Preliminary Distributions from an Estate or Trust -

The Basics
It is common for the probate of an estate or termination of a trust to require more than a year to
complete as taxes are paid, creditors satisfied and the various assets either liquidated to divided as
required in the Will or Trust. If litigation erupts, an estate or Trust may remain open for over a decade.
There are some estates which remain open after several decades, though the bulk of estates close
within a year to two years.

During that period of time, the estate assets remain under the control of the Trustee or Executor, and
the various beneficiaries do not see the proceeds until the Trust or Estate closes. See our article on
Probateof Estates in California.

This can be a definite disadvantage to those beneficiaries in need of funds sooner. For those
beneficiaries who are elderly, it can be particularly unfair. A beneficiary who is in his or her mid-eighties
may have to wait a third of his or her remaining lifetime to gain access to funds that the decedent
wanted them to enjoy as soon as possible!

Recognizing this, the Courts have allowed a special process whereby even before an Estate or Trust is
ready to be closed, preliminary distribution may be achieved for the beneficiaries. The basics of this
process and the criteria utilized by the Court are the subject of this article.

THE BASIC PROCESS:

The common reason for making a preliminary distribution of a portion of the decedent’s assets before
the estate can be finally closed and distributed is to allow one or more beneficiaries to enjoy all or a
portion of their inheritance before final distribution. Court policy favors such efforts.

This is particularly true when the gifts are monetary (“pecuniary”) since the Court may easily determine
the sums to be distributed. When hard assets (interests in a business or real estate) are involved, the
Courts may hesitate before dividing the distributions up.

In forming an overall plan for distribution, it should be recognized that preliminary distribution
implements the policy of favoring earliest distribution consistent with proper administration. Estate of
Buchanan (1955) 132 CA2d 81.

The basic policy provides that although an estate may be large, its administration complex, or ownership
of certain of its assets subject to litigation, the unaffected portion of the estate may be distributed if
such distribution will not jeopardize the rights of persons interested in the estate. The Courts support
such efforts normally since they allow the representative to minimize delays often inherent in the
probate proceeding by preliminary distribution of specific gifts or payment of pecuniary gifts.

Procedure for Preliminary Distribution: The Petition for Preliminary Distribution

The representative generally must obtain court approval before making a preliminary distribution.
Authorization to make a preliminary distribution may be obtained by filing a noticed petition with the
 court under Probate Code Section 11600-11602 and 11620-11622. Notice must be given as provided in
Probate Code Section 1220 to the beneficiaries and other interested parties listed in Probate Code
11601. Such notice will quickly determine if any parties object to the proposed distribution and they
may file their opposition with the Court or make an appearance to object.

Time for Filing Petition for Preliminary Distribution

Most counsel find it advantageous to file the petition after the expiration of the period for filing
creditors’ claims and a determination that all uncontested claims have been paid or are adequately
secured. If only two months have elapsed, courts may be very cautious in granting preliminary
distribution under Probate Code Section 11620 because there is little protection for persons interested
in the estate from additional creditors’ claims that may still be presented. See In re Painter (1897) 115 C
635.

At least 15 days before the hearing on a petition for preliminary distribution under Probate Code Section
11620, notice must be served as provided in Probate Code Section 11601 on certain designated persons
who constitute heirs, interested parties, and known creditors.

Required Findings of Fact by the Court

Petitions for preliminary distribution require the court to make the following specific finding of fact: For
all petitions, a finding that the “distribution may be made without loss to creditors or injury to the estate
or any interested person.” Probate Code Section 11621

Amount of Distribution

There are no express limitations on the amount of property that can be distributed under a petition for
preliminary distribution filed under Probate Code Section 11620 as long as the court determines that
adequate protection exists for the creditors and those interested in the estate. Realistically, the Court will
require ample funds remain for any likely obligation of the estate to creditors, tax authorities, litigation,
etc.

Who May Petition

A petition for preliminary distribution under Probate Code Section 16200, 11602, and 11620 may be
filed by any interested person - they must be able to show a direct pecuniary interest in the distribution.
See Estate of Baldwin (1943) 21 C2d 586.

Who May Object

Any person interested in the estate may oppose a petition for preliminary distribution under Probate
Code Section 11602. Case law has defined the phrase “person interested in the estate,” for purposes of
opposing a petition for preliminary distribution under former Probate Code Section 1000 as one who has
direct pecuniary interest that would be defeated if the distribution as requested were granted. See, e.g.
Estate of Molera (1972) 23 CA3d 993; Estate of Goyette (1971) 14 CA 3d 224.

Costs for Petition for Preliminary Distribution

The costs of a proceeding in connection with a petition for preliminary distribution are paid by the
distributee or the estate, in proportions determined by the court. Probate Code Section 11624. Note
that this means that persons who will not necessarily benefit from the preliminary distribution may have
to pay their pro rata share of the additional costs which, while not major, will be several thousand
dollars in most cases.

CONSIDERATIONS:

The essence of the law is simple: if other heirs or creditors (including taxing authorities) are not injured
and if the distribution can be easily calculated by the Court, then the preliminary distribution will
normally be granted. Indeed, in any complex estate which may take years to close, it is the choice a wise
fiduciary should make to benefit the heirs.

It does cost money to draft and file the petition and extreme care must be made to assure that no
creditors are harmed. The most common objection, however, is often from other family members not
receiving the distribution who may feel it is unfair or somehow may impact their interests. Quite often
those people will not file a formal objection but will appear at the hearing to voice their concerns.

Certainly unless there is an overriding reason, the preliminary distribution should seek to treat all
beneficiaries equally and it is common to have all beneficiaries receive, pro rata, their share of the
distribution. It is even more common for the wise fiduciary to take an informal poll of the beneficiaries
to determine their wishes and if there is real resistance to the preliminary distribution, determine if
there is good cause for the objection…and seek to remedy the concerns.

But regardless of such objections, if the proposed distributees need the funds, or if he or she is elderly
and if the others are not clearly harmed, the Court will normally uphold the petition and there is law
that seeking such a preliminary distribution is actually a duty imposed upon the fiduciary in such
circumstances.

Article Categories

Trusts and Estate Administration

Duties and Law Regarding Trustees and Executors

Share this article!

EmailGmailYahoo MailCopy LinkShare
Related Articles
Duties of an Executor in California - You've Been Nominated...Now What?
Probate in California - The Basics
Removal of the Administrator or Executor of an Estate
Trustees'/Executors' Duty to Pay Creditors - The Priorities Involved and Abatement

Find Articles in our Online Library

Find helpful legal articles & summaries on key areas of the law!

Stimmel, Stimmel & Roeser


o Home
o Our Firm
 Firm Overview
 Attorneys
 Typical Cases
 Videos
 Community
o Articles

o Cookie Policy
o Privacy Policy
o Terms of Use
o Contact

Founded in 1939, our law firm combines the ability to represent clients in domestic or international matters
with the personal interaction with clients that is traditional to a long established law firm.

Read more about our f