Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GEJD21 Mona Al Abbassiand Solomon Arulraj David
GEJD21 Mona Al Abbassiand Solomon Arulraj David
GEJD21 Mona Al Abbassiand Solomon Arulraj David
net/publication/355171356
CITATIONS READS
0 15
2 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Transformation of higher education and the impacts on teaching and learning View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Solomon Arulraj David on 11 October 2021.
Abstract Introduction
This study aimed to explore the impact of In the education system, the role of a teacher is not
continuous professional development on hidden and when the teacher comes with a
teachers’ performance. In particular, it developed and professional background it makes
explored teacher’s experiences in a private the education system more efficient and effective.
school in Dubai. Social development theory On students learning some things like facilitating
and organizational development theory were teachers in activities related to professional
supportive to form relevant understanding development and taking chances for innovation by
needed to develop the study. Supportive teachers have a positive effect. To increase the
related studies were explored that are well achievements of students an instructional leader
situated in the topic explored. The data was must support their teachers and encourage them to
collected using a survey questionnaire among improve their teaching practices. New skills are
150 teachers in a private school in Dubai. The being practiced by teachers in classrooms under
participants in the study were selected using this support, combining their sessions learning. The
random sampling technique. The collected job of an instructional leader is to gather the people
data was analyzed using descriptive statistics with this expertise to give access to teachings to
along with correlation and regression analysis. them in everything. The teachers are being
The findings indicated significant impacts of supported by the instructional leaders because they
continuous professional development and provide them with the resources and materials
increase in teachers’ performance. Based on required by them. For their staff, instructional
findings, it is recommended to widely leaders are resources of instructions. The principal
implement continuous professional as a resource of instruction keeps a check on the
development that will enhance teachers’ trends of the assessments and curriculums. (37).
performance. It is also recommended to enrich Instructors must be familiar with the terrain of the
the professional development programs by changes happening in their field and embrace this
setting lofty standards. The case study is the their curriculum, pedagogy, and assessment (19).
limitations of the study as it only offered There are positive effects on student learning when
insights on the case studied, which may or teachers are being supported in their work. The
may not be similar in other cases. Therefore, it level of responsibility of teachers, students, parents,
is suggested to consider multiple cases in and the community are high on the leader of the
future. school.
107
induction programs for teachers to teach them the Further, (8) research studied that, young teachers
best practices (12). are more involved in the professional development
activities which explain that more experienced
The learning techniques used by teachers are teachers show less interest in professional
affected by the development in the professional development as compared to less experienced ones.
activity, participation in seminars, and duration of Teachers can teach effectively and implement their
their learning sessions. Professional development teaching profession more precisely if they have
has been considered as regular task form past years, attended training and induction programs, and
but research studies has found it more than just improved students’ learning is also provided by
one-day training. Recent studies have explained them (12).
that professional development for a teacher is the
way of sharing information with the students Furthermore, there are many important activities
(Bautista et al., 2017, 39). Some researchers (28 & included in the induction of a new teacher which
39) have argued that the short- and long-term includes an orientation session for them, periods
activities can be compared where more for collaboration with faculty, supervisor’s
opportunities for active learning and collaboration meetings, and workshops for their development,
among the teachers can be discussed. Another some reduction in their workload and mentoring
study has revealed that if teachers enrolled also. The guidance usually provided to the new
themselves into the professional developmental teachers in the school by the seasoned veterans is
activities, they are more likely to provide known as mentoring. A dominant form of teacher
opportunities for the students where students can induction is teacher mentoring from the last few
discuss their content and misconceptions (26). decades as stated in research. And these two terms
are used for one another. As stated by Zey in his
Research studies have suggested that such teacher development theory, on the practice of
professional developmental activities leave a teachers and the achievement of the students the
positive impact on the teaching profession because preparation and induction of teachers had an impact
they get to know about new practices of getting (15). The probability that teachers will remain in
feedback from the students which in return helps their profession is increased because of the high
them to improve their teaching style. Research quality of professional development like in the
work done on the teaching and learning form of mentoring and induction. Furthermore,
international survey involves the forms of many studies conflict with this study and argue that
professional development where nine different the direct impact of this mentoring and induction is
choices were provided to the teachers so that they not unlimited (12). Some of the studies (13, 28 &
can choose their respective option including 44) also stated that there is a drawback of
workshops, conferences, seminars, qualification mentoring as it affects the ability of teachers like
programs, participation in international teaching managing time and managing workloads and
network, research collaboration and many others affects his management skills regarding
(28). Some other studies have also inserted classrooms. The research states that the
information regarding such choices which has characteristics of the induction program had a
provided teachers with a way to choose a course for strong impact on the influence experienced by the
themselves and start learning through professional teachers on their professional development, these
development activities. However, research studies programs are good enough for the professional
have not found it easy for the teachers to adopt the development of the beginning teachers, but it fails
professional development activities as the to do all this because there are some of the essential
organizational budget may not support the teachers characteristics missing in this.
and they must do it on their own. All the funding
cost might be sustained by the teachers, and they The impact of professional development on student
must look after each policy and campaign related to learning is less as compared to its impact on the
the professional development campaign (35). changes in the actual behaviour of the teacher and a
profound impact on the changes in teacher learning
Some successful factors impacting the professional (13 & 27). There is a positive association between
development implementation positively involve teachers and teacher professional development.
collaboration among the teachers and the Changes in the practices in the classrooms and
organizations. Another study (28) in teaching and community in the activities and time are seen
learning international survey analysed that the because of the self-report and it also increases the
participation of teachers in professional knowledge and skills. The impact of teachers’
development helps examine the characteristics of professional development on teacher’s instructional
the students. The difference between the interest practices will be proven from the literature review
level of males and females in a country can be stated above with the quantitative evidence.
noticed while working on the international survey. According to research, it is important to provide
108
opportunities for the professional development of technology use supports their professional practices
students in schools as it will lead to improving the (13).
quality of teachers and the learning power of
students (17). According to the national council of Methodology
staff development professional development is A good methodology chapter in any research is
among the high standard and quality-based judged not only by what choices were made to
programs which further provide support to collect or analyze the data but also clearly explains
individuals in their jobs and help them in why these choices were made in the first place. A
implementing their skills while dealing with research methodology should scientifically prove
financial problems (38). According to research findings that make the research look credible,
done by Hill and Beiseigel, the achievements and reliable, and valid. In this research of impact of
success of a student are related to his or her professional development on the performance of
professional development. Professional teachers, the research methodology has been
development not only helps individuals in the discussed under the following headings (24). A
development of different other skills such as it research design is a research approach is a well-
creates a positive work environment within organized and methodological procedure used by
schools, but it also makes them a responsible researchers and scientists to conduct a
citizen and helps them in learning under peer methodological, scientific, and factual study. It
pressure from their colleagues. The experience of a helps form comprehensive research of already
teacher is defined as the number of days, weeks, or identified components, including any other data or
years an individual has been working as a teacher information that helps lead to a reasonable outcome
within any educational institute (32). The or result. The research design requires to follow an
experience of a teacher is linked to the success of already well-thought-out and pre-planned
the student. methodology that is in accordance with the type of
research to be conducted, which is also selected
Professional knowledge of a teacher is defined as beforehand. But all of this is done to produce an
the knowledge a teacher has regarding curricular authentic, error-free conclusion (43).
activities, specific subject, or any specific topic.
The professional knowledge is based on graduate, The qualitative research approach is defined as a
undergraduate or master level degrees a teacher method that focuses on obtaining information or
has, his or her schooling, college, attended hours in data through open-ended interviews or
college or in any learning space training program communication done in the form of a conversation.
attended by the teachers and other opportunities of This approach is beneficial because it provides data
experience being availed by an individual during that gives an insight into the 'why' in addition to the
his or her growing age is the real definition of 'what.' Without a qualitative approach, we can
professional development (25). Different research know exactly what people are thinking but why we
has concluded that along with witty experience, are thinking or why a particular phenomenon is
advanced degrees, good schooling, specialization in taking place cannot be known. (29) The
a particular subject and involvement in different quantitative research approach is a systematic
training programs has also a very intense impact in analysis and assessment of phenomena by
success of a teacher. Studies conducted in different gathering quantifiable data and performing
countries have suggested that those degrees of a mathematical, statistical, and computational
teacher play a significant role in the outcomes of methods. Quantitative research involves collecting
students at a school. Furthermore, it has been information from potential or existing sampling
observed that professional development can help groups by using sampling techniques and sending
teachers in improving their ability to communicate out questionnaires, online polls, and service. The
and to provide instructions, but these experiences results that are concluded are mostly in a numerical
have little association with the success or form. (40) The primary quantitative research
effectiveness of a teacher. However, in secondary method includes four distinct types: survey
school such as in mathematics teachers who have research, correlational research, causal-comparative
gained experience based on different training research, and experimental research. The secondary
programs can affect outcomes of students in a quantitative research methods also include four
positive way more than the teachers of higher types, such as the conjoint analysis, TURF
grades. According to a study being conducted to analysis, cross-tabulation, and SWOT analysis.
determine the impact of professional development Quantitative research focuses on collecting
on overall success for students, it has been numerical or quantitative data and then
observed that there exists a positive relationship generalizing the results across the groups of people
between the professional development and success to help explain or understand a specific
of students (32). Relevant support to make teachers phenomenon. This study uses a quantitative
familiar with learning management system and research approach based on a survey questionnaire
109
(7). Data collection is a method or a process where from every person of that group. Instead, a sample
information on different variables of interest to the is selected. The sample involves a group of
researcher is gathered and measured. It is done individuals who intends to participate in the study
systematically, enabling the researcher or someone or research. For the researcher to draw reliable and
else to evaluate the hypothesis, evaluate and assess valid conclusions from the results, he or she must
various outcomes, and answer research-related carefully decide how to select a particular sample
questions. The data collection method is commonly that is representative of the population they want to
used in different fields of studies like social and conduct the research on. The data in this research is
physical sciences, business, humanities, etc. The to be collected with the help of a structured
data collection methods might vary in terms of questionnaire composed based on 5-point Likert
discipline. Still, the emphasis and importance of scale.
ensuring that the sample's data remain honest and
accurate stay the same (10). Data analysis refers to the application of analytical
and statistical techniques in a systematic form to
In contrast, the data collection methods in describe and explain the scope of the data,
qualitative research usually produce data obtained condensing the representation of data, illustrating
from a smaller number of people compared to data with the use of tables, graphs, and images,
many people in quantitative analysis that is modularizing the structure of data, and evaluating
incredibly detailed and can provide insights that a statistical or logical inclinations to derive to
researcher cannot usually get when he or she does meaningful results and conclusions. Quantitative
quantitative research. It is crucial to choose the data analysis is done in the form of numbers and
right data collection technique because it can make statistical representations of the information that is
all the difference when a conclusion or the research collected from the sample. The quantitative data
findings are drawn. There are four different analysis is presented in terms of statistical
techniques for collecting information or data for manipulation and measurement scales (14).
research, including a questionnaire, focus group Statistics include validation, interpretation, and
discussion, observation, and interview. This data collection. Statistical data analysis is a method
research includes the population of teachers where several statistical and mathematical
working in UAE. The sample of this study will operations are performed to be quantified and
consist of the 150 teachers working in the private statistical analysis as applied. The Diagnostic data
school sector of UAE. The data of the case is analysis is one step further to statistical data
primary which will be collected using a structured analysis because it provides an incredibly in-depth
questionnaire in this regard. Sampling is a method analysis and interpretation of the researcher's
that enables researchers to get information about a questions. Diagnostic data analysis helps determine
population that they can achieve from the result of causal relationships, drilling into the discovery of
a small group or subset of the entire population. the Analytics, and identifying any kind of
This is beneficial because one can collect all the anomalies. Validity and reliability or both are used
required information without collecting data or in evaluating the quality of a particular study or
investigating every individual of the population. research. This indicates how well a technique, test,
There are various kinds of Sampling methods and or a method measures the variable that the
techniques that are available for researchers, which researcher wants to measure. Reliability is about
they can choose or select according to the needs or how consistent measurement is, and validity is
requirements of their research. But all these various about how accurate measurement is. It is important
sampling techniques are subdivided into two for the researcher to consider the validity and
groups of sampling, such as Probability and non- reliability whenever he or she creates a research
probability sampling. design, plants the methods to be used, and writes or
conclude the results, especially when it comes to
Probability sampling referrals to the Random quantitative research. In case of this research, the
selection of people or individuals that allows the reliability of the data has been performed using
researcher to make inferences that are statistical Cronbach’s Alpha through IBM SPSS (41). This
and logical about the whole group. In comparison, study follows a quantitative research methodology
non-probability sampling refers to the non-random for which discussion and outcomes have been
selection of people, which is based on several discussed in the next chapter. The trustworthiness
criteria, for example, convenience, preferences, or of the quantitative research can be performed using
any other allowing the researcher to collect the techniques like external validity, internal validity,
initial information or data easily (2). Whenever a objectivity, and reliability.
researcher wants to conduct research about a
phenomenon that involves having to collect Results, Analysis and Discussion
information from a group of people or a particular This chapter contains a brief description of the
population, it is impossible for them to collect data research variables, model and the survey
110
instrument used followed by the results of the study the purpose of data collection. While drawing the
using descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, results of this study, the following variables were
regression analysis and the reliability analysis. A used:
sample of 150 private school teachers was used for
111
demographic dimensions of the population under demographic analysis has been performed under
study are observed. The demographic attributes the following two tables of Gender Analysis and
include the gender, age, income level and religious the Analysis of Respondent Age.
affiliation etc. In the case of this study, the
Gender
Frequenc Per
y cent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
V Male 78 52.0 52.0 52.0
al Femal 72 48.0 48.0 100.0
id e
Total 150 100.0 100.0
Table 3: Gender
The above table of gender states that a total of 150 participants is seventy-two. This indicates that most
individuals participated in the survey conducted for of the population consists of male members
research purposes. The count of male participants working in the private school sector of the UAE.
is seventy-eight whereas the count of female
Age
Frequenc Per
y cent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
V 20-25 38 25.3 25.3 25.3
al Years
id 25-30 24 16.0 16.0 41.3
Years
30-35 49 32.7 32.7 74.0
Years
35-40 39 26.0 26.0 100.0
Years
Total 150 100.0 100.0
Table 4: Age
The above table indicates the distribution of standard deviation in this regard. In the case of TP,
participants based on their age. The highest the minimum value is two and the maximum value
percentage of survey participants belongs to the age is five whereas the mean value is 3.27 along with a
group of 30 years to 35 years. Descriptive statistics standard deviation of 1.174. In the case of PD, the
are used for describing some of the most basic minimum value is three and the maximum value is
characteristics or features of the data collected for a five whereas the mean value is 3.69 along with a
study. They are used for providing simple standard deviation of 0.9550. In the case of PPD,
summaries about the measures and the sample. By the minimum value is three and the maximum
using graphics analysis, it can easily provide the value is 4.3 whereas the mean value is 3.584 along
simple basis of every quantitative analysis that is with a standard deviation of 0.4869. In the case of
required for a given data. The descriptive statistics IPD, the minimum value is one and the maximum
of this study has been determined using IBM SPSS value is four whereas the mean value is 2.711 along
and a total of 150 responses were processed. The with a standard deviation of 1.2789.
key outcomes are minimum, maximum, mean, and
Descriptive Statistics
Minimu Maximu Mea
N m m n Std. Deviation
TP 15 2 5 3.27 1.174
0
PD 15 3.0 5.0 3.69 .9550
0 3
PPD 15 3.0 4.3 3.58 .4869
112
0 4
IPD 15 1.0 4.0 2.71 1.2789
0 1
Valid N 15
(listwise) 0
Correlations
TP PD PPD IPD
T Pearson Correlation 1 -.169* -.128 .322**
P Sig. (2-tailed) .039 .119 .000
N 150 150 150 150
P Pearson Correlation -.169* 1 .624** -.978**
D Sig. (2-tailed) .039 .000 .000
N 150 150 150 150
P Pearson Correlation -.128 .624** 1 -.720**
P Sig. (2-tailed) .119 .000 .000
D N 150 150 150 150
I Pearson Correlation .322** -.978** -.720** 1
P Sig. (2-tailed) .000 .000 .000
D N 150 150 150 150
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
Table 6: Correlation Analysis
Regression analysis is a collection of statistical linear and simple linear regression analysis. This
approaches or methods that are used to estimate the study contained one dependent and three
relationship between one or more independent independent variables. Hence, multiple regression
variables and a dependent variable. This statistical analysis techniques were used, and the model
approach is most used to align the strength of the summary indicates a coefficient of determination of
relationship or association between the two kinds 1.00 which means 100% of the variation in the
of variables and for modelling any future dependent variable is caused by independent
relationship between the two variables. There are variables. Based on the model summary, the
several variations of regression analysis for relationship between the variables of this study is
example multilinear, linear, and non-linear. The significant.
most common among these variations is multi-
Model Summary
M
od R
el R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate
1 1.000 1.000 1.000 .000
a
113
The ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) table has been significance of the research model as the p-value
given as follows which indicates the overall (0.000 < 0.05) is less than the level of significance.
ANOVAa
Mean
Model Sum of Squares df Square F Sig.
1 Regressio 205.197 3 68.399 0.00 0.000
b
n 0
Residual .000 14 .000
6
Total 205.197 14
9
a. Dependent Variable: TP
b. Predictors: (Constant), IPD, PPD, PD
Table 8: ANOVA
The individual coefficient summaries have been variables are significant as the individual
presented as follows which indicates that all coefficients are significant at 0.05.
Coefficients
Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig.
Model B Std. Error Beta
1 (Constant - .000 . 0.00
) 46.417 0
PD 6.583 .000 5.357 . 0.00
0
PPD 2.667 .000 1.106 . 0.00
0
IPD 5.833 .000 6.357 . 0.00
0
a. Dependent Variable: TP
114
Reliability Statistics
N of
Cronbach's Alphaa Items
-.854 6
Table 11: Cronbach's Alpha
The value of Cronbach’s Alpha is -0.854 based on the respondents belonged to the age group of
six data sets which have been included in the 30 to 35 years in this regard.
analysis. The objective of this study is to determine 2. The data analysis also revealed that the
the impact of professional development and its average values of study variables fall between
related factors on the performance of private school 2.7 to 3.6 in this case. The range of standard
teachers. Based on the findings of the study, it has deviation of the variables is between 0.48 to
been concluded that professional development is a 1.27 in the given case.
significant predictor of the teacher's performance in 3. The correlation analysis and the regression
the private school sector. This argument has been analysis indicate a strong association between
validated by the results of correlation analysis and the variables based on significant correlations
regression analysis. All the three attributes of and coefficient of determination.
professional development (professional develop-
ment, perception of professional development and The findings of the study are consistent with the
the importance of professional development). findings of Opfer (28) in which he indicates the
These findings are consistent with the findings of positive impacts of classroom teaching practice
the previous literature as indicated by Capper (12) related to better learning and better outcomes by
that to improve the delivery of quality education, students. Further, that there is a direct connection
the performance of the teachers must be improved between the learning outcomes of the students and
by means of professional development. the performance of teachers in the class. The
findings also validate the argument of Capper
The findings of the study also answer the research (2018) that the teachers can teach effectively and
questions as prescribed in the beginning. The first implement their teaching profession more precisely
question was “how PDs affect the performance of a if they have attended training and induction
schoolteacher?” is answered with the significance programs, and improved students’ learning is also
of the model that impact of professional provided by them. Lastly, the findings also validate
development and perception of professional the research of Merchie et al (32) that there exists a
development improves the performance of teachers. positive relationship between the professional
Similarly, the second and third research question development and success of students.
has been answered accordingly that professional
development will enhance the learning abilities of Hence, the findings can be summarized that the
the students and that of the staff as well. The staff performance of teachers is influenced by
can produce new teaching ideas which will help professional development and its associated
them to deliver higher standard education to the variables. So, with the help of the findings, in the
students at private schools in this regard. following section, certain recommendations have
been given. Qualities student learning and teaching
Conclusion are tightly interconnected with each other. But
The main objective of this study was to explore the another crucial factor that forms an integral part of
role of professional development on the quality teaching and student learning that is often
performance of teachers working in the private overlooked is quality preparation and instruction
school sector of Dubai. The study used the data of for teachers.
150 teachers working in the private schools of
Dubai with the help of a structured questionnaire Conflict of Interest
and using IBM SPSS as a tool of analysis. The key There is no conflict of interest between the authors
findings of the study have been summarized as in this manuscript.
follows:
References
1. This study included a sample size of 150 1. Albasha, W. and David, S.A., (2019).
teachers and 52% of the participants were male “Teacher’s Perspectives on Engaged Teaching:
and 72% of the participants were female. In Study from an American Curriculum School in
addition to it, findings suggest that majority of Dubai”. Specialty Journal of Knowledge
Management, 4(2), 1.13.
115
2. Almalki, S., (2016). “Integrating Quantitative 15. Crilly, J., Panesar, L. & Suka-Bill, Z., (2020).
and Qualitative Data in Mixed Methods “Co-constructing a Liberated/Decolonised Arts
Research--Challenges and Benefits”. Journal Curriculum”. Journal of University Teaching
of Education and Learning, 5(3), 288-296. & Learning Practice, 17(2), 9.
3. Alvaez, A.V.Jr., Ventura, D.R.M. & Opiniano, 16. Daraghmeh, H.A.R. & David, S.A., (2017).
J.H., (2021). “Going the Distance: Perceptions “Benchmarking of Educational Leaders’
of Teachers in Open and Distance Continuing Technology Utilization: A study of the
Professional Development”. Globus Journal of attitudes of education leaders in using
Progressive Education: A Referred Research technology in the UAE”. Education Research
Journal, 10(2), 60-66. Journal. 7(3), 48-58.
4. Al Hassanieh, R. & David, S.A., (2020). “The 17. Darling-Hammond, L., Hyler, M.E. and
influence of distributed leadership on effective Gardner, M., (2017). “Effective teacher
school governance and improved school professional development.”
performance: A study conducted in two private 18. David, S.A., (2013). “A Critical Understanding
schools in the UAE”, 7(1). on Learning Management System”. A
5. Al Husseini, A & David, S.A., (2017). “The Quarterly Referred Journal on Dialogues on
Impact of Head Teachers’ Instructional Education, (ISSN 2278-2435), 2(4), 4-12.
Leadership Role on Teachers’ Professional 19. David, S.A., (2014). “Economic Globalisation
Practices in Four Private Schools in Dubai”, and Higher Education Transformation:
The UAE, Research Nebula, 6(1), 23-28. Comparing the Trends in the States, Kerala,
6. Al Samkari, H. & David, S.A., (2019). “The and Tamil Nadu of India”. J. Soc Sci, 38(3),
Role and Impacts of Authentic Leadership on 283-292.
Staff Engagement and Performance: A Study 20. David, S.A., et.al., (2017). “An exploration
among School Leaders and Teachers in Private into student learning mobility in higher
Schools in the UAE”. Specialty Journal of education among the Arabian Gulf
Psychology and Management, 5(4), 65-78. Cooperation Council countries”. International
7. Attia, M. & Edge, J., (2017). “Be (com) ing a Journal of Educational Development, 55,
reflexive researcher: A developmental pp.41-48.
approach to research methodology”. Open 21. David, S.A., (2017). “Internationalisation of
Review of Educational Research, 4(1), 33-45. higher education in the UAE and the
8. Barrera-Pedemonte, F., (2016). “High-quality implications for undergraduate student’s
teacher professional development and institutional choice for postgraduate studies”.
classroom teaching practices: Evidence from Transitions: Journal of Transient Migration.
TALIS 2013.” 1(2), 235-250.
9. Bashaireh, S. and David, S.A., (2019). 22. David, S.A., (2017). “Knowledge convergence
“Appreciate Leadership and Teacher’s towards economic polarisation: undergraduate
Subjective Well-being: An Appreciative Tool students’ postgraduate course choice in the
for an Appreciative Outcome”. Specialty UAE”. International Journal of Knowledge
Journal of Psychology and Management, 5(3), Management Studies, 8(3/4), 316-328.
46-63. 23. David, S.A. and Abukari, A., (2019).
10. Basias, N. & Pollalis, Y., (2018). “Quantitative “Perspectives of teachers on the selection and
and qualitative research in business & the development of the school leaders in the
technology: Justifying a suitable research United Arab Emirates”. International Journal
methodology”. Review of Integrative Business of Educational Management, 34(1), 56-69.
and Economics Research, 7, 91-105. 24. Dodds, S. and Hess, A.C., (2020). “Adapting
11. Bautista, A., Yau, X. and Wong, J., (2017). research methodology during COVID-19:
“High-quality music teacher professional lessons for transformative service
development: A review of the literature”. research”. Journal of Service Management.
Music Education Research, 19(4), 455-469. 25. Hammerness, K., Ahtiainen, R. & Sahlberg, P.,
12. Capper, C.A., (2018). “Organizational theory (2017). “Empowered educators in Finland:
for equity and diversity: Leading integrated, How high-performing systems shape teaching
socially just education”, Routledge. quality”. John Wiley & Sons.
13. Cooc, N., (2018). “Who Needs Special 26. Kennedy, A., (2019). “Looking beyond the
Education Professional Development?”, obvious: applying a critically reflective lens to
International Trends from TALIS 2013. professional learning literature.”
14. Creswell, J. W., Fetters, M. D. & Ivankova, N. 27. Liu, Y. and Liao, W., (2019). “Professional
V., (2004). “Designing a mixed methods study development and teacher efficacy: evidence
in primary care”, The Annals of Family from the 2013 TALIS”. School Effectiveness
Medicine, 2(1), 7-12. and School Improvement, 30(4), 487-509.
116
28. Opfer, D., (2016). “Conditions and practices on teachers’ specific praise rates”. Journal of
associated with teacher professional Positive Behavior Interventions, 19(1), 37-47.
development and its impact on instruction in 38. Suhairom, N., Musta’amal, A.H., Amin,
TALIS 2013.” N.F.M., Kamin, Y. & Wahid, N.H.A., (2019).
29. Ørngreen, R. and Levinsen, K., (2017). “Quality culinary workforce competencies for
“Workshops as a Research Methodology”. sustainable career development among
Electronic Journal of E-learning, 15(1), 70-81. culinary professionals”. International Journal
30. Maass, K. & Engeln, K. (2018). Impact of of Hospitality Management, 81, pp.205-220.
professional development involving modelling 39. Svendsen, B., (2017). “Teacher's experience
on teachers and their teaching”. ZDM, 50(1-2), from collaborative design: Reported impact on
273-285. professional development”. Education, 138(2),
31. Meissel, K., Parr, J.M. and Timperley, H.S., 115-134.
(2016). “Can professional development of 40. Svendsen, B., (2017). “Teacher's experience
teachers reduce disparity in student from collaborative design: Reported impact on
achievement?”. Teaching and Teacher professional development”. Education, 138(2),
Education, 58, 163-173. 115-134.
32. Merchie, E., Tuytens, M., Devos, G. and 41. Taherdoost, H., (2016). “Sampling methods in
Vanderlinde, R., (2018). “Evaluating teachers’ research methodology; how to choose a
professional development initiatives: towards sampling technique for research”, How to
an extended evaluative framework”. Research Choose a Sampling Technique for Research
papers in education, 33(2), pp.143-168. (April 10, 2016).
33. Rana, S., (2017). “Professional Attitude to 42. Täuscher, K. and Laudien, S.M., (2018).
Reduce Occupational Stress in Teachers”. “Understanding platform business models: A
Globus Journal of Progressive Education: A mixed methods study of marketplaces”.
Referred Research Journal, 7(1), 1-3. European Management Journal, 36(3), 319-
34. Ryan, K. & Dagostino, L., (2018). “Theory to 329.
Practice: Impact of Professional Development 43. Tong, F., Luo, W., Irby, B. J., Lara-Alecio, R.
Sessions on Teachers' Approach to Teaching & Rivera, H., (2017). “Investigating the impact
Fiction”. New England Reading Association of professional development on teachers’
Journal, 53(1), 64-105. instructional time and English learners’
35. Santos, D. and Miguel, L., (2019). “The language development: a multilevel cross-
Relationship between Teachers' Beliefs, classified approach”. International Journal of
Teachers' Behaviors, and Teachers' Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 20(3),
Professional Development: A Literature 292-313.
Review”. International Journal of Education 44. Zangirolami-Raimundo, J., Echeimberg, J. D.
and Practice, 7(1), 10-18. O. and Leone, C., (2018). “Research
36. Saric, M. and Steh, B., (2017). “Critical methodology topics: Cross-sectional studies”.
reflection in the professional development of Journal of Human Growth and Development,
teachers: Challenges and possibilities”. CEPS 28(3), 356-360.
Journal, 7(3), 67-85. 45. Zhang, S., Shi, Q. and Lin, E., (2020).
37. Simonsen, B., Freeman, J., Dooley, K., “Professional development needs, support, and
Maddock, E., Kern, L. & Myers, D., (2017). barriers: TALIS US new and veteran teachers’
“Effects of targeted professional development perspectives”. Professional Development in
Education, 46(3), 440-453.
117