Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How Do Absorbable Sutures Absorb? A Prospective Double-Blind Randomized Clinical Study of Tissue Reaction To Polyglactin 910 Sutures in Human Skin
How Do Absorbable Sutures Absorb? A Prospective Double-Blind Randomized Clinical Study of Tissue Reaction To Polyglactin 910 Sutures in Human Skin
How Do Absorbable Sutures Absorb? A Prospective Double-Blind Randomized Clinical Study of Tissue Reaction To Polyglactin 910 Sutures in Human Skin
Barry T. Cartmill, David M. Parham, Paul W. Strike, Liz Griffiths & Ben Parkin
To cite this article: Barry T. Cartmill, David M. Parham, Paul W. Strike, Liz Griffiths & Ben Parkin
(2014) How Do Absorbable Sutures Absorb? A Prospective Double-Blind Randomized Clinical
Study of Tissue Reaction to Polyglactin 910 Sutures in Human Skin, Orbit, 33:6, 437-443, DOI:
10.3109/01676830.2014.950285
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
1
Royal Bournemouth Hospital, Bournemouth, Dorset, United Kingdom and 2Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust,
Wiltshire, United Kingdom
ABSTRACT
Objective: To compare the tissue reaction produced by 2 gauges of implanted polyglactin 910(Vicryl) suture
material in human skin.
Methods: A prospective, double masked, parallel randomized IRB approved clinical trial. Consecutive patients
with involutional entropion and horizontal eyelid laxity were randomly allocated to 5/0 or 7/0 gauge test
suture groups. Symptoms were alleviated during the wait for definitive surgery by placement of eyelid everting
sutures. After 28 days, surgical entropion correction including eyelid wedge excision was achieved. Histological
analysis was carried out, masked to the suture gauge used, on the excised eyelid containing one of the
temporary everting sutures. Both patient and analyst were masked to the suture group. The four primary
outcome measurements were granuloma outer diameter, central cellular diameter, giant cell number and area of
fibrous coat and a statistical comparison made between suture gauge groups.
Results: 21 patients were allocated to each group, and histological analysis was possible in 36 patients.
Significant suture-related granulomatous inflammatory reactions were found in all specimens. Medians of the
measurements for 5/0 and 7/0 gauge sutures, respectively, were 0.855 mm versus 0.387 mm granuloma outer
diameter (p = 0.0001); 0.464 mm versus 0.250 mm central cellular element diameter (p = 0.0003); 0.194 mm2 versus
0.053 mm2 fibrous coat area (p = 0.0009) and 0.8 versus 1.2 giant cell number (p = 0.7511).
Conclusions: Polyglycolic acid sutures elicit a significant foreign body inflammatory response proportional to
suture gauge. This reaction may be minimized by early suture removal. The study validates a novel and ethical
approach to the examination of human skin response to implanted suture material.
Keywords: Human polyglactin response, polyglactin-induced scarring, polyglactin tissue reaction,
stitch granuloma, suture granuloma
Received 10 November 2013; Accepted 28 July 2014; Published online 22 September 2014
Correspondence: Dr. Barry T Cartmill, Clinical Fellow in Oculoplastic Surgery, Royal Bournemouth Hospital, Castle Lane East, Bournemouth,
Dorset BH7 7DW, United Kingdom, Tel: 02871345171. E-mail: barrycartmill@hotmail.com
437
438 B. T. Cartmill et al.
adverse effects on scarring and functional outcome, oral and written explanation of the study was given
particularly in facial and periocular surgery. by the clinician. It was specifically emphasized
Lower eyelid entropion is a common eyelid that everting sutures alone may be an effective
malposition typically affecting older patients. treatment for entropion in some patients.14
A delay before definitive surgical correction is Participants were advised that the long term recur-
normal in most centres due to high demand. rence rate following entropion surgery without eyelid
Symptoms may be controlled in the meantime by tightening is high.15
temporary everting sutures to reposition the eyelid. Once informed consent had been obtained, clin-
An important predisposing risk factor for the devel- icians contacted the research office and provided the
opment of entropion is eyelid laxity, and surgical date of birth and participant initials prior to allocation
management involves reduction of this laxity through of a study ID number. Research data were recorded on
eyelid shortening. The Quickert procedure is long a report form identified by ID number to ensure
established as effective in the correction of entropion anonymity and confidentiality. Participants were
and includes the excision of a wedge of the affected assigned to blocks by sex and age (above or below
eyelid.13 If this eyelid wedge includes implanted 75 years) prior to randomization. One eyelid from
suture material (previously placed for temporary each patient was randomised to either 5/0 (0.1 mm
relief of symptoms) a unique ethical opportunity for diameter) or 7/0 gauge (0.05 mm diameter) PCA
the study of human tissue reaction to implanted braided suture if a random number (generated
materials is created. between 0 and 1 by the RAND function in Excel)
The authors hypothesize that cutaneous sutures was greater or less than 0.5 respectively. Histological
generate a significant inflammatory reaction during parameters were measured in a separate department
hydrolysis proportional to the suture gauge. This by a single clinician masked to the suture gauge used.
paper reports the results of the first known prospect- The suture gauge group was identified for statistical
ive, double blind study investigating the histological analysis once recruitment and measurements were
reaction of normal unwounded human cutaneous complete.
tissue to PCA suture and a comparison of the reaction All study patients were masked to their suture
elicited by 5/0 and 7/0 gauge sutures. group and underwent insertion of temporary eyelid
eversion sutures in the minor operations theatre
without delay once informed consent was obtained.
MATERIALS AND METHODS Definitive surgery was carried out 28 days later.
oblique angle sectioning of the granuloma. giant cell number) were measured at a mean of 6
A 3D optical scanner (OPT scanner 30001 M, different levels. The medians were calculated for each
Bioptonics, MRC Technology, Edinburgh, UK) identi- index. The area of fibrous tissue in each granuloma
fied the location of suture in the wedge specimens cross-section was calculated by subtracting the area of
prior to sectioning (Figure 1). the central cellular element from the area of the
Any suture associated granuloma was identified fibrous coat. As area = (d/2)2 the fibrous coat
(Figure 2) and the four primary outcome measures area = (FD/2)2 ([FD FT]/2)2.
(outer diameter, central cellular element diameter,
fibrous coat diameter (FD) and thickness (FT) and
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
RESULTS
FIGURE 3. Graphs showing the distribution of measurements for granuloma diameter (mm), central cellular element diameter (mm),
giant cell count and fibrous coat area (mm2) in 5/0 and 7/0 suture groups (horizontals display medians, boxes, 50% data
spread, whiskers, 95% data spread and asterisks, outliers of more than 99% spread). p values less than 0.001 highly statistically
significant, after correlation corrected Bonferroni adjustment for multiple testing.
along its full length (serial sections) without for the 5/0 and 7/0 gauge suture respectively;
granuloma formation. In 1 case, the suture was p = 0.7511, 95% CI 0.95 to 1.26, ES 0.11).
knotted in the specimen preventing meaningful
measurement. Histological analysis was carried out
on the remaining 36 patients, 17 with 5/0 PCA and DISCUSSION
19 with 7/0 PCA test sutures. There were no statis-
tically significant age (p = 0.930) or sex (p = 0.671) Cutaneous scarring is an extremely important issue
differences between these two groups. The study in facial plastic, reconstructive and aesthetic
was terminated once sufficient participants in each surgery. In the periocular area scarring may addition-
group had been recruited. ally interfere with eyelid function. Although tissue
All sutures were associated with a typical foreign adhesives are occasionally used,17,18 sutures are
body granuloma consisting of an epithelioid cell the standard method for closing facial surgical
infiltrate with variable numbers of multinucleate wounds and suture choice is an important factor
giant cells and polymorphonuclear leucocytes sur- influencing the scarring process. Suture properties
rounded by a coat of fibroblasts (Figure 2). Statistical such as material, filament type, coating and
results are summarised in Figure 3. The median gauge all affect the tissue reaction and final
diameter of the suture granuloma was strongly scar. Although there is extensive scientific literature
dependent on suture gauge (0.855 mm versus on the cutaneous tissue reaction to sutures in animal
0.387 mm for the 5/0 and 7/0 suture respectively; models, as far as the authors are aware, there has been
p = 0.0001, 95% CI 0.20 to 0.57, Cohen’s treatment no prospective study in normal human cutaneous
Effect Size (ES) = 1.66). The median diameter of the tissue.
central cellular element was similarly dependent Polyglycolic acid (PCA) is a tough, fibre-forming
(0.464 mm versus 0.250 mm; p = 0.0003, 95% CI 0.12 polymer and has been used to produce synthetic
to 0.34, ES = 1.47). absorbable sutures since the early 1960s. VicrylTM
In these indices, the larger suture gauge resulted has become a highly popular braided coated PCA
in an approximate doubling of the diameter of suture worldwide and is extensively used in
inflammatory infiltrate. The area of fibrous coat was oculoplastic surgery. When exposed to physiological
even more strongly dependent with 5/0 gauge suture conditions, PCA is degraded by random hydrolysis
resulting in approximately 4 times more fibrous and esterase activity into glycolic acid. This can then
tissue in cross section (medians 0.194 mm2 versus be excreted in urine or enter the tricarboxylic
0.053 mm2; p = 0.0009, 95% CI 0.04 to 0.22, ES = 1.29) acid cycle to form water and carbon dioxide.19
than 7/0 gauge suture. The giant cell count was A simple tissue hydrolytic reaction would not be
highly variable and the suture gauge did not have a expected to stimulate significant inflammation and
statistically significant effect (0.8 cells versus 1.2 cells promotional literature is consistent with this assertion.
Orbit
Tissue Reaction to Absorbable Sutures 441
Excluded (n=5)
Enrolment
Not meeting eligibility criteria (n=3)
Declined to participate (n=2)
Other reasons (n=0)
Randomised (n=42)
Allocation
Allocated to 5/0 suture gauge (n=21, 13M, 8F): Allocated to 7/0 suture gauge (n=21, 12M, 9F):
Received allocated intervention (n=21) Received allocated intervention (n=21)
Did not receive intervention (n=0) Did not receive intervention (n=0)
despite 24 histological levels (all sutures were level despite 20 histological levels
the skin surface or deep in an epithelial cleft) 2) A female with suture enclosed by surface
2) A female with suture enclosed by surface epithelium along its full length without
epithelium along its full length without granuloma formation
granuloma formation
3) A male where the only suture was caught
at a turning point (a knot) and could not be
measured despite 16 histological levels
FIGURE 4. Flow chart summarising participant flow, numbers, randomization assignments, interventions and completeness of
follow-up. Reasons for loss to follow-up detailed.
e.g. ‘‘[PCA suture] absorbs by hydrolysis in 60 to This represents a balance between inflammatory and
90 days with virtually no tissue reaction.’’20 fibrotic reaction and can lead to extensive scarring if
‘‘Coated VICRYL sutures elicit only a mild tissue there is persistent inflammation.27–29 Granuloma size
reaction during absorption.’’21 However, suture- is closely related to the inflammatory activity and
associated inflammation and granuloma are well indicates biocompatibility of the suture material.30.
recognised in postoperative patients.10–12 Prospective studies in human oral mucosa have also
Investigation into cutaneous suture-induced tissue shown significant inflammation,1–5,31 but no prospect-
reaction has been performed in animal models, ive data on the human cutaneous suture reaction have
particularly the rat and rabbit.22–25 Initially, the been published.
foreign surface is thought to be covered with matrix The authors have developed a new model which
metalloproteinases (MMPs), MMP1 and MMP2.26 allows the prospective study of cutaneous tissue
Subsequent denaturation and absorption of these reaction to implanted suture material in patients
proteins causes recruitment of circulating monocytes presenting with eyelid entropion. Eyelid everting
and local macrophages which form a dense infiltrate sutures alone may be used as a temporary measure
around the foreign body. The release of inflammatory for symptomatic relief from entropion by correcting
cytokines recruits fibroblasts and results in the the lid position. In the presence of significant lid
formation of a fibrous capsule around the infiltrate.25 laxity, this is unlikely to be a permanent cure. In this
Eventually a mature foreign body granuloma forms. model, a test suture is included as one of the three
! 2014 Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.
442 B. T. Cartmill et al.
Orbit
Tissue Reaction to Absorbable Sutures 443
19. Gunatillake PA, Adhikari R. Biodegradable synthetic 26. Renò F, Traina V, Cannas M. Adsorption of matrix
polymers for tissue engineering. Europ Cells Mater 2003;5: metalloproteinases onto biomedical polymers: a new
1–16; discussion 16. aspect in biological acceptance. J Biomater Sci Polym 2008;
20. Anonymous. SURGICRYL from Surgitech Surgical 19:19–29.
Sutures. Available at: http://www.surgitech.cn/surgicryl. 27. Klinge U, Klosterhalfen B, Müller M, et al.
htm [Accessed June 1, 2012]. Influence of polyglactin-coating on functional and mor-
21. Anonymous. Ethicon wound closure manual - (February phological parameters of polypropylene-mesh modifica-
2004). Available at: http://www.scribd.com/7052XX/d/ tions for abdominal wall repair. Biomaterials 1999;20:
22757952-Ethicon-Wound-Closure-Manual-February-2004 613–623.
[Accessed June 1, 2012]. 28. Klosterhalfen B, Junge K, Klinge U. The lightweight and
22. Bridgens NK. A comparative study of surgical suture large porous mesh concept for hernia repair. Expt Rev Med
materials and closure techniques. J Amer Osteopath Asso Dev 2005;2:103–117.
1983;82:715–718. 29. Kuroyanagi Y, Taguchi M, Yano T, et al. Argon laser-
23. Cavallaro A, Sciacca V, Cisternino S, et al. Experimental assisted anastomoses in medium-size vessels: one-year
Evaluation of Tissue Reactivity to Vascular Sutures: follow-up. Lasers Surg Med 1991;11:223–231.
Dacron, Polypropylene, PTFE. Vascul Endovasc Surg 1987; 30. Klinge U, Theuer S, Krott E, et al. Absence of circulating
21:82–86. aldosterone attenuates foreign body reaction around sur-
24. di Marzo L, Hunter WJ, Schultz RD, et al. In Vivo Study of gical sutures. Langenbeck’s Archives of Surgery/Deutsche
Expanded Polytetrafluoroethylene Vascular Suture. Vasc Gesellschaft für Chirurgie 2010;395:429–435.
Endovasc Surg 1989;23:77–82. 31. Wallace WR, Maxwell GR, Cavalaris CJ. Comparison
25. Setzen G, Williams EF. Tissue response to suture materials of polyglycolic acid suture to black silk, chromic, and
implanted subcutaneously in a rabbit model. Plast plain catgut in human oral tissues. J Oral Surg 1970;28:
Reconstruct Surg 1997;100:1788–1795. 739–746.