Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ma'Aden Engineering Manual: Structural Design Criteria-Process Buildings and Structures
Ma'Aden Engineering Manual: Structural Design Criteria-Process Buildings and Structures
Table of Contents
1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 5
1.1 Scope ........................................................................................................................................ 5
1.2 Purpose ..................................................................................................................................... 5
2. Key Terms and Definitions ................................................................................................................. 5
3. Referenced Documents ...................................................................................................................... 6
3.1 Statutory Regulations ................................................................................................................. 6
3.2 Industry Codes and Standards .................................................................................................... 6
3.2.1 Local Codes and Standards ............................................................................................ 6
3.2.2 International Codes and Standards ................................................................................. 6
3.2.3 Alternative Design Codes ............................................................................................. 11
3.3 Ma’aden Standards .................................................................................................................. 11
4. General Design Criteria ................................................................................................................... 11
4.1 Design for Safety ...................................................................................................................... 11
4.2 Units of Measurement.............................................................................................................. 12
4.3 Design Life .............................................................................................................................. 12
4.4 Provision for Future Expansion................................................................................................. 12
4.5 Site Data .................................................................................................................................. 12
4.6 Materials .................................................................................................................................. 12
4.7 Temperature Range .................................................................................................................. 12
4.8 Drawings ................................................................................................................................. 12
4.9 Protective Coatings .................................................................................................................. 13
4.9.1 General ........................................................................................................................ 13
4.9.2 Steel Flooring ............................................................................................................... 13
4.9.3 Bolts ........................................................................................................................ 13
4.10 Clean Plant Design .................................................................................................................. 13
4.11 Electrical Requirements............................................................................................................ 13
5. Design Load Criteria ........................................................................................................................ 14
5.1 Dead Loads ............................................................................................................................. 14
5.2 Equipment Loads ..................................................................................................................... 14
5.3 Live Loads ............................................................................................................................... 15
5.4 Material Loads ......................................................................................................................... 16
5.5 Wind loads .............................................................................................................................. 16
5.6 Seismic Loads .......................................................................................................................... 16
5.7 Crane and Monorail Loads ....................................................................................................... 17
5.8 Thermal Loads ......................................................................................................................... 17
5.9 Earth Loads .............................................................................................................................. 18
5.9.1 Soil Properties .............................................................................................................. 18
5.9.2 Lateral Earth Pressures .................................................................................................. 18
5.9.3 Surcharge to Retaining Walls ....................................................................................... 18
5.10 Bin Loads ................................................................................................................................. 19
5.11 Vibrating Loads ........................................................................................................................ 19
5.12 Conveyor Loads ....................................................................................................................... 19
5.12.1 Belt Tensions ............................................................................................................... 19
5.12.2 Services on Conveyor Gantries .................................................................................... 19
5.13 Dust Loads ............................................................................................................................... 19
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Scope
This document provides structural design criteria for process buildings and structures for all
Ma’aden projects.
This document is intended to be used in conjunction with the applicable documents listed
herein.
1.2 Purpose
The design criteria is to:
• Establish a common basis for structural discipline design of process building and
structures for all Ma’aden projects
BS British Standards
3. REFERENCED DOCUMENTS
This specification requires compliance with the provisions of the latest revision of the
relevant standards or codes of the following authorities and technical organizations, as
applicable, and specifications which shall be considered to form part of this specification,
where applicable.
3.1 Statutory Regulations
All work performed and materials furnished shall comply with the applicable statutory
regulations, codes and other requirements of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (including but not
limited to directives of the High Commission for Industrial Security, Royal Commission
regulations applicable to the Site, regulations of the Presidency of Meteorology and
Environment, Saudi Building Code and other applicable codes and regulations). The
Contractor shall ensure that he is fully aware and informed of all Government laws, local
ordinances, regulations and all orders and decrees of bodies or tribunals having any
jurisdiction or authority over the Project and/or Site, which in any manner affect the Project
and those engaged or employed on the Project, or which in any way affect the conduct of
the Work. The Contractor shall at all times observe and comply with all such Government
and/or Ministry laws, bylaws, ordinances, codes, regulations, orders and decrees.
3.2 Industry Codes and Standards
All equipment and systems shall conform to the following:
3.2.1 Local Codes and Standards
AISC Load and Resistance Factor Specification for Structural Steel Buildings
Design
AISI –SG 673, Part I Specification for the Design for Cold-Formed Steel
Structural Members
AISI –SG 673, Part II Commentary on the Specification for the Design for
Cold-Formed Steel Structural Members
AISI – SG 913, Part I Load and Resistance Factor Design Specification for
Cold-Formed Steel Structural Members
ASTM C618 Standard Specification for Coal Fly Ash and Raw or
Calcined Natural Pozzolan for Use in Concrete
CMAA Spec No.70 Specification for Top Running Bridge and Gantry Type
Multiple Girder Electric Overhead Travelling Cranes
CMAA Spec No.74 Specifications for Top Running and Under Running
Single Girder Electrical Overhead Cranes Utilizing
Under Running Trolley Hoist
Guide to the Design of Concrete Structures in the
Arabian Peninsula
ISO 5048 Continuous mechanical Belt conveyors with carrying idlers -- Calculation of
handling equipment operating power and tensile forces
ISO 5049-1 Mobile Equipment for Rules for the Design of Steel Structures
Continuous Handling of Bulk
Materials
3. Provision of tested lifting lugs on large pre-assemblies to facilitate safe cranage and
installation.
In general, above-ground structures shall be fabricated from structural steel and foundations
constructed from reinforced concrete, except for the possibility of using steel piles. Flooring
shall be steel grating or floor plate, with grating preferred except where material containment
is required. Suspended concrete slabs shall be avoided.
4.7 Temperature Range
Temperature range, as specified in the site data specification, shall be adopted for structural
design, unless approved otherwise by the Employer.
4.8 Drawings
Design uniform floor live loads shall be clearly indicated on the general arrangement
drawings as kPa (kN/m2).
Reference shall be made, on the general arrangements or the general notes drawing to the
appropriate protective coating system to be used. Note that this applies to concrete as well
as structural steel.
a) To contain spills and facilitate clean up, generally steel plate floors shall be used under
all equipment that has the potential to spill material.
b) High strength steel shall be used to minimize flange widths and number of members.
c) Preference should be given to larger column spacing so as to have fewer members and
therefore less dust accumulation.
e) Floors beneath process areas shall be appropriately sloped to collect spills and wash
water.
f) Stairwells are to be located outside of buildings in order to isolate them from the main
process areas.
g) Sumps shall be designed to allow for the collection and recycling of spills.
4.11 Electrical Requirements
The Electrical Engineer shall advise requirements for earthing and lightning protection for all
buildings and structures. This may include the provision of lugs at the bases of steel
columns, and/or bonded concrete reinforcement. The requirement shall comply with
MD-101-SMEM-EG-EL-CRT-0001, Electrical Design Criteria.
Superimposed dead loads are defined as the weight of all materials forming static loads on
the structure, that are not structural elements, and which are likely to vary or be removed
during operation or construction. Superimposed dead loads such as weight of fluid or solids
in tanks, piping, chutes and equipment including cranes, lay down loads, equipment
handling, lateral earth pressure, overloads due to blocked pipes, chutes and equipment shall
be considered. Provision shall be made for spillages and equipment overload.
The design engineer shall assess the possibility of the removal of superimposed dead loads
which will result in the most severe combination of design actions on the structure. The
designer shall also consider the possibility of adding temporary dead loads during a repair.
Process piping, ducts or major electrical runs shall be individually assessed in each case,
with their design information obtained in writing from the respective discipline engineers.
The loads associated with hydrostatic pressure may be considered as dead load provided that
the full head (i.e. height of tank including freeboard or top of retaining wall) is used in
calculating the pressure.
5.2 Equipment Loads
Equipment load means the weight of equipment and its appurtenances supported by a
structure and shall be classified as follows:
a) Equipment load for erection means the load of the equipment during erection and, in
many cases, does not include the weights of internals, fluids and solids within the
equipment, nor the insulation, platforms and piping to be attached to the equipment.
b) Equipment load for operation means the load of the equipment during normal operating
conditions and includes weights of internals, fluids and solids within the equipment, and
the insulation, platforms and piping (with insulation and contents thereof) attached to the
equipment. Vibration caused by operation of the equipment shall be handled separately
as vibration loads.
c) Equipment load for testing or flushing shall mean the load of the equipment during
hydraulic testing or during flushing with water, and includes weights of internals,
insulation, platforms and piping attached to equipment, insulation of attached piping
and all water within the equipment and piping.
Dead and live loads associated with mechanical, electrical and vendor supplied equipment
shall be incorporated into the structural design loading. The source of the loading
information shall be clearly indicated in the structural calculations. Equipment loads shall be
certified prior to issuing drawings for construction, indicating all possible loading
combinations (e.g. vessel at normal and abnormal operating conditions, allowance for scale
build-up, and dynamic effects). Any maximum allowable deflections of support structures
specified by the equipment vendor shall be adhered to.
Dynamic loads shall be obtained from the equipment vendor and applied in accordance
with the appropriate structure design code. In the absence of Vendor supplied dynamic
loads specific for the Project, the static mass of the equipment shall be multiplied by the
following factors to determine a static equivalent of the dynamic or impact loads:
The floor area live load shall be omitted from areas occupied by equipment where the
weight of such is specifically included in dead load.
Minimum live loads to be used in design shall be in accordance with SBC 301 Structural –
Loading and Forces or as per Table 5-1, whichever is greater, unless directed otherwise by
the Employer.
Table 5-1 identifies common structural loading. Special loads such as those from specific
types of cranes and forklifts, or special heavy storage loads shall be considered when
appropriate in consultation with the discipline engineer.
Table 5-1 : Minimum Live Loads
Blocked chute loads shall be calculated from the maximum expected bulk density of
materials and the volume of the chute with free surface in contact with the lowest rotating or
oscillating machinery component. For column design, the simultaneous effects of live loads
on other floors need to be considered with the blocked chute load.
5.5 Wind loads
Wind loading shall be in accordance with SBC 301 Structural – Loading and Forces and the
parameters sourced from the project Site Data Specification.
Wind load is obtained by multiplying the effective velocity pressures by the wind pressure
coefficient described below:
• Basic wind speed and the type of exposure shall be set forth in Basic Engineering Design
Data (BEDD)
• Wind pressure coefficient for ordinary buildings and structures shall be in accordance
with “Structural Code” of Royal Commission, relevant site data specification and
SBC 301.
For special shapes, the value shall be determined by wind tunnel tests.
5.6 Seismic Loads
Seismic loading shall be in accordance with SBC 301 Structural – Loading and Forces and
the parameters sourced from the project Site Data Specification. Earthquake loading shall be
calculated in accordance with Royal Commission Structural Code, relevant site data
specification and SBC 301.
The impact forces affecting a monorail shall be deemed to work vertically and be 20% of the
sum of the lift load and the weight of the hoist of the chain block. For weights of hoists and
chain blocks, the standard weight furnished by the crane manufacturer shall be used. The
impact forces affecting a monorail shall comply with AISC, ASME B30.11 and CMAA.
5.8 Thermal Loads
Forces caused by expansion or contraction due to a change in temperature from the erection
condition shall be taken into account. Such forces shall include those caused by:
• For exposed steel frame structures not exceeding 40 m in length, or reinforced concrete
structures and steel frame buildings covered with exterior walls not exceeding 60 m in
length, loads due to thermal expansion of structural material need not be considered
• For structures exceeding the above lengths, appropriate expansion joints shall be
provided. However, when an expansion joint cannot be provided because it would foul
a conveyor line, crane, or other similar equipment, the thermal force shall be calculated
as follows:
N = AEα (t – to)
Where:
N = axial force in tonnes
A = cross section of material in cm2
E = Young’s modules in tons/cm2
α = coefficient of thermal expansion, per oC
t = temperature when thermal forces are considered in oC
to = standard temperature (normally temperature during erection in oC)
Friction loads caused by thermal expansion shall be determined using the appropriate
static coefficient of friction. The coefficient shall be as following:
• Modulus of sub-grade reaction: design for upper and lower bound cases of 5 kPa/mm
and 50 kPa/mm.
Water table level shall be taken into account for any soil- structure interaction design.
5.9.2 Lateral Earth Pressures
Active pressures shall be used to design flexible structures, such as cantilever retaining walls.
At rest pressures shall be used to design rigid structures, such as tied retaining walls and
concrete tunnels. The “at rest” pressure coefficient, ko, shall be taken as not less than 0.50.
Passive pressures shall not be assumed to resist lateral forces unless substantial movement
can be accommodated (e.g. free standing retaining walls).
Lateral earth pressure coefficients on retaining structures subject to repeated traffic loads shall
take into consideration the resulting long term compaction, which in some cases has been
measured as giving coefficients as high as the passive coefficient kp.
The minimum surcharge for which a retaining structure shall be designed is 10 kPa. (or as
agreed with the Lead Structural Engineer).
Where the edge of a road is within a horizontal distance from the top of a retaining structure
equal to one half of its clear height, the wall shall be designed for a road vertical surcharge of
20 kPa in addition to normal earth pressures.
Where high axle load vehicles or other items are able to apply point surcharge loads to
retaining structures, the effect of this load shall be calculated using established methods
approved by the Employer.
The belt tension used in the design of conveyor support structures shall be as follows:
• For connection of head/drive frame to support steelwork, support steelwork and the
connections out to the nearest columns: 2.0 x Ts
where Tr = normal operating belt tension load
Ts = drive start tension load
5.12.2 Services on Conveyor Gantries
Unless advised otherwise by the discipline engineer, load allowances for services on
conveyor gantries shall be as follows:
Ducts for fume systems and their supports shall be designed for an accumulation of dust
equal to a minimum of 30% of the duct volume. An accumulation of 50% of the duct
volume shall be used if warranted by operating conditions such as:
• Sticky dust
• Duct conditions that promote settling of dust (such as reduction in gas velocity in the
duct).
In addition to dust loading on ducts, the design of roofs and roof gutters shall take into
consideration the possibility of dust accumulation.
The dust loadings in general and dust accumulation in ducts for fume systems and their
supports shall be treated as live loads for analysis but should not be included in the
allowable live loads specified on the drawings.
5.14 Piping Loads
5.14.1 General
Piping load means the weight of pipe, fittings, valves, insulation and the fluid contents of
piping and shall be classified as follows:
a) Piping load for erection means the weight of prefabricated piping and consists of weights
of pipe, fittings and valves but does not include insulation and the fluid contents.
b) Piping load for operation means the weight of piping during normal operating conditions
and consists of total weight of pipe, fittings, valves, insulation and the contents of piping
during operation.
c) Piping load for testing or flushing means the weight of piping during hydraulic testing or
flushing with water and consists of total weight of pipe, fittings, valves, insulation and
the water contents therein.
Piping load should normally be assumed and calculated as a certain weight per horizontal
unit area of the pipe rack. However, concentrated loads of large diameter pipes and valves
shall be calculated separately.
For gas piping where loads may increase only during hydraulic testing, the load shall be
considered depending on the actual condition, such as section of piping to be tested. The
load of such piping shall not be considered to increase over its entire length.
For high pressure piping, forces due to internal pressure shall be considered in addition to
the above loads.
5.14.2 Pipe Rack Loads
5.14.2.1 Vertical Loads
Vertical pipe loads shall be calculated and used for the pipe rack design. Any unused areas
of pipe rack shall be designed for a load allowance of 2.5 kPa. Cable tray loads shall also be
included if applicable.
5.14.2.2 Transverse Wind Loads
For a typical pipe rack, transverse wind loading shall be calculated by assuming a bluff area
height that increases with pipe rack width, as per Table 5-2.
Using this method, an allowance is already included for structural steel, and the shape factor,
Cd, shall be taken as 1.2.
Table 5-2 : Effective Heights of Piperack Levels for Transverse Wind Load Calculations
Width of pipe rack B<4m 4m<B<6m 6m<B<8m 8m<B<9m
Height of wind 1.5 m 2.0 m 2.5 m 2.75 m
load per level of
pipe rack
• Horizontal loads equal to 15% of vertical loads of all lines shall be applied at each
transverse frame and the longitudinal steelwork immediately adjacent to the frame on
each side
• Horizontal loads equal to 10% of all vertical pipe loads shall be accumulated at braced
bays and carried down to the foundations.
5.14.3 Process Pipe Loads
Forces caused by the major process piping, together with a clear instruction of the location
and type of pipe anchor/support shall be supplied by the Piping Engineer. Pipe loads shall
be given as individual load cases together with assumptions made by the Piping Engineer on
coefficients of friction used for sliding and structural rigidity at each support.
The Structural Engineer shall advise the Piping Engineer of expected structural deflections, so
that realistic assumptions are made during pipe stress analysis with regards to fixity and
deflections of support members.
5.15 Cable Tray Loads
Cable tray loading shall be obtained in writing from the Electrical Engineer. For preliminary
design, a unit load of 0.75 kN/m may be adopted.
5.16 Blast Loads
Blast load is the load on a structure caused by overpressure resulting from the ignition and
explosion of flammable material or by overpressure resulting from a vessel burst.
Control houses or other buildings housing personnel and control equipment near processing
plants may need to be designed for blast resistance.
Blast load shall be computed and applied in accordance with the ASCE Design of Blast
Resistant Buildings in Petrochemical Facilities.
5.17 Impact Load
The following impact loads shall be used in addition to those listed in the AISC Specification:
• Vertical impact on davits and hitch points: 25% of the lifted load
• Lateral force on davits and hitch points: 20% of the lifted load
5.18 Miscellaneous Loads
A single point load of 2300 kg (22.5 kN) shall be allowed for at any one panel point of roof
trusses, main roof and floor girders to cover miscellaneous hoisting operations. This load
shall not be cumulative through the structure.
Any loads that are not noted here shall determined from SBC 301.
• Deformed bars: D10, D13, D16, D19, D22, D25, D29, D32
All major anchor bolts (e.g. for building columns, trestle columns, tank columns, pipe racks)
shall be cast into concrete. The minimum size shall be 20 mm diameter.
Chemical anchors (16 mm minimum) may be used for minor items. (stair stringers, ladder
stringer, minor pipe supports. Mechanical anchors shall not be used.
6.2.4 Grout
Standard thickness allowances of non-shrink grout shall be as follows:
6.3 Footings
6.3.1 Soil Condition and General Requirement
Sufficient soil investigation shall be performed to obtain soil data necessary for designing
concrete structures and foundations. The time of the soil investigation shall be subject to the
prior approval of Employer.
Based on the soil investigation by the soil consultant/engineer, foundation type shall be
determined.
The maximum foundation settlement for the recommended soil bearing pressures shall be
limited to 25 mm, and maximum differential settlement between two adjacent foundations
shall be limited to 20 mm. These requirements may vary depending on any special
requirement due to equipment functions.
The allowable soil bearing capacity and pile bearing capacity can be increased by 33% for
temporary loads such as wind load, earthquake load and bundle pulling force and by 25%
for testing loads.
When the foundation is within 300 mm of the water table or below the water table, the soil
bearing capacity shall be reduced taking into consideration buoyancy and loss of cohesion.
All footing shall have a 100 mm layer of blinding concrete unless the footing is based on
rock, in which case the rock shall be air-cleaned prior to placing of reinforcement.
6.3.2 Stability
Concrete structures and foundations shall be designed so that the safety factors nominated in
Table 6-1 are satisfied.
Table 6-1 : Concrete Design Safety Factors
Sliding 1.5
Overturning (temporary load) 1.5
Overturning (Permanent load) 2.0
Buoyancy 1.2
b) For minor columns and wind posts, the friction between the column base plate and the
concrete shall be included in combination with the bolt shear resistances. A friction
coefficient of 0.30 shall be used. Any combined tension and shear cases shall also be
considered, which will have zero friction. As a good design practice, only 50% of the
anchor bolts shall be assumed as being effective in resisting the shear, due to the
oversize holes in the base plates and misalignments.
Where rock anchors have been used to resist uplift, the residual ground pressure may be
included in sliding resistance calculations.
The co-efficient of friction between the rock and the footing shall be taken as 0.40.
6.3.4 Pedestals
The top of the pedestal shall be 300 mm minimum above nominal floor/ground level, with
all major pedestals in the one facility/building being at the same level. The pedestal height
may be reduced with the approval of the Employer if it is deemed that sufficient clearance is
maintained above any containment levels, and operational requirements are not adversely
affected.
6.3.5 Depth of Embedment into Ground
All footings shall be located such that:
• Where possible and within reason the underside of all footings within the one
facility/building shall be located at the same elevation
• If the top of the footing is to be below the finished surface level then it shall be a
minimum of 500 mm below finished surface level
• The top of the footing shall be located a minimum of 300 mm below the underside of
any slab on ground.
6.3.6 Uplift Resistance
Where footings are located on rock, the preferred method of resisting uplift on footings shall
be the use of rock anchors. Corrosion protection shall be provided to all rock anchors.
Where footings are not located on rock, the preferred method of resisting uplift shall be by
the mass of the reinforced concrete footings. Other options may be applicable with the
approval from the Employer.
6.4 Slabs on Ground
6.4.1 Design Procedure
The design method for slabs on ground shall be in accordance with SBC 304 and ACI 360R.
6.4.2 Slab Thickness
The minimum thickness of slabs shall be 150 mm.
6.4.3 Reinforcement in Slabs
The reinforcement to be provided in ground slabs shall be calculated in accordance with the
requirements of ACI 360R.
6.4.4 Slab Panel Sizes
Slabs shall be detailed so as to limit the area of any slab between joints to 50 m2, with the
ratio of longest side to shortest side of a panel not to exceed 1.5.
Bunded area dimensions and levels shall not be reduced below the area and wall levels as
laid out in the Drawings. For reference, bunded areas shall be designed for the capacity
requirements as set out in the Civil Design Criteria.
Process sumps shall be circular with a single sump pump. The pump motor platform and
access walkway shall to be located above bund wall to allow maintenance access to the
sump pump in the event of pump failure during a flooded bund.
Steel lined process drains may be used in various Process Areas to direct process flows to
local Area sumps. The extent and arrangement of these drains are indicated in the Drawings
for each Process Facility.
Steel lined process sumps and drains used in concrete rafts and slabs shall be as detailed in
the Drawings. All other sumps and tundishes indicated in the Drawings shall be constructed
of steel plate.
6.4.8 Joints
Joints shall be positioned to suit the process equipment requirement and minimize cracking.
Generally joints shall be set out on a square pattern and located along high point concrete
ridge lines. Specific joint design details shall be taken from the Project Standard Drawings.
6.5 Concrete Pile Design
All concrete pile design shall be in accordance with ASCE 20-96.
6.6 Foundations for Heavy Machinery
6.6.1 General
The design of ground bearing foundations supporting rotating and reciprocating machinery
including pumps and compressors shall be in accordance with the guidelines given below.
Multiple machines shall only be installed on a common foundation where the manufacturer’s
approval for this has been obtained.
The design of foundation for specialist machinery shall be as per the Manufacturer’s
guidelines and recommendations.
Design of foundations for heavy machinery shall encompass the following activities:
• Equipment footings for centrifugal machinery shall be sized to weigh three times as
much as the machine as a minimum
• Equipment footings for reciprocating machinery shall be sized to weigh five times as
much as the machine as a minimum
• Large machinery footings (compressors, pumps, blowers etc) shall be designed on the
basis of a frequency comparison. Machine operating frequency will be compared with
the natural frequency of the combined machine and its footings (refer to Section 6.6.6).
Finite Element Analysis may be used to reasonably predict the response of the footing.
• If pump plinths are not integral with a raft, the plinth shall be sized and laid out so that
suction and discharge pipe supports immediately adjacent to pump volute can be
attached to and form part of the pump plinth. This can be achieved by extending the
concrete directly under the suction and discharge piping to allow support points to be
mounted on the same concrete as the main pump base frame.
• For machinery, six degrees of freedom exist. Analysis of all six degrees of freedom or
natural frequencies (vertical, horizontal and rocking in a vertical plane) shall be
undertaken, depending on the availability of Supplier information.
• The machine footing shall be isolated from any adjacent footings and structures, where
ever possible, including steel associated with walkways and platforms. If the steel is
attached to the footing, the effect of this additional mass on the footing’s response to
vibration shall be included in the design.
• The clear distance in any direction between adjacent foundations for heavy machinery
shall be large enough to avoid transmission of detrimental vibration amplitudes through
the surrounding soil, otherwise the adjacent foundations shall be protected in other
ways. Transmissibility of amplitudes shall be limited to 20% between adjacent
foundations, unless otherwise agreed by the project engineer.
• The footing thickness for vibrating machines shall be at least 600 mm, unless a lesser
thickness is allowed by the machine manufacturer.
• Where practical and economical, the machine foundation system shall be proportioned
to be low-tuned. High-tuned machine foundation systems shall be used only when a
low tuned system is not practical or economical; e.g. for low-speed or variable-speed
machinery.
6.6.3 Design Details
Foundation shall be designed considering the following:
• Normal revolutions per minutes (for machinery and motors). Maximum continuous
operating speed. Maximum and minimum speed for trip and/or alarm setting.
• Horsepower
• For elevated machinery, the flexibility of the entire support structures must be
considered in the dynamic analysis
• Weight and gravity center of each machinery component, and location of the center of
gravity of the machinery
• Space restrictions
• Maximum static deformation allowed on the structure (if any) by the Vendor
• Steady state continuous dynamic force at long term normal operational speeds based
purely on an out-of-balance vibration level. This value should not be the static force
equivalent of a dynamic force.
The foundation design shall be capable of resisting all applied dynamic and static loads
specified by the machinery manufacturer, loads from thermal movement, dead and live loads
as applicable, wind or seismic forces, any loads that may be associated with installation or
maintenance of the equipment, and fatigue. For fatigue, the dynamic loads shall be increased
by a factor of 1.5.
The design should take into account the general guidance given by ISO 2631-1 and
ISO 2631-2 on human response to building vibration and weighting curves of frequency
responses for equal annoyance of humans together with measurement methods to be used.
Methods of quantifying whole body vibration in relation to human health and comfort, the
probability of vibration perception, and the incidence of motion sickness are presented in
these standards.
The design method shall be based on either static or dynamic analysis approach depending
on the power rating of the machinery. The following Table illustrates these requirements:
Notes:
1. Weight Ratio = weight of foundation/(weight of machine + driver)
2. Packaged equipments such as generators and compressors with built-in anti-vibration
mountings may be exempt from Dynamic analysis. Example of such machinery is the Essential
Diesel Power Generators (EDPGs). A confirmation from the Vendor is required to ensure anti-
vibration mountings are installed for the equipment in question. A raft foundation should be
provided thus.
3. Dynamic design shall be based on the dynamic forces resulting from a full Finite Element
analysis.
b) The centre of gravity of the machine shall coincide with the centre of gravity of the
foundation within ±5% of the relevant dimension.
c) The centre of gravity of the machine-foundation system shall coincide with the centre of
bearing pressure within ±5% of the relevant dimension.
d) The relevant dimension in rocking mode (normally the base width) shall be greater than
the vertical distance from the underside of the base to the centre of gravity of the
machine (in normal operation) or the rotating shaft axis, whichever is the greater. For
reciprocating machines this dimension shall be not less than 1.5 times the same vertical
distance.
e) The maximum bearing pressure shall not exceed 0.5 times the allowable bearing
pressure.
The shape and principal dimensions of foundations shall be determined from the following,
in addition to machinery dimensions:
a) The height from the ground or the floor to the top of the foundation shall be as little as
possible, provided that operational efficiency and drainage are maintained.
b) Foundations for machinery shall be isolated from other foundations and floors wherever
possible.
c) Generally, cantilevered beams shall not be used for frame foundations.
d) Common or combined footing shall not be advisable for reciprocating and rotating
machinery.
When the revolution of a machine changes within a certain range, the foundation shall be
designed so that is will not resonate within the range of revolution.
6.6.5 Vibration Absorbers
Rubber vibration absorbers shall not be used where the ambient temperature is constantly
below 10°C or above 70°C.
When using rubber vibration absorbers, rubber which may deteriorate within its modulus of
elasticity due to vibration shall not be used.
Preventive measures against aging of the rubber and the method for its replacement shall be
considered. Direct sunlight onto the rubber vibration absorbers shall be avoided in
particular. The absorber installation shall be accordance with manufacturer’s
recommendations.
Rubber vibration absorbers shall not be used for machinery that is anticipated to leak oil.
When use of air springs, metal coil springs, dampers or others are to be considered, approval
of Employer shall be required.
6.6.6 Frequencies
The foundations shall be designed on the basis of a frequency comparison. The equipment
operating frequency shall be compared with the natural frequency of the combined
equipment-foundation system. Foundations supporting rotating machinery shall have a
fundamental natural frequency of greater than 2.0 times or less than 0.5 times the frequency
of the disturbing force.
The calculated amplitude of vibration at any point on the foundation shall not exceed the
lesser of the following:
• Amplitude (single amplitude) which causes the effective velocity of vibration to exceed:
a) 3.0 mm/s for centrifugal and rotating machine and foundation.
b) 3.8 mm/s for reciprocating machine and foundation.
Note: The effective velocity is defined as the square root of the average of square of the
velocity, velocity being a function of time. In the case of a pure sinusoidal function,
the effective is 0.71 times the peak value of the velocity.
6.6.7 Damping
Rigid Foundation: Soil geometric and material damping ratios of 50% of that calculated from
the elastic half-space models as recommended by Novak (1970) or other proven values may
be used but not more than 25% as per DIN4024 Part 2. (ACI 351.3R, Clause 4.2.2).
Flexible Foundation: Damping ratio of the entire system shall be assumed to be 2% as per
DIN4024, Part 1; unless a more accurate value is available.
6.6.8 Applied Forces from Machinery
a) Dynamic forces: Operational forces are usually supplied by the Vendor. These normally
include out-of-balance and emergency forces. However, in the absence of such data
dynamic oscillating forces may be calculated using the empirical formula as follows
(ACI 351.3R, Clause 3.2.2.1d):
b) Malfunction (Emergency) forces: Unless otherwise given by the Vendor forces due to
machine malfunction shall be obtained from DIN 2024 Part 1 where these are specified
as six times the normal operating forces and shall be used for static design and stability
check of the foundation.
c) Psuedo static forces: In the absence of detailed calculations of member forces due to
dynamic loads an equivalent static load shall be used for static design. These forces are
additive to normal gravity loads and considered to act at the centerline of the machine
shaft. They shall not be considered to act concurrently with one another:
Horizontal Force equal to 25% of the total weight of each machine applied in the
transverse direction
Horizontal Force equal to 25% of the total weight of each machine applied in the
longitudinal direction.
6.6.9 Reinforcement
Reinforcing bars shall be provided on all faces in both directions using a minimum bar size
of 16 mm and spaced at 200 mm centers.
For large reciprocating machinery, the anchor bolts shall be designed to carry the full
horizontal and vertical loads specified by the equipment manufacturer with none of the
horizontal load assumed to be resisted by friction on the underside of the base plate, unless
specific shear keys are provided.
6.6.11 Ground Modeling
Foundations under vibrating equipments shall be modeled as structures supported on springs
the stiffness of which is based upon the weighted dynamic shear modulus of the ground.
Ground dynamic properties shall be based on the findings of the Geotechnical study taken
down to a sufficient depth below the foundation.
6.6.12 Steel Structures
Where structures are not properly isolated from vibrating equipment the relationship
between the natural frequency of the supporting members and their columns should be
checked against the frequency of the vibrating equipment. The structural supports shall be
so proportioned that excessive vibration of the supports and other parts of the structure
cannot take place.
The ratio of the natural frequency of the supporting member to the operating frequency of
the equipment shall not be below 2 for reciprocating equipment and below 1.5 for rotating
equipment.
Steel structures shall be designed for the actual dynamic loads generated by the equipment
as supplied by the vendor of the equipment. Documentary proof of these loads shall be
included in the design calculations.
Dynamic loads derived from factoring the weight of the equipment shall not be used unless
every other avenue of dynamic load assessment has been exhausted.
6.6.13 Vibration Isolating Foundations
If adjacent nearby buildings and equipment are liable to be affected by vibration due to
utilization of rigid foundations, vibration isolating foundations using rubber, metal coil
springs or other vibration absorbers may be used.
Since machinery resting on vibration isolating foundations vibrates violently when such
machinery passes its resonant point between start of operation and normal operating speed,
piping and other appurtenances attached thereto shall be installed in such manner that they
will not be adversely affected. The operating floor shall be isolated from the machinery.
The gravity centers of machinery and the height of their points of support shall be as close as
possible.
The allowable amplitudes of foundations shall normally be values obtained from Figure 1
below:
Figure 6-1 : Allowable Amplitude of Machinery – Reiher – Meister Chart (Ref: ACI 351.3R)
Minimum block thickness should be one-fifth the short plan dimension, one-tenth of the long
plan dimension, or two feet, whichever is greater.
Minimum width should be 1.5 times the vertical distance from the machine centerline and
the bottom of the foundation block.
Length and width should be adjusted so the center of gravity of the machine plus the
equipment coincides with the center of gravity of the foundation. Also sufficient area should
be available for maintenance.
6.6.14 Soil Bearing Foundations
When the permanent allowable bearing capacity of the ground is not less than 100 kPa, and
where strata, such as silt layers, or loose sand layers liable to cause settlement do not exist to
a depth of two times the width of the footing from the bottom of the foundation, a soil
bearing pressure shall not exceed 60% of the allowable bearing capacity.
For grounds where the soil type and the bearing capacity are not as mentioned above, soil
bearing foundations may be used on condition that the ground is improved by replacing the
surface soil with sand or by taking other appropriate methods to meet the above provision.
The depth and shape of the bottom of the foundation shall be determined by considering the
frost line and adjacent foundations.
Positive soil bearing over the entire base of the foundation shall be required.
If the ground water table is close to the bottom of the foundation, the condition of
liquefaction of soil has to be checked. Also the bearing capacity should be reduced taking
into consideration cohesion loss and buoyancy.
The foundation should be at least three times the mass of a centrifugal machine and five
times the mass of a reciprocating machine.
6.6.15 Pile Foundations
Pile foundations shall be used for machinery where the soil bearing foundations cannot be
used.
Types and dimensions of piles shall be determined by considering depth of bearing strata,
depth of underground water, weight of equipment to be supported, type of surface soil,
construction period, construction cost, and direction and magnitude of unbalanced inertia
forces.
Batter piles may be used when horizontal unbalanced forces are of great magnitude.
Pile shall extend not less than 100 mm into the footing of the foundation and the reinforcing
steel thereof shall be anchored to the foundation.
Pile cap should be at least two and a half times the mass of a centrifugal machine and four
times the mass of a reciprocating machine.
• Handrails: Handrail shall comply to requirements of ASTM E985 and ASSE A1264.1.
7.2.4 Purlins and Girts
Purlins and girts shall conform to ASTM 1008 Grade 50. Steel purlins and girts of C and Z
profile shall be designed in accordance with the manufacturers design guides. The full
specifications, including required laps and bridging, shall be clearly specified in the relevant
calculations and drawings.
7.3 Member Slenderness Ratios
7.3.1 Tension and Compression Members
Table 7-1 : Maximum Slenderness Ratios for Tension and Compression Members
7.3.2 Beams
Table 7-2 : Depth/Span Ratios for Preliminary Sizing
Refer to the Ministry of Transport Guidelines for load size limits for transportation.
All details shall be arranged to facilitate handling of sub-assemblies, such as not including
any welded cleats that protrude proud of the overall member. Consideration shall be given
to cranage requirements and site connections/splices.
7.5 Connections
7.5.1 Philosophy
Connections shall be designed in accordance with AISC with simplicity of fabrication and
erection given high importance. Connections must be designed to resist the applied load,
however over designed connections can add significantly to the cost of a structure, therefore
economical design principles shall be followed.
Standard connections shall be used wherever possible, however where applied forces
exceed the capacity of the standard connections, the connection shall be individually
designed.
Care shall be taken in connections involving members in three dimensions. Geometry and
clearances shall be thoroughly checked to avoid clashes and to allow for erection
requirements. Floor bracing shall avoid connecting into columns where possible.
Site welding shall be minimized, but not excluded if no other connection is practical.
Any single load shall be carried either entirely by bolting or entirely by welding, but not a
mixture of both.
7.5.2 Bolting
All bolting shall be in accordance with AISC, with installation procedures defined as follows:
• PT = Pre-tensioned Joints
Bolts shall be M20 except where loads are such that it is necessary to use larger bolts. All
bolt holes (with the exception of anchor bolts) shall have a diameter 2 mm greater than the
bolt. Mild steel bolts of sizes M12 or M16 may only be used in minor connections such as
purlins, girts, door frames, etc.
All bolts shall be designed, assuming thread projecting into the shear plane. All connections
shall have a minimum of two bolts with the exception of minor connections such as fly
bracing.
7.5.3 Welding
All welding shall be in accordance with AWS D1.1. Welding electrodes shall be specified as
E60XX.
Manual fillet welds should be limited to a maximum size of 10 mm if possible, as this is the
limit on a one-pass weld.
7.5.4 Beam End Connections
Beam end connections shall be either:
• Beam to beam connections: web side plates. The exception to this is where the
connection must carry substantial axial loads in which case the connection shall be
individually designed.
Shear keys shall be either single or cruciform arrangement to suit the loading conditions and
force directions in accordance with the Standard Drawings.
Bolt holes in base plates shall have a diameter 6 mm greater than the nominal diameter of
the bolt (e.g. an M20 bolt shall be provided with a 26 mm diameter hole). Anchor bolts
shall be designed in accordance with Section 7.5.2.
7.5.8 Connection Design Loads
Connections shall be designed for the greater of the design action in the member, or the
minimum actions specified in Table 7-3.
Table 7-3 : Minimum Design Actions for Connections
7.6 Bracing
As far as possible, vertical and horizontal systems are to be designed as a triangulated
concurrent system, with a preference to the ‘K’ brace configuration where access is a design
requirement, using circular hollow sections. If the loads are beyond the strength capacity of
circular hollow sections, consideration should be given to use rolled column sections.
Structural members, steel flooring and items of equipment connected to, but not directly part
of a triangulated bracing system, shall not be taken into account in the design of the bracing
system.
The preferable horizontal bracing arrangement for all structures shall be diagonal single
angle or circular hollow sections. Choice of steel section type shall be dependent on the
size of the loads to be transmitted. Roof bracing shall be designed for tension only and
where necessary may be fastened to underside of purlin in order to prevent sag.
Floor plate that is to be welded to deck secondary steel may be assumed to laterally restrain
the top flange of the secondary deck steel. Primary steel must rely on secondary steel or
bracing for lateral restraint. Floor grating shall not be assumed to offer lateral restraint to
deck beams.
Bracing members that are directly connected to beams supporting vibrating equipment shall
have a member length to radius of gyration ratio (l/r) not greater than 100.
Bracing members that are indirectly connected to beams supporting vibrating equipment but
are part of that structural framework or system shall be designed as compression members
with an l/r ratio not greater than 120.
1. Open grid flooring shall be deemed to offer no lateral restraint to the top flange.
2. Plate flooring that is bolted to the floor beams shall be deemed to offer no lateral
restraint to the top flange.
3. Plate flooring that is welded to the floor beams may be deemed to offer effective
lateral restraint to the top flange. The welds shall be designed to transfer the
required restraint forces.
4. Floor beams of a permanent nature only may be assumed to provide effective lateral
restraint to top flange of main beams. For global restraint to a floor a bracing system
shall be used.
5. Where a floor is constructed with an in-situ or precast reinforced concrete slab the
effective lateral restraint will depend on the physical connection between the slab
and the top flange of the beams.
6. Roof deck attached by screws shall generally be assumed to provide lateral restraint
to purlins that are perpendicular to the corrugation of the roof deck.
7. Siding, placed with corrugations vertically, in combination with sag rods shall be
assumed to provide lateral restraint to girts.
Note: Items 3, 6 and 7 shall apply in portions of the plant where corrosion is not expected
to be severe. If severe corrosion is anticipated, floor plate and roof/wall cladding
shall be assumed to provide no lateral restraint.
7.8 Deflection and Displacement
7.8.1 Process Buildings
Unless otherwise specified, deflections of structures subjected to serviceability loading (dead
load + live load) shall be limited as detailed in Table 7-4, in conjunction with the member
depth/span and slenderness ratio constraints detailed in Section 7.3.
Table 7-4 : Deflection Limits for Process Buildings
• In general, the minimum thickness of angles, tees, plates and flanges of sections shall be
6 mm
• The ends of all hollow sections shall be sealed to prevent moisture ingress
• Avoid details or arrangements that are inaccessible for inspection and plant maintenance
• Rolled steel structural shapes shall not be positioned in such a way as to retain moisture.
Provision shall be made for drainage where necessary
• For steel bins the stiffeners shall have all edges fully seal welded.
7.10 Structures Supporting Vibrating Equipment
Design parameters and operating frequencies of vibrating equipment shall be obtained in
writing from manufacturers or clients for each piece of equipment.
Loads due to vibrating machines, which will set up excessive building vibrations, shall be
isolated from the main structural framing. Where it is not possible to isolate such equipment,
all steelwork supporting the vibrating equipment shall be analyzed for fundamental natural
frequency of vibration and dynamic amplitude of vibration at the equipment operating
frequency. Care shall be taken to guard against resonant structures. For floor beams, the
ratio of natural frequency divided by equipment operating frequency shall not be less than
the values provided in Table 7-6.
Dynamic analysis shall be performed considering all appropriate dead loads and excluding
live loads. Areas subject to dynamic loading shall be checked for dynamic response against
limits for workers as specified in ISO 585:1997.
Special attention shall be paid to the vicinity of corners and perimeters of roofs and walls for
local pressure effects (refer to SBC 301). The capacity of purlin bolts shall be verified.
The maximum length of section without lapping shall be approximately 9.0 m. This is to
ensure that lengths of purlins can be handled manually once stacked on a roof, unless roof
sections are pre-assembled on the ground.
7.12 Steel Bins, Bunkers and Tanks
The design of steel bunkers and bins shall be in accordance with the following publications:
• Australian Steel Institute (ASI) “ Structural Design of Steel Bins for Bulk Solids”
One of the most important aspects of design of a bin (circular or rectangular) is to ensure that
loads are correctly carried into the columns, and that the columns are not loaded with
undesirable eccentricities. The design should begin at this detail, as it determines the final
position and orientation of the columns. The concentration of load in the bin plates from
column upwards must be carefully checked. Fabrication tolerances for the proper bearing at
the column cap must be specified. All bins shall be designed and detailed in such a way as
to minimize the site erection component of the work, and hence maximize the shop
fabrication. Consideration shall be given to the construction sequence and the possibility of
pre-fabricating sections of the bin either in the shop or on the ground at site, and then lifting
into place.
Design of bins, bunkers and tanks shall comply with the following requirements:
a) Wall plates shall have a minimum of a 2 mm wear allowance added to the theoretically
required thickness unless wear plates are being installed in the wear areas.
b) Only standard plate thicknesses shall be used.
c) Buckling shall be considered.
d) For rectangular bins, wall stiffeners shall be designed for composite action. The
slenderness ratios shall be no greater than the plasticity limit to allow for a compact
action (Ref. AISC). For all welded elements the slenderness limits shall not exceed the
values for heavily welded sections.
e) For circular tanks, the eccentricity of plates at wall splices shall be minimized by
ensuring plate centre lines coincide.
f) The corrosion considerations of Section 7.9 shall apply. The need for a corrosion
allowance to be added to the theoretically required wall thickness must be investigated.
7.13 Design of Conveyor Structures
7.13.1 Conveyor Gantries
Conveyor gantries and trusses shall be designed to meet the following criteria:
1. Gantry spans shall be arranged such that the standard span is 24.0 m and the closing
span, which shall occur at the lower end of the conveyor, may be less than 24.0 m.
Where existing conveyors are to be extended, the gantry span shall be the same as
the existing.
2. Where high-level conveyors are greater than 200 m long, a stabilizing anchor tower
shall be provided to take out longitudinal loads generated between sliding joints.
3. Sliding joints shall be provided at spacing not greater than 100 m for high-level
conveyors, and 30 m for low-level conveyors.
4. Sliding joints at conveyor gantry end frame to trestle connections shall only be
provided at the lower end of a sloping gantry, unless stated otherwise on the
drawings.
5. No belt tensions shall be carried along the length of conveyors unless specific
allowance is made in the design.
6. If the mechanical arrangement or conveyor equipment supplier drawings do not
show walkways on both sides of the conveyor, this shall be brought to the attention
of the discipline engineer.
7.13.2 Deflection Criteria
Table 7-7 provides deflection limits that shall apply to the design of conveyor trusses and
trestles.
Table 7-7 : Deflection Limits for Conveyor Structures
G + Qs + Mf Span/240
#
The height of a trestle shall be taken as the vertical distance between the underside of base
plate and the top-of-steel level of the crossbeam.
where: G = Weight of steelwork + idlers + belt + permanent dead loads
Qn = Live load on walkway/s without material spillage
* Live loads on a conveyor (Mn and Mf) shall be determined in accordance with ISO 5049.
7.13.3 Connection of Conveyor Trusses to Buildings
In the situation where a conveyor truss is connected to a building using a theoretically
pinned connection it is necessary to consider the horizontal sway of the first trestle out from
the building and take into account the resulting horizontal couple set up in the supporting
beam at the building as it attempts to resist this sway.
7.13.4 Conveyor Trestles
Conveyor trestles shall be designed for the loads originating from the gantry/truss design.
Generally conveyor trestles shall be standardized for the project and each trestle shall be
chosen from these standard trestles for rationalized heights ranges.
7.14 Cranes and Monorails
The design of crane girders, monorail beams and lifting device support structures shall be in
accordance with ASME B30.11.
Crane rail supporting steelwork (runway or girder) shall be designed to have adequate
strength to resist bending, shear, torsion and local effects. Interaction between global
bending, shear, torsion and local effects shall be included in the design considerations.
Crane rail supporting steelwork shall have supports designed to transmit reactions under the
least favorable loading condition. Crane rail supporting steel shall also be designed for
possible eccentric loads caused by inexact steelwork shapes, fabrication and construction.
The application of crane and monorail loads, load factors and the design of the steel framing
shall be in accordance with this Criteria and AISC publication, Steel Design Guide 7,
Industrial Buildings.
Cranes shall be installed and operated in accordance with ASME B30.2 or ASME B30.17.
Monorails shall be installed and operated in accordance with ASME B30.11.
Crane rails shall be supplied in accordance with BS 11 or BS EN 13674 and secured to the
crane beam by a proprietary crane rail fastening system approved by the Employer.
All lifting equipment with a rated load capacity in excess of 1 tonne must be certified by the
crane manufacturer. It is the Design Engineer’s responsibility to check that this has been
carried out in accordance with the code requirements.
7.15 Stacks and Chimneys
The design of stacks and chimneys shall be in accordance with the International Committee
on Industrial Chimneys (Comité International Des Cheminées Industrielles - CICIND) Model
Codes and Manuals.
7.16 Steel Pile Design
All steel pile design shall be in accordance with ASCE 20-96.