Group 6 Project Report

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Feasibility Study of Solar Charging Station for

Electric Vehicle in Bangladesh: Policies and


Prospects
Md. Golam Zakaria Md. Khairul Alam Md. Sakiluzzaman
Department of Electrical and Electronic Department of Electrical and Electronic Department of Electrical and Electronic
Engineering Engineering Engineering)
Bangladesh University of Engineering Bangladesh University of Engineering Bangladesh University of Engineering
and Technology and Technology and Technology
Dhaka, Bangladesh Dhaka, Bangladesh Dhaka, Bangladesh
mdgolamzakaria3@gmail.com khair@gmail.com sakil.zaman786@gmail.com

Abstract— The main focus of this paper is to present the current circumstance, charging those EVs does not generate any
prospects, policies and future concerns of Solar EVCS in profit for the electricity industry. Moreover, the non-linear
Bangladesh. EVs are supposed to be the frontrunner in the characteristics of EV charger affect the power quality by
transportation sector of the future. They are holding the key for producing harmonics, voltage fluctuation and causing power
green transportation and is currently a worldwide phenomenon.
Given their cost effectiveness, reliability, no greenhouse gas
loss [1]. In this way, these EVs are putting a lot of strain on
emission (GHS), they make excellent choice for the much- Bangladesh's national grid. A cost-effective alternative
cherished net zero future. Although the present EV space in strategy to generate power is necessary to relieve the strain
Bangladesh is at a very nascent stage, given the initiatives taken on the national system [3].
by GOB and various other organization the EV future is
seeming very flourished. GOB has decided to achieve a 10% of According to the NDC report, under the Business As Usual
all licensed vehicles to be powered by electricity by 2030. To (BAU) scenario greenhouse gas (GHG) emission in
achieve this goal EVs are being manufactured in the country Bangladesh from the power, transport and industrial sectors
and they are about to make their entry very soon. However, shall account for “69% of the total emissions by 2030
Bangladesh lacks the necessary infrastructure such as charging
stations and necessary policy framework to make the future of
(excluding Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry),”
EV sustainable. Both BRTA and SREDA are working on resulting in 234 MtCO2e (an increase of 264% with respect
drafting a regulatory policy framework for a sustainable EV to the level in 2011) [3].
future. Although EVs are considered as green; they are only as
green as the source of electricity that powers them. EVs are
about 96% more effective in emitting pollutants when they are
charged in a solar charge station. Although it is not possible to
charge all the electric vehicles using solar powered charging
stations, priority must be given on building a future for solar
charging stations; otherwise, the true purpose of the transition
to EV transportation is going to fail. This paper aims to examine
the present EV scenario and EVCS infrastructure and available
policy frameworks and attempts to give some general
recommendations to be added to the ‘Renewable Energy Policy’
and upcoming ‘EV Charging Station Guideline’ currently being
drafted by SREDA.
Figure 1: Projection of GHG Emission (MtCO2e) for Three Sectors
Keywords—Electric Vehicle, EVCS, Solar Charging Station,
from 2011 to 2030.
Renewable Energy Policy, GHG.

I. INTRODUCTION The emission reduction contribution intended by the GOB is


stated assuming international support and without
The sudden proliferation of Electric Vehicles (EV) like Easy international support. Assuming no additional international
Bike, Auto-Rickshaw, and Electric-Bike plays a vital role in support Bangladesh will reduce its GHG emissions in the
producing energy crisis in the worldwide. As a developing power, transport, and industry sectors by 12 MtCO2e by 2030
country, Bangladesh is also facing difficulties due to excess or 5% below BAU emissions for those sectors. Assuming
energy consumption. Although, Electric Vehicles are additional international support Bangladesh will reduce its
opening a new dimension in the transportation sector with GHG emissions in the power, transport, and industry sectors
several benefits such as- cheapest mode of transportation & by 36 MtCO2e by 2030 or 15% below BAU emissions for
lower greenhouse gas (GHG) emission, however the those sectors [3].
generation of huge energy required for charging the batteries
in every day is not very easy. In addition, lack of charging The policy document mandates that 10% of the total power
station in Bangladesh hampers the time and takes higher cost demand by 2020 should be sourced from various RE sources.
from EV owner. Owing to this reason, almost all the EV In absolute terms, this means that at least 2000 MW must be
owner takes power from the residential connection illegally generated from RE sources by 2020. Very recently, the Power
and pays the bill as the residential consumer. In such

XXX-X-XXXX-XXXX-X/XX/$XX.00 ©20XX IEEE


Division has also launched the Net Metering Guidelines-2018  Develop financing mechanisms and facilities by
[7], and RE based options have been included in the using grant, subsidy and/or carbon/CDM fund for
‘Bangladesh National Building Code’ for some time now. All public and private sector investments in all forms of
these efforts manifest the Government’s sincere commitment sustainable energy. Provide fund for the
towards propagating RE usage and building a sustainable development of standardized renewable energy
future for Bangladesh. configurations to meet common energy and power
applications.
Government incentives and regulations have been playing a
key role in spreading the awareness about RE technologies  Stimulate market development for sustainable
and thus fostering the demand for solar PV power. But still energy technologies, Provide financial support in
challenges remain in terms of unstable regulatory framework, the research and development of renewable energy
financial viability, and bankability, etc. Growing share of technology. Implement policies for mitigation of
solar PV power must be effectively integrated in a fair and environmental issues arising out of use of
sustainable fashion into electricity systems under varying Renewable Energy.
technical and market conditions. The widespread deployment
of new RE technologies has heralded the necessity to Other regulations of interest mandated by ‘Renewable
introduce new policies catering to the promotion and Energy Policy 2008’ are summarized below:
implementation of innovative, environment friendly and
resilient mechanisms  To prompt renewable energy in power sector, all
renewable energy equipment’s and related raw
materials in producing renewable energy
II. EXISTING POLICY FRAMEWORK AND PRESENT equipment’s will be exempted from charging 15%
SCENARIO OF EVCS VAT.
A. Existing Renewable Energy Policy
The ‘Renewable Energy Policy 2008’ has been developed  An incentive tariff may be considered for electricity
with the goal to spread the utilization of RE technologies generated from renewable energy sources which
across the country by strengthening a favorable technical, may be 10% higher than the highest purchase price
financial and legal environment [5]. One of the prime of electricity by the utility from private generators.
objectives of this Renewable Energy Policy was that an
institution, Sustainable Energy Development Agency Published in 2008, “Policy Guideline for Enhancement of
(SEDA), shall be established under the Companies Act, 1994, Private Participation in the Power Sector” that considers the
as a focal point for sustainable energy development and depleting domestic reserve of natural gas and the global trend
promotion, ‘sustainable energy’ comprising renewable of increasing RE utilization. The main objective of the policy
energy and energy efficiency. is to introduce and regulate competition by allowing private
investment in the power sector, and to establish new
The ‘Renewable Energy Policy’ of 2008 has laid the commercial power plants and rehabilitate old ones through
foundation of Sustainable and Renewable Energy Public Private Partnership (PPP). The main features of this
Development Authority (SREDA) with a broader aim to policy guidelines can be summed up into the following points
increase and promote the utilization of RE in the local domain [9]:
[6]. According to ‘Renewable Energy Policy 2008’, The  Private investors are allowed to build commercial
responsibilities of SEDA as a company is summarized below: power plants that comply with the existing
environmental laws & regulations, technical
 Provide coordination of sustainable energy standards of grid interconnection and operation.
planning, including action plans linking together the Considering the depleting natural gas reserve, they
activities of several agencies or organizations. are allowed to use any fuel including renewable ones
Promote awareness of renewable energy and other and are free to find their own buyers to sell
clean energy technologies and integrate their electricity at a mutually negotiated tariff.
development within overall national energy policy
and development.  Non-competition from public utilities is ensured in
case there is a contract with large consumers.
 Support demonstration of new technologies and new However, depending on the location, they must sell
business models for renewable energy and other 20% electricity to public utilities at a bulk tariff rate
clean energy technologies. as determined by BERC.

 Support establishment of small and medium  The private investors are to enjoy certain fiscal
renewable energy enterprises and providers. Create incentives, such as corporate income tax waiver for
market opportunities and start-up business models 15 years, relaxed customs duties on a certain amount
for sustainable energy technologies in Bangladesh, of import for 12 years, possibility of land lease
such as energy services companies and rural energy support from the GOB etc. and many more.
providers.
 Public Private Partnership (PPP) is allowed for joint
venture power plants under certain terms and
conditions.

In October 2013, SREDA has developed the ‘Guidelines for


the Implementation of Solar Power Development Program’
to act on the ‘Renewable Energy Policy 2008’ and went ahead
with two types of projects, namely, the Commercial and
Social Solar Power Projects. Solar powered charging station
was the least considered commercial project [9].

In July 2018, the Power Division of MPEMR has launched


the Net Metering Guidelines-2018 that aims to allows
consumers to become ‘prosumers’ by connecting their RE Figure 3: Trend of Hybrid Four-Wheelers in Recent Years.
systems to the distribution grid via a bi-directional smart
meter [7]. The capacity and energy export limit of NEM
system is as follows [according to revised Net Metering Hybrid cars varies on the technology they are operating.
Guideline, 2019]: Mainly there two varieties namely full hybrid and plug in
hybrid. Both variants are available in Bangladesh market.
 Any three-phase consumer can be considered
eligible for the net metering system. The EV space in Bangladesh is at a very nascent stage. The
 A consumer can install (capacity of solar PV government is currently formulating policies to promote
system) up to 70% of his sanctioned load. wide-scale EV deployment. Bangladesh Road Transport
Authority (BRTA) is working on a draft policy to expedite
 The maximum output AC capacity of the installed
the import, domestic manufacturing, and registration of EVs.
RE system for NEM can be up to 10 MW.
Automobile Industry Development Policy 2021 is in place
 For a medium voltage (MV) consumer, the installed
that talks about 10-year tax holiday, financial incentives,
capacity of the RE system can be a maximum of
interest waiver on loans for local manufacturing and
70% of the rated capacity of the distribution
assembly of EVs. Several large corporates have announced
transformers.
their plan to establish local EV manufacturing plants [12].
B. EV Future of Bangladesh
In Bangladesh the most prevalent e-mobility solution are the Bangladesh Auto Industries Limited (BAIL) is setting up the
electric two/three wheelers. Although the actual stock take of country's first ever electric car plant in Mirsarai Economic
these "Easy Bikes" are yet to be determined, it is estimated Zone. They plan to manufacture all sorts of vehicles starting
that 1.24 million of these vehicles are on the road which are from two/three wheelers, sedan, hatchback and subsequently
facilitating transportation of approximately 250 million SUVs and pickup trucks: with an initial investment of $200
people [8]. million. The plant will manufacture almost 60% of the
components of the vehicles, including lithium battery, motor,
controller, software platform, chassis, and body.

The company is expecting to sell an SUV at Tk 25 lakh, sedan


at Tk 12 lakh to Tk 15 lakh, and a hatchback at Tk 8 lakh or
even less. These electric vehicles would cut fuel cost by 90
per cent and per kilometer energy cost would be less than Tk
Figure 2: Currently Used Electric Vehicles in Bangladesh 2. The battery capacity will be 50-kilowatt hour. Fully
charging an EV would cost Tk 400 as per the existing
Considering the socio-economic context of the country, these electricity tariff. With a 20-minute charge, these EVs can run
vehicles are an ideal mode of transportation due to their 400 km according to their claim [13].
inexpensive nature. Moreover, sharing rides is one of the
distinctive features that make this transport more popular as Nitol Motors is also setting up an EV assembly plant with the
it reduces per head fare cost. brand name "Suvare"[12]. The project with an estimated cost
of BDT 3.5 billion, is being set up in Pabna and Bogura. They
The four-wheeler EV market is still virtually non-existent in will assemble sedans that will be able to cover 200 kilometers
Bangladesh. Currently, it is estimated that there are less than with just half an hour of charging. India’s automaker Omega
10 passenger EVs in the country, and all of them are Seiki has recently announced an investment of INR 1 billion
concentrated in the capital city. However, due to lower to set up EV manufacturing facilities in Bangladesh.
operational costs, the demand for Four-Wheeler Hybrid
vehicles has gone up over the last few years. In terms of sales, The government plans to introduce EVs in the public
the figure had been rising sharply up until the COVID-19 transportation system as well. Bangladesh Road Transport
pandemic in 2020. In 2018, the hybrid four-wheeler market Corporation (BRTC) has already taken the initiative to
has registered a 900% increase in sales [11]. introduce 50 electric buses that will run in long routes like
Dhaka-Chottogram. The electric buses, each having 50 seats,
will have two ways of recharging – on-route while operating market as car manufacturers are moving towards catering for
and overnight at bus depots. In the updated NDC, Bangladesh that market as mentioned above. Bangladesh will simply have
committed to establish charging station network and no option but to learn to adapt to the changes in the worldwide
introduce electric buses in major cities [14]. market trend.

C. Existing Solar Charging Station Scenarios

There are approximately 900,000 easy bikes in Bangladesh


which operate on battery power. Batteries are currently
charged through main supply electricity. Currently, around
9000MWh (9,000,000 kWh) energy is used daily from the
supply grid to meet easy bike charging demand. This has
resulted in more energy crises and load shedding in
Bangladesh. To reduce this huge burden on the national grid,
GOB has already started to implement solar-powered
charging stations at various locations [8].

Figure 4: Initiatives of the first EV Car Plant According to SREDA’s website, so far 14 solar charging
stations have been installed with total capacity of 0.253MW.
The Automobile Industry Development Policy 2021, okayed The stations are owned and financed by different utilities,
by the Cabinet in June this year, stipulates policy support, such as, BPDB, BREB, DESCO, DPDC and WZPDCL [6].
including tax holiday and fiscal incentives, for local assembly
of electric vehicles and development of technologies and Table 1: Present Installed Solar Charging Stations
infrastructures for energy efficient vehicles. The proposed
policy projects that at least 15% of registered vehicles will be SID Capacity Location Agency Finance
powered by environment-friendly electricity in 2030[15].
462 20 kWp Narayanganj DPDC Self
UNDP has pointed out that import taxes and duties are too 336 21 kWp Gazipur BREB Self
high making four-wheeled EVs simply prohibitively 337 21 kWp Mymensingh BREB Self
expensive for the Bangladesh market. The UN body, while 338 21 kWp Dhaka BREB Self
offering $1.78 crore support to enhance policy institutional 3245 15 kWp Rajshahi BMDA Self
framework for EVs and EV charging stations and tailored 281 21 kWp Jessore WZPDCL Self
capacity building, has identified several roadblocks, which, it 286 30 kWp Gazipur BREB Self
has stressed, must be removed to pave the way for a smooth 287 21 kWp Narayanganj BREB Self
transition [15]. 288 21 kWp Munshiganj BREB Self
335 20 kWp Chittagong BPDB Self
185 20 kWp Sylhet BPDB Self
188 21 kWp Keraniganj BREB Self
164 16 kWp Dhaka DESCO Self
1949 14.4 kWp Jhenaidah IDCOL Self

Table II: Solar Charging Stations Sorted by Agency

Figure 5: EV Future of Bangladesh Summarized. Organization Quantity Installed Capacity


BREB 7 156 kWp
There is also increased interest among the businesses to BPDB 2 40 kWp
integrate sustainable transport solutions into their business WZPDCL 1 21 kWp
operations. Ricardo-AEA Limited, UK and Infrastructure DPDC 1 20 kWp
Development Company Limited (IDCOL), Bangladesh has
DESCO 1 16 kWp
conducted a demand and needs assessment survey among the
Micro, Small and Medium-size Enterprises (MSMEs) in BMDA 1 15 kWp
Bangladesh. 30 per cent of the responding companies own at IDCOL 1 14.4 kWp
least one EV and 56 per cent of the companies expressed their Total 14 282.4 kWp
intent to develop an in-house fleet of EV in near future [12].

Although the EV market in Bangladesh is still virtually non-


existent, but the EVs are sure to gain more foot in the local
Table 3 gives the presently installed and running solar
charging stations and their aimed target of power generation
and reduction of CO2 emission. However, there are some
ongoing solar charging station projects at different stage of
development. These charging stations are being installed by
REB. They are about to install seven more solar charging
stations.
These stations will be located at Gopalganj PBS, Natore PBS-
1, Comilla PBS-2, Khulna PBS, Sylhet PBS, Rajshahi PBS
and Coxbazar PBS. Among these seven stations two are
under construction, tending is in process for one, and
administrative process is in progress for four of them. The
cumulative output of these seven stations is estimated to be
Figure 6: Solar Charge Stations Own Percentage
147 kWp or even higher [10].

Table 2: Currently Operational Solar Charging Stations with their target and achievement.

CO2
Expected Expected
Emission CO2 Emission
Energy Energy
Agency SID Capacity Cost Completion time Reduction Reduction till
Generation Generation
During Today
in Lifetime till Today
Lifetime
336 21 kWp 49.48 April, 2017 458 MWh 110 MWh 217 tCO2 52 tCO2
337 21 kWp 45.69 April, 2017 458 MWh 110 MWh 217 tCO2 52 tCO2
338 21 kWp 43.85 April, 2017 458 MWh 110 MWh 217 tCO2 52 tCO2
BREB 286 30 kWp 76.93 March, 2017 654 MWh 162 MWh 309 tCO2 76 tCO2
287 21 kWp 44.64 March, 2017 458 MWh 113 MWh 217 tCO2 54 tCO2
288 21 kWp 49.30 March, 2017 458 MWh 113 MWh 217 tCO2 54 tCO2
188 21 kWp 51.70 October, 2016 458 MWh 122 MWh 217 tCO2 58 tCO2
335 20 kWp N/A December, 2016 436 MWh 113 MWh 206 tCO2 53 tCO2
BPDB
185 20 kWp N/A October, 2016 436 MWh 117 MWh 206 tCO2 55 tCO2
DPDC 462 20 kWp N/A February, 2019 436 MWh 63 MWh 206 tCO2 30 tCO2
DESCO 164 16 kWp N/A September, 2016 349 MWh 94 MWh 165 tCO2 45 tCO2
BMDA 3245 15 kWp N/A April, 2017 327 MWh 79 MWh 155 tCO2 37 tCO2
WZPDCL 281 21 kWp N/A March, 2017 458 MWh 113 MWh 217 tCO2 54 tCO2
IDCOL 1949 14.4 kWp N/A June, 2016 314 MWh 90 MWh 148 tCO2 43 tCO2

1) Decade-wise Solar Charging Station Targets from


2021 to 2041

In this section, three scenarios of solar PV targets from 2021


to 2041 are presented, namely business as usual or BAU,
medium, and high solar PV deployment scenario. The
scenarios will aim for different levels of RE share in the
generation mix. In several important policy documents, GOB
has fixed a target of supplying 10% of the total power demand
from RE sources by 2020.

The most recent policy document titled Revisiting PSMP


2016 has adopted a similar path and extended it until 2041. Figure 7: 3D Model of a Solar EV Charging Station.
According to BAU projection RE generation capacity to be
The mid-case deployment is developed based on the
10% of total by 2041 translating into nearly 7,950 MW,
assumption that the sector will receive both international
which is close to 8,000 MW. Out of this 8000 MW solar
support and government patronage in the coming decades. By
charging stations will occupy only 31 MW.
2041, the renewable is set to cover nearly 31% of total
generation capacity in this scenario translating into 25,000 to find their own buyers to sell electricity at a mutually
MW. Out of this 25000 MW solar charging stations will negotiated tariff. There is no mention of a preset or regulated
occupy only 51 MW. The high solar PV deployment scenario tariff. Given the global trend of electric vehicles and about to
has been developed assuming aggressive attitude of the flourish electric vehicle charging station sector, a regulated
government and reliable international financial support. price model for different charging schemes and charging
Under this scenario, nearly 50% of installed power capacity period should be included in the policy.
will be covered by solar PVs, which will be 40,000 MW. Out
of this 40000 MW solar charging stations will occupy only 3) Considerable Administrative Overheads
101 MW. The three-development case scenario and the solar
charging station fate is tabulated in Table I. At present, an independent solar PV project developer needs
to organize more than 30 permits and acquiring such permits
Table 3: Solar Charging Station Projected Target is quite a challenging task in Bangladesh. Therefore, such
challenges and obstacles need to be converted into
Solar PV Until 2021- 2031- transparent and quantifiable cost components.
Cumulative
Development 2020 2030 2041
Scenario MW MW MW MW 4) Too Long a Lock in Period
BAU 1 10 20 31 The lock in period for the investor (The lead partner) and
Medium operating partner is for at least up to the 6th year of operation
1 20 30 51
Deployment of the plant. This hinders many developers from being
High interested to invest in Bangladesh. Many of the developers or
1 30 70 101
Deployment investors are interested to develop the project and they want
to sell it to potential buyers after the CoD.

5) Stringent Qualification Criteria For The Developer

The operations and maintenance of solar PV projects is easy


and many solar PV projects worldwide are observed to be
unmanned. The requirement of operating experience is
hindering local investors from developing large scale solar
PV projects. It takes time to select and appoint an operating
partner and negotiate terms with them (the operating partner
needs to hold at least 20% of equity share holding), as so far
none of the local business entities has experience of operating
solar PV projects. This fact is equally applicable for solar
Figure 8: Solar Charging Station Projected Target charging stations. According to SREDA there are 14 running
solar charging stations but there are several private owned
solar charging stations that are nowhere to be found in any
III. IMPENDING BARRIERS OF SOLAR CHARGING STATION
database.
IMPLEMENTATION IN BANGLADESH.
A. Policy and regulations 6) Solar PV Waste Disposable Policy
1) Inadequate and Unharmonious Policy Framework
Currently, there is no policy addressing the waste disposal
Bangladesh is yet to formulate policies and regulations to arrangements after the project life of solar PV power plants
address various aspects of the solar energy sector in Bangladesh. Given the state of rapid progression of the
development; a standalone dedicated policy for solar electric sector, it is imperative to formulate an appropriate regulation
vehicle charging station is very urgent. Solar Electric Vehicle addressing this issue.
Charging Station demands a dedicated policy and regulatory
framework. Moreover, a review of the existing policies Solar PV modules are complex pieces of technology that
reveals a sort of incongruity among them. A clear-cut, firm become big, bulky sheets of electronic waste at the end of
and stimulating policy and regulatory framework is of their lives. Solar panels contain toxic materials like lead that
foremost importance for any sector to develop and thrive. can leach out as they break down, landfilling also creates new
environmental hazards-and right now, most of the world
including Bangladesh doesn’t have a plan for dealing with
2) Regulated Tariff/Incentive that. But we’ll need to develop effective disposal policy,
because the solar e-waste glut is coming.
There is still an absence of regulated tariff structure for all
solar projects in Bangladesh. According to “Renewable By 2050, the International Renewable Energy Agency
Energy Policy-2008”, private investors are allowed to use any projects that up to 78 million metric tons of solar panels will
fuel including renewable ones for renewable power projects have reached the end of their life, and that the world will be
for instance solar electric vehicle charging station and are free generating about 6 million metric tons of new solar e-waste
annually. While the latter number is a small fraction of the
total e-waste humanity produces each year, standard C. Financing and Business Models
electronics recycling methods don’t cut it for solar panels. 1) Absence of Capacity Payment
Recovering the most valuable materials from one, including
silver and silicon, requires bespoke recycling solutions. And Unlike the conventional IPP projects, capacity payment is
if we fail to develop those solutions along with policies that absent in the solar IPP project. So, the financial model needs
support their widespread adoption, disaster will occur. to be adjusted to cover the risks. Solar plants usually operate
at 17–19% plant utilization factor. So, without capacity
B. Land and Weather Related Barriers payments, all O&M, returns and debt services needs to be
covered from the sale of electricity from solar PV Power.
1) Land Related Barriers
2) Risk Investment
If Bangladesh is to embrace the EV trend and achieve its CO2
emission target, the upcoming solar charging stations must be
The credit rating of Bangladesh is BB- (Standard & Poor’s).
sufficiently large enough to serve the huge crowd. As a result,
It is not very encouraging for foreign investors. So, if the
these projects may or will require vast stretches of land.
return is not high enough the foreign investors are not
Being agriculture dominated economy; GOB understandably
encouraged to invest. The lack of project realization related
preserves agricultural lands from being used for solar PV
information, knowledge and guidance relating to policy and
project development. As a result, there are very little non-
regulatory compliance obligations for solar PV projects
agricultural lands that lie mostly in the northeastern part of
forces the developers to take risks.
the country, in the riverbanks and islands, sand bars and in
coastal regions. Acquiring land to install solar charging
station may be easy but for urban and semi-urban areas where D. Non-Licensed Vehicle
the users on EVs is most likely to be maximum is not going There are no rules for registering EV in BRTA. But there
difficult and costly. Again, these areas are far away from the should be a legal framework for promoting sustainable
national grid facilities or limited by the grid capacity. So, environment through energy efficient method of EV use. The
operating a solar charging station with additional grid support rules and regulations for EV licensing should be designed by
for 24/7 availability may not be possible in all areas. technical and some other means as like motorized vehicle. As
the electric vehicle is unlicensed vehicle as per government
Very often it is found that the ownership of suitable lands for indication, it acts as an obstacle for EV penetration in
solar PV projects is distributed among several hundred Bangladesh. At first, EV i.e., Auto-rickshaw, Electric bike,
individuals. The legal acquisition of land from several Electric bi-cycle, Electric tricycle needs registration in the
hundred owners requires a considerable amount of time. national website. When it is completed then the total number
Moreover, it has also been found very often that the transfer of charging station required in different corners of
of lands through deeds was not properly conducted in the Bangladesh can be calculated easily. Charging rate of EV
past, which also delays the project implementation period and should be selected according to the energy consumption.
thus incurs cost. Until the ownerships of the lands are not
clear the project financial closure cannot be achieved. A solar
charging station no matter how big will not cover a very vast E. Technological Feasibility
area like a solar power plant does. So not all land related
problems are not implied to solar charging stations. 1) Additional Grid Support

2) Challenges Weather & Climatic Conditions One of the main problems of the adoption of PV power
sources is the lack of a stable and continuous electrical power
Very often, Bangladesh experiences cyclones in the southern production. The PV power sources suffer from an intermittent
region due to its geographical location. This creates the need and stochastic nature that caused by the continuous variations
for special precaution in the form of mounting structure in the solar isolation levels as well as the ambient temperature
design and the assembly, thus increasing the project cost. values. Additionally, the day-night cycles highly impact the
Solar irradiation is moderate in Bangladesh, about 4.5 kWh ability of using PV sources in standalone configurations.
(GHI) per m2 per day. This average value is also not available
all through the year. During the long monsoon, the generation Additional grid support is a much necessary option for the
is highly variable due to the frequent overcast sky. Dust effectiveness of a solar charging station. The additional grid
accumulation on the solar panels is much higher in support will provide the necessary boost to a solar charging
Bangladesh compared to other countries, which results in station to overcome its weakness of nature itself [16] [17].
higher O&M cost for the plants. Therefore, a higher The dependance on the main grid as a stable source can
maintenance cost needs to be allocated in the project O&M compensate the RES fluctuations.
budget, which also increases the cost of electricity from solar
PV projects. During the monsoon, most of the country’s land
is inundated and it is difficult to work in the rainy season,
which also delays project implementation time and thus
increases cost.
only 15%-20% of traditional chargers. Temperature raises of
battery while charging is also greatly lowered.

IDCOL’s Solar powered battery charging station R & D site


at Chuadanga use this technology and claimed that using this
device will increase the lifetime of the batteries of EV by a
significant factor and it is 22% more efficient than
conventional chargers used [22].

4) Smart Card Billing System

With a post billing system, the project owner would need to


rely on the charging station operational staff where there is a
Figure 9: Using AC Grid to compensate the fluctuations in solar moderate possibility of inconsistencies between the actual
money collection and the billing, due to a lack of monitoring
of the operations. In such situation the project owner will
2) Hybrid Topology for effective operational hours
have to face extra pressure when repaying the loan
instalments [22].
As the solar can provide power only at daytime and is absent
in cloudy & foggy days, thus hybrid system (such as solar, Therefore, Solar E Technology has developed a prepaid
biogas or solar, wind or solar, municipal waste) is mandatory metering system and has installed a smart meter in each
for sustainable production of electricity for EV charging [18]. charging terminal that could implement the prepayment
system through IC card meter management. Users would
recharge their IC cards and then insert them into the meter to
start charging their vehicle. Thus, the measuring of kWh,
billing, battery charging operation and data storage would be
managed by smart meters. Cloud based software can be
developed if we want to control and manage files, multi-
tariffs, parameters, and data storage and data analysis.

5) Other Technological Aspects


Figure 10: Hybrid topology for Solar Charging Station  Vehicle to Grid (V2G)
 Route Search: Range and Location
Several works have analyzed the design of EV charging
 Technical Standards Related Challenges
stations based on hybrid sources including the storage
 Remote Data Management System
system. All aspects of the Solar EV charging such as
topologies of power converters, charging mechanisms as well  Advanced Charging Control Architectures
as the control and optimization of on-grid, off-grid modes and
hybrid systems are summarized in [19-20] IV. GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS

3) Effective Charging Scheme


Motivations to put adequate emphasis on the installation of
There are three levels commonly used to describe the solar-powered charging stations are manifold. Apart from
charging power of EVSE: Level 1, Level 2, and DC Fast adding extra solar capacity, solar charging stations have the
Charging. This simplest form of charging uses a 120V AC potential to greatly reduce the burden on the national grid
connection, while level 2 requires a 208/240V AC power imposed by the large number of battery-driven electric
connection, and finally sometimes referred to as Level 3, DC vehicles, thus diversifying the demand. Keeping an eye on the
fast charging equipment delivers high power directly into an global development, it can be safely stated that solar charging
EV’s battery system, enabling rapid charging. Typically, an stations are likely to capture more attention in the future with
80% charge can be provided in 30 minutes or less for many the commercialization of electric vehicles.
all-electric vehicles. Some of the fast-charging systems A. Developing a favorable policy framework
presently available incorporate negative pulse fast charging For any well-defined national energy target to be met, a
algorithms that claim to have great benefits to batteries strong legal, policy, and regulatory framework is required.
including reduced recharge time, lower temperature rise, full Obviously, the first step will be to create a goal that will
recharge capabilities, as well as shorter equalization times generate and convey a critical high-end priority signal to all
stakeholders and actors in the industry. In Bangladesh a
The claims of the Negative Pulse Charger are often criticized couple of very important steps have already been
as myths but there is also some practical evidence proving its implemented that are in favor of a sustainable solar EVCS,
claims [21]. The intelligent negative pulse current charger is and they are:
designed to meet charger requirements of power battery on
the electric vehicle. This assists in reducing battery internal  Establishment of SREDA
impedance while charging. The battery gassing amount is
 Relevant policy and regulatory documents that are the adoption of solar EVCS, the tariff is recommended to be
already serving as basic guideline like ‘Renewable lower since solar charging stations are only going to use them
Energy Policy 2008’, ‘Net Metering Guidelines- in case of bad weather or storage system maintenance
2018’, ‘Power System Master Plan 2016’, ‘Policy scenario.
Guidelines for Commercial IPP 2008’
 Formation of a financial organization such as C. Role of BRTA: Licensing and modification of Existing
IDCOL within the scope of the Ministry of Finance EVs
with a priority on RE programs.
To ensure the roadworthiness of registered cars, particularly
Our suggestion is to set up a dedicated agency for solar electric or environmentally friendly vehicles, revise the
charging station industry under SREDA, that will speed up existing Motor Vehicle Act and other related legislation
the establishment of solar charging stations and related covering safety, quality, and emission restrictions. While
activities. This agency shall be responsible for: upgrading the inspection facilities owned by BRTA,
strengthen the vehicle inspection system so that fitness tests
 Site selection and land acquisition: This can correctly verify if safety, quality, and emission levels
organization with or without support from the comply with the required criteria. BRTA Should also be
responsible for mandating the modification of existing three-
governments will select the site, and acquire and
wheelers. IDCOL suggest that certain modification on the
develop the land for setting up the solar charging
existing EVs can extend their lifetime by 25% [22].
stations . For private entrepreneurs, there will be
provisions for long-term lease ensuring dispute
free acquisition of land . The selection of sites D. Competition with AC Charging Stations
shall be with higher solar irradiation, easy access As discussed earlier the era of EV in Bangladesh is
to mass population and should not create commencing. Bangladesh has simply no choice but to accept
additional traffic jam. Other facilities to be it and develop the necessary infrastructure to cope with the
provided are approved land with necessary situation. To meet the demand of these EVs, manufacturing
permissions,Telecommunication facilities and companies are sure to install charging stations. Besides to
centralized weather monitoring station. meet the demands of the govt. owned EVs (Public Transport)
GOB will also install charging stations.
 Financial models: This organization will be
responsible for estimating the total cost of the Our recommendation is to follow the “PSMP-2016” strictly
project and then formulating a recovery model to which mandates that 10% of all power should come from RE.
ensure the sustainability of the solar charging Adhering to that fact 10% of all the charging stations should
stations. It shall also be allowed to put in its own be solar EV charging stations. This should apply for both
equity, raise loans, create small corpus for working govt.-initiated projects and to the other agencies who are
capital and invest in the operation and maintenance building charging stations. Besides to compete with the AC
of the stations, activities related to marketing and EV charging stations, the solar EVCSs are needed to be
publicity. equipped properly so that they may not fall behind the race.
B. Net Metering Provisions and Tarrif incentives E. Ensuring a Safe Financial Landscape
Solar-powered charging stations with net metering can be It should be realized that the envisioned target must be met
prioritized to achieve net zero scenario. At present only three by merging the effort of both public and private sector. Since
phase consumers are eligible for net metering. Our the entry of private power producers in FY 1998-90, the net
recommendation is Solar Charging stations are to be included energy generation capacity has increased more than 4 times.
in NEM policy. In case of a holiday or low crowd, the excess The private sector surpassed the public sector in net
energy will be added to the grid which will do savings in generation around 2010 and has successfully sustained the
battery energy storage system. trend till now.

Vehicle-to-grid (V2G), uses a two-way charging port The same trend is desired in the solar charging station sector
connected to the home or charging station that can either draw as well and to achieve that a secured investment environment
or supply power between a battery-electric vehicle (BEV) or is of utmost importance. Since, the solar market is still in the
plug-in hybrid vehicle and the electricity grid, depending on developing phase in Bangladesh, the private investors
where it’s needed most. Although V2G in Bangladesh will understandably foresee higher risks to invest into such
take a long time to come. Allowing charging stations with projects. In addition to existing benefits, Other financial
NEM privileges the first step to the implementation smart incentives, such as introducing innovative business models,
grid can be started. It should be noted that DPDC is currently lowering interest rate, regulated NEM tariff/green certificates
building a localized smart grid in Dhaka. for small to medium scale investors, provision for capacity
payments, etc. can be considered for creating a safe financial
Bangladesh Energy Regulatory Commission (BERC) has environment in the long run. Although present policy
introduced a new tariff category for charging stations –setting suggesting that the income tax to be waived for 15 years, our
energy charge of 7.70 Tk./KWh along with an additional recommendation is to extend this period to the payback
demand charge of 40 Tk./KW/month. However, to promote period of the project.
[7] Power Division, Net Metering Guidelines-2018, Dhaka: MPEMR, GOB,
Multiple international donor institutions can be approached
2018.
for funding, including the UNFCCC's Green Climate Fund,
the Global Environmental Facility (GEF), and the World [8] SREDA, “National Solar Energy Action Plan, 2021–2041 (Draft Final
Bank's Climate Investment Fund, among others. UNDP, Report)”, Power Division, MPEMR, GOB, 2020.[online]. Available:
http://www.sreda.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/sreda.portal.gov.bd/notices/
ADB, GIZ, USAID, JICA, KOICA, and other development fba98896_568a_4efd_a48b_8d92bfc04049/2020-10-22-17-
partners are already playing critical roles in boosting RE 127b0e5a0c0dabd4c17492bcf3bd7488b4.pdf [Accessed 01 November
throughout the country. They can undoubtedly play an 2021].
important role in the financing of solar charging stations.
[9] Power Division, Policy Guideline For Small Power Plant (Spp) In Private
Sector, Dhaka: MPEMR, GOB, November 2008.
F. Solar Waste Disposal Policy
[10] BREB, “At a Glance of Renewable Energy Projects”, Power Division,
Each solar appliance has a labelled lifetime. After that MPEMR, GOB, 2020.[online]. Available:
lifetime, the appliances need to be disposed in proper ways, http://reb.portal.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/reb.portal.gov.bd/page/fb283
7ea_bee9_4775_98c1_d3c9b549a082/2.At%20a%20Glance%20of%20Ren
i.e., in ways that will be safe for the environment. Reduce,
ewable%20Energy%20Projects.pdf [Accessed 01 November 2021].
Reuse, Recycle or, in short, the 3Rs can be handled in a better
way if the processes are made technically and financially [11] S. N. Faiyaz Uddin Ayeshik, "Is Bangladesh Ready for The Adoption
viable. The average lifetime of solar module is around 20-−30 of Electric Vehicles?," 2 June 2021. [Online]. Available:
years, and of inverters is around 10−15 years. Charge https://www.lightcastlebd.com/insights/2021/06/the-current-shape-of-ev-
and-hybrid-vehicle-ecosystem-in-bangladesh. [Accessed 1 November
controllers, batteries and related appliances have similar a
2021].
lifetime. An exit plan for those solar products needs to be
[12] A. H. Bhuiyan, "Electric mobility in Bangladesh: prospects and
under planning before the lifetime ends. This can avoid possibilities," The Financial Express, 21 October 2021. [Online].
environmental pollution. Available: https://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/views/electric-mobility-in-
bangladesh-prospects-and-possibilities-1633702313. [Accessed 1
V. CONCLUSION November 2021].
Solar powered battery charging station is an innovative and
[13] A. S. Shawn, "On the road to an electric future," The Daily Star, 24
environmentally sustainable alternative to meet the on-going September 2021. [Online]. Available:
energy crises and to support the existing 1.24 million easy https://www.thedailystar.net/toggle/news/the-road-electric-future-
bikes in Bangladesh. To make it as an effective and mandatory 2182711. [Accessed 1 November 2021].
option for EV a proper policy should be made soon. This paper [14] S. Saif, "Govt takes positive e-vehicles policy to counter emission,"
presented some important recommendations for upcoming EV The Business Standard, 17 September 2021. [Online]. Available:
charging station policy giving importance on financial https://www.tbsnews.net/bangladesh/transport/govt-takes-positive-e-
benefits for investors and tariff incentives for the users. Net vehicles-policy-counter-emission-303949. [Accessed 1 November 2021].
metering provisions was also highlighted. Technical and
economical feasibilities also discussed in the paper. Solar [15] J. Chakma, "Five lenders arrange Tk 167cr for first electric vehicle
charging station should be and will be a very effective and plant," The Daily Star, 28 October 2021. [Online]. Available:
https://www.thedailystar.net/business/organisation-news/news/five-
economical solution for rural easy-bike charging without lenders-arrange-tk-167cr-first-electric-vehicle-plant-2208266. [Accessed 1
affecting and disturbing the national grid. Even sometime it November 2021].
can contribute to the national grid. Government should give
necessary attention on it and thus a green and clean [16] V. A. Kumar and M. Arounassalame, “PV-FC hybrid system with
environment can be built in future. By ensuring the prospects multilevel boost converter fed multilevel inverter with enhanced
performance,” Proceedings of 2017 IEEE International Conference on
of EV charging station we can solve our energy and gas crisis; Technological Advancements in Power and Energy: Exploring Energy
and ensure a green environment for the future generations. Solutions for an Intelligent Power Grid, TAP Energy 2017, pp. 1–6, 2018.

REFERENCES [17] Rasinab, Z. and M.F. Rahmana. Grid-connected quasi-Z-source PV


inverter for electricvehicle charging station. IEEE Computer Society.
[1] Sujitha, N. and S. Krithiga, RES based EV battery charging system: A
review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2017. 75: p. 978-988. [18] Eldeeb, H.H., S. Faddel, and O.A. Mohammed, Multi-Objective
Optimization Technique for the Operation of Grid tied PV Powered EV
[2] Islam, M.M.; Das, N.K.; Ghosh, S.; Dey, M. Design and implementation Charging Station. Electric Power Systems Research, 2018. 164: p. 201-211.
of cost effective smart solar charge station. In Proceedings of the 2014 9th
IEEE International Forum on the Strategic Technology (IFOST), Cox’s [19] Bhatti, A.R., et al., Electric vehicles charging using photovoltaic:
Bazar, Bangladesh, 21 October 2014; pp. 339–342 Status and technological review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews, 2016. 54: p. 34-47.
[3] Ministry of Environment and Forests (MOEF), Nationally Determined
Contributions (NDC), Dhaka: Government of Bangladesh, 2018. [20] Novoa, L. and J. Brouwer, Dynamics of an integrated solar
photovoltaic and battery storage nanogrid for electric vehicle charging.
[4] Ministry of Environment and Forests (MOEF), Bangladesh Climate Journal of Power Sources, 2018. 399: p. 166-178.
Change Strategy and Action Plan 2009, Dhaka: Government of Bangladesh,
2009. [21]Jung-Chieh Cheng, “Investigation on Pulse Charging Characteristics of
Lead-Acid Batteries”, Master's Thesis, 2002, National San-Yat Sen
[5] Power Division, Renewable Energy Policy of Bangladesh 2008, Dhaka: University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.
MPEMR, GOB, 18 December 2008.
[22]"SOLAR POWERED BATTERY CHARGING STATION: A pilot R
[6] SREDA, "Sustainable and Renewable Energy Development Authority," & D site at Chuadanga sponsored by IDCOL & World bank," Solar E
Power Division, MPEMR, GOB, 2020. [Online]. Available: Technology, Dhaka, 2016.
http://www.sreda.gov.bd/. [Accessed 01 November 2021].

You might also like