Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Meta-Analysis The Effect of Obesity and Stress On Menstrual Cycle Disorder
Meta-Analysis The Effect of Obesity and Stress On Menstrual Cycle Disorder
ABSTRACT
Background: There are many factors that PRISMA flow diagrams. Articles were analyzed
influence menstrual patterns to become irre- using the Review Manager 5.3 application.
gular, including stress and obesity. Menstrual Results: Meta-analysis of 8 observational
cycle irregularities can have a serious impact on studies showed that obese women were 4 times
women's health, which will affect the metabolic, more likely to have menstrual cycle disorders
fertility, sexual and reproductive systems. This than normal weight (aOR= 4.19; 95% CI= 1.99
study aims to analyze the influence of obesity to 8.84; p= 0.002). Meta-analysis of 6 observa-
and stress on menstrual cycle disorders with a tional studies showed that women with stress
meta-analysis study. had a risk of experiencing menstrual cycle dis-
Subjects and Method: This study is a syste- orders 1.28 times compared to women who did
matic study and meta-analysis, with the follow- not experience stress (aOR= 1.28; 95% CI= 1.13
ing PICO, Population = women of childbearing to 1.45; p = 0.001).
age. Intervention= obesity and stress. Compa- Conclusion: Obesity and stress affect
rison = not obese and not stressed. Outcome = menstrual cycle disorders.
disruption of the menstrual cycle. The articles
used in this study were obtained from several Keywords: obesity, stress, menstrual cycle
databases, including PubMed, ScienceDirect disorders, meta-analysis
and Google Scholar. The keywords used are
"menstrual disorder and obesity and stress", Correspondence:
"obesity and menstrual irregularity", "obesity Lutfi Annarahayu. Masters Program in Public
OR stress AND menstrual irregularity OR cross Health, Universitas Sebelas Maret. Jl. Ir. Su-
sectional study". The articles included in this tami 36A, Surakarta 57126, Central Java. E-
study are full text articles with a cross sectional mail: Lutfi.annarahayu@student.uns.ac.id. Mo-
study design. Articles were collected using bile: 081910979054.
www.thejmch.com 424
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
www.thejmch.com 425
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
www.thejmch.com 426
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
Table 2. Description of the primary study of the effect of obesity on menstrual cycle disorders included in the meta-analysis
P I C O
Author (year) Country Study Design Sample
Population Intervention Comparison Outcome
Reavey et al (2020) The UK Cross-sectional 358 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Castillo-Martínez et al. Mexico Cross-sectional 120 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
(2003) reproductive age
Zhou Xinyu et al. (2020) China Cross-sectional 1423 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Chen Xueyu et al. (2020) China Cross-sectional 5,373 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Ganesan et al. (2019) India Cross-sectional 163 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Seif et al(2015) English Cross-sectional 11,791 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Wei Shuying et al. (2009) Australia Cross-sectional 726 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Chang Pei et al. (2009) Taiwan Cross-sectional 1,095 Women of Obesity Not obese Menstrual cycle disorders
reproductive age
Table 3. Description of the primary study of the effect of stress on menstrual cycle disorders included in the meta-analysis
P I C O
Author (year) Country Study Design Sample
Population Intervention Comparison Outcome
Lin Hsin et al. (2007) Taiwan Cross-sectional 746 Women of Menstrual cycle disorders
Stressed Unstressed
reproductive age
Yamamoto.K et al. (2009) Japan Cross-sectional 264 Women of Menstrual cycle disorders
Stressed Unstressed
reproductive age
Chang Pei et al. (2009) Taiwan Cross-sectional 1095 Women of Menstrual cycle disorders
Stressed Unstressed
reproductive age
Palm Simona et al. (2014) Switzerland Cross-sectional 696 Women of Menstrual cycle disorders
Stressed Unstressed
reproductive age
Rafique N et al. (2018) Arab Cross-sectional 738 Women of Menstrual cycle disorders
Stressed Unstressed
reproductive age
Yu Mi et al(2016) Korea Cross-sectional 808 Women of Menstrual cycle disorders
Stressed Unstressed
reproductive age
The forest plot provides a summary of the effect of obesity on the risk of experiencing
data entered and gives weights for each menstrual cycle disorders. Obese women
study, effect sizes, methods and models have a risk of experiencing menstrual cycle
used to perform the meta-analysis, confi- disorders 4 times compared to normal
dence intervals used, impact estimates from weight (aOR= 4.19; 95% CI = 1.99 to 8.84;
each study, overall effect estimates, and p= 0.002). The heterogeneity of the study
statistical significance of the analysis. data shows I2 = 90% so that the distribution
Interpretation of the results of the meta- of the data is declared heterogeneous
analysis process can be seen through the (random effect model).
forest plot. Figure 2 shows that there is an
b. Funnel Plot
www.thejmch.com 429
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
A funnel plot is a plot that depicts the effect, as evidenced by there are 3 plots on
approximate size of the effect of each study the right, 4 plots on the left.
on the estimate of its accuracy which is 2. The relationship between stress
usually the standard error. and menstrual cycle disorders
Figure 3 shows that there is an Research related to the effect of stress on
asymmetrical picture in the funnel plot menstrual cycle disorders comes from the
which indicates there is a slight publication continents of Asia and Europe, consisting of
bias in the primary study with a small Taiwan, Switzerland, Arabia, Japan and
sample size, which overestimates the true Korea. An overview of each study can be
seen in Table 3.
a. ForestPlot
Figure 4. Forest plot meta-analysis effect of stress and menstrual cycle disorders
The interpretation of the results of the meta- had a risk of experiencing menstrual cycle
analysis of the relationship between obesity disorders 1.28 times compared to women who
and the incidence of PCOS in women of did not experience stress (aOR = 1.28; 95% CI
childbearing age can be seen through the = 1.13 to 1.45; p = 0.001). The heterogeneity
forest plot. Figure 4 shows that there is an of the research data shows I2 = 93% so that
effect of stress on the risk of experiencing the distribution of the data is declared
menstrual cycle disorders. Women with stress heterogeneous (random effect model).
b. Funnel Plot
www.thejmch.com 430
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
Based on Figure 5 funnel plot of the effect tion, increasing estrogen levels as a result of
of stress on menstrual cycle disorders, there peripheral conversion of androgens by the
is an asymmetrical picture in the funnel adipose tissue aromatase enzyme.
plot which indicates there is a slight publi- Ganesan et al (2019) also conducted a
cation bias in the primary study with a similar study with the results that obese
small sample size, which overestimates the women had a 3.08 times risk of experien-
effect. cing irregular menstrual patterns compared
to women with normal weight. This study
DISCUSSION found a very strong and significant relation-
This systematic review and meta-analysis ship between BMI and irregular menstrual
research is about the effect of obesity and patterns similar to various studies around
stress on menstrual cycle disorders. The the world. If the BMI is kept within the
independent variable in this study was normal range or even switched to a lower
obesity and the dependent variable analy- weight category by adapting simple but
zed was menstrual cycle disorders. proven effective measures like physical acti-
This meta-analysis study uses vity, dietary changes, etc., we can regulate
research that controls confounding factors the menstrual cycle to some extent without
because the research involved is a study needing any medication.
that uses multivariate analysis and the A high percentage of body fat can
statistical results reported are adjusted cause an increase in androgens which play a
odds ratio (aOR). The combined estimate of role in producing estrogen with the help of
the relationship between obesity and stress the aromatase enzyme which converts
on menstrual cycle disorders was processed androgens into estrogen in granulosa cells
using the RevMan 5.3 application. The and fat tissue, so that with increasing body
results of the systematic study and meta- fat, estrogen increases which can cause
analysis are presented in the form of forest hormonal imbalances and vice versa, the
plots and funnel plots. percentage of body fat Low levels cause a
1. The effect of obesity on menstrual decrease in the production of the hormone
cycle disorders estrogen so that it disrupts the balance and
There are 8 research articles from various causes menstrual cycle disorders (Septian,
countries using observational methods that 2017).
can be used as sources for this meta- 2. The effect of stress on menstrual
analysis research. The results of the forest cycle disorders
plot show that there is an effect of obesity There are 6 cross-sectional research articles
on the risk of experiencing menstrual cycle as a source of meta-analysis related to the
disorders. Obese women had a risk of expe- effect of stress on menstrual cycle dis-
riencing menstrual cycle disorders 4 times orders. The results of the forest plot of
compared to normal weight (aOR= 4.19; research articles with this cross-sectional
95% CI= 1.99 to 8.84; p= 0.002). study showed that women with stress had
This is in line with Reavey et al, 1.28 times the risk compared to women
(2020) which found that women with who were not stressed and the results were
obesity had an increased risk of menstrual statistically significant (aOR= 1.28; 95%
cycle lengthening 5.4 times compared to CI= 1.13 to 1, 45; p = 0.001).
women with normal weight. Increased BMI The results of this study are supported
will have an impact on endometrial func- by Chan Pei et al (2009) which states that
www.thejmch.com 431
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
women with stress are 1.7 times more likely factors such as smoking, alcohol consump-
to experience menstrual cycle disorders tion, exercise, dietary habits, physical
compared to women who are not stressed. factors such as body mass index (BMI), and
Psychological stress includes stressors in menstrual factors such as age at menarche
life, psychological stress or work stress and menstrual duration are associated with
resulting in longer cycles, cycle variability premenstrual symptoms, menstrual pain,
and pain during menstruation; However, and irregular menstrual cycles. Menstrual
women with excessive work pressure have cycle was defined as the period between the
also been shown to have shorter cycles. One first day of menstrual flow and the day
of the mechanisms linking stress to mens- immediately before the next menstrual
trual function occurs through impaired flow. Stress scores and BMI were shown to
function of the hypothalamic-pituitary- be significant predictors of experiencing
adrenal axis of the body's stress response so irregular menstrual cycles. Students who
that glucocorticoids have a reciprocal inter- had higher stress scores were more likely to
action with ovarian hormones that will experience irregular menstrual cycles.
affect a woman's menstrual cycle. Students with high stress scores have a risk
Lin Hsin et al. (2007) also conducted of 1.03 times experiencing irregular mens-
a similar study on nurses in 4 public hos- trual cycles compared to students with low
pitals in Taiwan. Nurses' menstrual cycle stress scores.
was considered abnormal if it was less than In women who experience stress will
24 days or longer than 35 days. Demogra- occur conditions that disrupt homeostasis.
phic variables for logistic regression analy- Reproductive status is a reflection of a
sis included: self-perceived work stress person's psychological state, if there is an
level, age, body mass index (BMI), marital increase in exposure to stress, reproductive
status, pregnancy history. However, not function will automatically decrease to
having a partner, having never been preg- maintain body homeostasis. The stress
nant and working for less than 5 years were system is regulated by the hypothalamic
statistically associated with longer and pituitary adrenal (HPA) axis and the
irregular menstrual cycles. In addition, autonomic system. The main mediators of
nurses who worked more than 40 hours per the stress system include Cortocoptopin
week were more at risk of experiencing Relaxing Hormone (CRH), glicorcorticoids,
irregular menstrual cycles (OR= 1.5, 95% and beta endorphins. CRH has various
CI= 1.1 to 2.1, p = 0.029). After adjusting tissues such as ovaries, endometrium,
for work stress, age, BMI, marital status, hypothalamus and inflammatory tissue.
pregnancy history, occupation and working Increased production of CRH and cortisol
hours, only those with high levels of job causes the restriction of GnRH secretion to
stress had a statistically significant risk of decrease ovulation. This decrease in ovula-
irregular menstrual cycles (AOR= 4.8; 95% tion will affect the length of the prolifera-
CI= 3.3 to 7.2, p<0.001). Work stress can tion and secretion period so that it affects
disrupt endocrine function and biological the menstrual cycle (Rakhmawati, 2012).
rhythms that can cause irregular menstrual
cycles, changes in abnormal menstrual AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION
bleeding patterns. Lutfi Annarahayu is the main researcher
A study by Yamamoto et al. (2009) who chooses the topic, conducts a search
involved 264 students in Japan. Lifestyle for data collection in this study. Yulia Lanti
www.thejmch.com 432
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
www.thejmch.com 433
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
www.thejmch.com 434
Annarahayu et al./ The Effect of Obesity and Stress on Menstrual Cycle Disorder
www.thejmch.com 435