Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Air Pollution Control by NTP
Air Pollution Control by NTP
200710067
Key words Non-thermal plasma, air pollution control, dielectric barrier discharge.
PACS 92.60.Sz, 52.40.Hf, 52.80.Hc, 88.33.Xj
The following paper presents some applications of air pollution control. After a brief introduction into recently
developed methods different reactor configurations on the basis of dielectric barrier discharges (DBDs) are
displayed. A preferred system for the treatment of soot comprises a reactor based on dielectric barrier discharge,
which combines both plasma and filter techniques. The special DBD-configuration consists of two electrodes.
One is porous and gas-permeable. The other reactor systems are a surface discharge DBD-system, deflector
arrangement and an ion extraction system. In a first application of these systems the elimination or reduction of
odours in the process of fabricating French fries was tested. Examples for the decomposition of vegetable oil
and the antimicrobial treatment of air.
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1 Introduction
Today the world is faced by several environmental problems. There is an urgent need to reduce pollutions caused
by gas emissions. Pollutants are e.g.: coal-, oil- and gas-burning electric power generating plants, diesel en-
gines, motor vehicles and chemical production plants. Besides gaseous components like VOC (volatile organic
compounds) there are harmful ultra fine particles or aerosols, sometimes substances with disagreeable smells.
Additionally, polluted air contains toxic substances. Increasingly stringent emission legislations are in progress
to cut down the emission of harmful substances significantly. Non-thermal plasma (NTP) techniques offer an
innovative approach to the solution of some environmental problems. In NTPs temperature differs substantially
between the electrons and other particles (ions, atoms, molecules). The electric energy is supplied only to charged
particles, mainly electrons (T ≈ 10.000 K), whereas the neutral gas molecules remain almost cold (room tem-
perature). In this case an NTP also refers to as non-equilibrium plasma or cold plasma. A strong electric field
causes ionization of an air stream and the formation of ions and radicals. These highly reactive species can lead
to partial or total oxidation of air pollutants. Since the typical concentration range of the pollutants is mostly in
the order of several hundred parts per million (ppm), direct interactions between the electrons and pollutants can
usually be neglected. Examples for NTP applications are air-pollution control systems, electrostatic precipitation,
sterilization, and water treatment [1-3].
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Contrib. Plasma Phys. 47, No. 7 (2007) / www.cpp-journal.org 521
One of the most important applications of non-thermal plasma is the corona discharge. This type of discharge is
applied in electrostatic precipitators for aerosol removal. Originally it was demonstrated by Cottrell in a large-
scale application for the collection of sulphuric acid mist [30]. Meanwhile large-scale facilities of pulsed corona
processing for industrial incinerators or collecting fly ash from a pulverized coal-fired power plant are state of
the art. Typical electrostatic precipitator configurations are wire electrodes centred in cylinders or wires mounted
in the centre between parallel plates forming ducts as seen in Fig.1. High voltage electrodes can be shaped in
a multi-pin configuration. The discharge electrodes contain parts with small radius of curvature or sharp edges
which cause locally high electric fields to enable corona discharge. Typical electrode plate distances are 0.2 - 0.4
m, the applied negative voltage can reach 50-110 kV.
The corona discharge can be characterised by a weak glow in the high field region of the discharge electrode.
Depending on the discharge conditions the breakdown is accompanied by streamer propagation towards the other
electrode. In the ”active” region the electrons, positive and negative ions are generated. Other advantageous types
of discharge reactors for environmental applications are dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) implementations. A
DBD consists of two electrodes with at least one insulating layer as a dielectric barrier in between (see Fig. 2a).
The dielectric barrier inhibits the flow of direct current. In the history of plasma physics there have been different
researches on the field of barrier discharge: plasmachemical applications, partial discharges, plasma display
discharges and excimer radiation sources. Several groups reported about a variety of appearances concerning
the spatial structure of the DBD. Due to the extent of possibilities of configurations and discharge parameters,
different terms are often used for the same type of discharge. Concerning the properties of the discharge, there is
www.cpp-journal.org
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
522 S. Müller and R.-J. Zahn: Air pollution control by non-thermal plasma
a rather complicated connection between the parameters. Furthermore different names for the DBDs result from
the obviously varying visible appearance. The DBD is known as barrier discharge, silent discharge, ac-discharge,
normal pressure glow discharge, ozonizer discharge and display discharge. The DBD stands out by the fact that
it can be operated in a wide range of pressure (mbar up to atmospheric pressure); the electrode distance reaches
from tenth of a mm up to a couple of millimeters. Generally the DBD can be operated with sine wave or square
wave alternating voltages in the frequency range of some Hz up to some 100 kHz. An example of the computed
pulsed current and corresponding electric field in the discharge gap for air is given in Fig. 3. There is a strong
growing electric field towards the cathode [31]. The results of numerical simulation indicate a high electric field
around the cathode due to field distortion by space charges. Here the space charge movement is the reason for
the fast discharge development.
Fig. 2 (a) Common dielectric barrier discharge configurations, (b) surface discharge configuration, (c) schema of a dielectric
pellet packed-bed reactor.
a) b)
Fig. 3 Examples of computed pulsed current and corresponding electric field for a gap of 1 mm (Uc = cell voltage, I =
discharge current, E = electric field).
Meanwhile a lot of different special reactor configurations were developed and tested on the basis of DBD for
the plasma production. In an arrangement where one electrode is positioned on top of a dielectric while the
second one is on its reverse side, there is a so-called surface discharge (SD)-DBD (see Fig. 2b). In another
arrangement the second electrode is part of a coplanar electrode system where both electrodes are at the same
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cpp-journal.org
Contrib. Plasma Phys. 47, No. 7 (2007) / www.cpp-journal.org 523
side (at least one electrode is covered by a dielectric). A survey on the peculiarities of DBDs and some results
of properties in extended coplanar electrode systems are given e.g. in [32, 33]. In addition to the configurations
above the dielectric pellet packed-bed reactors shown in Fig. 2c are established. It uses high permittivity dielectric
pellets which are held between a dielectric and two metal electrodes to which usually high voltage ac is applied.
Ferroelectric pellet packed-bed reactors were developed as a type of electrostatic precipitators and were found
to be effective not only in collecting particles but also for VOC decomposition and odour removal. The most
commonly used ferroelectric material is barium titanate. When the ferroelectric materials are exposed to an
external electric field the pellets are polarized and a high field is created at each contact point of the pellets.
This ends up in microdischarges at each pellet and in the vicinity. Packed-bed reactors can easily be modified to
incorporate a catalyst.
Fig. 4 Schema of the reactor configuration. Fig. 5 Photograph of scaled up reactor (active
length of channels - 28.5cm, diameter of the di-
electric barrier electrode - 4.2mm, width of the
honeycomb channels - 5.6mm).
www.cpp-journal.org
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
524 S. Müller and R.-J. Zahn: Air pollution control by non-thermal plasma
The performance of the reactor in the filtration efficiency is nearly the same as in the model of the honeycomb
filter elements without the inserted electrodes. The degree of soot reduction depends mainly on the pore size of
the ceramics. Normally the back pressure is rising without any cleaning or regeneration due to the collection of
particles. During plasma treatment the back pressure remains nearly constant. Like this a continuous regeneration
of the reactor can be achieved. Reaction products are CO and CO2 . The exhaust gas temperature averaged 190◦
C. In the majority of the experiments the diesel engine exhaust of a small emergency generator
(1 cylinder, 0.406 l) was used to accumulate soot. Usually DBDs do not show any noticeable gas heating effects.
Therefore we can conclude that the soot decomposition is achieved in a cold oxidation process. Thus soot is
constantly oxidised during all engine operation conditions and no filter regeneration by promoting the combustion
of the collected, particulate matter is necessary. Depending on the load of soot the process of treatment can be
controlled by the pulse break ratio of the sustaining voltage. Hence the dissipated power in the discharge can be
optimised in a simple way. Alongside the continuous operation of the reactor a plasma treatment can be chosen
from time to time depending on requirements of operation.
a) b)
Fig. 6 a) The regeneration of a loaded reactor in air, voltage amplitude 9.4kVptp 700µs on, 300µs off, b) Proportions of
carbon and oxygen during the ozone-oxygen treatment (XPS signal in counts per second).
The example in Fig. 6a shows the regeneration of a loaded reactor in air. The process is completed after a short
amount of time. In this case the pressure that is measured at the inlet remains almost constant after 30 min.
To get a better appreciation of oxidation mechanisms soot samples were analysed using X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy (XPS). In a first step soot was treated with an oxygen/ozone gas mixture. Previous results suggest
that the decomposition process with ozone is a process consisting of three-stages (soot* means decomposed soot)
[35, 36].
I. HC + O3 −− > products
The proposed reaction mechanism suggests furthermore that in the case of reaction II a soot-oxygen complex
was built (soot-O). So the ratio of carbon/oxygen should be changed. As expected from the equations above both
show an increase of the oxygen bound into the soot surface and a decrease of the carbon fraction (figure 6b). By
GC-MS tests we examined the PAH-16, coronene and other compounds. The PAH are reduced significantly by
the reactor from 21.38 µg/m3 down to <0.3 µg/m3 . Hence we assume that the PAH adsorbed on the soot are
removed, too.
Further developments of reactor configurations and methods
In further experiments we used four different plasma reactor arrangements. Mainly SD-DBD configurations with
structured electrodes were developed and tested.
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cpp-journal.org
Contrib. Plasma Phys. 47, No. 7 (2007) / www.cpp-journal.org 525
Fig. 7 Exploded view of stacked SD-DBD-configuration. Fig. 8 surface discharge configuration and Schema of dis-
charge arrangement grounded casing/extraction electrode .
Stacked SD-DBD-System
The special feature of this reactor configuration are structured electrodes arranged in a compact way. The struc-
tured electrodes are arranged alternating with flat disks from dielectric. Fig. 7 shows an exploded view of such a
stack configuration. An advantage is that there are no additional spacers necessary because the electrodes fulfill
this function likewise. The structured electrode in this example consists of woven wires of stainless steel with a
wire thickness of 0.5 mm and a mesh size of 0.8 mm. The dielectric barrier is formed by a composite material
of mica with a thickness of 1 mm. The stack is sealed on two opposite sides. This enables the working gas to
flow through the configuration in a specific direction. The gas gaps of the DBDs are formed by the exposed parts
of the wire mesh, the wave form of the woven wires and the round shape of the wires. The complete system is
mounted in a casing and embodies the plasma reactor. The stack planes of wire mesh are put on high voltage
potential or ground potential alternately. In this way gas discharges can be initiated between the structured elec-
trodes and the dielectrics with a suitable ac-voltage in the gas gaps. Furthermore the configuration permits the
filtration of aerosols and particles from the polluted gas stream, whereas the woven wire works as filter element.
Consequently the reactor combines both plasma and filter techniques. Apart from gaseous pollutions it is possible
to treat aerosols and particles with such a reactor configuration in the plasma. Another advantage of the open flow
structure is the low back pressure. We chose the following reactor sizes: depth of the electrodes (length in flow
direction) - 50 mm; width - 228 mm. A reactor was constructed with a stack of 150 active woven wire layers.
Realized with a compact design an active electrode area of 3.4 m2 is possible. A comparative large capacity of
the reactor of 25.3 nF is the outcome which is further increased in the treatment of waste air stream containing
aerosols.
Deflector SD-DBD-System
The feature of a second treatment system includes a DBD configuration with a deflection system. The waste
gas stream is directed onto the surface of a structured electrode arrangement by deflecting elements of dielectric
material. This causes an impact of gas molecules and aerosols on the surface of the electrodes, followed by a
deflection of the gas stream. The deflecting elements and the surface of the electrode arrangement cause a lot of
diversions of the gas on the way through the reactor. Accordingly the waste air stream often strikes the surfaces of
the plasma electrodes. The basic principle of the electrode system is similar to the adjustment above. A structured
electrode of woven wires is arranged on the surface of a flat disk from a dielectric and forms the gas treatment
side of the SD-DBD configuration. The flat disk from dielectric is mounted on the side wall of the casing. The
casing is made of stainless steel and forms the grounded electrode of the DBD. Seen fom the gas flow aspect the
gas back pressure of this system is rather low due to the open structure of the gas treatment flow path. In the
experiments we used a reactor with active areas of 485 cm2 on each side wall of the casing. Due to the numer-
ous impacts of the gas molecules and the aerosols at the active plasma electrodes an effective plasma treatment
of the waste gas can be realised. Reactive radicals as well as other plasma species contribute to the cleaning effect.
www.cpp-journal.org
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
526 S. Müller and R.-J. Zahn: Air pollution control by non-thermal plasma
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cpp-journal.org
Contrib. Plasma Phys. 47, No. 7 (2007) / www.cpp-journal.org 527
For additional investigations we introduced further plasma reactor configurations than described. Fig. 9 shows
results of the plasma treatment. The different plasma configurations are compared with the odour strength of
the raw gas and of the activated carbon filter. In the usual operation, where one of the electrodes is the high
voltage electrode and the other one is grounded, the odour reduction is not optimal. The waste gas is mostly
not in contact with the plasma part. Therefore this mode is predominantly applicable for reactions by long living
species like ozone. The waste air continuously flows through the pipe, but only the high voltage side is penetrated
by ions of both signs. In the mode of sine wave pulse voltages the odour reduction is nearly perfect. Due to the
grounded casing in front of the plasma electrodes positive or negative ions are extracted from the discharge side.
In this example positive ions are extracted on both sides of the mounted SD-DBD-system. By this potential
difference the ions penetrate the waste gas. We assume that the penetration of the waste air enables an efficient
decomposition mechanism of volatile organic compounds (VOC’s) by additional ion-molecule reactions. Further
investigations are necessary to clarify this point. The experiments showed a correlation of odour strength with
odourous compounds such as VOCs. The VOCs were identified mainly as aldehydes by using thermal desorption
GC/MS. The pre-filtration stage has no perfect efficiency in separation. Thereby, the waste gas comprises aerosols
apart from gaseous components. For the demonstration of the effect of the plasma with the ion extraction method
an aerosol stream was introduced into the reactor configuration (Fig. 10a-b). To make the process visible, sulfuric
acid was used. The SD-DBD is arranged on the left side, the aerosol beam is in the middle and the extraction
electrode is on the right side. A clear deflection of the aerosols is carried out in the on-state to the earthed
extraction electrode (Fig. 10b). The deflection demonstrates the charging of the aerosols by extracted ions.
a) b)
Ozone is considered to be an essential reactive species in plasma treatment of gases containing oxygen. Therefore
we tested the decomposition potential of vegetable oil by ozone in a separate experiment by a stacked SD-DBD.
The temporary behaviour of the decomposition process, the reaction products and the influence of the temperature
were measured. In Fig. 11 a result is given for temperature 180◦ C. The reaction products CO and CO2 can be
seen as a result of the decomposition process. The vegetable oil is oxidized in this case. The reaction rate depends
on the temperature and increases with rising temperature [35]. There is a similar result as in the case of the soot
decomposition [35, 36]. When introducing ozone the ozone concentration abruptly diminishes and the reaction
products CO and CO2 are produced. Both components show a fast peak and a subsequent decrease. After this
there follow a rise to a second maximum and a slow decay are scheduled. The temporal behaviour suggests that
the decomposition process is a three-stage process as can be seen in figure 11. A well scaled plasma system for
technical applications should be able to decompose oil aerosols as demonstrated. If the oil aerosol decomposition
is performed by pure ozone the temperature should be high enough for fast reactions. Another possible method
described above is the antimicrobial treatment of air. In this assembling a stacked SD-DBD-configuration was
used. The tests were carried out with Escherichia coli. The germs were given into liquid and then sprayed over
an air stream into the reactor. Results of microbiological tests are presented in Fig. 12. As one can see, there is a
reduction of the total number of microorganism in all samples. The best result is obtained by using 500 kHz with
7 log10 steps.
www.cpp-journal.org
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
528 S. Müller and R.-J. Zahn: Air pollution control by non-thermal plasma
5 Summary
Non-thermal plasma techniques offer an innovative approach for air pollution control. There are various devices
for non-equilibrium discharges and methods for pollution control. The most important applications of non-
thermal plasmas are the corona discharge and the dielectric barrier discharge. Advantageous and successful
implementations of non-thermal plasmas are oxidative decomposition of aromatic hydrocarbons, destruction of
hazardous waste, electrostatic precipitator applications, plasmachemical synthesis (ozone), removal of sulfur
dioxide and nitrogen oxides, decomposition of soot, reduction of odours, antimicrobial treatment of air. Different
reactor configurations were developed and tested for some arrangements.
References
[1] B.M. Penetrante, S.E. Schultheis, Proc. of NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Non-Thermal Plasma Techniques
for Pollution Control, Cambridge, Sept. 21-25, 1992, NATO ASI Series G: Ecological Sciences, 34 (1993).
[2] H.H. Kim, Plasma Process. Polym., 1(2004) (1991).
[3] K.H. Becker, U. Kogelschatz, K.H. Schoenbach, R.J. Barker, Non-Equilibrium Air Plasmas at Atmospheric Pressure,
Series in Plasma Physics, IOP Publishing Ltd 2005, Bristol and Philadelphia.
[4] A.G.Chmielewski, J. Licki, A. Pawelec et al., Radiation Physics and Chemistry 71, 441 (2004).
[5] J. Licki, A.G. Chmielewski, E. Iller et al., Applied Energy 75, 145 (2003).
[6] P.R. Chalise, Y. Wang, K.A. Mustafa et al., IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science 32, 1392 (2004).
[7] D.H. Han, T. Stuchinskaya, Y.S. Won et al. Radiation Physics and Chemistry 67, 51 (2003).
[8] W.J. Cooper, Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society 214,194-Phys Part (1997).
[9] U. Kogelschatz, Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 46, B63 (2004).
[10] E. Chan, M. Riley, M. J. Thomson, et al. ISIJ International 44 (2), 429 (2004).
[11] S.K. Nema, K. S. Ganeshprasad, Current Science 83 (3), 271 (2002).
[12] H.J. Hall, J. of Electrostatics 25 (1), 1 (1990).
[13] J.D. Bapat, J. of Hazardous Materials 81 (3), 285 (2001).
[14] G.J.J. Winands, K.P. Yan, A.J.M. Pemen et al., IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science 34 (5), 2426 (2006).
[15] G.J.J. Winands, Z. Liu, A.J.M. Pemen et al., J. of Physics D-Applied Physics 39 (14), 3010 (2006).
[16] T. Ohkubo, S. Kanazawa, Y. Nomoto et al., J. of Advanced Oxidation Technologies 8 (2), 218 (2005).
[17] K. Urashima, S.J. Kim, J.S. Chang, J. of Advanced Oxidation Technologies 6 (2), 123 (2003).
[18] G. Van Oost, C. Leys, M. Joos et al., Czechoslovak Journal of Physics 52, 784 (2002).
[19] B.M. Penetrante, J.N. Bardsley, M.C. Hsiao, Japanese J. of Applied Physics Part 1- Regular Papers Short Notes &
Review Papers 36 (7B), 5007 (1997).
[20] L.A. Rosocha, in Plasma Science and the Environment, W. Mannheimer, L.E. Sugiyama, T.H. Stix, Editors, Am. Institute
of Physics, Woodbury, New York, p. 261-298 (1997).
[21] S.L. Yao, E. Suzuki, A. Nakayama, J. of Hazardous Materials 83 (3), 237 (2001).
[22] Z. Machala, E. Marode, M. Morvova et al., Plasma Processes and Polymers 2 (3): 152 (2005).
[23] Z. Machala, E. Marode, C.O. Laux et al., J. of Advanced Oxidation Technologies 7 (2), 133 (2004).
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.cpp-journal.org
Contrib. Plasma Phys. 47, No. 7 (2007) / www.cpp-journal.org 529
[24] M.A. Wojtowicz, F.P. Miknis, R. W. Grimes et al., IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science 30 (4), 1587 (2002).
[25] U. Kogelschatz, Contributions to Plasma Physics 47, 80 (2007).
[26] R. Hippler, S. Pfau, M. Schmidt, K.H. Schoenbach, Low Temperature Plasma Physics Wiley-VCH-Verlag Berlin (2001).
[27] Z.H. Wang, J.H. Zhou, J.R. Fan et al., Energy & Fuels, 20, 2432 (2006).
[28] Y.S. Mok, H.J. Lee, Fuel Processing Technology, 87, 591 (2006).
[29] Y.S. Mok, E.Y. Yoon, Ozone-Science & Engineering, 28, 105 (2006).
[30] F.G. Cottrell, J. Ind. Eng. Chem. 3, 542 (1911).
[31] S. Müller and R.J. Zahn, 13th Intern. Sympos. on Plasma Chem. II, 731 (1997).
[32] G.J. Pietsch, Contrib. Plasma Phys. 41, 620 (2001).
[33] V.I. Gibalov, G. Pietsch, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 37, 2093 (2004).
[34] S. Müller, R.-J. Zahn, J. Grundmann and M. Langner, Plasma Treatment of Aerosols and Odours, 3rd International
Workshop on Microplasmas, Greifswald May 9 - 11, 2006, Proceedings IWM, p.121 (2006).
[35] J. Grundmann, S. Müller, R.-J. Zahn, Plasma Chem. Plasma Process., 25, 455 (2005).
[36] S. Müller, J. Conrads, W. Best, Int. Sympos. on High Pressure Low Temperature Plasma Chem., Contributed Papers 2,
340 (2000).
[37] J. Grundmann, S. Müller, R.-J. Zahn, A. Quade, H. Steffen, Topics in Catalysis, 42-43, 303 (2007).
[38] Th. Oppenländer, Photochemical Purification of Water and Air, Advanced Oxidation Processes (AOPs): Principles,
Reaction Mechanisms, Reactor Concepts, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (ISBN 3-527-30563-7) (2002).
www.cpp-journal.org
c 2007 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim