Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Peixoto Et Al, 2021 J Interperson Violen
Peixoto Et Al, 2021 J Interperson Violen
Cross-sectional Study
Janeiro, Brazil
5National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq), Brasília, Brazil.
Corresponding Author:
Eduardo Mesquita Peixoto, RN, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro State. Rua Dr Xavier Sigaud,
290, Sala do Programa de Pós-graduação em Enfermagem. Urca, Rio de Janeiro (RJ), Brazil.
Email: teachereduardo@outlook.com
2 Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Abstract
Trans women are specifically vulnerable to interpersonal violence. Being
perceived as the gender that a transgender person identifies with, defined in
some contexts as passing, may influence violence ratings. The EVAS (Violence
and Health Self-Evaluation) study was a cross-sectional study that enrolled
121 trans women between 2019 and 2020 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, aiming to
investigate the association between self-reported passing and different types
of interpersonal violence. We enrolled 121 participants who had a median
age of 36.3 (interquartile range [IQR] 13.7). Most of them were Black/mixed
(78.5%) and had at least a high school education (63%). Most participants
considered themselves as trans women (71.9%). Their median monthly
income was $252.50 (IQR $302.50). Only 40 (33.1%) trans women had a
main partner. Trans women with high passing had a higher prevalence of
family violence and lower prevalence of observed police violence, violence
in open and closed public spaces. Participants that reported a high passing
had higher prevalence of family violence (p = .016); moreover, they reported
observing less frequently police violence in the neighborhood they lived in
for the last 12 months (p = .012) as well as having lower rates of suffering
violence. Trans women who reported high passing had 81% (56%-92%)
lower chance of suffering violence in open public places more than once,
while prior racism experience had a positive association with violence in an
open public place (aOR = 3.93, 95% CI [.48, 15.40]). There is an urgent need
to better understand the complex relationships around violence and foster
its prevention.
Keywords
community violence, domestic violence, cultural contexts, GLBT, hate
crimes Background
Methods
Study Design and Population
The EVAS (Violence and Health Self-Evaluation study) was a cross-sectional
study conducted in a specialized center, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, between
July 2019 and March 2020. Eligible participants were aged 18 or older, self-
identified as trans women or as women who fit under the trans umbrella but
rejected the term “trans woman”, had no previous risk of suicide, depression,
or self-harm registered into their Electronical Medical Record, and were
capable of consenting with the participation. Individuals could participate
only once and could not be enrolled in another study that hindered co-enroll-
ment. Interviewers trained in sensitive and gender issues collected data on
demographics and violent experiences in a private and safe environment
using digitally structured questionnaires. Both institutional review boards of
the INI-FIOCRUZ and the Federal University of the State of Rio de Janeiro
approved the study. All participants provided written consent prior to any
study procedure.
Measures
Ordinal variables were categorized into dichotomous. We collected age as a
continuous variable and further categorized using the mean age of Brazilian
trans women that were murdered as cut-off (Benevides & Nogueira, 2019).
The equivalent to the Brazilian minimal wage served as the cut-off for
monthly income (considering the R$1 = USD 0.25 conversion rate).
Trans women self-rated their passing in response to item “Understanding
that passing is when the transgender person is seen by society as being a cis-
gender person, in this case as a cisgender woman; how often would you say
that you pass?,” with the potential answers: never, rarely, sometimes, very
frequently. In addition, we categorize high passing responses “very fre-
quently”, and low passing when responses were “never”, “rarely,” and
“sometimes.” The option to categorize responses in a dichotomous variable
occurred due to the high concentration of responses in the answer option;
also, all possible cuts and combinations were tested but it did not result in
usable models.
Peixoto et al. 5
Outcome
Interpersonal violence was assessed by using the JuviPool questionnaire
(Ramos & Musumeci, 2009), adapted for trans women during meetings with
trans collaborators between January and April of 2019, which included spe-
cific questions on family, police, acquaintance, and stranger violence, and in
open and closed spaces. Potential answers were never, once, sometimes, and
frequently. For each kind of violence, we tested all potential combinations of
answers using logistic regression. Only the combination comparing once or
less violent experience (0) and more than once (1) fit all the assumptions and
was selected. We also tested the outcome as an ordinal variable, but it did not
comply with its assumptions; we also tried all combination of cut-offs for the
outcome. All other cut-offs than the ones presented possibilities did not fit the
assumptions and could not be used, and thus were suppressed.
Statistical Analysis
Descriptive analysis included absolute and relative frequencies for categori-
cal variables and median and interquartile range (IQR) for numeric variables.
The Shapiro-Wilk normality test evaluated normality for the inferential anal-
ysis. We compared participants with and without violence report by using t
test, Wilcoxon test, Fisher or Chi-square accordingly. We performed linear
binary logistical models using the stepwise method, with a 5% level of sig-
nificance. The verification of the logistic models’ assumptions used the fol-
lowing criteria: (a) Harvey-Collier test in the binary models to evaluate
linearity, (b) Breusch-Pagan test to evaluate the homogeneity of variance, (c)
the variance inflation factor (VIF) to evaluate independence (using <5 as
adequate), and (d) the Hosmer and Lemeshow statistic to assess the fit quality
for binary logistic models. Initial models included age, monthly income, edu-
cation level, and race as effect modifiers for logistic regressions. Final mod-
els passed the assumptions verification. We used R software version 4.0 to
perform all analysis.
Results
We enrolled 121 participants who had a median age of 36.3 (IQR 13.7). Most
of them identified as Black/mixed (78.5%) and most reported at least a high
school education (63%). Most participants self-identified as trans women
(71.9%). Their median monthly income was $252.50 (IQR $ 302.50). Only
40 (33.1%) trans women had a main partner.
6 Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Table 1. continued
Low High Univariate
Characteristic Passing Passing p-value OR
Prior transphobia .108 .53
experiences
Once or less 27 (57.45%) 20 (42.55%)
More than once 53 (71.62%) 21 (38.38%)
Discrimination .240 .77
due to physical
characteristics
Once or less 50 (62.50%) 30 (37.50%)
More than once 30 (73.17%) 11 (26.83%)
Observed police .012 .25
violence in the last 12
months
Once or less 56 (60.21%) 37 (39.79%)
More than once 24 (85.71%) 4 (24.29%)
Observed police .283 .55
corruption in the last
12 months
Once or less 64 (64.00%) 36 (36.00%)
More than once 16 (76.19%) 5 (23.81%)
Physical violence by .469 .68
known person
Once or less 64 (61.54%) 35 (35.36%)
More than once 16 (72.72%) 6 (27.28%)
Physical violence by .109 .49
unknown person
Once or less 51 (61.44%) 32 (38.56%)
More than once 29 (76.31%) 9 (23.69%)
Physical violence by .016 2.77
family
Once or less 65 (72.22%) 25 (27.78%)
More than once 15 (48.38%) 16 (21.62%)
Physical violence in <.001 .18
open public spaces
Once or less 24 (45.28%) 29 (54.72%)
More than once 56 (82.36%) 12 (27.64%)
(continued)
8 Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Table 1. continued
Low High Univariate
Characteristic Passing Passing p-value OR
Physical violence in .010 .36
close public spaces
Once or less 31 (54.39%) 26 (45.61%)
More than once 49 (76.56%) 15 (23.44%)
* p<0.05 in bold, indicating significance.
Discussion
The current analysis identified the influence passing has on violence rates
experienced by Brazilian trans women. Passing very frequently had higher
rates of family violence as well as lower rates of observed police violence and
violence in open and closed public spaces. Our multivariate analysis showed
that passing very frequently reduced in 81% the chance of suffering violence
in open public spaces more than once in the lifetime. This analysis is the first
to address interpersonal violence among trans women in low- and middle-
income settings. Trans women are a highly stigmatized and marginalized
group, especially in transphobic settings. Brazil is the leading country in trans
homicides worldwide (Benevides & Nogueira, 2019). Being female and trans
synergistically interacts leading to exclusion (Lucca & Passamani, 2018).
There is a process of dehumanization, in which society considers trans people
as unhealthy and immoral. Violence against trans people is usually underre-
ported and often justified by conservative groups (Leal & Mendonça, 2019).
Peixoto et al. 9
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge all the EVAS team and participants.
Author Contribution
All authors contributed equally to this work.
Funding
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research,
authorship, and/or publication of this article: Damiana de Figueiredo Bezerra was
granted the Community-extension Program of the University of the State of Rio de
Janeiro, Brazil. Eduardo M. Peixoto received the Graduate Social Demand grant from
Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel, Brazil. Lívia
Machado de Mello Andrade received a scientific initiation grant from National
Council for Scientific and Technological Development, Brazil. Luciana Catarina
Santos de Melo Received a Scientific Initiation Grant from National Council for
Scientific and Technological Development, Brazil. Luciane de Souza Velasque
received a post-doctorate grant from National Council for Scientific and Technological
Development, Brazil. Ricardo de Mattos Russo Rafael was supported by funding
from the Carlos Chagas Filho Research Support Foundation of the state of Rio de
Janeiro and from the Program for Incentives to Scientific, Technical and Artistic
Production of the University of the State of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. (PROCIENCIA/
Peixoto et al. 11
UERJ). Maria Eduarda Dantas Messina received a Scientific Initiation Grant from
National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq).
ORCID iD
Eduardo Mesquita Peixoto https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5699-7290
References
Benevides, B. G., & Nogueira, S. N. B. (2019). Murder report against transvestites
and trans women in Brazil, Brasília: National Association for Transvestites and
Trans Women (NATT), Brazilian Institute of Trans Education (BIT).
Blondeel, K., de Vasconcelos, S., García-Moreno, C., Stephenson, R., Temmerman,
M., & Toskin, I. (2018). Violence motivated by perception of sexual orienta-
tion and gender identity: A systematic review. Bulletin of the World Health
Organization, 96(1), 29–41. http://dx.doi.org/10.2471/BLT.17.197251
Clark, L. (2019). The pressures of passing, reinforced by precedent. City University of
New York Law Review, 22(2), 17–32. https://academicworks.cuny.edu/clr/vol22/
iss2/6
Dahlberg, L. L., & Krug, E. G. (2006). Violence: Global Public Health Problem
Ciência & Saúde Coletiva, 11, 1163–1178. https://doi.org/10.1590 S1413-
81232006000500007
trans Identity on Transvestites and Trans Women Socialization. Revista De Terapia
Ocupacional Da Universidade De São Paulo, 26(3), 364. https://doi:10.11606/
issn.2238-6149.v26i3p364-372
Duque, T. (2017). “”We always have Courage”: Identification, Recognition and ex-
periences of (not) Passing By Man and/or Woman. Cadernos Pagu, 51. https://
doi.org/10.1590/18094449201700510010
Flentje, A., Leon, A., Carrico, A., Zheng, D., & Dilley, J. (2016). Mental and physical
health among homeless sexual and gender minorities in a major urban US city.
Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 93(6),
997–1009. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11524-016-0084-3
Johns, M. M., Lowry, R., Rasberry, C. N., Dunville, R., Robin, L., Pampati, S., Stone,
D. M., & Mercer Kollar, L. M. (2018). Violence victimization, substance use and
suicide risk among sexual minority high school students—United States, 2015-
2017. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 67(43), 1211–1215. http://dx.doi.
org/10.15585/mmwr.mm6743a4
Leal, B. S., & Mendonça, C. C. (2019). Dilemmas of journalistic visibility of violence
against LGBTQ+ people and against heterosexual women in Brazil. RECIIS
(Online), 13(2), 261 -272. https://www.reciis.icict.fiocruz.br/index.php/reciis/
article/view/1707/2272
Lee, C. (2019). The trans panic defense revisited. American Criminal Law Review,
57, 1141. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3481295
12 Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Author Biographies
Eduardo Mesquita Peixoto, RN, is a graduate student at the Federal University of
the State of Rio de Janeiro, Nursing Post-graduation Program.
Davi Gomes Depret, RN, MSc, is a gender and sexuality specialist and Family
Health specialist, assistant professor in Public Health Nursing Department, University
of the State of Rio de Janeiro.
Maria Eduarda Dantas Messina is a nursing student, University of the State of Rio
de Janeiro (UERJ), Scientific Initiation, National Council for Scientific and
Technological Development (CNPq).
Emilia Moreira Jalil, MD, PhD, is a public health researcher at Evandro Chagas
National Institute of Infectious Diseases (Oswaldo Cruz Foundation).
Cláudia de Moura Silva is a flux coordinator for Clinical Research, Chagas National
Institute of Infectious Diseases (Oswaldo Cruz Foundation) and holds a bachelor’s
degree in Social Work.
14 Journal of Interpersonal Violence
Edson José Abas Filho is a library sciences undergraduate student at the Federal
University of the State of Rio de Janeiro and has an Associate degree in Audio/Visual
Production.
Ricardo de Mattos Russo Rafael, RN, PhD, is an adjunct professor in the Public
Health Nursing Department, University of the State of Rio de Janeiro.