Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 1 Merged
Chapter 1 Merged
Chapter 1 Merged
(iv) To provide
mechanism for investigation into the affairs of
companies and also provide for effective audit in dealing with
cases of dishonesty and fraud in the corporate sector.
Bangladesh law in
1.2 Origin and development of company
law relating to companies is known as the
In Bangladesh the present
The present Act is based on the
Companies Act, 1994{Act No.18 of 1994).
structure of the Companies Act 1913.
Indian sub-
The efforts to make statutory laws relating to companies in the
Act
continent actually started from 1850 with the passing of the Companies
made and ultimately the
in that year. There after several amendments were
Indian Companies Act, 1913 was passed consolidating
the laws relating to
Act of 1908. The 1913
companies and associations, based on the English
Act was amended in 1914, 1915, 1920, 1926, 1930, and 1932. Major
1946,Thereafter the law continued
amendments were made in 1936 and in
0 remain in force with amendment only. The word 'India' in the name of
omitted and thus the name of thelaw as changed into simply
ACt was the Companies
une CompaniesAct, 1913. After liberation of Bangladesh
the Companies Act, 1956
remained in force. However, in India
was
adopted replacing 1913 Act.
The Companies Act, 1994 was passed by the Parliament on 12 September
1994
* 0n the basis of the recommendations of the Law Reforms Committee
Set
na . The recommendations were to remove the vacuum in the law
and to foreign
surge especially with regard
of problems
the
stments. The Act came into force with effect from the 1"day of January
1995 . It i to be
to note that through out the discussion, Sections,
referredortant
shall mean
an Sections of the Companies
Act 1994.
428 Text Book of Commercial Law
1.3 The salient features ofthe Companles Act 1994
The Companies Act 1994 underscores some features, which are as follow
ws:
1. It provides provisions for the effective maintenance
of
accountability on the working of the Board of directors;
2. It provides provisions preserving the rights of the
minority
shareholders;
3. It provides provisions to safeguard the interest of theinvestors
4. It contains provisions to open the affairs of the company to
the
public regarding the relation between the holding company and
subsidiary company;
5. It lays down provisions removing the disparity between the
companies in the private and public sector; and
6. It states the provisions allowing the formation and dissolution of
the companies more easily and to remove
govermmental control
over the affairs of the management of the company.
1.4 What is company?
The word 'company' has strictly legal meaning. The dictionary meaning
no
of 'company' is assembly i.e. gathering of a number of persons together. The
word company is traced from 1150 A.D (CE) from French
term campaignie
or body of soldiers and from
Latin companio (companies). The use of the
word in a sense of "business association" was first recorded
in 1553, having
earlier been used in reference to trade
guilds (1303) i.e. an association of
craftsmen in a particular trade.
Generally speaking, a
company is a
voluntary association of number of
persons or individuals or people formed for some common
of economic objects in terms
reality i.e. to carry on a business for profit or gain.
Lindley, Lord Justice: defines a company as:
an association of many
persons who contribute money to a common stock
and employ it in some common trade
or business. The
common stock so
contributed is denoted in money and is the
persons who contribute it or to whom it
capital the Company. The
of
A more
comprehensive legal definition of a company giving its main
essentials has been given by
Haney: as "A company is an incorporated
association, which is an artificial person created
entity, with a by law, having a separate
perpetual succession and a common seal."
Company Law 429
According to the Companies Act, 1994:
Company' means a company formed and registered under the Companies
Act or an existing company [Sec. 2 (1)(c).
Thus the word 'company' may be described as association of a number of
persons, formed for some common purpose and registered according to the
Companies Act, 1994 usually having the word Limited' e.g. Beximco
Phamaceuticals Limited, Dhaka', The Structural Design & Engineering
Ltd, Dhaka etc.
An 'existing company' means a company formed and registered under any
ofthe former Companies Acts" [Sec. 2(1(h)].
The Act excludes unregistered companies within the meaning of the Act,
1994. So, in our study we will make focus on registered companies.
1.5 Characteristics of a registered company
I. Legal personality distinet from its members: A company is regarded
as an entity separate from its members. In other words, it has an
independent existence. Any of its members can enter into contracts with t
in the same manner as any other individual can and he cannot be held liable
for the acts of the company even if he holds virtually the entire share
capital. The company's money and property belong to the company and not
to the shareholders (although the shareholders own the company).
The importance of the separate entity of a company was very well brought
out in the following English cases:
I. Private company;
IL. Public company.
the Companies Act, 1994 there are mainly three kinds of
According to
companies:
I. Companies limited by shares [Sec. 5(a)];
II Companies limited by guarantee [Sec. 5(b)]:
II. Companies with unlimited liability [Sec. 5(c)]
Company limited by shares: those companies in which the capital is of
are
fixed amount divided into number of shares and in which the liability of the
members is limited to the face value of his shares. This is the most common
form of company [Sec. 5(a)].
Companies limited by guarantee: are those companies in which the
liability of the members is limited to a fixed amount, which he/she
guarantees or undertakes to contribute to the assets of the company in case
of the company is wound up during his membership or within a year ater
conclusion of his membership [Sec. 5{5)).
the
Companies with unlimited liability: are those companies where
liability of the members is not limited. Such company may or may not have
a share capital. The members of such company are not exempted from
personal liability of different acts [Section 5(¢)].
Private company: A private company is a company which by its Articles
of association:
() Restricts the right to transfer its shares, if any;
o
(1) Prohibits any invitation to the public to subscribe for its shares
debentures, if any;
Wno
(11) Limits the number of its members to fifty not including persons
are in its employment [Sect. 2(10q).
Company Law 433
The word "limited" must end with the name of the company e.g., "Public
Limited or Ltd".
1.6.3.1 Distinction between private company and public company
be distinguished from a public company on the
A Private company can
following points:
1. Minimum num ber of member_: The minimum number of persons
case of a
to form a
required company is seven. It is two in
public
private company.
2. Maximum of members: There is no restriction of
number
whereas the
maximum number of members in a public company,
maximum number cannot exceed fifty in a private company.
must have at least three
3. Number of directors: A public company
at least two
directors. Whereas,
a company must have
private
of a public
directors. But where a private company is a subsidiary
a private company must
have three directors
company, in that case,
(Sec. 90).
directors: In the case of a
4. Restriction on appointment of
the directors must file with the Registrar
public company,
to take up
director or sign an undertaking
consent to act as need
shares. The directors of a private company
qualification
not do so (Sec. 92).
the shares are
Company Limited
Company Limited Company with
by Shares by Guarantee Unlimited Liability
Private
Public
Company Company
It is
important to note that all these
according to the
Companies Act, 1994. companies should be stered
regisei
Company Law 435
therein.
436 Text Book on Commercial Law
favour of
(a) that power of appointment cannot be exercised except in
an individual;
from his
(b) that an individual appointment thereto follows necessarily
appointment director, managing agent, secretary or manager o1,
as
or
or to any other office of employment in, that other company,
30-
Text Book on Commercial Law
438
directors, holds the majority shares of fo
composition of Board of mer
company and the former company is itself the subsidiary of ther
company.
Example: Company S subsidiary of a Company H and Company Sti
is a
of company H 1
subsidiary of a Company S. Company S1 is a subsidiary
the Company $2 is a subsidiary of Company S1 Company S2 will be a
subsidiary of Company S and consequently also of Company H. The
Company H( Holdingcompany)
document to the
obligation of the company to deliver any
Registrar shall cease,
provided it has no other
business in Bangladesh. place of
Failure to
comply with
fails to comply requirements( Sec.384): If any foreign
with the
requirements of law laid down in in Part company
Act ( Sections 378-392), the X of the
company shall be punishable with
may extend to one thousand taka, or, in a fine which
the case of a
with an additional fine of five hundred continuing offence,
taka for
during which the default continues; and everyday after the first day
every
company who is knowingiy and wiluly, makesofficer or agent of the
punishable with the same fine. such default,
shall be
However, any failure by a toreign
company to comply with
foregoing provisions of this Part sail any of the
dealing or transaction entered into by not aiect the
validity any contract
of
in respect thereof. But the tne company
or its
liability to be sued
company shall not be
entitled to
institute any bring any suit,
claim any set off, make any counter claim or
transaction untillegal
in respect of any such contract, dealing or
with the provisions of this Part ( Sec. 385).
it proceeding
complied
Fees for registration of documents under this Part
be paid to the Registrar for registering (Sec.386):
documents shall The fees
be a The fees to
as
Schedule Il to the Comnpanies Act. specified in
Company Law 443
Restriction on sale and offer for sale of shares (Sec.388): (1) It shall not
be lawful for any person-
(a) to issue, circulate or distribute in Bangladesh any prospectus offering to
the public for subscription to shares in or debentures of a company
incorporated or to be incorporated outside Bangladesh whether the
company has or has not established, or when formed will or will not
establish, a place of business in Bangladesh, unless-
(1) before the issue, circulation or distribution of the prospectus
in Bangladesh a copy thereof, certified by the chairman and
two other directors of the company as having been approved
by resolution of the managing body, has been delivered for
registration to the Registrar;
(i) the prospectus states on the face of it that the copy has been
so delivered;
(ii) the prospectus is dated; and
(iv) the prospectus otherwise complies with this Part; or
of application for
(b) to issue to any person in Bangladesh a form
shares in debentures of such a company or intended company as
or
which
aforesaid unless the form is issued with a prospectus
complies the requirements of this
Part.
or sell shares or
whether as principal or agent, shall not
debentures,
be deemed an offer to the public.
Text Book on Commercial Law
444
(5) A person who is knowingly responsible for the issue, circulation or
distribution of any prospectus, or for the issue of a form
bf
application for shares or debentures, in contravention of the
provisions of this section shall be liable to a fine not exceeding ten
thousand taka.
(6) The expression "prospectus" "shares" and "debentures" have the
same meaning as and when used in relation to a company
(a) as regards any matter not disclosed, he proves that he was not
cognizant thereof; or
contravention arose from an
b) he proves that the non-compliance or
honest mistake of fact on his part; or
or contravention in respect of matter
was
(c) the non-compliance
with the case, were
which, in the option of the Court dealing
otherwise such as ought, in the option of
that
immaterial or were
all the circumstances of the case,
Court, having regard to
reasonably to be excused.
a statement with
But in the of failure to include in a prospectus
event
Schedule-l or
specified in clause 18 in the Part-I of
respect to the matters
no director or other person
of sub-section (I) of section 135,
in pursuance that he
in respect of the failure unless it be proved
shall incur any liability
matters not disclosed [Sec.
389(3)].
had knowledge of the
may
diminish any liability which any person
However it shall not limit or
the Companies Act.
incur under the general law or shall be an
sale of shares ( Sec. 390): It
Restriction on canvassing for
house to house of the public
or any
from
offence of any person going outside
shares of a company incorporated
member of public offering
or sale of such
shares.
Bangladesh for subscription to for business
include an office used
The expression "house"
shall not
managing director manager and its members have no right to take in the
or
agent of the and has no such power to bind the company by his
company
acts.
8. Powers: A partnership for example, can do anything which the partners
limit to its activities; a company's powers are
agree to do and there is no
clause in its Memorandum of
limited to those allowed by the objects
association.
9. Restrictions on powers: In a partnership, restrictions on the powers of a
agreement will not avail
particular partner contained in the partnership
against outsiders, but those in the Articles of assoclation of a conmpany are
effective as against the public because it is a pubiic document and anyone
Formation of a Company
2.1 Different phases or stages of formation
Normally before a company comes into existence it has to under go three
importantphases or stages. They are as follows:
1. First phase: promotional stage
This is the very beginning stage of formation of a company. In this stage
some ground works or preliminary works are done. They include:
a) building up the idea of business through company:
b) choice of name i.e. whether it should be public or private company;
c)nature of capital;
constitutional documents i.e. Memorandum and
d) preparation of
Articles of association by experts or legal advisors.
known as
All these preliminary works are done by certain persons
members or shareholders of the
"promoters" or interchangeably subscribers,
newly formed company.
and
Promotion may be defined as "the discovery of business opportunities
into a
the subsequent organization of funds, property and managerial ability
business concern for the purpose of making profits therefrom."
After completing the promotional work and before getting the proposed
the following
company actually registered the promoters also take
preparatory steps:
(i) To ascertain from the Registrar of companies whether the name by
which the new company is to be started is available or not;
Cii) To get permission from Board of Investment, if the company's
business comes within the purview of the Companies Act.
either
(a) a company limited by shares that is to say, a company having tne
liability of its members limited by the Memorandum to the
amount, if any, unpaid on the share respectively held by them, or
(b) a company limited by guarantee, that is to say, a company having
the liability
of its members limited by the Memorandum to suc
amount as the members may respectively thereby undertake o
persons who later became directors of the company. Held, the'company was
not liable to pay the solicitor's cost, although the company had taken the
benefit of his work as the company could not be sued in law for those
existence at the time when the
expenses in as much as it was not in
expenses were incurred [English and Colonial Produce Co. Ltd. Rel (1906)
2 Ch. 435]
2. Similarly, the company cannot after incorporation, enforce the contracts
made before its incorporation
Thus, the N Company agreed with an agent of the P Syndicate Ltd. before
its formation to grant a mining lease to the Syndicate. The Syndicate was
registered and discovered a seam of coal. The N Company refused to grant
the lease. Held, there was no binding contract between the N Company and
the Syndicate.
3. The promoters stand personally liable on a contract made on behalf of
the company not yet in existence. Such contract is deemed to have been
entered into personally by 1he promoters.
In Kelner v. Baxter, (1966) L.R. 2 C.P. 174, a hotel company was about to
be formed and persons responsible for the proposed company signed an
agreement on 27h January 1866 for the purchase of stock on its behalf,
payment to be made on 28 January 1866. The company was incorporated
on 20h February 1866. The goods were consumed in the business and the
company went into liquidation before the debt was paid. The persons
signing the agreement were sued on the contract. Held, the persons signing
the agreement were promoters and personally liable on their signatures and
not the company.
2.6 Lifting or píercing the corporate veil
Legally speaking, a company is a legal person distinct from its members or
shareholders. This principle may be referred to as "the veil of
incorporation". In general, the Courts consider themselves bound by this
principle on which the corporate business is based. The effect of such
principle 1s that there is a fictional veil (and not a wall) between the
company and its members.
Company Law 457
In reality, the business of the company is always carried on by and for the
benefit of some individuals who are the real owners and the beneficiaries of
corporate property.
However, ingenuity of such human being stared using this veil of corporate
personality blatantly as a clock for fraud or for improper conduct. It
therefore became necessary for the Courts to lift the corporate veil and look
at the persons behind the company who are the real beneficiaries of the
corporate fiction.
Exceptions: There are some exceptional circumstances in which such
corporate veil may be lifted by the Courts. These exceptions have been set
up by the Court decisions as well as by the Companies Act
Exceptions under case law:
I) Protection of tax or revenue: The Courts may ignore the corporate
entity of a company where it is used for tax evasion or to circumvent
tax obligation. The following case illustrates the point: Sir Dinshaw
Maneckjee Petit, Ref. A.LR. (1927) Bom. 371. D, an assessee, who
was receiving huge dividend and interest income, transfered his
investments to four private companies formed for the purpose of
reducing his tax liability. These companies transferred the income to
D purely and simple as a means of avoiding tax obligation and the
pretended loans.
II) Prevention of fraud or improper conducts: The legal personality
of a company may also be disregarded in the interest of justice where
the machinery of incorporation has been used for some fraudulent
purposelike creditors or defeating or circumventing law.
defrauding
The following case illustrates the point:
342, L, agreedsell a certain land toJ
to
InJones v. Lipman, (1962) AIl E.R.
for f 5,250. He subsequently changed his mind and to avoid the specific
performance of the contract, he sold it to a company with a capital of £ 100
which was formed specially for the purpose. The company had L and a
clerk of his solicitors as the only member. J brought an action for the
specific performance of contract against L and the company. The Court
looked to the reality of the situation, ignored the transfer, and ordered that
the company should transfer the land to J.
III) Company avoiding legal obigations: Where the use of an
incorporated company is being made to avoid legal obligations, the
Court may disregard the legal personality of the company and
proceed on the assumption as of no company existed.
458 Text Book on Commercial Law
2
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
the above signatures
Name addresses and signatures of witnesses altesting
1.
Dated..
Dated....
466 Text Book on Commercial Law
Articles of association of a company to be attached with
Memorandum of association the
Number of members
1. The company for the purpose of registration is declared to consist ae
f
five hundred members.
2. The directors, hereinafter mentioned, may, wherever the business
or
the association requires it, register an increase of members.
Definition of members
3 Every person shall be deemed to have agreed to become a member of
the company who insures any ship or share of a ship in pursuance of
the regulations hereinafter contained.
General meeting
4. The first general meeting shall be held at such time not
than one month and not more than three months after the
being less
incorporation of the company, and at such place, as the directors may
determine.
5. A general meeting shall be held once in every year at such
time, not
being more than fifteen months after the holding of the last
general meeting, and place as may be prescribed by the company preceding
in
general meeting or, in default, at such time and in the month
following that in which the anniversary of the company's
incorporation occurs, and at such place, as the directors shall appoint
in default of a general
meeting being held, a general meeting shall be
held in the month next following, and
be called by any
members in the same manner as nearly asmay two
meetings are to be called by the directors. possible as that in which
Votes of members
19. Every member shall have one vote and no more.
20. If any member is a lunatic or idiot, he may vote through the
committee appointed for this purpose or through other legal guardian.
21. No member shall be entitled to vote at any meeting unless all moneys
due from him to the company have been paid.
22. On a pol, votes may be given either personally or by proxy. But a
proxy must be appointed in writing under the hand of the appointer
and if the appointer is a body corporate, under its common seal. It is
further that a company must not vote by proxy so long there is a
resolution of its directors in accordance with the provisions of section
86 ofthe Companies Act, 1994.
23. (1) No person shall act as a proxy unless he is appointed to act att the
meeting as such.
(2) The instrument appointing a proxy shall be deposited at the
registered office of the company not less than forty-eight hours
before the time of holding the meeting at which he proposes to vote.
24. Any instrument appointing a proxy shall be in the following form
....Company,Limited.
1,... . o f
...being a
6. K. L. Of
M. N. Of
32
470 Text Book on Commercial Lawv
Schedule- VIII
(See Sections 7 and 226)
Memorandum of association
Ist. The name of the
Company is . . .Company Limited, e.g. ("The
Snowy Range Hotel Company, Limited")
2nd. The registered office of the
company shall be situated in Bangladesh.
3rd.. The objects for
which the company is established are as follows- e.g.
providing facilities in the Snowy Range, by
conveyances by sea and by land for the
providing hotels and
accommodation of travellers and the
doing of all such other things as are
incidental or conducive to the
attainment of the above
objects".
4th. The liability of the
member is limited.
5th. Every member of the
the company in the event company undertakes to contribute to the assets of
of îts
within one year being wound up while he is a member, or
afterwards, for payment of the debts and
company, contracted before he ceases to be liabilities of the
and expenses of
winding
a
member, and the cost, charges
up the same and for the
the contributories adjustment
amongst themselves, such amount of the
rights of
exceeding fifty taka 50 (fifty taka). as
may be required, not
6th. The share
capital of the
company is
thousand taka, divided into ...
. g . five hundred
(one hundred) taka each.
e.g,
. .
We the several
persons whose
signed the documents and we are names and addresses are set forth
below
in
pursuance of this Memorandumdesirous of being
formed into a
to take the of
number of shares in the association and we company,
our respective names: capital of the respectively agree
company
set
opposite to
472 Text Book on Commercial Law
*******
2. ****°****s.i.
4.
5.
7.
1.
2.
Dated the.. . day of. 19
3.5 Alternation of Memorandum (Sec.10)
Sometimes, after the formation of a company, it requires to alter its
different clauses for certain purposes to meet the demand of time and
situation. If a company desires to
change its name or objects or liability
clause, that can be done by taking special resolution (i.e. a resolution
by three fourth majority of those present and voting at a meeting of the passed
company) and must be confirmed by the Court (Sec.13).
Normally, the company can change its objects for the following
(a) To cary on its business more economically or more purposes
efficiently;
(b) To attain its main purposes by new or
improved means;
(c) To enlarge or change the local area of its business
(d) To carry on some business which under
operations;
conveniently be combined with other existing circumstances may
objects mentioned in the
Memorandum.
(e) To amalgamate with any other company
(Sec.12).
Company Law 473
of the company.
3.6 Doctrine of ultravires
Memorandum of
A company has the power to do all things authorized by
association. Ultra' means eyond' and 'vires' means 'power'. The term
ultravires a company' means that the doing of the act is beyond the power
and authorty of the company.
The purpose of these restrictions is fold: two
First, to protect investors of the company so that they may know the objects
in which their money is to be used;
Secondly, to protect creditors by ensuring that the company's funds are not
Iron Co
wasted in unauthorized activities [Case, Asbury Rely. Carriage &
Lud v Riche (1875)]
such an act
If an ultravires the company (i.e. objects of the company)
act is
Is absolutely void and even the
whole body of shareholders can not approve
But there is nothing to prevent a
it and make it binding upon the company.
drafted and framned with the objects as set oul in the Memotandun of
association Articles are the ules of internal governance in detailed nature
Commercial Law
474 Text Book on
Prospectus
In order to finance its activities, a company necds to have
capital. This is
raised by a public company by the issue of a prospectus inviting deposits or
of the
offers for shares and debentures from the public. The central theme
money raISing pont of view, is that it sets out the
prospectus, from the
prospects of the company and the purpose for which the capital is required.
which the prospective investors form their
The prospectus is the basis on
Companies.
4.3 Dating of prospeetus (Sec.134)
in relation to a
A prospectus issued by or on behalf of a company or
ntended company must be dated and that date is, unless the contrary is
Commercial Law
480 Text Book on
Part 1 of Schedule 1
Matters to be set out
General information
addresses, descriptions and occupations of the
I. (a) The names,
the Memorandum
to and the number of shares
signatories
subscribed for by them.
the and
The number and classes of shares, if any, and
nature extent
b)
property and profits of the
of the interest of the holders in the
company.
shares intended to be issued.
(c) The number of redeemable preference
fixed the period of
with the date of redemption or, where no date is
method
notice required for redeeming the shares and the proposed
of redemption.
fixed by the Articles as the
(1) The number of shares, if any,
qualification of director.
to the remuneration of the
(2) Any provision in the articles as
directors whether for their services to the company as directors
managing directors or otherwise.
3. (1) The names, addresses, descriptions and occupations of
(a) The directors or proposed directors;
(b) The managing director or proposed managing director, if any
(b)
(The managing agent or proposed managing agent, if any:
(d) The manager or proposed manager, if any
where any such person is already a director, managing director
(0)
or manager of any other conpany, or
»
(i) where any such person, including a firm or body coporale,
already a managing agent if any other company.
The namnes of all the companies in which such person is a director
sucn
managing director or manager, and where any
managing agent or
person is a firm or a body corporate, the said particulars shall also be giv
in respect of every partner of the fiwn or, as the case may be, in respect o
every director of the body corporate
Company Law 483
(2) Any provision in the Articles or in any contract which has been entered
into as to the appointment of a managing director, managing agent or
manager, the remuneration payable to him or them, and the compensation,
if any, payable to him or them for loss of office.
4. In the case of a company managed by a managing agent which is a body
corporate, the subscribed capital of that body.
5. Where shares are offered to the public for subscription, particulars as to
if the
(a) The minimum amount which, in the opinion of the directors or
signatories of the Memorandum must be raised by the issue of th0se
in
shares in order to provide the sums, required to be provided
the amount
respect of each of the following heads and distinguishing
required undereach head:
The purchase price of any property purchased or to be purchased
(i)
which is to be defrayed in whole or in part out of the proceeds of
the issue
and any
(11) any preliminary expenses payable by the company,
commission so payable to any person in consideration ot his
(c) the consideration, if any, given or to be given for the option or for the
right thereto;
of the person to
(d) the names, addresses, descriptions and occupations
whom the option or the right thereto has been given or, is proposed
to be given, if given to existing shareholders or debenture holders as
number of the relevant shares
such, the descriptions and the or
debentures
(e) any other material fact or circumstances relevant to the grant of the
option or right.
for the purpose of
Explanation: Subscribing for shares ot debentures shall,
this clause, including acquiring them from a person to whom they have been
allotted or agreed to be allotted with a view to his offering them for sale
shall be deemed to subscription for such share or debenture.
9. The number description and amount of shares and debentures which
within the two preceding years have been issued, or agreed to be issued as
fully or partly paid up otherwise than in cash, and in the latter case the
extent to which they are so paid up, and in either case the consideration for
which those shares or debentures have been issued or agreed to be issued.
10. The amount paid or payable by way of premium, if any, on each share
which has been issued within the two years preceding the date of the
prospectus, or is to be issued, stating the dates or proposed dates of issue
and, where some shares have been or are to be issued at a premium and
other shares of the same class at a lower premium, or at a discount, the
reasons for the differentiation and how any premiums received have been o
are to be disposed of.
11. Where any issue of shares
debentures, is underwritten, the name o
or
the underwriters, and the opinion of the directors that the resources of the
underwriters are sufficient to discharge their obligations.
Particular as respect property
12. (1) The following particular as lause
respect any property to which this cla
applies is specified in sub-clause (2):
(a) the names, addresses, descriptions and the
33
Commercial Law
on
Text Book
486
of preliminary expenses and
ethe
.
estimated amount
14. The amount or been paid o r are payable
have and
those expanses
persons by whom any of of the issue and
the persons
eTsons by h
amount of the expenses
estimated
amount or or are payable.
have been paid
expenses
whom any ofthose within the two preceding years or
given
amount or benefit, paid or
for the
15. Any and the consideration he
be paid or given to any promoter,
intended to
of the benefit.
payment or the giving nature of every contract
of, parties to and general
(1) The dates
16.
the remuneration of a managing director
appointing or fixing whenever entered into, that is to sav
managing agent or manager date of the
than two years before the
whether within, or more
prospectus;
of every other material,
nature
(2) The dates, parties and the general course of
contract entered into in the ordinary
contract, not being a
intended to be carried on by the
the business carried on or
entered into more than two years
before the
company or a contract
namely
(a) Profits and losses, and assets and liahilities, as the case may be;
the company in respect of
(b) the rates of the dividends, if any, paid by
for each of the five financial
each class of shares in the company
the issue of the prospectus, giving
years immediately preceding
which the dividend bas
particulars of each such class of shares on
and also of the cases in which no dividend
particulars
been paid shares for any of those
has been paid on any of those classes of
years
in respect of any of the said
(c) if no accounts have been made-up
financial years, or part thereof ending on a date immediately
preceding three months prior to the issue of the prospectus
nereinafter referred to as the said period), then the following
matters
(i) a statement that such accounts have not been made up;
(i) an profit and loss of the conmpany up to a date
account of the
which date is not beyond
prior to the issue of the prospectus
one hundred and eighty days including the said period (three
months);
Commercial
Law
on
Text Book
488 sub-clause (i) may indicate as to
referred to in
the accounts made or yet to be made
(i)
ii)
whether any adjustment
has been
far
(ii) individually with the profits or losses of each subsidiary,
so
Explanation: For the purpose of this clause, the expression "officer" shall
include a proposed director but not an auditor.
4.7 The Golden Rule' for framing prospectus
A prospectus is a document which holds out to the public as to what a
company is, what it proposes to do and what its prospects are. It invítes
deposits from the public or invites offers from the public to subscribe to the
share capital and debentures of the company. It is therefore, but reasonable
facts with
that there must be full frank and honest disclosure of all material
fact should be miss-
scrupulous accuracy in a prospectus and no material
material facts in a
stated or withheld. Misstatements and non-disclosure of
prospectus fatal
are the contract for the purchase of shares and
to
The
debentures. As such the greatest care is necessary in its preparation.
imposed on those responsible for the issue of a prospectus
are
obligations
not only to state accurately all the relevant facts, but also not to omit any
rule as to framing of
fact which may be relevant. This is the golden
Brunswick & Canada Rly. & Land
prospectus which was laid down in New
Co. (1860) 1 Dr. and Sm. 363.
v. Muggeridge,
The prospectus as a whole must not give a misleading impression, even
though on analyzing the statements separately, a true sense could be made
if the
If there is any mis-statement of a material fact in prospectus
a or
out.
arise:
prospectus omits any material fact, there may
I. Civil liability.
II. Criminal liability.
I. Civil liability (Sec. 145)
for shares on the faith of a
A person who has been induced to subscribe
statement in a prospectus that is untrue has remedies against the company,
and its directors, promoters, and experts.
1. Remedies against the company
If there is a mis-statement of a material information in a prospectus, and if it
has induced an shareholder to purchase shares he can-
i) Rescind the contract: Any person, who takes shares on the faith of
statements of fact contained in a prospectus, can apply to the Court for the
rescission of the contract if those statements are false or fraudulent or if
some material information has been withheld. He must, however, apply for
the rescission within a reasonable time and before the company goes into
liquidation (Shiromani Sugar Mills Ltd. v. Debi Prasad. (1950) 20 Comp.
Cas. 226] But he will have to surrender the shares allotted to him to the
Text Book on Commercial Law
492
name is then removed
from the register to members and he
company. His
him to the company along with interest. The
gets back the money paid by
conditions are satisfied:
contract can be rescinded if the following
be a material misrepreseniation of fact. The
i) The statement must
to influence
misrepresentation is material when it is likely
reasonable man in his judgment whether or not to apply for the
shares.
must be distinguished from
Misrepresentation of facts in a prospectus
the subscribers of the
misrepresentation of law. Whereas the former gives
to rescind the contract, the
shares on the faith of such a prospectus a right
latter gives no remedy.
take the shares. Whether or
(i) It must have induced the shareholder to shares by reason of the
not an applicant has been induced to take the
the
misrepresentation is a question of fact depending
on
applicant.
(ii) It must be untrue. A statement included in prospectus is deemed to
a
those
finanvially stable compaby. However, the company had in each of
loses and was able to dividends
years incurred considerable trading pay
only out of past reserves. This fact was suppressed. Held, the prospectus
was 'false in a material particular' in that it conveyed a
false impression. A
statement could be false not only because of what was said but also because
of what was concealed, omitted or implied.
iv) The shareholder must have relied on the statement in the prospectus
while applying for shares and he is not bound to verify the statement
before relying upon it. If a person purchases shares in open market,
for
the prospectus ceases to be operative. He cannot, therefore, sue
rescission on the ground of untrue statement in the prospectus.
In Peek v. Gurney. (1872) LR. 6 HL. 377, a company issued a prospect
containing false statements. A, relying on the prospectus, applied for ana
wouna
was allotted shares. Later he sold these share to P. The company was
Company Law
493
up and P had to pay nearly 100,000 as a
indemnity for his loss from the directors at thecontributory.
P sought an
time of the issue of the
prospectus. Held, the directors were not liable to P.
( The omission
of a material fact must be misleading hefore rescission
isgranted. If a person relies on a ground for the rescission of a
contract the omission of a statement, he must show that
on
the
omission of the statement makes what is stated
misleading
In Coles v. White City Greyhound Assn., Ltd., (1929) 45 T.L.R. 230, a
prospectus described land as 'eminently suitable" for
greyhound racing.
However, before any buildings such as kennels or stands for the
could be erected, local authority's public
approval was necessary as a result of a
town-planning resolution. The local authority refused approval. Held, the
description of land was misleading and rescission was granted.
(vi) The proceeding for rescission must be started as soon as the allottee
comes to know of a misleading statement in the
prospectus on the
faith of which he had subscribed for shares and before the
company
goes into liquidation. Delay may defeat this right of the allottee.
(ii) Damages for deceit: Any person induced by a fraudulent statement in a
prospectus to take shares is entitled to sue the company for damages. He
must prove the same matters in
claiming damages for deceit as in claimingg
rescission of the contract. He cannot both retain the shares and
get damages
against the company. He must show that he has repudiated the shares and
has not acted as a shareholder after discovering the
misrepresentation.
(2) Remedies against the directors, promoters and experts
The persons who are liable to pay compensation for any loss or damage to
subscribers for any shares or debentures on the faith of a prospectus
containing untrue statements are the-
(a) directors at the time of the issue of the prospectus
(b) persons who have authorized themselves to be named as directors
inthe prospectus;
(c) promoters ; and
(d) persons who have authorized issue of the prospectus [Section
145(1))
Their liability may be studied under the following heads:
(i) Liability for damages for misstatement in prospectus (Sec. 145)
very director, promoter and every person who authorises the issue of
prospectus (no matter whether he has seen it or not) is liable to pay
compensation to the aggrieved party (who subseribes for any shares or
debenturcs on the faith of the prospectus) for loss or
incurred by reason of any untrue statement in the
danage he nay have
prospectus [Sec. 145(1)
Commercial Law
494 Text Book on
etc.: Section 145(2) provides that a
Defenses of directors, promoters
who authorises the iSSue of the prospectus.
director, promoter, or any person
which contains untrue statements, is not liable to pay compensation to the
aggrieved allottee provided:
(a) he withdrew his before the issue of the prospectus and that it
consent
was issued without his authority or consent;
(b) the prospectus was issued without his knowledge or consent and that
on becoming aware of its issue, he forthwith gave reasonable public
notice that it was issued without his knowledge or consent;
(c) after the issue of the prospectus and before allotment there under, he,
on becoming aware of any untrue statement therein, withdrew his
consent to the prospectus and gave reasonable public notice of the
withdrawal and of the reason therefor;
(d) he had reasonable ground to believe that the statement was true and
he, in fact, believed itto be true;
(e) the statement wascorrect and fair representation or extract to copy of
the statement made by an expert who was competent to make it and
had given his consent and had not withdrawn it ; and
(1) the statement was a correct and fair representation or extract or copy
of an official document based the
or was on authority of an official
person.
(i) Liability for damages for non-compliance with section 135: The
omission from the prospectus ofa matter
135 may give rise to an action for
required to be included by section
for shares who has suffered loss
damages at the instance of a subscriber
make the prospectus false or
thereby, even if the omission does not
misleading. The Act does not say that the
directors will be liable, but this seems to be
implied from section 135.
(ii) Liability under the general law: Under the
can hold all or any of the general law, a shareholder
persons responsible for the issue of a
liable for any misstatement or fraud on their
or his
prospectus
deceived by reason of his part if he was actually
having acted the faith of the misstatement o
on
fraud in the prospectus. According to section 17
of the Contract Act, 1872,
fraud' means and includes, inter alia, the
which is not true by one who does not suggestion, as a fact, of that
believe
concealment of a fact by one having knowledge or it to be true and active
A person can only be liable in
belief of the fact.
fraud in a
statement 1o be acted upon by others, which prospectus where he makes a
is false and is
knowingly; or (b) wilhoul beliel in its made (a)
whether it was true or lalse |Derry v. Peek,truth; or (c) recklessly, not caring
The remedy under general law Is also
(1889) 14 pp. Cas. 337).
rescission as against the company 1s lost available (a) where the right of
the company goes into liquidation. through negligence, and (b) where
Company Law 495
shown
that offer of the shares or debentures or of any of them for sale
(a) an
after
to the public was made within one hundred and eighty days,
the allotment or agreement to allot; or
whole consideration
(b) that at the date when the offer was made, the
of the shares or
to be received by the company in respect
debentures had not been so received.
135 shall
(3) In case document, mentioned in sub-section (1), Section
of the
addition to the matters
have effect as if it required a prospectus to state, in
required by that section to be stated, in a prospectus-
(a) the of the consideration received or to be received by
net amount
to which the
the company in respect of the shares or debentures
offer relates; and
time at which the contract under which the said
(b) the place and
debentures have been or are to be allotted may be
shares or
inspected.
(4) Section 138 shall apply to the person or persons making the offer
than the nominal The issued capital can never exceed the authorized
capital.
capital.
are not taken
Sometimes, all the shares offered to the public for subscription
which is taken up by the
up. In such a case that part of the issued capital,
public, is called the subscribed capital.
which has been
It is that part of the issued capital
.
Calied-up capital:
called up on the shares.
which has been
aid-up capital: This is that part ofthe issued capital on the
which is credited
as pad up
the share holders or
pid up by
shares. issued
remainder/unpaid portion ot the
.Uncalled capital: This is the call his amount at any
company a y
pal which has not been called. The
ime.
resoluton determine
limited company may by speeil
eserve capital: A not been callcd-up shall not be
that d portion 'of share capital, which has
512 Text Book on Commercial Law
called up except in the event for the purposes of
winding up of the
company. Such uncalled capital is called reserve capital. It is available only
for the ereditors on the winding up of the company (Sec. 74).
6.2 Kinds of share capital
Share capital of a company may be of two kinds, namely:
1. Preference share capital; and
2. Equity share capital
1. Preference share capital: It means in the case of a
company limited by
the shares, that part of the share
capital, which carries or bears a preferential
ights as to
a) payment of dividend during the lifetime of the company; and
b) return of capital on
winding up.
2. Equity share capital: With regard to a company limited by shares, it
means all share capital which is not preference share capital i.e. which
does not carry preference as to payment of dividend; and repayment of
capital
6.3 Alteration of
capital (Sec. 53))
A limited company having a share
Articles. alter its share capital as capital, may if so authorized by its
follows, i.e. it may
a) increase its authorized share
capital by issuing new shares;
b) consolidate and divide all or
any part of its share
of larger amount, capital into shares
c) convert fully paid up shares
into stock or vice
versa;
d) sub-divide its shares into
shares of smaliler
e) cancel shares, which
have not been taken
amount
The up.
company must give notice of such alteration
days of the alteration. But
the Court need
to the
registrar within 15
shares is not however deemed not confirm it. A
to be
reduction of
cancellation of
6.4 Reduction of share capital.
share capital (Secs. 59
A and 70)
company limited by shares or
capital may, if so authorized by its limited by guarantee and having a share
share capital. Articles, by special resolution, reduce sS
But the
company hasapply by to
confirming
the reduction (Sec.60). Thepetition to the Court for an order
the
objection of every creditor of theCourt, if satisfied, with respect to
confirming the reduction on such company may make an order
(Sec.64). terms and
conditions as it thinks In
Conpany Law 513
T nmny may rdce its share capital in any of the following manners:
may extingunsh or reduce
the liability on any of its shares in
(a)
wspot of share capital not paid up.
Fx exampe: Share capital 100000 shares
and face value of cach share is
of cach share is "Tk. 4.
1.10 and Tk. 6 per share paid. Uncalled amount
the remaining liability of
n r h a case the conpany may extinguish
share.
ancalld share capital at the rate of Tk. 4 per
without extinguishing or reducing liability
on
6) t may, either with or
share capital, which is lost or is
any of its shares, cancel any paid up
anrepresented by available assets.
without extinguishing or reducing liability on
(c)t may either with or of
capital, which is in excess
any of its shares. pay off any paid up
the
the wants of company
by reducing the amount of its
share
Memorandum
d) lt may alter its
capital and ofits shares accordingly [Sec.59 ()].
Addition to name of company of "and reduced" (Sec. 61)
for reducing share
On and from the passing by the company ofa resolution
of the order by the Court confirming
capital, then on and from the making the words "and
the reduction, the company must add to its name
by shall be deemed to
reduced" as the last words in its name and
those words,
be part of the name of the company
minutes of reduction (Sec. 65)
Registration of order and
the following documents,
The Registrar shall, on production to him, register
namely
order of the Court;
(a) the certified copy of the
the Court, showing the
(b) a copy of the minutes approved by
folowing:
share capital;
() the amount of the reduced
which it is be divided;
(i) the number of shares into
to
(Sec. 69).
Conclusive evidence as to reduction
The Registrar shall certify under his hand the registration of the order and
minutes and his certificate shall be conclusive evidence that all the
514 Text Book on Commercial Law
requirements of this Act with respect to reduction of share capital have hea.
been
complied with and that the share capital of the company is such as is stated
in the minute [ Sec. 65(4)].
The minutes when registered must be deemed to be substituted for
the
corresponding part of the Memorandum of the company, and shall be valid
and alterable as if it has been originally contained therein and shall
be
embodied in every copy of the Memorandum issued after its
registration
[Sec. 66(1)]
Consequences in default
Ifa company makes default in complying with the above requirements, it
shall be liable to a fine not exceeding Tk.100 for each copy in
respect of
which default is made, and every officer of the who
company knowingly
and willfully authorises or permits the default shall be liable to the
like
amount of fine [Sec. 66(2)]
TEST QUESTIONS
. Explain the concept of 'capital 'in relation to a limited company and state
the various senses in which the term
'capital' is used in company law.
2. How can the share capital ofa
company be reduced?
3 How and in what circumstances can a
company reduce, increase and
reorganize its share capital?
4. In what circumstances can a
company reduce its share capital? Describe
the formalities to be
complied with and the procedure to be followed.
5. Discuss the voting rights of members in a
with reference to both
public company limited by share
equity and preference share capital.
6. Write a short notes no:
(a) Conversion of debentures issued to
Government into shares: (0)
Procedure to be followed for reduction
of capital:(¢) Reserve
Capital;(d) Variation of sharcholders'
rights.
Chapter 9
(b) If the directors are not namedthe Aticles, the number of directors
in
and the names of the first d1rectors are determined in writing by the
subscribers of the Memorandum who are individuals become
directors of the company. They hold office until directors are duly
appointed in the first annual general meeting
2. Appointment of directors by the company
Directors must be appointed by the company in general meeting. In the case
of a public company and a private company which is a subsidiary of a
public company, not less than 1/3 of the total number of directors must De
appointed by the company in general meeting. However, the Articles may
provide for the retirement of all directors at an annual general meeting&
These directors are liable to retire by rotation and such directors are called
rotational directors. The remaining 1/3 directors in the case of any such
company and all the directors in the case of a private company not being
subsidiary of any public company are, subject to any regulations in the
Articles, also to be appointed by the company in general meeting.
3. Appointment of directors by the Board of directors
The Board of directors may appoint directors-
(a) As additional directors: Such additional directors hold office only uy
to the date of the next
annual general meeting of the company.
number of directors and additional directors must not exceed
maximum strength fixed for the Board by' the Articles of
company. Additional directors are not to be counted
wn
determining the number of directors who are to retire by rotation
the annual general meeting.
Company Law 547
manager or director
(d) any public company, the managing agent,
with the directions
whereof it is accustomed to act in accordance
or
company shall, after the commencement of the Act, appoint any person as
managing director, if he is a managing director or manager of other
company.
But no appointment under this section shall be made without the consent of
the company in a general meeting.
to be
However, the Government may, by order, permit any person
if the
appointed as a managing director of more than two companies
Government is satisfied that it is necessary that the companies should, for
their proper working, function as a single unit and have a common
managing director.
to than five years at a time
Managing director not to be appointed more
(Sec.110)
No company shall, after the commencement of the Act, appoint or employ
a
any individual as its managing director for a term exceeding five years at
time. It shall not be deemed to prohibit the re-employment or the extension
of the term of office of any person as managing director for a further pernod
not exceeding five years on each occasion.
But no such re-appointment, re-employment or extension of term of ottice
shall be made without the consent of the company in general meeting.
the
Any individual holding, at the commencement of this Act, the office of
be
managing director in a company shall, unless his term expires earlier,
deemed to have vacated his office immediately on the expiry of five yeal
from the commencement of this Act.
9.1.13 Compensation for loss of office
ole
Compensation for loss of office not permissible to managing or wo
time directors or directors who are managers (See. 111): Payment ma
made by a company, to a managing director, or a director holding the oft
of manager or in the whole time employment of the company, by way
compensation for loss of office, or as consideration for retirement
office, or in connection with such loss of retirement.
Company Law
553
No such payment shall be made by the company to any other director. But
na Dayment shall be made to a
managing or other director in the
cases, namely: following
(a) where the director resigns his office in view of
the reconstruction
of the company, or of its
amalgamation with any other body
corporate or bodies corporate, and is as the appointed
director, managing agent, manager or other officermanaging
of the
reconstructed company or of the body corporate
amalgamation;
resulting from the
(b) where the director resigns his office otherwise than on the
reconstruction of the company its
amalgamation as aforesaid.
or
(c) where the office of the director is vacated by virtue of
any of the
provision of the Act;
(d) where the company is being wound up, whether by or subject to
the supervision of the Court or
voluntarily, provided the winding
up was due to the negligence, or default of the director;
(e) where the director has been guilty of fraud or breach of trust in
relation to, of gross negligence in, or gross
or
mismanagement of,
the conduct of the affairs of the company or any subsidiary or
holding company thereof;
()where the director has instigated, or has taken part directly or
indirectly in bringing about, the termination of his office.
However any payment made to a managing or other director shall not
exceed the remuneration which he would have earned if he had been in
o11ice for the unexpired residue of his term or for three years, whichever is
shorter, and such remuneration shall be calculated on the basis of-
(a) the average remuneration received by him during the period of
three yearsimmediately preceding the date on which he ceased to
hold that office; and
(b) where he held that office for a period of less than three years, the
average remuneration received by him during the period for which
he held the office.
Bu
Dut no such payment shall be made to the director in the event of the
disclosure of
(C)to receive notice of
with the company;
arrangement
or of directors;
disclosure of shareholdings
to receive notice of is
(d) a person who
director or manager
as managing
()to appoint of another company.
or manager
acady managing director
Law
Text Book on Commercial
556
9.3 Duties of directors and administration a f
position in the management of a
Directors occupy key a
Articles of the comna
company. Their
dutics are usually regulated by
the
pany
on the directors. These statutos
There are also some statutory
obligations tory
at appropriate places. Again, there aete
obligations have been discussed
certain duties of a general nature.
be classified as (1) fiduciary duties, ( 2
The general duties of directors may
and (3) other duties.
duties of care, skill and diligence,
duties of directors are basically identical
1. Fiduciary duties: The fiduciary
They must exercise their
with those of any person in a fiduciary position.
the company and
and (b) in the interest of
powers (a) honestly, themselves in a position in
shareholders. As fiduciaries they must not place
duties to the company and their
which there is a conflict between their
personal interests.
These fiduciary duties are owed to the company and not to the individual
shareholders [Percival v. Wright, (1902) 2 Ch. 421].
As the directors owe a fiduciary duty to the company, they must not make a
secret profit out of their position. If they do so, they have to account for it to
the company [ Boston Deep Sea Fishing & lce Co. v. Ansell, (1888) 39 Ch.
D. 339.
2. Duties of care, skill and diligence: Directors should carry out their
duties with such care, skill and diligence as is reasonably expected from
persons oftheir knowledge and status. If they fail to exercise due care in the
exercise of their duties, they are guilty of neglignce. The standard of care.
skill and diligence would, however, vary with-
(a) the type and nature of work ;
(b) the division of power between directors and other officers;
(c) the general usages and customs of that type of business; and
(d) whether directors work gratuitously or
There is
remuneratively.
a brilliantexposition of director's duties in relation to
affairs the
a companys
in
following leading case:
City Equitable Fire Ins. Co., Re
(1925) Ch. 437. The directors of an
insurance company left the
management of the company's affairs alm0
entirely in the hands of B, the
managing director. Owing to B's fraud,
large amount of the company's assets
he was a partner had taken a disappeared.
B and the firnm in whie
huge loan from the company and the cash
bank or in hand included £7,300 in the a
stockbrokers, in which B was a partner. The hands of the companyato
how these items directors never inquirea aent.
were made up. Held, the
directors were neglige
Company Law 557
be expected to take
the reasonable care which an ordinary might man
shall disclose the nature of his interest at the meeting of the directors at
C n the contract or arrangement is determined on, of his interest then
558 Text Book on Commercial Law
exists, or, in any other case, at the first nmeeting of the directors after
acquisition of his interest or the making of the contract or arrangement
But a general notice that a director is a director or a member of a
specified company or of any specified firm, and is to be regarded any
interested in any subsequent transaction with such firm or company, shall.
regards any such transaction be sufficient disclosure and after such genera
eral
notice, it shall not be necessary to give any special notice relating to an
particular transaction with such firm or company. any
(2) Every director who contravenes the provisions of sub-section (1) shall
be liable to a fine not exceeding five thousand taka.
(3) A register shall be kept by the company in which shall be entered
particulars of all contracts or arrangements and which shall be open to
inspection by any member of the company at the registered office of the
company during business hours.
(4) Every officer of the company who knowingly and wilfully acts in
contravention of the provisions of sub-section (3) shall be liable to a fine
not exceeding one thousand taka.
9.4.2 Prohibition of voting by interested director (Sec. 131).
(1) No director shall, as a director, vote on any contract or arrangement in
which he is either directly or indirectly concerned or interested, nor shall his
presence count for the purpose of forming a quorum at the time of any such
vote, and if he does so vote, his vote shall not be counted.
But the directors or any of them may vote on any contract of indemnity
against any loss which they or any one or more of them may suffer by
reason of becoming or being sureties or surety for the company.
(2) Every director who contravenes the provision of sub-section (1) shall be
liable to a fine not exceeding five thousand taka.
(3) The above provisions shall not apply to a private company.
But where a prívate company is a
subsidiary company of a public company
this section shall apply to all contracts or arrangement made on behalt ol
subsidiary company with any person other than the holding conmpany.
9.4.3 Disclosure to members in of contract ger
(Sec. 132)
case
appointing a a
Where acompany enters into a contraci for the appointent of a
managing agent of the company in which contact any
nlIang the
direeto
company is directly or indirectly concemed or
interested, vaie
or
ae
existing contract, the company shall, within
twenty one days
Iiom
entering into thhe contract or the varying of he contract, sehu n
abstat
of the terms of such contract or
variation, as the case may be, toge wi
,logether
shallbe to inspection of
open member at the
any ofice of the registered
company.
section-
requirements of this
contract shall, at the option
of the company, be void as against
(a) the
the company; and
into his conduct and order him to repay or restore the money or
It shall not
apply to
private company except a private company which s
a
the subsidiary company of a public company or to
principal business is the business of insurance. any company whose
Restrictions on managing agent
Loans to managing agent (Sec.1 20):
No company shall make to a
managing agent of the
company
or to any
managing agent partner of the firm, if tne
is a firm, or to
any member of director of the
company if the managing agent is a privac
moneys of the company or guarantee
private company, any loan out
of
Shri Meenakshi Mills Co. Ltd. v Assistant Registrar of Joint Stock Companies,
called in
A.I.R (1983) Mad 640. The annual general meeting of a company
The next meeting
December, 1934 was adjourned and held in March, 1935. The
was held in February, 1936; other meeting being held in 1935.
no
resolution.
2. Minutes of the meeting (Sec. 89)
proceedings of every gencral
record of all
Every company must keep a
or extraordinary general
meeting, annual general meeting
meeting (statutory Board of directors and
and of proceedings of every meeting of its
meeting) done by making, within 14 days of
of the Board. This is
committee
ofevery such meeting concerned,
entries of the proceedings
the conclusion of every
for that purpose. These records are known as minutes and
in the books kept the minute book pasting of
the book in which the record is kept is known as
papers.
which records proceedings of a Board
Each page of the minute book
must be initialed or signed by
the chairman of the same meeting or
meeting record of proceedings of
of the
the succeeding meeting. The last page
next
dated and signed.
each meeting in a minute book must be
a fair and correct summary
of the
The minutes of each meeting must contain
absentee shareholders may be in a
proceedings at the meetings so that the
some reliable idea of what transpired
at these meetings. All
position to form
aforesaid must also be
appointments of officers made at any of the meetings
included in the minutes of the meeting.
an immediate inspection
of the books in respect of all proceedings of
be sent to the person
general meeting or direct that the copies required shall
requiring them.
appointed a revokes the authority of the proxy, but not until the
proxy,
company has notice of the death.
share capital
Every notice calling a meeting of a company, which has a or
the Articles of which provide for voting by proxy at the meeting, must
mention with reasonable
prominence
(a) that a member entitled to attend and vote is entitled to appoint a
company.
Memorandum to render the liability of d1rectors
(1) Alteration of
unlimited
voluntarily
0) Winding up a company
Onclusive evidence of voting ISec. 87(3)
resolution or a special resolution
any mecting at which an extraordinary
chauman on a show of hands
umited to be passed a declaration of the
a t the resolution is carried shall, unless a poll is demanded, be conclusive
ence of the fact without proof of the number or proportion of the votes
members;
2. by the requisitionists themselves on the failure of the Board to call
the meeting.
Company Law 575
The Board of directors may call such a meeting whenever it thinks fit.
Further. it must proceed duly to call such a meeting of the company on the
requisition of members which is signed:
a) In the case of a company having a share capital, by holders of at
least 1/1Oth of the paid-up capital of the company carrying voting
rights in regard to the matter of requisition;
b)In the case of a company not having a share capital, by members
representing at least 1/10th of the total voting rights in regard to
the matter of requisition.
The Board must proceed to call a meeting within 21 days from the date of
45 days
deposit of a valid requisition. The meeting must be held within
from the date of the deposit of requisition.
Example: The holders of 15 per cent paid-up share capital of a public
limited company deposited a requisition at the company's registered
office for an extraordinary general meeting. The requisition was deposited
of 28" February, 1991. The Board of directors must call the meeting by
within 21 days from 28 February). The said
21 March 1991 (i.e.,latest from
meeting must be held by 14" April 1991 (i.e., within 45 days
28h February, 1991).
the meeting and must be signed by
The requisition must state the objects of
office of the company, and
the requisitionists and deposited at the registered
documents in like form, each signed by one or
more
may consist of several
requisitionists.
the requisitionists by reason of the failure
Any reasonable expenses incurred by
the directors duly to call a meeting
shall be repaid to the requisitionists by the
of shall be retained by the company,
out of any sums
company. Any sum so repaid
of fees or other remuneration
due or to become due from the company by way
directors as were in default.
for their services to such of the
TESTQUESTIONS
meetings of the shareholders of a company? When
The different kinds of
and how these meetings held?
Whal S a statutory report and what are its
2. What is a statutory meeting?
contents?
the holding of an annual
3. What are the statutory provisions regarding
business is transacted at such a meeting?
general meeting? What
Companies Act, 1994 which particularly
4 What are the provisions of the
a geeral meeling of acompuny on
rclate to the convening and holding ol
a requisition'? a quorum be present
What do you understand by quorum? Must t a quorum is never fornmed?
What is the procedure
meeting?
throughout a
valid neeting?
What arc
What do
the requisites of a
you understand by a proxy? Wnat are tne Statutory provisions
1
regarding
What arc proxies?
the different types ol resoluions which niay be passed in the
nicetings of shareholders?
Chapter 14
Winding up of Company
14.1 What is winding-up?
Winding-up or liquidation of a company represents the last stage in its life.
It means a process by which a company is finally dissolved and the assets
and property of the company is redistributed. According to Professor
Gower, "winding-up of a company is the process whereby its life i5 ended
and its property administered for the benefit of its creditors and members.
An administrator, called official liquidator is appointed by the Court from
among the list of persons or from panel of administrators and he takes the
control of the company provisionally, collects its assets, pays its debts to the
creditors and finally distributes surplus (if any) among the members in
accordance with their rights" (See, L.C.B Gower, The Principles of Modern
Company Law, 2nd edt., (1957) London, Stevens & Sons Ltd.).
Having wound -up the company's affairs, the liquidator must call a final
meeting of the members (if it is a members' voluntary winding up),
creditors (if it is a compulsory winding-up) or both (if it is a creditors
voluntary winding-up). The liquidator is then usually required to send final
accounts to the Registrar and to notify the Court. The company is then
dissolved.
14.2 Modes of winding up (Sec.234)
The Companies Act, 1994 recognises three modes of winding up of a
company. They are:
(i) Winding up by the order of the Court or compulsory winding up:
(i) Voluntary winding up which includes-
(a) Members' voluntary winding up by resolution on the
declaration of solvency by a majority of the directors at a
meeting of the Board; or
(b) Creditors' voluntary winding up by resolution in the case or
bankruptcy of the company.
(iii) Winding up subject to the supervision of the Court, i.e. voluntary
(i)
Winding up but a request is made to the Court for supervision ol
the winding up for the interest of the creditors as well as members
or contributories.
It is important to note that the provisions of the Copmanies Act with respect
to winding up are equally applicable to the winding up of a company in any
of these modes.
Company Law 615
that effect.
of the creditor, or
(6) if execution or other process issued on a decree or order of any
returned
Court in favour of a creditor of the company is
unsatisfied in whole or in part; or
is
(C)if it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court that the company
is
unable to pay its debts, and in determining whether a company
the
unable to pay its debts, the Court shall take into account
contingent and prospective liabilities of the company.
616 Text Book on Commercial Law
The demand referred to above shall be deemed to have been duly give.
under the hand of the creditor if it is signed by an agent or legal advise
duly authorised on his behalf, or in the case ofa firm, if it is signed by such
agent, or by a legal adviser or by any one member of the firm on behalf of
the firm (Sec. 242).
6. Just and equitable grounds: Generally, application for just and
equitable winding up are brought by a member of the company who alleges
that the affairs of the company are being conducted in a prejudicial manner
and asking the Court to bring an end to the company's
existence
The term "just and equitable" is of very widest significance and do not limit
the powers of the Court. There is no hard and first rule in this regard. What
is "just and equitable" cause depends upon the facts and circumstances of
each particular case. However, the Editors of the Palmer's Company Law,
20h ed, p.698 state that the Court may order winding up of the company
nder this ground in the following cases:
1. When the substratum of the company is gone i.e. when-
(a) the object for which the company was incorporated has substantially
failed.
This was illustrated in German Date
Coffee Co., Re (1882) 20 Ch. D. 169.
The object clause of a company stated that it was formed for
the working of
a German
patent which would be granted for making a partial substitute for
coffee from dates and also for the
acquisition of inventions incidental
thereto, and to acquire other inventions for similar
purposes. The German
patent was never granted but the company did acquire and work a Swedish
patent and carried on business at Hamburg where coffee was made from
dates, but not under the protection of a
patent. Held, on a petition by
2
shareholders, that the main object could not
be achieved and it was,
therefore, just and equitable that the
company should be wound up.
(b) it is impossible to carry on the business
of the company except at
loss, which means that there is no reasonable
trading at profit can be attained. hope that the object o
(c) the existing and probable assets are
liabilities. insufficient to meet the existing
2. When the
majority of the shareholders is using their
has adopted an oppressive policy towards the powers unfarly o
management is carried on against the interest ofminority shareholders or u
the minority.
3. When there is a dead
lock in the
sense that it is management of the company I" the
not possible for the company
was ilustrated in to carry out its This
the following cases: business.
Yenidje Tobacco Co. Ltd, Re
shareholders and directors of a (1916) 2 Ch. 42. W
and R were the
S0
company with equal rights of ment
managem
Company Law 617
and voting power. After a time they became bitterly hostile to each other
and disagreed about the appointment of important servants of the company.
All communications between them were made through the secretary as they
were not on speaking terms with each other. The company made large
profits in spite of the disagreement. Held, there was a complete deadlock in
the management and the company should be wound up.
Similarly, if a person has subscribed to the company's share on the
understanding that he would be made a director a failure to appoint him so
by the majority shareholders may justify a winding up order [ re Zinoty
properties Ltd., (1984) 3 lI ER 754).
In Bashati Property Development Ltd. and others v. Younus Bhuiyan and
others, 4 BLC ( 1999) (AD) p.236, where an application by which one
faction offered to let the other faction run the company and thus save the
deadlock was rejected.
There must be a justifiable lack of confidence in the management grounded
on the conduct of the directors, not in regard to their private life or affairs,
but in regard to the companies business.
4. When the public interest is likely to be prejudiced by the business of the
company.
5. When the company was formed to carry out fraudulent or illegal business
or when the business of the company becomes illegal.
6. When the company is a more bubble and it does not carry on any
business or does not have any property.
7. When the petitioner is excluded from all participation in the business.
8. The principles which would justify the dissolution of a partnership can be
applied in case of small private company.
14.2.2 Applicatíon for winding up (Sec. 245)
An application to the Court for the winding up of a company is made by
petition. Under section 245, a petition for the winding of a company may be
presented by any of the following:
B y the company (245): A company may itself present a petition to the
Court for winding up. But it can do so only when it has passed a
The Court shall not give a hearing to a petition for winding up of acomn
by a contingent or prospective creditor
until such security for costs has
given as the Court thinks reasonable and until a prima facie case
the satisfaction of the Court.
winding up has been established to
3 contributory' mean
By any contributory /Sec.245(a)]: The term contributory' means
every person liable to contribute to the assets of the company in the
event of its being wound up. It includes the holder of fully paid.
shares also (Sec.237). A contributory is entitled to present a petition
A winding up of
a company the Court shall be deemed to
by commence at
the time of the presentation of the petition for the winding up.
evidence.
3. order (Sec. 250)
Stay of suits on winding p
liquidator has
h a winding up order has
been made or a provisional with or
C proceeding shall be proceeded
other legal
appointed, no suit or leave of the Court,
and subject
the company except by
nenced against
O Such term as the Court may impose.
Commercial
Law
Text Book on
620
the Court (Sec. 251)
attached to
4. Oicial receiver the Court, the
term "offcia
up of companies by if there is
In relation to the winding to the Court or,
receiver attached
receiver" means the
official
as the
Governmen may, bu
ent may, by
receiver. then
such person
such official for the purpose.
in the official Gazette, appoint
notification forthwith take into hie
the official liquidator,
receiver shall, as assets of the company
The official documents and the any.
and control al the books, as the Cour
custody such remuneration
receiver shall be entitled so
The official
shall fix.
to be liquidator
Oficial liquidator receiver shall become the
winding up order the official
On the making of a
act as such until his
of the company and shall continue to
oficial liquidator terminated of the Court.
by an order
further continuance is deemed to be
winding
of up order filed with the Registrar
5. Copy
notice of discharge (Sec. 252)
it shall be the duty of the petitioner
On the making of a winding up order,
in the winding up proceedings and
of the company to file with the Registrar
date of the making of the
a copy of the order
within thirty days from the
order.
the Registrar shall register a
On the copy of a winding up order,
filing of a
to the company, and shall notify n
summary thereof in his books relating
the official Gazette that such an order has been made.
Such order shall be deemed to be notice of discharge to the servants of the
company, except when the business of the company is continued
14.2.5 Procedure of winding up by the Court
. Official liquidator (Sec.257): For the purpose of winding up ot
Liquidator
On the making of a winding up order the official receiver shall become the
official u
liquidator of the company and shall continue to act as such il his
further continuance is termunated un
by an order of the Court |Sec. 251(291
Provisional liquidator
At any time after the
making of an order for presentation of a winding up petitio an be fore
tion and
the
impose, the Court may appoint a person or persons, other than the official
receiver, to be called an official liquidator or official liquidators.
If more persons than one are appointed to the office of official liquidator,
the Court shall declare whether any act, by the Act required or authorised,
to be done by the official liquidator is to be done by all or any
one or more
of such persons.
The Court may determine whether any and what security is to be given by
any official liquidator on his appointment.
defect
The of an official liquidator shall be valid notwithstanding any
acts
that may afterwards be discovered in his appointment.
to acts done by official
But nothing shall be deemed to give validity an
be invalid. A receiver
liquidator after his appointment has been showm to
shall not be appointed of assets in the hands of an official liquidator.
3. Resignations, removals, vacancies etc. of official liquidator (Sec.256)
Court on due
Any official liquidator resign, or may be removed by the
may
cause shown. Any vacancy in the office of an official liquidator appointed
is filled
by the Court shall be filled by the Court and until the vacancy
up
so
Soon
as practicable after receipt of the statement to be submitted under
Section 258, and not later than one hundred and twenty days or with the
caV OT ne Court one hundred and sixty days from the date of the order, or
Commercial Law
622 Text Book on
(8 to raise on the security of the assets of the company any more requisile;
(h) to take out, in his official name, letters of administration relating to
the estate of any deceased contributory, and to do in his offica
name any other act necessary for obtaining payment of any money
due from a contributory or his estate which cannot be convenientuy
done in the name of the company. In all such cases the money due
shal, for the purpose of enabling the liquidator to take out tne
letters of administration or recover the money be deemed to be du
the company,
such costs and expenses
affidavit as the official liquidator ma
statement and
the
and making of to the Court.
consider reasonable. subject to an appeal
258(5), (6) and (7I
(Sec.
Comsequences in default make
knowingly and willfully
without reasonable excuse, shall be liable to a
If any person, requirements, he
with the above
default in complying during which the defaut
hundred taka for everyday
fine not exceeding five
continues.
creditor or contributory of the
himself in writing to be a
Any person stating himself or his agent at all reasonable times,
by
company shall
be entitled by statement submitted in
on payment of the prescribed fee, to inspect the
or extract therefrom.
this section and to copy thereof
a
pursuance of
so stating himself to
be a creditor or contributory
Any person untruthfully Penal Code, 1860 (Act
under section 182 of the
shall be guilty of an offence
on the application of
the liquidator or of the
No. XLV of 1860), and shall,
official Receiver be punishable accordingly.
in a case where a provisIonal
The expression "the relevant date" means, case where
o
his appointment, and, in a
liquidator is appointed, the date of
order.
such appointment is made, the date of the winding up
IV.Committee of inspection (Sec. 261)
Appointment for
The official liquidator shall, within a month from the date of the order
f the
the winding up of a company, convene a meeting of the creditors o
company, as ascertained from the books and documents of the companyshall
the purpose of determining whether or not a committee of inspection "the
act with the liquidator, and who are to be membets
De appointed to
committees, if appointed. redhtor
The official liquidator shall, within a week from the date of the c
meeting convene a meeting of the contributories to consider the dee
the creditors and to accept the same with or without modification
creditors n 1
members thereof.
Company Law 627
Constitution and proceedings of the committee
C
mitteeof
mmittee of inspection so
appointed shall consist of not more than
A members being creditors and contributories of the company or
we holding general or
special powers of attorney from creditors or
Pihutories in such proportions as may be agreed on by the meetings of
contri
ors
itors and contributories, or as,
and ccon in case of difference,
may be determined
by the Court.
The committee of inspection shall have the right to inspect the accounts of
the official liquidator at all reasonable times.
The committee shall meet at such times as they may from time to time
anpoint, and, fail1ng such appointment, at least once a month, and the
iauidator or any member of the committee may also call a meeting of the
committee as and when he thinks necessary.
The committee may act by a majority of their members present at a
meeting, but shall not act unless a majority of the committee are present.
A member of the committee may resign by notice in writing signed by him
and delivered to the liquidator.
If a member of the committee becomes bankrupt, or compounds or
arranges, with his creditors, or is absent from five consecutive meetings of
the committee without the leave of those members who together with
himself represent the creditors or contributories, as the case may be, his
office shall thereupon become vacant.
A member of the committee may be removed therefrom by an ordinary
resolution at a meeting of creditors if, he represents creditors, or of
contributories, if he represents contributories, of which seven days, notice
has been given, stating the object of the meeting.
On a vacancy occurring in the committee, the liquidator shall forthwith
Summon a meeting of creditors or of contributories, as the case may require,
to fill in the vacancy, and the meeting may, by resolution, re-appoint the
ame or appoint another creditor or contributory to fill in the vacancy.
e Continuing members of the committee, if not less than two, may act
Any creditor or contributory may also take part in the examination either
personally or by any person entitled to appear before the Court.
Conduct of proceedings
The Court may put such questions to the person examined as the Court
thinks fit. The person examined shall be examined on oath, and shall answer
all such questions as the Court may put or allow to be put to him.
A person ordered to be examined under this section may at his own cost
employ any person entitled to appear before the Court, who shall be at
liberty to put to him such questions as the Court may deem just for the
purpose of enabling him to explain or qualify any answers given by him.
But if he is, in the opinion of the Court, exculpated from any charges made
or suggested against him, the Court may allow him such costs as, in its
discretion, it may think fit.
Notes of the examination shall be taken down in writing, and shall be read
over to or by and signed by, the person examined, and may thereafter be
used in evidence against him in civil proceedings, and shall be open to the
inspection of any creditor or contributory at the reasonable times.
The Court may, if it thinks fit, adjourn the examination from time to time.
The examination may, if the Court so directs, be held before any District
or before any officer of the High Court Division being an official
udge
referee, master, Registrar or Deputy Registrar and the powers of the Courts
under this section as to the conduct of the examination, but not as to costs,
may be exercised by the person before whom the examination is held.
3. Power to arrest absconding contributory (Sec. 280)
The Court, at any time either before or after making a winding up order and
believing that a contributory about to
is or
proof of probable cause for
conceal any of
ut Bangladesh or to abscond, or to remove or
otherwise
property, for the purpose of evading payment of calls or of avoiding
14.2.8 Contributory
Meaning of contributory (Sec.237)
The term "contributory" means every person liable to contribute to tha
ne
assets of a company in the event of its being wound up,
and, in all
proceedings for determining and in all proceedings prior to the final
determination of the persons who are to be deemed contributories, includes
any person alleged to be a contributory.
Nature of liability of contributory (Sec.238)
The liability of the contributory shall create a debt
payable at the time
specified in the calls made on him by the liquidation. No claim founded on
the liability of a
contributory shall be cognizable by any Court of Small
Causes.
Contributories in case of death of
If a
member (Sec.239)
contributory dies either before or after he has been placed on the list of
contributories, his legal representatives and his heirs shall be liable in the
due course of administration to contribute to the assets of
the company in
discharge of his liability and shall be contributories
accordingly.
If the legal representatives or heirs make default in
ordered to be paid by them, paying any money
proceedings may be taken for administering the
property of the deceased contributory, whether movable or
both, and for compelling payment thereout of the immovable, or
money due.
For this purpose, the
surviving coparceners of a
contributory who is a
member of a Hindu Joint Family governed by the Mitakshara School of
Hindu Law shall be deemed to be his
legal representatives and heirs.
Contributories in case of bankruptey of member
If
(Sec.240)
a
contributory is adjudged bankrupt either before or after he has been
placed on the list of contributors, then-
(a) his assignees shall represent him for
all the purposes of the
winding up, and shall be contributories accordingly, and maybe
called on to admit to
prove against the estate of the
otherwise to allow to be paid out of his bankrupt, or
assets in due course of law,
any money due from the
bankrupt in respect of his liability to
contribute to the assets of the
company; and
(b) there may be proved
against the estate of the bankrupt tne
estimated value of his
liability to future calls as well as cai
already made.
Liability as contributorles of present and past members
In the event of a company being wound (Sec.235)
up, nber
every present and past memo
shall, be liable to contribute to the assets of the company to an
amou
Company Law 633
and
fficient forpayment of its debts and liabilities and the costs, charges the
of
of the winding up. The adjustment of the rights
nenses qualifications, that
ributories among themselves subject following
is to
is tosay:
not be liable to contribute if he
has
(1) a past member shall
upwards before the
ccased to be a member for one year or
the amount, if
shall be required from any members exceeding
which he is liable as a
any, unpaid on the shares in respect to
present or past member
no
(v) in the of a company limited by guarantee,
case
contribution shall be required from any member exceeding
contributed by him to the assets
the amount undertaken to be
wound up;
of the company in the event of its being
invalidate any provision contained in
(vi) nothing in the Act shall
or other contract whereby the liability
any policy of insurance
contract is restricted
of individual members on the policy or
alone made liable in
or whereby the funds of the company are
respect ofthe policy or contract;
character of a
(VIn) a sumdue to any member of a company in his
shall not
member, by way of dividends, profits otherwise,
or
to that
be deemed to be a debt of the company payable
member in a case of competition between himself and any
other creditor who is not a member of the company.
In limited by guarantee which has a share
ninding up of a company
member thereof shall be liable to pay the following
amounts
aelry
Tamely:
4)the amount undertaken to be contributed by him to the assets of
the company in the of its being wound up; and
event
(b) an amount to the extent of any sums unpaid on any shares held
by him.
on Commercial
Law
634 Text Book
is unlimited (Sec.236)
whose liability
Liability of directors director whether past
limited company, any
In the winding up of a
Act, unlimited, shall in
or
of an extraordinary af
resolution of the company, and in the c the
creditors voluntary
winding up, with the sanction ot powes
Court or the committee of
inspection, exercise any
given by clauses (d), (e). () and
ot the
ny of n dlo q u i d a t o r
(h) of section
262 to a
Company Law 637
in a winding up. But the exercise by the
liquidator of the
given by this clause shall be subject to the control of powers
the
Court and
any creditor or contributory may apply to the Court with respect to
any exercise or proposed exercise of any of these powers;
(b) without the sanction referred to in clause (a), exercise any of the
other powers by the Act given on the
liquidator in a winding up by
the Court;
(c) exercise the power of the Court under this Act of settling a list of
contributories, and the list of contributories shall be prima facie
evidence of the liability of the persons named therein to be
contributories;
(d) exercise the power of the Court of making calls on shares or
otherwise,
(e) summon general meetings of the company for the purpose of
obtaining the sanction of the company by special or extraordinary
resolution or for any other purpose he may think fit.
The liquidator shall pay the debts of the company and shall adjust the rights
of the contributories among themselves.
When several liquidators are appointed, any power given by this Act may
be exercised by such one or more of them as may be determined at the time
of the appointment, or, in default of such determination, by any number not
less than two.
14.3.7 Cost of voluntary winding up (Sec.313)
All costs, charges and other expenditure properly incurred in the winding
up including the remuneration of the liquidator, shall, subject to the rights
of secured creditors, if any, be payable out of the assets of the company in
priority to all other claims.
14.3.8 Saving for rights ofcreditors and contributories (Sec.314)
he winding up of a company shall not bar the right of any creditor or
but in the of an
apply for a winding up by the Court,
case
contributory to
satisfied that the rights of
Ppication by a contributory, the Court must be
C Contributories will be prejudiced by a voluntary winding up.
1 9 Power of Court to adopt proceeding of voluntary winding up
(Sec.315)
and order is made for
company is being wound up voluntarily
an
a
e
the Court if it think fit, by the same or
ng up by the Court, may
of the proceedings
sut for the adoption of all or any
in uent order, provide
incidental on consequential
ntary winding up and also for any
situati
situation.
638 Text Book on Commercial Law
accept shares
liquidator to etc. as consideration for sale of
Power of
property of company (Sec.294)
where a copany proposed to be, or is in course of being, wound up
Is
But the creditors may, if they think fit, resolve that all or any of the persor
so appointed by the company ought not to be members of the
commi the
inspection. And, if the creditors so resolve, the persons mentioned n
resolution shall not, unless the Court otherwise directs, be qualineu
tion
remain or to act as members, of the committee, and on any
appnthet
the Court under this provision the Court may, if it thinks fit, appoint
other
the
"
persons to act as such members in place of the persons mentioned
resolution.
Company Law 643
4.Liquidator's remuneration (Sec.301)
On the appointment ofa liquidator, all the powers of the directors shall
cease, except so tar as the committee of inspection, or if there is no such
committee, the creditors sanction the continuance thereof.
5. Power of liquidator (Sec.303)
If a vacancy occurs by death, resignation or otherwise, in the office of a
liquidator then the vacancy may be filled in by the Court when the
liquidator was appointed by the Court or by the creditors where the
liquidator wvas appointed by creditors.
6. Duty of liquidator (Sec.304)
(1) In the event of the winding up continuing for more than one year, the
liquidator shall summon a general meeting of the company and a meeting of
creditors at the end of the first year from the commencement of the
winding
up, and of each succeeding year, or as soon thereafter as may be convenient
and shall lay before the meeting an account of his acts and dealings and of
the conduct of the winding up during the preceding year and a statement in
the prescribed form containing the
prescribed particulars
with to the
respect
position of the winding up.
(2) If the liquidator fails to comply with above the requirements, he shall be
liable to a fine not exceeding five hundred taka.
7. Final meeting and dissolution
(Sec.305)
(1) As soon as the affairs of the company are fulily wound
up, the liquidator
shall make up an account of the
has been conducted and the
winding up showing how the winding up
and
property of the company has been disposed of,
thereupon shall call a general meeting of the company and a meeting of
he creditors, for the purpose of laying the account before the meetings and
ving any explanation thereof.
Each such
meeting shall be called by advertisement specifying the time,
place and
object thereof and published one month at least before the
CCLing in the manner specified in section 289 for the publication of a
notice under that
section.
nin one week after the date of the meetings, or if the
n meetings, are not
the same date after the date of the later meeting, the liquidator shall
of
send to the Registrar a copy of the account, and shall make a return to him
of the
the re holding
holding of
of the meetings and of their dates. If the
copies are not sent or
Onour
one
IS not
made, the liquidator shall be liabl to a fine not exceeding
hundred taka for everyday during which the default continues.
Commercial Law
644 Text Book on
and generally on such terms and conditions as the Court thinks just.
2. Effect of petition for winding up subject to supervision (Sec.317) the
to
A petition for continuance of a voluntary winding up 'subject to
supervision of the Court shall, for the purpose of giving jurisdictuO the
powers which it might have exercised liquidators, and to exercise all other
wanding up the company altogether by the ifCourt.
an order had been made for
The
company
a general consequences to be followed by every mode of winding up
1.
Company are discussed below: ot
(a) rank equally among themselves and be paid in full, unless the
assets are insufficient to meet them, in which case they shall abate
in equal proportion; and
b)
(b) so far as the assets of the company available for payment of
general creditors are insufficient to meet them, have priority over
the claims of holders of debentures under any
floating charge
created by the company, and be paid accordingly out of
any
property comprised in or subject to that charge.
Subject to the retention of such sums as may be necessary for the costs and
expenses of the winding up, the foregoing debts shall be discharged forth
with so far as the assets are sufficient to meet them.
In the event of any person distaining or having distained on any goods or
effects of the company within three months next before the date of a
winding up order, the debts to which priority is given by this section shall
be first
a
charge on the goods or effects so distained on the proceeds of the
sale thereof.
But in
respect of any money paid under any such charge the said persons
Snall have the same
rights of priority as the person to whom the is payment
made.
The date referred to above is-
(a)in the case of a company ordered be wound up compulsorily
to
which had not previously commenced to be wound up
voluntarily the date of the winding up order; and
b) in any other
case, the date of the commencement of the winding up.
S.
Diselaimer of property (Sec.326)
Where any
p a r t of the property of a company which is being wound up
Sists of land of
tenure
ter burdened with onerous covenants, or shares,
or
stock in other any
companies,
co or unprofitable contracts or of any other
property that is unsaleable, or not
readily saleable, by reason of its binding
648 Text Book on Commercial Law
upon the possessor thereof the performance of any onerous act, or to th.
payment of any sum of money, the liquidator of the company,
notwithstanding that he had endeavoured to sell or has taken possession
the property, or had exercised any act of ownership in relation thereto, mav
with the leave of the Court and subject to the provisions of this section
Writing signed by him at any time within twelve months after the
commencement of the winding up or such extended period as may be
allowed by the Court, disclaim the property.
But where any such property has not come to the knowledge of the
liquidator within one month after the commencement of the winding up, the
power of disclaiming the property may be exercised at any time within
twelve months after he has become aware thereof or such extended period
as may be allowed by the Court.
The disclaimer shall operate to determine, as from the date of disclaimer,
the rights, interests, and liabilities of the company, and the property of the
company, in or in respect of the property disclaimed, but shall not, except
so far as is necessary for the purpose of releasing the company and the
property of the company from liability, affect the rights or liabilities of any
other person.
The Court, before or on granting leave to disclaim, may require such notice
to be given to persons interested and impose such terms as a condition or
granting leave, and make such other order in the matter as the Court thinks
Just.
The liquidator shall not be entitled to disclaim any property under this
section in any case where an application in writing has been made to him by
any person interested in the property requiring him to decide whether ne
will or will not disclaim, and the liquidator has not within a period of thiry
days after the receipt of the application or such further time as may De
allowed by the Court, given notice to the
applicant
that he tointends appiy
to the Court for leave to disclaim, and in the case of a contract, it
liquidator, after such an
application as aforesaid,
said
does not within the sa
period or further period disclaim the contract, the company shall be deet
med
winding up.
Company Law 649
(b) if the Court thinks fit, subject only to the same liabilities and
obligations as if the lease had been assigned to that person at that
date.
In either, if the case so requires, as if the lease had comprised only the
property comprised in the vesting order, and any mortgage or under
lease
declining to accept a vesting order upon such terms shall be excluded from
all interest in and security upon the property. If there is no person claiming
under the company who is willing to accept an order upon such terms, the
Court shall have power to vest the estate and interest of the company in the
property in any person liable, either personally or in representative, and
either alone or jointly with the company, to perform the lessee's covenants
in the lease, freed and discharged from all estates, encumbrances and
interests created therein by the company.
Any person injured by the operation of a disclaimer shall be deemed to be a
Creditor of the company to the amount of the injury, and may accordingly
prove the amount as a debt in the
winding up.
6.
Fraudulent preference (Sec.327)
uy ransfer, delivery of goods, payment, execution or other act relating to
perty which would, if made or done by or against an individual, be
d in his bankruptcy a fraudulent preference, shall if made or done by
f nsta company, be deemed in the event of its being wound upa
e n t preference of
its creditors, and be invalid accordingly.
650 Text Book on Commercial Law
For the purpose it, the presentation of a petition for winding up in the cas
of winding up by or subject to the supervision of the and a
Court,
for winding up in the case of a voluntary winding up, shall be resolution
deemedto
correspond with the acts of bankruptcy in the case of an individual
Any transfer or assignment by a company of all its property to trustees for
the benefit of all its creditors shall be void.
7. Avoidance of certain attachments, executions (Sec.328)
Where any company is being wound up by or
subject to the supervision of
the Court, any attachmerit, distress or execution
put in force without leave
of the Court against the estate or effects or
any sale held without leave of
theCourt of any properties of the company after the
commencement of the
winding up shall be void. But it does not apply to proceedings by the
Govermment.
8. Effect of charge created after commencement of
(Sec.329) winding up
A floating charge on the
undertaking or property of the company created
within ninety days of the commencement of the
is proved that the winding up shall, unless it
company immediately after the creation of the
solvent, be invalid except to the creation of, and in charge was
consideration for, the
charge, together with interest on that amount at the rate of five
annum. per cent, per
9. Power of Court to assess
damages against delinquent directors
(Sec.331)
Where, in the course of
who has taken
winding up a
company it appears that any person
in
part the formation
past or
or
promotion of the company or any
present director, manager or
liquidator, or any officer of the
company has misapplied or retained or become
liable or accountable for any
money or property of the or been
breach of trust in relation tocompany, guilty of any misfeasance o
the company, the Court
of the
liquidator or of any creditor or may, on the applicato
irom the date of the
first
contributory made within three yea
the appointment of a liquidator in the winding up or
misapplication,
retainer, misfeasance or breach of
be, whiche ver is
longer, examine of the conduct of the trust, as the case
tO,
manager, liquidator or officer and promoter,
may compel him to repay or
uu the
money or property or any
part thereof respectively with interest at resto
such rate
as the Court at
thinks, just, or to contribute such su the
company by way of sum to the assets
misfeasance or breachcompensation in respect of the net,
Registrar and shall furnish to him such information and give to him such
access to and shall furnish to him such information and give him such
access to and facilities for inspecting and taking copies of any documents,
the control of
being information or documents in the possession or under
the liquidator relating to the matter in question, as he may require.
Where any report is made to the Registrar, he may, if he thinks fit,
refer the
matter to the Government for further inquiry, and
the Govermment shall
thereupon investigate the matter and may, if they think expedient, apply
it
to the Court for an order conferring on any person designated by
the
concerned all such
Government for the purpose with respect to the company
as are provided by the
powers of investigating the affairs of the company
Act in the case of a winding up by the Court.
him that the case is not one in
t on any report to the Registrar it appears to
inform the liquidator
ought to be taken by him, he shall
wnich proceedings sanction of the Court,
ccordingly, and thereupon, subject to the previous
ne iquidator may himself take proceedings against the offender.
that any
appears the Court in the course of a voluntary winding up
to
member of the
or present director, manager or other officer or any
PASt that no report with respect to the
has been guilty as aforesaid, and
pany on
to the Registrar, the Court may,
th as been made by the liquidator winding up or of its own
4Pphcation of any person interested in the
652 Text Book on Commercial Law
and on a report
bein.
direct the liquidator to make such report,
a
motion,
made accordingly, the provision of this section shall have effect as thou
of this Section
ugh
the in
has been nmade pursuance of the provisions
report
referred to the Registrar and heconsiders th
that
If a matter is reported or
the
to be instituted thereon,
he shall place papers betore
prosecution ought
the Attorney General or the public prosecutor and shall u advised to do so,
institute proceedings.
without first giving the accused
But prosecution shall be undertaken
no
to the Registrar and
of making a statement in writing
person an opportunity
of being heard thereon.
contained in the Evidence Act, 1872 (Act No. 1
anything
Notwithstanding
instituted under this section it shall be
of 1872), when any proceedings are
officer and of the company past
the duty of the liquidator and of every in the agent
defendant proceedings, to give al
and present, other than the which he is reasonably able to
assistance in connection with the prosecution
shall be deemed to
give. The expression "agent" in relation to a company
include any banker or legal adviser of the company and any person
upwards; or
statement relating to the
( makes any material omission in any
affairs of the company; or
commeneement ot the
wthin twelve months next before the
makes or is privy to the
ding up or at any time thereafter
book or paper affecting
or relating
KIng of any false entry in any
t h e property or affairs o f t h e conpany, or
654 Commercial Law
Text Book on
(o)
(o) within twelve months next before the commencement of the
winding up or at any time thereafter pawns. pledges, or disposes of
any property of the company which has been obtained on credit
and has not has been paid for. unless such pawning pledging or
disposing is in the ordinary way of the business of the company,or
(p) is guilty of any false representation or other fraud for the purpose
of obtaining the consent of the creditors of the company or any of
them through an agreement with reference to the affairs of the
company or to the winding up;
he shall be punishable, in the case of the offence mentioned in
clauses (m).(n) and (o) with imprisonment for a term not exceeding
seven years, and. in the case of any offence, mentioned in other
clauses with imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
But it shall be a good defence to a charge under any of clauses (b), (c), (d), (1),
(n) and (o). if the accused proves that he had no intent to defraud, and to a
charge under any of the clauses (a). (h). (i) and (Gj), ifhe proves that he hado
intent to conceal the state of affairs of the company or to defeat the law.
Where any person pawns, pledges or disposes of any property
circumstances which amount to an offence under clause (o) every perso
who takes in pawn or pledge or otherwise receives the property knowIng
to be pawned. pledged or disposed of in such circumstances as afores
shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term not exceeding three yeal
Company Law 655
14. Meeting to ascertain wishes of creditors or contributories (Sec.336)
Where by the Act the Court is authorised in relation to winding up to have
regard to the wishes of creditors or contributories, as proved to it by any
sufficient evidence, the Court may, if it thinks for the purpose of
ascertaining those wishes, direct meeting of the creditors or contributories
to be called, held and conducted in such manner as the Court directs, and
may appoint a person to act as chairman of any such meeting and to report
the result thereof to the Court.
In the case of creditors, regard shall be had to the value of each creditor's
debt. In the case of contributories regard shall be had to the number of votes
conferred on each contributory by the Articles.
15. Evidentiary value of documents of company (Sec.337)
Where any company is being wound up, all documents of the company and
of the liquidator shall as between the contributories of the company, be
prima facie evidence of the truth of all matters purporting to be therein
recorded.
16. Inspection and disposal of documents of company (Sec.338)
After an order for a winding up by or subject to the supervision of the
Court, the Court may make such order for inspection by creditors and
contributories of the company of its documents as the Court thinks just, and
any documents in the possession of the company may be inspected by
creditors or contributories accordingly, but not, further or otherwise.
17. Disposal of documents of company (Sec.339)
When a company has been wound up and is about to be dissolved, the
documents of the company and of the liquidators may be disposed of as
follows, that is to say:
(a) in the case of a winding up by or subject to the supervision of the
Court, in such way as the Court directs;
(b) in the case of voluntary winding up, in such way as the company
by extraordinary resolution directs.
After three years from the dissolution of the company, no responsibility
shall rest on the company or the liquidators, or any person to whom the
custody of the documents has been committed, by reason of the same not
Deing 1orthcoming to any person claiming to be interested therein.
18. Power of Court to declare dissolution of company void (Sec.340)
where a company has been dissolved, the Court may, at any time within
made for the
Oyears of the date of the dissolution on an application beingwho
or the company or by any
other person appears to
upose by liquidator
LOurt to be interested, make an orderupon such terms as the Court may
656 Text Book on Commercial Law
thinks fit, declaring the dissolution to have been void, and
thereupon suc
proceedings may be taken as might have been taken if the company had
been dissolved. not
It shall be the duty of the person on whose application the order was made
within twenty-one days after the making of the order, to file withth
Registrar a certified copy of the order, and if that person fails so to do, he
shall be liable to a fine not exceeding one hundred taka for everyday
which the default continues.
during
19. Unclaimed dividends and undistributed assets to be paid to
Companies Liquidation Account (Sec.343)
Where any company is being wound up, if the liquidator has in his hands or
under his control any money of the company representing
unclaimed
dividends payable to any creditor or undistributed asset refundable to
any
contributory which have remained uncla imed for one hundred and eighty
days after the date on which they became payable or refundable, that
liquidator shall forthwith pay the said money into the Bangladesh Bank to
credit of the Government in an account to be called the
"Companies
Liquidation Account". The liquidator shall, on the dissolution of the
company, similarly
pay into the said Account any money representing
unclaimed dividend or undistributed assets in his hand at the date of
dissolution.
The liquidator shall, when
making any payment referred to above, furnish to
such officer as the Government
may appoint in this behalf a statement in the
prescribed form setting forth in respect of all sums included in such
payment, the nature of the sums, the names and last known addresses of the
persons entitled to participate therein, the amount to which each is
and the nature of his claim
entitled
thereto, and such other particulars as may be
prescribed.
The receipt of the Bangladesh Bank for any money paid to it under above
shall be an effectual discharge of the liquidator in respect thereof.
Any person claiming to be
entitled to any money,
paid into the Companies
Liquidation Account in pursuance of this section may
an order for apply to the Court tor
payment thereof, and the Court, if satisfied that the
claiming is entitled may make an order for the person
payment to that person of the
sum or the asset due to him.
Any liquidator retaining any money or asset which should have been
deposited by him into the "Companies Liquidation Account" under this
section shall pay interest the amount retained at
on
the rate of twenty pe
cent per annum and shall also be liable
to pay any
reason of his default and where the expense occasioned by
winding up is by or under tne
Company Law 657
sDervision of the Court, he shall also be liable to disallowance of all or
Such part of his remuneration as the Court may think just and to be removed
from this office by the Court
20. Power of Supreme Court to make rules (Sec.345)
The Supreme Court, may from time to time, make rules consistent with the
Act and with the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 (Act V of 1908) concerming
the following matters namely:.
(a) the mode of proceedings to be held for winding up of a company in
the High Court Division and in a Court subordinate
thereto
(b) in the case of voluntary winding up by members or creditors, for
the holding of meetings of creditors and members in connection
with proceedings under section 228 of the Act
(c) giving effect to the provisions of the Companies Act for the
purpose of reduction of share capital and sub-division of the share
of a company:
(d) all applications to be made to the Court under the provisions ofthe Act.
Under this authornty the Supreme Court has made rules as amended upto date.
14.7 Winding up of unregistered companies
1. Meaning of "unregistered company" (Sec.371)
The expression "unregistered company" shall not include a company
under any company law in
registered under the Companies Act,1994 or
force at any time before the commencement of the Act, but any partnership,
and not
associations or company consist1ng of more than seven members
shall be deemed to be an
registered under this Act or the said company law
"unregistered company".
2. Winding up of unregistered company -how made (Sec.372)
the Companies Act and
Any unregistered company may be wound up under
all the provisions of the Act with respect to winding up shall apply to an
unregistered company, with the following exceptions and additions,
namely:-
under the Act
(a) no unregistered company shall be wound up
voluntarily or subject to supervisien ef the Court;
(b) the circumstances in which an unregistered company may be
wound up are as follows, namely:-
if the company is dissolved or has ceased to carry on business or is
)
carymg on business only for the purpose of winding up its attairs;
(ii) if the company is unable to pay its debts;
(111) if the Court is of opinion that it is just and equitable that the
company should be wound up.
Commercial.Law
Text Book on
658
shall, be deemed to be unable to pay its
unregistered company
(c) an
debts-
or otherwise, towhom thee
(i) if a creditor, by assignment
five hundred taka
company is indebted in a sum exceeding
on the company, by leaving at its
then due has served
the secretaryto
principal place of business,
or by delivering y
officer of the
or some director, manager or principal
otherwise serving in such
manner as the
company, or by
or direct a demand under his hand
Court may approve
the sum so due, and the
requiring the company to pay
three weeks after the service of the demand
company has for
secure or compound for it to
neglected to pay the sum, or to
the satisfaction of the creditor; or
(ii) if any suit other legal proceeding has been instituted
or
demand due or claimed
against any member for any debt or
to be due, from the company or from him in his character of
member, and notice in writing of the institution of the suit or
other legal proceeding having been served on the company
by leaving the same at its principal place of business or by
delivering it to the secretary, or some director, manageT or
principal officer of the company or by otherwise serving the
same in such manner as the Court may approve or direct, the
company has not within ten days after service of the notice
paid, secured or compounded for the debt or demand,
procured an order for the suit or other legal proceeding to be
stayed, or indemnified the said member or defendant to his
reasonable satisfaction against the suit or other legal
proceeding, and against all costs, damages and expense to be
incurred by him by reason of the same; or
(111) if execution or other process issued on a
decree or order
obtained in any Court in favour of a creditor against tNe
company, or any member thereof as such, or any
authorised to be sued as nominal perso
defendant on behalf of me
company, is returned unsatisfied; or
(iv) if it is otherwise
the company is
proved to the satisfaction of the Court that
unable to pay its debts.
It shall not affect the
operation of any enactment which ro any
partnership, association or company provides
company or as unregistered being wound up or being wound as
the Act. company, under any enactment by
repca
Company Law
659
Winding up of companies incorporated outside Bangladesh
may direct, bring or defend in his official name any suit or other leoa
proceeding relating to that property, or necessary to be brought or defended legal
for purposes of effectually winding up the company and recovering its
property.
14.8 Defunct companies
A defunct company is one which is not carrying on business or which is not
in operation. Section 346 deals with such companies.
14.8.1 Registrar may strike defunet company off register (Sec.346)
(1) Where the Registrar has reasonable cause to believe that a company is
not carrying on business or in operation, he shall send to the company by
post a letter requiring whether the company is carrying on business or in
operation.
(2) If the Registrar does not within thirty days of sending the letter receive
any answer thereto, he shall within fourteen days, after the expiration of the
said thirty days send to the company by post a registered letter referring to
the first letter and stating that no answer thereto has been received and
that,
if an answer is not received to the second letter within thirty days from the
date, thereof, a notice will be published in the official Gazette with a view
to striking the name of the company off the register.
(3) If the Registrar either receives an answer from the company to the effect
that it is not carrying business in
on
operations, or does not within thirty
or
days after sending the second letter receive any answer, he may publish in
the official Gazette, and send to the
company by post a notice that, at the
expiration of ninety days from the date of that notice, the name of the
company mentioned therein will, unless cause is shown to the contrary, be
struck off the register and the
company will be dissolved, and in such a
case the Registrar may send a copy of the notice to the company while in
sending it to the concerned
authority for its
Gazette. publication in the official
(4) If, in any where a company is
case
being wound up, the Registrar has
reasonable cause to believe either that no
affairs of the company are liquidator is acting or that the
fully wound and the returns required to be
made by the liquidator have not been up,
made for a period of six
months after notice by the consecutive
Registrar
by post to the company, or to the demandingat
the returns, has been sen
business, the Registrar may publish inliquidator
his last known place o
the official Gazette and send to tn
company a like notice.
(5) At the expiration of.the time mentioned in
the notice the
unless because to the
is
contrary
Registrar ia
its name previously
shown by the company, su
off the register and on the publication in the
notice to the effect the official Gazette
çompany shall be dissolved.
Company Law 661
Rut the liability if any, of every director and member of the company shall
continue and may be enforced as if the company had not been dissolved.
14.8.2 Restoration [Sec. 346(6)|
If a company or any member or creditor thereof fecls aggrieved by the
company's having been struck off the register, the Court, on the application
of the company or member or creditor, may, if satisfied that the company
was at the time of the striking off carrying on business or in operation or
otherwise that it is just that the company be restored, to the register, and
thereupon the company shall be deemed to have continued in existence as
its name had not been struck off. The Court may by order give such
directions and make such provisions as seems just for placing the company
positions nearly may be as if thee
and all other persons in the same as as
TEST QUESTIONS
the
up of a company ? What
are
1. What do you understand by the winding
different modes of winding up ?
When can a company be wound up by the Court? Who are the persons
2.
of a company by the
entitled to present a petition for the winding up
circumstances in which each may present thèè
Court, and; what are the
petition?
Court order a compulsory winding up
3. Under what circumstances will the
effect of a winding up order?
of a company ? What is the
the Court commence? What are the
4. At what moment does a winding up by
order?
consequences of a winding up is
under which the Registrar of companies
5. What are the circumstances
for the winding up order?
competent to file an application of a company? Discuss their
are' contributories' in the winding up of
6. Who What is the nature and extent
the company.
right to claim set-off against
a contributor's liability?
regarding the liability of a contributory.
7. Give the statutory provisions What are the
company be voluntarily wound up? in case
8. When can a is followed