Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Giancarlo Vibraciones
Giancarlo Vibraciones
Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/energy
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Indirect methods have great potential for engine diagnosis. Several methodologies have been proposed
Received 29 December 2016 in the past in which indirect measurements are used for combustion sensing.
Received in revised form This paper presents the results of the application of a methodology developed by the authors in which
26 March 2017
an accelerometer mounted on the engine block is used to characterize the combustion development in a
Accepted 27 April 2017
Available online 28 April 2017
multi-cylinder common rail diesel engine. The high correlation between accelerometer and in-cylinder
pressure data allowed to use the vibration signals to evaluate the angular positions where: the com-
bustion starts, 50% of fuel is burned over an engine cycle (MFB50) and the combustion process ends
Keywords:
Diesel engine
(MFB95) in two of the engine cylinders. The great accuracy of the predictions (the square value of the
Combustion correlation coefficient was always higher than 0,97) demonstrated that a single accelerometer can be
Vibration used in control algorithms for the optimal positioning of the combustion process in more than one
cylinder.
© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2017.04.148
0360-5442/© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
844 G. Chiatti et al. / Energy 133 (2017) 843e850
acoustic signals may be used for combustion sensing. [6] presents engine specifications are listed in Table 1.
an acoustic approach for the diagnosis of abnormalities in the The engine is equipped with an electronically controlled com-
pressure signal, caused by faults. In Ref. [7], an experimental mon rail (CR) injection system characterized by an unit pump
methodology is presented to extract from the microphone trace the operated by a three-lobe cam that allows to reach a maximum in-
components caused by the combustion events. Some indices are jection pressure of 1400 bar. The injection strategy consisted of two
used to correlate the noise emission to the combustion injections per cycle, pilot and main. The torque output was
development. measured using a dynamometer load cell with a resolution of 1 Nm
The pressure increase caused by the combustion process in the (STIPAF L3B160M). Engine was fueled with commercial diesel and
chamber gives rise to the engine structure vibrations. The vibra- fuel consumption was measured by a gravimetric balance (AVL730)
tions contain information about the combustion phenomenon but at a frequency of 10 Hz and with an accuracy of 0.12%. Inlet air mass
also comprise non-combustion related components; therefore it is flow rate was measured by a hot-wire sensor. In order to monitor
necessary to process the signal in order to extract the combustion the combustion evolution, in-cylinder pressure signals were
related components and reduce the signal-to-noise ratio. Block detected by quartz transducers (AVL GH14P) characterized by
vibration based diagnostic methods have drawn a lot of attention in sensitivity of 15.6 pC/bar and natural frequency of 130 kHz. They
the past. were flush-mounted in the head of all the cylinders by means of
In Ref. [8], the continuous wavelet transform (CWT) is used to glow plug adaptors. The engine vibration measurements were
analyze the correlation between the vibration from a 1.6-L diesel carried out by means of a mono-axial piezoelectric accelerometer
engine and the maximum heat release rate. [9] is devoted to Endevco 7240C. The accelerometer was firmly mounted on the
investigate the relationship between in-cylinder pressure and block surface by means of a threaded pin oriented in line with the
accelerometer signal by means of the application of frequency cylinder axis. The transducer was placed on one side of the block,
response function via a single-input single-output and a multiple- close to the cylinder #1 (looking at Fig. 1, the cylinders have been
input single-output model. [10] and [11] use the block vibration numbered starting from left side, i.e. number 1, 2 and 3). Such a
to determine the in-cylinder pressure peak and its angular location position was selected basing on previous experimental activity
both in single cylinder and multi cylinder engines. devoted to investigate different positions and orientations of the
Literature highlights that most of research activity has been transducer able to guarantee high sensitivity as regards the com-
devoted to the application of accelerometer based techniques for bustion events [12,13]. The sensor sensitivity was 3 pC/g while the
the analysis of the combustion process in single cylinder diesel resonance frequency was 90 kHz. The vibration signal was condi-
engines; alternatively, in the case of multi-cylinder engines, tioned by means of the B&K Nexus device (amplifier and low pass
methodologies have been proposed focused on individual com- filter at 22.4 kHz).
bustion process. For each tested engine operating condition, the cylinder pres-
Prior research activity was devoted to investigate the effect of sure signal of 150 cycles was recorded by a high-speed data
combustion process on the engine vibration. Different positions of a acquisition system (AVL Indimodul) synchronized with the crank-
mono-axial accelerometer were tested and the most sensitive shaft position through the signals transmitted by an optical shaft
location for the transducer as regards the combustion process was encoder (AVL365C) at 0.5 crank angle degree increments.
selected during experimentation on a mono and a two-cylinder Accelerometer and crankshaft position signals were acquired by
diesel engines [12,13]. A methodology was developed in which NI boards type 6110 and 6533 by means of a software developed by
the engine block vibration signal is windowed with the aim of the authors in LabVIEW environment [13].
selecting the contribution due to one of the cylinders and is pro- All the acquired signals were averaged based on 25 cycles, in
cessed in order to remove all components due to sources other than order to attenuate the cyclic irregularities of the engine.
the combustion event. The obtained signal is then used to charac- Before starting the experiments, the engine was warmed up
terize MFB development in one of the cylinders [14]. until the coolant temperature reached 80 C. For all test cases, the
The main novelty of this paper consists in the application of the inlet air temperature and humidity were about 23 C and 45%,
above described accelerometer-based methodology to a three- respectively. The engine was tested in several steady-state oper-
cylinder diesel engine with the aim of obtaining information ating points. In particular, measurements were taken at several
about the combustion progress in more than one cylinder via the engine speeds from 1600 to 3600 rpm with a step of 400 rpm, and
signal from a single accelerometer. The transducer was mounted on at three different loads corresponding to 50, 70 and 100% of the
the engine block close to one cylinder in order to favor the com- maximum torque output (Fig. 2).
bustion process sensing related to one cylinder, whose pressure
development was investigated by extracting information from the 3. Results and discussion
acquired vibration signal. Then, the accelerometer data were used
to extend the combustion characterization procedure to the next The first part of this section presents the results obtained by
cylinder, too. applying the developed methodology to the characterization of the
The results obtained in the complete engine operative field combustion process in the cylinder located close to the acceler-
proved that the developed vibration-based methodology is effec- ometer placement (cylinder #1). Then, results are presented related
tive for remote sensing of combustion process in multi-cylinder to the identification of combustion phasing in the cylinder placed
diesel engines. close to cylinder #1 (cylinder #2).
Fig. 3 shows the pressure development in cylinder #1 over-
2. Experimental apparatus and procedures lapped to the accelerometer trace. It is possible to observe that the
acceleration signal is characterized by low frequency oscillations on
2.1. Engine setup which high frequency components are superimposed. The ampli-
tudes of these last components suddenly increase when the com-
The investigation was carried out on a three-cylinder, six valves, bustion event takes place. The vibration trace is characterized by
1028 cm3, CI engine (Fig. 1) manufactured by KOHLER Engines. It is the same behavior also in the crank angle domains where com-
compact in size and of high performance: maximum torque and bustion process takes place in cylinder #2 and cylinder #3. It has to
maximum power are available at low rotational speeds. The main be pointed out that the pressure development during combustion
G. Chiatti et al. / Energy 133 (2017) 843e850 845
a b
Fig. 1. a: Engine setup, the arrow indicates the accelerometer location; b: top view of the engine (without the tappet cover), the circle indicates the accelerometer.
Fig. 3. In-cylinder pressure trend , accelerometer trace at 3200 rpm, 100% load.
Table 2
Frequency bounds.
1600 550e800
2000 600e900
2400 650e950
2800 850e1150
3200 900e1200
3600 110e1400
Fig. 6. In-cylinder pressure trace , normalized filtered accelerometer trace (3200 rpm, 100% load).
Fig. 7. Cumulated heat release curve and filtered accelerometer trace (3200 rpm, 100% load).
fuel mixture; when the combustion process is completed, the select the combustion contribution of cylinder #1 (Table 2).
excitation ends and the law characterizing the variation of oscilla- The filtration process allowed to keep into the accelerometer
tion amplitude changes. trace the frequency components caused by the combustion events
Once the accelerometer was used to extract information about in the cylinders (the maxima amplitude of oscillations are in the
the combustion development in one cylinder (cylinder #1), the crank angle intervals in which combustions take place). It is
possibility of using the same accelerometer signal to provide a possible to observe that the amplitude of the signals is affected by
characterization of the combustion event in the adjacent cylinder the accelerometer position (the amplitudes related to cylinder #1
(cylinder #2) was investigated. are higher than those related to cylinder #2; combustion contri-
Fig. 8 shows the in-cylinder pressure signals and the acceler- bution of cylinder #3 cannot be detected).
ometer trace. The filtered vibration trace was used to evaluate SOC, MFB50
The effect of combustion on the vibration trend is noticeable, and MFB95 in the engine operative field. The same parameters
even if the amplitude of the high frequency components during the were computed basing on the cumulated heat release curve that
combustion event of cylinder #2 is smaller than that related to was evaluated starting from the pressure in cylinders #1 and #2.
cylinder #1. The ROHR for cylinder #2 was computed starting from Following Figures from 10 to 12 show the effect on the combustion
the pressure measurement and MFB50 and MFB95 were evaluated indicators of the engine speed variation when the load condition is
in the complete engine operative field. Fig. 9 presents the traces constant: plot of Fig. 10 presents the values related to full load
obtained for the condition of 3200 rpm, full load. In the plot, the condition; Fig. 11 displays the data obtained at 70% of load and
filtered accelerometer signal is also shown. The filtration was per- Fig. 12 shows the indicators related to 50% of load. In all plots, data
formed by using the same frequency band that was employed to on x axis show the data computed starting via ROHR, while crank
848 G. Chiatti et al. / Energy 133 (2017) 843e850
Fig. 8. Pressure trend in cylinder #1 , cylinder #2 , accelerometer trace at 3200 rpm, 100% load.
Fig. 10. SOC, MFB50, MFB95: cylinder #1 , cylinder #2 , 100% load, 1600, 2000, 24000, 2800, 3200 and 3600 rpm.
G. Chiatti et al. / Energy 133 (2017) 843e850 849
the mean absolute error values (MAE) of the obtained data were
computed. For each rating-computed pair, the absolute error was
evaluated. By first summing these absolute errors of the pairs and
then computing the average, MAE was estimated. Tables 4 and 5
report the MAE values obtained for cylinder #1 and #2,
respectively.
4. Conclusions
Fig. 12. SOC, MFB50, MFB95: cylinder #1 , cylinder #2 , 50% load, 1600, 2000, 24000, 2800, 3200 and 3600 rpm.
Table 3 ratio did not allow to obtain information about the combustion
Square of correlation coefficient - R2. progress.
Engine speed [rpm] Cyl#1 Cyl#2
The acquired signals have demonstrated that the angular posi- 2015;89:34e42.
[8] Lee S, Lee Y, Lee S, Song H et al. Study on the correlation between the heat
tions where the combustion starts, 50% of fuel is burned over an
release rate and vibrations from a diesel engine block. SAE Technical Paper
engine cycle (MFB50) and the combustion process ends (MFB95) 2015-01-1673.
may be evaluated in both cylinders from the processed acceler- [9] Jia L, Naber JD, Blough JR. Frequency response function adaptation for
ometer trace with high accuracy. These parameters are widely used reconstruction of combustion signature in a 9-L diesel engine. Proc Inst Mech
Eng Part C J Mech Eng Sci 2015;229(17):3071e83.
in control algorithms with the purposes of evaluating the com- [10] Taglialatela-Scafati F, Cesario N, Lavorgna M, Mancaruso E, Vaglieco B M.
bustion effectiveness, in terms of fuel consumption, pollutant Diagnosis and control of advanced Diesel combustions using engine vibration
emission, noise radiation, through its optimal positioning. signal. SAE Technical Paper 2011-01-1414.
[11] Taglialatela-Scafati F, Cesario N, Lavorgna M, Mancaruso E. Use of vibration
signal for diagnosis and control of a four-cylinder Diesel engine. SAE Technical
References Paper 2011-24-0169.
[12] Arnone L, Boni M, Manelli S, Chiavola O, Conforto S, Recco E. Diesel engine
[1] Chung J, Oh S, Min K, Sunwoo M. Real-time combustion parameter estimation combustion monitoring through block vibration signal analysis. SAE Technical
algorithm for light-duty diesel engines using in-cylinder pressure measure- Paper 2009-01-0765. 2009.
ment. Appl Therm Eng 2013;80(1e2):33e43. [13] Chiatti G, Chiavola O, Recco E. Combustion diagnosis via block vibration signal
M, Luj
[2] Jose an JM, Bermúdez V, Guardiola C, Abbad A. A methodology for in common rail diesel engine. Int J Engine Res 2014;15:654e63.
combustion detection in diesel engines through in-cylinder pressure deriva- [14] Chiatti G, Chiavola O, Recco E. Accelerometer measurements to optimize the
tive signal. Mech Syst Signal Process 2010;24(7):2261e75. injection strategy. In: 2012 SAE world congress. SAE Technical Paper 2012-01-
[3] Ponti F, Ravaglioli V, Serra G, Stola F. Instantaneous engine speed measure- 1341.
ment and processing for MFB50 evaluation. SAE Int J Engines 2010;2(2):
235e44. Abbreviations
[4] Taglialatela F, Lavorgna M, Mancaruso E, Vaglieco BM. Determination of
combustion parameters using engine crankshaft speed. Mech Syst Signal
Process 2013;38:628e33. CF: coherence function
[5] Desbazeille M, Randall RB, Guillet F, El Badaoui M, Hoisnard C. Model-based CHR: cumulated heat release
diagnosis of large diesel engines based on angular speed variations of the CR: common rail
crankshaft. Mech Syst Signal Process 2010;24:1529e41. MAE: mean absolute error values
[6] Jiang J, Gu F, Gennish R, Moore DJ, Harris G, Ball AD. Monitoring of diesel MFB50: crank angle degree for 50% of mass fraction burned
engine combustions based on the acoustic source characterization of the MFB95: crank angle degree for 95% of mass fraction burned
exhaust system. Mech Syst Signal Process 2008;22:1465e80. R: correlation coefficient
[7] Chiatti G, Chiavola O, Palmieri F, Piolo A. Diagnostic methodology for internal ROHR: rate of heat release
combustion diesel engines via noise radiation. Energy Convers Manag SOC: start of combustion