Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Moreno Et Al 1995 N-Fixing
Moreno Et Al 1995 N-Fixing
Moreno Et Al 1995 N-Fixing
17
© 1995 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printedin Belgium.
Key words: blue-green algae, cyanobacteria, nitrogen fixation, outdoor culture, phycobiliproteins, phycoerythrin
Abstract
Ten strains of filamentous, heterocystous nitrogen-fixing blue-green algae (cyanobacteria) were screened for growth
performance and tolerance to temperature, pH, irradiance and salinity, together with their potential as producers
of phycobiliprotein pigments. Phycobiliproteins typically accounted for about 50% total cell protein, the prevalent
type being C-phycocyanin, followed by allophycocyanin, with levels of 17 and 11% d.wt, respectively, in some
strains of Anabaena and Nostoc. C-phycoerythrin was the major pigment in several Nostoc strains, reaching 10%
d.wt. Some strains represent, therefore, excellent sources of one or more phycobiliproteins. All strains tolerated
an irradiance of ca 2000 mol photon m- 2 s- 1. Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047 and Nostoc sp. (Albufera) exhibited
the widest optimum range of both temperature (30-45 and 25-40 C) and pH (6.5-9.5 and 6.0-9.0) for growth,
the former also showing significant salt tolerance. In an outdoor open system, productivity of cultures of two
phycoerythrin-rich strains of Nostoc was over 20 g (d.wt) m- 2 d-' during summer. The growth performance of the
allophycocyanin-richAnabaenasp. ATCC 33047 in outdoor semi-continuous culture has been assessed throughout
the year. Productivity values under optimized conditions ranged from 9 (winter) to 24 (summer) g (d.wt) m - 2 d - '1.
This work deals with the screening of ten strains Fe-EDTA (Arnon et al., 1974). The culture medium
of nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria on the basis of specif- of Arnon et al. (1974) was used without modifica-
ic phycobiliprotein content, productivity and tolerance tion for Anabaena variabilis and modified to contain
to salinity, temperature, pH and irradiance. To derive 4 mM K2HPO 4 for the rest of the strains. In the case of
optimum conditions for outdoor production, the effect Anabaenopsis sp., the medium was also supplemented
of nutritional and environmental factors on the pro- with 30 mM NaCl. For the experiments aimed to deter-
ductivity of selected strains, has also been studied in mine optimum pH, the pH of the media was adjusted
outdoor cultures. Special emphasis has been given to by changing the proportions of KH 2PO 4 and K2HPO 4,
the allophycocyanin-rich strain Anabaena sp. ATCC keeping constant the total phosphate concentration. For
33047. achieving pH values over 7.5, NaHCO 3 (10-100 mM)
was also added.
At the laboratory, cells were grown photoau-
Materials and methods totrophically by bubbling through the cell suspen-
sion air supplemented with 0.4-1.5% (v/v) CO 2 as the
Biologicalmaterialand culture conditions source of carbon and nitrogen at a flow rate of 50-130 L
(L culture) - ' h - l . Cells were grown in 5 cm-deep 1 L-
The strains of nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria used in capacity Roux flasks, laterally illuminated with either
this work were: fluorescent or mercury halide lamps at the indicated
Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047 and Anabaena vari- irradiances, measured at the surface of the culture con-
abilis ATCC 29413 from the American Type Cul- tainers. The cyanobacteria were grown, as indicated,
ture Collection, Rockville (USA); Nostoc commune either in semi-continuous culture subjected to 12 h
B-1453-3 from the Culture Collection of Gbttingen light/12 h dark cycles, in batch culture with continuous
University (Germany); Nostoc sp. PCC 73102 from illumination or in continuous culture. Semi-continuous
the Pasteur Culture Collection, Paris (France); Nos- cultures were diluted with fresh medium to a cell den-
toc paludosum and Nostoc sp. (Albufera), isolated sity of 0.4-0.6 g (d.wt) L- 1 at the beginning of the
by V. Vidal (E.T.S. Ingenieros Agr6nomos, Valencia, light period, at which time samples were withdrawn
Spain) from the coastal lagoon Albufera de Valencia for analysis.
(Spain), the former being classified by M. Herndndez, Outdoor cultures were performed in 1m2 open con-
and the latter by us; Anabaenopsis sp. (Albufera), iso- tainers (miniponds) of 30 cm maximal depth (Fig. 1).
lated and classified by us from Albufera de Valencia Turbulence was provided by a rotating paddle-wheel
(Spain); Nostoc sp. (Dofiana), isolated and classified made up of three 28 x 32 cm paddles, operating, unless
by us from Santa Olalla lake in Dofiana National Park otherwise indicated, at a rotating speed of about 18 rpm
(Spain); Nostoc sp. (Chile), isolated from a lake in (culture flow rate, 0.35 m s-l). Pure CO 2 (at the flow
the Andes (Chile) and classified by us; Nodularia sp. required to keep the pH at a given value) was supplied,
(Chucula) and Nostoc sp. (Chucula), isolated from San from sunrise to sunset, through a PVC - porous tube
Pedro lake in the Andes (Chile) and classified by our placed on the bottom of the container. Cells were grown
group. in semi-continuous culture, cultures being diluted with
Nostoc paludosum, Nostoc sp. (Albufera), fresh medium early in the morning to the indicated cell
Anabaenopsis sp. (Albufera), Nostoc sp. (Dofiana), densities. Minimum temperature of the cultures was
Nostoc sp. (Chile) and Nostoc sp. (Chucula) have been maintained at 30 C, with the help of a 1.5 kW heater
recently deposited in the Pasteur Culture Collection, controlled by a thermostat. Growth rate and productiv-
Paris (France), and designed as PCC 9206, PCC 9202, ity values were estimated on a dry weight basis.
PCC 9215, PCC 9205, PCC 9201 and PCC 9203,
respectively. Nodularia sp. (Chucula) is available at Analytical methods
the authors laboratory, and cultures will be provided
upon request. For dry weight determinations, 50-200 ml aliquots
Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047 was grown on the were filtered through previously weighed GF/C What-
medium described by Moreno et al. (1987), contain- man glass microfiber filters, washed twice with dis-
ing 86 mM NaCI, 50 mM NaHCO 3, 8 mM KCI, tilled water and dried at 80 C for 24 h.
1 mM K2 HPO 4, 0.5 mM MgSO 4, 0.35 mM CaC12, Chlorophyll a (Chl) was determined spectrophoto-
as well as a supply of essential micronutrients and metrically in methanol extracts employing the extinc-
19
Table 1. Optimum temperature and pH for growth of several N2 -fixing cyanobacteria. Photon
-2 -1
flux density was 180 mol photon m s (fluorescent lamps).
Table 2. Protein and phycobiliprotein content (%d.wt; mean ± SD; n>3) of several N2 -fixing cyanobacteria.
-2 -1
Photon flux density was 180 mol photon m s (fluorescent lamps). Underlined figures correspond to
particularly high contents in specific phycobiliproteins.
Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047 45.0 ± 1.8 1.3 0.1 9.2 ± 0.5 10.6 1.1
Anabaena variabilis 56.1 ± 2.2 0.8 ± 0.1 17.6 ±- 0.2 11.0 ± 0.1
Anabaenopsis sp. (Albufera) 52.2 ± 2.5 0.8 ± 0.1 13.0 ± 0.9 6.3 ± 0.2
Nodularia sp. (Chucula) 42.9 ± 2.5 1.6 ± 0.0 11.5 ± 0.1 7.7 ± 0.3
Nostoc commune 39.9 ± 1.0 1.7 ± 0.2 5.2 ± 0.2 2.2 ± 0.1
Nostoc paludosum 40.4 4.5 0.6 0.1 16.7 ± 0.5 10.1 ± 0.3
Nostoc sp. (Albufera) 47.0 ± 3.5 8.4 ± 0.8 7.3 ± 0.6 3.5 ± 0.4
Nostoc sp. (Chile) 47.3 ± 3.9 1.9 ± 0.1 9.7 ± 0.3 6.1 ± 0.3
Nostoc sp. (Chucula) 37.3 ± 0.5 6.6 ± 0.3 4.1 ± 0.1 3.7 ± 0.2
Nostoc sp. (Dofilana) 51.6 ± 4.6 10.1 ± 0.6 7.1 ± 0.5 5.9 ± 0.6
The productivity of some nitrogen-fixing cyanobac- According to the wide optima with regard to pH and
teria under laboratory conditions at high irradiance has temperature, tolerance to high irradiances and NaCl
been assessed. Nostoc sp. (Albufera) was the most pro- concentrations, easy harvesting of the cells and high
ductive strain among the cyanobacteria tested in semi- biomass productivities achieved under fully controlled
continuous culture, with a yield of about 37 g (d.wt) conditions, the allophycocyanin-rich strain Anabae-
m- 2 d- 1 when grown at 1400 jmol photon m2 s - l and na sp. ATCC 33047, and the two phycoerythrin-rich
12 h light/12 h dark cycles. Productivity values under strains Nostoc sp. (Albufera) and Nostoc sp. (Dofiana)
the same conditions for the other strains tested were were tested for outdoor growth performance. The
between 18 g (d.wt) m- 2 d - l and 24 g (d.wt) m - 2 productivity of these strains in 1 m2-surface open
d -1 . When Anabaenopsis sp. (Albufera) and Nostoc miniponds provided with paddle wheels was 21-23 g
paludosum were grown in continuous culture and with (d.wt) m - 2 d - l in summer. It is worth mentioning that
continuous illumination, productivities obtained were productivity was not further enhanced by the addi-
about 40 and 54 g (d.wt) m- 2 d- 1, respectively. Under tion of combined nitrogen as 10 mM KNO 3 (data
these conditions, Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047 was the not shown), indicating that these N 2-fixing strains can
most productive strain, with yields higher than 100 g derive all the nitrogen needed for growth from dinitro-
(d.wt) m- 2 d - '.1 gen present in the air.
21
18
Table 3. Effect of carbon supply and pH on produc-
tivity (mean ± SD; n = 7) of Anabaena sp. ATCC
33047 in outdoor semicontinuous culture. Culture
14 depth was 15 cm. Cell density was maintained at
a minimal value of 0.18 g (d.wt) L- L.The experi-
ment was carried out in autumn at an average daily
irradiance of 516 pmol photon m- 2 s- .
L9 10
0
3 NaHCO 3 C0 2 pH Productivity
5g (mM) (mol m- 2 (g (d.wt)
day- m-2 day-l)
6
0 6.5 6.5 7.2 + 2.3*
10 4.9 7.4 11.3 - 2.5
50 2.8 8.6 12.1 - 1.7
9
50 0 9.3 11.7 2.1
0 1000 2000 3000
IRRADIANCE (mol photon m 2 s- 1) * Under these conditions, growth ceased after three
days, the indicated productivity value correspond-
Fig. 2. Effect of irradiance on doubling time of Anabaena sp. ATCC ing to this short period.
33047 in laboratory batch culture. Vertical bars represent standard
deviations; n = 3.
Table 4. Effect of seasonal solar irradiance on
25 productivity (mean ± SD; n > 3) of Anabae-
--- a-- summer na sp. ATCC 33047 in outdoor semicontinu-
· win ous culture. Cell density was maintained at the
20 _ optimum value for each season [spring, 0.20
g (d.wt) L-l; summer, 0.23 g (d.wt) L-l;
autumn, 0.21 g (d.wt) L-l; and winter, 0.11
I g (d.wt) L- 1].
15
Season Average daily Productivity
C3
irradiance (g (d.wt)
10 _
.
(ftmol photon m-2 day- )
DC m-2 S-1 )
(516, mol photon m - 2 s- ) and when bicarbonate was imental conditions, optimum cell density was 0.23 g
present, an extra supply of CO2 resulted in decrease of (d.wt) L- ' in summer, and about 0.11 g (d.wt) L- in
the pH value, without any significant enhancement of winter.
productivity. These results thus indicate that mixing of The results in Table 4 are a summary of productiv-
the cell suspension by the paddle-wheel system provid- ity values obtained throughout the year, and illustrate
ed the culture with all the carbon (as CO2 present in air) the influence of solar irradiance on the performance
required for a productivity of about 12 g (d.wt) m - 2 of outdoor semicontinuous cultures of Anabaena sp.
d- 1, optimum under conditions of moderate irradiance. ATCC 33047 maintained at the optimum cell densi-
Nevertheless, in summer, when irradiance was much ty for each period considered. Both productivity and
higher, addition of CO2 in adequate amounts (1-2 mol growth rate of the cultures increased with solar irradi-
CO 2 m- 2 d - 1) to the 50 mM NaHCO 3-supplemented ance, productivity values ranging from 9 g (d.wt) m- 2
suspension was an absolute requirement for pH main- d - 1 in winter, and 24 g (d.wt) m - 2 d-' in summer.
tenance and optimum productivity (over 20 g (d.wt) The latter productivity values are among the highest
m- 2 d - l ) (data not shown). reported for outdoor cultures of microalgae.
In microalgae mass culture, choice of appropri-
ate depth, cell density and turbulence is of utmost
importance for achieving high productivity (Rich- Discussion
mond, 1986). The effect of culture depth was stud-
ied in containers filled at different heights (10-25 cm) The screening carried out among a variety of filamen-
with suspensions of the same cell density. The highest tous nitrogen-fixing blue-green algae has allowed the
productivity (23.4 g (d.wt) m- 2 d- ) was achieved for identification of several strains, which exhibit unusu-
10-cm depth. Increasing the suspension depth resulted ally high levels of specific phycobiliproteins of com-
in decreased growth rate and productivity, the latter mercial interest. Some of these strains display besides
becoming only 60% of maximum for a depth of 25 cm wide tolerance to fluctuations in temperature and pH,
(data not shown). also resistance to salinity and high irradiance.
The influence of the turbulence of the cell suspen- The performance outdoors has been verified for
sion on the productivity of Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047 two phycoerythrin-rich strains of Nostoc and the
has been assessed in two different seasons of the year. allophycocyanin-rich Anabaena sp. ATCC 33047.
In summer, an increase in the flow speed from 0.17 Under optimized growth conditions, peak productivi-
to 0.42 m s - 1 (obtained by increasing the rotating ty values exceeding 20 g (d.wt) m - 2 d-' in summer
speed of the paddle wheel from 9 to 22 rpm) raised were obtained, with a mean annual productivity of
the biomass productivity by more of 50% (from 13 to about 15 g (d.wt) m- 2 d - 1. The productivity of phy-
20 g m- 2 d-l). On the contrary, in winter, productiv- cobiliprotein achieved was higher than 1 g m- 2 d - 1
ity was hardly influenced by increasing the flow rate of allophycocyanin, phycocyanin, or phycoerythrin for
over 0.17 m s- (data not shown). Thus, the beneficial the respective producer. Outdoor mass culture of these
effect of enhanced turbulence is patent in summer, at cyanobacteria thus represents an efficient way of pro-
high solar irradiance values, but not in winter. ducing these commercially interesting pigments, and
The population density represents a major parame- constitutes therefore an interesting and valid alterna-
ter in the production of photoautotrophic mass, exert- tive to the systems currently used.
ing far-reaching effects on the general performance and The market price for phycobiliproteins is around
productivity of the cultures. For a set of given condi- 50 US $ mg- ' (Gudin, 1988), which allows for high
tions, there is an optimum value of population density production costs. An evaluation of the latter for the
which yields the higher output rate and, therefore, the N2-fixing cyanobacterial systems here reported is pre-
highest photosynthetic efficiency (Richmond, 1986, mature, since the scale attempted is far from that of
1992). The effect of cell density throughout different a commercial facility. Although the results obtained
periods of the year on the productivity of Anabaena so far are encouraging, much work is still needed to
sp. ATCC 33047 has also been assayed. Optimal cell develop the mass cultivation of these organisms.
density varied along the year, according to seasonal
irradiance. The response of productivity in outdoor
semicontinuous culture to varying cell density in sum-
mer and winter is shown in Fig. 3. Under our exper-
23