Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Annual Report FY 2017-2018 Course Correction: Residential Power Factor
Annual Report FY 2017-2018 Course Correction: Residential Power Factor
Annual Report
To maximize the impact of efficient technologies, the industry needs to correct residential power factor
FY 2017-2018
August 2021
pecanstreet.org
pecanstreet.org
Our real-world testbed of volunteer research participants is the first of its kind
on the planet and has become an international model for how to develop
and conduct energy and resource research and product testing. Our com-
mercialization lab is an affordable, world-class proving ground for major
corporations and startups alike. And our database, the largest source of dis-
aggregated customer energy data, is used by university researchers and in-
dustry-leading companies around the world.
The Unsung Hero of in their service territory, number of outages, total hours of
outages, energy demand, and increasingly, the amount of
Distribution Capacity energy generated from rooftop solar. Utilities are also
looking at the adequacy of wires and other transmission
infrastructure required to get power from substations to
Over the past several decades, utilities, building energy homes and businesses, which is where total power factor
managers, and homeowners have been increasingly in- is used to measure how much of the electricity supplied to
vesting in energy efficiency measures, efficient appliances a facility is used to do work. Utilities monitor these indica-
and rooftop solar. These efforts have saved countless tors to ensure the grid can reliably operate and serve cus-
megawatt-hours of energy and millions of tons of green- tomer loads without interruption.
house gas emissions, and the need for these measures
Pecan Street’s research also looks at these indicators, in-
are only increasing as we continue to decarbonize the
cluding power factor, since we started collecting data
power sector. However, despite this progress, there is an
more than ten years ago. Over the course of the past
often overlooked but increasingly concerning metric that is
decade, we saw shifts in power factor as new efficiency
preventing the industry from maximizing residential sector
measures and rooftop solar were more widely adopted.
energy efficiency investments - total power factor. Or
Unfortunately, some shifts have not been for the better.
power factor for short, is a measurement for how difficult
This analysis explores the changes we’ve seen in residen-
it is to get power to a building. Power factor is measured
tial power factor, why these changes are happening, the
in fractions on a scale of 1.0, and a low power factor
problems it poses, and what can be done to improve
means that a utility has to supply more current to a home
residential power factor. We also outline strategies for
to get the same amount of work (heat, light, motion, etc.)
implementing broad scale residential power factor correc-
as a home with higher power factor.
tion technologies, including a preferred solution for whole-
To demonstrate the challenges and opportunities associat- home power factor correction in conjunction with device-
ed with total power factor, we used Pecan Street’s home level power factor correction for new appliances. The
energy use and PV data to explore the grid impacts of analysis provides a roadmap for utilities, regulators, and
poor residential power factor and the system benefits of appliance manufacturers for how they can set policy and
power factor correction. The analysis showed that by im- prioritize new technology adoption that will free up distri-
proving power factor of the homes in our sample, an ad- bution capacity and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
ditional current capacity of 12-16% to the distribution sys-
tem can be achieved. This savings represents a significant
increase in transmission and distribution capacity that
would lower energy sector emissions and free up capaci-
ty for serving additional customers with existing genera-
tion assets - all without upgrading any utility infrastructure.
PECANSTREET.ORG 1
The main contributors to poor power factor in a home are systems that rely on switch mode power supplies such as vari-
able speed HVAC systems, LED lighting, and other electronics. The circuitry and electrical design of these items have
evolved over recent decades, increasing efficiency (which is a good thing) but decreasing residential power factor. This
trade-off is not a zero-sum game. These efficiency gains can be achieved while also correcting for poor power factor.
The commercial and industrial sector already have economic and technological solutions that addresses power factor.
When an industrial or commercial facilities’ power factor drops between 0.8 and 0.9, they are often penalized and
charged additional fees by the utility because they are using up distribution resources that they do not need. These penal-
ties cover the cost of the excess capacity being used up by the facility’s poor power factor and incentivizes these cus-
tomers to take steps to improve their power factor. The penalties are typically high enough that the corrective equipment
pays for itself in a few years (sometimes months) and may have a lifetime of 7-30 years.
PECANSTREET.ORG 2
Apparent power is measured in Volt-Amperes (VA) and is the product of the current and voltage of the circuit, or stated
more simply, the combination of the active and reactive power. The beer glass analogy shows the apparent power is
the beer glass itself (the wires, transformers and protective equipment at the distribution level) and contains the sum of
the active and reactive power. The active power is the beer in the glass (the circuit's capacity to do work, a.k.a. the
good stuff). The reactive power is the beer foam (provides voltage support but lowers power factor... necessary but
should be minimized).
Reactive Power is required when current is displaced and/or distorted from voltage in a circuit. Current displacement
occurs when the current and voltage waveforms become out of phase with each other. Inductive loads like motors
cause the current to lag the voltage while capacitive loads like generators cause the current to lead the voltage. Cur-
rent distortion occurs when multiple current waveforms of varying frequency are combined. Current distortion is most
commonly caused by devices with non-linear loads like switch mode power supplies that turn on and off quickly. The
distorted current wave in Figure XX below is from a 13W LED that was measured in the Pecan Street lab.
Figure XX shows two examples of Power Factor and the corresponding waveforms of voltage and current. The figure
on the left has a power factor of 1 since the voltage and current are in phase with no harmonic distortion. When this
occurs no reactive power is required from the grid. The figure on the right has a power factor of 0.8 which is caused
by current displacement and/or distortion in the home’s circuits. In this case the grid must supply reactive power to
provide voltage support.
PECANSTREET.ORG 3
PECANSTREET.ORG 4
Figure X below shows the current transformer (CT) wiring for our
eGauges to measure current, voltage, harmonic distortion and
phase angle at our sample homes. All of the measurements are tak-
en from CT1 and CT2 at the main breaker. Our calculations use
voltage measurements from both legs of the electrical panel to
avoid any errors from approximating each leg at 120V.
Sa v e dC u r r e n t = A p p a r e n t C u r r e n t − (Re a lC u r r e n t )/(0.95)
PECANSTREET.ORG 5
Research Results
The average power factor of each home in the sample by state can be seen in Figure X be-
low. The chart is segmented by the hour of the day and quarter of the year to show how
changing loads throughout the day and year affect power factor. We expect to see differ-
ences in the power factor curve between Texas and New York because solar production
peaks at different times of the day (due to different latitudes) and the HVAC load profile in
the two regions is different. This results in seasonal differences between the two locations.
Figure 5: Average power factor by hour of day in New York and Texas Samples
Power factor is generally lowest during daylight hours in both Texas and New York. This is partly an effect of residen-
tial solar systems producing active power, but not reactive power. When residential solar systems displace some or all
of the grid’s active power with their own generation, the grid still must support the same amount of reactive power as it
would if there was no solar production. As the amount of active power supplied by solar systems increases, the amount
supplied by the grid decreases and the reactive power supported by the grid remains constant. This causes the power
factor in our measurement to decrease. However, it is important to note that the solar systems themselves do not cause
the reactive power to increase. The same amount of reactive power is supplied by the utility whether the solar system is
producing power or not. However, the ratio of the active power to reactive power at the grid interconnect does
change when a solar system is connected to a home.
PECANSTREET.ORG 6
Figure 6: Active and reactive power in solar vs. non-solar homes
Real current and apparent current averaged by hour of the day for each quarter of the year can be seen in Figure X.
The points on the chart where the difference between the apparent current and the actual current are the largest is
where the most reactive power (power that does not do work) is highest. In an ideal scenario, real current would
match apparent current and the space between the light and dark orange area of the graph would be minimized.
Figure 7: Average apparent current vs real current by hour of day in New York and Texas samples
PECANSTREET.ORG 7
The majority of the homes in our sample produce more solar power than they use in the middle of the day during sum-
mer months. Since real current is calculated with the absolute value of the grid power, the solar power sent to the grid
produces the midday ‘hump’ signature in both states. In Texas, the second hump in Q2 and Q3 is caused by the high
HVAC load during summer months. Notably, in Texas this hump occurs during the summer peak load hours of 2-6PM
on hot summer days. Correcting power factor would result in more usable distribution capacity at the time of day and
year when grid demand is highest and solar generation is high.
Similarly, power factor is also low on winter mornings in Q3 and Q4. As homes in Texas continue to electrify, particu-
larly with electric heat pumps for space and water heating, this will also coincide with the maximum current saved from
power factor correction. The New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) also experiences a late afternoon
summer peak for the grid serving homes in our New York sample. The summer peak is milder than in Texas, but the
winter peak is more drastic. This winter peak load will also increase as more homes electrify their space and water
heating, making electric distribution capacity increases from reduced power factor more economical.
Figure X shows the current that would be saved in our sample if the power factor for every hour below 0.95 was in-
creased to 0.95. In this scenario, the early hours of the summer peak demand hours in the ERCOT grid would see a
30% increase in saved current on homes with solar. ERCOT’s winter peak hours would see a 20% increase in current
capacity. Homes in New York follow a similar pattern for summer and winter grid peak, although the potential winter
savings aren’t as dramatic as in Texas.
Figure 8: Average percentage of current saved per home when power factor is corrected to
0.95 for each hour of the day in New York and Texas samples
PECANSTREET.ORG 8
Correcting power factor to 0.95 or better for every hour of the 2020 Average Apparent, Real & Saved
day would have provided an additional current capacity of Current Per Home at 0.95 Power Factor
12-16% to the distribution system in the homes in our sample.
The current savings seen in Figure X represent a significant
increase in transmission and distribution capacity that would
lower energy sector emissions and free up capacity for serving
additional customers with existing generation assets - all with-
out upgrading any infrastructure. The general trend of low
power factor during both summer and winter peak demand
hours seen in our sample likely exists in all regions of the coun-
try. Regional variation will occur between other regions as it
does between Texas and New York, but homes with solar Figure 9: Average apparent, real and saved current per home
when power factor is 0.95 in New York and Texas samples
systems throughout the country are expected to experience simi-
lar benefits to the homes in our sample from power factor correction.
There are three primary methods to resolve low power factor in homes:
• A whole-home approach: installing power factor correction solutions that have been effective in the commercial
and industrial sector at the electric meter interconnection with the home.
• For solar systems only: require that solar or battery storage inverters produce reactive power to meet the home’s
total power needs rather than only real power.
• At the device/appliance level: Mandate that devices and appliances meet a minimum power factor of 0.95.
PECANSTREET.ORG 9
An ideal whole-home solution would be a high efficiency, full time, cycle-by-cycle power factor correction based on
high speed, low loss Silicon-Carbide or Gallium Nitride semiconductors. The distortion and displacement components
of the line current for a residential structure are dynamic, changing as quickly as one 60Hz cycle to the next. Tradi-
tional approaches used for feeders or large commercial structures like fixed capacitor banks will not work because
home loads may change from inductive to capacitive hundreds of times per day. The distortion profile is even more
dynamic, changing every few seconds as electronics within the home change load current rapidly while in use. Given
the growing complexity of in-home devices, home load dynamics, and the effect these have on power factor, a whole-
home solution in combination with device level requirements for new appliances would lead to the greatest improve-
ments in performance and yield the greatest grid system benefits.
Industrial Solutions Applied to the Residential Sector: Power factor correction equipment used in the commercial
and industrial sectors could be adapted for residential applications that would require relatively simple electronics in-
stalled at a home’s electrical panel. Generally, this is a group of capacitors and inductors that are connected to the
main panel, which measures current displacement and uses capacitors (for leading current) or inductors (for lagging
current) to bring current and voltage closer to unity.
PECANSTREET.ORG 10
Current Distortion Solved at the Panel-Inductive Filtering: Current distortion can be remedied with harmonic miti-
gating transformers or line reactors. Harmonic mitigating transformers are generally used where there are large concen-
trations of computers or communication equipment, such as offices, schools or medical facilities. The issue with trans-
formers and line reactors is that they can introduce other system issues, such as higher voltage distortion, and are un-
able to dynamically adapt to changing load conditions. These solutions are best used with loads that are relatively
static, which preclude their use given the variety of home electrical loads. Additionally, as semiconductor technology
continues to improve the cost of active correction will quickly make it less expensive than technologies reliant on large
amounts of comparatively iron and copper, which are comparatively expensive.
Current Displacement Solved at the Solar Inverter: Another standalone solution for power factor correction is to
produce reactive power from a solar inverter. Producing reactive power onsite along with active power is preferable
because long range high voltage transmission of reactive power has high transmission losses. The main downside to
this solution is that solar inverters currently only provide reactive power in the form of displacement correction. Another
issue is that producing reactive power can sometimes lower the active power output which would potentially negate
some distribution capacity gains from increasing power factor. Since reactive power can be caused by current dis-
placement or distortion, this solution will only increase power factor if the majority of reactive power is caused by dis-
placement. Through our research we know that residential homes can have significant amounts of distortion depending
on the lighting, appliances and other miscellaneous loads. Therefore, while reactive power production from a solar
inverter could be effective at improving residential power factor, it is not a definitive solution to the problem unless the
inverters are designed to provide both harmonic cancellation and displacement correction, full time, without decreas-
ing the real-power production capabilities of the inverter.
Current Distortion Solved at the Device/Appliance Level by Manufacturers: Another way to increase residential
power factor is at the manufacturer level. The International Electrotechnical Commission maintains an international
regulation, IEC 61000-3-2, which aims to curb main voltage distortion by setting upper limits for harmonic currents in
equipment with a rated current of up to 16A. California’s Title 20 also has power factor requirements on over 50 ap-
pliances, many of which can be found in a residential setting. Table X shows some common residential loads and their
corresponding Title 20 power factor limit. Limits for computers, LED’s and large battery charging systems went into
effect in 2019 so their full impact won’t be realized until a full product refresh cycle takes place. Ideally, Title 20 will
improve residential power factor internationally as manufacturers raise all their products to California’s standards.
However, compliance in California is estimated to be 80-90% (source) and it is yet to be seen how the more stringent
regulations will affect that rate.
Several voluntary power factor correction programs have Table 1: California Title 20 Power Factor Requirements
been created to provide certification for devices that meet
California Title 20 Power Factor Requirements
minimum power factor standards. The 80 Plus certifica-
tion and the DOE’s EnergyStar guidelines both advocate
for devices to have a power factor of at least 0.9 (source).
The certifications theoretically help manufacturers market
their products to make them more appealing, but they
have not yet reached widespread adoption levels. Addi-
tionally, the EnergyStar requirements for residential light-
ing aren't particularly strict so it’s questionable whether
these types of programs can deliver significant results.
PECANSTREET.ORG 11
To achieve a return on investment commensurate with the overall system benefits that the technological solutions dis-
cussed above would provide to the grid, policies will need to be implemented that require utilities to analyze and ap-
propriately compensate customers for power factor correction.
Some policy recommendations grounded in precedent from the transition to energy efficient appliances include:
1. Making it law: Introducing it as a portion of a bill and making it part of the Code of Federal Regulations. In this
case, the likely enforcement authority would be the FTC, and therefore, compliance would likely be high. Unfortunately,
a likely pathway for this may take the form of updating EnergyStar standards, which are not mandatory – you can still
buy a non-energy-star version of an appliance.
2. Harmonizing product safety and operations standards with existing IEC standards: This would require stan-
dards process through ANSI/UL and would take 2-5 years for standards writing and then the enforcement would hap-
pen through local code inspectors. Compliance would be relatively high in areas with strong inspection requirements
and low in unincorporated areas of the country without inspections.
3. Requirements set in the National Electric Code: Compliance would be relatively high in areas with strong
inspection requirements and low in unincorporated areas of the country without inspections.
Furthermore, devices can be designed to achieve high energy efficiency and high power factor. In South Korea, elec-
trical code dictates that all appliances and power-consuming devices achieve a power factor of 0.95 or better. With-
out any such requirements or incentives in the United States, companies are not investing in certifying, selling and mar-
keting these options in the US. Establishing a power factor standard commensurate with Energy Star and working with
building code authorities to include requirements for appliances that meet this standard will help to correct poor power
factor upstream at the point of device manufacturing.
PECANSTREET.ORG 12
Literature Cited
California Energy Commission. (2021, July 21). Title 20 Appliance Efficiency Regulations - Reference Ace v5.3. Ener-
gy Code Ace. https://energycodeace.com/site/custom/public/reference-ace-t20/index.html#!Documents/sec-
tion16053statestandardsfornonfederallyregulatedappliances.htm
EnergyStar. (2021). ENERGY STAR® Program Requirements for Single Voltage External Ac-Dc and Ac-Ac Power Sup-
plies. https://www.energystar.gov/ia/partners/product_specs/program_reqs/eps_prog_req.pdf
Federal Trade Commission. (1960, February). DIAMOND CRYSTAL SALT CO. 463 Modifying Order IN THE MATTER
OF DIAMOND CRYSTAL SALT COMPANY MODIFYING ORDER IN REGARD TO ALLGED VIOLATION OF SEC-
TION 7 OF THE CLAYTON ACT. https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/commission_decision_vol-
umes/volume-104/ftc_volume_decision_104__july-_december_1984_pages_463-_561.pdf
Fortenbery, B. (2014). Power Factor Requirements for Electronic Loads in California. American Council an Energy-Effi-
cient Economy, 160–170.
Hodge, T. (2020, February 21). Hourly electricity consumption varies throughout the day and across seasons - Today
in Energy - U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). U.S. Energy Information Administration. https://
www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=42915
PECANSTREET.ORG 19