Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Use of Project-Management Information System For Planning Information-Systems Development Projects
Use of Project-Management Information System For Planning Information-Systems Development Projects
Industry conditions
Technology trends (competitiveness, new entries)
PM strategy
c
Congruence Congruence
I ,A
A
Goals
4
Congruence I Congruence
I
Measures Measures
I I
I
Critical I porfolio
PM
a b
I
1
Plans Plans
~ I
Control procedures -
I
Software
Management support requirements
system analysis
I 4
liardware Data model Hardware
requirements requirements
I
-
Database
c d
Figure 2. Linkages rhrough critical success factors between business strategy, project management and ~~for~at~o~-
MAPPING PROJECT-MANAGEMENT
INFORMATION REQUIREMENTS AND NECSY
INFORMATION-SYSTEMS PLANNING NECSY Network Control Systems is an Italian firm
with more than 400 people operating in the telecommu-
Once the CSFs have been determined, the project-team
nications field. The company designs and manufactures
members focus on the generation of project information
high-technology products that fall into three categories:
(e.g. exchange rates, inffation impact, design changes,
devices, instruments and systems. Generally, new pro-
customer requirements, contract-change orders, delivery
ject developments last approximately two years, and
times). From this project information a set of plans is
involve a design team which varies in number from three
developed to implement each goal. Then, control mech-
to 20 persons according to the project size. Currently,
anisms are established to ensure that the plans are being
there are 27 projects in progress. Because the company
implemented as intended. Information systems, which
operates in a high-technology field, it is confronted with
incorporate many of the informal indicators and prac-
an unstable and complex environment. Consequently, it
tices, are developed to support project teams during the
is necessary to provide project managers with tools that
whole project lifecycle. Subsequently, a data model maps
help them to intercept rapidly early-warning signals to
project-team needs and policy requirements into a corre-
undertake the appropriate corrective actions.
sponding data representation. Databases are needed to
store the data collected. Finally, software and hardware
requirements are defined (see, for example, Figure 2~).
ORGANIZATIONAL CHOICE
The IS must provide information at all levels of detail at
reasonable time intervals and cost. A second important The traditional organizational model involves the inter-
point is that the IS must provide constant monitoring action of two functions: the information-systems func-
and regular feedback, thus ensuring the project’s success. tion and the project-management function. On the basis
For example, one can use a software package to update of project-management needs, information-systems de-
plans, and the updates are then made available to all partments select the required hardware and software,
project-team members through an effective information and update and maintain applications. Because infor-
network. Each project-team member may be encouraged mation-systems people have ‘limited’ knowledge about
to send the project manager an electronic message informal organizational structures and methodology
raising issues that he/she sees in the plan update. With and organizational procedures to manage projects, in-
computer-based information support, management can fo~ation supplied to the project management too often
structure complex projects in an understandable way to does not correspond to managers’ needs. Generally,
EL
department (PSD). Figure 3 shows the migration from
the traditional organizational model to the new organiz-
ational model. The PSD integrates computer-science
knowledge and methodological organizational com- Organization
petency. The tasks of the PSD are
Project
management
to clarify the project management’s focus by high-
lighting similarities and differences between project
managers,
to develop project managers’ information needs,
to set project-management information-systems
priorities, by identifying
mation that must be provided,
to introduce
the various types of infor-
new methodology
project management,
and procedures
and to develop new software
for
r-l
Electronic
data
processing
~e~njtio~ of WBS: a task-oriented family tree of activi- only two of the most obvious results obtained following
ties which organizes, defines and graphically displays the the development and the introduction of the GPMI.
total work to be accomplished in order to achieve the Moreover, the WBS and the PBS (two modules of the
final objective of a project. Each descending level rep- GPMI) are stored in a relational database with other
resents an increasingly detailed definition of the project project data substituting for traditional archives,
objectives. It is a system for subdividing a project into making them directly available to project managers.
manageable work packages, components or elements to The instruments used in developing the GPMI have
provide a common framework for scope/cost/schedule been specifically chosen to favour the eventual migration
communications, allocation of responsibility, monitor- of software to other environments. Thus, the solution
ing and management’. adopted consists of the c language with the graphics
GKS library together with several Oracle modules with
The WBS is communicated in the PMTS through the Project/2 as a tool in project management.
assignment of each activity to each of several available
sorting codes. By using codes, the WBS module provides
complete management of the WBS of the project in
terms of sorting information by engineering and design SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
discipline, evaluating the status of work by area,
outlining sequences, major techniques and priorities, The PMIS development, i.e. the GPMI,
and so on.
forces organizations such as NECSY to map project
management and information systems,
allows project managers to communicate accurate
Tie PMIS to project schedule
information, and consequently enhances Ieadership,
Every activity in the PMIS should be reflected in the allows project managers to meet schedule require-
detail schedule. This is accomplished by listing the ments,
detail-level schedule activity number of each activity. By allows the support of teamwork by providing facilities
developing a common database, project managers can to interchange information,
retrieve sufficient detail to evaluate the project status and allows the insertion, modification, movement, print-
the necessary resources. ing, visualization and deletion of elements.
Using the GPMI, the managers associated with the
project will be enabled to understand further the
PMIS development
status of the work in progress and the developing
Project-management information systems allow pro- trends. With sufficient shared information, project
ject-team members to target what is most critical to the managers can jointly impact the future execution of the
project. By having the ability to conduct ‘real- project.
time’ analysis and planning at all levels, project
managers bring key issues to the surface and react to
them quickly. The PMfS provides critical information
to team members and, consequently, the ability to REFERENCES
disseminate deviations from plans. The PMIS allows
the involvement of team members throughout the pro- Gareis, R ‘Management by projects: the management
ject lifecycle. It also allows the simultaneous carrying approach for the future’ Int. J. Project Manage.
out of the traditional phases. Information is the driving Vol 7 No 4 (1989) pp 243-249
force of the project instead of equipment, energy etc. Reich, R B ‘Entrepreneurship reconsidered: the
With a PMIS, ‘complexification’ becomes possible. One team as hero’ Harvard Bus. Rev. (May/Jun 1987)
is no longer tied to a formalized network that limits Drucker, P F ‘The coming of the new organization’
flexibility. Changes can be made as the project Harvard Bus. Rev. (Jan/Feb 1988)
progresses. Hauptman, 0 and Allan, T J ‘The influence of
communication technology on organizational
structure: a conceptual model for future research’
PMIS deveIopment requires new orga~zational ~orkjng Paper Sloan School of Management,
model Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA (May
1987)
The NECSY example shows how to create the linkages
Chandler, A Strategy and Structure MIT Press, USA
between the project-management department and the
(1962)
information-systems department. Although particular
Leavitt, H ‘Applied organizational change in indus-
to that company’s environment, the GPMI development
try’ in March, J G (Ed.) Handbook of Organizations
was the result of the creation of an interfacing depart-
Rand McNally, USA (1965)
ment (the planning-systems department).
Rockart, J and Bullen, C ‘A primer on critical success
factors’ Center for Information Systems Research,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA (June
Project manager’s satisfaction
1981)
The project manager’s satisfaction and the decreased Project management Body of ~no~~iedge Project
necessity for personnel responsible for input data are Management Institute, USA (1987)
l introduction,
l interview of CEO and top managers, Giorgio Beghini graduated in elec-
l focusing workshop: (a) aggregate plus analyse individ- tronic engineering from the Univer -
ual CSFs, (b) develop agreement on organization’s sity of Padova, Italy, in 1983. In
CSFs, 1985, he joined NECSY Network
Control Systems in the Planning
l define organization’s CSFs, Systems Department. He has been
l use CSFs for PM portfolio selection. involved in methodology and soft-
ware projects for project manage-
ment using a relational-database
The principal method used in CSF analysis is that of
management system. He is currently
interviews with the CEO and top managers to identify involved in the analysis and develop-
their goals and the resulting CSFs. These personal CSFs ment of integration between configuration management and proJect
are aggregated in a workshop to develop a picture of management. He also cooperates with the University of Padoua in
the organization’s CSFs. Then, a project-management project-management methodology.
portfolio is selected.
Once the CSFs have been determined, and a project-
management portfolio has been selected, the project Marco La Manna graduated in
managers focus on the generation of a critical-infor- electronic engineering from the
mation set and thereby on the PMIS definition. The University of Padova, Italy, in 1985.
In 1986, he joined NECSY Network
transition from CSFs to a system definition is not a Control Systems in the Planning
straightforward simple process, The transition relies Systems Department. He has been
heavily on the technical expertise, on the accurate involved in methodology and sofi-
identification of user sets, on the interfacing organiz- ware projects for project manage-
ment using a relational-database
ations, and on the kind of optimality that one wants to
management system. He is cur-
reach. By using the CSF approach, the IS manager is rently working on the software-
able to understand better the project managers’ needs develooment environment and its
and the organization’s objectives, and he/she may relationship IO project and configuration management. He also
develop systems which incorporate many of the in- cooperates with the University of Padova in expert-systems
applications for project management.
formal indicators and practices. In doing this, CSFs