GE1712

Names: Section:
Date: Score:

Directions: Complete the Comparative Matrix table below. (100 points)

Historical Source Author Event Date Event Objective Persons Involved Main Argument Bias

General for Katipunan Santiago V. Alvarez March 25 1897 Convention was held in Andres Bonifacio When Bonifacio was Bonifacio’s concern on
Tejeros in order to settle Messrs. Mariano Alvarez elected secretary of the lack of official and
the dispute between the Artemio Ricarte interior Daniel Tirona representatibe from other
two council and to decide Santos Noconi contested and argued that province. The Magdalo
on what type of Luciano San Miguel a lawyer should handle still began election
government should be Pablo Mojica the position. Bonifacio
intalled Severino de las Alvarez felt insulted and
Artemio Ricarte demanded an apology
Santos Noconi from Tirona because of
Luciano San Miguel humiliation and anger.
Pablo Mojica Bonifacio declared that
Baldomero Aguinaldo all matters convened
Daniel TIrona were null and void
Cayetano Topacio Together with his
suppoters he left the
estate house

Andres Bonifacio wrote Andres Bonifacio

Filipino Histoorian Teodoro A. Agoncillo December 1896 to his uncle in law Marian Alvarez Daniel Tirona insulted The bias of Agoncillo
Mariano Alvarez about Pascual Alvarez Supremo Andres for covers uo what happened
January 2, 1897 the Magdiwang rebels a Mariano Trias being elected as before the Tejeros
parade took place in Ariston Villanueva Secretary of Interior, and convention happened.
December 31, 1896 Noveleta Santiago Dios he disregards the Also Agoncillio
Bal domero Aquinaldo reminder of Supremo mentioned some different
January 1897 In the assembly hall the Candido Tirona Andres that whoever significant battles before
two faction met and Cayetano Topacio should get elected to any the Tejeros convention
March 22, 1897 exchange the usual Emilio Aguinaldo position must be happened He is
greetings. Vilo Belormino respected Supremo pinpointing some of the
Crispulo Aguinaldo declared the assembly important events the took
Andres Bonifacio left for Daniel Tirona null and void. The voting place before or prior to
Cavite with his wife and was being planned by the Tejeros convention.
two brothers upon the Magdalo Council. Unlike the events that
request of Magdiwang Alvarez has given,
leaders. Agoncillo’s events have
different significant dates
also.

01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI

Page 1 of 2
 HISTORICAL SOURCE ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES
Source Material 1 Disorder ensured as the convention secretary tried to disarm the supreme
Mr Andres Bonifacio the supreme won over Mr. Daniel tirona request for a
restorstion of order and then spoke load

Greatly embarrassed the Supremo Bonifacio quickly stood up and said we

agreed to abide by the majority vote and accept its choice no matter what the
station in life of the person elected

Source Material 2 Andres Bonifacio who was acclaimed by all do succeed him took the chair as The misunderstanding that existed between the followers so destrivo of the
the presiding officer by virtue of his being the president of the supreme Katipunan plans deepened into mutual suspicion and jealous that resulted in
government military reverse in several sectors.

Jealouses continued to plugue the rants rebels and even among the members.

Conclusion and Implication

The Supremo replied that from the rank and file to the highest levels, the Katipunan was united in its respect for universal brotherhood and equality
of men.he be proclaimed vice president of the government of the Philppine Republic

Belonged to the opposite faction, found in Bonifacio’s heart and mind he believed he should have been given the presidency, he contended that
irregularities were committed by the magdalo men and that he would have been elected had it not been for the premeditated frauds of the rival
faction

For the Comparative Matrix: For the Advantages and Disadvantages:

CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS
Provided the correct information with pieces of evidence and supporting Provided a sound argument with pieces of evidence and supporting
Content 12 Content 20
details. details.
Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1 Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1
Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the
6 8
of Ideas paragraph. of Ideas paragraph.
Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1 Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1
TOTAL 20 TOTAL 30