Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

ScienceDirect
IFAC PapersOnLine 52-13 (2019) 2674–2679

Taxation and revenues of central places as the regulator of available human


resources in manufacturing - related to the bid rent curve
Samo Drobne1, Perta Janež2, Marija Bogataj1,2 , Bogataj David3
1
University of Ljubljana, 2Institute INRISK, Slovenia & 3University of Padua,
Department of Management and Engineering, Italy
1
samo.drobne@fgg.uni-lj.si; 2petra.janez1@gmail.com; 1,2marija.bogataj@guest.arnes.si;
3
david.bogataj@unipd.it

Abstract: Ageing and shrinking of the European population will decrease the availability of human
resources in manufacturing. Therefore, the wage policy will operate in an increasingly sensitive
environment, which will need to be well understood and able to fast respond to its changes. To
understand and forecast the attractiveness of manufacture companies and abilities to attract additional
workers, it is not enough to study wage policy independently, but also to know the real estate market
and the distance of areas from where we can attract new workers. It means, therefore, wage policy
should be tied to the location, real estate market and fiscal policy of a city in which the company and the
real estate market are in order to achieve the optimum effect in finding new employees. In the paper, we
show how useful it is to analyse the bid rent curve of the housing market at the central places through
the changes of parameters in a gravity model. In such a model, the municipalities are considered as the
regional centres, where different regional centres compete for new workers. Namely, the municipalities
represent essential cells, competing with the other municipalities in the total economic area. A
successful fiscal policy leads regions, and local communities along the path of balanced and
environmentally friendly long-term growth or a steady decline analysed through the bid rent curves, but
also influence the availability of human resources. The paper discusses the impact of changes in the
wages, property taxes and municipal revenues on the bid rent curve and attractiveness for migrants.
Therefore, the indicators evaluated through the changes of parameters in a gravity model, which are
subject of the changed wages and taxation policy, gives proper forecasting of the future dynamics. From
all these interactions the inflow of new workers can be forecasted, and the appropriate wage policy can
be chosen as the regulator of available human resources. © 2019 IFAC
© 2019, IFAC (International Federation of Automatic Control) Hosting by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Human resources, wages, taxation, Bid rent curve, municipal revenue, spatial interaction
model, internal migration

factors influence the real estate market which again has an


1. INTRODUCTION impact on the attractiveness for human resources. It means,
therefore, wage policy should be tied to the location, real
The European population is ageing. According to the Ageing estate market and fiscal policy of a city in which the
Report 2018 (Directorate-General for Economic and company and the real estate market are in order to achieve
Financial Affairs, 2018). European workforce will shrink the optimum effect in finding new employees. Therefore, our
for 14 million workers in the next half-century. Ageing and aim is to show how useful it is to analyse the bid rent curve
shrinking will decrease the availability of human resources of the housing market at the central places through the
in manufacturing (Žnidaršič, Dimovski, 2009; Grah et al., changes of parameters in a gravity model. In such a model
2018). Therefore, the wage policy will operate in an the municipalities with the location of companies, looking
increasingly sensitive environment, which will need to be for new human resources, are considered as the regional
well understood and able to fast respond to its changes centres. The regional centres compete with one another to
(Temeljotov Salaj et al., 2015, 2018, Grum, 2017, Bjørberg attract new workers. Namely, the municipalities represent
et al., 2017, Nahtigal and Grum, 2015, Boge et al., 2018). essential cells, competing with the other municipalities in the
To understand and forecast the attractiveness of total economic area.
manufacturing companies and abilities to attract additional The pressing challenge of Slovenia and other EU states is
workers, it is not enough study of an optimal wage policy, to embark on the path of smart, sustainable and inclusive
but also to know other factors which influence attractiveness growth, to develop age-friendly urban environment and
of location to attract new human resources and stickiness to invest in the infrastructure and supply networks that will
retain them (Boge et al., 2018, 2019; Boge and Temeljotov transform European cities to smart cities, creating jobs,
Salaj, 2017). Therefore also other factors which influence wellbeing for older inhabitants who need a help of others,
migration and commuting flows should be considered. These and enhancing competitiveness. In responding to this task,
2405-8963 © 2019, IFAC (International Federation of Automatic Control) Hosting by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Peer review under responsibility of International Federation of Automatic Control.
10.1016/j.ifacol.2019.11.611
Samo Drobne et al. / IFAC PapersOnLine 52-13 (2019) 2674–2679 267

Europe faces large-scale, long-term investment needs, where function influencing the final bid rent curve. This extension
housing and infrastructure investments represent a major made it possible to analyze the housing rent, transaction
part of the gross fixed capital formation. To support required prices and capacity of facilities. Nice simplification is given
policies and for evaluation of potential investments the by McDonald & McMillen (2007, p. 107).
general theory of land rent as a regulator of urban growth As the slope of the bid rent curve determines accessibility
should be reconsidered, the behaviour of the bid rent curve to workplaces and other activities in a space (i.e. commuting
should be better analysed. The impact of investments, as costs as a complementary costs of the land use) and taxation
well as taxation on the monopoly or oligopoly position of additionally influence the slope as presented in Bogataj and
central places, should be studied, and the taxation and Bogataj (1995) the impact of differences in the commuting
investment decision should base on the models of costs and taxation can also be observed through the gravity
attractiveness, stickiness and bid rent curve equilibrium model.
analysis. The bid rent theory is the basic theory in the social
geography for supporting urban studies, developed by
Alonso (1964).

Figure 2. Urban land rent depending on the distance from


the CBD in Alonso’s bid rent theory, creating bid rent curve
(bold).

2. THE IMPACT OF TAXATION ON THE SLOPE OF


Figure.1. Von Thünen’ model of the use of agricultural land
THE BID RENT CURVE
It bases on the von Thünnen agricultural economics on the
With fiscal policy, we can influence the demand and the bid
marginal productivity (fig.1), written in a mathematically
rent slope (Bogataj and Bogataj, 1995), mostly because of
rigorous principles (see edition 1910) and on one of the most
the changed flows of migrants (Bahl, Martinez-Vazques and
important theoretic contributions to the Chicago School,
Youngman, 2010). For example, local communities, with
named “Burgess Zones”, describing concentric circles of
their economic power, are attracting migrants and at the
differing land use radiating from a cities’ central business
same time retaining existing inhabitants. Economic power,
district (CBD), which became a standard concept in urban
among other things, is also facilitated by the revenues of
demography. The theory refers to how the market price and
municipalities from which public services and investments
demand for real estate decrease as the distance from the
in the social infrastructure are financed. Thus, the net result
CBD increases. It states that different land users will
of the migration depends also on real estate taxes and the
compete with one another for land close to the city centre.
level of public services that people are asking. Therefore,
Alonso was looking for a general market balance in urban
the attractiveness of municipalities can be analyzed through
land use, similar to Von Thünen’s balance in agriculture.
demographic trends. Dealing with permanent relocations
According to this theory, households will select a location
between municipalities we can also study the changes in the
where their utility is maximum, that is, the location where
bid rent curve of their central places. The migration is
the usefulness curve touches the price curve. Alonso (1964)
influenced by the indicators of the location of residence as
similarly extends the housing concept to determine the
well as the indicators at the location of possible immigration.
location of an industry and market areas.
Municipalities with different mechanisms influence the
According to his game theory approach, equilibrium is
development of their area, and consequently further
supposed to be achieved when no user of the plot will be
demographic trends. Empirical research enables the advance
able to achieve greater utility or profitability by moving to
knowledge, foresight and forecasting direction of the effects
another location or by buying more or less land.
of demographic trends (Janež, Bogataj, Drobne, 2016).
Muth (1969) and Mills (1972), extended Alonso’s model
George (1948) included in his theory the impact of the
by combining land and capital in utility or profitability relocation of the population to the land rent. He proved that
one of the reasons for the increase in land rent was also an Estate Tax Act - ZDavNepr and the generalized market
increase in the population due to immigration which was values of real estate, estimated value based on the mass
studied on the bases of developed asymmetric gravity model appraisal of real estate (GURS). For estimates based on the
by Janež, Bogataj, and Drobne (2018). Revenues from land mass appraisal we took the latest available data from 2017,
tax are supposed to be used in such a way that all land users other data are from 2015. Calibration of the model of
will benefit from it through the services for residents being migration was carried out for 2015 when there were 212
financed from these sources. municipalities in Slovenia; the register of municipalities is
The model derived here is based on the derivation of the available at SORS. Based on the approach described in
normalised NE_SIM model and proves of Janež, Bogataj, Janež, Bogataj, and Drobne (2016), we first calibrated the
and Drobne (2016, 2018), who had already proved, that the expanded spatial interaction model of inter-municipal
inter-municipal migration and commuting in Slovenia is migrations in Slovenia for 2015.
supposed to be influenced, among other factors, by the The approach used is derived from the previous simple
taxation policy and revenues of municipalities. The proofs model of Cesario (1973, 1974), first upgraded by Bogataj
are based on the data for the year 2011. Based on the data and Drobne (2005) and improved by Drobne in Bogataj,
for the year 2015 the authors here demonstrate the influence (2011), by adding the theory of taxation and deriving the
of land rent taxation, which consequently influences the size influence of taxation on the coefficients in the model of
of the collected revenues of the municipalities and Drobne and Bogataj (2011, Janež et al., 2016, 2018 and
possibility of investments in the social infrastructure, on the Janež, 2017). The general form of the spatial interaction
slope of bid rent curve. From this, it follows that it is model used here is:
important for municipalities to plan carefully the increase in
net migration flows, which will increase the bid rent curve
values and, consequently, their revenues from the taxation of
(1a)
real estate and possibilities to invest in the municipality’s
infrastructure. Similarly, already Chun (1996) claims that Regarding the significance of the coefficients in (1a), we
migration is a means of achieving economic efficiency and have derived the following model
equity, but did not present the advantages of the gravity
models to find the shape of the bid rent curve.
With the approach described in Janež, Bogataj and Drobne
(2016, 2018), the aim of our research is to calibrate the
general interaction model of migrations between the
municipalities of Slovenia for 2015, after the change of
(1b)
taxation on the basis of the provisions in the repealed Real
Estate Tax Act (ZDavNepr, Official Gazette of the Republic In (1a) we denoted the yearly migration flow from the
of Slovenia, No. 101/2013 and 22/2014 - decree) and show municipality to the municipality , is proportional
the approach how to forecast the changes of the shape of the constant, is the coefficient of the time distance from
bid rent curve. the central business district (CBD) of the municipality i to
To analyze the simultaneous impact of the change in the the CBD of the municipality j relative to the average in
taxation of real estate and the time distance on the constant Slovenia , and in the model (1a) are the
net internal migration (stability of flows), we used the coefficient of the studied indicators of in origin and
primary data obtained from Statistical Office of the
destination .
Republic of Slovenia (SORS). Data on migration between
These coefficients are derived as the value in the
municipalities of Slovenia were collected from the Central
municipality divided by the average of Slovenia; the
Population Register (CRP). At SORS we obtained data on coefficients with the required significance are written in (1b)
the number of inhabitants, the number of registered and described in table 1. The sources are available from the
unemployed persons, average gross personal income and the Statistical Office of Republic of Slovenia (SORS,
number of dwellings in the municipality. Data on revenues www.stat.si/statweb ) and Ministry of Finances (MFRS,
of municipalities were obtained at the Ministry of Finance of http://www.mf.gov.si ).
the Republic of Slovenia (MFRS). Data on the average price
of dwellings and the estimated value based on the mass Table 1. The notation of g in the model (1b), the definition and
appraisal of real estate in the municipality were obtained at the sources
the Surveying and Mapping Authority of the Republic of Description Source
Slovenia (GURS). We summarized the time travel through
the fastest route with a car between centres of municipalities, Time distance from CBD of to CBD of Own
by the procedure described by Drobne and Bogataj (2017).
Number of inhabitants in the municipality SORS
In order to calculate the revenues of municipalities in the
case of the introduction of a new property taxation, we The rate of unemployment in the SORS
applied the tax rates from the provisions in the repealed Real municipality
Gross income per capita in the municipality SORS
Urban land rent in a given time distance GURS

Municipality income per capita MFRS

Number of dwellings in the municipality SORS


The powers (the regression coefficients , and of the (4)
linearised model present:
The significance of the values of all written exponents are
α( )------- the impact of the indicator in the destination
very high. All p-values were lower than 0.005.
------- the power of the time distance;
γ( )-------the impact of the indicator in origin. 3.2 The impact of the changed taxation on the bid
rent curve of a chosen municipality
The model (1b) was calibrated by Microsoft Excel 2016.
The taxes have been calculated from the basic data in the Let us now turn our attention back to the bid rent curve. The
database of the Register of the real estate of Slovenia and impact of taxation on the bid rent was explained in Bogataj
calculated by SPSS. and Bogataj (1995) and drown in Bogataj (2000), as given in
In the case that is the yearly urban rent in a certain Figure 3.We see that a household will tend to move to
location, is the interest rate, and is the yearly tax on the another location if the change of his rent curve slope is
basic value of the real estate V, then we can write (Janež, higher or lower from the neighbor’s activity or housing
Bogataj in Drobne, 2016): slope. If the taxes will increase the gross value by 10%, the
household whose slope is now like tg o =0.5 will increase
to tg 1 =0.55.At the same time, the changed taxation will
(2) move the activities line up or down if the attractiveness is
increasing or decreasing respectively.
where is the capitalisation rate (developed from the
basic approach of McDonald in McMillen, 2011).
From (1b) and (2) the following equation has been derived
for the attractiveness of the central place after the changed
taxation ( if the attractiveness during is
known:

(3) The slopes: V1/a=tg 1; Vo/a=tg o

In (3) is the percentage of people who lives in j, Figure 3. The change of slope of the gross urban land rent
is the percentage of the change of the indicator depending on the distance from the CBD in case of
in , while is the percentage of the change changing taxation so that the gross value is equal to the
gross value of the indicator in , due to changed taxation. previous value Vo multiplied by (1+vj /100), which means
present the time of observation, , and forecasting, that it increases relatively for vj /100.
. In a similar way, we can develop the model for
forecasting the expected flows from the origin i. Let us assume that in our considered municipality M,
where yearly migration is equal to 1000 new residents and
where is leaving pM= 0.7% of all inhabitants of Slovenia, the
3. THE RESULTS coefficients of the indicators which influence the
3.1 The results of the gravity model attractiveness of the municipality are the following:

The model (4) is a calibrated model of internal migration


between the municipalities of Slovenia in the year 2015, in
which we observed 44,944 migration interactions. The
adjusted R2 of the regression model is 37%. The values of
the coefficients in the model (4) are very low (significant
at <0.0001), and F statistics are very high (
Let us assume that the municipality intends to raise the
):
yearly rent tax from 7% to 14% which would increase the low predictability of long-term cash flows, needed for asset
municipality’s real estate taxes for 6.5% regarding the liability matching.
average in the state and the municipality income per capita Housing expenditure constitutes nearly one-third of the
for 5%. How will it influence the attractiveness of household's income, and housing wealth makes more than
municipality indicated in the number of newcomers? half of the median household's net worth in Europe. The
Following the equation three at a given value in (4) and (5) macro implications of housing dynamics are significant,
we can write: following one of the largest residential real estate boom-and-
busts and the subsequent recession which additionally
disclosed the specific problems of the ageing European
societies and their dependence on the stable housing market.
Therefore the crucial question in today’s European economy
= 0.9982 0.9774= 0.9757 is: ”How to leverage the European wealth and facilitate the
flows to achieve well-being for all generations (job
It means that an increase of taxation and revenues for opportunities for the young and proper care for seniors)”?
investments in the municipal infrastructure and services, The answer is in the development of a firm understanding of
when the other municipalities do not change the taxation, the interaction between the attractiveness of a municipality
would decrease the migration flow for 2.4% (=1-0.9757). By in the set of competitive local areas. The theory can be
adding the impact of the outflow which can be derived from developed based on gravity approaches. We found that the p-
equation 1b by summation over j on the same way as for (3), values of the estimates of parameters in our model as the
we can see, what are the changes of the monopoly urban level of marginal significance are all lower than 0.005. It
land rent which moves the equilibrium bid rent curve up or helps to improve further a general theory of land rent in the
down. post-industrial age, where the attractiveness depends on the
The model derived here is dterministic. To determine the age structure of inhabitants, and therefore also the bid rent
stability and variations of bid rent curve we have to consider curve is dependent on the age structure. Because the IC
also the stochastic behaviour of this curve, as presented by technology is improving, the distances between homes and
Martínez and Henríquez (2003), often being influenced by workplaces are becoming less and less costly. Therefore the
many subjective factors, therefore sometimes also fuzzy
value of the potential - the power of the time distance
approach to the evaluation of parameters is suggested, like
is approximate to 0. Consequently the relationship between
presented by Bogataj, Tuljak-Suban, and Drobne (2011),
the exponents should be monitored when developing new
where the fuzzy set theory was also facilitated.
technologies and consequently the dynamic control is
needed. Smart technology influence social issues and
4. CONCLUSIONS AND GUIDELINES FOR
parameters, evaluated in our model (Roblek et al., 2019;
FURTHER WORK
Božič and Dimovski, 2019). We have evaluated the values
To embark on the path of smart, sustainable and inclusive α(g) - the impact of the indicator in the destination; -
growth, to develop age-friendly urban environment and the power of the time distance, and γ(g) - the impact of the
invest in the infrastructure and supply networks that will indicator in the origin for Slovenia, but it is easy to find
transform European cities to smart cities, creating jobs, these values for any region or other spatial areas, based on
wellbeing for older inhabitants who need a help of others, the national data, available at related statistical and financial
and enhancing competitiveness, Europe faces large-scale, office.
long-term investment needs, where housing and For further planning and forecasting, the model should be
infrastructure investments represent a major part of the gross extended to the daily commuting, which also can use the
fixed capital formation, but influence also attractiveness and gravity approach. Based on the models outlined here and
stickiness of municipalities, which can be studied on the even extended to the gravity models of daily commuting and
bases of gravity models. To support required policies and for on the interaction of them like presented here, the decision
evaluation of potential investments, the general theory of support systems could be provided to the municipalities
land rent as a regulator of urban growth should be
reconsidered. Recent experience in several European REFERENCES
countries has clearly and painfully shown that the housing
market volatility has a substantial impact on financial flows, Alonso, W. (1964). Location and Land Use. Cambridge:
supply chains and migration in the society, on a wealth of Harvard University Press.
households, and national and international financial systems Bahl, R., Martinez-Vazquez, J., & Youngman, J. (2010).
as collateral for mortgage financing. This volatility Challenging the conventional wisdom on the property
influences the investments in the development, maintenance, tax. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Lincoln Institute of
and redevelopment of urban areas, in public utilities, Land Policy.
Bjørberg, S., Larssen, A.K., Boge, K., Temeljotov Salaj, A.
transport, and ICT infrastructure, and makes institutional
(2017). Contribution of facilities management to value
investors reluctant to invest in city infrastructures due to the
creation. Journal für Facility Management, iss. 14, pp.
7-21
Bogataj, L., Bogataj, M. (1995). Fiscal policy as a regulator George, H. (1948). Progress and poverty: An inquiry into
of urban growth in the spatial structure. In: XXIII IAHS the cause of industrial depressions and of increase of
world housing congress = Excellence in housing: want with increase of wealth. New York: Robert
prospects and challenges in the 'Pacific century: Schalkenbach foundation.
Proceedings of IAHS, Suntec city, Singapore. Vol. 2.pp. Grah, B., Dimovski, V., Peterlin, J. (2018). A shift in
1-9, Singapore: School of building & Estate perceiving organisational metaphors among business
Management. administration students in an EU country : a window
Bogataj, M. (2000) Mobilistika in proctor (= Mobilistics into the current thinking of future employees. Društvena
and Space), Portorož: UL-FPP. istraživanja : časopis za opća društvena pitanja, 27(1):
Bogataj, M., Drobne, S. (2005). Does the improvement of 133-154
roads increase the daily commuting?_ : Numerical Grum, B. (2017). Impact of facilities maintenance on user
analysis of Slovenian interregional flows. In: Zadnik satisfaction. Facilities, 35(7-8): 405-421
Stirn, L. (ur.), et al. Selected decision support models Janež, P. (2017). Policentrični prostorsko-davčni
for production and public policy problems, (SDI-SOR simulacijski model migracij na ravni NUTS 5 in NUTS
series, no. 3). Ljubljana: Slovenian Society Informatika, 3. Doktorska disertacija. Novo mesto: Fakulteta za
Section of Operational Research, pp. 185-206, organizacijske študije.
Bogataj, M., Tuljak Suban, D., Drobne, S.(2011). Janež, P., Bogataj, M., & Drobne, S. (2016). Impact of the
Regression-fuzzy approach to land valuation. Central real estate taxation and municipal revenue on dynamics
European Journal of Operations Research, vol. 19, no. of internal migration: Case study for city municipal of
3, pp. 253-265. Ljubljana. Geodetski vestnik, 60(4), 644–684. doi:
Boge, K., Temeljotov Salaj, A., Bakken, I., Granli, M., 10.15292/geodetski-vestnik.2016.04.615-626
Mandrup, S. (2019). Knowledge workers deserve Janež, P., Drobne, S., Bogataj, M. (2018). Forecasting
differentiated offices and workplace facilities. dynamics of daily commuting to work to other
Facilities, 37(1/2): 38-60 municipality in the case of changing taxation policies.
Boge, K., Temeljotov Salaj, A., Bjørberg, S., Larssen, A. K. Lecture notes in management and industrial
(2018). Failing to plan - planning to fail : how early engineering, ISSN 2198-0772, Cham: Springer, pp. 105-
phase planning can improve buildingsʼ lifetime value 112
creation. Facilities, 36(1/2): 49-75 Martínez, F., Henríquez, R. (2003). A Stochastic Land Use
Boge, K., Temeljotov Salaj, A. (2017). Practice vs theory : Equilibrium Model . Moving through nets: The physical
short-term financials trumps long-term value creation. and social dimensions of travel, 10th International
Journal of corporate real estate, 19(3): 186-204, Conference on Travel Behaviour Research, Lucerne
Božič, K., Dimovski, V.. (2019). Business intelligence and McDonald, J. F., & McMillen, D. P. (2011). Urban
analytics for value creation: the role of absorptive economics and real estate: Theory and practice.
capacity. Int. j. inf. manage., 46: 93-103. Danvers, MA: George Hoffman Publisher.
Cesario, F. J. (1973). A generalized trip distribution model. Nahtigal, D., Grum, B. (2015). Segmentation and the value
Journal of Regional Science, 13, 233–247. frame of buyers of residential apartments. Geodetski
Cesario, F. J. (1974). More on the generalized trip vestnik, 59(1): 71-101
distribution model. Journal of Regional Science, 14(3), Roblek, V., Meško, M., Dimovski, V., Peterlin, J.. (2019).
389–397. Smart technologies as social innovation and complex
Chun, J. (1996). Interregional migration and regional social issues of the Z generation, Kybernetes, 48(1): 91-
development. Avebury: Bruton Center for Development 107.
Studies Series. Temeljotov Salaj, A., Roumboutsos, A., Verlič, P., Grum, B.
Dimovski, V, Grah, B., Colnar, S. (2019). Modelling the (2018). Land value capture strategies in PPP - what can
industrial workforce dynamics and exit in the ageing FM learn from it? Facilities, 36(1/2):24-36.
society. IFAC PapersOnLine, to appear Temeljotov Salaj, A., Maamari, B., Baričič, A., Lohne, J.
Drobne, S., & Bogataj, M. (2011). The attractiveness of (2015). The influence of workplace on overall health in
European regions and cities for residents and visitors. Slovenia and Lebanon - empirical research. HealthMed,
Case study of Slovenia: The accessibility and the flow of 9(7): 281-300.
human resources between Slovenian regions on NUTS 3 Thünen, Johann Heinrich von, (1910) Der isolierte Staat in
and NUTS 5 levels. Ljubljana: ESPON, University of Beziehung auf Landwirtschaft und Nationalökonomie.
Ljubljana & MEDIFAS. Jena: Verlag von Gustav, Fischer
Drobne, S., & Bogataj, M. (2017). The impact of public Zakon o davku na nepremičnine (=Real estate tax law),
investments in facilities on the potential housing market ZDavNepr. (2013, 9. december). Uradni list RS št.
for older persons. Facilities, 35(7/8): 422–435. 101/13, 22/14 – odl. US.
Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs Žnidaršič, J., Dimovski, V.. (2009). Retaining older
(2018). The. 2018 Ageing Report. Economic & workers: fields of action - constituting a comprehensive
Budgetary. Projections for the 28 EU. Member States age management model, J. appl. bus. res., 25(4): 85-98.
(2016-2070). Institutional Paper 079. Luxembourg:
Publications Office of the EU.

You might also like