Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diagnostic Laparoscopy: Surgical Endoscopy February 2004
Diagnostic Laparoscopy: Surgical Endoscopy February 2004
Diagnostic Laparoscopy: Surgical Endoscopy February 2004
net/publication/10579581
Diagnostic laparoscopy
CITATIONS READS
53 1,330
1 author:
Tehemton E Udwadia
Grant Medical College and J.J.Hospital / Hinduja Hospital, Mumbai
92 PUBLICATIONS 793 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Tehemton E Udwadia on 03 August 2015.
Diagnostic laparoscopy
A 30-year overview
T. E. Udwadia
Department of Minimal Access Surgery P.D., Hinduja National Hospital and Research Centre, and the Department of Surgery,
B.D. Petit Parsee General Hospital, Breach Candy Hospital, Mumbai, India
Key words: Diagnostic laparoscopy — Cost effective Over the years, by trial and error, a technique of DL [13] has been
standardized that ensures the three essential criteria we set for
— Developing countries — Malignancy — Tubercu- ourselves:
losis — Acute pain — Trauma
1. A high margin of safety and freedom from complications
(primum non nocere).
2. A high diagnostic yield.
The axiom ‘‘truth is change’’ applies very aptly to 3. Cost effectiveness for a developing country.
medicine. In the 30 years since we started using diag- We began DL in 1972 with the double-puncture Storz instrument using
nostic laparoscopy (DL), there has been appreciable a 7-mm 30° telescope and a 5-mm trocar for the second puncture. We
change in the technique, the instrumentation and the prefer the double-puncture instrument for the following reasons:
indications of DL. In 1972, noninvasive diagnostic
1. The narrower 7-mm cannula of the double-puncture instrument
methods were nonexistent in most parts of the Indian has a shorter trocar, making injury to intraabdominal structures
during introduction less likely.
2. Ascites leak, omental prolapse, and incisional or Richter’s her-
Correspondence to: T. E. Udwadia nia are unlikely after the use of the narrower cannula.
7
3. The second puncture is made safely under laparoscopic vision patient’s subjective discomfort. The method we first used because of
and can be suitably sited, depending on the intraabdominal financial necessity we used until 1990 by choice. Under local anes-
pathology, as seen through the peritoneoscope. thesia, the conscious patient’s tolerance of abdominal distension and
4. The double puncture gives a three-dimensional view, providing pressure combined with careful clinical monitoring makes overinflation
a better sense of depth and distance; permits the use of both very unlikely.
hands; and greatly increases the versatility of translaparoscopic The purpose of creating the pneumoperitoneum is twofold: to
procedures, [5] as well as their safety. ensure that the main trocar puncture can be performed with safety in
an air cushion that separates the anterior abdominal wall from the
Movement and palpation of organs with a probe, biopsies under abdominal viscera and to provide a medium in which examination of
vision, suction–coagulation of bleeding areas, aspiration of cysts and the peritoneal viscera can be performed.
abscesses, and severence of adhesions, all performed through the The infraumbilical midline, the left subcostal region, the (right)
double-puncture instrument make it eminently suitable for surgical McBurney point, and various other sites have been recommended for
practice and an ideal teaching method for laparoscopic surgery. entry of the pneumoperitoneum needle. Unless there is a strong reason
Since 1990, we use the 5-mm 30° Storz telescope and a 5- or 3-mm to contraindicate the use of the left McBurney point, such as scars or a
trocar for the second-puncture. grossly enlarged spleen, we routinely use the left McBurney point for
Diagnostic laparoscopy can be performed with the patient under introduction of the pneumoperitoneum needle for the following reasons:
general anesthesia and with the use of relaxants and intubation. Local It is seldom the site of varices or surgical scars.
anesthesia is far safer, faster, more suitable for general surgery and While the pneumoperitoneum is being created, the Veress needle
high risk cases. It has been used in more than 3,200 consecutive adult can be used as a probe to ensure that there are no adhesions in the
elective laparoscopies. Intravenous diazepam is used for sedation only infraumbilical midline at the site of the main trocar entry, and to gauge
if required. With increasing experience, the need for sedation has de- the depth and safety of the air cushion before trocar insertion. Our
creased, ensuring earlier ambulation and discharge. Patient tolerance technique of using the Veress needle as a probe is, we think, one of the
has made it impossible to achieve or maintain an intraabdominal most important factors responsible for our low complication rate. We
pressure exceeding 6 to 8 mmHg in a conscious patient under local have had no perforation since we evolved this method after a trocar
anaesthesia. The average procedure time is 12 min. All these factors perforation of the ileum in our first 100 cases.
have obviated the incidence of pulmonary embolism. In children and in The second puncture trocar can be inserted at the same site, after
the acute abdomen, the procedure is performed with the patient under removal of the Veress needle, under vision for all upper abdominal
general anesthesia. An anesthetist with complete anesthesia equipment pathology, permitting right-hand translaparoscopic procedures.
is available during every laparoscopy session.
Table 1. Range of applications for diagnostic laparoscopy Table 2. Clinical presentation in 3,200 cases of diagnostic laparoscopy
from 1972 to 1994a
Clinical presentation
Elective Disease process Clinical presentation Cases
Table 4. Diagnostic laparoscopy for 3,200 patients under local anes- for a large volume of patients, making it entirely cost
thesia (1972–1990) effective in the long run (Table 5).
%
No mortality References
0.09% Morbidity
Histologic diagnosis 72.5 1. Almeida J, Sleeman D, Sosa JL, Puente I, McKenney M, Martin L
Visual diagnosis 12.0 (1995) Acalculus cholecystitis: the use of diagnostic laparoscopy.
Positive diagnosis 84.5 J Laparoendosc Surg 5: 227–231
2. Brandt CP, Priebe PP, Eckhauser ML (1993) Diagnostic lapar-
oscopy in the intensive care patient: avoiding the nontherapeutic
laparotomy. Surg Endosc 7: 168–172
3. Carnevale N, Baron N, Deleney HM (1997) Peritoneoscopy as an
Table 5. Equipment cost of diagnostic laparoscopy aid in the diagnosis of abdominal trauma. J Trauma 17: 634–637
4. Connor TJ, Garcha IS, Ramshaw BJ, Mitchell CW, Wilson JP,
Rupees Mason EM, Duncan TD, Dozier FA, Lucas GW (1997) Diagnostic
laparoscopy for suspected appendicitis. Am Surg 61: 187–189
Equipment cost 37,000 (1972) 5. Corson SL (1977) In: Philips JM (Ed.) Laparoscopy. Baltimore,
Repairs, replacement 57,000 Williams and Wilkins, p 98
Total 94,000 6. Gloor B, Todd KE, Reber HA (1997) Diagnostic workup of pa-
Used from 1972 to 1990 for 3,200 cases tients with suspected pancreatic carcinoma: the University of
Equipment cost per case Rs. 30.30 [50/- = $1/-] California-Los Angeles approach. Cancer 79: 1780–1786
7. Quorain AA al, Sethi MB, et al. (1991) Tuberculous peritonitis:
a
The apparent disparity between the cost of equipment and the cost of value of laparoscopy. Hepatogastroenterology 38: 37–40
repairs, for example, results largely from the falling value of the rupee 8. Spirtos NM, Eisenkop SM, Spirtos TW, Poliakin RI, Hibbard LT
over 30 years (1987) Laparoscopy: a diagnostic aid in cases of suspected ap-
pendicitis: its use in women of reproductive age. Am J Obstet
Gynecol 156: 90–94
9. Stahel E, Robyn L, Burnier E, Gyr K, Stalder G, Bianchi L, Bets-
instrument for more than 3,200 cases in a surgical unit chart B, Weiss N, Degremont A, Tanner M (1989) Liver disease in
rural Tanzania: a diagnostic approach. East Afr Med J 66: 693–699
[15]. This often appears ‘‘remarkable’’ or ‘‘unbelievable’’ 10. Udwadia RT (1997) Laparoscopic appendicectomy in laparo-
to workers in the developed world. However, they would scopic surgery in developing countries. In: Udwadia TE (Ed.)
realize that fiberoptic bundles do not darken with use, JAYPEE Brothers Medical Publishers, New Delhi, pp 218–237
but with misuse if 11. Udwadia TE (1978) Peritoneoscopy in the diagnosis of abdominal
tuberculosis. Ind J Surg 40: 91–95
1. their income is limited and they pay a large pro- 12. Udwadia TE (1978) Role of surgery in abdominal tuberculosis. J J
J Group Hosp 14: 34–37
portion of their own annual income to purchase 13. Udwadia TE (1986) Peritoneoscopy for surgeons. Ann R Coll Surg
the equipment, as in our case Engl 68: 125–129
2. the equipment is used only for welfare patients and 14. Udwadia TE, Udwadia RT, Menon K, Kaul P, Kukreja L, Jain R,
Prasad S (1995) Laparoscopic surgery in the developing world: an
hence generates no revenue for the surgeon, as in overview of the Indian scene. Int Surg 80: 371–375
our case 15. Udwadia TE (1997) Role of laparoscopy in amoebic liver abscess.
3. they realize they cannot afford to buy new equip- Bombay Hosp J 39: 187–191
16. Udwadia TE (2001) One world – one people – one surgery. Surg
ment, as in our case Endosc 15: 337–343
4. after every procedure the surgeon cleanses and 17. Vargas C, Jeffers LJ, Bernstein D, Reddy KR, Munnangi S, Behar
dries the equipment himself, as in our case. S, Scot C, Parker T, Schiff ER (1995) Diagnostic laparoscopy: a 5-
year experience in a hepatology training program. Am J Gast-
Being underprivileged has distinct advantages. We have roenterol 90: 1258–1262
18. Wilairatane P, Wilairatane S, et al. (1993) Role of diagnostic
prototyped a model that uses sunlight as the light
laparoscopic in fibro-adhesive tuberculous peritonitis. S E Asia J
source. Besides being cost effective, laparoscopy has the Trop Med Public Health 24: 762–765
great advantage of providing a final histologic diagnosis 19. Zantut LF, Ivatury RR, Smith RS, Kawahara NT, Porter JM, Fry
on target biopsy, with no element of shadow, image, or WR, Poggetti R, Birolini D, Organ Jr CH (1997) Diagnostic and
conjecture. (Table 4). In developing countries with large therapeutic laparoscopy for penetrating abdominal trauma: a
multicenter experience. J Trauma 42: 825–829
populations and an immense patient load, the initial cost 20. Zhang AT, Liu X, Zhang GZ (1991) Diagnostic value of fibrola-
of the equipment, repairs, and the like is more than paroscopy and direct-vision peritoneal biopsy in a typical tuber-
compensated by the fact that the same equipment is used culous peritonitis. Chung Hua Nei Ko Tsa Chih 30: 286–308