Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Raizada Survival and Growth of Tiger Shrimp (Penaeus Monodon) in Island Saline Water With Potassium Sup
Raizada Survival and Growth of Tiger Shrimp (Penaeus Monodon) in Island Saline Water With Potassium Sup
Raizada Survival and Growth of Tiger Shrimp (Penaeus Monodon) in Island Saline Water With Potassium Sup
DOI 10.1007/s40011-014-0372-1
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Abstract Survival and growth of tiger shrimp (Penaeus the site with potassium supplementation. Individual cations
monodon) at three salinity levels, 5, 10 and 15 g/L were and ratios between other cations were found to be equally
investigated in potassium deficient natural inland saline important for survival and growth. The results of the
water (PD-ISW) and potassium supplemented inland saline present study will be useful in utilizing degraded ISW sites
water (PS-ISW). Shrimps reared in PS-ISW survived well, for the culture of tiger shrimp.
whereas total mortality occurred in PD-ISW. The survival
at 45 and 60 days at the salinities of 5, 10 and 15 g/L was Keywords Inland saline water Tiger shrimp
assessed in PS-ISW. The supplementation of potassium Survival Growth
showed significant effect on the survival rates at different
salinities. Length-weight studies at different salinities and
periods of time in PS-ISW showed significant differences Introduction
in the linear component, but there was no significant dif-
ference in respect to interaction of salinity and rearing Tiger shrimp (Penaeus monodon) is a brackish water spe-
periods in a two-way ANOVA repeated measures. Growth cies cultured in coastal areas as an important and valuable
parameters indicated that a salinity of 10 g/L was best for aquaculture commodity with high export demand. Efforts
the survival and growth of shrimps in inland saline water of made to culture this species in inland saline water (ISW)
which is generally deficient in potassium (potassium defi-
cient ISW, PD-ISW) in natural form were unsuccessful,
S. Raizada (&) V. K. Sharma V. Harikrishna however the species survived well when K? (potassium
M. Rahaman R. K. Agrahari J. Hasan A. Kumar chloride, KCl) was supplemented (potassium supplemented
Rohtak Centre, Central Institute of Fisheries Education,
ISW, PD-ISW) in ISW [1–4]. Supplementation of potas-
Lahli, Rohtak 124411, Haryana, India
e-mail: sudhirraizada@hotmail.com; sraizada@nbfgr.res.in sium (KCl and K-mag) has also been recommended for the
survival and growth of marine fish species like Australian
Present Address: snapper [5], mulloway [6], barramundi [7], pacific white
S. Raizada
shrimp [8–10] and the giant freshwater prawn larvae [11] in
Fish Conservation Division, National Bureau of Fish Genetic
Resources, Canal Ring Road, P.O. Dilkusha, Telibagh, ISW. ISW is different from coastal seawater in both salinity
Lucknow 226 002, Uttar Pradesh, India and ionic quality which varies from place to place and also
depends on the depth of water aquifer, soil structure, and
C. S. Purushothaman
rainfall or drought [12]. The ionic quality of ISW of India,
Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Fisheries University
Road, Seven Bungalows, Versova, Mumbai 400 061, Australia and the USA have been evaluated and major
Maharashtra, India differences have been observed in the levels of potassium,
calcium and magnesium in comparison to seawater [3, 5,
G. Venugopal
11, 13–15]. The ionic composition of ISW is more impor-
Kakinada Centre, Central Institute of Fisheries Education,
Beach Road, East Godavari District, Kakinada 533 001, tant than salinity for shrimp survival and growth. The
Andhra Pradesh, India concentrations of individual elements (Na?, K?, Ca2?,
123
S. Raizada et al.
Mg2?) as well as their ratios, vary from site to site. They are upon finding. The number of shrimps counted on days 5,
important for normal osmoregulatory functions [15]. 15, 30, 45 and 60, and lengths and weights were recorded
Therefore, the objective of the present study was to evaluate on the 45th and 60th days of rearing.
the optimum salinity regime and composition of major ions
suitable for evolving the commercial culture technology for Water Quality
tiger shrimp in ISW.
The water quality of ISW and Coastal seawater with
respect to major cations Na?, K?, Mg2? and Ca2? was
Material and Methods analysed at the beginning and at regular intervals during
the experiment. The temperature, pH, total alkalinity, total
Preparation of Control and Treatment Media hardness, and dissolved oxygen of the experimental tanks
were analyzed on weekly basis, and calcium and magne-
ISW of 18 g/L was pumped from a bore-well and allowed to sium on fortnightly basis following the standard methods of
settle for a week in cement tanks. The water was then drawn APHA [16]. Sodium and potassium were measured fort-
inside the wet laboratory, filtered with a 100-lm filter-bag and nightly with a microprocessor-based flame photometer
stored in 12 FRP tanks (1,000 L). The water was disinfected (Electronic India, Model 1381E), phosphate with an
with bleaching powder at 15 mg/L and vigorously aerated for ultraviolet spectrophotometer (thermo spectronic), and
at least 48 h before use. The stored water was diluted with salinity by a handheld salinity refractometer (Atago).
potable water to prepare six tanks, having salinities of 5, 10,
and 15 g/L. Three such tanks having salinities of 5, 10 and Data Analysis
15 g/L were designated as PD-ISW and the other 3 tanks, each
containing water of 5, 10, and 15 g/L salinity were supple- Specific growth rates (SGR) and survival rates (S) were
mented with K? (KCl, K? 49 %) equivalent to coastal sea- calculated using the following formulae:
water and designated as PS-ISW tanks. The levels of
potassium amendment at different salinities were adapted 100 ðln Wt ln W0 Þ
SGR ¼ 100
from Boyd and Thunjal [14]. The different media water was t
prepared in the same way when needed. where, SGR is specific growth rate, Wt is the total weight at
time t, and W0 is initial weight at the time of commencement
Experimental Animals of experiment; and
nt
Hatchery-bred, post-larvae (PL-10) of P. monodon were S ¼ 100
n0
obtained from Kakinada, Andhra Pradesh by air. The PL
were acclimated to 10 g/L salinity and were subjected to where, S is survival rate (%), nt is the number of prawn at
negative PCR test for white spot syndrome virus (WSSV) time t, and n0 is the number of prawns (150) at the com-
prior to dispatch by air to the experiment site (road distance mencement of the experiment.
approximately 1,800 km). The PL were transferred to A two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with repe-
artificial seawater of salinity 10 g/L at the experiment site ated measure on survival was conducted to determine
and reared for 30 days before use in the experiment. whether there was statistical significance between salinity
and potassium levels in PD-ISW and PS-ISW at different
Experimental Design rearing durations. The significance levels between gain in
length and weight at different days of rearing in different
Eighteen circular FRP tanks (Dia 80 cm, height 60 cm; salinities was also evaluated using two-way ANOVA with
300 L capacity) were used for conducting the bioassay. repeated measures. One-way ANOVA was used to deter-
Tanks were filled with 200 L PD-ISW and PS-ISW media mine the significance levels between water parameters at
in triplicate sets of 5, 10 and 15 g/L salinities and treat- different levels of salinity and an independent samples’ ‘t’
ments were assigned using completely randomized design. test was used to compare the significant difference between
Tanks were provided continuous aeration from a portable PD-ISW and PS-ISW water parameters at the same salin-
air-blower (Hiblow-60). Each tank was stocked with 150 ity. The regression graphs ‘Y’ (simple linear regression)
PL-40 of average weight 100 ± 10 mg acclimated in the and ‘R’ (coefficient of correlation) were evaluated for
stocking media for 24 h and fed commercial shrimp diet comparing the length-weight relationship at different
(CP brand) ad libitum. Around 25 % of the tank water was salinities and different period of time using M.S. Excel
changed daily at the time of cleaning the tanks. Mortality (2007). SPSS version 16.0 [17] was used to analyse two-
was recorded daily and the dead samples were removed way ANOVA repeated measures, one-way ANOVA and ‘t’
123
Rearing of Penaeus monodon in Inland Saline Water
test. The data were expressed as mean ± SD. Significance Mortality started both in 10 and 15 g/L salinities in PD-
was considered at p \ 0.05. ISW within 12 h and total mortality occurred within 3 days
at salinity 15 g/L and in 6 days at salinity 10 g/L. The rate
of mortality was, however, slow at salinity 5 g/L where
Results and Discussion total mortality did not occur for 40 days. The PL survived
in all the PS-ISW treatment media at 5, 10 and 15 g/L
The quality of ISW was compared with that of coastal salinities up to 60 days of experiment period (Fig. 1;
seawater (CSW) for major cations Na?, K?, Mg2? and Table 3). Survival levels of 90 % on day 45 and 88 % on
Ca2? at 5, 10 and 15 g/L salinities (Table 1). Significant day 60 were recorded at 10 g/L salinity, which was sig-
differences were observed in potassium level in ISW in nificantly higher than at the salinity of 15 g/L with the
comparison to CSW at all the three salinity levels. ISW: survival of 81.3 % on day 45 and 78.7 % on day 60, and
CSW ratios for potassium were recorded as 0.21:1.00 at also at 5 g/L salinity with the survival of 72.7 % on day 45
5 g/L, 0.12:1.00 at 10 g/L and 0.08:1.00 at 15 g/L salini- and 63.4 % on day 60 (Table 3).
ties. The ratios of potassium were found inversely pro- The rate of mortality in PD-ISW water increased with an
portional to salinity which was in contrast to coastal increase in salinity from 5 to 15 g/L, which was different
seawater. Calcium also showed significantly higher values from the behaviour of P. monodon in seawater. The opti-
in ISW in comparison to CSW. ISW:CSW ratios for cal- mum salinity of coastal seawater for growth and survival of
cium were recorded as 3.10:1.00 at 5 g/L, 3.85:1.00 at P. monodon has been reported as 25 g/L by Lee et al. [18],
10 g/L and 2.89:1.00 at 15 g/L salinities, which followed a 15–25 g/L by Ferraris et al. [19] and 1.7–40 g/L by Caw-
parabolic curve between 5–15 g/L. There were compara- thorne et al. [20], which was in contrast to the present study
tively less differences amongst sodium and magnesium as the mortality rate was observed to be the highest at the
ions in comparison to potassium and calcium. The level of salinity 15 g/L and lowest at 5 g/L. However, the survival
sodium was found higher only at 5 g/L salinity in ISW and rate in all PS-ISW media supplemented with potassium
was low at both 10 and 15 g/L. Magnesium also followed was higher than that in PD-ISW though there was signifi-
similar trend with higher levels at 5 and 10 g/L salinities, cant difference among treatments (salinity and potassium
and low at 15 g/L salinity in comparison to CSW. supplementation) [F (5, 10) = 704.19], rearing durations
In PS-ISW, the levels of sodium, magnesium and cal- [F (4, 8) = 68.38] and combined interaction of treatments
cium were insignificant from that of PD-ISW with the and rearing durations [F (20, 40) = 9.16] on survivals
exception of potassium, where higher levels were main- (Fig. 1).
tained through amendment with KCl at all salinities. Other Collins and Russel [1] also reported survival of P.
water parameters like temperature, pH, total alkalinity, and monodon by increasing potassium level from 5.9 to
dissolved oxygen were not significantly different both 40.0 mg/L at low salinity of 3 g/L ground water. The
between the same salinity and amongst different salinities present findings were greatly supported with the work of
with the exception of total hardness which differed sig- Tantulo and Fotedar [4] on P. monodon, who did not
nificantly as salinities increased but was insignificant observe any difference in survival rates in ISW fortified
between the same salinities (Table 2). with 100 % K? and seawater at salinities 5, 25 and 45 g/L.
Table 1 Comparison of water quality of PD-ISW, PS-ISW and coastal seawater* at 5, 10 and 15 g/L salinity
Salinity (g/L) Treatment Sodium Potassium Magnesium Calcium
(mg/L) Ratio ISW:CSW (mg/L) Ratio ISW:CSW (mg/L) Ratio ISW:CSW (mg/L) Ratio ISW:CSW
123
S. Raizada et al.
Dissolved oxygen (mg/L) PD-ISW 15.50 ± 0.17a 16.00 ± 0.20a 16.03 ± 0.58a
a a
PS-ISW 15.17 ± 0.31 15.08 ± 0.38 15.04 ± 0.39a
c b
Sodium (mg/L)* PD-ISW 12143 ± 50.6 13114 ± 12.8 13991 ± 38.1a
c b
PS-ISW 12167 ± 50.0 12973 ± 123.0 13968 ± 86.4a
a a
Potassium (mg/L) PD-ISW 111.4 ± 0.15 112.8 ± 0.87 113.7 ± 0.15a
PS-ISW 254.8 ± 5.70c 2105.1 ± 4.18b 2153.5 ± 6.61a
c b
Magnesium (mg/L) PD-ISW 1265.1 ± 9.9 1467.5 ± 10.6 561.8 ± 11.6a
b a
PS-ISW 1266.6 ± 13.8 1471.0 ± 12.4 559.0 ± 17.8a
c b
Calcium (mg/L) PD-ISW 1188.5 ± 20.0 1446.6 ± 30.5 1503.0 ± 5.77a
c b
PS-ISW 1182.6 ± 16.9 1446.0 ± 23.6 1499.0 ± 29.4a
Data in the same column within the same parameter having different subscript figures (1, 2) are significantly different at a level of 0.05. Data in
the same row having different superscript letters (a, b, c) are significantly different at a level of 0.05
n = 5 for all PS-ISW treatment tanks and 5 g/L PD-ISW tanks, n = 1 for other control tanks
The major cause of mortality in shrimps, therefore, was 5, 8, 15, 21]. Deficiency of potassium in ISW has been
assessed to be the deficiency of potassium in inland ground responsible to cause mortality in fishes [5, 6, 22], crusta-
saline water. Low level of potassium in inland saline ceans [1, 3] and molluscs [23]. High mortality rate at 15
ground water has been reported by several researchers [3, g/L and the low rate at 5 g/L in PD-ISW indicate that the
123
Rearing of Penaeus monodon in Inland Saline Water
Table 3 Survival percentage of P. monodon larvae at varying salinities with PD-ISW and with PS-ISW during different rearing durations
Salinity Potassium treatment Initial no. 5 days 15 days 30 days 45 days 60 days
mortality rate depends on the ratio of potassium with that weight], but there was no significant (p [ 0.05) effect of
of salinity in ISW as ISW:CSW potassium ratios were combined action of salinity and rearing durations [F (2,
assessed higher (0.21:1.00) at salinity 5 g/L, in comparison 118) = 0.93 and F (2, 118) = 1.88 respectively for length
to salinities of 10 g/L (0.12:1.00) and 15 g/L (0.08:1.00) in and weight] (Figs. 2 and 3).
PD-ISW (Table 1), which were similar to the findings of
Fielder et al. [5]. Partridge and Lymbery [7] correlated
potassium deficiency in ISW with the elevated level of
plasma sodium and chloride, lower water content and
muscle potassium concentration. Low potassium level in
ISW has also been reported to cause widespread, severe
skeletal muscle degeneration and necrosis that affect both
epaxial muscle groups and muscles within the pharyngeal
area in Lates calcarifer [22]. Its supplementation improved
mortality, degeneration and necrosis of skeletal muscle,
SGR, sodium, chloride and potassium concentration in
plasma [7]. Potassium is the main cation of intracellular
fluids, while sodium and chloride are the major extracel-
lular ions [24]. These are essential electrolytes for acid–
base balance in animals [25]. The maintenance of potas-
sium balance within the body is necessary for the proper
functioning of membrane potential and all life systems.
The lack of an adequate supply of K? in water profile has Fig. 2 Effect of various salinities supplemented with potassium on
been shown to negatively impact survival and growth of L. length of P. monodon during different rearing durations
vannamei [15, 26]. The supplementation of potassium in
ISW improves osmoregulatory capacity and organo
somatic indices of P. monodon [4], though with a longer
exposure time to ISW, the impact of potassium on prawn
condition indices become more pronounced [27].
Growth analysis of shrimp was performed in PS-ISW
water to observe the effect of salinity and potassium sup-
plementation on body indices on days 45 and 60. The
growth in terms of length was found highest at 10 g/L
salinity followed by the salinities of 15 and 5 g/L,
respectively, on days 45 and 60. The growth in terms of
weight also followed more or less similar trend both on day
45 and day 60. The maximum gain in weight was recorded
at salinity 10 g/L followed by salinities 15 and 5 g/L at day
45 and 60. A two-way ANOVA with repeated measures
showed significant growth both in length and weight with
respect to the effect of salinity [F (2,118) = 9.02 for length
and F (2, 118) = 4.52 for weight) and rearing durations [F Fig. 3 Effect of various salinities supplemented with potassium on
(1, 59) = 83.40 for length and [F (1, 59) = 71.02 for weight of P. monodon during different rearing durations
123
S. Raizada et al.
Table 4 Growth parameters of P. monodon at varying salinities supplemented with potassium and rearing durations
Parameter 5 g/L 10 g/L 15 g/L
45 days 60 days 45 days 60 days 45 days 60 days
Length (cm)
Average 4.94 ± 0.713 5.56 ± 0.91b 5.27 ± 0.801 6.01 ± 0.76a 5.09 ± 0.562 5.60 ± 0.72b
Minimum 3.2 4.0 4.0 4.5 4.0 4.0
Maximum 7.0 8.0 8.2 8.0 6.2 7.9
Weight (g)
Average 0.84 ± 0.352 1.20 ± 0.60b 0.96 ± 0.311 1.38 ± 0.53a 0.91 ± 0.291 1.14 ± 0.42c
Minimum 0.26 0.4 0.38 0.55 0.32 0.51
Maximum 2.56 3.68 1.8 3.08 1.9 2.54
Regression (Y) 0.608x - 2.179 0.608x - 2.179 0.663x - 2.606 0.663x - 2.606 0.425x - 1.255 0.547x - 1.917
Correlation (R) 0.840 0.840 0.826 0.826 0.648 0.859
SGR (%) 1.81 ± 0.373 1.60 ± 0.32b 1.96 ± 0.311 1.73 ± 0.27a 1.90 ± 0.322 1.58 ± 0.27c
Data in the same row within the same parameter at 45 days having different superscript letters (1, 2, 3) are significantly different at a level of
0.05. Data in the same row having same parameter at 60 days with different superscript figures (a, b, c) are significantly different at a level of
0.05
The growth in terms of length-weight relationship was be 28.5:1.0 in PS-ISW at the best salinity of 10 g/L and
found to follow a linear trend (Y) and a strong correlation was similar to the level in seawater at equivalent salinity
(R) of around 0.826–0.859 existed in PS-ISW, with the [14], which clearly showed that not only the ionic level but
exception of salinity of 15 g/L at 45 days culture. SGR was ionic ratios are equally important. Similarly, Mg2?/Ca2?
found to be significantly different at all salinities and ratio was also found to be comparatively low in ISW at 5 g/
during different rearing periods. The highest SGR was L (1.46:1.00), 10 g/L (1.05:1.00) and 15 g/L (1.12:1.00)
recorded at 10 g/L salinity both on day 45 and day 60 salinities in comparison to CSW (3.37:1.00) at equivalent
followed by 15 and 5 g/L salinities on day 45, and at 5 and salinities. Since the water quality of inland saline sites
15 g/L salinities on day 60 (Table 4). varies from place to place, it needs to be studied in details
A significantly low growth in 15 g/L in comparison to to correlate not only the levels of various ions in ISW, but
10 g/L may be due to higher calcium levels which also the ratios amongst the various major cations for dif-
increases with the rise in the salinity though this species ferent salinity required for optimum survival and growth in
performs better at salinity 15 g/L than to lower salinities in ISW.
natural seawater conditions. Ketola et al. [28] stated that
high level of calcium in water could disturb the osmoreg-
ulatory process. Rahman et al. [3] have reported higher
Conclusion
survival of P. monodon in ISW when the level of calcium
was reduced from 921.8 mg/L to 200 mg/L at a salinity of
The low levels of potassium in ISW at different salinities
12.5 g/L. High level of calcium has also been found to
was the major cation responsible for mortality of P. mon-
impair the larval development in Macrobrachium rosen-
odon. The supplementation of potassium at the salinity of
bergii [11]. Wurts and Stickney [29] have correlated the
10 g/L was found to give higher survival and growth at the
survival and mortality of red drum with calcium-sodium
experimental site in comparison to salinities of 5 and 15 g/
ratio, and recommended this to be closer to 0.038. Raizada
L. The most important factor that needs to be studied at
et al. [11] and Zang et al. [30] have given importance to
each site is the availability of major cations in the water in
Mg2?/Ca2? ratio and recommended this ratio to be main-
comparison to seawater, as salinity plays secondary
tained at 2.5:1.0 and 1.9:1.0 respectively for the larval
importance.
rearing of M. rosenbergii, when ISW is used. However, the
role of calcium needs to be evaluated in future studies. Zhu Acknowledgments The authors are thankful to Dr. Dilip Kumar, Ex
et al. [21] have reported that the Na?/K? ratio may be a Director, Central Institute of Fisheries Education (CIFE), Mumbai,
limiting factor in marine organisms and the manipulation for providing facilities for carrying out this work. They also record
of these ratios could significantly influence the growth, their sincere thanks to Dr. S. C. Mukherjee, Ex Joint Director, CIFE,
Mumbai, for the constant encouragement in carrying out this work.
energy allocation and feed intake of shrimp. They sug- The authors also thank the Indian Council of Agricultural Research,
gested the optimum ratio to be 34:1 for L. vannamei. New Delhi for funding this work under the Niche Areas of Excellence
However, in the present study, Na?/K? ratio was found to Project.
123
Rearing of Penaeus monodon in Inland Saline Water
123