Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Muscle Strain Injuries: Current Opinion in Rheumatology April 2000
Muscle Strain Injuries: Current Opinion in Rheumatology April 2000
net/publication/12565405
CITATIONS READS
182 10,415
4 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Study of new therapeutic approaches for skeletal muscle injury View project
Falls among the old population / projects in the UKK Institute View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Tero A H Järvinen on 03 April 2018.
155
156 Nonarticular rheumatism, sports-related injuries, and related conditions
muscle, two different types of hematomas can be identi- Figure 2. A schematic presentation of a shearing injury of
fied: (1) Intramuscular: Intact muscle fascia limits the skeletal muscle
size of the hematoma. In this case, the extravasation of
blood increases the intramuscular pressure, which
compresses and finally limits the size of hematoma.
Clinical findings are pain and loss of function; (2)
Intermuscular hematomas develop if the muscle fascia is
ruptured and the extravasated blood spreads into the
intermuscular spaces without a significant increase in
the pressure within the muscle. The patient may not
experience major pain as long as pressure in the injured
area does not increase.
tal material to form the so-called contraction band, Figure 3. A schematic presentation of fetal development and
which can limit the necrosis to a local process of about regeneration of myofibers via the activation of satellite cells
1.5–2 mm in length (regeneration zone) (Fig. 1) [7].
Inflammation
The blood vessels are also torn in shearing injuries; thus,
blood-borne inflammatory cells gain immediate access
to the injury site [9] (Fig. 2). Later, substances released
from the necrotized parts of myofibers serve as chemoat-
tractants for further extravasation of inflammatory cells
[9]. Macrophages and fibroblasts within the injured
myofibers are also activated and provide additional
chemotactic signals (eg, growth factors) to circulating
inflammatory cells [9,10]. In the acute phase, polymor-
phonuclear leukocytes predominate but are soon
followed by monocytes, which are transformed into
macrophages actively engaged in proteolysis and phago-
cytosis of the necrotic material (Fig. 2) [9,11]. Satellite cells (A2-B2-C-D or A3-B3-C-D) have been set aside underneath the
Remarkably, the basal lamina surrounding the necro- basal lamina during fetal development (A2 and a3), to be used in growth and
tized part of the injured myofiber is resistant to the repair. After injury, committed satellite cells (csc) immediately begin differentia-
tion into myoblasts (mb) without prior cell division (B2), whereas the stem satel-
attack of macrophages; it remains intact and serves as a lite cells (ssc) first divide and thereafter one of the daughter cells differentiates
scaffold inside which the viable satellite cells begin the into a myoblast (B3) and the other one replenishes the pool of stem satellite
formation of new myofibers [11]. cells (B4). Myoblasts fuse into myotubes (mt), which then grow and mature into
myofibers, the sarcoplasm of which becomes filled with contractile filamentous
proteins organized in myofibrils and with myonucei located subsarcolemmally.
An additional complication of muscle injuries is the mpc, myogenic precursor cell.
damage of the intramuscular nerve branches, which leaves
the whole muscle or parts of it denervated (Fig. 1) [7,12].
form with cross-striated bundles of myofilaments and
Repair and remodeling phase peripherally located myonuclei [11].
The healing of muscle strain consists of two simultane-
ous processes: (1) regeneration of the damaged After regenerating myofibers have filled the old basal
myofibers and nerves, and (2) formation of a connective lamina (Fig. 2), they extend out of the opening of the
tissue scar. These two processes are at the same time basal lamina to the connective tissue scar. The emerging
supportive but also competitive with each other [7,13]. muscle cells form multiple branches, tips of which have
the structure of a growth cone [15]. These try to pierce
Regeneration of myofibers through the scar, but after having extended only a rela-
Although myofibers are considered to be irreversibly tively short distance from the opening of the basal
postmitotic, the marked regenerative capacity of skele- lamina, the tips begin to adhere to the connective tissue
tal muscle has been guaranteed already during fetal by forming mini-MTJs. It is known that the intervening
development by the setting aside of undifferentiated scar progressively diminishes in size, and thus the
reserve cells called satellite cells, which lie underneath stumps are brought closer to each other.
the basal lamina of each individual myofiber (Fig. 3).
There are two different populations of satellite cells in Myofiber regeneration continues to the myotube phase
skeletal muscle [14]. One population, called committed without nerve supply, after which atrophy follows, if
satellite cells, is ready to begin differentiation to reinnervation is not accomplished (Fig. 1) [12]. If the
myoblasts immediately after the injury, whereas the axons rupture (neurogenic denervation), the reinnerva-
other population, stem satellite cells, undergoes cell tion requires growth of new axons distal to the rupture.
division(s) before differentiation. By proliferation the On the other hand, because myofibers are innervated at
latter population at the same time replenishes the a single neuromuscular junction (NMJ), rupture usually
reserve of satellite cells for future episodes of regenera- creates an adjunctional stump with preserved contact
tion [14]. Thus, satellite cells proliferate within the with the NMJ, and an abjunctional stump which has
preserved basal lamina of the regeneration zone, differ- become “myogenically” denervated. Reinnervation of
entiate to myoblasts, and thereafter fuse with each other the abjunctional myofiber stumps requires sprouting of
into multinucleated myotubes. They also fuse with the healthy axons, their penetration across the scar
surviving parts of the injured myofiber. Finally, the tissue, and the formation of new NMJs on the dener-
regenerating parts of myofibers acquire their mature vated myofiber stump (Fig. 1) [12].
158 Nonarticular rheumatism, sports-related injuries, and related conditions
Formation of the connective tissue scar regeneration of multinucleated myofibers [25]. Therefore,
The gap between the ruptured muscle fibers is filled by the regeneration of muscle fibers does not progress from
a hematoma. Within the first day the hematoma is the myotube stage unless capillary ingrowth provides
invaded by inflammatory cells, including phagocytes, enough oxygen for aerobic metabolism [23,25].
which begin disposal of the blood clot [9,15]. Blood-
derived fibrin and fibronectin cross-link to form a Adhesion of myofibers to the extracellular matrix
primary matrix, which acts as a scaffold and anchorage In normal skeletal muscle, the ends of each fiber are
site for the invading fibroblasts and gives the initial attached to either a tendon or a fascia by specialized
strength to the scar to withstand the forces applied on it MTJs, constructed to withstand considerable loads. The
(Fig. 2). Fibroblasts begin to synthesize proteins as well binding of the myofibers (in essence of the sarcoplasmic
as proteoglycans of the extracellular matrix (ECM) contractile myofilaments) to the ECM is mediated by
[16–19]. Fibronectin is expressed among the first ECM two main chains of molecules: (1) an integrin, and (2) a
proteins, followed by type III collagen. The production dystrophin-associated chain [7,26,27••].
of type I collagen is activated later and remains elevated
for several weeks [16–19]. When myofibers are breached, the upregulation of inte-
grin-associated molecules appears to be the “first aid” in
From the time of injury until days 10–12, the scar is the reestablishing adhesion between myofibers and ECM.
weakest point of the injured muscle [20•], but thereafter Integrin-associated molecules are incorporated in the
the rupture occurs within myofibers next to the newly plasma membrane along the sides of the breached
formed mini-MTJs [26]. Subsequently, increase in the fibers, which reinforces lateral adhesion to surrounding
tensile strength of the scar takes place simultaneously endomysium at the early phase, when the tips of the
with the production of type I collagen [17,20]. The stumps are still growing into the scar tissue [27••].
mechanical stability of the collagen, in turn, is based on Later, and most important, mini-MTJs are formed at the
the formation of intermolecular cross-links [21]. After tips of regenerating stumps with clustering of integrin-
maturation of the scar, rupture usually occurs within the associated and dystrophin-associated molecules at these
regenerating myofibers near the proximal/distal attach- new mini-MTJs [7,27••]. At the same time, dystrophin-
ment line to the scar (ie, next to the newly formed mini- associated molecules become responsible for lateral
MTJs). However, the scar and the muscle do not reach adhesion in the regeneration zone. Thus, strong termi-
normal strength until weeks after the injury, indicating nal adhesions employing exactly the same adhesion
that a long time is needed until the strength of the molecules as normal MTJs are established at the ends of
muscle is completely restored [13,20,22]. the stumps [27••]. Thus the single (preinjury) tendon-
myofiber-tendon unit becomes replaced by two units of
Connective tissue transmits contraction forces across the tendon-muscle-mini-MTJ units separated by the scar;
gap, allowing the use of the injured limb before the whether myofibers will ever be able to fuse across the
repair process is completed. However, proliferation of scar is not known.
fibroblasts can rapidly lead to an excessive formation of
scar tissue, creating a mechanical barrier that restricts Effects of immobilization and remobilization
and delays regeneration of muscle and nerve fibers on the healing process
across the injury gap [13,22]. An attempt should be Current opinion is that early mobilization is the method
made to prevent this by limiting the size of the of choice in the treatment of muscle ruptures [2]. Early
hematoma by adequate immediate treatment of the mobilization induces more rapid and intensive capillary
injured muscle (see below). ingrowth to injured area, as well as better muscle fiber
regeneration and orientation than other forms of
Vascularization of the injured muscle therapy [2,13,23]. More important, the functional prop-
The key step in the regeneration of injured muscle erties of injured muscle return sooner to the normal
tissue is the vascularization of the injured area [7,23–25]. level [22].
The restoration of vascular supply is a prerequisite for
the regeneration of injured muscle [23]. The new capil- Mobilization started immediately after the injury often
laries sprout from surviving trunks of blood vessels and causes reruptures at the original injury site. However,
pierce toward the center of injured area [23], providing reruptures can be avoided by immobilizing the injured
adequate oxygen supply in the regenerating area [24]. muscle immediately after the injury [13,17,21,22].
Immobilization allows the newly formed granulation
Young myotubes have only a few mitochondria and a tissue to reach sufficient tensile strength to withstand
moderate aerobic metabolism, but strongly increased the forces created by contracting muscle [17,22].
activity of anaerobic metabolism [25]. However, aerobic Although short immobilization is beneficial in the
metabolism is the major energy pathway during the final early phase of muscle regeneration, long immobiliza-
Muscle strain injuries Järvinen et al. 159
tion causes significant atrophy of healthy myofibers Elevation of the injured extremity decreases blood flow
and has a tendency to reduce the tensile strength to the injury site and increases venous return, thus further
[13,17,22]. Therefore, the immobilization period limiting the size of the hematoma. The rest period
should be kept as short as possible, ie, only the first provides an adequate immobilization period and should
few days immediately after the injury [2]. Active mobi- last 1 to 5 days, depending on the severity of injury. Use
lization started right after the first few days provides of crutches is recommended in severe injuries, as well as
ideal conditions for regeneration and the best final when injuries are located at sites (like the groin area)
outcome [2,13,17,22]. where immobilization can not be otherwise attained [6].
Deciding upon the right time to start active remobiliza- Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
tion after the muscle strain can be difficult for the physi- Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) should
cian. This decision can, however, be based on two be a part of early treatment and should be started imme-
simple and inexpensive measures: the ability to stretch diately after the injury [30–34•]. Short-term use of
the injured muscle as much as the healthy contralateral NSAIDs in the early phase of healing decreases the
muscle, and the pain-free use of injured muscle in basic inflammatory cell reaction [31], and has no adverse effects
movements. When this critical point is reached, the on tensile or contractile properties of injured muscle
patient should be encouraged to start active, progressive [31,33]. Although the use of NSAIDs in the treatment of
mobilization [2,6]. muscle injuries can be recommended [30–34•], glucocor-
ticoids lead to a delayed elimination of hematoma and
Treatment of muscle injuries necrotic tissue as well as retarded muscle regeneration.
Immediate treatment Therefore, their use is contraindicated [31,35•].
The immediate treatment for muscle strain is known as
the RICE principle: Rest, Ice (cold), Compression, and Therapeutic ultrasound
Elevation. These four procedures have the same objec- Therapeutic ultrasound is widely recommended and
tive: to minimize bleeding from ruptured blood vessels to used in the treatment of muscle strains, although no
rupture site. This will prevent the formation of a large clinical evidence exists on its effectiveness.
hematoma, which has a direct impact on the size of scar Experimental studies are not encouraging: although
tissue at the end of the regeneration. A small hematoma therapeutic ultrasound promotes the proliferation phase
and the limitation of interstitial edema accumulation on of myoregeneration, it does not have a significant effect
the rupture site also shorten the ischemic period in the on the final outcome [36•].
granulation tissue, which in turn accelerates regeneration.
Hyperbaric oxygen
After the initial treatment during the first few days, the Experimentally, adequate restitution of the blood
contractile status of the injured muscle should be re- supply to the injured area is the first sign of the regener-
examined. If it has not improved from the original ation and the requirement for restoration of injured
postinjury level, the possibility of large intramuscular muscle [23–25]. Indeed, it was recently presented in
hematoma or total rupture of the muscle should be rabbits that hyperbaric oxygen therapy during the early
suspected. Measurement of intramuscular pressure, phase of the repair substantially improves the final
puncture and aspiration of the injured area (if fluctua- outcome [37••]. Clinical studies to prove the efficacy of
tion is present), ultrasonography or magnetic resonance hyperbaric oxygen therapy in the treatment of soft
imaging examination, and sometimes even surgical tissue injuries in sports are still lacking, but this therapy
intervention may be necessary. is a fascinating possible option to speed up muscle
regeneration [37••,40].
Compression
A compression bandage reduces the size of an intramus- Operative treatment
cular hematoma [28]. Compression should be applied Surgical treatment of muscle injuries should be reserved
immediately after the muscle injury (in the field), even in for the most serious injuries, because in most cases conser-
cases when injury is just suspected (diagnosis can await vative treatment results in a good outcome. Surgical treat-
the immediate care!). Together with the compression, ment is indicated only in cases of (1) large intramuscular
cold should be applied to the injured area (ice packs), hematomas, (2) third-degree strains or tears of muscles
and should last for 15 to 20 minutes and be repeated at with few or no agonist muscles, and (3) second-degree
intervals of 30 to 60 minutes. Experimentally, early strains, if more than half of the muscle belly is torn [6,38].
cryotherapy has beneficial effects: it is followed by a
significantly smaller hematoma between ruptured Experimental studies suggest that in the most severe
myofiber stumps, less inflammation, and somewhat cases, the operative treatment may be of benefit
accelerated regeneration [29]. [32••,38], especially when the gap (diastasis) between
160 Nonarticular rheumatism, sports-related injuries, and related conditions
the stumps is long. By surgically bringing the stumps 6 Kujala U.M, Orava S, Järvinen M: Hamstring injuries: Current trends in treat-
ment and prevention. Sports Med 1997, 23:397–404.
closer to each other, the surgeon improves circum-
stances [20•,32••,38]. Surgery can eliminate the devel- 7 Kalimo H, Rantanen J, Järvinen M: Muscle injuries in sports. Bailliere’s Clin
Orthop 1997 (special issue), 2:1–24.
opment of extensive scar tissue within the muscle tissue
8 Garrett WE Jr, Safran MR, Seaber AV, Glisson RR, Ribbeck BM:
and facilitate the reinnervation of the myogenically Biomechanical comparison of stimulated and nonstimulated skeletal
denervated stumps (see above) [32••]. muscle pulled to failure. Am J Sports Med 1987, 15:448–454.
9 Tidball JG: Inflammatory cell response to acute muscle injury. Med Sci
Sports Exercise 1995, 27:1022–1032.
Treatment after 3 to 5 days
After the primary treatment, 3 to 5 days after the injury, 10 Cantini M, Carraro U: Macrophage-released factor stimulates selectively
myogenic cells in primary muscle cultures. J Neuropath Exp Neurology
lesser partial ruptures and intramuscular hematomas 1995, 54:121–128.
should be supported with elastic bandage and early 11 Hurme T, Kalimo H: Activation of myogenic precursor cells after muscle
mobilization of the injured muscle carefully started in injury. Med Sci Sports Exercise 1992, 24:197–205.
the following order: 12 Rantanen J, Ranne J, Hurme T, Kalimo H: Denervated segments of injured
skeletal muscle fibres are reinnervated by newly formed neuromuscular
junctions. J Neuropath Exp Neurol 1995, 54:188–194.
1. First, isometric training without load, and later
13 Järvinen M: Healing of a crush injury in rat striated muscle. 2. A histological
with increasing load within the limits of pain. study of the effect of early mobilization and immobilization on the repair
2. Cautious and controlled isotonic training with and processes. Acta Pathologica Microbiologica Scand 1975, 83A:269–282.
without load. Isokinetic dynamic training with 14 Rantanen J, Ranne J, Hurme T, Kalimo H: Satellite cell proliferation and
expression of myogenin and desmin in regenerating skeletal muscle:
minimal load can also be started early (requires evidence for two different populations of satellite cells. Lab Invest 1995,
special equipment). 72:341–347.
3. Local heat or contrast treatment (ie, alternating 15 Hurme T, Kalimo H, Lehto M, Järvinen M: Healing of skeletal muscle injury.
An ultrastructural and immunohistochemical study. Med Sci Sports
cold and heat) may be of value, accompanied with Exercise 1991, 23:801–810.
careful passive and active stretching of the affected 16 Hurme T, Kalimo H, Sandberg M, Lehto M, Vuorio E: Localization of type I
muscle within the limits of pain. and III collagen and fobronectin production in injured gastrocnemius
muscle. Lab Invest 1991, 64:76–84.
A carefully structured rehabilitation program accelerates 17 Lehto M, Duance VC, Restall D: Collagen and fibronectin in a healing
skeletal muscle injury: an immunohistochemical study of the effects of
recovery. All physical rehabilitation activities should physical activity on the repair of injured gastrocnemius muscle in the rat. J
start with warming-up of the injured muscle, which Bone Joint Surg 1985, 67B:820–828.
reduces muscle viscoelasticity and relaxes muscles 18 Lehto M, Järvinen M: Collagen and glycosaminoglycan synthesis of injured
gastrocnemius muscle in rat. Eur Surg Res 1985, 17:179–185.
neurally. Stimulated (warm) muscles absorb more energy
during physical exercise than unstimulated muscles and, 19 Lehto M, Järvinen M, Nelimarkka O: Scar formation after skeletal muscle
injury: A histological and autoradiographical study in rats. Arch Orthop
thus, the risk of reruptures is reduced [1,39]. The other Trauma Surg 1986, 104:366–370.
purpose of the stretching is to distend the scar tissue 20 Kääriäinen M, Kääriäinen J, Järvinen TLN, Sievänen H, Kalimo H, Järvinen
while it is still plastic. Painless elongation can be gradu- • M: Correlation between biomechanical and structural changes during the
regeneration of skeletal muscle after laceration injury. J Orthop Res 1998,
ally achieved by stretching at first for 10 to 15 seconds, 16:197–206.
with gradual prolongation up to 1 minute. It is important Comparison of biomechanics and morphology in injured skeletal muscle.
that the patient always warm up before stretching. This 21 Lehto M, Sims TJ, Bailey AJ: Skeletal muscle injury: molecular changes in
the collagen during healing. Res Exp Med 1985, 185:95–106.
will minimize the risk of reruptures [1,39].
22 Järvinen M: Healing of a crush injury in rat striated muscle. 4. Effect of early
mobilization and immobilization on the tensile properties of gastrocnemius
References and recommended reading muscle. Acta Chirurgica Scand 1976, 142:47–56.
Papers of particular interest, published within the annual period of review, 23 Järvinen M: Healing of a crush injury in rat striated muscle. 3. A microangio-
have been highlighted as: graphical study of the effect of early mobilization and immobilization on
• Of special interest capillary ingrowth. Acta Pathologica Microbiologica Scand 1976,
•• Of outstanding interest 84A:85–94.
24 Józsa L, Reffy A, Demel Z, Szilagyi I: Alterations of oxygen and carbon
1 Garrett WE: Muscle strain injuries. Am J Sports Med 1996, 24:S2–S8.
dioxide tensions in crush-injured calf muscles of rat. Zeitschrift
2 Järvinen M, Lehto MUK: The effect of early mobilization and immobilization Experimentelle Chirurgie 1980, 13:91–94.
on the healing process following muscle injuries. Sports Med 1993,
25 Järvinen M, Sorvari T: A histochemical study of the effect of mobilization
15:78–89.
and immobilization on the metabolism of healing muscle injury. In Sports
3 Crisco JJ, Jokl P, Heinen GT, Connell MD, Panjabi MM: A muscle contu- Medicine. Edited by Landry F, Orban WAR. Miami: Symposia Specialists,
sion injury model: biomechanics, physiology, and histology. Am J Sports 1978:177–181.
Med 1994, 22:702–710.
26 Hurme T, Kalimo H: Adhesion in skeletal muscle regeneration. Muscle
4 Thorsson O, Lilja B, Nilsson P, Westlin N: Comparing ultrasonography, Nerve 1992, 15:482–489.
magnetic resonance imaging and scintigraphy in evaluating an experimentally
induced muscular hematoma. Scand J Med Sci Sports 1993, 3:110–116. 27 Kääriäinen M, Kääriäinen J, Järvinen TLN, Nissinen L, Heino J, Järvinen M,
•• Kalimo H: Integrin and dystrophin associated adhesion protein complexes
5 Thorsson O, Lilja B, Nilsson P, Westlin N: Ultrasound examination of soft have complementary functions during regeneration of shearing-type muscle
tissue injury of the lower limb in athletes. Am J Sports Med 1993, injury. Neuromusc Dis 1999, in press.
20:601–603. Description of the adhesion of injured muscle fibers to the scar.
Muscle strain injuries Järvinen et al. 161
28 Thorsson O, Hemdal B, Lilja B, Westlin N: The effect of external pressure 35 Beiner JM, Jokl P, Cholewicki J, Panjabi MM: The effects of anabolic
on intramuscular blood flow at rest and after running. Med Sci Sports • steroids and corticosteroids on healing of muscle contusion injury. Am J
Exercise 1987, 19:469–473. Sports Med 1999, 27:2–9.
Description of the effects of anabolic steroids and corticosteroids in the injured
29 Hurme T, Rantanen J, Kalimo H: Effects of early cryotherapy in experimental
skeletal muscle.
skeletal muscle injury. Scand J Med Sci Sports 1993, 3:46–51.
30 Almekinders LC: Anti-inflammatory treatment of muscular injuries in sports. 36 Rantanen J, Thorsson O, Wollmer P, Hurme T, Kalimo H: Effects of thera-
Sports Med 1993, 15:139–145. • peutic ultrasound on the regeneration of skeletal muscle myofibers after
experimental muscle injury. Am J Sports Med 1999, 27:54–59.
31 Järvinen M, Lehto M, Sorvari T, Mikola A: Effect of some anti-inflammatory A study on the therapeutic ultrasound in the treatment of skeletal muscle injury.
agents on the healing of ruptured muscle: an experimental study in rats. J
Sports Traumatol 1992, 14:19–28. 37 Best TM, Loitz-Ramage B, Corr DT, Vanderby R Jr: Hyperbaric oxygen in
•• the treatment of acute muscle stretch injuries: results in an animal model.
32 Menetrey J, Kasemkijwattana C, Fu FH, Moreland MS, Huard J: Suturing
Am J Sports Med 1998, 26:367–372.
•• versus immobilization of a muscle laceration: a morphological and func-
tional study in a mouse model. Am J Sports Med 1999, 27:222–229. A study of hyperbaric oxygen therapy.
Excellent study on the operative treatment of muscle injury.
38 Almekinders LC: Results of surgical repair versus splinting of experimen-
33 Obremsky WT, Seaber AV, Ribbeck BM, Garrett WE Jr: Biochemical and tally transected muscle. J Orthopaedic Trauma 1991, 5:173–176.
histological assessment of a controlled muscle strain injury treated with
piroxicam. Am J Sports Med 1994, 22:558–561. 39 Noonan TJ, Best TM, Seaber AV, Garrett Jr WE: Thermal effects on skele-
tal muscle behavior. Am J Sports Med 1993, 21:517–522.
34 Thorsson O, Rantanen J, Hurme T, Kalimo H: Effects of nonsteroidal anti-
• inflammatory medication on satellite cell proliferation during muscle 40 Research Committee on the AOSSM: Hyperbaric oxygen therapy in sports
contraction. Am J Sports Med 1998, 26:172–176. •• [editorial]. Am J Sports Med 1998, 26:489–490.
NSAIDs in the early phase of the muscle regeneration. Current opinion on hyperbaric oxygen therapy in sports medicine.