Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ge007 Prelim Chapter 1.2
Ge007 Prelim Chapter 1.2
Ge007 Prelim Chapter 1.2
GLOBAL CULTURE
• Global flows of culture today tend to move more easily around the globe than
before, especially through non-material digital forms. The discussion of these
global cultural flows (movements) has three perspectives. These are
differentialism, hybridization and convergence.
CULTURAL DIFFERENTIALISM
• This perspective emphasizes the fact that cultures are essentially different and are only
superficially affected by global flows. Since these cultures are different, the interaction of cultures is
deemed to contain the potential for the so-called “catastrophic collision”.
• Samuel Huntington explained in his theory of the Clash of Civilization (1996) that after Cold
War, political economic differences were overshadowed by new fault lines, which were primarily
cultural in nature. Increasing interaction among different “civilizations” (Sinic, Islamic, Orthodox,
and Western) would lead to intense clashes, especially the economic conflict between the Western
and Sinic Civilizations and bloody political conflict between the Western and Islamic civilizations.
However, this theory of Huntington has been criticized especially due to its portrayal of Muslims
as being “prone to violence”. (Huntington, 1996)
CULTURAL HYBRIDIZATION
• This approach emphasizes the integration of local and global cultures (Cvetkovich and Kellner, 1997).
Globalization has been seen as a creative process which paves the way of hybrid entities that are not
reducible to either global or local.
• A key concept to this approach is “glocalization”. It refers to the interpenetration of the global and local
cultures resulting in unique outcomes in different geographical areas (Giulianotti and Robertson, 2007).
• Another key concept is “scapes” by Arjun Apparadui (1996). This concept explains that global flows involve
people, technology, finance, political images, and media and the disjuncture between them leading to the
creation of cultural hybrids.
CULTURAL CONVERGENCE
• This approach stresses homogeneity since cultures are deemed to be radically altered by strong flows while
cultural imperialism happens when one culture imposes itself on and tends to destroy at least parts of
another culture. However, cultural imperialism is being criticized especially by John Tomlinson by providing
the idea of “deterritorialization” of culture.
• Deterritorialization means that it is much more difficult to tie culture to a specific geographic point of
origin.
GLOBALIZATION OF RELIGION
• Globalization has played a very important role in providing a context for the
current revival and the resurgence of religion. Today, presence of religions are
not only limited to the countries where they began as it spread and scattered
on a global scale.
• Information technologies, transportation means, and the media are the ways
on which religionists rely on the dissemination of their religious ideas.
• Religion has always been promoted by its practitioners so that it could reach
the level of globality and be embraced by as many people as possible. For
instance, Muslim, aspire to establish the Islamic Ummah, a community of
believers.
• Many policymakers and scholars think that globalization must be regulated and
managed. The threats of an “ungoverned globalization” can be countered
what Jacoby and Meunier called managed globalization which refers to “all
attempts to make globalization more palatable to citizens”.
• Due to this threat, states prefer regional organizations in order to reduce the
perceived negative effects of globalization. As a result, it weakens the potential
benefits coming out from liberalized global economy. Therefore, regionalism
is a sort of counter- globalization.
GLOB ALIZATION AND REGIONALIZATION
• One of the reasons behind regionalism is the concern for security, which is
to ensure peace and stability. Confidence building can be enhance through
economic cooperation within a region. The ASEAN and the Shanghai
Cooperation Organization (SCO) are regional organizations that seek strong
security in Asia through cooperation.
• Culture and identity, on the other hand, were seen by Huntington (1996)
as the guide for regionalization. For him, culture and identity are civilizations
identifying the nine major civilizations such as Western, Latin America, African,
Islamic, Sinic, Hindu, Orthodox, Buddhist and Japanese. He argued that
organizations like EU or Mercosur share a common culture and identity and
are far more successful than NAFTA, whose members states belong to
different civilizations.
GLOB ALIZATION AND REGIONALIZATION