Professional Documents
Culture Documents
World Gold Analyst - Zimbabwe Special Report September 2010
World Gold Analyst - Zimbabwe Special Report September 2010
A N A L Y S T
Zimbabwe – 2010 www.gfmsworldgold.com
WO R L D
GO L D
Gold pour at Turk mine (courtesy New Dawn Mining)
The Zimbabwean
Gold Mining Industry
WO R L D
GO L D
2 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Table Title
2.1 Short and medium term production targets for the main producers 10
3.1 GDP growth 24
3.2 Projected growth rates for selected indicators 25
6.1 Power generating facilities in Zimbabwe 42
7.1 Top ten gold producers in 2009 50
7.2 5-year production split 50
7.3 Blanket production history 51
7.4 Zimbabwe Chamber of Mines: Gold Producers’ Committee 74
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 3
Contents
Editor:
Paul Burton ACSM, MSc, MBA
Chapter 1 – Introduction 5
Contributors:
Paul Wheeler, Professor Rudo Gaidzanwa
Design & Sub-Editor: Chapter 2 – Overview 7
Gavin Khanna, gavink@mac.com
Published by:
GFMS World Gold Ltd Chapter 3 – Zimbabwe:
Hedges House
153-155 Regent Street Political & Economic Profile 17
London W1B 4JE. UK
Tel: +44 (0)20 7478 1777
Fax: +44 (0)20 7478 1779 Chapter 4 – Geological Overview of Zimbabwe 29
paul.burton@gfmsworldgold.com
www.gfmsworldgold.com
Marketing & Subscriptions: Chapter 5 – Mineral Production in Zimbabwe 33
emma.hastings@gfms.co.uk
Printing: Latimer Trend & Company Ltd., Plymouth
© GFMS World Gold Ltd 2010
Chapter 6 – The Gold Industry:
World Gold Analyst is an independent publication
committed to providing subscribers with factual A SWOT Analysis 35
information on selected publicly traded companies,
business and economics.
World Gold Analyst, its publisher, editor and writers do not Chapter 7 – Gold Production Review 49
own or trade in shares of any of the companies mentioned.
All statements and expressions are the sole opinions of
the editor and are subject to change without notice. A
profile, description, or other mention of a company in the Company profile – GAT Investments 81
newsletter is neither an offer nor solicitation to buy or sell
any securities mentioned. While we believe all sources of
information to be factual and reliable, in no way do we
represent or guarantee the accuracy or completeness
Company profile – New Dawn Mining 87
thereof, nor the statements made herein. World Gold
Analyst shall have no liability for any representations (express
or implied) contained in, or for any omissions from, this
presentation or any other written or oral communication
transmitted to the recipient whether or not World Gold
Analyst knew or should have known of any such errors
or omissions or was responsible for or participated in its
inclusion in or omission from the publication.
The staff of World Gold Analyst are not registered
investment advisors and do not purport to offer
personalised investment related advice.
World Gold Analyst has full editorial control of this
publication and all other information and analysis it prepares
in connection with the companies mentioned herein.
The profiles, critiques, and other editorial content of the
World Gold Analyst may contain forward-looking statements
relating to the expected capabilities of the companies
mentioned herein. The reader should verify all claims and
do their own due diligence before investing in any securities
mentioned. Investing in securities is speculative and carries a
high degree of risk.
The information found in this profile is protected by
copyright laws and may not be copied, or reproduced in any
way without the expressed, written consent of the editors of
World Gold Analyst.
WO R L D
GO L D
FOLLOW THE TREND...
find out who’s hitting the seam
with World Gold Analyst
www.gfmsworldgold.com WO R L D
For more information email paul.burton@gfmsworldgold.com GO L D
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 5
Chapter 1 – Introduction
L D
L DGO
L D DGO
WO R
WO R
L DGO W OR L S T
T L D L Y
L Y S A N A
A N A
A N A L Y S
M
D C O
G O L
R L D
T
S WO
G F M
sworldgold.com
www.gfm
Extract 2008
2010
from Onta No 2 June
Vol 11
frica
rio/Quebec –
WestWoA
2009
a – 2010
West Afric Report
lyst Special
rld Gold Ana ;
www.gfm
$400/oz ase
sworldgold.co
Mau ough US
m
Ontario cre
/Quebe dore –
costs thr sting a 2% de
w: Cash by po s the
c 2009 Q1 Revie t bucks trend e Mines remain Gold
agl
Newmon sts; Agnico-E rrick
Extract
from r; Ba
World Gol
co duce r, both
d Analyst
in cash cost pro produce
Special
Report s lowest ’s largest gold .
industry’ rld basis
s the wo d 12-month
remain an
arterly
on a qu
:
and Chile
Argentina er
Focus: Copp
More Than two elonga
te
the
Eye and Chile, ours, are
London Argentina
London can neighb copper
s London: South Ameri known for their
Producer
new comes to world’s t, but
Silver section Silver giant ing the perhaps
better gold outpu
ded in attract to than their Moz)
has succee producer production 40 t (1.4
ets y silver ces around
& Mark of results largest primar Mexican compa
ny there are
Metals Review und in each produ year. Moreover
s, t as each being
in six month its marke ires’ playgro of gold ation dollars gold
but up 13% ise. Fresnillo
lists; Billiona at Polyus and of explor t of
Gold volatile stocks fail to capital rer struggles . millions in pursui
Gold Explo Russia: Power min upgrad
es Sukari the region
whereas
gold World Centa
spent in its.
etal; depos
Ghanaian t Polym and silver d looks
w fears as the curren Des Cliffor
ter Revie Gold Coast intimates that l Focus
In this Specia exploration
activity
h 2008 Quar Gover nment regime
may be
of the companies
Marc on taxation at some foreign
analysis royalty and but Keegan and
PMI taken by
ent and ny being under ce basis.
28 pages
of comm
2008 quarter tightened
up,
rest joins Harmo ce-by-provin
the March . Newc silver on a provin
results for top gold press ahead adds 30 Moz
world’s Chinese
y of the earnings, in PNG;
Orko
for sevent ction, costs, t Sino Gold boosts Milligan
Produ projec
producers. , resour
ces, equivalent; to build
Mt
capitalisation Terrane
market reserves;
L D update.
WO R
Mine.
D
GO L
ANDINA
WO R
L D
GO L
D
6 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Chapter 2 – Overview
the resurgence of inflation, the lack of capital, Concerns over new mining legislation
modest recovery in capacity utilisation and a and indigenisation.
general drop in confidence in the economy.
Turning to the mining industry more specifically,
Inflationary pressures picked up during the first
there is also much uncertainty over amendments
half of 2010 with average annual inflation for
to the Mining Act. The policy of ‘use it or lose it’
the year expected to rise to 4.5%. Meanwhile,
looks likely to be be included. The revised Act is
the Minister has revised growth rates for the
likely to be finalised in Q3 or Q4 this year. This
economy down to 5.4%
will go a long way to removing uncertainty over
Zimbabwe’s biggest problem is its debt position, what is expected of the industry.
which is hampering efforts to seek refinancing
However, the greatest uncertainty surrounds the
and aid. The IMF, in an April 2010 report, was
subject of indigenisation, one of the most divisive
unequivocal in its assessment that “Zimbabwe is in
issues that government and the mining industry
debt distress, which is compounded by unresolved
will have to resolve.
economic policy challenges”. The IMF report
comments that achieving debt sustainability would The Indigenization and Economic Empowerment
require a significant strengthening of economic Act 14, 2007 was signed into law in April 2008 and
policies and an improvement of relations with provided for all companies operating in Zimbabwe
the international community whose support is to arrange for 51% of their shares or interests
essential for securing debt relief. therein to be owned by indigenous Zimbabweans.
To achieve that Zimbabwe needs to lose its The mining industry has accepted the broad
position as one of the pariah states in world principles of indigenisation in the Act, but is
investment terms and start to be a place where concerned about exactly how empowerment
investors feel comfortable putting their money. should be achieved. The Chamber of Mines
has put forward a proposal that of the 51% to
New constitution and elections key be put into local hands, 15% is as equity with
the remainder being made up of credits in
In February 2009, on the formation of the new equity equivalents, which could include local
unity government, the coalition partners agreed procurement, CSI, support to the small scale
to write a new constitution within eighteen mining sector, skills development, starting
months. Progress on a new constitution, however, new businesses and any other socially and
has been slow with the two parties disagreeing economically desirable activities. The COMZ is
on many implementation issues. also keen to have a listing on the ZSE as a way of
The processes for constitution-making, holding acheiving indigenisation.
the referendum and proceeding with elections The discussion between the Chamber and the
by 2011 are already behind schedule by at least government continues.
12 months. The GNU was expected to last for
If uncertainty regarding politics and the economy
two years after which elections would be held
can be reduced, the gold mining industry could
after February 2011.
develop into a major player again.
Professor Rudo Gaidzanwa, of the University of
Zimbabwe, in writing specifically for this report, Zimbabwe’s gold mining industry has
is pessimistic on progress. “...it is unlikely that potential to expand
elections will be held in 2011, judging from the
interests and statements of the political parties Zimbabwe’s gold mining industry is characterised
involved. Thus, it is realistic to surmise that the by rich greenstone belts that support many small
GNU might last at least four years instead of the gold mines, many of which are underground,
two years stipulated in the agreement and the narrow vein mining operations, which are often
elections would be held in 2013 at the earliest...”, privatively owned.
he writes.
The Zimbabwe Craton hosts some of the
Such delays will do nothing to ease the fears of world’s great greenstone belts. Greenstones
international investors. are one of the most extensive and productive
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 9
Despite the air of neglect, this plant at a former Central African Gold mine (now acquired by New Dawn Mining) is typically of the plant
that can be refurbished relatively easily to treat surface material (Photo: Paul Burton)
sources of gold on the planet and as such the problems are resolved (if not nationally at least
Zimbabwean rocks represent a huge potential at individual mine level through provision of their
treasure chest for miners. Examples of this type own generated power) by processing surface
of mineralisation include the Yilgarn (Australia) material, such as old heap leach dumps and oxide
and Abitibi (Canada) belts that have supported, stockpiles. With some investment, perhaps from
and continue to support, large, world-class gold cashflow, it might possibly produce at its reported
mining operations. capacity of 20 t/y of gold from existing resources.
The geology should not be a constraint to large The gold producers and explorers have some
scale mining but the miners in Zimbabwe have a exposed oxide ore on surface, which, when taken
mindset that favours small, underground mines as with old heap leach dumps, can be processed
the default option. Hence they need to rethink their through rather old mills and plants to get some
strategy and there are a number of companies who cashflow. But that is not their long-term goal.
are already actively pursuing such plans. They generally have an idea of the sulphide
potential that lies not far below the surface but
need intensive drilling programmes to define this
Producers need funds to finance...
potential. Thereafter they will need capital to
The industry could creak along in its current develop projects and operations.
state for some years, maybe reaching a third One of the keys to obtaining funding, which
of the output of its 1999 peak if the power invariably will come from overseas investors,
10 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
is to adopt business structures that facilitate the resources. They already have an idea of
investment. As mentioned earlier, many of the the potential on these former Anglo American
companies are privately owned. Although in itself projects. A 2009 independent technical report
this is not necessarily a bad thing, it is often a sub- assessed the potential sulphide resources at one
optimal way to run a capital intensive enterprise. of the projects as between 3 and 5 Moz.
Private companies do not have the same degree Some of the companies are already public.
of access to the capital and equity markets as a RioZim, for instance, is listed on the Zimbabwe
public quoted company will have and that can Stock Exchange. But the ZSE has limited
limit the amount of finance the company can funding potential. Other companies are listed in
raise to build mines, construct new plant and fund London. Caledonia Mining, African Consolidated
exploration programmes. Resources and Mwana Africa are all London
companies, although Caledonia is listed in Canada
...aggressive growth plans as well. What marks these particular companies
out is how diverse they are, both by commodity
Metallon Gold Zimbabwe, for example, is the and geographically. In the longer term it may make
country’s largest gold producer, yet it is a private sense for them to spin off their Zimbabwean gold
company, owned ultimately by Metgold Ltd, a assets into a separate vehicle.
London-based company. As readers will discover
later in Chapter 7, the company wants to pursue Perhaps ahead of the game with an international
an aggressive growth strategy that will see it listing, and thus access to the capital and equity
produce 1 Moz/y of gold within five years. To markets in North America already, is New
achieve its targets, the company needs to raise, by Dawn Mining.
its own estimates, some US$600 million to invest
in capital projects. It can’t do that as a private Large, open pits may revitalise
company. Therefore, Metallon is looking to go the industry
public and list on one of the world’s international
resource stock exchanges (probably London). So although most of the mines are currently small
producers, with the right type of exploration and
It’s not alone. Duration Gold and Bilboes by adopting the most sensible mining method, they
Holdings, two other private gold producers, could develop into mines comparable in scale with
are intent on obtaining listings to be able to those on other greenstone belts around the world.
tap into the international capital markets to
Producers will have to do away with any
fund expansion.
preconceived ideas that underground mining is
Bilboes Holdings, owned by GAT Investments, the way to go, of course. Looking at the Dalny
is looking to raise some US$15 million to mine, for instance, now part of New Dawn
undertake systematic drilling programmes on Mining’s portfolio, the company will investigate
two of its projects to take them through to the potential to not only mine, using bulk
bankable feasibility study and thereafter to list mining methods perhaps, multiple reef systems
the company to raise the finance to develop underground but also the ‘halos’ of lower grade
Table 2.1: Short and medium term production targets for the main producers
Company Short term production goal (1-3 years) Long term production goal (3-5 years)
Koz/y Mine Koz/y mine
Caledonia Mining 40 koz/y Blanket na na
Duration 60 koz/y 4 mines 300 koz/y 4 mines
GAT Investments 15 koz/y oxides 340 koz/y oxides and sulphides
Metallon 56 koz/y 5 mines 1 Moz/y 7 mines
Mwana Africa 30 koz/y Freda Rebecca 50 koz/y Freda Rebecca
New Dawn Mining 35-50 koz/y Turk 100 koz/y 3 mines
RioZim 24 koz/y Renco 112 koz/y Renco
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 11
gold mineralisation that the old timers missed The larger producers have been hardest hit
when following the quartz vein systems. Surface over the past few years by the tough economic
work at Colne/Stella on the property has circumstances and collectively their proportion
showed that high grade reefs have lower grade has fallen from 80% to 67%. “Large”, though, is
in between, over a total width of 12-15 m. This something of a misnomer in Zimbabwean gold
sequence is replicated underground (at 60 m mining terms as many of those classified as
depth) but the old miners only mined the two such are small in global terms as classified by
high grade reefs, so management is working on World Gold Analyst. The largest producer in
the theory that there may be economic grade in 2009, RioZim, produced only 24 koz. The COMZ
between, which opens up the possibility of bulk, categorises producers as ‘large’ although their
perhaps open pit, mining. production may amount to no more than 1 koz/y.
Many of the underground mines are quite low
grade. Freda Rebecca for instance had a head Figure 2.2: Zimbabwe gold production Source: COMZ
grade of just 1.76 g/t in the six months to end
March. Reserve grades are only 2.61 g/t.
years in having hardly any early stage, Detection Imara, a pan-African investment group, notes
projects. We came across just seven (7%) in a recent research report that investment in
standalone, greenfields projects. There is some Zimbabwe’s mining sector is starting to pick up
exploration work going on, it’s just that it is all despite investor concerns about an impending
centred on existing brownfields sites or defunct indigenisation law.
mining properties. This is in total contrast to the
Indeed, there are tentative moves to invest in
likes of Ontario, Quebec, Ghana, Burkina Faso
the country and its mining industry in some
and Mali, all countries we have featured in recent
quarters. For example, a new Zimbabwean-
reports and where there is a greater emphasis on
focused fund, Masawara, has just been launched
greenfields exploration.
on London’s AIM.
In total, we catalogued one hundred projects,
In addition, to finish on a positive note, this year
ranging from the smallest defunct pit, to fully
the gold industry has seen new entrants into
operating mines at 1,200 m depth. In fact, we had
the country who are prepared to spend money
to introduce a new category to our 6D model of
investigating the exploration potential. Although
the industry – “Defunct”! We identified twenty
there are only two at present, and their spending
four properties (a fraction of the total around the
is modest, South African producer, DRDGold, and
country that we did not have any data on) where
Australia’s Cape Range are both exploring in joint
mining has ceased but the mineralisation is being
ventures with local companies.
re-evaluated.
We have defined thirty eight projects as being in
operation (i.e. Depleting).
The following pie chart shows the breakdown by
percentages.
Development 1%
Definition
13% Discovery17%
Detection 7%
Defunct 24%
Depleting 38%
COMPANY SUMMARY
Company Project 6D Status
African Consolidated Resources Pickstone-Peerless Definition
Blue Rock Definition
Giant Definition
Chakari Detection
One-Step Discovery
Caledonia Mining Corp Blanket Depleting
GG Definition
Mascot/Penzance Definition
Cape Range Ltd Blue Duck Discovery
Eiffel Blue Discovery
Orcus Discovery
Inex Depleting
Carslone Globe & Phoenix Defunct
Golden Kopje Defunct
Chizim Investments Leny Discovery
Conquest Resources Beehive Defunct
Babs Defunct
Piper Moss Defunct
DRDGold Leny Discovery
Duration Gold Athens Depleting
Gaika Depleting
Queens Depleting
Royal Family Defunct
Vubachikwe Depleting
Auric Detection
Carry Detection
Tuff Nut Detection
Kernel Detection
Tiberius Detection
FA Stewart and Son Jessie Depleting
GAT Investments Bubi Depleting
Isabella Depleting
McCays Depleting
When Depleting
Gold Quarry Definition
John Mack Golden Valley Depleting
Metallon Gold How Depleting
Midwinter Definition
Shamva Depleting
Redwing Depleting
Arcturus Depleting
Mazowe Depleting
Motapa Definition
Mwana Africa Freda Rebecca Depleting
West Midlands Discovery
14 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
COMPANY SUMMARY
Company Project 6D Status
Lonely Discovery
Makaha Discovery
Prince Phoenix Discovery
New Dawn Mining Golden Quarry Definition
Old Nic Depleting
Camperdown Definition
Turk Depleting
Venice Definition
Angelus Development
Dalny Definition
Ladville Discovery
Basil Payne Discovery
Ox Mining Inex Depleting
RioZim Renco Depleting
Cam and Motor Definition
One Step Discovery
Spot Discovery
Kenilworth Detection
Sab Rock Miners Blue Duck Discovery
Eiffel Blue Discovery
Orcus Discovery
Zimbabwe Mining Development Corporation Jena Defunct
Elvington Defunct
Sabi Defunct
Asumura Ghana
Ity (46%) Cote d'Ivoire
Others Ashanti, Bayham Mining, Bronfield Mines, Calcite, Depleting
Canterbury Mining, DTZ – OZGEO, Eureka,
Exmine Syndicate, F A Stewart, Forbes &
Thompson, Hunderson And Sons, John Mack &
Company, LE Starling, Olympus gold mines, Pan
African Mining, Sabi Consolidated
Others Ardcor Ltd + Bilbos Holding, Ascot, Boreal Defunct
Investments, Boulder Mining, Delta Gold
Zimbabwe, Epsom, Harris J E, Homestake
Mining, Horn Mine, Knobthorn Mining, Maligreen,
P E Steyn, Pegolin Mining Ltd, Sebwe Investments,
Tiger Reef
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 15
Chapter 3 – Zimbabwe:
Political & Economic Profile
3.1 Zimbabwe at a glance
The UK annexed Southern Rhodesia from the first Prime Minister, was installed as the country’s
British South Africa Company in 1923. A 1961 President in 1987.
constitution was formulated that favoured whites
In 2008, after elections, ZANU-PF and MDC formed
in power.
a government of national unity with Robert Mugabe
In 1965, Ian Smith’s minority government as President and Morgan Tsvangirai, from coalition
unilaterally declared its independence, but the partner MDC, as Prime Minister.
UK did not recognize the act and demanded Source US Dept of State/IMF
more complete voting rights for the black African
majority in the country (then called Rhodesia). 3.2 Political developments
UN sanctions and an uprising finally led to
free elections in 1979 and independence (as The following article was largely written by
Zimbabwe) in 1980. Robert Mugabe, the nation’s Professor Rudo Gaidzanwa, from the University
18 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
race, arguing that Tsvangirai’s withdrawal was and generate new initiatives to restore their
unlawful and had no legal effect. The international legitimacy in Zimbabwe. While many governments
and regional bodies tried to stop the run-off, in the SADC may express solidarity with ZANU-
arguing that the conditions were not conducive PF, a significant number of them have borne the
to free and fair elections. However, their brunt of the economic meltdown in Zimbabwe
arguments were disregarded by ZANU-PF and through hosting refugees and asylum seekers and
the run-off went ahead. providing services to them. The long decade of
Mugabe was duly declared the winner and sworn conflict with the internal democratisation forces
in hastily, thereafter departing to an African and the international community has taken its toll
Union summit, in Egypt, where his reception on ZANU-PF, building sufficient pressure to force
was lukewarm. The African Union called for a ZANU-PF into a political compromise.
Kenya-style negotiated agreement amongst the The crisis period was followed by uneven
major political parties, demonstrating that there recovery in the various sectors of the
was declining tolerance for governments which Zimbabwean economy. Food and beverage
encouraged violence in their political systems, sectors recovered faster reaching just over 60%
threatened property rights and the rule of law capacity utilisation while other sectors recovered
and violated the rights of their citizens. more slowly at 30-40% capacity utilisation. While
The SADC bloc in turn, pushed for a negotiated the adoption of multiple currencies stabilised
political settlement in Zimbabwe as a result of the economy, limited liquidity in the economy
the findings by the Mbeki government’s delegation remained, which has also reduced the resources
of generals from South Africa, who had been sent available for patronage politics and forced
to investigate the state of affairs in Zimbabwe. the state to focus on delivering services to
According to the Democratic Alliance and civil the people.
society organisations in Zimbabwe and South Specific measures have been developed to curb
Africa, the generals confirmed the gross violence
the powers of various functionaries such as the
against certain sections of the population. This
Reserve Bank governor, ministers and others in
increased the impetus of the SADC in seeking
the state sector. Strict cash budgeting has curbed
mechanisms for ensuring stability in Zimbabwe.
excesses and diversion of budgets to unbudgeted
In July 2008, Mbeki brought ZANU-PF and the expenditures. Results-based management also
MDC parties to the negotiating table. makes politicians and civil servants accountable
The political agreement between ZANU-PF for their performance whereas in the past,
and the MDC formations was crafted amidst political imperatives dominated the civil service.
conditions of economic collapse in Zimbabwe. This stabilisation also halted the worst excesses
The Zimbabwe dollar was no longer accepted experienced during the hyperinflation period.
as currency by the majority; schools and Policy framework
hospitals had closed and 95% of the population
were unemployed. While the state press give the impression that the
policies and dominance of ZANU-PF continue
The negotiations continued into December uninterrupted, there have been major shifts in
when on the 13th, the draft constitutional policies and behaviour by the state. For example,
amendment, which marked a major step towards notwithstanding the continued rhetoric against
the formation of an inclusive government in donors, western countries and NGOs that are
Zimbabwe, was gazetted. On the 5th of February, active in the governance and human rights sector,
2009 both houses of parliament passed the Unity Mugabe has not signed the NGO Bill into law.
Government bill unanimously, with an eye on the There are indications that the Look East policy
impending African Union Summit which endorsed of the government has also nudged some western
the agreement between the political parties. governments towards re-engagement with
The post-crisis period: politics Zimbabwe’s political class in order to re-engineer
and policies. a more workable relationship with them.
President Mugabe and ZANU-PF have been In the context of the economic and social
forced to undertake political modernisation problems in Zimbabwe, there is some recognition
20 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
that there is a price to be paid at the polls community has taken its toll on ZANU-PF while
by any party that does not take the demands the long struggle against ZANU-PF over two
of the populace seriously. While the parties decades has also exhausted the MDC and the
in the agreement may stall the constitution- civil rights and democracy movement. Thus, the
making exercise for various reasons, it is quite fatigue on both sides creates the possibility for
clear that it is no longer prudent to ignore or accommodation, notwithstanding the struggles
circumvent the wishes of significant players in the for supremacy within and between these
economy and society. political formations.
The increased privatisation The gradual engagement of the International
of the economy Financing Institutions, western countries and
There has been a significant shift in focus donors since 2007 indicates that the politics of
towards the economy as the form and content expediency have taken hold while the rhetoric
of the economy has changed. While rent-seeking against capital, the west, imperialism and
activities could provide windfall incomes, there colonialism may give the impression that the
is recognition that in a stabilised economy, situation remains the same. While the ZANU-PF
significant economic activities requiring segment of the government continues to extract
investment in capital, time and skills have resources such as diamonds, the stringency of the
gained importance. IFIs’ funding conditions prevents significant access
to state coffers. There is an inexorable shift
Thus, the struggle over the diamond fields
towards regularisation of trade, commerce and
in Marange shows the attempt by ZANU-PF
other activities as shown by the compromise and
functionaries to participate in the diamond
negotiations with the Kimberley Process players.
sector on a more formal basis. In this respect,
many of the political players who accumulated Slow reform within ZANU-PF as the
wealth during the hyperinflationary era desire economy becomes more regularised
to institutionalise and internationalise their
ZANU-PF continues to face problems with
businesses, creating linkages with existing and
succession but this may be an issue only as
established players within and outside Zimbabwe.
long as the securocrats’ stake in the economy
For these politicians, there is a significant
is not assured. Many of the securocrats may
incentive to stabilise the economy and society, re-
become significant players in business and
engage the international community and re-join
all the international bodies that can help further institutionalisation of their interests post-Mugabe
their economic interests. Thus, it is critical to may be the price of peace. They are anxious about
recognise that while there remains a radical fringe their fate and in these situations they are usually
which can destabilise the recovery, there is also bought off as the price for stability. If this were to
a moderate segment that is not willing to remain happen, it would enable the moderate segment
marginal to the recovery, the economy and the of ZANU-PF to open dialogue with all sectors of
accumulation of significant wealth. This is the the population and the international community.
element that can support business interests. Since This is the option that the successive Mbeki
the mining sector, particularly gold and diamonds, and Zuma governments in South Africa appear
remain the focus of many politicians’ interest, to favour on the basis that ZANU-PF, with
there is merit in engaging these politicians in the support of the securocrats, can help
dialogue over progress in the mining sector. avert political strife and state disintegration
Thus, the post-GPA period has lowered the in Zimbabwe. The South African government
political temperature even though there are appears to have shared the securocrats’ fears
episodes of strident and radical rhetoric of about the MDC-T, assuming that the MDC is
previous years. The segments of ZANU-PF that at best an unknown quantity and at worst, a
are inclined towards reform share some common western puppet, with little support amongst the
ground with their MDC counterparts, raising ‘liberation’ leaders in the region, making close
the possibility of a moderate middle faction ties to ZANU-PF necessary if only to ensure that
comprising elements from both parties. The the ANC is not isolated in the region and the
decade of bitter struggle against the international continent on the Zimbabwe question.
22 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
This option has been overtaken by events as the This long journey to a new constitution, one
MDC has remained quite popular in comparison that lessens the powers of the President and
with ZANU-PF. The problem of succession and guarantees greater civil freedom, is not going
the structures in the party that have supported to be easy one as there are already claims by
Mugabe against other leaders in ZANU-PF have MDC-T and human rights group Zimbabwe Peace
split ZANU-PF into factions and frustrated Project and Zimbabwe Election Support Network
attempts to reform the party, in the process of intimidation of villagers by ZANU-PF members
weakening the party quite substantially. during the outreach process. There are concerns
that the lead up to charter reform could be
Thus, political compromise with one or both
marred by the kind of violence that the country
factions of the MDC has occurred. The agreement
experienced in 2008 in the presidential run-off.
that was reached after the violent run-off under
an unreconstructed ZANU-PF is supported ZANU-PF has even stated that elections may
by slow economic growth. Thus, the business go ahead regardless of whether or not the new
community can play a critical role in hastening constitution is in place. Clearly it plays into
economic growth, effecting an economic their hands to frustrate the process for as long
transition, which will not be controllable by as possible.
politicians. With or without a new constitution, The SADC and its mediator, South African
economic growth can help to support social and President Jacob Zuma, will have a key role to
political liberalisation. play here.
In many countries such as those of South Meanwhile President Mugabe was back to his
East Asia, which have experienced significant most radical rhetoric recently, telling the West
economic growth, political and social transitions to go to hell with their interfering and sanctions.
have not necessarily been violent and traumatic. “We should not allow colonial thieves to take our
This scenario would be ideal if it were allowed to resources” he said.
unfold through significant economic investment
That should encourage foreign investment!
and growth. This scenario appears to have
started unfolding slowly as food availability in
3.3 The Economy
the shops has increased, schools and hospitals
have re-opened, albeit with very little staff and
Hyperinflation
resources to deliver basic services. There is a role
for business in general, and the mining sector The country’s economy has just been through
in particular, to accelerate the unfolding of this a period of unprecedented turmoil, which saw
scenario through investment, job creation and hyperinflation and a rapidly depreciating currency
economic growth. that led to the removal of the Z$ and installation
of the US dollar (and the South African Rand) as
2011– A new constitution the country’s currency, at least until 2012.
and elections?
The backdrop to this was that in May 2008, the
Progress on a new constitution, to replace the official Z$ to US$ exchange rate was revised to a
one drawn up in 1979, has been slow with the floating rate of about Z$165,000,000=US$1, from
two parties within the GNU disagreeing on issues a fixed rate of Z$30,000=US$1.
such as funding and who should be collecting
views on the constitution, despite the fact that After the official inflation rate reached
they agreed on formation of the new government 231,000,000% in July 2008, the government
to write a new constitution within eighteen ceased to release consumer price index data,
months. The ‘outreach’ programme, whereby mainly because there were few goods available
analysts are sent out to garner feedback on the for purchase on the shelves of stores!
constitution through a series of public meetings In August, the newly-issued Z$10,000,000,000
with local communities, only started in June this dollar bill was revalued to Z$1. Hyperinflation,
year, so there is little likelihood of anything being which was estimated to have reached
drafted this year. According to observers the about 500,000,000,000% in September and
process is almost a year behind schedule. 89,700,000,000,000,000,000,000% in November,
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 23
was finally dampened in late 2008 by the de facto dollarisation of the economy came in tandem
migration from the Zimbabwe dollar to foreign with the agreement that gold producers could
currencies1. be paid international prices in US$, a move that
galvanised the industry back into production.
STERP
The improvement in economic fortunes was
One of the first acts of the unity government,
immediate and dramatic in 2009 through to 2010
which came into office in mid-February 2009,
as the inflation rate was brought under control
was to introduce measures to tackle the
and stability returned to the markets. Shops were
unprecedented economic crisis. Its “Short Term
full again.
Economic Recovery Plan (STERP)” came in at a
time of “unprecedented levels of hyper-inflation, STERP was an emergency package to see the
sustained period of negative GDP growth country through to the end of the year. It was
rates, massive devaluation of the currency, low to be followed by a five-year plan to guide the
productive capacity, loss of jobs, food shortages, economy through to 2015 but although this was
poverty, massive de-industrialisation and general drafted it was never inacted and remains a ‘work
despondency”2 in progress’.
One of the main aims of STERP was to ensure The Ministry of Finance did, however, follow up
that there was increased capacity utilisation in December 2009 with its 2010 Budget and a
in every sector of the economy, especially subsequent The Three Year Macro-Economic
agriculture and mining, where the government Policy and Budget Framework: 2010-2012 (STERP
undertook to abolish the retention of commodity II) the same month.
earnings by any authority in Zimbabwe with
The aim of STERP II was to build on the
the promise, however, to “review upwardly
foundation laid by STERP and continue the
the taxation and royalty structures in line with
restoration of economic stability and growth in
international standards”.
the country. The Ministry of Finance recognised
But the key response to hyperinflation was the that although inflation had been controlled,
dispensation that “all enterprises are free to trade there was still much to do with the economy
in South African rands, United States dollars or (still fragile with a number of challenges which
any other convertible currency”. This effective required urgent attention, including: capacity
24 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
The centre of Bulawayo where trade has grown again (Photo: Paul Burton)
Challenges facing the government According to IMF statistics, at the end of 2009,
and the economy total public and publicly-guaranteed debt
amounted to US$6.9 billion or 157% of GDP, of
The Mid-Year Fiscal Policy Review identified which 102% of GDP was in arrears. Zimbabwe’s
several challenges to sustained, rapid economic overdue financial obligations to IFIs include
growth, the most important of which we the World Bank (US$731 million), African
discuss here. Development Bank (US$483 million), and the
Lack of inflows of capital IMF (US$140 million).
The estimated lack of inflows of investment capital The IMF report comments that achieving
resources is US$10 billion annually or US$30 debt sustainability would require a significant
billion over the period 2010 – 2012. The bulk of strengthening of economic policies and an
these resources can only come from external improvement in relations with the international
sources. However, the country has not been able community whose support is essential for
to attract meaningful external support in the form securing debt relief.
of lines of credit, foreign direct investment and Reserve Bank problems
donor support, according to the Finance Ministry.
The IMF is blunt in its assessment that “The
Lack of fiscal space Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe is in financial distress
The Minister is having problems balancing and suffers from weak governance”.4
the budget. With a fragile economy, revenue The government has taken actions and with
collections estimated at US$1.75 billion are the amendment of the Reserve Bank Act and
consumed largely by current expenditures the subsequent appointment of the Reserve
Bank Board, the focus is now on implementing fiscus. Therefore he has urged amendments to
the requisite governance reforms through the Mining Act to include greater transparency
restructuring, and downsizing of the Bank to align in exploration licence registration, the
it to core functions under the multi-currency entrenchment of the principle of ‘use it or
regime. Central to these reforms, is also the issue lose it’ with regard to claims, greater mineral
of addressing the indebtedness of the Reserve beneficiation and greater taxation of mining
Bank estimated at about US$1.5 billion. companies with the warnng that “the current
legal structure codified in our Mining law that the
Power supply
State can only look to corporate tax and royalties
The supply of adequate power is a huge issue that from the mining sector is unsustainable”. He
the government admits it has thus far not dealt with. has announced the increase in royalties on gold
The Minister stated in the Mid-Year Review that it revenue to 4%.
was important that government deals urgently with
Economic prospects
the key issues of power generation, including the
refurbishment and upgrading of power transmission Table 3.2 (previous page) shows projected
lines and of power stations. However, he has economic growth indicators according to the
allocated only US$15 million to the problem when, latest IMF report4.
by his own estimate, the upgrade of Hwange and
3.4 Mining Law & Mineral Policies
Kariba, the country’s main generating stations, will
require a total of US$139 million. The Mines and Minerals Act is the principal law
governing mining in Zimbabwe. This law provides
Mining legislation
security of tenure and has clear provisions for
The Minister is concerned that the mining acquisition, maintenance and relinquishing of
industry does not contribute enough to the mining title.
Companies need a Mining Lease to mine on a scale such as at Duration Gold’s ML 16 property (Photo: Paul Burton)
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 27
The Act (as amended) has been in force since process of signing off EPOs already approved will
1965. Currently it is being amended again to resume later in 2010.
improve the administration and management of
A Mining Claim is a permit to prospect and
the ‘use it or lose it’ policy and government and
mine over a small area and usually several claims
the Chamber of Mines have consulted with each
are grouped to form a block of claims. Ordinary
other throughout the process. The revised Act is
claims are up to 25 ha and a block of claims may
likely to be finalised in Q3 or Q4 this year. This
be transformed into a Mining Lease for simplicity
will go a long way to removing uncertainty over
of administration.
what is expected of the industry.
Meanwhile, there are two types of mining licences
The Act is enforced by the Ministry of Mines &
available for gold companies.
Mineral Development (MMMD).
A Mining Lease confers the exclusive right of
Although not solely applicable to the mining
mining any ore or deposit which occurs within
industry, the Indigenization and Economic
the vertical limits of the area covered by the
Empowerment Act 14, 2007 was signed into law
lease. A Special Mining Lease (SML), on the
in April 2008 and provided for all companies
other hand, applies where the holder of one or
operating in Zimbabwe to arrange for 51% of
more contiguous registered mining locations
their shares or interests therein to be owned by
intends to establish or develop a mine where the
indigenous Zimbabweans. The COMZ has put
investment will be wholly or mainly in foreign
forward the views of the mining industry that
currency and will exceed US$100 million and the
the equity component should be restricted to
mine’s output is intended principally for export.
15%, with credits in equity equivalents, including
SMLs are valid for 25 years.
local procurement and support to the small scale
mining sector, making up the remainder (see 2010 budget and mining
section 6.3 for more details). There were a number of provisions brought in
Mineral rights and licences in this year’s Budget that will affect the mining
industry. Among these were conditions to enforce
All mineral rights are vested in the President and
the “use it or lose it” philosophy as it applies to
an application to take out a licence must be made
mining claims. In order to discourage holders of
to the MMMD through a process defined in the
mining claims from retaining un-worked ground
Act. The Mining Commissioner issues exploration
for speculative purposes, the Minister introduced
licences, of which, for gold, there are two main
a fee of US$100 per ha per annum on unworked
applicable types.
claims and removed the option to spread taxable
A Prospecting licence may be taken out by any income earned from the sale of mining claims
person who is permanent resident of Zimbabwe over a period of four years.
for a period of two years. This licence entitles the
Also in the Budget, the royalty rate for gold was
holder to undertake reconnaissance work but they
increased from 3% of gross market value to 3.5%,
are not allowed to drill or remove any materials.
from the start of 2010. However, the Minister of
Any person or company (local or international) Finance recently further increased the royalty
may take out an Exclusive Prospecting rate to 4%, effective October 1, 2010. Designated
Order (EPO) for a period of three years with financial institutions now collect the royalties
an option to extend the period by an additional instead of Fidelity Refineries.
three years. The area under licence was limited
The Budget also had bad news for gold miners
to 65,000 ha in the case of gold, but in the 2010
in the shape of an increase in the corporate tax
Budget (presented on December 5, 2009) the
rate to 25% in line with other industry sectors.
Minister of Finance proposed a reduction to a
Previously the gold producers received a special
maximum 20,000 ha for each EPO. The Minister
dispensation that had them paying just 15%, while
further proposed that application and renewal
the basic corporate tax rate was 30%.
fees for EPOs be set at US$100,000.
The COMZ is also working with the MMMD on a
Incidentally, the President has not signed any
new mineral development policy for the country.
EPOs since 2002 but the Ministry of Mines and
Mineral Development has announced that the Presently, government participation in mining
28 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Bibliography
Biti, Tendai. “The Death of Constitutionalism: Constitutional Amendment No. 17 and
the State of the State.” Unpublished paper, 2005.
Bracking Sarah, ‘Development Denied: Autocratic Militarism in Post-election
Zimbabwe.’ Review of African Political Economy, Nos: 104/105, 2005, pp 341-357.
Brett E.A. “Political Victories and Economic Defeats: Managing the Post-Election crisis
in Zimbabwe.” Unpublished paper. 2005.
Games, Dianna. A Nation in Turmoil: The Experience of South African Firms doing
Business in Zimbabwe. Business in Africa Report NO. 8, South African Institute for
International Affairs, 2006.
Hawkins, Tony. ‘Still Standing: The economic, political and security situation in
Zimbabwe 2006 and implications for the SADC region.’ Paper presented to the
Institute for Security Studies, University of Pretoria, 4th May 2006.
Hilsum Lindsey, ‘Briefing: Re-enter the Dragon: China’s New Mission in Africa,’
Review of African Political Economy, 2005, pp 419-425.
International Crisis Group, “Zimbabwe’s Continuing Self-Destruction”. Africa Briefing
No 38, Pretoria/ Brussels 6th June 2006.
Lodge Tom, ‘Quiet Diplomacy in Zimbabwe: A case study of South Africa in Africa.’
Unpublished mimeograph. 2004.
Maroleng Chris, ‘Situation Report: Zimbabwe: Increased securitisation of the state?”
Institute for Security Studies, September 2005.
Movement for Democratic Change (Tsvangirai), “MDC Proposals for the
Resolution of the Zimbabwean Crisis: Sign posts to Peace, Democracy, Legitimacy,
Reconstruction and National Healing.” Harare May 2006.
Muleya Dumisani, ‘Government Spooks run Economy’, Zimbabwe Independent
7th April 2006.
Raftopoulos, Brian. ‘Reflections on the Opposition in Zimbabwe: The Politics of
the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).’ Raftopoulos, Brian and Alexander,
Karin. (eds) Reflections on Democratic Politics in Zimbabwe. Institute for Justice and
Reconciliation, Cape Town, 2006.
Rupiya, Martin. ‘Explaining the Transformation of Relations between the Armed
Forces and Society in Zimbabwe since 2000,’ in Karen Alexander (ed) The Future
of Democratic Politics in Zimbabwe Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, Cape
Town 2005.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 29
The craton is made up of highly deformed and In the north of the country the Zambezi
regionally metamorphosed grantitic gnesses metamorphic belt extends for some 900 km
and granitoids of Archean age (older than from Wankie in the west through Kariba to
2,500 million years) that formed in the root the northeast, although much of the western
zones (basement) of mountain building regions part is covered by much younger cover rocks.
of the crust. The great age of the terrane means Deformation in the high-grade metamorphic belt
that these basement rocks have been uplifted is complex and the lithologies are dominated
and deeply eroded to produce the current level by garnet-mica-schists and granitic-gneisses
of exposure. and granulites.
The granitoid rocks of the basement complex West of the Zimbabwe Craton, the Magondi
consist of coarsely crystalline rocks with Basin was formed during a period of crustal
compositions from tonalite through to extension after the emplacement of the Great
adamellite; true granites are rare. The gneissic Dyke, and represents the northwestern margin
rocks are foliated or banded grey gneisses of the Zambezi Basin. The basin is filled with a
and darker coloured migmatites, the majority thick sequence of sediments of Pre-Cambrian
of which are tonalitic in composition. Both age, subdivided into the Deweras Group in the
granitoids and gneisses contain cross-cutting east, comprising arkoses, greywackes, argillites
and conformable sheets and veins of quartz and and basaltic lavas, overlain by the Lomagundi
aplite and xenoliths of ultramafic and banded iron Group consisting of quartzites, slates and
formations are common, particularly in the gneiss. greywackes and to the west by the Piriwiri Group
A younger generation of granitoid rocks intruded of extensive phyllites and greywackes. Felsic and
the basement complex some 2,650 million years mafic volcanics are intercalated with sediments
ago. These rocks are predominantly medium- near the base of the sequence and all rocks are
coarse grained adamellites and they form deformed and metamorphosed.
30 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
The southern part of the Magondi Basin is The Bulawayan Group is the most important
covered by sediments of the Karoo Supergroup host for gold mineralisation and has been divided
and Tertiary sandstones and aeolian sands of the into an older Lower Greenstone sequence and
Kalahari Group. The Karoo sediments were laid a younger Upper Greenstone sequence, which
down in three major basins during the Permian volumetrically is the dominant greenstone
to Jurassic, with similar lithologies in all the assemblage. The Shamvaian Group is the youngest
basins. Terrestrial clastic sediments predominate, division within the greenstone stratigraphy
with feldspathic sandstones, mudstones and and is dominated by rhyolite-dacitic tuffs and
shales, and including the coal beds of the Wankie agglomerates, porphyry intrusives and clastic
Coalfield. These sediments are overlain by a thick meta-sediments, in particular greywackes.
succession of basaltic lavas.
Within the Lower Greenstone sequence of
The Karoo basalts are most spectacularly the Bulawayan, bi-modal basaltic and andesitic
revealed in the Victoria Falls on the far western volcanics and volcaniclastics predominate, with
border with Zambia, but they reach their most interflow BIFs and meta-sediments. The Upper
extensive outcrop in the south and south-eastern Greenstone sequence includes a lower meta-
part of Zimbabwe, where they are intruded by sedimentary unit (greywackes, conglomerates and
several large granophyre bodies. limestones), which is an important stratigraphic
The Kalahari sediments occur extensively marker horizon; overlain by a thick assemblage of
between Bulawayo and Victoria Falls in the komatiitic lavas, tholeiitic basalt to andesitic lavas
western part of Zimbabwe and consist of poorly and pyroclastic rocks, capped by volcaniclastic and
consolidated sandstones and sands. clastic and chemical sedimentary rocks.
Historically the Midlands (Kadoma-Hartley) gold
Greenstone belts belt, around KweKwe and Gatooma in central
Zimbabwe, was the most significant greenstone
Zimbabwe’s greenstone belts are principally belt, hosting the country’s two largest (both in
composed of bimodal assemblages of mafic, excess of 4 Moz) production mines at Cam and
ultramafic and felsic volcanics and associated Motor and Globe & Phoenix as well as numerous
intrusives, clastic meta-sediments and banded smaller operations. Brownfields exploration
iron formations (BIF). These assemblages of around former mines in the Midlands belt is
rocks were emplaced as a pronounced series the focus of a number of junior companies,
of elongate, linear volcanic belts; tens of kms notably New Dawn Mining at Dalny and African
wide and several hundred kms long; the term Consolidated Resources at Giant-Gadzema.
greenstone reflecting the colour of chloritic and
epidote alteration seen in the typical assemblage To the south of the Midlands Belt, the Shurugwi-
of basic volcanic and volcanoclastic units. Gweru belt is centred on the city of Gwelo,
and the Selukwe mining district hosted
Thirteen major greenstone belts have been
significant deposits at Wanderer and Tebekwe.
identified, and are believed to have developed
The former lies at the centre of a package of
in three successive stratigraphic phases: the
concessions, including Camperdown and Golden
Sebakwian Group, the Bulawayan Group and the
Quarry, which are being re-explored by New
Shamvaian Group. Each of the greenstone belts
Dawn Mining.
has its own distinctive structural and lithological
setting, but are commonly intensely folded and In more recent years the production and
faulted with major strike-slip ductile shears and exploration focus switched to the Shamva-
are separated from each other by granitoids and Harare, Bulawayo-Buli and Gwanda belts, centred
gneissic rocks of the basement complex. The on their namesake cities in the northeast and
metamorphic grade and intensity of deformation south west and south of the country respectively.
various between the greenstone belts but is As well as the historic Shamva mine (1.5+ Moz),
mainly in the lower to medium greenschist facies. the Shamva-Harare belt currently hosts one of
the country’s main producers, Mwana Africa’s
Dominant lithologies in the Sebakwian Group are
Freda-Rebecca mine.
komatitic and tholeitic basalts, intercalated clastic
meat-sediments, BIFs and ultramfic intrusions. One of the country’s other key producer in
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 31
recent years has been Caledonia Mining’s Blanket a broad spectrum of styles from extensively
mine, in the Gwanda belt. On account of the mineralised ductile shear systems through
close proximity of the Gwanda belt to the stockworks and multiple anastomosing and
Limpopo Mobile Belt, the grade of metamorphism bifurcating quartz veins to massive quartz veins
at Gwanda is distinctly higher than in the typical and breccias. In around half the known deposits,
Zimbabwean greenstone belts, reaching upper the host rocks are mafic volcanics but ultramafics,
greenschist to amphibolite facies. banded iron formations and granitoids are
also important.
Great Dyke Shear zones are typically steeply dipping to
vertical on average; individual fractures within
The Great Dyke forms a band of hills and ridges
the main shear zones exhibit a broad range of
that trends nearly 540 km, north-south through
orientations with patterns reflecting riedel and
the centre of Zimbabwe. In geological terms
compressive fracturing which has developed by
the Great Dyke is not a dyke, but a long, linear
consistent progressive deformation. Lode systems
series of lopolithic (lenticular) shaped ultramafic
may have strike lengths in excess of 1,000 m but
intrusions, from 3 to 12 km wide, that been
individual ore shoots and veins are usually only of
emplaced stratiformly along a NNE-SSW trending
the order of 10-100 m in strike length.
graben structure.
In lode-gold deposits, gold and gold-bearing
Four complexes have been identified from north
sulphide mineralisation is present in quartz-filled
to south, the Musengezi, Hartley, Selukwe and
shear zones and in altered wallrocks adjacent
Wedza complexes. Each of these complexes has
to the shear zones. Gold occurs as free gold
an elongate, gently dipping synclinal structure
intimately intergrown with quartz, as microscopic
and can be sub-divided stratigraphically into a
grains with sulphide minerals and as late gold in
lower ultramafic sequence of peridotites (dunites
fractures within vein quartz or coating sulphides.
and harzburgites) and pyroxenites together with
Gold is most commonly fine grained, although
narrow bands of chromitite; and an upper mafic
occurrences of coarse visible gold have been
sequence consisting of a variety of plagioclase-
found in numerous orebodies.
rich rocks, such as norites and olivine gabbros.
Although quartz vein related mineralisation is
The dyke lies within the Zimbabwe craton and
most commonly seen, in some deposits (or even
is flanked by granitic rocks for most of its length.
as a second type of mineralisation within the
The Great Dyke has been dated at 2,575 million
same deposit) disseminated, sulphide replacement
years old and is essentially undeformed, which
mineralisation hosts the bulk of the gold. Typically
indicates that the last phase of major deformation
these zones have little quartz, silica is present
in the craton occurred before its emplacement.
as chert or chalcedony, and sulphide minerals in
Economically the Great Dyke is of significant various combinations are major components.
importance, with major chromite and platinum
Sulphide mineralisation is principally disseminated
resources. Chromite occurs in a varying number
assemblages of pyrite, pyrrhotite, arsenopyrite
of bands towards the ultramfic base of each
and galena, with lesser amounts of chalcopyrite,
complex and is mined throughout the Dyke.
tetrahedrite, stibnite and minor tellurides and
Base-metal sulphides (Ni-Cu-Co +/- Au) and
scheelite. Sulphide-rich ores are generally not
platinum group metals (PGMs) occur in the
refractory and respond well to conventional
uppermost pyroxenite unit just below the
treatment in gravity-CIL/CIP circuits; although
ultramafic-mafic contact.
increasing proportions of sulphides may require
preparation of a flotation concentrate prior
Gold mineralisation
to leaching.
At least 95% of Zimbabwe’s total gold production Numerous small deposits and several larger ones
has been derived from orogenic lode-gold style are associated with banded iron formations or
mineralisation which occurs within many of granitioids. In the latter, gold bearing quartz-
the greenstone belts. Lode gold mineralisation sulphide veins and shear-hosted disseminated
is predominantly structurally controlled with mineralisation is of a similar style to orogenic
32 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Figure 4.1: Simplified geological map of Zimbabwe showing main greenstone belts (courtesy, Duration Gold)
type, but there is a much clearer relationship with Gold deposits are found in the Limpopo Mobile
the emplacement of granitoid intrusions and the Belt, outside of greenstone belts, but the type of
subsequent remobilisation of gold. mineralisation is also that of orogenic lode gold,
with similar styles and ore mineralogy. Minor gold
These BIF units typically form topographic
production is reported as a by-product of base-
features of considerable strike extent and are metal and PGM production from mines on the
hard, cherty ferruginous rocks with repeated Great Dyke.
magnetite-quartz +/- grunerite bands which
in many deposits are tightly folded and heavily Placer (alluvial) deposits in streams draining
fractured. Auriferous sulphide minerals occur as areas of primary gold mineralisation are not
a replacement of the iron-rich minerals along significant sources of gold in Zimbabwe. Gold in
fractures and in the hinges of the folds. the weathered, eluvial (“float”) profiles of primary
deposits is more widespread; but its exploitation
In all deposit types, wallrock alteration is is largely by small-scale, artisanal mining using
dominated by carbonatisation, with siderite traditional panning and sluice methods.
and ankerite the commonest phases. Sericite
Key References
is very common in mafic and granitoid hosts,
Foster R.P. and Piper D.P. 1993, Archean lode gold deposits in Africa. Ore Geology
with magnesite , fuchsite and talc common in Reviews 8.
ultramafic hosts and pyrite and pyrrhotite in Schulter.T. and Trauth, M.H. 2008; Geological Atlas of Africa 2nd Edition, Springer
banded iron formations. Pyroxene rich wall rocks Stagman.J.G., 1978 An Outline of the Geology of Rhodesia, Zimbabwe Geological
Survey Bulletin No.80 (Reprinted 1981).
are commonly altered to hornblende, chlorite
and carbonate.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 33
in September 2009, as the concentrator reached Meanwhile, RioZim, another company with gold
design throughput of platinum-in-matte of 180 koz, operations, aims to refurbish its Empress nickel
almost double the production in 2008. Production refinery, which refines nickel and copper matte
in 2009 was 131 koz of platinum and 100 koz from Botswana. It also hopes to start chrome
of palladium. mining in a joint venture project and produce
30 kt/y of chrome concentrate a year from 2012.
According to Reuters, Zimplats recently said
it planned to go ahead with its US$500 million Zimasco, owned by Chinese mining and trading
expansion project to lift annual output by 50% to group Sinosteel Corp, has a capacity of around
270 koz of platinum. It’s Hartley mine remains on 200 kt/y of ferrochrome, making it the country’s
care-and-maintenance. biggest ferrochrome producer.
Figure 6.1: This chart shows how weak the Zimbabwean banks are in relation to other Southern African countries’ banks
Source: Mining Sector: Engine for Economic Growth”, Douglas Munatsil
I intimated this in the discussion of funding to suggest that the geological environment in the
above. Invariably, with all the gold producers Zimbabwe Craton was not favourable for the
and explorers that I saw or spoke to, they have development of large gold deposits. However,
some exposed oxide ore on surface, which, taken current exploration is indicating that world-class
with old heap leach dumps, can be processed deposits are not necessarily associated with large
through rather old mills and plants to get some alteration zones and crustal scale shear zones”.
cashflow. But that is not their long-term goal.
They go on to conclude that, “Recent work has
They generally have an idea of the sulphide
shown that the Zimbabwe Craton, like other
potential that lies not far below the surface but
similar geological environments elsewhere, is
need intensive drilling programmes to define this
highly heterogeneous, being cut by crustal scale
potential. For this they will require an injection
shear zones that impart a conspicuous control
of capital, firstly to bring existing plants up to
on gold localisation. It is therefore becoming
scratch to process the surface material and
increasingly apparent that structural and
secondly, to expand the operations. This is what
Metallon, Duration et al are striving to do. lithological controls affecting localisation of gold
deposits in Australian and Canadian Cratons are
in many ways analogous to the Zimbabwe Craton
6.2 Is there potential to develop
situation. There is no reason why mines of the
the industry?
same significance as those in other Archaean
We have learnt in the preceding section granite-greenstone terrains should not be found
that Zimbabwe has the right rocks for gold in the Zimbabwe Craton”.
production, but there are questions as to Many, small mines – blame the British!
whether the geometry and scale of the
The next point in our checklist of characteristics
mineralisation and deposits is such that they can
is the fact that there are a great many gold
support larger scale operations or are miners
restricted in what they can achieve by physical mines and they are invariably small scale. From
dimensions of deposits? The answer seems to be the discussion above, the geological potential
that, for historic reasons, most of the restrictions seems to be there, so what has stopped the
are of the miners own making. The norm of development of gold operations to rival those
small mines doesn’t have to be the template in Australia and Canada? For an understanding
going forward. of that conundrum we have to look back in
history to see how the mining industry developed
A very interesting article by the Zimbabwe within the country.
Geological Society (ZGS) in 20052 argued
passionately that conventional wisdom on lack of Zimbabwe’s countryside is littered with a vast
reserves, and a geology that was only amenable number of ancient gold workings as the first
to hosting small scale mines, was wrong. miners discovered and worked the easy-to-find,
easy-to-extract auriferous quartz veins where
So let’s evaluate the industry characteristics in a they outcropped on the hillsides. The Portuguese,
more objective fashion. and more latterly the British, came to the country
Common ground in greenstones and took over where the ancients left off.
Firstly, the issue of geology of the greenstones. As As a slight, but interesting digression, the country
the ZGS article explains, terranes like the Yilgarn was first formally occupied by the British
and the Abitibi have greenstone belts associated South Africa Company, under Cecil Rhodes,
with crustal scale shear zones, whereas in in September 1890, under a Royal Charter
Zimbabwe the gold deposits are found in granted by the British Government. As one
association with more localised shear zones. The modern day explorer notes, “Whilst this Charter
authors also note the difference between the conferred both administrative powers as well as
classical greenstone belts and Zimbabwe with commercial rights, it was probably the only British
regard to the width of alteration zones – the proclaimed territory ever settled primarily for its
Australian/Canadian belts have much wider mineral wealth”6.
alteration zones.
Anyway, by concentrating on the old, recognised
They commented, “These features would tend deposits the Europeans sought to short cut the
38 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
The Vubachikwe mine, owned by Duration Gold, is typical of the many underground mines in private ownership, although the depth of
workings at 1,200 m is far from typical (Photo: Paul Burton)
more formal exploration process in order to they often did not have rights over more than
extract the gold as quickly as possible. In many a small patch of land and so couldn’t investigate
ways they worked in a similar fashion to the band and expand along strike. For that we must
of small and informal miners that continue such blame the piecemeal division of the land to the
practices to this day. prospectors by the early chiefs. Breaking up a
discrete mineralised zone into small parcels to
“The usual methods of exploration by the early
appease demand from a hoard of prospectors
Europeans were to get information from local
with gold fever in their eyes, may have seemed
villagers about the existence of old workings,
like a good idea at the time but it is self-defeating
on which prospecting shafts were sunk”, the
in terms of sustainability. Nature, in her wisdom,
ZGS notes.
doesn’t work with such artificial boundaries. But
Such methods are notoriously inefficient as they such criticism with the benefit of hindsight is
fail to take into consideration the geological probably harsh.
setting and the potential of the whole mineral
Again, the ZGS article sums it up well. “...
deposit. With a more systematic and objective
strike extensions of many mines have not been
approach they could determine not only the
investigated because of an entrenched tradition
scope of the whole deposit, but also which
of going underground before fully understanding
techniques would serve them best for optimal
lateral extensions of the ore bodies – a result
exploitation of the mineral wealth.
of the lack of usage of geologists by many
One reason they were constrained in what mining companies. Probing of lateral extensions
development they could do was the fact that of ore bodies is also prohibited by adjoining
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 39
The many mapped vein systems near surface at the Dalny mine, which new owner New Dawn Mining will investigate and evaluate for
open pit potential (Photo: Paul Burton)
mining claims belonging to different individuals”, constraint to large scale mining but the miners
they conclude. have a mindset that favours small, underground
mines as the default option.
Failure to recognise the ‘big picture’ has been an
enduring fault with the industry but, hopefully, As I’ve tried to explain in the proceeding
perspectives will change.This is not to say that paragraphs, there is now no reason why they
all mines should be big. Many deposits may not can’t start to think in terms of the large open pit
be suitable and in any case there are unique model that has been applied so successfully in
circumstances in Zimbabwe, such as empowerment Western Australia. Perhaps even more compelling
and social welfare issues, that suggest there is a than the Australian experience are some of the
continuing role for a small mining sector. developments on the Abitibi greenstone belt, in
Canada. At Detour Lake, for example,the former
Open pits are also mines!
owner mined the deposit for the bulk of its life
So the mine developers went ‘down’ and not ‘along’ as an underground operation. Between 1987 and
on their leases, leading to the still-current fascination 1999 the underground mine produced 1.5 Moz of
with working underground. As the ZGS states, “It gold at a grade of 4.98 g/t before it closed because
is astonishing to note that this form of exploration of low gold prices.
became so entrenched in the exploration culture
In the last few years, with gold prices much higher,
of Zimbabwean prospectors that it has remained
a new company, Detour Gold, has evaluated
basically unchanged up to today”.
the deposit as an open pit prospect with
So to recap, the geology should not be a phenomenal results.
40 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
A feasibility study released in mid-2010, has paralysed by debt and taken a big step in the path to
confirmed reserves of 11.4 Moz of gold sensible consolidation within this industry.
contained, capable of supporting production
of almost 650 koz/y for a capital investment 6.3 Major risk factors that will
of almost US$1 billion. Could any of the challenge growth
Zimbabwean underground mines be re-invented
in such a spectacular fashion, I wonder? In this section we will look at some of the most
A lesson from West Africa critical challenges that the gold producers and
the politicians face in order to ensure a thriving
But for that type of mining they need access to gold mining industry. Some can be overcome by
funding, which takes us to another characteristic structural political overhaul; others by capital
of the industry, the fact that it is undercapitalised investment which can only come after the first
and seriously lacking in modern plant. condition is satisfied.
Here’s where the government has a major role to Politicians need to get it right
play. The country needs a stable, democratically
elected government with sensible mining laws and Looking from the outside, the level of political risk
tax regime that is not punitive to the industry in Zimbabwe is the most fundamental hindrance
in order to encourage inward investment from to the development of a robust gold (and other
abroad. The government only has to look to minerals) industry. The government has a key role
the western limb of the continent to see how to play in making sure Zimbabwe loses its image of
successful Ghana, for instance, has been in being one of the pariah states in world investment
attracting capital and building a major gold mining terms and starts to be a favoured destination for
industry for the benefit of the economy and mining companies and a place where investors feel
ultimately, its people. comfortable putting their money.
Or what about the dramatic rise in gold One of the most authoritative reports on mining
production in Burkina Faso and Mali, two other investment moods each year is conducted by
countries situated on the greenstone belt of the Canada’s Fraser Institute4. The Fraser Institute
West African craton? Burkina Faso’s production surveys companies worldwide and compiles a
grew from 2.7 t in 1999 to a forecast 13.5 t last “Policy Potential Index”, which, as the Institute
year and Mali saw its gold output increase from explains, serves as a report card to governments
25.4 t in 1999 to 56.9 t in 2006, before declining on how attractive their policies are from the
slightly to 48.9 t3 as a result solely of exploration point of view of an exploration manager.
and development by foreign mining companies. The Policy Potential Index (PPI) is a composite
We’ll pick up again on the critical, but thorny, index that measures the effects on exploration
issue of government support in a later section, of government policies, including uncertainty
but I think the industry needs to change its concerning the administration; interpretation,
approach and look to consolidate leases/ and enforcement of existing regulations;
claims which cover identified mineralised zones, environmental regulations; regulatory duplication
especially when they are a continuation of one and inconsistencies; taxation; uncertainty
strike, so they can then properly investigate concerning native land claims and protected
prospective claims through the use of modern areas; infrastructure; socioeconomic agreements;
geophysical and geochemical techniques (instead political stability; labour issues; geological
of just following a quartz vein) and design database; and security.
operations to suit the size of the deposits. As the Institute notes in its introduction, “In
To be fair, all the companies I spoke to realise today’s globally competitive economy where
this and if they haven’t already started to employ mining companies may be examining properties
modern exploration methods to define the located on different continents, a region’s policy
sulphide potential, then they have them in their climate has taken on increased importance in
plans, they just can’t afford them yet! attracting and winning investment”.
And as far as M&A activity is concerned, New Dawn In the 2009/10 survey, published a few months
Mining has just moved to acquire another producer ago, Zimbabwe scores poorly (as it has done for
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 41
many years). On the composite index scoring because producers were unable to benefit from
it came 69th out of 72 countries, with only the the rising gold price and increase cashflow. They
Philippines, Ecuador and Venezuela below it were either paid in Z$ of eroding value or, as
(Quebec was number one). happened eventually last year, were not paid at all
by the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe.
As the Institute commented, “Unfortunately, (out
of the bottom 10 scorers) except for California, Under the legislation that existed up until
these are all developing nations which most need early 2009, the gold miners were forced to sell
the new jobs and increased prosperity mining can their gold production to the Reserve Bank of
produce”. Zimbabwe’s subsidiary, Fidelity Printers and
Refiners, but when that organisation found itself
Breaking down the PPI into its component
in dire straits in 2008 it reneged on agreements
factors reveals some interesting observations
and refused, or was unable, to pay the mining
with regards to the political risk perception of
companies. The companies were left with little
Zimbabwe. For instance, 96% of the respondents
alternative but to place their mines on care-and-
said that the lack of political stability within
maintenance.
Zimbabwe was either a strong deterrent or
dissuaded them completely from investing there. The unity government, to its credit, recognised
76% felt as strongly about physical security within that something had to be done as up until recent
the country. years gold mining had become an important
source of income, accounting for more than
On the issue of “Mineral potential, assuming 50% of export earnings. And so, the government
current regulation/land use”, the country was introduced STERP in an effort to stimulate the
placed 67th out of 72, with only 9% of those economy by liberalising the mining sector.
surveyed indicating that the current situation
encourages investment. However, this figure Probably the most significant initiative in the
rises to 41% when “Policy/mineral potential, reform package was the deregulation of gold sales,
assuming no land use restrictions in place, and which meant that gold producers were removed
assuming industry ‘best practices’” is the question from the obligation to sell their gold production
asked, which is an indication of how geologically to the Reserve Bank and were free to sell on the
prospective the land is deemed. international market and get paid in US$.
Financial and funding risks tied These days, gold bullion is delivered, as still
to credible government required by Zimbabwean gold-mining law, to
the government-operated Fidelity Printers and
There are certainly signs that the government is Refiners, but for sampling only and onward
responding to the country’s problems and it may delivery, often to the Rand Refinery in South
not be just coincidence that this happen since Africa. The Rand Refinery undertakes final
the formation of the GNU in early 2009. The refining and sell the resultant gold with 100%
dollarisation move and the introduction of “Short of the proceeds being credited to companies’
Term Economic Recovery Plan (STERP)” was a Zimbabwean bank accounts in US dollars within
very effective measure, but they needed to do 5 days of sale.
something as having hyperinflation and a currency
that devalues by the minute is no good for the When the Reserve Bank stopped paying for gold it
economy or would-be investors. Obviously, issued bonds in lieu of payment, which were due to
investors want to see stability and a clear path be redeemed in August this year but thus far many
forward for economic and political reform. Thus companies have been left holding their certificates
the installation of a new constitution and free when they are in desperate need of cash!
elections will be critical landmarks. Power to the industry
The longer term, fundamental reason for the The limited availability of power in Zimbabwe
slump in gold output within the country over the has severely hampered miners over the past year
past few years, was the deteriorating economic or more at a time when they are trying to ramp
situation, which meant that there was a lack of up production to installed capacity levels after
investment by companies in mine infrastructure the 2008 hiatus. Capacity utilisation of mining
not only because of rampant inflation but also operations and treatment plants is only about
42 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
40% at present because of the inability of the by poor reliability of the power stations and
state power provider, ZESA, to maintain output faults in the grid system, which has meant
to match demand. that supply has often been closer to half the
Last year, at least, the schedule of load shedding was country’s needs. Essential maintenance work at
agreed between ZESA and the individual miners so Kariba and Hwange requires US$139 million,
that they could plan their operations accordingly. according to the Minister of Finance. He has
This year the industry has been hit by random allocated US$15 million from this year’s budget
outages that they have struggled to cope with. for the maintenance work. To add generating
capacity, Zimbabwe would need to spend some
New Dawn Mining reported at some length US$4 billion for expansions at Hwange and
earlier this year in its March quarterly results, Kariba (US$0.8 billion), and new power stations
highlighting how critical this issue is. New Dawn at Gokwe North (US$1.6 billion) and Bakota
said, “Management has previously identified the
(US$1.8 billion).
reliability and availability of power as one of
the main strategic threats to its operations and The current situation according to the Minister
growth plans. The reason for this is that, generally of Finance, is shown in the following table.
in the southern African region, there has been
a shortage of power for a number of years and Table 6.1: Power generating facilities in Zimbabwe
in particular Zimbabwe has, for a considerable Power Station Installed Current
period, experienced rotating scheduled outages Capacity Output
(load shedding), as well as unexpected power cuts Kariba South 750 KW 735 KW
at irregular intervals”. Hwange thermal 920 KW 574 KW
Harare thermal 80 MW 0
Demand for power countrywide is of the order
Munyati thermal 80 MW 0
of 2,000 MW. Zimbabwe has power generating
capacity of around 1,900 MW (920 MW at Bulawayo thermal 90 MW 0
Source: Ministry of Finance5
Hwange coal-fired power station and 750 MW
at the Kariba hydro plant)5 and, in theory, can
import some 300-500 MW from neighbours New Dawn Mining’s management is fairly gloomy on
Zambia and Mozambique. So there is already a the matter. “Due to this general shortage of power
capacity shortage, which has been exacerbated in the southern Africa region, Zimbabwe cannot
China’s Gold Industry – been a producer of significance in move away from State control and
A case study in attracting global terms. towards private ownership.
foreign capital (and then
Most of the China’s production In the 1980s and 1990s the State
driving it away!)
comes from small, underground poured money into the gold
China’s gold production has risen mines working vein deposits with industry in an effort to consolidated
significantly in recent years to a little mechanisation or infrastructure. production units and encourage the
position, where with an output of There are thought to be over 1,000 growth of large mines. But by 2000,
324 t in 2009, it was the world’s small to medium-sized mines in although the country’s output had
largest gold producer, a position it operation throughout the country grown annually at a rate of 10%,
has held for three years. with the average mine producing in few mines of any size had been
This success comes as a result of the region of 16 koz/y. built, and most still contributed only
substantial government investment This could almost be a description 10 koz/y.
during the 1990s, and despite the of Zimbabwe’s gold mining industry! The government then decided
still fragmented and archaic nature to change its approach and
Since 1998, the Chinese gold
of most mining operations.
industry has undergone two phases moved funding away from direct
Gold mining in China stretches of major restructuring aimed at investment in gold mining, deeming
back into antiquity but the creating a much more liberalised it ‘unproductive’, to concentrate
country has not, until recent years, industry, with the central thrust a more on infrastructure construction
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 43
import its power deficit”, it observes.The prognosis industry have to resolve for the greater good
does not seem to be any better according to the of the country’s economy. Clarity on what the
company. “Given the lack of available government government’s intentions are is needed urgently
funding for investment in major infrastructure to remove the uncertainty that hangs over the
projects together with the uncertain political mining industry and deters foreign investment.
environment, it is probable that, for the foreseeable
Incidentally, indigenisation was another
future, the power supply will continue to be
high negative scorer in the Fraser Institute
unreliable and unpredictable”, it concludes.
report mentioned earlier, with 60% voting
The government is acutely aware of the problem. against investment because of the uncertainty
Addressing the Chamber of Mines AGM in May surrounding the issue.
this year, President Mugabe stated that it hopes
The Indigenization and Economic Empowerment
to attract investment into new power generating
Act 14, 2007 was signed into law in April 2008
facilities6. “I wish to inform this meeting that
and provided for all companies operating
several power projects requiring new investors
in Zimbabwe, with a value greater than
are pending, including the Hwange Power Stations
US$0.5 million, to arrange for 51% of their
7 and 8, Kariba and Batoka”, he affirmed, going
shares or interests therein, to be owned by
on to say that “...Government will institute the
indigenous Zimbabweans.
necessary energy sector reforms required for
attracting new investment in that sector”. Over two years later the industry is still waiting
to see exactly what the 51% requirement means,
In the meantime, the gold producers have, or are,
although it is understood that the government is
implementing contingency plans by installing their
not pressing for a simple transfer of ownership
own power generating facilities to counteract
to Zimbabweans. Rather the process is likely to
the load shedding and outages that have blighted
involve a series of credits against the 51% as an
operations. It is more expensive but at least they
acknowledgement of giving certain concessions
can guarantee the mine and plant can operate to
in social and welfare areas.
increase operations up to installed capacity.
In January this year, the Zimbabwe Government
Power to the people – Indigenisation
published regulations with respect to the
The subject of indigenisation is one of the most Act that included the requirement for
divisive issues that government and the mining companies operating in Zimbabwe to provide
throughout the country. It also Local organisations, meanwhile, companies have exited after
opened up the industry and now starved of central having been frustrated by
invited foreigners to participate government funding, were bureaucratic impediments and
with the anticipation that foreign amenable to courtship by the uncertainty of licence tenure. So
investment would immediately foreigners and hence there was China provides an object lesson
replace state funding. a willingness on each side to in what to do right but with
do business. warnings on how to sustain this
However, it was only later, with inward investment. The Chinese,
economic reform (China became So there was something of a however, are now self-reliant and
a member of the World Trade flood into the country based have become the world’s largest
Organisation in 2001) and a on its geological prospectivity. In minerals investor, so they are
greater openness to foreign GFMS World Gold’s 2005 Special hardly concerned with the lack of
investment, with foreigners Report on China, we catalogued foreign investment. They generate
permitted to own gold deposits the activities of almost sixty enough funding through their
in 2002, that Australian and foreign gold companies engaged in domestic economy.
North American companies felt over one hundred projects.
Zimbabwe will never be in that
comfortable enough to seriously However, since that time, the position so will always need a flow
begin investigating the recognised flood has dwindled to a trickle of foreign capital into its mining
gold potential of this vast country. and, in fact, has reversed as and industrial sectors.
44 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
specified information to the Minister of Youth generally been accepted as a form of compliance
Development, Indigenization and Empowerment, and some companies’ proposals have already been
including an indigenisation implementation accepted on the basis of a public listing in 3 to 5
plan, by April 15. The government planned to years. The COM also believes that mineral rights
use this information as a basis for determining in Zimbabwe (of which over 50% are already held
what amount less than 51% would apply to any in local hands and state controlled organisations,
sector or subsector and the maximum period for according to the COM) should form the basis of
achieving indigenisation. The regulations require an empowerment programme. “Owners of mineral
the Minister to complete the determinations by rights should use these rights as their contribution
the end of February 2011. in joint ventures with foreign investors who
should bring capital to develop the mineral rights.
The Chamber of Mines of Zimbabwe is actively
I would urge those holding such mineral rights to
consulting with the relevant government
be creative and start engaging international capital
authorities to convey its members’ views on
to achieve development of the mineral rights”, Mr
this matter and to work towards finalising the
Gapare told this May’s AGM.
indigenisation and empowerment metrics for the
mining industry. Security of tenure – nationalisation/
expropriation
At the Chamber of Mines AGM in May this year,
Chamber President,Victor Gapare, expressed If indigenisation possibility represents a form of
the industry’s broad support for the sentiments creeping nationalisation, overt nationalisation still
expressed in the Act and outlined the industry’s hovers as a perceived threat to many looking
recommendations on how empowerment could at the country and the administration from
be achieved. London, New York, Toronto, Johannesburg or
Sydney. The fear is generated by the government
Broadly, as presented by Mr Gapare, these include
sponsored actions of the early part of the decade
the following:
that saw expropriation of land owned by white
• Equity of at least 15% as a minimum, which farmers, and particularly the acts of violence that
means it is possible to have even up to 100% accompanied the re-distribution moves.
equity being locally owned. Ministers have
Such fears may be unfounded, however, as
confirmed that companies could use listing on
President Mugabe has publically denied that
the ZSE as a way of achieving indigenisation. nationalisation is on the agenda. At the COM
• Credits in equity equivalents which include AGM, he addressed the subject head on.
local procurement, CSI, support to the small “Government has no intention of expropriating
scale mining sector, skills development, starting the mining industry”, he stated. He went on to
new businesses and any other socially and stress the government’s record on this issue. “No
economically desirable activities. mine has been nationalized since independence”,
he stated and continued with an explanation
At the same COM AGM in May, President Mugabe
of the government’s goal for the nation to own
confirmed that a system of credits would form the
natural resources in circumstances in which
basis of compliance with the Act. He stated in his
they could share with other friendly countries
speech to the assembled members of the mining
as equitable partners. “This sense of direction,
industry that, “Government has also accepted the
of seeking to correct historical wrongs, has
principle of empowerment credits as an integral
persuaded Government to explore the path
component of the 51% and this is detailed in
of profitable partnerships and joint venture
Section 5(4)(c) of the (Indigenization and Economic
initiatives with foreign investors in the mining
Empowerment) regulations.”, although clearly
sector”, he confirmed.
whether “integral component” means the 36% that
the Chamber is seeking remains open for debate. The ongoing dispute over the ownership of
diamonds found and mined in the Marange area,
But the principle is acceptable to all concerned
with government-owned mining companies
and there now needs to be some horse trading
seemingly disregarding the Supreme Court’s
to set the level of equity participation.
instructions to stop mining and selling the
Listing on the Zimbabwe Stock Exchange has diamonds until ownership has been determined,
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 45
has made international headlines. There these migrants are gaining valuable experience.
is apparently a hoard of diamonds worth However, we need to make plans to get these
US$1.7-1.8 billion at play here so the stakes are Zimbabweans back as our economy takes off”.
high for a cash-strapped government.
The COM is a major sponsor of the School
The saga of the Marange diamonds, the Kimberley of Mines and as part of the indigenisation and
Process and explorer African Consolidated empowerment programme; mining companies
Resources is described in the box (overleaf). have undertaken to make skills development a
major priority.
Infrastructure
The question of appropriate level of 6.4 SWOT analysis
infrastructure to support mining is an important
one that would-be explorers and miners place Strengths
high on their list of desirables when considering
• World class greenstone belts
investing in a particular country.
Zimbabwe has a proven gold producing record
We have discussed the power situation earlier in
and there may be deposits of greater size than
this chapter and it remains a very real concern
those already exploited.
for mining companies.
• Evidence of extensive, generally unexploited
Elsewhere, the country is well served with over
sulphide resources
90,000 km of roads. Main roads seem to be well
maintained (there is a toll on many roads now Sulphide potential needs to be quantified as little
to pay for upkeep) although some of the more structured exploration work has been undertaken
rural roads need substantial upgrading. When I thus far throughout the long history of the
travelled to minesites, some of the metalled and industry. If delineated, sulphides offer not only large
dirt roads were in poor condition, but at least deposit potential but also open pit mining potential
there are road connections. which could increase production dramatically.
The rail network needs an upgrade with ageing • Long mining heritage and culture
equipment hampering operations. Some 415 km An understanding of mining, it’s importance
of track is operating under cautions/speed plus the skills needed to develop the
restrictions. industry (although they might not all be in
As with most African countries, water is always Zimbabwe currently)
a concern and droughts have often disrupted Weaknesses
power supplies.
• Perceived security risks
Skills
Perception probably doesn’t represent the
Lack of appropriate skills at all levels of the situation on the ground within the country now
industry is of great concern to mining management but perceptions count. Investors need reassurance
and a very real limiting factor on growth. Many from a government tough on law and order
Zimbabwean professional geologists and mining
engineers have long since left the country to • Lack of consolidation, too many small mines
undertake careers in other mining friendly countries Sub-optimal working of deposits. Opportunity,
such as South Africa, Australia and Canada. though, for aggressive companies to lead the
Also, it is reported that something like 3 million consolidation process.
people have left the country in recent years, with • Extensive private ownership
many across the border in South Africa.
Aggravates the small-mine syndrome. Little capital
The COM sums it up thus, “The industry has lost to expand and little chance to obtain capital as no
a lot of skills in the last decade. The skills base market to tap into
which had been developed in this country since
• Undercapitalised
1980 were second to none and today, if you go
anywhere in the world, Zimbabweans are running Again, lacking money to build more logically-
major undertakings. This is good in a way as sized mines
46 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
• Power supply problems • Political pressure from SADC and South Africa,
in particular.
Limiting normal operating and constraining
expansion. Mines are installing their own South Africa’s President Zuma, in particular,
generators but this is costly. must play a major role in conciliating between
the two parties in the GNU and also in keeping
Opportunities
pressure on the government to move forward
• Evidence of near-surface sulphides on elections.
Possibility of developing large open pits to exploit Threats
sulphides. Lower cost, more productive than
• Failure to install new constitution and hold
underground mining.
democratic and free elections.
• Use of modern exploration techniques
It is critical that the GNU continues to move the
Huge amount of ground in Zimbabwe’s process of rewriting the constitution forward
greenstone belts has not been explored using and keeps momentum towards elections. Already
modern methods. Opportunity to discover the timetable has slipped and elections look like
more goldfields. being delayed, perhaps until 2012 or even, as this
Professor Gaidzanwa suggests in this report, to
• Consolidate claim areas
2014. The country is desperate for foreign capital
Opportunities to consider more regional scale and the mining industry needs to attract investors
exploration and exploitation, which could lead to and this will not happen at the scale required
more optimally-sized mines. until there is a stable, democratic government.
Diamond’s are a... were from the Marange-Chiadzwa Diamond Trading Network said it
government’s best friend kimberlite field. Sales had been will not allow its members to trade
The Kimberley Process suspended last November by in them.
& ACR the influential Kimberley Process
Meanwhile, the wrangle over
Certification Scheme (KP), which is
In August, the Zimbabwean ownership of these diamonds
a body set up in 2003 by the United
government sold 900 kct of continues. The two protagonists are
Nations to certify the source of
certified diamonds, out of a the government and explorer African
rough diamonds with powers to
stockpile believed to be as large Consolidated Resources (AGR).
sanction trade of any diamonds
as 4.5 Mct, raising US$72 million they believe are so-called ‘blood The diamonds fields at Marange
in the process, according to Mines diamonds’. After a monitoring were discovered by ACR in 2006,
Minister, Obert Mpofu. That’s one mission, the KP officials alleged after it picked up claims originally
part of the story, the other being that they had found instances of held by De Beers as its EPO
that a London-listed minerals non-compliance and human rights expired that year. The government
exploration company is in dispute violations when government cleared has revoked any claims the London
with the government over illegal miners (Reuters report up to company has and gone ahead with
ownership of those diamonds. 30,000) from the site of the mines. mining operations and the recent
The first part of the story is auction sales of mined diamonds
This dispute was resolved in July at
interesting in that it shows that seemingly in direct opposition to
the World Diamond Council’s 7th
the Zimbabwean authorities can High and Supreme Court rulings.
annual meeting in St. Petersburg,
work with a world monitoring when the KP reached consensus on When ACR listed in London in
body, but the second part is an agreement to enable the renewal 2006, its admission document
perhaps more absorbing for of rough diamond exports from the listed three groups of claims in the
would be mineral investors as Marange fields. Wasting no time the Mutare region of eastern Zimbabwe
there may be clues as to how the government took the first diamonds held by three 100% subsidiaries of
government will act on mineral to auction in August. Although ACR. The company simply stated
rights in the future.
the process went off smoothly, that it had acquired ground in the
The diamonds that were sold the influential US-based Rapaport eastern part of Zimbabwe where
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 47
• Political unrest and turmoil Costs are relatively high in the low grade,
underground mines especially when they are
Clearly this will deter investors.
not working at full capacity owing to the power
• Low economic growth problems. Significant and sustained gold price
Dollarisation’ has lowered inflation and stabilised weakness to U$850/oz would threaten any
the economy to a degree. Forecast GDP growth recovery of the gold mining industry.
for this year is 5%, which is better than many • New mining legislation
developed countries, but the finance minister
The government is in the process of amending
is still having problems funding the current
the Mining Act and is making noises that the
account. In addition, the country has a serious
mining industry does not contribute enough to
debt problem. Without foreign financing packages
the fiscus. The Minister of Finance has already
the minister will not be able to fund any capital removed the mining companies’ favourable tax
infrastructure projects which the country regime (corporate tax has been increased from
badly needs. 15% to 25%) and imposed a royalty of 4% of
• Worldwide recession and economic crisis. revenue. A more punitive tax regime will further
deter investors. Allied to this is the indigenisation
If major western economies fail to grow or if
legislation issue, which is still surrounded by
they fail to lower their high debt levels then they
uncertainty. The industry fully accepts the
may not be able to assist Zimbabwe whatever the
principle of empowerment and favours the model
political state of the country.
whereby equity is put into indigenous hands to
• Gold price weakness the level of 15% with credits on socially desirable
previous exploration identified exploration licence over the ACR has suggested a holding
kimberlite indicator minerals and same area. agreement until the Supreme
was re-sampling the area. The situation remained Court ruling has been made on
unresolved until September 2009 ownership, which it claims the
Within three months, in
when the High Court upheld government has ignored. The
September 2006, it made the
ACR’s title. The government company thus sought an urgent
simple announcement of “a
appealed to the Supreme Court, injunction through the High Court
diamond find in Zimbabwe”,
which issued a Judgment on 16 to stop sales of any diamonds
without giving any details.
February 2010, which ordered held by Mbada and Canadile and
But by November 2006, not only that all diamonds acquired from that the stockpile be deposited
had the company had to deal the Marange Claims Area be with the RBZ as per the Supreme
with the influx of illegal miners surrendered to the Reserve Bank Court ruling. The High Court
but it also announced that there of Zimbabwe, and that all mining dismissed the application on the
was disagreement between activities on the Marange Claims basis that the matter was not
the company and the Mining Area cease until determination urgent, and ACR is now obliged
Commissioner’s office over the of the appeal against the 25 to re-lodge the application
validation of ACR’s claims. September Judgement in the as a normal (i.e. non-urgent)
In a press release in December Supreme Court. application in the High Court,
that year, the company advised which ACR has now done.
ACR has stated that only the
that the Ministry of Mines had diamonds mentioned in the The issue here is one of security
invoked a clause in the Zimbabwe 25 September Judgement were of tenure that international gold
Mines and Minerals Act and lodged with RBZ, whereas ACR companies will no doubt, be
intended to cancel registration understands that diamonds are still following with avid interest as it
of the company’s title to the being mined, which are continually may be a better measure of the
Marange diamond deposit on stockpiled by the companies government’s true intentions
the grounds that title should not mining upon the Marange Claims with valuable minerals than their
have been granted in the first Area (Mbada and Canadile) are rhetorical statements in speeches
instance because of a pre-existing retained by those companies. at mining conferences.
48 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Chapter 7 –
Gold Production Review
7.1 Historic gold production in Zimbabwe
Our parent company, GFMS Ltd, has been collating and publishing annual data on global
gold supply patterns in its Gold Surveys since the mid-1970s, when it was an internal
department within Consolidated Gold Fields, so its proprietary records have given us a
great source of statistics to chart the rise and fall of Zimbabwe’s gold mining industry.
As mentioned earlier, Zimbabwe’s gold output Custom millers 9% 6% 11% 14% 17%
slumped in 2008, as the catastrophic economic + 1kg
situation and the Reserve Bank’s inability to pay Other producers 1% 2% 3% 1% 2%
for gold production gave owners little option but Ngezi + Mimosa 5% 9% 13% 16% 13%
to close operations for most of the fourth quarter. Total Gold 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Output recovered slightly in 2009 to 4.9 t. Production
This year, with mines sure of US$ receipts for their Koz 365 226 112 160 105
gold, production at most mines has ramped up but Source: complied from COMZ data
The delay with the 4-shaft project was caused by lack of funds due to
the failure of the RBZ to pay for gold production in 2008 and 2009,
compounded by the subsequent failure of the RBZ to redeem Gold
Bonds, which matured in February 2010 with a redemption value of
US$3.16 million. The company secured US$2.5 million loan in May this
year to pay for this and the genset (see later).
Geology and reserves
Blanket is situated in a typical greenstone terrain; the 70 km long
by 15 km wide Gwanda Greenstone belt. The Blanket property is
the largest of the three remaining large gold producers, from a gold
resource area that has given rise to no less than 268 gold mines.
Blanket is part of the group that makes up the North Western
Mining camp extending from Sabiwa and Jethro in the south, through
Blanket itself to the Feudal, AR South, AR Main, Sheet, Eroica and Lima
ore bodies.
The geological sequence strikes north-south, dips vertically and consists,
from east to west, of a basal felsic unit (which is not known to carry
mineralisation), a higher ultramafic unit that includes a banded iron
formation (which hosts the eastern dormant cluster of mines and the ore
bodies of the adjacent Vubachikwe mine complex belonging to Duration
Gold), and finally the mafics that host the active Blanket ore bodies and an
andesitic unit, which lies to the west, caps this whole stratigraphy.
Ore bodies at Blanket are epigenetic and are associated with a later,
regionally developed deformation zone characterised by areas of high
strain, wrapping around relatively undeformed remnants of the original
basaltic lava flows. It is within the higher strain regime (highly sheared
rocks) that the wider of the orebodies are located.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 53
The company has not updated its ore reserve statement since that
published and certified in terms of NI 43-101 at December 31, 2008.
Reserves amounted to 3.8 Mt at grade of 3.81 g/t for contained gold
of 465 koz. Additional Indicated resources were just 67 koz of gold
contained, although Inferred resources were estimated at 418 koz of
gold contained at the higher grade of 5.19 g/t.
Exploration
Elsewhere on the property, the company is investigating expansion and
extension opportunities within the existing orebody through its Lima
project. It is extending the 22 Level haulage from 4-shaft through to
the Eroica and Lima and orebodies to allow for underground resource
drilling down to 1,100 m. In a second phase, it intends to extend either
the Lima shaft or sink a new shaft at AR Main to 1,300 m in depth to
increase production capacity.
Outside of the mining lease, the company holds forty seven precious
metal claims covering 415 ha in the Gwanda greenstone belt. Blanket’s
main exploration efforts are focused on the potential for finding
satellite orebodies in the Blanket vicinity. After completion of the
4-shaft project, there will be 500 t/d of surplus milling capacity and
2,800 t/d of surplus CIL capacity that needs to be filled.
The main targets are at GG and Mascot/Penzance. GG lies
approximately 7 km from Blanket and the company has started
sinking a 140 m exploration shaft. The company plans to undertake
development at the 120 m level by the end of the year to gather data
for an in-house scoping study.
At Mascot/Penzance, located approximately 40 km from Blanket, the
company plans to refurbish the existing shaft and headgear before
following up on drilling results from over a decade ago.
Carslone Enterprises
Carslone is a subsidiary of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe which
owns the Globe & Phoenix, now obsolete, but it was once the second
largest historical gold producer in Zimbabwe with an output of almost
4.0 Moz at an average grade of 27.6 g/t. Carslone also owns the
Golden Kopje mine.
Casmyn Mining
Casmyn Mining is the wholly-owned, Zimbabwean subsidiary of
Canadian-domiciled, New Dawn Mining Corp. See New Dawn Mining
for more details of gold production activities.
Duration Gold
Duration Gold Ltd, a private company based in Jersey, Channel Islands
was formed in 2006, and holds an extensive portfolio of gold mines
and advanced stage projects in Zimbabwe. Duration Gold is wholly-
owned by the Jersey-based Clarity Capital Group.
Group gold mines
The company owns 112 gold deposits and prospects, which have now
been consolidated to enable the construction of four medium- large
54 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Expansion at Vubachikwe
Duration’s principal mine is Vubachikwe, located near the town of
Gwanda, some 180 km south east of Bulawayo, which currently
accounts for almost 60% of the group gold output.
The mine was originally operated by Lonrho before being acquired
by a family firm (the Thompsons) in 1955, who ran it until 2006 when
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 55
Zimbabwe’s leading
ISO accredited commercial assay lab
56 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Kwekwe by previous owners, but the company now believes that not
all ore accessed from Bar 20 Shaft is refractory.
The company is also looking at options to process the 1.2 Mt
refractory concentrate dump, with ultra fine grinding or BIOX
technologies being considered. A feasibility and optimisation study is
currently underway on this.
Other operations
Outside of Lease 16, Duration has resumed operations at the Athens
mine and commenced a resource drilling programme in 2009.
In addition, the company has resumed operations at the Umviga
properties with development ore currently being trucked to Queens
mill for gold extraction. Pending completion of a final study, the
company will look to refurbish the Umviga plant for the treatment of
tailings and sand dumps.
At the Gaika mine (KweKwe) where a small vat leach programme
is currently being run, the company is planning to start an open pit
operation (20 kt to 30 kt/mth) in 2013 with the view to producing
around 24 koz/y.
On the exploration front, Duration is undertaking resource drilling at
Athens, Gaika,Vubachikwe, and Royal Family, while commencing scout
drilling at the Auric, Carry, Tuff Nut, Kernel and Tiberius mines, all in
the Bulawayo area.
Part of the old plant at Vubachikwe with the new CIL plant in the foreground (Photo: Paul Burton)
58 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Earlier this year, Clarity Capital agreed a strategic alliance with South
African engineering group, E+PC Engineering & Projects Co Ltd, with
the aim of developing the Vubachikwe high grade, refractory tails re-
processing project; the initiation of bankable feasibility studies for the
expansion of the Vubachikwe mine and the development of the Athens
and Gaika mines.
Clarity Capital companies’ also work closely with the Cotton Tree
Foundation. The Foundation is committed to progressing education,
training and entrepreneurship in rural communities. The communities
surrounding Duration’s mines are currently the key focus. Such
initiatives should stand the company in good stead with regard to
indigenisation legislation that is being interpreted at present.
In September last year, the Duration raised US$8.0 million through a
private placement to fund the resource drilling programme across the
group and the Vubachikwe mine processing plant expansion.
The company is looking to raise additional financing in Q3/Q4 through
another private placing.
FA Stewart and Son
Jessie mine near Blanket and Vubachikwe
Falcon Gold
Falcon Gold is listed on the Zimbabwe Stock Exchange. After its mid-
year takeover of Central African Gold, New Dawn Mining now owns
85% of Falcon Gold and its three mines at Dalny,Venice & Golden
Quarry. See New Dawn Mining for details of these operations.
Freda Rebecca Mine
The Freda Rebecca mine is owned by Mwana Africa plc. See Mwana
Africa entry for details of the mine.
GAT Investments
GAT Investments, a private Zimbabwean company, owns a number of
gold mining operations and projects in Zimbabwe through local private
entity, Bilboes Holdings (Private) Ltd.
Its main claim blocks are located in Matabeleland province, 80 km
due north of Bulawayo. These properties were formerly owned by
Anglo American Zimbabwe and the company acquired them through a
management buyout in 2003.
The company’s short term business plan revolves around dump and
oxide material treatment but the longer term future is dependent on
the successful delineation and exploitation of sulphide mineralisation at
these former Anglo American properties.
Oxide production at Isabella group mines
The Isabella EPO hosts three operating mines at Isabella, McCays and
When grouped together, with Bubi (on the Gwizaan EPO) some 32 km
away. These shallow (less than 30 m deep) open pit/ heap leach mines
have produced some 230 koz of gold since start up by Anglo American
in 1989 but only 40 koz of gold since the 2003 acquisition.
Each mine has heap leach facilities although Isabella is the site of the
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 59
single elution and smelting plant. Isabella has an installed crushing plant
with a capacity to treat 100 kt/mth of ore. Future production will be
based on an installed crushing plant capacity of 80 kt/mth at McCays,
When 15 kt/mth and Bubi 80 kt/mth. The mines are connected to
the national electricity grid via 300 kVA transformers with a 150 kVA
backup generator at Isabella.
Production for seven months in 2009 amounted to approx 4 koz, well
below rated capacity, at a cash cost of US$689/oz.
The short term production target at the Isabella plant is 6 koz/y from
old heap leach dumps and some open pit oxide ore, with a longer
term forecast of approx 15 koz/y from oxides.
Current oxide reserves amount to 104 koz of gold contained at an
average grade of 0.67 g/t. Measured and Indicated resources are 79 koz
at a grade of 0.50 g/t.
In order to reach planned output the company is looking to spend
US$5 million on the oxide facilities.
Although the continuing processing of oxide material should enable
Bilboes to generate cashflow over the next few years, the longer
term future of the operations in Matabeleland lies with the deeper
sulphide resources.
The sulphide project
The Isabella EPO is underlain by felsic and mafic schists and
greywackes of the Upper and Lower Bulawayan volcanic units that
form part of the Archaean Bubi greenstone belt. Mineralisation is
truncated by fault splays.
60 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
The existing plant at Isabella, which Bilboes will utilise for oxide and dump material processing initially (Photo: Paul Burton)
US$882 /oz. In 2006, the mine produced 32 koz. By 2013, the company
hopes to push production up to 164 koz, while pushing costs down
below US$350/oz. The key projects are shaft and mill upgrades
over the next two years with the construction of a new 120 kt/mth
sand treatment plant and the introduction of open pit mining on
brownfields targets which are in the vicinity.
Shamva had 2P underground reserves of 5.5 Mt at grade of 2.82 g/t
for contained gold of 503 koz at the end of September 2008. LOM
resources at the same date were 14.0 Mt at grade of 2.49 g/t for
1.12 Moz of gold contained.
Redwing mine
The largest injection of capital will be at the company’s Redwing mine,
where planned expansion is expected to cost over US$220 million. This
will see production rise from a 2010 estimate of over 2 koz to 200 koz/y
by 2015. Cash costs, meanwhile, are forecast to fall from US$1,183 /oz
to US$285/oz by 2015. Production for the mine in 2006 was 18 koz.
The company intends to refurbish the existing flooded underground
operation, including major works on the shaft systems, to take
production from underground up to 360 kt/y, but the bulk of the capital
is destined for the development of a new open pit (2 Mt/y) and a new
plant to process this open pit and underground ore. The company
will also construct a new slimes dam to accommodate the increased
production at a cost of US$12.5 million. The open pit is projected to
contribute 166 koz to total mine production of 200 koz in 2015.
Figure 7.3: Metallon’s forecast production
1200
Mid-Winter
1000 Motapa
800 Mazowe
koz
600 Redwing
400 Shamva
200 Arcturus
How
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Freda-Rebecca
District
Mutoko
Bindura
Greenstone
Greenstone
Belt
Belt
Makaha
Midlands
Greenstone
West Belt
Midlands
P j
Project
Bubi
Greenstone
Belt
Nubobs
Greenstone
Belt
Mwana Project Areas
Funding
The IFC approved a US$10 million debt facility for Freda Rebecca in
November 2009 and the agreement was signed in March this year.
Although the board of IDC has since approved the final terms of the
facility, and the company has completed the environmental management
plan for the mining operations at Freda Rebecca to the IDC’s satisfaction,
drawdown of the facility remains subject to certain conditions.
The most notable of the conditions is the provision by the Export
Credit Insurance Corporation of South Africa (ECIC) of political risk
insurance for the facility, which is itself subject to ratification of the
Bilateral Investment Promotion and Protection Agreement (BIPPA)
between Zimbabwe and South Africa. Whilst this agreement has been
signed by both countries, formal ratification by the South African
parliament remains outstanding.
In addition, the External Loans Coordinating Committee (ELCC) of
the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) has approved the terms of the
facility. However, ELCC has not approved the provision of certain of
the ancillary arrangements, including the mortgage charge over the
land on which the Freda Rebecca plant is built and the operation of
offshore accounts.
Mwana Africa is working with the ELCC and IDC to agree
amendments to the security package, compliant with the current
exchange control regulations in Zimbabwe.
Provision of the second tranche of the facility, totalling US$6 million, is
also subject to independent verification of JORC/SAMREC compliant
Measured gold resources, sufficient to support a ten year mine life.
An independent technical report on resources after a programme of
re-sampling of existing drill cores is expected imminently.
Geology and reserves
As described in a 2007 technical report by SRK Consulting, Freda
Rebecca lies on the central axis of the synclinal Mazowe-Bindura
Greenstone belt. The geology of the area around the mine is
characterised by the Shamvaian sediments, diorite and granodiorite.
The orebodies are largely hosted by the Prince of Wales diorite
and the Bindura granodiorite. The mineralisation is hosted within
two major shear envelopes. Individual shears are variable in width
and these two systems merge to the south west at depth flattening
at around 850 m elevation and extending into the metasediments.
The shear system is characterised by a set of anastomosing shears
separated by relatively undeformed rock units.
There are two styles of sulphide mineralisation: older disseminated,
pervasive sulphides occurring throughout the sediments, diorite
and granodiorite, which vary in intensity and grade; and younger
mineralisation restricted to shear zones and associated with higher
gold grades. In both types of mineralisation, higher grades are
associated with fine-grained sulphides , such as arsenopyrite, pyrite,
pyrrhotite and chalcopyrite.
As at March 31, 2010, Freda Rebecca had reserves of 4.01 Mt at a grade
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 67
of 2.61 g/t for 340 koz of gold contained (91% underground). M&I
resources (including reserves) were 13.2 Mt at a grade of 2.46 g/t for
1.0 Moz of gold contained (97% underground, at a cut-off of 1.5 g/t).
Exploration
On EPOs outside the mining lease, Mwana Africa has identified a number
of exploration targets, perhaps the most significant of which is the
former mine Phoenix Prince, located two kilometres to the south east.
Originally the mine exploited thin, high-grade, near vertical bodies but
exploration has outlined broad, 5 m to 10 m, low-grade oxide lenses.
Outside of the Freda Rebecca area, the company is active on a number
of exploration properties throughout the main greenstone belts
within the country. In the Midlands greenstone belt it is conducting
exploration at the West Midlands project, which lies adjacent to the
dormant Maligreen mine, in which Mwana Africa has a 50% interest.
The interest was acquired through the purchase of Cluff Mining in
December 2005. Pan African (Private) Limited, a Zimbabwe registered
company, holds the other 50% and manages the property.
Located in the Nkayi-Silobela greenstone belt, the mine produced
roughly 23 koz of gold by heap-leaching methods between August
2000 and September 2002.
Irrigation of the dumps continued to August 2004 with some minor
gold recovery. Cluff conducted an extensive drilling campaign to
evaluate the deposit and the sulphide resource, which is open to
depth and to the north, leading to an Indicated resource of 371 koz
contained.
In the Mutoko greenstone belt, Mwana Africa has 100% ownership
of the Makaha deposit, situated 140 km north-east of Harare.The
prospect has a historic (non-JORC compliant) resource of 350 koz at
a grade of 1.2 g/t.
Elsewhere, Mwana is active in the Bubi greenstone belt, at Turk and
Lonely mine areas, and in the Nubobs greenstone belt.
Mwana Africa owns a 53% stake in Bindura Nickel Corp, which
comprises two nickel mines, Trojan and Shangani, a smelter and a
refinery. The Zimbabwe government holds 22%, with the remainder
as free float traded on the Zimbabwe stock exchange. The company
completed construction of an upgraded concentrator at Trojan in
February 2008, but then was forced to place the complex on care-and-
maintenance at the end of that year. In August, Mwana Africa received a
positive report from SRK Consulting on re-starting the Trojan mine.
New Dawn Mining Corp (TSX:ND)
Canadian-listed New Dawn Mining operates the 100%-owned Turk mine
and in mid-2010 completed the acquisition of several more historic mining
projects with its acquisition of an 89% controlling interest in AIM-listed
Central African Gold Plc (CAG).
Its Turk mine, owned through local subsidiary Casmyn Mining
Zimbabwe, which it restarted in 2009, is expanding operations to a
capacity of 23 koz/y and is working towards 35-50 koz/y.
With the acquisition of CAG, giving it an 84.7% interest in Falcon Gold
68 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
Location of New Dawn’s mines and projects post the Central African Gold acquisition
KARIBA
0 250km
HARARE
3
Dalny Mine
HWANGE
Venice Mine
2 MUTARE
1
GWERU Golden Quarry Mine
Turk and
Angelus Mine Cam perdown Mine
BULAWAYO
Old Nic Mine LEGEND
MAJOR TOWNS 1 BULAWAYO GOLD CAMP
MAJOR GOLD MINES 2 GWERU GOLD CAMP
(<10000KG AU)
3 KADOMA GOLD CAMP
CAG MINES
BEITBRIDGE
NEW DAWN MINE
GREENSTONE BELTS
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 69
The old Camperdown pit is in poor repair but the future may lie underground (Photo: Paul Burton)
reported gold output of only 15 koz in 2008 (when it was the only
gold mine that stayed open) and 23 koz in 2009. Production in 2009
came from treating 709 kt/d of ore at a grade of 3.32 g/t with a
recovery of 84%. The mine operated at only 75% of rated capacity
because of frequent power outages, as a result of load shedding, and
numerous plant breakdowns.
The mine is located in the Limpopo Mobile Belt and not in one of the
greenstone belts.
As a result of the reclassification of some ore reserves, proved
reserves at the end of 2009 fell 19% to 346 kt, containing 62 koz
of gold. Over the next five years, the company intends to employ
a combination of diamond drilling and accelerated underground
development of haulages to increase reserves once again to support
significantly increased production levels from 2015 onwards.
According to Reuters, the mine is forecast to produce 24 koz of gold
this year with an increase to 70 koz by 2013 and a further increase to
112 koz in 2015.
In 2009, the company reported a loss of US$16.2 million. At the end
of the year, it had cash of US$2.9 million and borrowings, through an
overdraft facility, of US$29.4 million. Such production expansion as
outlined above will require a substantial capital investment and therefore
RioZim is reportedly looking to raise US$40 million through a rights
issue, having apparently abandoned a similar placement plan last year.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 73
Makorakozas
working in one of Duration Gold’s old pits (Photo: Paul Burton)
production each year the actual level is not known for obvious
reasons. It is very difficult to measure an activity that by definition is
informal and thus not exactly intent on publishing public records.
The COMZ believes Makorkoza production cannot amount to more
than a few kilograms a year for the following reasons:
1) Over the last ten years or so the oxidised gold resource that small
scale and illegal workers had been working on have largely been
exhausted. This leaves hard rock gold resources at depths that
require drilling and blasting with grades far less that the surface
enriched resource of yesteryears. There is no evidence of mining
that leads to such high levels of production.
2) The number of people involved has also drastically reduced
compared to the numbers involved in the 1990 to 2000.
3) The pull for this illegal activity has also disappeared with the use of
multiple currency in the conduct of business. The skewed exchange
rate that existed before the dollarisation in 2009, coupled with the
unrealistic Z$ price offered by the RBZ, were major incentives for
illegal operations. Miners would produce gold, export it illegally and
bring back hard currency that was exchanged on the parallel market
for huge rewards. This does not pay anymore.
Notwithstanding the Chamber of Mines’ comments, in the short time I
was in the country I witnessed considerable Makorakozi activity in some
76 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
of the disused open pits. ‘Mining’ usually involves some sluicing of ‘run of
mine’ dirt and then hand shovelling into wheelbarrows. Gold extraction
often involves the hazardous use of mercury.
Sometimes the illegal miners are more adventurous and actually engage in
actual mining, burrowing into the walls of old open pits.The Camperdown
pit, shown on the previous page, has evidence of this adit mining.
The Makorakoza activity at this subsistence level is obviously fraught
with danger for the individuals themselves. Despite it being illegal,
neither the police nor the mining companies show much interest in
putting an end to it. The police do occasional ‘raid’ a site and arrest the
miscreants but after receiving a small fine they are back at work the
next day. The mining companies turn a blind eye to it, although most
mine sites employ security guards and fencing, and will probably look
to employ the illegals when they recommence organised mining in the
affected pits.
The final category of producer outside of the formal sector is the
custom millers. These small operations use old style stamps to crush
and mill gold bearing rock that they buy from small, informal miners
and, presumably, from illegals as well. Their setups can be seen all over
the place. One such operation was pointed out to me just metres off
the main road as we drove south from Bulawayo along the road to
Beit Bridge.
7.6 Explorers
GAT Investments
New Dawn Mining
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 81
GAT Investments
Corporate Details Project: Isabella oxides (100%)
6D Status: Depleting
Name GAT Investments (Private) Ltd
Registered Zimbabwe
Its main claim blocks are located in Matabeleland
province, 80 km due north of Bulawayo. These
Address 3 Cecil Rhodes Drive, Newlands, properties were formerly owned by Anglo
Harare, Zimbabwe American Zimbabwe and the company acquired
Telephone +263 4 788151 them through a management buyout in 2003.
The Matabeleland properties consist of a total of
Fax +263 4 788156
696 claims covering an area of 3,480 ha.
Email VGapare@gat.co.zw
The Isabella EPO hosts three operating mines at
Website na Isabella, McCays and When grouped together, with
Company Description Bubi (on the Gwizaan EPO) some 32 km away.
GAT Investments, a private Zimbabwean company, owns a These shallow (less than 30 m deep) open pit/
number of gold mining operations and projects in Zimbabwe heap leach mines have produced some 230 koz of
through local private entity, Bilboes Holdings (Private) Ltd. gold since start up by Anglo American in 1989.
The company’s short term business plan revolves around dump McCays’ ore reserves were depleted by
and oxide material treatment but the longer term future is December 2002 and the company suspended
dependent on the successful delineation and exploitation of mining at Bubi and When by May 2005, although it
sulphide mineralisation at these former Anglo American properties.
did continue with intermittent re-leaching of pads
The company has a long term production target from its sulphide thereafter at the three mines.
projects of 300 koz/y from a potential resource base of up to
6.5 Moz. Isabella, meanwhile, operated (mining and leaching)
In total, the company holds 1,217 claims covering 6,086 ha in on a start-stop basis until October 2008, when all
Matabeleland, Midlands and Manicaland provinces as well as the processes at all the mines were stopped until
198,229 ha of exploration licenses under application within the April 2009.The company has produced 40 koz of
same provinces, namely: Isabella, Gwizaan, Lower Gweru, Gweru gold from the four mines since the 2003 acquisition.
and Mutare EPO applications..
Each mine has heap leach facilities although
Key Officers & Management (Bilboes) Isabella is the site of the single elution and
Chairman: Edgar Nyamupingidza, Chief Operating Officer of smelting plant. Isabella has an installed crushing
Kingdom Financial Holdings, a Zimbabwean financial services plant with a capacity to treat 100 kt/mth of ore.
group. Group Chief Executive: Victor Gapare, led the Future production will be based on an installed
management buyout of Bilboes in 2003 from Anglo American crushing plant capacity of 80 kt/mth at McCays,
Corporation Zimbabwe Limited, current president of the When 15 kt/mth and Bubi 80 kt/mth. The mines
Chamber of Mines of Zimbabwe. Technical Executive: Simba
are connected to the national electricity grid via
Chimedza. Projects Executive: Willie Cherewo. Non-executive
300 kVA transformers with a 150 kVA backup
directors: Washington Gapare, Jean Maguranyanga, Vulindlela
Ndlovu, Duncan Smith, Michael Tapera. generator at Isabella.
Funding & Financial Position When I visited in late July 2010, Isabella was the
In 2009, Bilboes reported revenue from gold sales of US$3.8
only plant operating, retreating heap leach dumps,
million with a gross profit of US$1.7 million. The net loss for although it was running well below rated capacity.
the year was US$0.8 million. The company ended 2009 with a Production for seven months in 2009 amounted
negative working capital position of US$1.0 million. to 120 kg (3.9 koz) at a cash cost of US$689/oz.
The company is undertaking a private placement to raise The short term production target at the Isabella
US$15 million, mainly to complete the work for bankable feasibility plant is 175 kg/y (6 koz/y – it has operated at
studies for the Sulphide and Gold Quarry projects as well as around 70 koz/y) from old heap leach dumps
recapitalising its gold mines.The mines have a capacity to produce
and some open pit oxide ore. Longer term, the
15koz/y from dumps and oxide material for the next five to 10 years.
company forecasts steady state production from
The company, through Bilboes Holdings, hopes to undertake oxides of 450 kg/y (approx 15 koz/y).
a stock exchange listing and an IPO in 2 years after successful
completion of bankable feasibility studies to fund mine construction. Current oxide reserves amount to 104 koz of
82 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
gold contained at an average grade of 0.67 g/t. Project: Sulphide (100%) Status: Definition
Measured and Indicated resources are 79 koz at a
Although the continuing processing of oxide
grade of 0.50 g/t.
material should enable Bilboes to generate
In order to reach planned output the company cashflow over the next few years, the longer term
is looking to spend US$5 million on the oxide future of the operations in Matabeleland lies with
facilities, comprising new crushing plants at the deeper sulphide resources.
McCays and When (US$1.2 million); additional
The Isabella EPO is underlain by felsic and
earthmoving equipment and refurbishment of
mafic schists and greywackes of the Upper and
process plants at all the mines (US$3.5 million)
Lower Bulawayan volcanic units that form part
and heap leach pad extensions at Isabella and
of the Archaean Bubi greenstone belt. The area
McCays (US$0.3 million).
is transacted by three major structural faults
The production schedule for the oxides is shown with a number of associated splays which have
in the following table. controlled the mineral deposition. Mineralisation
trends north east- south west and is truncated
2009a 2010f 2011f 2012f 2013f 2014f by fault splays and is hosted in a banded iron
Tonnes 294 877 1,860 1,670 1,740 1,740 formation unit.
treated (kt)
Gold (koz) 3.9 5.5 14.2 15.4 14.5 14.5 The Isabella mine mineralisation is located within
Cash costs 689 748 514 486 505 525 a broad shear zone cutting through felsic schists
(US$/oz) close to the contact between the Bulawayan and
a= actual; f= forecast Shamvaian units. Orebody widths range from 5 to
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 83
20 m and have strike lengths from 75 m up to undertaken by previous owner Anglo American
500 m. The oxide cap is deepest (between 12 and Zimbabwe between 1994-98, which consisted of
40 m, with an average depth of 24 m) at Isabella. 123 diamond drill holes (for 17,700 m) over a
Sulphides throughout are predominantly pyrite strike of 3.4 km and down to an average depth
and arsenopyrite and are refractory. of 150 m.
Isabella’s geological strike covers over 6 km of Following its study of the data, SRK concluded
which 70% has been fully explored for oxides. that there is ‘potential to increase this (534 koz
A December 2009, independent technical report of Inferred) by 4 Moz through strike and depth
by SRK Consulting confirmed significant sulphide extensions of the known open ended mineralisation.’
resources drilled out on the Isabella, McCays This potential comes out of a strike of 8.4 km to
and Bubi claims and also suggested considerable a depth of 300 m. Furthermore, the consultant
potential to upgrade these resources and inferred that out of this potential resource, about
delineate additional resources. 1-2 Moz could be amenable to mining by open pit
methods down to 100 m.
End-2009 Inferred resources, based on a
2 g/t cut-off, were 4.7 Mt at a grade of 3.49 g/t Accordingly, the company is planning to invest
for 534 koz of gold contained down to a depth of US$7.2 million over the next two years to
100 m. Beneath this, SRK identified an additional explore systematically the sulphide potential and
3.5 Mt of ‘unclassified’ material at a grade of complete a bankable feasibility study.
2.11 g/t for 240 koz of gold contained. The bulk of the money (US$5.4 million) will
The resource estimate is based on drilling fund an exploration programme to include, as
recommended by the consultants’ study, infill resource, in oxide and transition material, using
drilling to upgrade the existing Inferred resource historic drill data, over the Main, South and
and to provide samples for metallurgical testing, Woodstock areas containing just 40 koz at
as well drilling along strike down to a target 0.81 g/t gold, but with 745 koz of silver in the
depth of 300 m to expand the resource. The Main zone.
company plans to drill some 48,000 m in total.
However, the consultant has stated that it
The sulphides are known to be refractory so believes the potential for Gold Quarry and
metallurgical test work will follow up on flotation, neighbouring claims is ‘between 0.5 and 1.5 Moz
BIOX and ultra fine grind tests, some of which with a grade of between 3 and 4 g/t’, based on an
were conducted during the Anglo American assumption that mineralisation is continuous
era, and an amount of US$0.3 million has been and to a depth of 400 m and with a strike length
budgeted for this. of 400 m.
At this stage, Bilboes is projecting production SRK bases its estimation on two holes, which
from the Sulphide project of 1,200 kg (39 koz) in intersected sulphide mineralisation at a depth
four years time, building to 8,000 kg/y (257 koz/y) of 300 m but were not assayed, as well as the
eight years’ out. presence of four parallel zones of mineralisation
at Gold Quarry which have only been partly
Project: Gold Quarry (100%)
explored and similar likely extensions at the
Status: Definition
adjacent Woodstock claims.
Gold Quarry lies within the Mutare EPO
Based on these conclusions, Bilboes intends to
application, which is located approximately
initiate an exploration programme consisting of
50 km east of the city of Mutare. The Manicaland
6,000 m of drilling at a cost of US$0.5 million as
properties consist of four claim blocks for a
part of a US$1.6 million investment to take the
total of 59 claims covering an area of 296 ha.
Gold Quarry project through to completion of a
The company acquired the claims from
bankable feasibility study within 2 years.
Anglo American Zimbabwe in early 2006.
Anglo American explored the area back in Metallurgical work so far has shown that the
the 1960-70s after small mines worked the ore is not refractory but that there may be
property sporadically in the first half of the recovery problems associated with the silver.
twentieth century. Thus the company plans to take bulk samples to
test gravity concentration for free gold recovery
At Gold Quarry there is potential for both open
before cyanidation, with an option to agglomerate
pit oxide and underground sulphide mining, with
the fine ore.
silver as a by-product.
The company is projecting first production from
The claims are located within the Mutare
Gold Quarry after five years at a rate of 360 kg/y
Greenstone Belt, which strikes west to southwest
(approx 12 koz/y) rising to 2,100 kg/y (68 koz/y)
as a narrow synclinal structure comprising
from year eight.
ultramafic and mafic rocks of the Bulawayan
group with banded iron formation intercalations Project: Exploration (100%)
overlain by sediments. Mineralisation within Status: Detection
the Mutare greenstones is associated with
The company has applied for Exclusive
shear zones which tend to be located along the
Prospecting Orders (EPOs) which consist of
contacts of the different lithological units and
two contiguous areas in Matabeleland (Gwizaan
within the BIF.
and Isabella), another two in the Midlands
Gold deposits are scattered throughout the belt Province (Gweru and Lower Gweru) and one in
within and surrounding quartz diorite stocks. Manicaland (Mutare).
Most have high silver content with associated
The EPOs have yet to be approved although the
lead, zinc and nickel. The sulphides present
company applied for three of them back in 2003
include galena, chalcopyrite, pyrite, pyrrhotite
and the remaining two a year later. The official
and arsenopyrite.
government standpoint is that the company must
The 2009 SRK report determined a Measured demonstrate its technical ability to complete a
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 85
proposed exploration programme and raise the • Thirdly, although, the extent of the work
necessary finance for the exploration. So work has not allowed the independent consultant
cannot commence until the funds are raised. to define fully the scale of the deposit, it
Statutory annual fees are up to date. has given it enough confidence to suggest
that the resource potential is probably
The company also owns 472 claims covering a
some 3-5 Moz. That represents a sizable
total area of 2,310 ha in Matabeleland, Manicaland
orebody by anybody’s standards. Finally, the
and Midlands.
depth of the sulphides is relatively shallow
(the average depth of the oxide cap is
Investment Comment
only 24 m) and therefore the potential to
by World Gold Analyst
develop a large open pit is very good. The
consultant’s report suggests that there may
• On the Matabeleland claims, the company has
be 1-2 Moz of gold that could be mined
a reasonably-sized oxide reserve/resource
this way. The sulphide mineralisation is
that can be exploited relatively easily. Although
refractory and although these days that
the material is low grade there are no real
does not represent a technical challenge, it
mining costs involved and processing is
will add to the operating cost profile.
straightforward.The company has a clear
business plan to achieve a production rate • The company’s other project, Gold Quarry,
of 15 koz/y from the oxides, but it will need is at a much earlier stage than the Sulphide
to raise and spend US$5 million to bring the project in Matabeleland, and probably
facilities fully on line. represents less of a compelling investment
given that it appears to be smaller scale
• Re-establishing the oxide processing would
and lower grade. Nevertheless, the
generate cashflow and see the company
consultant’s report has indicated potential
moving into a profit situation in 2011 and
of 0.5-1.5 Moz in resources so it clearly
for five years thereafter.
warrants investigation.
• Longer term, the company’s growth into
• The key with GAT (and Bilboes) is to
a mid-tier gold producer, in world terms,
secure the necessary financing to enable it
depends on the successful development of
to proceed with its plans.
the sulphide resources on the Matabeleland
claims. Already, based on the work that • The management and technical team are
Anglo American did, an independent former Anglo American employees so are
consultant’s report has estimated over familiar with the projects. Both GAT and
0.5 Moz of Inferred resources. The company Bilboes are 100% owned Zimbabwean
plans to upgrade these resources and companies so there is no concern about
expand exploration to cover the full 8.4 km compliance with indigenisation legislation.
of strike length of the mineralisation.
• There are several points that make this
project interesting from an investment
point of view. The first is that it was
owned by Anglo American, which gives it
credibility. A company the size of Anglo
American does not invest in a short term,
small oxide pit project. The company must
have realised the longer term potential and
clearly that’s why it drilled almost 18,000 m
over 3.4 km to outline the sulphides. This
exploration programme represents one of
the few systematic drilling programmes to
investigate and evaluate a deposit on a large
scale that I came across in the country; and
that’s the second point.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 87
Location of New Dawn’s camps and projects post the Central African Gold acquisition
KARIBA
0 250km
HARARE
3
Dalny Mine
HWANGE
Venice Mine
2 MUTARE
1
GWERU Golden Quarry Mine
Turk and
Angelus Mine Cam perdown Mine
BULAWAYO
Old Nic Mine LEGEND
MAJOR TOWNS 1 BULAWAYO GOLD CAMP
MAJOR GOLD MINES 2 GWERU GOLD CAMP
(<10000KG AU)
3 KADOMA GOLD CAMP
CAG MINES
BEITBRIDGE
NEW DAWN MINE
GREENSTONE BELTS
ZESA moved away from its agreed load shedding multiple reefs and cross-linking structures is also
schedule and imposed random power cuts on present and that Angelus simply represents a
the mine. Consequently, the company has decided faulted extension of the Turk structure.
to implement the expensive remedial option
Turk has reserves containing 167 koz of gold and
(US$1.2 million) of installing 3 MVA of diesel
M&I resources of 769 koz according to an SRK
generating capacity as standby power.
Consulting audit at the end of 2009 and as shown
Geologically the properties are located within in the following table.
the Bulawayo-Bubi greenstone belt that typically
comprises volcanic and sedimentary successions. Category Tonnes Grade Gold
The mines are hosted by a large northeasterly (Mt) (g/t) (koz)
striking shear zone, which dips steeply to the 2P Reserves 1.32 3.92 167
south within a typical Archaean greenstone M&I resources 4.81 4.98 769
succession of meta-sedimentary and meta- Inferred resources 2.08 5.14 343
volcanic rocks. Based on a cut-off of 2.45 g/t and a gold price of US$875/oz.
will spend some US$7-8 million on increasing Camp: Gweru Project: Golden Quarry (75%)
the hoist capacity, installing a new fine grinding Status: Definition
mill (Deswik) and other equipment, such as The Golden Quarry mine complex consists
compressors and underground equipment. This of an open pit/heap leach and a higher grade
will be funded from cashflow and take gold underground mine feeding a CIL plant (which also
production up to 35-50 koz/y. processed higher grade ore from Camperdown),
Although it’s primary focus at this stage is on although neither are operational at present.
getting the operations bedded in at the current The Golden Quarry main ore deposit is located
capacity rate and working on the expansion, in a large shear in a structurally complex
New Dawn is starting to apply more time and area, with considerable alteration of the host
resources on its exploration on the properties. lithologies. The original rock types are from
The company is probing the lateral and down dip a greenstone assemblage, with evidence of
extensions of the gold lodes mined previously ultramafic and mafic rocks and some intercalated
on shallower and deeper levels through cross- sediments and local occurrences of banded iron
cutting and diamond drilling at Batyali and MVS- formation and chert. However, owing to a lack
Armenian zones at Turk, and at Angelus. of detailed geological mapping and drilling, the
Project: Old Nic (100%) Status: Depleting orebody is not well understood.
The Old Nic Mine is situated on the eastern The hoisting capacity is 10 kt/mth, although the
side of the city of Bulawayo, and is one of the plant can treat up to 20 kt/mth. Management
oldest gold mines in Matabeleland. The mine has will re-commission the plant and has blocked
produced some 290 koz from high grade (9.4 g/t) out eighteen months of ore to feed the mill at
ore but it is not regarded as a key asset because 7-8 kt/mth to produce 1,200 oz/mth or 14 koz/y.
expansion potential is limited given its proximity The mine has a very small global resource
to the city. delineated underground (70 koz), which will
90 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
supply some 40% of the mill feed with the rest recommended an open pit survey to map out
originating from other, as yet undelineated, the extent of the quartz veins and re-assess the
resources. Once the plant is fully utilized it is extent of the important Collingwood Leader.
expected to produce approximately 14 koz/y.
In the short term, the company’s plan is to
To this end the company is proposing a trenching generate cashflow by processing dump material
programme on the main shear zone strike where from the old Wanderers mine (4.5 Mt at a grade of
illegal miners (makorakoza) are working and will 0.64 g/t for around 90 koz gold contained), which
also explore at the Santoy/Santoy West claims to lies on the property. This, along with a smaller
the north. dump, has the potential to produce 20-25 koz/y
Project: Camperdown (100%) of gold.
Status: Definition Camp: Kadoma Project: Dalny (75%)
The Camperdown mine is situated approximately Status: Definition
30 km southeast of Gweru, 5 km from Golden The Dalny mine complex is situated 36 km north
Quarry.The orebody previously produced of Kadoma in the Chakari district, approximately
ore material from both a dual open pit and an 175 km southwest of the capital, Harare. The
underground mining operation, with the higher property consists of greater than 3,500 claims
grade ore sent for treatment at the Golden Quarry covering a strike length of some 25 km.
plant and lower grade oxides treated on site.
Historical production (to 2006) was 2.4 Moz of
Camperdown has a total M&I resource of gold from 10.2 Mt of ore treated at a grade of
270 koz, of which 183 koz is open pit oxides and 7.42 g/t. Power is supplied by ZESA.
surface dump material.
The mine operated as an underground mine
The mine lies in part of the Shurugwi Schist Belt with numerous vertical shafts feeding a flotation/
that is a sedimentary succession of conglomerates, roaster plant. At its peak the operation produced
grits, phyllites, sandstones, and banded ironstones 50-60 koz/y, with the Dalny mine the largest,
(BIF) that gives rise to a small range of hills north although most recently Arlandzer, Turkoise and
of Shurugwi. The most important ore source in the the Dawn-Brilliant mines were being worked. In
underground mine was the Collingwood Leader. recent years, Dalny has treated dump material at
The BIF, which is exposed in the open pit, dips a separate leach plant onsite.
gently to the northwest and east, forming a flat
arch with folding towards the south-east portion The Dalny complex is located on the north-
of the pit. The ‘Brown’ dyke and another felsic dyke western limb of the plunging Kadoma anticline
are main control features on gold deposition. and is hosted by andesitic to basaltic lavas of the
Upper Bulawayan System that is Archaean in age.
The deposit is not well understood as under Several intrusive quartz porphyries and dolerite
Falgold’s ownership the only exploration dykes of different ages crop out in the area.
was underground development, although
re-interpretation of old data has led to a new A strong structural control has given rise to
model of the BIF ‘arch structure’. mineralised zones oriented along a northeast to
southwest strike with a steep dip towards the west.
Accordingly, the company is planning a 4,000 m Most of the mineralised deposits situated west
Phase 1 drilling programme (25 diamond holes of the Chevy Chase fault (Arlandzer,Turkoise and
and 75 RC holes) to fully investigate the potential. Dalny) are predominately of the replacement type,
The plan may involve the building of a modular whilst those to the east tend to be narrow quartz
CIL plant to treat tailings ore sources within the veins with erratic gold distributions, eg Chadshunt,
region at a rate of 70-90 kt/mth for 5-6 years, at Double H, Cheshire Cat and Dawn-Brilliant.
an estimated capital cost of US$4-5 million.
The most common sulphides are pyrite and
Once a larger ore resource is defined at the arsenopyrite, which extend into the schistose
Camperdown and nearby deposits like Golden country rock surrounding the narrow, gold-rich
Quarry, then a crushing and milling circuit would
part. Although most of the gold is very fine
be added to the tailings CIL plant.
grained and associated with the sulphides, coarse
A recent independent technical report gold has been observed.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 91
According to a recent independent NI 43-101 production (to 2002) was 318 koz of gold from
report, M&I resources contain 337 koz of gold, 2.5 Mt of ore treated at a grade of 3.77 g/t. The
164 koz of which are located underground (at mine complex has a metallurgical facility that has
grades between 5.73 g/t and 7.87 g/t), with the capacity to process 18 kt/mth.
remaining 173 koz in surface dumps (at a grade The property is considered geologically very
of 0.67 g/t). prospective, although the reef geometry is
The site has potential for short term dump complex and the shaft is flooded. Near term
retreatment but the longer term attraction is for potential lies with the retreatment of a 1.8 Mt
recommencement of underground mining and dump using hydraulic sluices utilising water from
possible open pit opportunities along the strike underground at a treatment rate of 30 kt/mth
of the shear zone. over a 4 year period.
The W14 shaft had a capacity 18 kt/mth and the Project: Other properties
company plans to dewater the shaft and use it Status: Definition/Discovery
again as a production shaft. In addition, by spending In the Gweru camp, the company has options at
around US$250,000, the existing plant can be Ladville (Ashtonkop and Altimus claims) and Basil
brought back into operation at around 9 kt/mth. Payne, all former mining areas.
The company will investigate the potential to not At Altimus, the company has completed 3,000 m
only mine multiple reef systems underground of trenching on a broad geochemical anomaly.
(Dalny mineralisation extends down to 38 level at
1,500 m) but also the ‘halos’ of lower grade gold Other potential within the camp exists to the
mineralisation that the old timers missed when north where New Dawn has options on the RKB
following the quartz vein systems. Surface work property and will conduct trenching on 7.2 km of
at Colne/Stella has showed that high grade reefs BIF strike
have lower grade in between, over a total width of New Dawn is in discussions with a company for a
12-15 m. This sequence is replicated underground regional dump processing project.
(at 60 m depth) but the old miners only mined the
two high grade reefs, so management is working Investment Comment
on the theory that there may be economic grade by World Gold Analyst
in between, which opens up the possibility of bulk
mining over a potential 1 km strike. • The company completed the acquisition of
CAG through the issuance of 3.5 million shares
Recent structural remote sensing work (using
with an equivalent value of roughly C$4 million.
QuickBird high-resolution earth observation
In addition, New Dawn effectively settled the
satellite in conjunction with Aster image
debt owed to the three shareholding groups
interpretation) led to a new geological map, which
by CAG through issuing a further 5.3 million
has picked up structure and identified changes in
shares and 2.2 million, 4-year warrants
shears (E-W) which have potential for duplex reef
with an exercise price of C$2.00/share. As
structures. It also clearly picked out potential drill a consequence, US firm, Emerging Capital
targets in areas where illegal miners are working. Partners, is now the third largest shareholder in
There are also thought to be open pit New Dawn with a 12.8% interest.
opportunities at Colne, Maldon and Arlandzer • Although the new assets will need some
where near-surface mineralisation remains intact. not-inconsequential refurbishment work,
The company plans to conduct an audit of this move will give the company the
geological information for the Dalny complex and opportunity to grow at a much faster rate
explore some of the shallower mines that have been than organically from its own projects.
redundant for years, such as Dalny, Pixy and Stella. The potential offered by these new assets,
particularly in the Kadoma camp, will show
Project: Venice (75%) 6D Status: Definition
this acquisition to be great value in the
Venice is situated approximately 28 km south of longer term. It also establishes New Dawn
Kadoma and consists of over 2,500 claims that as the prime consolidator in the burgeoning
have numerous exploration targets. Historical Zimbabwe gold landscape.
92 WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE
• There was an immediate outcry from the • The company is looking to raise a
government over New Dawn’s acquisition minimum of US$10 million (possibly up to
of CAG with the claim that it “did not US$25 million) – US$3 million for accrual
comply with empowerment regulations payable for Falgold; US$2 million for working
and threatened Zimbabwe’s security and cap to rejuvenate existing ops; US$5 million
economic interests”. There should be no to new compressors and equipment to take
concern for investors on this. Management production up to 50-60 koz/y over next
has had discussions with government officials 18 months for all ops.
and explained New Dawn’s long presence in • In October last year, New Dawn managed to
Zimbabwe through Casmyn Mining and the sell the bond secured from the Reserve Bank
fact that the chief executive is a Zimbabwean of Zimbabwe in lieu of payment for gold sales
national and lives in Bulawyo. Furthermore, in 2008 for the sum of US$2.4 million. Other
the acquisition is unlikely to fall foul of the companies are still waiting for the RBZ to
Competition Act of Zimbabwe. honour it’s bonds.
• At its original operating property, Turk/ • The company is listed in Canada and has
Angelus, there is potential to expand the access to capital markets. After the CAG
mining focus to additional lodes as past acquisition it still only has 38 million shares
mining at Angelus only exploited one lode outstanding.
(the miners worked two at Turk). Also,
historic mining operations worked to a
depth of 800 m and with current mining no
deeper than 200 m this suggests that there
is scope to develop deeper parts of the
mine property.
• Exploration work could open up significantly
more resources according to SRK
Consulting. In a December 2008 independent
report, the consultant states “SRK are of
the opinion that it is not unreasonable
to expect that between 1.5 and 2 million
ounces at a grade of between 4.0 and 4.5 g/t
will eventually be mined at Turk and Angelus
Mines, excluding the current Resource and
Reserve inventory...”.
• With the installation of power generators at
Turk, the company should be able to reach
its current capacity and then to expand
operations up to the intended 35-50 koz/y
level. Importantly, New Dawn does not have
to really on outside funding for this expansion
– it will be funded from cashflow.
• At the Kadoma camp, the potential is good
to look at bulk mining opportunities once
the company has completed a full geological
investigation. There is underground potential
to mine two parallel reefs and the halo
in between. In some case the same reef
orientation is relatively close to surface so
may be amenable to open pit mining.
WO R L D G O L D A N A L Y S T Z I M B A BWE 93
Company Index
Makorakoza at one of Duration Gold’s pits Examining vein contact underground at Turk (courtesy New Dawn Mining)
Mine geologists and miners underground at Turk (courtesy New Dawn Mining)
FOLLOW THE TREND...
find out who’s hitting the seam
with World Gold Analyst
www.gfmsworldgold.com WO R L D
For more information email paul.burton@gfmsworldgold.com GO L D