Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Xiaomi Versus Samsung Analysis in Chines
Xiaomi Versus Samsung Analysis in Chines
Weihua Li ID 20142379
Abstract
In smart phone industry, Xiaomi has been creating a sensation threatening Samsung as a
market leader in recent years. While Samsung decreased their market share and volume
shipments, Xiaomi impressively saw through the strategic gaps in smart phone industry,
occupied it and became number 1 smart phone vendor in Chinese market in 2014. The most
striking feature regarding this industry is that in two big markets of the world, local
companies are on the rise whereas global companies tend to wither and fall. Despite that,
however, Samsung retains a market leader worldwide. This essay will investigate feasibility
Our main Critical Analysis tool is SWOT Matrix Analysis. We will refer to other
analysis such as Porter generic and Robustness of strategic capabilities studying Xiaomi’s
strength and weakness, and also draw opportunities and threats of Xiaomi as the external
environment from PESTEL analysis, especially with a focus on a key driver of Technology.
Xiaomi’s strength is definitely inexpensive, high-end devices and can grab a lot of
nerds’ needs who want upscale smart phones but do not have adequate money. Nevertheless,
Xiaomi’s weak brand equity and no history and culture are remarkable. When connecting
with opportunities and threats, our conclusions to be drawn are obvious that Xiaomi should
not fight squarely with Samsung and Apple, pursue its unique market segment as nicher and
solidify its positioning by repelling other competitors in the niche market. This will lead to
Table of Contents
1.0 Introduction
1.1 The Strategy Purpose-The Smart phone Industry
1.2 How to approach and Strategic Management Tools
2.0 SWOT Matrix
2.1 Strength
2.1.1 Consistent Strategic Group-Specific Positioning as nicher
2.1.2 Product
2.1.3 Price
2.1.4 Place
2.1.5 Supply chain management-efficient operation management based
On Pull-system
2.2.6 Promotion
2.2 Weakness
2.2.1 The specific market segment
2.2.2 Insufficient brand power & Lack of Strategic Capabilities
2.2.3 Limited product range
2.2.4 Technological limit & Low Quality
2.2.5 Plagiarism
2.2.6 No advertisement Strategy, compared with Samsung’s Promotion
2.3 Opportunity
2.4 Threat
2.5 SWOT Matrix Analysis
3.0 Conclusion and Recommendation
4.0 Reference
1.0 Introduction
1.1 The Strategic Purpose- The Smart Phone Industry
20.00%
18.00%
16.00%
14.00%
12.00%
10.00% Xiaomi
Samsung
8.00%
6.00%
4.00%
2.00%
0.00%
2013 Q4 2014 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4
In smart phone industry, Xiaomi has been creating a sensation threating Samsung as a
market leader in recent years. The smart phone market has extremely been dynamic and
companies have waxed and waned over the past few years. Even though the market is
continuously growing, something revolutionary is invariably taking place. The dividing line
between the high-end market and the low-end market is obvious. In the third quarter of 2014,
Samsung, which attempts to cover both markets, really faced serious losses. While worldwide
327.6million smart phones shipped, an increase of 25.2%, Samsung’s share declined 8.2%
year on year. Despite that, however, Samsung retained a market leader worldwide making up
23.8% (78.1million units), followed by Apple. Apple, which sticks to the high-end market,
(Livedoornews, 2015). It is the established theory that high quality products correspond with
high price and low quality ones with low price. Nevertheless, it is Xiaomi that overturned this
theory in the blink of an eye. In particular, the demand for the affordable smart phones is
the Strategic Gap in smart phone industry and successfully occupied it in the blink of an eye.
According to Canalysis, (2014), in the second quarter of 2014, China accounted for
37% of world smart phone shipments at 108.5million units. In this Chinese market, Xiaomi
became the number 1 smart phone vendor, overtaking Samsung. Xiaomi comprised 14% of
Chinese market shares on the back of 240% year-on-year growth. Samsung made up 12%
with shipments of 13.2million units and fell to 2nd place in the rankings for the first time since
the fourth quarter of 2011 followed by Lenovo, Yulong, and Huawei. The eight Chinese
vendors in the top 10 together were responsible for shipments of 70.7million units and 65%
of this country’s market shares. These Chinese vendors reigned supreme in Chinese market.
Samsung and Apple, which were the only international vendors in the top 10, together made
up 20.0million units and 18% of the overall smart phone market in China. 97% of Xiaomi’s
shipments were into China in the second quarter of 2014. Xiaomi is about to expand into
south-east Asia market and Indian market. It is anticipated to increase the proportion of other
markets. On the other hands, Samsung made way for Xiaomi of a local company in China
smart phone market and was superseded by Micromax of a local company, sliding to 2nd
The most striking feature is that in two big markets such China and India, the local
companies go from strength to strength and the global companies tend to wither and fall.
None the less, Samsung is a market leader worldwide. This essay will investigate feasibility
Our primary critical analysis tool is SWOT Matrix Analysis, because after analysing
the internal and external factors that the company faces, SWOT Matrix analysis is given to
provide further information about how the organization is going to use the SWOT analysis in
their future decision makings. SWOT Matrix “can be used to identify options that address a
different combination of the internal factors (strength and weakness) and the external factors
(opportunities and threats) (Johnson, Whittington, Scholes, Angwin, & Regner, 2014)”.
This essay will refer to other analysis such as Porter generic and Robustness of Strategic
Capabilities, gleaning Xiaomi’s strength and weakness from SWOT, and also draw
opportunity and threat as the external environment from PESTEL Analysis, especially with a
2.1 Strength
Offering ultimate high-end devices at low price by reducing MUDA as much as
possible
According to Porter generic, Samsung uses Overall cost leadership. Samsung’s positioning is
apparently a market leader and targeting wide customer layer, ranging from the high-end
market to the low-end one with cost leadership. Samsung can hold off challengers by
Remaining number one calls for action on three fronts. Firstly, the firm must find ways
to expand total market demand. Second, the firm must protect its current market share
through good defensive and offensive actions. Third, the firm can try to increase its
On the other hand, Xiaomi is not a market leader, a challenger and a follower. Xiaomi is a
nicher. Xiaomi’s strategy is Focus. Kotler & Keller (2006) said that “Smaller firms normally
avoid competing with larger firms by targeting small markets of little or no interest to the
larger firms” (p.362). “The business focuses on one or more narrow market segments. The
firm gets to know these segments intimately and pursues either cost leadership or
Xiaomi’s strategic vision is to offer the mobile phone with high-end feature at low price
range. Its targeting segment is originally computer nerds who intend to an upmarket smart
phone but cannot do that. As mentioned above, the high-end devices are usually expensive
and cannot be available to anyone. So Xiaomi was gunning for such nerds, that is, niche
2.1.2 Product
Indeed, Xiaomi’s strength is the high quality and low price. However, only price is not
Xiaomi’s key strategy. For instance, regarding function, the latest model, Mi4, which was
sold on Chinese Website in July, 2014, with the size of display of 5.0 inches and 13 MP Sony
camera is second to none, compared with Apple’s iPhone series and Samsung’s GALAXY
series whereas its price is 1999 yuan, just more than a third the price of 5288 yuan for
(Livedoornews, 2015). Xiaomi has been sending out mainly high-end devices to the market
since the outset, overturning the established theory. It is the only one product strategy that
makes such this situation possible. Compared with Samsung, which sends out new products
one after the next to the market, Xiaomi focuses on just one product during a year and can
reduce costs of mass production. Xiaomi can make profits by contribution toward selling only
one product as maximum as possible. On the other hand, other competitors such as Samsung
taking various-range-products strategy suffer from their supply chain management costs
2.1.3 Price
Surely, Xiaomi’s phones and tablets are considerably cheaper than its competitors’ such as
Samsung’s and Apple’s. Mi4 was offered at a third of the price of iPhone6. However, initially
According to China Marketing Tips (2014), Xiaomi “decided to go with the Amazon’s
model-just cover the cost of the devices and make money from selling content”. Even though
Xiaomi is often compared to Apple and Lei Jun resembles Steve Jobs in his style and
charisma, “it is clear that Xiaomi’s true inspiration comes from Amazon”. Xiaomi’s profits
are not made by selling hardware, but by contents offered to customers. Like Google and
Facebook, Xiaomi’s price strategy begins with getting customers, which eventually leads to
profits (Nikkei, 2013). After offering phones at the same costs or at a loss they were
manufactured, Xiaomi can make profits by selling services such as software and games.
2.1.4 Place
Xiaomi never use typical, traditional channel such as wholesalers and retailers, but the on-
demand style through the Internet, that is, the homepage of Xiaomi. According to the order
short lead time. So these direct selling products and lean manufacturing enable Xiaomi to
reduce costs as much as possible and relieve stress such as price setting and relationship with
channel members.
Xiaomi engages in just the development of software and application, and outsources the
designing and production of hardware. The supply chain consists of Apple’s OEM such as
Qualcomm, Samsung, LG and so on. As a result, Xiaomi can be exempted from high costs of
In addition, in the processes the impressive lean management can be seen. As mentioned
above, the manufacturing depends on the order customers place. “Once Xiaomi receives
orders through their own homepage, they decide the purchase of components and the amount
of production according to the information about the orders” (Tech-on, 2012). Xiaomi only
makes what is need, when it is needed and in the amount needed. So Xiaomi can reduce
inventory losses in terms of raw materials, components and finished goods at any process.
Furthermore, Xiaomi uses different raw materials from competitors. Xiaomi can express the
same function as Apple and Samsung with different components and raw materials.
According to Toyokeizai (2013), a supplier indicates that despite the same size of the screen
and the same camera function, there is a substantial difference in components of Apple and
components and raw materials that provides the key to bring down the price.
On the other hand, Samsung keeps most of its supply chain in-house from development to
Samsung only uses these suppliers for low-cost commoditized components that are more
Samsung implement the ‘industrial park’ mode, the major suppliers located around the phone
factory, parts supplied directly from the supplier to the phone factory, reducing agency costs
In sales, Samsung began to try to direct supply model, reducing the supply level between
Samsung use vertically integrated production model, which provide a stable supply of parts to
Samsung mobile phones and other digital products, such as: Samsung Semiconductor Corp.
own consumption reaches 50%, and increased year by year; Samsung Motor Company
produces chips and camera modules; Samsung SD I manufactures liquid crystal displays and
In smart phone industry, companies usually spend lavish money on advertising in order to
impress their customers with their own brand image. However, Xiaomi never uses
Xiaomi has pioneered flash style sales which were done with little or no advertising.
Flash sales basically mean selling limited quantities during limited periods. They
always create anticipation and urgency – great factors to win customers’ mind and
heart. Needless to say, the units were sold quickly and talked over a lot over China’s
vibrant social media. Word of mouth marketing worked very well for Xiaomi and they
Xiaomi’s fans never fail to flock to social media, because Xiaomi’s targeting market segment
is nerds. Once Xiaomi grabs their fans’ heart, their commitment to the Xiaomi brand is
beyond question. Xiaomi takes advantage of their fans’ psychology and social media to the
full, and disseminate their own brand equity through word of mouth.
In addition, Xiaomi’s charismatic CEO, Lei Jun is an important play in making the brand
equity. He knows that an iconic image of Steve Jobs is still presented among Chinese. It is
well-known that he deliberately imitates Steve Jobs in the way of talking about the brand and
2.2 Weakness
Owing to reducing costs, Xiaomi cannot build their strong brand equity
Customers tend to choose a product of high brand value if two products have the same quality
Xiaomi’s strength can become their weakness like heads and tails of a coin.
Xiaomi targets unique market segment of nerds who are completely different from ordinary
customers. If Xiaomi sticks to this market segment, pursue this niche market and ignore the
In addition to that, Samsung as a market leader could certainly participate even in a tiny
minority segment and attack Xiaomi with cost leadership. It is uncertain that Xiaomi can
repel Samsung and retain the overwhelming advantage in the market segment of niche.
Xiaomi launched at the end of 2010, that is, launched late. Samsung already occupied most of
the market worldwide. Xiaomi’s main market is in China and the brand image is less known
outside the country. From this viewpoint, Xiaomi’s unique brand image cannot establish in
customers’ mind. In addition, indeed, Xiaomi has got capabilities which are valuable to
customers and relatively rare. However, Xiaomi does not have robustness of strategic
capabilities, which is Complexity, Culture and History. In other words, it is the identity and
personality of Xiaomi which is a result of systematic and sustainable effort over years.
Xiaomi is devoid of its history and culture. So it leads to ease copy of capabilities by other
Xiaomi focus on one product for a year. However, this limited product range is one of the
weaknesses.
The problem with them is that they are relying on a single model, which wouldn’t help
them to get more market share or mind share of the user. When a new brand or product
comes in, they will have a hard time to defend their market share.
It is the key point whether Xiaomi can overcome this weakness or not in order to expand the
Xiaomi is not a hardware manufacture. Xiaomi has been succeeding to reduce costs
ultimately and offer the low price by outsourcing the manufacturing of hardware. Conversely,
NFC technology enables smartphones and other digital devices to communicate by touching
them together or bring them close in a distance of 10 cm or less. Applying this technology,
people can only use smartphones to pay for public transportation or shopping in stores.
We compared five types of smartphones which have similar or better specs and same or even
Date 2014
Display Size 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.5 5.0
(inches)
Resolution 1920X1080 1920X1080 1920X1080 1920X1080 1280X720
Network 4G 3G 4G 4G 4G
CPU Quad-core Quad-core Quad-core Quad-core Quad-core
2.5 GHz 1.9 GHz 1.7 GHz 2.5 GHz 2.5 GHz
& quad-core
1.3 GHz
Cortex-A7
RAM 3GB 2GB 3GB 2GB 1GB
Battery Non- Li-Ion 2600 Non- Non- Non-
MP MP MP MP MP
MP MP MP MP MP
NFC No Yes Yes (32GB Yes Yes
only)
Comparing to Xiaomi, its competitors, like Samsung, Huawei, ZTE and Lenovo, have been
integrated NFC technology. Especially for Samsung Galaxy S4, which was released on May
2013, already integrated with this technology ahead Xiao at least one year and a half. If
Xiaomi wants to keep increasing its market share, the forecasted commonly used
Heating Problem
As one consumer’s feedback, “Well, it is warm in winter, but too hot in summer!” According
to more than 1000 comments from gsmarena.com, part of the consumers comment that the
heating problem of Mi4 are serious problems. The biggest complains with Mi 4, besides the
prices, is heating (Thomas, 2015). Jaiob (2014) stated that Xiaomi Mi4 came at the worst
place during a heating test comparing with Huawei Honor 6 Plus and Meizu MX4 Pro. This
technical issue arose dissatisfactions from customers and is supposed to be solved on the new
MIUI System
Xiaomi added many personalized and new features to MIUI system, which is built and
developed based on Android operating system, and bring much convenience and great
experience to customers. However, it keeps developing and releasing new version every
week, which may bring a high risk for customers who are not fanciers since the system may
2.2.5 Plagiarism
It has been a long time that customers keep criticizing Xiaomi’s copy from Apple. Especially
when Mi4 is unveiled in July 2014, from industry design to user interface design, you can
Compared with Xiaomi, it is well known that Samsung splash out on its marketing strategy.
In the Chinese market, in order to maintain its own line of high-end brands, Samsung
launched a series of multi-level, all places of promotional activities, and use almost all of the
marketing channels. The investment funds and the intensity is very large.
Advertisement
As many other companies, Samsung smart phone advertisement is an essential part in its
marketing strategy. Including long-term advertising and short-term advertising. The Long-
term advertising investment is mainly to choose the best location of the cities core business
district. Maximum subtle impact on the mobile phone consumers. The short-term advertising
is when a new product launch in the market, the company choose the form of investment in
Among the many forms of advertising, Samsung mainly through large-screen video ads, light
boxes advertising, cinema posters advertising. Coupled with broadcasting ads on higher
In addition, newspapers and magazines advertisements and other publicity campaign make
Sports marketing strategy has been frequently used by Samsung. Samsung has been
sponsored many world’s top sport events ,such as1998 Bangkok Asian Games and 2008
Beijing Olympic Games, especially the strong support and sponsorship to give the Chinese
delegation.
Samsung invested annually in marketing costs about $ 2 billion, of which, the sports
Samsung's president has said publicly that Samsung's success in the global market, 80%
http://enterprise.dbw.cn/system/2013/07/30/054944909.shtml)
In the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games, Samsung Electronics was the Beijing Olympic Games
as the world's mobile phone partner and also as the Chinese Olympic delegation partner.
This effectively into the branding strategy for sports, Samsung has won the trust and goodwill
good social networking boom of the Internet era, opened Facebook, twitter and other social
networks, create two-way communication with the users, and provide a more perfect service,
Charity
Samsung has long adhered to a basic operating principle is to return to the community.
Samsung regularly organize employees in Beijing to Xiangshan and help to do the cleaning,
set up scholarships at many major colleges and universities. Through these public service
activities, Samsung shows to Chinese consumers that it is not just a company only produce
In China, on every New Year's Day, Spring Festival, May Day and National Day, Samsung
will take a variety of promotions to attract consumers. For example, Samsung makes large-
scale promotion in large digital stores or shopping malls, and arrange road shows, allow
2.3 Opportunity
On December 2013, China Mobile, China Unicom and China Telecom got the first license
(TD-LTE) of 4G network. In less than one year, the number of China Mobile’s 4G subscriber
has reached over 100 million (Jones, 2015). According to Chinese Academy of Information
February accounted for 80% among the total shipment of mobile phones. Later on 27th
February 2015, both China Unicom and China Telecom received the second license (FDD-
LTE) of 4G network (Meng and Gao, 2015). It is predicable that the three telecommunication
suggested to go further. Not only high price smartphones, like Mi 4 and Mi Note, but also
low price smartphones, like Redmi and Redmi Note, are expected to support all 4G networks
Cooperating with online shopping website is very necessary. According to Shengli Hu, the
Genearl manager of 360buy Ltd., (jd.com), the market share of online selling mobile phones
has been achieved 24% by the end of 2014. For 360buy, it achieved 53% in B2B online
2.4 Threat
Xiaomi has built its success on low-cost smartphones with high specifications, appealing to
consumers in emerging markets such as China and India. But in western countries it has yet
to gain any kind of market share. (Kharpal, 2014). It has allegations of infringing other
company’s patents such as Ericsson and has legal issues in many countries halting its growth
outside China.
If other competitors brought down the price, Xiaomi would be implicated in price war. This
situation would be detrimental to Xiaomi which does not have strong brand equity.
Combining strengths and opportunities, Xiaomi can generate options to use the company’s
launched its first smartphone, the company was developing its own Android-based firmware
MIUI online, and shared its resource to the public. It already gained a number of loyal
followers and fans before it decided to build their own smartphones. With these movements,
the company has already gain some reputation. It is also producing hardware and software
relating to network development at the same time, which gives them the ability to prove their
technology strengthens to other companies. Also, with the technology evolution, people has
shown their increasingly dependence on high-tech products. The new and modern
technologies will always take replacement of the old ones. For these opportunities, Xiaomi
can use its technology strengths to build up more customer focused devices, such as centre
controlled electrical home wares. And on 14th December last year, Xiaomi and Midea (one of
the largest electrical application manufactures) made an announcement saying that they
Adding more features and provide price competitive but high spec products to customers to
acquire the market share during the development of 4G. Chine Mobile, the biggest
communication operator in China, has over 800 million customers and over 100 million are
4G subscribers. Looking for the opportunity to gain the rest 700 million consumers is
significant for Xiaomi. Cooperating with China Mobile to promote contract phones should be
their main strategy at present. Meanwhile, China Unicom and China Telecom, who just
received second 4G license have prepared a long time to construct FDD-LTE base station,
will dedicate to develop their 4G network since they have been left far away than China
Mobile. Cooperation with these two companies in the beginning, also will help Xiaomi to
For the integration of weakness and opportunities, improvements can be made to take
builds its brand late but it develops and spreads rapidly, which leads some flaws uncovered
and consumers can be picky. But thanks to the Internet, information flows in a flash. People
have more information access on comparing prices and bargains. Xiaomi’s low cost and
reasonable quality makes what the company is these days. Still, improvements can be made
on customer services and more maintaining services afterwards. Speed of solving problems
can be risen up, because one of Xiaomi’s selling strategy is by word of mouth. If complaints
cannot be handled well, then its sales will go down as quickly as it raised. Earlier this year,
Xiaomi announced that they are opening shops in the US this year, but not for phones.
Xiaomi was known as the “Apple” of China in previous years, similarities can be found in
Xiaomi’s products and Apple’s. So, if Xiaomi is thinking of spreading its business
internationally, which is a certainty for every business, specialization and patents is where
The company can also use strengths to avoid threats. As we analysed before, the company
started late on this smartphone business, and the market has already fragmented. And other
competitors are also working on reducing their selling prices, which makes a real big threat to
Xiaomi smartphones. But Xiaomi has its own fans and followers and it is working on both
hardware and software and is developing its own firmware. By inventing more customer
focused and convenient devices to gain more customer loyalty can overcome the threats that
come from its competitors and find its own place in this market. Jun Lei, the CEO of Xiaomi
makes a target of 100 million phones selling in 2015. From previous years’ experience, this
target may not be hard to get. At a certain level, the more it produces, the less of the average
Furthermore, Xiaomi's strength is really inexpensive high-end devices. In India, 200 million
mobile phones can be sold in a year, but the smart phone makes up 20% of all shipments of
entry to the country of more than 140million where demand for cheaper smartphones is
growing (Bloomberg, 2015).accordingly, this tendency coincides with Xiaomi's strength and
its weakness such as low brand power can be overcome. In developing countries, consumers
demand low price devices with high quality. They do not show concern for brand equity.
From the point of view of legal issues such as plagiarism and patents, Xiaomi should avoid
fighting squarely with Samsung and Apple in the United States and the Europa Union
markets, or Xiaomi would expose its weakness otherwise. Xiaomi should retain its own
BRICKs.
There are two primary ways for feasibility of expansion of market share of Xiaomi. One
is to fight squarely with strong foes such as Samsung and Apple in the major markets.
Another one is to pave the way for getting share the developing markets. If Xiaomi uses its
strength efficiently, it should choose the latter. From the point of legal issues such as
plagiarism and patents, it seems to be difficult for Xiaomi to enter the United States and
Europa Union markets in which Samsung and Apple reigns supreme with their strong brand
powers. Judging from Xiaomi’s SWOT Matrix Analysis, Xiaomi could have a massive
impact in developing countries such as Asia, Russia and Brazil at current situation. Xiaomi is
a young company and does not have enough culture and history yet. None the less, a ray of
light in the dark can be found by keeping Xiaomi’s own specific positioning, developing its
brand equity and establishing its identity, history and culture longitudinally.
4.0 Reference
http://news.livedoor.com/article/detail/9704340/
Canalys. (2014). Xiaomi becomes China’s top smart phone vender. Retrieved
from http://www.canalys.com/newsroom/xiaomi-becomes-china-top-
phone-vender/
Kotler,P. & Keller,K (2006). Marketing Management (12th ed.). Upper Saddle:
Prentice Hall.
http://toyokeizai.net/article/-/20365
China Market Tips. (2015). Retrieved from
http://chinamarketingtips.com/T-lessons-of-xiaomi-marketing-success-story-in-china/
http://business.nikkei.co.jp/article/report/
http;//techno.nikkei.co.jp/article/COLUMN/20120601/
Bloomberg. (2012). Xiaomi Amazon Tack to IPhone Fight May Mean 3Years of Losses
tack-to-iphone-fight-may-mean-3-years-of-losses
Thomas, T.(2015). Xiaomi Mi4 Reviews Indicate Fans Not Satisfied. Mobile Phones,
http://rtn.asia/t-t/10471/xiaomi-mi4-reviews-indicate-fans-not-satisfied
Jajob, L. (2014) Meizu MX4 Pro vs. Huawei Honor 6 Plus vs. Xiaomi Mi4 Heat Test.
http://enterprise.dbw.cn/system/2013/07/30/054944909.shtml
CAICT. (2015). The analysis report of national mobile phone market of February 2015.
explosive-4g-growth-is-positive-for-apple/
Meng,J. & Gao,Y. (2015). China issues 4G FDD-LTE Licence. Retrieved from
http://europe.chinadaily.comcn/business/2015-02/27/content 19681059.htm
Kharpal,A. (2014). ‘China’s Apple’ Xiaomi’s expansion is under threat. Retrieved from
http://www.cnbc.com:http://www.cnbc,com/id/102259859#.
Sell-xiaomi-phone/