Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Management of Flail Chest: Brian L. Pettiford, MD, James D. Luketich, MD, Rodney J. Landreneau, MD
The Management of Flail Chest: Brian L. Pettiford, MD, James D. Luketich, MD, Rodney J. Landreneau, MD
The Management of Flail Chest: Brian L. Pettiford, MD, James D. Luketich, MD, Rodney J. Landreneau, MD
Initial evaluation
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: landreneaurj@upmc.edu The diagnosis of flail chest is clinical and
(R.J. Landreneau). requires evaluation of the injury mechanism,
1547-4127/07/$ - see front matter Ó 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.thorsurg.2007.02.005 thoracic.theclinics.com
26 PETTIFORD et al
Fig. 1. Schematic of flail chest physiology. (From Mayberry J, Trunkey D. The fractured rib in chest wall trauma. Chest
Surg Clin N Am 1997;7:253; with permission.)
physical examination, and radiographic studies chest. Emergency medical personnel reports of
including plain film chest radiograph. With regard steering wheel deformity, high speed frontal or
to injury mechanism, motor vehicle crash is lateral crash, and the presence or absence of front
a major contributor to the development of flail and side airbags is useful during patient triage.
Fig. 2. (A) Anterior and posterior flail segments schematic. Note the location of the anterior and posterior fractures
along the anterior and posterior rib angles, respectively. (B, C) Preoperative and postoperative chest radiograph of ante-
rolateral flail segment. (D, E) Preoperative and postoperative chest radiograph of posterolateral flail segment. (From
Borrelly J, Aazami M. New insights into the pathophysiology of flail segment: the implication of anterior serratus muscle
in parietal failure. Eur J Cardiothor Surg 2005;28:743; with permission. Copyright Ó 2005, European Organization for
Cardio-Thoracic Surgery.)
THE MANAGEMENT OF FLAIL CHEST 27
Shoulder harness seatbelt use may also provide At present, most patients with isolated flail
information about the possibility of sternal or rib chest are admitted to a trauma ICU and receive
fracture versus chest wall contusion. aggressive pulmonary toilet and pain control. In
Patients with flail chest should undergo a stan- patients with an isolated flail chest injury, ade-
dard initial trauma resuscitation including airway, quate analgesia greatly facilitates pulmonary toi-
breathing, and circulation assessment. Physical let and early patient mobilization. Systemic
examination generally reveals a paradoxical mo- opioids, such as intravenous fentanyl or morphine
tion of the flail chest wall segment with normal sulfate, may provide adequate pain relief. Patient-
respiration. The flail segment becomes depressed controlled anesthesia is also effective. Patient-
with inspiration and moves laterally with expira- controlled anesthesia with a continuous infusion
tion. The awake patient usually complains of has been shown to improve pain scores; however,
severe chest wall pain and may manifest signs of respiratory depression may result. Bupivacaine
respiratory insufficiency including tachypnea and intercostal nerve block is useful for pain manage-
splinting. Decreased breath sounds may indicate ment of isolated rib fracture. Multiple rib frac-
a pneumothorax, pulmonary contusion, or hemo- tures require several injections, however, and may
thorax. Radiographic evaluation begins with result in additional chest wall pain, pneumotho-
a portable anteroposterior chest radiograph. rax, and even local anesthetic toxicity [19].
This may not reveal an underlying rib fracture Epidural analgesia has proved extremely effec-
along the lateral and more posterior aspects of the tive in managing the acute pain from chest wall
rib. Given the severity of the accident and injury. Splinting and paradoxical chest wall mo-
concomitant intra-abdominal injuries, most pa- tions are improved to near normal levels. Epidural
tients undergo a chest and abdominal CT scan. use improves pulmonary toilet by enabling the
This study better identifies rib fractures and patient to breathe deeply, cough effectively, and
further defines additional intrathoracic injury, actively participate in chest physiotherapy [20–22].
such as aortic dissection-transection, hemothorax, Adverse effects, such as hypotension in the underre-
and anterior pneumothorax. suscitated patient, respiratory depression, and epi-
dural infection, can limit its effectiveness [21]. In
addition, epidurals can hinder diagnosis of intra-
Medical management
abdominal injuries in critically ill trauma patients
The initial management of flail chest focuses [23]. Despite these potential complications, epidu-
primarily on maintaining adequate ventilation. ral analgesia remains central in the management
Intermittent positive pressure ventilation was first of flail chest.
successfully used to manage flail chest in the mid Thoracic paravertebral block is a technique
1950s [13]. Cullen and colleagues [14] further sup- whereby local anesthetic is injected along the
ported the use of intermittent mechanical ventila- thoracic vertebrae. This modality provides ipsilat-
tion in the treatment of flail chest. During the late eral analgesia over a dermatomal distribution and,
1960s and early 1970s, flail chest was managed unlike epidural anesthesia, minimizes hypotension
with early tracheostomy and mechanical ventila- secondary to a unilateral sympathetic blockade
tion. It was believed that the hypoxia, decreased [24–26]. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs,
compliance, increased work of breathing, and de- such as ketorolac and indomethacin, are effective
cline in pulmonary function testing were solely in the management of mild to moderate chest wall
caused by the flail segment. At that time, only pain. They are particularly useful when used as an
the paradoxical motion of the flail segment char- adjunct to patient-controlled anesthesia or epidu-
acterized flail chest, with no consideration for un- ral analgesia. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory
derlying pulmonary contusion [15–17]. Trinkle drug use is limited in many trauma patients who
and colleagues [18], however, recommended pri- may have acute renal failure or stress gastric ulcers.
mary treatment of the underlying lung injury
with a combination of fluid restriction, corticoste-
Outcome and prognosis
roids, aggressive pulmonary toilet, and pain con-
trol. They described a decrease in mortality rate The high mortality rate is primarily caused by
from 21% to 0%, a 5-fold decrease in morbidity, associated injuries, such as pulmonary contusion
and a nearly 3.5-fold decrease in hospital stay in and intra-abdominal or intracranial injury. In one
these patients when compared with those under- series, 100% mortality was observed in patients
going tracheostomy and mechanical ventilation. with flail chest and concomitant head injuries [27].
28 PETTIFORD et al
The Injury Severity Score has been a useful contusion increases risk for the development of
marker for determining the effects of associated pneumonia and is associated with prolonged
injuries on outcome in patients with flail chest. An mechanical ventilation and higher mortality rate
increased Injury Severity Score has been related to in flail chest victims [33,34]. Functional residual
an increased morbidity and mortality in patients capacity is also decreased in flail chest patients
with flail chest [2,27]. who survive pulmonary contusions [35]. A subset
Early mechanical ventilatory assistance is pro- of these patients become progressively more diffi-
vided to patients with severe concomitant injuries. cult to oxygenate and may require pressure con-
An Injury Severity Score greater than 23, head or trol ventilation. Combined differential lung
truncal organ injury, shock on admission, and ventilation with inhaled nitric oxide may also be
blood transfusions within the first 24 hours have used in the management of flail chest complicated
all been associated with the need for mechanical by severe pulmonary contusion [36]. Extracorpo-
ventilation. The mortality rate of patients with real membranous oxygenation may be used in iso-
severe associated injuries may be decreased from lated cases of pulmonary contusion that is
50% to 6% if mechanical ventilation is instituted refractory to the previously mentioned measures
within 24 hours of injury. The mortality rate can [37–39]. Such factors as intracranial hemorrhage,
exceed 90%, however, for patients with flail chest sepsis, and poor overall prognosis limit the use
and hypotension who develop hypoxia for a period of this therapeutic modality. Treatment of pa-
of more than 24 hours [27]. tients with flail chest and severe pulmonary contu-
Internal pneumatic stabilization may allow for sion is difficult. Prolonged mechanical ventilation
fibrous chest wall stability. In addition, pulmo- with early tracheostomy is the rule when manag-
nary toilet can be provided by flexible bronchos- ing this patient group.
copy. Even so, the incidence of pneumonia
progressively increases with the duration of in-
Surgical management
tubation and mechanical assistance [28]. Other
pneumatic stabilization measures, such as contin- The surgical management of flail chest has
uous positive airway pressure (CPAP), may de- traditionally been reserved for the following in-
crease atelectasis in awake, spontaneously dications: (1) patients with flail chest who require
breathing patients and improve outcome in the thoracotomy for other intrathoracic injury, (2)
critically ill and in trauma patients [29–31]. In those who are unable to be successfully weaned
a prospective randomized study comparing from mechanical ventilatory assistance, (3) severe
CPAP with mechanical ventilation with intermit- chest wall instability, (4) persistent pain secondary
tent positive pressure ventilation, Gunduz and to fracture malunion, and (5) persistent or pro-
colleagues [32] demonstrated a lower mortality gressive loss of pulmonary function [40,41]. Land-
and lower nosocomial infection rate. There was reneau and colleagues [42] demonstrated that
no difference in oxygenation and ICU length of Luque rod strut fixation of extensive flail chest
stay. The authors supported the use of CPAP as resulted in restoration of normal volume of the
initial treatment of flail chest. affected hemithorax. This external fixation
Some patients with flail chest progress to approach allowed for successful ventilator wean-
develop respiratory failure manifested by an in- ing after several weeks of continued ventilator
creased work of breathing, progressive hypox- support (Fig. 3). Furthermore, the strut fixation
emia, and hypercarbia. Other patients have apparatus was easily removed at the bedside using
serious concomitant injuries, such as brain minimal sedation. Tanaka and colleagues [43], in
trauma, that dictate intubation and mechanical a randomized prospective study of surgical versus
ventilation. Those patients who are mechanically internal pneumatic stabilization of flail chest,
ventilated may be maintained on synchronized demonstrated less ventilatory support, low pneu-
intermittent mandatory ventilation setting with monia incidence, and a shorter ICU stay in patients
pressure support or positive end-expiratory pres- undergoing surgical stabilization. Furthermore,
sure if their hemodynamic status permits. Patients surgical stabilization was associated with a lower
with flail chest and pulmonary contusion may medical cost and a faster return to employment.
develop a clinical profile similar to acute respira- Internal fixation techniques including plate
tory distress syndrome, with progressive hypox- stabilization, wire cerclage, intramedullary fixa-
emia, elevated airway pressures, and a progressive tion, and vertical bridging have all been used in
infiltrate in the affected lung. Pulmonary the management of flail chest. Haasler [44]
THE MANAGEMENT OF FLAIL CHEST 29
Fig. 3. (A) Chest radiograph of Luque rod fixation of posterolateral flail chest stabilized with orthopedic external fix-
ation devices. (B) Plain film approximately 3 months after device removal. (From Landreneau R, Hinson J, Hazelrigg S,
et al. Strut fixation of an extensive flail chest. Ann Thorac Surg 1991;51:474; with permission. Copyright Ó 1991, The
Society of Thoracic Surgeons.)
performed an open fixation using Adkins struts to cortical screws (Figs. 6 and 7). Special care is
stabilize the anterior and posterior fractures in taken to avoid neurovascular bundle injury. The
a patient with flail chest and refractory dyspnea main advantages of this technique are the speed
with minimal exertion (Fig. 4). The patient had of implantation and that plate extraction is not
resolution of her symptoms with normalization generally required.
of her pulmonary function testing profile at 1 A possible disadvantage of the metal prosthesis
year postoperatively. Judet struts and acetabular is that it absorbs most of the stress directed
reconstruction plates may be used to provide in- toward the affected rib, potentially resulting in
ternal fixation (Fig. 5). Oyarzun and colleagues delayed fracture healing. Furthermore, the rigidity
[45] described a technique of operative stabiliza- of metal prostheses exceeds that of the affected
tion using 3.5-mm acetabular reconstruction ribs and may result in screw loosening, plate
plates. The plates are contoured appropriately dislocation, or chronic chest wall pain, requiring
and secured along the long axis of the rib using subsequent removal [46]. Absorbable polylactide
Fig. 4. (A) Chest radiograph showing volume loss and rib cage deformity after multiple left-sided rib fractures. (B) Post-
operative film at 1 month following metallic strut placement. Note improved volume in the left hemithorax. (From Haas-
ler G. Open fixation of flail chest after blunt trauma. Ann Thorac Surg 1990;49:994; with permission. Copyright Ó 1990,
The Society of Thoracic Surgeons.)
30 PETTIFORD et al
Fig. 7. Chest films made (A) preoperatively, (B) immediately postoperatively, and (C) 1 year postoperatively. (From
Oyarzun J, Bush A, McCormick JR, et al. Use of 3.5-mm acetabular reconstruction plates for internal fixation of flail
chest injuries. Ann Thorac Surg 1998;65:1473; with permission. Copyright Ó 1998, The Society of Thoracic Surgeons.)
References
[1] National Safety Council 2002. Injury Facts, 2002
edition. Itasca (II): National Safety Council; 2002.
[2] Clark G, Schecter W, Trunkey D. Variables affecting
outcome in blunt chest trauma: flail chest vs. pulmo-
nary contusion. J Trauma 1988;28:298–304.
[3] Gaillard M, Herve C, Mandin L, et al. Mortality
prognostic factors in chest injury. J Trauma 1990;
30:93.
[4] LoCicero J III, Mattox K. Epidemiology of chest
trauma. Surg Clin North Am 1989;69(1):15–9.
[5] Mayberry J, Trunkey D. The fractured rib in chest
wall trauma. Chest Surg Clin N Am 1997;7(2):
239–61.
Fig. 8. Example of absorbable reconstruction plate se- [6] Zuckerman S. Experimental study of blast injuries to
cured with absorbable suture cerclage. (From Mayberry J, the lungs. Lancet 1940;2:219–24.
Terhes J, Ellis T, et al. Absorbable plates for rib fracture [7] Viano D, Lau I, Ashbury C. Biomechanics of the hu-
repair: preliminary experience. J Trauma 2003;55:836; man chest, abdomen and pelvis in lateral impact.
with permission.) Accid Anal Prev 1989;21:553–74.
32 PETTIFORD et al
[8] Ciraulo D, Elliott D, Mitchell K, et al. Flail chest as [26] Eason M, Wyatt R. Paravertebral thoracic block:
a marker for significant injuries. J Am Coll Surg a reappraisal. Anesthesia 1979;34:638–42.
1994;178:466–70. [27] Sankaran S, Wilson R. Factors affecting prognosis
[9] Glinz W. Problems caused by the unstable thoracic in patients with flail chest. J Thorac Cardiovasc
wall and by cardiac injury due to blunt injury. Injury Surg 1970;60:402–10.
1986;17:322–6. [28] Freedland M, Wilson R, Bender JS, et al. The man-
[10] Miller H, Taylor G, Harrison A, et al. Management agement of flail chest injury: factors affecting out-
of flail chest. Can Med Assoc J 1983;129:1104–7. come. J Trauma 1990;30(12):1460–8.
[11] Borrelly J, Aazami M. New insights into the patho- [29] Antonelli M, Conti G, Rocco M, et al. A com-
physiology of flail segment: the implication of ante- parison of noninvasive positive pressure ventila-
rior serratus muscle in parietal failure. Eur J tion and conventional mechanical ventilation in
Cardiothorac Surg 2005;28:742–9. patients with acute respiratory failure. N Engl J
[12] Cappello M, Legrand A, De Troyer A. Determi- Med 1998;339:429–35.
nants of rib motion in flail chest. Am J Respir Crit [30] Hurst J, DeHaven C, Branson R. Use of CPAP mask
Care Med 1999;159:886–91. as the sole mode of ventilatory support in trauma pa-
[13] Avery E, Morch E, Benson D. Critically crushed tients with mild to moderate respiratory insuffi-
chests: a new method of treatment with continuous ciency. J Trauma 1985;25:1065–8.
mechanical hyperventilation to produce alkalotic [31] Tanaka H, Tajimi K, Endoh Y, et al. Pneumatic sta-
apnea and internal pneumatic stabilization. J Thorac bilization for flail chest injury: and 11-year study.
Surg 1956;32:291–311. Surg Today 2001;31:12–7.
[14] Cullen P, Modell J, Dirby R. Treatment of flail chest: [32] Gunduz M, Unlugenc H, Inanoglu K, et al. A com-
use of intermittent mandatory ventilation and posi- parative study of continuous positive airway pres-
tive end-expiratory pressure. Arch Surg 1975;110: sure (CPAP) and intermittent positive pressure
1099–103. ventilation (IPPV) in patients with flail chest. Emerg
[15] Davidson J, Bargh W, Cruickshank A, et al. Crush Med J 2005;22:325–9.
injuries of the chest: a follow up study of patients [33] Voggenreiter G, Neudeck F, Aufmkolk M, et al. Op-
treated in an artificial ventilation unit. Thorax erative chest wall stabilization in flail chest: out-
1969;24:563–7. comes of patients with or without pulmonary
[16] Duff J, Goldstein M, McLean A, et al. Flail chest: contusion. J Am Coll Surg 1998;187(2):130–8.
a clinical review and physiological study. J Trauma [34] Richardson J, Adams L, Flint L. Selective manage-
1968;8:63–74. ment of flail chest and pulmonary contusion. Ann
[17] Diethelm A, Battle W. Management of flail chest in- Surg 1982;196:481–7.
jury: a review of 75 cases. Am Surg 1971;37:667–70. [35] Kishikawa M, Yoshioka T, Shimazu T, et al. Pulmo-
[18] Trinkle J, Richardson J, Franz J, et al. Management nary contusion causes long-term respiratory dys-
of flail chest without mechanical ventilation. Ann function with decreased functional residual
Thorac Surg 1975;19(4):355–63. capacity. J Trauma 1991;31:1203–8.
[19] Shanti C, Carlin A, Tyburski J. Incidence of pneu- [36] Johannigman J, Campbell R, Davis K Jr, et al. Com-
mothorax from intercostals nerve block for analge- bined differential lung ventilation and inhaled nitric
sia in rib fractures. J Trauma 2001;51:536–9. oxide therapy in the management of unilateral pul-
[20] Mackersie R, Karagianes T, Hoyt DB, et al. Pro- monary contusion. J Trauma 1997;42:108–11.
spective evaluation of epidural and intravenous ad- [37] Shapiro M, Anderson H, Bartlett R. Resp failure:
ministration of fentanyl for pain control and conventional and high-tech support. Surg Clin
restoration of ventilatory function following multi- North Am 2000;80(3):871–83.
ple ribs fractures. J Trauma 1991;31:443–9. [38] Kause J, Parr M. Extracorporeal membranous oxy-
[21] Worthley L. Thoracic epidural in the management genation in the management of severe thoracic
of chest trauma: a study of 161 cases. Intensive trauma: a case report. Crit Care and Resusc 2001;
Care Med 1985;11:312–5. 3(2):97–100.
[22] Dittman M, Ferstl A, Wolff G. Epidural analgesia [39] Voelckel W, Wenzel V, Rieger M, et al. Temporary
for the treatment of multiple rib fractures. Eur J In- extracorporeal membranous oxygenation in the
tensive Care Med 1975;1:71–5. treatment of acute traumatic lung injury. Canad J
[23] Ward A, Gillatt D. Delayed diagnosis of traumatic Anesth 1998;45(11):1097–102.
rupture of the spleen: a warning of the use of tho- [40] Cacchione R, Richardson D, Seligson D. Painful
racic epidural analgesia in chest trauma. Injury nonunion of multiple rib fractures managed by
1989;20:178–9. operative stabilization. J Trauma 2000;48(2):
[24] Cheema S, Ilsley D, Richardson J, et al. A thermo- 319–21.
graphic study of paravertebral analgesia. Anesthe- [41] Lardinois D, Krueger T, Dusmet M, et al. Pulmo-
sia 1995;50:18–21. nary function testing after operative stabilization
[25] Karmakar M. Thoracic paravertebral block. Anes- of the chest wall for flail chest. Eur J Cardiothorac
thesiology 2001;95:771–80. Surg 2001;20:496–501.
THE MANAGEMENT OF FLAIL CHEST 33
[42] Landreneau R, Hinson J, Hazelrigg S, et al. Strut fix- [45] Oyarzun J, Bush A, McCormick JR, et al. Use of
ation of an extensive flail chest. Ann Thorac Surg 3.5-mm acetabular reconstruction plates for inter-
1991;51:473–5. nal fixation of flail chest injuries. Ann Thorac
[43] Tanaka H, Yukioka T, Yamaguti Y, et al. Surgical Surg 1998;65:1471–4.
stabilization of internal pneumatic stabilization? A [46] Engel C, Krieg J, et al. Operative chest wall fixation
prospective randomized study of management of se- with osteosynthesis plates. J Trauma 2005;58:181–6.
vere flail chest patients. J Trauma 2002;52(4):727–32. [47] Mayberry J, Terhes J, et al. Absorbable plates for rib
[44] Haasler G. Open fixation of flail chest after blunt fracture repair: preliminary experience. J Trauma
trauma. Ann Thorac Surg 1990;49:993–5. 2003;55:835–9.