Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Utilization of Time Motion

Analysis in the
Development of Training
Programs for Surfing
Athletes
Michael J. Redd, MS, CSCS and David H. Fukuda, PhD
Institute of Exercise Physiology and Wellness, College of Education and Human Performance, University of Central
Florida, Orlando, Florida

ABSTRACT be defined as a member of the World performance and training programs


Surf League (WSL) [formerly known as (6,13,16). At this time, TMA can be
ADVANCES IN TECHNOLOGY,
The Association of Suring Professionals used to record, process, and interpret
SUCH AS GLOBAL POSITIONING
(ASP)]. Currently, there are over 1,200 specific activity duration in competi-
SYSTEM DEVICES AND TIME tion to a greater degree than traditional
surfers in the WSL; however, only the
MOTION ANALYSIS SOFTWARE, video-only analysis, which primarily
top-ranked 34 male and 17 female ath-
ARE CREATING A MORE ACCU- letes are included in the World Cham- involved the establishment of general
RATE MEANS FOR ANALYSIS OF pionship Tour (see World Surf League activity patterns (5). Evaluation of
AN ATHLETE’S PERFORMANCE. website at www.worldsurfleague.com). these data and their relation to the
RESEARCH STUDIES FREQUENTLY With limited opportunities to compete physiological demands placed on the
USE THIS TYPE OF TECHNOLOGY at the highest level, athletes have taken athlete during competitive surfing
TO ASSESS THE PHYSIOLOGICAL their training from the water to the can be used by coaches to help design
DEMANDS PLACED ON SURFING weight room and have begun seeking training programs, as well as maximize
ATHLETES. THIS ARTICLE APPLIES the guidance of professional strength athlete performance under similar
THESE FINDINGS TO TRAINING and conditioning coaches. When con- conditions.
PROGRAM DESIGN TO MEET THE sidering a needs assessment for surfing,
SPECIFIC NEEDS OF TODAY’S endurance of the trunk and abdominal FORMAT OF COMPETITIVE
SURFING ATHLETES. musculature, as well strength and power SURFING
requirements of the upper and lower Professional surfing contests are based
limbs, would be identified (9). Thus, on elimination heats (World Surf
INTRODUCTION training programs that address these de- League. WSL Rule Book 2015. Santa
ith surfing becoming more mands, while considering intensity and Monica, CA, 2015. Available at: http://

W popular on a global basis,


the number of athletes in
competitive surfing has also risen (see
duration specific to surfing-related tasks,
should be developed in an effort to
improve competitive performance.
www.worldsurfleague.com/asset/5882/
2015_wsl_rule_book_09172015.pdf ).
The normal contest format consists of
International Surfing Association web- 20- to 40-minute heats in which 2, 3,
Because of the recent development
site at www.isasurf.org), which has or 4 surfers are given scores by a group
and increased accessibility of com-
resulted in a concomitant increase in puter, video, and mobile technologies,
athletes attempting to pursue a profes- surf coaches and strength coaches can
KEY WORDS:
sional career. A professional surfer can time motion analysis; GPS; surfing;
now use time motion analysis (TMA)
program design; heart rate monitors;
Address correspondence to David H. Fukuda, and global positioning system (GPS)
work: rest ratio
david.fukuda@ucf.edu. devices to effectively evaluate surfing

Copyright Ó National Strength and Conditioning Association 1


Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Time Motion Analysis and Surfing

of judges. The top 2 scoring waves of the


heat determine the heat point total.
These scores are based on a 1–10-point
scale which are determined by the qual-
ity of execution of a variety of maneuvers
performed on the face of a wave accord-
ing to established judging criteria (11).
These criteria reward higher scores to
the surfer who executes maneuvers in
the most critical part of the wave with
power, style, and speed. The top 2 surfers
of each heat advance to the next round
until they reach the final round. Exam-
ples of “power” surfing and multiple surf-
ers in a competitive heat are shown in
Figure 1 and Figure 2, respectively. Figure 1. Power surfing. Photograph credit: Nathaniel Harrington.
The different competitive tours (Men’s
and Women’s Championship tours, the
Qualifying Series, the Longboard
software, and the introduction of A primary outcome of TMA is the cal-
Championships, the Junior Champion-
GPS technology, TMA has increased culation of sport-specific work-to-rest
ships, and the BIG Wave Tour) include
accuracy and flexibility while provid- ratios (1). This is a somewhat subjec-
several competitions throughout the
ing a wide array of data that must be tive procedure whereby a number
season. The number of events counted
interpreted by knowledgeable perfor- of locomotor patterns are defined as
toward the end of year totals vary
mance analysts. Specifically, TMA “rest” periods, and the others are con-
between competitive tours. Surfers
can allow for a detailed representation sidered to be “work” periods. The
receive a point total based on their final
of the activity patterns performed dur- application of these work-to-rest ratios
position in each event, and at the end
ing competitive heats in professional to individualized training programs
of each respective tour, the surfer with
surfing. Surfing competition can be may better prepare an athlete by sim-
the highest point total is considered the
subcategorized into 5 distinct phases ulating the conditions of elite compe-
final overall champion.
(paddling, pop up, wave riding, sta- tition (1,13). In a 2006 study (8), TMA
tionary, and miscellaneous) (8,13). was used to examine the activity profile
METHODS OF TIME MOTION Evaluation of TMA based on the fre- of world-class professional surfers dur-
ANALYSIS quency of these activities gives coaches ing a competition heat. During their
When designing surfing-specific train- and athletes both quantitative and investigation, Mendez-Villanueva et al.
ing programs, it is important for the qualitative feedback related to compe- (8) examined competitive heats during
strength coach to have an understand- tition or training. an international surfing contest, with
ing of the specific muscular and cardio-
vascular demands of the sport. TMA,
a notational methodology that provides
an objective means of recording ele-
ments of surfing competition that can
be quantified in a valid and consistent
manner, provides useful information on
which to base a strength and condition-
ing program (8). For example, the fre-
quency and duration of surfing activities
and the ratio between work and rest
periods obtained through TMA can
be used to develop sport-specific train-
ing protocols.
Performance analysis has traditionally
been conducted through the record-
ing, processing, and interpreting of
events in sports. However, with advan-
Figure 2. Competitive heats. Photograph credit: Michael Redd.
ces in video recording and computer

2 VOLUME 38 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2016

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
video analysis and TMA, to categorize or wetsuit top, or on the wrist similar to insight into the work performed during
the activity patterns of elite male surfers. a wristwatch, and record information, surfing and may be useful in designing
One surfer per 25-minute heat was re- such as time, position, displacement, training programs. The researchers re-
corded using a tripod-mounted video velocity, acceleration, and frequency ported that the surfers spent 60% of the
camera during each of 42 total heats of high-intensity paddle bouts or waves total event time (TET) between 54%
over the course of a 7-day competition, ridden, during a heat or training session and 76% of their age-predicted HR
and the analysis was performed by a sin- (3,8). Currently, GPS devices are being maximum (HRmax), 19% of TET
gle observer. The researchers found that worn and used by professional athletes above 46% HRmax, and approximately
surfers were paddling and stationary on the WSL men’s and women’s tours, 3% of TET above 83% HRmax. Fur-
51.4% (25–70%) and 42.5% (23–72%) whereas Australian National team thermore, the mean HR during the
of the total time, respectively. In addi- coaches and researchers are using this surf competitions equated to 64.4%
tion, wave riding accounted for 3.8% technology during surf training (8). HRmax, whereas the peak HR reached
(2–7%) of the total time, whereas mis- Farley et al. (3) conducted a perfor- 87.5% HRmax (3). The HR values from
cellaneous (other) activity accounted for mance analysis study to examine as- this study suggest that periods of
the remaining 2.2% (0.1–6%) of the total pects of competitive surfing that moderate-intensity activity, indicating
time and, on average, there was a change should be addressed in a training pro- use of the aerobic energy system,
in movement category every 28 seconds gram. The researchers examined dis- are interspersed with bouts of high-
(8). This study provides activity patterns tances traveled by the surfer while intensity exercise demanding both the
that illustrate the dynamic nature of paddling and wave riding, and deter- aerobic and anaerobic energy systems.
the sport including frequent but irregu- mined the intensities of the various As a result, both sport-specific and
lar changes in intensity and duration phases of the event. The subjects wore phase-specific intensities should be
throughout a competitive heat. There- devices that integrated heart rate (HR) considered when developing training
fore, training programs should feature measurement and GPS technology programs for surfers.
a dynamic structure with varying during heats at 2 events featuring Mendez-Villanueva and Bishop (7)
work-to-rest ratios and intensities unique environmental conditions. Ini- examined HR collected continuously at
involving both the aerobic and anaero- tial data collection was conducted dur- 5-second intervals during a simulated 20-
bic energy systems. ing the first event, wherein the beach minute competitive heat and categorized
In a research study examining the break swell ranged between 1 and HR according to time spent in 6 different
physiological aspects of surfing, Farley 1.5 m (3- to 4-ft faces), with an onshore zones, as follows: ,75% HRpeak, 75–
and colleagues (3) found most bouts wind causing the waves to be choppy. 80% HRpeak, 80–85% HRpeak, 85–
of paddling lasted 20 seconds or less Data were collected at a second event 90% HRpeak, 90–95% HRpeak, and
and, on average, lasted 16.9 seconds, conducted at a point break beach .95% HRpeak. The established HRpeak
whereas wave riding, on average, was where wave conditions were approxi- was determined using a modified kayak
14.9 seconds, resulting in approxi- mately 1.5 m (4 ft.) generating waves ergometer in a laboratory, and the
mately 45 seconds of activity com- that offered the surfer a longer period researchers reported that during the
pared with 15 seconds of recovery. to ride in a standing position (3). The 20-minute simulated competitive heat,
Surfing intensities may vary between study subcategorized activity during surfers spent approximately 25% of the
practice and competition due to envi- events into paddling (54 6 6.3%), sta- TET at .95% HRpeak. This study pro-
ronmental conditions or stressors tionary (28 6 6.9%), wave riding (8 6 vides further evidence for the importance
associated with the desire to win in 2%), paddling for a wave (4 6 1.5%), of training program design that addresses
competition. Furthermore, the varia- and miscellaneous (5 6 1%) (3). This exercise intensity based on the specific
bles contributing to specific work-to- information can be used to help design cardiovascular demands associated with
rest ratio activities, such as the 3:1 a program for the surfer focused on the competitive surfing.
work-to-rest ratio reported by Farley necessary components of strength and
et al. (3), likely deviate based on a num- endurance related to paddling
DATA-DRIVEN PROGRAMMING
ber of extrinsic factors, that is wave performance.
height, surface water conditions, and For training programs to be successful,
break type (reef or beach). EVALUATION OF SURFING they must be transferable to sport set-
INTENSITIES tings (4). Therefore, using a training
GLOBAL POSITIONING SYSTEM HR response during exercise has been program that can closely imitate the
DATA used as a way to measure exercise intensity, duration, and joint angle
GPS devices worn by athletes can pro- intensity in a variety of sports (3,4,7). trained can prove highly beneficial
vide quantitative information not pre- Farley et al. (3) also examined HR val- (5). Studies have shown that surfers
viously provided by traditional TMA ues during surfing competition and es- with greater muscular power, explo-
(12). GPS systems as small as a golf ball tablished 7 HR intensity zones. The siveness, and endurance have a greater
can be worn under a surfer’s rash guard time spent in each zone provides success rate at the international level. A

3
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Time Motion Analysis and Surfing

Table 1
Sample training program based on the reviewed time motion analysis findings

Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5


Warm-up 5-min jog at low/ 5-min cycling at low/ Rest 5-min jog at low/ 5-min cycling at low/
moderate intensity moderate intensity day moderate intensity moderate intensity
(45–55% HRmax) (45–55% HRmax) (45–55% HRmax) (45–55% HRmax)
Resistance Medicine ball circuit; Weights circuit; 3 cycles Medicine ball circuit; 3 Weights circuit; 3 cycles
training 3 cycles with light/ at ;50% 1RM (18–20 cycles with light/ at ;50% 1RM (18–20
moderate weighta: reps); 1-min rest moderate weighta: reps); 1-min rest
cycle 1 (8 reps); cycle between cycles cycle 1 (8 reps); cycle between cycles
2 (10 reps); cycle 3 2 (10 reps); cycle 3
(12 reps); 1-min rest (12 reps); 1-min rest
between cycles between cycles
Conditioning Upper-body ergometer; Burpees; 45-s work: 15-s Upper-body ergometer; Burpees; 45-s work: 15-s
45-s work: 15-s rest; rest; 3 rounds (15–20 45-s work: 15-s rest; 3 rest; 3 rounds (15–20
3 rounds high/very burpees/round) rounds high/very burpees/round)
high intensity high intensity (65–
(65–85% HRmax) 85% HRmax)
Accessory Mobility #1: 1 set of Stability #1: 1 set of Mobility #1: 1 set of 20 Stability #1: 1 set of
(Table 2) 20 reps/side 20 reps reps/side 20 reps
1RM 5 1 repetition maximum; HRmax 5 heart rate maximum.

Intensity zones for warm-up and conditioning portions are based on age-predicted max HR.
a
Light to moderate weight based on individual athlete’s ability to achieve desired number of repetitions without loss of proper technique.

2015 study (12) examined differences in relative vertical jump peak force, vertical shown between sprint paddle times
surfers selected or not selected to the jump height, relative lower-body maxi- and upper-body strength (assessed using
Australian national team based on a val- mum isometric strength, and various pronated grip pull-up 1 repetition
idated performance-testing protocol. measures related to sprint paddling maximum).
The surfers selected to the national (15). In a study conducted by Sheppard Examination of findings from existing
team demonstrated significantly greater et al. (14), strong correlations were studies on surfing reveal a number of

Table 2
Sample exercise circuits
Medicine ball Weights Mobility Stability

Ball slams Power cleans Shoulder front raise with Balance board squatsa (Figure 5A)
resistance band (Figure 3A)
Clean and press Bench press Shoulder side raise with Balance board lungesa (Figure 5B)
resistance band (Figure 3B)
Rotational throws left Lat pull-down or supine Hip adductor with resistance Balance board alpine toe
pull-ups band (Figure 3C) touchesa (Figure 5C)
Rotational throws right Shoulder press Hip abductor with resistance Balance board plank (feet on
band (Figure 3D) board)a (Figure 5D)
Kneeling overhead throws Triceps cable push-down Ankle series with resistance band Balance board plank (arms on
(Figure 4A–D) board)a (Figure 5D)
a
Balance board exercises can be performed using different styles of boards. The examples here show use of a roller and an inflatable balance disc
under the board.

4 VOLUME 38 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2016

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
physiological requirements of the sport. the pop-up phase of surfing, where the of scoring opportunities (2). The act
Surfboard paddling places demands on surfer uses his/her hands on the rail of of wave riding places emphasis on
upper-body muscular strength, power, the board to transition from a prone lower-body muscular strength, dynamic
and endurance, while requiring both position to a standing position as balance, leg strength, and rotational
aerobic and anaerobic power (8). For quickly as possible to begin riding the power. Strength and endurance in the
example, Mendez and colleagues (7) wave. A surfer must complete this abdominal muscles, as well as the low
found that 50% of a 1-hour recreational movement numerous times in a heat back, are necessary for the surfer to exe-
surfing session was spent paddling. The while maintaining force and quickness cute different maneuvers while riding
upper-body demands are also evident in capabilities to increase the number the wave (7). Balance ability has been

Figure 3. Mobility series: shoulder and hip exercises. (A) Shoulder front raise with resistance band. (B) Shoulder side raise with
resistance band. (C) Hip adductor with resistance band. (D) Hip adductor with resistance band.

5
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Time Motion Analysis and Surfing

shown to be significantly different in (4). TMA methods, including the use recommended exercise intensities have
athletes of different competitive levels, of HR monitors and GPS devices, pro- been selected with consideration for
with elite athletes having superior bal- vide strength and conditioning coaches the previously reported surfing-
ance when compared with their less with detailed data to establish the specific percentages of predicted or
proficient counterparts (10). The effec- physiological portion of this analysis derived maximal HR and the time
tiveness of a surf training program can and allows for proper program devel- spent in different intensity zones
be evaluated on its ability to address opment. Based on the findings of stud- (3,7). Similar to the work-to-rest ratios,
these different physiological aspects in ies examining the activity patterns
exercise intensities can and should be
the same workout or a series of work- during surfing (3,8), and previously re-
altered by the strength coaching pro-
outs. Thus, strength and conditioning ported frequency and duration data
fessional to be suited to the athlete and
coaches should prescribe training (7,8,16), a sample training program that
could be used by an in-season profes- the expected environmental conditions
programs aimed at developing these based on the location of the upcom-
sional surfer is presented in Table 1 and
areas, while integrating exercises and ing event.
Table 2. A 3:1 work-to-rest ratio was
intensities that address the demands of
used as a base for the conditioning por- This proposed workout focuses on
the sport.
tion of the training program, while the a single microcycle in the athlete’s peri-
A strength and conditioning profes- specific exercise durations are sug- odization scheme and would ideally be
sional designing a program for a surfer, gested to minimize potential disparities used during the noncontest weeks of
should first conduct a needs analysis, between training and competitive ses- a competitive season. The framework
which is composed of physiological, bio- sions and to encourage physiological of this program may be used as a tem-
mechanical, and medical components adaptations. In addition, the currently plate to allow the athlete to train with

Figure 4. Mobility series: ankle exercises. (A) Point toe downward and roll ankle (inversion) slightly against resistance. (B) With foot
flat and in neutral stance, laterally rotate ankle against resistance. (C) While seated, pull toes (dorsiflex) against resistance.

6 VOLUME 38 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2016

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
a greater chance of crossover to the that may occur. However, a critical part body strength during the offseason. Fur-
physiological demands of surfing. The of the year-round training program is thermore, the components of each
training exercises selected in Table 2 the incorporation of appropriate micro- circuit can be modified, based on the
address structural movements and cycles for in-season and out-of-season individual needs of the surfer regarding
muscles that are used predominantly training. This training template can be areas for improvement, injury preven-
in surfing (7,8,14) (Figures 3–5). This altered based on the athlete and the tion, or recovery from injury. For
suggested program would likely be used specific point in the training/competi- instance, the stability circuit, which
during the competitive season to atten- tion cycle. For example, additional focuses primarily on proprioception,
uate any losses of strength or endurance emphasis might be placed on lower- could be enhanced to include an

Figure 5. Stability series. (A) Balance board squats on roller. (B) Balance board lunges on disk. (C) Alpine toe touches on roller. (D)
Balance board plank, feet on board and forearms on board.

7
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Time Motion Analysis and Surfing

emphasis on visual and vestibular train- performance to indicate injury risk among
Michael J. surfing athletes. Int J Sports Phys Perf 10:
ing by having the athlete perform move-
Redd is a Doc- 1029–1035, 2015.
ments with their eyes closed or while
toral Student in 7. Mendez-Villanueva A and Bishop D.
maintaining their gaze on a moving
the College of Physiological aspects of surfboard riding
object.
Education and performance. Sports Med 35: 55–70,
Additional surfing research, incorporat- Human Perfor- 2005.
ing both TMA and laboratory-based mance at the 8. Mendez-Villanueva A, Bishop D, and
investigation, must be performed to University of Hamer P. Activity profile of world-class
address other sport-specific factors Central Florida. professional surfers during competition: A
related to training program design. case study. J Strength Cond Res 20: 477–
These investigations could address the 482, 2006.
specific assessment of aerobic and David H. 9. Mendez-Villanueva A, Perez-Landaluce J,
anaerobic characteristics of surfers, Fukuda is an Bishop D, Fernandez-Garcia B, Ortolano R,
physiological stressors related to the Assistant Profes- Leibar X, and Terrados N. Upper body
aerobic fitness comparison between two
sport, and further examination of sor with the Col-
groups of competitive surfboard riders.
surfing-specific tasks. The data derived lege of Education
J Sci Med Sport 8: 43–51, 2005.
from such studies would add to the and Human Per-
10. Paillard T, Margnes E, Portet M, and
surfing literature and be beneficial to formance at the
Breucq A. Postural ability reflects the
strength and conditioning professionals University of athletic skill level of surfers. Eur J Appl
tasked with designing training pro- Central Florida. Physiol 111: 1619–1623, 2011.
grams for surfing athletes.
11. Peirão R and Santos SG. Judging criteria in
international professional surfing
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
championships. J Kin Hum Perf 14: 439–
The goal of training programs, for elite 449, 2012.
REFERENCES
competitive athletes, focuses on main-
1. Andreato LV, Julio UF, Panissa VLG, 12. Rampinini E, Alberti G, Fiorenza M,
taining sport performance levels, mini- Esteves JVDC, Hardt F, de Moraes SMF, Riggio M, Sassi R, Borges T, and Coutts A.
mizing the risk for overtraining, and de Souza CO, and Franchini E. Brazilian jiu- Accuracy of GPS devices for measuring
reducing the potential for injury. One jitsu simulated competition, part II: Physical high-intensity running in field-based team
of the greatest challenges for any performance, time-motion, technical- sports. Int J Sports Med 36: 49–53, 2015.
strength coach is how to implement tactical analyses and perceptual
13. Secomb JL, Sheppard JM, and
responses. J Strength Cond Res 29:
an effective year-round training pro- Dascombe BJ. Time–motion analysis of
2015–2025, 2014.
gram for their athletes. Adopting an a 2-hour surfing training session. Int J
in-season program, that closely relates 2. Eurich AD, Brown LE, Coburn JW, Sports Phys Perf 10: 17–22, 2015.
Noffal GJ, Nguyen D, Khamoui AV, and
to the specific physiological demands of 14. Sheppard JM, McNamara P, Osborne M,
Uribe BP. Performance differences
the sport, helps the athlete maintain the between sexes in the pop-up phase of
Andrews M, Borges TO, Walshe P, and
strength and power necessary for con- Chapman DW. Association between
surfing. J Strength Cond Res 24: 2821–
anthropometry and upper-body strength
sistent performance. Examining the 2825, 2010.
qualities with sprint paddling
findings of TMA, including HR and 3. Farley OR, Harris NK, and Kilding AE. performance in competitive wave surfers.
GPS data, coaches and trainers can Physiological demands of competitive J Strength Cond Res 26: 3345–3348,
design programs that can be adjusted surfing. J Strength Cond Res 26: 1887– 2012.
to the surfer and their current level of 1896, 2012.
15. Tran TT, Lundgren L, Secomb JL,
fitness. As use of this approach contin- 4. Hoffman J. Physiological Aspects of Sport Farley OR, Haff GG, Seitz LB, Newton RU,
ues to develop, specific training pro- Training and Performance. Champaign, IL: Nimphius S, and Sheppard JM.
grams might be considered based on Human Kinetics, 2014. Comparison of physical capacities
the competition location and/or surf 5. Lees A. Technique analysis in sports: A between nonselected and selected elite
conditions, including wave size and critical review. J Sports Sci 20: 813–828, male competitive surfers for the national
2002. junior team. Int J Sports Physiol Perform
type (i.e., point break, beach break, reef
10: 178–182, 2015.
pass etc.). 6. Lundgren LE, Tran TT, Nimphius S,
Raymond E, Secomb JL, Farley OR, 16. Watsford M, Murphy A, and Coutts A.
Conflicts of Interest and Source of Funding: Newton RU, Steele JR, and Sheppard JM. Energy expenditure and time–motion
The authors report no conflicts of interest Development and evaluation of a simple, analysis during recreational surfing. J Sci
and no source of funding. multi-factorial model based on landing Med Sport 9: 9, 2006.

8 VOLUME 38 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2016

Copyright ª National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

You might also like