Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reactions of Nitrate Salts With Ammonia in Supercritical Water
Reactions of Nitrate Salts With Ammonia in Supercritical Water
Los Alamos National Laboratory, Mail Stops C920 and J567, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545, and
Department of Environmental and Water Resources Engineering, The University of Texas at Austin,
Austin, Texas 78712
Reactions involving nitrate salts and ammonia were investigated in supercritical water at
temperatures from 450 to 530 °C and pressures near 300 bar. Reaction products included nitrite,
nitrogen gas, and nitrous oxide. Observed reaction rates and product distributions provided
evidence for a free-radical reaction mechanism with NO2, NO, and NH2• as the primary reactive
species at supercritical conditions. In the proposed elementary mechanism, the rate-limiting
reaction step was determined to be the hydrolysis of MNO3 species, which resulted in the
formation of nitric acid and subsequently NO2. A simple second-order reaction model was used
to represent the data. In developing an empirical kinetic model, nitrate and nitrite were lumped
as an NOx- reactant. Empirical kinetic parameters were developed for four MNOx/NH3 reacting
systems, assuming first orders in both NH3 and NOx-. Observed MNOx/NH3 reaction rates and
mechanisms suggest immediately a practical significance of these reactions for nitrogen control
strategies in supercritical water oxidation processes.
Experimental Approach tions were fed from collapsible polyethylene bags with
zero headspace to eliminate volatilization losses. Flow
Kinetics experiments were performed in the reactor rates of nitrate/nitrite feed streams were determined by
shown schematically in Figure 1. The primary feature measuring the mass loss of the solution over time. The
of this apparatus was a fluidized sandbath, which total volumetric flow rate was measured at the reactor
served to preheat feed streams and provide an isother- exit, using a calibrated graduated cylinder and a
mal reaction zone. Reactant feeds were separately stopwatch. The flow rate of the ammonium hydroxide
preheated prior to entering the sandbath using auxiliary solution was calculated by difference from the measured
clamshell heaters. Reactant streams were further flow rates. Reactor residence times were determined
heated to reaction temperature in the sandbath. The knowing the measured flow rate, reactor volume, and
preheated streams were mixed at a tee. A coiled piece water density at reaction conditions (Haar et al., 1984).
of tubing (alloy C276, 6.35 mm o.d. × 2.11 mm i.d. The system was brought to temperature while flowing
(reactors A and C); alloy 625, 6.35 × 2.11 mm (reactor deionized water through the tubing as the sandbath
B)) leading from the mixing tee served as an isothermal heated. When the pressure and temperature were
reactor. The total volumes of reactors A-C were 13.1 stable, the deionized water was switched to feed solu-
( 0.25, 12.3 ( 0.25, and 12.2 ( 0.25 cm3, respectively. tions. After approximately 30 min, sampling of the
These values were determined experimentally (Dell’Orco, effluent was initiated. For each residence time, three
1994) and differed by as much as 10% from volumes sets of 40 cm3 quadruplicate samples were taken. Upon
calculated using quoted tubing diameters. Reaction the completion of sampling at a residence time, flow
quench was achieved with a heat exchanger placed at rates were adjusted to provide a new residence time;
the reactor exit from the sandbath. The small uncer- the system was then equilibrated for 30 min, and
tainty in the reactor volume arises from an uncertainty samples were collected for this new condition. Effluent
in the exact point of reaction quench. samples were typically collected at five residence times.
Following the quench, the reacted stream was filtered For ammonium hydroxide/sodium nitrate/nitrite reac-
and then reduced to atmospheric pressure with a tions and for sodium nitrate decomposition studies, each
backpressure regulator (Tescom). Eleven thermo- set of four samples was analyzed for pH, nitrate, nitrite,
couples (type K) monitored surface and fluid tempera- ammonium, sodium, and potential reactor corrosion
tures in the preheaters and the reactor. An Inconel- products, iron, chromium, molybdenum, and nickel. This
sheathed thermocouple, in contact with the fluid at the approach to sampling and analysis provided three true
mixing tee, provided the primary determination of replicates, from which combined experimental and
reaction temperature. Surface thermocouples placed at analytical error could be estimated.
various positions on the reactor tube were within 1-2 One gas sample was collected at each residence time.
°C of the fluid temperature at the mixing tee. Pressure Gas sampling was accomplished by diverting the efflu-
was measured with transducers (Ashcroft, K1) placed ent to a gas-liquid separator consisting of a 2.54 cm
near the pump outlet and immediately preceding the o.d. stainless steel vessel (100 cm3 volume) previously
backpressure regulator. evacuated to less than 0.1 Torr. Later, a gas-liquid
Feed streams were pumped to the apparatus with separator with a 150 cm3 volume was used. Additional
low-pulse, high-performance liquid chromatography details of the gas sampling apparatus have been pre-
(HPLC) feed pumps (LDC Constametric 3000), which sented elsewhere (Dell’Orco et al., 1995a). Gases evolved
accurately metered flow from 0 to 10 cm3/min for each from approximately 80 cm3 of effluent were collected in
feed stream. Feed solutions were prepared daily using an evacuated gas sample cylinder and analyzed by gas
analytical-grade reagents. Ammonium hydroxide solu- chromatography (GC). Some samples were analyzed
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 7, 1997 2549
qualitatively using mass spectrometry. Because the
water used to prepare the reactant solutions contained
dissolved oxygen and nitrogen from equilibration with
air at ambient temperature (25 °C), a background gas
sample was collected, and the quantities of nitrogen and
oxygen in this sample were subtracted from those
measured for gas samples. The absolute yield of
gaseous products was determined from the known
effluent volume, gas volume, and partial pressures.
Gas products were analyzed with a gas chromato-
graph, using a Chrompack CarboPLOT column (30 m
long × 0.53 mm i.d.) with carbon molecular sieve
adsorbent, helium carrier gas, and a thermal conductiv-
ity detector. The GC unit was an HP 5890A Series II,
operated with HP ChemStation software control from
a 80386 based computer. This arrangement allowed the
detection of nitrogen, oxygen, carbon monoxide, carbon
dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide. A quadrapole
mass spectrometer (Balzer) was used to qualitatively Figure 2. Reaction products for NaNO3/NH4OH reactants at 500
determine the presence of NO and NO2 in gas samples. °C and 300 bar. Experiment performed using reactor A.
Nitrate and nitrite were measured with ion chromatog-
raphy (IC), using a bicarbonate/carbonate eluent and a rately preheated prior to mixing. For the most part,
Dionex IonPac AS4 column, on a PC-controlled Dionex reactions were performed at equimolar nitrate/ammonia
4500i Series ion chromatograph. Ion chromatography concentrations (3-10 mM). Hydrogen peroxide was
standards were prepared daily. Ammonia was analyzed used for some experiments as a cooxidant. Concentra-
first with a gas-sensing electrode (Orion 95-12), using tion and pH data provided in the following discussion
an ionic strength adjuster (ISA) containing 5 M NaOH, are values at ambient conditions.
0.05 M EDTA, and 10% methanol. Calibrations for the
Alkali Nitrate/Ammonium Hydroxide Reactions
electrode were performed with standards prepared
and Alkali Nitrate Decomposition. Typical trends
daily. Later, ammonium was analyzed using the Dionex
of reaction products for MNO3/NH3 reactions are il-
4500i ion chromatograph, using a CS2 column, mem-
lustrated in Figure 2 for an NaNO3/NH3 experiment,
brane suppression, and a dilute acid eluent. Am-
performed at 500 °C. Observed reaction products
monium IC standards were prepared daily. All metals
included nitrogen and nitrous oxide gases, and nitrite
were measured by inductively coupled plasma spec-
ion. As nitrate and ammonia concentrations decreased,
trometry. Mass balances were performed using nitrate,
the concentrations of nitrogen gas, nitrous oxide, and
nitrite, ammonia, nitrogen, and nitrous oxide data.
nitrite ion increased. Nitrogen gas was the primary
reaction product, while N2O was only produced in small
Data and Results quantities. The mass balance for this experiment (102%
Reaction kinetics results from four separate NH4X/ of nitrogen recovered as products) indicated that all
MNO3 (M+ ) monovalent cation, e.g., Na+; X- ) reaction products were identified. These data im-
monovalent anion, e.g., Cl-) systems are reported here: mediately indicate the utility of MNO3/NH3 reactions
NaNO3/NH3, LiNO3/NH3, HNO3/NH3, and NaNO3/NH4- for the conversion of ammonia and nitrate to benign
Cl. In addition, NaNO3 decomposition was also inves- gaseous products at moderate reaction temperature/
tigated. Experiments were performed to determine the residence time conditions.
effect of the cation M+ or the anion X- on product yields In addition to the main reaction of interest, MNO3
and reaction rates and to aid in the elucidation of with NH3 to produce benign gaseous products, other
elementary reaction mechanisms. Most reactions were parallel reactions were found to occur. One parallel
conducted at a constant pressure (300 ( 5 bar), at reaction of particular importance was the reduction of
temperatures from 450 to 530 °C (except for NH4Cl/ sodium nitrate to sodium nitrite, and eventually to NO,
NaNO3 and HNO3/NH4OH experiments). Assuming a apparently through the oxidation of reactor walls (e.g.,
negligible effect of the dilute reactants on bulk super- corrosion). These results are illustrated in Figure 3,
critical water properties, experimental conditions re- which compares similar experiments performed using
sulted in water densities from 150 to 80 kg/m3, a reactors A and B. The difference in decomposition
dielectric constant varying between 1 and 2 (Uematsu reactions is evident by the lower nitrate and higher
and Franck, 1980), and a water ion product ranging nitrite concentrations reported for the reactor B experi-
from 10-20 to 10-23 mol/kg (Quist, 1970). Based on the ment, at the same residence time and temperature. In
known properties of supercritical water (Franck, 1970; addition, mass spectrometry analysis identified NO as
Marshall and Frantz, 1987), these reaction conditions a reaction product for the reactor B experiment indi-
favor ion association over dissociation (Mesmer et al., cated in Figure 3. This nitrate decomposition is impor-
1988) and free radical reaction mechanisms over ionic tant to dispel the common assertion that NO production
reaction mechanisms (Xu et al., 1990; Antal et al., 1988; cannot occur in supercritical water environments at
Holgate and Tester, 1993). Reactants used in this moderate temperatures. This assertion, although likely
research would, in most cases, be expected to be in the valid for prompt and thermal NO evolution mechanisms,
associated form, i.e., MNOx(aq) and NH3(aq). may not be true for fuel NO mechanisms (for a descrip-
Concentrations of nitrate salts were chosen such that tion of NO formation mechanisms in combustion, see
these values were less than solubility thresholds re- Miller and Bowman, 1989).
ported in the literature (Dell’Orco et al., 1995b). Except The explanation for this decomposition phenomenon
where stated, NH4X and MNO3 solutions were sepa- is that reactors A and B had quite different histories,
2550 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 7, 1997
Using the solver function in Excel 4.0, values of AR, Figure 10; this may indicate that the stoichiometric
Ea, and b were optimized such that the following coefficient b has a slight dependence on reaction tem-
variation of the χ2 statistic was minimized: perature. From Table 2, it is evident that nearly all
reactions are equally activated; this may indicate that
N (XA,i(expt) - XA,i(model))2 all MNO3/NH3 reactions share a common rate-limiting
χ ) 2
∑
i)1 Wi
+ step, despite exhibiting different overall reaction kinet-
ics. The NH4Cl/NaNO3 model has a significantly higher
frequency factor than the MNO3/NH4OH data sets,
N (XB,i(expt) - XB,i(model))2 perhaps indicating that this MNO3/NH4X reaction pro-
∑
i)1 Wi
(3) ceeds without the inhibition present in elevated pH
experiments.
In this equation, XA/B,i(expt) represents experimentally Discussion of Reaction Mechanism
determined conversions for the ith observation, while
XA/B,i(model) represents the model prediction of the con- MNO3/NH3 reactions have been studied in aqueous,
version for the ith observation. Wi represents a weight- gas, and liquid melt phases. Aqueous- and melt-phase
ing factor, which is the standard deviation of experi- reaction mechanisms at temperatures below 200 °C
mentally observed conversion. proceed ionically through a nitronium ion intermediate
Parameters were determined for three different data (Friedman and Bigeleisen, 1950). The nitronium ion
sets. These included data collected for reactor A (NaNO3/ (NO2+), formed by Brönsted acid equilibria, electrophili-
NH3 and NaNO3/NH4Cl, alloy C276, no cooxidant, cally nitrates ammonia to form nitramine and water;
reactions), reactor B (alloy 625, equimolar H2O2, NaNO3/ at temperatures above ambient, nitramine rapidly
NH3 reactions), and reactor C (LiNO3/NH3, equimolar decomposes to N2O and H2O. A similar mechanism
H2O2). No constraints were placed on the values that occurs in nitrite-ammonia reactions, through the ni-
the estimated variables could assume. Different initial trosonium ion (NO+) intermediate, to form N2 and H2O
guesses for AR, Ea, and b reduced the chance that (Feick and Hainer, 1954).
solutions were not simply local minima. Studies of NH4NO3 decomposition in the pure-
Table 2 shows the values of the variables obtained component melt phase have been determined to undergo
for the different data sets. Also included in the table an ionic to free-radical reaction mechanism change at
are a comparison of calculated rate constants at 500 °C, temperatures near 290 °C (Brower et al., 1989). The
and the χ2 statistic for the data sets, defined as ionic melt-phase mechanism is essentially the same as
that observed in acidic, aqueous solutions (i.e., through
Xiexpt - Ximodel a nitronium ion intermediate). The free-radical mech-
2
χ ) ∑i N-K-1
(4) anism involves the decomposition of NH4NO3 to HNO3
and NH3, followed by the homolysis of nitric acid to form
OH• and NO2. After the OH• abstracts a hydrogen from
where N is the number of data points and K is the ammonia, NO2 and NH2 react to form nitramine. As
number of adjustable parameters used to fit the data; with the ionic mechanism, the nitramine decomposes
for the proposed model, K ) 3. The table shows that to form N2O and water.
the three MNO3/NH3 data sets have similar adjustable An immediate difference between previous aqueous-
parameters. Rate constants at 500 °C are of the same and melt-phase results and this research is the fact that
magnitude. Small discrepancies in kinetic parameters N2, not N2O, is formed as the primary reaction product.
may simply be due to differences in the reactors used; This behavior was observed for experiments performed
rate parameters are similar for sodium and lithium. The with and without added oxidant (as H2O2). Two possible
NaNO3/NH4Cl model, while having an activation energy explanations can be provided to explain this behavior.
similar to those of the MNO3/NH4OH data sets, had a Either nitrous oxide is initially formed through an ionic
substantially higher preexponential factor and a much or melt free-radical mechanism and then reacts quickly
higher 500 °C rate constant than the other data sets. to form molecular nitrogen and atomic oxygen or
This is consistent with experimental observations. nitrogen is initially formed by a different mechanism,
A graphical comparison of experimental observations with a small side reaction leading to N2O formation.
with model predictions is shown in Figure 10. Overall, Possibilities for nitrous oxide conversion to N2 include
the model prediction is within error of the experimental unimolecular decomposition by collision with third
observation, and the simple second order rate expression bodies (i.e., water), hydrogen abstraction reactions with
appears to adequately represent the data. In fact, the ammonia to form N2, OH• and NHx• species, and
second-order model produced lower χ2 values than zero- oxidation reactions, such as NaNO2 oxidation to form
or first-order models. A slightly S-shaped curve is N2 and NaNO3. From the observation of HNO3/NH3 and
evident in the ammonia conversion comparisons in NH4NO3 experiments (exeriments H1-H5), where NH3
2554 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 7, 1997
Figure 10. Comparison of experimentally observed conversions with model predictions. Reactants and reactors used are indicated in
the upper right-hand corner of each plot. Points falling on the dotted line exhibit perfect agreement between the experimental observation
and the model prediction.
conversions were near complete from 425 to 475 °C with following reaction mechanism for describing the system:
no change in N2/N2O selectivity, it can be concluded that
the decomposition of N2O via reactions with water, NH3 + NO2 T NH2• + HNO2 (7)
molecular oxygen and its radical species, and nitrite was
not significant in this temperature range. Because NH2• + NO2 T NH• + HNO2 (8)
ammonia was depleted at these conditions, reactions
with ammonia could not be discounted. Further inves-
tigations have indicated that N2O is unreactive with NH• + NO2 T HNO + NO (9)
NH3 at temperatures up to 600 °C at 300 bar (Masten,
1993). 2NHO T N2O + H2O (10)
Gas-phase reactions between NO2 and NH3 have been
shown to form N2 as a primary reaction product (Oden- NH2• + NO T N2 + H2O (11)
brand et al., 1986). In studies involving heteroge-
neously catalyzed NO2/NH3 reactions, global reactions A difference between the supercritical water reactions
shown by reactions (5) and (6) were observed. These and these gas-phase results is that the SCW reactions
are all most likely at their high-pressure limit. As a
6NO2 + 8NH3 f 7N2 + 12H2O (5) result, species such as HNO2 are likely unstable at
supercritical water conditions. Nonetheless, the gas-
2NO2 + 2NH3 f N2 + N2O + NH4NO3 (6) phase results presented above qualitatively agree with
the NOx/NH3 reaction stoichiometries and N2/N2O se-
reactions resulted in NO2/NH3 stoichiometries of 1.33 lectivities observed in this work.
at 302 °C and 1.22 at 252 °C, due to differences in For supercritical water reactions, a simplified reaction
reaction branching at the different temperatures. mechanism which considers these gas-phase results is
Gas-phase NO2/NH3 reactions were studied in more suggested by reactions (12)-(19). In this mechanism,
detail at temperatures from 342 to 387 °C to elucidate the production of reactive species is initiated by a
the elementary reaction steps (Bedford and Thomas, substitution reaction (reaction (12)) involving an alkali
1972). This study investigated initial rate data to nitrate/nitrite salt (MNOx) and an acid (HX), which in
determine reaction orders and looked at the effect of these experiments was H2O or HCl. Such reactions
added NO on the reaction in order to elucidate elemen- (e.g., hydrolysis) have been observed previously in
tary reaction mechanisms. The authors developed the solubility studies of NaNO3 and NaCl salts (Dell’Orco
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 7, 1997 2555
et al., 1995b; Armellini and Tester, 1993). Following Cl reactions is due to the substitution reaction (reaction
this substitution, either nitric acid or nitrous acid is (12)), which is suggested here to be the rate-limiting step
formed. Both of these species undergo homolysis to for alkali nitrate studies. When this substitution reac-
yield HO• and NO2/NO (reactions (14) and (15)). HONO2 tion occurs quickly (NH4Cl/NaNO3) or is not required
to occur (HNO3/NH3), the rate-limiting step is proposed
MNO2 + HX T HONO2 + MX (12) to be the homolysis of nitric and nitrous acid. Nitric
acid homolysis was also determined to be a rate-limiting
MONO + HX T HONO + MX (13) step in the free-radical decomposition of NH4NO3 melts
(Brower et al., 1989).
HONO T HO• + NO (14) The reaction mechanism described here demonstrates
why nitrate is a better oxidizing agent for ammonia than
HONO2 T HO• + NO2 (15) oxygen in supercritical water. Oxygen oxidation of
ammonia both in the gas phase and in supercritical
OH• + NH3 T NH2• + H2O (16) water proceeds primarily through successive hydrogen
abstractions of NH3 to form NO, which can react with
NO2 + M T NO + M + O• (17) NH• and NH2• species to form N2 and N2O (Webley and
Tester, 1991; Miller and Bowman, 1989). The succes-
sive hydrogen abstractions from ammonia to eventually
NH2• + NO T N2 + H2O (18) make NO require temperatures higher than those
reported in this research. Moreover, the formation of
NH2• + NO2 T N2O + H2O (19) HNO species through reaction (9) is not possible due to
the absence of NO2. Conversely, NH3/MNO3 reactions
homolysis has been observed in NH4NO3 melt decom- require only one hydrogen abstraction from ammonia,
position at temperatures of less than 350 °C (Brower et which is energetically possible at temperatures below
al., 1989). The HO• produced from reaction (16) ab- 500 °C and <1 min time scales. This is due to the fact
stracts a hydrogen from ammonia to make water and that NO and NO2 are produced by energetically favor-
NH2• (reaction (13)), which then quickly reacts with able hydrolysis-homolysis rather than hydrogen ab-
either NO2 or NO to make N2O or N2 (Kurusawa and straction reactions. The mechanism also explains why
Lesclaux, 1979; Miller and Bowman, 1989). H2O2, nitric acid is utilized as a rate enhancer in SCWO
present in some experiments, may also provide a source applications (Bouhris et al., 1994): the homolysis of
of OH• radicals for reaction (16). Because H2O2 did not nitric acid forms OH• at lower temperatures and at
significantly affect observed global rates, reaction (16) shorter time scales than O2/H2O reactions. Thus, free-
does not appear to be a rate-limiting reaction step. radical pools which can both promote O2 conversion into
NO2 and NO have an equilibrium shown by reaction useful radicals or react directly with oxidizable species
(18). At reaction temperatures similar to those used in are established at lower reaction temperatures, and
this work (377-427 °C), calculations have shown NO with substantially reduced induction times.
to be the favored NOx equilibrium species at low It is evident from the suggested mechanism why it is
pressures (∼2 bar) in even in the presence of oxygen possible for NO and NO2 to be observed in SCWO
(Odenbrand, 1986). Elevated pressures, as used in this effluents. Upon reaction quenching, these species only
research, would only shift the equilibrium in eq 15 convert back to their original ionic state by the equi-
further to the right. The favorability of NO as the libria shown in reactions (11) and (12) or by reaction in
predominant NOx species partially explains the high N2/ slow equilibrium steps with water. The equilibria with
N2O selectivities observed in this work. This results water proceed through N2O4 and N2O3 intermediates
in reaction (18), rather than reaction (19), being the and are generally too slow to be significant. Thus, if
primary NH2• removal path. Increased N2O formation quenching radicals (i.e., OH•) have been depleted by
for HNO3/NH3 and NaNO3/NH4Cl reactions may be other paths, such as corrosion (reaction (20)) or reaction
attributed to higher equilibrium values of NO2 relative with organic matter, it is possible that NO and NO2 will
to NO (via reaction (17)) at lower reaction temperatures, appear in gaseous effluents.
resulting in the increased importance of reaction (19).
A problem evident in reactions (9)-(16) is that this 2HONO2 + Cr f H2CrO4 + 2NO (20)
mechanism results in a stoichiometry of 1 mol NH3
reacted/mol of NOx- reacted. Experimentally, this ratio In nitrate decomposition studies and solubility studies
was observed between 1.08 and 1.22 for MNO3/NH3 (Dell’Orco, 1994), the appearance of NO and NO2 was
reactions and was even greater for HNO3/NH3 and linked to reactor corrosion, as implied by reaction (20).
NaNO3/NH4Cl reactions. That is, experiments produc- Specifically, Cr and Mo were selectively leached from
ing the highest N2/N2O selectivities resulted in stoichi- the alloy C276 and 625 surfaces, in proportion to the
ometries nearest to 1. In order to account for this excess amount of NO3- decomposed. This, in part, explains
ammonia disappearance, species such as HNO (reac- the difference in reaction rates observed in Figure 3;
tions (9) and (10)) need to be considered. The result of the unpassivated reactor (reactor B) undergoes reactor
reactions (9) and (10) is that two initial NH3 molecules corrosion, which allows reaction (20) to proceed in
react through a series of elementary steps to form a final parallel with the primary reaction mechanism. As NHx/
product, without the consumption of an NOx- species. NOx reactions are known to be catalyzed by Cr and Fe
This may account for experimentally observed reaction oxides (Baurle et al., 1978), it is also quite possible that
stoichiometries. In order for reactions (9) and (10) to MNOx/NH3 reactions observed here happen to a large
occur, NH• must also be formed; this can occur through degree at the reactor wall. Because most SCWO ap-
reaction (8), or perhaps through reaction of NH2• with plications operate under a high excess of oxygen (and
OH•. OH• radicals at elevated temperature conditions), the
The significantly reduced rate of alkali nitrate/am- chances for NO and NO2 to persist in gaseous effluents
monia reactions relative to HNO3/NH3 and NaNO3/NH4- are generally low.
2556 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 7, 1997
Elementary pathways presented above are somewhat Baurle, G. L.; Wu, S. C.; Nobe, K. Parametric and Durability
simplified; not all possible radical species are specifically Studies of NOx Reduction with NH3 on Fe-Cr Oxide Catalysts.
considered. For example, OH• and O• react in the Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. Dev. 1978, 17, 123.
Bedford, G.; Thomas, J. H. Reaction Between Ammonia and
presence of water, forming many additional free radicals Nitrogen Dioxide. J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 1 1972, June,
(i.e., HO2•). In addition, there are many other possible 2163.
reaction paths for the species presented. Nonetheless, Bouhris, A.; Swallow, K. C.; Hong, G. T.; Killelea, W. R. The Use
the suggested elementary steps qualitatively explain of Rate Enhancers in Supercritical Water Oxidation. AIChE
observed product selectivities and observed reaction Annual Meeting, San Francisco, Nov 1994; Paper 122E.
rates in a manner consistent with previous gas-phase Bramlette, T. T.; Mills, B. E.; Hencken, K. R.; Brynildson, M. E.;
studies. Johnston, S. C.; Hruby, J. M.; Feemster, H. C.; Odegard, B. C.;
Modell, M. Destruction of DOE/DP Surrogate Wastes with
Supercritical Water Oxidation. Sandia Report SAND900-8229,
Conclusions Contract DE-ACO4-76DP000789; Sandia National Laborato-
ries: Livermore, CA, 1990.
These experiments demonstrated the ability to con- Brower, K. P.; Oxley, J. C.; Tewari, M. Evidence for Homolytic
vert nitrates, nitrites, and ammonia to nitrogen gas and Decomposition of Ammonium Nitrate at High Temperatures.
nitrous oxide by reaction at supercritical water condi- J. Phys. Chem. 1989, 93, 4029.
tions. Arrhenius parameters and stoichiometric coef- Cox, J. L.; Hallen, R. T.; Lilga, M. A. Thermochemical Nitrate
Destruction. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1994, 28, 423.
ficients were determined for several sets of reactants: Crain, N.; Tebbal, S.; Li, L.; Gloyna, E. F. Kinetics and Reaction
NaNO3/NH3, LiNO3/NH3, and NaNO3/NH4Cl. In addi- Pathways of Pyridine Oxidation in Supercritical Water. Ind.
tion, HNO3/NH3 and NaNO2/NH3 reactions were inves- Eng. Chem. Res. 1993, 32, 2259.
tigated in order to elucidate elementary kinetic steps. Dell’Orco, P. C. Reactions of Inorganic Nitrogen Species in
Based on observations of reaction product trends and Supercritical Water. Ph.D. Dissertation, The University of Texas
comparison with reactions studied in the literature, a at Austin, Austin, TX, 1994.
set of global reactions was proposed for the system. The Dell’Orco, P. C.; Foy, B. F.; Robinson, J. M.; Buelow, S. J.
Hydrothermal Treatment of Hanford Tank Waste Constituents.
proposed reaction scheme involved the formation of NO Hazard Waste Hazard. Mater. 1993, 10, 221.
and NO2 through hydrolysis and homolysis pathways; Dell’Orco, P.; Foy, B.; Wilmanns, E.; Le, L.; Ely, J.; Patterson, K.;
these species reacted with NH2•, formed by hydrogen Buelow, S. Hydrothermal Oxidation of Organics by Nitrate and
abstraction from ammonia, to produce the observed Nitrite. In ACS Symposium Series; Hutchenson, K., Foster, N.,
reaction products N2 and N2O. Eds.; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1995a; Vol.
It was determined that nitric oxide can be produced 608, p 179.
Dell’Orco, P. C.; Eaton, H. K.; Reynolds, T. R.; Buelow, S. J. The
when nitrates and nitrites are present without excess Solubility of 1:1 Nitrate Electrolytes in Supercritical Water. J.
oxygen. This contradicts previous assertions that NO Supercrit. Fluid 1995b, 8, 217.
cannot be formed under supercritical water conditions. Feick, G. F.; Hainer, R. M. On the Thermal Decomposition of
Although prompt and thermal NO mechanisms are not Ammonium Nitrate. Steady-state Reaction Temperatures and
likely, fuel NO mechanisms can occur. It was also Reaction Rate. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1954, 76, 5860.
determined, however, that NO production was not Foy, B.; Dell’Orco, P.; Wilmanns, E.; McInroy, R.; Ely, J.; Robinson,
observed in oxidizing environments. J.; Buelow, S. Reduction of Nitrate and Nitrite Under Hydro-
thermal Conditions. In Physical Chemistry of Aqueous Solutions;
This reaction is suggested as a method for the White, H. J., Sengers, J. V., Neumann, D. B., Bellows, J. C.,
reduction of high ammonia and/or nitrate concentrations Eds.; Begell House: New York, 1995.
in wastewaters. Such a reaction could be employed to Franck, E. U. Water and Aqueous Mixtures at Elevated and
remove ammonia after organic destruction is achieved Supercritical Temperatures and Pressures. Pure Appl. Chem.
in a supercritical water reactor. The destruction of 1970, 24, 49.
organic matter must be achieved prior to the initiation Friedman, L.; Bigeleisen, J. Oxygen and Nitrogen Isotope Effects
in the Decomposition of Ammonium Nitrate. J. Chem. Phys.
of ammonia destruction, as nitrate will also participate
1950, 18, 1325.
in organic oxidation reactions. The reaction could also Haar, L.; Gallagher, J. S.; Kell, G. S. NBS/NRC Steam Tables;
be employed to remove nitrates from waste streams, Hemisphere Publishing Corp.: Washington, DC, 1984.
such as in the hydrothermal treatment of explosives and Harradine, D. M.; Buelow, S. J.; Dell’Orco, P. C.; Dyer, R. B.; Foy,
propellants. B. R.; Robinson, J. M.; Sanchez, J. A.; Spontarelli, T.; Wander,
J. Oxidation Chemistry of Energetic Materials in Supercritical
Water. Hazard. Waste Hazard. Mater. 1993, 10, 233.
Acknowledgment Holgate, H. R.; Tester, J. W. Fundamental Kinetics and Mecha-
nisms of Hydrogen Oxidation in Supercritical Water. Combust.
P.C.D. acknowledges the Environmental Restoration Sci. Technol. 1993, 88, 369.
and Waste Management Fellowship Program, admin- Hong, G. T.; Fowler, P. K.; Killilea, W. R.; Swallow, K. C.
istered by the Oak Ridge Institute for Science Education Supercritical Water Oxidation: Treatment of Human Waste and
for the U.S. Department of Energy. This project was a System Configuration Tradeoff. Presented at the 17th Interso-
cooperative effort between the supercritical water oxida- ciety Conference on Environmental Systems, Seattle, WA, July
tion laboratories at The University of Texas at Austin 13-15, 1987; SAE Technical Paper Series No. 87144, 1987.
and Los Alamos National Laboratory. The authors Kurasawa, H.; Lesclaux, R. Kinetics of the Reaction of NH2 with
NO2. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1979, 66, 602.
thank Rhonda McInroy, Hilary Eaton, Dale Counce, and Lasalle, A.; Roizard, C.; Midoux, N.; Bourret, P.; Dyens, P. J.
Pat Trujillo for their technical support. Removal of NOx from Flue Gases Using the Urea Acidic
Process: Kinetics of the Chemical Reaction of Nitrous Acid with
Literature Cited Urea. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1992, 31, 777.
Lee, D. S.; Gloyna, E. F. Hydrolysis and Oxidation of Acetamide
Antal, M. J.; Brittain, A.; DeAlmeida, C.; Ramayya, S.; Roy, J. C. in Supercritical Water. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1992, 26, 1587.
et al. Heterolysis and Homolysis in Supercritical Water. In ACS Lyon, R. K. Thermal DeNOx. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1987, 21, 231.
Symposium Series; Squires, T. G., Paulaitis, M., Eds.; American Marshall, W. L.; Frantz, J. D. Electrical Conductance Measure-
Chemical Society: Washington, DC 1988; Vol. 406, p 77. ments of Dilute Aqueous Electrolytes at Temperatures to
Armellini, F. J.; Tester J. W. Solubilities of Sodium Chloride and 800 °C and Pressures to 4264 Bars: Techniques and Interpreta-
Sulfate in Sub- and Supercritical Water Vapor from 450 °C- tions. In Hydrothermal Experimental Techniques; Ulmer, G. C.,
550 °C and 100-250 bar. Fluid Phase Equilib. 1993, 84, 123. Barnes, H. L., Eds.; John Wiley and Sons: New York, 1987.
Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., Vol. 36, No. 7, 1997 2557
Masten, D. Personal communication, Los Alamos National Labo- ment and Fundamental Research. In ACS Symposium Series;
ratory, 1993. Tedder, D. W., Pohland, F. G., Eds.; American Chemical
McBrayer, R. Design and Operation of the First Commercial Society: Washington, DC, 1993; Vol. 518, p 35.
Supercritical Water Oxidation Facility. First International Tongdhamachart, C. Supercritical Water Oxidation of Anaerobi-
Workshop on Supercritical Water Oxidation, Jacksonville, FL, cally Digested Municipal Sludge. Ph.D. Dissertation, The
Feb 1995. University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, 1990.
Mesmer, R. E.; Marshall, W. L.; Palmer, D. A.; Simonson, J. M.; Uematsu, M.; Franck, E. U. Static Dielectric Constant of Water
Holmes, H. F. Thermodynamics of Aqueous Association and and Steam. J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 1980, 9, 1291.
Ionization Reactions at High Temperatures and Pressures. J. Webley, P. A.; Tester, J. W.; Holgate, H. R. Oxidation Kinetics of
Solution Chem. 1988, 17, 699. Ammonia and Ammonia-Methanol Mixtures in Supercritical
Miller, J. A.; Bowman, C. T. Mechanism and Modeling of Nitrogen Water in the Temperature Range 530-700 °C at 246 Bar. Ind.
Chemistry in Combustion. Prog. Energy Combust. Sci. 1989, Eng. Chem. Res. 1991, 30, 1745.
15, 287. Wong, W. C.; Nobe, K. Reduction of NO with NH3 on Al2O3 and
Odenbrand, C. U. I.; Andersson, L. A. H.; Brandin, J. G. M.; TiO2 Supported Metal Oxide Catalysts. Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod.
Lundin, S. T. Catalytic Reduction of Nitrogen Oxides 2. The Res. Dev. 1986, 25, 179.
Reduction of NO2. Appl. Catal. 1986, 27, 363. Xu, X.; De Almeida, C.; Antal, M. J., Jr. Mechanism and Kinetics
Quist, A. S. The Ionization Constant of Water to 800 °C and 4000 of the Acid-Catalyzed Dehydration of Ethanol in Supercritical
Bars. J. Phys. Chem. 1970, 74, 3396. Water. J. Supercrit. Fluid 1990, 3, 228.
Robinson, J. M.; et al. Destruction of Nitrates, Organics, and
Ferrocyanides by Hydrothermal Processing. Waste Manage-
Received for review September 27, 1996
ment ’93, Tucson, AZ, Feb-March 1991.
Revised manuscript received March 10, 1997
Shanableh, A.; Gloyna, E. F. Supercritical Water Oxida-
tionsWastewaters and Sludges. Water. Sci. Technol. 1991, 23, Accepted March 19, 1997X
389. IE9605894
Takahashi, Y.; Wydeven, T.; Koo, C. Subcritical and Supercritical
Water Oxidation of CELSS Model Wastes. NASA Conf. Publ.
No. 10040 1989, 94.
X Abstract published in Advance ACS Abstracts, May 1,
Tester, J.; Holgate, H.; Armellini, F.; Webley, P.; Killilea, W.; et
al. Supercritical Water Oxidation Technology: Process Develop- 1997.