Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 15

ROBIN SKEATES

TRITON’S TRUMPET: A NEOLITHIC SYMBOL IN ITALY

Summary. The distribution and uses of triton shells in Italyfrom the Neolithic
to modern times are described in detail, along with a summary of examples
from the Neolithic and Copper Age of Central Europe and the central and eastern
Mediterranean. Attention is then focused upon the triton shell trumpet, which
is interpreted both as a Neolithic visual symbol and an oral signal, and
suggestions are offered concerning its changing meaning in historical and more
recent times.

INTRODUCTION

Triton shells have long been recognized by found world-wide. The name ‘Triton’s
archaeologists as more than mere molluscs. Trumpet’ belongs, strictly speaking, to the
The deposition of these shells and their Indo-Pacific species, Charonia tritonis,
skeuomorphs in prehistoric ritual contexts has whereas the Mediterranean variety is Charonia
been frequently attested in the eastern nodifera. The latter are characterized by high
Mediterranean (Mosso 1910, 363-365; spires, long siphonal canals, and large
Montagu 1981; Reece 1985, 353-364), and apertures, and can grow up to 30 cm in length.
their use as conch shell trumpets is known from They are carniverous, and live on rocks and
around the world (Jackson 1917). The Italian gravel in the lower coastal zone in fairly deep
examples of these shells, however, have so far sea water. They can, however, be collected
received little attention, which is surprising, dead on beaches (Oliver 1975, 144; Reece
considering their early date and prolonged use. 1985,353). Fossil examples have been found
This paper therefore seeks to redress the in Sicily and Calabria, and also throughout the
balance. Detailed contextual data are presented Mediterranean, in Pliocene and Quaternary
below concerning the human uses of triton marine formations (Gignoux 1913).
shells in Italy, from Neolithic to modem times,
and more generally for Neolithic and Copper
Age examples from Europe and the Mediter- TRITON SHELLS AND TRUMPETS:
ranean. Interpretations of these uses are then CONTEXTUAL DATA
offered.
Neolithic Italy
CHARONIA NODIFERA
1 ) Caverne dei Balzi Rossi, Liguria
Triton shells belong to the genus Charonia. Triton shells were found here in an unspeci-
There are about a dozen species, which are fied context (Mosso 1910, 363):

0 OXFORD JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGY lO(1) 1991 17


TRITON’S TRUMPET

2 ) Grotta di Bergeggi, Liguria the central group of a necklace, flat circular


Some triton shells were found. Human pendants with a small hole, a pendant cut
remains comprised a minimum of 14 indivi- horizontally at the apex and in the middle of
duals, predominantly adults. Many Neolithic the shell, and a cylindrical curved strip with
Square Mouthed Pottery (SMP) sherds were hole; awls; cut, thinned, and smoothed pieces;
also found. (Issel 1886,218; Tink 1968; Issel sea-worn pieces; and numerous fragments (200
1892, 242; Delfino 1981, 114-5). fragments were found by Don Morelli). These
were found by Bernabb Brea in the following
3) Grotta di Galuuo, Liguria
Triton shells were found here in an strata: 26 and 25 (Cardial impressed, graffiti
decorated and SMP pottery) - three examples;
unspecified context (Mosso 1910, 363).
24, 23, 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 17 (SMP) - 23
4) Caverna della Pollera, Liguria examples; 11 (Lagozza pottery) - one
Five triton shells were found, all with the example. A radiocarbon sample, R-101, from
apex artificially cut off, and one with a small levels 25 and 26, produced a date range of
drill hole through its lip. Artefacts made of 5316-5005 Cal. BC (2-sigma) (Alessio et al.
shell fragments included a segment of a large, 1966; Stuiver and Reimer 1986). Many other
regular, and well smoothed bracelet probably shell species were also found here. There were
made of triton shell. Human remains com- numerous Neolithic burials found in the cave,
prised at least 49 individuals, including 27 particularly of children and young people, and
children and juveniles, and 11 adults. Charac- especially heads or parts of heads. (Issell886,
teristic pottery included bichrome painted ,218; Issel 1892, 190; Mosso 1910; Bernabo
sherds, SMP, and Lagozza pottery. (Issel Brea 1946 and 1956; Delfino 1981).
1893, 64; Bernabb Brea 1946, 218; table
7) Grotta delle Felci, Capri
LIX. 1 and 5 , Bernabb Brea 1947,85; Delfino
Pieces of large shells, probably triton,
1981, 109-113).
forming necklaces and bracelets were found,
5) Arma del Sanguineto or della Matta, along with onraments of Patella and Ciprea.
Liguria Human remains found at the mouth of the cave
One triton shell was found, with its apex comprised two skulls and female skeletal
artificially cut off. Human remains included remains, in the little cave there were bones
a minimum of 11 individuals, all children. from six or seven individuals, and in the small
Perrando’s excavations in 1870 revealed a cave near to this there were human bone
group of three skulls (two coated with red fragments. Capri painted pottery and Diana
ochre), the mandible of a child and other pottery were characteristic. (Rellini 1923,
bones, and near to these were found: shells, 351).
a ‘pintadera’, a bone spatula, two greenstone
8) Ripoli, Abruuo
axes, and a sherd of pottery. SMP, Lagozza,
Triton shells were found in ‘Hut’ XXV in
and painted pottery were found. (Issel 1893,
the settlement. One human tibia came from the
75; Delfino 1981, 115-6).
upper deposits of this cavity. Artefacts in the
6) Caverna delle Arene Candide, Liguria lower deposits included: three bone awls;
Triton shell finds included: whole examples; numerous lithics, such as blades, flakes and
others with artificially removed apexes (18 of single barbed arrowheads; a limestone mace-
these were found by Don Morelli); spoons or head; and many pierced Pectunculus and
scrapers; pendants - three pendants forming Ostrea shells. Pottery comprised: coarseware

18 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R. SKEATES

- trunco conical vessels with walls riddled


with small holes, and ring handles with raised
edges, sometimes pointed; black fineware -
spherical vessels with tubular handles; and fine
yellow ‘figulina’ - high cylindrical cups, and
large plates with raised and slightly inturned
rims decorated with little applied discs (Rellini
1934, 16). This assemblage was similar to
pottery from ‘Hut’ 3, which produced a radio-
carbon sample for the Pisa laboratory, and a
date range of 4231-3438 Cal. BC (2-sigma)
(Cremonesi 1965, 152; Stuiver and Reimer
1986).

9) Grottu dei Piccioni, Abruzzo


A triton shell, identified as Churoniu
nodifera, was found in the ‘Level of the
Circles’. It measured 16.5 cm in length. Its
apex had been removed, a small cylindrical
hole was drilled near to the lip, and it was
partly tinted with red ochre (Fig. 1). It is worth
describing the context of the ‘Level of the
Circles’ in some detail, because it is the best
recorded and published Neolithic context for
a Neolithic triton shell in Italy. (See Cremonesi Figure 1
1976). Charonia nodifera from the Grotta dei Piccioni in
A line of rather scattered circles of stones Abruzzo. Length: I I cm. Reproduced by kind
permission of Prof. G . Cremonesi (University of
lay on a large flat slab of rock near to the back Pisa).
wall of the cave. The shallow soil around these
was blackened, and contained charcoal, ashes
and pebbles, in contrast to the brown soil found stones, and these exhibit clear, and seemingly
in the same stratigraphic level in a trench ten intentional, spatial patterning in relation to the
metres away. child remains. Overall one can distinguish two
Articulated human bones from the upper half major concentrations of animal bones and
of the body of an infant were uncovered within artefacts at each end of the line of circles, close
circle I, at the left hand end of the line of to the child remains, along with a smaller
circles; and at the opposite end, near to a small concentration in the middle of the line.
niche in the cave wall, the skulls of two The intentional breaking of pottery vessels
children were found along with a few skull possibly took place, for there is a notable
fragments and particularly some post-cranial decrease from left to right in numbers of whole
body parts of a child. vessels. and a corresponding increase in
A large quantity of animal bones, pottery, numbers of sherds. Ethnographic instances
lithics, and bone and shell artefacts were show that the deliberate breaking of vessels
deposited both in and around the circles of is sometimes associated with conspicuous

OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY 19
TRITON’S TRUMPET

feasting. Such an interpretation is supported on the edge of the Neolithic settlement land-
by the predominance of meat bones amongst scape, high above the Orta gorge, might be
the remains of the major animal species considered as liminal, and hence appropriate
(sheep/goat, pig, red and roe deer, and cattle), for ritual activities (Skeates forthcoming a).
and the almost exclusive presence of meat
bones for the minor species (bear, dog, wild
cat, hare, fox, and marten). Neolithic and Copper Age Temperate Europe
An outstanding group of unusual artefacts
was located around circle XI, near to the main 1 ) Chamblandes culture, S. W. Switzerland
Bracelets made from Tritonium species shells
group of child remains, and the triton shell was
were found in cist graves of the Chamblandes
found amongst these. There were 11 bird
culture (Sauter and Gallay 1969, 61). This has
humeri (mostly of surface feeding duck) and
its closest affinities with the final Neolithic
one hare metatarsal, each with a red coloured
Chassey/Lagozza culture (Sakellaridis 1979,
pellet of clay at the distal end (or traces of this);
57), which perhaps points towards a north
six clay weights; a half drilled round and flat
Italian or southern French source for the shells.
pebble; and a collection of five intact fineware
pottery vessels which included: two bowls, and 2) BtMsmegyer 11, Hungary
two closed forms with handles, one of which A triton shell with its apex neatly removed
was covered by an inverted third bowl. was found in this settlement. It lay on a pottery
Pottery fabrics included coarseware and fine dish of the Baden Pkcel culture. (Banner 1956,
‘figulina’?the latter being sometimes decorated 69 and plate 39.1; Montagu 1981, plate 11).
with red paint or little applied discs. Forms
3) Fenkpuszta I , near Keszthely on lake
included flasks with high necks and everted
Balaton, Hungary
rims, ollas with small handles, and round
A triton shell, with a large irregular sided
bodied vessels with straight necks and lug
hole in its body, its apex removed, and a small
handles. There were also fine burnished fab-
round hole drilled in its lip, was found in a
rics, of which were made a variety of bowls
‘cult house’ at this site of the Copper Age
and cups, wide handled vessels with low necks,
Balaton group (Kalicz 1973, fig. 11S ) .
convex walls and flat bases, one spout, and
two black burnished fineware cups carrying 4) Osel, Wolfenbuttel, Lower Saxony, W.
graffiti decoration. Germany
Typologically the material has been assigned A triton shell, with its apex worked off, and
to the later Neolithic Ripoli culture, which is filled with 12 worked pieces of flint, was found
broadly confirmed by a C14 sample, Pi-49, on the summit of the Osel hill in 1898. It lay
taken from the overlying levels. This produced on the bedrock in the middle of a soil filled
a 2-sigma date range of 3780-3340 Cal. BC. pit, and was surrounded by a further seven
(Ferrara et al . 1961; Stuiver and Reimer 1986). pieces of worked flint, which were thought to
The deposits in the ‘Level of the Circles’ have been placed intentionally. The lithics
seem markedly ritual in nature, as is suggested were generally non-retouched, but the three
by the presence of human remains and some retouched pieces have been typologically
particularly unusual artefacts, the high degree assigned to the early Neolithic Bandkeramik.
of structure in the spatial deposition of material A Neolithic pottery sherd decorated with
remains, and the possible evidence of feasting. horizontal impressed lines was found three
In addition, the location of the cave, hidden metres away, and numerous lithics, including

20 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R . SKEATES

arrowheads and perforated axes, were col- off. The latter was decorated with ochre, and
lected from the surface of the hill (Virchow was found with two vessels which were also
1902; Busch 1983). decorated with ochre. The remains of 29 triton
shells were found at the Early Minoan IIA-B
site of Myrtos (Fornou Korifi), and one whole
example, from Room 28, had its apex broken
Neolithic and Copper Age Eastern and Central
off.
Mediterranean
4) Cyprus
A full account of triton shells from the
Neolithic Triton shell vessels and spoons
eastern Mediterranean has been published by
were found at Cape St. Andreas. Five whole
Reece (1985). A summary of this is provided
triton shells, along with two vessels and eight
below, with the addition of some recently
fragments, came from Khirolutia. One of these
discovered examples, and others from Malta.
shells was found with a flint implement among
1 ) Mainland Greece boulders placed on the head of a child buried
A Neolithic example of a worked triton shell in Grave IV of Tholos XXII. Unworked triton
comes from Kitsos cave in Attica, and another shells were found at Ayios Epiktitos, and other
triton shell was found in the Rachmani examples are known from Erimi, Episkiop,
Neolithic deposits at Magula Pevkakia in and Maa-Palaeokastro.
Thessaly. In the middle Chalcolithic settlement at
Kissonerga-Mosphilia, a pit (1015), containing
2 ) Cyclades
material described as ritual in nature, was
The remains of 94 triton shells were found
found under a building (994). There were fire-
at Late Neolithic Saliagos, and included ground
cracked stones mixed with pebbles, ground
spoons. The remains of 31 triton shells were
stone tools, organic remains, and some sherds;
found in the Final Neolithic settlement at
and against the south wall of the pit there was
Kephala on Keos, and two large distal end
a stack of pottery vessels in Red-on-White
fragments came from the upper cemetery area
ware, of the Ermini culture, which overlay a
there. A triton shell vessel was also discovered
building model with thirty objects packed
in the Early Cycladic tomb 21 at Panayia on
tightly into it, including figurines, stone tools,
Paros, and fragments were found at the Early
a bone point, and a whole triton shell
Cycladic cemeteries at Lakkoudhes and Ayioi
(Peltenburg et al. 1988, Peltenburg and Project
Anargyroi on Naxos.
Members 1989). Radiocarbon samples from
the pit date this deposit to the later 4th
3) Crete
millennium Cal. BC (E. Peltenburg pers.
Fragments of triton shells were recovered
comm. 1990).
from the Neolithic deposits at Knossos,
including one whole example with the apex 5) Malta
removed, and a cut and smoothed piece from A portion of a triton shell, ‘sharpened as if
the Early Neolithic stratum IX. Many broken for use as a cutting instrument’, was found at
triton shells were also discovered in the the Hajar Qim Temples (Evans 197 1, 94). A
Neolithic rock shelter at Magasa. Two triton triton shell wzs also found recently during the
shells were found at Final Neolithic Phaestos. excavation of a ritual pit, known as the
One of these was broken, but the other was Brockdorf Circle, on the island of Gozo (S.
whole, save for its apex, which has been cut Stoddart pers. comm. 1990).

OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY 21
TRITON’S TRUMPET

Roman Italy Tritons, collectively, were also half-men,


half-fish, who frisked around the chariots of
I ) Mythological contexts Amphritite, and Venus. They lived at sea, but
According to Greek and Roman mythology, sometimes ventured onto land (Guirand 1959:
the sea god Triton was the son of Poseidon and 169). Lucius Apuleius, in lhe Golden Ass (Bk.
Amphitrite, and was Neptune’s trumpeter. He IV: 31), describes them accompanying Venus:
was half-man and half-fish, anci lived in the
depths of the sea, especially near to the coast ‘straight away appeared her servitors from
of Libya. He is associated especially with the the deep . . . the bands of Triton trumpeters
roar of the sea and its wild movement, as his leaping hither and thither, the one blowing
attribute, the conch or triton shell trumpet, on his shell with heavenly noise’
tends to indicate (Guirand 1959; also see (trans. Gaselee 1915)
Dressler 1916-24). and Pliny reports, in his Natural History
The use of his shell trumpet, following a (Bk. IV: IV), that:
flood, is described in Ovid’s Metamorphoses
(Bk. 1 : 330-345): ‘An embassy from Lisbon sent for the
purpose reported to the Emperor Tiberius
‘Then he called to the sea-god Triton, who that a Triton had been seen and heard
rose from the deep, his shoulders covered playing on a shell in a certain cave, and that
with clustering shellfish. Neptune bade him he had the well-known shape.’
blow on his echoing conch shell, and recall (trans. Rackham 1947)
waves and rivers by his signal. He lifted his
hollow trumpet, a coiling instrument which 2) Coins and sculpture
broadens out in spiraling circles from its A few Italian coins, dated to c 200-67 BC,
base. When he blows upon it in mid-ocean, show the figure of a Triton carrying a trident
its notes fill the furthest shores of east and and blowing a conch shell; and a Greek coin
west. So now, too, the god put it to his lips, from Agrigentum shows a Triton holding a
which were damp from his dripping beard, conch in both hands and blowing into it (Poole
and blew it, sending forth the signal for 1876, 15).
retreat as he had been bidden. The sound A colossal figure of a river-god, known as
was heard by all the waters that covered the ‘Marforio’, holding a conch shell trumpet
earth and sea, and all the waves which heard in one hand, and a horn of plenty in the other,
it were checked in their course.’ was found at the bottom of the Capitoline Hill
(trans. Innes 1955) in Rome, and is now housed in the Capitoline
Museum (Rossiter 1971, 53-4).
In Virtil’s Aeneid (Bk. VI: 170-5) he kills
a rival trumpeter, Misenus: 3) Funerary contexts
Tritons blowing trumpets are depicted on a
‘Yet on that day, while haply he makes the number of Roman funerary monuments
sea ring with his hollow shell, madman! and (Cumont 1942). For example, the sarcophagus
with his blare calls the gods to contest, of the Nereides in the Vatican Museums carries
jealous Triton - if the tale can win belief centrally a Triton blowing a conch (Cumont
- caught and plunged him in the foaming 1942, 167, plate XII.l). The tomb of the
waves amid the rocks.’ Valerii on the Latin Way also has a Triton
(trans. Fairclough 1927) blowing a conch, accompanied by a Nereid

22 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R. SKEATES

(Cumont 1942, 167, fig. 68). A sarcophagus, fresco a Triton blowing a conch shell trumpet.
formerly housed in the Villa Ludovisi, shows: This was painted in 1514 for the Villa
above, two wives accompanied by spirits of Farnesina (Vermeule 1964, 65, fig. 52).
the four seasons; in the middle, two Tritons
blowing into conches, two sirens, and two lions
each ripping apart a roe deer; and below a 2) Late Renaissance and Baroque fountain
description of the donor of the sarcophagus sculptures
(Cumont 1942, 165). Also, a cremation urn Between 1575 and 1576 the Fountain of the
in the Galleria Lapidaria in the Vatican shows Moor was sculpted, based on a design by
Tritons carrying conches and holding up an Jacopo della Porta. It showed four Tritons
epitaph (Cumond 1942, plate XII.2). blowing water from double conch shell
A partial explanation of this funerary trumpets. It was intended for the Piazza del
symbolism may be provided by the scene on Popolo, but was placed in the Piazza Navona,
a stucco relief which fills the semi-dome of where it was later modified by Bernini, and
the subterranean basilica outside the Porta from where it was removed in 1874 to the
Maggiore in Rome. It depicts the last voyage Giardino del Lago of the Villa Borchese.
of the soul of a woman over the sea to the (D’Onofrio 1957, 67-8, figs. 49, 51, 52).
Islands of the Blest, and an element in the scene There were also two fountains in the Vatican
is a Triton who is not only blowing his gardens which incorporated Tritons: a fountain
trumpet, but also holding an oar (Cook 1925, sculpted by Cordier (Franciosino) between
136, plate XIX). 1609 and 1610, which showed a child with a
conch in its hand spouting water (D’Onofrio
4) Pompeii 1957, 194-5); and the Fontana dell’aquila,
A large conch shell (probably belonging to designed by Maderno and constructed between
the Strombus genus rather than Charonia), 161 1 and 1612 by de Pomis and Valperga,
with its apex missing, was found in the which is a so-called rustic or grotto fountain.
‘atriolum’ (courtyard) of the Cassa Menandro. A Triton sits in one of the caves on a dolphin
It was found near to a wall niche containing blowing water up through a conch shell
three lamps, which was situated above a trumpet (D’Onofrio 1957, 193, figs. 159,
platform. The triton shell was found with two. 162).
much smaller shells, three shallow bronze Tritons blowing conch shell trumpets are a
‘frying pans’, a terracotta jug, and two strigils, feature of the work of Bernini, Baroque
which had presumably fallen from above, Rome’s leading sculptor and architect, who
perhaps from a shelf. Groups of other shells believed that historical subjects from
were found in other courtyards. This context mythology, ancient history and the Bible were
must be considered as domestic until shown the most worthy of representation.
otherwise. (P. Allison pers. comm. 1990). In 1620 Bernini executed his ‘Neptune and
Triton’ sculpture, which shows Neptune and
Triton holding a trident and a conch trumpet
Art in 16th-19th century Rome: some respectively. It was designed to crown a large
examples fish pond in the garden of Cardinal Peretti’s
Villa Montalto, and is now in the Victoria and
1 ) Renaissance painting Albert Museum (Wittkower 1955, 4-5, fig.
Raphael included in his Triumph of Galatea 21).

OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY 23
TRITON’S TRUMPET

More than a decade later, between 1632 and 19th and 20th century Italy
1637, he designed the lay-out of the Piazza
1) Religious contexts
Barberini, and placed his monumental ‘Triton
Mosso (1910, 365), the Italian prehistorian,
Fountain’ in the centre. This masterpiece is
relates that: ‘The triton shell is still sounded
formed by four dolphins supporting an open
in church in Piemont, and I have myself
bivalve shell on which is seated a Triton
sounded it as a child. During the services in
blowing a jet of water through a conch shell
Holy Week at Chieri, when the choir was
held up in his hands (Rossiter 1971, 175). It
singing the psalms, and a table was struck with
was created in honour of the Barberini family,
sticks during the Tenebrae of the Sepulchre,
Bernini’s greatest patrons, as is shown by the
the sacristan gave us the triton shell to sound.
entwining of the papal insigna and the
Dr. Issel relates that during the services of
Barberini coat of arms in the dolphins’ tails,
Holy Week in the Cathedral of Genoa a Triton
and was completed in 1643.
nodiferum used to be sounded, the same shell
Finally, between 1641 and 1644, he
which I have found in caves among axes and
designed the monumental Trevi Fountain for
knives of stone’. At Piedigrotta, near Naples,
Pope Urban VIII, with two giant Tritons, one
a Strombus shell trumpet is played in the
blowing a conch, conducting the winged
festival of the Madonna (Fig. 2), accompanied
chariot of Neptune.
by a clay friction drum and a small squeaker
In 1652 the Fountain of the Snail was
(Harrison and Rimmer 1964, fig. 9).
sculpted by Vannelli, reputedly based on a
design by Bernini. It shows three dolphins 2) Economic contexts
supporting a conch shell spouting water. It At Casamicciola on the island of Ischia
originally stood in the Piazza Navona, but was conch shell trumpets were sounded to scare
later moved to the Villa Pamphilj (D’Onofrio away thieves and birds from vineyards and
1957, fig. 54). gardens. On the islands of Elba and Sicily shell
trumpets were blown to summon fishermen
3) 18th and 19th century sculptures and field labourers, and Sicilian fishermen are
During the second half of the 18th century reported to have used triton shells as trumpets.
the sculptors Penna and Righi produced stone Also, the larger species of Buccinum is still
relief wall panels for the Roman-style Room used by Italian herdsmen in directing their
of the Emperors in the Casino Borghese, which cattle. (Jackson 1917, 32-33).
formed part of the renovations carried out
under Prince Marcantonio Borghese. Penna’s INTERPRETATIONS
panel depicts Venus on the sea with an
attendant blowing a conch; and Righi’s shows To begin with, it can be argued that the
Neptune, accompanied by an attendant blowing examples of whole triton shells, with their
a conch, stirring up the winds against the navy apexes intentionally removed, were used as
of Eneo (unpublished Borghese Gallery guide). trumpets. This is in agreement with the
After the return of Pope Pius VII from interpretations of their excavators, such as
France in 18 14 the Piazza del Popolo was laid Cremonesi (1976). This view is based upon
out according to a design by Valadier. This analogies with Classical and more recent
included a fountain on the west side showing ethnographic evidence from Italy. The mytho-
Neptune with two Tritons, one blowing a logical sounding of conch shell trumpets by
conch shell trumpet (Rossiter 1971, 148-9). both Triton and the Tritons is described by

24 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R . SKEATES

Figure 2
Shell trumpets (Srrornbus gigas) blown at the festival of the Madonna at Piedigrotta near Naples. Photo by
courtesy of the Pitt Rivers Museum. Oxford.

Classical authors and depicted on Classical trumpets have continued in use up until modern
funerary monuments and coins, and their actual times suggests that they have functioned
use has been variously observed in northern efficiently in these ways.
and southern Italy during the nineteenth and More specifically, the Neolithic examples
twentieth centuries. from Italy may have been blown in connection
Experimental studies and ethnographic with Neolithic ritual performances. They have
observations suggest, however, that triton shell been found almost exclusively in contexts in
trumpets were not used simply as musical which human remains were present, (with the
instruments. End blown triton shell trumpets possible exception of the poorly recorded
produce only a limited range of notes: one or Grotta di Galuzzo), and usually in caves. As
two harmonics (Picken 1975, 552), and the Mosso (1910, 363) says: ‘the fact that they are
nature of the sound has been described, more found near human bones gives reason to
subjectively, as loud, braying and unmusical suppose that even in neolithic times these shells
(Jackson 1917). The sound produced by them were sounded with a religious signification’.
probably acted as a signal: evoking emotions, These bones were in general intentionally
announcing simple messages, directing and deposited and positioned, along with collec-
impelling men and gods to action. That shell tions of artefacts, (although it is unclear

OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY 25
TRITON’S TRUMPET

whether the Ripoli tibia was intentionally in the middle and later Neolithic levels of
deposited, or found its way less directly into Arene Candide came from the same sources
the upper levels of cavity XXV). The ‘Level as that found in the Grotta delle Felci and at
of the Circles’ can be regarded explicitly as Ripoli. Arene Candide received obsidian from
a ritual context, although the ritual perform- three sources, Sardinia, Palmarola and Lipari,
ances carried out there may not have been but only Palmarolan obsidian is known from
simply funerary in nature (Skeates forthcoming the Grotta delle Felci and from the island of
a). The fact that a shell trumpet was deposited Capri, and only Liparian obsidian from Ripoli
in a ritual context does not necessarily mean and other sites in the Abruzzo region (Hallam
that it was sounded in that place, but it is at et al. 1976; Williams Thorpe et al. 1979;
least possible that this was so. And one can Bigazzi and Radi 1981). Also, a sherd was
think of the modem examples of the sounding found at the Caverna dell’Acqua in Liguria
of triton shell trumpets during religious with a distinctive painted motif of a row of dots
ceremonies in northern and southern Italy. bordered on each side by a single line, which
The coast of Liguria seems to have acted as almost certainly indicates that the vessel to
a source for triton shells in Neolithic Italy. In which it belonged originated in the Abruzzo
support of this, one can cite the facts that: the region. This motif is found most frequently and
earliest dated Italian examples come from the characteristically at Ripoli (Cremonesi 1965),
late 6th millennium Cal. BC Neolithic levels and also at other sites in Abruzzo, including
26 and 25 in the Caverna delle Arene Candide; level 15 of the Grotta dei Piccioni, which was
there were sea-worn fragments reported from stratigraphically associated with the ‘Level of
that cave; and triton shells were present in the the Circles’ where a triton shell was found.
Ligurian caves in outstandingly greater num- The Hungarian Copper Age examples of
bers than in Abruzzo or Capri. However, it triton shells can less definitely be linked to Italy
must be stated that both living and fossil triton as a source. Links have been recently postu-
shells were potentially available elsewhere in lated between the artefacts of the Balaton
Italy. Lasinja I1 or ‘Furchenstich’ culture and
There is some evidence to suggest that triton material found in north-east Italian caves
shells moved down the Italian peninsula, and (Kalicz 1988, 87), but similar links have also
possibly across the Alps to Switzerland, as been suggested between the Baden culture and
elements in a late Neolithic long-distance the Early Bronze Age Aegean, which could
exchange network which indirectly linked equally have acted as a source for the
different regions and sites (see Barfield 1981; Hungarian triton shells. The discovery of a
and Malone 1985) (see Fig. 3). Where suffi- triton shell so far north of the Mediterranean
ciently detailed publications exist, it is possible in a possible early Neolithic context at Osel
to say that the late Neolithic Italian triton shells is simply astounding. That it was exchanged
were usually found in contexts which also con- is perhaps suggested by its association with a
tained other exchange goods, such as obsidian group of worked flints, found in and around
and trichrome painted fineware pottery. it, but the possibility that this is a fossil
Furthermore, the wide range of exchanged example originating away from the Mediter-
material found in Arene Candide and neigh- ranean should be borne in mind.
bouring caves seems to indicate that the Finale Triton shell trumpets not only functioned as
area was a nodal point in this network during emitters of oral signals, they also seem to have
the late Neolithic. For example, obsidian found been regarded and used as visual symbols in

26 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R. SKEATES

Figure 3
Distribution map of Neolithic and Copper Age triton shell finds from around the central Mediterranean. 1.
BCkismegyer I1 2. FenCpuszta I 3. Chamblandes culture graves 4. Caverne dei Balzi Rossi 5 . Caverna delle
Arene Candide 6. Grotta di Galuzzo 7. Caverna della Pollera 8. Arma della Sanguineto or della Matta 9.
Grotta di Bergeggi 10. Grotta dei Piccioni 1 1 . Grotta delle Felci 12. Brockdorf Circle 13. Hajar Qim Temples
14. Ripoli

OXFORD JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGY 27


TRITON’S TRUMPET

ritual. Symbols have been defined by Cohen especially as they have only been found in
(1974) as: ‘objects, acts, relationships or association with human remains, but this
linguistic formations that stand ambiguously symbolism may not have been specific to the
for a multiplicity of meanings, evoke emotions species, for triton shell ornaments have usually
and impel men to action. They usually occur been found with shell ornaments belonging to
in stylised patterns of activities, such as ritual, a range of other species.
ceremonial, gift exchange, prescribed patterns The Caverna delle Arene Candide might be
of joking, taking an oath, eating and drinking regarded as a manufacturing centre for triton
together, acts of etiquette and various cultural shell ornaments, due to the outstanding num-
traits that constitute the style of life of a group.’ bers of fragments found there, many with cut
The example from the Grotta dei Piccioni marks. However such evidence could also
best illustrates this: it stands out as an exotic reflect their use as a molluscan food source.
and unique artefact in the Neolithic of Charonia nodifera is not commonly eaten in
Abruzzo, and, as if that were not enough, it the Mediterranean, and is not listed with the
was also partially painted red; it was provided molluscs in Palombi and Santarelli’s (1969)
with a hole, which can most sensibly be catalogue of edible animals of the Italian seas,
regarded as a suspension hole, perhaps in order but it was reportedly eaten by the poor of
to display it as an ornament, and also to tie Marseilles and also on Crete (Reece 1985,
it to its owner to avoid loss; and it was inten- 354).
tionally placed within a collection of similarly The long and recurrent use of the conch shell
unusual artefacts, adjacent to the main group trumpet in Italy from the Neolithic to modern
of child remains, which included two skulls times is remarkable. This might partly be
(powerful symbols in their own right), and in attributed to its successful functioning in
a context where the deposits seemed to focus secular contexts, as perhaps at Pompeii, and
attention upon those child remains. The in relation to subsistence activities more
repeated occurrence of triton shell trumpets in recently in Italy. However, its repeated
similar, although less well defined contexts, recognition as a symbol was probably a more
is also suggestive of a symbolic value. important factor. Conch shell trumpets and
I do not intend to guess at the significance representations of them have most commonly
of this symbol, but the similarities between the been found in association with ritual activities,
treatment of the Grotta dei Piccioni trumpet and in religious and mythological contexts.
and those from the Ligurian caves do suggest Symbols are employed in all of these contexts,
a certain similarity in the ideas behind the and through their emphasis upon tradition and
symbol. For example, one of the specimens oral history, old symbols can be expected to
from the Caverna della Pollera carried a have been maintained in them. In ritual, for
suspension hole, and the one from the Arma example, the repeated use of old symbols is
del Sanguinetto was associated with three encouraged by the formalization and very
skulls and a predominance of the remains of repetitiveness of the performances, and by their
young children. reference to tradition and the past in justifi-
Triton shells were also used as a source of cation of their more inexplicable aspects. Bloch
raw material for ornaments, such as pendants ( 1986) emphasizes the extraordinary continuity
and bracelets, and other artefacts, such as awls and stability of ritual symbolism over time. In
and either spoons or scrapers. Triton shell this light, Mosso’s (1910) blowing of a triton
ornaments probably had some symbolic value, shell trumpet during church services in Holy

28 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R. SKEATES

Week at Chieri can be seen indirectly to relate dated to about 520-510 BC, formerly in the
back, through its use in a religious and ritual Castle Ashby collection of vases, which shows
context, to the use of conch shell trumpets by a youth raising a conch to his mouth with his
Roman sea gods, which, ultimately, can be right hand and holding a spear in his left hand
traced, via a circuitous route around Classical (Robertson 1979,22). Conch-blowing Roman
Greece and the Iron and Bronze Ages of the sea-gods were then reused as a theme by
central and eastern Mediterranean, to their painters and sculptors in Rome from the 16th
symbolic use in rituals in Neolithic Italy. century onwards, particularly on secular muni-
Despite this apparent continuity in use, it is cipal monuments, which can be seen in the
clear that the significance of the conch shell light of the revival of that city as an artistic
trumpet as a symbol changed greatly over time, and political centre in Italy, and as a reference
and that its meaning should be understood in by its artists and rulers to their inheritance of
relation to its changing historical context. The the strengths and traditions of the Roman
introduction of the triton shell trumpet to Italian Empire. Triton’s trumpet may have been
ritual contexts during the later Neolithic can sounded throughout the Italian past, but its
be related to other changes in the nature of meaning has been continually modified to suit
ritual taking place at this time, and to broader the present.
changes and stresses in society. In the later
Neolithic of the Abruzzo region, for example,
Acknowledgements
there was an increased distinction between
ritual taking place at this time, and to broader I should like to thank the following people for their advice
changes and stresses in society. In the later and encouragement in the preparation of this paper:
Dennis Britton, Sarah Milliken and Susan Keates
Neolithic of the Abruzzo region, for example, (Department of Ethnology and Prehistory, Oxford);
there was an increased distinction between Andrew Sherratt (Ashmolean Museum, Oxford); HCltne
ritual deposits in settlements and caves, and La Rue (Pitt Rivers Museum, Oxford); Nicholas Argente
between the treatment of children and adult (Department of Social Anthropology, Oxford); Eddie
remains (Skeates forthcoming a), and more Peltenburg (Department of Archaeology, Edinburgh);
Lawrence Barfield (Department of Ancient History and
generally an intensification and expansion in Archaeology, Birmingham); Robert Novella (Institute of
the settlement pattern, and a shift in the Archaeology, London); and Catherine Coouts and
exchange relations of Abruzzo from southern Penelope Allison (British School at Rome). I am also
to northern Italy (Skeates forthcoming b). grateful to the British School at Rome for awarding me
Thousands of years later, Roman sea-gods a ‘Grant in Aid of Research’ which enabled me to
undertake research for this paper in Rome.
emerged blowing conch shell trumpets. This
use of the shell trumpet probably derives from
Greek mythology, represented, for example, Department of Ethnology and Prehistory,
on an Athenian red figure cup from Culci, University of Oxford.

REFERENCES
and CORTESI. C. 1966:
ALESSIO. M.. BELLA. F.. BACHECHI. F. BARFIELD. L.H. 1981: Patterns Of north Italian trade
University of Rome Carbon-I4 Dates IV. Radiocarbon 5000-2000 BC. In: Barker, G. and Hodges, R. (editors),
8, 401-412. Papers in Italian Archaeology II. Archaeology and Italian
Society. Prehistoric, Roman and Medieval Studies
BANNER. J. 1956: Die PPceler Kultur (Budapest, Verlag (Oxford, British Archaeological Reports International
der Ungarischen Akademie der Wissenschaften). Series 102) 215-223.

OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY 29
TRITON'S TRUMPET

BERNABO BREA. L. 1946: Gli scavi nella caverna delle FAIRCLOUGH. H.R. 1927: Virgil. Aeneid. Book VI
Arene Candide. Part I - Gli strati con ceramiche (London, Heinemann).
(Bordighera, lstituto di Studi Liguri).
FERRARA, G . , FORNACA-RINALDI. G. and TONGIORGI, E.
BERNABO BREA. L. L. 1947: Le Caverne del Finale 1961. Carbon-I4 Dating in Pisa-11. Radiocarbon 3,
(Bordighera, Instituto di Studi Liguri). 99-104.

BERNABO BREA. L. 1956: Gli scavi nella Caverna delle GASELEE.s. 19 15: Apuleius. The Golden Ass. Being the
Arene Candide. Volume 2 (Bordighera, Instituto di Studi Metamorphoses of Lucius Apuleius (London,
Liguri). Heinemann).
BIGAZZI. G and RADI. G . 1981: Datazione con le tracce 1913: Les Formations Marines PliocPnes et
GIGNOUX. M .
di fissione per I'identificazione della provenienza dei Quaremaires de I'Italie d u Sud et de la Sicilie (Lyon,
manufatti di ossidiana. Rivista di Scienze Preistoriche 3 6 , Rey).
223-250.
GUIRAND. F. (editor) 1959: Larousse Encyclopedia of
BLOCH. M 1986: From blessing to violence. History and Mythology (London, Hamlyn).
ideology in the circumcision ritual of the Merina of HALLAM, B.R., WARREN, S.E. and RENFREW. C. 1976:
Madagascar (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). Obsidian in the western Mediterranean: characterization
BUSCH. R . 1983: Eine Schnecke (Charonia nodifera) mit by neutron activation analysis and optical emission
Feuersteindepot vom Osel bei Wolfenbuttel. In: Wegner, spectroscopy. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 42,
G. (editor), Friihe Bauernkulturen in Niedersachsen 85-1 10.
(Oldenburg: Staatliches Museum fur Naturkunde und HARRISON. F. and RIMMER. J . 1964: European Musical
Vorgeschichte) 1 7 7 - 8 . Instruments (London, Studio Vista).
COHEN, A. 1974: Two-Dimensional Man. An Essay on the INNES. M.M. 1955: The Metamorphoses of Ovid
Anthropology of Power and Symbolism in Complex (Harmondsworth, Penguin Books).
Society (London, Routledge and Kegan Paul).
ISSEL. A. 1886: Scavi recenti nella caverna delle Arene
1925: Zeus. A Study in Ancient Religion.
COOK, A . B . Candide in Liguria. Bullettino di Paletnologia Italiana
Volume 2 (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). 1 2 , 1 1 2 - 1 3 3 , 217-228.

CREMONESI.G. 1965: II villaggio di Ripoli alla luce dei ISSEL. A. 1892: Liguira Geologica e Preistorica. Volume
recenti scavi. Rivista di Scienze Preistoriche 2 0 , 85-155. 2.
CREMONESI, G . 1976: La Grotta dei Piccioni di ISSEL. A . 1893: Note paletnologiche sulla collezione del
Bolognano nel quadro delle culture dal neolitico all 'eta sig. G.B. Rossi. Bullettino di Paletnologia Italiana 19,
del bronzo in Abruuo (Pisa, Giardini). 1-17, 5 7 - 9 2 .
CUMONT. F. 1942: Recherches sur le Symbolisme JACKSON. J.W. 1917: Shells as Evidence of the Migrations
Funeraire des Romains (Paris, Service des Antiquites). of Early Culture (Manchester: Manchester University
Press).
DELFINO. E. 198 1 : Liguria preistorica. sepolture dal
Paleolitico superiore all'eta del ferro in Liguria e 1973: Uber die chronologische Stellung der
KALICZ. N .
nell 'area ligure (Savona, Sabatelli). Balaton-Gruppe in Ungarn. In Chropovsky, B. (editor),
Symposium uber die Entstehung und Chronologie der
D'ONOFRIO. c. 1957: L.e Fontane di Roma (Rorna, Badener Kultur (Bratislava, Verlag der Slowakischen
Staderini). Akademie der Wissenschaften) 13 1 - 165.
DRESSLER. F.R. 1916-24: Triton, Tritonen. In Roscher, KALICZ, N . 1988: The New Results of the Investigations
W.H. (editor), Ausfihrliches k.rikon der Griechischen on the Hungarian Copper Age. Rassegna di Archeologia
und Rdmischen Mythologie (Leipzig, Teubner) 7, 7 5 - 1 0 3 .
1150-1207.
MALONE. c. 1985: Pots, prestige and ritual in Neolithic
EVANS. J.D. 1971: The Prehistoric Antiquities of the southern Italy. In Malone, C. and Stoddart, S. (editors),
Maltese Islands: a Survey (London, The University of Papers in Italian Archaeology IV. The Cambridge
London, Athlone Press). Conference. Part ii. Prehistory (Oxford, British

30 OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY
R. SKEATES

Archaeological Reports International Series 244) ROSSITER. S . (editor) 1971: The Blue Guides, Rome and
I 18- I5 1. Environs (London, Benn).
MONTAGU. J . 1981: The conch in prehistory: pottery, SAKELLARIDIS, M . 1979: The Economic Exploitation of
stone and natural. World Archaeology 12, 273-279. the Swiss Area in the Mesolithic and Neolithic Periods
(Oxford, British Archaeological Reports Internatonal
1910: The Dawn of Mediterranean Civilisation
MOSSO. A.
Series 67).
(London Fisher Unwin).
SAUTER. M . R and GALLAY. A . 1969: Les premieres
1975: The Hamlyn Guide to Shells of the
OLIVER. A . P . H .
cultures d'origine miditerraneenne. Ur- und
World (Feltham, Hamlyn). friigeschichtlichiche Archaologie der Sch weiz 2, 47-66.
PALOMBI. A . and SANTARELLI, M. 1969: Gli Animali SKEATES. R.G. forthcoming a: Caves, Cult and Children
Conimestibili dei Mari d 'Italia (Milano, Hoepli). in Neolithic Abruzzo, Central Italy. In Garwood, P.,
and ELLIOTT. C .
PELTENBURG. E.J.. BOLGER, D . , GORING, E. Jennings, D., Skeates, R. and Toms, J. (editors), Sacred
1988: Kissonerga-Mosphilia 1987: Ritual Deposit, Unit and Profane. A Conference on Archaeology, Ritual and
1015. Report of the Department of Antiquities Cyprus Religion. Oxford, 28th-20th October, 1989 (Oxford,
1988, 3-52. Oxford Monograph Series, Committee for Archaeology).
PELTENBURG. E. and PROJECT MEMBERS 1989: Excavations SKEATES. R . G . forthcoming b: The Neolithic and Copper
at Kissonerga-Mosphilia, 1988. Repon of the Department Age in Abruuo and Marche, Central Italy (D. Phil. thesis,
of Antiquities Cyprus 1989, 29-40. University of Oxford).
PICKEN. L . E . R . 1975: Folk Musical Instruments of Turkey 1986: A Computer program
STUIVER. M . and RIEMER, P.J.
(London, Oxford University Press). for radiocarbon age calibration. Radiocarbon 28,
1022 - 1030.
POOLE. R . S . (editor) 1876: A Catalogue of the Greek
Coins in the British Museum. Sicily (London, The TINE, s. 1968: Scoperte e scavi preistorici in Italia
Trustees of the British Museum). durante il 1968. Rivisra di Scienze Preistoriche 23,
393-5.
1947: Pliny. Natural History. Volume I l l
R A C K H A M .H .
(London: Heinemann). VERMEULE, c. 1964: European A n and the Classical Past
(Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press).
REECE. D.S. 1985: Shells, ostrich eggshells and other
exotic faunal remains from Kition. In Karageorghis, V. VIRCHOW. R . 1902: Sur un depot des temps nkolithiques,
(editor), Excavations at Kition V. The Pre-Phoenician forme d'une coquille de Tritonium remplie d'eclats de
Levels. Part I1 (Nicosia, The Department of Antiquities, silex taillis. Congrks International d 'Anthropologie et
Cyprus) 340-415. d 'ArchPologie prPhistoriques. Compte Rendu de la
douzieme session. Paris 1900 (Paris, Masson) 295-7.
RELLINI. u. 1923: La Grotta delle Felci a Capri.
Munumenti Antichi 29, 305-408. WILLIAMS THORPE. 0.. WARREN. S.E. and BARFIELD. L.H.
1979: The sources and distribution of archaeological
RELLINI.u.
1934: La piu anrica ceramica dipinta in Italia obsidian in Northern Italy. Preistoria AIpina 15, 73-92.
(Roma, Meridionale).
WITTKOWER. R. 1955: Gian Lorenzo Bernini. The
ROBERTSON. M .1979: J. Boardman and M. Robertson, Sculptor of the Roman Baroque (London, The Phaidon
Corpus Vasorum Antiquorum Castle Ashby (Oxford, Press).
British Academy).

OXFORDJOURNALOF ARCHAEOLOGY 31

You might also like