Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Performance of Coreless Winding Axial FL
Performance of Coreless Winding Axial FL
Abstract— An axial-flux permanent-magnet machine (AFPM) can be easily overcome by using electronic circuits for power
topology with coreless winding is proposed for generator units conditioning.
required aboard ships, aircraft, or hybrid electric vehicles. Within the broad category of PM machines, several distinct
In the proposed AFPM configuration, the winding consists of
rhomboidal-shaped coils encapsulated in fiber-reinforced epoxy magnetic circuit configurations can be identified. These include
resin. The coils have a double-layer arrangement to leave space the axial-flux permanent-magnet machine (AFPM) topology,
for a cooling water duct being used to remove heat directly which has been under investigation in the past [1]–[8] and, in
from the interior surface of the winding. The overall machine the last few years, has received renewed interest concerning
structure has high compactness and lightness and, due to the various machine applications, such as wheel motor drives [9]
lack of the iron core, generator operation with power output at
400 Hz can be accomplished with high efficiency and acceptable and portable generator sets [10].
voltage regulation. This paper discusses the basic design and Among the AFPM topologies which have been investigated
construction of AFPM generators with coreless winding and more recently, a machine configuration with coreless winding
experimental results taken from a 16-pole machine prototype sandwiched between two PM rotor discs was proposed [11],
rated 230 N1m, 3000 r/min are finally reported. [12] for use in a prototype of wheel direct drive [13]. Such
Index Terms— Aerospace power generation, on-board electric an AFPM arrangement has similarity with the PM ac disc
generators, permanent-magnet machines. motor presented in [6] and basically is a brushless machine
version of the well-known disc-armature or printed-circuit dc
I. INTRODUCTION motor which, in the past, has been widely used in servomotor
applications requiring fast-response dynamics [1]–[5]. How-
(a) (b)
Fig. 2. Coil shapes for AFPM’s with coreless winding. (a) Trapezoidal coil.
(b) Rhomboidal coil.
use of rhomboidal coils allows a two-tier arrangement of the loss of winding coils. For a fixed value of , the coil
end windings with consequent reduction of the winding axial resistance can be expressed as a function of and then given
thickness and simplification of manufacturing. in per unit with respect to the resistance of a trapezoidal coil
The geometry of rhomboidal coils is characterized by the which has the same value of . Such design calculations
inclination angle and the ratio between the inner radius show that the loss of rhomboidal coils decreases as
and outer radius . For given values of the outside increases and, thereby, benefits would arise from values of as
diameter and of the magnetic and electric loadings, machine high as possible. On the other hand, the higher values of lead
characteristics such as torque, torque-to-weight ratio, and to an undesirable decrease of and, thereby, of the machine
efficiency are greatly affected by the coil geometry. Hence, torque. A compromise value of is needed, and it is found
the machine design optimization process primarily consists that the best design approach is based on the minimization of
of selection of suitable values for both and . With the the ratio between loss and torque [13].
values of and related to an optimized design, it is
found that the use of rhomboidal coils results in 25%–30% E. Eddy-Current Power Loss
reduction of winding resistance and 10%–12% reduction of
The winding is located in the airgap and, hence, is situated
EMF, compared to trapezoidal coils.
in the main field. Motion of the magnets past the winding
causes the field through each conductor to vary periodically
B. EMF Waveform
and to induce eddy currents. The loss due to eddy currents in
The EMF is nearly sinusoidal, whereas iron-cored AFPM’s the conductors depends on both the geometry of the wire cross
tend to produce a trapezoidal EMF. The sinusoidal waveform section and the waveform of the flux density variation.
is the result of using short-pitch distributed coils as in a Round wires are less prone to eddy currents, but they
conventional three-phase ac winding and of the rhomboidal have a worse fill factor compared to rectangular conductors.
coil shape which further suppresses harmonics in the same Hence, in cases where the phase current is large, the use of
way as skewed or herringbone coils. Both the flux density rectangular-section conductors is unavoidable and, thereby,
distribution at the machine airgaps and the coil geometry a conductor arrangement consisting of either Litz wires or
influence the peak value of the induced EMF and, thereby, thin wide rectangular-shaped conductors is to be adopted to
the machine torque. lower the high eddy-current loss that otherwise would occur.
Litz wires allow a great reduction of the eddy-current loss,
C. Machine Torque but they are much more expensive and have much lower
The electromagnetic torque developed at the machine air- fill factor compared to solid wire conductors. On the other
gaps can be expressed as hand, provided that the field through conductors has negligible
component of flux density in the direction orthogonal to the
(1) conductor width, the use of copper-strip conductors with a
where is the electric loading at the radius is the thickness of 1 mm, or even below that, allow a low-cost
peak flux density of an ideal square-wave distribution at the conductor arrangement where the total winding loss, i.e.,
machine airgaps, is a machine constant which depends on and eddy current, is reduced to an acceptable value.
both the actual airgap flux-density distribution and the coil Sinusoidal variation of uniform field through rectangular-
geometry being utilized. For any particular machine design, section conductors gives rise to eddy-current loss per unit
the constant can be viewed as the per-unit torque referred volume
to the torque of the same machine, but having square-wave
(2)
flux-density distribution and concentrated full-pitch coils.
Due to flux leakage and fringing, the flux density at the where is the peak flux density of a sinusoidal distribution,
airgaps is not a square wave in distribution and, therefore, is the electrical angular frequency, is the conductor
whatever coil geometry is being used, it is found that . thickness, and is the conductor resistivity at the winding
On the other hand, compared to the conventional trapezoidal working temperature. In AFPM’s, however, the flux density
coils, rhomboidal coils result in a further reduction of , distribution at the airgap is much closer to a trapezoidal
as the peak of the EMF induced in the machine winding waveform with significant harmonic content of third and fifth,
is substantially affected by the inclination of the coil active although fringing of flux at the edges of the poles contributes
conductors. For the purpose of machine design, first-tentative to lower the amplitude of the higher harmonics. Further to
values of as a function of the inclination angle can that, in a machine with coreless winding arrangement, the
be determined by assuming a square-wave distribution of the field through each conductor has tangential component of
airgap flux density. It is found that a maximum value of flux density, which can lead to serious additional eddy-current
actually does exist, and this is achieved with a particular value loss. Taken together, these features lead to eddy-current power
of which depends on the selected value of [12]. loss greater than the one resulting from (2) and, thereby, for
the purpose of design and performance calculations, the loss
D. Power Loss found from (2) is to be multiplied by an empirical factor
In a rhomboidal coil, the length of the conductors depends obtained through a finite-element study of the distribution of
on and and, therefore, these parameters affect the flux density at the airgap.
1266 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 34, NO. 6, NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 1998
TABLE I
LEADING CHARACTERISTICS OF THE PROTOTYPE MACHINE
F. Design Criteria
From design optimization studies, it is found that mainly
influences torque and torque-to-weight ratio, whereas it has machine, a 4-mm-thick toroidal duct is left between the active
a small impact on the machine efficiency. For given outside sides of the coils. This toroidal duct is used for providing cool-
diameter and loadings, the torque is maximized if is set ing of the machine winding through pump-assisted circulating
equal to , but, in most designs, the maximum torque- water. Due to the prototype nature of the above-described
to-weight ratio is achieved at a slightly higher value of . AFPM generator, thermocouples for monitoring temperature
Therefore, for , a compromise value is required to be were placed at several points within the winding.
generally found in the range from 0.6 to 0.7. Table I summarizes the leading characteristics of the above-
On the other hand, the angle greatly affects the machine described prototype machine, which actually was designed
efficiency because of the influence on both the torque and the having in mind motoring operation in a wheel direct drive with
loss, as previously discussed. Hence, for a given value base speed at 750 r/min. For this application, all the winding
of , the machine efficiency is maximized if is chosen coils were connected in series among them, but to the aim
to result in loss as low as possible without producing of testing the machine at 3000 r/min, it was found suitable
significant reduction of the torque. For most machine designs, to modify the connection of the winding coils to keep the
an optimum value of is generally found in the range from open terminal voltage at its original value. Hence, generator
60 to 70 . operation with power output at 400 Hz was tested with the
machine winding being formed of four paralleled paths.
IV. MACHINE PROTOTYPE
Fig. 3 shows an external view of a prototype of an AFPM V. 400-Hz GENERATOR PERFORMANCE
with coreless winding which was initially constructed with
Testing of the prototype machine operation with power
the aim of testing the novel winding arrangement with water-
output at 400 Hz required the arrangement of a test rig, as
cooled rhomboidal coils [13]. This machine has axially po-
schematically depicted in Fig. 4. Hence, laboratory tests were
larized rectangular slabs of Nd–Fe–B material being mounted
devoted to evaluate generator performance concerning no-load
on the surface of soft-iron disc rotors. The remanence of the
operation with variable speed up to 3000 r/min and machine
PM grade used is approximately 1.3 T and the coercivity
load conditions at 3000 r/min under either three-phase resistive
is approximately 1000 kA/m. The winding consists of 48
load or diode rectifier with adjustable dc load.
rhomboidal coils wound from rectangular copper strip. To
achieve the machine stator as it stands in its final form, the
winding coils are placed side by side in a toroidal fashion A. No-Load Tests
and then encapsulated with fiberglass-reinforced epoxy resin to Tests were initially carried out driving the machine at
form a rigid body. Owing to the particular method being used open terminals to display the machine EMF waveform and
for encapsulating the winding with epoxy, in the prototype determine the no-load power loss from the measurement of the
CARICCHI et al.: CORELESS-WINDING AXIAL-FLUX PERMANENT-MAGNET GENERATOR 1267
Fig. 6. No-load power loss of the test generator running at various speeds.
(a)
Fig. 7. Output voltage regulation of the test generator running at 3000 r/min
and with various loads.
REFERENCES Fabio Crescimbini (M’90), for a photograph and biography, see p. 116 of
the January/February 1998 issue of this TRANSACTIONS.
[1] P. Campbell, “Principles of a permanent magnet axial-field D.C. ma-
chine,” Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng., vol. 121, no. 12, pp. 1489–1494, Dec.
1974.
[2] P. Campbell, D. J. Rosenberg, and D. P. Stanton, “The computer design
and optimization of axial-field permanent magnet motors,” IEEE Trans.
Power App. Syst., vol. PAS-100, pp. 1490–1497, Apr. 1981. Onorato Honorati (M’73), for a photograph and biography, see p. 116 of the
[3] G. R. Slemon and A. Straughen, Electric Machines. Reading, MA: January/February 1998 issue of this TRANSACTIONS.
Addison-Wesley, 1980, pp. 335–336.
[4] A. E. Fitzgerald, C. Kingsley, and S. Umans, Electric Machinery. New
York: McGraw-Hill, 1990, pp. 523–524.
[5] G. Henneberger, H. Harer, S. Schustek, and L. Verstege, “A new range of
DC and AC pancake motors,” in Proc. Int. Conf. Electrical Machines,
1986, pp. 916–919.
[6] G. B. Kliman, “Permanent magnet AC disc motor electric vehicle drive,” Giulia Lo Bianco received the Degree in electrical
presented at SAE Int. Congr. Exposition, Detroit, MI, Feb. 28–Mar. 4, engineering and the Ph.D. degree from the Univer-
1983. sity of Rome “La Sapienza,” Rome, Italy, in 1992
[7] W. S. Leung, and J. C. C. Chan, “A new design approach for axial-field and 1998, respectively.
electrical machines,” IEEE Trans. Power App. Syst., vol. PAS-99, pp. She is currently with ENEA C.R.E. Casaccia,
1679–1685, July/Aug. 1980. Rome, Italy. Her research interests are renewable-
[8] C. C. Chan, “Axial-field electrical machines—Design and applications,” energy generating systems and generator application
IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. EC-2, pp. 294–300, June 1987. of permanent-magnet machines.
[9] F. Caricchi, F. Crescimbini, E. Fedeli, and G. Noia, “Design and
construction of a wheel-directly-coupled axial-flux PM motor prototype
for EV’s,” in Conf. Rec. IEEE-IAS Annu. Meeting, 1994, vol. I, pp.
254–261.
[10] E. Spooner and B. J. Chalmers, “TORUS—A slotless toroidal-stator,
permanent magnet generator,” Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng., vol. 139, pt. B,
pp. 497–506, Nov. 1992.
[11] F. Caricchi, F. Crescimbini, and E. Santini, “Optimum design of ironless
stator winding for axial-flux PM machines,” in Proc. IEE 6th Int. Conf. Ezio Santini (M’91) was born in Rome, Italy, in
Electrical Machines and Drives, Oxford, U.K., Sept. 8–10, 1993, pp. 1956. He received the Degree in electrical engineer-
652–658. ing (cum laude) from the University of Rome “La
[12] F. Caricchi and F. Crescimbini, “Axial-Flux permanent-magnet machine Sapienza,” Rome, Italy, in 1982.
with water-cooled Ironless stator,” in Proc. IEEE Power Technology From 1983 to 1990, he was an Assistant Professor
Conf., Stockholm, Sweden, June 18–22, 1995, pp. 98–103. in the Department of Electrical Engineering, Uni-
[13] F. Caricchi, F. Crescimbini, F. Mezzetti, and E. Santini, “Multi-stage versity of Rome “La Sapienza,” and, since 1991,
axial-flux PM machine for wheel direct drive,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appli- he has been an Associate Professor of Design of
cat., vol. 32, pp. 882–888, July/Aug. 1996. Electromagnetic Devices. His research activities are
in the fields of electrical machines models, transient
phenomena in transformers and rotating machines,
FEM analysis of electromagnetic fields in electrical devices, and numerical
methods in electrical engineering.
Federico Caricchi (M’90), for a photograph and biography, see p. 116 of the Prof. Santini is a member of the Italian Association of Electric and
January/February 1998 issue of this TRANSACTIONS. Electronics Engineers and the IEEE Power Engineering Society.