Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JOHE v8n2p94 en
JOHE v8n2p94 en
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
Quality of work life and its association with job burnout and job performance
among Iranian healthcare employees in Islamabad-e Gharb, 2016
1- MSc of Ergonomics, Health Center, Islamabad-e-Gharb Health Network, Kermanshah University of Medical Science, Kermanshah,
Iran.
2- Assistant Prof., Department of Occupational Health, School of Public Health, Kermanshah University of Medical Science,
Kermanshah, Iran.
3- Faculty of Humanities, Kermanshah Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah, Iran.
4- Medical Doctor, Islamabad-e-Gharb Health Network, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran.
Citation: Bakhshi E, Gharagozlou F, Moradi A, Naderi MR. Quality of work life and its
association with job burnout and job performance among Iranian healthcare employees in
Islamabad-e Gharb, 2016. JOHE 2019; 8(2):94-101.
* Corresponding author: Background: Health care centers play an important role in providing health service to the
Ehsan Bakhshi, public and maintaining the health of the community. This study was an attempt to evaluate
E-mail: the quality of work life and its association with job burnout and job performance among
Ehsanbakhshi63@gmail.com healthcare employees.
Material and Methods: This cross-sectional study was carried out on 136 employees of
Article history healthcare centers and health homes in Islamabad-e Gharb in 2016. The data collection
Received: Dec, 2018
tools were a demographic characteristics questionnaire, Walton's Quality of Work Life
Accepted: Mar, 2019
Questionnaire, Maslach Burnout Inventory, and Hersey and Goldsmith's Job Performance
Questionnaire. The statistical analysis was conducted using descriptive statistics, the
10.29252/johe.8.2.94 spearman correlation coefficient, one-way ANOVAs, and independent t-tests.
Results: The quality of work life was obtained to be low for only over a quarter of
participants, whereas only 0.7% of them reported it to be high. The majority of
Print ISSN: 2251-8096 respondents (72.63%), however, stated it as moderate. The quality of work life had a
Online ISSN: 2252-0902 significant negative correlation with job burnout (r= -0.291 P = 0.001) and held a significant
positive association with job performance (r=0.642 P = 0.000).
Conclusion: The findings of this study suggested a clear link between the quality of
Peer review under
working life and both job burnout and job performance. Therefore, taking actions such as
responsibility of Journal of
Occupational Health and providing opportunities for the staff to continue their education, increasing their salaries
Epidemiology and benefits as well as promoting their jobs would be considered as common-sense
approaches contributing to enhancing the quality of work life.
© The Author(s) 2019; All rights reserved. Published by Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences Press.
it includes the physical, psychological, and identification of the various organizational factors
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
environmental factors that compare the desires and that influence individuals' performance (16). The
needs of individuals between what they should have employees’ attitude towards different organizational
and what is available (5). The concept of quality of issues, especially towards the job and the
work life is currently related to a philosophy in the profession they perform, as well as promotions,
organizations that seek to increase employees' assigned tasks, selection for training, and pay raise
dignity. In some organizations, managers aim to based on assessment can play an important role in
enhance employees' trust, engagement, and increasing their motivation and cause them to
problem-solving skills by implementing appropriate perform their duties and responsibilities in the best
quality of work life plans and, thereby, to enhance way, which, in turn, leads to an increase in the
organizational satisfaction and effectiveness (6). effectiveness and efficiency of the organization (17,
Downloaded from johe.rums.ac.ir at 13:53 +0430 on Saturday March 27th 2021
.These plans and programs will exert significant 18). Today, healthcare organizations are in need of
impacts on employee’s behavioral responses such strong support on part of managers in terms of
as job satisfaction, work participation, job performance evaluation. Performance
performance, intention for job resignation, and measurement is one of the most important strategic
organizational change and transformation (7). Hood processes that determines the extent to which the
& Smith believe that of managers’ close attention to goals and plans of an organization are fulfilled
quality of work life variables can facilitate a more inasmuch as the enhancement of accountability and
humanistic work environment, which not only responsiveness (19). Regarding the role of health
addresses the basic needs of employees but also staff in the quality of service delivery, it can be
encompasses the needs of higher levels, argued that the progress and enhancement of an
continuous growth, and improved performance (8). organization hinges upon the employees, who must
Much attention has been recently drawn to QWL as be aware of the quality of care in their organization.
an approach to balancing job burnout (9). With regard to the important role of staff of health
Job burnout arises from the response to long-term centers and public health centers in the
stress in the workplace, and this syndrome is related maintenance of people's health, this study aimed to
to the workplace, in which one's attitudes towards evaluate quality of work life and its effect on burnout
efforts and endeavors in the workplace are and job performance.
negatively affected (10). People with burnout often
suffer from headaches, sleep disorder, irritable Materials and Methods
mood, anxiety, depression, and hypertension (11).
In the beginning, this project was approved by the
Job burnout reduces cognitive ability and, hence,
Vice Chancellor of Research Affairs at Kermanshah
results in reduced job satisfaction and increased
University of Medical Sciences, Iran (ID code:
disorder in organizational commitment as well as
IR.KUMS.REC.1397.988).
personal injury (12). The imbalance between
This cross-sectional, descriptive study was
expectations, knowledge, and skills of employees
conducted based on the census methods at the
on one hand, and job requirements, job resources,
healthcare centers in Islamabad-e Gharb in 2016. In
and responsibilities on the other hand lead to
total, 180 questionnaires were distributed among
burnout. In addition, high workload and the lack of
the participants, and 136 questionnaires were
social support are among the other major risk
completed and returned (response rate: 75%)
factors for this phenomenon (13). Since job burnout
In this study, the following four questionnaires were
creates a negative attitude toward the job and a
used:
sense of disconnection with the patient during care
A demographic characteristics questionnaire: It
delivery, it leads to a serious loss of quality of
included information about age, gender, marital
healthcare services; therefore, a careful
status, work experience, education level, history of
identification of more effective factors in this area
smoking, place of employment, and employment
will be beneficial for improving the quality of services
status.
provided in the field of health and treatment (14). In
Walton's Quality of Work Life Questionnaire: This
addition to job burnout, quality of work life could also
questionnaire is constructed based on Walton's
have impact on job performance of employees.
components (20). The reliability of the questionnaire
Job performance has a significant association with
was reported by Ghaleei et al. to be 0.78 (21). This
an organization's goals, and it is necessary for the
questionnaire includes such components as
organization to pay special attention to it (15). Job
adequate and fair compensation, safe healthy
performance refers a set of behaviors controlled by
working environment, opportunity for continued
individuals, which affect the goals of the employing
growth and security, constitutionalism in the work
organization. The main key to the development and
organization, social relevance of work life, social
improvement of job performance of individuals is the
integration and cohesiveness, and the development questionnaire, developed by Hersey and Goldsmith,
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
of human capacities. The questionnaire items are consists of 16 questions under seven components
scored based on a five-point, qualitative Likert scale including ability, clarity of role, support, motivation,
(very low =1, low = 2, moderate = 3, high = 4, very feedback, validity, and environment. The validity
high = 5). The scores can range from 32 to160, and reliability of this questionnaire were confirmed
where scores lower than 74 are considered as low, by Ardestani et al. with a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.86
75 to117 as moderate, and those higher than 118 (24). The Cronbach’s alpha reliability of this scale
are known as high. was calculated to be 0.75 in the present study. The
Maslach Burnout Inventory: This questionnaire is scores are classified into three ranges: 16-37, 37-
one of the most common tools used for the 58, and 59-80 representing low, moderate, and high
measurement of burnout, which consists of 22 job performances, respectively.
Downloaded from johe.rums.ac.ir at 13:53 +0430 on Saturday March 27th 2021
statements. It was designed by Maslach and The obtained data were analyzed using descriptive
measures three dimensions of job burnout (22). statistics, the spearman correlation coefficient,
where nine items pertain to emotional exhaustion, independent t-tests, and one-way ANOVAs at a
five items relate to depersonalization, and eight confidence level of 0.95 in version 19 of the SPSS
statements are about personal accomplishment. software.
The reliability and validity of this questionnaire were
confirmed in Iran for the first time by Filian, who Results
reported a test-retest reliability index of 0.78 (23).
In this study, 48.52% of the participants were male.
for the questionnaire. The total score range for total
The mean and standard deviation of the
job burnout varies between 0 and 132, in which the
participants' age was 36.4 ±8.1 years old. Table 1
scores below 44 (≤44) represent low job burnout, 45
shows the demographic characteristics of the staff
to 89 show moderate job burnout, and those higher
in healthcare centers and health homes.
than 99 (≥90) indicate high job burnout. Hersey and
Goldsmith's Job Performance Questionnaire: This
Table 1: The demographic characteristics of the staffs in healthcare centers and health homes
Variable N %
Male 66 48.52
Sex
Female 70 51.48
Married 27 19.85
Marital status
No married 109 80.15
Less than diploma 18 13.23
Diploma 39 28.67
Education level
Associates degree 27 18.85
Bachelor degree 52 39.25
Under 30 22 16.17
Age groups 31-40 55 40.53
41 and older 59 43.30
1-10 years 55 40.44
Years of service 11-20 years 52 38.24
21-30 years 29 21.32
Contractual 26 19.11
Type of employment Employment contract 28 20.58
Permanent 82 60.29
Health center 77 56.61
Job category
Health house 59 43.38
Yes 12 9
Cigarette smoking
No 124 91
In this research, the most experienced QWL level respectively. Table 2 illustrates the mean and
(72% of the participants) was at moderate, followed standard deviation of all components of QWL, job
by low (26%). The mean and standard deviation of performance and job burnout in staff of healthcare
job burnout, job performance, and quality of work centers and health homes.
life were 45.95 ±17.77, 52.5 ±9, and 73.91 ±13.22,
Table 2: Mean and standard deviation of QWL, job performance, job burnout and their aspects
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
The Pearson correlation coefficient showed that quality of work life, with the exception of the overall
quality of work life had a significant negative work environment, had a significant effect on job
correlation with job burnout (p-value = 0.001) but a performance (p-value≤0.05). Similarly, job burnout
significant positive correlation with job performance was significantly influenced by all components of
(p-value = 0.001). Moreover, there was a significant quality of work life, except for social integration (p-
negative association between job burnout and job value≤0.05) (table 3).
performance (p-value = 0/01). All components of
Table 3: Association between aspects of quality of work life with job performance and job burnout
Job performance Job burnout
Dimensions of quality of work life
r r
Adequate and fair compensation 0.397** -0.281**
Safe and healthy working environment 0.336** -0.184*
Growth and security 0.479** -0.205*
Organizational legality 0.675** -0.282**
Social relevance of work life 0.533** -0.192*
Work and the total life span -0.087 0.233*
Social integration in the work organization 0.561** -0.085
Developing human capabilities 0.537** -0.224*
Quality of work life 0.642** -0.291**
Job burnout -0.242** -
Spearman correlation efficiencies level of significant: p≤0.05 p<0.001** p<0.050*
The Pearson correlation coefficient showed that environment. In addition, quality of work life was
quality of work life had a significant effect on all significantly correlated with emotional exhaustion
components of job performance except the work (p-value≤0.05) (Table 4).
Table 4: Association of quality of work life with aspects of job performance and job burnout
Quality of work life
Job performance: 0.642**
-Ability 0.307**
-Clarity 0.423**
-Help 0.651**
-Incentive 0.538**
-Evaluation 0.571**
-Validity 0.506**
-Environment -0.070
Job burnout: -0.291**
-Emotional Exhaustion -0.329**
-Depersonalization -0.069
-Personal Accomplishment -0.136*
Spearman correlation coefficients level of significant: p≤0.05 p<0.001** p<0.050*
The one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed between job performance and gender (p-value =
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
that job performance and quality of work life were 0.04). Table 5 shows the association between
correlated with educational level (p-value <0.05). An quality of work life, job performance, and job
independent t-test revealed a significant association burnout with demographic and contextual variables.
Table 5: Association between quality of work life, job performance, and job burnout with demographic and contextual
variables
Job Quality of work
Variables Job burnout Type of test
performance life
Age groups 0.70 0.11 0.21 ANOVA
Sex 0.04 * 0.31 0.355 T-TEST
Married status 0.90 0.66 0.29 T-TEST
Downloaded from johe.rums.ac.ir at 13:53 +0430 on Saturday March 27th 2021
confirming the association between job burnout and payment, observance of rules and fairness in
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
job performance is Hosseini et al.'s study, which dealing with all staff, the provision of a healthy
was conducted on auditors wherein it was revealed physical and mental environment, promoting
that there is a significant negative association employees' job status, encouraging employees to
between job burnout and job performance (40). continue education, and job-time adjustment.
The promotion of quality of work life is essential in
improving organizational performance (33) and Acknowledgement
individuals' job performance, and quality of work life
We extend our gratitude to all the colleagues at the
can be improved through an autonomous work
Vice Chancellor of Research Affairs, the hospitals,
redesign, job security, opportunities for growth,
and health centers for assisting us in this research
administrative and organizational justice, job
project.
Downloaded from johe.rums.ac.ir at 13:53 +0430 on Saturday March 27th 2021
12. West CP, Huschka MM, Novotny PJ, Sloan JA, Challenges and Solutions ; 2013 Dec 26; Shiraz,
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
Performance of the Staff in Mazandaran Provin the relationship between stress and job
[ DOI: 10.29252/johe.8.2.94 ]
Tax Affairs General Directoratece. Journal of Tax performance of auditors. Quarterley Journal of
Research 2013; 21(19):171-96. Health Accounting 2015; 4(1):57-80.
38. Honkonen T, Ahola K, Pertovaara M, Isometsä 41. Srivastava S, Kanpur R. A Study on Quality of
E, Kalimo R, Nykyri E, et al. The association Work Life: Key Elements & It’s Implications.
between burnout and physical illness in the IOSR Journal of Business and Management
general population--results from the Finnish 2014; 16(3):54-9.
Health 2000 Study. J Psychosom Res 2006; 42. Nasl Saraji G, Dargahi H. Study of Quality of
61(1):59-66. Work Life (QWL). Iranian Journal of Public
39. Gandi JC, Wai PS, Karick H, Dagona ZK. The Health 2006; 35(4):8-14.
role of stress and level of burnout in job 43. Chan KW, Wyatt TA. Quality of Work Life: A
performance among nurses. Ment Health Fam Study of Employees in Shanghai, China. Asia
Med 2011; 8(3):181-94. Pacific Business Review 2007; 13(4):501-17.
Downloaded from johe.rums.ac.ir at 13:53 +0430 on Saturday March 27th 2021