Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Educator No1
The Educator No1
NO 1 , MAY 2010
THE EDUCATOR
NOBODY’S PERFECT...
MISTAKES THAT MAKE
Polish learners don’t comprehend present perfect because there
TEACHERS WANT TO
isn’t any in their native tongue. Or perhaps, there should be one... CHANGE THEIR JOB
Some mistakes made by Polish
learners will forever remain a
mystery. They happen in most
levels, with a different frequency,
o f c o u r s e . S o m e t i m e s s i l l y,
sometimes impossible for their
cause to be explained, but always
n o t s o u n d i n g to o n i ce a n d
terribly recurrent...
1. He like football
Okay, so this is the last time I’m telling you! I like
When I explain the intricacies of You use Polish past. You think football, you like football, but he, she and it _ _
present perfect to students, they about changes that took place in _ _ _ football.
seem to believe that such tense is the past. But can you actually 2. I go on Sunday shopping
unnecessary in conversation and specify the exact moment when This is a perfectly fine sentence, the problem is it
is not what the speaker often wants to say. no
rarely used by native speakers. London got so different? Not 2 does not mean: “chadzam w niedziele na
God, please kill me! Perfect is a really... And also, is this statement zakupy”, but: “chadzam na niedzielne zakupy”.
Order is a crucial thing in English grammar, and
fundamental element of real-time really about the past? After all, the closer the object to the verb, the better!
conversation! The problem is that you re actually commenting on the
3. I want buy...
all we ve got is przeszly dokonany current situation! Which is why
Of course, it is “want to buy”. But why would I
and niedokonany. But do we always sentence (1) is translated into: b o t h e r ? B e c a u s e s u c h p h r a s e s o u n d s
use Polish past tenses to talk about (2)London has changed !
dangerously close to “I won’t buy”, which means
exactly the opposite!
the past? Let s consider such an
and NOT: 4. We need ten potato
example:
(3)London changed ! One potato, two potatoes, three potatoes
After a long time you come back to four...
a city, and you notice it s completely Why? To put it simple, English has So remember, if you need 1 potato, then it is
different. Naturally, you will think: two ways of seeing past events: fine, but if you need 2 or 200, then babe, you
need some DAMN POTATOES :)
[TO BE CONTINUED ON P. 2]
(1) Londyn sie zmienil!
! PAGE 1
LEARN ENGLISH IN ENGLISH BY YOURASS EDUCATION ! NO 1 , MAY 2010
THE EDUCATOR
NOBODY’S PERFECT...
Polish does not differentiate between these two
continued "om page 1 aspects - we make it clear from the situational
context.
a. specifically located in the past, that
happened and finished in a time that no
longer has any influence on us. Also,
these events are unimportant for the
current situation (sentence 3 ). For
example: London Changed a#er the war.
There was no sanitation and drinking water
for more than a year!
b. located somewhere in the past, it
is hard to point where exactly, but the
event or its result is important for the
current picture of the situation
(sentence 2). For example: London has
changed dramatica$y, man! I cannot even
recognize my own neighborhood!
! PAGE 2