Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Job Satisfaction As A Mediating Variable
Job Satisfaction As A Mediating Variable
Rohina Naderi
Muhammad Shahid Shams
Abstract
Absenteeism is one of the major concerns for all types of organizations,
from the public to private types and from small to big ones. Absenteeism is
considered to be one of the underlying factors of loss of productivity, waste
of resources, and fragile structure of the organizations and industries around
the world. Therefore, it shows the necessity of research and investigation to
find out factors that are related to this costly phenomenon of absenteeism
not only among developed nations but also among developing and less
developed countries such as Afghanistan where the organizations of the
public sector are facing a high level of absenteeism. Therefore, this paper aims
to study the relationship between workplace factors, job satisfaction, and
absenteeism. This study thusly proposes a framework to investigate the effect
of workplace factors on absenteeism via the mediating role of job satisfaction.
Further, the direct effect between the variables has been discussed. Hence
this paper is expected to fill the research gap and contribute to the body of
knowledge in this area of research.
Ms. Rohina Naderi is MBA Student, Kardan University, Kabul, Afghanistan <rohinanadiri@gmail.com>
Mr. Muhammad Shahid Shams is Assistant Professor, Kardan University, Kabul, Afghanistan
<mshahidshams@gmail.com>
27
Job Satisfaction as a Mediating Variable between Workplace Factors and Absenteeism: A Proposed Conceptual Framework
Introduction
Absenteeism comes from the Latin word "absentia" referring to the non-
attendance status of the employee at the work (ikeš, 2018). Absenteeism is
present in all types of organizations, public and private, small and big, profit,
and non-profit (Beheshtifar, 2016). There are two types of absenteeism,
culpable and non-culpable (Kocakulah, 2016). Non-culpable absenteeism
refers to an employee’s authorized leave or absenteeism and there is no
charge or penalty for that such as annual leave quota, sickness leave,
paternity, and maternity leaves. Culpable absenteeism means unauthorized
and non-allowed absenteeism of the employees. The type of absenteeism
in the literature and past studies refers to the kind of absenteeism which is
un-authorized. Unauthorized or not-allowed absenteeism has been
perceived as a major management problem for the organization and poor
performance indicator for individuals within the organization (Raja, 2019;
ikeš, 2018; Kuma, 2014)
Employee absenteeism is considered as a costly phenomenon to the
organizations and the economy as a whole in terms of loss of productivity
(Kocakulah, 2016; Nicola, 2017; Martin, 2017). Statistics Canada reports that
the average rate of absenteeism per worker in 2013 was about 9.1 days and
it cost around $16.6B directly to the Canadian economy (Eric, 2013). US
Bureau of Labour Statistics reports the rate of absenteeism around 2.9%
which imposed a total cost of $74B to the US economy in 2013 (Akgeyik,
2014). The estimated cost of absenteeism becomes more severe when we
consider it in the developing world where absenteeism is not taken seriously
and there are no disciplinary measures or queries for being absent from
work (Beheshtifar, 2016). To find a solution to this costly phenomenon in the
organizations, first, we should identify the underlying workplace factors
contributing to high absenteeism. What workplace factors cause employees
to be absent from work? What workplace factors increase the employees’
satisfaction with their job and how this relates to decreasing the level of
absenteeism? The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the body of
knowledge and practices related to human resource management by
shedding light on workplace factors that are assumed to affect job
satisfaction and absenteeism. Based on the extensive theoretical review on
what has been advanced in the literature about absenteeism, arguments,
and logical justifications, this study suggests a conceptual framework with
propositions and invites researchers to test it empirically. This study will not
only explain the effect of workplace factors on job satisfaction and
absenteeism only but also will focus on the mediating effect of job
28
Naderi & Shams (2020)
29
Job Satisfaction as a Mediating Variable between Workplace Factors and Absenteeism: A Proposed Conceptual Framework
2. Literature Review
This section will study relevant theories about absenteeism and studies
regarding the relationship between workplace factors, job satisfaction, and
absenteeism. Variables conceptualized in the framework are inferred from
the extant literature available on the issue.
2.1 Absenteeism Related Theories
As discussed in the beginning that absenteeism refers to un-authorized
leaves of employees. Alexander (2019) in his study, referred to absenteeism
as a "deviation of cooperative states". He argued that due to perceived
dissatisfaction in the workplace, employees intend to be absent from the
work. In the short term, it can be named as absenteeism and in the long
term, it ends on withdrawal from the job and workplace. This is consistent
with Maslow’s (1958) theory of motivation which states that human beings
are mostly concerned with psychological and job-related needs (cited in
Alexander, 2019). This theory implies that besides food, sleep, and shelter,
human beings are in need to have job security, good working conditions,
and satisfactory compensation for the time and energy they are using.
In the same vein, the Herzberg theory of motivation states that work-
related factors are categorized as motivators and hygiene factors
(Herzberg, 1957). He stated that motivators are recognition and
appreciation and hygiene factors are pay level, relationship with
supervisors, good working conditions. Herzberg’s (1957) theory of
motivation postulates that the absence of these hygiene factors causes
employees to lose interest in their job which results in absenteeism in the
short term and quitting the job in the long term.
2.2.1 Workplace Factors and Absenteeism
Workplace factors generally include pay level, nature of the work,
working condition, supervisory relationship, relation with co-workers, and
fairness. Many studies recently conducted have found a direct and indirect
impact of these workplace factors on absenteeism (Abuhashesh, 2019;
Nicola, 2017; Rebecca, 2017). A short description of each of the above-
mentioned workplace factors has been provided below.
30
Naderi & Shams (2020)
31
Job Satisfaction as a Mediating Variable between Workplace Factors and Absenteeism: A Proposed Conceptual Framework
friendly environment and support from their other co-workers are less
interested to be absent at work. Also, Verma (2016) stated in his research
about absenteeism that employees who experienced harassment or felt
discriminated against because of their gender and nationalities showed a
higher level of absenteeism.
Fairness : Fairness refers to the comprehensive implementation of policy,
discipline, and regulations in the organization (Rebecca, 2017). Rebecca
(2017) stated that when an employee is being appreciated and promoted
just because he/she is a relative of supervisor or director, it decreases the
level of commitment and satisfaction among other employees in the same
organization and it also causes the employees to show a higher level of
absenteeism. In the same study it is further argued that if an employee feels
that his/her work does not contribute to his/her personal development and
organizational achievement, he/she perceives attendance to be un-useful at
work. In the same connection, Nicola (2017) stated in her research about
absenteeism that when employees feel that the policies and regulation are
implemented fairly in the organization, it motivates employees not only but
they also feel that their rights are secured and there is no injustice and
inequality in their working environment.
Even though there are numerous studies on the relationship between
workplace factors and absenteeism in the context of developed and
developing nations, yet there is a dire need to undertake further studies to
understand the association between the variables particularly in the context
of less developed countries such as Afghanistan. As per the best knowledge
of the researcher, in the Afghanistan context particularly among employees
in the public sector organizations, there are limited studies that have
examined the association between workplace factors and absenteeism.
Consequently, investigating more on the nature of this relationship is
worthy. Therefore, the following proposition was formulated:
Proposition 1: Workplace factors, if satisfactory, have a significant
negative effect on absenteeism.
2.2.2 Workplace Factors and Job Satisfaction
Several studies show that job satisfaction is an explanatory variable
resulting from individual and organizational interaction (Akgeyik, 2014;
Bakotić, 2016; Raja, 2019). Job satisfaction refers to the overall perception
of well-being and satisfaction at the workplace (Bakotić, 2016). Danica
(2016) states that job satisfaction is the overall judgment of employees
related to the working-based experience. According to the Mc Gregor's
theory of motivation (theory X and theory Y) (as cited in Alexander, 2019),
employees are irresponsible and lack the willingness to work in general
32
Naderi & Shams (2020)
33
Job Satisfaction as a Mediating Variable between Workplace Factors and Absenteeism: A Proposed Conceptual Framework
35
Job Satisfaction as a Mediating Variable between Workplace Factors and Absenteeism: A Proposed Conceptual Framework
Job
Workplace Factors
satisfaction
Pay level
Working condition
Supervisory relationship Absenteeism
Co-workers relationship
Nature of the work
Fairness
4. Methodology
This paper offers a proposed conceptual framework for important
factors affecting absenteeism. The researcher proposes a quantitative
approach to test the phenomenon. The population of this study is full-time
employees working in public sector organizations. According to a recent
report published by the International Labour Organization (ILO) (Dasgupta,
Anhal, & Bhatnagar, 2019), a total of 723488 employees are working in the
public sector organizations in Afghanistan. Based on the sampling table
suggested by Krejcie and Morgan (1970), for the mentioned population, 382
participants as minimum sample size is required to carry out the analysis.
The survey questionnaire will be distributed among the targeted employees
to collect important data. The measurement will be adapted from existing
literature. To test the proposed model, the Structural Equation Modeling -
Partial Least Square (SEM-PLS) will be employed to establish the validity and
reliability of the measurements and to test the postulated hypothesis.
5. Conclusion
As mentioned above, this study aimed at investigating the effect of
workplace factors on absenteeism, and the mediating role played by job
satisfaction on the said relation. By providing empirical evidence on the
study’s proposed constructs, this research is expected to support
managers, practitioners, and decision-makers in the public sector
organizations to identify the real sources of absenteeism. In the previous
studies, researchers have tried to link workplace factors with absenteeism,
but they have ignored the role of job satisfaction as a vital predictor of
absenteeism. The main concern of the managers in organizations is to
prevent absenteeism. The better way of doing that is to increase the level
of job satisfaction among employees. Thus, the addition of job satisfaction
as a mediator in the relationship between workplace factors and
absenteeism will help in minimizing absenteeism on one hand and provide
36
Naderi & Shams (2020)
References
Abuhashesh, M. (2019). Factors that affect employees job satisfaction and
absenteeism . Journal of Human Resource Management Resource, Vol 19.
Akgeyik, T. (2014). Factors affecting employee absenteeism* (a study on a sample
of textile workers) . European Journal of Management, 14 (3), 69-76. .
Alexander, S. (2019). Presenteeism and Absenteeism, an analysis of public sector
employees . Journal of Business and Psychology , 241-255.
Bakotić, D. (2016). Relationship between job satisfaction and Organizational
Performance . Economic Research, 118-130.
Bank, W. (2012). Worldbank/Afghanistan/Good Governance . Retrieved from World
Bank :
<http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/418011489413141185/pdf/ISR-
Disclosable-P123845-03-13-2017-1489413129361.pdf>
Bank, W. (2018). Worldbank/Afghanistan . Retrieved from WorldBank.org:
worldbank/afghanistan/TAGHIR
Banks, J. (2012). Perceptions of inequity in the workplace: Exploring the link with
unauthorised absenteeism. Journal of Human Resource Management, Art. #402.
Bayarcelik, E. B., & Afacan Fındıklı, M. (2016). The mediating effect of job satisfaction
on the relation between organizational justice perception and intention to
leave.
37
Job Satisfaction as a Mediating Variable between Workplace Factors and Absenteeism: A Proposed Conceptual Framework
38
Naderi & Shams (2020)
39