History and The Art of Interpretation

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

PHILIPPINE HISTORY

MODULE 1

HISTORY AND THE ART OF WHAT OTHER SOCIAL SCIENCES IN


INTERPRETATION AID THE STUDIES OF HISTORY
✓ Historia in Spanish • Anthropology
✓ Histoire – French • Sociology
✓ Gesichte – German • Philosophy
✓ Kasaysayan – Filipino • Theology
Kasaysayan – rooted in 2 words SEMIOTICS
- salaysay (narrative) & saysay (meaning) - The science of signs and symbols
HISTORY OR KASAYSAYAN - We live in the world of signs and
symbols be it verbal, non-verbal,
• a “narrative that can be written, sexual.
visual or oral or a combination
SEMIOTICS APPLICATIONS
of the three about past events
that has meaning to a certain
group of people in a given time
and place” (Ocampo, A., 2011)
HISTORY IN SAYSAY
• Past – HindSIGHT
• Future – foresight
• Present – synergy to find HERMENEUTICS
inSIGHT - The art and science of interpretation
HISTORY IN INTERGRATED SCIENCE - Deconstruction and Reconstruction
of Ideas and Meanings.
• Interdisciplinary – the
interdependence of sciences BASIC PROCESSES IN
where they are seen to be COMMUNICATION
interconnected and not isolated
from each other. There is focal MESSAGE
science to serve as a lead.
• Multi-disciplinary – the
difference is there are multiple
interconnected sciences
examining in equal terms, a SENDER RECEIVER
certain issue or object of
analysis.
BASIC HERMENEUTICAL PROCESSES INTERTEXTUAL
1. INTERNAL CRITICISMS
World of
the Text 2. EXTERNAL CRITICISMS

World World
Behind Before EXEGESIS
the Text the Text
- The blending process between
the world behind the text to draw
WORLD OF THE TEXT out the contextual meaning.
- Subject (content as it is)
- Theme
- Form: Elements and Style
Contextual World
World of Behind the
the Text Meaning
WORLD BEHIND THE TEXT Text

• History Background
• People Behind the Story, Culture,
Time
EISEGESIS
• Context
- The application of the contextual
- Diachronic Analysis meaning to the contemporary
- Historical Criticism readers be it relevance to certain
- Contextual Reading which personal, social, or global issues
could be in a form of:
Ideological Criticism, Feminist
Criticism, Psycho-Analytic
Contemporary
Realities
Contextual Application confronted by
Meaning derived of Meaning the Interpreters
THE CONTEXT OF JUAN LUNA from Exegesis and Readers
Today

- JUAN NOVICIO LUNA (1857-


1899) -

• History
• Artist
• Culture
• Ideology, worldview, and
perspectives
• Beliefs
• Power struggle
• Intention
HERMENEUTICS APPLICATION o The text is mostly in OLD MALAY
LANGUAGE (similar to the
standard form of the Early Kawi
Script used around the 10th Century
C.E like the OJ Randoeseri
inscription of Central Java, dated 905
A.D)
o There are several technical Sanskrit
words, common to this type of
inscription, and some Old Javanese
words expressing ceremonious forms
ARTIFACT (WORLD OF THE TEXT)
of address, but the main language of
the LC1 is clearly Old-Malay
o According to Dr. de Casparis, an
expert in Indonesian paleography,
this type of script can be found from
Balie (Indonesia) in the East, to
Thailand and Champa (Central
Vietnam) in the West.
o LC1 seems to be a semi-official
certificate of acquittal of a debt
incurred by a person in high office,
together with his whole family, all
relatives, and descendants.
o Dutch anthropologist and Hanuno’o
ARTIFACT – INTERNAL CRITICISM script expert Antoon Postma have
Internal Criticism – appraising the concluded that the document also
meaning and intent of the data source. Much mentions the places of Tondo
of it is engaged into textual criticism. (Tundun); Paila (Pailah), now an
enclave of Barangay San Lorenzo,
Norzagaray; Binuangan
(Binwangan), now part of Obando;
and Pulilan (Puliran).
ARTIFACT – EXTERNAL CRITICISM
o Date and Provenance:
The LC1 bears the Saka date of
882, or 900 A.D which situates it
at the beginning of the reign of
King Balitung of Central Java,
without implying that the LC1
necessarily originated from that
Area (Postma, PhilStudies)
o LCI was found in 1989 near the often together with his whole family
mouth of the Lumbang River near and descendants, thus becoming the
Laguna de Bay, by a man who was victim of a purposeful scheme of the
dredging sand to turn into concrete. onewho lent him the money.”
The man suspected that the artifact (Postma, PhilStudies)
might have some value but found no
buyers. He eventually sold it to the • Value of the Artifact in Sociofact
National Museum of the Philippines, Analysis in the Life of Early
where it was assigned to Alfredo Filipinos
Evangelista, head of its - Artifact Corroborates the Claim of
Anthropology Department. Social stratification existing before
SOCIOFACT the Coming of the Spanish
Colonizers
• World Behind the Text - It can also deconstruct the claim of
- Concepts like gold, debt, slavery, the early Spanish chroniclers that the
and class distinctions occur in the society was barbaric and crude.
LCI
- Gold as indicator of an advanced
society at that time as shown in the
MENTIFACT
narrative of Scott: • World Before the Text
- “The glitter of just such gold - Tagalog: Kung anong inutang siya
chains dangling from Filipino necks ring kabayaran
that first dazzled the eye of the - Cebuano: Utang lipay (happy) kita
Spanish conquistador--those kamagi likay (avoidance) Singil away
as thick as a man's finger and (conflict)
reaching down to the chest” (Scott - Ilokano: Nu inayab na utang
1982, 533) Mapilitan ka agbayad (Kapag
• Debt tinawag na utang sapilitang
- Practice of debt was existing as babayaran)
shown in Postma’s analysis: - Judeo-Christian Tradition shown
“a debt could increase on a daily, in Proverbs 37:21 the wicked
monthly or yearly basis by as much borrows but does not pay back but
as 100 percent or, upon repayment the righteous is generous and gives
within any time period agreed upon, • Utang, Hiya, and Loob
with an increase from 50 to 150 - Pag may utang, nakakahiya at
percent interest. If not paid with mabigat ang loob
money, land property was another - Pag nakabayad, naibalik ang dangal
means of payment, or service to the at pangalan at magaan ang
person indebted to” kalooban
• Slavery of Class Distinctions - Pag di nakabayad, nagkakaroon ng
- In his further examination, Postma sama ang loob, at ang hindi
stated that the “the debtor could nakabayad ay itinuring na walang
legally be forced to become a slave, utang na loob.

You might also like