Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UNIT-1 Analogy Questions
UNIT-1 Analogy Questions
..,.
F . . = B [ d X1(t) _ d x: (t)]
• The spring between two
moving points causes
change in displacement.
L---► f(t)
l fncuonal dt dt
,____________________________,,
Step 5 : Elements causing same change in displacement will get
connected in parallel in between the respective nodes. 1 • According to Newton's
motion, applied force will cause
law of
f{t)
• Remember that only spring and friction can cause change in displacement x(t) in spring of
displacement if connected between the two moving masses. The mass constant K , acceleration to mass M
can not cause change in displacement hence can not exist between the
against frictional force having Fig. Q.4.1
nodes. The spring and friction with respect to fixed support can not
constant B.
cause change in displacement.
= Md 2
1 2•3 : F-V and F-1 Analogous Systems I f(t)
dt2
x(t) d x(t)
+ Bdt + K x(t)
Q.3 Wha~ do you understand by analogous systems ? Mention the Talcing Laplace transform, I F(s) = Ms 2 X(s) + Bs X(s) + K X(s) I . .(!)
two analogies.
~ [ AKTU : 2010-11, 2014-15, Markt 2]
• This is equilibriwn equation for the given mechanical system.
· ·1 : ·In between electrical and mech antcal
Ans. .
systems their exists
a
s1m1 anty between their equilibm. un equations.
.
Analogous S)isie,,.
2-6 Basic Signals and Systems 2 _7
Bosic Signals and Syst.e_ms~-- L -----------------~ Analogous~
I = IL+IR +le
Mass M Inertia J Inductance L ~
Basic Signals and Systems Ans. : Refer Table Q.4.1 from the answer of Q.4 and Table Q.5.1 from
V dV the answer of Q.S.
I :::: .!. J Vdt + R+ Cdt
L V(s) + V(s) + sCV(s) Important Points to Remember
I(s) == -;i::- R
Taking Laplace u-ansfonn, . • Remember that in F-V analogy,
. •iar form as that of F(s) we will use
f .dt, •• d 2x di
I
. e uation in the sunt , •
As x ➔ -
dx .
➔ 1 , x ➔ 1 x ➔ - ➔-
• But to get tbis q (s) == V(s) where qi = Flux dt dt 2 dt
d q, . V(s) == s<l> (s) i.e. <l> s
v(t) == dt i.e. • Remember that in F-1 analogy,
. . ~ ~in~e~q~ua~t~io:n~fo:r__:I:(s::_
)':--- ---;----
•
As x ➔
dx
➔ v (voltage),
J .. d 2 x dv
x ➔ v dt, x ➔ - ., ➔ -d
• Substttutm~ 7 -
½s $(s) + Iqi(s)
. dt dt - t
I(s) == Cs 2 <l>(s) + ... (2)
• This is useful in transforming mechanical equlibrium equations into II
electrical equlibriurn equations.
• Comparing equations (1) and (Z), • The electrical analogous system based on F-V analogy ts to be
. 'C' . alogous to mass M. obtained on the basis of Loop method.
i) Capacitor 1s an
. _!_ is analogous to frictional constant B. • The electrical analogous system based on F-1 analogy 1s to be \
ii) Reciprocal of resistance R obtained on the basis of Node method.
1 is analogous to spring constant K. • The elements which are in series in F - V analogy, get connected in
.
iii) Reciprocal of inductance L parallel in F - I analogous network and which are in parallel in F - V
analogy, get connected in series in F - I analogous network.
. ts according to F-1 analogy are tabulated
• The v~ous analogous e1emen
as,
Rotational Electrical 2.4: Steps to Obtain F-V and F-1 Analogous Systems
Translational
T Current I
F Force Q.7 Explain the steps to obtain the electrical analogous systems
J C based on F-V and F-1 analogies.
M Mass
B 1/R
B friction Ans. : The steps of obtaining the electrical analogous systems based on
K Spring K 1/L F-V and F-1 analogies are,
x displacement 6 $
Step 1 : Identify all the displacements due to the applied force.
· d6
d$
. VI .
X e OC! ty = dt
dx 6= - = w Voltage ' e' = dt · Step 2: Draw the equivalent mechanical system based on node basis.
dt ~
F = B I l newtons
• The direction of the mechanical force is given by Fleming's left hand
rule.
A nalogous Sys,~
BB~as~ic~S~i~g11~a~ls'...'.a:11:,:d_:S:::ys_te_ms
2 - 11
_ _ __ _ _ _
----... Basic Signals and Systems 1 - 13 Analogous Syste,n
- ber of conductors placed on ti._
h re are num " "lC
• In practical motor, t ell of them expereince a . iorce and overau x(t)
e periphery. A d motor starts rotating .
armatur reinces a torque an . i - - - - - f(t)
armature expe .. d drive a mechanical load conner-ta.i
d is uttltse to . fi . "'II
• Th' s torque generate . . friction and spnng orce .
i . t the load inerua.
to its shaft agams . system. both electrical as well ••
. . the enttre . ...
• Thus while analysing equired to be studied .
. arts of the system are r
mechanical P hanical system .
. called electromec
Hence such a system is . 1 (a) Physical system (b) Equivalent mechanical system
• . al system is an e ectromechanicai
l ctromechantc .
• Basically an e e , 1 of energy mto the other. Fig . Q.9.1
transducer v.·hi·ch converts one iom .
telephone recei\'ers, tachogencraton The equilibrium equation will be,
loudspe ak ers. 2
• The microphones. . runes are the examples of 22 d x(t) K ( ) B d x(t)
and various elecmcal mac f(t) = M + X t + -d -
dt 2 t
electromechanical system. . .
..·n below draw its equivalent system Talcing Laplace,F(s) = M s 2 X (s) + K X(s) + Bs X(s)
h . · 1 s\'Stem sho "
Q.9 For the P ~sica · . s Hence draw its electrical analoio111
. Uibrium equanon •
and wnte equ . •oltage il) Force _ cu r rent method. = X (s)[ Ms 2 + K+ Bs] ... (1)
circuits based on i) Force - ,
i) Force-Voltage Method : Use the analogous terms as,
.___ _ f( t) 1
M ➔ L, B ➔ R, K ➔ C' X ➔
dx
q, dt dq .
➔ dt-, l, X ➔
J
All quantities are expressed in terms of current i.
()
Vt = L -d i
dt
+ -1
C
J .d t+ Ri
1 ... (2)
B l(s)
V(s) = sL l(s) + sC + l (s )R ... (3)
Fig. Q.9.1
Simulate using loop method : Analogous to K is a capacitor C but
Ans. : Mass 'M' \\i ll displace by amount ·x• and as spring is conn~ its value is proportional to 1/K hence it is indicated by v.,Titing (1 /K) in
to fixed support and friction 'B' is also v.ith respect to fixed support, the bracket near C. This is shown in the Fig Q 9.2 (c).
K and B will be under influence of ·x• only . N ow its equivalent ~ L C(1 /K)
will contain one node and as all elements are under influence of In F-V analogy, the quantities which are ' ~r-
alone, must be connected in parallel under that no de . under the same displacement m \
mechanical system , carry the same v(t) _.,J ~ '
i ~ ~ _:;
current in analogous electrical system I t ,.,,___ _ _ __ _
l(IJ
Fig. Q.10.1
Using F - V analogy : M ➔ L, B ➔ R,
Basic Slgna/5 and Systems 1-17 Analogous System
Basic Slgnids (llld Systems
d2x di 0 = _l_ (v2 - \·1)+C2 d \' 2 + .! Jv z d t . ..(6)
- 4-
• dq
-,----tl,
x -, J dt,
i f(t) ---t v(t), dt2 dt R2 dt L
'X dt Using node basis, equations (5) and (6) give the F ~ I analogous system
. (1) and (2), as shown in the Fig. Q.l 0.4.
using in the equauons . . .
d1t + R i + R, ( ' 1 - i:) ... (3) a.11 Obtain the transfer function of the mechanical system shown in
, ·(t) = L, dt l I -
Fig. Q.11.1. I& [ AKTU : 2011 -12, Marks 5]
di1 1 Ji ,dt-rR , (i , -i1) .. (4)
0 = L1 dt -r ( • • -
I 1, Fig. Q.11 .1
' - - - - -_L-----' Ans. : The force is applied to mass M2 which is displaced by x(t). The
Fig. Q.1 0.3 friction B2 is under the influence of displacement x(t) as B2 is between
1 • I ~ 2 and fixed support.
. \ [ ----" ( B ---t - , K 4 -L, X ~ 0
[sing F - I ana Io~· , • -, · R Due to spring K and D
• do . f . d 2 x d \' friction D between M2 I
X ---+ - ---+ \ X ---+ \' dt f{t) ---+ 1(1), 1 ~ dt and M 1, the
. dt ' · dt ·
displacement of ~ 1
l ·smg in the equanons (1) and (2),
will be x 1(t) which is
1 1 .. .(5)
i(t) = C d\· 1 - - \' 1 - - (\· 1 - \· , ) other than x(t).
! dt R1 R:: -
While M1 , K1 and B1
are under the influence
of x 1(t) as K 1 and B1 Fig. Q.11 .1 (a)
are \\ith respect to
fixed support.
I The equivalent mechanical system is sho""n m the Fig. Q.11 .1 (a)
lt)r.'\ Same displacement
\.;/ ""'1-
-
same voltage The equilibrium equations are,
ftt) = M2 d2x(t) ... B? dx(t) ... D d [x( t) - x • (t)] - K [x(tJ-x1 (t)]
TTT7 JJ)/ 7 >1J 7 J I )' 7 777777777777 d t2 • dt dt
d 2 x 1(t)
2
-
Basic Signals and Systems
O= D dt dt
The friction B is under the
dx 1(t) () displacement (x 1 - x 2 ). The
+ B1 - + K1 X1 t
dt mass M2 and spring K are K
Taking laplace rransfonn of both the equations, under the displacement . x 2 .
:. F(s) = X(s) [M2s2 + B2s+ Ds+K] -X1(s) [Os + K] ... (1) Hence the equivalent
mechanical system is as
0 = - X(s) [Ds+ K] + X1 (s) [M1s2 +Os+ Bi s+ K+ Ki] Fig. Q.12.1 (a)
shown in the Fig.
... (2) Q.16.1 (a).
[Ds+ K]
ftt) == A sin wt
From (2),X1 (s) =X(s) (B D)+(K+K)
M1s 2 +s 1 + 1
The equilibriwn equations are,
Using in (I),
ftt) = M d 2 x 1 + B d (x J - x 2 )
X(s) [Os+ K] 2 1 ... (I )
2 dt 2 dt
F(s)=X (s) [M2s +s(D +B2)+K]- 2 (B D) (K K)]
[M 1s + s 1 + + + 1
0 = B d (x2 - xi) d2 x2
Hence the transfer function of the system is, d + M2 - - +Kx1 .. (2)
t dt2 -
X(s) _ [M1s 2 + s (B1 + D) + (K.+ K1)J For F-V analogy,
F(s) - (M1 s 2 + s (Bi + D) + (K + K1)J [M2 s 2 + s (D + B2) + KJ- (Ds + K) 2 1 . dx di d 2x
M ➔ I., B ➔ R K ➔ C' 1 =- dt - dt2 ' ➔ J i dt
dt' X
Q.12 Draw the analogous electrial circuit of the given mechanical
system shown in Fig. Q.12.1. Use f-v analogy. Write the system v(t) ... (3)
equations. ~ [ AKTU : 2010-11, Marks 5 J
0 = R [·12 -11
. ] + L 2 dt
di2 + C
1 fi 2 dt .. . (4)
M1
r/ I
~
i1 (t)
~
i2(t)
C (1 /K) .
f(t) = A sin wt f I
I
1
system shown in Q.13.1.
&W [ AKTU : 2014-15, Marks
8 i(t) = C1 dv 1 + - fv 1 dt+.!.[v 1-v 2]+ - -J (v 1 - v 2 )dt
--- - .. . I dt 11 R L2
B2 B3 (frictionless)
•·.~--·· - ·--- ------
R( 6)
Fig. Q.13.1
Ans. : Let the force is applied , ·· D
to M 1. So M1 and K1 are W1der v(t} ♦
For f - i analogy : M ➔ C, D ➔ R1 , K ➔ I1 , dt
dx = v, x ➔ v dt, f ➔ i J The equilibrium equations are,
d 2 x2 d(x-, -xi)
F(t) = M2 -
dt-
..,- + K2 (x2 - x1 ) + B2 dt ... (1 )
================,,__- - - -===-
, 22 Analogous t\. ds
BR~a.s~ic~ S~i!gn~a~ls~a~n~d'._:SJ
~·s~t~em~s~ - - - --=-
• -· - --:=-:=------=:---~- -- ..,Y&tt~ Basic Signals an ystems
=- ~ -=--------- - - - - - -..Analogous
2 - 23 System
.:.:.:.: ::!::::=:~
analysing a given system. In the mathematical model, the various
operations in the system are represented by the mathematical equations.
Q.16 What is the force voltage analogy of mechanical spring ?
F(t)
Ans, : A capacitor is force-voltage analogy of mechanical spring. Its
value is proportional to the reciprocal of the spring constant.
Fig. Q.14.2 Q.17 What is electrical analogous to gear ?
Ans, : The gear alters the torque-speed ratio as per the load requirement.
d(x - x 2 ) d 2 x1 dx 1
0 = K -,(X1 - x, ) +B~ · Id +M1-2-+K1X1 +B1 d t ... (2) As per force-voltage analogy, the voltage is analogous to torque and
- · - - t dt current is analogous to the speed. So electrical device which adjusts the
1 1 dx voltage to current ratio from one side to other as per the load, is
For F-1 analogy use M ➔ C, K ➔ L' B ➔ R , dt ➔ v,
analogous to gear. Thus electrical transformer is analogous to gear.
d 2x dv Q.18 What are the basic elements used for modeling mechanical
x ➔ f v dt, - ? ➔ -d rotational system ?
dt· t
I (t) = dv?
C2 - -+-
1 f (v 2 - v 1) dt +1- (v 2 - \-, 1) .. . (3) Ans. : The elements used for modeling mechanical rotational system are
dt L2 R2 inertia J, friction B, spring K, torque T, angular displacement e, angular
0 = -1 f (v 1 -v 2 ) dt+-
1
(v 1 -
dv 1
v 2 ) +C 1 - +-
1 f v 1dt +R1- V1 .. .(4) velocity w and angular acceleration ex.
L2 R2 1dt L1 Q.19 Write the analogous electrical elements in force current analogy
Using the equations (3) and (4), the F-I analogous network is as shown for the elements of translational mechanical system.
in the Fig. Q.14.3 Ans. : The mass M is analogous to capacitor C, friction is analogous to
resistance R and spring is analogous to an inductor L. The values of R
l(t)flc,
V2 and L are proportional to the reciprocals of frictional constant B and
spring constant K respectiv ely . The displacement is analogous to flux
while velocity is analogous to voltage.
Q.20 Write the analogous electrical elements in force voltage analogy
for the elements of translational mechanical system.
;
Fig. Q.14.3 Ans. : The mass M is analogous to inductor L, friction is analogous to
resistance R and spring is analogous to a capacitor C. The value of C is
Short Answered Questions proportional to the reciprocal of spring constant K. The displacement is
analogous to charge while velocity is analogous to current.
Q.15 What is mathematical modeling ?
0.21 What do you understand by an analogous system and bow it
Ans. : Obtaining the set of mathematical equations, describing the is useful in practice ?
dynamic characteristics of a system is called mathematical modeling of
the system. Obtaining the mathematical model is the first step in
1-24 Analogous Systt11i
Basic Signals and Systems ---
.d to be analogous to each other if the
Th systems are sai l . ·1 ..-
Ans. : e two . .b. the systems are exact y sum ar to each
3
equilibrium equations des~~ ; ; two systems are said to be analogous 10
other. Then the elements in between electrical and mechanical systellls FOURIER TRANSFORM ANALYSIS
each other. For example d their exists a similarity between their
there exists a fix~d analogy an th' it is possible to draw an electrical
·i·b · ations Due to is, •
eqw I num equ · ti ·mi'lar to the given mechanical systelll
· h ·n b have exac y si · 3.1 : Exponential and Trigonometric
system whic WI : us of given mechanical system and vice
1 1
This is called electnca ana ~go be analysed easily b form of Fourier Series
versa. In practice a comphcated system can . . y
· other fonn, for which its analysis
studying its analogous system m Important Points to Remember
methods are easily available. 00
Q.22 What are the three basic elements in electrical and mechanical ' • Exponential Fourier series : x(t) = X (k) ejkwot L
k=-oo
systems.
X(k) = T1 j• x(t) e-J'k·wot dt
Ans. .. The three basic elements in electrical system are inductor,
· al
resistor
· wh.l
and capacitor Ie
the three basic elements in mechanic system are <T >
• (.t:.f
mass, friction and spring. • Multiplication of Fourier coefficients is equi}:)ffleftt to convolution in
Q.23 Differentiate the force voltage analogy and force current time domain. i.e., x(t) * y(t) ~ T X(k) Y (k).
analogy. ~ ( AKTU : 2016-17, Marks 2 J , 00 ,.,
ii) Charge is analogous to Flux is analogous to displacement. Q.1 Define the fourier series and state its importance. Also state its
displacement.
types. ~ [ AKTU : 2006-07, Marks 3]
iii) The analogous circuit is The analogous circuit is based on Ans. : Fourier representation : The signal is represented as a weighted
based on loop basis. node basis.
superposition of complex sinusoids.
iv) The elements under the same The elements under the same Importance : • Fourier series used to analyze periodic signals.
displacement carry some displacement have same voltage
current. across them. • The hannonic content of the signals is analyzed with the help of
Fourier series.
• Fourier series can be developed for continuous time as well as discrete
END...i3 time signals.