Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reeve 1972
Reeve 1972
ABSTRACT
The large pH dependent CEC in Natal Oxisols effectively limits the downward movement of lime.
Although heavy fertilization, particularly with acid-forming nitrogenous fertilizers, increases the rate of
movement, relatively small amounts of Ca salts having little ability to neutralize subsoil exchangeable A1
could be leached from limed topsoil. In contrast, bases equivalent to 80% of that applied leached rapidly
from gypsum-treated topsoil. Although gypsum could not entirely eliminate subsoil exchangeable Al, it
lowered the level of exchangeable Al in the subsoil more effectively than did lime. However, gypsum
caused severe loss of exchangeable Mg which could have serious nutritional consequences if not cor-
rected.
1
AMELIORATION OF SUBSOIL ACIDITY BY LEACHING OF SURFACE-APPLIED AMENDMENTS
σ>
Ο Ο
ο Ο
\ \
σ σ
ω ω
ε Ε
Oi Oο
i
ο
"5 "5
Oi
Ό Ό
ω ω
σ> σ>
Ό +
C
<ο
Ο
10
FIG. 1 Total bases leached from Clovelly topsoil (0-15 cm) treated with lime (set B), lime 4 NaNO3 (set C), and lime + NH4CI (set D)
FIG. 1 Totale base geloog van Clovelly bogr,,nd (0-15 cm) bebande/ met kalk (stel B), kalk + NaN03 (s/el C), en kalk } NHtCl (ste/ D)'
TABLE 1 Experimental treatments applied to sets of Clovelly top- Ca, Mg, and Κ leached from the limed soil are presented
Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2012)
soil treated with increments of lime or gypsum in Fig. 1 and from the gypsum treated soil in Fig. 2.
TABEL 1 Proefbebandelings toegedien aart slelle Clovelly bogrond bebandel Κ lost from individual treatments is not shown since
met inkremente van kalk of gips the maximum Κ lost was <0,05 meq/100 g and <0,12
Amelio- Sub- meq/100 g from lime and gypsum-treated soil respective-
Set No. Leach rant Topsoil soil ly. Although application of NaNO s and NH4C1 m-
Stclnr. Loog Verbete- Ν Bogrond Onder-
ringsmiddel grond
A No Ca(OH)2 No Yes No
Β Yes Ca(OH)2 No Yes No
C Yes Ca(OH)2 NaN0 3 Yes No
D Yes Ca(OH)2 NH4C1 Yes No
Ε Yes C a S 0 4 . 2 H 2 0 No Yes No
F Yes Ca(OH)2 NH4C1 Yes Yes
G Yes C a S 0 4 . 2 H 2 0 No Yes Yes
2
Ν. G . R E E V E & Μ . Ε. S U M N E R
creased the loss of bases from lime-treated topsoil, the CF^C accounts for the minimal movement of bases from
maximum amount leached (1,5 meq/100 g) was far less limed soil. F^xchangeable Al decreased to zero with
than in the case of gypsum-treated soil where total increased rates of lime application as expected. In agree-
bases leached were equivalent to 80% of that applied. ment with the findings of Reeve & Sumner (1970b),
At low levels of ameliorant more Mg than Ca was re- the neutralization of exchangeable Al is not a preferen-
moved supporting the earlier finding (Reeve, 1968) that tial reaction; the neutralization of other forms of acidity
in these soils Mg is considerably less strongly absorbed
than Ca. NaNO., and NH4C1 increased the removal of
Mg from limed soil but losses were nevertheless not
appreciable. In the case of gypsum-treated soil, how-
ever, serious losses of Mg occurred, more than half the
native exchangeable Mg (1,7 meq/100 g) being lost for
gypsum applications above 3 meq/100 g. Comparison
of Fig. 1 and 3 shows that the greater loss of Ca, Mg,
and Κ from Ν fertilized soil is adequately accounted
for by the increase in exchangeable Na (set C) and large-
ly by the increase in exchangeable NH 4 (set D). Nitri-
fication increased with increased rate of liming as ex-
pected (Fig. 3); the quantitative agreement between the
decrease in exchangeable NH 4 and the increase in N 0 3
produced (set D) indicates that nitrification of added
NH 4 takes place preferentially to that of native organic
N. On the other hand, the considerable nitrification of
organic Ν which took place in the unfertilized soil (set
B) is further evidence that cation exchange rather than
physiologically produced acids is mostly responsible for
the increased loss of base from limed soil fertilized with
N. In support of this, field experiments in Natal fre-
quently show little or no crop response to Ν on newly
Ca(OH) applied toegedien (mcq'lOOg)
cultivated soils.
Neutral salt or "field pH" CEC is known to increase
FIG. 3 Nitrate leached (sets Β and D) and exchangeable Na and
with liming due to neutralization or replacement of NH4 remaining in limed Clovelly topsoil (0-15 cm) ferti-
initially non-salt exchangeable "H" with salt exchange- lized with NaNO3 (set C) and NH4C1 (set D) after leaching
able Ca (Bhumbla & McLean, 1965; Reeve & Sumner, with de-ionised water. Soil not fertilized with Ν contained
1971). CEC values obtained at different levels of negligible amounts of Na and NH4 after leaching
Ca(OH)2 are shown in Fig. 4 (set B). CEC values for the FIG. 3 Nitraat gelooj,; (stelle Β en D) en uitruilbare Na en NH4 mat oor-
Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2012)
Δ Δ-CEC^ Δ Δ
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10
FIG. 4 CEC and exchangeable cations in Clovelly topsoil (0-15 cm) treated with lime and gypsum after leaching with water
FIG. 4 Κ UK en uitruilbare katione in Clovelly bogrond (0-15 cm) bebandel met kalk engips na loging met water
AMELIORATION OF SUBSOIL ACIDITY BY LEACHING OF SURFACE-APPLIED AMENDMENTS
CEC CEC
leading to an increase in CEC takes place simultaneous- and the small loss of bases from limed soil (Fig. 1).
ly. For gypsum-treated soil on the other hand, the CEC Thus on liming, sites which were formerly not salt-
remained unchanged, exchangeable Ca increasing large- exchangeable become so at least semi-permanently (that
ly at the expense of exchangeable Mg and to a lesser
Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2012)
4
Ν. G. REEVE & Μ. Ε. SUMNER
Fig. 1, 2 and 5 show that gypsum is far superior to efficace que la chaux. Par ailleurs le platre causa des pertes
lime in increasing subsoil base status. The small amounts severes de Mg echangeable. Et ceci pourrait avoir de serieuses
of Ca leached from lime-treated topsoil (Fig. 1) were repercussions sur les consequences nutritives si cela n'etait pas
entirely adsorbed in the subsoil ( 1 5 - 3 0 cm) (Fig. 5): corrige.
in the case of gypsum, at the respective levels of appli- REFERENCES
cation, 100, 61, 50, 38, 37, 30, and 25% of the Ca ABRUNA, F., VICENTE-CHANDLER, J . & PEARSON, R . W . , 1964.
leached from the topsoil (Fig. 2) was adsorbed in the Effects of liming on yields and composition of heavily fertilized
subsoil ( 1 5 - 3 0 cm) (Fig. 5), the rest being leached to grasses and on soil properties under humid tropical conditions.
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 28, 657-661.
below this horison. Although the reduction of exchange- ADAMS, W . E., WHITE, A . W . , & DAWSON, R. N., 1 9 6 7 . Influence
able Al either by cation exchange or the proposed "self of lime sources and rates on "Coastal" Bermudagrass produc-
liming" mechanism is not highly efficient, it is never- tion, soil profile reaction, exchangeable Ca and Mg. Agron. J.
theless more effective than lime in decreasing the ex- 59, 1 4 7 - 1 4 9 .
BHUMBLA, D . R. & MCLEAN, E. O . , 1 9 6 5 . A l u m i n u m in soils: V I .
changeable Al content of subsoils. It is interesting to Changes in pH dependent acidity, cation exchange capacity and
note that movement of bases from gypsum-treated extractable aluminum with additions of lime to acid surface
topsoil was essentially complete within only 16 pore soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 29, 370-374.
volumes of leaching (32 cm of H 2 0 ) which is consider- BROWN, Β. Α . , MUNSELL, R. I., HOLT, R. F. & KING, Α . V . , 1 9 5 6 .
Soil reaction at various depths as influenced by time since appli-
ably less than the annual precipitation in areas where cation and amounts of limestone. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 20,
Oxisols occur (ca.100 cm). Since gypsum is not as 518-522.
effective as lime in decreasing topsoil exchangeable Al, DE VILLIERS, J . M . & JACKSON, M . L., 1 9 6 7 . C a t i o n exchange
a combination of gypsum and dolomitic lime (to offset capacity variations with pH in soil clays. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc.
31, 473-476.
Mg loss caused by gypsum) should give better results DUTHION, C , 1968. Potassium in the soil. Potash Review, subject 4,
than either alone. In support of this, the authors have suite 43.
obtained a significant yield response of Sorghum suda- ESTRADA, J. & CUMMINGS, G. Α., 1968. Effects of lime and
nense in the field to 4 m. tons gypsum/ha in the presence phosphorus treatments in specific horisons of acid soil on
of amounts of dolomitic lime shown to be adequate growth and chemical content of corn. Agron. J. 60, 447-450.
HAYNES, J. L. & ROBBINS, W. R., 1948. Calcium and boron as
(up to 18 m. ton/ha) on soil of the Farningham series. essential factors in the root environment./. Am. Soc. Agron. 40,
795-803.
Opsomming HELLING, C. S., CHESTERS, G . & COREY, R. B., 1 9 6 4 . C o n t r i b u t i o n
of organic matter and clay to soil cation exchange capacity as
VHRBHTBRING VAN ONDERGROND- affected by the pH of the saturating solution. Soil Sci. Soc. Am.
SUURHEID IN NATAL OXISOLS DEUR Proc. 28, 517-520.
Ο Ρ PER VLAKTOEDIENING VAN HOURIGAN, W . R., FRANKLIN, R. E., MCLEAN, E. O . & BHUMBLA,
D. R., 1961. Growth and calcium uptake by plants as affected by
WERBETE RINGS MID DELS rate and depth of liming. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 25, 491-494.
Die groot pH-afhanklike KUK in Natal Oxisols beperk HOWARD, D . D . & ADAMS, F . , 1 9 6 5 . Calcium r e q u i r e m e n t for
die afwaartse beweging van kalk doeltreffend. Alhoewel hoepenetration of subsoils by primary cotton roots. Soil Sci. Soc.
bemesting, veral met suurvormende stikstofbemestingstowwe, Am. Proc. 29, 558-562.
KEHOE, J. K. & CURNOW, B., 1963. Root growth of subterranean
die spoed van beweging verhoog, kon betreklik klein hoeveelhede clover on some acid sandy soils in Victoria. Aust. J. exp. Agric.
Reproduced by Sabinet Gateway under licence granted by the Publisher (dated 2012)
van Ca-soute met feitlik geen vermoe om uitruilbare Al te Anim. Husb. 3, 11-16.
neutraliseer geloog word uit die bekalkte bogrond. In teenstellingMCLEAN, E. O . , REICOSKY, D . C. & LAKSHMANAN, C., 1 9 6 5 .
Aluminum in soils: VII. Interrelationships of organic matter,
het base gelyk aan 80% van die wat toegedien is vinnig uit liming and extractable aluminum with "permanent charge"
gipsbehandelde bogrond geloog. Alhoewel gips nie geheel en al (KC1) and pH-dependent cation exchange capacity of surface
ondergrondse uitruilbare Al kon uitskakel nie, verlaag dit soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 29, 374-378.
nietemin die peil van uitruilbare Al in die ondergrond meer PEARSON, R. W . , ABRUNA, F. & VICENTE-CHANDLER, J . , 1 9 6 2 .
Effect of lime and nitrogen applications on downward move-
doeltreffend as kalk. Gips het egter aansienlike verliese vanment of Ca and Mg in two humid tropical soils of Puerto Rico.
uitruilbare Mg meegebring wat, indien dit nie reggestel word Soil Sci. 93, 77-82.
nie, emstige voedingsprobleme tot gevolg kan he. POHLMAN, G. G., 1946. Effect of liming different soil layers on
yield of alfalfa and on root development and nodulation. Soil
Set. 62, 255-266.
Resume , RAGLAND, J. L. & COLEMAN, Ν. T., 1959. The effect of soil solu-
AMELIORATION DE L'ACIDITE DU tion, aluminum and calcium on root growth. Soil Sci. Soc. Am.
SOUS-SOL DES OXISOLS DU NATAL Proc. 23, 355-360.
REEVE, N. G., 1968. Amelioration of some acid Natal soils. M.Sc.
PAR LESSIVAGE D'AMENDEMENTS Agric. dissertation, University of Natal.
APPLIQUES EN SURFACE REEVE, N. G., 1970. Soil acidity and liming in Natal. Ph.D. thesis
La teneur elevee de CEC dont depend le pH dans les oxisols University of Natal.
du Natal limite de maniere effective le mouvement descendantREEVE, N. G. & SUMNER, Μ. E., 1970a. Effects of aluminum
toxicity and phosphorus fixation on crop growth on Oxisols in
de la chatix. Bien que 1'application d'engrais chimiques et Natal. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 34, 263-267.
particulierement ceux formant des engrais azotes, accroit le REEVE, N. G. & SUMNER, Μ. E., 1970b. Lime requirements of
degre de ce mouvement, des quantites relativement peu elevees Natal Oxisols based on exchangeable aluminum. Soil Sci. Soc.
de sels de Ca ayant tine faible aptitude a neutraliser Am. Proc. 34, 595-598.
I'Al REEVE, N. G. & SUMNER, Μ. E., 1971. Cation exchange capacity
echangeable du sous-sol, purent etre lessivees a partir d'une and exchangeable aluminum in Natal Oxisols. Soil Sci. Soc. Am.
couche arable chaulee. Par contre, des bases equivalent a 80% Proc. (in press).
de celles appliquees se lessiverent rapidement d'une couche Rios, M. A. & PEARSON, R. W., 1964. The effect of some chemical
superficielle traitee au platre. Bien que le platre ne put en- environmental factors on cotton root behaviour. Soil Sci. Soc.
Am. Proc. 28, 232-235.
tierement eliminer I'Al echangeable dans le sous-sol, il diminuaSUMNER, Μ. E. 1963a. Effect of iron oxides on positive and nega-
le niveau d'Al echangeable dans le sous-sol de maniere plus tive charges in clays and soils. Clay Minerals Bull. 5, 218-226.
Printed in the Republic of South Africa for the Government Printer, Pretoria, by Heer Printing Co. (Pty) Ltd., Pretoria