
The peaks seen in this XRD diffractogram show that the prominent minerals consist of
Quartz and Calcite with traces of chromium in the rock sample analysis (Supplementary
Table 6).
According to the d-spacing value, other minor minerals were also identified by soil sediment
analysis of the region. The minerals were identified based on the d-spacing values at °2theta
(Supplementary Table 7). In both the XRD data for rock and soil sample analysis shown
above, Pyrite (FeS2) has not been detected in the mineral composition. Therefore the role of
pyrite and the reduction of Fe(III) to Fe(II) leading to the production of hydroxyl ion might
not be a significant contributor of hydrogen peroxide in the groundwater in this study. Also,
if Iron reduction was playing a role in the production of hydroxyl radical then Iron would
have been detected in the total iron concentration in the spring water samples.
Further, if the process of the formation of hydroxyl radical on pyrite surfaces is the dominant
process leading to the formation of hydrogen peroxide, then sulphate concentration would be
higher in the geothermal samples as compared to the western alluvial aquifer. To discount the
26
role of pyrite and redox conversion of Iron as the source of hydrogen peroxide production, we
analysed the sulfate ion concentrations (based on chloride to sulphate ratio (Cl/SO4 ratio)).
The obtained ratios showed that the western alluvial aquifer sample showed sulphate
enrichment relative to seawater (Cl/SO4 ~ 4). The ratio for the Sohna thermal spring samples
showed slight enrichment (Cl/SO4 ~ 6) whereas the eastern alluvial aquifer showed a ratio
similar to that of seawater (Cl/SO4 ~ 7). This indicates that the sulphate concentration in the
groundwater samples from the western alluvial aquifer is higher than the spring and the
borewell samples north of the geothermal aquifer. Therefore, the hydrogen peroxide
concentration having being higher in the spring water samples indicates that the process of
All the physico-chemical analysis and seismic data point at two important deductions, one
that the region experiences continuous minor crustal deformation and therefore seismic stress
is active as seen from the frequent microtremor activity. Secondly, comparatively higher
with this crustal deformation and stress build-up activating the peroxy defects within the
bedrock along the fault zone. The hydrogen gas and hydrogen peroxide production both are
inferred to be the result of rock water interaction taking place due to constant availability of
freshly exposed rock surface for aqueous chemical interaction along the active fault zone.
The physico-chemical properties and the long circulation time through the interconnected
fractures, both suggest that the presence of hydrogen peroxide within the geothermal waters
can be attributed to the stress activation of positive holes taking place upon rock deformation
The spatial distribution map of hydrogen peroxide concentration was prepared for the study
region in the premonsoon season (April, 2015) in order to observe correlation with the
27
distribution of hydrogen peroxide and microtremor activity. The spatial interpolation map for
the alluvial region showed that the region with high peroxide concentration falls adjacent to
the intersection zones of MDSSF, DSR and a lineament running NE-SW (Fig. 13a).
According to the laboratory simulations, it was inferred that the stress activated charge
carriers can travel distances of kilometres in the field therefore any major seismic event in the
far field Himalayan tectonic convergent boundary can activate the faults such as the MDSSF
leading to observed changes within the seismic zones of the study region. The distribution of
hydrogen peroxide concentration ranges from 0-1 ppm in the premonsoon season. Further a
region falling adjacent to the Delhi mega fold having a distinct lineament along which the
epicentre of a microtremor event was recorded on 13th April, 2015 with a magnitude of 2.1
also shows high concentration of hydrogen peroxide within the samples collected on April
26th, 2015 from the aquifers adjacent to the epicentre (Fig. 13b).
28
Fig. 13. Premonsoon spatial distribution of hydrogen peroxide concentration; a, magnified
image of the region with high peroxide ion concentrations; b. Part of Delhi mega fold hard
rock region showing high hydrogen peroxide concentration within the aquifers adjacent to the
The region close to the thermal spring water along the active Sohna fault also shows
build up and the seismic swarms in these zones correlate positively with the high hydrogen
peroxide concentration. The frequent microtremor activity leads to crustal deformation post
29
stress build up intermittently when movement occurs along one or more faults and fractures
5.0 Conclusion
The findings of this study support that reactive oxygen species potentially result from
deformation of mineral defects from seismic stress and can be potential indicators of seismic
monitoring of hydrogen peroxide concentration within the geothermal field over extended
periods of time should therefore be undertaken to monitor rock stress and the associated
earthquakes.
Geothermal zones lying along active faults or deep hard rock aquifers can be explored in
concentration of hydrogen peroxide within geothermal waters especially springs falling along
active fault boundaries, the estimation of seismic stress can possibly be achieved. Accurate
and timely estimation of this indirect measure of seismic stress would require continuous
monitoring of groundwater chemical properties. This can further be employed for devising
models for early warning system for disaster preparedness and reduction.
Author Contributions
P.S. has prepared the final manuscript and conducted the field work and data analysis. S.M.
Competing Interests
30
References
1. Andrén, M., Stockmann, G., Skelton, A., Sturkell, E., Mörth, C., Guðrúnardóttir, H.R.,
Keller, N.S., Odling, N., Dahrén, B., Broman, C., Balic-Zunic, T., Hjartarson, H.,
Siegmund, H., Freund, F. and Kockum, I. (2016) Coupling between mineral reactions,
2. APHA (1995) Standard methods for the examinations of water and waste water (19th
relation to the aquifer disposition: A case study from Gurgaon-Sohna Region, Haryana.
4. Balk, M, Bose, M., Ertem, G., Rogoff, D.A., Rothschild, L.J. and Freund, F.T. (2009)
activated electric current in rocks. Earth and Plan. Sc. Letters. 283, 87-92.
doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2009.03.044.
5. Barberio, M.D., Barbieri, M., Billi, A., Doglioni, C. And Petitta, M. (2017).
Hydrochemical changes before and during the 2016 Amatrice-Norcia seismic sequence
6. Batllo, F., LeRoy, R.C., Parvin, K., Freund, F., (1990). Dissociation of O22− defects into
the composition of thermal waters on Vulcano Island, Italy. Geothermics, 26(3), 379-
392.
31
8. Borda, M.J., Elsetinow, A.R., Strongin, D.R. and Schoonen, M.A. (2003). A
mechanism for the production o hydroxyl radical at surface defect sites on pyrite.
10. Chaudhary, B.S., Kumar, M., Roy, A.K. and Ruhal, D.S. (1996) Application of Remote
11. Chlieh,M., De Chabalier, J.B., Ruegg, J.C., Armijo, R., Dmowska, R., Campos, J. And
Feigl, K.L. (2004). Crustal deformation and fault slip during the seismic cycle in the
North Chile subduction zone, from GPS and InSAR observations. Geophysical Journal
12. Cinti, D., Voltattorni, N., Quattrocchi, F. and Walia, V. (2009) Geochemistry of
thermal waters along fault segments in the Beas and Parvati valleys (north-west
Himalaya, Himachal Pradesh) and in the Sohna town (Haryana), India. Geochemical
13. Claesson, L., Skelton, A., Graham, C., Dietl, C., Mörth, M., Torssander, P. and
14. Dasgupta, S., Pande, P. et al. 2000. Seismotectonic Atlas of India and its Environs.
15. Deb, S. and Ray, D.K. (1971) Study on the Origin of Sohna Thermal Spring in Gurgaon
32
16. Freund, F. (1985) Conversion of dissolved ‘‘water’’ into molecular hydrogen and
3093(85)90288-1.
17. Freund, F. (2002) Charge generation and propagation in igneous rocks. Journal of
19. Freund, F. and Freund, M.M. (2015) Paradox of peroxy defects and positive holes in
rocks. Part I: Effect of Temperature. Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 114, 373-383.
20. Freund, F.T. and Sornette, D., (2007). Electromagnetic earthquake bursts and critical
21. Freund, F.T., Takeuchi, A. and Lau, B.W.S. (2006) Electric currents streaming out of
22. Ghose D., Das, N. K., Sinha, B., Das, S.K. and Chatterjee, S.D. (1994) Heat and
Helium release from thermal springs and influence of volcanic eruption. Proc. India
23. Gibbs, R. J. (1970). Mechanisms controlling world water chemistry. Science Journal,
170, 795–840.
24. Grant, R.A., Halliday, T., Balderer, W.P., Leuenberger, F., Newcomer, M., Cyr., G.
And Freund, F.T. (2011) Groundwater chemistry changes before major earthquakes and
its possible effects on animals. Int. J. Environ Res. Public Health, 8(6), 1936-1956.
25. Hamling, I.J., D’Anastasio, E., Wallace, L.M., Ellis, S., Motagh, M., Samsonov, S.,
Palmer, N. and Hreinsdóttir. (2014). Crustal deformation and stress transfer during a
propagating earthquake sequence: The 2013 Cook Straight sequence, central New
33
Zealand. Jour. of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 119(7), 6080-6092.
doi:10.1002/2014JB011084.
26. Hirose, T., Kawagucci, S. and Suzuki, K. (2011) Mechanoradical H2 generation during
27. Hurowitz, J.A., Tosca, N.J., McLennan, S.M. and Schoonen, A.A. (2007) Production of
hydrogen peroxide in Martian and lunar soils. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 255,
41-52.
28. Igarashi, G., Saeki, S., Takahata, N., Sumikawa, K., Sasaki, Y., Takahashi, M. And
Sano, Y. (1995). Groundwater Radon anomaly before the Kobe earthquake in Japan.
29. Inan, S., Balderer, W.P., Leuenberger-west, F., Yakan,H., Özvan,A. and Freund, F.T.
30. Ito, T., Nagamine, K., Yamamoto, K., Adachi, M. and Kawabe, I. (1999) Preseismic
31. Jeffery, G.H., Bassett, J., Mendham, J. and Denney, R.C. (1995) Vogel’s textbook of
33. Kita, I., Matsuo, S. and Wakita, H. (1982) H2 generation by reaction between H2O and
Crushed Rock: An experimental study on H2 Degassing from the Active Fault zone.
34
34. Kravtsov, A. I. and Fridman, A. I. (1974) Geology and geochemistry of natural gases in
the vicinity of deep faults and earthquake prediction. Search for Earthquake Precursors
35. Lindholm, R. C. (1987). A Practical Approach to Sedimentology. Allen & Unwin (New
36. Mazor, E. (1991) Applied Chemical and Isotopic Groundwater Hydrology. Halsted
37. McMahon, S., Parnell, J. and Blamey, N.J. (2016) Evidence for seismogenic hydrogen
gas, a potential microbial energy source on Earth and Mars. Astrobiology, 16 (9), 690-
702.
38. Molnar, P. and Lyon-Caen, H. (1989). Fault plane solutions of earthquakes and active
tectonics of the Tibetan Plateau and its margins. Geophys. J. Int., 99, 123-153.
doi:10.1111/j.1365-246X.1989.tb02020.x.
39. Pandey, O. P. and Negi, J. G. (1995) Geothermal fields of India: a latest update. Proc.
40. Prakash, R., and Shrivastava, J. P. (2012). A review of the seismicity and
41. Royden, L.H., Burchfiel, B.C., King, R.W., Wang, E., Chen, Z., Shen, F. and Liu, Y.
(1997).Surface deformation and lower crustal flow in Eastern Tibet. Science, 276
42. Sato, M. (1986) Hydrogen along the San Andreas and Calaveras Faults in Central
magmatic arc of the north Chilean Coatal Cordillera (22°-26°S): A story of crustal
35
deformation along a convergent plate boundary. Tectonics, 18(5), 895-910,
doi:10.1029/1999TC900024
44. Sharma, M. L., Wason, H. R. and Dimri, R. (2003) Seismic zonation of the Delhi
region for bedrock ground motion. Pure Appl. Geophys. 160, 2381–2398.
45. Shukla, A.K., Prakash, R., Singh, R.K., Mishra, P.S. and Bhatnagar, A.K. (2007).
46. Singh, A. (1996) Study of subsurface isotherm, Sohna hot spring area, Gurgaon
District, Haryana. Geoth. Energy in India, Geol. Survey of India Special Publication,
45.
47. Skelton, A., Andrén, M., Kristmannsdóttir,H., Stockmann, G., Mörth, C.,
Sveinbjörnsdóttir, Á., Jónsson, S., Sturkell, E., Guðrúnardóttir, H.R., Hjartarson, H.,
48. Sugisaki, R, Ido, M., Takeda, H., Isobe, Y., Hayashi, Y., Nakamura, N. Satake, H. And
Mizutani, Y. (1983) Origin of Hydrogen and carbon dioxide in fault gases and its
peroxide in water and cream samples. Bull Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 81, 422-426,
doi:10.1007/s00128-008-9477-7.
50. Takeuchi, A. Lau, B.W.S. and Freund, F.T. (2005) Current and surface potential
51. Thussu, J.L. (2001) Origin of Quaternary Basin of Sohna Valley, Southeastern
36
52. Tripathi, J.K. and Rajamani, V. (2003) Geochemistry of Proterozoic Delhi quartzites:
Implications for the provenance and source area weathering. Journal of the Geological
53. Wang, Qi, Zhang, P., Freymueller, J.T., Bilham, R., Larson, K.M., Lai, X., You, X.,
Niu, Z., Wu, J., Li, Y., Liu, J., Yan, Z. and Chen, Q. (2001). Present-Day crustal
54. Wästeby,N., Skelton, A.,Tollefsen, E., Andrén, M., Stockmann, G., Liljedahl, L.C.,
55. White, D., Hem, John D. and Waring, G.A. (1963). Chemical composition of
56. Yuan, X., Nico, P.S., Williams, K.H., Hobson, C and Davis, J.A. (2017). Hydrogen
doi:10.1021/acs.est.6b04803.
37
Author Contribution
P.S. has prepared the final manuscript and conducted the field work and data analysis. S.M.
38