Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Departmental Experience and Lessons Learned With Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine During The COVID-19 Crisis
Departmental Experience and Lessons Learned With Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine During The COVID-19 Crisis
Departmental Experience and Lessons Learned With Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine During The COVID-19 Crisis
Abstract
Alexander E. Loeb, MD Despite the use of digital technology in healthcare, telemedicine has
Sandesh S. Rao, MD not been readily adopted. During the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare
systems have begun crisis management planning. To appropriately
James R. Ficke, MD
allocate resources and prevent virus exposure while maintaining
Carol D. Morris, MD effective patient care, our orthopaedic surgery department rapidly
Lee H. Riley III, MD introduced a robust telemedicine program during a 5-day period.
Adam S. Levin, MD Implementation requires attention to patient triage, technological
resources, credentialing, education of providers and patients,
scheduling, and regulatory considerations. This article provides
practical instruction based on our experience for physicians who wish
to implement telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic. Between
telemedicine encounters and necessary in-person visits, providers
may be able to achieve 50% of their typical clinic volume within
2 weeks. When handling the massive disruption to the routine patient
care workflow, it is critical to understand the key factors associated
with an accelerated introduction of telemedicine for the safe and
effective continuation of orthopaedic care during this pandemic.
Level of Evidence: V
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Alexander E. Loeb, MD, et al
Table 2
Task Checklist for Telemedicine Launch
Category Tasks
deemed appropriate for telemedicine. to perform video visits from a patient portal, patients connect remotely
Patients whose scenarios are indeter- care area, such as an office examina- through the Polycom RealPresence
minate are offered a telemedicine visit tion room, may consider using a lens application (Plantronics, Santa Cruz,
for remote triage to decide whether cover to avoid unintentionally cap- CA) for a secure, synchronous (real-
an in-person visit is necessary. Each turing video of other patients. Our time) audiovisual encounter. EMR-
patient who must be seen in the clinic department purchased several addi- linked telehealth applications have
is screened for symptoms of COVID- tional cameras with lens covers for this the advantages of HIPAA compliance
19 before entering the clinical care purpose. In addition to testing the and integration with the patient’s
area. microphone’s audio and camera’s medical record for documentation and
video quality, we found it helpful to billing purposes. Server requirements
test each device to ensure adequate for such a platform included 16
Technological Resources bandwidth to support video trans- physical cores and at least 2.0-GHz
Several priorities were identified for fer, particularly in remote locations speed, and 16 virtual cores to support
the introduction of this initiative such as providers’ homes. approximately six simultaneous en-
(Table 2). One of the first priorities is To implement telemedicine, practi- counters. Practices running an EMR
to determine the technology resources ces may use routine consumer video typically have adequate server capac-
available in the practice. Each pro- applications or may select more ity to support remote video visits
vider requires a device with a func- sophisticated medical applications without interfering with office oper-
tioning camera and microphone, that interface with common EMR ations. Anecdotally, when running a
and computing power similar to that platforms (Table 3). For example, HIPAA-compliant platform through
required for common video-chat ap- our health system uses Epic soft- our practice’s server, we have expe-
plications, such as Skype (Microsoft, ware (Epic Systems, Verona, WI) rienced an audiovisual delay of ap-
Redmond, WA) or FaceTime (Apple, and hosts a HIPAA-compliant re- proximately 1 second during video
Cupertino, CA). Providers who intend mote patient portal. Through this visits. This delay may not impair the
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine
Table 3
Examples of Telemedicine Technology Applications and Their Functions
HIPAA Integrates with
Application Manufacturer (Location) Pros Cons Compliant EMR
American Amwell (Boston, MA) Integrates with Higher cost; Yes Yes
Well EMR for billing greater server
and requirements
documentation
MDLink MDLink, Ltd. (Kingston, Yes Yes
Jamaica)
Polycom Plantronics (Santa Yes Yes
RealPresence Cruz, CA)
SnapMD SnapMD (Glendale, CA) Yes Yes
CyraCom CyraCom (Tucson, AZ) Low cost No EMR interface Potentiallya No
for billing or
documentation
Zoom Zoom Video Potentiallya No
Communications
(San Jose, CA)
FaceTime Apple (Cupertino, CA) No No
Skype Microsoft (Redmond, No No
WA)
WhatsApp Facebook (Menlo No No
Park, CA)
EMR = electronic medical record; HIPAA = Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
a
Standard or basic services with these telecommunication applications may not be HIPAA-compliant, although advanced packages with encryption
and password protection can be made to comply with HIPAA security standards.
quality of the visit but occasionally telephone numbers, eg, for FaceTime made available for providers and office
interrupts the smooth flow of dis- encounters). Cellular connections that staff to send to patients electronically,
cussion.15,16 For practices not using can support FaceTime or WhatsApp and our EMR provider was engaged
an EMR system, more basic telecon- (Facebook, Menlo Park, CA) are to add “smart phrases” into the
ferencing software may be preferable, adequate for providers and patients EMR’s lexicon to document the use
which may not require this server using telemedicine. When using these of a 2-way synchronous audiovi-
capacity. commercial applications, however, sual platform of communication,
In addition, the US Department of documentation of the encounter the duration of the encounter (for
Health and Human Services, together within the medical record is still time-based billing), and verbal consent
with the Office for Civil Rights, necessary. for the telemedicine encounter (if
announced that it would “exercise its applicable).
enforcement discretion” regarding Credentialing
HIPAA violations made by providers Considerations Education of Providers
during “good faith” attempts to Telemedicine capabilities were veri- When introducing our department’s
provide patient care during the fied as being within the credentialing telemedicine capabilities, we found it
COVID-19 pandemic, when use of a guidelines for providers at our insti- helpful to distribute learning modules
non–HIPAA-compliant IT platform tution and within the scope of prac- about the workflow for scheduling
is necessary.16 In light of these HI- tice of individual provider licenses in (for office staff) and performing (for
PAA considerations, surgeons may our state. For advanced practice providers) remote video encounters,
use consumer applications (eg, Fac- providers, the addition of a virtual including videos and webinars that
eTime) that can be implemented practice location to their state licenses simulated the telemedicine function-
easily and immediately (Note: pro- was determined to be unnecessary, ality. Virtual “office hours” were held
viders who use such applications although this may differ by jurisdic- by credentialed faculty members who
may consider obscuring their cellular tion. Telemedicine consent forms were were comfortable with the technology
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Alexander E. Loeb, MD, et al
Table 4
Tip Sheets Developed to Assist Patients, Office Staff, and Providers With Critical Areas of Troubleshooting
User Group Tip Sheet
Patients Welcome letter (explains process, functionality, rationale, and limitations of telemedicine)
Telemedicine consent form
Equipment testing and software downloads (for mobile devices, computers)
Electronic patient registration
Office staff Scheduling a video encounter
Arranging for an interpreter for a video visit
How to troubleshoot for patients
Electronic patient registration
Providers Equipment testing and software downloads (for mobile devices, computers)
Starting a scheduled video encounter
Starting an “on the fly” (unscheduled) video encounter
Navigating the telemedicine platform
COVID-19 clinical communications
Legal and billing FAQs
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine
Table 5
Comparison of CMS Telehealth Regulatory Requirements Before and After the COVID-19 Emergency Declaration17
Requirement Before Declaration After Declaration
CMS = Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services; DHHS = Department of Health and Human Services; OCR = Office of Civil Rights; POS = place of
service
Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for patients who were not in rural providing telehealth services across
will reimburse physicians for services locations or within another health- state lines. This flexibility has been
rendered through telehealth at the care facility, and suspension of inter- important for our department because
same rate as in-person visits, for state licensing laws (paving the way approximately 19% of our patients
all diagnoses. Additional relaxa- for states to allow providers to prac- travel from other states for their
tion of restrictions on telemedicine tice telemedicine across state lines if orthopaedic care. Continued daily
visit requirements by CMS during certain criteria are met) (Table 5).18 updates on regulatory changes, as well
the COVID-19 crisis include the State licensure laws still apply during as an online posting of frequently
following: allowing for new visits this time, although as individual states asked billing, coding, and regulatory
to be performed remotely, easing have declared healthcare emergencies, questions, are provided by our depart-
“originating site” (ie, the patient’s many have suspended or altered re- ment’s “physician champion” to our
location at the time of the visit) strictions on providers with valid li- practitioners to keep all informed dur-
requirements to allow telemedicine censes in other states or jurisdictions ing this period of frequent changes.17
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Alexander E. Loeb, MD, et al
Billing and Coding online. Patients are contacted 10 mi- drove the accelerated introduction of
Current CMS recommendations fa- nutes before the scheduled encounter to novel tools to provide evaluation and
vor use of the standard office-based help them prepare and to answer any treatment involving a concerted effort
evaluation and management codes questions. This format has worked well across all orthopaedic divisions. We
for remote telemedicine encounters during the first 2 weeks, with visits now are still learning and troubleshooting
performed in the outpatient setting. commonly scheduled every 30 mi- our new workflows, but telemedicine
Although CMS suggests a “place nutes. Most providers are templated has been critical to the safe and effec-
of service” code of 11 during the for blocks of 2 to 3 consecutive hours tive continuation of orthopaedic care
COVID-19 public health emergency of remote encounters on specific days during this challenging time. We hope
for telemedicine encounters, indi- of the week. that, by using such technology, we
cating the office location where the can continue serving our patients
patient would normally have been with musculoskeletal conditions
Early Experience while reducing infection risk and
seen, other payors may prefer a
place of service code of 02 for the burden on our healthcare
One week after implementation, we
telehealth services. For the dura- system.
surveyed providers to identify bar-
tion of the public health crisis, riers to their use of telemedicine and
CMS has allowed level of service to compile additional tips and best References
requirements to be based on time- practices. Providers anticipated see-
based billing or on medical decision- ing, on average, approximately 25% References printed in bold type are
making alone. of their normal clinic volume re- those published or accessed online in
motely during the following week. 2020.
Scheduling Respondents estimated that nearly 1. Baker J, Stanley A: Telemedicine
one-third of their patients would be technology: A review of services,
Electronic check-in, consent processes, equipment, and other aspects. Curr Allergy
appropriate for telemedicine visits
and billing queues were streamlined Asthma Rep 2018;18:60.
during the pandemic. Considering
and automated to improve clinic 2. Mechanic OJ, Kimball AB: Telehealth
both telemedicine and in-person vis-
coordinator workflow. Since the Systems. Treasure Island, FL, StatPearls
its, we estimate that most providers [Internet]. StatPearls Publishing.
initial provider setup, the greatest
will achieve nearly 50% of their typ- Available at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.
continuing challenge has been manag- gov/books/NBK459384/. Accessed
ical clinic volume within 2 weeks of March 30, 2020.
ing the cameras, microphones, and
implementation. The 50% of patients
software on patients’ devices to allow 3. Scott Kruse C, Karem P, Shifflett K, et al:
visits not completed via telemedicine Evaluating barriers to adopting
HIPAA-compliant video communica-
or in person has consisted predomi- telemedicine worldwide: A systematic
tion. In recognition of the learning review. J Telemed Telecare 2018;24:4-12.
nantly of nonurgent follow-up and
curve involved with telemedicine,
routine postoperative visits. These 4. Barnett ML, Ray KN, Souza J, Mehrotra A:
the number of remote visits was Trends in telemedicine use in a large
patients can be safely managed with
limited at first. New clinic tem- commercially insured population,
asynchronous (messaging or e-mail) 2005-2017. JAMA 2018;320:
plates were developed to facilitate 2147-2149.
communication or postponement until
telemedicine visits. Within the first
the COVID-19 crisis has abated.17-19 5. Del Rio C, Malani PN: COVID-19-New
2 weeks, most providers scheduled insights on a rapidly changing epidemic.
approximately three remote syn- JAMA 2020; 323:1339-1340.
chronous visits per day, with en- Summary 6. Ranney ML, Griffeth V, Jha AK: Critical
counters scheduled hourly to allow supply shortages—the need for
ventilators and personal protective
time to troubleshoot and orient As we adapt to the quickly evolving equipment during the covid-19
to the new interface. As our pro- challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic. N Engl J Med 2020; Mar 25
vider workflows have become more pandemic, we embrace the flexibil- [Epub ahead of print]. doi: 10.
1056/NEJMp2006141.
streamlined, each provider is paired ity that is imperative for crisis man-
with a medical office coordinator agement. The pandemic has upended 7. American College of Surgeons: COVID-19
and surgery: Clinical issues and guidance.
or medical assistant to help prepare routines and patterns in our depart- Available at: https://www.facs.org/covid-
patients for remote visits. Office co- ment and removed the barriers of 19/clinical-guidance. Accessed March 30,
2020.
ordinators and medical assistants were inertia that would have prevented
taught how to help patients set up such major changes in our practice. 8. Bashshur RL, Shannon GW, Krupinski EA,
et al: National telemedicine initiatives:
their telecommunications software, The marked disruption of our ability Essential to healthcare reform. Telemed J E
test their devices, and check-in to continue routine patient care Health 2009;15:600-610.
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Accelerated Introduction of Telemedicine
9. NEJM Catalyst: What is telehealth? 14. Anonymous: Coronavirus Prepardness and www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/
Available at: https://catalyst.nejm.org/doi/ Response Supplemental Appropriations Act, medicare-telemedicine-health-care-
full/10.1056/CAT.18.0268. Accessed HR 6074, 116th Congress (2020). Available provider-fact-sheet. Accessed March 30,
March 30, 2020. at: https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/ 2020.
116/hr6074. Accessed March 30, 2020.
10. Gruca TS, Pyo TH, Nelson GC: Improving 18. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services:
rural access to orthopaedic care through 15. Polycom: Polycom RealPresence Platform, 2019-Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19)
visiting consultant clinics. J Bone Joint Surg Virtual Editions. Available at: https:// Medicare Provider Enrollment Relief
Am 2016;98:768-774. www.polycom.com/content/dam/ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs).
polycom/common/documents/data-sheets/ Available at: https://www.cms.gov/files/
11. Buvik A, Bugge E, Knutsen G, Smabrekke
realpresence-platform-virtual-editions-ds- document/provider-enrollment-relief-
A, Wilsgaard T: Patient reported
outcomes with remote orthopaedic enus.pdf. Accessed April 3, 2020. faqs-covid-19.pdf. Accessed March 30,
consultations by telemedicine: A 2020.
16. U.S. Department of Health and Human
randomised controlled trial. J Telemed Services: Notification of Enforcement 19. Wongworawat MD, Capistrant G,
Telecare 2019;25:451-459. Discretion for Telehealth Remote Stephenson JM: The opportunity
12. Marsh J, Hoch JS, Bryant D, et al: Communications During the COVID-19 awaits to lead orthopaedic telehealth
Economic evaluation of web-based Nationwide Public Health Emergency. innovation: AOA critical issues. J Bone
compared with in-person follow-up after Available at: https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/ Joint Surg Am 2017;99:e93.
total joint arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg for-professionals/special-topics/emergency-
preparedness/notification-enforcement- 20. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services:
Am 2014;96:1910-1916.
discretion-telehealth/index.html. Accessed Medicare telehealth frequently asked
13. Hollander JE, Carr BG: Virtually March 30, 2020. questions (FAQs) March 17, 2020.
perfect? Telemedicine for covid-19. Available at: https://edit.cms.gov/files/
N Engl J Med 2020; Mar 11 [Epub 17. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: document/medicare-telehealth-frequently-
ahead of print]. doi: 10.1056/ Medicare Telemedicine Health Care asked-questions-faqs-31720.pdf. Accessed
NEJMp2003539. Provider Fact Sheet. Available at: https:// April 7, 2020.
Copyright © the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.