Task 2.

Instruction: Read and examine the research paper assigned to you: Analyze the content of
the methodology written in the paper, check if it satisfy the functions of the Experimental Design.

Title: Chicken (Gallus gallus domesticus) Manure as an Alternative Fertilizer

Researchers: Shan Emmanuel Infante, Lardner Lanao, John Precious Pelobello, and Gillean Abiel
Viajante
Peer Reviewer: Arnold Jheff E. Mahipos and Szhan Wayne S. Timosan

Criteria Present Not Comment/s

Present

✓
1. Provides direction The researcher was able to list all of the
during the actual methodologies employed in the study, as well as
experimentation. the methodology, which was divided into sections.
Several subtopics have been created to further
explore what has been accomplished. In addition,
the researcher was able to submit photographs to
explain the study's methods.

✓
2. Allows a gain of The researchers made good use of their resources
maximum information and time, as well as gaining some useful
relevant to the problem information.
at minimum cost.

✓
3. Makes the statistical We need to use a statistical tool in order to have
test significant or valid valid results, which was greatly done by the
taking into researcher, and thus answered all of the research
consideration all the questions or assumptions in the studywhere, it was
assumptions that went stated that they used One-way Analysis of Variance
into deriving the (ANOVA), in the plant height, the F-value was
various statistics. 65.25 percent lower than the critical value, and the
ANOVA of the number of leaves showed that the
F-value was also lower than the critical value by
85.58 percent. The ANOVA of all factors measured
were significant at a=5
Task 3. Study and analyze the Basic Principles of Experimental Design. Identify if the assigned Research
follows the replication, randomization and local control. If the it follows, write the specific evidence in
the table below.

Title of the Research Replication Randomization Local Control

1. Chicken (Gallus gallus According on the study, This study did not The study did not include
domesticus) Manure as there are 3 replications indicate whether the a local control or control
an Alternative Fertilizer that were conducted for samples taken were setting, and the
the samples in each setup. randomized or not. The experimental setups were
sampling technique merely provided, but they
was not mentioned. were not well-organized or
explained.