Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Accepted Manuscript: Applied Thermal Engineering
Accepted Manuscript: Applied Thermal Engineering
Investigation of PCM Charging for the Energy Saving of Domestic Hot Water
System
PII: S1359-4311(17)37816-X
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2018.04.016
Reference: ATE 12013
Please cite this article as: M. Gorzin, M.J. Hosseini, A.A. Ranjbar, R. Bahrampoury, Investigation of PCM Charging
for the Energy Saving of Domestic Hot Water System, Applied Thermal Engineering (2018), doi: https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2018.04.016
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers
we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Investigation of PCM Charging for the Energy Saving of
Domestic Hot Water System
Majid Gorzina, Mohammad J. Hosseinib,1, Ali A. Ranjbara, Rasoul Bahrampouryc
a
School of Mechanical Engineering, Babol University of Technology, POB 484, Babol, Iran
b
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Golestan University, POB 155, Gorgan, Iran
c
Department of Mechanical Engineering, K. N. Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
In this paper an investigation on the charging process of a phase change material (PCM)
integrated in a domestic hot water system is presented. In order to increase the amount of the
stored energy in a limited portion of time during maximum solar radiation it is preferred to reduce
the melting time of the PCM used in the heat exchanger. Therefore the effect of mass distribution
of a PCM in a multi-tube heat exchanger is studied. Paraffin RT50, is used as the PCM and water
as the heat transfer fluid (HTF) carries the energy gained in solar flat plate collector. Enthalpy
porosity method is applied for modeling the phase change process and an experimental result is
used to validate the model. There are six different cases in order to examine the effect of mass
distribution on the melting time to reach the minimum value. Temperature and heat flux versus
time as well as liquid fraction contours and behavior of the charging process are described. The
results show that by distributing the PCM mass in a specific arrangement in which 40% of PCM
mass is in inner tube, 52% reduction in melting time is achieved hence solar energy can be used
Keywords: PCM charging, domestic hot water system, Heat exchanger, solar
1
Corresponding Author: (M.J. Hosseini) Department of Mechanical Engineering, Golestan University,
P.O. Box 155, Gorgan, Iran, Email: Mj.hosseini@gu.ac.ir
1. Introduction
Rapid increase in economic development all over the world causes strong demand of an
uninterrupted supply of energy. Since there are limitations in conventional fossil energy sources
and the use of the fossil fuels leads to emission of harmful gases, renewable energy sources are
attracting more and more attentions. Therefore, scientists and engineers are looking for
technologies that may facilitate the use of renewable energy sources. One of these technics that
opens the door for the use of renewable energy is efficient application of energy storage systems.
By utilizing effective energy storage systems, the variable and unpredictable gap between the
demand and supply of almost all kinds of renewable energy vanishes. Thus, energy storage is one
Thermal energy can be stored in three different ways; sensible, latent and thermal–chemical.
Latent heat thermal energy storage (LHTES) (in which PCM is a critical component) because of
its several acceptable characteristics such as high energy storage density and small variations in
temperature is the most favorable method for storing thermal energy [2].
Zalba et al. [3] conducted a review on thermal energy storage with PCM, heat transfer perusal and
applications.
Numerical and experimental investigations with different types of PCM containers are published
in several cases. Some of these types are sphere [4–7], rectangular [8–12] and shell and tube
designs [13–18]. The largest portion of these investigations is related to the shell and tube
Hosseini et al. [13, 15, and 16] studied melting and solidification of a PCM in a shell and tube
heat exchanger for different operating conditions. HTF inlet temperature and its flow rate are the
variables that are studied in the paper. Results indicate that by increasing the HTF inlet
exchanger in which the HTF passes through the inner tube and the shell is filled with the PCM,
Low thermal conductivity is the main defect of PCMs that limits the rate of heat transfer during
melting and solidification processes. To overcome this drawback, various methods are developed
for enhancing the rate of heat transfer in storage systems including PCM microencapsulation
[19, 20], applying multiple arrays of PCMs [21,22], diffusing high thermal conductivity materials
[23,24] and exerting nano enhancement phase change material (NePCM) [16,25]. So many papers
investigated applying extended surfaces including fined tubes and multi-tubes arrangements [32].
To enhance heat transfer rate during melting, Adine and Qarnia [26] investigated a shell and tube
system in which PCMs with different melting temperatures are applied. Two-PCM system
(LHSU2) and single-PCM system (LHSU1) were used during melting process and their thermal
performances were compared. Their results show that by increasing the HTF mass flow rate, the
two-PCM system is more suitable just for the lowest inlet temperature of the HTF. Thus, low
values of mass flow rate and HTF inlet temperature can be handled with multiple-PCM units
more efficiently. Experimental results show that the charging rate of the multiple-PCM
cylindrical capsule is more than the ordinary single-PCM cylindrical capsule. A shell and tube
(LHSU) system utilizing various multiple PCMs was theoretically investigated by Fang and Chen
[27].
Also in order to increase heat transfer surface, Rahimi et al. [11] experimentally studied charging
and discharging processes of RT35 as PCM in a finned heat exchanger and the results of finned
heat exchanger and simple heat exchanger were compared. They found that for the heat
exchanger without fin, increasing HTF inlet temperature leads to a faster pace of charging time
reduction in comparison to the similar heat exchanger enhanced with fins. In addition,
discharging time for the heat exchanger without fins is more affected by mass flow than the one
with fins. Rahimi et al. [8] investigated the effects of mass flow rate and HTF inlet temperature
and fin pitch on a latent heat thermal storage system. They found that in both laminar and
turbulence flows, PCM average temperature increases when finned tubes are applied. The results
show that reduction in fin pitch does not affect PCM average temperature sensibly for both
Recently triplex tube heat exchanger (TTHX) using a concentric configuration of the tubes has
been studied for thermal energy storage system [30, 31]. The motivation of using a triplex
configuration is that the generated annulus between the two cylindrical tubes provides a larger
heat transfer area. A comparison between a concentric triplex tube and similar double tube
storage, both having the same inner radius and containing the same amount of PCM, indicated
that by employing a triplex tube heat exchanger, the melting time of the PCM reduces
considerably in comparison with the traditional double tube storage system. Mat et al. [30]
numerically studied melting process of RT82 as the PCM in a triplex tube heat exchanger
(TTHX). They used three methods for increasing the rate of heat transfer in the heat exchanger;
internal fin, external fin and implementation of fins at the both sides. Their results show that
In another paper, Esapour et al. [32] studied melting of a phase change material (PCM) in a
multi-tube heat exchanger (MTHX). The main purpose of the study was to investigate the effect
of number of inner tubes as a geometrical parameter during charging process. The results show
that by increasing the number of inner tubes from 1 to 4, melt region enlarges faster which leads
to dominated convective heat transfer and higher melting rate. In fact, the increase in number of
In this paper, PCM mass distribution is conducted to find the best mass distribution for reducing
melting time in order to use limited time of solar radiation existence. By distributing the mass,
heat transfer surfaces area enlarges and mass of the PCM in each annulus decreases. Considering
natural convection and PCM mass, there must be an optimized mass distribution for attaining
minimum melting time. There are six different cases in order to examine the effect of mass
distribution. At first, the base case, double-tube, is considered as the base case and a comparison
between cases is conducted. Then PCM is distributed between the inner and outer PCM
containers for achieving the minimum melting time. Temperature, liquid fraction and heat flux
versus time and liquid fraction contours are exhibited and explained.
2. Numerical model
In order to simulate phase change phenomenon, the enthalpy porosity method for the three
dimensional model [33, 34] is utilized in a multi-tube heat exchanger. Some assumptions have
Viscous dissipation term is considered to be zero, thus the temperature distribution and
the viscous incompressible flow in the annulus are described by thermal energy equations
PCM. So the density of the PCM is considered to be the average of liquid and solid
Therefore, the continuity, momentum and thermal energy equations can be obtained as follows:
Continuity:
(1)
Momentum:
(2)
Energy:
(3)
Sum of the sensible enthalpy ( ) and the latent heat ( ) is equals to the total enthalpy of the
material:
(4)
(5)
The latent heat content is written as below where is latent heat of the material:
(6)
Where may be a value in the range of zero to . Zero and L signify solid and liquid phases
(7)
The Darcy's law damping term, , as the source term of the Eq. (2) is added to the momentum
equation in order to include the effects of phase change in the convective heat transfer. This term
is defined as follow:
(8)
The coefficient is a large number, usually in the range of - , that is called mushy
zone constant. In the present study is considered to be constant and is set to [13].
3. Model description and boundary condition
Schematic of the domestic hot water system integrated with PCM heat exchanger is displayed in
Fig. 1. A 3D configuration of the studied physical model is exhibited in Fig. 2. The heat
exchanger unit is 1 meter long. The diameter of the HTF tube is 73 mm which is constant for all
the cases. The dimensions of heat storage system are presented in Table 1 and computational
domain scheme is shown in Fig. 3. Different scenarios of PCM mass distribution are shown in
Fig. 4. It is notable that the code after the dash of the cases’ title is corresponding to the
percentage of the PCM in the inner tube. For example PCM-40 means 40% of the PCM mass is
allocated to the inner tube container. The dimensions of the PCM tubes are carefully calculated to
keep the mass of PCM constant for all the cases. RT50 (Rubitherm Gmbh-Germany) is used as
the PCM in this study. Thermophysical properties of RT50 are presented in Table 2. The initial
system temperature is considered to be 25 . Water, as the HTF transfers the energy gained from
solar collector. Water temperature increases up to 75 in the flat plate collector and is assumed
to remain constant until the HTF enters heat exchanger. Total mass flow rate of the HTF is
considered to be 0.087 and the mass of PCM is fixed for all the cases. Outer wall is set to
be adiabatic.
Fig. 1. Schematic of the domestic hot water system integrated with PCM
PCM
HTF
r2
r1
r3
Properties Values
Finite volume method technique is used for discretizing the governing equations of the model. In
order to solve the governing equations, SIMPLE algorithm was employed [35] within a 3D in-
house developed code. The flowchart of the developed code is presented in Fig. 5. Map face
meshing method is applied on meshing style and Grid number and time step for each case are
listed in Table 3 and Table 4, respectively. Grid sizes and time steps that are selected for each
case are shaded in each table.
The resulting curves that confirm the independency of the solution to the grid number and time
step for the case PCM-00 are shown in Fig. 6. Fig. 7 exhibits a cross section view of the case
PCM-40 heat exchanger in which the grids are shown. Under relaxation factor values are set to
0.3, 0.6, 1 and 0.9 for pressure, velocity, energy and liquid fraction, respectively. The values of
the residual convergence for continuity, momentum, and energy are set to .
Table 3. suitable Grid Numbers
s s
Set:
sdsSolving sds
pressure correction equation
Stop
Fig. 6. Independency verification of PCM-20 (a) Grid number independency (b) Time step
independency
Some of obtained results have been compared with the experimental data reported by Mat et al.
[30] to validate the computational model. Fig. 8 shows the liquid fraction versus time for both the
present study and the cited reference. The comparison shows that the results of the present study
are close enough to those of Mat et al. [30]. In order for more assurance of the precession of the
simulation another validation is presented in Fig. 9. Temperature for specific points versus time is
compared with the experimental data reported by Jesumathy et al. [36]. Considering the Fig. 9
HTF
PCM
(b) (a)
Fig. 7. (a) Cross section view and (b) 3D view of the computational grid of PCM-40
Fig. 8. Comparison of the average temperature profile between the present work and Mat et al.
[30]
Fig. 9. Comparison of temperature profile for different locations between present study and
Liquid fraction contours of the cases PCM-00 and PCM-100 for the middle section of heat
exchanger are shown in Fig. 10. Considering Fig. 10, it can be deduced that the dominated
mechanism at initial moments of the process is conduction and as the process progresses, the
melting front enlarges and convection becomes the leading mechanism. It can also be seen that
after 55 minutes, there is no solid PCM in the PCM-100 case while small amount of PCM
remains at the bottom of the case PCM-00. This observation reveals that there are still natural
convection consequences in the case PCM-100 when the last pieces of solid PCM vanishes.
However, the consequence of convection near the remaining solid is negligible enough that the
solid PCM persists in the shell even after 55 minutes. This presence of natural convection heat
transfer, as shown in Fig. 10, results in a reduction in total melting time of the PCM-100 with
respect to PCM-00.
PCM-100
PCM-00 10 minute 20 minute 30 minute 40 minute 50 minute 55 minute
Fig. 11 and Fig. 12 respectively show the variation of liquid fraction, temperature and heat flux
versus time for both PCM-00 and PCM-100. According to the Fig. 11, before liquid fraction of 80
percent, the slope of PCM-00 liquid fraction is more than that of PCM-100. According to Fig. 12,
this trend of variation until t=30 min is due to higher heat flux area of the PCM-00, in comparison
with PCM-100 (in which 80 percent of the PCM is melted). On the other hand, regarding Fig. 11
which also shows the temperature of the phase change material, this higher heat flux is sensible.
In fact, during this portion of time the average temperature of the PCM-00 is about 10 centigrade
degree less than PCM-100 which results in higher temperature difference between the HTF and
the PCM that increases the heat flux. After the moment, the slop of the PCM-00 curve reduces in
a way that the total melting time of this case exceeds that of PCM-100. This variation can be
explained by considering the Fig. 12. In fact, after t=30 min, the heat absorption of PCM-00
reduces more dramatically with respect to PCM-100. This accelerated reduction in heat flux of
the PCM-00 is due to the temperature increase of the PCM and the resultant temperature
As is clear from Fig. 11, in the melting range, a reduction in the slope of the PCM-00 occurs
while this reduction doesn’t hold for the PCM-100. In fact when the inserted PCM in the PCM-
100 reaches to the melting temperature, 40 percent of the PCM has been melted. In fact in this
selection the transferred heat is absorbed via both sensible and latent forms. The sensible heat
absorption by the PCM results in the PCM temperature increase. However, considering the PCM-
00, at the initiation of the melting range, 20 percent of the PCM has been melted; therefore the
PCM absorbs energy mostly in latent form which doesn’t rise the PCM temperature.
Fig. 12. Heat flux through PCM walls versus time for PCM-00 and PCM-100
Liquid fraction versus time and total melting time for all the cases are shown in Fig.13 and Fig.
14. As can be seen in Fig. 14, by changing the PCM distribution between the annuluses, the total
melting time varies. Fig. 13 indicates that as the amount of the PCM in each of the annuluses
reduces the melting time of the related part diminishes which seems to be obvious. It is
interesting that the total melting time assigns to none of the extreme cases but to the case PCM-
40, in which the melting time of the inner annulus almost equals that of the outer one. It can be
concluded from Fig. 14 that there is 52% reduction in the melting time for the case PCM-40
80
70
60
Melting Time (min)
50
40 pcm-in
30 pcm-out
20 pcm-total
10
0
PCM-00 PCM-20 PCM-40 PCM-60 PCM-80 PCM-100
cases
Fig. 15 shows liquid fraction contours for the cases that PCM mass is distributed for the middle
section of heat exchanger. Considering the figure, it can be concluded that by decreasing the
PCM in outer annulus, melting rate increases which is due to the reduction of the PCM in outer
side where that heat transfer area constant and due to the small thickness of the PCM, the leading
heat transfer mechanism is conduction. As can be seen in the inner tube, although the heat
transfer area is enlarged, the effect of the amount of PCM is more pronounced on the melting
process.
Liquid fraction versus time of both inner and outer sections of the case PCM-40 is shown in Fig.
16 separately. As can be seen, the slope of the outer-annulus-related curve is more than its
corresponding counterpart until the moment of 80 percent progression of phase change. After this
moment the slope of the outer-annulus-related curve reduces. This trend, as shown, holds for all
the cases. However, the only difference is that in this case, the distribution leads to almost equal
melting in the both annuluses. The slope of this curve is more than the case in which all the PCM
is in the inner annulus and the total melting time of this optimum distribution is not as long as the
Fig. 17 illustrates PCM liquid fraction along the heat exchanger in outer section of the case PCM-
40 in a 3D view. As can be seen in the Fig. 17, as the HTF passes through the pipe along the heat
exchanger liquid fraction of the PCM decreases. By comparing among all the cases, it reveals that
this trend is the same for all cases. This is due to the fact that the HTF loses energy as flows along
the heat exchanger. Therefore, the flow reaches its minimum energy level at the end of the heat
exchanger so the least liquid fraction would occur at the ending section of heat exchanger.
5 min
15 min
20 min
25 min
Fig. 17. 3D PCM liquid fraction along heat exchange of the outer tube for PCM-40 r
6. Conclusion
In the present paper a PCM heat exchanger integrated in a solar water heater system was studied.
Charging process of RT-50 as the phase change material on a shell and multi-PCM-tube by
heated water from flat plate solar collector is studied to find the best PCM distribution between
Heat transfer rate in the case that all the PCM is in the inner tube, is more stable than the
considering melting pattern of phase change, it is obvious that convection governs the
Melting time in a simple shell and tube is considerably large but by distributing the PCM
between inner tube and outer shell, heat transfer surface enlarges and in a specific
arrangement in which 40% of PCM mass is in inner tube, minimum melting time is
Maximum PCM temperature is achieved in the case that all the PCM is in the inner tube
which is higher than the one which assigns the whole PCM to the outer shell.
Nomenclatures
Gravity (m/s2)
Source term
Temperature (K)
Greek symbols
Liquid fraction
Density (kg/m3)
Subscripts
Mushy zone
Melting
Solid
Liquid
References
different shape containers: A review, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 43 (2015) 449-
477.
evaluation of longitudinally finned latent heat thermal storage systems, Energy and Buildings 99
(2015) 263-272.
[3] B. Zalba, J. M. Marin, L. F. Cabeza, H. Mehling, Review on thermal energy storage with
phase change materials, heat transfer analysis and applications, Applied thermal engineering 23
[4] W. Li, S.G. Li, S. Guan, Y. Wang, X. Zhang, X. Liu, Numerical study on melt fraction during
Energy (2017).
[5] J.N Ehms, R.D.C. Oliveski, L.O. Rocha, C. Biserni, Theoretical and numerical analysis on
phase change materials (PCM): A case study of the solidification process of erythritol in
spheres ,International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 119 (2018) 523-532.
[6] J.N Ehms, R.D.C. Oliveski, L.O. Rocha, C. Biserni, Theoretical and numerical analysis on
phase change materials (PCM): A case study of the solidification process of erythritol in
spheres ,International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 119 (2018) 523-532.
[7] L. Navarro, C. Barreneche, A. Castell, D.A. Redpath, P.W. Griffiths, L.F. Cabeza, High
density polyethylene spheres with PCM for domestic hot water applications: Water tank and
[8] M. Rahimi, A.A. Ranjbar, D.D. Ganji, K. Sedighi, M.J. Hosseini, R. Bahrampoury, Analysis
of geometrical and operational parameters of PCM in a fin and tube heat exchanger, International
density polyethylene spheres with PCM for domestic hot water applications: Water tank and
[10] L. Navarro, C. Barreneche, A. Castell, D.A. Redpath, P.W. Griffiths, L.F. Cabeza, High
density polyethylene spheres with PCM for domestic hot water applications: Water tank and
investigation of phase change inside a finned-tube heat exchanger, Journal of Engineering (2014)
in a rectangular storage unit heated by upward heat transfer fluid, Energy Procedia 139 (2017) 86-
91.
computational study on the melting behavior of a medium temperature phase change storage
material inside shell and tube heat exchanger, International Communications in Heat and Mass
[14] S. Seddegh, X. Wang, M.M. Joybari, F. Haghighat, Investigation of the effect of geometric
and operating parameters on thermal behavior of vertical shell-and-tube latent heat energy storage
shell and tube heat exchanger as a PCM thermal storage system, International Communications in
phase change material inside shell and tube heat exchanger, Journal of Engineering (2013)
heat transfer characteristics of paraffin wax in horizontal double pipe heat latent heat storage unit,
[18] A. Pizzolato, A. Sharma,K. Maute, A. Sciacovelli, V. Verda, Design of effective fins for fast
PCM melting and solidification in shell-and-tube latent heat thermal energy storage through
[19] N.S. Roberts, R. Al-Shannaq, J. Kurdi, S.A. Al-Muhtaseb, M.M . Farid, Efficacy of using
[20] W. Zhao, A. F. Elmozughi, A. Oztekin, S. Neti, Heat transfer analysis of encapsulated phase
change material for thermal energy storage, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 63
(2013) 323-335.
[21] H. Wang, Z. Liu, H. Wu, Entransy dissipation-based thermal resistance optimization of slab
LHTES system with multiple PCMs arranged in a 2D array. Energy, 138, (2017) 739-751.
[22] Y. Q. Li, Y. L. He, H. J. Song, C. Xu, W. W. Wang, Numerical analysis and parameters
optimization of shell-and-tube heat storage unit using three phase change materials, Renewable
space: Scale analysis and heatline tracking, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 119
(2018) 841-859.
material solidification in a rectangular latent heat storage unit including natural convection,
studies of a latent heat storage system containing nano-enhanced phase change material, Thermal
heat storage unit using phase change materials, Applied mathematical modelling 33 (2009) 2132–
2144.
[27] M. Fang, G. Chen, Effects of different multiple PCMs on the performance of a latent thermal
viscosity of liquid by dispersing ultra-fine particles, Netsu Bussei 7 (4) (1993) 227–233.
transfer for PCM melting in triplex tube with internal-external fins, Energy Conversion and
[31] A.M. Sefidan, A. Sojoudi, S.C. Saha, M. Cholette, Multi-layer PCM solidification in a
finned triplex tube considering natural convection, Applied Thermal Engineering (2017).
diffusion phase change: application to the melting of a pure metal, Numerical Heat Transfer 13
(1988) 297-318.
dominated melting in a rectangular cavity with an isothermal vertical wall, Applied Thermal
[35] S. V. Patankar, Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow, Hemisphere, Washington, DC,
USA, (1980).
[36] S. P. Jesumathy, M. Udayakumar, S. Suresh, and S. Jegadheeswaran., An experimental study
on heat transfer characteristics of paraffin wax in horizontal double pipe heat latent heat storage
Highlights: