Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Musculoskeletal Clinical Reasoning Form - Cognitive Domain
Musculoskeletal Clinical Reasoning Form - Cognitive Domain
What questions will you ask to clarify or gather information to support/refute each hypothesis? (planning the interview)
September 2020
Aggravating factors? History of Onset: Are you experiencing night pain?
Alleviating factors? Does your shoulder pain arise after -pain c̅ sleeping on shoulder OR insidious
History of onset? your neck pain? pain
(specifically loading history) Did your pain begin with cervical and
Recent injury – if recent neck injury? overtime contribute to should Are you experiencing pain without a
Recent changes in daily life that would link pain/irritation? pattern – for example, not in relation to
to onset of pain. movement/mechanical aggravation
Aggravate/Alleviate?
24 hour pain history/behavior patterns? -here, patient may experience pain at Are you experiencing a change in weight
Sleep? different times OR different triggers without direct cause?
-when you have shoulder pain, do
Ask patient goals of shoulder and activities you have cervical pain If thinking GI problem?
in which she wishes to return to – this to AND VIS VERSA -as about medication list – often c̅ NSAIDs
direct interventions. -when you have cervical pain, do you a patient may experience gastrointestinal
have shoulder pain? distress
Identify expectations of therapy. -ask if patient has problem during or after
Identify current activity level and relative eating/digestion
lifestyle factors.
Highly limited exam due to Moderately limited exam Minimally limited exam due Unlimited exam due to
anticipated tolerance due to anticipated tolerance to anticipated tolerance anticipated tolerance
ROM 1st onset of sx ROM to active limit ROM to passive limit ROM to sustained/ combined
Very low vigor and extent Low vigor and extent of Moderate vigor and extent High vigor and extent of
of tests/measures tests/measures of tests/measures tests/measures
Pt presented guarded No, no recent acute injury -- just be
Pt is currently in minor pain so Does the nature, diagnosis, or co- mindful of aggravating the patient.
Rationale for this
slightly limited morbidities warrant special caution Keep in mind patient trust.
vigor and extent.
Pt can move and complete for exam or treatment? Yes / No
Justify your
everyday tasks so she should If yes, what?
assessment of
be able to tolerate most PT (e.g. Trauma / Inflammation / Red
severity &
examination movements Flags / Instability/ Pathological
irritability Process)
Remember Pt and PT trust!
Limitation of movement due to How is this activity limitation Limited in completing her hobbies
What is the pain in shoulder region affecting the patient’s participation activities of gardening and quilting
2
AND due to build up of pain
Pain in cervical region due to
primary activity increased sitting/typing/poor Limited with pain at the end of the
limitation (ICF posture in normal social roles (ICF day to confidently complete day to
classification)? She is in pain and want to get classification)? day tasks and be in comfortable
back to her activities of positions
washing her hair and clasping
her bra!
REVISED AND REPRIORITIZED HYPOTHESES AFTER THE PATIENT INTERVIEW
Most Likely Hypothesis: Less Likely Hypothesis: Remote Hypotheses:
(Primary Hypotheses) (Secondary Hypotheses) (Include at least 1 non-MSK hypothesis
requiring referral)
1. MRI and subjective examination 1. decreased likelihood of only a 1. shoulder pain after eating and/or
push us to believe more in the shoulder OR only a neck problem drinking alcohol specifically bringing on
musculoskeletal mix of shoulder due to pain pattern often paired referral pain from liver/pancreas
and neck pain! relatively together or in a specific
2. This d/t pattern of pain, onset of increasing pattern – therefore we But thankfully, she did not have this issue.
pain, symptoms of pain, etc all link should not categorize these After our questions, we are steering away
towards biomechanical pattern separately as they change pain levels from this as the primary cause/limitation.
and cause upon one another
Observe/Palpation: shoulder/spinal region/cervical Palpation: note areas of pain, tenderness, heat, swelling, etc if
region present
-clear cervical spine!
-observe overhead reach Observe: if compensation in shoulder (is decrease in range due to
stiffness, tightness, pain?)
Strength:
-test if strength is limited to pain Strength is key point to aide in decreasing impairment and will also
-flex, abduction, IR, ER aide in ROM
ROM: Appropriate ROM allows patient to complete daily tasks and currently
-test if certain positions are more aggravating/alleviating patient is unable to clasp bra or wash her hair.
-this often limits need to special tests b/c̅ you can find
many results in these sections listed Joint Play may show us a motion that relieves the patient of pain or
help steer away from capsular problems
Joint Play:
-help steer away from AC diagnosis and lead more into
relief in posterior/caudal direction
Cervical spine issues b/c̅ this pain is not as prevalent as Cervical spine issues b/c̅ this pain is not as prevalent as the shoulder
the shoulder pain pain and we first must calm down symptoms and then work into
functional and eventually global movement patterns.
IV.ASSESSMENT AFTER THE PHYSICAL EXAM
Yes, patient is appropriate for physical therapy to aide in decreasing
Is the patient an appropriate candidate for physical pain, increasing strength and increasing ROM in the shoulder and
therapy intervention? Do they require additional also the cervical spine.
referral?
(Treat, Refer, or Treat & Refer). Indicate reason for No, patient does not steer towards a referral because she tested
referral (imaging, lab work, etc.)? What? Why? Justify. away from non MSK causes and pt already met physician and MRI
also steers towards MSK tear in RTC
Most Important Baseline Subjective findings (Activity Most Important Baseline Objective tests and measure findings
limitations and Participation restrictions) from the Patient (Impairments) from the Physical Exam that are associated with the
Interview: Put most important findings at top Activity Limitation
Activity Limitation or Symptom(s) Time Related Impairment/ Results Symptom(s What limits
Participation to ease Movement Test or ) it
Restriction Baseline
Unable clasp bra Sharp Shoulder pain 30min R shoulder decreased ROM Positive Sharp pain in Pain limits range
and increased pain painful arc shoulder 7/10 and strength
pain
Unable to wash hair Sharp & sore shoulder 30min R shoulder IR limited Decrease Sore and sharp pain
pain ROM value
Pain with lifting overhead Shoulder pain sore 30min Decrease strength flex.abd, IR, 4/5 MMT Pain in all Pain
ER movements
Difficulty gardening at the end Progressive shoulder hours Caudal glide GH to grade IV Movement Relieving, less Shoulder
of the day soreness improves symptoms decreases stiff, less sore, tissues/protectin
sx no sharp pain g/guarding
Difficulty completing full day of Neck/back pain hours
work s̅ pain
V. CONTEXTUAL FACTORS: Are there contributing factors that may affect prognosis? (check all that apply)
Occupational
Personality Environmental Societal Health and/or Other (describe)
and/or Wellness
motivational
List and describe how these factors may act as barriers to recovery:
Occupation: induces patient into forward head and rounded shoulders posture
Motivation: poorly motivated d/t lack of compliance with body weight, diabetes mellites and hypertension
Environmental: poor desk conditions to support her body for long hours at her desk
Societal: COVID – less human interaction, increased stress, and less movement activity d/t restrictions to stay home
Health: currently pt is overweight, prehypertension, pre diabetic
List and describe how these factors may act as facilitators of recovery:
Occupation: patient may want to get back to work to feel accomplished, make money, and b/c̅ she enjoys her career
4
Motivation: patient may be motivated to feel better about one’s̅ body.
Environmental: changing her desk station to accommodate the long hours at the computer
Societal: fall weather promotes walking/biking – being outside to move and enjoy the weather!!
Health: currently pt is overweight, prehypertension, pre diabetic and she may want to take charge of her health finally!
Describe how you will manage or address any relevant contextual factors:
Occupation: teach patient positive effects of proper desk ergonomics to reduce neck/shoulder pain
Motivation: teach how of compliance with body weight, diabetes mellites and hypertension all will make her feel better and move easier
Environmental: teach patient positive effects of walking and being outside to uplift mood and aide in cardiovascular fitness
Societal: take part in fitness program virtually or with a group to stay accountable
Health: currently pt is overweight, prehypertension, pre diabetic so again teach health holistically and how each small step is a success towards a healthier body!
VI. PROGNOSIS:
What is the natural history of the disorder? How will it progress over the life span?
If untreated, a continual wear and tear will continue to strain the shoulder joint, muscles, and tendons. Lifting, reaching overhead, and poor posture of forward
shoulder will promote a negative continuation of wear and tear.
In time, scapular stabilizers will weaken, blood supply will decrease, and ability to complete day to day activities without pain will become even more difficult as
the shoulder joint continues to wear and tear.
Likelihood of recurrence: MILD / MODERATE / HIGH – if patient does not comply with therapy, pain may persist
How will you attempt to prevent a recurrence of symptoms? How will you educate the patient to manage an exacerbation if it
does happen?
To prevent recurrence, a patient needs consistency in a workout program to continuously strengthen the shoulder joint, maintain ROM, and promote proper
posture.
Additionally, the patient needs to be mindful of her age and her activities. RTC tears occur more frequently as one continues to age so proper nutrition and
holistic exercise will be beneficial to strengthen her body’s̅ system to help in systemic healing.
The patient should prepare an ergonomic work setting to promote proper poster and decrease forward shoulders while working and quilting. Additionally, the
patient need to work on holistic body care. This regarding better sleep quantity and quality to assist her body’s̅ natural healing processes and to decrease
exacerbation of pain. With this by promoting a healthy diet and cardiovascular fitness she will feel the difference a health lifestyle makes on the body’s̅ system
systemically.
To educate patient how to manage exacerbation of symptoms, I would teach the patient how to best listen to her body.
Truly listening to the body is difficult as patient’s̅ often want to be strong and push through the pain, but we need to listen to what the pain is telling us about the
body.
If the patient experiences a flare up, she should continue to complete isometric strengthening exercises to maintain strength but while giving the body a rest from
overhead motions or lifting too heavy of objects. With this, the patient should avoid overhead activities and reset herself for proper posture. Finally, she should
use our symptom easy techniques to decrease pain.
Functional SMART goals: a behavior characteristic duration time and
Short Term (indicate timeframe):
1. In 2 weeks, patient will demonstrate the ability to incorporate meaningful breaks in her work day to allow time for pain decreasing exercise (shoulder
pendulum/codman) in order to decrease shoulder joint pain (no greater than 4/10) and to reset the spine for proper posture to also help decrease
cervical pain (no greater than 2/10)
2. In 2 weeks, patient will become a part of a walking fitness regime of walking 4x a week for at least 15min a day to promote cardiovascular fitness.
Long Term (indicate timeframe) – briefly explain why you selected the goal
1. In 12 weeks, patient will be able to paint room (arm overhead) for 1 hour at a time with pain no greater than 1/10 in order to reintegrate into her normal
life habits
2. In 12 weeks, patient will be able to complete a full workday (8 hours) without shoulder and neck pain no greater than 1/10 in order to rejoin her work
routine without interrupting her evening activities with pain.
Initial Day 1 interventions. Rationale (What from the interview or Expected Response (What movement
BE SPECIFIC and include dosage. physical exam indicates this treatment is test will you reassess to prove that your
important?) treatment was effective?)
In class discussion: We must decrease pain for patient to be able to Asking patient overall pain scale and pain after the
move into functional patterns and eventually into work day will help to reassess if this pain relieving
Warm up c̅ bike: global movement patterns. Patient stated she felt exercise is aiding in minimizing pain symptoms.
-warm up shoulder muscles 5min warm up relief with the arm swing when walking and during
-joint mobs/stretching (specifically pt stated distraction joint play so this exercise promotes
5
distraction felt good) to warm up and ease pain, movement and motion for lubrication and nutrition of
esp if pt has flare up shoulder joint. Patient also stated she is already
taking breaks and feels better after resetting her
ROM/Stretching body.
-in general, passive ROM if flared up vs.
AAROM when pt is having a good day
--seated roll back passive shoulder flexion
stretch maintain for 45 seconds at home (this
also has component of distraction to ease pain
while also combo of ROM)
-active assisted to also work into range with
strengthen factor
--towel slides on table at home
-for neck: gentle chin tucks in supine as a break
from the arm
Scapular Positioning
-posture shoulders back and down – educational
piece!!
-pectoral stretches (doorway stretch, seated
scap squeezes – 10x for 10 seconds)
Education:
-motion is lotion
-chin tucks/change in posture to relieve tension
-activity pacing with shoulder b/c̅ she feels good
with mild motion but too much irritates patient
--get patient involved: when you garden take a
break when you pull weeds after 20min
3. Shoulder flexion on the table with a Patient presented with decrease flexion strength and To test if this exercise is effective, shoulder strength
towel/ball. Press into the towel/ball to ROM. By keeping strength as the key component, in flexion range and ROM in flexion while
activate shoulder muscles and research shows this factor will be a primary aide in demonstrate an effective or ineffective response.
gradually push into forward flexion to healing and adding in the piece of ROM will promote
promote strength and comfortable motion in overhead motions to allow patient to better
ROM reach overhead to grab her coffee cup, etc.
6
4. 3x a day (breakfast, lunch, and dinner
when sitting at the table)
5. 8 repetitions to promote patient
adherence without getting
overwhelmed
6. 4x a week
3. isometric internal and external rotation Patient struggles with IR and ER to wash hair and To assess effectiveness, shoulder IR/ER can be
exercises to continue to promote clasp bra so this exercise will promote range and tested or more specifically we can see if the patient
strength (esp as she states she strength to complete this daily task. can reach to clasp bra or washing hair has
struggles with washing hair and improved.
clasping bra)
4. 3x a day for 8 repetitions
5. Hold isometric position for 6 deep
breaths
6. 4x a week
Assume good patient adherence and no red flags are present. At the next visit, what treatment will you consider if the
patient is:
Better: Worse: The Same:
My Initial Response: My Initial Response: Maintain pain relieving symptom exercises but
Flexion strengthening activities in Ask when patient feels worse (if related to specific increase sets and repetition and intensity of
concentric/eccentric pattern with hand held exercise) exercises to promote a change in shoulder/neck
weight and increasing repetitions to promote an Ask where patient feels worse (to narrow in on if it region.
increase in challenge for shoulder strength. was from an exercise prescription from myself) OR
Ask patient if they have exercise they found
Continuing with IR/ER no longer in isometric More patient education in treatment to teach the beneficial, analyze it and work more collaboratively
pattern and similar to above with weight/more need for strength exercises to find exercises the patient feels a response from
resistance and loading to the shoulder to again the shoulder and closely monitor the changes.
promote further shoulder strength and If patient is in too much pain, I would provide more
stabilization small movement activities and holistic body exercise
programs. We need to calm the painful symptoms
Additional holistic body movements with the before adding too much motion and by also adding in
shoulder as a priority – meaning changing from a holistic approach we are promoting increased
supine position to standing or moving exercises healing time. I would promote more supine/relaxing
to increase resistance against gravity and breathing techniques into the exercises to strip the
incorporate lower body exercises into the program down to a relaxing level.
exercise routines.
In class discussion:
In class discussion: -did you do anything different
-if she is doing well, add in weight, resistance for -light stretching, modalities work to minimize pain
example, rows, pull downs,
Treatment Progression: Describe how you plan to progress this patient over the next 4-6 weeks. BE SPECIFIC AND
DETAILED including all appropriate parameters. This may include the following: Physical Agents, Therapeutic Exercise,
Manual Therapies, Neuro Re-education, Motor Learning/Skill Acquisition Strategies, Activity Modification, & Home
Education.
*Be sure to include principles of dosage and progression for all interventions.
7
To educate patient how to manage exacerbation of symptoms, I would teach the patient how to best listen to her body.
Truly listening to the body is difficult as patient’s̅ often want to be strong and push through the pain, but we need to listen to what the pain is telling us about the
body.
If the patient experiences a flare up, she should continue to complete isometric strengthening exercises to maintain strength but while giving the body a rest from
overhead motions or lifting too heavy of objects. With this, the patient should avoid overhead activities and reset herself for proper posture. Finally, she should
use our symptom easy techniques to decrease pain.
For work, teach patient positive effects of proper desk ergonomics to reduce neck/shoulder pain and understanding importance of breaks and variety of
posture.
Additionally, teach how of compliance with body weight, diabetes mellites and hypertension all will make her feel better and move easier and all will aide in
healing process.
Teach patient positive effects of walking and being outside to uplift mood and aide in cardiovascular fitness
Advocate for the patient to take part in fitness program virtually or with a group to stay accountable
Currently, pt is overweight, prehypertension, pre diabetic so again teach health holistically and how each small step is a success towards a healthier body!