Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Suicidal Behavior in Latency-Age Children: An Study
Suicidal Behavior in Latency-Age Children: An Study
Latency-Age Children
An Empirical Study
Dr. Pfeffer is Assistant Clinical Professor of Psychiatry and Pediatrics; Dr. Conte is Assistant Pro-
fessor of Psychiatry; Dr. Plutchik is Professor of Psychiatry; and Ms. Jerrett is Research Assistant, all
at Bronx Municipal Hospital Center-Albert Einstein College of Medicine. Reprints may be requested
from Dr. Pfeffer, The New York Hospital4onzell Medical Center, Westchester Division, 21
Bloomingdale Road, White Plains, New York 10605.
This paper was presented at the Twenty-Fifth Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Child
Psychiatry, San Diego, Calfornia, October, 1978.
The authors would like to thank Paulina F. Kerberg, M.D., and Joseph Richman, Ph.D., who were
consultants f o r this study. The assistance of the child psychiatry fellows and child psychology trainees
who participated in this study was appreciated.
0002-7138/79/1804-0679 $01.23 1979 American Academy of Child Psychiatry.
679
680 Cynthia R. Pfefler et al.
factor was “disturbed relations with the parents” and the main etio-
logical factor in suicidal behavior of children was “abnormal paren-
tal personality” (p. 430).
We decided, therefore, to assess the child’s ego functioning, the
specific types of stressful environmental factors that exist, the
child’s affective state, and his understanding of death, and to relate
these variables to suicidal behavior.
METHOD
Table 1
Child Suicide Potential Scale
Scale Purpose
1. Spectrum of Suicidal Behavior Classifies suicidal behavior along a 5-point
spectrum of severity ranging from nonsui-
cidal to serious attempts.
2. Precipitating Events Documents environmental stress during 6
months preceding the child’s evaluation. Ex-
amples: school problems, household changes,
quality of friendships, losses.
3. Affects and Behavior (recent) Documents emotional states and symptomatic
behavior during 6 months preceding the
child’s evaluation. Examples: anxiety, sad-
ness, hopelessness, temper tantrums, defiance,
running away, firesetting.
4. Family Background Documents family events and parental psy-
chopathology. Examples: separations, death,
severe discipline, parental depression, alcohol
and drug abuse.
Affects and Behavior (past) Similar to variables in 8 3 , except this docu-
ments period before 6 months preceding the
child’s evaluation.
Concept of Death Documents the child’s preoccupations and ex-
perience with death and his view of death as
pleasant, unpleasant, temporary, final.
Ego Functioning Documents qualities of ego functioning. Ex-
amples: intelligence, affect regulation, im-
pulse control, reality testing.
Ego Defense Mechanisms Documents utilization of ego defenses. Exam-
ples: denial, reaction formation, repression.
Table 2
Child Suicide Potential Scale - Spectrum of Suicidal Behavior
1. Nonsuicidal: No evidence of any self-destructive or suicidal
thoughts or actions.
2. Suicidal Ideation: Thoughts or verbalization of suicidal intention.
Examples: (a) I want to kill myself.
(b) Auditory hallucination to commit suicide.
3. Suicidal Threat: Verbalization of impending suicidal action and/
or a precursor action which, if fully carried out,
could have led to harm.
Examples: (a) I am going to run in front of a car.
(b) Child puts a knife under his pillow.
(c) Child stands near a n open window and says
he will jump out.
4 . Mild Attempt: Actual self-destructive action which realistically
would not have endangered life and did not ne-
cessitate intensive medical attention.
Example: (a) Ingestion of a few pills and child’s stomach
pumped.
5 . Serious Attempt: Actual self-destructive action which realistically
could have led to the child’s death and may have
necessitated intensive medical care.
Example: (a) Child jumped out of fourth floor window.
RESULTS
Table 3
Demographic Characteristics of the Hospitalized Children
Suicidal Nonsuicidal Total
N % N % N %
Number of children 42 72 16 28 58 100
Socioeconomic class Low Low Low
Race-ethnicity
White 5 12 1 6.2 6 10
Black 16 38 8 50 24 41
Hispanic 21 50 7 43.8 28 49
Sex
M 37 88 13 81 50 86
F 5 12 3 19 8 14
Mean age (years) 9.0 9.0 9.0
Diagnosis
Behavior disorder 14 33 8 50 22 39
Learning disabilities 15 36 8 50 22 40
Borderline personality 19 45 5 31 24 41
Depression 10 24 4 24 14 24
Psychosis 7 19 2 12 10 17
Organic brain syndrome 9 21 3 19 12 21
Adjustment reaction 5 12 2 12 7 12
Mental retardation 3 7 3 19 6 10
Language disturbance 3 7 1 6 4 7
Neurosis 1 2 1 6 2 3
Table 4
T h e Spectrum of Suicidal Behavior and Suicidal Methods
Undeter-
Children Jumping Stabbing Burning Ingestion Traffic mined
Nonsuicidal
N 16 0 0 0 0 0 0
% 28 0 0 0 0 0 0
Suicidal ideation
N 11 6 0 1 0 0 4
% 19 55 0 9 0 0 36
Threats
N 15 12 3 0 0 0 0
% 26 80 20 0 0 0 0
Mild attempts
N 8 3 0 2 2 1 0
% 13.5 38 0 25 25 12 0
Serious attempts
N 8 3 2 1 2 0 0
70 13.5 38 25 12 25 0 0
Total
N 58 24 5 4 4 1 4
70 100 57 11 10 10 2 10
Suicidal Behavior in Latency-Age Children 685
Table 5
Affects and Behavior Shown by the Suicidal and Nonsuicidal Children
RECENT PAST
Non- Non-
Suicidal suicidal t, P Suicidal suicidal t, p
% % % 70
Affects
Anxiety 71 62 NS 75 56 NS
Depression or
sadness 60 19 2.79, p < .01 36 25 NS
Hopelessness 50 12 2.32, p < .05 38 12 NS
Worthlessness 56 12 2.63, p < .01 44 6 2.48, p < .01
Wish to die 62 0 3.82, p<.O1 44 0 3.00, p < .01
Aggression 90 75 NS 94 88 NS
Symptoms
Sleep disorder 52 38 NS 42 31 NS
Stealing 24 46 NS 24 53 NS
Firesetting 46 54 NS 42 23 NS
Running away 28 23 NS 24 15 NS
Family Issues
Several important variables in the family did not distinguish be-
tween the suicidal and nonsuicidal children: parental separations
existed in the families of 94%of the suicidal children and 75% of
the nonsuicidal children; 62% of the fathers of suicidal children
and 56% of the fathers of the nonsuicidal children were absent or
there were multiple father figures; abusive home atmospheres
including frequent violent parental arguments, and severe punish-
ment toward the child occurred in 75% of the suicidal and
nonsuicidal populations.
A significant finding is that the mothers of suicidal children
w e r e more frequently depressed (t = 2.11, p < .05) than the
mothers of the nonsuicidal children. In addition, there was a
significant correlation between parents who were depressed and
suicidal and the degree of dangerousness of suicidal behavior in
their children (t = 2.61, p < .01). In the entire population, 13
mothers (22%) had suicidal ideas, 10 mothers (17%) attempted sui-
cide, and 2 mothers (3%)committed suicide; there were 2 fathers
Suicidal Behavior in Latency-Age Children 687
DISCUSSION
Table 6
Risk Factors for Suicidal Behavior of Latency-Age Children
kept her daughter out of school for 90 days in one year and forced
her daughter to stay in the house to care for her.
Such parental qualities may promote the development and repe-
tition of similar characteristics in the children. Intense outbursts of
impulses, rapid and frequent shifts in affects, low self-esteem, and
disturbed object relations were qualities commonly noted in this
population of children. They were constantly in search of empathic
relationships and responded hopefully to supportive adults. How-
ever, the children were sensitive to being easily rejected and aban-
doned, and they lacked a firm concept that people were predict-
able and trustworthy. Furthermore, believing that they had omni-
potent powers, the children sometimes attempted to control others
by means of suicidal behavior. However, because the children also
feared the consequences of their behavior, they sought to be
controlled by seemingly omnipotent but empathic adults.
Table 6 also lists specific high-risk variables for childhood sui-
cidal behavior, which include sadness or depression, hopelessness,
worthlessness, and statements of the wish to die. Suicidal behavior
and depression among the parents were specifically correlated
with childhood suicidal behavior. This finding lends support to
the value of further investigating the nature of the parent-child in-
teraction. A. Freud (1963) mentioned “that depressive moods of
the mother during the first two years after birth create in the child
a tendency to depression . . . such infants achieve their sense of
unity and harmony with the depressed mother not by means of
their developmental achievements but by producing the mother’s
mood in themselves” (p. 264). As a corollary, one may hypothesize
that the identification with the sadistic punitive parental feelings
may create the channeling of hostile impulses onto the self, with
one outcome being self-destructive behavior.
Perception and identification with other parental traits may also
be internalized as self-images. States of hopelessness and worth-
lessness may increase the vulnerability to suicidal behavior. In addi-
tion, the relatively frequent incidence of suicidal behavior in the
parents provides a cognitive awareness and experience with threats
of death, either real or fantasized. Identification with parent fan-
tasies of death may add to the potential for suicidal behavior.
Death viewed as pleasant and temporary serves as an immediate so-
lution to feelings of despair and deprivation. Chronic depression
and anxiety may be defended against by denial and the fantasy of
being somewhere else.
Suicidal Behavior in Latency-Age Children 69 1
Implications
Many of the risk variables described in this study are similar to
those commonly recognized for adolescents and adults. T h e assess-
ment of risk for suicidal behavior should therefore become a rou-
tine aspect of the psychiatric evaluation of children. Questions
about preoccupations with death and self-destructive behavior
should be included in the mental status of children.
Evaluation of learning disabilities, assessment of appropriate
school planning, and educational remediation are important as-
pects of the interventions for potentially suicidal children.
T h e high percentage of suicidal children in this hospitalized
population also implies that treatment should focus on an intensive
long-term intervention approach. Mattsson et al. (1969) remarked
that “the child with suicidal behavior was rather consistently judged
as more in need of inpatient and long term aftercare than the
nonsuicidal child” (p. 106).
Finally, this study has established that suicidal behavior is one of
the most common symptoms among severely disturbed latency-
age children. Although this investigation may lend support to
Ackerly’s ( 1967) assumption that children with suicidal behavior
have “severe emotional disturbances,” additional studies of popula-
tions of less disturbed children are needed to determine if suicidal
behavior is only associated with severe psychopathology.
REFERENCES
ACKERLY, W. C. (1967), Latency-age children who threaten or attcmpt to kill themselves. This
Journal, 6:242-261.
CYTRYN, L. & MCKNEW,D. H., JR. (1972). Proposed classification of childhood depression.
Amer. J . Psychiat., 129:149-155.
FREUD,A. (1963), T h e concept of developmental lines. The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child,
18:245-265.
GREEN,A. H. (1978), Psychopathology of abused children. This Journal, 17:92-101.
LOMONACO, S. & PFEFFER, C. R. (1974), Suicidal and self-destructive behavior of latency-age
children. Read at the Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, San
Francisco, California.
LOURIE,R. S. (1966), Clinical studies of attempted suicide in childhood. Clinical Proceedings
Children’s Hospital of Washington, D.C., 22: 163-173.
LUKIANOWICZ, N. (1968), Attempted suicide in children. Acta Psychiat. Scand., 44:415435.
MATTSSON, A,, SESSE,L. R., & HAWKINS, J . W. (1969),Suicidal behavior as a child psychiatric
emergency. Arch. Gen. Psychiat., 20: 100-109.
MORRISON,G. C. & COLLIER, J. G. (1969). Family treatment approaches to suicidal children
and adolescents. This J o u m l , 8: 140-153.
692 Cynthia R.Pfeffer et al.
PFEFFER,C. R. (1978), Psychiatric hospital treatment of suicidal children. Suicide and Life-
Threatening Behavior, 3: 150-160.
POZNANSKI, E. & ZRULL,J . P. (1970). Child depression. Arch. Gen. Psychiat., 23:8-15.
SABBATH, J. C. (1969). The suicidal adolescent. This Journal, 8:272-289.
SHAFFER, D. (1974), Suicide in childhood and early adolescence. J . Child Psychol. Psychiat.,
15~275-291.
SHAW,C. R. & SCHELKUN, R. F. (1965), Suicidal behavior in children. Psychiatry, 28:157-168.
TOOLAN, J. M. (1962), Depression in children and adolescents. Amer. J . Orthopsychiat.,
33:404-415.
-(1975), Suicide in children and adolescents. Amer. J . Psychother., 29:339-344.