Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cognitive Behavior Therapy For Children and Adolescents
Cognitive Behavior Therapy For Children and Adolescents
Cognitive Behavior Therapy For Children and Adolescents
for
CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS
This page intentionally left blank
Cognitive-Behavior Therapy
for
CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS
Edited by
Washington, DC
London, England
Note: The authors have worked to ensure that all information in this book is accu-
rate at the time of publication and consistent with general psychiatric and medical
standards, and that information concerning drug dosages, schedules, and routes of
administration is accurate at the time of publication and consistent with standards
set by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the general medical community.
As medical research and practice continue to advance, however, therapeutic stan-
dards may change. Moreover, specific situations may require a specific therapeutic
response not included in this book. For these reasons and because human and me-
chanical errors sometimes occur, we recommend that readers follow the advice of
physicians directly involved in their care or the care of a member of their family.
Books published by American Psychiatric Publishing (APP) represent the findings,
conclusions, and views of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent
the policies and opinions of APP or the American Psychiatric Association.
To buy 25–99 copies of this or any other APP title at a 20% discount, please contact
Customer Service at appi@psych.org or 800-368-5777. To buy 100 or more copies
of the same title, please e-mail us at bulksales@psych.org for a price quote.
Copyright © 2012 American Psychiatric Association
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Manufactured in the United States of America on acid-free paper
15 14 13 12 11 5 4 3 2 1
First Edition
Typeset in Revival565 and Swis721.
American Psychiatric Publishing,
a Division of American Psychiatric Association
1000 Wilson Boulevard
Arlington, VA 22209-3901
www.appi.org
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Cognitive-behavior therapy for children and adolescents / edited by Eva Szigethy,
John R. Weisz, Robert L. Findling. — 1st ed.
p. ; cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-1-58562-406-5 (alk. paper)
I. Szigethy, Eva, 1962– II. Weisz, John R. III. Findling, Robert L. IV. American
Psychiatric Association.
[DNLM: 1. Cognitive Therapy. 2. Adolescent. 3. Child. 4. Mental Disorders—
psychology. 5. Mental Disorders—therapy. WS 350.6]
616.891425—dc23
2011039536
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A CIP record is available from the British Library.
Contents
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix
Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .xvii
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xix
DVD Contents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxiii
1 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy:
An Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Sarah Kate Bearman, Ph.D.
John R. Weisz, Ph.D., ABPP
2 Developmental Considerations
Across Childhood . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
Sarah A. Frankel, M.S.
Catherine M. Gallerani, M.S.
Judy Garber, Ph.D.
Appendix 2–A: Tools for Assessing
Developmental Skills . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .62
Appendix 2–B: Practical Recommendations
for Treatment Planning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .65
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .535
Contributors
Michael Ascher, M.D.
Resident in Psychiatry, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences,
Beth Israel Medical Center, New York, New York
ix
x Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Disclosures of Interest
The following contributors to this book have indicated a financial interest in or other
affiliation with a commercial supporter, a manufacturer of a commercial product, a
provider of a commercial service, a nongovernmental organization, and/or a govern-
ment agency, as listed below:
David A. Brent, M.D. Works for the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine
and University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Western Psychiatric Institute
and Clinic; Research support: National Institute of Mental Health; Royalties:
Guilford Press; UpToDate psychiatry section editor; Honoraria: presentations
for continuing medical education events
Judith A. Cohen, M.D. Research support: Annie E. Casey Foundation, National
Institute of Mental Health, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Ad-
ministration; Royalties: Guilford Press (books); Training contracts (includes
funds for travel): California Institute for Mental Health; Pennsylvania Depart-
ment of Mental Health; New York State Office of Mental Health
Mina K. Dulcan, M.D. Royalties: Books published by American Psychiatric Pub-
lishing
Robert L. Findling, M.D., M.B.A. Receives or has received research support,
acted as a consultant, and/or served on a speaker’s bureau for Abbott, Ad-
drenex, AstraZeneca, Biovail, Bristol-Myers Squibb, Forest, GlaxoSmith-
Kline, Johnson & Johnson, KemPharm, Lilly, Lundbeck, Neuropharm,
Novartis, Noven, Organon, Otsuka, Pfizer, Rhodes Pharmaceuticals, Sanofi-
Aventis, Schering-Plough, Seaside Therapeutics, Sepracore, Shire, Solvay,
Sunovion, Supernus Pharmaceuticals, Validus, and Wyeth
Mary A. Fristad, Ph.D., ABPP Royalties: MF-PEP and IF-PEP workbooks
(www.moodychildtherapy.com) and Psychotherapy for Children With Bipolar
and Depressive Disorders (Guilford Press)
Philip C. Kendall, Ph.D., ABPP Royalties (income) from sales of books and
treatment materials for the treatment of anxiety in youth
Fadi T. Maalouf, M.D. Speaker’s bureau: Eli Lilly
John S. March, M.D., M.P.H. Equity: MedAvante; Scientific Consulting Fees:
Johnson & Johnson, Lilly, Pfizer; Scientific Advisor: Alkermes, Attention
Therapeutics, Avanir, Lilly, Pfizer, Scion, Translational Venture Partners, LLC,
Vivus; Royalties: Guilford Press, MultiHealth Systems, Oxford University
Press; Research support: Child/Adolescent Anxiety Multimodal Study
(CAMS); Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Trials Network (CAPTN); K24;
National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia and Depression; Pfizer (prin-
cipal investigator); Pediatric OCD Study (POTS) I, II, Jr; Research Units on
Pediatric Psychopharmacology and Psychosocial Interventions (RUPP-PI);
Treatment for Adolescents with Depression Study (TADS)
Dana L. Rofey, Ph.D. Research support: National Institutes of Health
Moira A. Rynn, M.D. Research support: Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals,
National Institute of Mental Health, Neuropharm LTD, Pfizer; Royalties:
American Psychiatric Publishing
Eva Szigethy, M.D., Ph.D. Oakstone child psychiatry review video completed in
2010
Contributors xv
The following contributors to this book have indicated no competing interests to dis-
close during the year preceding manuscript submission:
Rachel E. Baden, M.A.; William Beardslee, M.D.; Sarah Kate Bearman, Ph.D.;
Ronette Blake, M.S.; Caroline L. Boxmeyer, Ph.D.; Douglas M. Brodman, M.A.;
Angel Caraballo, M.D.; Jeremy S. Cohen, M.A.; Patty Delaney, L.C.S.W.; Julie M.
Edmunds, M.A.; Benjamin W. Fields, Ph.D., M.Ed.; Rebecca Ford-Paz, Ph.D.;
Sarah A. Frankel, M.S.; Martin E. Franklin, Ph.D.; Jennifer Freeman, Ph.D.;
Patrick C. Friman, Ph.D.; Catherine M. Gallerani, M.S.; Gayle Y. Iwamasa, Ph.D.;
Audra Langley, Ph.D.; John Paul Legerski, Ph.D.; Laurie Reider Lewis, Psy.D.; John
E. Lochman, Ph.D., ABPP; Kelly A. O’Neil, M.A.; Jennifer E. Phillips, M.S.;
Nicole P. Powell, Ph.D.; Annie E. Rabinovitch, B.A.; Thomas M. Reimers, Ph.D.;
Jeffrey J. Sapyta, Ph.D.; Sarabjit Singh, M.D.; Rachel D. Thompson, M.A.; Susan
Turner, Psy.D.; John R. Weisz, Ph.D., ABPP
This page intentionally left blank
Foreword
xvii
xviii Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
number, structure, format, and content of sessions and when and how to
include parents. Chapter authors also discuss how developmental and cul-
tural factors may require special attention or adaptation of techniques.
One of the most interesting and useful sections of each chapter is how to
identify and address challenges and obstacles to treatment. A unique fea-
ture of this book is a DVD containing video vignettes (presented by actors
and actual therapists) that bring to life selected CBT techniques described
in the text.
This 13-chapter therapy manual begins with an introduction to CBT
with children and adolescents. A novel part of this chapter is a section de-
bunking common myths and misperceptions about CBT. The next chapter,
on developmental considerations, is coauthored by Judy Garber, Ph.D.,
noted expert in developmental psychopathology. Following a chapter on
aspects of therapy with culturally diverse youth, there is a unique chapter
on integrating CBT with psychopharmacology—a topic too often ignored.
The following chapters cover the range of disorders, with contributions by
many leading lights: David Brent, M.D., on depression and suicidal behav-
ior; Mary Fristad, Ph.D., on bipolar disorder; Philip Kendall, Ph.D., on the
use of Coping Cat for anxiety disorders; Judy Cohen, M.D., on posttrau-
matic stress disorder; John March, M.D., on obsessive-compulsive disor-
der; and John Lochman, Ph.D., on disruptive behavior disorders. In
addition, there are chapters on problems with physical manifestations: pe-
diatric chronic physical illness, with inflammatory bowel disease as a pro-
totype; obesity and depression, with a focus on polycystic ovary syndrome;
and enuresis and encopresis—notoriously difficult disorders to treat once
children become too old for star charts and simple behavioral pediatric in-
terventions.
Not only would this book, with its illustrative DVD, be a top choice
for individual practitioners in any mental health discipline who wish to ap-
ply CBT to children and adolescents, it would also be ideal for classroom
or seminar use with clinical students, residents, and fellows, especially in
programs that may lack faculty expertise in these techniques.
xix
xx Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
a fiscal impact in the form of decreased emergency room visits and hospi-
talizations. As a psychotherapy researcher, university professor, and Presi-
dent and Chief Executive Officer of the Judge Baker Children’s Center,
John Weisz, Ph.D., ABPP, has also seen the potency of CBT, both in ran-
domized effectiveness trials with clinicians in community clinics and in the
impact of CBT-enhanced school and outpatient programming at Judge
Baker. Robert Findling, M.D., M.B.A., a pediatrician, child psychiatrist,
medical school professor, and treatment researcher who directs a division
of child and adolescent psychiatry at an academic medical center, has re-
peatedly seen the practical obstacles to (as well as the feasible solutions
for) incorporating evidence-based treatments into routine clinical care.
This book was created to help fill the gap between clinical science and
clinical practice for children and adolescents by making CBT accessible
through the written word and companion videos. Our goal has been to pro-
vide a practical, easy-to-use guide to the theory and application of various
empirically supported CBT techniques for multiple disorders, written by
experts in CBT practice from around the world. These experts have pre-
sented core principles and procedures, clinical vignettes, source material
from their various workbooks, and video demonstrations of some of the
more challenging applications of CBT—including treatment of suicidality,
oppositional defiant disorder, obesity, and various anxiety disorders. An-
other unique feature of this book is the illustration of how CBT can be
used to treat psychological disorders in the context of chronic physical
conditions in children. The chapters are developmentally sensitive as well,
noting modifications needed to make the techniques applicable to differ-
ent age-groups and with differing levels of parental involvement. These
chapter features are complemented by introductory chapters on general
developmental consideration across CBT modalities, as well as cultural
and ethnic considerations. Finally, we have addressed the growing evidence
for the utility of CBT as a strategy for augmenting psychotropic medica-
tions, including some of the algorithms used to guide such augmentation.
The content has been designed to be user-friendly for clinicians across
different disciplines including pediatrics, psychiatry, psychology, and social
work. In addition, given the increased emphasis in graduate and profes-
sional training on achieving competence in psychotherapy during training,
the material was written to be accessible and useful to both trainees and
seasoned clinicians. We hope this resource will allow for the dissemination
of CBT-related expertise to clinicians in diverse treatment settings through-
out the world so that the children and adolescents with these disorders can
benefit from an approach to treatment that has such broad and growing
support from clinical scientists and practitioners.
Preface xxi
xxiii
This page intentionally left blank
1
Cognitive-Behavior
Therapy
An Introduction
Sarah Kate Bearman, Ph.D.
John R. Weisz, Ph.D., ABPP
1
2 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Coping With Depression Course); all are unified by the guiding belief that
an individual’s thoughts, behaviors, and emotions are inextricably linked
and that maladaptive cognitions and behaviors can produce psychosocial
dysfunction and impairment. Moreover, all CBTs approach cognitions and
behaviors as malleable agents of change through which client distress and
impairment may be alleviated. In this chapter, we will give a broad over-
view of key concepts shared across the various CBTs. Given that much of
CBT development has been focused on adults, the most influential theo-
ries and applications are reviewed by drawing from literature on both
adults and children, with some attention to animal studies as well.
Chapter 2 will review specific practical developmental considerations in
using CBT for children and adolescents.
A Brief History
Although the notion that individuals’ experience of the world is largely
shaped by their thoughts and behaviors predates the field of psychology, some
leaders in the field should be credited with laying the early foundation for
modern CBT. Particularly important theoretical precursors include Pavlov
(1927, 1928), whose experiments with animals using what is now known as
classical conditioning highlighted the relationship between prior experience
and involuntary responses, and Watson (1930), whose emphasis on the study
of observable behavior and the organism’s capacity to learn new behaviors
gave rise to learning theory. The more recent work of Skinner (1953) ex-
panded the scope of learning theory to encompass detailed analysis of rein-
forcement processes in operant conditioning. Learning theory arguably
established the ideological underpinnings of what would later be known as be-
havior therapy, with a number of notable contributors—among them Lazarus
(1971), London (1972), and Yates (1975)—and led to the understanding
that maladaptive behaviors are to a large degree acquired through learning. It
followed from this perspective that additional learning experiences might be
used to modify maladaptive behaviors and promote improved functioning.
An early adopter of this notion, Jones (1924) used the pairing of pleasant ex-
periences with feared stimuli to treat a child for a phobia.
The work of Wolpe (1958) is one of the best-known early comprehen-
sive approaches to the use of conditioning techniques in psychosocial in-
tervention. Building on his research with animals and counterconditioning,
Wolpe introduced the notion that anxiety in humans could be inhibited by
invoking an incompatible parasympathetic response, such as relaxation, as-
sertive responses, or sexual arousal. Likewise, the influential work of
Cognitive-Behavior Therapy: An Introduction 3
Negative beliefs
Bad grade on a test “I am not very “This class is stupid “I will never do well
smart.” and a waste of in school.”
my time.”
client to become more aware of the thoughts that preceded a change in af-
fect. Using a gentle questioning technique, the clinician would probe these
thoughts to better understand the underlying assumptions that led to the
thought. For example, a person who thinks “I failed a test” may have a
deeper belief that “Others will love me only if I am smart.” Once clients
became adept at noticing the occurrence of these rapid, involuntary, “au-
tomatic” thoughts, Beck encouraged them to question the validity and util-
ity of the cognition. Because these thoughts typically occur quickly and are
rarely examined for their veracity, much of the therapy involved helping
clients to consider how their thoughts may be inaccurate, unhelpful, or
distorted. In theory, once these thoughts were repeatedly challenged, a
gradual change in feelings and in behavior would result.
Simultaneous to the development of cognitive therapy, Ellis (1958,
1962) introduced rational emotive therapy (RET), later named rational
emotive behavior therapy. Much as in cognitive therapy, RET is predicated
on the belief that an individual’s feelings are largely determined not by the
objective conditions but by the way in which the individual views reality
through his or her language, evaluative beliefs, and philosophies about the
world, himself or herself, and others. Clients in RET learned to perceive
the relationship among thoughts, feelings, and behaviors using the A-B-C
model, in which activating events or antecedents (A) constitute the objec-
tive event that “triggers” the belief (B) about the meaning of the event.
When the beliefs are rigid, dysfunctional, and absolute, the consequence
(C) is likely to be self-defeating or destructive.
In contrast, beliefs about objective events that are flexible, reasonable, and
constructive are likely to lead to consequences that are helpful. Thus, in the
RET model, beliefs play a mediating role in the relation between events that
occur and the behavioral and emotional consequences. RET theory postulates
that most individuals have somewhat similar irrational beliefs and identifies
three major absolutes as particularly problematic: 1) “I must achieve well or
I am an inadequate person”; 2) “Other people must treat me fairly and well
or they are bad people”; and 3) “Conditions must be favorable or else my life
is rotten and I can’t stand it” (Ellis 1999). Although clients may not be com-
pletely aware of these beliefs in their totality, they are able to verbalize them
when queried and encouraged by the therapist—in other words, the beliefs
are not unconscious but may not have been examined or articulated fully.
In practice, clients in RET work with the therapist to identify the
A-B-C sequences in the client’s life that are leading to impairment and dis-
tress. The therapist then teaches the client to use a series of disputing
thoughts (D) to challenge or refute the dysfunctional belief. In particular,
RET emphasizes distinguishing between statements that are objectively
true and those that may be irrational. Once the belief has been refuted, a
Cognitive-Behavior Therapy: An Introduction 5
Beliefs Consequences
Antecedents “I’m not very smart.” Sad feelings
Bad grade on test “I will never do well Decreased effort
in school.” in school
more flexible, effective thought (E) is generated and used to replace the
original belief. RET holds that clients have an existential choice about
transforming their hopes, expectations, and preferences to absolutistic,
rigid demands that will lead to emotional and behavioral disturbances—or
conversely, seeing their hopes, expectations, and preferences as flexible
and consequently to act in a healthy, self-helping manner. Figure 1–2 pro-
vides an example of the A-B-C-D-E sequence.
Although the original iterations of both cognitive therapy and RET ex-
plicitly mentioned cognitive processes, later work by both Beck and Ellis
noted that cognition is a facet of behavior and that behavioral components
have always been present in both therapies. Indeed, in cognitive therapy,
efforts are continually made to test the veracity of clients’ beliefs by using
behavioral experiments. A client who feels rejected by a loved one may be
encouraged to pursue activities and relationships in order to receive dis-
confirming information regarding the maladaptive belief (Beck et al.
1979). Likewise, RET has historically made use of behavioral activities,
such as encouraging a client to do something he or she is afraid of doing, in
order to demonstrate the irrationality of certain beliefs (Ellis 1962). Both
the Beck and Ellis cognitive models, however, were developed in adults.
Another central figure in the development of modern CBT, Donald
Meichenbaum, focused on children as well as adults. Meichenbaum noted
that people’s self-statements, or verbalized instructions to themselves, of-
ten appeared to guide their behavior. Much of Meichenbaum’s work fo-
cused on impulsive and aggressive children, who used fewer helpful
instructional self-statements than less impulsive children (Meichenbaum
and Goodman 1969, 1971). Self-instructional training (SIT) grew from
these observations. In SIT, the therapist works with the client to reduce
6 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Common Principles
As we have noted, CBT is a broad category that includes various therapies
to address a range of disorders and problems, and it may emphasize differ-
ent techniques, modalities, and target populations. Despite this variety,
some common principles of CBT can be identified. We illustrate some of
these common principles by focusing on the case of Ellen.
Case Example
A 9-year-old girl, Ellen, was diagnosed with major depression and attention-
deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), combined type. When Ellen was
age 5, her mother was diagnosed with a serious illness at the same time that
Ellen started a stimulant medication to address symptoms of ADHD. Ellen
Cognitive-Behavior Therapy: An Introduction 7
had several side effects from the medication and became severely agitated
and aggressive at school when her mother was undergoing intensive treat-
ment and was largely unavailable; Ellen was briefly hospitalized. Following
the hospitalization, Ellen’s aggressive and agitated behavior subsided; how-
ever, because of her sensitivity to stimulant medication, she was not medi-
cated for ADHD symptoms. Ellen struggled in school, and although she was
bright, she did not achieve highly in academic situations and was moved to a
special education classroom to receive academic support. At the time that
Ellen came into treatment, she was experiencing an episode of major depres-
sion: she reported feeling sad and down more often than not, experienced
little pleasure from activities or events she once enjoyed, felt hopeless and
guilty, and had difficulty making decisions and concentrating. In the presence
of stressful situations, particularly in academic settings, Ellen would quickly
become tearful, stating “I can’t do this” or “No one will help me.” Behavior-
ally, she would often give up on the task, refuse to reattempt the task, and
withdraw. In the face of these behaviors, caregivers and teachers typically re-
acted with frustration, negative consequences, and finally resignation.
The CBT formulation of a case like Ellen’s would consider her biological and
medical vulnerabilities and earlier life experiences as contributing factors to
the development of a negative self-schema, through which Ellen now pro-
cesses new information and which becomes particularly activated during
times of stress. Experiences such as academic challenges remind Ellen of her
previous failures, confirm her beliefs that she is not capable of handling prob-
lems and that she cannot be helped, and lead to her acting-out and sullen be-
haviors. These behaviors are off-putting to adult figures and lead to negative
consequences, which further reinforce Ellen’s belief that she is helpless. Fig-
ure 1–3 provides an example of the form such a formulation might take.
another and with the maintaining factors. Although the CBT formulation
considers all of these components, the core elements of the client concep-
tualization are the cognitions and the behaviors. Changing these thoughts
and behaviors will be the focus of intervention.
Of course, there are some important exceptions. The past may become
central in treatment when the content of current thoughts and beliefs di-
rectly involves past events, as is often the case in the treatment of post-
traumatic stress disorder. However, even in these instances, the focus is on
changing current thinking about the past, or current behavior in the pres-
ence of memories, rather than a focus on the past per se.
Current stressors
Academic difficulties
Biological/genetic/
medical factors
ADHD and sensitivity to Symptoms of
stimulant medication
depression
Self-schema Sadness, anhedonia,
Life events “I am helpless.” guilt, indecision,
Mother’s illness; hopelessness, difficulty
hospitalization due to concentrating
medication side effects
Maintaining factors
Negative thoughts: “I can’t do this”; “No one will help me”
Maladaptive behavior: Withdrawal, defiance, sullen attitude
Others’ reaction: Adult withdrawal or punishment
The symptoms of ADHD make it more difficult for Ellen to tolerate frus-
tration, and this certainly plays a large role in her propensity to give up
when faced with academic demands. At the same time, this behavior has
been reinforced by the consequences that have typically followed: teachers
have punished her (sent her from the room to time-out) or walked away
from her—in both instances, allowing her to escape from the aversive task.
These consequences also serve to underscore her belief that she can’t do
these tasks, increasing the likelihood that she will repeat this same thought
when faced with the next similar task. Similarly, the times when she is able
10 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
When asked what she wanted to work on in therapy, Ellen initially stated
that she wanted to be in a regular education class rather than continue in
special education. Because this goal may not have been attainable, Ellen’s
therapist used a process of questioning to understand how Ellen’s life
might be different if she were no longer identified as needing extra aca-
demic help. Through these queries, Ellen revealed that she would like to
develop strategies that would allow her to remain in her classroom, com-
plete her coursework and homework, and do better in school. Additionally,
Ellen wanted to feel less anxious in academic settings and to make more
friends. Having clearly defined goals allowed Ellen and her therapist to
clearly measure her progress as therapy advanced, and these goals also pro-
vided a therapeutic rationale for the interventions that the therapist intro-
duced.
ment, and the CBT therapist encourages the client to speak up about his
or her own unique experiences. Furthermore, the knowledge that the ther-
apist possesses regarding the client’s difficulties and treatment is not a
closely guarded secret—instead, the therapist hopes to educate the client
about his or her disorder and about the treatment strategies so that the cli-
ent eventually becomes an “expert” in his or her own treatment.
In other words, the CBT therapist’s goal is not only to help the client
set goals, identify and evaluate maladaptive thoughts and behaviors, and
modify those thoughts and behaviors, but also to teach the client how to do
these things so that the therapist is not necessary. In work with children,
CBT therapists may often use the analogy of a sports “coach” to explain
this role. A coach helps athletes hone their skills by teaching new strate-
gies, encouraging practice, and providing support. However, the athletes
must actively participate by practicing the skills and putting them into ac-
tion. In a similar way, CBT is viewed as a process of “teamwork” between
the client and therapist.
Part of the process of developing the client’s expertise is therefore ed-
ucation. CBT typically begins with education regarding the nature of the
disorder, including the symptoms, causes, course, and prevalence. It can
be tremendously comforting, for example, for a client to learn that the
scary feelings he or she has experienced have a name—panic attacks—and
that they are relatively common and are caused by the misinterpretation
of harmless bodily sensations. In addition to education about the disorder,
the therapist also provides education about the cognitive-behavioral for-
mulation of the disorder—the way in which the client’s thoughts, feelings,
and behaviors interact and lead to the distress or impairment he or she is
experiencing.
Client education also includes the therapeutic rationale for all pre-
scribed interventions. In CBT, the therapist is not using a technique that is
unknown to the client—the process of the therapy is explained to the cli-
ent in terms of how it relates to the symptoms or to the objective goals the
client has set. Thus, when a therapist begins asking a series of questions
about a client’s negative thought, the client knows that the purpose of
these questions is to test the evidence that supports the negative thought.
A client who is asked to repeatedly confront a feared situation in a slow,
graded manner understands that over time, he or she should begin to feel
less fearful.
Eventually, the CBT therapist will take a less central role in prescribing
and implementing such interventions, instead supporting the client’s own
use of these techniques. CBT teaches clients to identify, evaluate, and re-
appraise their own maladaptive thoughts and behaviors. Key to this pro-
cess is a technique called Socratic questioning, in which the therapist asks
12 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
practice of new skills outside the therapy session is often key to achieving
therapeutic effect.
Many of Ellen’s sessions began with her or her parents wanting to discuss
a recent incident, such as a tantrum over homework completion or an emo-
tional outburst. In general, these topics would be added to the agenda but
would not require a change to the planned content. For example, for a ses-
sion in which the plan was to learn how relaxing muscles and taking calm-
ing breaths could result in less distorted thinking and disruptive behavior,
the therapist could skillfully use the client’s examples above as a way to
make this new skill salient to Ellen and her parents. Likewise, those spe-
cific examples introduce an opportunity to identify and evaluate negative
thoughts; examine the relationship of thoughts, behaviors, and emotions;
and perhaps modify those thoughts or behaviors. In this way, CBT ad-
dresses the client’s concerns but does so in a structured way.
Clients and caregivers are also given an overview of the course of treat-
ment from the beginning, and this topic is revisited as treatment progresses.
In an early session, for example, the client is informed that initially, the
therapist will be teaching the client about his or her disorder and about how
thoughts, behaviors, and feelings affect each other. Depending on the target
disorder, clients will be informed about the therapeutic interventions that
they can expect—that they will be learning how to test how true or helpful
their thoughts are, or learn to solve problems, or begin slowly facing situa-
tions that have caused them anxiety. They will be told that they will prac-
tice new skills until they can do them on their own and are moving toward
their goals. And they are told that the treatment will be time limited—that
it will not last forever.
Although many manualized CBT treatments have a specific prescribed
number of sessions, in practice CBT can vary widely in length. The severity
of some client’s problems requires treatment that greatly exceeds the 8 to
20 sessions so often described in efficacy trials. Despite variations in the
number of sessions, CBT is generally intended to be time limited, with a
focus on providing symptom relief, facilitating remission of the disorder,
increasing client functioning, training clients in skills to prevent future re-
lapse, and then ending treatment. CBT clients may return to therapy for
“booster” sessions when they experience a lapse, and CBT emphasizes
helping clients learn to recognize their symptoms so they can determine
when a return to therapy may be helpful. CBT does not, however, typically
“hold” clients in the therapeutic relationship once symptoms have remit-
ted and gains have been maintained for a reasonable length of time.
7. CBT is tailored to meet the particular needs of the client. CBT for-
mulates client difficulties using a cognitive-behavioral framework, places a
14 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
wise highlights the collaboration between client and therapist, with each
committing time, energy, and effort to addressing the areas of concern.
CBT therapists approach each therapy session intent on structuring the
session to maximize the time, introduce and implement interventions that
may be helpful for the client, use client material to highlight the ways in
which cognitions and behavior are causally linked to emotions, and con-
firm or revise the ever-evolving “working hypothesis” of the client’s case
conceptualization. Over time, the client becomes increasingly involved in
the structure of sessions, but the CBT therapist remains highly involved in
planning the treatment in order to deliberately progress toward the behav-
ioral objectives or goals.
In contrast to therapies that advocate following the client’s lead, CBT
is initially quite directive. Clients whose current thinking and behavior are
self-defeating or cause difficulties are in need of new strategies. The ther-
apist considers which of these strategies will be most beneficial to the cli-
ent and works to introduce the intervention, ensures that the client
understands the intervention, and plans for implementation in the areas
where the client experiences difficulty. Because therapists are often asking
clients to try radically different ways of thinking or acting, the client would
not necessarily volunteer some of the strategies most useful to overcoming
the area of difficulty. Therefore, it is the CBT therapist’s job to suggest
new strategies and to provide a compelling therapeutic rationale.
tions salient and requires both flexibility and creativity on the part of the
therapist. Providing experiential in vivo opportunities wherein the client
actually uses a new strategy or has the chance to test his or her beliefs is
far more potent than discussing the strategy or belief in the abstract. Like-
wise, acting out what happens outside of therapy using role-plays can pro-
mote greater generalization of therapeutic gains. The therapist must
actively plan for these activities and be willing to perhaps go beyond the
boundaries of other types of therapies. For example, if a client is fearful of
crowds, the CBT therapist would try to find an opportunity to experience
crowds with the client. If the client’s caregiver has had difficulty creating
a home-rewards program to motivate behavior, the therapist should be
willing to spend time in session working out the logistics of this reward
program. The case of Ellen provides an example of this real-world inter-
vention.
Ellen had been practicing the skill of positive self-presentation in her inter-
personal interactions, particularly when she was upset. Typically, Ellen
practiced this skill in session, using role-plays with her therapist and even
videotaping herself in order to critique her verbal and nonverbal behaviors.
Ellen and her therapist agreed to work on positive self-presentation with a
teacher with whom Ellen found interactions especially challenging. The
therapist was able to go to the school in order to coach Ellen through an
interaction with this teacher, first discussing with the teacher the plan and
sharing the goals of the in vivo interaction. Although this intervention re-
quired planning on the part of the therapist, Ellen’s successful discussion
with this teacher disconfirmed many of her beliefs about what would hap-
pen if she approached him, in ways that merely discussing or role-playing
might not have achieved.
Role of Beliefs
As previously discussed, Beck and Ellis both postulated that individuals
hold certain beliefs or attitudes, constructed in part from early life expe-
riences and biological vulnerabilities, that are activated during times of
stress and form a lens through which new information is processed. At the
deepest level, these are known as core beliefs—beliefs so deeply ingrained
with a client’s fundamental sense of self, the world, and the future that
they may not be recognized or articulable. Core beliefs are not generally
examined in everyday life; instead, they are just accepted as “the way
things are.” Consider Ellen once again: she never stated a belief that she
was helpless; in her view, others withheld help from her. However, she en-
countered all new and potentially stressful situations with a deep-seated
belief that she could never succeed. Experiences that were inconsistent
with this belief were quickly forgotten or misattributed (for example, a
test she passed was deemed “easy”). By discounting or failing to notice the
experiences that disconfirm the core belief, the client maintains the belief,
despite its inaccuracy.
We have also discussed automatic thoughts, the actual thoughts or im-
ages that go through a client’s mind in response to a given situation. These
are the superficial expression of the core belief—the accessible thought
that flashes through the head for just an instant. Ellen thought, “No one will
help me,” or “I can’t do this,” when approaching demanding tasks. Between
these two levels of cognition (i.e., core beliefs and automatic thoughts) are
the rules, attitudes, and assumptions that link the core belief to the auto-
matic thoughts, known as intermediate beliefs. For example, Ellen may have
had several rules that governed the stressful situations: “If I don’t under-
stand something immediately, I’ll never understand it”; “If people don’t of-
fer help to me, it is because I can’t be helped”; and “If I don’t try, I won’t
have to fail.”
thoughts, it is often the case that further questioning about the thought
will reveal a set of maladaptive assumptions or rules that are contributing
to the development of these more proximal ideas.
A technique called guided discovery is often used in CBT to help the
client move from automatic thoughts to intermediate beliefs, perhaps even
unveiling core beliefs. The therapist continues to ask the client questions
about the thought and its meaning in relation to the client, others, and the
world. This work is sometimes described as the downward arrow technique
(Burns 1980), beginning with a maladaptive automatic thought and win-
nowing downward to learn more about what it means to the client. At each
step, the therapist poses a question assuming that the automatic thought
is true. Below is an example of this technique.
Therapist: So you were working in your math group and you started to feel
really frustrated. What was going through your mind in that moment?
Client: I don’t know. I wasn’t paying attention—and then I did, and I felt
really annoyed.
Therapist: Let’s imagine I’m your teacher, and I’m talking about fractions,
and you suddenly start paying attention and you think ...
Client: I don’t get it.
Therapist: OK, so your thought was, “I don’t get it.” And then you felt
frustrated.
Client: And then I said, “You’re not making any sense!” and my teacher
told me to go to time-out.
Therapist: Ah, I see. So I wonder if there was anything else that connected
your thought “I don’t get it” to feeling frustrated and then saying
that to your teacher. I’d like to understand why that thought made
you feel so upset. Let’s assume for a moment that you didn’t under-
stand what the teacher was teaching. What would that mean?
Client: Then I won’t be able to do the exercise.
Therapist: Oh, OK. So if you couldn’t do the exercise, then what?
Client: Then the teacher will ask me why I didn’t do it.
Therapist: And if the teacher asks you why you didn’t do it. ..
Client: When I say I didn’t understand it, she says I didn’t pay attention.
She always says that!
Therapist: What would be the worst thing about that?
Client: She won’t help me; she never does! She always thinks I’m doing it
on purpose, and I’m not—I just don’t ever know how to do these
math problems. I just can’t do it, and I never will.
Therapist: What does that mean about you, do you think, if that’s true?
What does it mean that you can’t do these math problems?
Client: I can’t do anything right!
Whereas the thought “I don’t get it” was the most available to the cli-
ent, what made the thought so upsetting was the more fundamental belief
that failure to do the math problem was just another example that the cli-
Cognitive-Behavior Therapy: An Introduction 19
ent “can’t do anything right.” Further exploration might have revealed that
the client’s self-perception is that of inadequacy. Regardless, the belief “I
can’t do anything right” is a clear distortion, and the therapist can work
with the client to examine how accurate or helpful that thought may be.
It is important to remember that most clients have lived with their dis-
torted thoughts and beliefs for some time and are very familiar with these cog-
nitions. At first, more realistic cognitions may not “feel true.” This transition
from the familiar, maladaptive thought to a more realistic interpretation is a
bit like exchanging an old, worn-out shoe for a newer one: the new shoe works
better, but it takes time for it to feel right. Therefore, therapists should not be
discouraged when clients state that they still strongly believe the original, mal-
adaptive thought or belief. With continued practice, the client will find that
new beliefs begin to seem more accurate. Even when the client’s commitment
to the original thought changes very slightly, this slight change is still progress
toward more useful and accurate thinking.
On the other hand, on the occasions when Ellen was able to focus her
attention on the assigned task, approach the task with a positive attitude,
and put forth effort, she rarely received any attention at all. From the per-
spective of her teachers and other adults, these behaviors were not re-
markable—they simply exemplified what a student was expected to do.
However, because these desired behaviors were not reinforced when they
occurred, they were effectively extinguished.
Behavioral principles are important to CBT because they shed light on
how behaviors develop and are preserved. Behavioral principles also pro-
vide a road map for changing behaviors via interventions. Once the unde-
sirable behaviors are identified, the CBT therapist can work with the
client, or with the caregiver, to eliminate the reinforcement that keeps
these behaviors in place. Likewise, new behaviors can be identified, rein-
forced when they occur, and shaped to occur more frequently.
It is important to remember that thoughts and behaviors do not exist
in isolation from one another; rather, a central tenet of CBT is that the two
interact with one another and are inextricably linked to emotions. There-
fore, it is wise to consider both thoughts and behavior, even when the bulk
of the work in session may focus more on one or the other. Recall that for
some people, behavioral experiences are discounted because of a cognitive
processing error that causes them to give more weight to experiences that
confirm negative beliefs. Therefore, an awareness of negative cognitions is
important even when the emphasis in session may be on behavioral inter-
ventions. For example, suppose the client has a fear of spiders, but over
the course of a therapy session has repeatedly confronted a live spider in a
jar and has noted that the initial fear has decreased over time. It is very im-
portant to check in with such a client to ascertain what meaning he or she
may make of this experience. Perhaps there is a thought like “I can only
face this spider because my therapist is with me—I could never do this on
my own.” Attributing the success to an external force would, in this case,
somewhat decrease the potency of the exposure exercise.
In the same vein, behaviors can reinforce negative cognitions, and thus
it is most helpful to address behaviors that are related to maladaptive
thoughts in treatment. For example, depressed clients who think “I never
have any fun” may decide to decline social invitations and isolate them-
selves. In this way, the behavior actually leads to a verification of the belief.
Introducing some basic behavioral interventions—such as assigning pleas-
ant, reinforcing activities as homework—may result in the client’s receiv-
ing some disconfirming evidence about the belief. This technique, known
as behavioral activation, may also lead to an increase in energy and hope-
fulness. In short, although some CBTs may emphasize behavioral interven-
tions (for example, the treatment of disruptive behavior disorder in youths
22 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
via behavioral parent training), and some may focus more on cognitive pro-
cesses (as with cognitive therapy for depression), recognizing the ways in
which thoughts and behavior are mutually influential benefits both the
case formulation and the intervention.
Common Myths
and Misperceptions
Although many clinicians use CBT techniques, a number of “negative be-
liefs” remain about CBT practice and require some corrective attention.
found the opposite. Indeed, one study found that therapists who engaged
youth clients in a collaborative manner formed the best therapeutic alliances
with their youth clients (Creed and Kendall 2005), and another study com-
paring the use of manualized CBT for youth depression to usual care services
noted that the early therapeutic alliance was stronger for those youths re-
ceiving CBT (Langer et al. 2011). In short, a strong therapeutic relationship
is a key component in CBT, and CBT’s emphasis on collaborative empiricism
in the service of changing thoughts and behaviors may actually bolster—not
weaken—the bond between client and therapist.
2. CBT addresses symptoms but not the root of the problem. Some
therapeutic orientations suggest that addressing a symptom while not at-
tending to the underlying cause of the problem will result in the later re-
currence of the symptom or in a phenomenon known as symptom
substitution, wherein the original symptom is merely replaced with an-
other. Within this model, treatment of symptoms is seen as insufficient,
and there is an emphasis among some schools of thought that therapists
must uncover the latent, and perhaps unconscious, cause of the disorder.
In CBT, the underlying cause of the disorder is very much a part of the
client formulation and intervention approach, but the cause is understood
as the processes that serve to reinforce and maintain the maladaptive cog-
nitions and behaviors. For example, consider the case of Ellen.
A previous therapist had suggested that Ellen’s acting-out behavior and de-
pression were caused by anger toward her mother, whom Ellen uncon-
sciously perceived as having “abandoned” her when she was young and her
mother was ill. The therapist posited that because Ellen was threatened by
this anger, she turned it against herself via her depression and against other
adult authority figures, such as teachers. Alternatively, in the cognitive-
behavioral approach, the acting-out behavior and the depression were seen
as the result of the interaction of Ellen’s negative beliefs (“I am helpless”)
and an environment that negatively reinforced her attempts to escape aver-
sive experiences and failed to reinforce her positive behaviors.
and plans for lapses in which symptoms may transiently return. In planning
for treatment termination, the therapist helps the client and the caregiver
to consider how problems may manifest in the future, how to manage
these recurrences, and how to differentiate between a lapse and a relapse.
“real world” of typical clinical care (Weisz et al. 2006). Although CBT still
does better, on average, than the comparison conditions of usual care ser-
vices, the clinical impact is lessened when treatments are moved from aca-
demic research into frontline services. Identifying the causes for these
weaker effects and increasing the focus on how CBT is implemented in the
real world are important topics that are beginning to be the focus of research-
ers and clinicians alike (Weisz and Gray 2008; Weisz and Kazdin 2010).
Conclusion
CBT has evolved from two distinct traditions—cognitive therapy and be-
havioral learning principles—to form one of the most widely practiced and
thoroughly studied psychosocial treatments. CBT continues to evolve, in-
corporating new techniques for managing maladaptive cognitions and be-
haviors that are aimed at mitigating their impact on emotions, and it is
increasingly being transported from research settings into clinical practice
26 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Self-Assessment Questions
1.1. What is the most readily available form of core beliefs called?
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
Beck JS: Cognitive Therapy: Basics and Beyond. New York, Guilford, 1995
References
Beck AT: Thinking and depression, I: idiosyncratic content and cognitive distor-
tions. Arch Gen Psychiatry 9:324–333, 1963
Beck AT: Thinking and depression, II: theory and therapy. Arch Gen Psychiatry
10:561–571, 1964
Cognitive-Behavior Therapy: An Introduction 27
Beck AT: Depression: Clinical, Experimental, and Theoretical Aspects. New York,
Hoeber, 1967 (Republished as Beck AT: Depression: Causes and Treatment.
Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 1970)
Beck AT: Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorders. New York, Basic Books,
1976
Beck AT, Rush AJ, Shaw BF, et al: Cognitive Therapy of Depression: A Treatment
Manual. New York, Guilford, 1979
Beck JS: Cognitive Therapy: Basics and Beyond. New York, Guilford, 1995
Burns DD: Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy. New York, Signet, 1980
Chambless DL, Hollon SD: Defining empirically supported therapies. J Consult
Clin Psychol 66:7–18, 1998
Creed TA, Kendall PC: Therapist alliance-building behavior with a cognitive-
behavioral treatment for anxiety in youth. J Consult Clin Psychol 73:498–
505, 2005
Ellis A: Rational psychotherapy. J Gen Psychol 59:35–49, 1958
Ellis A: Reason and Emotion in Psychotherapy. Secaucus, NJ, Citadel, 1962
Ellis A: Why rational-emotive therapy to rational emotive behavior therapy? Psy-
chotherapy (Chic) 36:154–159, 1999
Eysenck HJ: Learning theory and behaviour therapy. J Ment Sci 105:61–75, 1959
Hayes SC: Acceptance and commitment therapy, relational frame theory, and the
third wave of behavioral and cognitive therapies. Behav Ther 35:639–665,
2004
Hughes A, Kendall P: Prediction of cognitive behavior treatment outcome for chil-
dren with anxiety disorders: therapeutic relationship and homework compli-
ance. Behav Cogn Psychother 35:487–494, 2007
Jones MC: A laboratory study of fear: the case of Peter. Pedagogical Seminary
31:308–315, 1924
Karver M Shirk S, Handelsman JB, et al: Relationship processes in youth psycho-
therapy: measuring alliance, alliance-building behaviors, and client involve-
ment. J Emot Behav Disord 16:15–28, 2008
Keijsers GP, Schaap CP, Hoogduin CA: The impact of interpersonal patient and
therapist behavior on outcome in cognitive-behavioral therapy: a review of
empirical studies. Behav Modif 24:264–297, 2000
Langer DA, McLeod BD, Weisz JR: Do treatment manuals undermine youth-ther-
apist alliance in community clinical practice? J Consult Clin Psychol 79:427–
432, 2011
Lazarus AA: Reflections on behavior therapy and its development: a point of view.
Behav Ther 2:369–374, 1971
London P: The end of ideology in behavior modification. Am Psychol 27:913–920,
1972
Meichenbaum DH, Goodman J: Reflection, impulsivity, and verbal control of mo-
tor behavior. Child Dev 40:785–797, 1969
Meichenbaum DH, Goodman J: Training impulsive children to talk to themselves:
a means of developing self-control. J Abnorm Psychol 77:115–126, 1971
Pavlov IP: Conditioned Reflexes: An Investigation of the Physiological Activity of
the Cerebral Cortex. Translated by Anrep GV. New York, Oxford University
Press, 1927
Pavlov IP: Lectures on Conditioned Reflexes, Vol 1. Translated by Gantt WH. Lon-
don, Lawrence and Wishart, 1928
28 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Developmental
Considerations
Across Childhood
Sarah A. Frankel, M.S.
Catherine M. Gallerani, M.S.
Judy Garber, Ph.D.
This work was supported in part by grants from the National Institute of Mental
Health (R01MH 64735; RC1 MH088329; T32 MH18921).
29
30 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case Example
Karen is an 11-year-old girl referred for treatment because of her inability
to sit still in the classroom, lack of motivation in school, difficulty concen-
trating, sleep problems, restlessness, and overall bad mood. At her intake
appointment, Karen presents as a well-spoken, socially skilled girl. Indeed,
assessment of Karen’s social skills indicates that she is appropriately so-
cially competent. However, the cognitive assessment reveals that Karen
has difficulties reflecting on her own thoughts and emotions, as well as
problems with abstract and hypothetical reasoning. Therefore, the thera-
pist decides to draw on Karen’s interpersonal strengths by using more con-
crete role-play examples based on actual situations from Karen’s life (e.g.,
interactions with her teacher) rather than using abstract, hypothetical
(e.g., “what if ”) and future-oriented scenarios. Thus, by matching thera-
peutic techniques to Karen’s actual cognitive level, the therapist is able to
induce greater behavioral change over time.
Although the terms age and development are often used interchangeably,
they are not synonymous (Durlak et al. 1991; Holmbeck and Kendall 1991).
Development is significantly more complex than the linear progression of
chronological age. As such, clinicians cannot assume that older children will
always benefit more than younger children from CBT approaches. For ex-
ample, some studies have shown greater improvements in adolescents than
in children receiving CBT for anxiety, whereas others have found that chil-
dren benefit more than adolescents (e.g., Sauter et al. 2009; Weisz et al.
1995). The unique developmental characteristics associated with adoles-
cence may impact adolescents’ willingness to participate in therapy as well
as their ability to apply therapeutic skills (Weisz and Hawley 2002). Addi-
tionally, given the heterogeneity of development, not all adolescents (or even
adults) will possess the developmental competencies necessary to grasp
some of the abstract and hypothetical constructs involved in CBT.
Clinicians also need to be mindful of the link between clinical symp-
toms and development, as well as the relations among the individual areas
of development (e.g., cognitive, social, and emotional). Because clinical
symptoms may disrupt normal developmental pathways, one treatment
goal should be to return children to a more normative trajectory (Shirk
1999). In addition, attention should be paid to the ways in which delays in
one area of development may be associated with difficulties in other de-
velopmental domains.
Given the importance of incorporating development into treatment
design and planning, why is it that developmental approaches are not al-
ready an empirically validated and universally implemented standard of
care? The translation of developmental principles into practice is neither
simple nor direct, and as such the integration of clinical and developmental
psychology continues to be a challenge (Holmbeck et al. 2006; Ollendick
et al. 2001). In the next section, we describe what has been attempted al-
ready to tailor CBT, and we provide recommendations for additional ways
to developmentally modify treatments for youth.
2006). One complicated clinical issue affected by the child’s level of social de-
velopment is the amount and type of parental involvement in treatment.
Whereas family-based interventions have been found to be more effective for
younger children, individual treatment has been shown to be more effective
with older children (Ruma et al. 1996). Given the emergence of autonomy
during adolescence, having parents play a directive or even “coaching” role
during this developmental stage may be contraindicated, though this may de-
pend on other factors such as the youth’s temperament and the quality of the
parent-child relationship. Adolescents who are given appropriate control and
input into how parents can be helpful in supporting their new skills may par-
ticularly benefit from parental involvement.
Case Example
Kevin, a 14-year-old adolescent boy, was an average student and socially en-
gaged with his friends. Six months ago, Kevin became more irritable, easily
frustrated with others, and disinterested in school and social activities. He
was diagnosed with a major depressive episode and oppositional defiant dis-
order. The therapist began individual CBT with Kevin to try to elicit more
behavioral activation and work on his disengaged social interaction style. Al-
though Kevin and his mother had always had a good relationship, it was
clearly worsening as a result of greater conflict between them, particularly
about Kevin’s recent misguided expressions of autonomy (e.g., breaking cur-
few). With Kevin’s permission, the therapist added sessions with the mother
to help her understand his growing need for independence. A family prob-
lem-solving exercise was initiated where Kevin came up with the solution
that he would try to talk with his mother calmly and less disrespectfully, and
in turn, his mother gradually would grant him greater freedom as long as he
was safe and legal. Kevin began trying out more of the CBT skills he was
learning in therapy at home in order to improve his relationship with his
mother and steadily obtain more age-appropriate privileges.
Developmental Domains
Cognitive Development
The complex cognitive strategies taught in CBT place demands on children’s
information processing and presuppose a certain level of cognitive function-
Developmental Considerations Across Childhood 41
Assessment
Because cognitive skills are changing over time, it is important to assess chil-
dren’s developmental level at any particular point in time. Some informal as-
sessments have been used to gather information about metacognition,
systematic thinking, recognizing consequences, and generating alternatives
(Holmbeck et al. 2006). Example questions include “What went through
your mind when...” and “What is going through your mind now?” Measures
of intellectual ability also have been used to assess cognitive development; for
Developmental Considerations Across Childhood 45
example, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, 4th Edition (WISC-
IV), similarities subtest measures abstract reasoning skills (Sauter et al.
2009). Subscales of intelligence measures might not be sufficiently compre-
hensive, however, to serve as indicators of how children think (Spritz and
Sandberg 2010). Thus, although useful, more general intelligence measures
may not provide a complete picture of a child’s level of cognitive develop-
ment. A more formal assessment battery for evaluating relevant cognitive de-
velopmental skills would allow clinicians to gather more specific information
needed to tailor treatment appropriately.
A list of several existing measures of cognitive development is provided
in Appendix 2–A. Although this is not a comprehensive catalog of all pos-
sible measures, it provides a resource of commonly used tools for assessing
several important aspects of children’s cognitive development. Not every
measure should be used for every child all of the time. Rather, measures
can be selected on the basis of which will provide incremental knowledge
to guide treatment planning for a particular child.
Social Development
Children’s level of social development also should be evaluated and used
in treatment planning (Eyberg et al. 1998; Masten and Braswell 1991).
Many forms of psychopathology both affect and are affected by interper-
sonal relationships. Consideration of the social context in which children’s
psychiatric problems occur and how well children negotiate their interper-
sonal challenges is central to their treatment.
recognize that people have their own goals, intentions, and expectations, al-
though they may not yet be able to conceive of what these might be.
Perspective-taking ability is multifaceted and various components of this
skill may emerge at different times. For example, children can comprehend
that others have different views than their own, but they may think that the
others’ perspectives are incorrect and that only their own view reflects real-
ity. Thus, children’s “normal” processing of social information may appear to
be distorted compared with that of adults (Grave and Blissett 2004). As chil-
dren mature socially, they become better at reflecting on their own actions
through the perspective of another person. This developing ability enables
youth to take a more impartial position over time.
The cognitive advances that develop in tandem with social develop-
ment facilitate children’s understanding that perspectives are created by
the mind and are not exact copies of reality but are instead interpretations
and representations of the world. Such awareness leads to an understand-
ing of the causes underlying multiple perspectives about the same situation
and that external as well as internal factors contribute to personal perspec-
tives and associated behaviors (Fireman and Kose 2010; Keating 1990).
Another important aspect of the emergence of perspective taking is the
increased motivation to take another’s perspective, which often is linked
to a desire to engage in prosocial behavior (Eisenberg et al. 2009). Al-
though motivation to engage in perspective taking typically is a marker of
healthy social development, some youth try to anticipate what people are
thinking and often assume that they are the focus of others’ thoughts; this
belief is often referred to as the imaginary audience (Keating 1990). Such
thinking is part of normative development but can be problematic when it
takes the form of excessive self-consciousness or rumination.
Achievement of social competence in children is cultivated through
their encounters with different types of challenging social situations
(Spence 2003). Adaptive social skills produce positive peer relationships
and include expressing positive affect, attending to play partners, initiating
nurturing behaviors (e.g., helping, sharing), being agreeable, and mastering
reciprocal play (e.g., turn taking) (Bierman et al. 2010; La Greca and Prin-
stein 1999). Thus, good peer relationships are formed once children learn
how to initiate and maintain positive social interactions.
As children become more socially advanced, they develop the self-control
that makes possible engaging in rule-based play and joining in prosocial behav-
ior, thereby enhancing their peer acceptance and avoiding rejection (La Greca
and Prinstein 1999). Social skills acquired early continue to be important (e.g.,
sharing, helping, cooperating). In addition, prosocial characteristics such as be-
ing kind and considerate contribute to being accepted by others.
48 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Assessment
Assessing children’s social development, particularly regarding their peer
relationships and friendships, is important for constructing an age-appro-
priate treatment plan (La Greca and Prinstein 1999). Children’s social
competencies and skills have been assessed with role-play vignettes or
questionnaires (Matson and Wilkins 2009). Multimethod, multi-infor-
mant approaches are likely to provide the most comprehensive assessment
of children’s social aptitudes and deficiencies (Spence 2003), although
this can be time-consuming and expensive.
Developmental Considerations Across Childhood 49
Emotional Development
The set of emotional skills that allows individuals to effectively interact in
their world has been conceptualized in several different ways. Salovey and
Mayer (1990) defined emotional intelligence as “the ability to monitor one’s
own and others’ feelings and emotions, to discriminate among them and to
use this information to guide one’s thinking and action” (p. 189). These abil-
ities include perceiving and identifying emotions, using emotions to facili-
tate thoughts, understanding emotions, and managing emotions. Bar-On
(1997) offered a different definition of emotional intelligence, describing it
as “an array of noncognitive capabilities, competencies, and skills that influ-
ence one’s ability to succeed in coping with environmental demands and
pressures” (p. 14). He outlined five clusters of emotional intelligence skills:
intrapersonal, interpersonal, stress management, adaptability, and general
mood. Saarni (1999) described the development of emotional competence
as consisting of a set of eight skills: an individual’s awareness of his or her
own emotional state, discerning others’ emotions, using an emotion vocabu-
lary, empathy and sympathy, recognizing the distinction between inner emo-
tional state and outer emotional expression, adaptive coping, awareness of
relationships, and emotional self-efficacy. Despite the different labels, there
is considerable overlap in the skills considered to constitute emotional intel-
ligence and competence and a consensus that these skills develop over time
(Mayer et al. 2000; Saarni 1999).
Assessment
The number of assessment tools available to measure emotional intelli-
gence in children is limited (Luebbers et al. 2007; Stough et al. 2009).
Many of these measures either have been constructed recently or are still
being developed. A review of measures for assessing emotional compe-
tence in children concluded that most existing measures focus on social
rather than emotional competence and that few measures focus solely on
emotional competence (Stewart-Brown and Edmunds 2003).
Extant measures of emotional competence include parent or teacher
observations, self-report questionnaires, and performance measures.
These different measurement methods often are not correlated, however,
and thus they likely are assessing different aspects of emotional intelli-
gence, such as perceived versus actual awareness (Ciarrochi et al. 2001).
Some performance measures assess a variety of emotional competencies
(e.g., Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test; Mayer et al.
2002), whereas others assess one specific skill (e.g., ability to recognize
emotional facial expressions; Nowicki and Duke 1994). Appendix 2–A
presents some existing measures of emotional intelligence or competence
for children and adolescents.
Other Important
Developmental Considerations
1. Language and vocabulary. Although modifying the language used in
adult treatment manuals is insufficient to achieve developmental tai-
loring, such changes are nonetheless necessary. CBT with children
should use clear, simple, and child-specific vocabulary (Sauter et al.
2009). Clinicians also should be aware of any discrepancies between
receptive and expressive language that could impact children’s abilities
to understand or respond to therapeutic demands.
2. Executive function. Developments in executive functions (e.g., atten-
tion, flexibility, planning) are occurring simultaneously with develop-
ments in cognitive, social, and emotional development to allow
children’s effective engagement in treatment (Grave and Blissett
2004). Therefore, the link between children’s executive functions and
the demands of CBT also needs to be explored.
3. Treatment modality. The context in which the therapy is implemented
(e.g., family, individual, group) may be more or less appropriate and/
or effective depending on the child’s developmental level, particularly
within the social domain.
4. Sex/race/socioeconomic status/culture. Developmental norms may not
always incorporate sex, race, socioeconomic status, and other aspects
of culture that could impact development (Ollendick et al. 2001).
5. Parameters of treatment. Developmental level also can affect the
length of sessions, frequency of sessions (e.g., twice a week, weekly,
biweekly, monthly), number of sessions, and overall duration of treat-
ment (e.g., weeks, months). The child’s ability to sustain attention, re-
member what was discussed within sessions, and use the new skills
outside the therapy session will affect decisions about these parame-
ters of the treatment process.
Self-Assessment Questions
2.1. True or False: Adolescents are always better able to engage in cogni-
tive-behavioral strategies than are young children.
Suggested Readings
Holmbeck GN, O’Mahar K, Abad M, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy
with adolescents: guides from developmental psychology, in Child and
Adolescent Therapy: Cognitive-Behavioral Procedures, 3rd Edition.
Edited by Kendall PC. New York, Guilford, 2006, pp 419–464
Merrell K: Helping Students Overcome Depression and Anxiety: A Prac-
tical Guide. New York, Guilford, 2001
Shirk S: Developmental therapy, in Developmental Issues in the Clinical
Treatment of Children. Edited by Silverman WK, Ollendick TH.
Needham Heights, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 1999, pp 60–73
Vernon A: More of What Works When With Children and Adolescents: A
Handbook of Individual Counseling Techniques. Champaign, IL, Re-
search Press, 2009
References
Achenbach TM: Integrative Guide for the 1991 CBCL/4–18, YSR, and TRF Pro-
files. Burlington, University of Vermont, Department of Psychiatry, 1991
Artman L, Cahan S, Avni-Babad D: Age, schooling and conditional reasoning. Cogn
Dev 21:131–145, 2006
Bacow TL, Pincus DB, Ehrenreich JT, et al: The Metacognitions Questionnaire for
Children: development and validation in a clinical sample of children and ad-
olescents with anxiety disorders. J Anxiety Disord 23:727–736, 2009
Bajgar J, Ciarrochi J, Lane R, et al: Development of the Levels of Emotional Aware-
ness Scale for Children (LEAS-C). Br J Dev Psychol 23:569–586, 2005
Bar-On R: The Bar-On Emotional Quotient Inventory (EQ-i): A Test of Emotional
Intelligence. Toronto, ON, Canada, Multi-Health Systems, 1997
Bar-On R, Parker JDA: Emotional Quotient Inventory: Youth Version (EQ-i:YV).
Toronto, ON, Canada, Multi-Health Systems, 2000
Beauchamp MH, Anderson V: SOCIAL: an integrative framework for the develop-
ment of social skills. Psychol Bull 136:39–64, 2010
Beck AT, Rush J, Shaw BF, et al: Cognitive therapy of depression. New York, Guil-
ford Press, 1979
Developmental Considerations Across Childhood 57
Bierman KL, Torres MM, Schofield HL: Developmental factors related to the as-
sessment of social skills, in Practitioner’s Guide to Empirically Based Mea-
sures of Social Skills (ABCT Clinical Assessment Series). Edited by Nangle
DW. New York, Springer, 2010, pp 119–134
Bornstein MR, Bellack AS, Hersen M: Social-skills training for unassertive chil-
dren: a multiple-baseline analysis. J Appl Behav Anal 10:183–195, 1977
Bryant BK: An index of empathy for children and adolescents. Child Dev 53:413–
425, 1982
Cartwright-Hatton S, Mather A, Illingworth V, et al: Development and preliminary
validation of the Meta-Cognitions Questionnaire—Adolescent Version.
J Anxiety Disord 18:411–422, 2004
Chorpita BF: Modular Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Childhood Anxiety Dis-
orders. New York, Guilford, 2007
Christophersen ER, Mortweet SL: Treatments That Work With Children: Empiri-
cally Supported Strategies for Managing Childhood Problems. Washington,
DC, American Psychological Association, 2002
Ciarrochi J, Chan AY, Bajgar J: Measuring emotional intelligence in adolescents.
Pers Individ Dif 31:1105–1119, 2001
Ciarrochi J, Heaven PC, Supavadeeprasit S: The link between emotion identifica-
tion skills and socio-emotional functioning in early adolescence: a 1-year lon-
gitudinal study. J Adolesc 31:565–582, 2008
Crosnoe R, Needham B: Holism, contextual variability, and the study of friend-
ships in adolescent development. Child Dev 75:264–279, 2004
Delis DC, Kaplan E, Kramer JH: The Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System.
San Antonio, TX, The Psychological Corporation, 2001
Doherr L, Reynolds S, Wetherly J, et al: Young children’s ability to engage in cog-
nitive therapy tasks: associations with age and educational experience. Behav
Cogn Psychother 33:201–215, 2005
Donaldson SK, Westerman MA: Development of children’s understanding of am-
bivalence and causal theories of emotions. Dev Psychol 22:655–662, 1986
Durlak JA, Furhman T, Lampman C: Effectiveness of cognitive-behavior therapy
for maladapting children: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull 110:204–214, 1991
D’Zurilla TJ, Nezu AM, Maydeu-Olivares A: Social problem solving: theory and as-
sessment, in Social Problem Solving: Theory, Research, and Training. Edited
by Chang EC, D’Zurilla TJ, Sanna LJ. Washington, DC, American Psycholog-
ical Association, 2004, pp 11–27
Eisenberg N, Morris AS, McDaniel B, et al: Moral cognitions and prosocial re-
sponding in adolescence, in Handbook of Adolescent Psychology, Vol 4: Indi-
vidual Bases of Adolescent Development, 3rd Edition. Edited by Lerner RM,
Steinberg L. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley, 2009, pp 229–265
Elfers T, Martin J, Sokol B: Perspective taking: a review of research and theory ex-
tending Selman’s developmental model of perspective taking. Adv Psychol
Res 54:229–262, 2008
Eyberg SM, Schuhmann EM, Rey J: Child and adolescent psychotherapy research:
developmental issues. J Abnorm Child Psychol 26:71–82, 1998
Fireman GD, Kose G: Perspective taking, in A Clinician’s Guide to Normal Cog-
nitive Development in Childhood. Edited by Sandberg EH, Spritz BL. New
York, Routledge/Taylor & Francis, 2010, pp 85–100
58 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Flavell JH, Green FL, Flavell ER: Development of children’s awareness of their
own thoughts. J Cogn Dev 1:97–112, 2000
Goodnow JJ: A test of milieu differences with some of Piaget’s tasks. Psychol
Monogr 76:555, 1962
Grave J, Blissett J: Is cognitive behavior therapy developmentally appropriate for
young children? A critical review of the evidence. Clin Psychol Rev 24:399–
420, 2004
Gresham FM: Social competence and students with behavior disorders: where
we’ve been, where we are, and where we should go. Educ Treat Children
20:233–249, 1997
Gresham FM, Elliot SN: The Social Skills Rating System. Circle Pines, MN, Amer-
ican Guidance Services, 1990
Halpern-Felsher BL, Cauffman E: Costs and benefits of a decision: decision-making
competence in adolescents and adults. J Appl Dev Psychol 22:257–273, 2001
Harrington R, Wood A, Verduyn C: Clinically depressed adolescents, in Cognitive-
Behaviour Therapy for Children and Families. Edited by Graham P. Cam-
bridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, 1998, pp 156–193
Hoffman ML: Empathy and prosocial behavior, in Handbook of Emotions, 3rd Edi-
tion. Edited by Lewis M, Haviland-Jones JM, Barrett LF. New York, Guilford,
2008, pp 440–455
Holmbeck GN, Kendall PC: Clinical-childhood-developmental interface: implica-
tions for treatment, in Handbook of Behavior Therapy and Psychological Sci-
ence: An Integrative Approach. Edited by Martin PR. Elmsford, NY,
Pergamon, 1991, pp 73–99
Holmbeck GN, Colder C, Shapera W, et al: Working with adolescents: guides from
developmental psychology, in Child and Adolescent Therapy: Cognitive-
Behavioral Procedures, 2nd Edition. Edited by Kendall PC. New York, Guil-
ford, 2000, pp 334–385
Holmbeck GN, O’Mahar K, Abad M, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy with ad-
olescents: guides from developmental psychology, in Child and Adolescent
Therapy: Cognitive-Behavioral Procedures, 3rd Edition. Edited by Kendall
PC. New York, Guilford, 2006, pp 419–464
Janveau-Brennan G, Markovits H: The development of reasoning with causal con-
ditionals. Dev Psychol 35:904–911, 1999
Karniol R, Koren L: How would you feel? Children’s inferences regarding their
own and others’ affective reactions. Cogn Dev 2:271–278, 1987
Keating D: Adolescent thinking, in At the Threshold: The Developing Adolescent.
Edited by Feldman SS, Elliot GR. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press,
1990, pp 54–89
Kendall PC: The Coping Cat Workbook. Ardmore, PA, Workbook Publishing, 1990
Kendall PC, Choudhury MS, Hudson JL, et al: The C.A.T. Project Manual: Manual
for the Individual Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of Adolescents With Anxi-
ety Disorders. Ardmore, PA, Workbook Publishing, 2002
La Greca AM, Harrison HM: Adolescent peer relations, friendships, and romantic
relationships: do they predict social anxiety and depression? J Clin Child Ad-
olesc Psychol 34:49–61, 2005
La Greca AM, Prinstein MJ: Peer group, in Developmental Issues in the Clinical
Treatment of Children. Edited by Silverman WK, Ollendick TH. Needham
Heights, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 1999, pp 171–198
Developmental Considerations Across Childhood 59
Lazarus AA, Abramovitz A: The use of “emotive imagery” in the treatment of chil-
dren’s phobias. J Ment Sci 108:191–195, 1962
Leahy RL: Cognitive therapy of childhood depression: developmental consider-
ations, in Cognitive Development and Child Psychotherapy: Perspectives in
Developmental Psychology. Edited by Shirk SR. New York, Plenum, 1988,
pp 187–204
Litschge CM, Vaughn MG, McCrea C: The empirical status of treatments for chil-
dren and youth with conduct problems: an overview of meta-analytic studies.
Res Soc Work Pract 20:21–35, 2010
Lohman DF, Hagen EP: The Cognitive Abilities Test: Form 6. Itasca, IL, Riverside
Publishing, 2001
Luebbers S, Downey LA, Stough C: The development of an adolescent measure of
EI. Pers Individ Dif 42:999–1009, 2007
March JS, Mulle K: OCD in Children and Adolescents: A Cognitive-Behavioral
Treatment Manual. New York, Guilford, 1998
Masten AS, Braswell L: Developmental psychopathology: an integrative frame-
work, in Handbook of Behavior Therapy and Psychological Science: An Inte-
grative Approach. Edited by Martin PR. Elmsford, NY, Pergamon, 1991,
pp 35–56
Matson JL, Wilkins J: Psychometric testing methods for children’s social skills. Res
Dev Disabil 30:249–274, 2009
Matson JL, Rotatori AF, Helsel WJ: Development of a rating scale to measure so-
cial skills in children: the Matson Evaluation of Social Skills with Youngsters
(MESSY). Behav Res Ther 21:335–340, 1983
Mavorveli S, Petrides KV, Shove C, et al: Investigation of the construct of trait emo-
tional intelligence in children. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 17:516–526, 2008
Mayer JD, Caruso DR, Salovey P: Emotional intelligence meets traditional stan-
dards for an intelligence. Intelligence 27:267–298, 2000
Mayer JD, Salovey P, Caruso DR: Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test
(MSCEIT): User’s Manual. Toronto, ON, Canada, MHS Publishers, 2002
Merrell K: Helping Students Overcome Depression and Anxiety: A Practical
Guide. New York, Guilford, 2001
Nowicki S, Duke MP: Individual differences in the nonverbal communication of
affect: the Diagnostic Analysis of Nonverbal Accuracy Scale. J Nonverbal Be-
hav 18:9–35, 1994
Ollendick TH, Grills AE, King NJ: Applying developmental theory to the assess-
ment and treatment of childhood disorders: does it make a difference? Clin
Psychol Psychother 8:304–314, 2001
Parker JG, Asher SR: Friendship and friendship quality in middle childhood: links
with peer group acceptance and feelings of loneliness and social dissatisfac-
tion. Dev Psychol 29:611–621, 1993
Petrides KV, Sangareau Y, Furnham A, et al: Trait emotional intelligence and chil-
dren’s peer relations at school. Soc Dev 15:537–547, 2006
Piaget J: Development and learning (1964), in Piaget Rediscovered. Edited by Rip-
ple RE, Rockcastle VN. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University, School of Education,
2006, pp 7–20
Quinn M, Kavale KA, Mathur SR, et al: A meta-analysis of social skill interventions
for students with emotional or behavioral disorders. J Emot Behav Disord
7:54–64, 1999
60 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Hypothetical and causal reasoning Generation of Alternatives Task Janveau-Brennan and Markovits 1999 Grades 1–6
Conditional reasoning Conditional Reasoning Task Janveau-Brennan and Markovits 1999 Grades 1–6
Reasoning and problem solving Cognitive Abilities Test, Form 6 Lohman and Hagen 2001 5–18 years
Self-reflection and insight Self-Reflection and Insight Scale for Sauter et al. 2010 9–18 years
Youth
Appendix 2–A: Tools for Assessing Developmental Skills
APPENDIX 2–A. Tools for assessing developmental skills in cognitive, social, and emotional domains (continued)
Developmental skill Assessment measure Citation Age
Social development
Social perspective-taking Interpersonal Understanding Selman 1980 4.5–32 years
Interview
Social skills Social Skills Rating System (SSRS) Gresham and Elliot 1990 Grades K–6
Social skills Matson Evaluation of Social Skills Matson et al. 1983 4–18 years
with Youngsters
Assertiveness; social problem- Social Problem-Solving Inventory— D’Zurilla et al. 2004 13 years
solving skills Revised (SPSI-R)
Friendship quality Friendship Quality Questionnaire Parker and Asher 1993 7–12 years
Empathy Bryant’s Index of Empathy for Bryant 1982 Grades 1, 4, and 7
Children and Adolescents (BEI)
Assertiveness; social skills Behavioral Assertiveness Test for Bornstein et al. 1977 8–13 years
Children (BAT-C)
63
64
APPENDIX 2–A. Tools for assessing developmental skills in cognitive, social, and emotional domains (continued)
Developmental skill Assessment measure Citation Age
Emotional development
Cognitive development
Problem solving Hypothetical, systematic, Children with less developed reasoning ability may need more teaching
a. Generate solutions logical, and causal about how to examine each solution, more practice in evaluating
b. Evaluate solutions reasoning possible solutions, and greater scaffolding from therapists and parents.
Connecting thoughts, feelings, and Conditional and Avoid if-then language with children who do not display hypothetical
behaviors; using “if-then” statements hypothetical reasoning reasoning abilities.
(e.g., “If I think ____, then I will feel Use in vivo strategies to induce mood and help children draw
_____”) connections through experiences in the moment.
Practice explicit labeling of the cause and effect.
When explaining the connections among thoughts, feelings, and
behaviors, check children’s understanding of each relation. Make sure
that less cognitively developed children understand these associations
before progressing.
Differentiating thoughts, feelings, and Abstract and causal Children with less developed abstract reasoning will benefit from more
behaviors; recognizing the reasoning concrete and visual methods.
connections among them In place of role-playing, use cartoons or puppets.
Pictures (e.g., the body with thoughts in the head, feelings in the
stomach or heart, and behaviors on the hand) or tangible illustrations
(e.g., string connecting thoughts, feelings, and behaviors) can help
show more complex concepts.
These techniques are particularly relevant for children who grasp
65
external constructs more readily than internal, psychological concepts.
66
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Cognitive restructuring; examining Systematic and logical Less cognitively advanced children may struggle with being impartial
evidence for and against child’s reasoning and may give more weight to evidence that supports their beliefs.
beliefs Children may have difficulty separating facts from their beliefs, which
is necessary for cognitive restructuring.
Use other cognitive restructuring strategies with less cognitively
advanced children (e.g., alternative explanations, helpful vs. unhelpful
thoughts).
Thought monitoring and cognitive Hypothetical reasoning Hypothetical reasoning about the past typically develops after reasoning
restructuring; reflecting on past and about the past and future about the future.
future patterns of thinking For less cognitively mature children, first focus on the here and now
rather than the past or future. Ask children “How do you feel when
you think _____?” before moving on to the more advanced questions:
“How will you feel the next time you think _____?” or “How might
you have felt if you had thought _____?”
Using analogies and metaphors to Abstract and analogical Keep it simple. Although analogies and metaphors can convey
convey information reasoning information in a more memorable and attainable way, children who
have not yet developed this type of reasoning may find these strategies
confusing.
Appendix 2–B: Recommendations for Treatment Planning
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Identifying and recognizing child’s Logical reasoning Some “cognitive distortions” may be normative and not linked to
cognitive distortions in order to psychopathology.
modify them Thinking errors that are “typical” but maladaptive may be especially
intractable.
Clinicians need to train children to think differently (e.g., to see the gray
instead of black and white) before children can overcome these thinking
errors.
Identifying own thoughts; recognizing Metacognition; Children first need to be able to identify their thoughts in general before
negative thinking and cognitive self-reflection they can recognize their negative thinking or cognitive distortions.
distortions For children who struggle with metacognition, first focus on identifying
neutral and positive thoughts.
Cartoons with thought bubbles can help explain thinking, although even
this may be difficult for less cognitively advanced children.
Ask children “What do you like?” and then help them see that their
response was a thought (e.g., “Your brain/mind told you that you like
_____”).
Identify children’s thoughts in session, rather than asking them to
remember a situation and identify past thoughts.
Identifying thoughts in the present is less cognitively demanding than
reflecting on past thoughts.
67
68
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Introspection; understanding own Self-reflection Children in the midst of identity formation may become anxious when
identity; motivation to change confronted with information that threatens their tenuous identity,
which might then impede therapeutic progress.
Motivational interviewing techniques may facilitate children’s decision
making about change and likely will be more effective than the
therapist directing children to change.
Generalizing new skills learned in Self-reflection; For less cognitively developed children who are unlikely to
therapy to the child’s everyday life metacognition spontaneously reflect on their own thinking outside of therapy,
caregivers will need to provide scaffolding. Parents can act as coaches
at home to encourage children to think about their thinking. Clinicians
can help children recognize physiological sensations or emotional
reactions that may cue them to reflect on their thinking.
Social development
Disputing negative thoughts; ability to Advanced perspective- For children who do not demonstrate advanced perspective-taking,
step outside own perspective and taking; realizing the therapy may be more effective if less focus is placed on disputing
take the viewpoint of another validity of another’s view, beliefs. Instead, therapists may prefer to rely on social-skills training
not just that other views to modify target behaviors.
exist
Appendix 2–B: Recommendations for Treatment Planning
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Learning social problem-solving Ability to reflect on own Evaluate child’s social competencies and deficits from multiple sources
behaviors in solving social (e.g., parents, teachers).
problems; identifying Create a profile of the child’s strengths and weaknesses; design an
what perpetuates intervention targeted at the child’s specific interpersonal skills
maladaptive behaviors deficits.
Build on the child’s existing skills through didactic instruction,
modeling, role-playing, performance feedback, reinforcement, and
practice in the natural environment.
Assertiveness training; understanding Understanding cause-and- When teaching assertiveness, first have children achieve mastery of
the impact of own statements and effect sequences that their own assertive behaviors before requiring that they recognize the
actions on others involve others; predicting full rationale for how their behaviors affect others.
others’ social behaviors Use simple role-play scenarios between the therapist and child to
demonstrate the various possible consequences of the child’s actions.
Meeting new people; starting, Role-taking skills; ability to For less socially advanced children who have difficulty role-playing, first
maintaining, and ending shift and assume multiple have them 1) learn the concrete behaviors involved with meeting new
conversations perspectives people (e.g., introducing self, being friendly, active listening); then
2) watch video clips of people meeting and identify others doing these
specific behaviors successfully (or unsuccessfully) without yet having
to role-play or take multiple perspectives.
69
70
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Developing and maintaining Empathy Some children with self-regulation difficulties may have problems with
relationships: understanding how empathy such that their empathic distress for another exacerbates
moods, words, and behaviors impact their own distress, possibly leading to emotional overarousal, anxiety,
relationships; focusing on others and self-focus. They also might respond to their heightened distress
instead of the self over another’s hardship by disengaging and reducing their involvement
with that person.
Clinicians can assist children in recognizing how others’ emotions affect
them and can teach children strategies for appropriately managing
their empathic distress and maintaining emotional control.
Understanding how relationships Self-reflection; perspective Although a child may report a healthy quantity of friends, the quality
affect mood taking and consequences of their friendships also should be evaluated.
Help children recognize the connection between their social
relationships and their mood.
Teach children to monitor their moods in the context of these
relationships.
Seeking social support; strengthening Self-reflection; social skills For more socially competent youth without clear social difficulties,
social skills clinicians can enhance children’s interpersonal strengths and frame
social support–seeking as a potentially healthy coping strategy for
dealing with stress when done appropriately.
For less socially adept children, help them identify when to seek
support from others.
Appendix 2–B: Recommendations for Treatment Planning
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Improving and enhancing peer Social skills (e.g., Less socially advanced children will be less able to converse with adults
relationships conversational skills, and peers and unable to engage in more nuanced interpersonal
generating questions) strategies, such as asking questions to generate conversations or
constructing positive statements about others.
Some skills (e.g., making eye contact, smiling, engaging in friendly
greetings) will be important for less socially competent children to
master first.
Conflict resolution; interpersonal Perspective taking; Pair therapy involves two children matched for their perspective-taking
negotiation cooperation; reciprocity; abilities and interpersonal negotiation strategies to promote better
appraising others’ coordination between them.
intentions Pair counseling involves children being paired to provide opportunities
for aggressive, withdrawn, and socially immature children with
contrasting relationship styles to practice social skills and learn from
each other.
Peer therapy involves a peer chosen by the child, parent, or clinician to
attend one to two sessions.
Identify and modify maladaptive interaction patterns in vivo (e.g.,
co-rumination).
71
72
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Monitoring feelings; recognizing Perception, identification, Children who do not have the ability to reflect on their own emotional
multiple, simultaneous feelings and awareness of experience in a more complex manner will be unable to engage in
emotional intensity; mood monitoring outside the therapy session.
experiencing multiple Help children label and describe emotional experiences in vivo.
simultaneous emotions Teach parents to help children describe emotional experiences as they
are happening outside of the therapy session.
To increase awareness of simultaneous emotions, teach children to
“scan” for multiple feelings when in an emotional situation.
Learning that changes in thoughts or Perception, identification, Children who are not yet able to describe varying levels of emotional
behavior can impact emotions and understanding of intensity will have difficulty noticing changes in their emotions
emotions following changes in their thinking or behaviors.
Help children recognize indicators of emotional intensity (e.g.,
physiological sensations) using visual representations (e.g., emotion
thermometer).
Describing emotional experiences Emotion vocabulary For children with a limited emotion vocabulary, focus on expanding
their understanding of emotional experiences through feeling
identification exercises that help them define emotions, talk about
emotions, and recognize their experience of emotions in different
situations.
Games using pictures of people displaying different facial expressions
can help children associate emotion labels with outer affective
expressions (e.g., facial expression cards or facial zone puzzle).
Appendix 2–B: Recommendations for Treatment Planning
APPENDIX 2–B. Practical recommendations for treatment planning based on cognitive, social, and emotional
development (continued)
Therapeutic demands Developmental skills Clinical recommendations
Developing and maintaining social Awareness of emotions in Assist less emotionally developed children to generalize their own
relationships others; emotion emotional knowledge in order to better understand others.
management Use exercises describing the therapist’s or parents’ emotional
experiences; encourage parents to talk about their emotions at home
and to draw connections for the child among situations, emotional
expressions, and emotional experiences in others.
Use interpersonal vignettes (through narratives or use of puppets) to
illustrate emotional experiences in others.
Social problem-solving; conflict Awareness of emotions in Activities designed to improve understanding of others’ emotional
resolution self and other; emotion experiences will help children engage in conflict resolution.
management In session, practice and role-plays using relaxation techniques to
regulate emotional experience can help prepare children for real-life
conflict situations.
If a child’s emotional management skills are severely underdeveloped,
increasing emotion-regulation skills should be the focus of
intervention before expecting children to engage effectively in social
problem-solving.
Parents can model conflict resolution methods and can coach children
to use effective emotion-regulation techniques both in preparation for
and during conflicts.
73
This page intentionally left blank
3
Culturally Diverse
Children and
Adolescents
Rebecca Ford-Paz, Ph.D.
Gayle Y. Iwamasa, Ph.D.
75
76 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
issues to light. These groups have less access to mental health services, are
less likely to receive mental health services when needed, are likely to re-
ceive poorer quality of mental health care when they do receive services,
and are underrepresented in mental health research (U.S. Surgeon Gen-
eral 2001). Even when treated, ethnic minorities often terminate prema-
turely, improve more slowly, and have poorer outcomes (Cooper et al.
2003). Ethnic minorities experience disproportionately more psychosocial
stressors than do non-Latino white Americans (Bernal and Scharrón-del-
Río 2001; U.S. Surgeon General 2001). These include social and environ-
mental inequalities such as exposure to discrimination, violence, poverty,
and limited access to education.
A disproportionate number of children of color are referred for mental
health services (Kazdin et al. 1995; Manoleas 1996), yet they continue to
be underrepresented in randomized controlled trials of EBTs, resulting in
a relative absence of treatments that may be deemed well established for
ethnic minority youth (Huey and Polo 2008). To date, no EBT (including
CBT) has been tested in at least two independent, high-quality, between-
group trials (with random assignment and adequate sample size) that dem-
onstrate that the treatment is superior to placebo or alternative treatment
or is equivalent to an already established treatment with ethnic minority
youth. Similarly, underrepresentation of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and trans-
gender (GLBT); differently abled; religious minority; ethnic minority; and
low-income populations in the research has led some investigators to pose
the following question about empirically supported treatment: “Empiri-
cally supported treatments ...for whom?” (Pantalone et al. 2010, p. 452).
More research is clearly needed to support the efficacy of CBT with eth-
nocultural minority youth.
interest in cultural and ethnic minority groups in the EBT and CBT litera-
ture (Hays 2006; Whaley and Davis 2007). In theory, the clinician would
expect that the basic tenets of CBT would be universal (Hays 1995; Pan-
talone et al. 2010)—that is, behavior is learned and can be unlearned;
thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are interrelated; and social learning and
operant conditioning are processes that fit with the human experience
across diverse populations (Hansen et al. 2000; Pantalone et al. 2010).
This belief that CBT is universally applicable, culture-free, value-neutral,
or color-blind, however, has come about from practice-oriented research
that historically has focused on people of middle class, heterosexual orien-
tation, and European American descent (Balsam et al. 2006; Hays 2006;
Organista 2006; Pantalone et al. 2010; Vera et al. 2003). The idea that
cognitions affect emotions may, indeed, be relevant cross-culturally. How-
ever, CBT’s emphasis on cognition, logic, verbal skills, and rational think-
ing as therapeutic tools is influenced by American and European cultural
values (Hays 2006; Hoffman 2006). Eastern cultures may attend more to
context and relationships, rely on more experience-based knowledge in-
stead of logic, and show more tolerance for contradiction (Hoffman
2006). In addition, CBT’s emphasis on rational thinking may overlook the
importance of spirituality, which may be as central and equally important
as rational thinking among many cultural groups (Abudabbeh and Hays
2006; Hays 2006; Iwamasa et al. 2006a; Kelly 2006) and may detract from
the credibility of cognitive-behavioral strategies for coping (Falicov 2009).
Consistent with collectivism, most ethnic minority groups value inter-
dependence, family, harmony, and community (Nagayama Hall 2001).
CBT’s focus on the individual client may clash with these values and result
in missed opportunities to capitalize on a potential source of strength for
many ethnic minority groups (Kelly 2006). The U.S. mainstream cultural
value of individualism (i.e., personal independence, self-control, verbal
ability) informs the promotion of assertiveness skills and direct expression
of thoughts in CBT (Hays 1995; Pantalone et al. 2010). This value may di-
rectly conflict with collectivist cultures that may view direct communica-
tion as disrespectful and that prefer nonverbal and indirect behavioral
communication (Nagayama Hall 2001). Relatedly, assertiveness training’s
basis in egalitarian democratic principles runs counter to more traditional,
hierarchical family structures (based on age and gender) in less accultur-
ated ethnic minority families, where the person’s “right” to express him-
self or herself is not a priority (Abudabbeh and Hays 2006; Organista
2006). The use of “I statements” in assertiveness training would be espe-
cially challenging for Native Americans whose preferred language does not
have a word for “I” (McDonald and Gonzalez 2006). Thus therapists
wanting to implement CBT with diverse populations should carefully con-
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 81
social supports, and acquire skills to meet goals more effectively (Kelly
2006). Despite the potential of CBT to address contextual factors, CBT
proponents have not directly addressed the impact of racism and oppres-
sion on ethnic minority clients by creating explicit strategies to deal with
these negative sociocultural influences. Critics suggest that CBT focuses
too much on changing individual-level variables (thoughts and behaviors)
in order to effect therapeutic change and adapt to current environmental
conditions (Casas 1995; Organista and Muñoz 1996; Vera et al. 2003).
This self-focus neglects unfair, discriminatory environmental factors that
restrict an individual’s ability to effect change (Hays 2006). As a result,
therapists of the majority cultural group often overlook diversity issues
and are inconsistent in focusing on problem solving in relation to the cli-
ent’s environment (Hays 1995).
There are a few potential advantages of using CBT with diverse youth:
Intersection of
Development and Culture
Culture influences many aspects of mental illness, including symptom
manifestation, coping styles, family and community support, willingness
84 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Acculturation and
Immigration Issues
The impact of immigration and acculturative stress on help seeking, treat-
ment engagement, and family functioning for ethnic minority and immi-
grant youth cannot be overstated. Acculturation, the extent to which an
individual adopts aspects of the dominant culture versus his or her indige-
nous culture, is a process pertinent to both immigrant and nonimmigrant
ethnic minority populations (Klonoff and Landrine 2000). Nonimmigrant
ethnic minority groups, such as Native Americans and African Americans,
often struggle to maintain their indigenous cultural lifestyles and values
while adopting the behaviors they need to function in the dominant cul-
ture (Kelly 2006; McDonald and Gonzalez 2006). Acculturation has been
identified as a risk factor for depressive symptoms among ethnic minority
groups (Sáez-Santiago and Bernal 2003), with some evidence indicating
that more acculturated immigrants have worse mental health outcomes
than less acculturated immigrants (Vega et al. 1998). Individuals who as-
similate into the dominant culture (disregard their culture of origin’s val-
ues and adopt dominant cultural values) may undergo a loss of traditional
support systems coupled with feelings of self-deprecation due to exposure
88 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
parents may contradict those of the dominant culture and cause identity
confusion for ethnic minority youth (Ho 1992; Rivers and Morrow 1995)
and conflict between parents and their children (Hansen et al. 2000).
Also, traditional hierarchies in immigrant families can be disrupted by par-
ents who must rely on children to translate and advocate for their families
(Suárez-Orozco et al. 2002).
Contextual Factors
Ethnic and racial minority groups are often overrepresented in lower so-
cioeconomic strata (U.S. Surgeon General 2001). Poverty and lack of re-
sources often produce hopelessness and helplessness among ethnic
minority clients and adversely affect their expectations for positive thera-
peutic outcomes (Bernal and Sáez-Santiago 2006; Koss-Chioino and Var-
gas 1992). Additionally, because of financial hardship, some parents need
to work multiple jobs and, as a result, are less available to their children.
While affluent, two-parent households may have the resources necessary
to supervise children’s out-of-session practice and therapeutic homework,
single parents struggling to provide for their families may not have the en-
ergy or time to devote to such endeavors (Greene 1992). For these rea-
sons, these parents are less likely to provide positive racial socialization to
the children who most need it.
Low-income communities often are characterized by unsafe neighbor-
hoods, gang activity, inadequate schools, poor housing conditions, limited
access to quality health care and social services, and a number of other
stressors. The ability of the family living in such conditions to follow
through on therapy assignments (such as behavioral activation) may be sig-
nificantly restricted due to these contextual factors. The limited literacy
skills of many immigrant and some ethnic minority parents provide an-
other potential barrier to compliance with written therapy homework and
behavioral plans. The intersection of undocumented legal status and low
SES creates another challenge for immigrant populations. Undocumented
families may have difficulty regularly attending appointments scheduled
during typical office hours because of the unpredictable nature of under-
the-table day labor or repercussions of missing a day of work (e.g., no ben-
efits and likely job loss for being absent).
Despite these barriers to compliance and treatment, diverse popula-
tions present with a number of strengths that can enhance treatment out-
comes. Social affiliation, common in many collectivist cultures, has been
found to be inversely associated with depression (Sáez-Santiago and Ber-
nal 2003). Resources such as strong connection to family, religious involve-
ment, and voluntary associations may be powerful therapeutic assets in
promoting positive change in ethnic minority clients.
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 91
Clinical Recommendations
Suggestions for Beginning CBT
Therapist Self-Assessment
The therapeutic process needs to start with the therapist’s own self-eval-
uation of his or her own cultural values, notions of acceptable behavior that
may be culturally laden, personal experience with social oppression versus
privilege, knowledge deficits, comfort in addressing and discussing issues
of diversity and discrimination, and personal biases (Arredondo and Ar-
ciniega 2001; Hays 2006; Pantalone et al. 2010). To begin, therapists must
be able to clearly identify their own cultural identity and the significance
of belonging to that cultural group, including the relationship of individuals
in that group with individuals from other groups institutionally, histori-
cally, and educationally (Arredondo et al. 1996). Therapists must examine
differences between themselves and their clients and assess their level of
comfort with working with culturally diverse clients who may have differ-
ent values and beliefs. Such self-evaluation can make the therapist more
attuned to social and environmental stressors that shape the client’s expe-
rience, such as exposure to oppression, and further help the clinician to
identify areas in which he or she needs more education and training
(Arredondo et al. 1996; Vera et al. 2003).
Therapists must remember that they have a stimulus value (e.g., gen-
der, race, dress) and that youth size them up the moment they meet re-
garding the therapist’s ability to help and to recognize differences between
them. Culturally skilled therapists are aware of their social impact on oth-
ers in the form of communication differences or interpersonal style
(Arredondo and Arciniega 2001). Therapists who have thought critically
about how they will be perceived by ethnocultural minority youth will bet-
ter prepare thoughtful questions and ways to recognize and address poten-
tial cultural differences.
Assessment
As discussed above, basic cultural competence calls for the therapist to
find a balance between educating himself or herself about the sociocultural
groups to which clients belong and recognizing that each client’s experi-
ences are unique and not necessarily dictated by group membership (Pan-
talone et al. 2010). At the same time, clinicians who overestimate the role
of these issues, inadequately assess individual differences, and neglect to
92 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
consider other relevant factors affecting mental health will likely have
poor treatment engagement and outcomes with diverse young populations
(Sue et al. 2009).
The Multidimensional Ecosystemic Comparative Approach (MECA;
Falicov 1998) balances the universalist (assumption that Western psycho-
therapeutic concepts are universally applicable across cultures) and cul-
ture-specific positions to help clinicians appreciate human similarities,
consider cultural differences, and recognize the uniqueness of each individ-
ual. MECA maintains that culture develops over time through membership
in a variety of domains (e.g., language, race and ethnicity, sexual orienta-
tion, religion, SES) and experiences in different contexts (e.g., discrimina-
tion or isolation where the individual lives and attends school). By adopting
a culturally responsive approach to assessment, clinicians will be informed
of cultural factors at each step of the CBT process, including case formula-
tion, diagnosis, treatment planning, and therapeutic intervention.
Tanaka-Matsumi and colleagues (1996) outlined the Culturally In-
formed Functional Assessment to assist behavioral therapists who are
culturally different from their clients in identifying the functional relation-
ship between the client’s presenting problem and the sociocultural envi-
ronment. The underlying assumption is that good behavioral therapists
assume that each individual’s reinforcement history is unique (i.e., differ-
ent from the therapist’s and other individuals’ from their cultural group).
The two major tasks facing CBT therapists are 1) the need to evaluate the
presenting problems using functional analysis and 2) the need to assess the
larger context of the client’s social network with attention to cultural in-
fluences (e.g., cultural definitions of problem behavior, knowledge of
accepted behavioral norms, cultural acceptability of behavior change strat-
egies, and culturally approved behavior change agents) (Okazaki and
Tanaka-Matsumi 2006). Recommendations include the use of an inter-
preter or cultural informant and acculturation measures to examine the
cultural identity, cultural match or mismatch with the clinician, and accul-
turative stress.
In addition to standard functional assessment with the client, the clini-
cian should interview family members to explore how the presenting prob-
lem is viewed from the family’s and sociocultural group’s perspective (i.e.,
is this a culturally normative idiom of distress?), what the family perceives
as the causes of the behavior, what characterizes traditional help-seeking in
the cultural group, and how the family responds to the behavior in everyday
situations (Tanaka-Matsumi et al. 1996). Assessment of cultural explana-
tions for the individual’s behaviors will reveal pertinent cognitive schemas
that may be targeted by interventions (e.g., it is inappropriate for a child to
challenge the authority of an elder family member). The clinician needs to
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 93
assess not only the quality of the child’s self-image but also the life experi-
ences of the parent to understand the role of racial pride, shame, or confu-
sion and how these factors influence the parent-child relationship (Greene
1992). Ensuring that these areas of inquiry are covered in the assessment
process will allow the clinician to entertain hypotheses to explain client be-
havior with a consciousness of what is culturally normative for this individual
and the sociocultural groups to which he or she belongs.
The task of culturally responsive assessment may seem daunting be-
cause there are so many domains of diversity to consider and no clinician
is bias-free. For this reason, a number of different models and tools have
been developed to guide clinicians’ assessment of both risk and protective
factors in the individual’s cultural environment. Hays (2008) proposed the
ADDRESSING model to guide assessment and consideration of the vari-
ous domains of diversity in case formulation:
with you?” or “What are your spiritual or religious beliefs?” the therapist
communicates a willingness to discuss these issues (Kelly 2006). Often cli-
ents are relieved when the therapist asks this type of question, or they
themselves have not previously considered how race and ethnicity contrib-
ute to their presenting problem (Harper and Iwamasa 2000). Culturally
competent therapists should “do their homework” to inform themselves
about what questions to ask and potential influences that the diversity is-
sues may have on the presenting problem. Alternatively, if the clinician
does not touch on such issues, the youth may perceive that the therapist
is uncomfortable discussing the client’s ethnic minority status, does not
value the client’s ethnicity, or truly cannot understand him or her (Harper
and Iwamasa 2000). Some investigators maintain that failure to address
ethnicity and cultural values contributes to dropout and treatment failure
(Fudge 1996; Harper and Iwamasa 2000).
Considering that many individuals belong to more than one minority
group, the clinician also should assess the degree to which the client’s self-
identity is tied to each of these diversity domains (Pantalone et al. 2010). For
instance, in many cases, gay ethnic minority youth identify more with being
a member of the GLBT community than with being an ethnic minority.
Case Example
Avery, a 14-year-old biracial (African American and white) adolescent pre-
sented for treatment with the primary concern of conflict with her father.
After having been raised by her white mother, Avery had to move in with her
African American Baptist father at age 10 when her mother died unexpect-
edly. Her father perceived that Avery had internalized racist messages and
that her conflicted relationship with him was rooted in her struggling with
her biracial identity. With further assessment, Avery revealed that in her
opinion, her bisexual orientation and conversion from Christianity to Bud-
dhism were the primary issues of contention between herself and her father.
housing, adequacy of health care and social services, legal problems, and
exposure to trauma need to be well understood in order to develop effec-
tive recommendations for intervention (Crawley et al. 2010; Hays 2006;
Vera et al. 2003). Additionally, clinicians may find useful outlets to en-
hance treatment engagement and effectiveness by fully understanding a
family’s cultural isolation versus access to a cultural community (e.g.,
availability of preferred foods or cultural art, music, and events), access to
nature, participation in a religious community in their preferred language,
interpersonal support (e.g., extended kinship, godparents, social net-
works), and involvement in political or social action groups (Hays 2006).
Framing treatment in a culturally acceptable way is crucial in promot-
ing treatment engagement, retention, and compliance. If the assessment
process has been truly culturally responsive, the diagnosis and treatment
planning stages should be consonant with the family’s perception of the
problem and will reflect a collaborative effort between clinician, client,
and the client’s family (Vera et al. 2003). Clients’ treatment goals may
place less emphasis on cognitive and behavioral changes but rather may fo-
cus on having more involvement in a supportive faith community or having
more balance in their lives (Pantalone et al. 2010).
Treatment Engagement
and Orientation to Treatment
The debate is ongoing about whether factors specific to theoretical orien-
tation or nonspecific factors in therapy (e.g., being understood, receiving
unconditional positive regard or respect, and being accepted) are respon-
sible for clinical improvement. Arguably, attention to nonspecific factors
in therapy is central to effective treatment engagement with ethnic minor-
ity youth (Harper and Iwamasa 2000; Sue et al. 2009). Engagement of
ethnic minority families may be particularly challenging given the stigma
associated with mental health treatment and a history of exploitation,
abuse, and disparities in mental health care that has created a deep-seated
suspicion of mental health professionals of the dominant culture (e.g.,
Tuskegee experiment, conversion therapy for GLBT individuals). It is in-
cumbent upon clinicians to understand how previous experiences and/or
misconceptions about mental health service providers may influence the
client’s perception of them. As mentioned before, these misconceptions
can be addressed by acknowledging cultural differences between clinician
and client, thus signaling openness to further discuss the topic and sensi-
tivity to the youth’s cultural context. Clinicians may need to be prepared
to do home visits or to reach out by phone to persuade reluctant family
96 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Family-Focused Interventions
Because of the emphasis on collectivism in many ethnic cultures, an em-
phasis on family-focused intervention may be most effective when work-
ing with ethnically and religiously diverse youth (Falicov 2009; Kumpfer
et al. 2002; Organista 2006; Paradis et al. 2006). As part of culturally re-
sponsive assessment, the therapist should already understand family struc-
tures and backgrounds as well as how clients’ behaviors affect the family
and vice versa (Pantalone et al. 2010). In a trial of CBT for depressed La-
tino adolescents that demonstrated treatment effectiveness, familismo
was considered in the assessment and treatment engagement phases by as-
sessing and addressing parent goals in the treatment process (Rosselló and
Bernal 1996). Additionally, family can be integrated into CBT sessions
post–treatment engagement. The Treatment for Adolescents with Depres-
sion Study demonstrated that involvement of extended family supported
compliance among African American youth in CBT (Sweeney et al. 2005).
With Latino adolescents, the module of family communication was em-
phasized to address intergenerational gaps in values. Therapists normalized
cultural differences to alleviate family stress and facilitated discussion
about the values and beliefs of the host culture and culture of origin with
the following goals: 1) promoting understanding between parents and ad-
olescents, 2) teaching the family positive communication and negotiation
skills, and 3) teaching the adolescent how to cope with negative feelings
and cognitions (Sweeney et al. 2005). Encouraging families to share migra-
tion narratives has been a helpful adaptation to family therapy to reduce
misunderstandings and to decrease silent suffering (Falicov 2009). When
there is a clash between personal and family obligations (individualism vs.
collectivism), the therapist should be careful not to impose his or her val-
ues, pathologize, or criticize. It is the therapist’s role to help the youth an-
ticipate the potential social consequences of certain decisions (Pantalone
et al. 2010).
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 99
Case Example
Naomi, a 16-year-old Filipina girl raised in the United States, presented
with conflict with her mother (a first-generation immigrant, single
mother) about her mother’s traditional belief that girls should not date un-
til after college (consistent with the mother’s upbringing). Due to the Fil-
ipino cultural taboo against discussing sexuality and intimate relationships
and her mother’s vehemence about her not dating, Naomi was unable to
engage her mother in open communication and started dating behind her
mother’s back. Family therapy focused on allowing the mother to explain
her values and express her concerns about dating while supporting Naomi
to resist peer pressure. Parent-centered sessions provided psychoeducation
about how difficult it is to bridge two cultures and the risks to Naomi if
she did not have a parent to talk with about her challenges. These sessions
included a discussion of the reality of the mother not being able to super-
vise her daughter 24 hours a day, the likelihood that Naomi might stop
seeking her advice and would be more vulnerable to peer pressure if com-
munication remained strained, the normalization that Naomi was likely at-
tracted to the boy and he to her, and the possibility that Naomi might
choose to defy her mother if she perceived the mother as being overly re-
strictive. Individual therapy helped Naomi weigh the pros and cons of con-
tinuing to deceive her mother versus choosing to be a nonconformist and
not follow her peers’ examples, as well as learn to evaluate relationships
with peers and with potential boyfriends.
Cognitive Restructuring
As one of the core CBT skills, cognitive restructuring can be a powerful
tool to use with youth to address diversity issues. A culturally competent
CBT clinician will strive to integrate what is known about the child’s cul-
tural values and environment into the teaching and implementation of this
skill. In many cases, cognitive restructuring with diverse youth parallels its
use in majority populations. For example, youth with disabilities often
need assistance in decatastrophizing the impact of their disability (Mona
et al. 2006). Cognitive restructuring can focus on personal strengths that
were unaffected by the disability to dispute the belief that “Nothing will
ever be the same.”
For diverse youth, clinicians may want to simplify the A-B-C-D-E method
(based on Albert Ellis’s work), which teaches the client to identify the
Activating event,
Beliefs about the activating event,
Consequences (feelings and behaviors),
Disputation of irrational beliefs, and
Effects of disputation.
100 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case Example
José, a 17-year-old gay Catholic adolescent from Mexico, presented for in-
dividual therapy for depression. He was struggling to reconcile his Catholic
identity with his sexual orientation. He had internalized negative messages,
102 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Behavioral Activation
When designing behavioral activation for diverse youth, the clinician
should attend to contextual factors such as income, safety of neighbor-
hoods, gender roles, and other cultural norms. A clinician who recom-
mends that a child living in the inner city exercise regularly by walking or
running around the neighborhood, going to the park, or working out at the
gym without thoroughly assessing such contextual factors may inadvert-
ently put the child in danger of crossing gang lines and exposing himself or
herself to violence, assumes access to parks, and presumes that the family
has the resources to pay for private gym membership, respectively (all of
which demonstrate the clinician’s lack of skill, knowledge, and under-
standing of the client). Clinicians need to help children identify activities
that are congruent with their environment, do not require payment, or are
readily available to low-income families (e.g., free admission days at mu-
seums, visiting friends, mall walks) (Organista 2006).
Follow-through on behavioral activation may be highly dependent on
how it is viewed by the family. For Latinos, focusing on themselves and im-
proving their own moods may cause problems for more traditional families
who value familismo. Therefore, activity schedules that include activities
for the youth to do with and without family are more likely to be well re-
ceived (Organista 2006). Additionally, traditional gender roles dictate that
Latinas take on a caretaking role in the family by helping around the house
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 103
with child care, cleaning, and chores. In these cases, behavioral activation
might be more well received if instead of framing it as a way for the client
to take care of herself, the clinician proposes the rationale that when the
client takes care of herself, she is better able to care for her family (Organ-
ista 2006). For children who manifest psychological distress primarily in
somatic symptoms, behavioral activation (e.g., physical exercise, distrac-
tion) in conjunction with relaxation techniques may be an intervention
that is easily understood by the family (Interian and Díaz-Martínez 2007).
Behavioral activation may also serve as a useful complement to cogni-
tive restructuring to buffer youth from oppressive influences by connect-
ing them to culturally specific networks and religious institutions (Hays
1995). For African American and Latino youth, clinicians can connect
youth with church communities, local cultural organizations, English
classes (for those whose first language is not English), and mentoring as
part of their behavioral activation interventions (Interian and Díaz-
Martínez 2007; Sweeney et al. 2005). GLBT youth, in particular, benefit
from assistance in identifying appropriate agencies and organizations that
will allow them to build social support networks and experience more pos-
itive events (Safren et al. 2001). Such culturally attuned behavioral acti-
vation interventions may decrease social isolation, enhance positive ethnic
identity development, and improve overall mental health.
Case Example
Ming is a 13-year-old girl who emigrated from China at age 11 and recently
relocated to a new city in the United States. She feels isolated and differ-
ent at her new school because most of the students are African American.
She reported that the only other Asian students were “Gothic” (an off-
shoot of punk culture), a group with which she did not identify. In order
to increase her social activity level, I (RFP) found a Chinese American
agency near where Ming lived and suggested that she and her mother in-
vestigate some of the classes and recreational activities. We discussed how
classes on Chinese cultural heritage might lead Ming to meet other youth
with whom she would feel more connected. We also discussed that the
youth group field trips could help her get to know her new city. To address
her mother’s concern that Ming was not serious enough about academics,
I explained that the agency also provided academic assistance such as tu-
toring and English-language classes, which might help Ming improve her
writing for standardized testing.
Problem Solving
Problem solving is another useful complement to cognitive restructuring
when there is an environmentally based problem (Hays 2006). Problem
solving is especially relevant to ethnocultural minority youth’s contextual
104 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
experiences that may negatively influence their mood and behavior be-
cause of the focus on effecting change on the environment. Therapists can
help youth (already disempowered because of their age) draw on commu-
nity and family resources to address unjust treatment. For example, using
family problem-solving to address discriminatory practices at the child’s
school can empower parents to file complaints, request to speak to some-
one’s supervisor, seek out a new school, or consult an attorney. Helping
ethnocultural minority children (and at times, their parents) successfully
change their environment may serve to increase their self-efficacy and
willingness to implement learned coping skills in subsequent situations.
CBT with ethnic minority youth may require a higher level of interven-
tion in the larger community than CBT with dominant cultural groups. Ef-
fecting change on the community level and healing a community of
oppressive influences resonates with Afrocentric values of responsibility
and self-determination, empowers clients to use more active coping styles,
and strengthens positive ethnic identity (Kelly 2006). Problem solving can
promote external change in the contingencies in the environment that may
maintain child symptoms (Kelly 2006). This intervention may entail em-
powering the child or family to start an ethnocultural youth group at the
school or in the community when one does not already exist (e.g., Latino
Student Association, Gay-Straight Alliance).
Case Example
Kadija is a 13-year-old African American girl who was having significant
difficulty getting along with a particular teacher at school. She and her
mother viewed this teacher as often discriminating against Kadija (e.g.,
blaming only her for something a group of students did). Her mother at-
tempted to advocate for her daughter by talking to the teacher, but she had
a strong emotional reaction to the teacher and would end up raising her
voice, which only seemed to exacerbate the teacher’s discriminatory be-
havior. Through the use of problem solving and a review of communication
skills in different cultural contexts during therapy, the family was able to
enlist the help of an African American teacher who was willing to facilitate
this discussion and identify assertive, rather than emotional, methods of
opening discussion of the issue with school staff.
Exposure Therapy
Traditional exposure therapies for anxiety and panic disorders have in-
cluded interoceptive exposure to somatic symptoms evoked during a panic
attack. Panic attacks brought on by stressors related to the client’s minor-
ity status, however, may need additional culturally relevant exposures cou-
pled with relaxation training and problem solving to decrease chronic
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 105
stress levels. For GLBT youth, coming out to specific individuals can be
planned as clinicians would plan any other exposure—using a hierarchy of
how difficult it would be to come out to particular individuals (Glassgold
2009).
When engaging the client in exposure therapy, CBT clinicians need to
be mindful of cultural factors that may alter effectiveness. For example,
clinicians may need to address the role of shame with Asian American cli-
ents by weighing the pros and cons of the client experiencing short-term
embarrassment while completing exposures versus the long-term conse-
quences of not doing the exposures (Iwamasa et al. 2006a). For religious
clients, the therapist needs to be careful not to engage the client in some-
thing that is specifically prohibited by religious law (Paradis et al. 2006).
Case Example
Nicolas, an 8-year-old Dominican boy and observant Jehovah’s Witness,
presented with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). He was experienc-
ing blasphemous obsessions about swearing at or hating God that were
highly embarrassing and distressing to him and his family. I (RFP) worked
with the family in psychoeducational sessions to help them understand the
nature of OCD and how obsessions were often ego-dystonic and not stem-
ming from a budding rebellion or defiance. We worked collaboratively to
externalize OCD and separate it from Nicolas’ identity by making OCD
the “bad guy” who bothered Nicolas with the most personally distressing
thoughts it could generate. With a solid understanding of OCD and the ra-
tionale for exposure and response prevention, he and his mother were will-
ing to proceed with exposures to acting out his obsessions (e.g., swearing
at God).
Assertiveness Training
Traditional assertiveness training stresses the rights of the individual,
which may pose problems for youth from more collectivist cultural back-
grounds. A breach in the therapeutic relationship may occur if the CBT cli-
nician is perceived as trying to impose his or her cultural value system on
a child or family by empowering the child to put his or her needs above
those of the family or community. Organista and Muñoz (1996) suggested
that instead, clinicians should frame assertiveness training as a way to help
children develop bicultural competency. Assertiveness may be described
as an effective communication skill in mainstream America that will serve
the youth well in school and in pursuing a professional career. At the same
time, the clinician may help youth recognize that assertive communication
is inappropriate or may need to be used sensitively in other contexts, such
as at home or in religious communities (Hays 1995; Koss-Chioino and Var-
106 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case Example
Esmeralda is a 12-year-old Guatemalan girl exhibiting oppositional behav-
ior at home, poor self-esteem, and academic decline. In addition to parent
training and school consultation, I (RFP) engaged Esmeralda in a variety of
activities meant to bolster positive ethnic identity development. Every
week, I had Esmeralda read a printout from a Web site featuring successful,
famous Latinas in the United States and answer questions about them to
help her draw connections between their ethnic backgrounds and hers.
I recommended seminars at the nearby university that were open to the
community, focusing on Latino leadership and higher education, so that
Esmeralda was exposed to role models, such as Latino politicians and col-
lege students. I also helped the family find ethnic minority college students
at the local university who were willing to donate time to tutor Esmeralda
after school to help increase her self-efficacy in her classes.
Future Directions
The topics covered in this chapter illustrate the need for a coherent ap-
proach to integrating cultural competence and CBT. To accomplish this
goal, a number of changes must occur in the fields of mental health train-
ing, service provision, and research. Training programs for all types of men-
tal health professionals need to improve preparation of clinicians to work
with culturally diverse populations in addition to training them in EBTs
(Vera et al. 2003). Diversity and cultural competence training has been
demonstrated to increase knowledge about ethnocultural populations
among trainees, improve client perceptions of therapist sensitivity, and en-
hance treatment outcomes (Yutrzenka 1995). Clinical CBT supervisors
need to be willing to examine their own values, beliefs, attitudes, and
worldviews to build the foundation of self-awareness (Iwamasa et al.
2006b). Likewise, cultural issues need to be raised in supervision to pro-
mote the competence of clinicians in training (Iwamasa et al. 2006b).
Additionally, culturally responsive assessment in clinical practice is incon-
sistent in part because of the lack of training, but also because of the de-
emphasis of culture in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders (American Psychiatric Association 2000) by relegating cultural
formulation to an appendix as opposed to inclusion of such issues as an in-
herent part of multiaxial assessment (Hays 2008).
Culturally Diverse Children and Adolescents 109
Self-Assessment Questions
3.1. Which of the following is NOT a strength of CBT when implemented
with ethnocultural minority youth?
3.2. Parent training protocols with ethnic minority youth may improve
treatment retention and outcomes by including an emphasis on
A. Time-out.
B. Physical discipline.
C. Natural consequences.
D. Racial socialization.
A. Acculturation stress.
B. Internalized oppression.
C. Feelings as facts.
D. Ableism.
3.4. CBT with an Iraqi (Muslim) 12-year-old girl with externalizing prob-
lems might be enhanced by
A. Family-focused sessions.
B. Individual-focused sessions.
C. Emphasis on assertiveness training in all contexts.
D. Behavioral activation.
A. Behavioral activation.
B. Problem solving.
C. Assertiveness training.
D. Cognitive restructuring.
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
Population-Specific Information
American Psychological Association: Guidelines on multicultural education,
training, research, practice, and organizational change for psychologists.
August 2002. Available at: http://www.apa.org/pi/oema/resources/
policy/multicultural-guidelines.aspx. Accessed April 19, 2011.
112 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Assessment
Hays PA: Addressing Cultural Complexities in Practice: Assessment, Di-
agnosis, and Therapy, 2nd Edition. Washington, DC, American Psy-
chological Association, 2008
Tanaka-Matsumi J, Seiden DY, Lam KN: The Culturally Informed Func-
tional Assessment (CIFA) Interview: a strategy for cross-cultural be-
havioral practice. Cogn Behav Pract 3:215–233, 1996
References
Abudabbeh N, Hays PA: Cognitive-behavioral therapy with people of Arab heri-
tage, in Culturally Responsive Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy: Assessment,
Practice, and Supervision. Edited by Hays PA, Iwamasa GY. Washington, DC,
American Psychological Association, 2006, pp 141–159
American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric
Association, 2000
Arredondo PT, Arciniega GM: Strategies and techniques for counselor training
based on the multicultural counseling competencies. J Multicult Couns Devel
29:263–273, 2001
Arredondo PT, Toporek R, Brown SP, et al: Operationalization of the multicultural
counseling competencies. J Multicult Couns Devel 24:42–78, 1996
Balsam KF, Martell CR, Safren SA: Affirmative cognitive-behavioral therapy with
lesbian, gay, and bisexual people, in Culturally Responsive Cognitive-Behav-
ioral Therapy: Assessment, Practice, and Supervision. Edited by Hays PA,
Iwamasa GY. Washington, DC, American Psychological Association, 2006,
pp 223–243
Bandura A: Self-efficacy mechanism in human agency. Am Psychol 37:122–147,
1982
Barona A, Santos de Barona M: Recommendations for the Psychological Treatment
of Latino/Hispanic Populations. Washington, DC, Association of Black Psy-
chologists, 2003
Bernal G, Sáez-Santiago E: Culturally centered psychosocial interventions.
J Community Psychol 34:121–132, 2006
Bernal G, Scharrón-del-Río MR: Are empirically supported treatments valid for
ethnic minorities? Toward an alternative approach for treatment research.
Cultur Divers Ethnic Minor Psychol 7:328–342, 2001
Bernal G, Jiménez-Chafey MI, Domenech Rodríguez MM: Cultural adaptation of
treatments: a resource for considering culture in evidence-based practice. Prof
Psychol Res Pr 40:361–368, 2009
Carter MM, Sbrocco T, Lewis EL, et al: Parental bonding and anxiety: differences
between African American and European American college students.
J Anxiety Disord 15:555–569, 2001
114 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
SINCE the 1990s, the field of mental health has significantly expanded
its knowledge base on the treatment of pediatric psychiatric disorders
through empirical research, which informs everyday clinical practice. This
is most evident in the area of pediatric psychopharmacology. Pharmaco-
therapy has become an important treatment tool for clinicians treating
children and adolescents with psychiatric disorders. Another effective
treatment modality for many of these disorders is cognitive-behavior ther-
apy (CBT), a well-established psychosocial intervention. Empirical evi-
dence now exists to support the combination of both pharmacotherapy
and CBT in the pediatric mental health sector for optimal outcome. Al-
though the evidence supporting the efficacy of both interventions is rela-
119
120 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Pharmacotherapy Treatment
Depression
The evidence-based literature supports the use of a class of antidepressants
called the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) for children and
adolescents. Although each of the SSRIs has individual pharmacological pro-
files, they all share the common property of effecting serotonin transporter
inhibition. Abnormalities of serotonin function are believed to be critical in
the etiology of depression and anxiety. In addition, serotonin is believed to
affect sleep and appetite, and reduced serotonin functioning may cause in-
somnia and depression (Hamrin and Scahill 2005). When an SSRI is initi-
ated, it generally takes 3–4 weeks to show evidence of an effect. Some of
the better-known and common adverse effects associated with SSRIs in-
clude gastrointestinal upset, insomnia, restlessness, and sexual dysfunction.
The clinician should carefully monitor the patient for the emergence of side
effects during treatment, and the medication timing of dose and dosage may
need to be adjusted to minimize adverse reactions.
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 121
The only medications approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Adminis-
tration (FDA) for the acute and maintenance treatment of major depres-
sive disorder in children and adolescents are fluoxetine for ages 8–18 and
escitalopram for ages 12–17. Currently fluoxetine is the only medication
to yield three positive double-blind placebo-controlled trials to support its
efficacy (Emslie et al. 1997, 2002b, 2008). Given its long half-life (i.e., the
time it takes for the plasma concentration of a drug to reach half of its orig-
inal concentration), there are fewer concerns about discontinuation syn-
drome. Discontinuation syndrome is a flu-like condition consisting of
symptoms such as malaise, nausea, and headaches; the syndrome may oc-
cur after the patient stops taking the medication. Two studies have shown
escitalopram to be more efficacious than placebo in adolescents (Emslie et
al. 2009; Wagner et al. 2003). Escitalopram has the safest profile of all the
SSRIs regarding interactions with other medications. This medication has
an intermediate half-life; thus, discontinuation syndrome is possible and
should be watched for.
Despite positive studies indicating the effectiveness of other SSRIs in
the treatment of pediatric depression, such agents are still considered off-
label treatments at this time. These medications include citalopram, ser-
traline, and paroxetine. The efficacy of citalopram over placebo is sup-
ported by one of two published studies (Wagner et al. 2004b; von Knorring
et al. 2006). Two parallel placebo-controlled trials of sertraline showed sta-
tistically significant differences with sertraline compared with placebo
when the data were pooled (Wagner et al. 2003). Paroxetine (Paxil) was
shown to have antidepressant activity in adolescents on some primary and
secondary measures Keller et al. 2001, whereas two other studies did not
demonstrate efficacy versus placebo (Berard et al. 2006; Emslie et al.
2006).
Results were mixed in studies of non-SSRI antidepressants in children
and adolescents. Trials of nefazodone and mirtazapine resulted in unpub-
lished negative double-blind, placebo-controlled depression trials (Emslie
et al. 2002a). When venlafaxine ER was studied in the pediatric popula-
tion, it was found to be effective only in depressed adolescents (Emslie et
al. 2007). To date, no studies have been designed to assess the efficacy of
bupropion for pediatric depression.
A meta-analysis of tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) for the treatment of
pediatric depression found that they are not more efficacious than placebo
(Ryan and Varma 1998); therefore, TCAs are not recommended at this time.
They are considered inappropriate for children and adolescents because of
their significant side effects, including anticholinergic effects (e.g., memory
changes, constipation, confusion, blurred vision, dry mouth, sedation), and in
overdose their cardiovascular effects and high lethality (Varley 2001).
122 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Anxiety Disorders
CBT and pharmacotherapy are the treatments with the broadest evidence
of efficacy for pediatric anxiety disorders. When CBT and medication are
used in combination, they are more efficacious than either treatment alone
(Walkup et al. 2008). As with major depression, SSRIs are the first-line
medication for the treatment of anxiety disorders. Three of the most rig-
orous randomized controlled trials (RCTs) investigated the efficacy of
treating children diagnosed with one or several anxiety disorders (i.e., gen-
eralized anxiety disorder [GAD], separation anxiety disorder, and social
phobia) with the following SSRIs: fluvoxamine (Research Unit on Pediat-
ric Psychopharmacology Anxiety Study Group 2001), fluoxetine (Birma-
her et al. 2003), or sertraline (Walkup et al. 2008). Each of these studies
provides strong evidence for the efficacy of SSRIs in treating GAD, social
phobia, and/or separation anxiety disorder.
Studies have demonstrated the efficacy of sertraline and venlafaxine
ER (Rynn et al. 2001, 2007) for the treatment of GAD. Paroxetine (Wag-
ner et al. 2004a), fluoxetine (Beidel et al. 2007), and venlafaxine ER
(March et al. 2007) have been found beneficial in the treatment of social
anxiety. Alprazolam in a very small trial of avoidant adolescents demon-
strated benefit but lacked statistical significance over placebo (Simeon et
al. 1992).
For panic disorder, daily use of paroxetine demonstrated significant im-
provement in subjects, with only transient and mild adverse effects asso-
ciated with higher doses (Masi et al. 2001). In addition, an open case series
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 123
Attention-Deficit/
Hyperactivity Disorder
Hundreds of studies conducted since the 1960s have consistently shown the
efficacy of stimulant medication in improving symptoms associated with
ADHD in children and adolescents. The recommended initial psychophar-
macological treatment of ADHD is a trial with one of the medications cur-
rently approved by the FDA (Pliszka 2007). The FDA-approved stimulant
medications for the treatment of ADHD include dextroamphetamine,
D- and D,L-methylphenidate, mixed amphetamine salts, and lisdexamfet-
amine. The two nonstimulant medications that are currently FDA approved
for ADHD are atomoxetine and guanfacine XR. It is believed that inatten-
tion and/or hyperactivity may be the result of insufficient dopamine and
norepinephrine activity. Stimulant medication primarily increases synaptic
concentrations of dopamine whereas nonstimulant medications, such as ato-
moxetine, increase norepinephrine synaptic concentrations (Solanto 1998).
Evidence reflecting the benefits of stimulant medication was demonstrated
by the Multimodal Treatment Study of Children With ADHD (MTA),
which is detailed in the section “Review of Combination Treatment,” in
“Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder” later in this chapter.
Some of the better-known adverse effects associated with stimulant
use are suppression of appetite, weight loss, insomnia, and headache. Chil-
dren with a preexisting heart condition should receive a consultation with
a cardiologist before initiation of treatment with a stimulant medication
(Pliszka 2007). According to Mosholder et al. (2009), symptomatology
consistent with psychosis or mania may arise during treatment with stim-
ulants and represents adverse effects. It is controversial whether or not tics
occur more often in children and adolescents treated with stimulant med-
ication. Some researchers have found that most tics that emerge during
treatment are transient, and chronic tics are rather rare (Gadow et al.
1999). In children and adolescents with comorbid Tourette’s syndrome
124 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Depression
There has been empirical support for the combination of CBT and phar-
macotherapy for depressive disorders.
TADS (March et al. 2004) was a large, multisite study designed to com-
pare four different interventions: CBT alone, fluoxetine alone, CBT plus
fluoxetine, and CBT plus placebo. The trial showed that combination treat-
ments held an advantage over CBT or pharmacotherapy, specifically for ad-
olescents with moderate to severe depression. The combination (fluoxetine
plus CBT) was superior to placebo plus CBT, to fluoxetine alone, and to
CBT alone. Additionally, fluoxetine alone was superior to CBT alone.
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 125
Anxiety Disorders
In the treatment of anxiety disorders, both CBT and pharmacotherapy are
considered efficacious as monotherapies; however, often symptom resolu-
tion is not complete, and many patients remain symptomatic. Additionally,
predictors and moderators have been difficult to identify from these stud-
ies (Compton et al. 2004). Until recently, only a scarcity of research dem-
onstrated the relative or combined efficacy of these interventions. Over
the past several years, the field of mental health has focused on studying
126 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Attention-Deficit/
Hyperactivity Disorder
The largest clinical trial conducted to evaluate the efficacy of different
treatment modalities for ADHD is the MTA. The study found that at
14-month follow-up, the combined treatment arm (stimulant and behav-
ioral treatment) and stimulant treatment alone provided greater symptom
improvement for core symptoms of ADHD than did the behavioral treat-
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 127
ment arm (MTA Cooperative Group 1999). At 24-month and 8-year fol-
low-ups, the greatest predictors of outcome were initial severity of
symptoms and continued medication compliance (Molina et al. 2009). In-
terestingly, when areas of functioning were reviewed—such as opposi-
tional or aggressive symptoms, internalizing symptoms, teacher-rated
social skills, parent-child relations, and reading achievement—combina-
tion treatment was consistently more effective than routine community
care, whereas medication alone and behavioral treatment alone were not
as effective (MTA Cooperative Group 1999). However, these longitudinal
findings need to be interpreted with caution because no random assign-
ment was in effect, and children in all the “conditions” were receiving as-
sorted treatments and a variety of self-selected combinations.
Clinical Characteristics
In selecting an individualized treatment strategy, we recommend a de-
tailed assessment, with particular attention to the factors discussed in the
128 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
1. Patient factors
2. System factors
3. Practitioner factors
Patient Factors
Patient Perspective
Patients may envision themselves playing an important role in their treat-
ment. They may want to be an active participant in the treatment process.
Such individuals readily agree to a CBT approach. Other patients, how-
ever, may want their treatment driven by the clinician only. These patients
may not be strong candidates for CBT, and pharmacotherapy may be more
acceptable to them.
Symptom Severity
It is essential to assess the severity of symptoms before determining which
intervention should be initiated first (CBT, pharmacotherapy, or com-
bined). Clinical wisdom supports the recommendation that the more se-
vere the symptoms, the more strongly medication should be considered.
Some clinicians might consider pharmacotherapy as the only intervention.
This is more likely to be the case for disorders such as ADHD, for which
the evidence of medication as the main intervention is very strong.
For depressive and anxiety disorders, if the severity is mild, then the
recommendation is to initiate CBT first. Continuous monitoring is needed
and a switch to a combined approach should be made if symptoms worsen.
For moderate to severe symptoms, medications (alone or combined with
CBT) are recommended. Data from TADS (March et al. 2004) indicates
that adolescents with moderate to severe depression have the best chance
of clinically significant improvement at 12 weeks if they start with a com-
bination of medication and CBT. Similarly, for moderate to severe anxiety
disorders, recent research supports the use of combined treatment
(Walkup et al. 2008). With medication treatment, symptom reduction is
seen as early as week 3 or 4; and with CBT, symptom reduction occurs
later in treatment (Keeton and Ginsburg 2008). Furthermore, early im-
provement also leads to overall successful treatment (Westra et al. 2007).
Although previous studies recommended CBT for mild to moderate
pediatric anxiety cases only (James et al. 2005), more recent evidence
from CAMS (Walkup et al. 2008) shows that CBT is an effective interven-
tion for patients with moderate to severe symptoms and is a relatively risk-
free intervention compared to pharmacotherapy. However, patients might
not be able to participate in CBT if they have significant symptoms. Severe
symptoms could become a hindrance to compliance with psychotherapy
appointments and could also lead to a general feeling of hopelessness and
a pessimistic outlook (e.g., “I am feeling terrible, and it is too hard to do
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 131
the things I need to feel better”). Therefore, in severe cases, the combined
approach should be considered as first-line treatment.
Notwithstanding, a combined approach can have its challenges. For ex-
ample, symptom reduction with medication could make implementing
CBT difficult: in a patient who no longer has anxiety arousal or symptoms,
it is difficult to teach the skills necessary to cope effectively with those
triggers. Severity of symptoms is an important factor in determining which
intervention to choose first, and a combined approach of CBT and phar-
macotherapy is recommended if symptoms are severe.
Case Example
Feliciana is a 10-year-old Latino girl with no formal psychiatric history who
was referred by her pediatrician to the emergency room secondary to impair-
ing symptoms of anxiety over the past 2 months. At presentation, Feliciana
reported daily symptoms of nausea, vomiting, trembling, feeling nervous,
and school refusal. Other symptoms included initial insomnia >3 hours (as
a result of worrying about school), appetite disturbance (not eating anything
during school time and nighttime overeating), and having occasional feelings
of dizziness. She also reported feeling sad, frustrated, and overwhelmed. The
mood symptoms were in the context of her getting “tired” of her anxiety.
Onset of symptoms was described as “sudden,” and a recent change in school
with subsequent difficulty in adjusting to the new environment was the main
stressor. She reported a long-standing history of excessive worries. The wor-
ries were about her school performance, the health of her mother, the rela-
tionship between her parents, earthquakes, and someone breaking into their
house. She reported symptoms suggestive of a panic attack (heart beating
too fast and breathing rapidly). She was medically discharged from the
emergency room and given a provisional diagnosis of GAD; separation anxi-
ety disorder and panic disorder were ruled out.
Although CBT was the preferred intervention by the parent, consider-
ing the severity of symptoms (progressive worsening of anxiety leading to
school refusal) and symptom profile (severe insomnia and other physiolog-
ical symptoms), a combined approach (CBT and fluoxetine) was recom-
mended and agreed on. Fluoxetine was started at 10 mg for 2 weeks and
then increased to 20 mg. Psychoeducation was provided to the parent by
discussing the disorder, its course, and the role of medications in address-
ing target symptoms of anxiety and insomnia. By week 3, Feliciana re-
ported some improvement in her anxiety symptoms, especially with
respect to her insomnia and feeling less overwhelmed. The CBT therapist
focused on psychoeducation, identification of triggers, relaxation breath-
ing, cognitive restructuring, problem solving, and behavior modification.
Feliciana was maintained at that dose for the next 5 months. She was able
to successfully start attending school on a regular basis after week 6 of
treatment. By week 12, Feliciana reported significant improvement in
symptoms, with resolution of most of her symptoms. CBT was tapered to
once every 2 weeks and then monthly sessions. Feliciana has been attend-
ing school regularly and has been symptom-free for the past 4 months.
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 133
Treatment Response
In patients who started with monotherapy (CBT or pharmacotherapy
alone), lack of improvement or suboptimal improvement after 6–8 weeks
of treatment typically becomes an indication for a combined approach
(Keeton and Ginsburg 2008). Provided that the lack of improvement is
not due to noncompliance with recommendations (therapy or medica-
tions), it is reflective of the severity of illness and lack of response to one
intervention. An alternative to a combined approach would be to intensify
the same intervention; for example, the therapist could increase CBT ses-
134 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
sions to twice weekly or the psychiatrist could increase the dose of medi-
cation or add other agents.
Case Example
Jonna, a 14-year-old Jewish adolescent girl in ninth-grade regular education
at a coed Jewish private school, presented to the outpatient clinic with
symptoms of inattention, distractibility, and poor organization. Other
symptoms included losing items (like her debit card), impulsivity related
to speaking out of turn, and poor concentration. Symptoms of inattention
and impulsivity were negatively impacting her academics regarding time
needed to complete her assignments, ability to focus in school, and her
peer relationships. Regarding her symptoms of inattention, Jonna and her
parents noted that she frequently made careless mistakes in her homework
and exams, often appeared dazed (as reported by teachers and peers), had
difficulty organizing tasks, forgot to hand in homework assignments that
were completed, and was easily distracted. Hyperactive and impulsive
symptoms that were currently noted included fidgeting, appearing as if she
was driven by a motor, talking excessively, blurting out answers in class be-
fore being called on, and often interrupting others in conversation.
Jonna was previously diagnosed with ADHD, combined type, at age 7
and was successfully treated with Adderall XR, 30 mg, until age 13. About
1 year ago, medication had been discontinued by her parents.
Jonna met criteria for ADHD and was willing to restart medications. Ad-
ditional areas of clinical concern included Jonna’s anxiety related to succeeding
at school and being a competitive candidate for college. In light of her strong
desire to apply to a number of competitive universities, Jonna had signed up
for a plethora of extracurricular activities at school, including the environmen-
tal and drama clubs, debate and soccer teams, and art group. Jonna did not
meet criteria for a specific anxiety disorder but had worries and anxiety related
to school pressure, measuring up to her peers and older sibling, and meeting
her future goals. Family history was relevant for anxiety disorder (mother, suc-
cessful remission of symptoms following psychotherapy), bipolar disorder (fa-
ther), and suicide (paternal uncle with unknown psychiatric diagnosis).
Jonna was restarted on medication, and immediate improvement in
symptoms of ADHD was noted. Benefits far outweighed the side effects
(mild loss of appetite). However, over the next several months, her anxiety
symptoms worsened, which resulted in more impairment and academic
decline. This led to negativistic thinking (“I will never get better”), sad
mood, low self-esteem, and hopelessness. Jonna recognized the need to
seek treatment for her anxiety and depressive symptoms to achieve overall
better outcome. The possibility of stimulants worsening her anxiety was
considered, but this seemed unlikely because Jonna was persistently anx-
ious even during times of an extended drug holiday. The need for medica-
tions to address ADHD was clear, but the question was, “Should we treat
comorbidities with an SSRI, CBT, or a combined approach?”
Owing to successful remission of core symptoms of ADHD on medi-
cations, Jonna initially expressed willingness for a medication trial of an
SSRI to target symptoms of anxiety as well. We conducted a detailed as-
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 135
System Factors
In addition to patient factors that may influence clinical decision-making
regarding the use of a specific treatment approach, system factors also me-
diate treatment choices. These system factors are especially critical to con-
sider when working with youth, because these patients are heavily
dependent on and influenced by the family, social, school, and cultural sys-
tems in which they are embedded.
Parental Attitudes
Treatment choice. In most cases, parents are the ultimate arbiters of
the type of treatment in which their child will engage. The way parents
conceptualize the nature of their child’s psychiatric condition and associ-
136 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case Examples
Mariela is the 50-year-old mother of a 16-year-old girl with major depres-
sion. At the age of 45, Mariela was prescribed an SSRI for symptoms asso-
ciated with a debilitating major depressive episode; she reported not liking
“the way it made me feel” and stopped taking her medication against med-
ical advice. She explained that her negative experience was exacerbated by
the fact that “my doctor didn’t listen to me.” Consequently, she was ex-
tremely reluctant to even consider employing psychotropic medication
when the recommendation was made by her daughter’s clinician after a
trial of CBT failed to address some unremitting neurovegetative symptoms
of the illness.
Societal Factors
The larger social, intellectual, and political zeitgeist by which a child and
his or her family is influenced is another system factor that can inform the
clinician’s attitudes about treatment and associated treatment choices.
Practitioner Factors
Both patient and system factors that inform decision-making practices for
the selection of a single or combined treatment are mediated by a third
variable: practitioner factors. The clinician should consider the influence
of his or her own specific characteristics when making treatment recom-
mendations and/or assisting youth and families with the treatment deci-
sion-making process. The following factors should be considered:
Conclusion
CBT and pharmacotherapy have been shown to be efficacious interven-
tions to treat many psychiatric disorders in children and adolescents. It is
not uncommon for clinicians to use a combined treatment approach (CBT
plus medication) to improve outcomes when the use of a single interven-
tion is suboptimal and/or symptom remission is incomplete. In recent
years, empirical support for use of the combination treatment approach
has grown; however, there is still the need for developing guidelines to di-
rect when to use these treatments alone or in combination, as well as
guidelines for sequencing approaches.
We suggest that a detailed assessment with special attention to child and
parent factors and system factors would assist a clinician in making treatment
decisions. In addition, there are certain practitioner factors that could influ-
ence the choice of the treatment approach. Consideration of all these factors
and creation of an inventory of the patient’s clinical characteristics will help
clinicians in providing individualized care and achieve the desired outcome.
142 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Self-Assessment Questions
4.1. The only other medication besides fluoxetine that the U.S. Food and
Drug Administration has approved for the treatment of major de-
pressive disorder in adolescents (12–17 years) is
A. Sertraline.
B. Escitalopram.
C. Paroxetine.
D. Fluvoxamine.
E. Imipramine.
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 143
4.4. For a 13-year-old patient presenting with a first episode of major de-
pression, the clinician should
4.5. Which of the following are important factors to consider when de-
ciding which intervention to choose from?
A. Severity of symptoms.
B. Prior experience with treatment.
C. Comorbidities.
D. Availability of resources.
E. All of the above.
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
Leahy RL (ed): Contemporary Cognitive Therapy: Theory, Research, and
Practice. New York, Guilford, 2004
Morris TL, March JS (eds): Anxiety Disorders in Children and Adoles-
cents, 2nd Edition. New York, Guilford, 2004
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, www.aacap.org
American Psychiatric Association, www.psych.org
Anxiety Disorders Association of America, www.adaa.org
Attention-Deficit Disorders Association, www.add.org
Family Guide to Keeping Youth Mentally Healthy and Drug Free,
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration,
www.family.samhsa.gov
MindZone, Annenberg Foundation Trust at Sunnylands with the Annen-
berg Public Policy Center of the University of Pennsylvania,
www.fhidc.com/annenberg/copecaredeal
National Alliance for the Mentally Ill, www.nami.org
National Institute of Mental Health, www.nimh.nih.gov
National Institutes of Health, U.S. National Library of Medicine, Medline
Plus: Child mental health. Available at: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/
medlineplus/childmentalhealth.html. Accessed April 19, 2011.
TeensHealth, Nemours Foundation, www.teenshealth.org
References
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry: Practice parameters for
the assessment and treatment of children and adolescents with depressive dis-
orders. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 37(suppl):63S–83S, 1998
Asbahr FR, Castillo AR, Ito LM, et al: Group cognitive-behavioral therapy versus
sertraline for the treatment of children and adolescents with obsessive-com-
pulsive disorder. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 44:1128–1136, 2005
Combined CBT and Psychopharmacology 145
Labellarte MJ, Ginsburg GS, Walkup JT, et al: The treatment of anxiety disorders
in children and adolescents. Biol Psychiatry 46:1567–1578, 1999
Lepola U, Leinonen E, Koponen H: Citalopram in the treatment of early-onset
panic disorder and school phobia. Pharmacopsychiatry 29:30–32, 1996
March JS, Biederman J, Wolkow R, et al: Sertraline in children and adolescents
with obsessive-compulsive disorder: a multicenter randomized controlled
trial. JAMA 280:1752–1756, 1998
March J[S], Silva S, Petrycki S, et al: Fluoxetine, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and
their combination for adolescents with depression: Treatment for Adolescents
with Depression Study (TADS) randomized controlled trial. JAMA 292:807–
820, 2004
March JS, Entusah AR, Rynn M, et al: A randomized controlled trial of venlafaxine
ER versus placebo in pediatric social anxiety disorder. Biol Psychiatry
62:1149–1154, 2007
Masi G, Toni C, Mucci M, et al: Paroxetine in child and adolescent outpatients with
panic disorder. J Child Adolesc Psychopharmacol 11:151–157, 2001
Melvin GA, Tonge BJ, King NJ, et al: A comparison of cognitive-behavioral therapy,
sertraline, and their combination for adolescent depression. J Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 45:1151–1161, 2006
Molina BS, Hinshaw SP, Swanson JM, et al: The MTA at 8 years: prospective fol-
low-up of children treated for combined-type ADHD in a multisite study.
J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 48:484–500, 2009
Morley S: The stress-diathesis model of illness. J Psychosom Res 27:86–87, 1983
Moses T: Parents’ conceptualization of adolescents’ mental health problems: who
adopts a psychiatric perspective and does it make a difference? Community
Ment Health J 47:67–81, 2011
Mosholder AD, Gelperin K, Hammad TA, et al: Hallucinations and other psy-
chotic symptoms associated with the use of attention-deficit/hyperactivity
disorder drugs in children. Pediatrics 123:611–616, 2009
MTA Cooperative Group: A 14-month randomized clinical trial of treatment strat-
egies for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. The MTA Cooperative
Group. Multimodal Treatment Study of Children with ADHD. Arch Gen
Psychiatry 56:1073–1086, 1999
Mukolo A, Heflinger CA, Wallston KA: The stigma of childhood mental disorders:
a conceptual framework. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 49:92–103;
quiz 198, 2010
Nemeroff R, Levitt JM, Faul L, et al: Establishing ongoing, early identification pro-
grams for mental health problems in our schools: a feasibility study. J Am
Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 47:328–338, 2008
Newcorn JH, Schulz K, Harrison M, et al: Alpha 2 adrenergic agonists. Neuro-
chemistry, efficacy, and clinical guidelines for use in children. Pediatr Clin
North Am 45:1099–1122, viii, 1998
Pediatric OCD Treatment Study (POTS) Team: Cognitive-behavior therapy, ser-
traline, and their combination for children and adolescents with obsessive-
compulsive disorder: the Pediatric OCD Treatment Study (POTS) random-
ized controlled trial. JAMA 292:1969–1976, 2004
Pliszka S: Practice parameter for the assessment and treatment of children and ad-
olescents with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. J Am Acad Child Ad-
olesc Psychiatry 46:894–921, 2007
148 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Westra HA, Dozois DJ, Marcus M: Expectancy, homework compliance, and initial
change in cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety. J Consult Clin Psychol
75:363–373, 2007
Winters NC, Pumariga A: Practice parameter on child and adolescent mental
health care in community systems of care. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychia-
try 46:284–299, 2007
150
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents
Medication, dose, N, age, diagnostic
duration of qualifications, Primary and secondary Comments, limitations,
151
152
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents (continued)
Medication, dose, N, age, diagnostic
duration of qualifications, Primary and secondary Comments, limitations,
153
average; 60 mg/day time.
maximally.
154
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents (continued)
Medication, dose, N, age, diagnostic
duration of qualifications, Primary and secondary Comments, limitations,
155
hospitalizations 6 months
before study, and lower
levels of functioning.
156
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents (continued)
Medication, dose, N, age, diagnostic
duration of qualifications, Primary and secondary Comments, limitations,
157
158
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents (continued)
Medication, dose, N, age, diagnostic
duration of qualifications, Primary and secondary Comments, limitations,
159
on the CGAS: 9 TF-CBT+
SERT; 6 TF-CBT+PBO.
160
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents (continued)
N, age, diagnostic
Medication, dose, qualifications, Primary and secondary Comments, limitations,
161
suicidal or homicidal ideation
162
APPENDIX 4–A Combination treatment of cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) and pharmacotherapy for anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents (continued)
Note. AE=adverse event; ARC-R=Anxiety Rating Scale for Children—Revised; BDD =body dysmorphic disorder; BDI=Beck Depression Inventory;
CAMS=Child/Adolescent Anxiety Multimodal Study; CBCL=Child Behavior Checklist; CD=conduct disorder; CDRS-R=Children’s Depression Rating
Scale—Revised; CES-D=Center for Epidemiologic Studies—Depression Scale; CGAS=Child Global Assessment Scale; CGI-I=Clinical Global Impres-
Depression and
Suicidal Behavior
Fadi T. Maalouf, M.D.
David A. Brent, M.D.
S This chapter has a video case example on the DVD (“Depression and Suicide”)
demonstrating CBT for a depressed and suicidal adolescent.
163
164 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
medication switch with or without CBT. There was a higher response rate
with those who received both the medication switch and CBT, compared
to those who received a medication switch alone (Brent et al. 2008). In-
terestingly, CBT appears to perform particularly well in depressed adoles-
cents with comorbidity, especially anxiety (Brent et al. 1998). In the
TORDIA study, the greater the number of comorbid conditions, the stron-
ger the performance of CBT plus medication compared with medication
alone (Asarnow et al. 2009).
Studies have found that adolescents with higher levels of cognitive dis-
tortion are less likely to respond to CBT (Brent et al. 1998; Ginsburg et al.
2009). Marital and parent-child discord also militate against CBT efficacy
(Birmaher et al. 2000; Feeny et al. 2009). CBT appears to be more effec-
tive in those youths from more advantaged socioeconomic backgrounds
(Asarnow et al. 2009; Curry et al. 2006). CBT is also less efficacious com-
pared with other treatments in patients who have a history of abuse and in
those whose parents are currently depressed (Asarnow et al. 2009; Barbe
et al. 2004; Brent et al. 1998; Lewis et al. 2010). In general, CBT is a treat-
ment whose results are robust in patients with comorbidity, suicidal ide-
ation, and hopelessness, but it performs less well in patients with a history
of maltreatment or current parental depression.
CBT has also been shown to be effective in preventing the onset of de-
pression in adolescents who are at high risk because of subsyndromal de-
pression, a previous history of depression, and/or a parent with a history
of depression (Clarke et al. 2001; Garber et al. 2009). However, in the
presence of current parental depression, CBT is not more effective than
usual care in preventing depression in offspring of parents with a history of
depression (Garber et al. 2009).
world around them, and they selectively attend to negative stimuli in their
environment (Maalouf and Munnell 2009).
In addition to cognitive models, there are behavioral models of depres-
sion, of which social learning theory has been the most prominent (Lewin-
sohn et al. 1998). This behavioral model posits that life stressors cause a
disruption in normal adaptive behavior, and this disruption leads to and
tends to perpetuate depression. This disruption causes individuals to use
maladaptive skills to control their depressive feelings when these skills can
only lead to worsening of these feelings (e.g., a girl who isolates herself in her
room and declines an offer to go out with her friends because of depression
would most likely feel more depressed secondary to social isolation). CBT
for youths with depression aims to target the above-mentioned maladaptive
cognitive processes and behavioral patterns that contribute to low mood. In
order to achieve this goal, a repertoire of techniques is used in CBT.
Application
CBT treatment is not a long-term treatment but rather is time limited.
Acute treatment typically consists of 12 weekly sessions of 60–90 minutes
each. Most of these sessions are individual sessions, but family sessions can
take place as needed (typically 3–6 sessions during the treatment course).
In addition, at the beginning of each individual session, the therapist typi-
cally checks in with the parent for 5–10 minutes. Although specific CBT
manuals vary in the extent to which they emphasize one technique over
the other (Brent and Poling 1997; Clarke et al. 2003; Curry et al. 2000),
we will focus here on techniques that in our clinical experience, have been
relevant to most depressed youths: psychoeducation, mood monitoring,
problem solving, cognitive restructuring, emotion regulation, behavioral
activation, and social skills training. At times, other specific intervention
strategies are selected on the basis of an assessment of the cognitive, be-
havioral, and environmental variables contributing to the depressive symp-
toms; these strategies may include family interventions and relaxation
techniques. The different CBT components are summarized in Table 5–1.
Session Format
Start by setting the agenda for the session together with the youth. Review
his or her current mood symptoms and assess the youth’s suicide risk.
Then review events that took place since the last session and the CBT skills
that were practiced. If the youth did not practice the CBT skills, it is im-
portant to explore the reasons and whether anything can be done to make
the skills more easily and readily usable. Next, review the material covered
Depression and Suicidal Behavior 167
Component Content
in the previous session, including the homework given. Devote the rest of
the session to teaching a new set of skills. Rehearse the skills with the
youth using role-play. Elicit feedback from the youth as you go along in the
session and then agree with the youth on a homework assignment.
168 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
If, for instance, a depressed girl talks about a verbal altercation with her
parents every time she doesn’t abide by curfew hours, coach her to iden-
tify the problem as such and then to brainstorm solutions, which may in-
clude negotiating other hours with her parents, having friends over after
hours, or not doing anything differently. Next, guide her to evaluate the
options by identifying the consequences of each and to choose the most
suitable solution that doesn’t leave her depressed or hopeless.
Generalizing these skills may involve some challenges. Youths may give
up on this technique if they attempt to apply it to complex problems pre-
maturely. Help them practice this strategy to solve problems with increas-
ing difficulty to help them gain mastery of the skills. Depressed youths
need to experience success with this strategy in order to believe in it and
use it more generally.
Start by teaching the youth about the most common cognitive distor-
tions (e.g., dichotomous thinking, overgeneralization, dismissing the posi-
tive) that a person with depression may have. Then elicit automatic
thoughts from the youth by asking, “What images and thoughts go through
your mind when a specific event occurs?” Introduce the paradigm of ante-
cedent, belief, and consequence while trying with the youth to understand
the context in which automatic thoughts occur. By asking a series of gentle
questions, the clinician can guide the youth to recognize distortions in his
or her thought process and help him or her come to a new, more adaptive
way of thinking.
To generalize this skill outside the therapy session, ask the youth to
record automatic thoughts on a four-column dysfunctional thoughts
record, as shown in Figure 5–1.
In general, the following questions are useful for the youth to ask him-
self or herself (Brent and Poling 1997):
• “A very FAST emotional response: it does not take much to get the ball
rolling, and the ball gets rolling very rapidly down the hill to the land
of emotion dysregulation.”
• “A very BIG emotional response: emotions are felt and expressed with
much intensity, making it difficult to think clearly; when the ball gets
rolling down the hill, it quickly becomes a BIG ball.”
• “A very SLOW return to being calm or relaxed: it takes a long time to
roll the ball back up the hill; there may have been damage done by the
Depression and Suicidal Behavior 171
2. 2. 1.
3. 3. 2.
4. 4. 3.
4.
Evidence against
1.
2.
3.
4.
ball as it sped down the hill, so extra distress may have been added to
whatever got the ball rolling in the first place.”
Next, use the HEAR ME acronym to educate the youth about other
vulnerabilities that can make emotion regulation more difficult (Bonner
2002):
The clinician can illustrate one way to regulate emotions by using the
picture of a blank feelings thermometer. Ask the youth to identify differ-
ent feelings corresponding to different temperature readings on the ther-
mometer before the strength of his or her feelings would reach the top of
the thermometer, which corresponds to an irreversible point of losing con-
trol. Then help the youth identify the physical and psychological cues as-
172 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
sociated with these feelings (e.g., muscle tension, rapid breathing). Finally,
ask the youth to identify the point where he or she needs to take action
before getting to the irreversible point of dyscontrol, and identify what the
adolescent can do (e.g., walking away from the situation, calling a friend,
taking a warm bath).
Another important emotion regulation skill is opposite action. Intro-
duce this term by telling the youth that this method is based on the fact
that bodily posture, facial expressions, and actions strongly influence how
people experience their emotions. Thus, it is sometimes possible to change
how someone experiences an emotion by altering the posture, behavior,
and facial expressions that go with the emotion. The clinician may want to
illustrate this concept by focusing on one emotion, such as anger. Explain
that most people find that if they make an angry face and also make their
body language consistent with this feeling, they actually find themselves
experiencing anger. Tell the youth that the opposite is also true—that is, if
he or she feels angry and at the same time tries to smile, take some deep
breaths, and relax his or her posture, then he or she will less likely act im-
pulsively on the angry feeling.
Generalizing these skills to apply them outside the therapy session can
be challenging for youths. For this reason, rehearsing situations that are very
likely to happen in the near future and reenacting situations that happened
in the recent past are key factors that help youths master these skills and
make it more likely that they will use them when faced with emotionally
charged situations.
Case Example
Jessica is a 15-year-old white adolescent girl referred by her pediatrician due
to concerns regarding her mood. Jessica presents in session wearing overly
baggy clothes and with disheveled hair. She slumps in her chair, maintains a
flat affect, and yawns throughout the initial session. She is soft-spoken and
allows her mother to speak for her unless she is specifically addressed.
Jessica’s mother reports that she is extremely concerned about her
daughter. She reports that Jessica is “always irritable” and has rarely inter-
acted with family members or even friends for the past month. She ex-
plains that Jessica has been slowly dropping out of all her extracurricular
activities, even theater, which Jessica has always loved. Initially, her parents
wondered whether Jessica was ill given how much she was sleeping, her
lack of appetite and sudden weight loss, and her low energy level. How-
ever, medical concerns were ruled out after they met with the pediatrician.
174 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
During intake, Jessica reported that she was very hard on herself and
never felt she was as good as her friends in all areas of her life, including
schoolwork, her appearance, and even theater. Her grades have been drop-
ping recently, and she reported that she has been having a difficult time fo-
cusing in class, even though this has never been an issue for her in the past.
Jessica became emotional when admitting that at times she feels hopeless,
as if nothing will ever turn out right for her. Jessica held her mother’s hand,
and she explained that she has not experienced any thoughts about suicide
and that she would never do this to her family.
During the first therapy session, Jessica’s therapist informed her that
she was reporting clinically significant symptoms of major depressive dis-
order. The clinician then provided Jessica and her mother with education
regarding depression. Once Jessica and her mother were able to clearly un-
derstand depression, the therapist then explained how CBT could be ben-
eficial. The therapist explained the relationship of thoughts, feelings, and
behaviors and explained that CBT helps individuals change the way they
think and behave to help them decrease negative feelings. The therapist
was able to link this information with the symptoms Jessica reported dur-
ing the initial session. Jessica was able to understand that when she thinks
“No one ever calls me anymore,” she feels sad—and that when she is sad,
she tends to isolate herself by going to her room and falling asleep. Once
asleep, Jessica has little chance of changing her mood, and thus when she
wakes, she continues to experience negative thoughts. By the end of the
session, Jessica was able to form some goals, including becoming more ac-
tive with friends and theater, as well as improving school performance.
In the following session, Jessica was taught how to monitor her mood
using a feelings thermometer. She was then assigned to begin monitoring
her mood three times daily and to note the situation when she also noted
her mood. Jessica mentioned that she had been feeling lonely and felt that
her friends were leaving her out. Her mother gently pointed out that Jes-
sica had not been returning phone calls or text messages lately. The clini-
cian then met individually with Jessica to teach a problem-solving skill.
With the help of this skill, Jessica was able to calmly brainstorm some so-
lutions for her current peer difficulties and to weigh the pros and cons of
each solution. Jessica decided to try calling her friends more frequently and
asking them to take part in activities.
At the next session, Jessica brought in completed feelings thermome-
ters, which supported the idea that when she took part in social or pleasur-
able activities, her mood was improved—and that her mood was low when
she isolated herself. The clinician then taught Jessica about how thoughts
affect feelings and provided common examples of maladaptive thoughts.
Jessica admitted that she frequently views situations as “all or nothing” and
that this can cause her to feel sad and blue. She also recognized that she
can become overly focused on negative events that occurred throughout
the day and ignore positive events. Jessica was then taught how to chal-
lenge these negative thoughts and was assigned thought records to com-
plete.
The next few sessions focused on Jessica’s thought records and cogni-
tive challenges. She gradually became better at recognizing and challenging
Depression and Suicidal Behavior 175
her cognitive distortions, and her mood ratings were improving. At the same
time, Jessica’s solution for improving her relationships with friends was be-
ginning to work, and she was reporting improved social relationships.
Jessica still reported a tendency to react quickly to any social cues she
perceived as negative, and the next few sessions focused on emotional dys-
regulation. Jessica was taught the HEAR ME tips for self-care and was as-
signed to work on applying these to her daily life. In particular, Jessica
focused on forming a more balanced sleep routine and meal patterns.
Jessica’s mood ratings continued to improve, and she was feeling very
pleased with her progress. The next few sessions focused on behavioral ac-
tivation, and Jessica began to increase her time spent in pleasurable activi-
ties, including theater. At this point, Jessica’s mother reported feeling
relieved and felt that the “old Jessica is back.” Jessica continued to monitor
her mood and use her skills taught in previous sessions.
Eventually, Jessica was feeling confident about her ability to manage
her mood on her own. She and the therapist agreed that she would come
back to review skills monthly for the next 3 months. All of Jessica’s follow-
up sessions were positive and focused on refreshing any skills that were
needed. Overall, Jessica left therapy feeling proud of her ability to cope
with her emotions and improve her mood.
Suicide Prevention
The Treatment of Adolescent Suicide Attempters (TASA) study devel-
oped a cognitive-behavior therapy for suicide prevention (CBT-SP; Stanley
et al. 2009) that is feasible and accepted by adolescent suicide attempters.
The efficacy of CBT-SP is worth testing in the future. CBT-SP draws from
the principles of CBT and DBT. This treatment was piloted in a mostly
open study of 124 depressed adolescent suicide attempters and resulted
in a 6-month hazard of recurrence of suicidal behavior that was less than
has been reported in similar samples (hazard ratio = 0.12; Brent et al.
2009).
CBT-SP aims primarily to reduce suicide risk factors among adolescents
who are recent attempters, to help them develop more adaptive coping
skills—and ultimately, to refrain from suicidal behavior. CBT-SP involves
the parents and the adolescent in treatment, which lasts about 24 weeks.
CBT-SP consists of two treatment phases:
• Chain analysis: In this component, the clinician helps the youth iden-
tify the series of events that led to the recent suicidal crisis; the work
in this component aims to reveal concurrently the youth’s precipitating
thoughts, feelings, and actions.
• Safety planning: Here, the clinician helps the youth identify internal
(distracting activities) and external (family, friends, psychiatry emer-
gency contact numbers) resources to use as coping strategies when
Depression and Suicidal Behavior 177
faced with suicidal urges. This technique aims to help youths stay safe
by not engaging in suicidal behavior at least until the next session.
• Psychoeducation: The clinician educates the youth and family about
suicide risk factors and behaviors and about the goals of therapy.
• Identifying reasons for living: In this component, the clinician helps the
youth identify reasons to live and sources of hope that he or she can
hold on to when having a suicide crisis.
• Case conceptualization: The clinician and patient determine target prob-
lems and deficits revealed in the chain analysis and identify the personal-
ized strategies that are needed to reduce suicide risk in the adolescent.
End phase (3 sessions). The clinician aims to test the efficacy of skills
learned thus far by having the youth review the recent attempt during the
session, following these recommended steps:
Continuation Phase
In this 12-week treatment phase, the clinician and patient review the skills
learned in the acute treatment phase, go over the course of treatment, and
identify accomplishments. The clinician prepares the youth to deal with
any future fluctuations or episodes and assesses the need for ongoing treat-
ment. The following case example on DVD illustrates CBT techniques to
assess (e.g., chain analysis) and treat depression and suicidal ideation in
Jane, an adolescent who recently attempted suicide.
S Case Example
Jane, a 17-year-old adolescent girl, was referred to the clinician by an emer-
gency room physician at the local children’s hospital after she was treated
for a suicide attempt, in which she swallowed a bottle of her mother’s
sleeping pills. Jane presented in session as sad and tearful. She did not
178 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
make eye contact and was soft-spoken. She cried at times throughout the
session, especially when her parents began to cry. Jane reported that she
hated high school and that she attempted suicide because she was ex-
tremely hopeless that anything would ever get better.
During the first session, the clinician discussed with Jane what led up to
her suicide attempt. Initially, Jane could only say, “I hate school.” However, the
therapist provided a series of open-ended questions about what was happening
in Jane’s life before the event, what Jane was thinking about, and how she was
feeling. Jane recalled that she was having a particularly bad week in school be-
cause her best friend was out sick and she did not have anyone to sit with at
lunch. She found herself feeling embarrassed and lonely and told herself that
she was a “loser” and that “no one would notice” if she didn’t exist. In addition,
Jane said that her ex-boyfriend had spread a rumor about her, and this was
causing her unwanted negative attention from others. When she went home
one day from school, Jane said that she decided she could no longer deal with
the stress and took the bottle of pills quickly.
After discussing this event, Jane reported that she “did not think” and that
she never considered how this would affect her family. The therapist then dis-
cussed the idea of forming a safety plan so that Jane could be sure to keep her-
self safe in between sessions. Jane reported that she was willing to do this and
felt bad about how she had upset her family. She admitted that she continues
to have suicidal thoughts and would like a plan for managing these thoughts.
Jane agreed to a plan where she would initially try to get her mind off the
thought by listening to music. If her thoughts continued or she began to expe-
rience a suicidal urge, she agreed to tell a parent or call the local crisis center.
In addition, the therapist provided Jane and her family with education about
suicide and risk factors. One risk factor in particular was discussed with Jane’s
family: leaving prescription medications lying around the home, because Jane’s
attempt and suicidal thoughts generally focused on ingestion. Jane and her
family added reducing risk factors to the safety plan.
During the next few sessions, Jane and her family agreed that she did
well following through with her safety plan. These sessions focused prima-
rily on establishing rapport with Jane and helping her to begin to think
about why her life was in fact worth living. This list began to grow, and Jane
became more motivated for treatment.
In addition, the therapist began to form a case conceptualization regarding
Jane’s suicidal behavior. This focused on Jane’s difficulties with social skills.
Throughout sessions it became apparent that Jane had difficulties making new
friends. She had one group of peers that she had made friends with in elemen-
tary school, and through the years, these peers had made new friends and grad-
ually drifted off except for her best friend. Jane was aware of her social
difficulties and embarrassed by her lack of popularity. This led to low self-es-
teem, and Jane began to overly focus on her difficulties with peers. Once Jane
became depressed, her level of energy and ability to concentrate decreased,
and she began to have difficulties problem solving. When faced with a social
problem at school after the breakup with her boyfriend, she was unable to
think of an adequate solution and became hopeless. This conceptualization of
Jane’s suicidal behavior helped the therapist to then form a treatment plan for
the middle phase of Jane’s acute treatment.
Depression and Suicidal Behavior 179
During the middle phase of Jane’s acute treatment, the therapist spent
about five sessions focusing on continuing to assess for safety, as well as
teaching skills focused on improving mood. The therapist focused on social
skills training for making new friends, cognitive challenging for decreasing
Jane’s tendency of focusing on the negative, HEAR ME skills for improving
her energy level and decreasing emotional lability, and problem-solving
skills for helping Jane to cope in an effective manner with life stressors.
Jane participated actively in learning these techniques and reported im-
provements in her mood at each session.
The last three sessions focused on summarizing these skills to ensure that
Jane would be able to apply them in the future. The clinician asked Jane to
think about her previous suicide attempt and to discuss what skills she could
have used to prevent herself from getting to that point. Jane was able to effec-
tively apply the problem-solving skill in session to find solutions both for feel-
ing lonely at lunch and handling the made-up rumor. In addition, she was able
to discuss how she was focusing on the negative and putting herself down and
to challenge these negative thoughts in session. Lastly, Jane was able to discuss
some active coping skills, such as going for a jog or playing a video game, that
she had learned generally worked for her when she needed to distract herself.
Jane was also able to discuss which skills she felt would work best for her in
future stressful situations. By the end of treatment, Jane reported that she no
longer experienced either suicidal ideation or depressive symptoms.
Self-Assessment Questions
5.1. A 14-year-old Hispanic boy diagnosed with a major depressive disor-
der has not responded to a trial of a selective serotonin reuptake in-
hibitor (SSRI). The next management step that the youth would
most likely respond to is to
A. Cognitive restructuring.
B. Emotion regulation.
C. Behavioral activation.
D. Social skills training.
A. Interpersonal therapy.
B. CBT used with depressed youths.
C. Relaxation techniques.
D. Cognitive-behavior therapy for suicide prevention.
5.5. You see an adolescent youth with depression who is having difficulty
initiating and maintaining relationships with peers. The most helpful
CBT technique to include in the treatment plan of this youth is
A. Cognitive restructuring.
B. Emotion regulation.
C. Behavioral activation.
D. Social skills training.
References
Asarnow JR, Emslie G, Clarke G, et al: Treatment of selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitor-resistant depression in adolescents: predictors and moderators of
treatment response. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 48:330–339, 2009
Barbe RP, Bridge JA, Birmaher B, et al: Lifetime history of sexual abuse, clinical
presentation, and outcome in a clinical trial for adolescent depression. J Clin
Psychiatry 65:77–83, 2004
Beck AT: Depression: Clinical, Experimental, and Theoretical Aspects. New York,
Hoeber, 1967 (Republished as Beck AT: Depression: Causes and Treatment.
Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 1970)
Birmaher B, Ryan ND, Williamson DE, et al: Childhood and adolescent depression:
a review of the past 10 years. Part I. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
35:1427–1439, 1996
Birmaher B, Brent DA, Kolko D, et al: Clinical outcome after short-term psycho-
therapy for adolescents with major depressive disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry
57:29–36, 2000
182 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Birmaher B, Brent D; AACAP Work Group on Quality Issues, et al: Practice pa-
rameter for the assessment and treatment of children and adolescents with
depressive disorders. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 46:1503–1526,
2007
Bonner C: Emotion Regulation, Interpersonal Effectiveness, and Distress Tolerance
Skills for Adolescents: A Treatment Manual. 2002. Available at: http://
www.box.net/shared/jbbu7c4xc7. Accessed April 19, 2011.
Brent DA: Correlates of the medical lethality of suicide attempts in children and
adolescents. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 26:87–91, 1987
Brent DA, Poling K: Cognitive Therapy Treatment Manual for Depressed and Sui-
cidal Youth. Pittsburgh, PA, Star Center Publications, 1997
Brent DA, Kolko DJ, Birmaher B, et al: Predictors of treatment efficacy in a clinical
trial of three psychosocial treatments for adolescent depression. J Am Acad
Child Adolesc Psychiatry 37:906–914, 1998
Brent D, Emslie G, Clarke G: Switching to another SSRI or to venlafaxine with or
without cognitive behavioral therapy for adolescents with SSRI-resistant de-
pression: the TORDIA randomized controlled trial. JAMA 299:901–913,
2008
Brent DA, Greenhill LL, Compton S, et al: The Treatment of Adolescent Suicide
Attempters study (TASA): predictors of suicidal events in an open treatment
trial. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 48:987–996, 2009
Bridge JA, Goldstein TR, Brent DA: Adolescent suicide and suicidal behavior.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry 47:372–394, 2006
Clarke GN, Hornbrook M, Lynch F, et al: A randomized trial of a group cognitive
intervention for preventing depression in adolescent offspring of depressed
parents. Arch Gen Psychiatry 58:1127–1134, 2001
Clarke GN, DeBar LL, Lewinsohn PM: Cognitive-behavioral group treatment for
adolescent depression, in Evidence-Based Psychotherapies for Children and
Adolescents. Edited by Kazdin AE, Weisz JR. New York, Guilford, 2003,
pp 120–134
Clarke G[N], DeBar L, Lynch F, et al: A randomized effectiveness trial of brief
cognitive-behavioral therapy for depressed adolescents receiving antidepres-
sant medication. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 44:888–898, 2005
Curry J, Wells K, Brent D, et al: Cognitive Behavior Therapy Manual for TADS.
Durham, NC, Duke University, 2000
Curry J, Rohde P, Simons A, et al: Predictors and moderators of acute outcome in
the Treatment for Adolescents with Depression Study (TADS). J Am Acad
Child Adolesc Psychiatry 45:1427–1439, 2006
Feeny NC, Silva SG, Reinecke MA, et al: An exploratory analysis of the impact of
family functioning on treatment for depression in adolescents. J Clin Child
Adolesc Psychol 38:814–825, 2009
Fristad MA, Verducci JS, Walters K, et al: Impact of multifamily psychoeduca-
tional psychotherapy in treating children aged 8 to 12 years with mood disor-
ders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 66:1013–1021, 2009
Garber J, Clarke GN, Weersing VR, et al: Prevention of depression in at-risk ado-
lescents: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 301:2215–2224, 2009
Ginsburg GS, Silva SG, Jacobs RH, et al: Cognitive measures of adolescent depression:
unique or unitary constructs? J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 38:790–802, 2009
Depression and Suicidal Behavior 183
Weisz JR, McCarty CA, Valeri SM: Effects of psychotherapy for depression in chil-
dren and adolescents: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull 132:132–149, 2006
Weisz JR, Southam-Gerow MA, Gordis EB, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy
versus usual clinical care for youth depression: an initial test of transportability
to community clinics and clinicians. J Consult Clin Psychol 77:383–396, 2009
Wood A, Harrington R, Moore A: Controlled trial of a brief cognitive-behavioural
intervention in adolescent youths with depressive disorders. J Child Psychol
Psychiatry 37:737–746, 1996
Wood A, Trainor G, Rothwell J, et al: Randomized trial of group therapy for re-
peated deliberate self-harm in adolescents. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychi-
atry 40:1246–1253, 2001
6
Bipolar Disorder
Benjamin W. Fields, Ph.D., M.Ed.
Mary A. Fristad, Ph.D., ABPP
Empirical Support
A small but growing literature base supports the use of cognitive-behavior
therapy (CBT) in the treatment of pediatric bipolar disorder (Table 6–1).
185
186
TABLE 6–1. Studies of CBT-based interventions for the treatment of pediatric bipolar disorder
Child- and family-focused cognitive-behavior therapy (CFF-CBT) or RAINBOW program for pediatric bipolar disorder
187
188
TABLE 6–1. Studies of CBT-based interventions for the treatment of pediatric bipolar disorder (continued)
189
190 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Although only a minority of this research (with roots in the more sizable
literature involving psychosocial treatment for adults with bipolar disor-
der) focuses on treatment nominally identified as CBT, interventions de-
signed for youth with bipolar disorder are largely based on techniques
traditionally associated with CBT and implement strategies consistent
with it.
Pavuluri et al. (2004) have developed child- and family-focused cogni-
tive-behavior therapy (CFF-CBT; also referred to as the RAINBOW pro-
gram) for children and adolescents with bipolar disorder. An adaptation of
Miklowitz and Goldstein’s (1997) family-focused treatment for adults,
CFF-CBT is delivered in conjunction with medication management and
organized around seven general components, including the establishment
and maintenance of healthy routines, regulating affect, building self-effi-
cacy and coping skills, restructuring negative cognitions, social skills train-
ing, problem-solving techniques, and the identification of a useful and
accessible social support system. The program is composed of 12 hour-
long sessions implemented over 6 months. Meetings include combined
family sessions, in which both parents and children participate, child-only
and parent-only sessions, and a session for siblings to participate along with
parents. Treatment feasibility has been found to be high; families attend
most sessions; and they unexpectedly miss (“no showing”) an average of
less than one session. Parents have indicated high satisfaction with the
treatment protocol and efficacy. Participation in an open-label trial of
CFF-CBT has been associated with improvement in mania, depression, ag-
gression, psychosis, sleep disturbance, symptoms of attention-deficit/
hyperactivity disorder, and global functioning as rated by therapists, al-
though the use of random assignment and independent evaluators in fu-
ture trials will help to evaluate the true efficacy of the program.
A maintenance model of CFF-CBT, in which the original treatment is
followed by psychosocial booster sessions and continued medication man-
agement, has also been developed (West et al. 2007). Booster sessions
focus on potential barriers to treatment. Preliminary results of the main-
tenance model—the addition of which has successfully maintained im-
provement in symptom severity and global functioning associated with
CFF-CBT over a 3-year follow-up period—along with results of the origi-
nal CFF-CBT trial, suggest the addition of a CBT-oriented adjunctive
treatment may hold promise for effecting and maintaining therapeutic
gains with a pediatric bipolar disorder population.
Miklowitz and colleagues (2004, 2006, 2008) have developed family-
focused treatment for adolescents with bipolar disorder (FFT-A). FFT-A
was designed to be implemented in twenty-one 50-minute sessions over a
9-month period, in combination with closely supervised medication man-
Bipolar Disorder 191
Application
The initiation of CBT for a child or adolescent with bipolar disorder should
occur after assessment and diagnosis by a mental health professional famil-
iar with the disorder, and once the patient’s mood symptoms have been sta-
bilized enough pharmacologically that retaining information and learning
new skills are possible (Kowatch et al. 2005). Guidelines for identifying bi-
polar disorder in youth have been described elsewhere in considerable de-
tail but generally include 1) obtaining a complete developmental history, a
longitudinal examination of symptoms, a family history of mood and re-
lated disorders, data from multiple informants (i.e., parents, child, and
school); 2) systematically ruling out alternative medical and psychiatric di-
agnoses; and 3) determining any comorbid diagnoses (Danner et al. 2009;
Fields and Fristad 2009a). Refer parents or other family members for indi-
vidual treatment, as needed, to reduce the overall level of dysfunction in
the family (Kowatch et al. 2005).
Although a multifamily group format for PEP has been developed
(MF-PEP), the therapeutic protocol described herein is designed for use
in an individual-family format (IF-PEP). The primary advantage of con-
ducting treatment in a multifamily format is the social support parents and
children often experience through interaction with individuals facing sim-
ilar issues. In addition, participants may benefit from opportunities to
learn from the successes and struggles of others. The individual-family for-
mat outlined here, however, is often more convenient for families, who
may not wish to delay treatment until a new group can begin, and who may
appreciate the more individualized consultation and privacy offered by
such a format. Clinicians may also find an individual-family format desir-
196 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
able, both because billing for services may be simplified and because many
clinicians do not have access to a number of families appropriate for inclu-
sion in multifamily group treatment.
Below appears an outline of one version of CBT, IF-PEP. First, the gen-
eral format of sessions is described, then key elements of each session are
discussed. These elements share much in common with the other CBT
treatments for bipolar disorder in youth reviewed above.
Session 1
Child session 1: purpose of treatment; goal setting, rating feelings,
and symptoms of bipolar disorder. Begin the introductory session to-
gether with the parents and child. Orient them to the purpose of treat-
ment; emphasize that better understanding gained from this education
along with skill building should improve treatment utilization and decrease
family conflict, leading to a better outcome for the child. Successful man-
agement of the disorder, as opposed to a “cure,” is the ultimate goal. Share
your expectations, which include the importance of regular attendance
and practicing skills between sessions, the planned duration of treatment,
and the potential for maintenance sessions after the initial course of inter-
vention. Set the stage for establishing feasible treatment goals. Given the
probable lifetime waxing and waning of symptoms, complete obliteration
of any future symptoms is not realistic. However, improving family life
through concrete actions, taking steps to build friendships, and developing
a plan to address school concerns are all realistic and doable over the
course of treatment.
Finally, introduce both parents and child to the concept of bipolar dis-
order as a “no fault” disorder. Your motto for treatment is, “It’s not your
fault, but it’s your challenge.” Although no one is to blame for the child’s
diagnosis, it is a card the family has been dealt and a challenge the entire
family can and must confront. Underscore this perspective in future ses-
sions by providing information regarding the biological etiology of bipolar
disorder and by helping to distinguish the child from his or her symptoms.
Revisiting this message throughout the course of treatment serves to alle-
viate guilt and shame surrounding the disorder, while concurrently estab-
lishing a positive, proactive, and solution-focused approach to managing
the disorder.
After accomplishing the above, spend most of the remainder of the ses-
sion with the child alone, inviting parents to rejoin at the end of the session
to review progress and discuss activities to be completed before the next
session. While with the child, you have three tasks to accomplish: 1) to
help the child develop a basic understanding of his or her mood disorder
as well as any comorbid conditions; 2) to help the child develop realistic
treatment goals; and 3) to teach diaphragmatic breathing to use as a calm-
ing technique.
the session, however, may be to set the tone for an empathic, hopeful, and
solution-focused approach to treatment. Essential to establishing this tone
is the presentation of bipolar disorder as a no-fault diagnosis (briefly
touched on in the introductory session), beginning with a focus on the bi-
ological nature of the disorder, including its high genetic heritability. Help-
ing parents view bipolar disorder as a brain disorder can assist them in
approaching their child’s mood and associated behavioral issues with com-
passion, while also easing parents’ fears that they are responsible for their
child’s problems.
Youth with bipolar disorder can exhibit exceedingly aversive behaviors,
occupy an inordinate amount of family resources, and be extremely diffi-
cult to manage. Parents, in turn, receive an unfortunate and often unfair
share of the blame for these issues, often in the form of criticism from
friends and family who attribute the child’s behavioral difficulties to noth-
ing more than poor parenting. Without proper psychoeducation, parents
can begin to view their affected child as selfish and willfully disruptive,
leading to a decline in positive interactions within the family and an in-
crease in expressed emotion (discussed earlier as a potentially significant
factor in the course of bipolar disorder).
Ironically, attempting to alleviate parental guilt over the child’s diagno-
sis by introducing information on the heritability of bipolar disorder can in-
advertently lead to more self-blame by some parents, who feel guilty over
passing down the disorder. No one, of course, selects his or her own genes;
as the saying goes, you can pick your friends but not your relatives. Re-
minding parents of this can be useful in reframing unproductive and guilty
cognitions regarding their child’s diagnosis.
Providing information to parents regarding the neuroanatomy and neu-
rochemistry putatively involved in bipolar disorder can also help place the
disorder in a biological light, though the level of sophistication that will be
useful to parents can vary significantly. In session, it is sufficient to explain
that various structures of the brain appear different in bipolar disorder
than in typical brains (e.g., different in size) and that these abnormalities,
in conjunction with chemical irregularities in the brain that affect how
messages are sent between brain structures, are thought to be involved in
the symptoms of bipolar disorder. If parents express a deeper curiosity and
would benefit from information regarding particular neuroanatomical and
neurochemical abnormalities, refer them to additional up-to-date scien-
tific findings (see References at the end of this chapter for suggestions).
Provide parents with information on how bipolar disorder is diagnosed,
including the symptoms, symptom duration, and impairment necessary to
meet diagnostic criteria. This process requires helping parents develop fa-
miliarity with clinical nomenclature, so that terms such as mania, hypoma-
200 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Session 2
Child session 2: “Naming the Enemy”; medications. T h e p r i m a r y
goals of this session are twofold: 1) to assist the child in differentiating
symptoms of bipolar disorder from his or her “self,” and 2) to instill a
firmer understanding of the use of medication in treatment for bipolar dis-
order, thereby enlisting the child as a more informed and active participant
in treatment.
Bipolar Disorder 201
The first goal can be addressed with the exercise Naming the Enemy
(Fristad et al. 1999), inspired by the concept of “externalizing the symp-
tom” (White and Epston 1990), in which patients are encouraged to ob-
jectify problematic symptoms as separate from the self. Over time,
symptoms can come to be seen by the child and others as static and reflec-
tive of the child’s true self, as opposed to being surmountable and tempo-
rarily obscuring the child’s positive qualities. Identifying symptoms of
bipolar disorder as an external “enemy” reconceptualizes the problem as a
challenge to be overcome rather than a burden to be passively endured,
while simultaneously encouraging more positive self-esteem in children of-
ten in need of just such a boost.
To implement Naming the Enemy, write the child’s name at the top of a
page, with two columns splitting the page below. In the left-hand column, la-
beled “Self,” have the child write positive qualities about himself or herself
(e.g., “artistic,” “good sense of humor,” “helps Grandma”). In the right-hand
column, have the child write his or her mood symptoms as the child under-
stands them (e.g., “mean to brother,” “cries a lot,” “brags too much”). After
the lists are complete, fold the right side of the paper over the left, covering
the child’s positive qualities with the half of the paper listing symptoms. Ex-
plain how the symptoms of bipolar disorder can cover up the wonderful at-
tributes the child has to offer. Then, refold the paper so the right side is behind
the left side, and explain that treatment can help “uncover” the child’s posi-
tive qualities once more. The child will do this again at home with his or her
parents; it can be very helpful in changing the language families use to describe
symptoms (rather than negative attributes about the child).
Raising the topic of treatment provides a segue into discussing the role
medications play in managing bipolar disorder. All too often, children take
medications with no knowledge of the names and dosages, let alone the
purpose of these prescriptions. As medication adherence is essential to
treating bipolar disorder, children should have an awareness of what they
are taking, the reasons for doing so, how to manage the nearly inevitable
side effects that occur with medications, and how to provide useful feed-
back to the provider on how the medicine is working. Children invested
with this knowledge gain an additional stake in their treatment—a sense of
ownership likely to be welcomed by parents, who often struggle to ensure
daily medication adherence. To this end, review information with the child
about the medications he or she is taking, including dosages, the symptoms
each medication is intended to address, common side effects, and poten-
tial methods of mitigating these side effects (e.g., taking the medication
with food for prescriptions causing stomach upset; keeping a bottle of wa-
ter nearby for those causing dry mouth). Note that a discussion of why the
medication has been prescribed may necessitate consultation with the
202 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case Example:
The Medication Dilemma
Emily is an 11-year-old girl who received a diagnosis of bipolar I disorder a
year ago after a manic episode that resulted in hospitalization. Since then,
she has undergone numerous medication trials. Upon beginning psychoed-
ucational psychotherapy, Emily’s parents are vocal regarding their medica-
tion concerns. On the one hand, Emily’s father views medication as a
crutch—moderately helpful in the short term, but ultimately undermining
Emily’s ability to “really deal with her problems.” Her mother, on the other
hand, has grown weary of Emily’s incomplete symptom remission, in spite
of frequent medication adjustments.
In response to these concerns, the therapist’s first step is to provide ba-
sic psychoeducation regarding the biological nature of bipolar disorder. Af-
ter the therapist discusses the high heritability of the disorder, Emily’s
parents are able to identify a familial pattern.
Mom: My sister is also bipolar, and there was some talk about my grand-
mother having manic depression. It also seemed like my dad always
had problems with depression.
Dad: I struggle with depression, too, and it seems like half my cousins
have been on antidepressants.
Mom: Between mood problems and diabetes, seems like our family can’t
catch a break.
Therapist: Diabetes runs in your family?
Mom: I actually have an insulin pump. My mom was diabetic, too, and so
is my brother.
Dad: Well, sometimes diabetes can be controlled with diet and exercise.
Mom: Not me. I’m really careful. Without my pump, though, I’m in trouble.
Dad: But maybe Emily’s bipolar disorder isn’t that bad. Maybe she can
manage without it if she just had the right—I don’t know—tools.
Therapist: Research would suggest that learning coping skills may be
enough to address depression, and they’re very important in manag-
ing bipolar disorder, too, but only if manic symptoms like Emily’s are
stabilized first. That’s why the medication is essential.
Dad: I don’t know. ... I just don’t like it.
Therapist: I don’t think there are many parents who love the idea of their
child needing medications, but let’s look at Emily’s history. How
were her symptoms before she began the medication?
Dad: She ended up in the hospital. It was awful.
Therapist: Right. And has she needed to be hospitalized since starting her
medications?
Mom: No, but it’s not like she’s ever been ... better.
Therapist: Let’s talk about what you mean by “better.”
Mom: I hate to say it, but. . .normal. She still has rages sometimes, has
nights where she’s up forever, sometimes talks about sexual things—
it can be so embarrassing and frustrating. And that’s after who knows
how many med changes.
Therapist: OK, so when you say Emily’s not “better,” it sounds like you’re
saying that she still has some symptoms, and really, we may never to-
tally get rid of all those issues. It also sounds like, though, that her
medications have helped reduce her symptoms.
Mom: That’s true. But how can we be sure she’s on the right medications?
Dad: Yeah, sometimes it seems like her psychiatrist is just throwing darts
at a dartboard.
Mom: Sure. I have to watch what I eat, watch my weight. Before I got my
pump, I had to monitor my sugar levels regularly.
Therapist: That monitoring is just as important with bipolar disorder.
When you take Emily to see the psychiatrist, I bet she asks you lots
of questions about her symptoms.
Dad: Yes, but it’s so hard to keep track of everything. Her symptoms can
change so much from week to week, even day to day.
Therapist: That’s why the daily mood logs we will discuss are so important.
The next time you go to the psychiatrist, you can actually take the log
to her, and she can see details of how Emily’s symptoms have fluctu-
ated without you having to recall them on the spot. As long as Emily
is taking the medications as prescribed, the doctor can make the most
informed decision about whether Emily’s medications should be
changed, the dosage adjusted, or both.
Session 3
Child session 3: establishing healthy routines. Regulating sleep, nu-
trition, and exercise is an important aspect of regulating mood. In this first
session devoted to healthy routines, provide an overview of these three
topics, and have the child pick the topic he or she finds most troublesome
to focus on first. Monitor the child’s progress with this first goal in each
subsequent session; the child will pick a second goal from this list in his or
her seventh session.
Inadequate sleep can trigger mania (Malkoff-Schwartz et al. 1998,
2000) and is a frequent cause of increased irritability. Help the child iden-
tify any dysfunctional sleep practices, set goals for proper rest, and de-
velop strategies for those goals to succeed. This involves structuring an
environment conducive to sleep and may require relocating a television or
video game system to another room and setting guidelines for hours of use.
Many medications prescribed for youth with bipolar disorder lead to
weight gain, which can lead to self-esteem concerns, not to mention very
real health concerns of type 2 diabetes and hypertension. Thus, a focus on
healthy food choices is often beneficial. Reviewing fundamentals of nutri-
tion guidelines and troubleshooting how the child can make wiser food
choices, often in the face of intense carbohydrate cravings, are important
steps. The emphasis here should not be on dieting, but rather on establish-
ing lifelong healthy eating habits.
Much as sleep can play a role in mania, exercise has been found to de-
crease depressive symptoms (Pollock 2001). Increasing physical activity
has several added benefits, including helping the child maintain a healthy
weight, which also has physical and mental health benefits. Additionally,
many ways in which a child can increase activity levels also increase social
interaction, for example, through a team sport, playing in the park where
other kids have gathered, or a martial arts class.
206 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Session 4
Child session 4: triggers, physical cues, feelings and actions, coping
tool kit. Perhaps the technique most identified with CBT is increasing
patient awareness of how thoughts, feelings, and behaviors impact each
other, then translating this knowledge into skills to relieve or prevent
symptoms and impairment. Undertaking this practice with children re-
quires a developmentally appropriate approach that organizes the process
into manageable, routinized steps. Begin by helping the child to identify a
208 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
recent trigger, an event that elicited negative feelings, and the somatic sen-
sations that accompanied those feelings. Often children claim no aware-
ness of physical indicators of mood states. If you provide examples (e.g.,
face flushing when angry, stomach tightening when afraid), children often
begin to respond. Next, have the child identify actions he or she took in
response to these negative feelings, along with the eventual consequences
of these actions. A child could indicate, for example, that she became an-
gry last week when her mother allowed a sibling to play the video game she
was hoping to play (the “trigger”). She could tell she was becoming angry
because her “forehead got wrinkled” and she began biting her lip (somatic
sensations). In response to her anger, the child grabbed the video game
controller from her brother and threw it against the wall (actions), break-
ing a button and rendering the game unplayable. As a result of these ac-
tions, she was unable to play the game at all and was yelled at by her
mother (consequences).
After identifying an example that illustrates how negative feelings can
lead to negative choices and behaviors, the next step is to assist the child
in developing a coping tool kit. This tool kit will contain reminders of ef-
fective strategies—identified by the child—to help the child regain control
of his or her emotions and self-soothe. Younger children often enjoy con-
structing and decorating an actual shoebox or other container for this pur-
pose, while adolescents may prefer to make a list that can be tucked into
a school binder or posted on their bedroom wall.
Regardless of the chosen format, the tool kit should include a range of
coping strategies that can be implemented in a variety of situations and in
response to a number of maladaptive or “hurtful” emotions. To help the
child successfully identify an assortment of coping responses, break strat-
egies down into four basic categories: creative, active, relaxation, and social
(CARS becomes a useful acronym to remember these categories—just as
a car can take someone places he or she wants to go, these coping CARS
take a person to the mood state he or she prefers). Creative “tools” might
include drawing or playing the piano; active tools might include shooting
baskets or playing on the jungle gym; relaxation tools might include read-
ing a book or listening to soothing music; and social tools might include
calling a friend on the phone or playing with the family dog.
Coping strategies need to match the child’s situation and mood. For ex-
ample, riding a bike might be an excellent strategy for the child to use at
home when feeling grumpy, but it won’t work when the child is at school.
Talking to a trusted teacher or using one of the breathing techniques taught
in therapy, on the other hand, would work in a school setting. Similarly, lis-
tening to dance music when feeling sad is a reasonable and adaptive strat-
egy to use at home; however, using that strategy when thoughts are starting
Bipolar Disorder 209
ful” or negative thought, feeling, and action in the lower half and the
“helpful” or positive/desired thought, feeling, and action in the upper half.
To explain TFD, begin by asking parents to identify a recent event that
triggered negative feelings in themselves (e.g., sadness, anger, frustration,
or fatigue) and that they didn’t feel they handled particularly well (e.g.,
“Makayla threw a tantrum just as we were leaving for a nice dinner—the
babysitter refused to deal with her, and we had to cancel our night out”).
Next, have parents recall the negative thoughts that accompanied these
feelings (e.g., “Makayla is so selfish”; “We’ll never be a normal family”;
“What’s the use of trying?”). Simply acknowledging these inevitable and
understandable thoughts is a requisite step in this approach and provides
an opportunity to validate the frustration and hurt experienced by parents
struggling with a child with a mood disorder (e.g., “I can imagine how dis-
appointing it was to anticipate a relaxing night out and to have that fall
through at the last minute”). It’s not easy raising a child with bipolar dis-
order, and parents deserve to hear this from someone who understands the
challenges they face on a daily basis and who is supportive of their desire
to seek help.
Once parents have identified the negative feelings and thoughts that
arose in response to an event, have them specify the actions they took in
response to these thoughts (e.g., “I yelled at Makayla, went to my room,
and cried”). Ask parents to notice the negative cycle that occurs: negative
feelings lead to negative thoughts, which lead to negative behaviors. Then
help parents understand where they can intervene to break the cycle.
Although it might seem easiest just to eliminate the frustrating event
in the first place, this isn’t always under parental control, especially when
the issue stems from a child experiencing mood symptoms. Further, nega-
tive feelings are part and parcel of raising a challenging child. Thus, the
first area on which to focus is negative thinking. Encourage parents to
brainstorm more positive, realistic, and helpful ways of thinking about the
event. Instead of thinking “Makayla is so selfish,” they could reframe the
event in a way that differentiates the child from the symptom (e.g.,
“Makayla’s really struggling with her manic symptoms this week; she’s
been much more irritable and hasn’t been sleeping much”). Alternatively,
parents could reframe the event in a way that emphasizes learning some-
thing from the experience (e.g., “This is an opportunity to help Makayla
learn how to manage these emotions. Fortunately we were still here, be-
cause the babysitter might not have been able to help her through this as
well as we can”).
Next, help parents to generate ideas for actions that would have been
more helpful in this situation, while also noting how much easier it is to
act positively in response to problem-focused, helpful thoughts. For exam-
Bipolar Disorder 211
ple, instead of yelling at the child and retreating to the bedroom to cry,
parents could help the child choose a calming strategy from her tool kit
and could make a plan to call her psychiatrist the next day to voice con-
cerns that the child’s manic symptoms are increasing. They could take a
long walk together after the situation at home calmed down sufficiently
and order takeout from one of their favorite local restaurants.
Generating these more adaptive thoughts and actions not only moves
the family toward effectively managing the problem, but also positively
impacts parents’ emotions. Whereas hurtful cognitions and responses be-
get more negative feelings, helpful thoughts and actions beget more posi-
tive feelings.
Sessions 5 and 6
Child session 5: Thinking-Feeling-Doing. This session introduces the
TFD exercise to the child. As with the parents, help the child recall an up-
setting event, identify and acknowledge the negative emotions associated
with that event, discuss hurtful cognitions and actions arising in response to
the negative feelings, and finally guide the child through the experience of
restructuring thoughts and choosing more adaptive behaviors to alleviate
emotional dysregulation. This session builds on the work from the previous
session, in which the child focused on identifying triggers, accompanying so-
matic responses and negative affect, and hurtful actions. This new step adds
in the role of cognition and links thoughts, feelings, and actions together.
uation. Again, this session builds on the work of the previous sessions,
as the child now has an understanding of how thoughts, feelings, and
actions are integrated and affect each other. Because excessive emo-
tional reactivity can compromise problem-solving skills (Pavuluri et al.
2004), a child needs to calm down affectively before he or she is likely
to be successful in generating, selecting, and implementing sound deci-
sions.
• Next, have the child generate a list of possible solutions to the prob-
lem. Using a brainstorming approach, write down every suggestion
made before weighing their merits. For example, a child dealing with
anger over receiving a detention might generate suggestions that range
from “Ask the teacher what I did wrong and try to avoid doing this in
the future” to “Refuse to attend detention.”
• Then, have the child think through the pros and cons of each action.
After doing so, select an appropriate plan of action and encourage the
child to implement the solution next time the situation arises. Most
importantly, draw the child’s awareness to the results of his or her de-
cision. If the child’s choice solves the problem, he or she should plan
to use the strategy again in the future. If, on the other hand, the child’s
choice fails to ameliorate the situation, a new strategy should be con-
sidered next time, taking into account what has proven previously un-
successful.
Session 7
Child session 7: revisiting healthy routines. Given the importance of
healthy routines in maintaining affective stability, revisiting these routines is in
order. Progress on the child’s first goal should have been monitored at each
session since the child began tracking sleep, nutrition, or exercise. At this ses-
sion, have the child select the topic of second most importance, set reasonable
goals around that behavior, and begin to track it. Suboptimal treatment adher-
ence regarding healthy behaviors is common; because the child has now
learned problem-solving skills, work with him or her to apply those skills to
increase compliance. Often, the first step of identifying the problem is very
important to successful problem-solving. For example, the problem “I need to
lose 15 pounds before my senior pictures” may not lead to a successful out-
come in a teenager 2 months before the event, but changing the problem to “I
need to cut out most of the junk food in my diet” is more likely to lead to con-
crete but not extreme behaviors that can be maintained over a lifetime.
Session 8
Child session 8: nonverbal communication. Impaired communica-
tion, including the presence of expressed emotion, has been identified as
a possible influence on the course of bipolar disorder. Thus, addressing
maladaptive communication patterns between parents and children as
well as every dyad in the family is important. Parents can usually absorb
information, can typically practice using effective verbal and nonverbal
communication in a single session (as will be discussed in parent session 8),
and likely are at least somewhat familiar with the concepts. In contrast,
children may benefit from separate presentations about verbal and nonver-
bal communication, with eventual integration of the two topics. Research
indicates children with bipolar disorder tend to struggle with interpreting
216 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Session 9
Child session 9: verbal communication. As a follow-up to the session
on nonverbal communication, begin this session with a quick review of the
communication cycle. Then, focus on helping children to differentiate be-
tween helpful and hurtful words (e.g., “D’Shaun keeps coming in my room,
and it’s making me angry” vs. “D’Shaun’s being a brat!”). Using helpful words
involves standard training in assertive communication—i.e., describe the situ-
ation, express your feelings, state your desired outcome. Making the distinc-
tion between helpful and hurtful language increases children’s awareness of
how they are speaking and how their words are impacting others.
presses an immediate intent to harm himself or herself and who may have the
ability to do so should be immediately referred for emergency services, partic-
ularly if parents have any doubt about their ability to constantly monitor the
child and ensure safety. Especially with children who have demonstrated sig-
nificant physical aggression toward themselves and others, helping parents se-
cure training in administering therapeutic holds may be advisable, as well as
knowing when (and how) to call the police for assistance.
Hospitalization, if necessary, should never be used punitively or as re-
spite for overstressed parents. Stress that hospitalization is a setting for
short-term stabilization of acute symptoms and a means of returning chil-
dren to everyday routines as efficiently as possible.
Managing the symptoms of a child with bipolar disorder also requires
parents to manage the inherent stress of dealing with a chronically ill child.
Use your knowledge of the family and its resources to help parents iden-
tify sources of emotional support and how to utilize them (e.g., family and
friends who feel comfortable supervising the child for short periods; sup-
port groups for parents of children with mood disorders, including online
forums; spiritual or religious groups, if consistent with the family’s be-
liefs). In addition, all family members, regardless of age or relationship to
the child, should make time for themselves and for enjoyable activities
with others. Parents are often so overwhelmed with the demands of man-
aging their child’s disorder that they don’t realize the necessity of self-care.
Those who do recognize the need often feel guilty about considering their
own needs, out of understandable yet counterproductive concern for the
child. Remind parents this is a marathon, not a sprint. They need to give
self-preservation a high priority, and set aside time for exercise, medita-
tion, other “refueling” activities, or therapy for themselves.
rassment. A key challenge in this session is balancing the need to involve sib-
lings in helping to create an environment conducive to the health of all
members of the family, while also maintaining appropriate boundaries that
avoid placing excessive responsibility on these other children. Finally, as sib-
lings have the same familial risk as the child with bipolar disorder, referral
for an evaluation and treatment of one or more siblings may also be in order.
Cultural Considerations
Due to the relative infancy of research regarding psychosocial interventions
for youth with bipolar disorder, evidence-based guidelines for making cul-
turally specific adaptations to a CBT program of this type are not yet avail-
able. In lieu of such information, an emphasis on sensitivity to the specific
needs of each family is likely the most optimal approach (see Chapter 3). A
strength of the intervention described here is that it allows for therapists to
adjust content to meet the family “where they are” as opposed to “where
they should be.”
220 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ing with our daughter, I’d be better off raising her alone”) is often uncom-
fortable for parents but can be ultimately cathartic and empowering,
especially when the parents are interacting with an empathic therapist who
responds to the presence of these thoughts with a sense of understanding
(though without confirmation that the thoughts are accurate or helpful).
Once negative cognitions have been brought to the forefront and stripped of
the guilt that so often accompanies them, parents can begin to examine their
thoughts from a fresh perspective more conducive to progress.
Conclusion
While additional research is needed to further refine CBT-based, adjunc-
tive treatments for pediatric bipolar disorder, the intervention described
in this chapter (IF-PEP) has shown promise in helping patients and fami-
lies to meet the challenges of this complex illness. Because bipolar disorder
is typically believed to have a lifelong, chronic course, the intervention’s
focus on providing families with a sound knowledge base and the develop-
ment of essential skills (e.g., effective communication, problem-solving)
should appeal to clinicians who wish to equip their patients with more
than just a “band-aid” to address immediate concerns.
Self-Assessment Questions
6.1. CBT would be considered an appropriate treatment strategy for a
child with bipolar disorder
A. Academic problems.
B. Social problems.
C. Suicidal ideation.
D. All of the above.
A. CBT.
B. Antidepressants.
C. Mood stabilizers or atypical antipsychotics.
D. Electroconvulsive therapy.
A. Family involvement.
B. Use of a therapist of the same sex as the child.
C. Residential treatment.
D. Psychoeducational testing.
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
For Families
Books
Andersen M, Kubisak JB, Field R, et al: Understanding and Educating
Children and Adolescents With Bipolar Disorder: A Guide for Educa-
tors. Northfield, IL, The Josselyn Center, 2003—a book for parents to
share with school professionals
Child and Adolescent Bipolar Foundation: The Storm in My Brain. Evans-
ton, IL, 2003. Available at: Child and Adolescent Bipolar Foundation
(CABF): (800) 256–8525, www.bpkids.org—a book for children
Fristad MA, Goldberg Arnold JS: Raising a Moody Child: How to Cope
With Depression and Bipolar Disorder. New York, Guilford, 2004—a
book for parents
Jamieson PE, Rynn MA: Mind Race: A Firsthand Account of One Teenag-
er’s Experience With Bipolar Disorder. New York, Oxford University
Press, 2006—–a book for adolescents
Miklowitz DJ, George EL: The Bipolar Teen: What You Can Do to Help
Your Child and Your Family. New York, Guilford, 2007—a book for
parents
Web Sites
The Balanced Mind Foundation: www.thebalancedmind.org—for parents
and adolescents
BPChildren: www.bpchildren.com—for parents and children; features
“BPChildren Newsletter”
224 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
For Clinicians
Books
Fristad MA, Goldberg Arnold JS, Leffler J: Psychotherapy for Children
With Bipolar and Depressive Disorders. New York, Guilford, 2011
Kowatch RA, Fristad MA, Findling RL, et al: A Clinical Manual for the
Management of Bipolar Disorder in Children and Adolescents. Wash-
ington, DC, American Psychiatric Publishing, 2009
Web Sites
Juvenile Bipolar Research Foundation (JBRF): www.bpchildresearch.org—
includes a Listserv for therapists treating children with bipolar disorder
MF-PEP and IF-PEP workbooks can be ordered directly from
www.moodychildtherapy.com
References
Basco MR, Rush AJ: Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Bipolar Disorder. New York,
Guilford, 1996
Danner S, Fristad MA, Arnold LE, et al: Early onset bipolar spectrum disorders:
diagnostic issues. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev 12:271–293, 2009
Fields BW, Fristad MA: Assessment of childhood bipolar disorder. Clinical Psychol-
ogy: Science and Practice 16:166–181, 2009a
Fields BW, Fristad MA: The bipolar child and the educational system: working with
schools, in A Clinical Manual for the Management of Bipolar Disorder in Chil-
dren and Adolescents. Edited by Kowatch RA, Fristad MA, Findling RL, et al.
Washington, DC, American Psychiatric Publishing, 2009b, pp 239–272
Fristad MA: Psychoeducational treatment for school-aged children with bipolar
disorder. Dev Psychopathol 18:1289–1306, 2006
Fristad MA, Gavazzi SM, Soldano KW: Naming the enemy. J Fam Psychother
10:81–88, 1999
Fristad MA, Goldberg-Arnold JS, Gavazzi SM: Multifamily psychoeducation
groups (MFPG) for families of children with bipolar disorder. Bipolar Disord
4:254–262, 2002
Fristad MA, Goldberg-Arnold JS, Gavazzi SM: Multi-family psychoeducation
groups in the treatment of children with mood disorders. J Marital Fam Ther
29:491–504, 2003
Fristad MA, Davidson KH, Leffler JM: Thinking-feeling-doing. J Fam Psychother
18:81–103, 2008
Fristad MA, Verducci JS, Walters K, et al: Impact of multifamily psychoeduca-
tional psychotherapy in treating children aged 8 to 12 years with mood disor-
ders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 66:1013–1021, 2009
Bipolar Disorder 225
Miller AL, Rathus JH, Linehan MM: Dialectical Behavior Therapy With Suicidal
Adolescents. New York, Guilford, 2006
Pavuluri MN, Graczyk PA, Henry DB, et al: Child- and family focused cognitive-
behavioral therapy for pediatric bipolar disorder: development and prelimi-
nary results. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 43:528–537, 2004
Pavuluri MN, Schenkel LS, Subhash A, et al: Neurocognitive function in unmedi-
cated manic and medicated euthymic pediatric bipolar patients. Am J Psychi-
atry 163:286–293, 2006
Pollock KM: Exercise in treating depression: Broadening the psychotherapist’s role.
J Clin Psychol 57:1289–1300, 2001
Strober M, Morrell W, Lampert C, et al: Relapse following discontinuation of lith-
ium maintenance therapy in adolescents with bipolar I illness: a naturalistic
study. Am J Psychiatry 147:457–461, 1990
West AE, Henry DB, Pavuluri MN: Maintenance model of integrated psychosocial
treatment in pediatric bipolar disorder: a pilot feasibility study. J Am Acad
Child Adolesc Psychiatry 46:205–212, 2007
West AE, Jacobs RH, Westerholm R, et al: Child- and family-focused cognitive-
behavioral therapy for pediatric bipolar disorder: pilot study of group treat-
ment format. J Can Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 18:239–246, 2009
White M, Epston D: Narrative Means to Therapeutic Ends. New York, Norton,
1990
Wozniak J, Biederman J, Kiely K, et al: Mania-like symptoms suggestive of child-
hood-onset bipolar disorder in clinically referred children. J Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 34:867–876, 1995
Young ME, Fristad MA: Working with patients and their families, in A Clinical
Manual for the Management of Bipolar Disorder in Children and Adolescents.
Edited by Kowatch RA, Fristad MA, Findling RL, et al. Washington, DC,
American Psychiatric Publishing, 2009, pp 217–238
7
Childhood Anxiety
Disorders
The Coping Cat Program
S This chapter has a video case example on the DVD (“The Coping Cat Program”)
demonstrating CBT for an anxious child.
227
228 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Empirical Evidence
Cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) for youth anxiety has been found to be
effective in several randomized clinical trials conducted in the United
States (e.g., Kendall 1994; Kendall et al. 1997, 2008b; Walkup et al.
2008). Additional studies with similar outcomes have been conducted in
Australia (e.g., Barrett et al. 1996), Canada (e.g., Manassis et al. 2002),
and the Netherlands (e.g., Nauta et al. 2003). Collectively, although not
all participants are responders, the results of these trials indicate that be-
tween 50% and 72% of children with GAD, social phobia, and/or SAD
who receive CBT do have a positive response—they no longer meet crite-
ria for their presenting anxiety disorder following treatment. In contrast,
such trials indicate that between 10% and 37% of youth who receive pill
placebo, wait-list assignment, or active comparison treatment for their
anxiety disorder have a positive response following treatment (Barrett et
al. 1996; Kendall et al. 2008b; Nauta et al. 2003.
The maintenance of therapeutic gains has been found up to 7 years
posttreatment. In two follow-up studies of different samples of anxious
youth (3.35 and 7.4 years after treatment), 80%–90% of successfully
treated children continued to not meet criteria for their presenting anxiety
disorder (Kendall and Southam-Gerow 1996; Kendall et al. 2004). To
date, rates of long-term treatment maintenance following CBT have not
been compared with a control group, because generally, the wait-listed
youth in such trials were offered treatment following the initial wait-list
period. It is pleasing to note that reviews of the evaluation literature sup-
port the utility of CBT for childhood anxiety disorders. Such reviews ap-
pearing earlier than 2008 and applying Chambless and Hollon’s (1998)
criteria for evidence-based treatments conclude that CBT for youth with
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 229
CBT Approaches
Consistent with a cognitive-behavioral model (Kendall 2010), CBT for
childhood anxiety disorders targets the somatic, cognitive, and behavioral as-
pects of anxiety. For a discussion of the theoretical underpinnings of CBT for
childhood anxiety disorders, see Gosch et al. 2006. Several CBT approaches
to treating child anxiety have been developed and the majority have core
treatment components in common: psychoeducation, recognition and man-
agement of somatic symptoms, cognitive restructuring, and exposure. The
Coping Cat Program (Kendall and Hedtke 2006a, 2006b) is a manual-based
individual CBT for youth with considerable empirical support when com-
pared with a wait-list control condition, active comparison treatment, and
pill placebo (Kendall 1994; Kendall et al. 1997, 2008b; Walkup et al. 2008).
Other CBT approaches, such as Social Effectiveness Therapy for socially
phobic youth (Beidel et al. 2000), may include a greater emphasis on social
skills training. Individual CBT with an added parent component (e.g., Bar-
rett et al. 1996), group CBT (e.g., Manassis et al. 2002), and family CBT
(e.g., Wood et al. 2006) also have empirical support. In this chapter, we de-
scribe the CBT approach used at the Child and Adolescent Anxiety Disor-
ders Clinic of Temple University, the Coping Cat Program. Although we
describe the implementation of the Coping Cat Program to treat GAD, so-
cial phobia, and/or SAD specifically, the core principles of CBT for child
anxiety are highlighted throughout the chapter.
Treatment Planning
There are several important issues to consider when implementing CBT
for childhood anxiety, such as assessment, the format and length of treat-
ment, and the structure and content of sessions. We consider each of these
issues below.
Assessment
We recommend a multimethod, multi-informant approach to assessment.
Clinical interviews, youth self-report measures, and parent- and teacher-
230 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Format
Typically, the Coping Cat Program involves child-focused therapy, with
two specific parent sessions included in the program. In the Coping Cat
Program, parents serve as consultants (i.e., provide the therapist with in-
formation about the child) and as collaborators (i.e., help with implemen-
tation of the program). Therapists who wish to work with parents in the
sessions (family CBT) can consult the family therapy manual (Howard et
al. 2000). Additionally, youth anxiety disorders have been treated within
a group format.
Length of Treatment
The Coping Cat Program is designed as a 16-session program. As opera-
tionalized in one study, treatment was 14 sessions provided within
12 weeks (Walkup et al. 2008). In accordance with the concept of “flexi-
bility within fidelity” (e.g., Kendall et al. 2008a), some youth may require
slightly more or fewer than 16 sessions.
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 231
Structure of Sessions
The Coping Cat Program is designed to be implemented in weekly child-
focused sessions lasting 50–60 minutes. There are two parent sessions, and
each may be scheduled for the same day as an adjacent child-focused ses-
sion. Each child-focused session begins with a review of the weekly home-
work assignment (referred to as a STIC [Show That I Can] task). The
majority of each session is devoted to psychoeducation (phase I) or expo-
sure (phase II) content. Each session ends with an assignment of a STIC
task (i.e., homework) and a fun activity or game.
Content of Sessions
The Coping Cat Program combines behavioral strategies (e.g., modeling,
relaxation training, in vivo exposure tasks, and contingent reinforcements)
with cognitive strategies (e.g., problem solving, cognitive restructuring) to
help youth identify and cope with anxiety. The content of the Coping Cat
Program is described below. Therapists interested in using the Coping Cat
Program with an anxious child should consult the therapist manual (Ken-
dall and Hedtke 2006a) and the child’s workbook (Kendall and Hedtke
2006b). The therapist manual and the client workbook are designed to be
used together: the manual guides the sessions of the treatment, whereas
the workbook contains corresponding client tasks. A similar program is
available for adolescents (Kendall et al. 2002a, 2002b), and a computer-
assisted version of the treatment (Camp Cope-A-Lot; Kendall and Khanna
2008) has been evaluated in research (Khanna and Kendall 2010).
Coping Modeling
An important component of the Coping Cat Program is for the therapist to
serve as a coping model for the child. A mastery model demonstrates success,
whereas a coping model demonstrates encountering a problem, developing a
strategy to deal with the problem, and then success. Therapists serve as a cop-
ing model by demonstrating their own anxiety, strategies that helped them
cope with the anxiety, and then success. The therapist continues to serve as a
coping model throughout treatment as each new skill is introduced. The ther-
apist demonstrates the skill first, then asks the child to participate with him
or her in role-playing. Finally, the therapist encourages the child to role-play
scenes alone, practicing the newly acquired skills.
Weekly Homework
Homework is an important component of the Coping Cat Program.
Throughout treatment, ask the child to complete weekly homework as-
signments (STIC tasks). STIC tasks provide the child with an opportunity
to test out and practice each of the skills learned in session. Consistent
with behavioral theory, reward the child for STIC task completion.
Psychoeducation
In phase I, the therapist presents four important concepts.
To teach these concepts to the child, the therapist uses an acronym, re-
ferred to as the FEAR plan, to help the child learn, remember, and apply
these four concepts.
F = Feeling frightened?
E = Expecting bad things to happen?
A = Attitudes and actions that can help
R = Results and rewards
Exposure Tasks
In phase II, the therapist guides the child through exposure tasks—creat-
ing anxiety-provoking situations and helping the child practice the FEAR
plan during anxious arousal. The purpose of exposure is prolonged, sys-
tematic, and repeated contact with the avoided stimuli or situation. The
goal is to have the child remain in the situation until she has reached an
acceptable level of comfort (i.e., habituation). Be sure to tailor the expo-
sure tasks to each child according to the child’s specific anxieties and fears.
For example, anxiety-provoking situations for a child with social phobia
might include playing a game with a new person or peer, whereas anxiety-
provoking situations for a child with separation anxiety might include
waiting for a parent who is late. The exposure tasks increase in difficulty
over the course of the second half of treatment; later exposure tasks are
more anxiety provoking than earlier ones.
S Case Example:
The Coping Cat Program
We illustrate the Coping Cat Program using the case of a youth named
Zoe. (See the DVD for a demonstration of the FEAR strategy and STIC
assignment.)
Zoe, a 10-year-old girl, met criteria for a diagnosis of social phobia at the
intake assessment. She is easily embarrassed, and afraid that others will
laugh at her in social situations. Zoe’s feared situations include speaking to
adults, reading aloud in class, giving presentations, and asking questions in
class. Her parents report that Zoe’s distress is highly impairing and affects
her academic performance. When Zoe is faced with a social situation, she
“freezes up.” She has great difficulty maintaining eye contact.
234 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
On the day of her first appointment, Zoe enters the therapy room without
looking at the therapist. The therapist invites Zoe to make herself comfort-
able. The therapist asks Zoe to look around the room and see if there are any
interesting games that she would like to play later in the session. Zoe finds
the game Guess Who? and brings it to the therapist. The therapist lets Zoe
know that they will save time at the end of the session to play the game to-
gether. The therapist gives Zoe an overview of what the session will involve.
They play a get-to-know-you game (asking each other for personal facts, such
as “What is your favorite TV show?”). During the game, Zoe’s eye contact
improves slightly and the therapist notes that she seems more relaxed.
After the get-to-know-you game, the therapist shares some of the logis-
tics of the Coping Cat Program with Zoe. The therapist shares with Zoe that
they will learn skills that can help kids when they are feeling worried or
scared. She explains to Zoe that for the first half of the program, they will
focus on recognizing and learning about anxiety, and in the second half, they
will focus on knowing what to do about feeling anxious. The therapist points
out to Zoe that they will work as a team, with the therapist as the coach. She
encourages Zoe to ask questions and is enthusiastic when Zoe talks.
The therapist introduces The Coping Cat Workbook and Zoe is assigned
a STIC task from the book (e.g., “Write about a time you felt great”). The
therapist and Zoe agree that she will earn stickers for each STIC task com-
pleted and can exchange those stickers for rewards every four sessions. As
promised, the therapist and Zoe spend the last 10 minutes playing Guess
Who?
task, complete it together. Next, discuss with the child how different feel-
ings have different physical expressions. Collaborate with the child to list
various feelings and their corresponding physical expressions. Once the child
has a general understanding that different feelings correspond to different
expressions, normalize the child’s own experience of fears and anxiety. To
serve as a coping model, disclose a time when you felt anxious and how you
handled it. Be a coping model rather than a mastery model—everything
doesn’t always go well! Discuss the child’s own anxiety, including the types
of situations that are difficult, and the child’s responses in the anxiety-pro-
voking situation. Introduce the feelings thermometer, which is used to rate
anxiety on a scale from 0 to 8 (see the therapist manual for details). With
the child, begin to construct a hierarchy (or FEAR ladder; Figure 7–1) using
the ratings from the feelings thermometer.
Zoe and her therapist begin session 2 by reviewing her STIC task. Zoe
wrote about feeling great during a recent soccer game. The therapist listens
with interest to the account of Zoe’s soccer game. Together they pick out
two stickers as Zoe’s reward. Next, the therapist introduces Zoe to the
concept that different feelings have different physical expressions. Zoe and
the therapist create a feelings dictionary by cutting out pictures of people
with various expressions from magazines and labeling the pictures with the
emotions depicted. During this project, Zoe and the therapist note that
different facial or physical expressions (e.g., a smile, head hanging down)
are linked to different emotions (e.g., feeling happy, feeling sad). The ther-
apist and Zoe also play a brief feelings charades game. They take turns act-
ing out various feelings and having the other person guess the feeling.
The therapist shares with Zoe that everyone (including the therapist) feels
anxious at times. The purpose of the program is to help Zoe learn to recognize
when she is feeling anxious and then to use skills to help herself cope. Zoe and
her therapist begin to develop a fear hierarchy of anxiety-provoking situations
by categorizing the things Zoe is afraid of into easy, medium, and challenging
categories. Zoe identifies talking to a new adult (e.g., store clerk) as a medium
fear and giving an oral presentation as the most challenging fear.
Zoe is assigned a STIC task: record one anxious experience and one
nonanxious experience in her workbook. Zoe and her therapist play a game
of Guess Who? before the session ends.
FEAR Ladder
up there!
’re
u
Yo
Getting hig
he
r...
high...
oo
tt
No
The therapist and Zoe start session 3 by reviewing Zoe’s STIC task and
putting stickers in her bank. Next, the therapist introduces today’s topic:
identifying the body’s reaction to anxiety. The therapist mentions several
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 237
The therapist meets with Zoe’s mother and father. She shares with the
parents that she has enjoyed meeting with Zoe and notes some of Zoe’s
strengths. The therapist briefly outlines the treatment program, noting
what Zoe has learned so far and what will happen in the remainder of treat-
ment. The therapist explains that a parent can be involved in treatment by
providing information about Zoe’s anxiety and by helping to carry out ther-
apy tasks at home. The therapist talks with the parents to learn more about
situations where Zoe becomes anxious. The parents describe Zoe’s reac-
tion in several recent social situations, such as refusing to order for herself
in a restaurant.
The therapist begins Zoe’s session 5 by mentioning the parent session and
inviting her to ask questions. Next, they review Zoe’s STIC task. Zoe has
accumulated enough stickers to trade in for a small prize.
The therapist introduces relaxation as a tool that Zoe can use when she
is anxious. The therapist recalls that when Zoe has to answer a question in
class, she gets a stomachache and feels tense. The therapist links this bodily
response to the F step (Feeling frightened?) of the FEAR plan. The thera-
pist explains that our bodies provide cues when we are feeling nervous, and
these cues can be signals for us to relax. The therapist and Zoe engage in a
robot–rag doll exercise (Kendall and Braswell 1993) and note the differ-
ence between feeling tense and feeling relaxed.
Next, the therapist and Zoe practice deep breathing. The therapist
suggests that Zoe sit comfortably on a beanbag chair. She asks Zoe to take
a deep breath and then let it out slowly, focusing on how her body feels.
The therapist asks Zoe how her body feels after a few deep breaths. Then,
the therapist introduces relaxation. She gives Zoe a CD with the thera-
pist’s voice guiding her through a progressive muscle relaxation exercise.
The therapist and Zoe practice relaxation together with the therapist serv-
ing as a coping model. The therapist suggests that Zoe can use the CD to
practice these skills at home. She also asks Zoe to consider times when re-
laxation may be useful. The therapist suggests that even when Zoe can’t
complete an entire relaxation session, she may be able to take deep breaths
Afterward, the therapist and Zoe invite Zoe’s parents into the session. Zoe
“teaches” her parents relaxation and everyone follows along with the CD.
Together, they discuss when and where Zoe will be able to practice her re-
laxation during the coming week (her STIC task). Zoe plans to practice
each night in a comfortable chair in her bedroom.
types of coping self-talk using the first two steps in the FEAR plan (see Ta-
bles 7–1 and 7–2).
Zoe and the therapist begin session 6 by reviewing the STIC task from last
week. Zoe reports that she was able to relax while listening to her CD and
that her mom joined in some nights.
The therapist introduces Zoe to the idea that thoughts are connected
to feelings. They work on a thought-bubble exercise in Zoe’s Coping Cat
Workbook. They also look through magazines and give people in the pic-
tures a thought bubble. The therapist helps Zoe differentiate between anx-
ious self-talk and coping self-talk. The therapist introduces the E step
(Expecting bad things to happen?) of the FEAR plan. She tells Zoe that in
this step, she will ask herself, “What’s in my thought bubble? Am I expect-
ing bad things to happen?” and that Zoe will start to pay attention to her
240 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
thoughts when she is anxious. Together, Zoe and the therapist practice cop-
ing self-talk and review the F and E steps of the FEAR plan. At the end of
the session, Zoe’s therapist assigns a STIC task from the workbook. They
play a game on the clinic Wii for the final 5 minutes of the session.
Zoe and the therapist review the STIC task and pick out stickers to place
in the bank. Next, the therapist reviews the F and E steps with Zoe by ask-
ing her to describe what they stand for. Following Zoe’s explanations, the
therapist presents the idea that now that Zoe knows how to check what’s
going on in her body and her thoughts when she is nervous, it’s time to
learn how to cope with that anxiety. The therapist introduces the A step in
the FEAR plan: Attitudes and actions that can help. The therapist briefly
describes the process of problem solving. She begins the discussion of
problem solving with a concrete, nonstressful situation. The therapist gives
the following example: “You can’t find your shoes. How would you try to
find them?” The therapist and Zoe go through the steps of problem solving,
having some fun along the way as they include silly solutions in their brain-
storming. After they have practiced with a nonstressful situation, the ther-
apist guides Zoe in using problem solving in low and high anxiety–
provoking situations. To end the session, Zoe’s therapist assigns a STIC
task from the workbook, and she and Zoe play a game of tic-tac-toe.
Feeling frightened?
Expecting bad things to happen?
Attitudes and actions that can help
Results and rewards
Inform the child that the next part of the program involves practicing
the FEAR steps in anxiety-provoking situations. Remind the child that the
practice will be gradual, starting with a situation that makes the child only
a little anxious—an easy one. Let her know that the FEAR steps will need
to be practiced in the same situations more than once.
Zoe and her therapist begin by reviewing the STIC task. The therapist in-
troduces the final step in the FEAR plan: Results and rewards. The thera-
pist asks Zoe what she thinks about rewards, and they discuss the
difference between a reward and an award. Together, Zoe and the therapist
create a list of potential rewards (e.g., baking cookies with her mom, a
high-five from the therapist, a new soccer ball) that she might be able to
earn for completing challenging tasks in and out of session.
Zoe and her therapist practice self-reward for effort through the exer-
cises in the workbook and role-plays. They review the steps of the FEAR
plan. Together they create a Coping Keychain with a personalized FEAR
plan for Zoe to use as a keychain and when she is feeling anxious. Zoe and
her therapist review Zoe’s fear hierarchy, which includes speaking to an
adult she doesn’t know that well, reading in front of others, and answering
questions in class.
The therapist tells Zoe that the next part of treatment involves practicing
the skills Zoe has learned in the program thus far. The therapist explains that
Zoe may feel anxious during the practices but now she has the FEAR plan to
help her cope. The therapist also reminds Zoe that she is going to meet with
her parents again next time. The therapist assigns Zoe a STIC task from her
workbook. They end the session by kicking around the Nerf soccer ball.
242 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Both of Zoe’s parents attend the second parent meeting. The therapist be-
gins the session by giving them an overview of the remainder of treatment.
She introduces the exposure tasks by explaining that Zoe has learned ways
to cope with her anxiety in social situations and that now she will get to
practice in real situations. As Zoe starts to face her fears, she will gain a
sense of mastery and her anxiety will be reduced in future situations. The
therapist notes that most children feel anxiety during the practices, and
this is OK.
Zoe’s mother expresses some concern about putting Zoe in upsetting
situations. The therapist validates this concern and reminds Zoe’s parents
that Zoe and the therapist will start with the least challenging practice and
work their way up the hierarchy. Zoe now has the tools to cope with these
upsetting situations. The therapist reminds the parents that the goal of
treatment is not to get rid of all Zoe’s anxiety, but to “turn down the vol-
ume” on Zoe’s anxiety so she can cope in social situations.
Finally, the therapist reviews Zoe’s fear hierarchy with her parents.
Zoe’s mother emphasizes that Zoe needs practice presenting or reading in
front of others, as this fear is currently causing interference in the school
setting. The therapist agrees that this is an important situation for practice,
and lets the parents know that she may ask for their help in planning some
of the exposures.
243
from session
244
TABLE 7–3. Examples of exposure tasks (continued)
Take a difficult “test” and receive a “poor grade” GAD X Fake test No
Read or record an imaginal exposure script about the GAD X X Paper for No
child’s worst fear (e.g., parents dying, world ending) and script or tape
read or listen to the script repeatedly until anxiety recorder
decreases by 50%
Therapist and child take a ride on a bus, train, or other GAD, specific X X Money for No
feared form of transportation phobia trip
Therapist and child go to the top of a tall building Specific phobia, X X No
GAD
Call to order pizza or takeout on the phone (to make it Social phobia, X X Money if Yes
more difficult, call back to change or cancel the order) GAD actual order
Give the child or have someone else give the child a Specific phobia X Syringe Yes
pretend injection
Draw a “mystery challenge” or “mystery practice” out of a GAD (fear of X Jar or hat, No
jar or hat uncertainty)b paper
Note. GAD=generalized anxiety disorder; SAD=separation anxiety disorder.
aIn addition to therapist.
bSymptoms targeted are included in parentheses.
245
246 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
through an imaginal exposure. With the child, prepare for the exposure
task. Write out the FEAR plan for the specific situation in The Coping Cat
Workbook. Serve as a coping model by thinking aloud about the situation.
Then have the child walk through all the steps during the imaginal expo-
sure task. Make the imagined situation as real as possible by using props or
details. Ask for ratings on the feelings thermometer before, after, and ev-
ery minute during the imaginal exposure.
Next, it’s time for an in vivo exposure task. Develop a FEAR plan and
negotiate a reward for completing the in vivo exposure. It is important to
help the child prepare and think through any possible roadblocks or other
outcomes to the task. A main goal of the exposure is to assist the child in
approaching (not avoiding) until she feels an acceptable level of comfort in
the anxiety-provoking situation. Ask for ratings on the feelings thermom-
eter before, after, and at a regular time interval (every minute or two) dur-
ing the in vivo exposure. A general guideline is to have the child stay in the
situation until her ratings decrease by about 50%. After the exposure task,
reward the child for effort. To end the session, plan an exposure task for
the next session.
At the beginning of Zoe’s session 10, the therapist reminds Zoe that they
are going to start “doing challenges”—practicing the FEAR plan in real-life
situations. They begin by agreeing on a situation that makes Zoe a little
anxious, such as conducting a survey of several unfamiliar adults. Together,
Zoe and the therapist develop a FEAR plan for coping with the challenge.
Zoe plans to ask survey questions about favorite sports. She and her ther-
apist decide to kick a soccer ball outside for 5–10 minutes as a reward for
completing the challenge.
First, Zoe and her therapist practice the FEAR plan by having Zoe
imagine herself in the situation. The therapist has Zoe close her eyes and
pretend that she is asking the survey questions. The therapist asks Zoe to
talk through the FEAR plan. Zoe shares that she knows she is feeling fright-
ened because her stomach hurts. She is having the anxious thought “What
if I mess up one of the questions?” She shares the coping thought “It’s no
big deal if I mess up. They probably won’t make a big deal of it, or even
notice, and everyone makes mistakes.” She also practices taking deep
breaths to help herself cope. Finally, she imagines herself doing a good job
(not perfect) and receiving her reward. Zoe successfully completes the
imaginal exposure task, providing ratings of her anxiety using the feelings
thermometer.
Next, Zoe and her therapist prepare for the in vivo exposure task. Zoe
is able to ask her survey questions of five unfamiliar people. Throughout
the exposure, the therapist asks for Zoe’s ratings of her anxiety and pro-
vides her own ratings as well. Zoe rates her anxiety at a 5 before asking the
first person her survey questions, and the ratings decrease to a 2 by the
fifth person. Afterward, the therapist asks, “What did you notice about
your anxiety during the survey?” and Zoe responds that it went down, and
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 247
the task became easier. As a reward, Zoe and the therapist play soccer out-
side the clinic. Finally, the therapist and Zoe plan a challenge for the up-
coming session and complete a brief relaxation exercise together. For her
STIC task, Zoe agrees that she will practice the FEAR plan in one low anx-
iety–provoking situation (an at-home challenge).
Zoe and her therapist begin session 12 by talking about Zoe’s at-home chal-
lenges from the prior week. Zoe is proud of how well she coped with them
and excited about the rewards. Together, Zoe and her therapist develop the
FEAR plan for today’s challenge—Zoe will read a passage from a book in
front of two members of the clinic staff. Zoe shares that her stomach hurts
already and that she is thinking, “What if I mess up? They will laugh at me!”
Zoe and her therapist come up with the coping thought “It’s not likely that
I will mess up because I’ve practiced. Even if I do, it’s OK because every-
one makes mistakes.” Zoe is reminded of a TV star who made a few slips
when interviewed, but it wasn’t a big deal. The therapist and Zoe agree to
go get a special snack together as a reward.
First, Zoe practices reading the passage to the therapist and talks
through the FEAR plan. Zoe provides ratings of her anxiety on the feelings
thermometer while she practices. Next, it’s time for the challenge. Zoe
and the therapist invite two unfamiliar clinic staff members to join them
in the therapy room. Zoe takes a deep breath, goes to the front of the
room, and then reads a passage from her book. Afterward, Zoe and the
therapist talk about the challenge. Zoe shares that her stomach hurt at
first, but both her stomach and her anxiety felt better once she started. She
“messed up” a few times, but she reminded herself that everyone makes
mistakes. The therapist and Zoe note that the other audience members did
not seem to notice the mistakes. Zoe is very proud of her effort and accom-
plishment today. Zoe and the therapist plan at-home challenges and next
week’s exposure task before heading out for a treat.
Zoe’s session 14 begins with a review of her STIC task and at-home chal-
lenges. Zoe and her therapist prepare for today’s high-level exposure by de-
248 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
veloping a FEAR plan. Zoe’s challenge today is to order food for herself but
purposely make a mistake and need to change the order. The therapist helps
Zoe to identify aspects of the exposure task that may generate anxiety. Zoe
describes how her body will feel (stomachache), what she is expecting
(“They will laugh at me for the mistake”), and what she can do to help her-
self cope during the challenge (take deep breaths; use the coping thought
“Everyone makes mistakes”). The therapist and Zoe plan for a reward of eat-
ing the snack that she orders. After practicing in the therapy room, Zoe and
her therapist head out to the nearby fast-food restaurant for the challenge.
Zoe provides ratings on the feelings thermometer before, during, and after
the exposure task. Zoe is able to complete the task and enjoys her snack as
a reward. Zoe, Zoe’s mother, and the therapist plan challenges for the re-
maining two sessions. The therapist reminds Zoe about the “commercial”
that she can create in the final session. The therapist explains that the com-
mercial is something to show off what she has learned and accomplished and
to teach other kids about the FEAR plan. Zoe immediately decides she
would like to create a collage and the therapist encourages her to keep think-
ing about what she would like to include in the collage.
During Zoe’s final session, Zoe and the therapist complete one final imag-
inal and in vivo exposure task: a personal speech in front of a group of clinic
staff members. Zoe and the therapist put the finishing touches on Zoe’s
commercial (a collage that includes the FEAR plan and pictures of some of
Zoe’s at-home challenges). Zoe, the therapist, and Zoe’s parents review
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 249
Zoe’s progress in treatment. They list ways that Zoe can keep practicing
her skills at home. The therapist reminds the family about calling to check
in next month. The therapist presents Zoe with a certificate of completion
and a list of all the challenges she completed in the program with a little
ceremony. To conclude, Zoe, her family, and the therapist have a pizza
party to celebrate Zoe’s successful completion of the Coping Cat Program.
Cultural Considerations
Given the rich cultural diversity in most countries, it is important for ther-
apists to be aware of the cultural factors that can impact the perception,
etiology, symptom expression, and treatment of anxiety in youth. Though
limited, the available literature suggests some differences in symptom ex-
pression among anxious youth. For example, research shows that Latino
youth tend to report higher rates of somatic symptoms compared with
white youth (Canino 2004; Pina and Silverman 2004), Asian American
youth tend to exhibit somatic symptoms as early signs of anxiety (Gee
2004), and African American youth tend to score higher than white youth
on measures of anxiety sensitivity (Lambert et al. 2004). It is possible that
therapists will find these same patterns when working with diverse youth.
However, bear in mind that research on cultural differences is based on
group averages; clinicians will likely encounter variations in symptom ex-
pression in youth from the same cultural background.
In addition to informing therapist expectations for symptom expres-
sion, research on treatment outcomes has implications for how therapists
treat diverse clientele. A majority of the participants in randomized con-
trolled trials examining the efficacy of CBT for anxious youth have been
white, limiting the examination of race and ethnicity as potential modera-
tors of treatment outcome. However, available literature suggests that
CBT is an appropriate treatment option for youth from various racial and
ethnic groups. Treadwell et al. (1995) found comparable outcomes for
white and African American youth who received the Coping Cat Program
for their anxiety. Pina et al. (2003) found comparable outcomes for white
and Latino youth who received exposure-based CBT for their anxiety. Al-
though Asian American youth responded similarly to others in one study
(Walkup et al. 2008), more research is needed regarding the responses of
Asian American youth to CBT for anxiety. Nevertheless, on the basis of
the available findings, therapists can have confidence in choosing CBT as a
treatment choice for anxious youth from various cultural backgrounds.
Although race and ethnicity have not been found to moderate treatment
outcomes, they have been found to predict lower rates of treatment-seeking
behavior and higher attrition rates among racial and ethnic minority groups
250 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
(Hwang et al. 2006; Sood and Kendall 2006). Possible reasons for these
findings include the presence of stressors (e.g., low socioeconomic status),
lack of trust in psychology, unfamiliarity with treatment, and reliance on
family or church for mental health needs. Given these findings, it is possible
that therapists will encounter difficulty initially engaging and then maintain-
ing in treatment some youth from minority racial and ethnic groups. If this
occurs, we recommend spending additional time building rapport with these
clients and their families, as well as seeking to identify and address the spe-
cific barriers inhibiting their involvement in treatment.
With each client, regardless of his or her background, we and others
(e.g., Hwang et al. 2006) encourage therapists to adopt an ecological ap-
proach to assessment and therapy practices. An ecological approach involves
evaluating how a client’s affect, cognition, and behavior are influenced by
contextual factors, including cultural background. An ecological approach
is warranted at each stage of the therapeutic process: assessment, concep-
tualization, and treatment.
Assessment
Before treatment begins, assess the client’s presenting problem with an
eye for contextual factors. To accomplish this, use measures that have been
validated for the cultural group of the child being assessed or choose cul-
ture-specific assessment instruments (when available). Supplement ques-
tionnaires with interviews to gather contextual information and to better
understand the client’s and parents’ worldview (Gee 2004).
Conceptualization
Develop treatment goals and tailor treatment for individual clients based
on knowledge of cultural norms. For example, the normative age at which
a child sleeps in her own bed may vary by cultural background.
Treatment
Be flexible when delivering treatment. Given the variation found within
cultural groups, it is important not to establish strict protocols for all mem-
bers of a cultural group. Instead, we advocate adopting an open mind-set
that seeks to understand and personalize treatment for each individual cli-
ent. We do not advise eliminating the core components of CBT (i.e., psy-
choeducation and exposure). However, we do encourage therapists to
flexibly adapt the treatment to meet the needs of diverse clients. For ex-
ample, during the A step, the therapist might enlist various cultural and/
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 251
Comorbidity
Comorbidity is the rule, not the exception, among childhood anxiety dis-
orders (Kendall et al. 2001). Although research indicates that the presence
of comorbidity does not affect the efficacy of the Coping Cat Program
(Kendall et al. 2001), making some flexible adjustments may be necessary
in the implementation of the intervention nonetheless (while maintaining
its fidelity). If, as is typical, a child presents with multiple anxiety disor-
ders, assess which disorder is primary and causes the greatest interference.
This information guides and prioritizes treatment goals. When construct-
ing a list of graduated exposure tasks, for example, the therapist and the
youth may decide to create multiple hierarchies addressing different sets
of situations and then complete each hierarchy sequentially (e.g., first con-
struct a hierarchy for social fears corresponding to the child’s social phobia
and then complete a hierarchy for GAD fears). Alternatively, the therapist
and the youth may opt to construct one hierarchy incorporating fears
across various domains.
Children with a primary anxiety disorder may also present with a co-
morbid externalizing disorder, such as attention-deficit/hyperactivity dis-
order (ADHD). First, check that the ADHD is adequately managed (e.g.,
through medication and/or behavioral intervention). Even when ADHD is
controlled, it can still complicate intervention practices for treating anxi-
ety. For instance, because youth with comorbid ADHD may benefit from
very clearly structured sessions, consider providing the youth with a writ-
ten agenda at each session and reinforcing on-task behavior with rewards.
252 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Developmental Level
and Cognitive Abilities
Throughout treatment, keep in mind the youth’s developmental level and
cognitive abilities. The Coping Cat Program (Kendall and Hedtke 2006a)
is for treating children ages 7–13 years. The Being Brave program (Hirsh-
feld-Becker et al. 2008), an adaptation of the Coping Cat, was developed
for children ages 4–7 years and includes a greater emphasis on parent train-
ing. The C.A.T. Project Manual (Kendall et al. 2002a, 2002b) is for ado-
lescents. Regarding overall cognitive functioning, the various programs are
best matched for youth with an IQ>80.
Younger children or children with cognitive limitations can benefit from the
simplification of some of the cognitive-behavioral concepts. For example, it
may be easier for them to rely on one or two general coping thoughts such as
“I can do this!” or “I will be brave!” rather than 1) having to generate a wide
range of novel responses to various situations or 2) having to self-reflect to iden-
tify what type of “thinking trap” they commonly fall into. Similarly, relaxation
strategies can be simplified by demonstrating them in a fun, brief manner and
by having children focus on just one or two steps. For example, children can
choose their favorite part of progressive muscle relaxation (e.g., pretending to
squeeze lemons in their hands) and use it to help relax when facing an anxiety-
provoking situation. The therapist can provide visual and aural reminders of
coping strategies to facilitate recall of session information. For example, youth
may create index cards with brief statements or pictures reminding them of
the FEAR plan or specific coping thoughts and actions. Parents may help cue
children to follow the steps outside of therapy. To help solidify gains and foster
a sense of accomplishment, particularly for children with cognitive limitations,
incorporate the use of creative projects for children to take home. One such
project that youth often find enjoyable and beneficial is creating a photo album
documenting the exposure tasks completed during treatment.
Case Example
Chloe is a 7-year-old who was diagnosed with SAD. She and her therapist
begin today’s session by reviewing a STIC task that Chloe completed at
home during the week. Because Chloe has difficulty reading and writing,
her mother jotted down a few notes in Chloe’s workbook about Chloe
staying in her bedroom by herself for the night. The therapist spoke to
Chloe’s mom on the phone before the therapy session to find out how the
exposure task went because Chloe sometimes has trouble accurately re-
calling and reporting her experiences. In session, Chloe shows the therapist
a picture she drew of herself completing the exposure task. The therapist
asks Chloe a few questions, such as “What were you feeling when you were
first in your room all by yourself?” “What did you think might happen?”
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 253
and “What did you tell yourself to help?” Sometimes the therapist has to
prompt Chloe. For example, in response to the first question, Chloe states
that she is not sure how she felt. The therapist provides her a few foils,
such as “Were you feeling happy?” or “How about angry?” before Chloe en-
dorses feeling “scared.” Chloe states that she used her coping card that she
made with the therapist in the previous session to remind her to tell her-
self, “I can do this!” She notes that when she got really nervous, she colored
a picture. Chloe and the therapist set up these activities with her mother
before completing the exposure task. The therapist reinforces such effort
by enthusiastically telling Chloe that she is proud of her for showing that
she can be brave. Chloe receives two stickers of her choice, which she puts
in her workbook. On the sticker chart is a picture of the prize that Chloe
is working toward (a small stuffed animal).
The therapist waits and then tells Chloe that this is a really difficult
challenge—and maybe they should try other challenges first to get more
practice. The therapist has Chloe repeat an exposure in which she goes up
on the elevator one floor by herself with a walkie-talkie so she can talk to
the therapist. Chloe receives a sticker for completing this exposure. Now
that Chloe’s inertia has been overcome, the therapist suggests that Chloe
go up one floor without the walkie-talkie. Chloe appears reticent, but she
takes a peek at her sticker chart and notices she is one sticker away from
that adorable teddy bear she has so longed for. The therapist praises Chloe
again and acknowledges that she can earn her teddy bear today if she com-
pletes one more challenge (i.e., exposure task). Chloe musters the energy
to complete the challenge, and with a big smile, high-fives the therapist
when she gets back from her courageous, walkie-talkie-free journey. Al-
though they have run out of time for the session, Chloe agrees to complete
the tenth-floor challenge next week and to complete other exposure tasks
at home during the week.
Parental Psychopathology
Although the Coping Cat Program is largely a child-focused, individual
treatment, parents play an important role in the intervention. As such, pa-
rental psychopathology is a potential obstacle to favorable outcomes.
There are two specific parent sessions built into the program, but parents
are involved even more as they help youth implement exposure tasks out-
side of the therapy setting. Parental anxiety is common when working with
anxious youth, and although parental anxiety management is not a neces-
sary part of treatment, the therapist can help parents manage their own
anxiety using the same cognitive-behavioral strategies taught to the chil-
dren. For example, parents may express anxiety about allowing their child
to be in an anxiety-provoking situation. In these instances, the therapist
can explore what is the worst that can happen, how likely is that scenario,
what can the parents tell themselves to help, and what can they do to help.
Note that parental anxiety management is not the focus of treatment and
it is not a substitute for parents’ own treatment when necessary.
Conclusion
CBT for child anxiety has been found to be effective in several randomized
controlled trials. The Coping Cat Program is a manual-based CBT for anxious
youth that comprises two phases of treatment: psychoeducation and expo-
sure. Within the psychoeducation phase, the child learns to identify when he
or she is feeling anxious and to use anxiety management strategies. The strat-
egies include identifying bodily arousal, engaging in relaxation, recognizing
256 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
anxious thoughts (self-talk) and using coping thoughts, and problem solving.
In the second phase of treatment, the child practices the skills learned in the
first phase through exposure tasks. The exposure tasks are guided by a collab-
oratively determined hierarchy so that the child practices skills in increasingly
anxiety-provoking situations. Potential obstacles to implementing CBT for
child anxiety may include comorbid psychopathology, varying cognitive abili-
ties, noncompliance, and parental psychopathology. However, in order to ad-
dress these potential barriers and individualize treatment, the Coping Cat
Program should be implemented flexibly while maintaining fidelity.
Self-Assessment Questions
7.1. Which of the following clients is an appropriate candidate for CBT
for child anxiety?
7.2. Which of the following is NOT a core component of CBT for child
anxiety?
A. Cognitive restructuring.
B. Exposure tasks.
C. Psychoeducation.
D. Behavioral activation.
Suggested Resources
Treatment Manuals
Kendall PC, Hedtke K: Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Anxious Chil-
dren: Therapist Manual, 3rd Edition. Ardmore, PA, Workbook Pub-
lishing, 2006a
Kendall PC, Hedtke K: The Coping Cat Workbook, 2nd Edition. Ard-
more, PA, Workbook Publishing, 2006b
Training DVD
Kendall PC, Khanna M: CBT4CBT: Computer-Based Training to Be a Cog-
nitive-Behavioral Therapist (for Child Anxiety). Ardmore, PA, Work-
book Publishing, 2009
Further Reading
Beidas RS, Benjamin CL, Puleo CM, et al: Flexible applications of the Coping
Cat Program for anxious youth. Cogn Behav Pract 17:142–153, 2010
Kendall PC: Treating anxiety disorders in youth, in Child and Adolescent
Therapy: Cognitive-Behavioral Procedures, 4th Edition. Edited by
Kendall PC. New York, Guilford, 2010, pp 143–189
Kendall PC, Robin JA, Hedtke KA et al: Considering CBT with anxious
youth? Think exposures. Cogn Behav Pract 12:136–150, 2005
Podell JL, Mychailyszyn M, Edmunds J, et al: The Coping Cat Program for
anxious youth: the FEAR plan comes to life. Cogn Behav Pract 17:
132–141, 2010
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 259
References
Achenbach TM, Rescorla LA: Manual for School-Age Forms and Profiles. Burlington,
University of Vermont, Research Center for Children, Youth, and Families, 2001
Albano AM, Kendall PC: Cognitive behavioral therapy for children and adolescents
with anxiety disorders: clinical research advances. Int Rev Psychiatry 14:129–
134, 2002
American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric
Association, 2000
Ameringen MV, Mancini C, Farvolden P: The impact of anxiety disorders on edu-
cational achievement. J Anxiety Disord 17:561–571, 2003
Aschenbrand SG, Angelosante AG, Kendall PC: Discriminant validity and clinical
utility of the CBCL with anxiety disordered youth. J Clin Child Adolesc Psy-
chol 34:735–746, 2005
Barrett P, Dadds M, Rapee R: Family treatment of child anxiety: a controlled trial.
J Consult Clin Psychol 64:333–342, 1996
Beidel DC, Fink CM, Turner SM: Stability in anxious symptomatology in children.
J Abnorm Child Psychol 24:257–269, 1991
Beidel DC, Turner SM, Morris TL: Behavioral treatment of childhood social pho-
bia. J Consult Clin Psychol 68:1072–1080, 2000
Canino G: Are somatic symptoms and related distress more prevalent in Hispanic/
Latino youth? Some methodological considerations. J Clin Child Adolesc Psy-
chol 33:272–275, 2004
Chambless DL, Hollon SD: Defining empirically supported treatments. J Consult
Clin Psychol 66:5–17, 1998
Chavira D, Stein M, Bailey K, et al: Child anxiety in primary care: prevalent but
untreated. Depress Anxiety 20:155–164, 2004
Costello E, Mustillo S, Keeler G, et al: Prevalence of psychiatric disorders in chil-
dren and adolescents, in Mental Health Services: A Public Health Perspective.
Edited by Levine B, Petrila J, Hennessey K. New York, Oxford University
Press, 2004, pp 111–128
Gee CB: Assessment of anxiety and depression in Asian American youth. J Clin
Child Adolesc Psychol 33:269–271, 2004
Gosch EA, Flannery-Schroeder E, Mauro CF, et al: Principles of cognitive-behav-
ioral therapy for anxiety disorders in children. Journal of Cognitive Psycho-
therapy: An International Quarterly 20:247–262, 2006
Greco L, Morris T: Factors influencing the link between social anxiety and peer ac-
ceptance: contributions of social skills and close friendships during middle
childhood. Behav Ther 36:197–205, 2005
Harmon H, Langle A, Ginsburg G: The role of gender and culture in treating youth
with anxiety disorders. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy: An International
Quarterly 20:301–310, 2006
Hirshfeld-Becker DR, Masek B, Henin A, et al: Cognitive-behavioral intervention
with young anxious children. Harv Rev Psychiatry 16:113–125, 2008
Howard B, Chu B, Krain A, et al: Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapy for Anxious
Children: Therapist Manual. Ardmore, PA, Workbook Publishing, 2000
260 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Hwang WC, Wood JJ, Lin KH: Cognitive-behavioral therapy with Chinese Ameri-
cans: research, theory, and clinical practice. Cogn Behav Pract 13:293–303, 2006
Kazdin AE, Weisz J: Identifying and developing empirically supported child and ad-
olescent treatments. J Consult Clin Psychol 66:8–35, 1998
Kendall PC: Treating anxiety disorders in children: results of a randomized clinical
trial. J Consult Clin Psychol 62:100–110, 1994
Kendall PC: Guiding theory for therapy with children and adolescents, in Child
and Adolescent Therapy: Cognitive-Behavioral Procedures, 4th Edition. Ed-
ited by Kendall PC. New York, Guilford, 2010, pp 3–24
Kendall PC, Braswell L: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Impulsive Children, 2nd
Edition. New York, Guilford, 1993
Kendall PC, Hedtke K: Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Anxious Children: Ther-
apist Manual, 3rd Edition. Ardmore, PA, Workbook Publishing, 2006a
Kendall PC, Hedtke K: The Coping Cat Workbook, 2nd Edition. Ardmore, PA,
Workbook Publishing, 2006b
Kendall PC, Khanna M: Camp Cope-A-Lot: The Coping Cat DVD. Ardmore, PA,
Workbook Publishing, 2008
Kendall PC, Southam-Gerow M: Long-term follow-up of treatment for anxiety
disordered youth. J Consult Clin Psychol 64:724–730, 1996
Kendall PC, Flannery-Schroeder E, Panichelli-Mindell SM, et al: Therapy for
youths with anxiety disorders: a second randomized clinical trial. J Consult
Clin Psychol 65:366–380, 1997
Kendall PC, Brady EU, Verduin TL: Comorbidity in childhood anxiety disorders and
treatment outcome. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 40:787–794, 2001
Kendall PC, Choudhury MS, Hudson JL, et al: The C.A.T. Project Manual: Manual
for the Individual Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of Adolescents With Anxi-
ety Disorders. Ardmore, PA, Workbook Publishing, 2002a
Kendall PC, Choudhury MS, Hudson JL, et al: “The C.A.T. Project” Workbook for
the Cognitive Behavioral Treatment of Anxious Adolescents. Ardmore, PA,
Workbook Publishing, 2002b
Kendall PC, Safford S, Flannery-Schroeder E, et al: Child anxiety treatment: out-
comes in adolescence and impact on substance use and depression at 7.4-year
follow-up. J Consult Clin Psychol 72:276–287, 2004
Kendall PC, Gosch E, Furr JM, et al: Flexibility within fidelity. J Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 47:987–993, 2008a
Kendall PC, Hudson JL, Gosch E, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety
disordered youth: a randomized clinical trial evaluating child and family mo-
dalities. J Consult Clin Psychol 76:282–297, 2008b
Khanna M, Kendall PC: Computer-assisted cognitive-behavioral therapy for child
anxiety: results of a randomized clinical trial. J Consult Clin Psychol 78:737–
745, 2010
Lambert SF, Cooley MR, Campbell KD, et al: Assessing anxiety sensitivity in inner-
city African American children: psychometric properties of the Childhood Anx-
iety Sensitivity Index. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 33:248–259, 2004
Manassis K, Mendlowitz S, Scapillato D, et al: Group and individual cognitive-
behavior therapy for childhood anxiety disorders: a randomized trial. J Am
Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 41:1423–1430, 2002
Childhood Anxiety Disorders 261
March JS, Parker J, Sullivan K, et al: The Multidimensional Anxiety Scale for Chil-
dren (MASC): factor structure, reliability, and validity. J Am Acad Child Ad-
olesc Psychiatry 36:554–565, 1997
Nauta M, Scholing A, Emmelkamp P, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy for children
with anxiety disorders in a clinical setting: no additional effect of cognitive par-
ent training. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 42:1270–1278, 2003
Ollendick TH, King NJ: Empirically supported treatments for children with phobic
and anxiety disorders: current status. J Clin Child Psychol 27:156–167, 1998
Pina AA, Silverman WK: Clinical phenomenology, somatic symptoms, and distress
in Hispanic/Latino and European American youths with anxiety disorders.
J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 33:227–236, 2004
Pina AA, Silverman WK, Weems CF, et al: A comparison of completers and non-
completers of exposure-based cognitive and behavior treatment for phobic
and anxiety disorders in youth. J Consult Clin Psychol 71:701–705, 2003
Rapee RM, Barrett PM, Dadds MR, et al: Reliability of the DSM-III-R childhood
anxiety disorders using structured interview: interrater and parent-child agree-
ment. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 33:984–992, 1994
Seligman LD, Ollendick TH, Langley AK, et al: The utility of measures of child
and adolescent anxiety: a meta-analytic review of the Revised Children’s Anx-
iety Scale, the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children, and the Child Be-
havior Checklist. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 33:557–565, 2004
Silverman WK, Albano AM: Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-IV:
Child and Parent Versions. Boulder, CO, Graywind Publications, 1996
Silverman W, Kurtines W, Ginsburg G, et al: Treating anxiety disorders in children
with group cognitive-behavioral therapy: a randomized clinical trial. J Consult
Clin Psychol 67:995–1003, 1999
Silverman WK, Saavedra LM, Pina AA: Test-retest reliability of anxiety symptoms
and diagnoses with the Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-IV:
child and parent versions. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 40:937–944,
2001
Silverman WK, Pina AA, Viswesvaran C: Evidence-based psychosocial treatments
for phobic and anxiety disorders in children and adolescents. J Clin Child Ad-
olesc Psychol 37:105–130, 2008
Sood ED, Kendall PC: Ethnicity in relation to treatment utilization, referral
source, diagnostic status and outcomes at a child anxiety clinic. Presented at
the annual meeting of the Association for Behavioral and Cognitive Therapies,
Chicago, IL, 2006
Treadwell KR, Flannery-Schroeder EC, Kendall PC: Ethnicity and gender in rela-
tion to adaptive functioning, diagnostic status, and treatment outcome in chil-
dren from an anxiety clinic. J Anxiety Disord 9:373–384, 1995
Verduin TL, Kendall PC: Differential occurrence of comorbidity within childhood
anxiety disorders. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 2:290–295, 2003
Walkup J, Albano AM, Piacentini J, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy, sertraline,
or a combination in childhood anxiety. N Engl J Med 359:2753–2766, 2008
Wood JJ, Piacentini JC, Bergman RL, et al: Concurrent validity of the anxiety dis-
orders section of the Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-IV:
child and parent versions. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 31:335–342, 2002
Wood JJ, Piacentini JC, Southam-Gerow M: Family cognitive behavioral therapy for
child anxiety disorders. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 45:314–321, 2006
This page intentionally left blank
8
Pediatric Posttraumatic
Stress Disorder
Judith A. Cohen, M.D.
Audra Langley, Ph.D.
263
264 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
This chapter will focus on two types of CBT trauma treatment models:
1) individual CBT, represented by trauma-focused cognitive-behavior ther-
apy (TF-CBT); and 2) group (primarily school-based) CBT, represented by
the Cognitive-Behavioral Intervention for Trauma in Schools (CBITS; Stein
et al. 2003). TF-CBT (Cohen et al. 2006) has been evaluated in eight ran-
domized controlled treatment trials (RCTs) for sexual abuse, domestic vio-
lence, and multiple traumas among children ages 3–17 years (reviewed in
Cohen et al. 2009). CBITS has been tested in two RCTs for children exposed
to community violence (Kataoka et al. 2003; Stein et al. 2003). Other CBT
models have been tested for single-episode traumas (Smith et al. 2007) and
for war-exposed children and adolescents. Described later in this chapter,
these models include largely overlapping components, which emphasizes the
broad applicability of CBT interventions for traumatized children across dif-
ferent types of traumas and a broad developmental spectrum.
Cognitive-Behavioral Theory
for PTSD
PTSD was only officially recognized in the Diagnostic and Statistical Man-
ual of Mental Disorders in 1980 (American Psychiatric Association 1980).
Several complementary theories explain its complex symptoms. Accord-
ing to learning theory, PTSD results from overgeneralization and failure of
extinction of fear and other negative emotions. Traumatic experiences are
by definition accompanied by negative emotions such as horror, fear, help-
lessness, and anger (American Psychiatric Association 2000, p. 463); these
emotions are often associated with physiological arousal in such forms as
rapid heartbeat, elevated blood pressure, flushing, and sweating. Studies
indicate that interpersonal violence such as child sexual or physical abuse,
neglect, and domestic and community violence have a clearly negative im-
pact on children; that early and/or multiple traumatic exposures lead to
increasingly negative outcomes for children; and that if left untreated, im-
pairment cuts across multiple domains of functioning as described in the
case examples below (e.g., Felitti et al. 1998).
Case Examples
Mariel, age 8 years, is referred for a mental health evaluation because of
several recent episodes of getting into fights with boys at school. Her
mother brings Mariel to you for an initial evaluation. According to the
mother’s report, Mariel’s main problems are the fighting at school and fall-
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 265
ing grades. Her mother also reports that recently Mariel has started going
to the school nurse’s office with headaches. During the evaluation, you ask
Mariel whether anything bad or scary has happened to her. She says, “Peo-
ple fighting.” You ask, “Do you mean the fights that have happened at
school?” to which Mariel replies, “No, fighting at home.” You administer a
brief interview to assess trauma exposure and symptoms of PTSD. Mariel
endorses witnessing domestic violence between her parents and the fol-
lowing symptoms: Mariel loves her father but has scary thoughts about him
hurting her mother. She tries to push these thoughts out of her head, but
some boys at school remind her of this fear. They make her very mad some-
times. She can’t concentrate at school or sleep at night because she is al-
ways worried about what her father will do, and she is more jumpy and
irritable than she used to be. She doesn’t want to spend time with her
friends like she used to.
friend; although his friend was simply another witness to the traumatic
event, he became a cue to the traumatic experience.
Memories and thoughts about the trauma can also become conditioned
trauma reminders and trigger highly negative physical and psychological
responses in traumatized children. Operant conditioning may teach chil-
dren to avoid such cues in order to reduce the likelihood of experiencing
these negative emotions. As avoidance is reinforced (i.e., if it successfully
keeps the child from feeling bad, even intermittently), the child will learn
to avoid talking about or being around trauma reminders. For example,
Mariel loved her father but was scared of him and tried to avoid him when
he was “mad.” She also avoided talking or thinking about her family situa-
tion, which contributed to her avoidance of friends or social situations. As
avoidance becomes more generalized, it is rarely successful, because most
traumatized children have experienced multiple episodes of interpersonal
violence and reminders of these experiences are so internally and exter-
nally ubiquitous that it is difficult to totally avoid them.
Children with high levels of avoidance or emotional numbing may have
trouble using optimal coping strategies such as implementing a safety plan
or seeking help from supportive adults when violence occurs. In Joaquin’s
case, he hadn’t even shared his traumatic experience with his mother and
siblings, both because he didn’t want to think about it and because he
didn’t want to burden his hardworking mother. Avoiding thinking and talk-
ing about the experience also meant avoiding his guilt and fear that not be-
ing able to stop the shooting meant that he was incompetent to protect his
siblings and mother, something his father had implored of him as the old-
est son when he was deported to their country of origin last year.
Children, like adults, are prone to developing maladaptive cognitions
about the cause and/or impact of having experienced trauma, such as being
inherently defective or damaged (i.e., shame), being responsible for the
trauma (i.e., self-blame), or being undeserving of love or care from others
(i.e., low self-esteem). In addition, there can be cognitive developmental
issues, particularly in younger children, such as magical thinking or causal
misattributions. These cognitions may have been modeled for children
(e.g., the perpetrator, a neglectful parent, or bullying peers may have told
the child he or she was worthless or deserved to be maltreated), or chil-
dren may come to these cognitions through faulty deductive reasoning
(e.g., “Other children aren’t treated badly; therefore, I must be treated
badly because of something bad about myself ”). Children who have expe-
rienced long-standing, severe, and/or interpersonal traumas such as child
maltreatment, neglect, or domestic violence often lack skills such as affect
expression, self-soothing, and affective and behavioral regulation. There-
fore, these skills can be important components of a trauma treatment plan.
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 267
Assessment
A major challenge to effectively treating traumatized children is that child
PTSD symptoms can be very difficult to accurately identify. How CBT is
applied depends on this accurate assessment. Several self-report instru-
ments, such as the UCLA PTSD Reaction Index for DSM-IV, assess PTSD
symptoms. However, children often underreport PTSD symptoms due to
trauma avoidance (not wanting to think or talk about the trauma or symp-
toms associated with it) or due to general child unreliability in reporting
externalized symptoms such as anger or behavioral problems. Including
parents in assessment is helpful in gaining additional information about
children’s behaviors. However, parents may be unaware of the child’s in-
ternal trauma symptoms (e.g., having frightening recurrent thoughts about
the trauma; being hypervigilant about the trauma recurring; avoiding
trauma reminders or thoughts about the trauma; having maladaptive cog-
nitions related to the trauma, such as self-blame, shame, or fear of trusting
others), or parents may minimize these problems. For example, Mariel’s
mother did not think Mariel was aware of the domestic violence occurring
268 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
in the home and was shocked to learn that her daughter had serious PTSD
symptoms related to these occurrences. Parents are typically more focused
on children’s externalized trauma symptoms (e.g., irritability, sleep prob-
lems, anger, aggression). Mariel’s mother had made no connection be-
tween Mariel’s fighting in school and the father’s behavior at home.
To optimally assess children for PTSD symptoms, consider the ABCs
of trauma impact:
• A—Affect: The classic feelings associated with PTSD are anxiety and
fear, but clinicians should also ask about sadness, anger, or flat affect,
as well as affective dysregulation (e.g., “going from 0 to 60,” not being
able to soothe oneself after becoming upset) and dissociation.
Mariel both loved and feared her father. It was not safe for her to show anger
at home, but she was angry and experienced affective dysregulation at school.
She also did not feel her usual happiness around her friends (flat affect).
Joaquin exhibited sadness and anxiety in his classes and at home and had
lost interest in what he used to find enjoyable, but he also would very
quickly “fly off the handle” for what appeared to others as minor things,
such as someone bumping into him or a teacher raising his or her voice to
get the class’s attention.
Joaquin avoided his best friend, who was with him during the shooting, as
well as the park where the shooting occurred. His anxiety generalized to
other outdoor settings, and he refused to let his younger siblings play out-
side when they were under his care in the afternoons and on weekends
when his mother was working.
Mariel was aggressive toward boys in part because they reminded her of her
father’s aggression toward her mother. She was afraid of them but also angry
because they reminded her of times when her father had hurt her mother.
Joaquin was able to avoid going to school and walking near the park (on the
route between school and home) by complaining of stomachaches. Like-
wise, when he felt anxious or overwhelmed at school, he frequently asked
for a pass to go to the bathroom or to the nurse’s office with the same com-
plaint.
Mariel thought that her father’s “bad moods” and his subsequent abuse of
her mother were in part her fault because they were sometimes preceded
by her father yelling at her.
Joaquin blamed himself for what happened because he came home later
than usual that day, and he felt guilt and shame for not being able to stop
the shooting and for potentially endangering his family by being a witness
to gang-related violence.
Mariel felt alienated from her friends and became socially isolated.
Likewise, Joaquin’s feelings of sadness and guilt and his isolation from his
best friend left him feeling very different from his peers and made him
withdraw from all social activity.
Application
Reviews of individual (Cohen et al. 2009) and school-based (Jaycox et al.
2009) child CBT trauma treatments document that these treatments
share many common treatment components (described later in this sec-
tion). In addition to these core components, two general treatment con-
cepts are critical when implementing CBT for traumatized children: 1)
engaging families in treatment and 2) use of gradual exposure throughout
the treatment process.
Treatment Concepts
Treatment Engagement
Treatment engagement is essential for effectively treating any family but is
especially critical in addressing the needs of traumatized individuals, be-
cause trauma typically has a negative impact on trust. Children and parents
may feel betrayed by a trusted person, community, educational system,
criminal justice system, their faith, and/or society at large that allowed such
an unfair thing to happen. When the trauma was perpetrated by a parent
or other caregiver or over a long period of time, attachment is often nega-
tively impacted. Because successfully engaging families in psychotherapy
requires that they trust the clinician, this may be more challenging with
traumatized children and their parents. The following strategies are effec-
tive for engaging even multiply traumatized children and their parents:
• Ask what the family wants and expects from mental health treatment.
• Ask about potential barriers to participation in mental health treat-
ment, including differences between the family and yourself based on
ethnicity, race, religion, socioeconomic status, or other factors that may
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 271
Gradual Exposure
Gradual exposure refers to the process through which you gradually, pur-
posefully, and incrementally increase the intensity, duration, and/or degree
to which you introduce trauma-related material during each subsequent
treatment session. As you implement subsequent CBT components, con-
nect them to children’s trauma experiences by asking how children will
implement these components when they are reminded of the traumatic
events they experienced.
It is important not to do anything that inadvertently models avoidance
to children or parents. For example, you may avoid the topic of the trauma
or do so indirectly by communicating that trauma is embarrassing or diffi-
cult for you to talk about. This may be the case when you start using
trauma CBT models. Children who have experienced trauma are apt to
blame themselves or feel ashamed about what happened. Either out of em-
barrassment or in an attempt to convey empathy, you may lower your
voice, look away, use euphemisms, or say “I’m sorry” when talking directly
about children’s trauma experiences. Children or parents may interpret
these behaviors to mean that you think what happened was shameful. It is
important to make a conscious effort not to do these things.
Refer to traumatic events by their accurate descriptions (e.g., “sexual
abuse,” “domestic violence,” “your father’s death,” “the car accident”). Do
not use euphemisms such as “the scary thing,” “the upsetting situation,”
“the events of September 11th,” or “passing away.” Do not use the term
“down there” to refer to private parts (e.g., “vagina,” “penis,” “anus,”
“breasts”). These behaviors may seem inconsequential, but they commu-
nicate to the child that you are not ready to hear or talk about the child’s
trauma.
Be conscious not to avoid talking about children’s trauma experiences
(the opposite of gradual exposure). Gradual exposure is a critical part of
trauma CBT models. Do not wait for children to give you a cue or other-
wise show you that they are ready to talk about their traumatic experi-
ences. Because avoidance is a core feature of PTSD, few children will
272 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Core Components
Parenting Component
When feasible, include parents in CBT treatment of child PTSD in order to
provide effective parenting skills, as well as to parallel other CBT compo-
nents. This may be accomplished in parallel parent groups, in parallel indi-
vidual child and parent sessions, in family sessions, or in a combination of
these formats. Help parents understand the connection between the child’s
behavior problems and past traumatic exposure, so that trauma-focused
treatment makes sense. Behavioral parenting skills might include encourag-
ing parents to use active praise; selective attention (i.e., to actively attend to
and praise desired behaviors while attending less to undesired behaviors);
and appropriate contingency reinforcement and other reward and punish-
ment procedures that are tailored to the specific child behaviors.
If parents can’t attend sessions regularly, provide them with written in-
formation about what the child is learning in treatment so that the parents
can reinforce the skills their child is learning. In school-based trauma treat-
ments, teachers may receive some instruction regarding how to support
the implementation of CBT skills in the educational setting. This will en-
hance children’s optimal use of such skills in school and help teachers un-
derstand manifestations of trauma symptoms in the classroom.
Psychoeducation
Many children and parents have inaccurate information about trauma because
of societal stigma, family or cultural beliefs, or other reasons. They may also
feel alone because they do not understand that trauma is a common experi-
ence that they share with many other children and families. Moreover, chil-
dren and parents often do not make a connection between what the child has
been through and the current difficulties they are having. Psychoeducation
can reverse the negative impact of inaccurate information and normalize trau-
matic experiences. Educate children, parents, and/or teachers about the im-
pact of trauma. Help them to understand the child’s current symptoms from
a trauma perspective; normalize these problems as common reactions to trau-
matic events while providing hope for recovery. Also share information about
how many children experience the type(s) of trauma the child has experi-
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 273
enced. Information sheets about child trauma are available on the Web site of
the National Child Traumatic Stress Network (www.nctsn.org).
Relaxation Skills
Help children and parents understand and recognize the physiological im-
pact of trauma (e.g., rushing pulse, pounding head, stomachache, in-
creased muscle tension, “seeing red”), and ideally, help them to identify
the early warning signs of these symptoms (i.e., recognize them when they
first start to occur). Ask children what the earliest manifestations or ante-
cedents of physical trauma-related symptoms are, and ask them to keep a
record of when these early signs occur during the week. Their responses
will assist you in developing tailored relaxation strategies for preempting,
preventing, and/or “turning down the volume” (i.e., decreasing the inten-
sity) of these symptoms when they occur in specific settings. Individualize
different relaxation skills if the setting allows (e.g., individual therapy).
Group settings may offer fewer opportunities for tailoring interventions to
individual needs. Younger children may need ongoing assistance from par-
ents or other adults to implement relaxation strategies. Teach parents
these strategies so that they can encourage their children to use them.
Cognitive Coping
Cognitive coping is a specialized skill for helping children to regulate upset-
ting emotions and negative behaviors. Help children recognize maladaptive
(inaccurate and/or unhelpful) thoughts that are related to their negative
emotions and how these in turn are connected to their behaviors. For ex-
ample, if a child gets a bad grade on a test, he might think, “I’m stupid,”
274 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
leading him to feel very upset and to not pay attention or to misbehave in
school because he has given up any hope of success there. Examine with the
child whether another thought besides “I’m stupid” could explain getting a
bad grade (e.g., “I didn’t study enough”; “I didn’t study the right things to
do well on this test”; “I didn’t understand the material on that test”; “The
teacher picked really hard questions”; “I can do better if I ask for help”).
Ask the child how he would feel if he focused on one of these thoughts in-
stead of the thought “I’m stupid” and how this feeling (e.g., better, hopeful,
OK) might lead to different behavior (e.g., studying harder, asking the
teacher or a parent for help with studying, paying more attention in class,
not giving up). Practice this for a variety of ordinary (non-trauma-related)
situations and help the child generate alternative thoughts in order to feel
better. Parents typically need to practice cognitive coping also. Provide cog-
nitive coping skills to parents and help them to start processing their diffi-
cult feelings about the child’s trauma experiences. Typically, you will not
start processing details of the traumatic experiences with the child until af-
ter he or she has developed a personal trauma narrative, described in the
next section, “Trauma Narration and Processing.”
lence or with ongoing community violence), you will probably need to ad-
dress safety issues early in treatment instead of later.
Case Management
It may be important to collaborate with systems of care such as child wel-
fare, juvenile justice, pediatric, educational, and other providers who are
working with traumatized children.
Developmental Adaptations
Child CBT trauma models (and TF-CBT in particular) have been used and
tested for children ages 3–17 years with relatively minor adaptations on
the basis of children’s developmental level. Adaptations for preschoolers
and adolescents are briefly described.
Cultural Adaptations
At least three child CBT trauma models have been culturally adapted and
pilot-tested:
• CBITS for Latino immigrant children (De Arellano et al. 2005) and
American Indian children (Morsette et al. 2009)
• TF-CBT for Latino immigrant (Kataoka et al. 2003), American Indian
(Bigfoot and Schmidt, in press), and Zambian HIV-affected sexually
abused children (Murray 2007)
• KidNET for international war refugee immigrants to Germany (Ruf et
al. 2010)
Obstacles to Treatment
You may encounter many obstacles when first starting to implement child
CBT trauma treatment. These might include child-related challenges, such
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 279
as children who are highly trauma avoidant; parents who have their own se-
vere trauma history (and thus raise concerns about whether they can handle
hearing the material this type of treatment might raise); children who have
serious affective or behavioral dysregulation (whether or not related to
trauma); and “crises of the week” (i.e., children and/or parents who come in
each week with a new crisis, usually but not always caused by the child’s
negative behaviors, that threatens your ability to follow the treatment
plan). To help therapists who face these common problems, a new online
resource has been developed through funding by the Annie E. Casey Foun-
dation, TF-CBTConsult (www.musc.edu/tfcbtconsult).
Case Examples
“having a parent like you who believes and supports her child through ther-
apy. Mariel already has that, so she is already on her way toward getting
over this. She is so lucky to have you here.” Anita is visibly relieved to hear
you say this. You then describe to Anita Mariel’s concerns about safety and
her belief that she must keep the family safe. Anita becomes tearful, but
says, “I understand why she feels that way; my husband has been angry a
lot, and it must not feel safe to her sometimes.” You ask, “Help me under-
stand what it is like at your house.” Anita gradually confirms more about
what Mariel has told you, and additional information about the father’s
controlling behavior. You provide Anita with written information about do-
mestic violence that describes these behaviors as being part of a pattern of
domestic violence. You also provide her with information about other re-
sources for domestic violence, including a local domestic violence treat-
ment center, and suggest that it might be helpful for her to look online and
consider going to this center to seek counseling or other services. Anita de-
nies that her husband would ever seriously hurt her. You tell her that you
and Mariel are both very concerned about her safety, and you do not want
anything to happen to her, not only because you care about her, but be-
cause Mariel loves her and needs her. You suggest that if Mariel could have
a safety plan, this might help her to feel safer right now. Anita agrees to this
idea but does not know what to include in the plan. You ask whether any
of Anita’s friends or relatives know about how her husband treats her and
Mariel and whom Mariel could call on the phone when she is afraid. Anita
tearfully admits that she has been too ashamed to tell them. You encourage
Anita to consider telling her sister, Carolina, who is the closest to Anita in
her family. Anita also agrees to talk to Mariel about calling her aunt Caro-
lina if she is afraid.
During the next session, Mariel tells you that her mother talked to her
about safety and said that she could call her aunt Carolina if she was scared
about her parents’ fighting. Mariel says that she feels safer since her mother
told her this. You teach Mariel progressive relaxation and focused breath-
ing, and in collaboration with Mariel, her mother, and the school develop
the following plan in order to address Mariel’s headaches in school:
1. When getting ready for school, Mariel will use visualization. She
loves butterflies, so these will be her focus during visualization.
She will keep this vision in her head when she is walking to school
and will use deep breathing and progressive muscle relaxation on
the way to school. If she is not relaxed, she will tell her mother,
who will practice these relaxation strategies with her before she
leaves for school.
2. Once in school, she will go to her first classroom. In her backpack,
she will have a picture of butterflies. She will arrive 5 minutes
early so that she has time to look at the butterfly picture before
class begins. She will sing her favorite song in her head (a lullaby
her mother used to sing to her), which makes her feel safe.
3. If she starts getting a headache, she will have a special signal (put-
ting her hair in a ponytail) that her teacher recognizes as her help
signal. Her teacher will come to her desk if she puts her hair in a
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 281
ponytail and will ask her to do her deep breathing and butterfly
visualization exercise. Mariel has a second visualization exercise
to use as well. She can do this at her desk quietly without attract-
ing the attention of other children in the class. If this doesn’t
work, she will be allowed to go to the nurse’s office to get some
aspirin, after which she will return to class.
You meet alone with Anita, who tells you that she told her sister Caro-
lina about the domestic violence. Carolina was very upset when she heard
this but was supportive of Anita and quickly agreed to Mariel calling her
anytime, day or night, if she was worried or scared. Anita explained that
she and Mariel were getting help for the problem, and Carolina was re-
lieved and told Anita that she was proud of her for telling someone about
it and getting help. Anita says, “I was surprised that Carolina said this;
I thought she would put me down for staying with him, but she actually
said she was proud of me for coming to therapy. I feel so much better now
that someone knows about this. I wasn’t sure it was the right thing to do,
but I’m really relieved that I told her.” Anita agrees to practice the above
relaxation strategies with Mariel.
During the following session, you begin working on affective expres-
sion and modulation skills. Mariel reports that she called her aunt Carolina
twice this week. Once she called when she was upset, and this helped her
feel safer. She says, “Once I just called her to talk—I just liked knowing
I could talk to her.” She has also been using the relaxation strategies in
school and has had fewer headaches. You and Mariel play Emotional Bingo,
and she is able to name times when she has felt happy (when her mother
is happy), sad (when her parents fight), anxious (when her father comes
home in a bad mood), angry (when the boys at school are loud), confused
(when she doesn’t understand what her teacher says in school), and ex-
cited (when she gets a present). When she can’t think of a time she has felt
hopeful, you ask, “When would another child feel hopeful?” Mariel says,
“When her family gets along and is happy.” You then ask what kids can do
to feel better when they have upsetting feelings like being sad or angry. Ma-
riel is not sure at first, but you say, “Some kids go to their rooms and read
a book, other kids talk to their moms or a friend, other kids like to get ac-
tive, and other kids have a hobby or something else they like to do. Is there
anything you can do to help yourself feel better when you’re upset?” Mariel
says, “I try not to think about things that upset me.” You ask, “Does that
help you feel better?” Mariel says, “Sometimes.” You say, “I bet sometimes
it’s really hard not to think about your parents fighting. Let’s see if we can
figure out some other ways to help you feel better.” Mariel thinks for a
minute and says, “I call Aunt Carolina.” You say, “Has that been helping
you to feel better?” Mariel says, “Yes, that helps me feel less scared.” You
say, “So that’s another way to feel better—reaching out to adults who can
help you feel safe is called asking for support. Are there other grown-ups
you can ask to help you feel better? How about at home—are there other
adults you can ask for help?” Mariel says, “Mommy, if Daddy isn’t fighting
with her.” You say, “So Mommy is someone you can ask for help when
you’re feeling sad or scared. Anyone at school you can ask for help?” Mariel
282 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
week. She says, “Yes, for the first time in a while I felt like playing with
some of my friends during lunch, but none of them asked me to play with
them. I felt really sad.” You say, “That’s a perfect example. When you felt
sad, what were you thinking? What was your brain saying to you?” Mariel
says, “I don’t know, I guess it was saying that I feel sad.” You say, “Sad is
what you were feeling. Usually we can say our feelings in one word, like
sad, mad, or happy, like we talked about last week. So I’m really glad that
you are so good at recognizing your feelings. Thoughts are connected to
feelings, but they are a little different. When we have a feeling, we often
have a more complicated thought that is connected to it, like something we
are telling ourselves in our head that is more than a one-word feeling, like
a sentence. So when you felt sad, what sentence were you telling yourself
in your head about your friends?” Mariel says, “Um... maybe they didn’t
like me anymore.” You say, “Great job, Mariel, that’s exactly what I mean
by a thought. So when you thought, maybe my friends don’t like me any-
more, this was the thought that made you feel sad. Of course it did;
I would feel sad, too, if I thought my friends didn’t like me anymore. When
you felt sad, what did you do?” Mariel says, “I went back inside and sat in
the bathroom by myself.” You say, “So, this is how we would write this
down to show the connection between what you thought, what you felt,
and how you acted” (Figure 8–1).
You say, “What if you had a different thought instead of that they didn’t
like you? Can you think of any other thought a child could possibly have in this
situation?” Mariel thinks for a minute and shakes her head no. You say, “What
about this thought: Maybe they thought that you didn’t want to play with
them anymore because it’s been so long since you’ve wanted to spend time
with them. You didn’t ask them to play either, did you? So maybe your friends
thought you still wanted to stay by yourself? If you thought that, how would
you feel?” Mariel says, “I never thought of that. I guess I wouldn’t feel so bad.”
You say, “And if you didn’t feel so bad, what might you have done?” Mariel
says, “I might have asked them if I could play with them.” You say, “That’s
right. So this is how we would write this down” (Figure 8–2).
You encourage Mariel to use cognitive coping during the coming week
when she is upset and to replace maladaptive thoughts with more accurate
and/or more helpful ones. You meet again with Anita to introduce her to
cognitive coping and to encourage Mariel to use this in the coming week.
During the next three sessions, Mariel writes the following trauma narra-
tive. As she is writing it, you share it with Anita during her individual sessions.
Chapter 2: My Family
I have a very big family that includes lots of aunts, uncles, cousins,
and three grandparents, but my family in my house is just three peo-
284 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ple: Mommy, Daddy, and me. When I was little, things were better.
Daddy played with me and said he loved me. That was when we had
a happy family.
Chapter 3: Fighting
My parents started to not be happy when I was little, like about
when I was 5, in preschool. My parents were not happy like before.
My father had trouble with working, and his anger was bad. He and
Mommy were fighting, and it was bad a lot at home. One time I re-
member was when Daddy came home, and he was really mad. He
yelled at me to get in my room right now. He yelled, “What is wrong
with you?” I ran to my room crying. I thought, “Daddy is mad at me.
He does not love me anymore. I am not a good child.” My stomach
hurt. I had to go to the bathroom, but I was afraid it would make him
madder, so I did not go and it made my stomach hurt more and
more. What will happen if he doesn’t love me and Mommy any-
more? I felt sad and scared about what he would do to Mommy.
I heard the door slamming and Mommy crying. I tried not to hear,
but I know Daddy was hitting Mommy, and I heard her head hit the
wall. I heard Daddy call her bad names; he said really bad things to
her over and over so that I held my hands over my ears so I couldn’t
hear. It was so bad, I can’t even stand to think about it. I was afraid
he would hurt her or kill her and who will love me then? I am sick
when I think about this. I wish I had hit him. I felt really mad, but
I was too sick and too scared, and I cried to sleep at night. And
Mommy cried all night and so did I, and I was praying and please let
it stop, but all night long he was hitting and yelling and kicking and
she was crying, and I just wanted to stop him and hit him, but I was
so afraid that he would kill her. The next day she had a black eye and
her face was swollen up, and she said she fell down but I knew it was
because of Daddy. I was scared to tell her what I heard, so I just
hugged her and went to school.
When you read this to Anita, she is shocked. She is sobbing and says she
had no idea that Mariel knew about this episode. She says, “I thought I had
hid it from her, but she’s known all along. This makes him look like a mon-
ster. She is growing up with these horrible things, and I’ve let it happen.”
You say, “You have both been the victims in this story, and until now you
didn’t understand what Mariel’s trauma experiences have been like. How
does hearing about her experiences change this for you as her mother?” An-
ita says, “I—I just, I can’t believe it. I can’t believe I let my own child live
through this. I have to get her out of here. I can’t let her live through this
one more minute. I can hardly live with myself knowing that I let. ..” Anita
sobs at this point, saying, “How could I not see—how could I think she
wouldn’t know?” You validate Anita’s pain and support her use of cognitive
processing to replace these maladaptive thoughts with more accurate and
helpful ones (e.g., “My husband perpetrated the violence, not me”; “Now
that I understand what Mariel has gone through, I can protect her”; “If
I hadn’t brought her to therapy, she might not have talked about this and
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 285
Situation:
My friends didn’t play with me.
Situation:
My friends didn’t play with me.
gotten better”; “Mariel is getting better, and this is largely because I’ve
been a good mother to her”).
During the following week, Anita calls to tell you that she and Mariel
have moved to the shelter, but they will attend their appointment as sched-
uled. At the next session, you ask Mariel how she has been, and she says
that she is relieved, mad, and sad. She is relieved that her mother is safe
but mad at both of her parents for “making it be like this. Why can’t they
love each other like they did before? Why does he have to be so mean, and
why can’t she make him be nicer? I never want to get married.” You vali-
date Mariel’s sadness and anger at losing the family she had. You take out
three cans of Play-Doh and use the metaphor of Mariel (blue Play-Doh),
Mommy (red Play-Doh), and Daddy (yellow Play-Doh). At the start of
their family, there was just red and yellow; then there was red, yellow, and
blue. You ask Mariel to put them into a shape that shows the family in
Chapter 2 of her story. Mariel makes a circle with red, blue, and yellow to-
gether. Then you explain that the family changed in Chapter 3; they were
not the same as in Chapter 2: red and yellow were fighting, and blue was
hiding from yellow sometimes, so their shapes were very different from in
Chapter 2 when they were all happy together. You ask Mariel to show what
shape the family looked like in Chapter 3. Mariel makes a configuration
with blue away from red and yellow, which are mashed together with her
fists. Now you explain that there will be a Chapter 4, when blue and red
live in one place and yellow lives somewhere else. But all three people are
still part of a family even if they live in different places. So how will their
shapes change in this chapter? You ask Mariel to show what their shapes
will look like in this next chapter. Mariel thinks and makes a circle of blue
and red, with yellow on the outside. You ask what the feeling is, and she
says, “Sad, but not scary. It’s quieter than fighting.” Mariel completes her
narrative with Chapter 4.
Anita and Mariel meet together with you for Mariel to read her narra-
tive to her mother (until now you have been reading it to Anita in her in-
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 287
dividual sessions) and to fine-tune safety plans. Mariel and her mother
have just moved to a small apartment near Carolina and her family, and
Mariel’s symptoms have significantly improved. She has started to visit
with her father at her paternal grandmother’s house; this has decreased her
worry about her father. At the end of treatment, she is doing well and her
UCLA PTSD Reaction Index has fallen to within the normal range.
and doesn’t hang out with his friends anymore near the park. The group
supports him by saying that those thoughts, feelings, and behaviors make
sense given what he went through. You talk about how this CBITS group
can help him and the others learn to think, feel, and act in a way that makes
them feel better so that each person can get back to doing what he or she
likes and needs to do that is safe. At the end of the first group session, you
ask students to fill out a goals worksheet to give you information to better
understand what each student hopes to get out of the group and for you to
begin to individualize their treatment plans. They are sent home with a
similar form for parents to write in goals they have for their child.
The week after the first session, you have scheduled an early morning
parent session, which Joaquin’s mother attends along with a couple of
other parents from the group. After some introductions and brief sharing
at the meeting, you review common reactions to stress and trauma; have
the parents engage in the same relaxation training exercises you will do
with the students; discuss the link among thoughts, feelings, and behaviors;
explain the rationale for the group; and answer any questions. You highlight
the issue of avoidance and why it is important for youth to be able to pro-
cess and digest their experiences by telling their stories. You emphasize
that students will be practicing skills between sessions at home and that
they may need support in doing so, especially as they work toward getting
back to doing things that they may have been avoiding. You explain that the
next parent group will be in 3 weeks and that you will further discuss
avoidance and exposure along with problem solving. You provide handouts
for the content of both sessions in case some parents do not return for the
second session. You notice that some parents exchange contact informa-
tion, and you have provided time in the room in case anyone wants to speak
to you afterward.
In the second group session, you facilitate a discussion with the stu-
dents about common reactions to stress and trauma, and as each is dis-
cussed, you are able to normalize why that symptom would occur and
provide hope for how the group may help it improve. For example, Joaquin
offers that one reaction may be to not want to go places or see people that
remind you of what happened. You reinforce him for participating and
state, “Avoidance is common and makes sense because you may feel better
for the moment, but just like not wanting to talk or think about the trauma,
avoiding situations or people that remind you of the shooting can keep you
from doing normal things that are an important part of your life, right? In
this group, we’ll be learning about how to cope with some of these bad feel-
ings so you can get back to doing those things. Can anyone else relate to
what Joaquin just said about avoidance?” Following the discussion of com-
mon reactions, where many symptoms that come up are related to physi-
ological arousal, you transition into teaching different forms of relaxation
training, including deep breathing, progressive muscle relaxation, and pos-
itive imagery. You explain the idea of a feelings thermometer (i.e., rating
how you feel on a scale of 0–10, where 0 is feeling OK and 10 is feeling
very, very upset, anxious, or scared) and ask for ratings before and after the
relaxation exercises. You give students a “Common Reactions to Stress or
Trauma” handout to take to their parents, and ask them if they are com-
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 289
fortable doing so, to share with their parents which reactions they may be
experiencing. In addition, you ask them to practice some form of relax-
ation two times during the next week and report back.
You spend the next two group sessions reviewing and practicing cogni-
tive coping (similar to the description in “Mariel: Individual CBT”), allow-
ing each student to practice how to replace negative thoughts with more
helpful and accurate thoughts. Between sessions, you monitor each stu-
dent’s practice with relaxation and cognitive coping. Joaquin reports that
he finds taking deep breaths before his tests in class useful, and when an-
other group member mentions that she is trying to do deep breathing and
positive imagery when she gets headaches, Joaquin decides this could be
something for him to try when his stomach is bothering him and when
teachers or kids are loud. When he has thoughts about the shooting,
Joaquin uses positive imagery of his “safe and happy place” (his grand-
mother’s kitchen in El Salvador) and imagines the feeling of warmth and
calm and the good smells of his favorite foods there that comfort him. He
later reports that he has been able to find privacy in the bathroom at home
to do muscle relaxation and that helps him feel “less angry” when his sib-
lings frustrate him. When you ask group members to write down a couple
of helpful thoughts on a small card to carry with them, it reminds Joaquin
of his brother’s Yu-Gi-Oh! Power (Japanese video animation) cards, so he
begins to carry the power card in his pocket to remind him to check his
thoughts and to use helpful and accurate thinking when negative thinking
gets in his way.
In addition to the group sessions, during weeks 3 and 4 you meet indi-
vidually with Joaquin twice to work on his trauma narrative (and with each
student one to three times). During the initial discussion, you find out that
Joaquin has experienced other traumatic events, including his family being
robbed and temporarily separated while crossing the border into the
United States 7 years ago, a home invasion 5 years ago, and his father being
deported during a raid at his workplace last year. However, Joaquin reports
that it is the recent shooting that is causing him the most distress currently.
You ask Joaquin to tell you the story of what happened the day of the
shooting and to add information so you can imagine what is happening as
if it is projected onto a movie screen in front of you. You let him know that
you are going to jot down parts of the story as he tells it.
Joaquin shares the following: “My best friend, Carlos, and I stayed af-
ter school for a while that day because some kids were playing basketball
and we watched. I started thinking that I should get home so my brothers
and sister wouldn’t be alone, because I’m supposed to take care of them
after school. So finally, Carlos and I took off for home. When we got to the
park on 3rd Street, it was starting to get dark, and we cut through by the
rec [recreational center] like we always did on the way home. When we
got past the corner of the building, we saw two guys from a gang pointing
a gun at a high school kid in a big jacket near the other corner of the rec.
They were cursing and yelling back and forth, and I felt frozen, like I was
just stuck in time and didn’t know what to do. The next thing I knew there
was the gunshot—loud in my ears—and the other gangster looked right in
my eyes. Carlos pushed me, and we both started running through the park.
290 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
his mother and that the family may benefit from a referral to some com-
munity and social resources given the father’s deportation. Some time be-
fore session 5, you also try to make phone contact with each parent, letting
him or her know that beginning in session 5, youth will begin working on
concrete steps toward things that may be anxiety provoking or that they
have been avoiding that they want or need to be able to do. You assess the
extent to which parents, other caregivers, or extended family may be avail-
able to provide support and /or transportation if needed during that prac-
tice. You invite parents to the second parent session and briefly review the
information you will be providing in case they do not attend. In your phone
conversation with Joaquin’s mother, you realize she will not be able to at-
tend the parent session, so you provide her with information on the re-
maining sessions over the phone. She shares with you that Joaquin told her
about the shooting and that he is starting to talk with her about other things
when he is upset. She tells you that things are very difficult for her now
that she is supporting her family alone and that she sometimes does not
know how they will survive financially. You validate her concerns and rein-
force all she is doing for the well-being of her children and family. You refer
Joaquin’s mother to a community agency that provides resources and ser-
vices for recent immigrants and to a nonprofit legal aid group that may be
able to provide her with information regarding her husband’s status and
any options the family may have for reuniting. You praise her again for be-
ing involved with Joaquin’s program even though she is so terribly busy.
During group session 5, you focus on things that students may have
been avoiding since their traumatic event. Each child makes a list of things
he or she has been avoiding but would like to be able to do again. You cir-
culate to each student, helping each one refine his or her hierarchy of grad-
ual approach steps, getting feelings thermometer ratings for each of the
steps, and having each student choose one to two things that can feasibly
be practiced over the next week that are rated at 3–4 or under on his or
her feelings thermometer. Joaquin lists that he has been avoiding Carlos,
his best friend, and that he has stopped letting his siblings play outside
when he cares for them. After assessing for the safety of having siblings
play outside (“Do other children in the neighborhood play outside?” “Did
your siblings used to be able to play outside safely?” “Is there a place it is
safest to be while playing outside?” “Is it safe to do so during the day,
evening, or weekends?”), you help Joaquin list steps for allowing the kids
to play outside, and he accords each step with a rating of how anxious it
will make him feel to do so (at present), as shown in Figure 8–3.
You also help him create a hierarchy of gradual steps for getting back
in touch with Carlos. He constructs the steps and ratings shown in Figure
8–4.
Joaquin decides that this week, he will practice letting his siblings play
outside at his cousin’s house, where he has started hanging out again on
weekends. He will also text message Carlos after school one day.
You begin group session 6 by checking in with group members about
their progress with in vivo exposures and how they used their coping strat-
egies to manage their anxiety during exposure practice. Joaquin reports
that he let his siblings play outside two times at their cousin’s house and
292 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
that it got easier for him by the second time. He even went in the house to
play video games while they played outside at one point. He also sent a text
message to Carlos, but as soon as he sent the text, he felt much more anx-
ious than he anticipated (he had written an 8 on his practice sheet for his
feelings thermometer rating at the time). On the same form, Joaquin had
logged his automatic thoughts and alternative helpful thoughts for why
Carlos didn’t get right back to him and noted that he took some deep
breaths to reduce his anxiety. You ask how it all worked out, and Joaquin
says that Carlos was surprised and happy to hear from him. They texted
back and forth a few times, joked, and ended with “See ya at school.” You
use the opportunity to remind the group that the next time they feel upset
or anxious, they can reflect back on how they have felt that way before and
what coping strategies helped them get through it, and remember that
things may even turn out well. You then help each group member decide
on which in vivo steps he or she is ready to progress to in the coming week.
In group sessions 6 and 7, you focus on allowing students to continue pro-
cessing their trauma memory. First, by passing each student the notes you took
during his or her individual sessions, you remind each student of the parts of
the story that he or she wanted to continue digesting in group. You then guide
the group through an imaginal exposure. The students imagine a particular
point in their story as you slowly ask questions to guide them to think about
what they are picturing—engaging their senses around what is happening, who
is there, how they are feeling, what they are thinking, and so forth (they do not
answer, but use your guidance to create an individual exposure experience
even though they are in a group setting). You pause intermittently and ask for
students to show you their feelings thermometer ratings on their fingers so
that you have a sense for when ratings have gone down across the group and
you can move forward. Next, you provide art supplies and paper and ask each
student to draw a picture of part of his or her story. You allow students to draw
without instructions or asking questions about what they are doing, being re-
spectful that each may do something very different. Joaquin draws a picture
of him and Carlos near the corner of the recreational center and the two boys
holding another one at gunpoint on the other side of the building. You check
in with students to see how they are feeling as they finish their drawings. You
decide to do a relaxation exercise with the group, and afterward you help to
focus everyone back to the present by asking about what classes they have next
and who is doing what after school that day.
In group session 7, you review in vivo exposure practice and progress.
Joaquin describes that he played outside at home with his siblings over the
weekend and that he has been eating lunch with Carlos and his old group
of friends again. You again help each student decide what his or her next
in vivo steps will be and then distribute the students’ drawings from the
previous week and allow some time for them to finish their drawings.
Next, you lead the group in a verbal sharing of part of each student’s story,
explaining that students can show their drawing to the group and talk about
what is happening in the picture if they like, or they can tell about a differ-
ent part of their story. You let them know that if someone does not feel like
sharing verbally that day, he or she can take a few minutes to write out the
story instead—and either keep it private or read it to you at the end of the
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 293
group session. Joaquin shares his drawing, describing what he saw at the
park to the group. You then lead the group through another drawing or
imaginal exposure and end the group in a similar fashion to group session 6.
At the outset of group session 8, you review students’ progress with
in vivo practice and plan for continued movement up their hierarchy.
Group sessions 8 and 9 focus on problem solving to enable group members
to look at options for managing their real-life problems. You illustrate the
link between thoughts and actions by working through an example with the
group, listing potential actions someone could take and making links to the
underlying thoughts. You ask the group for ideas of problems they encoun-
294 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ter in daily life. The situations include someone writing something bad
about you on the bathroom wall, a teacher yelling at you, and parents fight-
ing with each other. You engage the group via games and teamwork in
brainstorming and in rating and selecting potential actions for these situa-
tions. You emphasize that there are many things a person cannot control in
situations like these, but someone can always control how he or she thinks
about the situation and what he or she decides to do. Toward the end of
group session 9, you engage the students in a trivia game, CBT Jeopardy,
which reviews the skills they have learned thus far. You discuss plans for
celebrating their success in the final session. You reassess student PTSD
symptom levels and find that Joaquin’s PTSD scores have significantly de-
creased. You also note that he has reconnected with Carlos, even having
him over to his house; is spending time with extended family on the week-
ends; has been allowing his siblings to play outside before dark; and is at-
tending class on a more regular basis.
Group session 10 includes a celebration of each student’s progress,
marked by your verbal acknowledgment of each child; the handing out of
certificates of accomplishment; and a piece of paper for each student, with
his or her name on it, passed around for each student to write something
positive and to be taken home afterward. Most of the students exchange
contact information with one another, and you let them know that al-
though the group is ending, you will still be at school each week and how
to contact you if they need anything. You ask the group if they would like
to check in before the semester ends and have a booster session, and the
group agrees this is a great idea. You hand out a small bag or folder with
reminders of their CBT skills and ways to take care of themselves, includ-
ing small cards for them to write helpful thoughts on; steps they want to
continue to make with their hierarchy; relaxation scripts or reminders,
such as a worry stone to rub; and lists of things that make them happy, the
people they can go to when they feel upset or need advice, and pros and
cons for problem-solving issues that come up.
You contact parents of group members to let them know that the group
has ended and how to contact you if any concerns arise. You remind par-
ents of the skills their children have learned and how to reinforce them at
home. Joaquin’s mother is very grateful for the changes she sees in Joaquin.
She also reports that she has followed up with the community referral you
have given her and has an appointment with a legal advocate to discuss im-
migration options and community and social services her family may be el-
igible for. You also get information about students’ classroom functioning
from their teachers. Joaquin’s math teacher reports that he is coming to
class more settled down, that his concentration and participation level have
improved, and that he is no longer asking for passes out of class.
Conclusion
Individual (TF-CBT) and group (CBITS) trauma-focused CBT have been
extensively tested and found to be effective for traumatized children, in-
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 295
Self-Assessment Questions
8.1. Which of the following is a characteristic of gradual exposure?
A. Severity of symptoms.
B. Accessibility of school-based treatment.
C. What treatment parents will accept.
D. All of the above.
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
Cohen JA, Mannarino AP, Deblinger E: Treating Trauma and Traumatic
Grief in Children and Adolescents. New York, Guilford, 2006
Jaycox L: Cognitive Behavioral Interventions for Trauma in Schools. Long-
mont, CO, Sopris Educational Press, 2003
Pediatric Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 297
CTGWeb: A free online training course for applying TF-CBT for childhood
traumatic grief that provides 6 free continuing education credits upon
completion. http://ctg.musc.edu
The National Child Traumatic Stress Network: Provides information
sheets about child trauma, as well as a host of other resources for cli-
nicians and families. www.nctsn.org
TF-CBTConsult: An online consultation tool for therapists maintained by
the National Crime Victims Research and Treatment Center.
www.musc.edu/tfcbtconsult
TF-CBTWeb: An online training course that offers 10 free continuing ed-
ucation credits upon completion. http://tfcbt.musc.edu
References
American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Dis-
orders, 3rd Edition. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric Association, 1980
American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric
Association, 2000
Bigfoot DS, Schmidt S: Applications for Native American and Alaskan Native chil-
dren: honoring children—mending the circle, in Applications of Trauma-
Focused Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy. Edited by Cohen JA, Mannarino AP,
Deblinger E. New York, Guilford, in press
CARES Institute: What Do You Know? A therapeutic card game about child sexual
and physical abuse and domestic violence. 2006
CATS Consortium: Implementation of CBT for youth affected by the World Trade
Center disaster: matching need to treatment intensity and reducing trauma
symptoms. J Trauma Stress 23:699–707, 2010
Cohen JA, Mannarino AP: A treatment model for sexually abused preschoolers.
J Interpers Violence 8:115–131, 1993
Cohen JA, Mannarino AP, Deblinger E: Treating Trauma and Traumatic Grief in
Children and Adolescents. New York, Guilford, 2006
Cohen JA, Mannarino AP, Deblinger E, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy for chil-
dren, in Effective Treatments for PTSD: Practice Guidelines From the Inter-
national Society for Traumatic Stress Studies, 2nd Edition. Edited by Foa EB,
Keane TM, Friedman MJ, et al. New York, Guilford, 2009, pp 223–244
Cohen JA, Berliner L, Mannarino AP: Trauma-focused CBT for children with
trauma and behavior problems. Child Abuse Negl 34:215–224, 2010
Copeland WE, Keeler G, Angold A, et al: Traumatic events and posttraumatic
stress in childhood. Arch Gen Psychiatry 64:577–584, 2002
De Arellano MA, Waldrop AE, Deblinger E, et al: Community outreach program
for child victims of traumatic events: a community-based project for under-
served populations. Behav Modif 29:130–155, 2005
298 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Obsessive-Compulsive
Disorder
Jeffrey J. Sapyta, Ph.D.
Jennifer Freeman, Ph.D.
Martin E. Franklin, Ph.D.
John S. March, M.D., M.P.H.
299
300 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
as soon as the disorder is identified. Since the mid-1990s, there have been
tremendous advances in the treatment of pediatric OCD, and cognitive-
behavior therapy (CBT) has consistently been shown to be the monother-
apy of choice for OCD in youth (Abramowitz et al. 2006).
Although the superiority of CBT as a monotherapy or in combination
with serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SRI) treatment is clear, there remains a
need to disseminate this efficacious approach from treatment laboratories
to frontline clinicians. From our years of experience in successfully treat-
ing youth, including treatment-resistant patients referred from seasoned
CBT therapists, we have developed a CBT approach that facilitates treat-
ment compliance and avoids common pitfalls that may lead to ineffective
implementation of CBT principles. For clinicians seeking to better serve
patients with OCD, this chapter is geared toward improving implementa-
tion of an exposure and response prevention (E/RP) approach.
This chapter begins with a general review of the CBT treatment out-
come literature and then illustrates our particular CBT approach for pediat-
ric OCD. First, we present the empirical evidence for cognitive-behavioral
approaches in pediatric OCD in both clinical and research settings. Second,
we describe the various theoretical models within the CBT framework used
to treat OCD and how elements of these various models are typically imple-
mented within pediatric OCD protocols. Next, we explain in detail our clin-
ical assessment, treatment planning, and treatment approach for pediatric
OCD. Finally, we discuss common issues that arise in special populations,
particularly for children with OCD content related to scrupulosity or sexual
obsessions.
Empirical Support
Since the mid-1990s, there has been significant work developing CBT in-
terventions for pediatric populations with OCD. Initially, these interven-
tions began with age-downward extensions of protocols found efficacious
with adults, which led eventually to open clinical trials involving these pro-
tocols (Franklin et al. 1998, 2001; March 1998). Collectively, the pub-
lished uncontrolled evaluations led to randomized studies evaluating the
efficacy of CBT (e.g., Barrett et al. 2004; Bolton and Perrin 2008; de Haan
et al. 1998; Franklin et al., in press; Pediatric OCD Treatment Study
Team 2004; Storch et al. 2007). Our research group did a quantitative re-
view of the child and adolescent CBT literature. Efficacy studies in youth
have consistently demonstrated large effect sizes for CBT interventions,
particularly for individual and family-based formats (Freeman et al. 2007).
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder 301
Theoretical Models
Behavioral Learning
Most protocols used today are based on principles derived from conditioning
models or belief and appraisal models applied to the development and main-
tenance of OCD symptoms (Taylor et al. 2007). The theoretical models
closely tied to E/RP have their start in early learning models. The two-factor
model of fear describes a process in which unconditioned behavioral re-
sponses (e.g., unlearned escape responses) occur in situations where physi-
ologically mediated anxiety is experienced (Mowrer 1960). If an individual
performs a behavior that succeeds in reducing anxiety, the behavior will be
negatively reinforced; and subsequent situations where similar anxiety-pro-
voking stimuli occur will more likely reproduce this learned anxiety-reduc-
ing behavior. In addition, behaviors related to avoiding situations that evoke
physiological fear will also be reinforced. From this initial work, operant con-
ditioning models were described specifically for OCD (e.g., Rachman and
Hodgson 1980). When escape behaviors involve learned, compulsive rituals,
an individual could be considered to have OCD.
Using this descriptive framework, E/RP is thought to work because it
makes those learned connections between safety behaviors and the physi-
ological experience of anxiety more ambiguous (see Foa and Kozak 1986).
In a typical successful E/RP exercise, a patient begins by exposing himself
or herself to an OCD-related trigger that elicits a moderate level of fearful
arousal. If the patient then refrains from performing the ritual, the patient
will experience a gradual decline of the physiological arousal. With succes-
sive E/RP trials, the physiological response to the exposed trigger will grad-
ually reduce (i.e., habituation). As a patient habituates to the OCD trigger,
the extinction of OCD behaviors typically follows.
tress. Cognitive theorists also advance the argument that compulsions persist
because they prevent individuals from having opportunities to test whether
obsessions lead to their unrealistic predictions of harm (Salkovskis 1989).
An enduring legacy of the early cognitive theorists includes articulating
the various themes of dysfunctional beliefs found in OCD obsessions. Al-
though it has been shown that using pure cognitive therapy techniques
(e.g., Socratic questioning) in isolation is not effective over and above ap-
plying E/RP techniques (Abramowitz et al. 2002), the nomenclature of cog-
nitive content is quite useful in setting up exposures that directly target the
core fears of an individual. Advancing on Salkovskis’s seminal ideas, a collab-
orative group of OCD treatment experts outlined additional cognitive do-
mains involved in obsessive content (Obsessive Compulsive Cognitions
Working Group 1997). Combining the expert consensus of its members,
the Obsessive Compulsive Cognitions Working Group outlined the most
common cognitive domains involved in OCD. The final cognitive domains
included inflated responsibility, overestimation of threat, thought-action fu-
sion (e.g., a belief that a thought is morally equivalent to performing the ac-
tion), superstitious or magical thinking, intolerance of uncertainty or doubt,
perfectionism, and concerns for controlling thoughts. Although these cogni-
tive constructs were not necessarily specified for child and adolescent OCD,
many of these cognitions have been observed as ways to differentiate chil-
dren with OCD from control subjects and those with other anxiety disor-
ders (Barrett and Healy 2003).
Despite the distinctions in theoretical explanations of OCD, it should be
emphasized that there is no evidence that any one of these can uniquely ac-
count for the symptom variability observed in OCD patients (Himle and
Franklin 2009). Our treatment approach emphasizes a neurobehavioral
framework, which combines biological, developmental, learning, and family
dynamic models (Freeman et al. 2003; March and Mulle 1998). However,
techniques used in other treatment approaches (e.g., motivational interview-
ing, mindfulness-based treatments) can also be useful in the flexible imple-
mentation of this program, particularly to promote sustained practice in E/RP
activities and remove family involvement in escape and avoidance behaviors
that reinforce OCD. Next, we describe our CBT approach in more detail.
Application
Assessment
A thorough clinical assessment is necessary to determine whether OCD is
present and if it should be considered primary over other comorbidities. If
304 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
other comorbid conditions are identified, the clinician must consider care-
fully whether E/RP should be the primary focus of treatment for the pa-
tient. For example, if OCD-appearing behavior could be better described
in terms of other disorders with intrusive thoughts or repetitive behaviors
(e.g., impulse-control disorders or tic disorder, respectively), then the best
approach would not normally involve E/RP. Furthermore, if the severity of
OCD symptoms would make E/RP hard to tolerate, SRI medication treat-
ment should be considered. In children, it is also important to determine
whether observed behaviors are clinically significant or fall within the
range of normal development (Evans et al. 1997). Finally, identifying fam-
ily factors such as family dynamics related to OCD behaviors (e.g., family
accommodation) and history of OCD members is also of tremendous im-
portance. The assessment process that occurs in our treatment clinic is de-
scribed in detail below.
Table 9–1 describes the assessment battery that is used in our collabo-
rative treatment studies and respective clinics. In general, we use the Chil-
dren’s Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (CY-BOCS; Scahill et al.
1997) and Anxiety Disorders Interview for Children (ADIS; Silverman
and Albano 1996) for most children and adolescents. However, at times
due to a patient’s age or comorbidity rule-outs, we also use sections of the
Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School-Age Chil-
dren—Present and Lifetime Version (K-SADS-P/L; Kaufman et al. 1997),
Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS; Leckman et al. 1989), or Child-
hood Autism Rating Scale—High Functioning, 2nd Edition (CARS2;
Schopler et al. 2010) as appropriate. We also routinely use the Multidi-
mensional Anxiety Scale for Children (MASC; March et al. 1997), Child
Obsessive-Compulsive Impact Scale—Revised (COIS-R; Piacentini et al.
2007), and Children’s Depression Inventory (CDI; Kovacs 1981) to
screen for comorbidities and improve treatment planning.
Next, we describe a few key assessment considerations for every po-
tential CBT candidate. These clinical considerations are important to de-
termine whether a CBT approach is appropriate for a given family.
Age
Measure (years) Target Notes
Interviews
ADIS 8–17 DSM-IV criteria for Preferred for ruling out
anxiety disorders; anxiety comorbidities
ratings on severity and
impairment
CARS2-HF 6–17 High-functioning autism Best when ruling out
spectrum behaviors autism spectrum–
related stereotypies
and rigidity
CY-BOCS 5–17 OCD symptoms and Score of 16 indicates
severity clinically significant
OCD
K-SADS-P/L 5–17 Full range of DSM-IV Preferred for
criteria ages <8 years and
children with wider
range of comorbidities
YGTSS 5–17 Motor and vocal tics and
severity
Self-report
CDI 7–17 Depression symptoms Includes parent- and
child-rated scales
COIS-R 7+ OCD-related functional Includes parent- and
impairment child-rated scales
MASC 8–19 Child-rated anxiety Includes normed
symptoms severity and validity
ratings
Note. ADIS=Anxiety Disorders Interview for Children; CARS2-HF=Childhood Autism
Rating Scale—High Functioning, 2nd Edition; CDI=Children’s Depression Inventory;
COIS-R=Child Obsessive-Compulsive Impact Scale—Revised; CY-BOCS=Children’s
Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale; DSM-IV=Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders, 4th Edition; K-SADS-P/L=Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizo-
phrenia for School-Age Children—Present and Lifetime Version; MASC=Multidimensional
Anxiety Scale for Children; YGTSS=Yale Global Tic Severity Scale.
OCD, these behaviors are typically more acute, pervasive, and hard to re-
sist even with parental encouragement. Repetitive behaviors that children
approach because they are considered fun or enjoyable are never consid-
ered OCD. Some examples of developmentally appropriate behavioral
routines are listed in Table 9–2.
1–2 Strong preference for rigid routines around home rituals (e.g.,
bedtime goodnight). Very aware and can get upset about
imperfections in toys and/or clothes.
3–5 Repeat same play activity over and over again.
5–6 Keenly aware of the rules of games and other activities (e.g.,
rules in classroom settings) and may get upset if rules are
altered or broken.
6–11 Engage in superstitious behavior to prevent bad things from
happening and may show increased interest in acquiring a
collection of objects (e.g., Pokémon cards).
12+ Become easily absorbed in particular activities enjoyed (e.g.,
video games) or with particular people (e.g., pop stars); may
also show superstitious behavior in relation to making good
things happen (e.g., performance in sports).
Source. Adapted from Evans et al. 1997; Freeman and Garcia 2009.
ficult especially with younger children, who may not be articulate or have
complete insight into their obsessions. But from the start of the assessment
and continuing into treatment, the clinician should at every opportunity at-
tempt to understand the specific characteristics of OCD triggers and the
feared consequences of not completing OCD rituals. For example, a child
may avoid things that are “germy,” but why? Does the child fear getting sick
himself or dread getting loved ones sick? If the child gets sick, does she fear
she might die or just experience acute illness (headaches, sore throat, vomit-
ing)? For a girl with scrupulosity obsessions, if she doesn’t confess to her
mom, does she fear only that her mom will be mad at her or that there is a
chance she will go to hell for the offense? These crucial details will assist the
therapist in developing a well-targeted fear hierarchy for E/RP activities later
in the program. Some typical obsession and compulsion themes we see in
children are described in Table 9–3. Note that in particular cases, the specific
fears may be a blend of two or more of these themes.
sion per weekday) outpatient formats with similar results. Regardless of the
chosen session schedule, the general structure of the program is the same:
1) psychoeducation, 2) externalization from OCD, 3) mapping the hierar-
chy and identifiying family involvement in OCD, 4) engagement in “boss-
ing back” strategies, and 5) graded E/RP and family disengagement from
OCD. However, because of developmental considerations for insight and
maturation, we do adjust our protocol emphasis on the basis of the child’s
age. For an older child or adolescent, the treatment focus can be primarily
with the child. In this format, parental check-ins will be only at the begin-
ning and end of sessions, with periodic family sessions scheduled when
needed (see March and Mulle 1998). For younger children or in families
with extensive family involvement in rituals and avoidance of OCD trig-
gers, parents should be involved in most sessions, with a focus on differen-
tial attention, appropriate modeling of CBT skills, and scaffolding
assistance to the child in ways that do not reinforce OCD symptoms (Free-
man and Garcia 2009). Contingency management should also be develop-
mentally appropriate for the child. The clinician should help parents
provide appropriate rewards and privileges for the child completing as-
signed homework and using CBT skills spontaneously in unplanned situa-
tions. The clinician must also be explicit that the plan will reward behaviors
reflecting good effort toward CBT practice, not necessarily results.
Psychoeducation
The first task of the protocol is to ground the family in the neurobehavioral
model for OCD and highlight elements of the treatment program. By the
time a family comes to treatment, they have likely experienced excessive
distress, conflict between family members, fears of stigma, and feelings of
hopelessness. Therefore, the clinician’s initial focus should involve pre-
senting OCD as a neurobehavioral condition that is no one’s fault, as well
as providing hope that there are now proven tools to manage OCD’s influ-
ence on the child and the larger family. Depending on the clinician’s com-
fort level with describing recent advances in the understanding of OCD, it
may be helpful to briefly emphasize the point that OCD is a condition in
the brain, albeit influenced by how the individual and family interact with
OCD behaviors. Metaphors involving descriptions of “brain hiccups,” in-
effective “circuits,” or broken “alarms” have been used effectively. An ex-
ample of a typical explanation to the family is given below.
In recent years, we have learned a lot about what OCD is and how it can
be treated in families. The first thing to understand is that OCD is no dif-
ferent from other medical conditions found in childhood, like asthma or di-
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder 309
to the child’s obsessions), their brain alarm goes off loudly even if there is
no real danger. These kids might even know that they are not in that much
danger, but that alarm circuit sounds off anyway! For other kids, the cir-
cuits might not be too loud, but once they go off it’s very hard for those
alarms to shut off. For example, when the alarm goes off for (insert obses-
sion) and (describe a relevant repetitive compulsive behavior), they either
don’t feel better for long or spend a lot of time trying to do it “just right.”
Again, they might know that they are safe by (doing the compulsion), yet
their alarm circuit does not remain quiet for long.
after doing this program, but their brains look different. It’s true! Research-
ers have taken pictures of people’s brains with OCD before this treatment
and then taken pictures of those people’s brains after the people worked
with this program for 3 months. Amazingly, after a relatively short time,
their brains actually don’t look as much like OCD brains anymore. And the
only thing these kids have changed in those 3 months was how to think and
act toward their OCD in a different way. So what do you think, do you
want to learn more?
At this point, the clinician should check in about any questions the
family has about OCD as a neurobehavioral disorder and assess the overall
treatment engagement of each participant. After these issues have been
addressed, the clinician can continue by describing the nuts and bolts of
OCD and how CBT can help.
At this point, we should probably talk a little more about what OCD is. As
you know, OCD involves things called obsessions and compulsions. Do you
know what exactly makes something an obsession or compulsion? First, let
me say that having obsessions or compulsions is actually quite normal.
(Looking at parents) If you ever had an annoying song stuck in your head
for awhile, you had a brief obsession. Similarly, if you ever found yourself
checking and double-checking something very important, you were having
compulsions. But when these behaviors are happening every day, becoming
increasingly distressful, and they are getting in the way of life, that’s when
someone is considered to have OCD. Obsessions are persistent ideas,
thoughts, pictures, or sounds that get stuck in someone’s head even though
the person doesn’t want to think about them. These thoughts that get
stuck are either stressful or gross, and the person would do anything to not
think about them. Now, compulsions are things people do, either in their
head or where others can see them, to try to feel better about the obses-
sions they are thinking about. Typical compulsions include hand washing,
checking things, counting, arranging, and doing things just right; they may
even involve other people by causing the person with OCD to repeatedly
ask for reassurance from someone. Let me stress that although someone
with OCD spends a great deal of time doing these compulsions, they
would rather not be doing them. They only do them to “change the sub-
ject” or feel less bad about an obsession they are having; these compulsions
are never fun.
Therapist: The last thing for today is how we can start bossing back these
worries you are having. We have discussed already how OCD in-
volves a part of your brain hiccupping or not acting like it should, and
that part of the brain may be making you feel bad in a way that is not
as strong or loud as in other kids.
Child: But I don’t want to get sick ... and I definitely don’t want Mom to
get sick either.
Therapist: You absolutely don’t want to get sick, and you also care about
your mom so much that you don’t want her to get sick either.
Child: That’s right.
Therapist: And most people, myself included, don’t like getting sick, not
at all.
Child: The thought of getting sick from germs is just so gross.
Therapist: Absolutely—when you think about germs, OCD seems to be
yelling in your ears so loud that you just have to avoid germs and
wash whenever you think you’re germy.
Child: That’s right.
Therapist: And that must be so annoying.
Child: Yeah.
Therapist: I wonder what other kids your age feel when they think about
germs? Do you think they need to wash their hands as much? Do you
think their brains are screaming at them as loud?
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder 313
10
9
C
8
Worry/anxiety rating
5 O
4
3
T
2
1
E/RP
0
Time
FIGURE 9–1. Example of drawing used in psychoeducation session
to explain typical obsessive-compulsive disorder pattern.
T= trigger; O=obsession; C= compulsion; E/RP= exposure and response
prevention.
the clinician should begin to conceptualize the best way to structure the
graded E/RP that will be implemented later in the program. The use of an
OCD fear thermometer to build the fear hierarchy will help the child and
family get a little insight into the relative distress each OCD symptom
causes. When the clinician reviews the hierarchy, it is important to care-
fully verify the feelings thermometer ratings that the child has given, mak-
ing sure that the ratings correspond to the level of difficulty or fear the
child anticipates when trying to alter or eliminate the ritual. This task has
the potential to be confusing if not done correctly, because it is possible
that the level of general distress or fear associated with a certain symptom
is not the same as the distress or fear associated with trying to resist that
ritual. For example, a child may rate the distress or fear associated with do-
ing his or her handwashing ritual as a 4 but may rate the distress or fear
associated with not doing (or resisting) this ritual as an 8. Finally, there are
often examples where a child may resist OCD differently outside the
presence of family members. For example, sometime children may be bet-
ter at resisting rituals, even if they feel general distress, at school or around
peers than they are at home. Identified instances where the child can resist
for a time, due to fear of peer rejection or other motivation, could be a
good place to start building E/RP tasks that can tried later on.
Case Example
Crystal is a 7-year-old white girl who has become increasingly concerned
about germs in the past few months. At school, she has been learning that
there are very dangerous germs out there that can get people very sick, and
she must be careful not to touch germy things without washing her hands
thoroughly. At home, she has been increasingly checking in with her mom
about whether certain places are completely clean from germs. If some-
thing has not just been washed, she will ask her mom if it’s clean enough
and the chances she will get sick if something is mostly clean. Crystal’s par-
ents, at first, were very patient with her concern about cleanliness, explain-
ing in detail how she’s safe from most germs. They even thought it was nice
that she was becoming aware of germs and taking an active role in washing
her hands, but lately things have become increasingly concerning. Crystal
is beginning to avoid touching anything that she thinks could have germs.
She even has begun avoiding her little brother, a toddler who is still in di-
apers and puts his hands in his mouth and touches things all over the house.
Crystal’s hands are getting pink with the amount of washing she is doing,
and she checks with her mom almost constantly about things related to
germs.
Therapist: So we talked a little bit about how Germy makes you feel bad
before. But I have here a way you can tell me a little better, with
what is called a fear thermometer. As you can see, it has some faces
next to numbers that go from 0 to 10. You can see that next to the
0, there is a smiley face—meaning Germy is not talking to you and
you are not feeling bad. Next to 10 is a frown face—meaning Germy
is talking to you a lot and it can be like one of the worst times Germy
was messing with you.
Child: OK.
Therapist: Now before we go into how Germy is at home, I want to check
in on how you are feeling now. What do you think your number is
right now, from 0 to 10?
Child: About a 2.
Therapist: Oh, about a 2. You don’t feel completely relaxed, but you don’t
feel very bad either?
Child: Yes.
Therapist: OK, now when you are home, what’s a typical thing Germy can
talk to you about that makes you feel bad?
Child: Germy says I might get sick because I touched something my
brother touched. He sticks his hands in his mouth all the time. It’s
gross.
Therapist: That can be gross. So if you were close to touching something,
like a toy, that you just saw Jack touch after his hands were in his
mouth, what number would that be?
Child: A 10, maybe a 12.
Therapist: Wow.. .so even if you didn’t actually touch it, Germy would
make you feel that your thermometer was as high as it could go?
Child: Well, if I did touch it, that would be the highest. If I didn’t touch
it, but it was close to me, probably a 9.
Therapist: 9/10. (Near the 10 on fear thermometer, the therapist writes,
“Touch toy Jack’s wet hands just touched.” At 9: “Close to wet toy,
no touching.”) Most kids might think that stuff that their kid brother
drools on might be gross. ... Does Germy have you also worry about
stuff that Jack might not have touched for a while?
Child: Well, anything that is Jack’s might have germs on it, I guess.
Therapist: So, if you were to touch something that is Jack’s, like his high
chair, what would that number be?
Child: 10.
Therapist: What if he hadn’t been in it in a while? Like after lunch, Mom
had washed his high chair tray and put it back on the high chair.
What would be your number if you touched that?
Child: If Mom cleaned it and he hadn’t touched it? Probably a 9... . He
eats there and gets his food everywhere.
Therapist: So for places that Jack touches, even if they have been cleaned,
Germy can get loud, yelling at you about germs?
Child: Yes.
Therapist: What if it’s a part of the high chair he can’t touch? What about
the back of the high chair seat that is too tall for him to reach?
Child: Probably a 5.
316 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Therapist: Now, from all the research that has been done in OCD, we un-
derstand pretty well how OCD works in families. Let me describe
for you how OCD works and see if it makes sense to you (see Figure
9–1). So if we draw here (the y-axis) how stressed Crystal can feel
on a scale of 0 to 10 and this line (the x-axis) is just time, let’s draw
out how OCD might work at home. So let’s say she’s having a nor-
mal day (draws a horizontal line near the 2 on the fear axis), but then
she accidentally touches her baby brother’s high chair as she walks
past it (writes a “T”). Now on a typical day, what happens next?
Mother: Crystal gets extremely upset.
Therapist: OK, so she starts feeling really anxious (draws line at a
45-degree angle), and then what happens?
Mother: She will walk up to me and start saying, “Mom, I just touched
Jack’s high chair. Am I going to be OK? Am I going to get sick?”
Therapist: And then what happens?
Mother: Well, of course, I tell her that she’s OK and there’s nothing to
worry about, just like I always do.
Therapist: And does that help?
Mother: Yes, she typically is not as upset with a little reassurance.
Therapist: (Stops upward line at about 8/10; now draws the line turning
downward at a 45-degree angle from the apex; writes “C” at the
apex of the first sawtooth) OK, so her anxiety starts coming down.
And is that all it takes? Does it go all the way down to 0, and she’s
good for the rest of the day?
318 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Mother: No, it might help for a few minutes, but then she’s touched
something else and is coming back to ask me if she’s dirty.
Therapist: Oh, so after a few minutes she’s getting increasingly anxious
again (draws line moving up again at a 45-degree angle), and then
what happens?
Mother: I’m again explaining to her that she’s OK, which reassures her,
but then this goes on all day when we’re home together... .
Therapist: So she comes to you upset, you again explain the facts and re-
assure her that she’s safe and nothing will happen... . (draws down-
ward, completing the second sawtooth)
Mother: Explaining things to her all the time is not helping, is it?
Therapist: Well, I don’t know, what do you think? How will the pattern go
as you go through the day?
Mother: It just keeps going up and down through the day, and my reassur-
ance never satisfies her. (Therapist draws a repeating sawtooth pat-
tern.)
Therapist: So let me summarize how it seems OCD is working with Crys-
tal. Crystal is fine until she becomes confronted with some sort of
OCD trigger, or the T here. Then, those OCD alarm circuits begin
going off and making Crystal feel very anxious (draws an “O” near
first upward line). When that happens, all she wants to do is to make
those thoughts and feelings stop, so sometimes she will go wash her
hands and other times she will check in with you about whether
she’s safe, or the O here. That washing or cleaning works very well
in the short term; she gets nearly immediate relief. But the relief is
short-lived and starts the pattern we have been talking about.
Mother: So what should we do? I feel in the moment I’m helping her feel
better, but I am afraid I’m part of these rituals. I just don’t see any
other way to help her!
Therapist: You are not expected to. No parent gets a manual on how to
help their kid in every situation. And for most kids, a little bit of re-
assurance, perhaps with some facts about how germs work and how
our bodies are equipped to fight them off, actually makes them feel
better. But for a child with OCD, where those leaky circuits are
never quite satisfied with Mom and Dad’s reassurance, we see this
sawtooth pattern over and over again. And as you guys know from
trying to help Crystal, this response can actually set up a pattern that
a kid will go through for hours and hours.
Mother: So what should I do instead?
Therapist: What we’ll do here is teach you a different strategy. It will take
a few weeks to teach you and several more weeks to practice. As we
get in the program, we’ll be able to teach everyone in the family how
to approach this differently so OCD doesn’t win. We may have cer-
tain situations where Crystal’s OCD is triggered and it goes up, but
instead of Crystal falling into the trap of a compulsion, we will teach
you and Crystal other things you can do instead. What we know by
seeing lots of kids with OCD is that when the family does these
other skills they learn in CBT, the anxiety does not go down imme-
diately (uses a different colored marker to draw gradual habituation
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder 319
line), but it goes gradually yet steadily down to where it was before
the trigger happened.
The general approach looks like this. We will first teach you and
Crystal, when OCD shows up, what to do instead of the compulsion
that begins that sawtooth pattern. Second, we also will teach Crystal
how to proactively boss back OCD on her own, by helping her ap-
proach the triggers she’s currently avoiding or trying to neutralize with
compulsions. We do this by teaching her an approach called exposure
and response prevention, or E/RP. When we use E/RP, we will help her
actively practice feeling what OCD makes her anxious about in small
doses (draws an upward line at about 4/10) and using those skills to
show her that she doesn’t have to do any compulsions. Simply put, her
body will get calm all by itself. To get her to do this, we will be teach-
ing you how to encourage or reward her when she does her E/RP prac-
tice. What we know from working with lots of kids with OCD is that
the more a kid practices E/RP, the less her body reacts to those trig-
gers. And these peaks will become less extreme over time, and the
time it takes for her body to recover will decrease.
Bossing-Back Strategies
For active treatment components, our program is separated into two major
categories: 1) E/RP and 2) elements that facilitate engaging in E/RP. As
discussed earlier, our clinical experience and meta-analytic reviews show
that E/RP is the primary active component for symptom reduction in
OCD. Although this may suggest that clinicians should rush to do E/RP, an
early misplaced E/RP exercise can sabotage treatment irrecoverably, which
is why we carefully establish the CBT model, introduce symptom moni-
toring, and add other bossing-back skills that will facilitate future E/RP ad-
herence. Within bossing-back strategies (i.e., cognitive resistance), the two
major categories are 1) externalization from OCD and 2) cognitive ther-
apy elements such as cognitive restructuring and constructive self-talk.
The bossing-back strategies we have found to be the most helpful for treat-
ment success are those consistent with externalizing OCD. Identifying
OCD thoughts and feelings as external to the child and subsequently in-
teracting with these thoughts and feelings with a level of detachment is at
the heart of E/RP and the process leading to habituation. In contrast, we
have found cognitive restructuring strategies helpful only in very specific
situations. Although cognitive restructuring activities can be important to
a family before a given E/RP exercise (e.g., What is the likelihood we will
contract swine flu if we touch this table?), it is important not to emphasize
these activities too strongly as a means to reduce stress beyond the first
few sessions. We have found that for some kids, an overemphasis on talk-
ing back to OCD with coping thoughts during acute stress (e.g., reminding
320 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
themselves that “I’m safe” or “These germs can’t really kill me”) can elicit
OCD-reinforcing mental safety behaviors at times when an emphasis on
habituating to the stress without additional efforts to promote safety
would be more effective. We recommend that clinicians use only enough
cognitive training to make the child’s engagement in E/RP effective and to
facilitate approaching activities the child was otherwise avoiding due to
OCD-related triggers. For the most part, cognitive strategies should only
be used before and never during E/RP to maximize effectiveness. The ther-
apist must be vigilant to deemphasize anything that could potentially be-
come an emerging mental ritual.
onstrating the task concurrently (e.g., “So the first thing we can do against
OCD is take our finger like this, touch the table, and then quickly touch it
on our tongue”). Second, when planning in-session E/RP, the therapist
should discuss any proposed exposure matter-of-factly in front of the child.
Third, unless the family has demonstrated several successes with E/RP that
they did independently at home, it’s best to first initiate any increase in ex-
posure intensity in a treatment session. Allow the family to practice these
new exposures at home without escalating them, unless the child is no
longer getting anxious at home when these E/RPs are attempted. Finally, do
not disengage from an E/RP until the child habituates or has experienced
at least a 50% reduction. For this reason, budget enough time at the end of
sessions if a new E/RP exercise is to be attempted.
In conjunction with E/RP work for the child, the clinician must also be
mindful of helping the family disengage from OCD accommodation and
related behaviors. A recent text from one of our clinics describes in steps
how to systematically put this program into place for the parents while
concurrently working with the child (Freeman and Garcia 2009). Most of
the skills taught are consistent with other parent training approaches in-
volving differential attention and scaffolding more responsibility to the
child regarding distress management. Allowing parents to see how the
therapist conducts symptom monitoring, OCD mapping, and E/RP exer-
cises will also provide them a model on how to do similar behaviors at
home instead of accommodating OCD.
Relapse Prevention
Once E/RP activities have been introduced and successfully implemented in
session and during in-home practice, subsequent sessions will be devoted to
going ever higher up the hierarchy as the child habituates to previous triggers.
Once the child begins demonstrating little distress while doing E/RP on his or
her hierarchy and otherwise not exhibiting distress or interference from OCD
in home, school, transitions, or social situations, session frequency can be
scaled back and relapse prevention strategies can be introduced.
Effective relapse prevention involves anticipating when OCD might
likely try to return and using CBT skills proactively to boss back symptoms
as they occur. Therefore, the family should be educated about the poten-
tial for OCD to return at some point, particularly in times of developmen-
tal changes (e.g., advancing to middle or high school) or any acute stressful
time. It’s important to normalize the fact that OCD can try to come back,
but also to stress that the family and child now have the tools to boss it
back effectively when it is identified for what it is. OCD can look different
when children age because of developmental changes in concerns and val-
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder 323
ues (see Table 9–2); however, the sawtooth pattern typically demonstrated
in OCD (see Figure 9–1) rarely changes. Parents should be encouraged to
be vigilant for signs of OCD but not to overprotect their child from stress
or triggers related to it. Rather, the child should be provided significant
support and encouragement to use his or her CBT skills using praise and/
or other rewards that work for the family in other areas. Families should
also be encouraged to seek a phone chat or booster session with their ther-
apist if symptoms do reappear and initial attempts of addressing it inde-
pendently from treatment appear not to be working.
Cultural Considerations
CBT may need to be altered in order to be sensitive to the context of spe-
cific cultural backgrounds. Although reviews in the pediatric OCD litera-
ture find little support for race or ethnicity moderating treatment effects,
the reality is that OCD symptoms are often misdiagnosed or underdiag-
nosed in minority populations (Hatch al. 1996). More research is required
in tailoring CBT interventions to minority populations before we can com-
ment further on how to tailor our treatment to better serve them.
One particular cultural consideration that routinely comes up in our
clinic is treating children with scrupulosity, harm, or sexual obsessions in
families who are deeply religious. These families may pose some unique
challenges (e.g., being overly concerned about sinning) to clinicians trying
to treat OCD symptoms through exposure, yet continuing to be support-
ive and validating of the family’s spiritual values. Some families could even
be skeptical of the therapist’s motives, particularly if the therapist doesn’t
share the family’s particular religious tradition.
Huppert and Siev (2010) recently discussed some excellent ap-
proaches to treating religious individuals with scrupulosity obsessions that
we have used with success in treating children. The therapist’s stance
should be at all times respectful and supportive of the child’s wish to have
a more fulfilling religious life, regardless of the therapist’s personal beliefs.
Once OCD has been established as the main presenting problem, the ther-
apist must clearly explain to the family that the child’s OCD is not a result
of their religious beliefs. Rather, OCD typically preys on the core values
of the individual, leading to scrupulosity in children who are religious. The
therapist can explore this concept in detail during psychoeducation and
the initial effort of externalization of OCD from the family’s religious tra-
dition. If the therapist can paint OCD as opportunistically messing with
their faith, the therapist may be able to discuss some distinctions between
the religious practices of devout peers and how OCD might be distorting
324 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
the child’s sincere attempts to live a religious life. Most older children can
articulate a perceived distinction between the true joy or awe of being spir-
itually connected versus the emptiness felt when doing compulsive rituals.
Exposures for scrupulosity need to be handled sensitively and explic-
itly discussed ahead of time with both the child and family. The therapist
should provide sufficient time to discuss the rationale for engaging in ex-
posures and collaboratively discuss how these can be done in a manner
with which the family is comfortable. The family must provide the thera-
pist with guidance on the boundaries about what their faith considers in-
tentionally sinning (e.g., worshipping the devil) versus doing things that
elicit anxiety because they increase the person’s risk of sinning (e.g., saying
out loud the word devil). For example, one mother once said it was OK to
do exposures regarding sinful images because “OCD puts these in his head
all day anyway.” In some cases, collaborative discussions with the family’s
clergy could also be useful.
Conclusion
Since focused empirical attention began in the mid-1990s, CBT for pedi-
atric OCD has blossomed into an empirically supported treatment for an
often severe and disabling condition. As is the case in treatment studies for
adults with OCD, the effects of CBT for children and adolescents appear
to be both robust and durable. When used in combination with serotonin
reuptake inhibitors, weekly treatment as described above for approxi-
mately 12–14 weeks appears to be sufficient, although as noted earlier, the
format of sessions can be accelerated with little impact on overall efficacy.
Therefore, the primary challenge moving forward is less about improving
the techniques, but rather how to disseminate this approach to a wider va-
riety of trainees and community clinicians, particularly in geographical ar-
eas that do not have medical centers that routinely treat children with
OCD. This will remain a pressing challenge to the field, but recent studies
suggesting that a “supervision of supervisors” community model can yield
comparable results to efficacy studies involving academic medical settings
is encouraging and should be a focus of replication.
Self-Assessment Questions
9.1. CBT treatment research has indicated that the most efficacious
component for decreasing obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)
symptoms is
A. Prolonged exposure.
B. Socratic questioning.
C. Progressive muscle relaxation.
D. Exposure and response prevention.
9.2. Research by Storch and colleagues has indicated that CBT with ex-
posure and response prevention (E/RP) is
A. 10.
B. 12.
C. 16.
D. 20.
E. 30.
Selected Readings
For Clinicians
Freeman J, Garcia A: Family Based Treatment for Young Children With
OCD: Therapist Guide. New York, Oxford University Press, 2008
March J, Mulle K: OCD in Children and Adolescents: A Cognitive-Behav-
ioral Treatment Manual. New York, Guilford, 1998
Piacentini J, Langley A, Roblek T: Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of
Childhood OCD: It’s Only a False Alarm: Therapist Guide. New
York, Oxford University Press, 2007
References
Abramowitz JS, Franklin ME, Foa EB: Empirical status of cognitive-behavioral
therapy for obsessive-compulsive disorder: a meta-analytic review. Romanian
Journal of Cognitive and Behavioral Psychotherapies 2:89–104, 2002
Abramowitz J, Whiteside S, Deacon B: The effectiveness of treatment for pediat-
ric obsessive-compulsive disorder: a meta-analysis. Behav Ther 36:55–63,
2006
American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry: Practice parameters for
the assessment and treatment of children and adolescents with obsessive-
compulsive disorder. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 37(suppl):27S–
45S, 1998
Barrett PM, Healy LJ: An examination of the cognitive processes involved in child-
hood obsessive-compulsive disorder. Behav Res Ther 41:285–299, 2003
Barrett P, Healy Farrell L, March JS: Cognitive-behavioral family treatment of
childhood obsessive-compulsive disorder: a controlled trial. J Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 43:46–62, 2004
Beck A: Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorders. New York, International
Universities Press, 1976
Bolton D, Perrin S: Evaluation of exposure with response-prevention for obsessive
compulsive disorder in childhood and adolescence. J Behav Ther Exp Psychi-
atry 39:11–22, 2008
de Haan E, Hoogduin KA, Buitelaar JK, et al: Behavior therapy versus clomip-
ramine for the treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder in children and ad-
olescents. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 37:1022–1029, 1998
Evans DW, Leckman JF, Carter A, et al: Ritual, habit, and perfectionism: the prev-
alence and development of compulsive-like behavior in normal young chil-
dren. Child Dev 68:58–68, 1997
Flament M, Whitaker A, Rapoport J, et al: Obsessive compulsive disorder in ado-
lescence: an epidemiological study. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
27:764–771, 1988
Foa EB, Kozak MJ: Emotional processing of fear: exposure to corrective informa-
tion. Psychol Bull 99:20–35, 1986
Franklin ME, Kozak MJ, Cashman LA, et al: Cognitive-behavioral treatment of pe-
diatric obsessive-compulsive disorder: an open clinical trial. J Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 37:412–419, 1998
Franklin ME, Tolin DF, March JS, et al: Treatment of pediatric obsessive-compul-
sive disorder: a case example of intensive cognitive-behavioral therapy involv-
ing exposure and ritual prevention. Cogn Behav Pract 8:297–304, 2001
Franklin ME, Sapyta J, Freeman J, et al: Cognitive behavior therapy augmentation
of pharmacotherapy in pediatric obsessive-compulsive disorder: the Pediatric
OCD Treatment Study II (POTS II) Randomized Controlled Trial. JAMA (in
press)
Freeman J, Garcia A: Family Based Treatment for Young Children With OCD:
Therapist Guide. New York, Oxford University Press, 2009
Freeman JB, Garcia AM, Fucci C, et al: Family based treatment of early onset ob-
sessive-compulsive disorder. J Child Adolesc Psychopharmacol 13 (suppl
1):S71–S80, 2003
Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder 329
Freeman JB, Choate-Summers ML, Moore PS, et al: Cognitive behavioral treat-
ment for young children with obsessive-compulsive disorder. Biol Psychiatry
61:337–343, 2007
Hatch M, Friedman S, Paradis C: Behavioral treatment of obsessive-compulsive
disorder in African Americans. Cogn Behav Pract 3:303–315, 1996
Himle M, Franklin M: The more you do it, the easier it gets: exposure and response
prevention for OCD. Cogn Behav Pract 16:29–39, 2009
Huppert JD, Siev J: Treating scrupulosity in religious individuals using cognitive-
behavioral therapy. Cogn Behav Pract 17:382–392, 2010
Kovacs M: Rating scales to assess depression in school-aged children. Acta Paedo-
psychiatr 46:305–315, 1981
Leckman JF, Riddle MA, Hardin MT, et al: The Yale Global Tic Severity Scale: ini-
tial testing of a clinician-rated scale of tic severity. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
Psychiatry 28:566–573, 1989
Kaufman J, Birmaher B, Brent D, et al: Schedule for Affective Disorders and
Schizophrenia for School-Age Children—Present and Lifetime Version
(K-SADS-PL): initial reliability and validity data. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
Psychiatry 36:980–988, 1997
March J: Cognitive behavioral psychotherapy for pediatric OCD, in Obsessive-
Compulsive Disorders: Practical Management, 3rd Edition. Edited by Jenike
M, Baer L, Minichello WE. Philadelphia, PA, Mosby, 1998, pp 400–420
March J, Mulle K: OCD in Children and Adolescents: A Cognitive-Behavioral
Treatment Manual. New York, Guilford, 1998
March JS, Mulle K, Herbel B: Behavioral psychotherapy for children and adoles-
cents with obsessive-compulsive disorder: an open trial of a new protocol-
driven treatment package. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 33:333–341,
1994
March JS, Parker JD, Sullivan K, et al: The Multidimensional Anxiety Scale for
Children (MASC): factor structure, reliability, and validity. J Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 36:554–565, 1997
Mowrer OH: Learning Theory and Behavior. New York, Wiley, 1960
Nakatani E, Mataix-Cols D, Micali N, et al: Outcomes of cognitive behaviour ther-
apy for obsessive compulsive disorder in a clinical setting: a 10-year experi-
ence from a specialist OCD service for children and adolescents. Child
Adolesc Ment Health 14:133–139, 2009
Obsessive Compulsive Cognitions Working Group: Cognitive assessment of obses-
sive-compulsive disorder. Behav Res Ther 35:667–681, 1997
Pediatric OCD Treatment Study Team: Cognitive-behavioral therapy, sertraline,
and their combination for children and adolescents with obsessive-compulsive
disorder: the Pediatric OCD Treatment Study (POTS) randomized controlled
trial. JAMA 292:1969–1976, 2004
Piacentini J, Peris TS, Bergman RL, et al: Functional impairment in childhood
OCD: development and psychometrics properties of the Child Obsessive-
Compulsive Impact Scale—Revised (COIS-R). J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol
36:645–653, 2007
Rachman S, Hodgson RJ: Obsessions and Compulsions. Englewood Cliffs, NJ,
Prentice Hall, 1980
Rasmussen S, Eisen J: Epidemiology of obsessive compulsive disorder. J Clin Psy-
chiatry 51 (suppl 2):10–13, 1990
330 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
This work was supported by grant nos. K23 MH064604, R01MH077770, and
1DP2OD001210 from the National Institutes of Health.
331
332 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
related factors (e.g., social isolation, adjustment to illness, damaged self, fam-
ily conflict, and health-related quality of life) and psychiatric comorbidities,
such as anxiety and depression. The existing literature, however, is difficult
to integrate and interpret given the wide diversity of presenting medical con-
ditions, specific subpopulations of youth sampled, variations in CBT ap-
proach and dose, and different outcomes assessed. Moreover, various
components of CBT have been studied, including cognitive restructuring,
contingency contracts, relaxation, systematic desensitization, social role-play,
problem solving, and conflict resolution, making it challenging to determine
which elements comprise the most “active ingredients” in CBT. Treatment
modality has also varied, with individual, group, and family-based interven-
tions having some empirical support (see Table 10–1).
PASCET Theory
The original PASCET program is a structured CBT approach developed by
John Weisz and his team (2009) for the treatment of depression in youth.
The PASCET program is based on the Skills-and-Thoughts (SAT) depres-
sion model, which focuses specifically on skill deficits and habits of
thought that underlie and prolong depression in youth. Skill deficits often
include poor activity selection, poor self-soothing skills, disengagement or
avoidant social style, and inferior performance in academic or extracurric-
ular domains (Hammen and Rudolph 1996; Weisz et al. 1992). Habits of
thought include 1) negative cognitions (e.g., inappropriate self-blaming,
catastrophizing, failure to find the “silver lining”); 2) rumination over de-
pressogenic events and cognitions; and 3) perceived helplessness, hope-
lessness, and/or lack of control leading to low-level persistence in coping
with stress and challenges (Gladstone and Kaslow 1995; Weisz et al. 1992,
2001). Youth with chronic physical illness are likely to be even more pre-
disposed to such skill deficits (from loss of social practice time due to
physical disease flares) and cognitive habits (from having to deal with a
medical stressor out of their control). The SAT perspective holds that
these skill deficits and cognitive habits can generate sad affect and make
youth vulnerable to overt depressive symptoms in response to adverse,
stressful, or ambiguous life events. Furthermore, these deficits and habits
may actually generate their own stressful cascade (e.g., unsuccessful inter-
actions and social rejection), which then stimulate further depression, in a
cyclical fashion (Hammen and Goodman-Brown 1990). Not only can this
cycle disrupt psychological functioning, but learned helplessness can also
compromise immune system functioning, thus leading to a worsened ill-
ness course in physically ill populations (Sieber et al. 1992). A central task
334
TABLE 10–1. Findings from cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) trials in the pediatric medical population
Type of
Study N Design intervention Findings
Type of
Study N Design intervention Findings
335
2. Standard care
336
TABLE 10–1. Findings from cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) trials in the pediatric medical population (continued)
Type of
Study N Design intervention Findings
Grey et al. 2009 82 Randomized Group Coping skills group did not fare better statistically than
controlled trial 1. Coping skills education group on measures of distress, medical
2. Education outcome, quality of life, or familial functioning.
Note. PASCET-PI=Primary and Secondary Control Enhancement Training for Physical Illness.
Chronic Physical Illness 337
A). It is hypothesized that the ACT skills help the youth reverse behavioral
inhibition and passivity by inducing positive or reinforcing appetitive behav-
iors. The resulting mood improvement likely makes the youth more recep-
tive to the THINK skills aimed at reversing erroneous cognitive processing
(i.e., negative distortions and attributional style). Using the principles of
learning theory, these early changes are reinforced with repetitive practice
of the skills, with the eventual goal of establishing automatic and more sta-
ble behavioral repertoires to counter the negative mood and thought-induc-
ing effects of depression. The developmental plasticity of the brain during
childhood provides a critical window in which to stamp in such cognitive
and behavioral changes, which is particularly relevant for youth who must
deal with lifelong physical diseases.
The original PASCET program involved 10 structured sessions with the
individual youth, focused on learning the ACT and THINK skills, followed
by 1–4 individually tailored sessions involving 1) applications of the most rel-
evant PASCET coping skills to important situations or problems in the
youth’s life and 2) planning for future applications of the PASCET skills after
the treatment has ended. The 10 structured sessions included in-session ex-
ercises and take-home practice assignments, guided by a workbook that each
youth used throughout the program and kept afterward. The individual ses-
sions were supplemented by three parent sessions designed to help parents
support the practice of the new coping skills in their children.
there support in adults with IBD that CBT can improve emotional distur-
bances, improve quality of life, and decrease patient suffering, but our
studies show a positive impact of PASCET-based CBT in terms of reduced
depression and improved functioning (Szigethy et al. 2006, 2007). Other
investigators have shown that a modified CBT approach using the Coping
Cat Program (see Chapter 7) for IBD-related anxiety in children has a pos-
itive impact on patient outcomes (Reigada et al. 2010).
Empirical Evidence
Our PASCET-PI model was empirically tested in both an open trial (Szi-
gethy et al. 2004) and randomized trial compared with a medical treat-
ment-as-usual condition (Szigethy et al. 2007, 2009). Not only did the
PASCET-PI group show improved depressive severity and global function-
ing posttreatment, but these positive effects were maintained 1 year post-
treatment compared to the standard care group (Szigethy et al. 2006). In
addition, IBD severity (as measured by validated disease activity measures
as well as circulating inflammatory markers) was reduced at 6-month fol-
low-up in youth receiving PASCET-PI. Although other factors could ac-
count for these positive changes in the CBT group, collectively these
results are consistent with PASCET-PI having a positive effect on both
emotional and physical aspects of IBD. Moreover, youth who had more
pessimistic illness narratives and received PASCET-PI showed significantly
more optimistic attitudes toward having IBD and more positive contin-
gency and active coping post–CBT treatment (McLafferty et al. 2010).
There are several potential mechanisms to explain the impact of PASCET-
PI on IBD activity, including improved medical compliance, integration of
a more positive attitude toward and active coping with IBD, and a brain-
mediated effect on the peripheral immune system. Recent data from our
laboratory suggest that depressed youth with IBD receiving CBT have in-
creased metabolism in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, which is linked
to emotional regulation relative to healthy matched controls (Szigethy et
al. 2010).
Domains
In addition to the traditional focus of PASCET-based CBT on altering mal-
adaptive skills and cognitions, PASCET-PI integrated three components
into the program.
1. Educating the family and youth about IBD in consultation with the ap-
propriate medical specialist is important to correct any misperceptions
about IBD and its treatment. For example, explaining depressive
symptoms as extra-intestinal manifestations of IBD instead of as an
additional and stigma-inducing psychiatric diagnosis is helpful and rec-
ommended.
2. Teaching strategies to reduce abdominal pain, including relaxation,
hypnosis, biofeedback, distraction, and cognitive coping strategies,
provides valuable education to the youth and his or her family. Daily
practice of relaxation and calming techniques alone with minimal ther-
apist contact has been shown to yield increased functionality in daily
activities and decreased health care utilization (Gil et al. 2001). In
adults with IBD, hypnosis not only improved quality of life, but also
decreased IBD-related inflammatory markers (Mawdsley et al. 2008;
Miller and Whorwell 2008).
3. Enhancing social skills through focused social problem-solving (e.g.,
how to share aspects of having a chronic physical illness with peers to
increase support), utilizing in-session role-plays that target cognitive
distortions and related feelings in settings with peers (e.g., perceived
social rejection due to physical illness), and facilitating problem solving
around social limitations related to physical illness (e.g., how to choose
and maintain fun activities during IBD disease flares) address an impor-
tant facet of the youth’s life and enhance coping skills. The develop-
ment of such coping strategies not only can help the youth overcome
depressive symptoms but also may serve to buffer the effects of stress
on IBD flares and improve daily functioning.
4. Medication nonadherence is an important issue to address and often
can be effectively targeted through cognitive restructuring and active
problem-solving.
Family Involvement
Living with a chronic physical illness often involves a host of psychosocial
stressors in addition to the demands of addressing illness symptoms and
medical treatment, including negotiating academic and occupational limi-
tations, financial burden and medical coverage, communication difficul-
342 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ties, and lack of adequate leisure-work balance (Barakat and Kazak 1999).
Parents can experience difficulties related to the impact of the youth’s
physical illness on the family system, and how parents respond to these
difficulties directly influences how the rest of the family copes. Parents of-
ten focus most of their attention on the ill child and struggle to balance
their jobs, personal needs, and the needs of their other children effectively.
Although the normal developmental push during this critical period is to-
ward separation and individuation from the nuclear family, increased de-
pendence on parents because of physical illness–related issues and altered
parenting styles (overprotection or excessive lenience) can make the tran-
sition through adolescence particularly tumultuous. In addition, there is
evidence that families of children with comorbid depression and physical
illness deserve special attention. Families of children who have physical ill-
ness have increased rates of psychological distress and poor communica-
tion (Engstrom 1999). Depressed children are more likely to have parents
who are depressed, and parental depression may interfere with compli-
ance with both medical and psychological treatments (Beardslee et al.
1993; Cohen and Brook 1987). Cognitive approaches have been shown to
be quite effective in educating families about childhood depression, in-
creasing family understanding and communication, and decreasing risk
factors for future depression (Beardslee et al. 1997; Brent et al. 1993).
To meet the special needs of this population, family psychoeducational
sessions modeled after the clinician-facilitated family preventive interven-
tion of Beardslee (1990) are provided. Beardslee’s Family Talk Interven-
tion has been tested in a long-term randomized trial and has received very
high ranks in the National Registry of Effective Programs. It has been
adapted for use with low-income African American and Latino families
and used in country-wide programs in Scandinavia and Costa Rica. We
have chosen those core components most relevant to PASCET adaptation
and integrated them with treatment of the child.
In PASCET-PI, adolescents and their families participate in three family
psychoeducational sessions corresponding to the beginning, middle, and end
of the individual CBT protocol. Content areas that are covered during these
separate family sessions help parents reinforce the child’s ability to use
PASCET-PI skills to cope, deliver education about depression and resiliency
in adolescents, address salient parental concerns about their adolescent and
family, and help families develop more effective communication. Beards-
lee’s work has shown the critical importance of linking cognitive material to
an individual’s narrative life experiences (Beardslee and Podorefsky 1988;
Focht and Beardslee 1996). This approach can help families identify affect,
deal with stigmatization, and decrease noncompliance, psychosocial deficits,
and resistance to the concept of illness. Training parents to become CBT
Chronic Physical Illness 343
coaches for their children not only provides an active and constructive focus
of parental energy, but the role may also help them to avoid maladaptive pa-
rental coping practices such as distancing, denial, and overprotection of the
sick child. Furthermore, there is a preventive tone to these family sessions,
in that parents are building strengths that will help promote long-term resil-
ience in the family.
Just as in the original PASCET, both the youth and parents work from
a PASCET-PI workbook. The youth receives 9 individual sessions and up
to 3 flexible sessions to stamp in the skills most useful to the child. Parents
participate in 3 sessions during the approximately 3-month intervention.
In addition to modifications in content to incorporate physical illness–
related realms, structural changes include the choice of phone sessions for
up to 60% of the total sessions and coupling face-to-face sessions with
medical appointments to improve compliance with therapy. We have
found the phone sessions most helpful and effective when the initial ses-
sion is conducted face-to-face with the ongoing therapist. On the part of
the therapist, the key to making the phone sessions productive is ensuring
that youth have their PASCET-PI workbook at hand and that their envi-
ronment is private and free from distractions.
Application
The following section will outline the application of the PASCET-PI inter-
vention for youth with IBD and comorbid depression, with emphasis on the
case formulation and content of both the individual and family sessions.
Case Formulation
The successful application of the PASCET-PI skills is dependent on the
formulation of the case and the integration of psychological and physical
illness–related information. In addition to a thorough psychiatric and med-
ical history, it is also important to consider potential obstacles to treatment
progress, as well as personal and familial strengths so that these factors can
be used as building blocks to target more maladaptive areas of coping. Ad-
ditionally, an evaluation of precipitating events or situations, assessment of
how the youth shows depressed feelings, and a thorough exploration of the
youth’s social functioning can facilitate the development of a comprehen-
sive case formulation. Collectively, this type of reformulation of the classic
psychiatric evaluation into a CBT-based assessment can help the therapist
hypothesize a priori regarding which ACT and THINK skills will be most
applicable to the youth. The following is an example of a case history and
formulation for PASCET-PI.
344 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case History
Kyle is a 13-year-old Hispanic adolescent boy in the eighth grade. He was
diagnosed with Crohn’s disease 4 years ago. He presented for a psychiatric
evaluation with a 6-month history of feeling sad and frustrated, decreased
motivation and energy, intermittent hopelessness, insomnia, and low self-
esteem. He also had increased complaints of stomach pain that were out of
proportion to the degree of Crohn’s disease activity (as determined by in-
flammatory markers from his blood and endoscopy). He missed more than
40 days of school during the past 6 months due to the abdominal pain, re-
sulting in a downward drift in his usually above-average grades. He has been
on intermittent steroid therapy for the past 4 years and identified that he
sometimes feels down when his steroid dose is high. Kyle reported being
good about taking his morning medications but has variable compliance with
the evening doses. Family history is positive for colitis, depression, posttrau-
matic stress disorder, alcohol dependence, and hypothyroidism on the pa-
ternal side. Kyle identified stressors as feeling isolated from his friends,
being restricted in physical activities because of his physical illness, and the
constant tension between his parents, who were frequently arguing and con-
templating divorce. When he did spend time with his friends, he reported
difficulty in negotiating conflicts between his school and neighborhood
friends. Kyle’s parents are concerned about his depressive symptoms and
stomach pain, his anxiety about falling behind in school, how their parental
conflicts may be affecting Kyle, the problems he has been having with his
classmates (e.g., he received his first suspension from school for fighting
with a peer in the cafeteria), and how Kyle is coping with having Crohn’s
disease. His father is often unemployed, and he stays home with Kyle dur-
ing missed school days. Kyle’s mother works as a high school teacher, often
withdrawing from conflicts at home and burying herself in her work. Kyle’s
strengths include being bright and future oriented, having a good sense of
humor, being sensitive to the feelings of others, having a variety of interests,
and displaying skill at video games, soccer, and biking.
PASCET-PI formulation: A 13-year-old white adolescent boy with
long-standing Crohn’s disease presents with worsening depressive symp-
toms over the past 6 months, increased abdominal pain (in the absence of
objective evidence of Crohn’s flare), decreased school attendance with re-
sulting failing grades, increased social isolation and peer conflict, and de-
creased physical activity. IBD and steroid use in addition to family history
of depression, anxiety, and hypothyroidism could predispose Kyle to de-
pression. Stressors include decreased academic performance, marital con-
flict between parents, interpersonal difficulties with peers, and coping
with a chronic physical illness. In addition, modeling of sick-role behavior
and possibly learned helplessness by his father may also be a contributing
factor to Kyle’s maladaptive coping.
Skill deficits and cognitive habits: Kyle’s skill deficits include diffi-
culty negotiating social conflicts with peers; difficulty eliciting positive so-
cial reinforcement from adults in his life; difficulty self-soothing, with
increased focus on pain; and difficulty setting goals in different life do-
Chronic Physical Illness 345
mains. Cognitive habits include lack of perceived control over his environ-
ment with resulting helplessness, negative cognitive distortions (e.g., “I
can’t do anything fun because of my Crohn’s”; “My friends will think I’m
weird if they know I am diseased”), and hopelessness. Together these neg-
ative behaviors and thoughts make him even more vulnerable to feeling de-
pressed. Using the following skills (i.e., ACT and THINK for relaxation,
STEPS problem-solving skills, and POWER skills) along with family ses-
sions aimed to increase parental communication and Kyle’s sense of pri-
mary control. (STEPS and POWER skills are discussed further in the
following section “Individual Sessions,” in “Session 2: Problem Solving”
and “Session 6: Talents,” respectively.)
Individual Sessions
The following section will provide an overview of the individual youth ses-
sions according to the PASCET-PI intervention. Table 10–2 provides an
outline of each session following the ACT and THINK skill format.
cess being regular attendance to learn new skills and consistent practice of
the skills between sessions. Next, explain the two types of skills: ACT
skills to learn new behaviors and THINK skills to change thinking about
what distresses the patient but that are not in his power to change. These
two types of skills will be used to target problems related to IBD and other
life problems. Next, deliver psychoeducation about how depression can be
caused by chemicals released in the gut during IBD flare-ups, affecting the
brain and causing depressed mood, fatigue, changes in sleep and appetite,
and increased sensitivity to pain. For youth who do not have a current IBD
flare-up, depression may be a response to the realization that they have a
lifelong chronic illness, or perhaps it can be linked to other life stressors
that are not directly related to IBD. Irrespective of the root cause, the im-
portant take-home message for patients is that applying ACT and THINK
coping skills can help facilitate positive changes in mood in either of these
causes. Finally, introduce the new skill for this session: learning to be aware
of mood and how it relates to what the patient is doing (or not doing). For
each day of the week, have the youth rate his overall mood on a scale of
1 to 10 (1=very bad and 10=very good). Next, have the youth choose a
word or phrase that best describes his mood for the day and also list good
things and bad things that happened that day.
Session Goals
structured sports). For youth who have active IBD, the amount and type
of physical activity should be determined in consultation with their gastro-
enterologist.
One way to measure the amount of stress we are holding in our body is to
measure the temperature in our hands. Hand temperature is caused, in
large part, by the distribution of blood in our body. When too much blood
is in our head, less blood is in our body, including our hands; and thus, our
hands are colder. This fact is useful to know because it is also the case that
too much blood in one area can cause pressure, which causes pain. So, for
example, tension headaches are often caused by too much blood in the
brain. Today we will work on learning to relax and use the power of our
mind to help shift the blood from the head to the hands. We will use
biodots to test how well our attempts are working. Here’s a biodot to place
on the back of your hand or another area of skin. Notice the color of the
biodot as we go through some relaxation training.
The practice tool for this session will consist of making a CD of the re-
laxation exercises completed during the session so that the youth can prac-
tice these techniques at home. Listening to music is another way in which
Chronic Physical Illness 349
youth can relax. Incorporating soothing music or the youth’s favorite songs
into the recording can be helpful in creating a calming experience.
ing the client to behave in a way that adults might like but that his peers
may find “nerdy” or socially undesirable. Use therapeutic judgment liber-
ally in coaching the youth to come up with his positive-self skills.
Session 6: talents. The goals of this session are to work with the youth
to further develop existing talents, develop new skills, and learn social
problem-solving to improve social skills. This session is particularly impor-
tant when illness symptoms are preventing youth from doing their usual
activities or from developing opportunities for socialization. The main con-
cept is that developing a skill takes three steps: goal setting, planning real-
istic steps, and practicing until the youth masters each of the small steps
and reaches his desired goal. Ask the youth to identify a goal involving
some talent or skill he wants to develop, and collaboratively identify some
of the small steps that would need to be mastered on the way to that goal.
For the weekly practice assignment, have the youth begin practicing one of
the steps.
The second part of this session focuses on teaching the youth social
problem-solving skills using the POWER steps (Problem with a relation-
ship, Outline the positive and negative parts of the relationship, Which
negative parts do I have the power to change? Explore the good and bad
aspects of making a change, Relationship improvement takes action; Ap-
pendix 10–A) to improve relationships with others. Introduce the idea
that everyone has had someone with whom they have had difficulty get-
ting along in a particular situation. The therapist can give common exam-
ples from other youth or from his or her own life (e.g., arguments,
breakups, disagreements with a parent). Tell the youth that just like there
are STEPS to solving other problems, there are concrete things someone
can do to improve a relationship with another person. Further, improving
relationships with others can help the youth feel good. For the practice as-
signment, have the youth pick one person to focus on to complete the
POWER worksheet on his own and to try out one of the solutions to im-
prove the relationship with this person. When going through the POWER
steps with the youth, make sure to hit on the following basic ideas, which
are organized according to the steps associated with each letter in the
POWER acronym.
• Outline the positive and negative parts of the relationship. This step
is the most difficult and germane to the process of improving a relation-
ship. Sometimes when a person is having difficulty with another per-
son, it is difficult to think about things that are going well in the
relationship or that he does like about the other person. A big step in
improving a relationship is to overcome this tendency and recognize
that there are both good and bad things about the relationship. Explore
with the youth whether the positive aspects of the relationship out-
weigh the negative ones. Oftentimes, even though it is clear that the
positives outweigh the negatives, people can forget about the positives
when they become focused on the negatives.
• Which negative parts do I have the power to change? Looking at
each of the negative parts of the relationship that the youth has listed,
help him decide which parts he has control over or has the power to
change. Explain that often the things that are not within a person’s con-
trol are the characteristics or qualities of the other person. It may be a
good idea to illustrate this point using an example of someone the
youth knows or a hypothetical person who is caught up in trying to
change another person. Often it is much easier to see from an outside
perspective how frustrating and futile it is to have a mission of changing
another person. This step is a specific application of one of the main
tenets of the PASCET model: deciding when to have primary control
(changing the environment) versus secondary control (changing one’s
own thinking) of a situation and changing personal actions or thinking
accordingly.
• Explore the good and bad aspects of making a change. In this step,
help the youth examine the potential outcomes of each of the pro-
posed solutions for changing something about the relationship.
• Relationship improvement takes action. This step simply involves
the youth actually trying out one of the listed solutions and seeing how
it works. Encourage him to make a commitment about when he will at-
tempt to make the change.
Case Example
Kyle initially presented as quiet and lethargic. He yawned several times
throughout the session and did not display consistent eye contact. During
the first few sessions, the clinician focused not only on psychoeducation
and introducing ACT skills, but also on establishing rapport. The main way
rapport was established with Kyle was by linking ACT skills with the con-
cerns he reported during the illness narrative. With time, Kyle became
more invested in treatment. He was receptive to learning about the ACT
and THINK skills and began to complete his mood monitoring assign-
352 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ments. Kyle openly discussed how his mood was lower on days when he
stayed at home and did not spend time with friends. His mood tended to
be better on days when he was busier. This pattern was discussed, and Kyle
agreed that he was happier when he was doing something social than when
he was home alone.
This discussion naturally led to introducing the ACT activities skill by
reminding Kyle that his mood ratings were better when he did fun activi-
ties and lower when he isolated himself. With the help of the clinician, Kyle
formed a list of pleasurable, social, active, and helpful activities in which
he could participate. He was assigned to take part in at least one of these
per day and to rate his mood both before and after taking part in the activ-
ity. Kyle followed through with this assignment, and his mood ratings began
to gradually improve. He also noted that the more time he spent with
peers, the closer he became with them and the less conflict he experienced
with them. Kyle explained that when he was not hanging out with friends
a lot, he began to assume that others thought he was “weird” and therefore
he needed to prove he was cool by fighting with others. However, as he in-
creased spending fun times with friends, he became less defensive and no
longer felt the need to appear tough; therefore, his fighting behavior de-
creased.
Another ACT skill that proved beneficial for Kyle was the set of
STEPS problem-solving techniques. Kyle rated his academic problems as
most upsetting to him currently. The STEPS problem-solving skills were
then introduced to Kyle, and together with the clinician, each step was ap-
plied to Kyle’s concerns regarding his dropping grades and poor attendance.
Eventually, Kyle was able to pick the solution of speaking with his teachers
and parents about 1) getting a tutor to help him to catch up on the work
he had missed and 2) starting to return to regular school attendance. He
was excited when the clinician explained that given his illness, the school
would likely agree to a specialized plan focused on providing him with ex-
tra time and support to catch up academically, as well as support him while
he gradually increased his time in school until attending full-time again.
Kyle’s parents joined in at the end of one session to sign a release for the
clinician to contact the school guidance counselor in order to begin the pro-
cess of obtaining accommodations in the school setting for Kyle because of
his health condition.
Kyle was pleased with how problem solving worked for him and there-
fore was also quite receptive to the POWER skill introduced during
session 6, focusing on talents. Kyle reported that one of the most concern-
ing things about his illness currently was that he was not able to tell his
friends what was going on for fear of being teased. This fear had caused him
to feel isolated from his friends, especially his best friend. Kyle realized
that it was his choice whether to open up to his friends, but that choosing
not to tell them caused him to feel more isolated from them. He formed
the solution of telling his best friend about his IBD diagnosis and seeing
how he would react. The clinician helped Kyle by role-playing how he
would bring this subject up with his friend, as well as how to deal with his
friend’s possible reactions. After sharing this information with his friend,
Kyle was surprised when his friend was “really cool” about it. Kyle said that
Chronic Physical Illness 353
this made a big difference for him. Even though he wasn’t as close to his
friend as he was before the IBD diagnosis, he felt a lot better once his ill-
ness wasn’t a big secret.
Although Kyle’s mood ratings were gradually improving with the use of
ACT skills, his IBD ratings did not initially improve because Kyle was re-
porting high amounts of pain, especially in the mornings before school.
Kyle was open to the idea that some of his pain might be related to anxiety
regarding school rather than IBD symptoms alone. He was taught calming
skills, including breathing techniques, visualization, and hypnosis. Kyle es-
pecially benefited from the hypnosis skills and found that he could reduce
his level of pain when he practiced this technique regularly. After learning
and practicing these techniques, Kyle began to experience less pain and
also felt a higher amount of control over his symptoms. His IBD weekly
ratings began to decrease.
letters. Finally, the youth will identify a less negative (or more neutral) way
of thinking and rate his associated mood. For example, instead of saying,
“I hate having IBD,” which may be an example of looking for the negative,
the youth might think, “It could be worse—I could be so sick that I would
need to be in the hospital, but I’m not.”
Case Example
Once Kyle’s symptoms were beginning to lessen due to the ACT skills, the
clinician moved on to teaching the THINK skills in later sessions. At this
point in the treatment, Kyle was functioning at a much higher level. How-
ever, he continued to maintain some hopeless and negative cognition re-
garding his illness. The therapist explained to Kyle the relationship
between thoughts and feelings and introduced the concept of BLUE
thoughts. Kyle was able to recognize his pattern of “looking for the bad” by
overly focusing on how IBD negatively affected him. In addition, his pat-
tern of exaggerating the negative impact of IBD on his life was also dis-
cussed. Kyle practiced countering these thoughts and replacing them with
more helpful thoughts. He also began regularly practicing “finding the sil-
ver lining” because this helped him to challenge his tendency to focus on
the negative. Kyle’s illness narrative slowly began to change. Although ini-
tially his thoughts about his illness caused him to feel sad, by the end of
treatment, his thoughts had become much more realistic. Most of the
time, Kyle was able to recognize when his thoughts were making him feel
worse and then work to challenge these thoughts.
Chronic Physical Illness 355
Sessions 9–12: keep trying. In the final structured session (session 9),
the overarching goal is to introduce the idea that often one skill alone is not
enough to optimally improve the youth’s mood. In fact, it is often the com-
bination of different skills that can lead to the best outcome. In session 9,
the ACT and THINK chart is reviewed, and the youth identifies a list of
current life and IBD-related problems. For each problem, encourage the
youth to think of three ACT and THINK skills that would be most helpful
in the given situation in an effort to develop plans for future action (Ap-
pendix 10–A). To solidify this concept of having several plans, it can be
useful for the youth and therapist to switch roles, with the therapist as the
depressed youth and the youth as the therapist who helps the “client” to
develop Plan A, Plan B, and Plan C for specific problems. This role reversal
not only allows the youth to experience mastery, but it also helps symbol-
ize a transition in the sessions, with the youth taking a more active role in
problem solving and generating solutions.
For the remaining sessions 10–12, the focus is on the application of the
most personally relevant PASCET-PI skills for the youth’s current prob-
lems, as well as the introduction of some skills that might be needed in the
future. These additional sessions may be most helpful for youth experienc-
ing only partial remission of depressive symptoms, youth with comorbid
anxiety problems, youth from more chaotic or less supportive families,
youth experiencing IBD flare-ups during the course of therapy, and youth
who are struggling to learn PASCET-PI coping skills or having trouble im-
plementing the skills into their daily routines. The session content will
consist of focused discussions, role-plays, brainstorming, and other exer-
cises aimed at practicing and reinforcing the application of specific PAS-
CET-PI skills to potentially depressogenic events and conditions that are
present in the youth’s daily life. Thus, a considerable part of each of these
later sessions will be devoted to collaboratively designing and trouble-
shooting the practice assignments for the following week.
Family Sessions
Individual youth sessions are complemented by contact with parents in
two forms. At the end of each individual youth session, a parent (or both,
if available) joins the therapist and youth for a 5-minute summary confer-
ence to discuss the main points of the session (excluding information the
youth does not want to share) and the youth’s practice assignment for the
upcoming week, which the parent is encouraged to assist the youth with.
Individual family sessions are held at the beginning, middle, and end of the
youth’s treatment. The goals of these family sessions are threefold, includ-
ing explaining the treatment program and soliciting the parent’s perspec-
tive on the youth’s depression and coping with IBD, educating the family
about depression and comorbid physical illness, and helping the family re-
inforce the youth’s ability to cope with depression and physical illness by
using PASCET-PI skills. Incorporate parents in a developmentally appro-
priate manner. For example, discuss confidentiality of the specific topics
brought up by the adolescent, but encourage the adolescent to share the
CBT coping skills learned with the parent at the end of the session. Help
the parents adopt a more appropriate perspective on the adolescent’s be-
havior, balancing firm control with warmth and granting autonomy.
The format of the family portion of the overall PASCET-PI protocol is
a short-term, intensive, psychoeducational, family-based intervention.
Just as the crux of the individual PASCET-PI is to help the adolescent de-
velop primary and secondary control, the central tool in the family sessions
is to apply a modified version of the STEPS skills for family problem-solv-
ing. To help families increase their behavioral problem-solving repertoire,
a variety of strategies are employed, including teaching about depression
and the interface of depression and physical illness, helping to develop a
sense of hope about the future, and linking cognitive information to both
the individual and family perspectives on affective illness and the unique
life experience of the family, including dealing with the physical illness.
Each family session is outlined below. Ideally, the first session involves
only the parents or parental figures in the youth’s life, and the subsequent
two sessions involve first the parents alone and then include the youth so
the therapist can help develop more constructive interactions between the
parents and the child. However, given differences in family structure and
degree of impairment, the therapist can decide on a case-by-case basis how
these family sessions will best assist the youth in the family’s ultimate goal
of learning more adaptive ways to cope with having IBD.
Chronic Physical Illness 357
Family de-stressing game: Each family member gets five popsicle sticks in
a certain color (red, orange, yellow, green, blue, or purple) or other unique
token identifiers. The idea of the game is for each player to get as many pop-
sicle sticks in colors other than his or her own from family members by the
end of the game. Players earn the sticks by saying something nice or doing
something nice for someone else in the family. For example, if the youth
says, “Dad, I really appreciate you spending time with me yesterday,” the
youth would get a stick from his father. If the youth’s mother baked him
358 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
cookies, he would give one of his sticks to her. The family decides as a unit
when they will begin and end the game, but ideally each game should be
played for 5–7 days. Negative comments or interactions are ignored.
Case Example
While Kyle’s individual sessions were greatly helpful for improving his
mood and functioning, the family sessions also played a large role in his im-
provement. Kyle’s parents attended the first session without Kyle to learn
about CBT and how they could support Kyle in his treatment. This educa-
tion helped Kyle’s mother to realize that she herself was also depressed.
She was referred for outside treatment and attended those sessions. Treat-
ing her own symptoms allowed her to more effectively support Kyle’s new
healthy lifestyle. At the same time, Kyle’s father was also encouraged to
support Kyle’s new healthy lifestyle by providing Kyle with praise and spe-
cial attention when he was using coping skills and reducing attention when
Kyle was not following through. In this way, the secondary gain of getting
more special time with his father when he did not go to school dissipated,
and this change also helped to improve Kyle’s attendance.
Follow-up family sessions also focused on problem-solving some difficul-
ties within the family unit. Kyle was able to explain that he often felt “put in
the middle” of his parents arguing and that this made him feel like he “can-
not win.” Therefore, the clinician helped Kyle’s parents to agree to discuss
marital problems privately and to avoid including Kyle in these discussions.
Although this intervention was not easy for the couple and at times they
made mistakes, Kyle noticed great improvement in his interactions with his
family, and his reported level of stress within the family was reduced.
Family processes
Negative expressed emotions
Decreased communication
Self-Assessment Questions
10.1. When CBT is used for the treatment of a youth with a chronic phys-
ical illness, which of the following treatment components will likely
be most useful for improving mood and positive coping?
10.2. Which of the following best describes the relationship between psy-
chological and physical processes?
10.3. A 14-year-old adolescent girl with comorbid Crohn’s disease and de-
pression spends most of her time lying in bed in her bedroom, isolat-
ing herself. Which of the following coping skills is a primary control
tool that will likely help her change this negative behavior?
A. The tool of identifying the silver lining so that the youth begins
to find the positive in her situation.
B. Taking part in relaxation training techniques such as deep breath-
ing and hypnosis.
C. Recognizing negative thought patterns and challenging them with
more helpful thoughts.
D. Activity scheduling: being encouraged to take part in an increased
variety of activities, including pleasurable, physically active, help-
ful, and social activities.
364 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
10.5. When working with a 17-year-old adolescent boy, the therapist no-
tices that he appears bored when presented with the information.
Which of the following developmental adaptations may be most use-
ful for this situation?
A. Leave out the ACT (i.e., Activities, Calm and Confident, Talents)
skills when conducting treatment in order to focus more on the
complex skill of cognitive challenging.
B. Focus on making the sessions collaborative and fun by learning
about the teen’s interests and linking skills with the teen’s illness
narrative.
C. Increase parent participation in the teen’s sessions to ensure that
he participates actively.
D. Do not make any adaptations, as this would decrease the overall
efficacy of the treatment.
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
American Society of Clinical Hypnosis, for hypnosis training and certifica-
tion: www.asch.net
Avery RR: Meet Thotso, Your Thought Maker. China, Smart Thot, 2008
Dudley CD: Treating Depressed Children. Oakland, CA, New Harbinger
Publications, 1997
Thomson L: Harry the Hypno-Potamus: Metaphorical Tales for the Treat-
ment of Children. Norwalk, CT, Crown House Publishing, 2005
Thomson L: Harry the Hypno-Potamus: More Metaphorical Tales for Chil-
dren. Bethel, CT, Crown House Publishing, 2009
Wester WC, Sugarman LI: Therapeutic Hypnosis With Children and Ad-
olescents. Bethel, CT, Crown House Publishing, 2007
Chronic Physical Illness 365
References
Barakat LP, Kazak AE: Family issues, in Cognitive Aspects of Chronic Illness in
Children. Edited by Brown RT. New York, Guilford, 1999, pp 333–354
Barlow C, Cooke D, Mulligan K, et al: A critical review of self-management and
education interventions in inflammatory bowel disease. Gastroenterol Nurs
33:11–18, 2010
Beardslee WR: Development of a clinician-based preventive intervention for fam-
ilies with affective disorder. J Prevent Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines 4:39–
60, 1990
Beardslee WR, Podorefsky D: Resilient adolescents whose parents have serious af-
fective and other psychiatric disorders: importance of self-understanding and
relationships. Am J Psychiatry 145:63–69, 1988
Beardslee WR, Keller MB, Lavori PW, et al: The impact of parental affective disor-
der on depression in offspring: a longitudinal follow-up in a nonreferred sam-
ple. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 32:723–730, 1993
Beardslee WR, Wright E, Rothberg PC, et al: Response of families to two preven-
tive intervention strategies: long-term differences in behavior and attitude
change. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 35:774–782, 1996
Beardslee WR, Salt P, Versage EM, et al: Sustained change in parents receiving pre-
ventive interventions for families with depression. Am J Psychiatry 154:510–
515, 1997
Beck AT: Depression: Clinical, Experimental, and Theoretical Aspects. New York,
Hoeber, 1967 (Republished as Beck AT: Depression: Causes and Treatment.
Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 1970)
Bernstein KI, Promislow S, Carr R, et al: Information needs and preferences of re-
cently diagnosed patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Inflamm Bowel
Dis 17:590–598, 2011
Brent DA, Poling K, McKain B, et al: A psychoeducational program for families of
affectively ill children and adolescents. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
32:770–774, 1993
Burke P, Elliott M: Depression in pediatric chronic illness: a diathesis-stress model.
Psychosomatics 40:5–17, 1999
Burkhart PV, Rayens MK, Oakley MG, et al: Testing an intervention to promote
children’s adherence to asthma self-management. J Nurs Scholarsh 39:133–
140, 2007
Chalder T, Deary V, Husain K, et al: Family-focused cognitive behaviour therapy
versus psycho-education for chronic fatigue syndrome in 11- to 18-year-olds:
a randomized controlled treatment trial. Psychol Med 40:1269–1279, 2010
Cohen P, Brook J: Family factors related to the persistence of psychopathology in
childhood and adolescence. Psychiatry 50:332–345, 1987
Ellis DA, Frey MA, Naar-King S, et al: The effects of multisystemic therapy on diabe-
tes stress among adolescents with chronically poorly controlled type 1 diabetes:
findings from a randomized, controlled trial. Pediatrics 116:826–832, 2005a
Ellis DA, Frey MA, Naar-King S, et al: Use of multisystemic therapy to improve
regimen adherence among adolescents with type 1 diabetes in chronic poor
metabolic control. Diabetes Care 28:1604–1610, 2005b
366 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Szigethy EM, Jones NP, Silk J, et al: Brain processing of illness perception in de-
pressed adolescents with inflammatory bowel disease. Poster presented at the
6th annual NIH Director’s Pioneer Award Symposium, Bethesda, MD, Octo-
ber 2010
Tang Y, Preuss F, Turek FW, et al: Sleep deprivation worsens inflammation and de-
lays recovery in a mouse model of colitis. Sleep Med 10:597–603, 2009
Weisz JR, Stipek DJ: Competence, contingency, and the development of perceived
control. Hum Dev 25:250–281, 1982
Weisz JR, Yeates KO, Robertson D, et al: Perceived contingency of skill and chance
events: a developmental analysis. Dev Psychol 18:898–905, 1982
Weisz JR, Rothbaum FM, Blackburn TF: Standing out and standing in: the psychol-
ogy of control in America and Japan. Am Psychol 39:955–969, 1984a
Weisz JR, Rothbaum FM, Blackburn TF: Swapping recipes for control. Am Psychol
39:974–975, 1984b
Weisz JR, Rudolph KD, Granger DA, et al: Cognition, competence, and coping in
child and adolescent depression: research findings, developmental concerns,
therapeutic implications. Dev Psychopathol 4:627–653, 1992
Weisz JR, McCabe MA, Denning MD: Primary and secondary control among chil-
dren undergoing medical procedures: adjustment as a function of coping style.
J Consult Clin Psychol 62:324–332, 1994
Weisz JR, Thurber CA, Sweeney L, et al: Brief treatment of mild-to-moderate
child depression using primary and secondary control enhancement training.
J Consult Clin Psychol 65:703–707, 1997
Weisz JR, Southam-Gerow MA, McCarty CA: Control-related beliefs and depres-
sive symptoms in clinic-referred children and adolescents: developmental dif-
ferences and model specificity. J Abnorm Psychol 110:97–109, 2001
Weisz JR, Southam-Gerow MA, Gordis EB, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy
versus usual clinical care for youth depression: an initial test of transportability
to community clinics and clinicians. J Consult Clin Psychol 77:383–396, 2009
Wysocki T, Harris MA, Buckloh LM, et al: Effects of behavioral family systems
therapy for diabetes on adolescents’ family relationships, treatment adher-
ence, and metabolic control. J Pediatr Psychol 31:928–938, 2006
Wysocki T, Harris MA, Buckloh LM, et al: Randomized trial of behavioral family
systems therapy for diabetes. Diabetes Care 30:555–560, 2007
Wysocki T, Harris MA, Buckloh LM, et al: Randomized, controlled trial of Behav-
ioral Family Systems Therapy for Diabetes: maintenance and generalization of
effects on parent-adolescent communication. Behav Ther 39:33–46, 2008
Appendix 10–A: PASCET-PI Selected Skills and Tools 369
Appendix 10–A
STEPS
S Stay calm and Say what the problem is: Solving problems creatively happens
best if a person is calm and relaxed. Thus, the first step in problem solving is
staying relaxed.
S See if it worked: If it worked, great! If it did not work, then go back to your list
of solutions and try another one.
BLUE thoughts
B: Blaming myself
L: Looking for the bad news
U: Unhappy guessing
E: Exaggerating—imagining a disaster
Appendix 10–A: PASCET-PI Selected Skills and Tools 371
Mood thermometers.
Appendix 10–A: PASCET-PI Selected Skills and Tools 373
1. 1.
2. 2.
3. 3.
1. Part: How?
2. Part: How?
3. Part: How?
E Explore each one: What good and bad things might happen if I try to
change part of the relationship in this way? List the good and bad results
for each “How?” listed above.
1. Good: Bad:
2. Good: Bad:
3. Good: Bad:
Keep trying
What happened when I felt bad:
Use ideas from the ACT and THINK chart to come up with THREE PLANS for feeling better:
Plan A
Letter from the ACT and THINK chart:
What this client should do:
Plan B
Letter from the ACT and THINK chart:
What this client should do:
Plan C
Letter from the ACT and THINK chart:
What this client should do:
Maintenance plan.
Appendix 10–B: Guided Imagery 375
Appendix 10–B
Induction
Make yourself as comfortable as you can either sitting or lying down. Gen-
tly close your eyes, feeling comfortable and relaxed—let your body go. ..
no need to tense any of your muscles ... all you need to do is listen to my
voice. Now begin to focus in on the feelings in your right fingers and right
hand and let go of whatever tension may be in those muscles—just relax—
you will feel relaxation like a warmth or perhaps a pleasant tingling sensa-
tion—let it happen—naturally... let the feeling of relaxation spread gradu-
ally up your right hand . . . forearm . . . upper arm . . . and into your right
shoulder—let go of the tension—relax, just relax... . Now do the same on
your left side. .. begin with relaxing the muscles in your left fingers and
hand. ..let it spread up your left arm and forearm... upper arm.. .and into
your left shoulder. ..now both your left and right shoulders, arms, hands,
and fingers are relaxed—keep feeling relaxed. ...
That’s great—you’re doing well. ..now, let’s turn your attention to the
muscles of your head and neck . . .smooth out the muscles in your fore-
head—above your eyebrows—down the muscles of your face—over your
eyes, your cheeks; your jaw is loose and relaxed—feel the relaxation
spreading around your ears—over your head—down the muscles of your
neck.. .. You’re doing great—just keep relaxing like that.. .feel relaxation
now spreading over your shoulders, down your back, and over your stom-
ach—let it flow further down the muscles of your left and right legs—over
your knees, feet, and toes... .
Sometimes it is useful to imagine the relaxation as warm waves of wa-
ter that begin at the top of your head and trickle gently over the muscles
of your face, further down over your shoulders, arms, back, legs, and down
to your feet—and with each gentle wave of water, feel the tension flushed
from your body. ... Now focus on the muscles in your stomach—relax these
376 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
muscles, releasing all the tension. Relax, just relax. In this way, you will be
able to chase away any pain or discomfort, leaving you tension-free and
calm.
To help you relax even more, I’m going to count slowly from 1 to 10,
and with each number I call out, you are going to feel even more comfort-
able and even more relaxed—even when you think it’s impossible to relax
any further—there’s always more relaxation you can enjoy just by letting
go. ... You may want to picture each number in your head as I call it out.. ..
Let’s begin—1, you’re very relaxed... 2, more and more—further and fur-
ther relaxed. . . 3, feel your whole body getting heavier and looser. . . 4,
deeper and deeper relaxed... 5, more and more relaxed. ..6, you are feeling
your whole body become totally relaxed.. .7, your body continues to be-
come more and more deeply relaxed.. .8, deeper and deeper into a relaxed,
comfortable state. ..9, no cares or concerns, just a carefree, gentle state of
relaxation.. .and 10, completely and totally relaxed, feeling carefree, with-
out worries or concerns.
Now turn your attention to your breathing...this is the breathing of deep
relaxation .. . rhythmic, smooth, effortless. . .listen to your breathing.. ..
I would like you to try the following exercise—every time you let out a
breath, think quietly to yourself of the word calm—this will help you to as-
sociate the word calm with the calm and relaxed state you’re now in—so that
at any time in the future you can bring on this state of deep relaxation just
by breathing rhythmically, slowly, and saying the word calm every time you
let out a breath—do that for a few minutes until I return to talk to you once
again (1–3 minutes). Now you are in a deep state of relaxation, and you are
going to become even more relaxed...and still more relaxed as we continue.
You will be able to shift your body to become more comfortable, and this will
not disturb your relaxation or your concentration. You will stay in this re-
laxed state until I tell you to wake up.
In Trance
Now focus on your body. Scan your body and notice the places that cause
you pain. When you are asked, you will be able to verbally communicate
these areas in your body to me without breaking your trance (pause).
When you are ready, please tell me which areas of your body experience
pain (pause and wait for the response). Thank you, you are doing a great job.
Please imagine your (name a body part that the patient verbalized to
you—e.g., stomach) and paint your (name the body part) with an imaginary
paintbrush. Paint the entire area that causes you pain. On a scale from 1 to
10, 1 being hardly any pain and 10 being the most pain you have ever had,
how much pain are you experiencing in your (name body part)?
Focus your attention on your (name the body part), imagining the exact
place you feel your pain and the type of pain you feel. Now, imagine a cable
or wire connecting your (name the body part) to your brain, the control
center for all your feelings, including pain. Can you see this cable? (Wait
for a response.) Good. Now, imagine a room in your brain, called the thal-
amus. When you look inside this room, it is a bright room and you see four
walls—each wall is covered by light switches from the ceiling to the floor.
Appendix 10–B: Guided Imagery 377
As you look around at these switches, you see that each switch has a piece
of tape under it with the name of a body part. You look around the room
until you find the switch that has the word “(name the body part)” under
it. Did you find this switch? Good. Now as you look closely at this switch,
you see it is labeled from 1 to 10, with 10 being the most intense pain set-
ting and 1 being almost no pain. Describe what setting the light switch you
are imagining is at. (Wait for a response.) Now imagine the setting being
cranked up to a 10, the most intense (name the body part) pain imaginable.
Describe how your (name the body part) feels right now. Now visualize
yourself turning the light switch down in the control room from 10, 9, 8,
and with each number on the switch that you see, imagine the pain becom-
ing less and less intense. Keep turning the switch lower and lower. What is
the lowest number you can see the switch turned to?
Encourage the child to keep imagining this until he can visualize the
switch being at least a 4 or 5, and continue reinforcing his control over the
switch and the corresponding change in pain experienced. Finish the exer-
cise on the lowest pain setting the child can achieve.
378 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Appendix 10–C
• Give your child permission to leave class to use the bathroom without
asking each time, or provide a private bathroom or nurse’s facility.
• Provide makeup work and extra help if your child is absent for long pe-
riods of time.
• Facilitate administration of medications by the school nurse so that
your child is not singled out at inappropriate times.
• Communicate with you and your child’s medical team about possible
flares or other difficulties noticed.
• Set up a buddy system with one of your child’s friends who will keep
track of homework assignments, bring over necessary books, and let
your child know what went on in school that day.
• Create a homework plan—set reasonable goals for completing home-
work, designate time in the day as homework time, and be available to
assist your child.
• Be clear on expectations for each class and the consequences of not
keeping up with schoolwork.
• When the child needs to miss school for medical reasons, the child
should not be penalized for it.
• The child should be given the assignments for missed work in writing.
• The child should be allowed a reasonable time after he or she has re-
covered from the episode to complete missed schoolwork, including
examinations.
• It is medically necessary that the child be able to self-limit physical ac-
tivity.
• It is medically necessary that the child have unrestricted access to a
bathroom.
Your gastroenterologist can provide you with a letter stating that IBD
is a medical disability and the types of accommodations frequently
needed, but you will need to work with the school to get these accommo-
dations implemented.
Obesity and
Depression
A Focus on Polycystic Ovary Syndrome
S This chapter has a video case example on the DVD (“Polycystic Ovary Syn-
drome”) demonstrating CBT for a depressed adolescent with obesity.
383
384 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
al. 2007; Rasgon et al. 2003; Weiner et al. 2004). To our knowledge, data
that have been collected from 2008 through 20011 reveal a rate of depres-
sion in adolescents with PCOS with rates of approximately 50% (n=119)
in a treatment-seeking sample. The intriguing aspect of the relationship
between obesity and depression is that it is biochemical in nature. To date,
only two studies have carefully explored the relationship among laboratory
values, depression, and weight in adult women with PCOS. Preliminary
findings reveal 1) testosterone levels that are slightly elevated and signifi-
cantly related to depression after controlling for weight (Weiner et al.
2004), and 2) higher body mass index (BMI) and insulin resistance in de-
pressed women (Rasgon et al. 2003). Therefore, adolescents with PCOS
present as an ideal treatment-seeking pediatric population given the high
comorbidity of obesity and depression.
In this chapter, we review the psychological consequences associated
with childhood obesity; provide empirical evidence for cognitive-behavior
therapy (CBT) to treat obesity; and provide an overview of the theory and
application of Healthy Bodies, Healthy Minds—a manualized CBT inter-
vention created to address concomitant obesity and depression in female
adolescents with PCOS.
Psychological Correlates of
Pediatric Obesity
In addition to the adverse physical health effects of pediatric obesity (BMI
percentile ≥95), a growing body of evidence indicates damaging psychoso-
cial consequences of severe overweight (BMI percentile ≥85). These in-
clude weight-based teasing (Eisenberg et al. 2003), social isolation and
discrimination (Latner and Stunkard 2003), body dissatisfaction and low
self-esteem (Eisenberg et al. 2003; Pierce and Wardle 1997), and depres-
sion and anxiety (Goodman and Whitaker 2002).
Body Dissatisfaction
Reviews conclude that obese children, particularly girls, exhibit greater
body dissatisfaction than their normal-weight peers (Ricciardelli and Mc-
Cabe 2001; Wardle and Cooke 2005). Further, body dissatisfaction may
have a negative impact on self-esteem in obese children. More recent data
document a mediation effect for body dissatisfaction in the association be-
tween obesity and self-esteem in a sample of elementary school children
(Shin and Shin 2008).
Low Self-Esteem
The internalization of weight-based discrimination may have negative im-
plications for self-esteem in obese youth. Weight-based teasing has been
associated with poorer self-esteem and an increased likelihood of depres-
sion among adolescents (Eisenberg et al. 2003). Prospective data demon-
strate that weight-based peer teasing, along with parental weight criticism,
mediates the relationship between overweight and low self-concept in
obese adolescents (Davison and Birch 2002). Further, weight-related teas-
ing has been shown to account for associations between weight and body
dissatisfaction in youth (Lunner et al. 2000; van den Berg et al. 2002). This
result appears to extend into adulthood, as a retrospective study of adults
reported an association between childhood weight-based teasing and
adulthood body dissatisfaction (Grilo et al. 1994).
Prospective studies examining the development of low self-esteem and
obesity generally show that excess weight in children predicts future low
self-esteem (Brown et al. 1998; Davison and Birch 2001, 2002; Hesketh
et al. 2004; Strauss 2000; Tiggemann 2005). Epidemiological (French et
al. 1996) and clinical (Zeller et al. 2004) data also demonstrate that body
mass is inversely related to self-esteem in children, although compre-
hensive reviews of self-esteem and obesity reveal this relationship to be
modest (French et al. 1995; Wardle and Cooke 2005). However, the rela-
tionship between self-esteem and obesity appears to be stronger when
obese children are compared with their nonobese peers, specifically on
measures of physical self-perception (Braet et al. 1997) rather than global
self-esteem.
CBT
One of the most empirically validated modalities for psychosocial aspects
of obesity is CBT. In pediatric obesity, the goal of CBT is to assist youth in
reducing self-defeating thoughts around wellness behaviors. It is important
to assist the patient in identifying more adaptive coping strategies, such as
less emotional eating, more assertiveness, and greater need sharing. When
applied in this context, CBT helps patients gain insight into the connec-
tions among their thought processes, emotional responses, and eating be-
haviors. CBT strategies attempt to address issues that may have been
overlooked in early behavioral programs, including cognitive distortions re-
Obesity and Depression 389
Motivational Interviewing
Although CBT is considered to be the safest modality for weight loss in
youth, compliance issues often lead the families of obese children and ad-
olescents to seek alternative, though riskier, strategies (e.g., pharmaco-
therapy, bariatric surgery) (Miller and Silverstein 2007). Motivational
interviewing techniques aimed toward enhancing adherence to dietary and
exercise recommendations in children and families could play a key role in
promoting safe and effective long-term weight management. Motivational
interviewing is a therapeutic strategy aimed at helping individuals to ex-
plore ambivalence about making behavioral changes and has been sug-
gested as a possible tool for helping achieve dietary and physical activity
modifications (DiLillo et al. 2004). Using reflective listening and methods
to elicit “change talk,” motivational interviewing seeks to resolve ambiva-
lence and strengthen clients’ reasons for engaging in positive behavior
change consistent with their goals and values (Miller and Rollnick 1991).
390 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Behavioral Facets
Dietary Guidelines
The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and The Obesity Society
recommend low caloric intake that is intended to induce a caloric deficit
greater than 500 kcal/day and thus assist children in losing approximately
0.5–1 pound per week. Moreover, specific guidelines are given for girls try-
ing to lose excess body weight, with consideration given to medical factors
(e.g., a certain percentage of calories should come from protein versus car-
bohydrates).
Physical Activity
The American College of Sports Medicine recommends 60 minutes per day
of physical activity for children. Physical activity refers to any movement
that occurs throughout the course of the day. For obese patients, small, man-
ageable changes typically lead to an increased heart rate and subsequent
weight loss. Therefore, physical activity during a CBT obesity treatment
should focus on activities targeted to the abilities of obese patients.
Self-Monitoring
Self-monitoring, or recording food intake (time, amount, calories, rela-
tionship to mood) and physical activity (type, duration, steps taken), is the
most important skill taught in standard behavioral programs. Being able to
accurately measure caloric intake and energy expenditure assists patients
and their families in reaching weight-loss goals.
Goal Setting
Setting goals is important for achieving success and overcoming challenges.
In a CBT obesity treatment, setting weekly reasonable goals for nutrition,
physical activity, and general lifestyle (i.e., positive thinking) is a major
component.
392 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Relaxation Training
Diaphragmatic breathing, progressive muscle relaxation, and guided imag-
ery are also taught during the intervention, to help the participant cope
with stressful situations. As more data show that aberrant eating patterns
may be due to emotionally stimulating events, relaxation training becomes
an even more salient component of obesity treatment.
Behavioral Activation
The participant is reminded to increase time spent in pleasurable activities
on a daily basis. Given the nature of obesity, small, manageable aspects of
behavioral activation are discussed (e.g., putting tennis shoes on as a first
step to being more active).
Cognitive Skills
Problem Solving
This lifestyle skill is emphasized to address healthier food intake, more
consistent and variable physical activity, and roadblocks to positive think-
ing. In the intervention, problem solving is encouraged by identifying what
the problem is, generating different solutions, and evaluating the conse-
quences of each solution.
Obesity and Depression 393
Cognitive Restructuring
When using this critical component of CBT for obesity, the coach (i.e.,
therapist) encourages the participant to identify dysfunctional thinking
and identify more adaptive, countering ways to reduce negative thinking.
By the end of the intervention, participants should be able to provide
countering alternatives to minimize stressors and maladaptive thinking
surrounding the presenting problem.
Relapse Prevention
This skill is used to help reinforce the CBT model and monitor for recur-
rence of weight gain and/or depression and to prepare for future stressors.
Further, the distinction between lapses (“slip-ups”) and relapses is dis-
cussed with the patient to prevent lapses from becoming relapses.
Component Description
Treatment Overview
Table 11–2 provides an overview of the behaviors targeted in HBHM. This
11-session “dose” is an initial active-phase treatment for adolescents with
obesity and co-occurring mood disturbance presenting within a clinical set-
ting. Because 8–12 sessions have been empirically validated for adoles-
cents with major depression and 4–12 sessions have been associated with
significant initial weight loss for adolescents presenting to outpatient obe-
sity centers, an 11-session intervention is implemented. However, the ac-
knowledgment needs to be made that longer, more intensive HBHM
treatments may be more efficacious.
Family-Based Sessions
Incorporating the family into the treatment plan is crucial for success. Of-
ten, parents and other family members dictate what food choices the ad-
olescent has at home. Additionally, the lifestyle habits of adolescents tend
Obesity and Depression 397
Session Behaviors
Many parents cannot easily cook every meal at home due to time constraints,
so the coach also addresses ways that parents can encourage healthy food
choices when dining out, complete with calorie charts from many restaurants.
The second parent session focuses on parenting strategies that the par-
ent can use to encourage healthy behaviors and discourage less healthy
habits. The coach will discuss the difference between reinforcement and
punishment, describing in detail the difference between positive rein-
forcement (giving something to encourage a behavior) and negative rein-
forcement (taking something away to discourage a behavior). During this
session, the coach guides and encourages parents to use positive reinforce-
ment (such as praise) by describing the utility of this strategy. The coach
also provides brief assertiveness training and techniques for setting limits
and rules within the home.
The third parent session focuses on preparing parents to serve as coaches
at home by providing an overview of the content that the behavior coach
has covered with the participant during the intervention. Here, the behavior
coach describes all of the tools that the participant has been educated to use
so that parents can encourage use within the home environment.
havior coach express his or her own desires (i.e., for the coach to avoid the
impulse of “righting the wrong”).
• Working with change and adherence talk: Change talk and adherence talk
are the “positive” side of ambivalence—indications that the patient desires
to work at overcoming her eating habits, physical activity behavior, or de-
pression. A patient’s change and adherence talk also indicate that she
would like to receive help, sees a need for treatment and/or change, has
reasons for committing to treatment and/or change, or believes she has the
ability to succeed at changing or sustaining a commitment to treatment.
• Supporting self-efficacy: Self-efficacy refers to a patient’s beliefs about
how likely she is to succeed at something she tries to do. Self-efficacy
plays a key role in engaging patients in treatment. No matter how much
the patient comes to believe she needs support, a patient who doesn’t
believe that she can succeed at treatment is unlikely to try very hard to
stick with it.
S Case Example
Mary, a 16-year-old, overweight, depressed adolescent girl diagnosed with
PCOS, was referred by her family doctor. Mary currently lives at home
with her parents, who are also overweight, and her older brother, who is
athletic and is not overweight. Mary is currently in the eleventh grade and
attends a local public high school.
Obesity and Depression 401
Mary has been overweight for most of her life, and she currently has a
BMI of 32. In addition to struggling with weight-loss issues, most recently,
Mary has found herself struggling academically and socially: her grades
have plummeted from As and Bs to Cs and Ds, and she is brutally teased
by her classmates because of her weight. Mary states that she has stopped
doing her homework because she won’t do well on it anyway, and she re-
cently failed a science test. Mary has started to eat her school lunch by her-
self because she is teased when she eats with classmates.
Mary finds herself feeling depressed 4 out of 7 days of the week and
often isolates herself during these periods, preferring to spend time alone
in her bedroom watching television or sleeping. Mary’s mother states that
during these episodes, Mary is irritable and argumentative and usually ends
up crying when confronted. Lately, Mary has been truant from school, re-
fusing to attend school at least once a week because she “feels sick.”
Mary often finds herself feeling out of control when she is eating, and
these bingeing episodes usually occur during her postschool snack. In the
past, Mary has tried a national weight loss program, a popular fad diet, and
diet pills. She lost weight with all three approaches but gained it all back
within a few months. Mary states that she eats fast food weekly and knows
that she “shouldn’t” because it is “bad.” Mary is frustrated and believes
that she is incapable of losing weight permanently and believes that nothing
will ever work, so why should she try?
At the beginning of the therapeutic intervention, Mary, a straight talker,
quickly admitted that she is not happy to be seeing a counselor and feels that
her mother is forcing her to be involved. Mary states that she doesn’t care to
be told what to do by someone who doesn’t understand her personal situation.
However, by Mary’s second session with her new counselor, she has admitted
that she does not dread attending sessions anymore. She has started to consis-
tently complete her in-between session assignments but always prefaces her
discussion about them by saying that she’s sure that she “didn’t do it right.”
Application
Session 1: Introduction to the Program
During this session, the behavior coach will introduce the purpose of The
PCOS Lifestyle Program. The coach will discuss the definition of lifestyle
change and how this differs from a diet. There will be ongoing conversa-
tions about all-or-nothing thinking and how it may be more helpful to the
patient to engage in behaviors that are sustainable. The concept of weight
maintenance, gain, and loss will be elucidated using calorie-in/calorie-out
scales with an emphasis on caloric intake and energy expenditure. Also, it
may be helpful to discuss the patient’s previous successes or failures,
which may serve as building blocks for future goals.
The next objective of this session is to discuss the link between PCOS
and depression and to assess how the participant is personally affected by
402 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
depression. The coach will help the participant to connect sadness through
emotions, thoughts, and behaviors (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 1). Note
that some patients may have depressive symptoms but not depression per
se. Coaches should be cognizant of how they phrase “depression” and al-
low the adolescent to claim or disclaim the symptoms. Assist the adoles-
cent in making a connection between family history, stressful life events,
PCOS, and focusing on negative experiences. Following this discussion, a
general overview of CBT and how it can help with weight loss and mood
is provided. The coach also introduces the general concepts for the ACT
and THINK acronyms: that people can control their feelings by 1) how
they act and/or 2) how they think (see Chapter 10, Appendix 10–A, for
the ACT and THINK chart).
The session includes a get-acquainted exercise designed to build rap-
port, in which the participant talks about three of her strengths. This ex-
ercise not only allows the coach to get to know the participant but also
serves to emphasize positive thinking over negative self-thoughts. Note
that some participants may be so depressed that they cannot think of three
strengths. If this happens and the coach has given the participant plenty of
silence, the coach should help the patient in order to reduce any discom-
fort in the first session. For example, the coach can say, “Would it be OK
if I shared something with you that I noticed from our work today that
I think is one of your strengths?” Additionally, depending on rapport, the
coach can then highlight the fact that the participant had difficulty coming
up with three strengths. This observation can serve as a building block to
emphasize empowering the participant to think positively, both generally
and about herself. Following this exercise, the participant sets three spe-
cific lifestyle goals to accomplish over the course of the program (Appen-
dix 11–A, Worksheet 2). Note that if the participant sets a specific weight-
loss goal, direct her to break it down into behaviors that are realistic (not
idealistic) and that could lead to weight loss.
Toward the end of the session, the coach should also start the weight
tracker (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 3) that will be used at the beginning
of each session when the participant gets weighed. Discuss what it feels
like for the participant to get weighed. In very rare exceptions, weights are
not shared with the participant; otherwise, explain that actual weight is
important as a concrete measure of behavioral changes that the participant
is making throughout the program.
The session concludes with an explanation of the first practice assign-
ments:
1. Having the participant monitor her mood using the Mood Monitoring
sheet (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 4).
Obesity and Depression 403
2. Setting goals for the next week (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 2).
3. Using the ACT and THINK chart before the next session (Chapter 10,
Appendix 10–A).
1. Discuss lifestyle goals and wellness accomplishments over the past week.
2. Review the ACT and THINK chart.
3. Introduce the PCOS food pyramid.
4. Establish food and activity logging.
To begin the session, thermometer ratings are used to gauge the partic-
ipant’s perception of her current levels of eating healthy, being active, feel-
ing good, and feeling bad (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 5). Research has
shown that in adolescents with depression, feeling “good” and “bad” are
actually two distinct facets of emotion. In other words, on separate mood
thermometers for feeling good and feeling bad, an adolescent can feel
mildly good but still feel really bad (i.e., depressed kids ruminate about
bad things but have difficulty savoring good events). After the participant
states a number, ask what that number means to her. The coach can also
use motivational interviewing to better understand why the number is a 5
and not a 4. The coach will also discuss the worksheet “What It’s Like
When I Feel Good” (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 6) with the participant.
At this point, focus on helping the patient to identify that feeling good isn’t
just a feeling, but that it makes other people feel a certain way toward her
and that it has somatic and behavioral consequences as well.
Proper nutrition plays a large role in the management of PCOS, and
this session focuses on how to eat healthy with PCOS. For the next several
pages of the manual (not provided here), allow the patient to read the in-
formation about a healthy diet, if she would like to. We don’t want this ac-
tivity to get too monotonous, especially if the patient already knows the
material. Instead, focus on the fact that even very minimal weight loss has
a long-standing impact on health. Also emphasize that the participant is
not going on a diet, but instead making lifestyle changes that will become
part of her life. The coach then discusses different weight management
tools (the PCOS Pyramid, 5/2/10 Guideline, Healthy Plate [Appendix
11–A, Worksheets 7–9, respectively], and the Traffic Light Diet) but en-
courages the participant to select only those tools that work best for her.
This session concludes with a discussion about the role that self-moni-
toring plays in weight loss with a focus on 1) tracking weight, 2) monitor-
404 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ing food and physical activity, and 3) making conclusions about the
relationship between weight and mood. Lifestyle and mood goals are set
for the following week.
The coach will start this session by reviewing the concept of emotional
eating versus overeating and explore whether these are challenges for the
patient. The coach will discuss these concepts by normalizing both types of
eating and attempting to elicit intrinsic motivation to identify these situa-
tions. The participant may have a lot of shame surrounding these concepts,
and at times, her self-disclosure may also be warranted. If nothing is dis-
closed, the coach can say something like “Other young women with PCOS
share with me that after school is their high-risk time. And I guess carbs are
the hardest to resist.” The coach will also address how negative thinking can
lead to emotional eating by reviewing different cognitive distortions (e.g.,
“I’ve always failed when I’ve tried to lose weight, so I’ll never be able to”);
revealing what negative self-talk (e.g., “I didn’t go to the gym today so my
weight loss efforts are a total failure”) can lead to, with a focus on eating
and wellness (e.g., concession of weight loss goals); and discussing how to
overcome overeating. The coach will want to return to the ACT and
THINK chart to illustrate that some of the skills used for addressing nega-
tive mood can also help with overeating and emotional eating.
Next, the session focuses on overcoming overeating by discussing food
cravings and PCOS. Many women with PCOS experience food cravings,
especially for starchy foods. The coach will discuss that these cravings can
sometimes lead to overeating, but more importantly, will focus on pointers
for combating food cravings cognitively. When cravings won’t stop, the
coach also provides pointers for how to cope with them behaviorally.
There are worksheets to complete after review of the session. One of
the most important worksheets for this program is the cognitive restruc-
turing worksheet, Cognitive Self-Monitoring (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet
10). Generally, the coach completes the first example provided and asks
for the patient to provide another example to elucidate the concept. Em-
phasize that the “Countering (alternatives, evidence)” column may be the
most challenging. Stress the importance of using material from this session
in the patient’s daily life after she leaves the session meeting place. Be-
cause the coach and patient exercise at the end of each session, coaches
periodically meet participants outside the clinical setting. Relaxation train-
ing is also incorporated. Typically, coaches allow the patient to pick one of
three relaxation methods (deep breathing, imagery, or progressive muscle
relaxation), but some patients may want to try each one. Feel free to be
creative and let the patient guide the activity (e.g., yoga with deep breath-
ing). Encourage the patient to practice these skills (e.g., turning negative
thoughts into positive thoughts, relaxation training).
The coach will discuss nutrition labels with the participant; typically, the
patient may know what the nutrition label shows but may feel confused
about exactly what to concentrate on changing. Go back to the 5/2/10 guide-
line and ask if the patient has used this tool. Explain that the Traffic Light
Guide is yet another tool that she may find helpful. Emphasize that some
people like it, whereas others find it too elementary. Overall, >5 g fat=RED
food, 2–5 g fat=YELLOW food, and <2 g fat=GREEN food. Although re-
ducing red foods to one or two per day is a goal, ask the participant what
would seem reasonable for her. Encourage the patient to record the red foods
as an in-between session assignment and to reduce those foods by one or two
items the subsequent days until she reaches the goal that was agreed on.
Explain that the Traffic Light Guide fits well with the PCOS Eating
Plan. The PCOS Eating Plan contains primarily green and yellow foods,
and the coach can use the PCOS Pyramid (see Appendix 11–A, Worksheet
406 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
7) to help guide appropriate serving sizes. Focus on portion sizes and por-
tion distortion. Be aware that most adolescents know this information but
that implementing the knowledge is a challenge. Remember to set goals
with the patient: logging food intake, physical activity, and mood; labeling
red foods consumed; and any other goals.
The coach will begin this session by eliciting from the participant what
she thinks the difference is between physical activity and exercise and dis-
cussing her response. Physical activity is any activity that causes the body
to work harder than normal and can involve a number of daily tasks,
whereas exercise is a planned, structured, and repetitive movement done
to improve or maintain physical fitness.
Additional ways in which physical activity can be increased should be
discussed. The coach will also discuss the different types of physical activ-
ity with the participant: aerobic exercise—activity that increases breathing
and heart rate; resistance exercise—exercise that increases the ability to
exert or resist force and makes the muscles stronger; and stretching—
activity that improves flexibility by warming up and lengthening the mus-
cles. After showing the participant the activity pyramid (Appendix 11–A,
Worksheet 11), probe for understanding. Ask about anything that stands
out or that she finds surprising. Clarify any confusion. At the end of the
session, help the participant set realistic physical activity and exercise goals
to complete before session 6. Although working out every day is ideal, em-
phasize realistic goals. Share with the participant that setting idealistic
goals sometimes leads to failure and an exacerbation of negative mood
symptoms. Set physical activity goals and encourage the participant to use
her pedometer to increase the number of steps taken.
First, assess the patient’s level of familiarity with the term self-aware-
ness, asking what she thinks it might mean. Many participants have never
heard this term used before in this context, so it is important to discuss its
meaning. Once the general definition is discussed and understood, discuss
what it means to be aware when eating. This type of self-awareness in-
volves focusing on what she is eating and drinking and noticing all of the
physical and mental sensations that occur before, while, and after the item
is consumed. Next, the coach should discuss awareness of physical activity.
Start by assessing what the participant thinks this could mean and discuss-
ing her experience with physical activity awareness. Awareness of physical
activity generally means noticing how her body feels when in motion:
breathing, heart rate, muscle movements, posture, coordination, and flow
(or being “in the zone”). Discuss with the participant whether she has ex-
perienced any of these things during physical activity. Last, discuss the par-
ticipant’s awareness of her mood. This means paying attention to her
emotions, knowing how she is feeling, and recognizing ways that she can
408 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
change her emotions. The coach can then practice the mood awareness ac-
tivity with the patient by focusing on the patient’s ability to control her
emotions (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 13). Note that more succinct dis-
tinctions for the concepts of mood, emotion, and affect are given in other
manualized treatments but that HBHM focuses on overall emotion, and at
times, depressive symptoms.
During this session, the coach will also discuss challenges to maintain-
ing a healthy lifestyle. The coach will talk about food temptations that
seem to be everywhere, inappropriate portion sizes that have become
common practice, and environmental cues that can signal overeating. Al-
low the participant to openly talk about challenges that she may face.
Given that most people encounter problems and challenges throughout
life, it is important to learn how to effectively manage them. During this
session, the coach will introduce the STEPS worksheet, allowing the par-
ticipant to apply this method of problem solving to an example that she
has faced recently.
This week, the participant should complete the STEPS worksheet for
one challenge she faces between now and the next session. Talk about jour-
naling and how this relates to self-awareness, and set a goal with the par-
ticipant for her to journal a certain number of days. Set any additional
wellness goals that the participant would like to achieve.
The coach should make sure that the participant understands how to
use the problem-solving worksheet when faced with a challenge; see if the
participant can state the challenge, brainstorm possible solutions, weigh
pros and cons of each solution, try one out, and assess whether that solu-
tion worked. Planning ahead for the future is important to ensure future
success when challenges are faced. During this session, the coach will dis-
cuss with the participant ways to plan ahead for daily meals, snacks, phys-
ical activity, special occasions, and challenges to positive thinking. An
entire packet is available highlighting healthier choices while dining out,
with a special emphasis on meals and foods that fall within the 5/2/10
Obesity and Depression 409
guideline. Because this is the last session in the intensive intervention (be-
fore the monthly booster sessions), goals are set that highlight continued
change. Encourage the patient to call to move the appointment to an ear-
lier date if challenges arise. Commend the participant for completing the
intensive part of the intervention and make sure to set wellness goals.
Booster Sessions
After the intensive part of the intervention, participants are encouraged to
attend three monthly booster sessions. For some young women, these are
maintenance sessions where they check in on their weight and mood. For
others (and contrary to the outcome in some pediatric obesity treat-
ments), young women begin to use the skills that they have learned and
begin to lose more weight and feel more positive. Booster session 1 con-
centrates on the patient’s physical illness narrative (see Chapter 10, Ap-
pendix 10–A). This serves to assist the coach and patient in better
understanding what it means for the patient to have PCOS. Booster ses-
sion 2 focuses on living with PCOS and attaining support from the pa-
tient’s environment. Topics that may be discussed consist of support
networks and feeling uncomfortable talking with peers about having
PCOS. Booster session 3 centers on reflecting not only about the program
but also about having PCOS (Appendix 11–A, Worksheet 14). Although
some participants decide that this session is the end of their HBHM jour-
ney, we offer participants follow-up sessions in our clinical PCOS pro-
gram.
Self-Assessment Questions
11.1. Which is not typically a psychological correlate of adolescent obesity?
A. Low self-esteem.
B. Compromised body image.
C. Depression.
D. Obsessive-compulsive traits.
C. CBT can target both the obesity and depression that these ado-
lescents may experience.
D. CBT can activate adolescents to exercise more frequently.
11.3. Which comorbid condition may CBT assist in the treatment of ado-
lescents with obesity and depression?
A. Obsessive-compulsive disorder.
B. Posttraumatic stress disorder.
C. Eating disorder not otherwise specified.
D. Alcohol dependence.
11.4. Which of the following is not a key strategy used during motivational
interviewing as a complementary approach to CBT?
A. Open-ended questions.
B. Nondirective empathy.
C. Affirmations.
D. Reflective listening.
11.5. An 8-year-old boy comes into the clinic with a body mass index per-
centile of 99.9. He complains that his family has a lot of high-fat,
high-calorie food in the home. Both parents are obese, and they
question why they should have to change their habits for their child.
Which of the following CBT techniques is most logical to employ
with this child and his family?
A. Behavioral activation.
B. Self-monitoring.
C. Stimulus control.
D. Cognitive restructuring.
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
Belle SH, Berk PD, Courcoulas AP, et al: Safety and efficacy of bariatric
surgery: longitudinal assessment of bariatric surgery. Surg Obes Relat
Dis 3:116–126, 2007
Dunican KC, Desilets AR, Montalbano JK: Pharmacotherapeutic options
for overweight adolescents. Ann Pharmacother 41:1445–1455, 2007
Obesity and Depression 413
References
Anderson SE, Cohen P, Naumova EN, et al: Relationship of childhood behavior dis-
orders to weight gain from childhood into adulthood. Ambul Pediatr 6:297–
301, 2006
Apter D, Butzow T, Laughlin GA, et al: Metabolic features of polycystic ovary syn-
drome are found in adolescent girls with hyperandrogenism. J Clin Endocrinol
Metab 80:2966–2973, 1995
Aragona J, Cassady J, Drabman RS: Treating overweight children through parental
training and contingency contracting. J Appl Behav Anal 8:269–278, 1975
Arslanian SA, Witchel SF: Polycystic ovary syndrome in adolescents: is there an ep-
idemic? Curr Opin Endocrinol Diabetes 9:32–42, 2002
Azziz R, Kashar-Miller MD: Family history as a risk factor for the polycystic ovary
syndrome. J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab 13:1303–1306, 2000
Azziz R, Carmina E, Dewailly D, et al: Positions statement: criteria for defining poly-
cystic ovary syndrome as a predominantly hyperandrogenic syndrome: an An-
drogen Excess Society guideline. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 91:4237–4245, 2006
414 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Bauer KW, Yang YW, Austin SB: “How can we stay healthy when you’re throwing
all of this in front of us?” Findings from focus groups and interviews in middle
schools on environmental influences on nutrition and physical activity. Health
Educ Behav 31:34–46, 2004
Becque MD, Katch VL, Rocchini AP, et al: Coronary risk incidence of obese ado-
lescents: reduction by exercise plus diet intervention. Pediatrics 81:605–612,
1988
Berg-Smith SM, Stevens VJ, Brown KM, et al: A brief motivational intervention to
improve dietary adherence in adolescents. The Dietary Intervention Study in
Children (DISC) Research Group. Health Educ Res 14:399–410, 1999
Braet C, Mervielde I, Vandereycken W: Psychological aspects of childhood obesity:
a controlled study in a clinical and nonclinical sample. J Pediatr Psychol
22:59–71, 1997
Brewis A: Biocultural aspects of obesity in young Mexican schoolchildren. Am J
Hum Biol 15:446–460, 2003
Britz B, Siegfried W, Ziegler A, et al: Rates of psychiatric disorders in a clinical
study group of adolescents with extreme obesity and in obese adolescents as-
certained via a population based study. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord
24:1707–1714, 2000
Brown KM, McMahon RP, Biro FM, et al: Changes in self-esteem in black and
white girls between the ages of 9 and 14 years: the NHLBI Growth and
Health Study. J Adolesc Health 23:7--19, 1998
Brownell K, Kelman J, Stunkard A: Treatment of obese children with and without
their mothers: changes in weight and blood pressure. Pediatrics 71:513–523,
1983
Buddeburg-Fisher B, Klaghofer R, Reed V, et al: Associations between body weight,
psychiatric disorders and body image in female adolescents. Psychother Psy-
chosom 68:325–332, 1999
Cash TF: The Body Image Workbook: An Eight-Step Program for Learning to Like
Your Looks, 2nd Edition. Oakland, CA, New Harbinger Publications, 2008
Coates TJ, Thoresen CE: Behavior and weight changes in three obese adolescents.
Behav Ther 12:383–399, 1981
Coates TJ, Killen JD, Slinkard LA: Parent participation in a treatment program for
overweight adolescents. Int J Eat Disord 1:37–48, 1982
Dahl R, Spear LP (eds): Adolescent Brain Development: Vulnerabilities and Op-
portunities. New York, New York Academy of Sciences, 2004
Davison KK, Birch LL: Family environmental factors influencing the developing be-
havioral controls of food intake and childhood overweight. Pediatr Clin North
Am 48:893–907, 2001
Davison KK, Birch LL: Processes linking weight status and self-concept in girls at
ages 5 and 7 years. Dev Psychol 38:735–748, 2002
Davison KK, Birch LL: Predictors of fat stereotypes among 9-year-old girls and
their parents. Obes Res 12:86–94, 2004
DiLillo V, Siegfried NJ, Smith WD: Incorporating motivational interviewing into
behavioral obesity treatment. Cogn Behav Pract 10:120–130, 2004
Duffy G, Spence SH: The effectiveness of cognitive self-management as an ad-
junct to a behavioural intervention for childhood obesity: a research note.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry 34:1043–1050, 1993
Obesity and Depression 415
Dunn C, Deroo L, Rivara FP: The use of brief interventions adapted from motiva-
tional interviewing across behavioral domains: a systematic review. Addiction
12:1725–1742, 2001
Eisenberg ME, Neumark-Sztainer D, Story M: Associations of weight-based teas-
ing and emotional well-being among adolescents. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
157:733–738, 2003
Elsenbruch S, Hahn S, Kowalsky D, et al: Quality of life, psychosocial well-being,
and sexual satisfaction in women with polycystic ovary syndrome. J Clin En-
docrinol Metab 88:5801–5807, 2003
Emes C, Velde B, Moreau M, et al: An activity based weight control program.
Adapt Phys Activ Q 7:314–324, 1990
Epstein LH, Goldfield GS: Physical activity in the treatment of childhood over-
weight and obesity: current evidence and research issues. Med Sci Sports Ex-
erc 31(suppl):S553–S559, 1999
Epstein LH, Squires S (eds): The Stoplight Diet for Children. Boston, MA, Little,
Brown, 1988
Epstein LH, Wing RR: Aerobic exercise and weight. Addict Behav 5:371–388,
1980
Epstein LH, Wing RR, Koeske R, et al: Child and parent weight loss in family based
behavior modification programs. J Consult Clin Psychol 49:674–685, 1981
Epstein LH, Wing RR, Koeske R, et al: Effects of diet plus exercise on weight
change in parents and children. J Consult Clin Psychol 52:429–437, 1984
Epstein LH, Wing RR, Penner BC, et al: Effect of diet and controlled exercise on
weight loss in obese children. J Pediatr 107:358–361, 1985
Epstein LH, Valoski AM, Kalarchian MA, et al: Do children lose and maintain
weight easier than adults: a comparison of child and parent weight changes
from six months to ten years. Obes Res 3:411–417, 1995
Epstein LH, Paluch RA, Gordy CC, et al: Decreasing sedentary behaviors in treat-
ing pediatric obesity. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 154:220–226, 2000
Epstein LH, Gordy CC, Raynor HA, et al: Increasing fruit and vegetable intake and
decreasing fat and sugar intake in families at risk for childhood obesity. Obes
Res 9:171–178, 2001
Epstein LH, Paluch RA, Beecher MD, et al: Increasing healthy eating vs. reducing
high energy–dense foods to treat pediatric obesity. Obesity 16:318–326, 2008
Erermis S, Cetin N, Tamar M, et al: Is obesity a risk factor for psychopathology
among adolescents? Pediatr Int 46:296–301, 2004
Faith MS, Allison DB, Geliebter A: Emotional eating and obesity: theoretical con-
siderations and practical recommendations, in Overweight and Weight Man-
agement: The Health Professional’s Guide to Understanding and Practice.
Edited by Dalton S. Gaithersburg, MD, Aspen, 1997, pp 439–465
Faith MS, Matz PE, Jorge MA: Obesity-depression associations in the population.
J Psychosom Res 53:935–942, 2002
Flodmark CE, Ohlsson T, Ryden O, et al: Prevention of progression to severe obe-
sity in a group of obese schoolchildren treated with family therapy. Pediatrics
91:880–884, 1993
Ford ES, Galuska DA, Gillespie C, et al: C-reactive protein and body mass index
in children: findings from the Third National Health and Nutrition Examina-
tion Survey, 1988–1994. J Pediatr 138:486–492, 2001
416 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Lamertz CM, Jacobi C, Yassouridis A, et al: Are obese adolescents and young adults
at risk for mental disorders? A community survey. Obes Res 10:1152–1160,
2002
Latner JD, Stunkard AJ: Getting worse: the stigmatization of obese children. Obes
Res 11:452–456, 2003
Legro RS: Detection of insulin resistance and its treatment in adolescents with
polycystic ovary syndrome. J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab 5 (suppl 5):1367–
1378, 2002
Levine M, Ringham R, Kalarchian M, et al: Is family based behavioral weight con-
trol appropriate for severe pediatric obesity? Int J Eat Disord 30:318–328,
2001
Lewinsohn PM, Hops H, Roberts RE, et al: Adolescent psychopathology: I. Preva-
lence and incidence of depression and other DSM-III-R disorders in high
school students. J Abnorm Psychol 102:133–144, 1993
Lewinsohn PM, Rohde P, Seeley JR: Major depressive disorder in older adoles-
cents: prevalence, risk factors, and clinical implications. Clin Psychol Rev
18:765–794, 1998
Lewy VD, Danadain K, Witchel SF, et al: Early metabolic abnormalities in adoles-
cent girls with polycystic ovarian syndrome. J Pediatr 138:38–44, 2001
Lunner K, Werthem EH, Thompson KJ, et al: A cross-cultural examination of
weight-related teasing, body image, and eating disturbance in Swedish and
Australian samples. Int J Eat Disord 28:430–435, 2000
Magarey AM, Daniels LA, Boulton TJ, et al: Predicting obesity in early adulthood
from childhood and parental obesity. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 27:505–
513, 2003
Miller JL, Silverstein JH: Management approaches for pediatric obesity. Nat Clin
Pract Endocrinol Metab 3:810–818, 2007
Miller WR, Rollnick S: Motivational Interviewing: Preparing People to Change Ad-
dictive Behavior. New York, Guilford, 1991
Miller WR, Rollnick S: Motivational Interviewing: Preparing People for Change.
New York, Guilford, 2002
Morin-Papunen L, Vauhkonen I, Koivunen R, et al: Metformin versus ethinyl estra-
diol–cyproterone acetate in the treatment of nonobese women with polycys-
tic ovary syndrome: a randomized study. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 88:148–
156, 2003
Mustillo S, Worthman C, Erkanli A, et al: Obesity and psychiatric disorder: devel-
opmental trajectories. Pediatrics 111:851–859, 2003
Neumark-Sztainer D, Story M, Harris T: Beliefs and attitudes about obesity among
teachers and school health care providers working with adolescents. J Nutr
Educ 3:3–9, 1999
Neumark-Sztainer D, Falkner N, Story M, et al: Weight-teasing among adoles-
cents: correlations with weight status and disordered eating behaviors. Int J
Obes Relat Metab Disord 26:123–131, 2002
Ogden CL, Carroll MD, Lester RC, et al: Prevalence of overweight and obesity in
the United States, 1994–2004. JAMA 295:1549–1555, 2006
Palmert MR, Gordon CM, Kartashov AI, et al: Screening for abnormal glucose tol-
erance in adolescents with polycystic ovary syndrome. J Clin Endocrinol
Metab 87:1017–1023, 2002
418 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Pearce MJ, Boergers J, Prinstein MJ: Adolescent obesity, overt and relational peer
victimization, and romantic relationships. Obes Res 10:386–393, 2002
Phillips J, Hull E, Rofey D: Childhood obesity: highlights of the American Medical
Association (AMA) Expert Committee Recommendations. American Acad-
emy of Family Physicians 38:411–419, 2010
Pierce JW, Wardle J: Cause and effect beliefs and self-esteem of overweight chil-
dren. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 38:645–650, 1997
Pine DS, Cohen P, Brook J, et al: Psychiatric symptoms in adolescence as predictors
of obesity in early adulthood: a longitudinal study. Am J Public Health
87:1303–1310, 1997
Puhl RM, Latner JD: Stigma, obesity, and the health of the nation’s children. Psy-
chol Bull 133:557–580, 2007
Rasgon NL, Rao RC, Hwang S, et al: Depression in women with polycystic ovary
syndrome: clinical and biochemical correlates. J Affect Disord 74:299–304,
2003
Renjilian D, Perri M, Nezu A, et al: Individual versus group therapy for obesity: ef-
fects of matching participants to their treatment preferences. J Consult Clin
Psychol 69:717–721, 2001
Resnicow K, Taylor R, Baskin M, et al: Results of go girls: a weight control program
for overweight African-American adolescent females. Obes Res 13:1739–
1748, 2005
Resnicow K, Davis R, Rollnick S: Motivational interviewing for pediatric obesity:
conceptual issues and evidence review. J Am Diet Assoc 106:2024–2033, 2006
Ricciardelli LA, McCabe MP: Children’s eating concerns and eating disturbances:
a review of the literature. Clin Psychol Rev 21:325–344, 2001
Richardson L, Davis R, Poulton R, et al: A longitudinal evaluation of adolescent de-
pression and adult obesity. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 157:739–745, 2003
Rocchini AP, Katch V, Anderson J, et al: Blood pressure in obese adolescents: effect
of weight loss. Pediatrics 82:16–23, 1988
Rofey DL, Kolko RP, Iosif AM, et al: A longitudinal study of childhood depression
and anxiety in relation to weight gain. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev 40:517–
526, 2009a
Rofey DL, Szigethy EM, Noll RB, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy for physical
and emotional disturbances in adolescents with polycystic ovary syndrome: a
pilot study. J Pediatr Psychol 34:156–163, 2009b
Schwartz R, Hamre R, Dietz W, et al: Office-based motivational interviewing to
prevent childhood obesity: a feasibility study. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
161:495–501, 2007
Senediak C, Spence S: Rapid versus gradual scheduling of therapeutic contact in a
family based behavioural weight control programme for children. Behavioural
Psychotherapy 13:256–287, 1985
Shin N, Shin MS: Body dissatisfaction, self-esteem, and depression in obese Ko-
rean children. J Pediatr 152:502–506, 2008
Smith DE, Heckemeyer CM, Kratt PP, et al: Motivational interviewing to improve
adherence to a behavioral weight-control program for older obese women
with NIDDM: a pilot study. Diabetes Care 20:52–54, 1997
Stice E, Bearman SK: Body image and eating disturbances prospectively predict
growth in depressive symptoms in adolescent girls: a growth curve analysis.
Dev Psychol 37:597–607, 2001
Obesity and Depression 419
Stice E, Hayward C, Cameron R, et al: Body image and eating related factors pre-
dict onset of depression in female adolescents: a longitudinal study. J Abnorm
Psychol 109:438–444, 2000
Strauss RS: Childhood obesity and self-esteem. Pediatrics 105:e15, 2000
Strauss RS, Pollack HA: Social marginalization of overweight children. Arch Pedi-
atr Adolesc Med 157:746–752, 2003
Szigethy EM, Kenney E, Carpenter J, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy for ado-
lescents with inflammatory bowel disease and subsyndromal depression. J Am
Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 46:1290–1298, 2007
Szigethy E, Hardy D, Craig AE, et al: Girls connect: effects of a support group for
teenage girls with inflammatory bowel disease and their mothers. Inflamm
Bowel Dis 8:1127–1128, 2009
Tanofsky-Kraff M, Yanovski SZ, Wilfley DE, et al: Eating-disordered behaviors,
body fat, and psychopathology in overweight and normal-weight children.
J Consult Clin Psychol 72:53–61, 2004
Tiggemann M: Body dissatisfaction and adolescent self-esteem: prospective find-
ings. Body Image 2:129–135, 2005
van den Berg P, Wertheim EH, Thompson JK, et al: Development of body image,
eating disturbance, and general psychological functioning in adolescent fe-
males: a replication using covariance structure modeling in an Australian sam-
ple. Int J Eat Disord 32:46–51, 2002
Wardle J, Cooke L: The impact of obesity on psychological well-being. Best Pract
Res Clin Endocrinol Metab 19:421–440, 2005
Wardle J, Williamson S, Johnson F, et al: Depression in adolescent obesity: cultural
moderators of the association between obesity and depressive symptoms. Int
J Obes (Lond) 30:634–643, 2006
Weiner CL, Primeau M, Ehrmann DA: Androgens and mood dysfunction in
women: comparison of women with polycystic ovarian syndrome to healthy
controls. Psychosom Med 66:356–362, 2004
Weisz JR, Southam-Gerow MA, Gordis EB, et al: Cognitive-behavioral therapy
versus usual clinical care for youth depression: an initial test of transportability
to community clinics and clinicians. J Consult Clin Psychol 77:383–396, 2009
Williams CL, Bollella M, Carter BJ: Treatment of childhood obesity in pediatric
practice. Ann N Y Acad Sci 699:207–219, 1993
Wrotniak BH, Epstein LH, Paluch RA, et al: Parent weight change as a predictor of
child weight change in family based behavioral obesity treatment. Arch Pedi-
atr Adolesc Med 158:342–347, 2004
Yildiz BO, Knochenhauer ES, Azziz R: Impact of obesity on the risk for polycystic
ovary syndrome. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 93:162–168, 2008
Zeller MH, Saelens B, Roehrig H, et al: Psychological adjustment of obese youth
presenting for weight management treatment. Obes Res 12:1576–1586, 2004
420 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Appendix 11–A
Healthy Bodies, Healthy Minds:
Selected Patient Worksheets
Thoughts
Emotions Behaviors
How our emotions, thoughts, and behaviors are connected:
Goal 1:
Goal 2:
Goal 3:
Initials:
Gender:
Birth date:
10
11
12
Appendix 11–A: HBHM Selected Patient Worksheets 423
Mood Monitoring
Practice assignment: During the next week, write down what your mood was for most of each
day (e.g., bored, happy, sad, angry, irritable, grumpy). Rate your mood for the day on a scale of
1–10 (1 being worse mood/more bored than ever, 10 being best mood ever/rarely bored). Then
write down what good and bad things happened that day.
Changes
Mood Good things Bad things in my eating
Describe rating that happened that happened (e.g., felt like
mood (1–10) today today eating more or
Day less than usual)
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
424 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Ratings
Eating Healthy Being Active
10 Wonderful 10 Wonderful
5 OK 5 OK
At the end of this session, we have provided copies of this pyramid, which
you can use daily to help guide your food choices.
Sweets
Lower
sugar varieties
1 serving
Dairy
Low-fat milk, Meat
yogurt, cheese Fatty fis
3 servings lean meat/ph, ou
3 servings ltry
Whole Gra
Pasta, bread, ric ins
e, cere
4-6 servings als
Fr
Fresh and frozeuits
n whole fruits Vegetables
3 servings Non-starchy ve
geta
5 servings bles
Appendix 11–A: HBHM Selected Patient Worksheets 427
NutritionData.com
By choosing items that fit the guidelines for fat, fiber, and sugar, you will have healthier
foods at home to put together for meals and snacks.
428 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
STARCH:
Rice, pasta, potatoes
Corn, bread, cereal LOW-FAT
FRUIT 1/2 to 1 cup MILK OR YOGURT
SALAD 1 cup
VEGGIES
2 cups total PROTEIN:
Meat (3-4 oz = size of
palm)
Beans (1 cup)
Milk or yogurt (1 cup)
Cheese (1 oz =1 slice)
Peanut Butter
(2 tbsp)
Egg (1)
Benefits of Logging:
Shows eating and physical activity patterns so that you can see your habits
Helps you to plan physical activity into your daily routine
Assists you in identifying benefits and challenges
Helps you set realistic goals to make lifestyle changes
Tracking your weight every week when you meet with us also is useful when
trying to make healthy changes to lose weight.
Appendix 11–A: HBHM Selected Patient Worksheets 429
Cognitive Self-Monitoring
Trigger/Event Automatic Anxiety Problem Countering Realistic Anxiety
thought (0–8) (0–100%) (alternatives, problem (0–8)
evidence) (0–100%)
Flexibility &
Stre
2-3 times a we ngth:
(stretching, yoga ek
, rope climbing,
push-ups)
Active Aero
bic & Recrea
tional Activ
3-5 ities:
(basketball, so times a week
ccer, swimming
, rollerblading)
Everyday Ac
tivities:
(cleaning your As of
room, taking th ten as possible
e stairs, playing
outside, going
shopping)
These levels correspond to how many calories you are burning. “Inactivity” burns the least number
of calories, whereas “Active Aerobic & Recreational Activities” burn the most, in a short period of time.
You’ll be surprised how many calories you can burn by increasing your “Everyday Activities.” Your
armband and pedometer/watch will help tell you how many calories you are burning on the
weekends that you wear it.
METs are an estimate of the intensity of a particular activity and are based on your resting metabolic
rate (or the amount of energy your body uses while at rest). The higher the MET, the more calories
you burn while doing the activity.
Sedentary activities require less than 2.0 METs and will not help you lose weight.
Moderate activities require between 2.0 and 2.9 METs. They are better than sedentary
activities but not as healthy as vigorous activities.
Vigorous activities require MET levels of 3.0 or higher. They make your body work
hard and will help you to lose weight.
Appendix 11–A: HBHM Selected Patient Worksheets 431
Step 2: Why do you have a negative body image? We know that body image stems from your
developmental past as well as from the current forces in your life. We will focus on where your beliefs
about your body image originate.
Step 3: A negative body image is emotionally draining. Feeling self-conscious or even ashamed
about your looks impairs your ability to feel in charge of your life.
Step 4: Typically, you feel what you think. How you feel about your looks is influenced by the
beliefs you have about yourself. Most people have assumptions about the importance of looks—
this can sometimes lead to trouble. We discussed these assumptions or myths and their opposing facts.
Step 5: In this step, we will talk about the negative ways of thinking from Session 2 and learn how
to identify these mental mishaps. Identifying the times when you are thinking negatively is a huge
first step to feeling better about yourself.
Step 6: A negative body image may lead you to act in ways that protect you from uncomfortable
feelings (for example, not going out with friends because you don’t like the way you look).
Avoidance can sometimes make your body image worse—after all, it only prevents you from having
fun. Learning that these behaviors are self-defeating will be an important step for change.
Step 7: Creating a positive body image is important. At times (and sometimes frequently),
the negative thoughts will come back, but it is important to recognize these thoughts and challenge
yourself to come up with countering and healthier ones.
Step 8: Planning ahead for possible challenges is an important step for staying healthy. It will be
important to continually check in with yourself to make sure you are staying on track.
432 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Activity:
Pretend you are in a room all by yourself and the door is closed. There are a set of knobs on the wall,
and each one has a different label: angry, sad, happy, jealous, selfish, greedy, and humorous.
As you turn each knob, you begin to feel that emotion. You can choose to turn any or all of the
knobs. You can also decide how much you want to turn each knob.
What knobs would you choose? Would you turn them all the way? Let’s assume you step
out of the room and are back to your normal self. Can you be more aware of your mood?
Can you choose to keep some of those emotions after leaving the room?
Create Awareness
The first step to making changes in your food choices, physical activity, and mood begins
with increasing your awareness of your current habits. You have already been doing this by
keeping a journal. You may have found from your own experience with logging that this has
been an important tool for raising your awareness in many areas, such as which foods give you
lasting energy and more satisfaction, what types of physical activity you enjoy, and when you feel
most positive. You are encouraged to continue keeping a journal to help you increase your
awareness of your own unique needs.
Keeping a journal will also show you that you don’t have to “go on a diet” and “exercise all
of the time” to lose weight, but a balanced approach to healthy living will support you in feeling
your best—physically and emotionally.
Appendix 11–A: HBHM Selected Patient Worksheets 433
Reflection Activity:
You have come a long way. We would like to hear your reflections about this process.
Is there anyone in particular who you would like to thank for his or her
support throughout this process? If so, who and why?
For our purposes, can you please provide feedback on the intervention delivered?
• Are there any changes you would recommend?
• How was it to work with your coach?
• Would you recommend this intervention to someone else?
Disruptive Behavior
Disorders
John E. Lochman, Ph.D., ABPP
Nicole P. Powell, Ph.D.
Caroline L. Boxmeyer, Ph.D.
Rachel E. Baden, M.A.
S This chapter has a video case example on the DVD (“Disruptive Behavior”)
demonstrating CBT for an adolescent with oppositional defiant disorder.
435
436 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Empirical Research
Several reviews have examined the efficacy of psychosocial treatments for
conduct problems in children and adolescents in comparison to no treat-
ment or wait-list control conditions (Kazdin 2005; Lochman and Pardini
2008). These reviews indicate that a vast majority of the empirically sup-
ported treatments for conduct problems in youth are based on behavioral
or cognitive-behavioral theoretical frameworks (Brestan and Eyberg 1998;
Farmer et al. 2002; Kazdin and Weisz 1998; Nock 2003). Many traditional
behavioral programs have cognitive-behavioral elements (e.g., stress man-
agement sessions during behavioral parent training), and most cognitive-
behavioral programs have substantial operant reinforcement elements, so
that there are few strictly behavioral or strictly cognitive programs in this
area of psychopathology. Meta-analytic reviews suggest a range of medium
to large effect sizes (0.47–0.90) for cognitive-behavioral interventions tar-
geting conduct problems (for review, see Nock 2003). In addition, re-
search suggests that cognitive-behavioral interventions that include a child
component focusing on social problem-solving and social skills develop-
ment together with a parent-management training component produce
broader positive effects and better maintenance of behavioral improve-
ments over time than interventions with either component in isolation
(Kazdin et al. 1992; Nock 2003; Webster-Stratton and Hammond 1997).
However, the parenting component of these interventions has been shown
to produce particularly robust reductions in conduct problems and delin-
quent behaviors (Beauchaine et al. 2005; Lochman and Wells 2004). Re-
search on cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) programs has examined CBT
interventions that have both parent and child components and CBT inter-
ventions that focus only on parents or only on children. Parent-only inter-
ventions are more likely to be delivered to families with younger children
with DBD.
In the sections below, we will first briefly summarize the results of in-
tervention research with the Coping Power Program, a CBT program for
preadolescent children with disruptive behaviors. We will also provide an
overview of results of several other examples of treatment and prevention
programs with substantial cognitive-behavioral elements for children with
DBD. These other programs target many of the same cognitive, emotional,
and behavioral processes that are the focus of the Coping Power Program,
and as a group, these programs cover three different developmental peri-
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 437
ods (Matthys and Lochman 2010). Later in the chapter, discussion of the
Coping Power Program components will provide the structure for the dis-
cussion of CBT techniques for children with DBD.
al. 2009); when used with aggressive children in a more abbreviated 24-
session format (Lochman et al. 2006a); when used with children with
DBD in Puerto Rico (Cabiya et al. 2008); and when used with specialized
populations, such as deaf children who have aggression problems in resi-
dential settings (Lochman et al. 2001). Coping Power in dissemination
studies has also been found to reduce children’s disciplinary suspensions
from schools (Cowell et al. 2008; Peterson et al. 2009).
Treatment Programs
The Art of Self-Control is a cognitive and behaviorally oriented group (and
individual) adolescent control program (Feindler and Ecton 1986). Out-
come research for this program, with adolescents in in-school programs for
multisuspended youth and in inpatient and incarcerated settings, has indi-
cated reductions in aggressive and disruptive behavior and improvements
in problem-solving abilities, social skills, cognitive reflectivity, and adult-
rated impulsivity and self-control (Feindler and Ecton 1986).
Multisystemic therapy (MST) is an intensive family- and community-
based treatment program that has been implemented with chronic and violent
juvenile offenders, substance-abusing juvenile offenders, adolescent sexual of-
fenders, youth in psychiatric crisis (i.e., homicidal, suicidal, psychotic), and
maltreating families (Henggeler and Lee 2003). MST is an individualized in-
tervention that focuses on the interaction between adolescents and the multi-
ple environmental systems that influence their antisocial behavior, including
their peers, family, school, and community (Henggeler et al. 1992). Although
the techniques used within these treatment strategies can vary, many of them
are either behavioral or cognitive-behavioral in nature (e.g., contingency man-
agement, behavioral contracting). Evaluations of the effectiveness of MST
with chronic and violent juvenile offenders have produced promising results.
Several investigations have shown that families who receive MST report lower
levels of adolescent behavior problems, improvements in family functioning at
posttreatment, and lower recidivism in a 4-year follow-up in comparison with
alternative treatment conditions (Borduin et al. 1995; Henggeler et al. 1992).
Conceptual Framework
A contextual social-cognitive model serves as the basis for many CBT pro-
grams for children and adolescents with DBD and is based on empirically
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 441
Family Factors
A wide array of factors in the family can affect child aggression, ranging
from poverty to more general stress and discord within the family (Loeber
and Stouthamer-Loeber 1998). Children’s aggression has been linked to
general family background factors, such as parent criminality, substance
use and depression, poverty, and stressful life events. All of these family
risk factors interrelate with one another, build on one another, and in turn,
can influence child behavior through their effect on parenting processes.
Parenting processes linked to children’s aggression (Patterson et al. 1992)
include 1) nonresponsive parenting at age 1, with the pacing and consis-
tency of parent responses not meeting children’s needs; 2) coercive, esca-
lating cycles of harsh parental demands to child noncompliance starting in
the toddler years, especially for children with difficult temperaments;
3) harsh, inconsistent discipline; 4) unclear directions and commands;
5) lack of warmth and involvement; and 6) lack of parental supervision and
monitoring as children approach adolescence. The relations between
parenting factors and childhood aggression are bidirectional, as child tem-
perament and behavior also affect parenting behavior (Fite et al. 2006).
Peer Factors
Children with disruptive behaviors are at risk for being rejected by their
peers. Aggressive children who are also socially rejected exhibit more se-
vere antisocial behavior than children who are either aggressive only or re-
jected only (Lochman and Wayland 1994). The match between the race
of students and their peers in a classroom influences the degree of social
rejection that students experience (Jackson et al. 2006), and race and gen-
der appear to moderate the relation between peer rejection and negative
adolescent outcomes. For example, Lochman and Wayland (1994) found
that peer rejection ratings of African American children within a mixed-
race classroom did not predict subsequent externalizing problems in ado-
lescence, whereas peer rejection ratings of white children were associated
with future disruptive behaviors. Similarly, whereas peer rejection can pre-
442 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Social Cognition
On the basis of children’s temperament, biological dispositions, and con-
textual experiences with family, peers, and community, children begin to
form stable patterns of processing social information and regulating their
emotions. A contextual social-cognitive model (Lochman and Wells
2002), based on social information processing theory (Crick and Dodge
1994), stresses the reciprocal interactive relationships among children’s
initial cognitive appraisal of problem situations, their efforts to think about
solutions to the perceived problems, children’s physiological arousal, and
their behavioral response. The level of physiological arousal will depend on
the individual’s biological predisposition to become aroused and will vary
depending on the interpretation of the event (Williams et al. 2003). The
level of arousal will further influence social problem-solving, operate to in-
tensify the fight-or-flight response, and interfere with the generation of so-
lutions. Because of the ongoing and reciprocal nature of interactions, it
may be difficult for children to extricate themselves from aggressive be-
havior patterns.
Aggressive children have cognitive distortions at the appraisal phases of
social-cognitive processing because of difficulties in encoding incoming so-
cial information and in accurately interpreting social events and others’ in-
tentions. In the appraisal phases of information processing, aggressive
children have been found to recall fewer relevant nonhostile cues about
events (Lochman and Dodge 1994), and reactively aggressive children
have a hostile attributional bias, as they excessively infer that others are
acting toward them in a provocative and hostile manner (Dodge et al.
1997; Lochman and Dodge 1994).
Aggressive children also have cognitive deficiencies at the problem-
solution phases of social-cognitive processing. They tend to have domi-
nance- and revenge-oriented social goals (Lochman et al. 1993), which
guide the maladaptive action-oriented and nonverbal solutions they gener-
ate for perceived problems (Dunn et al. 1997; Lochman and Dodge 1994).
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 443
Application
Cognitive-behavioral interventions are frequently applied to the treatment
of conduct problems in children and adolescents, and a number of CBT
programs have been developed for this purpose. As noted earlier, CBT pro-
grams are available for preschool-age children, school-age children, and ad-
olescents. Some CBT programs focus on prevention of conduct problems,
whereas others are designed to treat youth with clinical diagnoses. Still
other differences among CBT programs involve the inclusion of multiple
components (e.g., parent training, teacher consultation) and program
length. Nonetheless, most CBT programs for youth with conduct prob-
lems incorporate common elements such as goal setting, rewards, manag-
ing anger, and problem solving. In the following sections, cognitive-
behavioral elements for treatment are described, using the Coping Power
Program as an example.
Opening Activities
At the beginning of each session, ask students to recall key points from the
previous session, and conduct a brief review of the previous session’s con-
tent. Next, ask students to produce their weekly goal sheets for review.
The goal sheets are an integral part of the Coping Power Program, serving
as the main tool by which students practice target behaviors between ses-
sions. Goal sheets also provide students and leaders with feedback about
the students’ behavioral progress in the classroom. Each week, students
and leaders work together to identify an individualized, operationally de-
fined target behavior (e.g., “I will complete my math class work before go-
ing to the computer”). On a daily basis, teachers provide written and
verbal feedback to the child. At the end of the week, students bring their
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 445
goal sheets to the Coping Power meeting and are awarded one point for
each day the goal was achieved.
Closing Activities
At the end of each session, ask each student to provide positive feedback
to another student in the group, commenting on the student’s prosocial
behavior during the meeting or on a time the other child used appropriate
coping between the previous and current meetings. Next, review points
earned by each student during the meeting, announce point totals, and al-
low students to spend or save their points. Finally, award a brief free-play
period to all students who have displayed appropriate behavior during the
meeting. This activity serves as a reward for the students as well as an op-
portunity for leaders to observe peer interactions, providing coaching and
support as needed. Students who fail to earn the free-play period use the
time to discuss their difficulties with a leader and to problem-solve better
choices for future meetings.
Main Foci
Goal setting. The initial Coping Power Child Component sessions in-
troduce the concept of goal setting, a theme that is continued for the du-
ration of the program. Obtain input from teachers, then help students to
identify personally meaningful long-term goals to work on for the current
school year (e.g., to raise Cs to Bs, to be promoted to the next grade). As-
sist students in breaking down these long-term goals into manageable
steps. For example, a student who strives to raise his or her grades might
identify daily short-term goals such as accurately writing down homework
assignments, bringing books home, and completing and turning in home-
work. Students can then use these short-term goals on the weekly goal
sheets. Students may work on a short-term goal for 1 week or several
weeks, until they have mastered the goal or until it is apparent that the goal
requires modification for the student to achieve success.
Other activities in the goal-setting component involve students inter-
viewing or listening to an interview with an adult who set goals during his
or her youth and later achieved them. Community leaders, local business
owners, and college athletes can be effective role models for this task.
Organization and study skills. Given the frequency with which exter-
nalizing problems co-occur with behavioral difficulties in the school set-
ting, the Coping Power Child Component includes two sessions that
directly address students’ study habits. Have students discuss the impor-
446 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Perspective taking. The next set of sessions targets the problems with
perspective taking commonly seen in children with disruptive behavior
problems. The clinician can engage students in discussions and role-plays
to illustrate individual differences in perspectives. For example, have stu-
dents act out a situation and then interview each other about their percep-
tions of the events. The differing viewpoints highlight how the same event
can be perceived differently by different people. Lead additional role-
plays and games to foster awareness of how difficult it can be to accurately
understand another person’s intentions. Because the tendency to make
hostile inferences about others’ intentions is common among Coping
Power participants, make sure to encourage students to consider more be-
nign alternatives. Lead activities involving perspective taking in peer rela-
tionships and in interactions with teachers. For example, students can be
asked to interview a teacher, asking questions that allow the teacher to cor-
rect common student misperceptions about disciplinary procedures and
classroom management.
Stress Management
Introduce the topic of stress management by defining stress and leading
parents through a discussion of how stress can undermine their positive
parenting behaviors. Ask parents for their ideas about how they might take
care of themselves to reduce stress. Introduce the notion of active relax-
ation as a way to reduce stress. Practice in session, and ask parents to prac-
tice between sessions. In the second session, discuss time management as
a way to reduce stress and introduce the cognitive model of stress and
mood management, in which parents develop cognitive coping strategies
for stressful events and learn to recognize the connection between cogni-
tive perceptions and beliefs and related emotions. In reviewing this model,
discuss how thoughts can contribute to feelings and subsequent behaviors
in parenting situations. Role-play a stressful parent-child situation with
450 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
parents and identify the thoughts and feelings that resulted in a behavioral
overreaction by the parent.
the child grows older. Brainstorm strategies for how families might build
their cohesion both in the home (e.g., family game nights) and outside of
the home (e.g., going to a park). Parents are encouraged to follow through
with family cohesion–building activities.
Present the steps of the problem-solving PICC model. Describe (and
show) how through worksheets and videotaped role-plays the children are
coached in this problem-solving model—and encourage parents to use this
model to resolve family conflicts.
Lead parents through a discussion about their ongoing family commu-
nication patterns. Do family members have a way of talking with each
other about their concerns? When someone wants to change a preestab-
lished rule, how is that negotiated? Are family members satisfied with the
way they communicate? Introduce the notion of a family meeting as one
way to preserve positive parent involvement in children’s lives and to
tackle potential problems before they arise. Guide parents through a dis-
cussion regarding how they might establish family meetings at home. Also
present a communication system for helping parents monitor their child’s
outings with peers.
Cultural Issues
Culturally competent clinicians are those who can anticipate the culturally
related appropriateness of, and obstacles to, the use of common assessment
or intervention procedures for children and families. Ethnic and community
factors can require some adaptations in the delivery of CBT for children and
adolescents with DBD (Lochman et al. 2006b), especially among minority
low-income individuals. Parents may model and promote the use of physi-
cally aggressive problem-solving strategies by their greater dependence on
corporal punishment, as well as by actively teaching their children to retal-
iate when confronted with physically or verbally aggressive situations. These
parents’ messages can result from their ongoing struggle to protect their
children from danger in their impoverished neighborhoods and from their
efforts to inculcate responsibility for safety and personal rights. Another
factor that may interfere with easy dissemination of CBT techniques is that
children may receive conflicting messages from parents and other authority
figures (such as school personnel) about the use and value of aggression.
Thus, when working with minority children and families, clinicians should
attend to how contextual variables may have an effect on problem behaviors
and on children’s and families’ abilities to generate a culturally relevant
range of alternative solutions to their problems. These differences require
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 453
discussion, and intervention can focus initially on the utility of less aggres-
sive solutions in certain environments (e.g., the child’s school).
Case Examples
The following two case examples illustrate key points and challenges of
CBT for children with DBD addressed through the Coping Power Child
Component and the Coping Power Parent Component.
to her. I was just talking to myself. She wouldn’t have even heard me
say it if she hadn’t been standing right in my space. She should just
back off and leave me alone.
Clinician: Is it safe to say that what happened after you got your name on
the board—getting angry, hitting the teacher with your pencil, and
calling her a name—caused you to get suspended?
Tim: Yeah, but it’s all her fault. She lets other people sharpen their pencils
all the time. If she hadn’t made such a big deal out of it, none of that
would have happened.
Clinician: Well, let’s take a look at that. Do you remember when you in-
terviewed your teacher to get to know her better and find out where
she is coming from?
Tim: Yeah.
Clinician: What do you remember learning about her during that inter-
view?
Tim: She didn’t like having a lot of homework when she was in elementary
school, and she even got in trouble for talking too much in class
sometimes.
Clinician: That’s right. And what did she say about why she has rules for
the classroom?
Tim: So that we know what is expected of us and to help us learn.
Clinician: That’s right. And what did she say about what she wants most
for her students?
Tim: She wants us to enjoy learning and do well so that we can get a good
education and have a good life someday.
Clinician: That sounds like what she said. So let’s think again about the
situation that happened yesterday. Do you think she put your name
on the board just to make you mad?
Tim: No.
Clinician: Do you think she put your name on the board just because she
doesn’t like you?
Tim: Maybe—it sure seems like she doesn’t like me a lot of the time.
Clinician: Can you think of any other reason why she might have put your
name on the board?
Tim: Well, I guess maybe she could have just been trying to enforce her
rule. She said that she wants us to get better about staying in our
seats, especially because we’re getting close to testing time. She got
on Jamal’s case for asking to go to the bathroom.
Clinician: Oh, so you weren’t even the only one who got in trouble for get-
ting out of your seat?
Tim: No, I forgot about her getting on Jamal’s case until just now.
Clinician: So do you think that maybe she’s just trying to get better at en-
forcing her rule about staying in your seat as testing gets closer, and
you and Jamal happened to be the first ones who got in trouble now
that she is enforcing the rule more strictly?
Tim: Yeah, that could be it.
Clinician: OK, so let’s think about how the situation might have gone dif-
ferently if you had told yourself that instead. By the way, what did
you say to yourself when your teacher put your name on the board?
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 455
Tim: I said, “She’s a [something I can’t repeat].. ..” I said, “She’s mean and
she has it out for me.”
Clinician: And what happened to your anger on your anger thermometer
when you said that to yourself?
Tim: I got real mad and that’s when I threw my pencil.
Clinician: OK, so you’ve given a really good example about the way that
our thoughts are related to our feelings. When you told yourself that
your teacher is mean and has it out for you, you got really angry and
threw your pencil and called her a name, which is what led you to
get suspended. Now, what do you think might have happened if you
had noticed yourself getting angry and said a coping statement to
yourself instead?
Tim: Like what?
Clinician: Like, you could have said to yourself, “Mrs. Stephens seems like
she is getting nervous for our standardized testing, and she really
wants us to do a better job of staying in our seats for the next few
days. I should just not make a big deal of it right now and go back to
my seat and try to borrow a pencil from Terri instead.”
Tim: That probably would have been a better thing to do.
Clinician: That’s an example of a coping statement that you could have
used in the situation with your teacher to control your anger and stay
out of trouble. Now, it’s much easier to talk about using coping strat-
egies to stay calm than it is to do in real life. So how about if we act
out the situation from yesterday and see how it goes? I’ll pretend I’m
Mrs. Stephens, and I’ll start to write your name on the board for get-
ting out of your seat. How about if you start to respond like you did
yesterday, but then try to catch yourself and use a coping statement
instead? We’ll keep acting out the rest of the scene for a while and
see how it goes.
Tim: I can try to think of where the other person is coming from and try
to use coping statements to stay calm instead of getting angry.
Clinician: That sounds like a good idea. We’ll see how it goes. Would that be
something you might want to pick as your goal on your goal sheet for
the week? Then you could earn points for working on it, and it could
help you get feedback from your parents and teacher to see how you do.
Tim: Sure.
Clinician: How would you feel about bringing your mom in and telling her
what we’ve been talking about so she knows how to help you work
on your goal this week?
Tim: That’s fine.
Clinician: OK, is there anything else we should talk about before she
comes in?
Naomi: It’s been pretty rough. I had to keep Anna home from school on
Wednesday and Thursday because she got in a fight. The principal really
let me have it when I went to check her back in on Friday. I had to go
without pay those 2 days, so needless to say, I was pretty mad at Anna.
Clinician: Gosh, I’m sorry to hear that. It does sound like you had a diffi-
cult week. Last week, we talked about helping you reconnect with
Anna in two ways. We talked about having you try to set aside some
special time to do an activity with Anna that you thought she would
enjoy to help you two reestablish a positive bond. We also talked
about having you use a tracking grid to catch her being good, to make
sure you’re noticing the times she follows directions, puts effort into
her schoolwork, and helps you out around the house. How did those
things go for you this week?
Naomi: Not very well. I was going to take her shopping on Wednesday
night, but when she got in serious trouble at school that day, I did
not think it was a good idea to reward her like that. Then I had to
work overtime to make up for the days I missed at work, so we have
not had a chance to do that yet.
Clinician: Those do sound like real barriers to doing something special
with Anna this week, like taking her shopping. It’s still important to
not give up on the goal of you two having some positive time to-
gether though, so let’s think about how you might be able to do that
this week. Do you have any ideas about what you could do?
Naomi: Well, it might need to be something that doesn’t cost very much
money, because money is tight right now.
Clinician: That’s fine. The important thing is that you make it a priority and
set the time aside and find something that you think you’ll both enjoy.
Naomi: We both like watching the same singing competition on television,
so I was thinking of asking her if she would like to watch it with me
instead of watching it in her room.
Clinician: That sounds like a nice thing for the two of you to do together.
It would also be nice for you to find something the two of you can
do that is interactive as well. I know you are probably exhausted at
night when you get home from work. Are there any nights that you
get home earlier or that are less hectic for you?
Naomi: I’ve been trying to leave a little bit early on Friday afternoons.
Clinician: Would that be a good day to try to do something with Anna?
Naomi: Actually, it would because her brother and sister go to their aunt’s
house for a few hours after school on Fridays.
Clinician: OK, great. Now, what do you think might be a fun, inexpensive
thing you and Anna could do on Friday?
Naomi: Well, she has been begging me to let her get a pedicure. I don’t
have the money to let her get one at the salon, but I have all of the
stuff to give her one at home.
Clinician: That sounds fun. Have you ever done that before? Do you think
Anna would like it?
Naomi: Well, I was going to do it a few weeks ago, but Anna blew up about
something. I can’t even remember what it was. But the pedicure
never happened.
458 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Clinician: So it sounds like to make it work, you’ll have to try to keep the
mood pretty light with Anna beforehand so there aren’t any major
blowups.
Naomi: Yeah. ... How do I do that?
Clinician: Well, sometimes in order to keep special time special, you’ll
have to let things go with Anna that you wouldn’t ordinarily let go.
For example, if you don’t approve of how she’s wearing her hair
when you pick her up, don’t make a big deal of it. It might also help
to be cautious about how you react to things she brings up. For ex-
ample, if she tells you that she had a bad day at school, you might
say, “I’m sorry to hear that, honey,” instead of jumping in with an in-
quiry such as “Why? Did you do something wrong?” It can help if
you’re in the right frame of mind to interact calmly with her. We
talked a few weeks ago about how parenting is stressful and about
how our own feelings of stress affect our mood and our interactions
with our children. It is easier to be more patient with them when
we’ve had some time to rejuvenate ourselves. Any chance you’ll get
some time to yourself before you spend time with Anna on Friday?
Naomi: Well, I have a coworker who is always asking me to walk with her
for exercise on our lunch break. I would really like to do it but never
make time for it. Maybe I could do that on Friday so I’ll be more re-
laxed when I hang out with Anna.
Clinician: That sounds like a great idea. What will it take to make sure you
have the time to do that?
Naomi: I just need to write it in on my calendar like any other appointment.
Clinician: Do you want to take out your calendar and do that right now?
Naomi: There, I just did it.
Clinician: Great. I’ll check back next time and see how it goes, both the
walking and the special time with Anna. The other thing we were go-
ing to follow up on was whether you were able to pay attention to
how often Anna exhibited some of the target behaviors we’ve set for
her, such as following your directions, putting more effort into her
schoolwork, and helping you around the house. Tell me how that
went this week.
Naomi: Well, I have to confess, I forgot all about the sheet you gave me
until right before we came here. Sorry, it was just that kind of a
week.
Clinician: Even though you didn’t fill out the sheet, did you pay any more
attention to Anna’s behavior?
Naomi: I did pay more attention to her behavior early in the week, before
she got in trouble at school. I did notice that there are quite a few
things that she does around the house that I tend to overlook.
Clinician: Like what?
Naomi: Well, she pretty much takes care of herself a lot of the time, be-
cause I’m gone for work. She gets herself dressed for school in the
morning and fixes herself breakfast. I think she helps her brother and
sister with the dinner dishes some before I get home from work and
she does keep her room pretty clean.
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 459
Clinician: It sounds like you noticed quite a few things that she’s doing al-
ready to help out around the house that you weren’t very aware of
before. Did you say anything to Anna about that?
Naomi: Not really, because those are all things I think she should be doing
because she’s part of the family and we all have to do our part.
Clinician: It’s appropriate to have expectations for your children to help
out around the house. The difference is that in trying to improve
Anna’s compliance at home, it’s important to recognize where she is
already showing effort in this area and to provide her with some pos-
itive reinforcement. Quick labeled praise, such as telling Anna that
you appreciate her effort in getting herself ready in the morning and
cleaning up the kitchen at night, lets her know that you notice and
appreciate these things and can help her feel very encouraged.
Naomi: Yeah, I’ll try to do more of that this week.
Clinician: What I would like you to do is to make an effort to praise her
for her effort around the house several times this week and then to
pay attention to what effect it has on her willingness to help out
around the house and also on your relationship. We’ll follow up next
time to see if it made any difference. The other side of the equation
that we talked about last time is that it can also be helpful to ignore
small annoyances that could lead to a big blowup and might be better
left alone. Tell me about how that went this week.
Naomi: I did try that a few times this week.
Clinician: Great, can you give me an example?
Naomi: Yeah, it drives me crazy when Anna tracks water in the hallway
after she takes a bath and then she leaves the sink messy and sticky
after she brushes her teeth. In the past, when I’ve tried to make her
come back and clean these things up, it has led to a big blowup right
before bedtime. I decided to let it go a few times this week. It went
better than I expected. We were able to have some nice time to-
gether before bedtime several nights this week, and I guess that’s
what should be more important than having a perfectly clean bath-
room. Anna even cleaned out the sink on her own at one point.
Clinician: That’s terrific. What did you learn from that?
Naomi: I learned that it helps to pick my battles, especially with Anna,
where even the littlest thing could lead to a big rift between us.
Clinician: That seems like an important lesson for you to draw on in the
future. It’s almost time for us to bring Anna back in. Would you like
to use the time to tell her that you appreciate what she does to help
out around the house and also to talk about what you might do to-
gether on Friday?
Naomi: That sounds good. We will still need to talk about what happened
at school on Wednesday.
Clinician: Yes, we’ll talk about that, too. Perhaps we can use it as an op-
portunity for Anna to show you the approach she’s learning to stop
and think about the best way to solve problems when she is angry, so
that you can help her use it at home.
Naomi: That sounds good. I’ll go get Anna... .
460 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Conclusion
This chapter summarizes research-supported prevention and treatment
programs for DBD. The Coping Power Program, used in targeted preven-
tion and treatment interventions for aggressive children, is described in de-
tail. Coping Power is based on a contextual social-cognitive model and has
been tested in a series of efficacy and effectiveness studies. The major foci
of the Coping Power Child and Parent Components are described and are
illustrated with case examples.
Self-Assessment Questions
12.1. A 10-year-old boy with a history of aggressive, disruptive behavior at
home and at school is referred for psychological treatment. The most ef-
fective treatment for his referral problems is which of the following?
12.2. David is a 10-year-old boy who attends individual therapy to address his
diagnosis of oppositional defiant disorder. When his therapist asks about
his feelings, his responses are limited to “happy” and “mad.” In seeking
to broaden his recognition of various feeling states, his therapist should
work on helping him recognize which of the following?
A. Physiological sensations.
B. Behaviors.
C. Cognitions.
D. All of the above.
12.3. Amanda, age 11, has been referred for therapy because of her fre-
quent angry outbursts. When she is calm, she can articulate appro-
priate responses to problems such as peer teasing, but she tends to
act out aggressively when confronted with real-life problems. Which
of the following areas should Amanda’s therapist focus on first?
A. Social problem-solving.
B. Perspective taking.
C. Anger management strategies.
D. Identifying consequences for aggressive behaviors.
12.4. In one of the clinical vignettes in this chapter, 15-year-old Tim as-
sumes that his teacher “has it out for him” when she puts his name
on the board for getting out of his seat to sharpen his pencil. Tim’s
CBT-oriented clinician seeks to help him see the situation from his
teacher’s perspective to modify his initial
12.5. In another clinical vignette in this chapter, Naomi has sought mental
health services to reduce her daughter Anna’s disruptive behavior.
The family’s CBT-oriented clinician has asked Naomi to praise
Anna’s prosocial behaviors (such as following directions and helping
out around the house) and to ignore minor disruptive behavior (such
as whining or not cleaning out the sink thoroughly). The clinician is
likely trying to help Naomi use which of the following?
Suggested Readings
Eyberg SM, Nelson MM, Boggs SR: Evidence-based psychosocial treat-
ments for children and adolescents with disruptive behavior. J Clin
Child Adolesc Psychol 37:215–237, 2008
Farmer EM, Compton SN, Burns BJ, et al: Review of the evidence base for
treatment of childhood psychopathology: externalizing disorders.
J Consult Clin Psychol 70:1267–1302, 2002
Matthys W, Lochman JE: Oppositional Defiant Disorder and Conduct
Disorder in Childhood. Oxford, UK, Wiley-Blackwell, 2010
Nelson WM III, Finch AJ, Hart KJ (eds): Comparative Treatment of Con-
duct Disorder. New York, Springer, 2006
References
American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric
Association, 2000
Beauchaine TP, Webster-Stratton C, Reid MJ: Mediators, moderators, and predic-
tors of 1-year outcomes among children treated for early onset conduct prob-
lems: a latent growth curve analysis. J Consult Clin Psychol 73:371–388, 2005
Borduin CM, Mann BJ, Cone LT, et al: Multisystemic treatment of serious juvenile
offenders: long-term prevention of criminality and violence. J Consult Clin
Psychol 63:569–578, 1995
Botvin GJ, Griffin KW: Life skills training: empirical findings and future directions.
J Prim Prev 25:211–232, 2004
Brestan E, Eyberg S: Effective psychosocial treatments for conduct-disordered
children and adolescents: 29 years, 82 studies, and 5,272 kids. J Clin Child
Psychol 27:180–189, 1998
Cabiya JJ, Padillo-Cotto L, Gonzalez K, et al: Effectiveness of a cognitive-behavioral
intervention for Puerto Rican children. Interam J Psychol 42:195–202, 2008
Disruptive Behavior Disorders 463
Lonczak HS, Huang B, Catalano R, et al: The social predictors of adolescent alco-
hol misuse: a test of the social development Model. J Stud Alcohol 62:179–
189, 2001
Matthys W, Lochman JE: Oppositional Defiant Disorder and Conduct Disorder in
Childhood. Oxford, UK, Wiley-Blackwell, 2010
Miller-Johnson S, Coie JD, Maumary-Gremaud A, et al: Relationship between child-
hood peer rejection and aggression and adolescent delinquency severity and type
among African American youth. J Emot Behav Disord 7:137–146, 1999
Nock MK: Progress review of the psychosocial treatment of child conduct prob-
lems. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 10:1–28, 2003
Pardini DA, Lochman JE, Frick PJ: Callous/unemotional traits and social cognitive
processes in adjudicated youth. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 42:364–
371, 2003
Patterson GR, Reid JB, Dishion TJ: Antisocial boys. Eugene, OR, Castalia, 1992
Peterson MA, Hamilton EB, Russell AD: Starting well: facilitating the middle
school transition. Journal of Applied School Psychology 25:183–196, 2009
van de Wiel NM, Matthys W, Cohen-Kettenis PT, et al: The effectiveness of an ex-
perimental treatment when compared with care as usual depends on the type
of care as usual. Behav Modif 31:298–312, 2007
Webster-Stratton C: Enhancing the effectiveness of self-administered videotape
parent training for families with conduct-problem children. J Abnorm Child
Psychol 18:479–492, 1990
Webster-Stratton C: The incredible years: a training series for the prevention and
treatment of conduct problems in young children, in Psychosocial Treatments
for Child and Adolescent Disorders: Empirically Based Strategies for Clinical
Practice, 2nd Edition. Edited by Hibbs ED, Jensen PS. Washington, DC,
American Psychological Association, 2005, pp 507–555
Webster-Stratton C, Hammond M: Treating children with early onset conduct
problems: a comparison of child and parent training interventions. J Consult
Clin Psychol 65:93–109, 1997
Webster-Stratton C, Reid MJ, Hammond M: Treating children with early onset
conduct problems: intervention outcomes for parent, child, and teacher train-
ing. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol 33:105–124, 2004
Wells KC, Lochman JE, Lenhart LA: Coping Power Parent Group Program: Facil-
itator Guide. New York, Oxford, 2008
Williams SC, Lochman JE, Phillips NC, et al: Aggressive and nonaggressive boys’
physiological and cognitive processes in response to peer provocations. J Clin
Child Adolesc Psychol 32:568–576, 2003
Zelli A, Dodge KA, Lochman JE, et al: The distinction between beliefs legitimizing
aggression and deviant processing of social cues: testing measurement validity
and the hypothesis that biased processing mediates the effects of beliefs on
aggression. J Pers Soc Psychol 77:150–166, 1999
Zonnevylle-Bender MJS, Matthys W, van de Wiel NM, et al: Preventive effects of
treatment of disruptive behavior disorder in middle childhood on substance use
and delinquent behavior. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 46:33–39, 2007
This page intentionally left blank
13
Enuresis and
Encopresis
Patrick C. Friman, Ph.D.
Thomas M. Reimers, Ph.D.
John Paul Legerski, Ph.D.
467
468 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Enuresis
Diagnosis and Prevalence
Enuresis is the collective term for chronic urinary accidents occurring after
the conventional age of completed toilet training. The diagnostic criteria in
the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders, 4th Edition,
Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR; American Psychiatric Association 2000) in-
clude repeated urination into beds or clothing at least twice a week for at
least 3 months after the age of 5 years or the attainment of a 5-year level of
development if the child has a developmental disability. Additionally, the ac-
Enuresis and Encopresis 469
Empirical Support
The primary active component in all empirically supported CBT treat-
ments for enuresis is the urine alarm. Reviews of the literature show that
the success rate of the alarm is higher and its relapse rate lower than any
other method, including drug treatment and empirically supported non-
drug treatments, such as retention-control training. Outcomes from alarm-
based treatment range as high as 80% for success and as low as 17% for re-
lapse (Christophersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007, 2008; Mellon and
McGrath 2000). One problem with interpreting the review literature on
alarm treatment is that adjunctive components are often added to improve
effectiveness, resulting in treatment “packages.” Following the section on
theoretical perspectives below, we will describe the treatment components
and the treatment packages that have the most empirical support. How-
ever, because the effectiveness of the urine alarm when used alone ranges
as high as 70% and because it is the central component of the major treat-
ment packages, it should be considered the most empirically supported
treatment for all types of enuresis—nocturnal, mixed, and diurnal.
Theoretical Perspectives
Early psychological theory attributed the cause of enuresis to defective intra-
psychic variables (Sperling 1994); however, the forward march of science has
significantly reduced the relevance of the psychopathological perspective on
enuresis (Christophersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007, 2008). Among the
470 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
many contributors to this turn of events are the absence of scientifically se-
cured outcomes of treatment based on that perspective, the abundance of sci-
entifically secured outcomes of CBT (especially but not only alarm based),
and research showing the significant role a family history of enuresis plays in
the genesis of enuresis, regardless of whether afflicted children live with af-
flicted blood relatives. For a brief time in the 1990s, a cognitive perspective on
enuresis emerged following a report of cognitive therapy competing favorably
with conditioning treatment in a comparative trial (Ronen et al. 1992). Two
other papers describing successful cognitive therapy were published by the
same group (Ronen and Wozner 1995; Ronen et al. 1995), but they essentially
report the same findings. The relevance of cognitive theory that emerged fol-
lowing the initial study has diminished to almost nil, however, for at least four
reasons. First, after more than 15 years, the findings still have not been inde-
pendently replicated, despite the ease of their application. Second, the find-
ings are dramatically inconsistent, with over 50 years of research showing the
routine success of behavioral approaches and the routine failure of purely psy-
chological (e.g., cognitive) approaches to treatment of enuresis (Christo-
phersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007, 2008; Houts 1991, 2000; Mellon
and McGrath 2000). Third, the authors made no attempt to explain how a
purely cognitive approach could so powerfully influence a problem that has
such a fundamentally biological basis. Fourth and finally, the original study is
flawed methodologically in several ways (see Houts 2000 for a thorough cri-
tique). At present, the dominant theoretical perspective on enuresis is the
biobehavioral model, which assumes that enuresis results from a combination
of genetic predisposition and manipulable environmental events (Christo-
phersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007, 2008). Those manipulable events
provide the behavioral source material for CBT for successful treatment.
However, there is a role for cognition in the treatment of enuresis, al-
beit a supportive rather than a directly active one. Specifically, the incon-
tinent child is typically included in all discussions of treatment—and the
child’s understanding of the condition, its likely course, the benefits of
treatment, and the value of full compliance is important for treatment
progress. It is extremely important that the child be made aware that the
condition is not due to any psychological or characterological deficiency on
his or her part, and this too is a cognitive rather than a behavioral matter.
Treatment Components
Urine Alarm
Bed devices. The urine alarm uses a moisture-sensitive switching sys-
tem that when closed by contact with urine-seeped bedding, completes a
Enuresis and Encopresis 471
Retention-Control Training
Retention-control training (RCT) was developed following the observation
that many enuretic children had reduced functional bladder capacity, the
primary characteristic of which is frequent small volume urinations
472 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Waking Schedule
This treatment component involves waking enuretic children and guiding
them to the bathroom for urination. There are multiple potential benefits,
including changes in arousal, increased access to the reinforcing properties
of dry nights, managing urinary urge in lighter stages of sleep, and reduc-
tion in the length of time children must hold their urine. The early use of
waking schedules typically required full awakening, often with sessions
that occurred in the middle of the night, but subsequent modifications to
the procedure involved only partial awakening and conducting waking ses-
Enuresis and Encopresis 473
sions just before the parent’s normal bedtime, with no loss of effective-
ness. To use the waking schedule, have the parent who goes to bed latest
wake the incontinent child and take him or her to the bathroom for urina-
tion. If the bed is already wet, wake the child 15 minutes earlier the next
night. After one week of accident-free nights, have the parent awaken the
child one half-hour earlier. Continue making the wake times earlier until
the child’s original bedtime is reached.
Overlearning
Overlearning is a nocturnal version of RCT. Like the RCT procedure, this
method requires that children drink extra fluids—but just before bedtime
rather than during the day. Overlearning is an adjunctive strategy only, and
is used primarily to enhance the maintenance of treatment effects estab-
lished by alarm-based means. Thus, it should not be initiated until a dry-
ness criterion has been reached (e.g., 7 dry nights; Houts and Liebert
1985).
Cleanliness Training
Some form of consequential effort directed toward returning soiled beds,
bed clothing, and pajamas to a presoiled state is a standard part of empir-
ically supported treatment packages for enuresis. It has not been evaluated
independently of other components, and thus, the extent of its contribu-
tion to outcome is unknown. However, its contribution to the logic of
treatment is obvious, as is its relevance to the training of responsibility in
childhood, and thus we recommend its inclusion in all treatment for en-
uresis.
Reward Systems
Although contingent rewards alone are unlikely to cure enuresis, they are a
component of multiple empirically supported programs, and they are rou-
tinely recommended in papers describing effective treatment (Christo-
phersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007, 2008). With the current state of the
literature, it is impossible to determine their independent role in treatment.
A plausible possibility is that they sustain the enuretic child’s motivation to
participate in treatment, especially when the system reinforces success in
small steps. If dry nights are initially infrequent and motivation begins to
wane, decreases in the size of the urine stain can be used as the criterion for
earning a reward. To measure these decreases, merely place tracing paper
over the urine spot and trace it and then compare it with previous tracings.
474 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Fluid Restriction
Listing fluid restriction among treatment components with well-estab-
lished contributions to effective treatment presents an anomaly. Specifi-
cally, no research of any kind has ever shown fluid restriction to contribute
to the success of an enuresis treatment program. We mention fluid restric-
tion here because despite the complete absence of supportive evidence, it
continues to be an integral part of most treatments. We base our position
on the absence of evidence for several compelling reasons. First, fluid re-
striction is probably the most widely used intervention for enuresis in the
world. Second, it is probably the easiest form of treatment to conduct.
Third, its effects, if there were to be any, would be relatively easy to mea-
sure. Despite these characteristics of fluid restriction, it still has absolutely
no empirical support. Thus, we assert that it should not be part of any
treatment plan, with one exception. Specifically, if an enuretic child drinks
fluids to excess before bedtime, then his or her fluid intake should be re-
duced—not because of the enuresis, but because of the excess.
Medication
There are two primary drugs used for treatment of enuresis: imipramine
(Tofranil) and desmopressin (DDAVP). The former is a tricyclic antidepres-
sant whose mechanism for reducing bed-wetting is not clear; it appears to
make the bladder less sensitive to filling, thus allowing it to hold more urine
before urinary urge. Desmopressin is a synthetic antidiuretic that concen-
trates urine, thus decreasing urine volume and intrabladder pressure. Be-
cause of alarming reports of the potential cardiotoxic effects of imipramine
overdose (Herson et al. 1979) and other side effects of imipramine, desmo-
pressin briefly emerged as the most preferable medication for enuresis
Enuresis and Encopresis 475
Empirically Supported
Treatment Packages
The oldest, best-known, empirically supported treatment package is dry-bed
training (Azrin et al. 1974). Initially evaluated for use with a group of adults
with profound mental retardation, it has been systematically replicated nu-
merous times across child populations. In addition to the bed alarm, its initial
composition included overlearning, intensive cleanliness training, intensive
positive practice (of alternatives to wetting), hourly awakenings, close mon-
itoring, and rewards for success. In subsequent iterations, the stringency of
the waking schedule and the cleanliness training was reduced, positive prac-
tice was eliminated, and RCT was added. Other similar programs have also
been developed, the best known and most empirically supported of which is
full-spectrum home training (FSHT; Houts and Liebert 1985). FSHT in-
cludes use of the alarm, cleanliness training, RCT, and overlearning. Multiple
variations are now available (Christophersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007,
2008). Component analyses have been conducted on both dry-bed training
and FSHT programs, and the findings show that the alarm is the critical ele-
ment and that the probability of success increases as additional components
are added (Bollard and Nettelbeck 1982; Houts et al. 1986).
and parent willingness, and family resources (see Table 13–2 and Sug-
gested Readings and Web Sites at the end of this chapter for information
on obtaining necessary materials, such as the alarm). Strive to include the
waking schedule, reward system, and responsibility training with the
alarm. “Titrate” the components in the plan over time in accord with fam-
ily resources and motivation until a cure is obtained. For example, a two-
parent, one-wage earner, middle-income family with a motivated 10-year-
old bed-wetting child whose parents are also motivated could start with all
treatment components at once (i.e., alarm, waking schedule, Kegel exer-
cises, overlearning, RCT, cleanliness training, rewards).
When families have fewer resources or less motivation to conduct treat-
ment, prescribe fewer components but strive to ensure the alarm is one of
478 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Implications of Diversity
The major diversity issue in studies of enuresis involves gender. Enuretic boys
outnumber enuretic girls by as much as 3 to 1. On the basis of the abundance
of evidence indicating this disparity, one group of epidemiological researchers
has recommended changing the diagnostic criteria for boys from age 5 to age
8 because the proportion of enuretic girls at age 5 is about the same as the pro-
portion of boys at age 8. The implication of this position is our recommenda-
tion that clinicians consider delaying treatment for boys who at age 5 meet
criteria for enuresis but who clearly lack the motivation to participate in treat-
ment or the maturity to benefit from it. Cross-cultural research also indicates
that although enuresis is more prevalent in the United States than in Europe
and other developed countries such as Thailand and China, it may be more
prevalent in some developing countries, such as Nigeria. Enuresis is also more
prevalent in populations that have lower socioeconomic status or that exhibit
significant psychosocial deviancy, such as children in institutionalized settings
(for reviews covering this material, see Friman 1986, 2007).
Enuresis and Encopresis 479
Challenges to Treatment
One critical challenge to treatment is the rare but real possibility of a phys-
iopathic cause of enuresis (e.g., diabetes, urinary tract infection). Although
fewer than 10% of cases are attributed to these causes, alarm treatment in
these cases may be contraindicated. For this reason, it is paramount to re-
fer all enuretic children to a physician for a physical examination before
beginning CBT in earnest. When physiopathic causes are ruled out, age,
developmental level, and motivation levels are cardinal concerns. For ex-
ample, we recommend that CBT be forestalled until enuretic boys are at
least 7 years old or until girls are at least 5 years old (unless either younger
boys or girls are highly motivated). The difference in ages is due to the
lower incidence of enuresis, higher motivation, and advanced maturation
in enuretic girls versus boys. If the enuretic child is not motivated, suspend
treatment for 3–6 months and schedule a follow-up with the child and
family at that point.
Another challenge to treatment involves punishment. As mentioned
earlier, incontinence is a major cause of child abuse. With no access to ef-
fective treatment, parents faced with their child’s chronic incontinence
are at risk for directing punishing responses to their child’s accidents, rang-
ing from direct and indirect expressions of frustration to harsh physical
discipline. Prescribing effective treatment can reduce the risk, but to elim-
inate it altogether, we recommend that clinicians assess for a history of
punishment and obtain a verbal commitment from parents (with the en-
uretic child present) to never again punish or even criticize the child for
having accidents.
A final challenge involves nonadherence to treatment, in the child, par-
ents, or both. To limit child nonadherence, assess for motivation and capac-
ity to perform prescribed treatment steps and refrain from prescribing
steps that children are unwilling or unable to perform. To increase motiva-
tion, use a system that rewards progress in small increments—for example,
for dry nights, decreases in the size of the urine spot, or even compliance
with components of treatment. To limit parental nonadherence, follow sim-
ilar steps: assess for motivation and capacity and prescribe only steps that
parents are willing and able to perform. Help parents identify signs of
progress, which range from multiple dry nights for some children to mere
performance of treatment steps for others. More generally, describe conti-
nence as a skill that can be attained readily with diligent practice of treat-
ment steps; disclose that dry nights could be slow in coming, especially for
children with multiple nightly accidents; and schedule periodic booster
clinic visits and/or telephone calls to monitor progress.
480 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Case Example
Tommy is a white 8-year-old boy who lives at home with his natural parents
and two younger siblings, a girl age 5 and a boy age 3. His medical, psychi-
atric, developmental, and educational histories are unremarkable. He is in
the second grade and works a little below his potential, but routinely earns
grades in the B range. He is well liked in school and has at least two good
friends. At home, beyond some moderate resistance to bedtime, he does
not pose any behavior problems. His relationship with his siblings is de-
scribed as positive. The referral concern involved primary nocturnal enure-
sis. According to the parents, Tommy has been nocturnally incontinent
since birth and to the best of their memory, has never had a dry night. In
fact, they complained that he sometimes has more than one accident at
night. Although approached by grandparents, aunts and uncles, and his par-
ents about working harder to stay dry, he exhibited little interest in conti-
nence until a recent episode involving an accident while on a camping trip.
He had a friend along for the trip and was embarrassed by the friend’s dis-
covery of his accident, and from that point forward, he has been very con-
cerned about learning how to have dry nights.
His parents brought him to his primary care physician, who did a routine
physical examination including a urinalysis, and ruled out all organic causes
for nocturnal enuresis. During the history, it was revealed that Tommy’s fa-
ther had a history of nocturnal enuresis that ended at about age 9. Following
the physical examination, the physician referred Tommy and his parents to
a psychologist specializing in CBT, and that person began treatment by con-
ducting a joint interview with Tommy and his parents.
The psychologist explained the role of family history in the cause of en-
uresis and that it was unlikely that any form of psychopathology played a
significant determining role. However, he explained that the parental, fam-
ily, and social response to accidents could cause psychological problems if
it was aversive and perpetuated. Following that, he solicited Tommy’s par-
ticipation in treatment and reviewed all of the available treatment options
he had at his disposal, which included the urine alarm, RCT, waking sched-
ule, responsibility training, a reward system, and Kegel exercises. Also, in
the presence of the parents, he explained to Tommy that children who wet
their bed should never be punished for wetting. Additionally, he also com-
municated that it would be fine for Tommy to have water before bed as
long as he didn’t drink an excessive amount. He explained to the parents
that fluid restriction had never shown a significant role in reducing noctur-
nal accidents unless incontinent children were shown to be drinking exces-
sively before bed. Finally, he drew a picture of the bladder and explained
how the process of urination worked and how the alarm system, along with
the other treatment components, would influence Tommy’s system and
help him learn how to have dry nights.
Jointly, Tommy and his parents selected all of the treatment compo-
nents that were described. For the reward system, the parents selected the
dot-to-dot program, and Tommy selected a new video game as his reward.
While in the doctor’s office, Tommy and his mother drew a picture of the
video game using dots and the psychologist provided a handout describing
Enuresis and Encopresis 481
the reward system for the parents to bring home. The psychologist also
asked that the parents monitor progress along with Tommy using a calendar
to be attached to the refrigerator that could be easily inspected by them
and by Tommy. The parents also asked to include one other component in
the treatment program, one that has not been shown to play a role in the
treatment of enuresis, but that very well could play a role in the social ac-
ceptability of treatment. Specifically, the parents asked whether it might
be helpful if when Tommy said his prayers at night, he could ask for God
to help him have a dry night, and the psychologist agreed that it would be
a good idea. The parents obtained the urine alarm by consulting the Bed-
wetting Store online, and the brand they selected was the Nytone, which
attached to the pajamas.
The outcome of the case was successful, although Tommy did not have
a dry night for the first month or so. In fact, the parents initially com-
plained that he slept through the alarm and that its sound awakened one
or the other of them, and they then would wake him and take him to the
bathroom. However, as the program progressed, the alarm began to
awaken Tommy, at which point he would take himself to the bathroom, but
he would also alert one of his parents to help him. As the program pro-
gressed further, the alarm would quickly awaken Tommy, at which point
he would turn it off, and his accident would be so small that it didn’t re-
quire that he do anything about the accident until his typical wake-up time.
And finally, he began sleeping through the night without the alarm going
off, eventually one or two times a week, and ultimately ending with only
one or two accidents per month. At that point, the psychologist terminated
care and recommended that the parents stay in touch if questions arose.
Although the amount of clinical contact varies, for this case, the psycholo-
gist saw Tommy and his parents for the initial session and then Tommy with
one parent for two subsequent sessions, and the rest was done by tele-
phone follow-up.
Conclusion: Enuresis
Enuresis is the third most distressing experience reported by children, ex-
ceeded only by divorce and parental fights (Van Tijen et al. 1998). Left un-
treated, enuresis will likely persist for years, and in some cases, into young
adulthood, with considerable negative social consequences and disruption
of family life. Urine alarm treatment is an easily used, highly effective
method for treating one of the most prevalent and chronic of all childhood
problems. It represents an enormous breakthrough for enuretic children
because 1) it does not involve the physically aversive experiences typical
of ancient treatments; 2) its effectiveness undermines the historical psy-
chopathological characterization of enuresis; and 3) it eliminates much of
the expense, high relapse, and potential side effects of medication treat-
ment. Furthermore, the effectiveness of urine alarm treatment when used
alone is high and can be raised even higher when combined with any or all
482 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Encopresis
Diagnosis and Prevalence
The diagnostic criteria for encopresis outlined in DSM-IV-TR (American
Psychiatric Association 2000) include 1) repeated passage of feces into
inappropriate places (e.g., clothing or floor), whether voluntary or unin-
tentional; 2) at least one such event a month for at least 3 months; 3) chro-
nological age of at least 4 years (or equivalent developmental level); and
4) the determination that the behavior is not exclusively due to a physio-
logical effect of a substance (e.g., laxatives) or a general medical condition,
except through a mechanism involving constipation. Similar criteria are
outlined in the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Re-
lated Health Problems, 10th Revision (ICD-10; World Health Organiza-
tion 2007).
Two subtypes are identified with the DSM-IV-TR criteria for enco-
presis: with constipation and overflow incontinence (787.6) and without
constipation and overflow incontinence (307.7). For the subtype with con-
stipation, there should be evidence of constipation from a physical exam-
ination by a physician or a history of having a bowel movement on no more
than three occasions during a week. Individuals with this subtype typically
have stools that are poorly formed, with continuous leakage during the day
and in rare cases at night. Only small amounts of feces are passed in the
toilet and successful treatment usually involves intervention components
aimed at relieving the constipation (i.e., enemas, laxatives). In cases of
encopresis without constipation, stools are generally well formed, with
soiling intermittent and deposited in a toilet. Children with encopresis
without constipation typically present with comorbid emotional and be-
havioral problems; thus, treatment efforts for this subtype focus on the re-
mediation of psychological and behavioral problems (Friman 2008).
Prevalence rates in the United States are estimated to be around 1%–
3%, with boys three to six times more often affected than girls (Schonwald
and Rappaport 2008). Rates of fecal incontinence have shown to be 4.4%
in primary care pediatric settings (Loening-Bauck 2007). A Dutch popula-
Enuresis and Encopresis 483
tion-based study found that 4.1% of children ages 5–6 years and 1.6% of
children ages 11–12 years experienced soiling incidents once a month (van
der Wal et al. 2005), and comparable rates were found in the United King-
dom (Joinson et al. 2007).
Empirical Support
An obstacle to supportive research for CBT treatment of encopresis in-
volves the transdisciplinary, biobehavioral approaches to the disorder that
are most frequently used. It is virtually impossible to tease out the unique
cognitive, behavioral, or biomedical components, because successful treat-
ment almost always involves all three (Christophersen and Friman 2010).
Biofeedback represents a fourth, less commonly used biomedical-CBT ap-
proach that appears to have no greater level of effectiveness than behav-
ioral-medical interventions (Brooks et al. 2000). Medical interventions
have traditionally focused on three areas: 1) cleansing the bowels, 2) en-
couraging regular bowel movements with the use of facilitative medica-
tions, and 3) regulating dietary intake (Christophersen and Friman 2010).
In their most basic forms, CBT approaches emphasize the use of posi-
tive reinforcement to motivate the child’s adherence and success in using
appropriate toileting practices. Mildly aversive components are also some-
times used, in the form of overcorrection practices in which the child par-
ticipates in cleaning himself or herself and the soiled clothing after a bout
of encopresis (Reimers 1996). Many CBT treatment programs also incor-
porate stimulus-control procedures, enhanced scheduling, enhanced
health education, and various types of monitoring. These CBT approaches
are often administered alone or used to supplement biomedical interven-
tions put into place.
A number of studies have examined the effectiveness of these differ-
ent treatment modalities. In their meta-analysis, McGrath et al. (2000)
found that no published study at the time met criteria frequently used by
psychologists to determine which interventions can be declared empiri-
cally well established (Chambless and Ollendick 2001). Two studies using
a combination of medical plus behavioral interventions were shown to be
probably efficacious. Two extensive behavioral interventions plus medical
interventions also were shown to meet the efficacy criteria for the treat-
ment of constipation plus incontinence.
Another study published at the same time (Brooks et al. 2000) in-
cluded a review of randomized controlled published studies involving
medical, behavioral, psychological, and biofeedback treatments for enco-
presis, functional constipation, and stool-toileting refusal in preschool-age
and school-age children. This review found that anal sphincter biofeed-
484 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Theoretical Perspectives
There have been multiple theoretical perspectives on encopresis through-
out history, but the current dominant viewpoint involves a combination of
biological, learning/behavioral, and cognitive components; and consistent
with the theme of this book, we will refer to it as the CBT perspective.
Historically, early unpleasant toileting experiences were thought to deter-
mine personality and behavior (Freud 1905/1953). Although no actual re-
search confirmed or even supported this perspective, vestiges of this
position remain operative to this day (Friman 2002); this viewpoint is so
deeply rooted in antiquated theory and so resistant to the influence of
abundant contrary scientific evidence that it can be discarded as nonsense
with impunity (Sperling 1994). The problem with this position involves its
association with psychodynamic theory. The predicate for the initial posi-
tion involved infant sexuality (Freud 1905/1953), and as the position
evolved, a sexualized perspective on toilet training and incontinence re-
mained (Aruffo et al. 2000; Sperling 1994). As a blatant and disturbingly
mainstream example, the description of encopresis without constipation
in DSM-IV-TR (American Psychiatric Association 2000) includes an asso-
ciation with anal masturbation, despite there being no supportive scientific
evidence.
In early attempts to sketch an account of encopresis consistent with
the CBT theoretical perspective, Levine (1982) and colleagues described
Enuresis and Encopresis 485
Assessment
Obviously assessment is an important dimension of CBT treatment for any
disorder, but it is particularly important to conduct a thorough assessment
of the child’s behavioral, family, and bowel-training history before develop-
ing a treatment plan. Additionally and most importantly, it is critical with
encopresis to refer all cases to the primary care physician for a physical ex-
amination before initiating treatment (as with enuresis). It is not necessary
to refer affected children to a gastroenterologist; doing so prematurely
could lead to unnecessarily invasive and expensive biomedical evaluations.
We recommend that clinicians surrender the decision of whether to involve
specialists to the primary care physician. As for the clinician’s own assess-
ment, we recommend that it be conducted separately with the parents and
then with the child (age 4 and above). This approach allows both parties to
be less inhibited when sharing sensitive information (e.g., family mental
health history, negative behaviors or attributes of the child).
Parent Intake
Below, we will highlight a few general questions that are likely to be in-
cluded in the standard clinical assessment, highlighting those issues that
are relevant to the assessment and treatment of encopresis. Although it
will often be helpful to gain the child’s perspective on these issues, the cli-
486 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
nician may choose to reserve some of these questions for the parent intake
when considering the age of the child and the sensitivity of the questions.
Name:
Date of birth:
Stool Assessment
Date
Number of
stools in toilet
Number of
soiling episodes
Consistency
of stools a
Difficulty
ratingb
Medicine
taking
Medicine
amount
a
Enter number from Stool Consistency Continuum.
b
See Difficulty With Stool Passage Scale.
that it is taken. The timing of stool softener can sometimes have an effect
on the pattern of the child’s bowel movements.
What are the quality of the child’s diet and quantity of daily exercise?
The child’s dietary habits and level of exercise can impact both the fre-
quency and consistency of his or her bowel movements. In general, learn-
488 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
ing that a child has a “typical” diet and level of physical activity is probably
sufficient. In some cases, it is helpful to have the parents provide a descrip-
tion or log of a typical day regarding their child’s diet and physical activity.
This description will allow an assessment of whether a child has a diet that
is high in fat or low in fiber. Both fat and fiber intake can impact the bowel
habits of some children. Although high-fat diets are often blamed for fecal
impaction or infrequent stools in some children, the effect of high-fat diets
is idiosyncratic. However, if a child presents with a dietary history that is
atypical—that is, in which the balance is tilted in one direction or an-
other—then it may be necessary to have a discussion with the parents
about balancing their child’s diet and possibly increasing their child’s level
of physical activity.
What was the child’s experience with toilet training? Ascertain at what
age the parents started toilet training; whether the parents focused on
urine training, bowel training, or both; and the level of success achieved.
Question the parents about the type of approach that they have used and
the use of both positive reinforcement and punishment, as well as the
length of time spent during the training process. Determine the child’s re-
sponse to the parents’ training efforts, and focus on how the parents man-
age resistance on the part of their child, soiling accidents, and other
setbacks. It is especially important to determine to what level, if any, pun-
ishment techniques have been used. Finally, it is important to determine if
the child has ever experienced partial or complete success with either
urine or bowel training. Many children present with no experience with
Enuresis and Encopresis 489
complete success in the area of bowel training, while others have experi-
enced months or even years of success before the onset of the encopresis.
How frequently does the child have soiling incidents? Assess what
percentage of the child’s bowel movements result in some type of soiling
episode. Some children with encopresis will have occasional successful
bowel movements in the toilet, whereas other children experience a soil-
ing episode of some type with each bowel movement. Other children ap-
pear to have what can be considered an “accident” when they pass fecal
matter into their clothing because of the loose consistency of their stool or
because they did not respond quickly enough to the physical urge to have
a bowel movement. For some children, the soiling episode clearly involves
some volitional control. This includes children who hide in their room or
in a quiet part of the house while they intentionally have a bowel move-
ment, or children who have a bowel movement in their clothing regardless
of where they are, with no interest or intention of attempting to void in
the toilet.
What is the routine for managing the child’s toileting? The toileting
routine used by parents of encopretic children will likely vary from the ap-
proach that they used when they were initially toilet training their chil-
dren. The frustration caused by the child’s lack of success or the onset of
soiling accidents will cause parents to develop a variety of approaches and
routines to manage their child’s toileting habits. Ask parents to describe
their general routine for managing their child’s toileting habits and include
questions pertaining to scheduled sit times on the toilet, the parents’ re-
sponse when they see their child gesturing that he or she is about to have
a bowel movement, and the length of time that the child is expected to sit
on the toilet.
What type of underclothing does the child usually wear? The type
of underclothing that children wear can have an important effect on their
success with managing encopresis. Allowing children to wear diapers and
Pull-Ups beyond the developmentally appropriate age inhibits motivation
to use the toilet and is an obstacle to success. Some children insist on put-
ting on a Pull-Up when they need to have a bowel movement, only to be
accommodated by their parents. Ask parents about their child’s history
with the use of diapers, Pull-Ups, training pants, and regular underwear
and their current use of all of these throughout the day.
Child Intake
Conducting the child intake assessment separately will allow the clinician
to obtain more accurate information and perceptions from the child with-
out him or her being influenced by the parents’ presence. Learn the termi-
nology parents and child use to describe bowel movements and the
toileting practices that are in place. Obtaining the child’s perception of the
physical cues to which he or she attends when the toileting urge occurs is
Enuresis and Encopresis 491
important. This will allow discussion with the child about how he or she
responds to those physical cues. For example, does the child ignore them,
seek the parents’ assistance, or make an effort to have a bowel movement
independently? Review with the child his or her understanding of any
scheduled sit times that have been put in place, his or her perception of
personal responsibilities regarding toileting practices, what consequences
are in place for soiling accidents, and any rewards that may be available to
him or her for successfully voiding in the toilet. Finally, meeting with the
child separately will provide an opportunity to discuss, at the child’s level,
the treatment goals that involve helping him or her to learn to successfully
and reliably have all bowel movements in the toilet. This should be reiter-
ated with the parents as well.
Treatment
The treatment of encopresis does not follow the same course as that of
other disorders. For example, the treatment of disorders such as anxiety,
depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) involves
the assessment and treatment of a constellation of symptoms that consti-
tute the disorder, whereas encopresis can be assessed and defined in a
much more concrete manner—that is, the child is either successfully void-
ing in the toilet 100% of the time or he or she is not. Some children with
encopresis have never successfully voided in the toilet, whereas other chil-
dren have had good success with toilet training and are having only occa-
sional accidents. Thus, children vary regarding where they fall in the
appropriate bowel movement continuum. Because of that, it is perhaps
more prudent to develop a treatment plan based on the point in the toilet-
ing process where children are struggling. Thus, we have developed a sim-
ple task analysis to allow clinicians to determine where in the toileting
process their client is having success and where he or she needs interven-
tion. The steps below compose the task analysis that we typically use.
Children who are being evaluated for encopresis are experiencing prob-
lems with one of the above steps. Thus, the treatment approach and the na-
ture of the initial treatment session(s) will be dependent on where each child
falls on the task analysis continuum. Accordingly, we have outlined below a
492 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Educational Approach
The gastrointestinal system. Most parents, understandably, do not
have a thorough or full understanding of how the gastrointestinal (GI) sys-
tem works. A diagram (e.g., Levine 1982) or some other visual aid can be
beneficial when educating parents about the mechanics of the GI system
in general and about how fecal impaction and constipation affect the colon
in particular. It is important to help parents understand that when their
child’s colon becomes stretched from impaction, he or she is likely to lose
colonic sensation, thus adversely affecting the normal bowel movement
cycle. This explanation will also help parents understand that in most
cases, their child’s encopresis is not intentional and that there are clear
physical factors that need to be addressed, along with the behavioral inter-
vention. Parents’ increased understanding of the mechanics of the colon,
along with the importance of keeping their child’s stools soft, will hope-
fully help parents establish and maintain good compliance with their
child’s daily regimen of stool softeners as well as the behavioral recom-
mendations that are offered to them.
Mechanics. Young or physically small children will often sit on the toilet
with their feet dangling. This positioning makes it difficult for them to ad-
equately relax or to use proper musculature when attempting to have a
bowel movement. To avoid this problem, ensure that there is solid support
for the child’s feet when he or she is seated on the toilet and attempting a
bowel movement. A small stepstool can make a large difference in the me-
chanics needed for a child to have a successful bowel movement.
Diet and exercise. If the child has a diet that is inadequate in fluid in-
take and/or low in fiber, or if the child does not get an adequate amount
of exercise, then it will be important to educate parents about the benefits
of balancing the child’s diet, increasing fluids, and encouraging more phys-
ical activity. All of these factors will help promote normal bowel activity
(Dwyer 1995). The role of stool softeners, diet, and exercise is a critical
part of the treatment approach, and it is important for parents to know the
importance of any needed changes in these areas.
Parental demeanor. By the time that parents bring their child for man-
agement of encopresis, they are likely to be frustrated and to have yelled
or screamed at, or even spanked, their child for having accidents. Punitive
Enuresis and Encopresis 493
with sitting on the toilet and reaching a level of relaxation that will facilitate
a successful bowel movement. For young children, have parents “practice”
having their child sit on the toilet for very brief (30–60 seconds) periods of
time. This can be done multiple times throughout the day, with the parent
verbally praising or rewarding the child in some small way for participating.
The use of a timer can help facilitate the child’s cooperation, because the
child will know that the time that he or she spends sitting on the toilet is
limited. As the child’s level of cooperation increases, the amount of time
can be increased until the child is sitting on a regular basis for 5–10 minutes.
Once children are cooperatively sitting on the toilet for 5–10 minutes, help
parents establish a routine for regular sit times. As mentioned above, an
ideal time for children to sit on a regular basis is 15–20 minutes after a
meal, with the child sitting for 5–10 minutes. Having the child sit after
meals is designed to coordinate with the increased activity of the GI system
following meals. This will hopefully increase the probability for the child
passing stool in the toilet. As treatment progresses, work toward fading out
scheduled sit times and promoting and reinforcing independence. How-
ever, initially, scheduled sit times will be important. For young children, the
use of small, tangible rewards can help to promote cooperation. Continued
use of a timer to regulate the time spent sitting will also continue to be im-
portant. These and other shaping techniques should be used to promote
teaching the child to sit cooperatively for a length of time that will provide
him or her with the opportunity to relax and have a bowel movement. Once
sitting cooperatively has been accomplished, efforts can be made toward
promoting successful bowel movements.
reward also does not tend to be problematic for most parents, who are un-
derstandably concerned about their child’s nutrition. We recommend plac-
ing the dispenser on a bathroom counter or in a location that is visible to
the child but not easily accessible. These types of rewards could be used
to promote both sitting on and voiding in the toilet. For example, the child
could receive one Skittle (or other similar small candy) for sitting and sev-
eral for passing stool into the toilet. The main point here is that for young
children especially, the visual and immediate benefits of having this type
of reward evident for sitting and/or voiding are often necessary.
Sticker charts. Depending on the child’s level of motivation and the value
that he or she attributes to earning stickers, the use of a sticker chart can be
very motivating toward reinforcing both sitting and voiding. For children
who can count to a particular number or who understand quantity, consid-
eration should be given toward providing an additional reward for earning a
set number of stickers. For example, the clinician might ask a 4-year-old
child to draw four circles on a piece of paper and decorate it to signify its use
for documenting sitting and voiding. Each time that the child voids in the
toilet, a sticker would be placed on one of the circles. Once the child has
earned four stickers, he or she would earn an additional (not easily accessi-
ble) reward. This type of strategy will provide immediate feedback to the
child for his or her successfully sitting and voiding, and at the same time,
provide some intermediate reward for cumulative progress.
Wrapped rewards. These types of rewards are often useful for children
ages 3–6. Have the parents purchase small, inexpensive trinkets at a local
novelty store and wrap them using aluminum foil or some other wrap. The
reward should be placed in a basket that is visible to the child but not easily
accessible. The child should be told that each time that he or she voids in
the toilet, he or she will earn one of the rewards and will be allowed to un-
wrap it. Many children are motivated to put forth additional effort to void
in the toilet in order to earn the “mystery reward.”
Reward jar. The use of a reward jar is likely more appropriate for older
children (age 5 and older) and should be combined with immediate, tangi-
ble rewards. To implement this strategy, the parents select a jar in which
some type of token will be placed. The parent should discuss with the child
the different types of activities or rewards that the child would like to earn,
starting with small rewards and working up toward something larger. Once
a series of four or five rewards has been identified, the parent and child
should work together to rank the items from least expensive and motivating
to most expensive and motivating. The parent then writes the names of the
496 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
items on pieces of masking tape and places them on the jar in order, begin-
ning with the least expensive–motivating reward on the bottom and ending
with the most expensive–motivating reward at the top of the jar. The child
will earn one token each time that he or she sits on the toilet cooperatively
and two tokens each time that he or she voids in the toilet. The tokens
could include things such as pennies, marbles, poker chips, cotton balls, and
so forth. The size of the token will depend on the size of the jar and how
quickly the parent wants the child to earn the rewards. The child will con-
tinue to receive immediate, tangible rewards for sitting on or voiding in the
toilet but will also add tokens to the reward jar. The tokens should be in a
visible place, ideally in the bathroom. Parents should review with their child
his or her progress and how closely the child is getting toward earning the
next reward. Once the child has filled the reward jar, the process can start
over, with the child selecting new rewards, if he or she so chooses.
to check the technique that their young children (under age 5) are using
to make sure that they are wiping appropriately. Older children should be
reminded to wipe and clean themselves appropriately. Parents can check
the child’s underwear periodically to monitor this. Instruct the parents to
provide some type of reinforcement to their child when his or her under-
wear is found clean (e.g., a treat, points, verbal praise) to enhance compli-
ance with the monitoring procedure.
If possible, help the parent understand the difference between mild
soiling due to poor hygiene and unintentional minor soiling that can be as-
sociated with the use of stool softeners. Some children will occasionally
pass small amounts of stool with the addition of fiber and Miralax (or other
laxatives) to their daily regimen. The parents should be educated that
these types of minor soiling episodes may occur until the amount of stool
softener needed to promote regular bowel movements is reduced.
Corrective Approach
Parents need an effective way to respond to their child’s soiling episodes
(Reimers 1996). Whether soiling occurs intentionally or unintentionally,
an effective response to soiling episodes is an important component of suc-
cessful treatment (also see the section “Challenges to Treatment” later in
this chapter). An overcorrection technique is usually an effective conse-
quence that is naturally associated with the child’s soiling accident. Use of
this type of approach will remove the need for parents to use other, less
effective punishment techniques such as time-out, corporal punishment,
and verbal reprimands. In general, have parents follow the steps below af-
ter a soiling episode:
Implications of Diversity
There is much less epidemiological research on encopresis than there is on
enuresis. As with enuresis, the prevalence rate of encopresis is much
higher for boys. In terms of cultural variation in encopresis, very little is
found in the peer-reviewed literature on the subject, beyond the occa-
sional suggestion that encopresis is more likely to be found in families with
lower incomes (van der Wal et al. 2005). Although this suggestion is con-
sistent with our own experience, it has been questioned by others, who
have suggested it is merely a reflection of biased population sampling
(Fritz and Armbrust 1982). At least some early research on prevalence in-
dicates encopresis is much more frequent in boys than girls, with the ratios
ranging from 3:1 to 6:1 (Fritz and Armbrust 1982; Wright et al. 1978).
Some of the relevant research was conducted in foreign countries (Bell-
man 1966), but the samples were primarily whites from industrialized cul-
Enuresis and Encopresis 499
tures and thus not substantially different from the populations studied in
the United States. In sum, on the basis of extant empirical literature, there
are no significant implications of diversity to highlight here.
Challenges to Treatment
The most frequent and difficult challenge to treatment involves resistance
and noncompliance. Some children are resistant toward sitting on the toi-
let or entering the bathroom because of their painful bowel movement his-
tory or their negative experience with the training process that has been
used. For children who avoid entering a bathroom at all, some type of
shaping approach can be helpful by first establishing positive associations
with the bathroom itself. This could include reading, listening to music,
playing a game, or other fun activities to help eliminate the negative asso-
ciations of being in the bathroom. Once the child is able to engage in other
activities that are pleasurable in the bathroom, efforts can be made toward
shaping him or her to sit on the toilet. This may involve starting with the
child sitting on the toilet fully clothed while parents engage in some simple
activity, such as reading a book, listening to music, and so forth. For older
children, it might involve having them play some portable video game or
read a magazine while sitting. Gradually increase the expectations for the
child, such as having him or her go from being fully clothed to sitting in his
or her underwear to finally sitting unclothed on the toilet. For younger
children, the use of some type of simple, tangible reward (e.g., stickers,
small food items) may be helpful toward motivating them to follow the di-
rections. Any resistance by the child to participate should result in him or
her having no access to other preferred activities, with the parent remind-
ing the child of his or her choice to either play while sitting on the toilet
or not play at all.
For many children, the use of some simple contingency management
(described earlier) will be effective enough to promote compliance with
sitting on the toilet. We recommend avoiding time-out when possible, be-
cause it further creates negative associations with the toileting regimen
and increases conflict between the parent and child. Additionally, many
children would rather sit in time-out than sit on the toilet. Most children
will acquiesce to sitting on the toilet for a few minutes in order to gain ac-
cess to their preferred activities. Once this occurs, it will create an oppor-
tunity to shape more cooperative sitting for longer periods of time, until
the child is able to sit long enough to relax. For children who are highly re-
sistant toward sitting on the toilet or entering the bathroom, it may be nec-
essary to spend some time working with the parents on developing more
effective parenting skills and focusing on improved levels of instructional
500 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
control across a number of domains. Once these goals have been accom-
plished, it would likely be prudent to return to the management of the en-
copresis.
Case Example
Sam was a 5-year-old boy who was referred because of recurring soiling ep-
isodes. He had never been successfully toilet trained. Sam’s medical his-
tory was unremarkable. He took no medication other than Miralax for
periodic constipation. He met all developmental milestones as expected.
Outside of the encopresis, the parents noted no significant behavioral con-
cerns. Sam was otherwise compliant with demands made of him, outside
of toileting requests.
His parents had begun toilet training him when he was about 2½ years
of age. In time, he had begun engaging in some stool-holding behavior,
which led to constipation and large, painful bowel movements. Sam had
been placed on a regimen of Miralax for management of the constipation.
He continued to be resistant to his parents’ attempts to toilet train him.
His parents had reinstituted various toilet-training attempts approximately
every 6 months up to the current time. The parents had used a variety of
positive reinforcement programs, as well as some forms of punishment to
address Sam’s soiling episodes and resistance to sitting on the toilet. The
punishment strategies included time-out, spanking, and loss of privileges.
The parents noted that their efforts had not caused any significant im-
provements in Sam’s voiding in the toilet. Sam would urinate in the toilet
but was not having bowel movements in the toilet.
Despite taking Miralax, Sam would frequently attempt to hold his
stool for as long as possible. This would often lead to him having a large
bowel movement every 2–3 days, with some apparent overflow inconti-
nence multiple times each day. Sam would also hide when having a bowel
movement, and at times, hide his soiled underwear. This increased his par-
ents’ frustration and led to additional forms of punishment. Most recently,
he had seen a gastroenterologist, who admitted Sam to the hospital for a
fecal impaction clean-out. Sam’s pediatrician continued to monitor his
constipation and toileting difficulties. Given the long-standing soiling epi-
sodes and toileting difficulties, Sam and his parents were referred to a CBT
psychologist. (It is important to note here that we did not refer Sam for a
physical examination because he was referred to us by his primary care
physician.)
CBT Evaluation
During the intake assessment, the psychologist reviewed with Sam’s par-
ents his past medical history and their efforts to toilet train Sam. The ther-
apist obtained a thorough description of the toilet-training strategies the
parents had used as well as their use of different punishment techniques.
The parents had used a variety of sticker charts and other tangible reward
systems to motivate Sam to void in the toilet. The psychologist also learned
Enuresis and Encopresis 501
that the parents used time-out, corporal punishment, and restricting access
to preferred activities each time that Sam refused to sit on the toilet or any
time that he had a soiling episode in his clothing. The punishment tech-
niques had been used for the past 6–12 months. The parents indicated that
as their efforts met with limited success, their level of frustration in-
creased.
The psychologist met separately with Sam. It was learned during the
intake with Sam that he was afraid to sit on the toilet because he said that
it “hurt” when he had bowel movements while sitting on the toilet. Sam
also commented that he did not want his parents to know when he had a
soiling episode because he “didn’t want to get in trouble.” Sam was also
questioned about his awareness of physical cues and urges to have a bowel
movement. Sam indicated that his “tummy hurt” when he needed to “go
poop.” When asked if he tried to sit on the toilet and have a bowel move-
ment when his tummy hurt, Sam responded, “No, it will hurt.” Following
the intake assessment, the psychologist met with the parents and asked
them to collect data on Sam’s soiling episodes and their toilet-training
practices.
Data Collection
Sam’s parents were provided with a data form that allowed them, on a
daily basis, to record the number of bowel movements that Sam had in the
toilet, the number of soiling episodes, the consistency of Sam’s stools (a
chart was provided to the parents to help them record stool consistency),
a rating of the difficulty that Sam had with passing a stool, any medicine
that he was taking, and the amount of medicine taken. Additionally, the
parents were asked to record the number of times that Sam hid his soiled
underwear. They were also asked to journal their efforts toward prompting
Sam to have a bowel movement, as well as how they responded to Sam’s
successful bowel movements and accidents.
Treatment Sessions
Session 1. During the first treatment session, it was learned that Sam
was having a large bowel movement approximately every 2 days. None of
his bowel movements occurred in the toilet; all were soiling episodes. Sam
also had approximately five small liquid soiling accidents each day. Sam sat
on the toilet only on two occasions during the first week. Based on these
data and Sam’s history, the following treatment recommendations were
put in place:
ents rarely provided any candy or sweets to him at home. The par-
ents agreed to provide Sam with a piece of candy for sitting
cooperatively. They purchased a small candy dispenser, and Sam
earned one Skittle for successfully sitting on the toilet for
5 minutes (Sam seemed excited about the opportunity to earn
the Skittles).
2. The parents agreed to purchase small toys and other items, such
as action figures, that were meaningful to Sam in order to rein-
force his use of the toilet. They wrapped the toys in aluminum foil
and placed them in a basket that was placed on a shelf out of Sam’s
reach, but visible to him. Sam was told that he would be able to
unwrap one of the items any time that he had a bowel movement
in the toilet. The parents were instructed to provide one of the
items to Sam no matter how small the stool was that he passed in
the toilet.
3. The parents were asked to provide no verbal reprimands or any
form of punishment to Sam for having a soiling episode. Rather,
they were instructed on how to engage Sam in assisting them with
cleaning himself and his soiled clothing and placing new clothing
on himself to the best of his ability. The parents were encouraged
to make the cleanup process mildly aversive while maintaining a
neutral, matter-of-fact demeanor. If Sam had multiple soiling ac-
cidents and the parents were concerned about a possible rash,
then Sam was expected to soak in a bathtub for 5–10 minutes to
reduce the possibility of rash. Sam was to be provided with no
bathtub toys.
Session 5. Sam’s parents reported that the soiling episodes had almost
completely ceased. Sam occasionally would have very small amounts of liq-
uid stool in his underwear, but the parents attributed these to the loose
consistency of his stools. Sam was now having all bowel movements in the
toilet. Sam was also able to tell the psychologist that each time that he felt
his “tummy hurt,” he would go to the bathroom and attempt to have a
bowel movement. Sam was now voiding independently the majority of the
time. The parents were instructed to discontinue regular sit times after
meals, and instead to reward Sam only if he had a bowel movement in the
toilet independently. They were to continue to have Sam assist with any
cleanup for minor soiling episodes. It was also suggested that they consult
with Sam’s pediatrician to receive recommendations on possibly titrating
his Miralax dosage. Sam was praised for his progress, and it was evident
that he was very proud of his accomplishment.
Final session. Sam was seen 8 weeks later, and his encopresis had re-
solved fully. Sam was now voiding completely independently in the toilet
and was having no soiling episodes. Sam’s parents were working with the
pediatrician to reduce and eventually eliminate the Miralax dosage, which
helped to reduce the minor soiling episodes. The treatment components
were again reviewed with the parents, and final recommendations were of-
fered. The parents were encouraged to contact the psychologist with any
questions that arose in the future.
Conclusion: Encopresis
Although enuresis is one of the most distressing experiences reported by
children (Van Tijen et al. 1998), unfortunately no similar type of research
has been conducted on how distressing encopresis is for affected children.
Our clinical experience suggests that encopresis is even more distressing
for afflicted children than enuresis. Furthermore, the psychological, emo-
tional, social, and medical complications that result from chronic un-
treated cases of encopresis are greater than the complications that arise
from untreated enuresis. Although effective treatment for encopresis is
504 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
more invasive and potentially embarrassing for affected children and their
families than treatment for enuresis, it can actually involve less effort. For
example, all of the parental treatment efforts occur during the day,
whereas with enuresis, important treatment efforts are needed at night.
Presently, physicians are the major first line of defense against encopresis,
but their approach typically is mostly biomedical, and as we hope we have
clearly demonstrated, there is a substantial cognitive-behavioral dimension
to the condition. As with CBT for enuresis, CBT for encopresis is not an
obvious example of CBT. Classic examples of CBT application include
treatment for anxiety, depression, or habit disorders. Those conditions are
more dominantly psychological, and thus with the exception of cases in-
volving drug treatments, the emphasis in CBT treatment for these disor-
ders is mostly on the cognitive and emotional behavior of those affected.
With encopresis, however, the condition is quite obviously dominantly bio-
medical and so too is its most significant cause, constipation. Nonetheless,
effective treatment always involves cognitive and motoric behavior
changes, and therefore encopresis is an appropriate target for CBT-trained
therapists, with the caveat that they be highly familiar with the physiology
of defecation.
Conclusion
Enuretic and encopretic children have been misunderstood, misinter-
preted, and mistreated for centuries. Fortunately for them, scientists and
practitioners working in the latter half of the twentieth century supplied
a more accurate, humane, and treatment-relevant characterization of these
conditions. These characterizations have led to empirically supported
treatments, and the best known of these have been described in this chap-
ter. Although in this chapter we refer to the general category for these
treatments as CBT, this form of treatment is also characterized as biobe-
havioral in other work (Christophersen and Friman 2010; Friman 2007,
2008). The CBT understanding and approach to enuresis and encopresis is
substantially superior to the historically psychogenic understanding and
approach, and even more so to the moral and characterological under-
standing and approach of antiquity. The CBT approach incorporates the
physiology of elimination, and although it also incorporates the psycholog-
ical state of the child, it does not view psychological variables as necessarily
causal. Rather, psychological variables are viewed as critical to active par-
ticipation in treatment, and CBT provides methods for using or modifying
these variables to promote participation. When psychological abnormali-
Enuresis and Encopresis 505
ties are present, they are more likely to be viewed as a consequence rather
than a cause of either condition. The psychogenic approach virtually ig-
nores the physiology of elimination and views psychological variables as
dominantly causal. Although the psychogenic approach views psychologi-
cal variables as relevant to participation in treatment, it provides no meth-
ods for using these same variables to promote participation.
From the CBT perspective, the evaluation and treatment of enuresis
and encopresis always require the direct involvement of a physician, but
ideal management results from a partnership with the child, family, cogni-
tive-behavioral therapist, and physician. This unified approach, when ac-
companied by empirically supported CBT, can alleviate incontinence
completely—and eliminate or dramatically minimize the possibility of the
harmful overinterpretation and unhealthful forms of treatment that have
tarnished the health care approach to incontinence in children throughout
history.
• Shaping the child’s cooperation for sitting on and voiding in the toi-
let through positive behavioral strategies should be the center of
any intervention plan.
• The child’s stool consistency, successful bowel movements, and soil-
ing accidents should be monitored closely throughout treatment.
Self-Assessment Questions
Enuresis
13.1. Which of the following statements best characterizes enuresis?
A. It is a benign condition.
B. It is a psychopathological condition.
C. It is a psychopathological condition medically but not psycholog-
ically.
D. It is a psychopathological condition psychologically but not med-
ically.
13.3. Which of the following does not have strong evidence supporting its
role as a cause of enuresis?
A. Family history.
B. Reduced functional bladder capacity.
C. Difficulty arousing from sleep.
D. Psychopathology.
13.5. Which of the following treatments for diurnal enuresis has the most
empirical support?
Encopresis
13.6. Compared to enuresis, the prevalence rate for encopresis is
A. Lower.
B. Higher.
C. About the same.
D. Not available for the general population.
13.7. Which of the following factors is not known to contribute to the de-
velopment of encopresis?
A. Fiber intake.
B. History of painful bowel movements.
C. Volitional stool-holding.
D. Sodium intake.
13.11. Which of the following is true about the role of biofeedback treat-
ment for encopresis?
Suggested Readings
and Web Sites
Christophersen ER, Mortweet SL: Treatments That Work With Children:
Empirically Supported Strategies for Managing Childhood Problems.
Washington, DC, American Psychological Association, 2001
Enuresis and Encopresis 509
References
Achenbach TM, Edelbrock C: Manual for the Child Behavior Checklist and Re-
vised Behavior Profile. Burlington, University of Vermont, 1983
American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric
Association, 2000
510 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Aruffo RN, Ibarra S, Strupp KR: Encopresis and anal masturbation. J Am Psycho-
anal Assoc 48:1327–1354, 2000
Azrin NH, Sneed TJ, Foxx RM: Dry bed training: rapid elimination of childhood
enuresis. Behav Res Ther 12:147–156, 1974
Bellman M: Studies on encopresis. Acta Paediatr Scand 170(suppl):1–137, 1966
Bollard J, Nettelbeck T: A component analysis of dry-bed training for treatment for
bedwetting. Behav Res Ther 20:383–390, 1982
Borowitz SM, Cox DJ, Tam A, et al: Precipitants of constipation during early child-
hood. J Am Board Fam Pract 16:213–218, 2003
Brooks RC, Copen RM, Cox DJ, et al: Review of the treatment literature for en-
copresis, functional constipation, and stool-toileting refusal. Ann Behav Med
22:260–267, 2000
Byrd RS, Weitzman M, Lanphear NE, et al: Bed-wetting in US children: epidemi-
ology and related behavior problems. Pediatrics 98:414–419, 1996
Chambless DL, Ollendick TH: Empirically supported psychological interventions:
controversies and evidence. Annu Rev Psychol 52:685–716, 2001
Christophersen ER, Friman PC: Elimination Disorders in Children and Adoles-
cents. Cambridge, MA, Hogrefe, 2010
Cox DJ, Morris JB Jr, Borowitz SM, et al: Psychological differences between children
with and without chronic encopresis. J Pediatr Psychol 27:585–591, 2002
Dwyer JT: Dietary fiber for children: how much? Pediatrics 96:1019–1022, 1995
Freud S: Three essays on the theory of sexuality (1905), in The Standard Edition
of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Vol 7. Translated and
edited by Strachey J. London, Hogarth Press, 1953, pp 136–243
Friman PC: A preventive context for enuresis. Pediatr Clin North Am 33:871–886,
1986
Friman PC: The psychopathological interpretation of routine child behavior prob-
lems: a critique and a related opportunity for behavior analysis. Invited ad-
dress at the 28th Annual Convention of the Association for Behavior Analysis,
Toronto, ON, Canada, May 2002
Friman PC: Encopresis and enuresis, in Handbook of Assessment, Case Conceptu-
alization, and Treatment, Vol 2: Children and Adolescents. Edited by Hersen
M, Reitman D. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley, 2007, pp 589–621
Friman PC: Evidence based therapies for enuresis and encopresis, in Handbook of
Evidence-Based Therapies for Children and Adolescents. Edited by Steele
RG, Elkin TD, Roberts MC. New York, Springer, 2008, pp 311–333
Fritz GK, Armbrust J: Enuresis and encopresis. Pediatr Clin North Am 5:283–296,
1982
Glicklich LB: An historical account of enuresis. Pediatrics 8:859–876, 1951
Gross RT, Dornbusch SM: Enuresis, in Developmental-Behavioral Pediatrics. Ed-
ited by Levine MD, Carey WB, Crocker AC, et al. Philadelphia, PA, Saunders,
1983, pp 575–586
Herson VC, Schmitt BD, Rumack BH: Magical thinking and imipramine poisoning
in two school-aged children. JAMA 241:1926–1927, 1979
Houts AC: Nocturnal enuresis as a biobehavioral problem. Behav Ther 22:133–
151, 1991
Houts AC: Commentary: treatments for enuresis: criteria, mechanisms, and health
care policy. J Pediatr Psychol 25:219–224, 2000
Enuresis and Encopresis 511
Houts AC, Liebert RM: Bedwetting: A Guide for Parents. Springfield, IL, Thomas,
1985
Houts AC, Peterson JK, Whelan JP: Prevention of relapse in full spectrum home train-
ing for primary enuresis: a components analysis. Behav Ther 17:462–469, 1986
Houts AC, Berman JS, Abramson H: Effectiveness of psychological and pharma-
cological treatments for nocturnal enuresis. J Consult Clin Psychol 62:737–
745, 1994
Joinson C, Heron J, Butler R, et al: A United Kingdom population-based study of
intellectual capacities in children with and without soiling, daytime wetting,
and bed-wetting. Pediatrics 120:E308–E316, 2007
Kegel AH: Physiological therapy for urinary stress incontinence. JAMA 146:915–
917, 1951
Levine MD: Encopresis: its potentiation, evaluation, and alleviation. Pediatr Clin
North Am 29:315–330, 1982
Luxem MC, Christophersen ER, Purvis PC, et al: Behavioral-medical treatment of
pediatric toileting refusal. J Dev Behav Pediatr 18:34–41, 1997
Loening-Baucke V: Prevalence rates for constipation and fecal and urinary
incontinence. Arch Dis Child 92:486–489, 2007
McGrath ML, Mellon MW, Murphy L: Empirically supported treatments in pediatric
psychology: constipation and encopresis. J Pediatr Psychol 25:225–254, 2000
Mellon MW, McGrath ML: Empirically supported treatments in pediatric psychol-
ogy: nocturnal enuresis. J Pediatr Psychol 25:193–214, 2000
Muellner SR: Development of urinary control in children: some aspects of the
cause and treatment of primary enuresis. JAMA 172:1256–1261, 1960
Muellner SR: Obstacles to the successful treatment of primary enuresis. JAMA
178:843–844, 1961
Reimers TM: A biobehavioral approach toward managing encopresis. Behav Modif
20:469–479, 1996
Ronen T, Wozner Y: A self-control intervention package for the treatment of pri-
mary nocturnal enuresis. Child Fam Behav Ther 17:1–20, 1995
Ronen T, Wozner Y, Rahav G: Cognitive interventions for enuresis. Child Fam Be-
hav Ther 14:1–14, 1992
Ronen T, Rahav G, Wozner Y: Self-control and enuresis. J Cogn Psychother 9:249–
258, 1995
Schonwald AD, Rappaport LA: Elimination conditions, in Developmental-Behav-
ioral Pediatrics. Edited by Wolraich ML, Drotar DD, Dworkin PH. Philadel-
phia, PA, Mosby, 2008, pp 791–804
Sperling M: The Major Neuroses and Behavior Disorders in Children. Northvale,
NJ, Jason Aronson, 1994
Starfield B: Functional bladder capacity in enuretic and nonenuretic children. J Pe-
diatr 70:777–781, 1967
Starfield B, Mellits ED: Increase in functional bladder capacity and improvements
in enuresis. J Pediatr 72:483–487, 1968
U.S. Food and Drug Administration: Desmopressin acetate (marketed as DDAVP
Nasal Spray, DDAVP Rhinal Tube, DDAVP, DDVP, Minirin, and Stimate Nasal
Spray). FDA Alert, December 4, 2007. Available at: http://www.fda.gov/Drugs/
DrugSafety/PostmarketDrugSafetyInformationforPatientsandProviders/
ucm107924.htm. Accessed April 26, 2011.
512 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
van der Wal MF, Benninga MA, Hirasing RA: The prevalence of encopresis in a mul-
ticultural population. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 40:345–348, 2005
van Dijk M, Bongers ME, de Vries GJ, et al: Behavioral therapy for childhood con-
stipation: a randomized, controlled trial. Pediatrics 121:E1334–E1341, 2008
Van Tijen NM, Messer AP, Namdar Z: Perceived stress of nocturnal enuresis in
childhood. Br J Urol 81 (suppl 3):98–99, 1998
World Health Organization: International Statistical Classification of Diseases and
Related Health Problems, 10th Revision. Version for 2007. Available at: http://
apps.who.int/classifications/apps/icd/icd10online. Accessed April 26, 2011.
Wright L, Schaefer AB, Solomons G: Encyclopedia of Pediatric Psychology. Balti-
more, MD, University Park Press, 1978
APPENDIX 1
Self-Assessment
Questions and Answers
513
514 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Answer: False.
Answer: C.
Answer: B.
Answer: False.
Answer: D.
Answer: C.
3.2. Parent training protocols with ethnic minority youth may improve
treatment retention and outcomes by including an emphasis on
A. Time-out.
B. Physical discipline.
C. Natural consequences.
D. Racial socialization.
Answer: D.
516 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
A. Acculturation stress.
B. Internalized oppression.
C. Feelings as facts.
D. Ableism.
Answer: B.
A. Family-focused sessions.
B. Individual-focused sessions.
C. Emphasis on assertiveness training in all contexts.
D. Behavioral activation.
Answer: A.
A. Behavioral activation.
B. Problem solving.
C. Assertiveness training.
D. Cognitive restructuring.
Answer: C.
A. Sertraline.
B. Escitalopram.
C. Paroxetine.
Appendix 1: Self-Assessment Questions and Answers 517
D. Fluvoxamine.
E. Imipramine.
Answer: B.
Answer: C.
Answer: D.
Answer: B.
4.5. Which of the following are important factors to consider when de-
ciding which intervention to choose from?
A. Severity of symptoms.
B. Prior experience with treatment.
C. Comorbidities.
D. Availability of resources.
E. All of the above.
Answer: E.
Answer: C.
B. Cognitive restructuring.
C. Emotion regulation
D. Safety planning.
Answer: C.
A. Cognitive restructuring.
B. Emotion regulation.
C. Behavioral activation.
D. Social skills training.
Answer: C.
A. Interpersonal therapy.
B. CBT used with depressed youths.
C. Relaxation techniques.
D. Cognitive-behavior therapy for suicide prevention.
Answer: D.
5.5. You see an adolescent youth with depression who is having difficul-
ty initiating and maintaining relationships with peers. The most
helpful CBT technique to include in the treatment plan of this
youth is
A. Cognitive restructuring.
B. Emotion regulation.
C. Behavioral activation.
D. Social skills training.
Answer: D.
Answer: B.
A. Academic problems.
B. Social problems.
C. Suicidal ideation.
D. All of the above.
Answer: D.
A. CBT.
B. Antidepressants.
C. Mood stabilizers or atypical antipsychotics.
D. Electroconvulsive therapy.
Answer: C.
Answer: B.
A. Family involvement.
B. Use of a therapist of the same sex as the child.
C. Residential treatment.
D. Psychoeducational testing.
Answer: A.
7.2. Which of the following is NOT a core component of CBT for child
anxiety?
A. Cognitive restructuring.
B. Exposure tasks.
C. Psychoeducation.
D. Behavioral activation.
Answer: E.
Answer: A.
524 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
A. Severity of symptoms.
B. Accessibility of school-based treatment.
C. What treatment parents will accept.
D. All of the above.
Answer: D.
Answer: F.
Answer: B.
A. Prolonged exposure.
B. Socratic questioning.
Appendix 1: Self-Assessment Questions and Answers 525
Answer: D.
9.2. Research by Storch and colleagues has indicated that CBT with ex-
posure and response prevention (E/RP) is
Answer: C.
A. 10.
B. 12.
C. 16.
D. 20.
E. 30.
Answer: C.
Answer: A.
Answer: F.
10.2. Which of the following best describes the relationship between psy-
chological and physical processes?
10.5. When working with a 17-year-old adolescent boy, the therapist no-
tices that he appears bored when presented with the information.
Which of the following developmental adaptations may be most
useful for this situation?
A. Low self-esteem.
B. Compromised body image.
C. Depression.
D. Obsessive-compulsive traits.
Answer: D.
Answer: C.
11.3. Which comorbid condition may CBT assist in the treatment of ad-
olescents with obesity and depression?
A. Obsessive-compulsive disorder.
B. Posttraumatic stress disorder.
C. Eating disorder not otherwise specified.
D. Alcohol dependence.
Answer: C.
11.4. Which of the following is not a key strategy used during motiva-
tional interviewing as a complementary approach to CBT?
A. Open-ended questions.
B. Nondirective empathy.
C. Affirmations.
D. Reflective listening.
Answer: B.
530 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
11.5. An 8-year-old boy comes into the clinic with a body mass index
percentile of 99.9. He complains that his family has a lot of high-
fat, high-calorie food in the home. Both parents are obese, and they
question why they should have to change their habits for their
child. Which of the following CBT techniques is most logical to
employ with this child and his family?
A. Behavioral activation.
B. Self-monitoring.
C. Stimulus control.
D. Cognitive restructuring.
Answer: C.
Answer: C.
A. Physiological sensations.
B. Behaviors.
C. Cognitions.
D. All of the above.
Answer: D.
Appendix 1: Self-Assessment Questions and Answers 531
12.3. Amanda, age 11, has been referred for therapy because of her fre-
quent angry outbursts. When she is calm, she can articulate appro-
priate responses to problems such as peer teasing, but she tends to
act out aggressively when confronted with real-life problems.
Which of the following areas should Amanda’s therapist focus on
first?
A. Social problem-solving.
B. Perspective taking.
C. Anger management strategies.
D. Identifying consequences for aggressive behaviors.
Answer: C.
12.4. In one of the clinical vignettes in this chapter, 15-year-old Tim as-
sumes that his teacher “has it out for him” when she puts his name
on the board for getting out of his seat to sharpen his pencil. Tim’s
CBT-oriented clinician seeks to help him see the situation from his
teacher’s perspective to modify his initial
Answer: B.
12.5. In another clinical vignette in this chapter, Naomi has sought men-
tal health services to reduce her daughter Anna’s disruptive behav-
ior. The family’s CBT-oriented clinician has asked Naomi to praise
Anna’s prosocial behaviors (such as following directions and helping
out around the house) and to ignore minor disruptive behavior
(such as whining or not cleaning out the sink thoroughly). The cli-
nician is likely trying to help Naomi use which of the following?
Answer: D.
532 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
A. It is a benign condition.
B. It is a psychopathological condition.
C. It is a psychopathological condition medically but not
psychologically.
D. It is a psychopathological condition psychologically but
not medically.
Answer: A.
Answer: D.
13.3. Which of the following does not have strong evidence supporting
its role as a cause of enuresis?
A. Family history.
B. Reduced functional bladder capacity.
C. Difficulty arousing from sleep.
D. Psychopathology.
Answer: D.
Answer: D.
13.5. Which of the following treatments for diurnal enuresis has the
most empirical support?
Answer: C.
Encopresis
13.6. Compared to enuresis, the prevalence rate for encopresis is
A. Lower.
B. Higher.
C. About the same.
D. Not available for the general population.
Answer: A.
13.7. Which of the following factors is not known to contribute to the de-
velopment of encopresis?
A. Fiber intake.
B. History of painful bowel movements.
C. Volitional stool-holding.
D. Sodium intake.
Answer: D.
Answer: C.
Answer: A.
Answer: A.
13.11. Which of the following is true about the role of biofeedback treat-
ment for encopresis?
Answer: B.
Index
535
536 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents
Body image, and obesity, 386, 406– of Coping Cat Program for anxiety
407, 431 disorders, 233–234, 235, 236–
Body mass index (BMI), 385, 387, 390 237, 238, 239–240, 241, 242,
Booster sessions, and obesity 246–249, 252–253, 254–255
treatment, 409 of cultural issues, 94, 99, 101–102,
Bossing-back strategies, and OCD, 103, 108
319–320 of depression, 173–175
Brainstorming approach of development, 31, 33
to bipolar disorder, 212 of disruptive behavior disorders,
to disruptive behavior disorders, 453–459
452 of encopresis, 500–503
Bryant’s Index of Empathy for of enuresis, 470–481
Children and Adolescents (BEI), of obesity, 400–401
63 of OCD, 105, 314–319
Bullying, and childhood obesity, 385 of PTSD, 264–265, 279–287, 287–
Bupropion, 124, 161 294
of suicidal ideation, 177–179
Calming techniques, and chronic Case formulation, and chronic
physical illness, 348–349 physical illness, 343–345
Camp Cope-A-Lot, 231 C.A.T. Project, 138, 252
CAMS (Child/Adolescent Anxiety Causal reasoning, 43
Multimodal Study), 126, 130, CBCL (Child Behavior Checklist), 49,
160 230, 488
Cancer, 334. See also Chronic physical CBITS (Cognitive-Behavioral
illness Intervention for Trauma in
Candy dispensers, and encopresis, Schools), 264, 278, 287–294
494–495 CBT. See Cognitive-behavioral therapy
Caregivers CBT-SP (cognitive-behavioral therapy
bipolar disorder and, 197 for suicide prevention), 176
encopresis and, 493 CDI (Children’s Depression
CARS (acronym), and bipolar Inventory), 304, 305, 395, 396
disorder, 208 Centers for Disease Control and
CARS2 (Childhood Autism Rating Prevention, 383
Scale—High Functioning, 2nd CFF-CBT (child- and family-focused
Edition), 304, 305 cognitive-behavior therapy), 186,
Case conceptualization, and suicide 190, 193
prevention, 177 Chain analysis, and suicidal ideation,
Case examples 176
of bipolar disorder, 203–205, 212– Change talk, and motivational
214 interviewing, 400
of chronic physical illness, 344– Child abuse, and incontinence, 467,
345, 351–353, 354, 358 479. See also Sexual abuse
of combined therapy, 132, 134– Child/Adolescent Anxiety
135, 136 Multimodal Study (CAMS), 126,
of common principles of CBT, 6–16 130, 160
Index 539
Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), 49, Cleanliness training, and enuresis, 473
230, 488 Clinical applications, of CBT
Child- and family-focused cognitive- for bipolar disorder, 195–219
behavior therapy (CFF-CBT), combined therapy and, 127–141
186, 190, 193 cultural issues and, 91–108
Childhood Autism Rating Scale— for depression, 166–175
High Functioning, 2nd Edition for disruptive behavior disorders,
(CARS2), 304, 305 443–452
Child Obsessive-Compulsive Impact for obesity, 390–393
Scale—Revised (COIS-R), 304, for OCD, 303–323
305 for PTSD, 270–278
Children. See Adolescents and Coaches, and obesity, 399
adolescence; Age; Child abuse; Cognition-based theoretical models,
Chronic physical illness; of OCD, 302–303
Development; Encopresis; Cognition and cognitive skills. See also
Enuresis; Obesity; Patients; Cognitive restructuring;
Preschool children; specific Metacognition
disorders anxiety disorders and, 252
Children’s Depression Inventory conceptualization of problems in
(CDI), 304, 305, 395, 396 terms of behavior and, 7–8
Children’s Yale-Brown Obsessive developmental issues in, 34, 40–
Compulsive Scale (CY-BOCS), 44, 65–68
304, 305 obesity and lifestyle changes, 392–
Choice, as theme in CBT for bipolar 393
disorder, 209, 212 PTSD and, 266, 269
Chronic fatigue syndrome, 334 role of in treatment of enuresis,
Chronic physical illness. See also 468, 470
Polycystic ovary syndrome; Cognitive Abilities Test, Form 6, 62
Primary and Secondary Control Cognitive-Behavioral Intervention for
Enhancement Training for Trauma in Schools (CBITS), 264,
Physical Illness 278, 287–294
efficacy of CBT for, 332–333, Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT).
334–336 See also Assessment; Behavioral
encopresis and, 486 therapy; Chronic physical illness;
guided imagery for pain Clinical applications; Cognitive
management and, 375–377 therapy; Combined therapy;
inflammatory bowel disease as Culture; Development; Efficacy;
model illness in studies of Obesity; Treatment planning;
CBT for, 338–358 specific disorders
information worksheets for parents common myths and
and, 378–382 misperceptions in, 22–24
relationship between psychological common principles of, 6–16
and physical processes in, evidence-based treatments and,
331–332 1–2
Citalopram, 121, 123, 154 history of, 2–6
540 Cognitive-Behavior Therapy for Children and Adolescents