Document 196 Filed 09/22/09

1 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP

Theodore B. Olson, SBN 38137
2 tolson@gibsondunn.com
Matthew D. McGill, pro hac vice
3 Amir C. Tayrani, SBN 229609
1050 Connecticut Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
4 Telephone: (202) 955-8668, Facsimile: (202) 467-0539

5 Theodore J. Boutrous, Jr., SBN 132009

tboutrous@gibsondunn.com
6 Christopher D. Dusseault, SBN 177557
Ethan D. Dettmer, SBN 196046
7 Sarah E. Piepmeier, SBN 227094
Theane Evangelis Kapur, SBN 243570
8 Enrique A. Monagas, SBN 239087
333 S. Grand Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90071
9 Telephone: (213) 229-7804, Facsimile: (213) 229-7520

10 BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP

David Boies, pro hac vice
11 dboies@bsfllp.com
Theodore H. Uno, SBN 248603
12 333 Main Street, Armonk, New York 10504
Telephone: (914) 749-8200, Facsimile: (914) 749-8300
13
Attorneys for Plaintiffs KRISTIN M. PERRY, SANDRA B. STIER,
14 PAUL T. KATAMI, and JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO

15 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

16 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
17 KRISTIN M. PERRY, SANDRA B. STIER, CASE NO. 09-CV-2292 VRW
PAUL T. KATAMI, and JEFFREY J.
18 ZARRILLO,
Plaintiffs, STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
19 REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT
v. WITNESSES
20
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER, in his official
21 capacity as Governor of California; EDMUND
G. BROWN, JR., in his official capacity as
22 Attorney General of California; MARK B.
HORTON, in his official capacity as Director of
23 the California Department of Public Health and
State Registrar of Vital Statistics; LINETTE
24 SCOTT, in her official capacity as Deputy
Director of Health Information & Strategic
25 Planning for the California Department of Public
Health; PATRICK O’CONNELL, in his official
26 capacity as Clerk-Recorder for the County of
Alameda; and DEAN C. LOGAN, in his official
27 capacity as Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk for
the County of Los Angeles,
28 Defendants.

Gibson, Dunn &

Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 1 Plaintiffs Kristin M. Perry, Sandra B. Stier, Paul T. Katami, and Jeffrey J. Zarrillo

2 (“Plaintiffs”), Plaintiff-Intervenor City and County of San Francisco (“Plaintiff-Intervenor”),

3 Defendant-Intervenors Proposition 8 Official Proponents Dennis Hollingsworth, Gail J. Knight,

4 Martin F. Gutierrez, Hak-Shing William Tam, and Mark A. Jansson; and ProtectMarriage.com –

5 Yes on 8, A Project of California Renewal (“Defendant-Intervenors”), and Defendants Arnold

6 Schwarzenegger, Edmund G. Brown, Jr., Mark B. Horton, Linette Scott, Patrick O’Connell, and

7 Dean C. Logan (“Defendants”) (collectively the “Parties”), through their respective counsel of record,

8 hereby stipulate to the following regarding the scope of discovery concerning expert witnesses in

9 this matter:

10 1. The Parties stipulate and agree that no Party is entitled to discover the contents of

11 communications that involve counsel for any Party and any retained expert or outside consultant,

12 whether such expert or outside consultant is serving as a testifying or non-testifying expert;

13 2. Further, the Parties stipulate and agree that no Party is entitled to discover the contents

14 of drafts of expert witness disclosures or reports prepared in relation to Federal Rules of Civil

15 Procedure Rule 26(a)(2);

16 3. Nothing in this stipulation limits in any way the right of either party to discover and

17 examine the basis for a testifying expert’s opinion or conclusion, the data or other information

18 considered by the Outside Consultant in forming the opinion or conclusion, and any other

19 information subject to discovery under Rule 26(a)(2); and

20 4. This Stipulation may be signed in counterparts and facsimile signatures are deemed

21 originals for all purposes.

22 ///

23 ///

24 ///

25

26

27

28

Gibson, Dunn &

1
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 1 DATED: September 16, 2009 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP

3 By: /s/
Christopher D. Dusseault
4
and
5
BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP
6
David Boies
7
Attorneys for Plaintiffs KRISTIN M. PERRY,
8 SANDRA B. STIER, PAUL T. KATAMI, and
JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO
9

10 DATED: September 10, 2009 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY

11

12 By: /s/
Ronald Flynn
13
Attorneys for Plaintiff-Intervenor
14 CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

15
DATED: September 10, 2009 COOPER AND KIRK, PLLC
16

17
By: /s/
18 David Thompson

19 Attorneys for Defendant-Intervenors

PROPOSITION 8 OFFICIAL PROPONENTS; and
20 PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM – YES ON 8, A
PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RENEWAL
21

22 DATED: September 16, 2009 OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

23

24 By: /s/
Tamar Pachter
25
Attorneys for Defendant
26 ATTORNEY GENERAL EDMUND G. BROWN, JR.

27

28

Gibson, Dunn &

2
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 1 DATED: September 16, 2009 MENNEMEIER, GLASSMAN & STROUD LLP

3 By: /s/
Kenneth C. Mennemeier
4
Attorneys for Defendants ARNOLD
5 SCHWARZENEGGER, MARK B. HORTON, and
LINETTE SCOTT (the “Administration Defendants”)
6

7 DATED: September 10, 2009 THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY COUNSEL

9 By: /s/
Claude F. Kolm, Deputy County Counsel
10
Attorneys for Defendant PATRICK O’CONNELL,
11 Clerk-Recorder for the County of Alameda

12
DATED: September 10, 2009 THE OFFICE OF COUNTY COUNSEL
13

14
By: /s/
15 Judy Whitehurst

16 Attorneys for Defendant DEAN C. LOGAN,

Recorder/County Clerk for the County of Los Angeles
17

18
ORDER
19
PURSUANT TO STIPULATION, IT IS SO ORDERED.
ISTRIC
ES D
20
T TC
21 TA
O
S

U
ED

September 22, 2009

RT

22 Dated:_____________________ D
______________________________________
RDERE
UNIT

HON. VAUGHN S OR.OWALKER

23 IT ISDistrict Chief Judge
United States
R NIA

24
Walker
NO

aughn R
Judge V
FO

25
RT

LI

26 ER
H

N C
F
27 D IS T IC T O
R
28

Gibson, Dunn &

3
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 1 ATTESTATION PURSUANT TO GENERAL ORDER NO. 45

2 Pursuant to General Order No. 45 of the Northern District of California, I attest that concurrence
3 in the filing of the document has been obtained from each of the other signatories to this document.
4

6 By: /s/ Enrique A. Monagas

Enrique A. Monagas
7

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Gibson, Dunn &

4
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 DATED: September &,2009 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP

and
BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP
David Boies
Attorneys for Plaintiffs KRISTIN M. PERRY,
SANDRA B. STIER, PAUL T. KATAMI, and
JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO

DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY

By:
Ronald Flynn

Attorneys for Plaintiff-Intervenor

CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 COOPER AND KIRK, PLLC

By:
David Thompson

Attorneys for Defendant-Intervenors

PROPOSITION 8 OFFICIAL PROPONENTS; and
PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM - YES ON 8, A
PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RENEWAL

DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

YY'
Tamar Pachter
Attorneys for Defendant
ATTORNEY GENERAL EDMUND G. BROWN, JR.

2
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 1 DATED: September -, 2009 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP

By:
Christopher D. Dusseault
and
BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP

David Boies
Attorneys for Plaintiffs KRISTIN M. PERRY,
SANDRA B. STIER, PAUL T. KATAMI, and
JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO

DATED: ~ e ~ t e m b1e0r , 2 0 0 9 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY

By:
Ronald Flynn
Attorneys for Plaintiff-Intervenor
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

DATED: September -, 2009 COOPER AND KIRK. PLLC

By:
David Thompson
Attornevs for Defendant-Intervenors
PROPO'SITION 8 OFFICIAL PROPONENTS; and
PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM YES ON 8, A
-

PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RENEWAL

DATED: September -, 2009 OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

By:
Tamar Pachter
Attorneys for Defendant
ATTORNEY GENERAL EDMUND G. BROWN, JR

GlbSO". Dun" 8
2
Cwtchei LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
DATED: Septeambcr ~*-, , 2009 GIBSOS, DVNN & CRUTGII'ER LI,P

At%orneysfar PXaintifls KWfS7'IN M. P E M Y ,

SAiWR4 B. S*I."IER,PAldL T, Ks?iTi%le4l,and
JEFFREY J. ZARRII,I.O

DATED: Sepker~aber-- ",

2009 Qf;l21CE OF "TI.-IECITY tlTTORNEY

Attorneys for Plainti fGXntcnfenor

CITY AND CfjUNTY OF SAX FMMCXSGO

,4E~meyslor Defendm%=la%c~.~tgn~~s
PROPe;tSITfOX 8 OFFECtAl, PROP06.Jti%'rS; and
PROTECThfARRIAGE.COM --YES 0%8, A
PROJECT OI:CAL,IFBmZA R E S E WAS,

ill)/Yf*!il>: Sej3tcrrz$rr, 2009 CBFFlf E OF TEIE i"r'lVPORNiiYGGNERAI,

 DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP

By:
Christopher D.Dusseault
and
BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP
David Boies
Attorneys for Plaintiffs KRISTIN M. PERRY,
SANDRA B.STIER, PAUL T.KATAMI, and
JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO

DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY

By:
Ronald Fly-nn
Attorneys for PIaintiff-Intervenor
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 COOPER AND KIRK, PLLC

By:
David Thompson
Attorneys for Defendant-Intervenors
PROPOSITTON 8 OFFICLAL PROPONENTS;and
PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM - Y E S ON 8, A
PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RENEWAL

DATED: ~ e ~ t e t n b&,
e r 2009 OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

Attorneys for Defendant

ATTORNEY GENERAL EDMUND G. BROWN, JR.

Glbsm, Dunn &

2
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDTNG DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES
 DATED: Srptcniber k2 2009 CLASS&f>th'cRc S'I'RO UD LLP
r"vlEl.iXE122E1ER~

By:

.&ttornc_tsk ~ Defe~~ciai~ts
r AKNC?I,,Cl
SCI T't3rAIU-ENEGGER, MARK R. HOR'X'OX, ad
LmE'T'IE SCOT?' (rhe "'hcixninist~a~ion
X>cf*enda~ats")

D-U'EW: September -, 2009 'I-PIE OFFICL: OF 'PHE COLTN'I'Y C3X) UNSEX.,

Attorneys for Defei~daz~tXStlTl;tXCKB'CONKlil'I,I,,

Clerk-Recorder far tIzc County ur"Almecfa
12
DATED: September -, 2009 ?'MJ:.I OFFICE OF COUNTY t,<')ll.lYSEX,
13

Ilatcd: -- a-w --.*- ", *.,..-- - ---

WON, VAISGIXX R."WA~,KT+R
Xjxtilcd Sttldcs Disirict Chief Jtrdgr

3 P

159-@Y-2292Vt;'ktW S11X'UL4rtTI"IOhT AND {Pft,QPOSEDjORDER

REGARDIXC I31SCQVERY Qt' EXfaEKY a;i"lT&XSSES
 SEP. 10. 2 0 0 9 9:50AM

1 DATED: September. 2009 MENNEMEIER, GLASSMAN & STROUD LLP

3 By:
Kenneth C. Mememeier
4
Attorneys for Defendants ARNOLD
5 SCHWARZENEGGER, MARK B. HORTON, and
LMETTE SCOTT (the "Administration Defendants")
6
7 DATED: ~eptcmber& 2009 THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY COUNSEL

8
9 By:
Claude F. Kolm, Deputy County Counsel
10I
Attorneys for Defendant PATRICK O'CONNELL,
11 Clerk-Recorder for the County of Alameda

12
DATED: September, 2009 THE OFFICE OF COUNTY COUNSEL
13
14
By:
15 I Judy Whitehunt
16I Attorneys for Defendant DEAN C. LOGAN,
RecorderlCounty Clerk for the County of Los Angeles
l iI
15:
ORDER
1s1
PURSUANT TO STZPULATION, IT IS SO ORDERED.
2(1
21

2; ! Dated:,
HON. VAUGHN R. WALKER
2: i United States Diskkt Chief Judge
2 LI

2:!
2t )

2; I 100725508-1 (2009-09-09 Stipulation re expaa) (A).DOC

21$

Glbson, Dunn:h
c m e , LIP 09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION ANL) [PROPOSED]ORDER
T I C P . ~ T I ~ ~ T ~E T O ~ X T C T I Vne rve.cer nnnmocac
C:VD AT 911012009 9:53:20 AM [Pacific Daylight Time] ~VR:LA_FAXO110VNIS:6520YSlD:5102126841VURATO
PAGE 212 T
R I N (mmmss):O1mOO
 DATED: September -3 2009 MENNEMEIER, GLASSMAN & STROUD LLP

By:
Kenneth C. Mennemeier
Attorneys for Defendants ARNOLD
SCHWARZENEGGER, MARK B. HORTON, and
LINETTE SCOTT (the "Administration Defendants")

DATED: S e p t e m b e r , 2009 THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY COUNSEL

By:
Lindsey Stern
Attorneys for Defendant PATRICK O'CONNELL,
Clerk-Recorder for the County of Alarneda

DATED: September By
2009 THE OFFICE OF COUNTY COUNSEL

w
Attorneys for Defendant DEAN C. LOGAN,
RecorderICounty Clerk for the County of Los Angeles

ORDER
PURSUANT TO STIPULATION, IT IS SO ORDERED.

Dated:
HON. VAUGHN R. WALKER
United States District Chief Judge

100725508-1 (2009-09-09 Stipulation re experts) (4).DOC

Gibson, Dunn &

3
Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW STIPULATION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
REGARDING DISCOVERY OF EXPERT WITNESSES