Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

ARTICLE IN PRESS

GEM No. XXX


“Nutritainment” − A Nutrition Education Module for Indian
Adolescents
Radhika P. Hedaoo, MSc1; Pallavi Kabra, MSc2; SubbaRao M. Gavaravarapu, PhD3

INTRODUCTION and make them the necessary life nutrition and lifestyle knowledge of
skills.8 12−14-year-old adolescents are ex-
Health education is considered one of Entertainment education, also pounded.
the key drivers for promoting health- known as edutainment, is a communi-
related behaviors.1 Nutrition and life- cation strategy for social and behavior
style information presented convinc- modification that combines education MODULE DEVELOPMENT
ingly to adolescents has the potential with entertainment.9 Gardner’s 8.5 AND DELIVERY
to influence their behaviors. As ado- multiple intelligences theory suggests
lescents go through rapid cognitive that humans possess verbal/linguistic, The topics covered in Nutritainment
transitions, there is a constant need to visual/spatial, and musical/rhythmic were based on the dietary guidelines
experiment with innovative trajecto- interpersonal intelligence among for Indian adolescents and topics
ries in nutrition communication that other intelligences corresponding to covered in the school curricula pre-
are adolescent “psyche”-centric rather different learning styles.10 Therefore, scribed by the Central Board of Sec-
than “topic”-centric.2 In India, which learning can be boosted by using ap- ondary Education, India.11,12 The
has the world’s highest adolescent posite nutrition education strategies, possible topics to be covered were
population, this is a continuous and which mesh well with these varied listed by the research team and then
demanding process.3 With the general intelligences possessed by adolescents. reviewed by a panel of 4 experts: 2
enrollment rate of more than 80% The edutainment approach can nutritionists, a health communica-
−93% in grades 1 to 10, schools can invoke multiple intelligences of the tion professional, and a school sci-
be avenues for nutrition education.4 recipient and makes learning interest- ence teacher. The topics thus
However, nutrition and lifestyle ing. For example, individuals with a identified were balanced diet and
topics covered in school curricula in visual/spatial learning style compre- nutrition including food groups and
India are sparse and scattered and hend a subject better with visual cues diet diversity; nutrients and their
involve technical terms and jargon, such as videos, animation, and pic- functions; Indian food pyramid and
which are often difficult to compre- tures; similarly, people with kines- ideal food plate; food labels; healthy
hend and may lead to weariness.5 thetic/bodily learning style can eating and lifestyles; duration,
A content analysis of textbooks comprehend a subject better when nature, and importance of physical
concluded that content related to given hands-on tactile experiences. activity; diet-related deficiency disor-
nutritional needs of adolescence, The current study aimed at creat- ders and noncommunicable diseases.
healthy eating and lifestyles are sparse ing awareness about nutrition and Theoretical constructs evidenced to
and should be included in the curric- healthy lifestyles using an edutain- have made nutrition education suc-
ula.6 Although nutrition content in ment module called Nutritainment cessful and effective in school set-
school syllabi needs to be reoriented,7 (nutrition education combined with tings were reviewed and identified to
there is a felt need to present these entertainment). Herein, the develop- guide the development of the Nutri-
topics in a more engaging manner to ment of Nutritainment modules, tainment module. The components
promote their practical application their delivery and impact on the of the module were broadly based on
the Social Cognitive Theory concepts
of connection, independence, skill
1
Nutrition and Dietetics Department, Symbiosis Institute of Health Sciences, Symbiosis development and healthy norms,13,14
International (Deemed University), Lavale, Pune, India cognitive theory of multimedia learn-
2
Freelance dietitian, Pune, Hyderabad, India ing,15 experiential learning model16
3
Nutrition Information, Communication & Health Education Division (NICHE), Indian collaborative and shared learning the-
Council of Medical Research−National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad, Telangana, India ory,17 and classroom management
Conflict of Interest Disclosure: The authors have not stated any conflicts of interest. theory18 (Table 1). The preference and
Address for correspondence: SubbaRao M. Gavaravarapu, PhD, Nutrition Information, liking for the mode of delivery (kind
Communication & Health Education Division (NICHE), Indian Council of Medical of component) to be included in the
Research−National Institute of Nutrition, Jamai-Osmania PO, Tarnaka, Hyderabad 500007, Nutritainment module was assessed
Telangana, India; E-mail: subbarao.gm@icmr.gov.in using a preference rating scale that
J Nutr Educ Behav. 2020;&&:&&-&& listed 7 options. Of these, the most
Ó 2020 Society for Nutrition Education and Behavior. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights preferred 4 were selected (Table 1).
reserved. The Nutritainment module con-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jneb.2020.11.002 sisted of 4 distinct components as

Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior  Volume 000, Number 000, 2020 1
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2 Hedaoo et al Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior  Volume 000, Number 000, 2020

Table 1. Framework of Underlying Theories for Nutritainment Module Development

Nutritainment Underlying
Component Behavioral Theory Salient Principles Application
Nutri-Animation clip Social Cognitive Theory14  Pictorial channel Use of graphic or pictorial and aural
6 min 30 s Cognitive theory of multi-  Verbal channel or vocal media for better learning
media learning15  Inspirational experience through fun element.
experience
 Social influence
 Increase in self-
efficacy
Nutri-Bites Experiential learning  Reflective observation “Reflective observation” while wit-
(recipe demonstration) model16 (watching) nessing recipe making. Consider-
 Abstract (thinking) ing the idea of cooking and acting
 Concrete experience on the same is “abstract con-
(feeling) ceptualization.”
 Active experimentation Learning to make the recipes or to
(doing) cook was concrete experience
and active experimentation.
Nutri-Quiz Collaborative learning and  Creating environment Engagement of the learners with a
shared learning theory17 for empowered action self-evaluation tool that encour-
 Learning from ages social interaction, team
experience spirit, competitiveness, and pro-
 Acknowledging that motes thinking and learning
participants have together.
capability and capac-
ity to effect change
Nutri-Lecture Classroom management  “With-it-ness” Effective coverage of topics by way
theory18  Overlapping of transitioning from 1 topic to the
 Momentum another.
 Smoothness Reiteration of messages learned in
 Group focus other ways while maintaining
group focus and by engaging in
group activities to keep students
attentive and be with it.

shown in the Figure: (1) Nutri-Ani- diseases. The average duration taken 2016 (Redmond, WA). The topics cov-
mation clip: The animation clip to complete the quiz was approxi- ered included the food guide pyramid,
showed a basketball match between mately 4 minutes 30 seconds; (3) Nu- deficiency diseases, noncommunicable
less healthful food, such as burgers, tri-Bites: Five healthy snacks recipes diseases, and physical activity followed
chips, and fries, and healthful food, were finalized on the basis of criteria by a brief activity with students.
such as salads, fruits, and vegetables. such as nutritional quality, ease of
The clip, developed using Adobe making with minimum parental IMPLEMENTATION
Flash (version 27.0.0.187), Illustrator, guidance, seasonality, local availabil-
and Photoshop softwares (Adobe ity of ingredients, and appeal. The After seeking the necessary approvals
Inc., San Jose, CA, 2017), combined recipes incorporated sprouted le- from the Institutional Ethical Com-
fun and humor components in the gumes and pulses in sandwiches; mil- mittees of the Indian Council of
story in which the salads, fruits, and let-based wraps, which were healthy Medical Research−National Institute
vegetables team wins the match; (2) analogs to street food snacks pre- of Nutrition, Hyderabad, India and
Nutri-Quiz: A quiz titled “Kaun ferred by children; nut-based spreads Symbiosis International (Deemed
banega Nutriking or Nutriqueen?” and smoothies with a combination of University), Pune, India, approvals
(Who will be the Nutriking or Nutri- fruits and vegetables. The duration of from the school management and
queen?) was modeled around the the demonstration was 30 minutes for the principal were taken. Written
widely viewed television quiz show all recipes. Prepreparation was done in informed consents of parents and as-
“Kaun Banega Crorepati” (Indian advance, and adolescents were briefed sents of adolescents were obtained.
adaptation of “Who Wants to be a about the prepreparation required; (4) Apparently healthy adolescents in
Millionaire”). The quiz had 12 ran- Nutri-Lecture: An interactive lecture the age group of 12−14 years belong-
domly generated questions on food was conducted using a slideshow ing to the upper middle−income
groups, nutrients, and deficiency made using Microsoft PowerPoint group were recruited (n = 110,
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior  Volume 000, Number 000, 2020 Hedaoo et al 3

Figure. Nutritainment−educational aids. (1) Adolescents participating in Nutri-Bites recipe demonstration; (2) image
showing Nutri-Bites recipes; (3) image showing Nutri-Animation clip; (4) image showing Nutri-Quiz.

girls = 58 and boys = 52). The Nutri- The pre- and postintervention animation, and recipe demonstration,
tainment module was administered nutrition knowledge scores were ana- except for the lecture session (Table 3).
during their socially useful produc- lyzed using paired t tests with SPSS
tive work classes through 1 contact package (version 19.0, IBM Corp, Ar-
session per week for a period of 3 monk, NY). A Wilcoxon signed rank IMPLICATIONS FOR
weeks by the research team. The sci- test was used to evaluate the differ- PRACTICE
ence teachers were engaged through- ence between the pre- and postinter-
out the module delivery for support vention scores for the educational The Nutritainment module, which
and coordination. The impact of Nu- aids preferred by the adolescents. was based on the edutainment
tritainment module on nutrition There was a significant (P < 0.001) approach, was effective in improving
knowledge of the adolescents was as- difference in the mean (§ SD) pre- the nutrition knowledge scores of
sessed by conducting pre- and poste- (9.0 § 2.29) and postintervention the adolescents. Considering the pre-
valuations using a pretested and (17.8 § 1.70) knowledge scores ferred learning methods of the
precoded nutrition knowledge ques- (Table 2). adolescents, the assorted teaching
tionnaire containing 25 questions. The Wilcoxon signed rank test re- pedagogies were combined for sus-
In addition, pre- and postevaluations vealed a significant (P < 0.001) differ- tained attention. The study found
were done to assess the preference of ence in pre- and postintervention the need for dedicated sessions for
the modules using a 7-point scale of scores for preference of all Nutritain- nutrition education in the school cur-
ranking (from best-7 to worst-1). ment components, such as quiz, riculum and necessary skills can be

Table 2. Difference in Pre- and Postintervention Scores of Adolescents (n = 100)

Pretest Score Posttest Score


Topics No. of Questions Mean § SD Mean § SD
Balanced diet and nutrition 17 7.0 § 2.26 13.5 § 1.07
Food labels 3 1.3 § 1.01 1.7 § 0.63
Deficiency diseases and noncommunicable diseases 2 0.6 § 0.79 0.9 § 0.57
Physical activity 3 0.1 § 0.45 1.7 § 0.72
Total score 9.0 § 2.50 17.8 § 1.74
ARTICLE IN PRESS
4 Hedaoo et al Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior  Volume 000, Number 000, 2020

Table 3. Pre- and Posttest Scores of Preference of Various Edutainment Aids Among Adolescents (n = 100)

Median Median Wilcoxon Signed


Educational Aid Preintervention Postintervention Rank Test Value P
Nutri-Animation 4 2 5.9 0.001*
Nutri-Quiz 3 4 7.0 0.001*
Nutri-Bites 2 3 6.9 0.001*
Nutri-Lecture 1 1 0.0 0.93
*Significance P ≤ 0.001; Wilcoxon signed rank test was employed.

better inculcated through experiential educational attainment and health 10. Gardner H, Hatch T. Educational
learning, and the edutainment behavior: a Danish population-based implications of the theory of multiple
approach can be effective in doing so. study. J Health Commun. 2016;21(suppl intelligences. Educ Res. 1989;19:
The time allotted for recipe demon- 2):54–60. 4–10.
strations did not cover the preprepara- 2. Scolari CA, Masanet MJ, Guerrero- 11. National Institute of Nutrition. Dietary
tion phase, and more time for this Pico M, Estables MJ. Transmedia liter- Guidelines for Indians - A Manual. Hy-
component can enhance the group acy in the new media ecology: teens’ derabad, India: National Institute of
learning opportunity of the students. transmedia skills and informal learning Nutrition; 2011:89–117.
The topics covered in the Nutri- strategies. El Profesional de la informacion. 12. Central Board of Secondary Education.
tainment module were essentially 2018;27:801–812. Comprehensive School Health Teacher’s
from those covered in the school cur- 3. International Institute for Population Activity Manual, 1. New Delhi, India:
ricula, and this study shows that the Sciences (IIPS) and ICF. National Fam- CBSE; 2010.
edutainment approach has a great ily Health Survey (NFHS-4), 2015-16: 13. Dzewaltowski DA, Estabrooks PA,
potential to complement the conven- India. Mumbai, India: IIPS; 2017. Gyurcsik NC, Johnston JA. Promotion
tional teaching and thus supplement 4. Ministry of Human Resource Develop- of physical activity through community
the inadequacies of curriculum-ori- ment, Government of India. Educational development. In: Van Raalte JL,
ented nutrition education. This is in Statistics at a Glance. New Delhi, India: Brewer BW, eds. Exploring Sport and
alignment with the recently intro- Government of India, Ministry of Exercise Psychology. Washington, DC:
duced National Education Policy 2020 Human Resource Development; 2018. American Psychological Association;
of India, which emphasizes effective https://www.mhrd.gov.in/sites/up- 2010:209–223.
techniques in pedagogy and learner- load_files/mhrd/files/statistics-new/ 14. Mayer RE. How multimedia can im-
centered and collaborative learning ESAG-2018.pdf. Accessed May 14, prove learning and instruction. In:
methods.19 Therefore, they can be 2020. Dunlosky J, Rawson KA, eds. The
adapted with tailor-made, age-specific 5. Sharp JG, Hemmings B. I’m Bored, Cambridge Handbook of Cognition and
contents for various age groups of stu- Get Me Out of Here!. Lutterworth, Education. Cambridge, United King-
dent audiences. Nevertheless, knowl- United Kingdom: The British Asso- dom: Cambridge University Press;
edge gain does not always guarantee ciation for Counselling and Psycho- 2019:460–479.
behavior change; and therefore, a pro- therapy; 2016. 15. Bandura A. Social cognitive theory of
spective case control study needs to 6. Subba Rao GM, Vijayapushapm T, mass communication. Media Psych.
be performed to assess its impact on Venkaiah K, Pavarala V. Quantitative 2001;3:265–299.
knowledge retention and behavioral and qualitative analysis of nutrition and 16. Gavaravarapu SM. Group quiz: a tool
change among adolescents. In addi- food safety information in school sci- for nutrition education and self-assess-
tion, the small sample size was a limi- ence textbooks of India. Health Educ J. ment. J Nutr Educ Behav. 2013;45:380–
tation, and therefore, the outcomes 2012;71:725–735. 382.
may not be generalizable. However, a 7. Rathi N, Riddell L, Worsley A. Food 17. Kolb AY, Kolb DA. Learning styles
short-term professional course in and nutrition education in private and learning spaces: enhancing expe-
nutrition education delivery methods Indian secondary schools. Health Educ. riential learning in higher education.
for teachers may help complement 2017;117:193–206. Acad Manag Learn Educ. 2005;4:193–
the current pedagogies that they use. 8. Rathi N, Riddell L, Worsley A. Paren- 212.
ts’ and teachers’ critique of nutrition 18. Kounin JS, Sherman LW. School envi-
education in Indian secondary schools. ronments as behavior settings. Theor
REFERENCES Health Educ. 2019;119:150–164. Prac. 1979;18:145–151.
9. Singhal A, Rogers E. Entertainment- 19. Ministry of Education. Government of
1. Friis K, Lasgaard M, Rowlands G, Os- Education: A Communication Strategy for India. National Education Policy; 2020
borne RH, Maindal HT. Health liter- Social Change. New York, NY: Rout- http://niepid.nic.in/nep_2020.pdf.
acy mediates the relationship between ledge; 2012. Accessed September 13, 2020.

You might also like