Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LSCM03 - Coca Cola
LSCM03 - Coca Cola
LSCM03 - Coca Cola
INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY
Class: BABA184WE11
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................... 3
1. About Coca Cola Company ............................................................................................. 3
a. Coca Cola Company .................................................................................................. 3
b. Coca Cola Vietnam ................................................................................................... 3
2. Product............................................................................................................................. 4
3. Market ............................................................................................................................. 4
a. Target market .............................................................................................................. 4
b. Brand awareness ......................................................................................................... 5
4. Competitors ..................................................................................................................... 6
II. SUPPLY CHAIN OF COCA COLA VIETNAM ............................................................. 7
1. Main product of the supply chain .................................................................................... 7
2. Supply chain network ...................................................................................................... 7
a. Suppliers .................................................................................................................. 7
b. Factories ................................................................................................................... 9
c. Warehouses .............................................................................................................10
d. Distribution .............................................................................................................10
i. Transportation ...................................................................................................10
ii. Distribution channels ........................................................................................11
iii. Customers .........................................................................................................13
e. Elements in the supply chain ..................................................................................13
i. Material flow .....................................................................................................13
ii. Information flow ...............................................................................................13
III. PROBLEM ..........................................................................................................................14
1. Strengths of distribution system .....................................................................................14
2. Main problem and possible reasons ...............................................................................15
IV. METHODOLOGY .............................................................................................................16
V. SOLUTION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................................................19
1. Upgrading the standard for intermediaries, reducing channel conflicts .............. 19
2. Upgrade transportation facilities, create a beautiful image for Coca Cola .......... 20
3. Rebalancing costs ................................................................................................. 21
4. Looking for new market ....................................................................................... 21
VI. REFERENCES ...................................................................................................................21
VII. CONTRIBUTION FORM .................................................................................................23
2
INTRODUCTION
In 1886, Coca-Cola was introduced to the public for the first time in Atlanta, which really caught
the attention of most people who enjoyed it because of its wonderful aroma and attractive colors.
It is said that Coca-Cola is the world’s leading carbonated beverage company. The company has a
massive operation network, including North America, Latin America, Europe, Asia, the Middle
East and Africa. In Asia, Coca Cola has its factories located in 6 regions, which are China, India,
Japan, Philippine, South Pacific & South Korea, and West and Southeast Asia.
Coca Cola was first introduced in Vietnam in 1960 but it was not until 1995 that Coca Cola
Indochina Private Company Limited by Share entered into a joint venture with Vinafine, a state-
owned enterprise under the Ministry of Agriculture and Agricultural Development, to form Coca
Cola Ngoc Hoi Carbonated Beverage Company in Hanoi. Chuong Duong Coca Cola Limited
Liability Company in Ho Chi Minh City and Coca Cola Non Nuoc Carbonated Beverage Limited
Liability Company in Da Nang were also established afterwards under joint venture contracts in
1995 and 1998 respectively. However, these Coca Cola joint ventures were allowed to transform
into 100 percent foreign owned enterprises only after a short time of operation. In January 2001,
the Vietnamese Government allowed the merger of three businesses in the North, Central and
South into one company called Coca-Cola Vietnam Limited Liability Company, whose
headquarters is located in Thu Duc City with 2 branches in Ha Noi and Da Nang henceforth.
3
Product
products with rich flavors and designs such as Classic Coca-Cola, Coke it gas (diet Coke), Sprite,
Fanta, Vanilla Coke, Cherry Coke, Mello Yello, Dasani Mineral Water, and even different product
Market
Targer market
Coca-Cola is the largest soft drinks producer in the world. After years of improvement, Coca Cola
has been successful in many countries with its entire serving market strategy, and Vietnam is not
an exception. Initially, when penetrating into the Vietnamese market, Coca Cola focused on high
demand and condense population market segments as a firm foundation for its future development.
Cocacola had its headquarters in the North (Hanoi), Central (Da Nang), the South (Ho Chi
Minh City) and gradually expanded to neighboring cities. These cities are very potential for
massive Coca Cola’s products consumption after being carefully researched and evaluated by the
4
company. It is expected that the Vietnamese market will continue to grow significantly in the
upcoming years, with a projected annual growth rate of 6% by 2020 and beverage consumption is
estimated to reach 81.6 billion litres in 2016, with a forecast to reach 109 billion litres in 2020
(PET Packaging in the Vietnamese Beverage Industry, 2019). Coca-Cola assessed that Vietnam
will grow significantly in the next 10 years, possibly in the top 25 of its most potential markets.
As such, Cocacola conducts market segmentation mainly by geography (focusing on big cities
with high population density and frequency of usage) and by demographics (mainly targeting
young people - the audience that has high demand). This is also the target market of Coca Cola.
Brand awareness
Coca-cola has succeeded to become the number one carbonated soft drink in the world - a leading
product that is known by more than 94% of people worldwide (Why is Coca Cola the most
recognized brand?, Brandsvietnam, 2015). Coca Cola seeks to build a symbol of trust, inherent
uniqueness, and great refreshment. The company promises to “bring about refreshment to the
customers” by continuously searching for new markets and focusing on public communications.
5
Competitor
The beverage market is very competitive as many soft drink companies are making a lot of effort
to win the customers’ loyalty and dominate the market share. The competition between Coca Cola
and Pepsi to take over the 1st brand position in the beverage market has never stopped. According
to Statista, Coca Cola’s U.S market share in 2019 was 43.7 percent, whereas Pepsi only amounted
manufacturing drinks for a few other Coca-Cola competitors. The Pepsi story began in 1893 when
Caleb Bradham started to sell it in his drugstore as Brad’s Drink, the drink that would make
digestion easier. Thirty years later, facing bankruptcy, the company was sold to Charles Guth.
After the change of the company’s management, Pepsi’s profits went up. Soon, the brand was
In 1991, Pepsi Group came to Vietnam for the first time with high quality products and slightly
changed taste to better suit Vietnamese consumers. Over nearly 15 years of operation, Pepsi has
become a familiar soft drink brand to Vietnamese people. PEPSICO Vietnam International
Beverage Company was established on December 24, 1991, formerly a joint venture company
between SP.Co and Company Macondray - Singapore. On April 28, 2003 Pepsico Global
foreign owned company and renamed it PEPSICO Viet International Beverage Company. The
6
company has 2 factories in Hoc Mon and Dien Ban that are fully equipped with automatic bottling
and canning systems, and quality inspection system for food hygiene to reach the advanced level
in the world. PepsiCo Vietnam main products are soft drinks such as Pepsi, 7-up, Mirinda, Lipton,
Sting,etc. and snacks such as Frito Lay, Cheetos, Aunt Jemima waffle,etc. that meet international
To understanding the supply chain of this company, we are going to focus on the company’s main
product, which is Coca-Cola Classic. It has the name “Coca-Cola” due to being derived from the
Coca leaf and Cola from kola nuts. The ingredients inside this drink includes carbonated water
(around 90% of Cola is water and it gives the drink “bubbles” or “fizz”), sugar, caramel color,
phosphoric acid, caffeine (contained in kola nut) and last but not least is natural flavors.
Suppliers
Raw materials are an important component in commodity manufacture. The efficiency of the
production can be partially ensured by monitoring the quality of the materials provided by our
suppliers. Coca-Cola Vietnam has carefully selected the suppliers, including product consistency,
company operating modes, company status,etc. Moreover, Coca-Cola Vietnam also works with
hosts of local vendors. Raw materials are delivered to Coca-Cola manufacturing plants from four
main suppliers, which are Thanh Thanh Cong Bien Hoa Joint Stock Company, Dynaplast
Packaging Limited Liability Company, Bien Hoa Packaging Joint Stock Company (SOVI), and
Stepan Company.
7
Thanh Thanh Cong-Bien Hoa Joint Stock Company is one of
Dynaplast Packaging Limited Liability Company (Vietnam) belongs to Dynaplast Group, the
Southeast Asia's leading producer of hard plastic packaging, specializes in manufacturing and
selling plastic bottles for various industries. For several years, it has supplied high-quality plastic
Province, Vietnam.
carton boxes provider for Coca Cola Vietnam. Established in 1968, Sovi
has became the 1st packaging supplier in Vietnam with the annual growth
Stepan Company provides cola leaf for Coca Cola companies around the world, including Coca
Cola Viet Nam. Stepan’s headquarter is located in the Greater Chicagoland area (Northfield, IL).
8
Factory
Coca Cola production processes are subjected to stringent management, strict inspection and
follow the highest requirements of the Vietnamese Government and Ministry of Health, as well as
its own quality regulations. Coca Cola Vietnam received multiple prestigious quality
accreditations after fulfilling its dedication to quality, including ISO 9001:2015 for Quality
18001:2007 for Health & Safety Management System, FSSC 22000 V4 for Food Safety System,
and KORE & ATR for the Coca Cola Company's policies and practices on management system.
Efforts to save electricity and water, as well as reduce noise, wastewater, and pollution, have both
for the plant. There are Coca Cola factories 3 in Vietnam, which are located in Ho Chi Minh City,
9
Warehouse
Once the Coca Cola bottles are finished manufactured at the factory, they will be conveyed by
forklift drivers to fill the storage shelves in the warehouses and ready for delivering to the
consumers. According to the Coca Cola Company, Toyota forklifts are the most efficient
transportation for shipping, filling, and unloading merchandise in warehouses. The three main
factories in the North, Central and the South Vietnam ensure quick response to the massive demand
across the country. Coca-Cola goods will be sold to retailers, main accounts, and wholesalers
Distribution
Transportation
One of the Vietamese leading suppliers of transportation services to both domestic and
international businesses is Van Cong Thanh Transportation - Trading - Service Limited Liability
Company. Currently, the firm is serving as the primary transport provider for Coca Cola Beverage
Vietnam.
Binh Vinh Corporation is an organization that specializes in transportation services. The business
is headquartered in Da Nang, and it has branches in Ha Tay, Vinh, Nha Trang, Tien Giang, Thu
10
Company Limited, in the North-Central-South areas. Coca-Cola is sent from the company's factory
Distribution Channels
Coca Cola has developed its distribution channels in several ways. The first one is allocating Coca
Cola products to supermarkets and key accounts, from which the customer will buy Coca Cola
bottles. The company has distributed its product to several large supermarkets throughout Vietnam
such as AEON Mall, Coop mart, Lotte mart, etc. Key accounts are businesses or organizations
which typically purchase goods in vast amounts on a daily basis and have the potential to bring
about profit for the company such as cinemas or fast food chain stores.
The second channel has the Coca Cola products distributed through the chain from wholesalers to
retailers and then to the consumers. Wholesalers are responsible for operating and distributing
products to lower-level dealers in their region, hence extending the products regions’ reachable
possibility. Coca Cola Company has a crowded wholesalers network, enlarging from North to
11
South. Some of the wholesalers are Vifotex and Bach Khoa Distribution in Hanoi, Binh Ha Duy
Company and Siam Super Stream Vietnam in Da Nang City, and Fimexco and Quynh Anh Service
& Trading Company in Ho Chi Minh City. After taking over the Coca Cola bottles from the
company’s warehouses, wholesalers would sell these products to the retailers, which are groceries,
restaurants, cafe shops, bars, pubs,hotels, resorts,etc. Because the retailers are the intermediaries
that directly serve the end customer and focus on the purchasing habit of people, therefore they
According to the intermediary division, Coca-distribution Cola's agent rights would belong to the
form of commission middlemen who do not own the products, but in practice, these exclusive
rights are enjoyed at a discount (commission) for owning goods. According to the company's
rationale, this strategy would have a strong motivation for monopolists to improve their production
For each form of channel participant, the organization employs the required payment process.
Depending on their arrangement, small retailers or other end users will pay the wholesaler directly
in cash at the time of distribution or at the end of the month. The main account will pay for Coca
Cola via bank transfer for wholesalers and supermarkets. Prior to 2009, payments were made
through Vietcombank, but since January 2009, the transaction has been moved to SHBC. The
company's debt capability is 10 million a week. If the wholesaler does not pay, the wholesaler
12
Customers
Customers are a vital component of the supply chain because of the revenues and profits they
provide to the business, which helps to strengthen the supply chain. As a result, Coca-Cola has
always strived to provide various product experiences with the best quality, and always looks
forward to receiving customers feedback for further enhancement. Coca Cola believes that
everyone can be a potential customer, therefore Coca Cola bottles are made in different sizes and
Material flow
The commodity flow is a one-way flow that entails the delivery of materials from producers to
consumers. Many domestic and international manufacturers provide raw materials such as plastic
bottles, sugar, and Coca leaves. Binh Vinh Corporation, Van Cong Thanh Transportation - Trading
- Service Limited Company, and others have been contracted by Coca-Cola to assist in the delivery
of products to distribution networks. Components of the supply chain have their own function, but
Information flow
Information is seamlessly passed between channel members. The firm will provide information on
product types, weight and quantity, costs, payments, incentives, and so on to sales middlemen as
well as end users. The corporation frequently provides input from the channel's other participants
in order to encourage or identify and resolve its shortcomings. Information systems can be
streamed from one member to another member (e.g. from Coca Cola to a wholesaler) or to another
13
Coca Cola Vietnam keeps the processes operating smoothly and effectively by responding quickly
to complaints and ensuring the complete participation of individual servers and software, taking
responsibility for all factories' infrastructure systems, as well as the development and operation of
new systems and services such as ERP SAP, Margin Minder, and Sales Force Automation SFA.
Coca-Cola Vietnam uses SAP ERP to control sales process, including income analysis, benefit
estimates, etc.; customer relationships such as management of customer reviews and other
management and so on. Margin Minder clear out master data of channel, Customer Group, SR
classification,etc. to create a new bookmark for cross-functionality. SFA helps all area
administrators in resolving SFA process problems, recording and tracking bugs and CR in the Jira
PROBLEM
Coca Cola has developed a large distribution system in Vietnam, with scope that covers the entire
market and all types of customers, which is quite different from target demographics of other
brands or products. People drinking Coca Cola products can be seen everywhere. Coca Cola
Company is actively searching and implementing new products in order to compete with rivals
like Pepsi. The most successful exploitation of product ideas is focused on the coordinated
activities of departments such as Marketing, Distribution, and Production. The first thing Coca
Cola must do is claim its market role among the countless new products of other brands that are
constantly being introduced to attract consumers, but if Coca-Cola only builds its brand image, it
is easy for a brand's long-term ambitions to fall apart. Coca Cola has responded by creating a
unique distribution system with its own size and rigorous design process. Coca Cola's current status
14
is a commodity of global and foreign brands has been elevated thanks to a global distribution
channel structure that, as its name suggests, covers the global market. Advertising, promotion,
discount, and other similar measures have only short-term benefits because they are easy to be
duplicated. However, the distribution channel is distinct; it can be considered exclusive to each
corporation. Businesses that have the distribution channel in hand often have clients, who are the
lifeblood of the company. The strength of Coca-Cola is not only the brand of its products, but also
Aside from its strengths, each company or business will have gaps in its management and
supervision. The first consideration is about the transportation fees. The cost of distribution
remains very high, particularly the cost of delivery workers, direct distributions, and small
distributions. And now the company is correcting the situation by laying off employees,
particularly the small direct salespeople assigned to the distributor in that polar area's indirect
channel system. Responsible for jobs such as customer service, customers, contract signing,
stockpiling products, etc, now has only one employee to manage the distribution of jobs and
product intake, which leads to work overload and reduces performance efficiency.
Relationships with channel members are another "difficult" and painful aspect of distribution.
Channel members can easily process business contracts once a good partnership has been formed.
be far more effective. However, many conflicts occur within the channels, resulting in numerous
disadvantages for the company. Due to a lack of clarity in the division of responsibilities and
forces, there is a battle for customers among different vertical channels. A recent crash happened
in which a superior distributor used his power at the right time when Coca Cola launched a
customer care campaign and installed refrigerators for subordinate distributors and retailers. The
15
dealer requests that the wholesaler send a list of retailers, along with a list of quantity and
refrigerating installations. However, some distributors took advantage of their control to contact
and sell directly with the manufacturer rather than via the wholesaler in order to benefit from the
marginal price. Any of these distributors' employment is only recognized for their immediate
personal benefit, which has severely harmed Coca-Cola's image and created disputes between
wholesalers and higher-level distributors. Conflicts in the channel may also arise as a result of
conflicts of interest, especially those arising from promotions. Dealers or distributors may consider
how much to allocate during the promotion period in order to be competitive with distributors or
Comprehensive distribution channels with the aim of achieving product range, but not uniformly,
with market coverage density and an emphasis on small market areas that are not served such as
stores, entertainment areas, and festivals, etc. has not been researched to determine the best
distribution method. Mostly, delivery is still similarly rampant. Coca Cola sells products to general
agents in accordance with the process. Agents receive products from the general agent. The
products are sent by the agent to the retailers, who then sell them to the street vendors. With such
a process, the price of the product will be pushed up compared to the original starting price. So
when traveling, it is more difficult for street vendors to sell their goods than the grocery stores in
that area.
METHODOLOGY
Covering problem method, which has been introduced in the Logistic and Supply chain
management course, is applied to define new main distributors among Coca Cola’s existing
distribution channels. This method aims to locate specific places that are able to meet the crowded
demand of Coca Cola bottles with the smallest total delivery time and shipping cost.
16
First of all, we listed Coca Cola’s representative wholesalers throughout Ho Chi Minh City. These
distributors are selected based on scale, reliability and transparency (all the information is
Duc City
3 C Hoang Khang Coca Cola Distributor 19 Road No. 5, Cat Lai, District 2, Thu Duc
District
6 F Khuong Duy Import & Export No. 44 / 3A13 TTH10 Street, Quarter 3,
7 G Quynh Anh Trading and Service One 270b Ly Thuong Kiet Street, District 10
8 H Hiep Nhat Coca Cola Wholesale 173 Khuong Viet Street, Phu Trung Ward,
Tan Phu
9 I iWater Limited Liability Company 65/9 Cao Xuan Duc, Ward 12, District 8
10 J Hoang Lan Coca Cola Distributor 55 Temple Street Binh Dong, Binh Hung
17
Then we used Google map to define each of the distributors’ locations and the distance between
each other. The results are shown in the map below and the number unit is minute.
A B C D E F G H I J
A 0 17 24 23 23 39 47 56 49 66
B 17 0 12 30 40 56 58 62 44 72
C 24 12 0 18 36 63 46 50 32 60
D 23 30 18 0 18 47 40 51 26 54
E 23 40 36 18 0 29 24 33 38 43
F 39 56 63 47 29 0 35 44 49 35
G 47 58 46 40 24 35 0 9 14 19
H 56 62 50 51 33 44 9 0 18 10
I 49 44 32 26 38 49 14 18 0 28
J 66 72 60 54 43 35 19 10 28 0
Maximum 66 72 63 54 43 63 58 62 49 72
Single
location E
Maximum
time 43
18
Since Coca Cola are dealing with many distribution
Two
C G
locations channels, including distributors and wholesalers,
A 24
B 12 therefore the management task would be intensive.
C 0
D 18 Base on the covering problem method calculation,
E 24
there are two ways that Coca Cola should consider
F 30
G 0 to reduce its distribution system but still ensure the
H 9
I 14 operation’s efficiency. The first table compares the
J 19
shipping time from each location to others, and
Maximum
24 30
time FMCG Viet has the lowest maximum delivery time,
therefore we suggest that Coca Cola should focus on working directly with FMCG Viet and then
the FMCG Company will responsible for distributing Coca Cola’s products to other places and the
maximum delivery time would be 43 minutes. Or if Coca Cola Company worry that one
distributors cannot handle the massive amount of Coca Cola’s products, the combination of two
distributors, which are Hoang Khang Coca Cola Distributor and Quynh Anh Trading and Service
One Member Limited Company, are proposed. With this distribution channel, the maximum
delivery time would be 30 minutes, which is 13 minutes lower than that of single location.
Currently in Hanoi, each Coca Cola exclusive agent is only responsible for distributing goods to
1200 retailers. However, the population density is increasing, there are also more and more grocery
retailers and the distance between them is shortening. So if an exclusive agency only works in a
narrow geographic area, waste of management and conflicts between agents would arise. To
alleviate this situation, Coca Cola should reduce the number of agents and increase the retail stores
they are in charge. It is essential to improve and upgrade their agents in terms of warehouse and
19
management so that they have good resources to execute smoothly and effectively. This effort not
only helps Coca Cola to reduce management costs but also reduces a lot of conflicts among the
channels.
Moreover, Coca Cola needs to come up with policies to support and encourage retailers to
cooperate with each other. Reality shows that there must be strict contracts that regulate what
activities to be done and which activities must have the consent of the company. Besides, there are
separate discounts as well as bonuses and penalties for the members whose performance is good
or not. This helps to motivate channel members to cooperate better. The most important thing is
to help retailers aware of the benefits of cooperation as well as active participation. Activity that
is widely used is to regularly hold customer conferences, which motivate the relationship among
retailers, make it get better and better, and at the same time create unity in the implementation of
company activities. In addition, the sales and marketing as well as business development team
need to do their best in convincing, answering questions and receiving feedback from retailer
members if there is any question or issue as soon as possible. If the cooperation wants to take place
effectively, the inspection and supervision between channel members must be strictly carried
out. This well done channel is also very beneficial for the company to monitor and adjust to the
During the past time, Coca cola still used relatively rudimentary means such as trolleys to deliver
goods to small retail outlets. Using a trolley creates a feeling of sleazy, unprofessional and has
many disadvantages to the image of Coca Cola while Coca cola is a famous global company in the
world. Therefore, Coca Cola Vietnam should upgrade its vehicles to create a beautiful image in
people's mind. Motorbikes can be used instead of trolleys. Besides, it is possible to create
professional and eye-catching means of transport for Coca Cola by printing logos and using the
20
main color of red to decorate motorcycles and freight cars. Moreover, some additional forms of
supply can also be considered such as Premix machine and plastic bottle with 19 liter extraction
nozzle.
Rebalancing costs
From the end of 2003 onwards, the company has always maintained a direct sales team, regularly
taking care of customers such as cleaning refrigerators, solving arising problems. However, due to
cost cutting, this activity no longer exists, which causes complaints and affects the relationship
between distributor and company. Therefore the company should reconsider and find a better
Over the past few decades, consumers have constantly changed their shopping habit, especially in
terms of shopping behavior on e-commerce channels and websites and businesses have to find
ways to adapt to this trend. With the support of ever-evolving technology, it is easier for
consumers to find and purchase items from online websites, e-commerce markets and mobile apps
instead of following commercial traditional trade models. In order to create more creativity in
refreshing customer experience on online platforms and stimulate customer demand, Coca Cola
should enter this new type of market with so many popular platforms such as Tiki, Shopee, Lazada,
Grabmart, etc.
REFERENCES
Evaluating the distribution channels of Coca Cola, Course Prject, National Economy University
https://www.cocacolavietnam.com
https://www.coca-colacompany.com/brands
21
PETnology - US company specialising in media and events related to the PET plastic industry,
2019
https://www.petnology.com/competence-magazine/news-details/pet-packaging-in-the-
vietnamese-beverage-industry.html
Brands Vietnam, Why is Coca Cola the most recognized brand?, 2019
https://www.brandsvietnam.com/8122-Vi-sao-CocaCola-la-thuong-hieu-duoc-nhan-biet-nhieu-
nhat
Brands Vietnam, Overview ‘The battle of the century 'between Coca-Cola and Pepsi, 2015
https://www.brandsvietnam.com/8212-Toan-canh-Tran-so-gang-the-ky-giua-CocaCola-vs-Pepsi
MBA Trong tầm tay, Chủ đề Marketing, NXB Trẻ, Tác giả: Alexander Hiam. Charles D.Schewe
https://www.ttcsugar.com.vn/
http://dynapackasia.com/services/
http://www.sovi.com.vn/
Van Cong Thanh Transport – Trading – Service Limited Liability Company Website
https://www.vancongthanh.com/
https://binhvinh.com/van-tai/
Investment Bridge Magazines, Eight Vietnamese companies join the supply chain of Coca-Cola,
2017
https://nhipcaudautu.vn/doanh-nghiep/8-cong-ty-viet-nam-gia-nhap-chuoi-cung-ung-cua-coca-
cola-3320814/
22
CONTRIBUTION FORM
Do Quoc Bao
BABAWE18513
23