Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Classics Illustrated in Literature
Classics Illustrated in Literature
Classics Illustrated in Literature
ANGLOPHONE LITERATURE.
ABSTRACT
The learning of Anglophone literature is a key element in the formation of students
of English in their History and culture of English speaking countries lessons. The
acquirement of cultural competence contextualized in a literary and historic frame
is a didactic goal across the curriculum. The use of classics illustrated and classical
comics books are a significant didactic and complementary tool for their cultural
formation. These comics will help students interpret not only the cultural and
historic features of the countries they study but will help them decode the social
conventions which permeate literature. At the same time, it should offer a great
opportunity to reinforce language competence through the integration of skills. This
work offers teacher a methodological alternative to face the literature lessons in the
subject History and culture of English speaking countries. To carry out this work
was set as objective… and different methods were employed such as…
Keywords:
Cultural competence, curriculum, foreign languages, Anglophone literature
lessons, classics illustrated, classical comics books.
INTRODUCCIÓN
¨Language is a means of existence, transmission and assimilation of the socio-
historical experience” (Petrovsky, 1981), this is an unquestionable principle due to
this, language is manifested in layer after layer of the human evolution, without
history no language can exist. In the curriculum for foreign languages major the
history and culture of the English speaking countries is conceived since the third
year till the fifth covering from England to Asian countries where English is spoken
as a second or third language.
The teaching of this subject not only deals with pure history but also with all the
elements that form part of the Anglophone civilizations, remarking above all their
literature, customs, traditions, music among other aspects. All these elements
must achieve an adequate communicative competence in the students for it plays
the leading role in foreign language learning where culture and literature are
indissoluble parts of good communication. Literature LESSONS, as Mainland
(2013: 145) states help students find their voice.
This is why this subject, and as an essential part of the curriculum, highly
contributes to the future professional of humanistic sciences cultural, humanistic
and spiritual world. On the other hand, it enables students to develop a critical
opinion of the world history which could consolidate their political and ideological
vision. Therefore, the analysis of literary works can positive influence the
axiological education as a cross curricular issue.
Using non-classic literature in the ESL lessons has motivated quite an intense
debate, some underestimate and devaluate any literature teaching moving away
from ‘‘classics’’ while others champion for including any literary form which – within
certain standards - allow and motivate students to conquer the spiritual world of
culture.
So, Are comics a form of literature? Can they play an important role in the teaching
learning process?
With the development of printing in times of the industrial revolution (1760 – 1840)
‘The Adventures of Obadiah Oldbuck’ by Rodolphe Toffler, printed in 1842,
became the first graphic novel and 50 years later, ‘The Yellow Kid’ published by
Richard Outcault became the first commercial success (Yildirim, 2013).
In the 1940s, it was a million-dollar industry; founded on the motivation of children,
teenagers and adults (Gorman, 2007). During the 70`s the comic market and
distribution turned more open and the graphic novels came true (O'English,
Matthews, and Lindsay, 2006).
Their effectiveness as a learning and developmental tool has been the subject of
debate since their very beginning in the 1930s, according to Gruenberg (1944);
and Hutchinson (1949). As early as its golden age in the 40s, Sones (1944) stated
that comics "evoked more than a hundred critical articles in educational and non-
professional periodicals."
Since early educators started experimenting with them as a teaching-learning tool.
It was evident that Comics had the potentialities to be seriously implemented as a
form of literature. Later, with the Pulitzer-winning ¨Maus¨, by Art Spiegelman and
the awarding plays Watchmen by Alan Moore and The Dark Knight Returns by
Frank Miller, a tremendous recognition for the genre has been evident (Yildirim,
2013).
There has been a global call for using comics in the classroom, as a form of
literature. There are official studies and experiences, which have played an
important role as, the Maryland's Comic Book Initiative in USA, which promotes
courses on how teachers can integrate comics into the classroom and the State of
California Department of Education's Brokers of Expertise website Comic Book
Initiative with its program of instructional strategies supporting the use of graphic
literature in elementary, secondary, adult, and corrections education. Another
important studied was developed in the Republic of China, with the Create a Comic
Project, promoting comics as educational literature.
All these studies side with the positive relation between literature and language
development, and they propose the didactic integration of booths.
It is also important to take into account the question of availability of bibliographic
resources and materials. In countries like Cuba, where due to political and
economic contexts the access to printed literature is conditioned to many difficult
decisions, and sometimes it cannot be a priority; Comics from the web are a saving
alternative.
This article aims at proposing professor some alternative guidelines on the usage
of comics as a source to teach literature, introduce students to the pleasure of
extensive reading and while doing so developing language and communicative
competence.
DESARROLLO
Literature and language are bound together. Literature is shaped by language and
represents its most recurrent usage. Language and linguistic are means to access
literature. Brumfit and Carter (1986) already emphasized the role of literature as
“an ally of language”.
Undoubtedly literature reading is a communicative activity based on authentic
texts, example of language usage. Some authors, as Brumfit and Carter (1986)
and Lazar (1993), reject the existence of a specific literary language, claim a
common language usage in literary texts, with the characteristic of concentrating
some linguistic features like metaphors, similes, poetic lexis, unusual syntactic
patterns, etc. This is not specific of literature works for it is also present in ordinary
language use.
Literature indorses cultural and intercultural consciousness (Van, 2009) especially
in the era of globalization where there is a need for understanding the whole world.
From the psychological stand point literature enables creativity, imagination,
comprehension, understanding and shapes one’s own personality. From the
linguistic point of view reinforces pronunciation, vocabulary acquisition and
grammar learning. From the pedagogical perspective fosters speaking, listening
and writing skills.
Reading also allows students to reaffirm the poly-semantic values of the words in
its objective realization of thought. Reading improves spelling, coherence and
cohesion. It permits students to go from low colloquial language to highly literary
where words and word equivalents actually show its connotation in real contexts.
On the most important outcomes from studies in using comics in literature
evidence that visual literacy conveys an instinctual understanding in different ways
to conventional texts. From it the expression "Use a picture. It's worth a thousand
words," published in a 1911 newspaper article discussing journalism and publicity.
Comics impact is not merely from juxtaposing text and images. Comics are now
viewed as genuine literature. They are prominent in libraries, movies and tv; they
have reached, even, beyond youngsters to all those interested in the pleasure of
reading. Comics, as a phenomenon, have transcended to the movie industry
breeding a new generation of fans worldwide.
As Byram (2001), points out, it would not be a difficult task persuading foreign
language teachers of the necessity to teach language and culture in an integrated
way. As stated, language is a cultural expression (Antich, 1988). Though, most
teachers seem comfortable with the practice of exposing their students to the
extensive hard reading classic texts.
Even though, we know our students find classics very difficult to read and deal with
their vocabulary and in many opportunities try to find – an easier - way around to
the book. This is evident when you read their book analysis and reports or when
they comment on the books. So, why not working on creating the proper incentive
to read literature for pleasure. But to do so we need to do it step by step, little by
little.
We dare saying one of the most valuable experiences we have had with the usage
of comics in our literature lessons is unquestionably introducing them to classic
literature. It is not difficult to access a graphic novel version of most major literary
plays searching online.
Some authors, as McTaggert speaks about a sort of chain effect with comics. He
states that readers become interested and so reluctant readers find motivation
beyond those text-only novels – which many of our students avoid - and so,
readers learning at a higher level would become challenged. It is obvious we find
plenty advantages when using comics for teaching, reluctant reader does play
quite the role in regards to the progress of the readers who have become even
more proficient (McTaggert, 2008).
Another important advantage we have experienced is being able to expose
students to different learning styles as a way to get a better understanding of plots
and content. The effect of using comics in education is one of those things that
have been researched for quite a bit now (Jacobs, 2007).
We need a wider diversity of materials to cater the students different learning
styles, hence, comics become more than just entertainment. Carter (2007a) talks
about non-text visual media as an appropriate choice for today’s youth learning, for
visualization plays an important role, both in understanding and using the
imagination to recreate it.
Through just combining the visual and the verbal element - comics can easily serve
to motivate the interest of the reluctant or discouraged reader, who are made so by
simply failing to read these difficult texts in their traditional form (Frey & Fisher,
2004).
Despite all the evidence of the positive impact comics may have in the cultural
formation of students, some criticism is based on the fact that comics comprise
some substandard literature. Some teachers refuse to accept comics as real
literary books but some other truly believe in their cultural importance, comics are
neither more nor less than any other reading material (Gravett, 2005).
Some other key points siding with using graphic books deserve to be mentioned,
for example their potentialities to be appealing to different intelligences (Gardner,
1983). We may find more than one kind of intelligence in our classroom, which is
really demanding when designing effective teaching literary and language tasks.
Comics are a useful tool to use with different kinds of intelligence and the learning
styles.
Perhaps, the main concern professor should have regarding the usage of comics in
their literature lessons is how integrating comics into the curriculum. Advantages
and disadvantages are quite simple for those who decide to experience it. The
background knowledge will help them assess the risks and to successfully help
them integrate these graphic novels into the multiple aspects of their curriculum
(Schwarz, 2002).
Comic literature and language learning.
If we analyze the use of comics for reinforcing the language learning, we could
champion for comics for they provide a genuine and authentic sample of language,
styles and registers. All these language expressions train learners at linguistic level
but also at social level, they all have a social communicative function (Sanz and
Fernández 1997).
There is also a methodological criterion, for comics text offers multiple
interpretations, generating difference of opinions among students, and leading
motivated interaction with texts, students and professors (Widdowson 1983).
Interaction is a key characteristic in communicative approach which stands by
interacting, by communicating, as the ways language is learned (Sanz and
Fernández 1997). Another positive point is the student active role with the literary
text as central focus of attention. Readers play an active and autonomous role in
learning.
Comics offer also visual-cultural information about the country language they are
learning (Lazar 1993). Finally, there is a motivational criterion, visual literacy
shows the author real feelings which stimulates learners. Students access this
personal experience when touched or provoked by the theme. Teacher must be
creative in designing stimulating tasks integrating the students challenge at
literature and language.
In Sancti Spíritus University José Martí Pérez, students of the foreign language
studies receive the subject History and culture of English speaking countries is
taught to 3rd year student up to 5th year, for its highly demanding linguistic and
communicative competence. This subject covers a vast panorama of themes which
include the analysis of important historical events and the cultural and literary
expressions representative of the socio cultural development of the Anglophone
world, so as the contribution to the universal culture of human beings.
During the study developed with the preparation and organization of the subject
some important questions in terms of materials and students’ performance were
detected. There is lack of printed literature for students, most of literary plays to be
studied through the curriculum are in digital format. Many are photocopied and lack
any kind of attractiveness. But the most important finding was that students show
reluctance to reading the long-texts, they find them hard to understand and not
motivating.
A diagnostic was applied to a sample of 25, 3 rd and 4th year students, of the
Foreign Language Teaching Course of Studies. Aimed at compiling some
information on the development of literature lessons and student’s performance; so
as the influence of the literary materials used in lessons. The following instruments
were employed: survey and interview. Accordingly, it is evident that the literary
materials used in the literature lessons were not offering effective and positive
results in terms of learning and conscious-pleasing reading. It was, then, the
authors´ decision to offer motivating alternatives which contribute to the students
learning of literature texts representative of the Anglophone countries they study,
introduce them to classic literature and reinforce the development of
communicative and language competences.
Proposal of alternative literature on England, cover graphic books not only from
comic illustrated but some other respectful editorial houses like: Europe comics,
Black Cats, Mc Graw Hill, Pearson (Penguin Books)
History and Culture of English Speaking Countries I: England
Section 1: Feudal England.
Beowulf. Black Cat Publishing, 2007.
Caesar's Conquest. Classic Illustrated No. 130. Author: Julius Caesar.
1066 The Norman Conquest. Europe comics editorial.
The Canterbury Tales. Arthur. Mc Graw Hill. 2006.
Robin Hood. Pearson (Penguin Books).
Knights of the round table. Classic Illustrated No. 108. Author: Uncredited;
based in part on The Story by Howard Pyle.
Men of Iron. Classic Illustrated No. 88. Author: Howard Pyle.
Castle Dangerous. Classic Illustrated No. 141. Author: Walter Scott.
The Black Arrow. Classic Illustrated No. 31. Author: Robert Louis Stevenson.
The White Compan. Classic Illustrated No. 102. Author: Arthur Conan Doyle.
Lorna Doone. December 1946. Classic Illustrated No. 32. Author: D. Blackmore.
Westward Ho! September 1943. Classic Illustrated No. 4. Author: Charles
Kingsley.
The Lady of the Lake. Classic Illustrated No. 75. Author: Walter Scott.
A Midsummer Night's Dream. Classic Illustrated No. 87. Author: William
Shakespeare.
Hamlet. Classic Illustrated No. 99. Author: William Shakespeare.
Macbeth. Classic Illustrated No. 128. Author: William Shakespeare.
Romeo and Juliet. Classic Illustrated No. 134. Author: William Shakespeare.
Proposal:
History and Culture of English Speaking Countries II: United States of America
Section 1: Genesis of USA. Colonization period.
In this unit students study the following historical and cultural aspects, among other
related to the same historical period.
Native cultures, cultural encounter.
American Colonial Literature
Proposal of graphic books for the unit:
Evangeline. Classic Illustrated No. 92. Classic Comics. Author: Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow.
The Song of Hiawatha. Classic Illustrated No. 57. Classic Comics. Author: Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow.
The last of the Mohicans. Classic Illustrated No. 4. August 1942. Classic
Comics. Author: James Fenimore Cooper.
Rip Van Winkle. Classic Illustrated No. 12. June 1943. Classic Comics. Author:
Washington Irving
The Headless Horsemen. Classic Illustrated No.12. June 1943. Classic Comics.
Author: Washington Irving.
The Path Finder. Classic Illustrated No.22. October 1944. Classic Comics.
Author: James Fenimore Cooper.
The Pioneers. Classic Illustrated No. 37. Classic Comics. Author: James
Fenimore Cooper.
History and Culture of English Speaking Countries III: United States of America
Section 1: Antebellum. Reconstruction, expansion and monopolist development:
1865-1898.
In this unit students study the following historical and cultural aspects, among other
related to the same historical period.
Reconstruction process of the south, the industrial development of US
The Murders in the Rue Morgue. Classic Illustrated No. 21. July 1944. Author:
Edgar Allan Poe.
The Pit and the Pendulum. Classic Illustrated No. 40. Author: Edgar Allan Poe.
The House of the Seven Gables. Classic Illustrated No. 52. Author: Nathaniel
Hawthorne.
The Scarlet Letter. Black Cat Editorial. Author: Nathaniel Hawthorne.
The Murders in the Rue Morgue. Classic Illustrated No. 21. July 1944. Author:
Edgar Allan Poe.
The Gold Bug and Other Stories. Classic Illustrated No. 84. Author: Edgar Allan
Poe.
The Pit and the Pendulum. Classic Illustrated No. 40. Author: Edgar Allan Poe.
The Luck of Roaring Camp. Classic Illustrated No. 62. Author: Bret Harte.
The Outcasts of Poker Flat. Classic Illustrated No. 62. Author: Bret Harte.
The Red Badge of Courage. Classic Illustrated No. 98. Author: Stephen Crane.
When working with this literary comics, it is also important to cover the general
cultural panorama related to the literary work. Students can work with other cultural
expressions which have represented the play they are studying; mostly painting,
movies, theater and dance. This will offer students the possibility to widen their
use of language in a cultural perspective, developing their cultural competences.
Another important point to be taken into account is the question of social
conventions, which may help students learn how to distinguish some particularities
between the society they are studying and their own culture. It is also advisable to
move learners to notice the ‘social evolution’ from the historical setting and
perspective of the play to the present characteristics which define modern society
in the same countries.
Students could also be asked to make a comparison of the cultural scenario of the
play with that of their home country at the same socio-historical moment. Take into
account similarities and differences. This would help them acquire a better
comprehension of the socio, historical and cultural moment.
After the application of the instruments the outcomes obtained showed the
pertinence of the comics in the teaching of Anglophone literature. Out of the
twenty-five students selected as sample only three were active readers and the
rest were reluctant readers. Once the comics were used in the literature lessons,
only four students kept being reluctant because they read the comics as an
obligation to fulfill assessments purposes while twelve became active readers
because they read more than 60% of the comics and searched for some original
classic works they felt really attracted to and nine were considered as average
readers that are expected to become active readers in the coming years, as they
started moving into the world of literature.
Conclusions.
The motivation of students for extensive reading, the pleasure they find in the
comprised form of the classic texts, combined by the artistic lines, shapes and
colors of the illustrators evidence the didactic and methodological potentialities of
using graphic books, mainly from the series ‘comics illustrated.’
It is not about substitution of classic works, which are undoubtedly a task to deal
with and the final achievement of a literary reader, but to offer an alternative to
students in which, even those who have been historically reluctant to literary
reading find the stimulus to start moving in the world of literature, an introduction to
the reading of the classics of literature.
There has unquestionably been a moving forward in the subject and the
effectiveness of literature lessons with the implementation of these alternatives in
the subject History and Culture of English Speaking Countries. There is a
contribution to develop cultural, communicative and language competences for
learners read enthusiastically and cover a wider range of literary works. So, their
cultural knowledge of the literary work of the English speaking world increases and
so their spiritual and cultural world.
The alternatives have been focused on the professor and the potentialities of
selecting the materials he finds more suitable to work with students. It is also
important to take into account the formative context.
This work made evident the students appreciation for the literary works, when
properly motivated, how they find pleasure in heavy-reading – even those who had
little experience in literary approach - when they find the reading stimulant.
Referencias
Antich, R.; Candarias, D.; López, E. (1988). Metodología de la enseñanza de
lenguas extranjeras. Editorial Pueblo y Educación, Cuba.
Brumfit, C.; A. C. Ronald. (1986). Literature and Language Teaching. Oxford,
Oxford University Press.
Byram, M. (2001). Developing Intercultural Competence in Practice. Multilingual
Matters.
Carter, J. (2007a). Building literacy connections with graphic novels, Page by page,
panel by panel. Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English.
Frey, N.; Fisher, D. (2004). Using graphic novels, anime, and the Internet in an
urban high school. The English Journal, 93(3), 19-25.
Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of Mind, The Theory of Multiple Intelligences. New
York, Basic.
Gorman, M. (2007). Getting Graphic! Comics for Kids. Linworth Publishing.
Gravett, P. (2005). Graphic novels: Stories to change your life. New York. Collins
Design.
Gruenberg, S. (1944). "The Comics as a Social Force". Journal of Educational
Sociology (American Sociological Association), 18 (4), 204–213.
Hutchinson, K. (1949). "An experiment in the use of comics as instructional
material". Journal of Educational Sociology (American Sociological
Association) 23 (4): 236–245.
Jacobs, D. (2007). More than words, Comics as a means of teaching multiple
literacies. English Journal, 96(3), 19-25.
Kelley, B. (2010). Sequential Art, Graphic Novels, and Comics: A Position Paper.
SANE journal, 1 (1), em3-26.
Lazar, G. (1993). Literature and Language Teaching. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Mainland, C. (2013). Teaching Literature like a Foreign Language; or, What I
Learned When I Switched Departments, Pedagogy, 13 (1), 2013: 145-148.
McTaggert, J. (2008). Graphic Novels: The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly. In N.
Frey, & D. Fisher (Eds.), Teaching visual literacy: Using comic books,
graphic novels, anime, cartoons, and more to develop comprehension and
thinking skills (pp. 27-46). Thousand Oaks, CA. Corwin Press.
O'English, L.; Matthews, J.; Lindsay, E. (2006). Graphic novels in academic
libraries, From Maus and beyond. The Journal of Academic Librarianship,
32(2), 173-182.
Petrovsky, A. (1981). Psicología General. Editorial Progreso, Moscu.
Sanz, M.; C. Fernández. (1997). Principios Metodológicos de los Enfoques
Comunicativos. Madrid. Fundación Antonio Nebrija.
Sawyer, M. "Albert Lewis Kanter and the Classics, The Man Behind the Gilberton
Company," The Journal of Popular Culture, Spring 1987, Vol. 20, p1-18.
Schwarz, G. (2002). Graphic novels for multiple literacies. Journal of Adolescent &
Adult Literacy, 46(3), 262- 265.
Sones, W. (1944). "The comics and instructional method". Journal of Educational
Sociology (American Sociological Association), 18 (4): 232–240.
Templer, B. (2009). Graphic Novels in the ESL Classroom, Humanizing Language
Teaching, 11(3), Pilgrims. Retrieved from:
http://www.hltmag.co.uk/jun09/mart03.htm
Van, T. (2009). The relevance of literary analysis to teaching literature in the EFL
classroom. English Teaching Forum, 3, 2-9.
Widdowson, H.G. (1983). “H.G. Widdowson on literature and ELT”, Talking Shop,
ELT Journal 37, 1: 30-35.
Wilson, B. (2005). More lessons from the superheroes of J.C. Holtz, The visual
culture of childhood and the third pedagogical site [Electronic version]. Art
Education. 58(6), 18-24, 33-34.
Wright, G.; & Sherman, R. (1999). Let's create a comic strip. Reading Improvement, 36(2),
66-72.
Yildirim, A. (2013). Using graphic novels in the classroom, Dil Ve Edebiyat Egitimi
Dergisi, 2(8), 118-131.
Annex 1: LITERATURE READING HABITS WORKSHEET