Professional Documents
Culture Documents
What Would Google Do?: Jeff Jarvis
What Would Google Do?: Jeff Jarvis
Introduction
Google’s founders and executives understand how how various enterprises would be transformed if they
the introduction of Internet technology has changed applied the Google rules to their industries. Lastly,
the way business is conducted and how people inter- he discusses how Googlethink is affecting society
act with enterprises. This knowledge has made them and future generations. When faced with a challenge,
successful and powerful, running what The Times of business leaders should ask themselves: WWGD? By
London named as “the fastest growing company in answering, organizations can begin to better navigate
the history of the world.” The same could be said a world that has been changed radically and forever
about the founders of Facebook, Craigslist, Wikipe- by Internet technology.
dia, Amazon, and Digg. According to Jeff Jarvis in Analyzing Google
What Would Google Do?, these business leaders see
Since its origins in 1998, Google has become a model
the world differently, and therefore are completely
for success in the Internet age. It has gained over two-
transforming all old ways of thinking. Jarvis proposes
thirds share of all Internet searches, running millions
that the best way to respond to the vast changes hap-
of servers, tracking over a billion Web pages, and
pening in the business world is to ask what these
following over a trillion Web addresses. It would be
new leaders would do. By analyzing the way Google
difficult to imagine a situation where Google could
would respond to situations, Jarvis offers a set of
fail—but it is possible. It could grow too big to be
Google rules that businesses can use to operate—new
handled efficiently or too big to grow any further. Its
rules for a new age. Next, he proposes ideas about
dominance in the industry might be challenged by
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
ideas, and even involve customers in the design pro- men, made possible by a web of links.
cess of their products. Jarvis contends that the single
greatest transformative power of
the Internet and Google is about
[I]t comes down to relationships—relationships that are lived
making new connections with in public. Every time someone says something good about you
customers and developing new online because of your product, service, reputation, honesty,
relationships. openness, or helpfulness, you should knock another dollar off
New Architecture your advertising budget.
The Internet introduced a two-
The Internet is a network of networks, each creating a
way, collaborative format through which people and
web of links over the structure of society, connecting
enterprises communicate. This new system requires
people with information and each other. In those con-
that everything about a business—its products, its
nections, value is created, efficiencies are discovered,
processes, and its message—has a place online with
knowledge is fostered, and relationships are formed.
a permanent address so people can search and find
Google is the chief agent of value creation, using its
information, point to it, respond to it, and even
search capabilities to help make connections. Net-
distribute the information to others. Through the
works are built on top of platforms that enable others
information that a business puts online, it will join
to build value. Google is a platform, as are many
with customers in networks directly without middle-
others: Home Depot is a platform for contractors, and
Continental Airlines is a platform for booking tours.
Platforms help users create products, businesses,
communities, and networks of their own. Jarvis asks
About the Author businesses to look at how they can act as platforms by
adding value that other businesses can build upon. To
Jeff Jarvis is the proprietor of one of the Web’s do so, organizations need to stop thinking in a central-
most popular and respected blogs about the ized manner and start thinking “distributed.” Just as
Internet and media, Buzzmachine.com. He is a YouTube allows users to embed videos into their own
consulting editor for Daylife, a news start-up, websites and blogs, businesses need to learn how to
and he writes the new media column for The allow their content to be distributed onto other plat-
Guardian in London. He consults for media com- forms. However, Jarvis argues that not everything
panies, and he was named one of 100 worldwide online should remain distributed. For example, his
media leaders by the World Economic Forum at company, Daylife, collects and organizes news head-
Davos in 2007 and 2008. Jarvis was the creator lines from around the world, allowing users to find all
and founding editor of Entertainment Weekly. the latest news from anywhere. In turn, users link to
Until 2005, he was president and creative direc- Daylife pages and distribute them again. This cycle of
tor of Advance.net, the online arm of Advance distribution, aggregation, then distribution character-
Publications. Prior to that role, he held the roles izes the distributed Web.
of Sunday editor and associate publisher of the
New Publicness
New York Daily News, TV critic for TV Guide and
People, a columnist on the San Francisco Exam- Businesses must keep in mind that most users will
iner, and assistant city editor and reporter for access information on their websites by linking
the Chicago Tribune. He is on the faculty of the from somewhere else, and not by coming through
City University of New York Graduate School their home pages. Website owners need to produce
of Journalism in New York City. a series of answers that are clear and simple so that
Google can easily find them and use them. The most
important benefit that an organization receives is
what Jarvis calls Googlejuice—the value that Google
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 3
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
places on a business’s content. The more links, clicks, millions of tiny competitors. Society is entering an
and mentions that a business gets online, the higher economy in which Google is teaching how to manage
its webpages rise in Google’s search results, adding abundance: the law of supply and demand. Using an
the potential to receive even more clicks. If a business older business model, companies built their value on
does not format its online content for easy searching, scarcity. By providing a limited amount of products
it loses the benefits of Googlejuice. and services, the company could build demand and
charge what it wanted. However,
I suggest you start a blog… I see no reason why a CEO should that model has been turned on its
not open a direct conversation with the public. What’s to fear head by the Internet. A company
from your own customers? Having set that example, the CEO selling a product is no longer lim-
ited by the amount of shelf space
can expect other executives and employees down the ranks to in its retailers’ stores. Instead, it
enter into the same conversation and learn from it. can sell to anyone in the world
who is online. Google’s business
Customers now expect any information in the world to
model, based on creating, exploiting, and manag-
be available with a quick search on the Internet. A key
ing abundance, succeeds when there is more content
attribute of business and society in the Internet age is
to organize and when there are more places for it to
that information is readily available to the public—a
embed its advertisements.
situation called publicness that is about organizations
taking actions in public so customers can see what Mass markets have given way to niche markets. The
the companies are doing and react to it, make sug- Internet has given people the ability to gravitate
gestions, and tell their friends. Every time a company toward their own interests, even create their own
decides not make something public, it creates the risk content. Google has figured out how to navigate the
of a customer not finding the company online or not world of niches and profit from it. It created a new
trusting the company because it is keeping secrets. way for advertisers to reach highly targeted audiences
Publicness therefore also becomes an ethic. as they search for and read relevant content. It also
let the marketplace set the price of advertisements.
New Society
Like Google and similar businesses, companies must
The Internet allows people to self-organize. They discover how to make the transition from mass to
no longer need businesses and institutions to help niche, and effectively exploit it. The shift away from
organize communities of customers, constituents, or the mass market is really a shift of power from top to
members. However, the Internet also opens up so bottom, from company to customer, and from busi-
many new paths for information that people need nesses to people.
help making sense of it all. The next generation of
New Business Reality
organizations enterprises, like Facebook, Flickr, or
Wikipedia, does not organize people. Instead, these The Internet has generated a new business reality.
enterprises provide platforms that help people Amazon, for example, has no retail store expenses
organize themselves. Businesses cannot create com- and hires no sales clerks. It is a business of efficien-
munities; those communities already exist. People cies, volume, turnover, and tight margins. Businesses
now have the tools to organize, find each other, and are finding more value in what they know, how they
share knowledge. They are reorganizing society. serve customers, and how they anticipate their needs.
Middlemen are finding that they are quickly becom-
New Economy
ing obsolete as companies increasing interact directly
Small is the new big. A small start-up company can with suppliers and customers.
become a manufacturer using another company’s fac-
Google and the Internet have created a new model
tory and distribution while selling to a world-wide
for making money. Google does not own the con-
market that finds its products with Google searches.
tent it searches; it provides the online knowledge for
Big companies are getting “nipped at the heels” by
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 4
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
free and displays advertisements to pay for the ser- a key to innovation, because the company is willing
vice. Google understands the value of “free” better to accept risk. When a company seeks perfection, it
than anyone. It provides free services and charges for puts itself on a pedestal—a position from which it can
the advertising that it displays on the content pages. be easily toppled when hidden mistakes are revealed
Businesses, in this new era, must determine what over the Internet. In order to combat this, Google
type of business they subscribe to. Google is in the issues what is called a “beta” product, or a product
organization and knowledge business; however, its that is being tested. In reality, it is admitting that there
profits do not come from that effort. Its profit comes are mistakes in the product and is asking users to
from advertising, which it dominates, because it is so find them and make suggestions for enhancements.
good at providing search services and has so many The Internet allows Google to easily issue changes
users. Many businesses worry that they cannot make and improvements. Businesses can follow Google’s
the transition to the new world of the Internet, when approach by offering products and services, allowing
really they should be asking if they are a knowledge customers react to them, and making adjustments.
company, a data company, a community-enabling
Collaboration with customers is the highest and most
company, a platform, a network, or other service.
rewarding form of interactivity. To get customers to
New Attitude collaborate, a company must open up and share infor-
mation, designs, goals, and aspirations. A company’s
One of the counterintuitive lessons of the Google age
competitive advantage is not derived from its secret
is that the more businesses try to control things, the
designs; it comes from a strong relationship with its
less they are trusted; however, the more they hand
community of customers. However, companies are
over control, the more trust they will earn. This
not democracies. Business leaders should not turn
phenomenon is the opposite of how companies and
over the leadership to a committee of customers. The
institutions operated before the onset of the Internet.
company is still responsible to come up with good
Before the public learns to trust the powerful, the
ideas and inventions and execute plans well.
powerful must learn to trust the
people. Google’s business model
In every interaction you have with your constituents [or cus-
works because Google trusts its
users. Google builds on that trust, tomers], speak with a human voice as if you were speaking
realizing that trust is something face-to-face. Be boldly, bluntly honest when admitting your
its users share with each other. mistakes—and when disagreeing with the public.
Sometimes, users will abuse that
trust. When users post a few bad comments, hoaxes, New Speed
or ill-founded rumors, businesses should not retreat
Google has made Internet users an impatient people.
to pre-Internet approaches. People will misuse the
If they can obtain any bit of information in a blink
Internet, but businesses should seek the opportunity
of an eye, why would they want to wait on hold or
in that challenge. Because Google trusts its users, it
in line until a company is open for business? Every
believes its users collectively have great wisdom.
industry is now affected by this new speed. Those
Business leaders should ask themselves whether their
companies that are still burdened with physical pro-
companies have cultures that are built on trust, and
cesses and complexities find that their lack of speed
whether they have the processes in place that are
has become a strategic disadvantage. The need for
needed to capture and act on the wisdom of its cus-
speed is affecting even the Internet. As Web speeds
tomers and suppliers.
increase, users are no longer content with reading
New Ethic recent information; instead, they want live broadcasts
of information, witnessing events as they happen.
When a business leader stands up and admits mis-
Social media is bursting with live information about
takes, it gives customers faith that future wrongs also
what is happening in and around peoples’ lives. This
will be corrected. Being willing to make mistakes is
ability to transmit live information makes the Internet
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 5
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
wholly interactive. It also makes it perilous for busi- people with the skills needed to solve the problem.
nesses being discussed, unless they have the facility to In addition, it has acquired other products and ideas
listen to and join the conversation as it happens. The to solve problems, leading to new platforms for blog-
Internet has caused businesses to lose control of their ging, feeds, advertising systems, and other services.
brand, message, pricing, competition, and secrecy— In the end, Google’s lesson here is simple: companies
but most importantly, companies have lost control of must make innovation their business.
timing. Businesses no longer have the luxury of decid-
Along with innovation, Google strives for simplic-
ing when to put out their story or respond to critics.
ity. More than just a design aesthetic, simplification
Customers no longer will wait “on hold” without
is a design ethic that is infused into all of Google’s
complaining, revolting, and leaving quickly and pub-
products and services. Simple functions and design
licly. In short, when customers talk about a company
are more honest and empower the user. Google, and
in public, its business leaders better have the means
other platforms like craigslist, strive to empower
to hear and respond. Otherwise, competitors with the
their users and “get out of the way.” They do not try
ability to answer customer problems better and faster
to over-research or over-design their platforms to set
will steal away the customers in a flash.
up all kinds of rules, restrictions,
[No] amount of advertising will make up for a bad product… navigation, instruction, or fees.
Instead, they realize that “free” is
Make absolutely certain that you have a great product or service. a business model, and they allow
Make absolutely certain that you have great customer service. their users to build upon their
Those are the first two rules of so-called advertising in this platforms without limits, creating
world. If you don’t have those, don’t pay any money to anyone businesses and services that go far
beyond what the platform origina-
to do [any marketing]. tors could have predicted.
impact of the Internet age. Traditionally, the industry Other retail businesses can respond to the Internet in
was built on scarcity—only so many screens to show a similar manner. Retail stores can become a commu-
movies on, only a few channels on television, and nity built around particular needs, tastes, or passions.
limited shelf space to sell records, videos, and CDs. Retailers can start direct conversations among these
Now, the economics of abundance has opened up people, who in turn can become like sales agents as
the industry’s business models. Niche marketing has they share information and recommendations. Rather
had enormous growth. Control is no longer centered than treating the Internet as a competitor, retailers
among a few companies. Film and video has exploded should use it as a platform that will enable customers
over the Internet, providing news content, entertain- to help the businesses stand out from the crowd. Busi-
ment, and information to millions without being ness leaders should look at their customers as their
filtered or censored through large media conglomer- brands.
ates. The key for businesses is to
realize that the Internet is a new The best way to burnish a brand is no longer to rub it up against
medium entirely. Building rela- media properties like Vogue or the Super Bowl. The best way
tionships with audience members today is to rub up again people: Sally the blogger or Joe the
and collaborating to develop con-
Facebook friend. The medium is the message and the customer
tent is how businesses can use the
new medium to their advantage. is the medium. Sally in the new Vogue.
If Google Ruled Advertising If Google Ruled Utilities
Google is in the advertising business and has changed In this case, Google is actually making an effort to
advertising more than any other industry. It has remake an industry. Google.org, the company’s phil-
revolutionized the advertising economy, enabling anthropic wing, hopes to reinvent the energy industry
marketers to pay for performance rather than space, by funding ways to make power that will cost less
time, or number of readers. In the Google age, com- than that generated with coal. Their effort is an exer-
panies should focus on the customer first, and all else cise in enlightened self-interest, because Google’s
will follow. Jarvis imagines a day when marketers server farms are gigantic consumers of electricity.
will fire their advertising agencies, throw out their Jarvis imagines that a power company run by Google
traditional advertisements, and start over by building would give people power at the cheapest price pos-
relationships with customers. sible, and then find ways to take advantage of that. It
would give each business and household a webpage
Marketing is evolving into a field about developing
that would document power usage by device and
relationships, not messages. Google’s technology
encourage users to conserve. It would provide a plat-
enables and fosters these relationships. As relation-
form for people to generate electricity themselves and
ships replace advertising, spending will decrease.
feed it back into the Google grid.
Google’s system will target advertising more effi-
ciently. Google has ventured into the cable and phone indus-
try. It gives away free Internet service to the entire
If Google Ruled Retail
town where it is headquartered. It created a mobile
Jarvis speculates how Googlethink would transform a operating system, which any phone manufacturer
restaurant. Diners could provide feedback about their may use. If Google could achieve free or nearly free
meals, and unpopular items on the menu would be connectivity for most citizens, then Google would
quickly changed. Recipes could be posted online and have more users, and have more people creating
customers could make suggestions about alternatives content for the Internet. The business models of the
or enhancements. The best advertisement for a restau- telecommunications industry are ripe for disruption
rant is a happy customer—truer for restaurants than from technologies like Google. Jarvis posits that an
other business. ideal telecommunications company in the Google age
would help users do more than making calls and con-
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 7
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
suming content; it would help users create, share, and to capture knowledge from savvy travelers and turn
sell. it into value. The strategy for remaking an airline in
this way would be for their business leaders to give
If Google Ruled Manufacturing
control, respect, and organization to their customers;
Jarvis believes that manufacturers in the Google age help them find each other; and let them organize into
must allow customers to become collaborators in conversations and networks.
the design of products by suggesting features and
Jarvis believes that the real-estate business is ripe
enhancements. For example, automobile manufactur-
for disruption from Internet technologies, breaking
ers would evolve from car makers to facilitators of
their hold on the market and threatening their typi-
navigation and entertainment as users helped design
cal six percent fees. Real estate companies control the
ways to enhance the ability of cars to get them around
multiple-listing service that is necessary for having a
and entertain themselves while driving. Soft drink
house seen by buyers. Now, alternative databases are
manufacturers could let users design and market
emerging on the Internet, allowing homeowners to
their own niche recipes. Jarvis sees a time when
by-pass the fees charged by real estate companies and
Google might propose open standards for hardware
list their homes on the Internet themselves. Sellers and
devices that connect to the internet. Refrigerators
buyers still need services. Jarvis envisions a scenario
would tell homeowners by e-mail when supplies are
where sellers can list their homes online along with
low or provide recipes based on what is available
information about their neighborhoods, places where
inside. Other manufacturers are starting to create
the kids like to play, their favorite nearby shops and
platforms that allow consumers to create the products
restaurants, and other details that make their home
they want. CafePress, for example, allows people to
listing more appealing to buyers.
upload a design that can be printed on t-shirts, mugs,
baby clothing, pillows, or any number of products. If Google Ruled Money
Opening up conversations with customers and prod-
Venture capitalists traffic in innovation, change,
uct users could really help build product loyalty and
and risk. They watch Google carefully, covet its suc-
brand awareness.
cess, and take the lead from its
Who needs a university when we have Google? All the world’s investors. New Web technologies
make it easy and inexpensive for
digital knowledge is available at a search. We can connect those
entrepreneurs to start new sites,
who want to know with those who know. We can link students services, products, or companies,
to the best teachers for them (who may be fellow students). We and this presents both opportuni-
can find experts on any topic. ties and challenges for investors.
Many entrepreneurs no longer
If Google Ruled Service need vast infusions of funds from venture capitalists
to start businesses and succeed. Those that do need
Jarvis dreams about how the airline and travel indus-
funding are asking for less, so investors must fund
tries could be transformed by Google rules. He
lots of smaller companies to achieve their financial
suggests that airlines could help travelers become
goals. As investments are getting smaller, entrepre-
networked. Providing wi-fi in the plane cabins would
neurs are getting younger. Investors are using the
allow travelers to have alternative entertainment and
Internet to reach college students who are hatching
activities to do while traveling. They could connect
new ideas. Jarvis suggests that a venture capitalist
with each other, organize to share cabs, and help
who wants to think like Google would build a plat-
each other with tips about restaurants and activities
form for entrepreneurship, be open with ideas, and
to do at their destinations. Socialization would allow
use new technologies to establish direct connections
passengers to choose to fly on one airline versus
between other investors and start-ups. A Google-like
another because of the kind of people they would
venture capitalist would create networks of start-ups
meet there. Airlines could tap into these networks
so they could help each other and spin off other ven-
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 8
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 9
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
ily on physical products. Jarvis believes even these of how everyone and everything—from corpora-
businesses can be greatly impacted by the technolo- tions to governments, nations to individuals—must
gies and capabilities of the Google age. evolve in the Google era. The book will be beneficial
to leaders in all sectors of industry and in various
Generation G
institutions. Jarvis helps the reader see the world as
Google is making changes in society, lives, relation-
Google sees it. In that sense, the book is less about
ships, and worldviews. Because of its ability to keep
Google and more about how the world is changing
people connected, Google has changed the meaning
for business leaders, and what they can gain from a
of relationships, probably allowing people to stay
changed worldview. The extensive index and detailed
connected for a lifetime. The ethics and expectations
table of contents helps the reader use this book as a
about privacy have changed radically for the genera-
reference after completing a cover-to-cover reading.
tion coming into adulthood in the Google age. Privacy
is less of an issue; people need the ability to control Contents
their personal information, whether it is made public WWGD?
and to whom, and how it is used. People will be iden-
Google Rules
tified more by their accomplishments and creations,
the things that they are known for that narrow a New Relationship
Google search. • Give the people control and we will use it
The Internet and Google change the way people are • Dell hell
behaving. The values, ethics, customs, and models
• Your worst customer is your best friend
that are implicit in Google and how people use it
might be making deep impressions on the genera- • Your best customer is your partner
tion of users who are immersed in that environment. New Architecture
Some behavior changes might be short-lived fads;
• The link changes everything
others might have a longer-term influence on societal
norms. People are becoming accustomed to think- • Do what you do best and link to the rest
ing that most problems can be solved with machines • Join a network
and software. They are becoming very reliant on the
• Be a platform
belief that data and numbers reveal truth. In Jarvis’s
own experience, he knows that he now learns dif- • Think distributed
ferently, discusses differently, sees things differently, New Publicness
and thinks differently. Thinking differently is the key
• If you’re not searchable, you won’t be found
product and skill of the Google age.
• Everybody needs Googlejuice
g g g g • Life is public, so is business
• Your customers are your ad agency
Features of the Book New Society
Reading Time: 4.5 hours, 268 pages
• Elegant organization
In What Would Google Do?, Jeff Jarvis reverse- New Economy
engineers Google to discover forty clear and
straightforward rules to manage and live by. He offers • Small is the new big
one part prophecy, one part thought experiment, one • The post-scarcity economy
part manifesto, and one part survival manual to illu- • Join the open-source, gift economy
minate the new worldview of the internet generation.
His findings are counterintuitive, imaginative, practi- • The mass market is dead—long live the mass of
cal, and above all visionary, giving readers a glimpse niches
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 10
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 11
What Would Google Do? Jeff Jarvis
Copyright of Business Book Summaries, Business Book Review, BusinessSummaries and BizSum is property of EBSCO Publishing
Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder’s
express written permission. However, users may print, download or email articles for individual use.
Business Book Summaries® February 29, 2012 • Copyright © 2012 EBSCO Publishing Inc. • All Rights Reserved Page 12
Copyright of What Would Google Do - Business Book Summaries is the property of Great Neck Publishing and
its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.