Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Why President Is Elected Indirectly
Why President Is Elected Indirectly
Ans:
1. The farmers of the constitution wanted the presidential election to remain a quiet and dignified affair.
Tremendous loss of time, money and energy will be involved in a direct election of the president.
2. In a parliamentary system of government, power is vested in the council of ministers headed by the
PM and the union parliament. But the president is a constitutional head and no real power is given to
him/her. Hence it would be an anomaly, if the president is directly elected but not given any real power.
3. It would be difficult to provide an electoral machinery for an election in which millions of people
would have to take part.
4. A direct election would place too much power in the hands of the masses that are mostly illiterate.
5. There can be a conflict b/w PM and the President of India.
in Rajya Sabha it has functioned for 47%. A lower rate of functioning reflects time lost due to
disruptions which reduces the number of questions that may be answered orally.
3. While Parliament may sit for extra hours to transact other business, time lost during Question Hour is
not made up. Consequently, this time lost indicates a lost opportunity to hold the government
accountable for its actions.
4. Further, there is no mechanism currently for answering questions which require inter-ministerial
expertise or relate to broader government policy. Since the Prime Minister does not answer questions
other than the ones pertaining to his ministries, such questions may either not get adequately
addressed or remain unanswered.
5. In countries such as the UK, the Prime Minister’s Question Time is conducted on a weekly basis.
During the 30 minutes the Prime Minister answers questions posed by various MPs.
13. the position of the President of India under the Indian Constitution.
Ans:
Art. 53(1) which vests the executive power of the Union in the President provides that the power may
be exercised by the President either directly or through officers subordinates to him. For this purpose,
Ministers are deemed to be officers subordinate to him.
Article 74(1) provides that there shall be a Council of Ministers with Prime Minister at the head, to aid
and advise President in exercise of his functions.
Art. 74(2) lays that question whether any, and if so, what advice was tendered by minister to the
President shall not be inquired into in any court
Article 75(1) says that Prime Minister shall be appointed by President and other Ministers shall be
appointed by President on the advice of Prime Minister.
Art. 75(2) lays that Minister shall hold office during the pleasure of President.
Art. 75(3) lays that Council of Ministers shall be collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha