Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

452 PART IX  •  NEUROLOGIC DISORDERS

CHAPTER 87 
VESTIBULAR DISEASE
Simon R. Platt, BVM&S, MRCVS, DACVIM (Neurology), DECVN

KEY POINTS • Treatment of vestibular disease is determined by the underlying


etiology, but supportive care is extremely important, especially
• Patients with vestibular disease have dysfunction of the vestibular
during the initial stages of the disease.
system and often are presented for treatment on an emergent
basis.
• The vestibular system is comprised of a peripheral component
within the structures of the inner ear and central components in
the brainstem and cerebellum.
• The common clinical signs of vestibular disease include head tilt,
ataxia, and nystagmus.
• Peripheral vestibular disease can be accompanied by Horner’s Dogs and cats have the ability to control posture and movements of
syndrome and facial nerve paresis. the body and eyes relative to the external environment. The vestibular
• Central vestibular disease typically is accompanied by loss of system mediates these activities through a network of receptors and
proprioceptive and motor function, in addition to multiple cranial neural elements. Disease leading to dysfunction of the vestibular
nerve deficits and mentation changes.
system can lead to dramatic signs of disequilibrium. The investiga-
• The differential diagnosis for the cause of vestibular disease
depends on the localization of the lesion to the peripheral or tion, treatment, and prognosis of the cause of the disequilibrium can
central compartments. differ depending on whether the peripheral or central components
of the system are affected.
CHAPTER 87  •  Vestibular Disease 453

This chapter outlines the relevant anatomy of the vestibular meatus, along with the facial nerve, and enters the medulla of the
system and how this influences the clinical signs of its dysfunction, brainstem.1
in addition to the diseases that are most commonly responsible for
the acute onset of clinical signs. Neuron 2
The cell location for the second neuron is in the vestibular nuclei,
NEUROANATOMY OF THE VESTIBULAR SYSTEM which are situated in the medulla oblongata. From these nuclei, axons
travel in the medial longitudinal fasciculus within the brainstem. The
The vestibular system can be divided into (1) peripheral components ascending axons within the fasciculus give off numerous side branches
located in the inner ear and (2) central nervous system (CNS) com- to the motor nuclei of cranial nerves III, IV, and VI, thereby providing
ponents. Three major CNS areas receive projections from the periph- coordinated conjugated eyeball movements associated with changes
eral sensory receptors of the vestibular system: the cerebral cortex, in position of the head. Some axons project from the nuclei into the
the spinal cord, and the cerebellum. The projection to the cerebral reticular formation and go on to provide afferents to the vomiting
cortex incorporates extensions to the extraocular muscles. center located there.1

Nerve Pathways to the Extraocular Muscles Nerve Pathways to the Spinal Cord
Two neurons make up the pathway responsible for the sensory input The vestibulospinal tract descends from the vestibular nuclei and
of the head to the cerebral cortex (Figure 87-1). projects mainly onto α-neurons or extensor motor neurons through-
out the length of the cord via interneurons in the ventral grey
Neuron 1 column.1 This pathway is strongly facilitatory to the ipsilateral alpha
The cell location for the first neuron is within the vestibular ganglion and gamma motor neurons to extensor muscles.
of the eighth cranial or vestibulocochlear nerve, and the axon projects
into the ipsilateral vestibular nuclei. These neurons receive input Nerve Pathways to the Cerebellum
from the vestibular receptors in the membranous labyrinth con- The vestibular nuclei project directly to the cortex of the ipsilateral
tained within a bony labyrinth in the petrous temporal bone. The flocculonodular lobe (the flocculus of the hemisphere and the
sensory neurons are incorporated into the vestibulocochlear nerve, nodulus of the caudal vermis), as well as the fastigial nucleus of the
which leaves the petrous temporal bone via the internal acoustic cerebellum.1 The return pathway from a cerebellar nucleus to the
vestibular nuclei is also ipsilateral; this is an extremely large projec-
tion, providing the cerebellum with a strong influence over the activ-
ity of the vestibular nuclei. These pathways between the cerebellum
and the vestibular nuclei travel in the caudal cerebellar peduncle.

CLINICAL SIGNS
Unilateral vestibular disease produces asymmetric signs, often on or
toward the side of the disease. The most common clinical signs of
vestibular disease are head tilt, nystagmus, and ataxia; these may be
single entities or a combination of signs.2 The primary aim of the
neurologic examination is to determine if these vestibular signs are
due to a peripheral vestibular system (inner ear) disease or a central
vestibular system (brainstem and cerebellum, or both) disease. Local-
ization of the disease determines the most appropriate diagnostic
tests, the differential diagnoses, and the prognosis.
The essential determination of whether these signs are due to a
peripheral or central disease may be possible by the identification of
associated neurologic signs that are present only with central disease.2
Signs of central vestibular syndrome suggest damage to the brainstem
and are not present in patients with inner ear disease unless there has
been extension of the inner ear disease into the brainstem, such as
can be seen with otitis media, otitis interna, and neoplasia.3

Specific Signs of Vestibular Dysfunction


Signs of vestibular dysfunction are outlined in Table 87-1.

Head tilt
Loss of equilibrium is most commonly represented clinically as a
head tilt that may be present with either central or peripheral ves-
tibular disease. The head tilt is always toward the side of the lesion
with peripheral disease but may be toward either side with central
disease. When the head tilt is opposite to the side of the lesion, it is
termed paradoxical.2 This can be seen with lesions of the flocculo-
FIGURE 87-1  Diagrammatic overview of the neuroanatomy of the vestibu- nodular lobe of the cerebellum or the supramedullary part of the
lar system. (From Platt S, Olby N, editors: Manual of canine and feline caudal cerebellar peduncle, with sparing of the vestibular nuclei in
neurology, ed 4, Gloucester, 2012, British Small Animal Veterinary the rostral medulla; the head tilt often is accompanied by ipsilateral
Association. A. Wright, illustrator.) cerebellar signs, paresis, and proprioceptive deficits.3
454 PART IX  •  NEUROLOGIC DISORDERS

Table 87-1  Neurologic Examination Findings in Animals with Peripheral and Central Vestibular Dysfunction
Clinical Signs Peripheral Vestibular Disease Central Vestibular Disease

Head tilt Toward the lesion Toward the lesion, or away from the lesion with
paradoxical disease
Spontaneous nystagmus Horizontal or rotatory with the fast phase Horizontal, rotatory, vertical, and/or positional
away from the side of the lesion with the fast phase toward or away from the
Rarely positional lesion
Paresis and proprioceptive deficits None Commonly ipsilateral to the lesion
Mentation Normal to disoriented Depressed, stuporous, obtunded, or comatose
Cranial nerve deficits Ipsilateral CN VII deficit Ipsilateral CN V, VII, IX, X, and XII
Horner’s syndrome Common ipsilateral to the lesion Uncommon
Head tremors None Can occur with concurrent cerebellar dysfunction
Circling Infrequent but can be seen toward the Usually toward the side of the lesion
side of the lesion
CN, Cranial nerve.

Bilateral peripheral vestibular disease does not produce asym- middle or inner ear disease causing peripheral vestibular dysfunc-
metric lesions such as a head tilt. A characteristic side-to-side head tion.6 This association is seen because the vagosympathetic trunk
movement is seen instead. synapses in the cranial cervical ganglion deep to the tympanic bulla.
Horner’s syndrome rarely is associated with central vestibular
Nystagmus disease.1
Pathologic or spontaneous nystagmus is an involuntary rhythmic
oscillation of both eyes, occurs when the head is still, and is a sign of Conscious proprioception deficits
altered vestibular input to the neurons that innervate the extraocular Animals with central vestibular dysfunction often have ipsilateral
eye muscles.2 This is in contrast to physiologic nystagmus, which can proprioceptive deficits manifested by abnormal postural reactions
be induced in normal animals. Pathologic nystagmus may be hori- such as hopping and proprioceptive placing. These deficits are due
zontal, rotatory, or vertical. Vertical nystagmus implies a central ves- to the concurrent disturbance of the ascending proprioceptive path-
tibular lesion but it is not a definitive localizing sign. If nystagmus of ways located in the brainstem.
any direction is induced only when the head is placed in an unusual
position, it is known as positional nystagmus, which may be more Hemiparesis or tetraparesis
common with, but not specific for, central disease; this term also may Paresis suggests abnormal neurologic function (weakness) without
refer to nystagmus that changes its predominant direction with complete paralysis, which implies that some voluntary motion
altered head positions.2 remains. Locomotion is thought to be initiated in the brain stem of
Nystagmus occurs with the fast phase away from the damaged animals, so paresis usually is seen with any lesion within the neuraxis
side; the slow phase commonly is directed toward the affected caudal to the level of the red nucleus in the midbrain.3 With unilateral
side. In acute and or aggressive nystagmus, the eyelids may be seen focal central vestibular diseases, paresis of the ipsilateral limbs (hemi-
to contract at a rate corresponding to that of the nystagmus. Nystag- paresis) may be seen if the motor pathways in the medulla oblongata
mus may disappear with chronicity of the underlying lesion, particu- also are affected. A large lesion or multifocal lesions may cause an
larly with peripheral disease, but its presence usually indicates an asymmetric tetraparesis. Paresis does not occur with peripheral ves-
active disease process within the vestibular apparatus. Animals with tibular disease.
bilateral vestibular disease do not have pathologic or physiologic
nystagmus.4 Circling, leaning, and falling
With unilateral vestibular dysfunction, dogs or cats may exhibit an
Ataxia ipsilateral reduction in extensor tone, and contralateral hypertonic-
Ataxia is a failure of muscular coordination or an irregularity of ity, causing them to lean, fall, and circle toward the side of the lesion.2
muscle action. It generally is associated with a cerebellar, vestibular, Falling may occur when the animal shakes its head if there is aural
or proprioceptive pathway abnormality. Animals with vestibular dys- irritation.
function assume a wide-based stance and may lean or drift toward
the side of a lesion if the dysequilibrium is not too severe.4 Altered mental state
Disorders causing central vestibular dysfunction may be accompa-
Signs That May Be Associated nied by altered mentation. The reticular activating system of the
with Vestibular Dysfunction brainstem facilitates the alert and awake state in animals.1 Damage
Facial paresis, paralysis, and hemifacial spasm to this area may cause the animal to become disoriented, stuporous,
Cranial nerve VII, the facial nerve, is involved commonly in the same or comatose.3 Although peripheral vestibular disease does not cause
disease processes that cause peripheral vestibular disease.5 The result- stupor or coma, it may cause disorientation, which can make the
ing signs are those of facial paresis, paralysis or, more rarely, spasm. assessment of the animal’s mental status difficult.

Horner’s syndrome Multiple cranial nerve dysfunction


Horner’s syndrome (miosis, ptosis, enophthalmos, and protrusion of Central vestibular syndrome may be accompanied by other cranial
the third eyelid) of the ipsilateral eye may be present with either nerve dysfunction as well. Clinical signs can include ipsilateral facial
CHAPTER 87  •  Vestibular Disease 455

hypalgesia, atrophy of the masticatory muscles, reduced jaw tone, determine this, a complete history and a thorough physical and neu-
facial paralysis, tongue weakness, and loss of the swallow or gag rologic examination are essential.
reflex. The following tests can be performed in sequence, advancing in
expense and invasive nature until satisfactory information is acquired.
Decerebellate posturing All of the tests may be necessary if central disease is suspected,
In severe forms of central vestibular dysfunction, the underlying whereas cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis and advanced imaging
disease also may cause decerebellate posturing or rigidity; this is may not be necessary if peripheral disease is responsible for the
characterized by opisthotonus with thoracic limb extension, normal vestibular dysfunction.
mentation, and flexion of the pelvic limbs.3 This posture can occur
intermittently and be accompanied by vertical nystagmus, the com- Minimum Database
bination being confused by owners as some type of seizure activity. Hematology, a comprehensive serum biochemistry, thyroid function
Dorsiflexion of the neck sometimes elicits this posture. analysis, urinalysis with culture and susceptibility, thoracic radio-
graphs, and abdominal ultrasonography or radiographs should be
Vomiting analyzed in all cases of acute vestibular dysfunction to evaluate the
The vomiting center is located within the reticular substance of the patient for multisystemic or concurrent disease.
medulla, and there are direct connections to it from the vestibular
nuclei.1 Vomiting may be seen in animals affected acutely by vestibu- Otoscopy and Pharyngeal Examination
lar disease.2 General anesthesia is necessary to examine thoroughly the ears and
pharynx for abnormalities such as exudates and soft tissue masses.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF ACUTE Both ears should be examined with an otoscope. The tympanum
VESTIBULAR DISEASE should be examined for color, texture, and integrity; it is usually dark
gray or brown in cases of otitis. An intact tympanum does not rule
Tables 87-2 and 87-3 outline the overall etiologies and infectious out otitis media, and diagnosing otitis media on the sole basis of a
causes of acute vestibular disease, respectively. ruptured tympanum is also unreliable.5

DIAGNOSTIC APPROACH TO THE ANIMAL Radiography


WITH ACUTE VESTIBULAR DISEASE Radiography is useful for evaluating the osseous tympanic bulla.
Skull radiographs should be performed under general anesthesia to
The approach to an animal with vestibular disease can depend on achieve adequate positioning. This may not be possible always, par-
whether a peripheral or central lesion is suspected (Figure 87-2). To ticularly in the trauma patient. Assessment of the tympanic bulla can

Table 87-2  Etiologies of Peripheral and Central Vestibular Diseases1,2,13


Specific Diseases

Disease Mechanism Peripheral Disease Central Disease

Degenerative — Cerebellar cortical abiotrophy


Lysosomal storage diseases
Anomalous Congenital vestibular disease Hydrocephalus
Intracranial intra-arachnoid cysts
Metabolic Hypothyroidism Hypothyroidism17
Nutritional — Thiamine deficiency
Neoplasia Squamous cell carcinoma Meningioma
Fibrosarcoma Oligodendroglioma
Osteosarcoma Medulloblastoma
Ceruminous gland or sebaceous gland adenocarcinoma Lymphoma
Extension of middle ear neoplasia
Metastasis
Inflammatory or infectious Bacterial otitis interna or labyrinthitis See Table 87-3
Cryptococcosis
Nasopharyngeal polyps
(Cuterebra larval migration)
Idiopathic Idiopathic vestibular syndrome —
Toxic Aminoglycosides Metronidazole
Furosemide Lead
Chlorhexidine
10% fipronil solution (aural administration)
Traumatic Iatrogenic: external middle ear flushing or bulla osteotomy Head trauma
Bulla fracture or hemorrhage
Vascular — Infarction or hemorrhage
Feline ischemic encephalopathy
Cuterebra larval migration
456 PART IX  •  NEUROLOGIC DISORDERS

Table 87-3  Infectious and Inflammatory Central Cerebrospinal Fluid Analysis


Nervous System Disorders That May Cause Vestibular CSF analysis is a useful adjunctive test for determining the cause
Dysfunction1,12,13 of central vestibular disease, although results are rarely specific.
Class of Although serum and CSF antibody titers have been used previously
Etiologic Agent Disease to diagnose infectious diseases, polymerase chain reaction analysis of
CSF can now be performed in specialized laboratories to evaluate for
Viral Feline infectious peritonitis the presence of infectious antigens (rather than antibody titers).10
Feline immunodeficiency virus
Feline leukemia virus The risk of iatrogenic CNS trauma or cerebellar herniation after
Rabies cisterna magna puncture in animals with space-occupying lesions
Pseudorabies should not be underestimated. It is preferable to obtain advanced
Borna disease virus imaging studies of the brain (see the following section) before per-
Distemper virus
forming CSF tap, especially if a caudal fossa lesion is suspected.
Protozoal Toxoplasmosis, neosporosis
Encephalitozoonosis Advanced Imaging
Bacterial Aerobes Computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging
Anaerobes (MRI) have revolutionized the diagnosis of vestibular diseases. CT
Rickettsial Rickettsia rickettsii evaluation of the peripheral vestibular system is particularly useful if
Ehrlichia spp. radiographs have not determined an underlying cause, if nasopha-
Fungal Cryptococcosis ryngeal polyps and neoplasia are considerations and they cannot be
Blastomycosis visualized on physical examination, and if the extent of the lesion
Histoplasmosis needs accurate demarcating and the animal is a potential surgical
Coccidioidomycosis
candidate. CT evaluation for animals with central vestibular diseases
Aspergillosis
Phaeohyphomycosis may be less helpful because of the artifacts relating to the density of
the petrous temporal bones surrounding the medulla (e.g., beam
Parasitic Angiostrongylus vasorum
Cuterebra larval myiasis
hardening).11
Dirofilaria immitis MRI of the peripheral and central vestibular systems provides
excellent multiplanar soft tissue resolution when compared with
Agent Nonsuppurative meningoencephalomyelitis
unknown (presumed viral) CT.11 The improved soft tissue contrast provided by this modality
Eosinophilic meningoencephalitis allows better assessment of neoplastic and inflammatory conditions
Granulomatous meningoencephalitis that result in vestibular dysfunction (Figure 87-3). A typical MRI
Necrotizing meningoencephalitis (Pug, Maltese, study consists of T1-weighted, T2-weighted, and proton density–
Terrier, Chihuahua)
Necrotizing leukoencephalitis (Yorkshire Terrier)
weighted transverse images made before contrast medium adminis-
tration.11 Post-contrast sequences have been recommended if a mass
is present in the tympanic bulla or the external ear canal.

TREATMENT AND PROGNOSIS


be made using lateral, dorsoventral, or ventrodorsal, lateral-20 The damaged vestibular system can compensate over time with
degree ventral-laterodorsal oblique, and rostral-30 degree ventral- central reprogramming of eye movements and postural responses, as
caudodorsal open-mouth oblique radiographic images.7 well as reliance on visual and other sensory input that replaces lost
vestibular input.2,14 If the underlying disease process can be deter-
mined, the prognosis for a functional recovery can be good. Residual
Myringotomy signs, such as a head tilt, are always possible. Recurrences can occur
Myringotomy is the deliberate puncture or incision of an intact, at times of stress, recurrent disease, or after anesthesia.
although not necessarily healthy, tympanic membrane.8 Needle Supportive care is essential, especially because these animals are
puncture and subsequent aspiration through the ventrocaudal part frequently anorexic; feeding tubes and fluid therapy can be vital
of the tympanic membrane allows for collection of fluid from the initially until the patient can self-maintain. Vomiting, salivation, and
tympanic cavity for cytologic examination and microbial culture and nausea associated with vestibular disease can be treated with anti-
susceptibility testing. emetic medications. Drugs commonly used include the phenothi-
azine derivative chlorpromazine (0.5 mg/kg IV, IM, SC q-6-8h in
dogs, 0.2 to 0.4 mg/kg IM, SC q6-8h in cats), serotonin receptor
Brainstem Auditory Evoked Potentials antagonists dolasetron (0.6 to1 mg/kg IV, SC, or PO q12-24h) and
Brainstem auditory evoked potentials testing, also known as brain- ondansetron (0.1 to 1 mg/kg IV, PO q8-12h), metoclopramide, an
stem auditory evoked response testing, can be used to assess the integ- antidopaminergic serotonin receptor antagonist and chemoreceptor
rity and function of the peripheral and central auditory pathways, trigger zone inhibitor (0.1 to 0.5 mg/kg IV, IM, SC, or PO q6-12h or
which allows for indirect evaluation of the vestibular pathways as an IV infusion of 1 to 2 mg/kg q24h), or the antihistamines
because of their close association.9 Brainstem auditory evoked poten- diphenhydramine (2 to 4 mg/kg PO or IM q8h) and meclizine
tials are recordings of sound-evoked electrical changes in portions of (12.5 mg PO q24h; see Chapter 162).2 Recently, maropitant, a novel
the auditory pathway between the cochlea and the auditory cortex. neurokinin type-1 receptor antagonist, has been described as a good
Because of the level of patient cooperation required, sedation or a choice to prevent vomiting in dogs and cats (1 mg/kg SC q24h or
light plane of general anesthesia often is needed to perform and 2 mg/kg PO q24h),15,16 and anecdotally has been effective as an
interpret this test properly.9 adjunctive treatment in animals affected by vestibular disease.
CHAPTER 87  •  Vestibular Disease 457

Stupor or paresis and or


proprioceptive deficits?

No Yes

No Vertical nystagmus? Yes Central vestibular disease

Peracute onset/
Likely peripheral
asymmetric deficits/
vestibular disease
no progression?

Peracute onset/no other deficits No Yes


(e.g., Horner’s)/no progression?

Yes No CT or MRI/
Otoscopy/
 CSF tap
myringotomy/
culture and
susceptibility testing

CNS Consider
inflammatory vascular
Positive Negative disease or disease
findings findings neoplasia

Treat for
otitis media/interna

Radiographs/
CT or MRI
No response/
rapid recurrence
Negative Positive
findings findings

Polyp/
neoplasia/
abscess
Treat for
Idiopathic vestibular otitis media/interna; Surgical
syndrome consider toxicity treatment

FIGURE 87-2  Algorithm detailing the approach to the patient with acute vestibular disease. CNS, Central
nervous system; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; CT, computed tomography; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.
3. Bagley RS: Recognition and localization of intracranial disease, Vet Clin
North Am Small Anim Pract 26:667, 1996.
4. Kent M, Platt SR, Schatzberg SJ: The neurology of balance: function and
dysfunction of the vestibular system in dogs and cats, Vet J 185:247, 2010
5. Garosi LS, Lowrie ML, Swinbourne NF: Neurological manifestations of
ear disease in dogs and cats, Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract
42(6):1143, 2012.
6. Gelatt KN: Comparative neuroophthalmology. In Gelatt KN: Essentials of
veterinary ophthalmology, ed 2, Philadelphia, 2008, Blackwell.
7. Bischoff MG, Kneller SK: Diagnostic imaging of the canine and feline ear,
Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 34:437, 2000.
8. Harvey RG, Harari J, Delauche AJ: The normal ear. In Harvey RG,
Harari J, Delauche AJ: Ear diseases of the dog and cat, Ames, Iowa, 2001,
Iowa State University Press.
9. Sims MH: Electrodiagnostic evaluation of hearing and vision. In August
JR, editor: Consultations in feline internal medicine, ed 3, Philadelphia,
1997, Saunders.
10. Schatzberg SJ, Haley NJ, Barr SC, et al: Use of a multiplex polymerase
chain reaction assay in the antemortem diagnosis of toxoplasmosis and
neosporosis in the central nervous system of cats and dogs, Am J Vet Res
64:1507, 2003.
11. Tidwell AS, Jones JC: Advanced imaging concepts: a pictorial glossary of
CT and MRI technology, Clin Tech Small Anim Pract 14:65, 1999.
12. Munana K: Inflammatory disorders of the central nervous system.
In August JR, editor: Consultations in feline internal medicine, ed 4,
FIGURE 87-3  Transverse T2-weighted fluid-attenuated inversion recov-
Philadelphia, 2001, Saunders.
ery magnetic resonance study of a 4-year-old mixed breed dog with
13. Garosi L: Head tilt and ataxia. In Platt S, Garosi L, editors: Small animal
central vestibular disease and multiple cranial nerve involvement. A
neurological emergencies, London, 2012, Manson.
large irregular lesion hyperintense to the surrounding brainstem is
14. Tighilet B, Trottier S, Mourre C, et al: Changes in the histaminergic system
identified (arrows). Pathologic examination confirmed granulomatous
during vestibular compensation in the cat, J Physiol 573:723, 2006.
meningoencephalomyelitis.
15. Ramsey DS, Kincaid K, Watkins JA, et al: Safety and efficacy of injectable
and oral maropitant, a selective neurokinin 1 receptor antagonist, in a
randomized clinical trial for treatment of vomiting in dogs, J Vet Phar-
macol Ther 31:538, 2008.
16. Hickman MA, Cox SR, Mahabir S, et al: Safety, pharmacokinetics and use
REFERENCES of the novel NK-1 receptor antagonist maropitant (Cerenia) for the pre-
1. DeLahunta A: Vestibular system: special proprioception. In DeLahunta A, vention of emesis and motion sickness in cats, J Vet Pharmacol Ther
Glass E: Veterinary neuroanatomy and clinical neurology, ed 3, St Louis, 31:220, 2008.
2009, Saunders. 17. Higgins MA, Rossmeisl JH Jr, Panciera DL: Hypothyroid-associated
2. Rossmeisl JH Jr: Vestibular disease in dogs and cats, Vet Clin North Am central vestibular disease in 10 dogs: 1999-2005, J Vet Intern Med 20:1363,
Small Anim Pract 40:81, 2010. 2006.

You might also like