Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Student's Declaration: Gage University College
Student's Declaration: Gage University College
Student's Declaration: Gage University College
We, the understand, declare that this research paper is our original work, prepared under the
guidance of Garadew Kebede (MBA) All source of materials used for the manuscript have
duly acknowledged.
Advisor’s Declaration
Advisor
Name _____________________
Signature _____________________
Date __________________
ACKNOWLEDEMENT
First of all, we would like to thank our God, We are especially in debated to Mr. Garedew
Kebede Department head of Business Management and our Advisor, who have been
supportive of our carrier goal and who worked actively to provide us with the protected
academic time to pursue this goal.
Table of contents
page
Gage University College
Student’s Declaration..............................................................................................I
ACKNOWLEDEMENT.......................................................................................IV
Table of contents.....................................................................................................V
LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................IX
ABSTRCT................................................................................................................X
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION.....................................................................1
1.1. Background of the study.....................................................................................................1
1.2 Background of the originations.........................................................................................2
1.3 Statement of the Problem.....................................................................................................3
1.4 Research Questions..............................................................................................................4
1.5 Objectives of the Study........................................................................................................4
1.5.1 General Objective......................................................................................................4
1.5.2 Specific Objectives....................................................................................................4
1.6 Significance of the Study.....................................................................................................5
1.7 Scope of the Study...............................................................................................................5
1.8 Limitation of the Study........................................................................................................5
1.9 Operational Definitions.......................................................................................................6
1.10 organization of the Study...................................................................................................6
CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURER..........................7
2.1 Overview of Insurance.......................................................................................................7
2.2 General guidelines of Claims Handling...............................................................................8
2.3 Focus area of Claims Handler to Know...............................................................................9
2.4 Claims Management..........................................................................................................13
2.4.1 Quality Claims Handling.........................................................................................24
2.4.2 Claim.......................................................................................................................25
2.5 The claims Process............................................................................................................25
2.6 Customer Oriented Service................................................................................................28
2.6.1 Customer Service....................................................................................................29
2.6.2 Importance of customer’s service............................................................................29
2.6.3 Measure customer satisfaction................................................................................30
LIST OF TABLES
INTRODUCTION
According to ( Dorfman 2005: 1-2), Insurance is financial arrangement that redistributes the
costs of expected losses. Insurance involves the transfer of potential losses to an insurance
pool. The pool combines all the potential losses and then transfers the cost of the predicted
losses back to those exposed. Thus, insurance involves the transfer of loss exposures to an
insurance pool and the distribution of losses among the members of the pool. An insurance
system redistributes the cost of losses by collecting premium payment from every participant
(insured) in the system. In exchange for the premium payment, the insurer promises to pay
the insured’s claim in the event of a covered loss. From the legal point of view insurance is a
contractual agreement whereby one party agrees to compensate another party for losses.
According to (Teklegiorgis ,2004: 160), one basic purpose of insurance is to provide for the
indemnification of those members of the group who suffers losses. This is accomplished in
the claim settlement process, but it is some time a great deal more complicated than just
passing out money. The payment of losses that have occurred is the function of the claim
department. The nature of difficulties frequently encountered in this field is called ‘adjusters
‘The claim department is the ‘shop window’ of an insurance company. To purchase an
insurance policy is to purchase something intangible. It is simply a promise to pay in an
agreed set of circumstances. Consequently no one knows how good their Policy is until a
claim arises. How the claim is handled will ultimately decide whether the customer is
satisfied with the product they bought or will choose to take their business elsewhere it he
According to (ELiG division Head, 2013) the increase in the number of lapsed policies is
mainly caused by the dissatisfaction of customers in the service of claims management. It is
clear that Claims payment involves outflow of money from the insurance company and
inflow to the customers. Hence, the insurance company always works to minimize its costs
(claims payment) whereas the customers’ demands higher amount of payments. The claims
handling procedures in balancing the payable amount will obviously matter in delivering
quality service.(ELiG, April 2013)
If claims are handled efficiently and rapidly, customers will be satisfied and satisfied
customers will continue to place their business with the company and thus increases
company’s market share and contribute to the profitability of the company. But customers of
Ethio- life and general insurance are complaining in the service of claims and are not temped
to renew their policy. For this reason the researcher is interested to assess the major factors
involved in claims settlement process of Ethio- life and general insurance and affecting
customer satisfaction.
General (non life) insurance:-are insurance related to property, motor, liability & marine
policy
Life insurance:- are insurance related to life, person and permanent healthy policy
Claims service:-is formal request to an insurance company asking for a payment based on
the term of the insurance doing .insurance claims are revived by the company for their
validity and then paid out to the insured or requesting party (on benefit the insured).
In exchange for the premium payment, the insurer promises to pay the insured’s claim in the
event of a covered loss. From the legal point of view insurance is a contractual agreement
whereby one party agrees to compensate another party for losses (Dorfman, 2013).
One basic purpose of insurance is to provide for the indemnification of those members of the
group who suffers losses. This is accomplished in the claim settlement process, but it is some
time a great deal more complicated than just passing out money. The payment of losses that
have occurred is the function of the claim department. The nature of difficulties frequently
encountered in this field is called ‘adjusters’ (Teklegiorgis, 2004: 160).
Claims management is the core business area in the service of insurance company. The claim
is the tangible result of insuring. People take out insurance because they worry about the
possibility of misfortune. Ultimately the” value” of insurance will be judged for most
individuals by the way in which the claim is handled (Fricker, 2013).
A) Non- disclosure of a fact material to the risk which the policy holder couldn’t
reasonably be expected to have disclosed: or
B) Non-negligent misrepresentation of a fact material to the risk
C) Breach of warranty or condition unless the circumstances of the claim are
connected to the breach
The entirety of the contract between the insurer and the insured will be contained in the
policy documents. Conditions, broadly speaking, set of the insured’s obligations in relation to
the risk itself and often, more importantly, their obligations in the event of a loss (James,
2009).
In essence the insuring clause says that, subject to all the terms of the insurance, the insurer
will indemnify the insured in the manner and to the extent specified in the policy. For
acclaim to be paid, the insuring clause must be triggered (James, 2009).
Whether a policy is claims made or loss occurring, it will contain provisions that specify the
policyholder’s duties and obligations for making a claim under the policy. Usually the
notification provision will specify precisely who the policyholder should notify the claim to,
how they are to communicate it and the time limit for the notification (James, 2009).
Insurable interest
Formation of contract
The insurance policy is a contract and so the basic rules of contract law will apply as they
will to any contract. In the context of an insurance contract, the insurer provides
consideration through its promise to pay claims. The insured’s consideration is payment of
the premium (James, 2009).
Indemnity
Once the claim handler has established whether the insurance policy does indeed cover the
loss reported, their next task is to determine the amount the insurer should pay to their
policyholder in respect of that loss. In a simple case, the amount paid would equal the value
of the loss. However, there are many reasons why this does not always happen and claims
A condition precedent within a policy means that compliance with the condition is strictly
required if the obligation tied into it is to be binding. It is clearly important for the claims
handler to be able to identify within the policy those terms which do have the potential to
produce this draconian result (James, 2009).
The underwriter will narrow the scope of the cover through exclusions, setting out the risk
areas or perils they do not intend to include within the remit of the policy. Checking whether
the policy excludes a claim is crucial part of the claims handlers’ job (James, 2009).
Subrogation
Refers to the right of an insurer, who has indemnified an insured in respect of a particular
loss, to recover all or part of the claim payment by taking over any alternative right of
indemnity which the insured possesses ( James ,2009).
Contribution
It is concerned with the sharing of losses between insurers when there is double insurance
exists. The overriding principles being that the insured cannot recover for the same loss twice
and that the insurers should share the loss in fair way (James, 2009).
Reinsurance recoveries
Reinsurance is ‘Insurance of Insurance’ and is the protection of the prime insurer’s bottom
line by either sharing the risk with reinsurers. It is a mechanism of buying protection against
adverse loss experience. The claims handler needs a basic understanding of reinsurance so
It follows a series of stages at the end of which the status of a risk is decided .It is only after
the risk is weighed & all possible alternatives evaluated that the final underwriting is done
(James, 2009).
Whenever there is a claim, the insurer should Endeavour to provide the policy holder, who
suffers a loss, an appropriate indemnity. At the same time, it must ensure that (Koballa ,
2013) such payments are justified. This means that the Insurer must deal quickly and fairly
with all claims submitted be able to distinguish between valid and invalid claims; and operate
at minimum expense.
To do these functions successfully, an insurer must have an efficient claims department with:
Competent and well trained staff, efficient administrative support, efficient claims
procedures, efficient record keeping and management information system and clear corporate
claims philosophy (Koballa, 2013).
Oftentimes, loss situations awake the minds of the insuring public towards their insurer, as
many consumers pay little attention to their insurance coverage until they have a loss.
Claims, being the heartbeat of insurance, are the most critical contact the insuring public
perception of their insurer (Crawford, 2007).
Claims processing is the acquisition, retention, enterprise business intelligence for product
development insight sand profitability for the next several years (Cap Gemini, 2011a). The
speed, accuracy and effectiveness of claims processing is also paramount for controlling
costs, managing risks and meeting portfolio underwriting expectations (IBM, 2011).
The task of handling claims process has been challenging. However, modernizing the claims
process for efficiency, effectiveness and flexibility has been being daunting task, due to the
fact that it is a mission-critical function that touches all parts of the organization, affecting
competitive positioning, customer service, fraud management, risk exposure, cost control,
and IT infrastructure (TIBCO, 2011)
The insurance company writes insurance policies in easily understandable language. Policies
spell out what is covered and what is not covered. If necessary, plain language explanations
could be an addend unto the legal language. The insurance company draws the attention of
the policyholder/claimant/beneficiary1 both when he/she signs a policy (for policyholders
only)and when he/she reports a loss on his/her duties related to claim reporting which
include, to try to minimize losses
-To co-operate in the investigation by providing the company with all relevant information
and, in particular, copies of official documents regarding the damage (accident, loss, etc.)
-To authorize the company to handle necessary inspections and assess the extent of the
damage prior to any repairs or replacement
An appropriate claim form (when the loss reporting is made in writing) for the type of policy
-prepared either by an individual insurance company or at the national level by companies or
the supervisory authorities together with instructions and useful information on how to
comply with the terms of the policy and the legitimate requirements of the company. The
information necessary to help them to report the claims
Subsequently, if it appears that the claim cannot be settled rapidly, the company notifies the
policyholder/claimant/beneficiary and indicates that he/she will be re-contacted within
reasonable time limit. When it is necessary for the policy holder/claimant/beneficiary to
provide specific documents when filing a claim, the company sends him/her the list of these
documents as soon as possible
− If it appears that the claim is not covered by the insurance policy, the
companysendsanotificationassoonaspossibletothepolicyholder/claimant/beneficiary,
explaining why it is not covered.
− When the claimant is not the policyholder, the company sends him/her information on
his/her rights and duties when relevant.
Once a claim has been filed and, when applicable, after any additional documents that are
required to process the claim have been received, the file established by a company contains
the following documents:
They establish compliance programs for combating fraud and money laundering appropriate
to their exposure and vulnerabilities.
In the claim filing phase, they discourage fraudulent practices by making the
policyholder/claimant/beneficiary aware of the consequences of submitting a false statement
(which in particular could be liable to prosecution) and/or an incomplete statement. To this
end insurance companies place a notification on their claims forms referring to the
appropriate law statute or insurance regulation that addresses the filing of fraudulent or
incomplete claims. Where legally possible, companies participate in relevant databases
where claims susceptible to be fraudulent would be reported. Moreover, public authorities
may encourage or take steps to initiate the creation of a public or private bureau of insurance
fraud.
Besides, companies provide their claims department staff with adequate training on fraud
indention.
Any method of taking into account specific factors such as depreciation, discount in go
negligence on the part of the victim is clearly outlined in the claim file any loss evaluation
methods used by the company are reasonable and coherent. The insurance company uses
internal methods for assessing claim values based on the applicable law of the jurisdiction the
role of claims adjusters Companies that use claims adjusters or intermediaries will need to
ascertaintheircompetencequalifications.Moreover,iftheseclaimsadjusters/intermediaries were
to commit any errors or misappropriation of funds affecting their policyholders, claimants or
beneficiaries within the framework of the contract with the insurance company, the latter
would be held responsible. Consequently, companies may decide to limit the scope of action
of claims adjusters and intermediaries (for example, by setting ceilings on the number of
claims they can handle). Companies notify policyholders/claimants/ beneficiaries whenever
they use independent claims adjuster or intermediates.
General issues:- A company’s claim procedures are gathered together in a manual for
internal use. At least, one staff member should be responsible for ensuring that the manual is
kept up to date and additions/amendments are made when necessary
Companies’ claims department staff possesses proper qualifications. To this end, companies
encourage ongoing internal or external training of their claims staff.
Regular internal audits are carried out for all claims not settled in their entirety. Internal
audits apply to all stages of the claims management process. Peer reviews (where the claims\
department staffs each other’s files) could also be carried out.
Conceal policy coverage provisions of any insurance policy when they are pertinent to a
claim.
Dissuade policyholders/claimants/beneficiaries from obtaining the services of an attorney
or adjustor.
Attempt to settle claims for less than the amount to which the claimant would be entitled
to receive according to any written or printed advertising material accompanying the
application forms. However, insurers may take legal action against any intermediary that
has made irresponsible promises.
Deny claims without reasonable investigation.
Transfer responsibility for the claim to others, except as may be expressly provided for
by policy conditions Provision of information to policyholders.
If the claim is denied, the insurance company states explicitly to the policyholder/claimant/
beneficiary the policy provision, conditions or exclusion on which the denial is based. If the
amount offered is different from the amount claimed, the insurance company explains there
as on for this to the policyholder/claimant/beneficiary.
When the insurance company is not responsible (by virtue of policy clauses) for meeting all
or any part of the claim, it notifies the policyholder/ claimant /beneficiary of this fact and
explains
In accordance with applicable insurance law, companies may specify in the contract the most
likely period of time responding to correspondence from policy holders/ claimants/
beneficiaries. Once policyholders/claimants beneficiaries have filed a claim:
They are informed of the acceptance or denial of the claim within a reasonable amount of
time the receipt of the notification
The insurance company contacts any other company that is involved in the claim within a
reasonable amount of time, and resolves inter-company claim disputes as quickly as possible.
Quick claims settlement as well as high-quality and punctual information provided to the
policyholder/claimant/beneficiary are key competition features for insurance companies.
After an agreement has been reached between the company and the policyholder/claimant/
beneficiary on the amount of compensation, the payment is effected within a reasonable
amount of time.
Insurance companies implement and update their own statistical database tracing their
performance in the timely settlement of claims as well as in trends in settlements and
expenses.
A proper procedure for the coding and statistical processing of losses is developed for this
purpose.
If the policyholder/claimant/beneficiary is dissatisfied with the final response that he/she has
been sent by the company, he/she can activate an internal appeals process. He/she can also
The public authorities promote the implementation of a benchmark exercise regarding the
claims process or a specific part of this process (i.e. handling of complaints). The terms of
remuneration of insurance company employees or other services in charge of claim
Fraud Management
Not in the focus of top management, many insurers view fraud management more as a
specialist than a top management topic. They also often assume that the share of potential
fraudsters is below average due to careful underwriting and application checking processes at
their own company. (Michael Musiing ,2015) Journal
This often leads to high tolerance in the event of a claim, even if statements are clearly
contradictory. In most countries, it is the exception rather than the rule for fraud management
to be positioned as a top management topic, and for the level of tolerance to be defined as
zero in the interests of customers who are honest. (Michael Musiing ,2015)
Limited importance of fraud in operational claims processing. Usually a clear focus on the
topic of fraud is also lacking in individual claims organizations, and staff barely exchanges
notes. Alongside tools for the automatic recognition of fraud, systematic manual recognition
via checklists, fraud manuals or the like has proven especially effective, and can be
implemented fast. However, claims handlers responsible for manual fraud recognition are
often under heavy pressure from the high efficiency demands they come under from their
claims departments. (Michael Musiing ,2015)
The principle of having one claims file processed by several clerks is often the norm, too.
Both techniques make it harder to effectively recognize and fight fraud. Even comparatively
simple aids such as checklists or lists of guidelines can lead to considerably better results
without increasing the workload (Michael Mussing ,2015)
A quality claims service should therefore provide at least the quality that the customer
expects. Clients expect to be handled in an efficient, effective and appropriate manner. This
means that the claims must be handled in a consistent, yet flexible and fair manner that is
transparent, accurate and timely.
Claim handling is an important area in Insurance management, and should not be down
played as is often the case. This is because the core business of Insurance is to pay claims i.e.
No claims = No insurance. (Koballa ,2013)
2.4.2 Claim
An insurance claim arises when an insured event such as collision, overturning, fire,
accident, theft, sickness etc occur, resulting in a financial loss to the insured. A claim will
also arise out of liability of the insured to third parties ( Koballa ,2013)
A loss becomes a claim if there is in place a policy of insurance covering the events and the
insurance conditions are met i.e. when the occurrence of the perilous and subsequent events
meet the requirement of an insurance policy. This is necessary because failure to comply
with policy terms and conditions may lead to a delay in processing the claim or rejection of
the claim all together. Property to the insurer provided that you have been fully compensated.
(Koballa ,2013)
The object and peril must be insured under the policy of insurance for a claim to be sustained
under an insurance policy.
The policy terms should make it clear as to how claims should be notified, when and to
whom. This will be a condition in the wordings (usually 14 days of occurrence or
knowledge). The purpose of the claims condition is to enable the insurer to take steps to
investigate claims (or occurrence likely to give rise to a claim) in order to minimize its
exposure under the policy (Koblla,2013)
Claims review.
Reviewing the claims involves analyzing the claims in light of:-The proposal form, the
amount claimed, the exact terms of the policy, the legal requirements, market practice and he
Insurer’s corporate claims philosophy (Koblla,2013).
Response to claimant
The insurer’s first response to the insured may only be an acknowledgement or a request for
more information. Depending on what further information reveals, the insurers can take the
following actions:-Pay the claim, negotiate (bring in surveyors, claims adjusters etc) or reject
the claim. (Koblla,2013).
Claim investigation
In order to establish the facts surrounding the claim, it may be necessary to instruct an
internal claims inspector or external loss adjusters to undertake further investigations.
(Koblla, 2013).
The resolution of disputes is achieved via negotiations with the insured, alternative dispute
resolution mechanisms, arbitration or litigation. Sometimes, it is not possible to settle claims
amicably. On such occasions, the insurer and the insured must look for a form of dispute
resolution (Koblla, 2013).
Claim recoveries:-
Following payment of a claim, the insurer should investigate options of recoveries for all or
part of the claim from other sources. Third parties considered liable for the insured event may
be pursued; contribution or subrogation rights may be exercised. Reinsurers should be
contacted to contribute their share of claim (Koblla,2013).
The essential difference between insurance claims handling and reinsurance claims handling
is that reinsurance claims handling involves negotiations between two insurance specialists in
a business environment where a continuing business relationship may exist (Koblla, 2013).
Insurance claims handling, on the other hand often involves an insurance specialist
negotiating with a member of the public or commercial customer where a continuous
relationship is less likely if the claim settlement fails to meet insured’s expectation(Koblla,
2013).
Review of performance:-
Audits are usually carried out in respect of a sample of closed claims. Carrying out an audit
of claims handled can help the claims manager ensure that:-Standards of service are
maintained, internal decisions are made correctly, any reserves still attaching to the claims
According to (Alemnew T ,2005) No wander the claims department has been described as
the shop window of an insurance company. Bad experience of claims handling can affect
whether or not to renew with their current insurer. Hence the role of the claim department is
to: Provide a fast and efficient claims service, indemnify the policyholder in accordance with
the cover purchased, ensure that only valid claims are paid, deal with third party claim whilst
protecting the policyholder’s interest and protect the fund of premiums against overpayment,
fraud and expenses incurred due to inefficient claims- handling processes.
Today, customers are much more sophisticated. They are informed about how product should
perform and know that if they are dissatisfied with the service that they receive, someone else
probable sells the product and will provide better service. They may also expect that
expressing their unhappiness with a situation will elicit a positive result (Harris, 2000:2).
Customers need will change over time and therefore so will their expectation of service
standards. However if they are to keep up with the customer over changing demands they
will need to ensure that they have some methods of assessing exactly what those
requirements are and measure their satisfaction(Oberoi,2007:80).
Satisfied customers make repeat purchases and they tell others about their good experience
with the product. The key is to match customer’s expectations with company performance.
Smart companies aim to delight customers by “promising only what they can deliver, than
delivering more than they promise” (Kotler, 1996: 10)
Many companies in competing markets will redirect or allocate large amounts of resources or
attention towards customer retention as in market with increasing competition it may cost
five times more to attract new customers than it wood to retain current customers (Kotler,
1999).
The costs of obtaining new customers are three or five times greater than those of keeping
existing customers. Current customers are more receptive to the firm’s marketing efforts and
are, therefore, an important source of profit for the firm (Dorfman, M., 2005).
(Michael 2008) opines that insurance claims range from straightforward domestic building
and contents claims that are settled within days of notification to complex bodily injury
claims that remain open for many years. However, a claim on the policy is thus demand on
Gage university college 27
the insurer to fulfill its part of the promise, committed to while writing the contract with the
insured (Krishnan, 2010).
A claim is the defining moment in the relationship between an insurer and its customer
(Francis & Butler, 2010). (Singh, 2012) thus opines that retaining and growing market share
and improving customer acquisition and retention rates, insurers are focused on processing
by leveraging modern claims systems that are integrated with robust business intelligence,
document and content management systems which will enhance claims processing efficiency
and effectiveness.
According to (Low, 2000), efficiency measures relationship between inputs and outputs or
how successfully the inputs have been transformed into outputs. Efficiency is said to focus
on the input-output relationship, as opposed to output and outcomes; and that high efficiency
would be exemplified by the delivery of a large number for given inputs (Scott et al., 2008).
(Pinprayong & Siengthai 2012) had noted a difference between business efficiency and
organizational efficiency; while business efficiency reveals the performance of input and
output ratio, organizational efficiency reflects the improvement of internal processes of the
organization such as organizational structure, culture and community.
(Ilona & Evelina 2013) argued that effectiveness oriented companies are concerned with
output, sales, quality, creation of value added, innovation, cost reduction, and thus, must
measure the degree to which a business achieves its goals or the way outputs interact with the
economic and social environment.
(Capgemini ,2011a) opined that highly effective claims practices can be a key contributor to
a differentiated customer experience that strengthens customer loyalty and attract new
customers, which is especially valuable in a market with little or no growth. Excellence in
claims handling is being a competitive edge for an insurance company and it is a service that
clients greatly value.
Similarly, key components that must be in place in order to deliver excellence in insurance
claims handling according to (AIRMIC,2009), were noted as culture and philosophy,
(Brooks et al. 2005), more so, suggest some step-by-step claims handling activities to
include: acknowledging and assigning the claim, identifying the policy, contacting the
insured or e, investigating and documenting the claim, determining the cause of loss and the
loss amount, and concluding the claim.
Meanwhile, claim efficiency and effectiveness, according to(Capgemini ,2011b), had been
noted to be core benefits for claims transformation, which include: claim handling and
administration; allocated loss adjustment expense; indemnity exposure; and total cost of
ownership. The Productivity Commission (2002) as cited in (Yusuf & Dansu ,2014) suggest
a good claim management embraces: proactive in recognizing and paying legitimate claims;
assessing accurately the reserve associated with each claim; reporting regularly; minimizing
unnecessary costs; avoiding protracted legal disputation; dealing with claimants courteously;
and whatever possible, handling claims expeditiously. (Michael ,2008) stated that the key
elements of a modern claim management system that can process all claim types should
include a case management component along with the ability to calculate and process
complex reoccurring payments.
(Esri ,2012) pointed at five steps for optimizing the insurance claims process to involve data
organization, analysis and planning, mobility, management, and customer engagement.
(Singh,2012) postulated that for insurers to achieve higher levels of operational efficiency
and better process effectiveness, they must look towards implementing modern claims
system or enhancing their existing claims systems, leveraging advanced fraud detection
technologies and innovating around self-service through processing.
A claim is the defining moment in the relationship between an insurer and the customer
(Francis & Butler, 2010). (Singh ,2012) thus opines that retaining and growing market share
and improving customer acquisition and retention rates, insurers are focused on processing
by leveraging modern claim system that are integrated with robust business intelligence,
document and content management system which will enhance claim processing efficiency
and effectiveness.According to (Low, 2000) efficiency measure relationship with inputs and
outputs or how successfully the inputs have been transformed into outputs.(Ilon & Evelina ,
2013) argued that effectiveness oriented companies are concerned with output, sales, quality,
creation of value added, innovation, cost reduction, and thus, must measure the degree to
which a business achieve its goal or the way outputs interact with the economic and social
environment.(Brooks et al. 2005), more so, suggest some step-by-step claims handling
activities to include: acknowledging and assigning the claim, identifying the policy,
contacting the insured.
Sources of Primary Data: Sources for primary data are limited and at times it becomes
difficult to obtain data from primary source because of either scarcity of population or lack of
cooperation. Primary data can be collected through experiments, survey, interview,
observation or questionnaires, but in our research we collects through survey and interviews
and observation method mainly based focused Ethio-life general insurance sc staff or
employees and annual reports of Ethio-life general insurance company
Survey: Survey is most commonly used method in social sciences, management, marketing
and psychology to some extent. Surveys can be conducted in different methods.
Questionnaire: It is the most commonly used method in survey. Questionnaires are a list of
questions either open-ended or close-ended for which the respondents give answers.
Questionnaire can be conducted via telephone, mail, live in a public area, or in an institute,
through electronic mail or through fax and other methods.
Observations: Observation can be done while letting the observing person know that s/he is
being observed or without letting him know. Observations can also be made in natural
settings as well as in artificially created environment.
N 500
n= n=
1+ N ( e )2 1+ 500 ( 0.05 )2
n= 222
n =Sample size
N =Population Size
e = level of precision
Item
No. Questions Responses Number (%)
Male 24 67
1 Sex Female 12 33
Total 36 100
Diploma or below 10 28
1st Degree 20 55
2 Educational Level
2nd Degree & above 6 17
Total 36 100
< 1 year 2 5
1 to 2 - -
Work experience in
3 2 to 4 10 28
Handling Claims
4 to 10 24 67
Above 10 - -
As indicated in item 1 of Table 1, from the total respondents of the population, male
respondents were 24(67%) while the rest, female, consists of 12(33%). This indicates that the
gender distributions of both respondents are not proportional. Therefore one can infer from
the above data either the work nature requires male employee or there were discrimination
during hiring.
Item number 2 of Table 1 shows that 10(28%) respondents were Diploma holder or below,
20(55%) were Degree holder and 6(17%) employee holds 2 nd Degree and above. This data
implies that majority or 72% of employees are degree holder and above.
Department’s employees are well educated and this for efficient claims and risk underwriters
service.
Item number 3 of table 1 on the other hand shows that 2(5%) of the respondents had
experience of below 1 year, 10(28%) had an experience ranging from 2 to 4 , only 24(67%)
had an experience of 4 to10 Year and no employees had an experience more than 10 years .
This implies that 100 % of employees have an experience less than 10 years. The jobs nature
requires professionals and extensive interference with the customer. Hence, from this data
one can infer that the claim department of the company lacks experienced.
Man power making the service delivery in efficient. This is in line with the company’s
annual report of 2020/20 which states that “almost all work units were forced to operate
understaffed and with low level of expertise, which made the work to be done more
cumbersome”.
Total
S.No Question Yes % No % No.
Frequency %
Does your company clearly
1 defined claims management
34 94 2 6 36 100
strategy
Is strategy communicated to
2
the employee 26 72 10 28 36 100
From items 1, 34(94%) of respondent agreed as their company have defined clear claims
managements and 2(6%) disagreed. But from item 2,10(28%)respondent have not
communicated clearly the strategies to the employee and they don’t have the clear
information strongly advice that ELIG managements have to clearly communicated and
closely flow up his employee
From Table 4 we have concluded accordingly by data we collected from respondent 2(6%)
excellent,26(72%)very good customer relationship,8(22%) and no data we got. the employee
have very good relationship with their customer, but it’s not enough they should improve it
Yes No Total
S.No Question No. No. % No. %
management - - 20 16
periodically?
From the above table 5:-item 1 data collected from respondent 20(56%) were agreed that
their company using technology to enhance its claim management,16(44%) were not agree
that the company are not using technology to enhance the claim management ,so the
company should use the technology that are convenient claim management and reduce the
time consumed because of manual work or delay.
Item 3 most employee agreed that taken the training by most staff took quarterly20(56%) or
annually16(44%) this implies that the company is not interested to train his staff periodically
and once in a year or once in quarterly it is not enough, means the staff were not trained.
34 94 2 6 36 100
From the above items 1,employee respondent have excellent2(6%),very good 20(55) good
12(33%) and poor 2(6%)from all above data the means 2.05 and deviate to 1.2 which mean
ability to adopt working environment and conditions for constituent service delivery is at
very good level in ELiG insurance sc.
From item 2 data collected from respondent shows that 34(94%) have cooperatives and good
relationship to customers and 2(6%) haven’t good relationship with customer and
cooperative which means employee have good relationship with customer and cooperatives
in ELIG insurance SC.
Gage university college 40
4.2.1 Claim Management Challenges
Most Claim department today may face with many problem like lack of modern technology
facilities, insufficient information for risk management, existence of unqualified personnel’s
in claim the claim department and inefficient as regard the time used in assessing risk.
Yes No Total
List of Challenges
No. % No. % No. %
Lack of modern
1 -
technological facilities 16 44 36 100
Insufficient information for
2 -
risk management 10 28
Existence of unqualified
3 personnel’s in claim the -
6 17
claim department
Inefficiency as regards the
4 -
time used in assessing risks 4 11
From the above data collected from respondent16 (44%) mostly in ELiG insurance sc have
lack of modern technological facilities and 10(28%) insufficient information for risk
management which is going to affect the directly profit of the company,6(17%)existence of
unqualified personnel’s in claim department and 4(11%) in efficient as regards the time used
in assessing risks in ELiG insurance Sc.
< 1 year 35 27
1-3 46 36
>5 20 16
As noted on table 3.2 of item number 1, 112(87%) of customer respondents were male and
16(13%) of them were female. This implies that majority of claims were brought by Male.
From this data one can deduce that number of male and female respondent are not
proportional due to either majority of resources are controlled by males or females are not
insuring their property.
Item number 2 of table 3.2 shows that 92(73%) of claimants have business relationships of
more than 1 year. Only 35(27%) have experience of less than one year. This imply that
majority of claimants have already established relationship. Therefore the student researcher
concludes that the company should give due care in retaining its business with existing
customers.
Question
No. % No. % No. % No. %
Do you think your
appreciate your claim 20 16 60 47 45 37.5 128 100
1
settlement
procedure?
Table 4.9 indicates that with 20(16%) respondents believe that the clients appreciate a clam
settlement procedure of the company the rest 60(47%) they are not appreciate and 45(37.5)
of the respondents are not more clients appreciate or not the claim settle procedure. It implies
that the company give a less attention to the procedure of the claim settlement procedure and
they assess their claim settlement procedure because of procedure claim settlement may
delay and service quality may reduce.
satisfied
Very
Not
S.No Question
Total
Neutral
satisfied
Question
No
Total
Not
Yes
From the above Table 10.Item No. 1 indicates that 30(24%)of the respondents said that their
claim settled in the way of they expected ,45 (35 %) of the respondents said that claim settled
in the way of they expected which in turns , 8(6%) neutral and 45 (35%) they are not sure
about claim settlement. From above data mean is indicate 2.5 and it deviated to 1.1 or not
satisfied with claim settlement with the cover they have this shows that claim officers did not
reach quality claim service in accordance with cover they have and information gap created
between customer and both claim officer and underwriter. This may cause decrease the
quality of claim service and increase claimant complaints.
Item No. 2 of similar table shows that 33(26%) of the respondents have got fast claim
settlement while 50(39% ) they didn’t got fast claim settlement and 45(35%) they didn’t have
information or not are sure about claim settlement in other insurance company from data
above its mean indicate 1.9 and deviate to 1 ,it shows that the companies didn’t gave a fast
claims settlement to compare other insurance companies
Item No. 3 shows that it is relatively smaller proportion of respondents which is 31(24%)
who are willing to recommend EliG Insurance S.C and 7(5%) not sure but 90(70 % )of
respondents are not willing and not sure to recommend EliG Insurance S.C.to their friends .
Therefore, it is possible to conclude that the company gives less attention on it by creating
brand image.
Table 4.11 indicates that with a sum percentage of 50(39%) respondents did get good
information on claim handling procedure from risk underwriters while 60(47%) of the
respondents didn’t get information on the procedure of the claim rest 18(14%)respondents
not sure information on claim procedure at the time of policy issuance. It implies that most of
underwriting officer didn’t give a brief explanation to on the claim procedure at the time of
issuance of the policy this also creates a problem for the claim officer too.
5.1. Summary
This study tried to address 3 basic questions stated earlier in chapter one of this study.
Accordingly, all the necessary information is collected from respondents by raising specific
questions and the findings are summarized as follows:
Employee were asked through questionnaires the most challenges in ELiG Claim
department today in percentages as follow lack of modern technology facilities
(44%), insufficient information for risk management (28%), existence of unqualified
personnel’s in claim the claim department (17%)and inefficient as regard the time
used in assessing risk (11%).
The customers were asked if the claim settlement provided by EliG Insurance as per
their understanding and cover they have, But from the respondent we attend to only
24% of respondent said their claims settled or handle as per their understanding and
cover they have also 70 % of respondent have complaints and dissatisfied with their
claim settlements. But claim settlement is major factors involved in determining
indemnity but based on data collected the indemnity principle of insurance were
broken. Accordingly, indemnity insurance principle ensures that policy holder receive
and settle an amount in benefit equivalent to their actual losses, so do not make a
profit from it.
We try to compare ELiG with its competitor by asking customer the prompt claim
settlement service when comparing with other insurance company. But the
respondent answer as flow 74% of respondent didn’t get prompt claim settlement
service and only 26% of respondent get fast claim settlement service but majority of
claim settlement delay occur because of poor claim management. Based on this
analysis most customers decline to renew during policy renewal.
5.2. Conclusions
Based on the respondents answer and summary of findings, the student researcher has drawn
the following conclusions.
Most of underwriting officer didn’t give a brief explanation to on the claim procedure
at the time of issuance of the policy this also creates a problem for the Claims officer
too.
From the research finding it can be inferred that the claim practice of Ethio - life and
General insurance company is not as such convenient and transparent which is the
cause for customer dissatisfaction.
The research finding shows that supporting documents required to be fulfilled by the
customers are not requested at once and fragmented way of requesting documents
will lead to customer dissatisfaction.
As per the research findings the art of service recovery (complaint handling) is not
well addressed. As a result the company misses the opportunity to address its
weakness and take corrective actions to deliver the service to the satisfaction of the
customer.
5.3 Recommendations
Based on the data gathered from employees and customers and the major findings obtained,
the student researcher gives the following recommendations.
Insurance is a promise to pay in certain circumstances. When a claim occurs, this is often
the first contact a customer will have with the company since inception of the policy. A
perception of a company gained at this point is difficult to eradicate. Even if a claim is
paid in full, customers can be dissatisfied if the experience is less than what they
expected. Therefore the company should review the claim handling practice so that it will
be convenient, transparent and provide efficient services to the satisfaction of its
customers. In this aspect it will be better if it adopted management philosophy such as
total quality management or business process reengineering.
According to unpublished training book of Ethiopian Insurance Corporation, No wonder
the claims department has been described as the shop window of an insurance company.
Bad experience of claims handling can affect whether or not to renew with their current
insurer. Hence the role of the claim department includes Providing a fast and efficient
claims service as well as Indemnify the policyholder in accordance with the cover
purchased. Hence the department has to be organized by skilled, competent and
empowered employees.
(Esri 2012)GIS for the insurance claims process five steps for an effective workflow
(Frances and Butter, 2010) cutting the cost of insurance claims and taking control of the
process, strategy and retrieved from http.WWW.booz.com.
(IBM 2012).Insurance claims fraud assessment: Reducing loss costs by combating insurance
claims fraud. USA: IBM Corporation.
LoW
(Michael ,2008)The increasing important of claims management to insurance The national
underwriter company
(James ,2009) Risk Management insurance 12th edition.
APPENDIX I
Dear Respondents, the purpose of this questionnaire is prepared as part of the researches
effort to practically fulfill the requirements for BA degree in management from Gage
university college .The object of the research is to asses claim management practice of Ethio-
life and general insurance S.C. Your active participation in the research and your honest
feedback to the questioners will help us to achieve the objective .the date shall be kept
confidential and used for academic purpose only .you are not required to indicate your name.
INSTRUCTION
Please put tick mark () on the box provided and write your answer for those open-ended
question.
above 10 year ( )
3. Educational Background
Degree ( ) Diploma ( ) Masters ( ) Above Masters ( )
4. How many claims officer does your insurance company has?
10. Is there any claim challenge(s) over the recent years yet to be resolved?
Yes ( ) No ( )
Dear Respondents, the purpose of this questionnaire is prepared as part of the researches
effort to practically fulfill the requirements for BA degree in management from Gage
university college .The object of the research is to asses claim management practice of Ethio-
life and general insurance S.C. Your active participation in the research and your honest
feedback to the questioners will help us to achieve the objective .the date shall be kept
confidential and used for academic purpose only .you are not required to indicate your name.
INSTRUCTION
Please put tick mark () on the box provided and write your answer for those open-ended
question.
3. Educational Background
Degree ( ) Diploma ( ) Masters ( ) Above Masters ( )
1. Do you think your claim settled as per your understanding and cover you have?
Yes ( ) No ( )
4. How was the information given by the underwriter on claim procedure during the
time of policy issuance?
Very good ( ) Good ( ) Fair ( ) Neutral ( ) No ( )
5. Do you think your appreciate your claim settlement procedure?
Yes ( ) No ( ) Not sure ( )
6. If you have want to add something