Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Breast Care
Jurnal Breast Care
Breast engorgement affects lactation. The present study was conducted to determine the effect of hollyhock
combined with warm and cold compresses on improving breast engorgement in lactating women. Participants
included 40 women with breast engorgement divided into intervention and control groups, with participants in both
groups being applied routine interventions and warm compress before nursing and a cold compress after nursing;
however, the intervention group was also applied hollyhock compress. Both groups received these treatments 6
times during 2 days. The data collected were analyzed in SPSS-16 using a generalized estimating equation.
According to the results, a significant difference was observed in the overall breast engorgement severity in the
intervention group (P < .001). The severity of breast engorgement was also found to have a significant relationship
with time (P < .001). According to the findings, hollyhock leaf compress combined with performing routine
interventions for breast engorgement can improve breast engorgement.
Keywords
warm and cold compresses, herbal compress, breast engorgement, hollyhock (Althaea
officinalis L) Received June 18, 2015. Received revised October 13, 2015. Accepted for publication
Sampling
The study subjects were selected through convenience
Assessment
sampling and were then randomly divided into an intervention The data collection tools used in this study included a
group and a control group using blocks of 4. The sample size demographic information questionnaire (including items on
was calculated as 17 for each group according to the following age, level of education, and occupation), an obstetric
equation28 and the results of the pilot study, and considering a information form (including items on the number of days since
type I error of 0.05, a test power of 0.8, and d ¼ 2 as the least delivery, the type of delivery, parity, and the number of
significant difference. Sample size was ultimately extended to miscarriages), a lactation status form (including items on
22 for each group taking into account a 25% potential previous breastfeeding history, previous breastfeeding
withdrawal rate. problems, the onset of current lactation, the daily frequency of
2 breastfeeding, and the
s2f1 þ ðm 1Þrg
n¼ md2 and a checklist of breast engor gement
2 z1 a2 þ z1 b score.9,29,30 This checklist assessed
duration of breastfeeding in minutes), participants’ erythema
2 Marand, and confirmed by the Herbarium Department at Jahad
¼ 2 7:85 3:7 f1 þ ð7 1Þ0:15g University of Kash mar. To stabilize their weight, the collected
2 leaf and stem were placed in a dryer at 60 C for 24 hours and
6 2 17
milled to a powder and then irra diated with ultraviolet light for
Based on the sample size measured, a total of 48 women 30 minutes to prevent the development of infections. To
entered the study. prepare the herbal compress, 10 g of the powder were mixed
with cooled boiled water and the solution was ready for use
within 30 minutes. To prevent the development of infections in
Preparation of the Hollyhock Leaf Compress the breast, each participant received her separate tools,
To prepare hollyhock herbal powder, the plant’s leaf and stem including separate warm and cold compresses.
were collected and dried by an herbalist from the herbarium of
.82, and .81 for days 3, 4, and 5, respectively, of contacting the
breast feeding clinic.30 This checklist was also used in Iran in a
Care Program study con ducted by Kamali Moradzade,5 and its reliability was
Participants received instructions on performing the found as 0.8 using the equivalent forms reliability. The severity
interventions at home by themselves and on evaluating their of breast engorge ment was assessed using the total score
breast engorgement severity based on the groups to which obtained for the symptoms of engorgement (Severity Index ¼
they had randomly been assigned, as the researchers had Erythema þ Breast Tension þ Breast Pain, with scores ranging
limitations on visiting them in their home and performing the from 0 to 19).
interventions for them.
In the control group, a warm compress (43 C to 46 C)5,8 was Statistical Analysis
applied on the engorged breast for 2 minutes13 exactly before
The data extracted from the questionnaires and the checklists
breast feeding. The compress was then removed, and half an
hour later, the mother was asked to breastfeed her child and to were analyzed in SPSS-16 using the w2 and Mann-Whitney
simultaneously mas sage her engorged breast from the top to tests and the generalized estimating equation, which is an
effective method in the analysis of correlated longitudinal data.
the nipple. The cold compress (10 C to 18 C)5,8 was then
The analysis of the data also took into account the
applied for 15 to 20 minutes. To maintain this temperature, the
exchangeable covariance matrix based on the
compress was soaked in water every 2 minutes and then
pseudo-likelihood of the data.
reapplied. The breast engorgement severity was then
assessed and recorded.
In the intervention group, the interventions performed in the Ethical Considerations
con trol group were first repeated, and then, 10 to 15 minutes
The ethical considerations observed in the present study
later, 6 to 8 spoonful (40-50 mL) of hollyhock leaf herbal
included obtaining participants’ written consent for participating
compress were rubbed on their breast and then removed within
in the study, delivering the routine interventions for breast
10 minutes. So both groups had the exact same procedure
engorgement in the con trol group, observing the principles of
except for the application of the Hollyhock.
infection prevention, ensuring the confidentiality of the data,
The procedures were repeated in both groups 3 times per
and reporting the results in generalized form. Hollyhock is also
day for 2 days in a row. In case the mother’s breast
confirmed to be safe for lactating women.
engorgement severity
(with a score of 0 for ‘‘no redness,’’ 1 for ‘‘redness in patches in
a lim ited area,’’ 2 for ‘‘full redness in a limited area,’’ 3 for a Results
‘‘shiny redness in a limited area,’’ and 4 for a ‘‘shiny redness
over most of the breast tissue’’), breast tension (with a score of A total of 7 women were excluded from the study,
0 for ‘‘no changes,’’ 1 for ‘‘firm and no tenderness,’’ 2 for ‘‘tense including 4 women from the intervention group and 3
but not uncomfortable,’’ 3 for ‘‘tense and uncomfortable,’’ 4 for from the control group, for reasons such as having
‘‘tense and painful,’’ and 5 for ‘‘very tense and very painful’’),
performed the interventions improperly and, in one of the
and breast pain (a score between 0 and 10). This checklist has
controls, for having mastitis. A total of 40 women
been used in studies conducted by Kvist et al,9,29 and its
reliability has been verified with Cronbach’s a values of .79, completed the interventions, that is, 20 in each group.
28 Journal of Evidence-Based Complementary & Alternative Medicine 22(1)
Table 3. Results of the Generalized Estimating
Khosravan et al 29
hollyhock leaf compress, and the performing of routine
interventions. Given that no studies have yet been
therapy group managed to better improve nearly all the conducted on the effect of hollyhock on breast engor
symp toms of breast engorgement, except for body gement, the results obtained from this study could not be
temperature. The results of the present study showed compared to any similar studies; however, these results
that symptoms of breast engorgement improve faster may support sources of traditional medicine in claiming
with the combined use of warm and cold compresses, that holly hock has a softening quality, since traditional
medicine recommends hollyhock leaf and stem The present study was part of a master’s thesis in nursing by
compresses for healing and relieving the pain of Samane Ajam Khames Fadafen, Gonabad University of
swelling, such as swelling of the breast.19,20 In vitro Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran. This research was approved
studies on hollyhock also confirm the anti inflammatory by the Research Review Committee of Gonabad University of
and immune system stimulating effects of this flowering Medical Sciences (Research Code P/4/28).
plant; these studies have also shown that the root extract
of this plant stimulates phagocytosis and the release of Acknowledgements
oxygen radicals and leukotrienes from human The authors would like to express their gratitude to all the
neutrophils, and that its aqueous extract induces the individuals who helped conduct this study, especially the
release of cytokines, interleukin-6, and tumor necrosis deputy of education, research and technology and the vice
chancellor of the university; the authorities and employees of
factor from human mono cytes.21 Roohi Boroujeni et al31
the hospital and health centers of Kash mar; and all the
examined the effect of the oral intake of 40 mg of mothers without whose participation this study would not have
hollyhock extract with 300 mL of ginger in the treatment been possible.
of cough and showed anti-inflammatory effects for the
plant. Hollyhock is also suggested to be an Author Contributions
antispasmodic plant. Sadighara et al32 also examined All the authors have made contributions to (a) the proposal and
hollyhock and found it to have a much greater design of the study, the acquisition of the data, and the
anti-inflammatory effect compared to the other plants analysis and interpre tation of the data; (b) the drafting of the
studied. Nouraldini et al17 studied and confirmed the article and revising it critically for important intellectual content;
antispasmodic effect of the aqueous root extract of and (c) the final approval of the ver sion to be submitted.
hollyhock on the tracheal smooth muscles in rats, which
is consistent with the softening effect found for hollyhock Declaration of Conflicting Interests
in the present study. The authors declare to have no conflicts of interest with
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of the
article.
Limitations
The limitations of this study included having to delegate Funding
the performing of some of the interventions to the The authors disclosed receipt of the following financial support
participants (after providing training and ensuring that for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article:
both groups had learnt to properly perform the This study was funded by the Research Administration of
interventions) in order to avoid interfering with their Gonabad University of Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran.
personal lives by visiting them in their homes at
inappropriate hours. Furthermore, the researcher could Ethical Approval
not assess the severity of engorgement after each The present study protocol was approved by the Ethics
session of the intervention or blind the subjects to the Committee of Gonabad University of Medical Sciences,
type of interven tion they were receiving given the time Gonabad, Iran (Code No. GMU.REC.1393.6).
and place limitations of the study and the frequency of
the interventions. Moreover, to observe the codes of References
research ethics, the intervention group received the 1. Ekhtiari A, Emami P. Comparison of success rates in
routine interventions used for breast engorgement, breastfeed ing after vaginal delivery and cesarean section
breast massages, nursing consultation, and warm and [in Persian]. Med Sci. 2008;18(1):51-54.
cold com presses in addition to hollyhock compress. http://www.iau-tmuj.ir/browse.php?a_
Further studies are therefore recommended to be code¼A-10-1-132&slc_&sid¼1
conducted on the effectiveness of the sole use of 2. Hsien CF, Fu JC, Long CY, Lin HS. Factors influencing
hollyhock in treating breast engorgement compared to breast symptoms in breastfeeding women after cesarean
the other methods available and with larger sam ple section deliv ery. Asian Nurs Res (Korean Soc Nurs Sci).
sizes and by blinding the subjects. 2011;5(2):88-98.
3. Cash JC, Glass CA. Family Practice Guidelines. 3rd ed.
Berlin, Germany: Springer; 2014:409-410.
Conclusion 4. Chiu JY, Gau ML, Kuo SY, Chang YH, Kuo SC, Tu HC.
According to the findings of the present study, a Effects of Gua-Sha therapy on breast engorgement: a
hollyhock leaf compress combined with the performing of randomized con trolled trial. J Nurs Res. 2010;18(1):1-10.
routine 5. Kamali Moradzade M, Ahmadi M, Heshmat R, Akbarzade
interventions for breast engorgement can improve the Baghban AR. Comparing the effect of acupressure and
symp toms of this condition. intermit tent compress on the severity of breast hyperemia
in lactating women [in Persian]. Q Horizon Med Sci.
Authors’ Note 2013;18(4):155-160.
30 Journal of Evidence-Based Complementary & Alternative Medicine 22(1)
2009;3:149-157.
26. Frisch N. Nursing as a context for
6. Mangesi L, Dowswell T. Treatments for breast alternative/complementary modalities. Online J Issues
engorgement dur ing lactation. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. Nurs. 2001;6(2):2.
2010;(9):CD006946. 7. Mathew LA. Effectiveness of Cold 27. Abedzadeh Kalahroudi M. Complementary and alternative
Cabbage Leaves vs Hot Application on Breast Engorgement medi cine in midwifery. Nurs Midwifery Stud.
Among Postnatal Mothers in a Selected Hospital, Mangalore 2014;3(2):e19449. 28. Diggle PJ, Heagerty P, Liang KY, Zeger
(Master’s thesis). Mangalore, SL. Analysis of Longitu
India: Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences; 2013. 8. dinal Data. 2nd ed. Oxford, England: Oxford University
Arora S, Vatsa M, Dadhwal V. A comparison of cabbage Press; 2013.
leaves vs. hot and cold compresses in the treatment of breast 29. Kvist LJ, Larsson BW, Hall-Lord ML, Steen A, Schale´n C.
engorge ment. Indian J Community Med. 2008;33:160-162.
The role of bacteria in lactational mastitis and some consid
9. Kvist LJ, Hall-Lord ML, Rydhstroem H, Larsson BW. A erations of the use of antibiotic treatment. Int Breastfeed J.
randomized-controlled trial in Sweden of acupuncture and 2008;3:6.
care interventions for the relief of inflammatory symptoms 30. Kvist LJ, Hall-Lord ML, Larsson BW. A descriptive study of
of the breast during lactation. Midwifery. 2007;23:184-195.
Swedish women with symptoms of breast inflammation
10. De Sousa L, Haddad ML, Nakano AM, Gomes FA. A non during lactation and their perceptions of the quality of care
pharmacologic treatment to relieve breast engorgement given at a breastfeeding clinic. Int Breastfeed J. 2007;2:2.
during lactation: an integrative literature review [in 31. Roohi Boroujeni H, Ganji F, Roohi Boroujeni P. Effect of
Portuguese]. Rev Esc Enferm USP. 2012;46:472-479.
com bined ethanol extracts of ginger root and Althaea
11. Wong DL, Perry SE, Hockenberry MJ. Maternal Child officinalis L in cough due to acute bronchitis [in Persian]. J
Nursing Care. 2nd ed. St Louis, MO: Mosby; 2002:602-603. Shahrekord Univ Med Sci. 2008;6(1):38-43.
12. Snowden HM, Renfrew MJ, Woolridge MW. Treatments for 32. Sadighara P, Barin A, Jahed Gh, Farjadmand F.
breast engorgement during lactation. Cochrane Database Syst
Assessment of antioxidant capacity and anti-inflammatory
Rev. 2007;(2):CD000046.
of alcoholic extrac tion of chamomile, morus, marshmallow,
13. Lowdermilk E, Perry H. Maternity Nursing. 7th ed. St Louis, borage and rosemary [in Persian]. Knowledge Health.
MO: Mosby; 2006:637. 2013;8(1):31-34.
14. Katzung BG, Masters SB, Trevor AJ. Basic & Clinical
Pharma cology. New York, NY: McGraw Hill; 2012:1047.
15. Arzi A, Nazari Khorasgani Z, Rahmani M. Study the effects
of Malva sylvestris hydro-alcoholic extract on the
carrageenan induced inflammation in male rat paw [in
Persian]. Jentashapir. 2013;4(1):1-10.
16. Walls D. Herbs and natural therapies for pregnancy, birth
and breastfeeding. Int J Childbirth Educ. 2009;24(2):29-37. 17.
Nouraldini M, Mosavi-Lordejani M, Haghir-Ebrahimabadi AR,
Batooli H. Effect of aqueous extract of Althaea root on tracheal
smooth muscle in rat. J Shahrekord Univ Med Sci.
2010;11(4):1-8. 18. Halighi-Sigaroodi F, Jarvandi S,
Taghizadeh M. Therapeutic Indications of Medicinal Plants [in
Persian]. 1st ed. Tehran, Iran: Arjmand Pub, Nasle Farda;
2010:35-39.
19. Momeneh Tonekaboni SM. Tohfato-al Momenin
(Tohfehe-Hakim Momen) [in Persian]. Qom, Iran: Noore Vahy;
2011. 20. Aghili Alavi Khorasani Shirazi MH. Makhzan-Al
Advieh [in Per sian]. Tehran, Iran: Sabzarang; 2012.
21. Ali Shah SM, Akhtar N, Akram M, et al. Pharmacological
activity of Althaea officinalis L. J Med Plants Res. 2011;5:
5662-5666.
22. Humphrey S. The Nursing Mother’s Herbal. Minneapolis,
MN: Fairview Press; 2003.
23. Bryant CA. Nursing the adopted infant. J Am Board Fam
Med. 2006;19:374-379.
24. Maftoon F, Sadighi J, Azin SA, Montazeri A.
Complementary medicine and health system. Payesh.
2007;6(1):55-62. 25. Antigoni F, Dimitrios T. Nurses’ attitudes
towards complemen tary therapies. Health Sci J.