Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1.1 Robin DiAngelo and Resmaa Menakem - Towards A Framework For Repair - The On Being Project - The On Being Project
1.1 Robin DiAngelo and Resmaa Menakem - Towards A Framework For Repair - The On Being Project - The On Being Project
Guests
Resmaa Menakem (MSW, LICSW, SEP) teaches workshops on Cultural
Somatics for audiences of African Americans, European Americans, and
police officers. He is also a therapist in private practice, and a senior fellow at
The Meadows. His New York Times best-selling book is My Grandmother’s
Hands: Racialized Trauma and the Pathway to Mending Our Hearts and Bodies.
Robin DiAngelo has been a
consultant, educator, and
facilitator for over 20 years and is
an Affiliate Associate Professor of
Education at the University of
Washington in Seattle. She’s the
author of the influential book
White Fragility: Why It’s So Hard For White People To Talk About Racism. Her
new book is Nice Racism: How Progressive White People Perpetuate Racial Harm.
Transcript
Krista Tippett, host: Through all the ruptures of the past year and
more, we have been given so much to learn, and callings to live
differently. But how to do that? And how to begin? Resmaa
Menakem’s book My Grandmother’s Hands, and his original insights
into racialized trauma in all kinds of bodies, has offered new ways
forward for us all. He’s become one of my most important teachers,
and I immediately said yes when he asked to join me in conversation
together with Robin DiAngelo. She has been a foremost white voice in
our civilizational grappling with whiteness. Separately and together,
these two clarify the important work that those of us in white bodies
need to do in ourselves and with each other, in service to everyone
else. This conversation is not comfortable, but it is electric, and it
opens possibility.
Resmaa Menakem: White folks don’t even know that we’re not even
speaking the same embodied language. We don’t see the world in the
same way. And so white people coming up and just saying, this is
what I want to do, or this is what I think, you don’t even realize that
the language that you’re speaking is wounding.
Robin DiAngelo: At this point, anybody listening, anybody white
listening might be feeling, oh my God, I can’t get this right. And that
is true. You cannot get this right. Like, a piece of it is being in that
unsettling place of not knowing; that deep, deep humility.
[music: “Seven League Boots” by Zoe Keating]
Tippett: I’m Krista Tippett, and this is On Being.
Tippett: … or you talk yourself out of — I think for me, it would be, I
can’t do anything about this. I can’t let in the magnitude of this.
Menakem: So there’s a really interesting thing, a number of
experiences that I’ve had since brother George Floyd was murdered.
And one of them is having friends — white friends that I care for,
white friends that I love, and family members — one of the things
that’s kind of the thing that everybody’s starting to say now is, I’m an
ally. White folks love telling you that they’re an ally. And I had an
interesting conversation with a good friend of mine, this is somebody
that I’ve known for a very long time, and he told me, he said, “Man, I
did not understand how just oblivious to this stuff that I was.” He
said, “I’ve been your friend a long time.” And he said, “And I’m still
kind of not understanding.” He said, “One thing happened that just
crystallized this for me.” And he said that the neighborhood that he
belonged to is very liberal. They’re not the devout racists, they’re the
complicit racists. They’re very liberal. They have Black Lives Matters
in their yard. And he said, “One of the interesting things that
happened was that when all of this went down, all of a sudden, the
Black Lives Matter things that were on people’s lawns disappeared.”
And he said he found that strange, because if Black lives mattered
before all of this went down, what’s making you now pick them up?
And he said, “And the thing about it was, is that I immediately
thought about, Resmaa can’t remove his Black skin, that Resmaa can’t
remove the cops killing him. He can’t do that, but we can.” And so he’s
been working with that and struggling with that for a minute. And I
just let him struggle with it, because that’s an important struggle. It’s
an important question to begin to deal with.
DiAngelo: Can I add something to that?
Tippett: I’m just curious, would they take the signs down because they
were scared of how volatile things felt?
Menakem: What he said was, is that they got some report that —
because people were targeting those pieces.
Tippett: I see.
Menakem: And when he said that to me, I said — I can’t cuss on here,
but I said, dude, that is irrelevant. It is really irrelevant, whether or not
they thought that somebody would then target them. People target
me, every day. People target — so the moment you get uncomfortable,
you have escape hatches. You actually —
Tippett: It’s that easy.
DiAngelo: [laughs] Thank you. I shouldn’t have said “in your face,” but
“deal with.”
Menakem: I don’t have a space for either one of them fools. [laughs]
But what I would say is, I would rather have somebody that I know is
working for three years, three to 10 years, working with other white
people on their stuff. I can tolerate that. I can deal with that. I can
even support that. But your declarations don’t really mean anything.
The idea that people can come up to me and ask me, what should I
do?, when we have Google, is just crazy on its face.
And that’s one of the things that I really believe is why white folks
have got to do this work themselves, because white folks don’t even
know that we’re not even speaking the same embodied language.
We’re not even speaking the same verbal language. We don’t see the
world in the same way. So we are not saying the same things. We are
not vibing the same things. And so white people coming up and just
saying, this is what I want to do, or this is what I think, you don’t even
realize that the language that you’re speaking is wounding. It is
brutal. It always has been. And I don’t care who — I don’t care how
many babies you done had with a Black man or Black woman or how
many times you marched with Martin Luther King — none of that
matters. You have to develop culture.
DiAngelo: So, Resmaa, this is such a critical point. And I’m always
like, I want white people to hear this point. So when white people tell
you they’re not racist, that actually isn’t communicating to you that
they’re not racist?
Menakem: No, they’re actually saying the exact opposite. And the
other piece that they’re saying — so I’ve played with this idea of
devout racist and then complicit racist. There’s no such thing as a
nonracist. Either you are destroying this and looking to dismantle this
thing that currently exists, and you’re working towards it and you’re
working towards developing culture around it, or you’re either devout
or complicit. And so for me, when white people say these things that
they think are supportive, because they speak a different language
than I do, a different embodied language, a different verbal language,
what they’re actually telling me is, you are not safe.
DiAngelo: See, and I think a lot of white people listening are like, wait,
why? And so, if I may, Resmaa, and I know you will check me if I miss
this, when we say that, what we’re saying is, we don’t understand
what racism is; we don’t understand what it means to be white.
The other side of that is when we go to someone like Resmaa and we
say, tell me about racism, and then he — which is, basically: open your
chest, open your guts. Be vulnerable. Show yourself. I’m not going to
show myself. I’m just going to receive — it’s extractive — but I’m only
going to receive what I agree with. And so these are all the reasons
why Black people just don’t want to deal with us until we get a little
further along, so we don’t say things like, I’m not racist.
And let me just be really clear. As a result of being raised in this
society as a white person, I’m racist. I have a racist worldview. There’s
no way I don’t have a racist worldview, because it’s embedded in
everything. And that means I have racist assumptions and behaviors
and investments.
And it’s liberating to start from that premise and then just get to work
trying to figure out how it’s manifesting and interrupt that, rather
than the insistence that we could be untouched by the water we’re
swimming in. I mean, so many Black people have said to me, yes, give
me the upfront, in-your-face racist, because I know where they’re
coming from. I know how to protect myself. The white progressive is
smiling, but there’s a knife in my back.
Menakem: That all lands with great force on brother George Floyd’s
body. The thing I think about brother George that I’ve thought about
is that he was such an ordinary man. One of the things that I’ve been
doing is that I have not watched the video. I have not watched that
video all the way through, because I can’t.
But what I have done is I’ve taken the video, and I’ve pulled George
out of the frame and only focused on Chauvin, and looked at his face
for that whole eight, nine minutes, just look at his face. And when you
watch his face, you see such assuredness that the whole system is
behind him, that nothing is going to happen, that he is doing his job
and he’s not even doing it to a human being.
White people gotta work that out amongst themselves. They have to
work out that pus amongst themselves. They have to figure out, when
all of that stuff comes up when they’re in the room with each other,
they have to work that out. And that takes time, because it takes
people being intimate with each other — not intimacy like mother’s
milk, but intimacy like, I am being exposed to you, and we are going
to move through this to develop something and grow up. But white
people are not even willing to acknowledge that there is an infection.
Tippett: I think, also, this matter of white people, well, the work we
have to do together, this work has to happen for the world to change. I
worry about the culture we’ve created, the public discourse culture
we’ve created in recent years that got backgrounded during the
COVID early period and is kind of now back — that we don’t have
public space where it is reasonable to invite people to confess, to
change, to acknowledge shortcomings, or to let other people do that.
And I feel like that’s a space that we have to create. But I guess that’s
really the white people work among themselves that has to happen.
Menakem: You have to create it. You’re right, it doesn’t exist. An
embodied antiracist culture and practice doesn’t exist, and now you
have to create it — not for me, but so you don’t pass this infection
down to your children.
DiAngelo: And [laughs] a book group over a glass of wine — at this
point, anybody listening — anybody white listening might be feeling,
oh my God, I can’t get this right. And that is true. You cannot get this
right. A piece of it is being in that unsettling place of not knowing —
that deep, deep humility. And even the confession can be problematic.
It can range from just a form of masochism to a form of, well, I feel
bad enough that you can see that I’m actually good. And so that also
becomes performative —
Tippett: No, I’m talking about confession coupled with repentance,
which literally means you stop in your tracks and walk in a different
direction.
Menakem: And do something.
DiAngelo: Just had to put that out there, because we also have to figure
out how to do that work in accountable ways. I am a little nervous
about how many people now are like, oh, I read your book, and now I
want to start a book study, or, I want to start a workshop. And it takes
years of experience and study and struggle and mistake-making and
trust-building to hold a group around race and really hold that group
and push them and help them go where they need to go, in ways that
are constructive. It takes a lot of experience. So we just have to also
think — this isn’t the, maybe, format to give the answer to
accountability, but we need to be asking ourselves that.
Tippett: But somehow we need accountability that actually celebrates
change, because right now we just have yelling at each other and
putting other people down.
Menakem: Are you talking about white folk?
Tippett: Yeah, I’m talking about white folks, yeah. One thing — using
the word “we,” I’m really trying to actually stop myself [laughs] or
question it, every time I do it. And it’s hard. But you’re right, yes. I
mean white people.
DiAngelo: I usually just start out by saying, when I say we, I’m talking
to my fellow white people.
Tippett: So, years ago, I interviewed John Lewis in Montgomery,
Alabama, which was one of the most incredible experiences of my life.
And one of the things John Lewis talks about, about the Civil Rights
Movement in the 1950s and the 1960s, the kind of disciplines that they
brought, the spiritual and tactical discipline that they brought, was
that while you had to be strategic and tactical and fight the fights and
do the actions, you also had to know in your mind the world that you
wanted to create. And he said you had to live as if. So you were
working with what is, and you are applying your creativity and the
power of human imagination and courage to holding to that, that
world you want to be walking towards and walking with others
towards.
So I think maybe I’ll start with you, Robin. What is that as if, beyond
white fragility as the norm and as a determinant, a driving force, in
our culture, our society?
DiAngelo: Well, the word that keeps coming up to me is repair — that
we would have a framework that would allow us to repair. And the
framework that is causing white fragility is a refusal to repair, a
refusal to see or feel. Some defensiveness is a natural response, when
given direct feedback about something. It’s defensiveness that
functions to refuse to understand or stretch or go deeper, that is
absolutely certain that they know all they need to know. And I’m just
going to say it: many of your listeners right now are feeling that they
already have the answer, and they know all they need to know, and
here is the correct response. So it would be the fortitude to get to a
place of repair. What would it take?
I’ll never forget asking a group — I asked the Black people in the
group, what would it be like if you could just go there with us, give us
that feedback, tell us, talk to us, and we received it with grace, we
reflected, and we sought to change our behavior? And I’ll never forget,
a Black man raised his hand and said, “It would be revolutionary.”
Just notice that. That’s a revolution — we would receive that with
grace, reflect, and seek to repair?
But it’s actually not that tall an order. But it is a very tall order. I’d say
it’s too tall an order from the current paradigm that says it has to be
intentional to count.
Tippett: So, Resmaa, let’s say we’re walking along the long arc of the
moral universe. What is that as if that you want to be walking into
and you want your grandchildren to inherit?
Menakem: The first thing that comes to my mind is that Black women
can be in their beds, sleeping, and not have to worry about somebody
kicking a door in and putting eight bullets in them; that our schools
are such that they’re organized around the care of Black children’s
bodies and the need that they have, as opposed to trying to fit them
inside of something that is not working for them and that was never
designed for them. The system is not broken, it was designed this way.
It’s doing exactly what it should do. So for me, the opposite is what I
would need to see.
The opposite is, if something happens, that our people can be in a
situation where they can be redeemed. So if they go to do something
and they hurt somebody or something like that, and they are in prison
— which is not necessarily the case, because you don’t necessarily
have to do something, if you’re in a Black body and end up in prison.
That is not a prerequisite — but if you are, then that prison is actually
a school; that prison has things in it that will actually allow you to not
just sit and fester, but grow and prosper.
And so for me, if I’m thinking my children are living in a world that I
would design, it would be that they were not free of strife, or not free
of things happening, because difficult things can happen, and you can
be bettered through them. What I’m talking about is the structural
thing that makes it so that my life is not worthy. I would like for that
to be different and change. And so if I’m looking at, as you said the
ancestor said, if I’m looking at the world as I would like it, that’s
where it would start for me.
Tippett: I have to say, both of your answers are really modest. [laughs]
You know what I mean? And it says something, that it’s hard to
imagine that world you’d really, really want to live in, as opposed to a
world that’s just free of brutality that shouldn’t be there in the first
place.
Menakem: I just need that first.
Tippett: Well, then, that’s a good reason to stop. Thank you both, so
much.
Menakem: Thank you, Krista.
Tippett: Blessings.